Upload
dangnguyet
View
224
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 1
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp
for PE Pipe Fusion
HO Chun Yiu, Alan
Engineer
Technical Development Section, Distribution Operation Department,
The Hong Kong and China Gas Co. Ltd.
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 2
Abstract :
Electrofusion is one of the common methods for joining Polyethylene (PE) pipes to lay new
pipeline and rehabilitate aged metallic pipes. However, it is now suffering some limitations to
strive for excellent electrofusion quality by utilizing the existing strap clamp which is used to
hold the position of pipes and couplers when undergoing electrofusion process.
To eliminate these limitations for PE pipes electrofusion, an innovative equipment naming as
“Internal Alignment Clamp” (IAC) has been developed. It aims to improve the joint quality and
reliability as well as enhance gas safety by rectifying the pipe geometry imperfections actively,
especially in the fusion zones, when performing electrofusion regardless of the external
congested condition of the coupler.
This paper introduces the working principle, design features of this equipment and functional
verifications are shown to support its improvement beyond traditional strap clamp.
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 3
1. Introduction :
Similar with other international cities, Hong Kong has a high urban density, commercial and
residential buildings and congested underground utilities everywhere (Fig. 1). Due to this
congested underground situation, Electrofusion becomes the predominant joining method to
lay new pipeline and rehabilitate aged metallic pipes. As Hong Kong is densely populated, even
single accident cannot be tolerated and could be a disaster; the community could be benefited
from enhanced safety through pursuing a more qualitative and reliable electrofusion solution
by the gas company.
Fig. 1 The high urban density situation in Hong Kong
Having a detailed insight of the basic principle of Electrofusion process and the worsening
factors of joint quality is essential to understand the inspiration of developing the Internal
Alignment Clamp.
1.1 Principle of Electrofusion
Electrofusion (Fig. 2) is a method to join Polyethylene (PE) and other plastic pipes using
electrofusion coupler that have built-in electric heating coils which are used to weld the joint
together.
The pipes to be joined has to be cleaned and scraped, and then inserted into the electrofusion
coupler properly and fixed by clamp, after that a voltage is applied for a fixed time depending
on the coupler in use. The built-in heating coils then melt the inside of the coupler and the
outside of the pipe wall, the molten PE will flow and fill in the gap between the pipes and
coupler, which weld together to produce a very strong homogeneous joint. The assembly is
then cool down for a specified time. The electrofusion process is then completed.
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 4
Fig. 2 Principle of Electrofusion Process
1.2 Worsening factors of the electrofusion joint quality
The strap clamp is currently implemented to help maintain pipes in position with the coupler
when performing electrofusion. Both pipe ovality and misalignment do not favor electrofusion
jointing, while the use of traditional strap clamp is unable to control and rectify these potential
jointing imperfections. In addition, the congested underground environment also hinders the
use of strap clamp. These may lead to an inferior joint.
1.2.1 Geometry imperfections of pipes
Fig. 3 PE pipe deformation induced by pipes storage
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 5
Few geometry imperfections of the PE pipe might be induced through transportation
and storage (Fig. 3), such as Oval-shape-deformed and Locally flattened. Ovality is a
measure of the out-of-roundness of the pipe (Fig. A in Appendix), the larger the ovality
value, the larger the variation in the annular gap between the pipes and coupler (Fig. 4).
Fig. 4 Difference between pipes with ovality and perfectly circular after inserted into coupler
1.2.2 Misalignment of pipes and coupler
Both Angular and Parallel Misalignment (Fig. 5) would induce a large variation in the
annular gap between the pipes and coupler as well, due to the improper installation
process despite of having perfectly circular pipes. It might be caused by (a) improper
tightening force applied to the strap clamp which varies with different pipe size and the
alignment condition and (b) workmanship inconsistencies due to different jointers
operation.
Fig. 5 Angular and parallel misalignment of pipes and coupler
1.2.3 Congested environment outside the coupler
In some situations, the traditional strap clamp is not applicable, such as (a) limited space
in trench at pedestrian road and (b) congested trench which full of other underground
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 6
utilities (Fig. 6). It is a physical limiting factor of the external environment which hinders
the implementation of strap clamp.
Fig. 6 Congested trench situation
1.3 Design change incubated by disruptive innovation thinking
An innovative equipment “Internal Alignment Clamp” (in short, IAC) has been developed (Fig. 7)
to tackle the mentioned challenges of PE pipes electrofusion. It aims to improve the joint
quality and reliability, for instance, 1) improve the geometry of PE pipes in fusion zones actively,
i.e. auto-reround oval-shape-deformed pipes; 2) ensure proper alignment of pipes and coupler
automatically; 3) enable adaptability to different pipe sizes; 4) eliminate limitations of
congested environment outside the coupler; 5) lower the workmanship inconsistencies caused
by different jointers operation. Therefore, it can facilitate a good quality and reliable PE jointing
as well as enhance gas safety significantly.
Fig. 7 Design Change from Traditional Strap Clamp to Internal Alignment Clamp
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 7
2. Internal Alignment Clamp :
IAC is a set of pneumatic actuated device which expands in 2-stages; clamps and rectifies the PE
pipes dimension and alignment when undergoing electrofusion process. The whole system is
shown in (Fig. 8). It consists of (a) the Internal Alignment Clamp, (b) Control Unit, (c) Pneumatic
Multi-Core Tubing, (d) Power Cord and (e) Wire. IAC is connected to a control unit with a multi-
core pneumatic cable. And CCTV (Closed-Circuit Television) system and lighting are equipped
for transmitting real time video wirelessly to provide feedback of the clamps operating status.
Therefore, the operator can remotely control the IAC by the control unit.
Fig. 8 The whole setup of the Internal Alignment Clamp
IAC is designed and simulated by CAD (Computer Aided Design) (Fig. 9) software and some precise
parts are fabricated by CNC machine for the sake of fulfilling tight tolerance requirements.
Fig. 9 Computer Aided Design and Simulation of the Internal Alignment Clamp
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 8
2.1 Mechanism of the clamp
Fig. 10 Mechanism and component list of the Internal Alignment Clamp
IAC is a set of pneumatic actuated device that transforms forces from 2 pneumatic cylinders to
both 4-plates pressing clamp or expander through 8 sets of linkage (Fig. B in appendix). Most of
the machined parts are made of Aluminum (AL-6061 and AL-7075) and rods are made of steel.
All parts are simulated (Fig. 9) before fabrication, verified and optimized to ensure its safety
factor is larger than 10 during normal operation. (Fig. 11)
Fig. 11 Parts are verified to ensure its Safety Factor > 10 in normal operation
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 9
Refer to the (Fig. B in appendix) for the details of forces transformation from pneumatic
cylinder to individual press plates pressing force. And (Fig. C) for the comparison between
Simulated requiring force and Calculated providing force for pipe deformation. It shows that
the IAC could provide sufficient forces to rectify the ovality from 1.5% to 0 for all Dn315, Dn355
and Dn400 pipe.
2.2 Operating Procedures
There are 5 steps of the operating procedures shown in Fig. 12 :
1) Insert the IAC into the rear pipe. Expand the Rear Clamp (1st stage) to lock its position
with the rear pipe and rectify the geometry of rear pipe fusion zone to become circular
2) Install the electrofusion coupler to the rear pipe
3) Insert the front pipe to the coupler
4) Expand the Front Clamp (2nd stage) of IAC to lock its position with the front pipe and
rectify the geometry of front pipe fusion zone to become circular
5) Retract both 1st and 2nd stage of IAC after undergoing the electrofusion and cooling
stages, then withdraw the IAC from the pipe and the whole operation is completed
Fig. 12 Internal Alignment Clamp operating procedures (Cross-Sectional View)
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 10
2.3 Special Features (Quick change for adapting various pipe sizes)
IAC is designed to apply for 3 majority pipe sizes for the Electrofusion: Dn315mm, Dn355mm
and Dn400mm PE pipe. It can be transformed easily to fit different pipe configurations by
changing the specified press plate which is locked by a quick lock.
The press plates are made of Polyformaldehyde (POM) (Fig. D in appendix) material which has
the advantage of low coefficient of friction, wear resistance, low heat conductivity and
relatively higher Young Modulus than PE. Press plates for different pipe sizes are all machined
by CNC machine precisely, but only the curvature is distinguished to fit with specified pipe ID.
Fig. 13 Fabricated POM Press plates and the engineering drawing highlight
2.4 Control Unit
The control unit (Fig. 14) of the IAC system is the essence of the system which is the control
interface between the IAC and the operator. Though it is important, it is simple and user-
friendly, there are 2 handles to control the Front and Rear clamp and a power button could be
accessed by the operator. And 3 pressure gauges for displaying the source, Front and Rear
Clamp compressed air pressures. It converts electrical power to energy stored inside
compressed air which transmitted through a multi-core pneumatic cable to expand and retract
both Front and Rear Clamp. Refer to (Fig. 14) and (Fig. K in the appendix) for pneumatic
components arrangement and the pneumatic diagram for the system respectively.
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 11
Fig. 14 Pneumatic components inside the Control unit
Fig. 15 Multi-Core pneumatic cable and power cord connection is located at aside of control box
2.5 Real Time Video Feedback
The CCTV and lighting (Fig. 16) on the IAC captures the real time video and transmits it
wirelessly via Wi-Fi signal to the operator monitor or cell phone. It provides feedback of both
clamps real-time situation to the operator.
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 12
Fig. 16 Real time video signal is captured by the CCTV on the IAC and transmitted wirelessly
3. Functional Verifications :
3.1 Dimensions verification
Fig. 17 Comparison between the PE pipe ID before and after implementing the IAC
The dimensions verification is performed to check whether the pipe ovality is rectified under
implementing the IAC. In general practice of electrofusion jointing, the largest acceptable pipe
ovality is 1.5%. Only for this verification, 0.5% more additional requirement is added for
providing margin, thus, pipes are deliberately deformed to around 2% ovality are tested.
The results are acceptable and matched with simulation closely that the ovality of all Dn315 ~
Dn400 pipes are largely reduced. It is confident to ensure 1.5% ovality can be rectified to
around 0 by implementing IAC.
Item Norminal OD Norminal ID Status Remarks
Dn ID1 ID2 Ovality (%) ID1 ID2 Ovality (%)
1 351.4 357.8 1.81 354.2 355 0.23 Accept
2 352.3 356.9 1.30 354.3 354.5 0.06 Accept
3 349 359 2.82 353.3 355.7 0.68 Ignore org ovality 2.82% > 2% , Out of range
4 312.1 317 1.56 314.4 314.9 0.16 Accept
5 311.4 317.3 1.88 314.3 315.1 0.25 Accept
6 312.6 316.9 1.37 314.6 314.7 0.03 Accept
7 276.7 281.7 1.79 279 279.5 0.18 Accept
8 276.3 282.2 2.11 278.5 280 0.54 Ignore org ovality 2.11% > 2% , Out of range
9 277 281.4 1.58 279.1 279.3 0.07 Accept
355
315
314.66
279.2
Before After
Comparison between the PE pipe ID before and after using the Internal Alignment Clamp
400 354.55
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 13
3.2 Electrofusion Joint Quality verification
By benchmarking the peel test results (Fig. 18) of same badge of joints by implementing IAC and
strap clamp under a few extreme conditions and referring to the simplified peel test results (Fig.
19), it is observed that joints by IAC are performing better than joints by strap clamp. Please
refer to (Fig. E in appendix) for the detailed peel test results.
Fig. 18 An example of the Peel Test comparison between using Strap Clamp and IAC
Fig. 19 Simplified Peel Test results (Strap Clamp vs Internal Alignment Clamp)
4. Conclusion
Incubated by disruptive innovation thinking and utilized precision computer-aided design and
simulation, this first-of-its-kind equipment helps solve difficulties during electrofusion with its
special features.
The Internal Alignment Clamp is designed to aid for improving the joint quality and reliability as
well as the gas safety. Various benefits can be realized by using this equipment when
comparing to strap clamp,
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 14
Equipping with (a) the Auto-Rerounding function and (b) Alignment Correction, IAC
helps to tackle the ovality problem and misalignment of PE pipes when undergoing the
electrofusion process
2-Stage expansion for front and rear clamp mechanism
Press Plates are quick-changeable for adapting various pipe sizes
Limitation of the external congested environment can be minimized
This application, Internal Alignment Clamp, is not only beneficial to the gas industry, but also
has potential to extend to the water industry.
Fig. 20 Internal Alignment Clamp advantages : Auto-Rerounding and Alignment Correction
- THE END -
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 15
Appendix :
Fig. A Interpretation of the Ovality [1]
Fig. B Forces transformation from pneumatic cylinder to individual press plates pressing force
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 16
Fig. C Comparison between Simulated required force and Calculated provided force for pipe
deformation
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 17
Fig. D POM material - Mechanical properties
Fig. E Detailed Peel Test parameters and results (Strap Clamp vs Internal Alignment Clamp)
Size Clamp
Side
L R L R L R L
S5 -3.8 400C 6.24 6.7 399.15 399.3 3.36 3.3 Strap Pass -
S6 -5.1 400C 5.93 5.87 398 399.12 4.5 3.17 Internal Pass -
S11 28 315C 2.5 5 315.75 315.81 1.65 1.44 Internal Pass -
S12 29 315C 4 4.5 315.83 315.85 1.44 1.24 Strap Fail L9 (76%), L12 (100%), R12 (77%)
S13 25 315C 2.5 2 316.05 316.07 1.58 1.4 Strap Fail R12(45%)
S16 25 315C 3 2 315.5 315.9 2.84 2.37 Internal Pass -
Nominal
Dia.
Avg GapODSample
No.Temp/C
Peel Test ResultsPipe Gap
PT Result Fail LocationOvality
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 18
Fig.F Simulation results of rectifying 1.5% Ovality to 0
Fig. G Simulation results of rectifying 2.5% Ovality to 0.53%
Fig. H Machining parts verification to ensure Safety Factor > 10
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 19
Fig. I Example of the engineering parts drawing for the press plate
Fig. J Example of the engineering assembly drawing for the press plate assembly
The Design of Internal Alignment Clamp for PE Pipe Fusion
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2016 (Far East District Section) HO Chun Yiu, Alan Page 20
Fig. K Pneumatic diagram of the pneumatic circuit in the control unit
Reference :
[1] Ovailty: http://www.cmrp.com/dompdf/ovalitycalc.php