View
220
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
1/44
IKDNTK\\O@KO@ VOVK\ SK\NKS
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
2/44
8< os o a`)vo|tnso`* a`)v|at a|ho`nwotna tb|a{hb o hn |ai Hk|io`~ os o vk|io`k`t ikia|noj ta
Io|sbojj Vjo` ossnsto`ck* HIE ion ton`s o st|a`h v|ksk`ck a` latb sndks a tbk Otjo`tnc N` oddntna` ta nts bkodq{o|tk|s n`
Xosbn`hta`* DC* HIE bos aecks n` Lk|jn`* Vo|ns* L|{sskjs* Lkjh|odk* O`mo|o* L{cbo|kst* Xo|sox* o`d {`ns HIE ojsa bos
siojjk| |kv|ksk`totna`s n` L|otnsjouo* {|n`* o`d Stacmbaji
Ola{t tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` Vajnc~ V|ah|oi
Tk Ikdntk||o`ko` Vajnc~ V|ah|oi v|aiatks t|o`sotjo`tnc o`oj~sns o`d dnojah{k a` nss{ks okctn`h Sa{tbk|` K{|avk* @a|tb
O|nco* tbk Jkuo`t* o`d tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` losn` V|na|nt~ o|kos n`cj{dk7 {`dk|sto`dn h t|k`ds n` Ikdntk||o`ko` sacnktnks=
krvja|n`h avva|t{`ntnks a| sa{tb)sa{tb caavk|otna` o`d n`tkh|otna`= |ksko|cb a` mk~ {`ctna`oj nss{ks okctn`h Ikdntk|)
|o`ko` skc{|nt~ o`d dkukjavik`t= o`d st|k`htbk`n`h tbk @a|tb Oik|nco` vajnc~ dklotk a` tbk |khna` o`d t|o`sotjo`tnc
caavk|otna` a` Ikdntk||o`ko` st|otkh~
Ola{t Nstnt{ta Oeeo|n N`tk|`owna`ojn
Tk Nstnt{ta Oo|n N`tk|`owna`ojn "NON.* a{`dkd l~ Ojtnk|a Svn`kjjn n` ?>5;* daks |ksko|cb n` tbk kjds a a|knh` vajnc~*
vajntncoj kca`aincs* o`d n`tk|`otna`oj skc{|nt~ O a`)v|at a|ho`nwotna * tbk NON onis ta d nsskin`otk m`axjkdhk tb|a{hb
|ksko|cb st{dnks* ca`k|k`cks* o`d v{ljncotna`s a tbot k`d* nt caavk|otks xntb atbk| |ksko|cb n`stnt{tks* {`nuk|sntnks* o`d
a{`dotna s n` Ntoj~ o`d ol|aod o`d ns o ikilk| a uo|na{s n`tk|`otna oj ktxa|ms Ia|k svkcncojj~* tbk ion` |ksko|cb
skcta|s o|k K{|avko` n`stnt{tna`s o`d vajncnks* Ntojno` a|knh` vajnc~* t|k`ds n` tbk hjaloj kca`ai~ o`d n`tk|`otna`ojnwotna`
v|ackssks n` Ntoj~* tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` o`d tbk Inddjk Kost* dkk`sk kca`ai~ o`d vajnc~* o`d t|o`sotjo`tnc |kjotna`s Tk NON
v{ts a{t o` K`hjnsb)jo`h{ohk q{o|tk|j~ "Tk N`tk|`otna`oj Svkctota|.* o` a`jn`k xklwn`k "Oeo|N tk|`owna ojn.* o sk|nks a
|ksko|cb vovk|s "_{odk|`n NON. o`d o` Ntojno` a|knh` vajnc~ ~ko|laam "Jo Vajntnco Kstk|o dkjjNtojno.
Cauk| vbata7 Ojgowkk|ocai xkl vohk sbaxs tbk I{oiio| Hodoe v|ajk |o`cm|kva|tk|
http://www.gmfus.org/http://www.iai.it/index_en.asphttp://www.iai.it/index_en.asphttp://www.gmfus.org/7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
3/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko`n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h
Ikdntk||o`ko` Vovk| Sk|nks
dkckilk|
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
4/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h nnn
Ea|kxa|dSnjuno Cajaila
T ~ * I )
~ * I Lww*
T S Lw T
m *
I S~*
O X m
O S ~
* *
N m T
~ 7
w = ~
g ~
~
* * =
S N
~ ~ ~
~
T ~ O *
r *
T K~
g~ w ~
~
N w
J~
~ ~)
T O g
S C* T L K S S K~ S N* Av)I* H I E*@ *
N C H* D X S7 J~K C* NCHI K!@ O \v* @3* S 4*
T *
* ~
@ O r A *
* ~ O S
r *
*
H C C "HCC.
T O
S O* _* L*
M* [ O K "[OK.*
A C r
* ~
r ~ ~ *
*
V~ @ O*
~
~ I K*
HCC* _ S O*
N
@ O* HCC
r
T* J~* K~ *
~
T ~ ~
N
~
T ~
* * m N ~
m ~
)
I *
H *
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
5/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotksnu
S X E* m O
T ~ @ O ~
HCC
O S
~
~ H
S~ ~
HCC O S
X
* ~w
3 N
r H @ O
~ q7 r
H
@ O
1 D
O
~ * * m * * )
1
T q*
w \ G
*
H I*
K* [S r*
HCC @ O
O S T
H m
HCC
m )
@ O
3 S C* T HCC O S7 O T DS* T N Sv* U 48* @ 4* D* )5
T r T
m
q
~ T
)
HCC
@ O
X *
~)
T
HCC @ O
~ @
O T
N N
~* * m~
N K~
* ~
HCC
r
T
* V
B Im K~ H *
T HCC
m
H
HCC ~
@ O* *
HCC @
O I K
~
T ~
w
S O _ N
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
6/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h u
HCC )
~ HCC
O m
* HCC
*
m~
* N
N r*
X H ~ ~
m T
~ K[)HCC [S)HCC
B* )
* ~ *
w*
m
I ~* ~ Sq
H r
O S
~ H *
* ~*
~ X H
)
~ w
m m
*
r
T HCC
* ~
) *
O
~ * ~ ~
~ * m
T *
* ~ ~ ~
HCC *
* ~ ~
r M
T ~ K \
~
r
HCC K~* ~
T ~ m~
~ ~
r HCC
K~ O * *
r
HCC
* S O
[OK*
~ K~ I
L * *
_ A* ~
K~
~ V
I I O ~ ~
* r
N H T
~ g~
~ N
~ S
m~ X
N ~ M C)[*
HCC
O S
~ ~)
w T
HCC ~
m
~
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
7/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotksun
A O Gw O
O S HCC r
g*
HCC m~
~
T
K [ "K[.
HCC
)
@ O
E [S * ~
H
T
*
~
r
O *
[S ~
D ~* [ S
~ @ O* ~ K m
*
L q T
~ ~ S B
HCC* [ S*
@ O N
~*
* HCC
X * ~
@ O
J ~
* ~
~ HCC *
* X *
X ~
q*
~
O S
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
8/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h ?
Tbk O|ol \kuaj{tna`s7 O Skca`d N`dkvk`dk`ckSboekkq Hbol|o?
T O r ~
~
D ~ w
* * m
O ~ ~
T O m
T~ * *
T
=
Cajjovsk ae tbk Stot{s _{a
T q O
A *
m ~
r
N m
~
@ * *
~ O r
m O ~
* ~
X I Lww
D 8* * T
O G
* ~ * W K O L
O* q * r
G~ 4* N C* M
S ~ K~ ~ G
m ~
~ ^* T * ) *
K~ G~ ;*
N D* S~*
H J* @ \{7 T Cw \v{* S{O* C* O* O* ;
~ ~ ~ L )O
L V~ I
@ C m
G~ m ~
T~
~ 4*
T T~
) Em*
g T Sq T
*
* ~
O @ O
J H*
~ N
O
D~* * g
O
T m
)
* ~
T * T
q
~ T
T C w
~
=
* ~
T ~
V~* O
T ~*
q~*
V
N *
K~ T ~
L ^ K~
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
9/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks8
N * ~ S~
K~ >2 K
~ ~ N
>2* K~ ~ ;
~ ;*3 N ~
; ~ ;*
S Im
3 ~ * ~
r * N*
* K~ w
H ~
V
~
T
~ )
~
~ K~* J~* S~* T*
T *
*
~
T ~
w
T w
r ~
m m T
m
m ~
T
O T~ ~
)
3 T ~ D S K N* G~ N ~ K~ N C* G
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
10/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h 3
* * * ~ Em T
L ~
~
O * ~ qm~
O * m
@ M
*
m ~ ~ G)E
J~
) 4
N *
)
X
*
* ~
N K~* r*
m S K N*
S~* J~* T
V g
~ m
O I I m
O * ~
O T* *
~ T~
~ )
* * ~
;
O K~ *
Im
~ m
4 G)E J~* T V C7 O \v Mx)* I* I [~ V* >24
; I I* T O C T V I* @B* ^ [~ V* 2
N T Sq O \
~
T Sq ~ B
m @
O C E ~
* G~ >* * V Im
* *
m Im
"O
Sq. Sq
E~ 3* ^ * X
A 7Im ~
~* A S Sq
B 7 T
"Im. ~ ~
T
A ~ *
A S7 B X
7 ^ )B* I )@gg*
~ X * ]Y
g ]rY L
~ X ~ m
A S* ~ ~ r B ~
S 7 B * X
~ ~ r
L B K~
~ * * *
T m 7 X ~
5 ~ ~~ 5
M ~ )
O T K~
H S 8 T ~
m ~
5 N O \ ^* C* G
8 N 5 O K~ * C* G
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
11/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks4
X K~ T~
* J~
)
T ~
J~
@OTA) ~
N S~*
*
~*
* E
S~ O~ T m S~
~ w
K~ O *
I K O *
) O
K~ I~ C*
T * N
V I I Jm K~ T* ~ O ~ r
~
~*
T
~
* ~
O S~ ~
T O
q ~ *
~
~ T S~ ~
m O *
A * O
S*
T V
~ )
N * ~ >28
T
V O~
~ m ~
Tbk Ia`o|cbnks
T O
O w
O ~
) O * ~
m r* *
~ O ~
I ~
T
~ ~
L O
*
~
g
I G I ~
* ~
A *
I M I UN
~ O
T I g~
N G* M O NN
O S \
* *
N
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
12/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h ;
I~ * O M* ) *
M g
~
m N
~* * w*
~* g*
*
G G ~
~ )
~ O g
~ r N * G
~ m S~
N H* L
* w *
w S g~*
8 *
w* 5 T~
r
4 ~ L
M B )M L
~
N E~ * L
~ L
~ H C
C "HCC.*
T HCC* ~ S
O* g ~ ~
L ~
N @ HCC *
M* r* ~ T
L
E*
g O
N S S
N
E * M ~ H M
~ *
T O *
T
~
~ T * M
~) w
* w 5*
" M. O
* O *
~*
* ~ *
34 ; D *
* ~
~ D *
T D
* ~
A
2*
I~ ~) M
~ ~
~
T q* *
w g
S
~ m M
~ H B*
~ N
M* *
A *
4w [ O K "[OK.
G~
Cw D
r*
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
13/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks5
* ~
K A r *
A
S O* HCC
* r r
O M
O g
5* g
I~ N E*
m
~
[ S
m O S ~
*
S
* m~
m ~
2 D * S
r ~
~ O~ ~
T Em * *
A *
m~
> D O * ~
* A
*
T
T S O
* _ N T
S ~* ~ " ~.
; * ~
g* ~* *
* T S
2 K Mm~* N M* E V~* G~ >*
> G T* N S O* D N O X* A~ A V* T* G~ *
q~ m* @g
\~* ~
T )
S ~
S O D ~
~ ~ S
* ~ *
S m
~
m X G
M S
~
H{je \koctna`s ta \kuaj{tna`
T L A HCC
* ~ S O* ~
~ $
m
T S O
I~ G
I H C C HCC
~ m ~ X
HCC * I~ S O
~ r HCC T
_*
[OK* M ~ g ~
A A~ L
N ~* HCC
~ E N*
S)S *
O
~ L* * HCC
N J~* _ m
@OTA q
= HCC
T HCC
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
14/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h 8
r * S O V S
N S~* HCC
S~ * _ ~
A m
HCC
S~ = ~
HCC T m O
~
H S O
K~ I~
C * _
I L T ** m E *
~ ~ V
I* K~ I
L* S O
N ~* r HCC
* V* [OK
~ N* ~ H* ~
~ m
O
S
X ~ ~ ~ K~* J~*
T* S~* * HCC
~
O * HCC O S
m
*
r ~ X
m H* HCC
* N
m* m O
A HCC * _
O A H
*
* O
N * * ~ O S M*
*
N *
O ~ *
L * O I
K
S~* _* B Hw*
Bw J
~ K~ S O T
m S~ =
Bw =
K~ = _
S~)N r T
~
)* Tm~ O
S~
N * H *
~
*
T
~ K~
~ O)Gw O O~
T
N K~ S~*
~
N
X S O* *
N m~
~* * ~ m
E* N
I K m H
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
15/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks2
~ HCC N w
T
T HCC
I L N
Ca`cj{sna`
T O
O ~
r
C
* m K~* ^* J~* T*
S~* ~ ~*
D *
N
T
w N
D ~ ~ O S* E~
~ ~
O T * ~
E~ O
q T ~
O
X O
~ O m m
T m
~
O
q~
T O
~
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
16/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h >
>* S
L
S
N
L*
~* ~
S
T * ~ S O
M* [OK*
S
w E * S
S O*
E *
~
* ~
T S
* S
* ~ S8
N M* S
O w
~
* ~ m Nq)N 2 N
_
M* L *
L M
5 S O * * [OK ; * _ " _ . M ~ L S M S@~ T L " O.* E * ;
2 O C* M A Cm SI~* T @x ^m T* I >* >2>= M 7 7!!~!))!>
http://countrystudies.us/persian-gulf-states/19.htmhttp://countrystudies.us/persian-gulf-states/19.htmhttp://countrystudies.us/persian-gulf-states/19.htmhttp://countrystudies.us/persian-gulf-states/19.htm7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
19/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks? N _*
m L g
[S T L *
* _ *
5 ~* V
S E
T S O D
L* Em
". I
* ~ 8
S \~* S O
w ~ S
w *
~3
T ~
w*
~* ~
~ *
* L T*
) V
> L A O M I " O.*O)X* I = L S M IA*O)Gw* I 2*
M L \g _ I " O.*L I* @ >*
S O S A7 8;+ C D) A C~ " O.* O)O*I ;* = S~ Iw S KV O B \ " O.*
O)O* I ;* = C S C D~ X " O.*O)O* I * = \ Em* S q * T N)
v* I ;*
S C S C D~ X " O.*
3 S O ~ ~* $3 * ~m ~ r ~ r S Tm K)T~* A)\ S T~ T S A \ X C* CD* E~ 3*
\* ) m S *
T
~
E~ 4 ~* L
* 4
Tbk L|atbk|baad C|ksck`t Krva|tn`h
tbk O|ol Sv|n`h
T H m
~ *
K~ I
L
r HCC
I L K~
N
* H *
~
m L O
V K~;
T
~ I L
H
g * K~ T
E* H
m
T
L
g ~
* m ~
* ~
H S* I L
K~*
*
I L ~ q
4 N ~ L Bq* \ ^* O)Xq*L* O
; S* r* I M O* T L\/ " O.*O N* O *
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
20/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h ?3
I L T Sm
)_*
w L
[OK* D V C* D
M5 M _
I Hw* m
I L K~*
N [OK _
8 T
~ HCC* D O J
\ )W~*
* m * m
O N B w
m HCC
K~
~2
T*
~ ~ H
S ~ T
H * ~ *
m ~
I L* ~ *
I L
K~* T* O *
r *
M I T
@ O ~ M*
N H
5 T [OK S~ E * X L~ N ^ )_* [OK* D V C " O.* E
)N O C D*
[OK m~
~ ~*
~ ~ ~
3
HCC ~
_ *
~
m
~ N
)_ * g~ I L
_
I L*
w O
3 _
X L
= _
N m~ r
> T )N [OK 7!!!!19323
3 CI D* T [ O K7 E
O S* Av D~* S 2* 3 T ~ _ IL ~* r S * K~ G I* _ K~S O)Om V I D \ V~ E E C E E7 _ M H 5> O O OI) S~ " O.*O)Om* @ 8*
http://www.aleslaah.net/site/showthred.php?id=3803http://www.aleslaah.net/site/showthred.php?id=3803http://www.aleslaah.net/site/showthred.php?id=3803http://www.aleslaah.net/site/showthred.php?id=38037/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
21/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks?4
O X 3
A *
S O [OK E r*
D V C* D M*
~ *
HCC m L G~
2* * I L
H ~ q
N 33 N * [OK
* O W~* w I
L
~ B HCC
A
L
~
I L*
HCC Vajncnks taxo|d Kh~vt
O ~ *
H
K~
I HCC K~
O * ~
~ I~
H S
K~ *
34 E rO)\~
O)Gw ~
S O
3 \ M B S _ B G G )T* X N * E T* @ 3*
33 [OK7 H S S V* H{ T* A >*
34 S @7 K~ J O S S D~ " O.* O)O* I~ 4*
K~ ~3;
T S EI* S )E* K~
O
~35Amw* O)\~* O)Gw
K~ O
38 O * H
K~ ~
T ~ K~
D @ *
M S ~ K~ *
~ O
@* K~ ~ S O* r M
S
K~ m 32
T HCC O S
~
I I
K~
~ T w
m ~
H
I L *
T
~ r
*
>8> N
T H
*
3; T S @7 S K~ K@~ S L O X" O.*O)O* I~ *
35 S S )E7 K~ C
O X " O.*O)O* G~ 3*
38 S ^ )M* K~ S O7 N)~ N H " O.*O)\~* I~ 3*= S @7 K~ O S " O.*
O)O* I~ 4*
32 E * G L)I*J S{= {* JA { * V* O I>5
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
22/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h ?;
r I L
T M
L* I L
L m
N I O
N C I M T
[OK*
I L ~ *
Dx* ~
~
T ~ I
K~ T
m K~
K~
H * ~ ~
) *
~ N
H K~ ~*
H
S~ N 3>
T* K~ *
I L
~ O ~*H K~
7
Ca`ton`ik`t
T HCC
*
O
r N
m ~
H
K~ T m
3> E r* I B* T @ K~ V) H C " O.*O)L~* G~ *
~ m4
Kr ~
HCC m
~ S O O
r HCC I
G* ~ *
H
$; g
~4 T~
I*4 ~
g ~
A~* G I
T m I ~
~
HCC 43
H * ~ S O*
~
*
E r* S O*
HCC* m
4 E * I H B* ~ E \ C V O~ K~* K~ r [OK* K~ m * N m V* B m [OK ~7 [OK K~ m ~* I [OK ~ m T K~* * ~ S O K~E I7 X D [OK A \ C Xm U " O.* O)O*I 3* = B C S V D K~ Xm [OK " O.*
O)Nmx * I 2* 4 H S O $; L O I* G*\{* D *
4 G B* HCC S E N I*OGw C S{ \v* G~ *
43 S* r* M I C D G O O A C V S" O.*O O)Ox* G~ 3*
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
23/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks?5
*
O
X * H
~ *
44 T
~ ~ I~
HCC
r Im
r4; S O r)
L O*
T 45
T S!HCC
S O
m
Co{tna{s K`hohkik`t
T HCC
* ~ S O
[OK* K~ T~
K~ O
~*
I L*
~ K~* q r ~
T r ~ V I M
Hw
K~ V G~ 3* *
O X
K~
44 V S H)m 33~ *O)O~* @ 3*
4;
I~ K~ H S* r* ^ Em* T HC7 S J K~ " O.*O)S{m*E~ ;* = I L B* T @ K~ V) H C " O.*O)L~* G~ *
45 N Iwm O)O G~ 4* D O ;* * I * O)Iwm q r L O S O S
O)I~ ) {* O 8*
48
O E~w O K)@* K~
* O K~
G~ ;* $2 S O
$; I~ 5* *
m $38;
* K~
m* g*
K~
O [OK $3
K~ * * *
m ~
* K~r ~
T _ S
O [OK H _
I L *
_
S T
O O
S42 N _
T J~
K~= K _ Sm BL M )T T
~ T
G~ O
T
* _ ~
=
Sm ~ g T
_ V N *
m $; T
_ J~ *
H* *
* ~ $2 T J~
r D $;
48 T ~7 7!!~!19QS@LA2
42 T O C V C O S "O.* ^{ 8* I *
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SiNBOft18shttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SiNBOft18shttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SiNBOft18shttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SiNBOft18s7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
24/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h ?8
S w J~ * _
m
* $
4> O K~* ~ m
_ m
K~ _
K~
_
K~ $2
g*
K~ ~
;
Caavk|otna` a| Ca`ejncts1
S * H
~ B* )
~ @ O *
K~*
~ E 7
K~ H * N* S~*
Tm~ X I I
V K~ G 8* * r
~ K~
~ r * ~* ~
~ N r
* ~
* ~
~
~ T
G 4* *;
~ r K~
m
* ~
4> J~ A \q ; L D N) " O.*O)O~* O 4*
; K \* N _ \7 Iv H{ K O K~v \{ " O.* X O~ \ C S S* S *
; T ~7 7!!~!193V~QBBI[4
N* X
N *
H =
I L m
K~ N * ~
O O)Ox H
I T
Sq C [~*
~ X
H B* V I
S O G~ *
m T
K~ S
O I M O
m
K~ N
S N V~* S O
H *
I L D
* S
K~ I
I L
S
N V I
E G V~* g~
* w H
~
~ I
~
H B
K~ m r
~ ~ N
C [~* I
r K~ r
* *
~
[OK E I O W~
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3cPy_HHMUs4http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3cPy_HHMUs4http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3cPy_HHMUs4http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3cPy_HHMUs47/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
25/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks?2
w K~ C*
T
~ ~ M
L *
I @*
I ) m~
~
K~ I L ~
m H L
~ H
\ N* H K~
T
w
T 7
N K~
*
~ ~ ~
N Om~ K~
E* I L
N T
r ~ ~
T G * V I
N *
T O @)
O I
q w N
S~; T ~
I ~* m Im*
m g O
w N
N *
I L* ~
r w
T Sq N @* I
L r r
*
; K \* S{ C7 X{ I N O Lm{ S~ C1" O.* X O~ \ C S S* O 5*
T*~ N *
r I L
N * ~ S*
~
N g~ I
S
~
N
S * ~
I T T*
N ~ I L= S
m
X S~* H
K~ T
S~ *
K~ * r
E S~ *
* ~ ;3
K~ r I
* O ;* * S~ K~
q
S O* Tm~* N* K~*
O ;4 T
N S~ S
O r N
~ I N
S~ N*
[ S N
g E S~ * ~ _ ~
;3 D K~ E S~ Tm~ O \ O)^{{ O *
;4 K~ S S~ " O.*O O)Ox*O 5*
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
26/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h ?>
K~ T
* * K~
N
S
q
C S N r
* g S~ *
q Nq Uw g
T
q K~
S O ~ ;;
O ~ S * S O
N m
= Tm~ ~
N
E~* Tm~*
H r Tm~
K~ S N *
r Tm~
K~* O ~
I
\~ G~ ~ K~ S O
S N;5
Ca`cj{sna`
\ H K~*
I
* B ~
~ m ~
\
K~ I L*
~ H
;; T _ C \ S N SS I _ S~ " O.*O
O)Ox* S >* = \~ L~ _I " O.*I~ @x* A 3* = SO ~ m S~* \{* S8*
;5 I7 K~ S O V S)NVg " O.* C@@ O* O *
* r * N Tm~
T I
L*
~ T ~ w
K~ ~
w
~m C
w * ~
~
w
T HCC ~ *
* E *
w K~
T _ *;8
T S
O L O T
K H ~* * )
"!.
~ K~ A
* K~ ~
H E ~
V~*
K~ N
Tm~* H ~ HCC
~
K~ A * H
K~ I
N* H
T *
HCC )K~
;8 E r* H C V C w G~ * * _ ~ K~ _ ) K~ _ O S V D C _ K~ " O.*O)O* G~ 3*
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
27/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks* * 7!!!!)QIKIA));22Q
~* w N
*
S [ * [ S
K~ *5 ~
* *
N ~5 N *
[ S K[ ~
HCC
K~* HCC
5 O m [S ~ K~ )N * [S C m $4; K~ S V [S K~ C C A X* C@@* S 3* = S J I~*K~ O K~ K Ag* T @x^m T* S >*
5 S K \* \{ V7 Bx K~v I{L I \ x [S1" O.* XO~ \ C S S* G~ 5* B~ C C G~ 3* [S K~
* * C C S \m \ N \ E \* X* G~3* * 7!!!~!!!8!>;82
http://www.state.gov/s/d/2012/194682.htmhttp://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_MEMO-12-588_en.htmhttp://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_MEMO-12-588_en.htmhttp://www.state.gov/secretary/rm/2012/07/195782.htmhttp://www.state.gov/secretary/rm/2012/07/195782.htmhttp://www.state.gov/secretary/rm/2012/07/195782.htmhttp://www.state.gov/secretary/rm/2012/07/195782.htmhttp://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_MEMO-12-588_en.htmhttp://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_MEMO-12-588_en.htmhttp://www.state.gov/s/d/2012/194682.htm7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
28/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
29/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks; 8 " 2 ;2 .
J = 8;
@ O
354 O V \
L ;* ~ >;
IK@O ; 4 *
* *
~ ]Y ~
~
~ ~ 5; T
g ~ m N*
X Lm ; g
~ r
w 55
T*
~ m
w
T m
r ~m
m~ ~ m
*
~
~
q T ~
~
w
T~
54 C S* N7 @ O L*N O* U 2;* @ ;* S >* >4= OD~* V D~ L S A*N G{ I K S{* U 4* @ *
E~ * 4
5; \ O E \)E* ^ I K @ O7 D A~ C1* Vv{) \ L{{ V~ L* X* O 8*
55 T D L
C~ M K G H C) I K* T* @ 3* >* 7!!m!\U>^ON
~
S g r
~m N O S
~
~ ~
1 L~
~
~ " ~ .*
~ m
1 N ~
~* * r*
K~1 C )
r * "~
. Tm~ 1 B
) * ~
r*
1
N * ~ *
O
w
S
m ~
* m
~ w ~
*
w
w O
T K~
~
)~ *
* ~ N
w
g* * )
http://go.worldbank.org/0R2V9YA0I0http://go.worldbank.org/0R2V9YA0I0http://go.worldbank.org/0R2V9YA0I0http://go.worldbank.org/0R2V9YA0I07/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
30/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h
8 S II* N~ E @ O \* TH{* O 5*
8 G B~ J D* H E) H DV~ I S U* T H{* G 2*
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
31/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks* 4);
85 S D* C J* I Cm* T~ M B\ J~ D C* X S G{* A 8*
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
32/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h
O * H S
@ O m
T [OK S O
g K~ _
J~ T
~ I
g
~ T [OK* *
$3
Im* 3*
K~
88 N V O H7 D V C* H{ @x*I 8*
82 D V C X I L* NT* L{ N I K* G~ 5*
8> ^ T* O N Er I* K~ CD* T X S G{* G *
K~ ~2
N * S K~
$ r
$3; ~ I* G *
S O $43 g
K~ $8;
*
$;
2 _ J~
H*
T
2
N * HCC
) )
T M E O
K D* O D E
D* S E
D*
O I~ E* N
Lm D* O Lm
K D O
~ m HCC N~
~* w )
O N
S~*
~ ~ * ~
m )
w X
m ~
* * *
*
qm)r * m
2 SS O)_* X K~ @ V \ T [OK1* H{ @x* G 8*
2 SS O)_* @~ D7 \ L1*K~v Nv* G ;*
2 _* T S N O* H{ T* G~4*
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
33/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks
* N N E
m) $; ~ ;
L ~ m) r
$ ) [OK
m $3 2 $>
N M* N I~E
r
r ~ 8*
~
25 L
M 4
~ ~
2; T
q ~
~
I M q
2; S B* T C C)\ HCC*E V~* I~ 3*
25 T O* NIE T M C S \m\ A A I~* T @* I~ 8*
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
34/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h ; )3* $3; ~ >)328
T ~
~ ~
~ m~
~
~ m
~
N
w ~*
m r
~ ~
N * ~
~ m
~
*
m ~
22
\ q ~
~
~
) B* ~
*
A~
H *
q
T
[OK* ~
q~ ~
*
~
2> O G~ *
28 M C [* M V [D* B{ V{ L* O *
22 S B* T C C)\ HCC*
2> I S* BCT V J S~ \ B* T@* S 8*
;
[OK
m q
~
A ~ m )O S
H* g
@ O T
w m ~
m ~ r )
~ N *
O S*
* g*
~> N w
w
S O*
L A*
[OK
H
N * * ~ HCC
m
~ T ~
~
S O* A* M*
m~ m
S O* *
C V
~* A* S
_
m* *
) S
N M* m
~
O)S
> M C [* H S7 S S E O S* Av D~* O ;*
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
35/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks T
I L K~
S O _*
\~ ~ O Gw ~
B
^ ~
O O S* L
q* HCC
K~
O HCC *
O
~ ~
q
O~
H
K @ O
V ~
H
T* ~m
w ~ @
O* T
> D H Cr* H{ S @x* U35* @ >5* G * * 3
q ~ H S ~ r O S*
~ )m K
~ m @ O
N ~ m ~
) ~
@ O I
~
K H
@ O T
T
~
@ O O
~
~ *
)
~ ~ T
* ~ J~ m
r _ N
*
*
* ~*
~
T* ~m
I T
= g
~)=
rw C
HCC
~ K[ )
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
36/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h
~ * r*
S~* K
H
~ qm) g
~
T m J~*
r
* T K~*
A
~ I*
r m
w
* * N
r r
) *
~ ~ *
~ r~
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
37/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks36
\ktbn`mn`h tbk \ajk ae N`tk|`otna`oj Octa|s
S O D
*
7
O S ~ *
r *
O* *
T
* ~ * ~ [ S
K [ E *
r
~
X O N * H C
C "HCC.* S O* [
O K "[OK.* _*
~ ~
E *
~ O S*
* T
~ ~ *
T N K~* J~* ^*
S~ r ~ * * ~
T 2)~ K~ ~
w*
~
* *
* ~
~ T [ S r
K~
X
$3 ~ *
K~ * A
K~ S~ m
~))~ *
[S S~ D
\ H E I B T*
K~
X m * X
X
~
* * ~*
w B* K~ )X
[ S ~*
7 ~ K~*
~ A 2 ~*
m Im
m~ [ S N "
Im ~ B.
X T
K~ ~ * q
*
T
~* J~*
@OTA ~ q
I H B* HCC
)~ w I 2* *
~ S~* m J~*
q ~
E * ~
N S~ *
" S~ @ C
~ D
.> I*
O O S q r
S O
[ S* [~* HCC) S
> T S~ @ C C E [@ N) C~ T N~ K O S W V C S~* S~ @ C*D * * 7!!~!!)!!8
4Ajd E|nk`ds* @kx @knhbla|baad7 Tbk [`ntkd Stotks*tbk HCC* o`d tbkn| \ksva`sks ta tbk O|ol Sv|n`hSbodn Boind
http://www.syriancouncil.org/en/press-releases/item/127http://www.syriancouncil.org/en/press-releases/item/127http://www.syriancouncil.org/en/press-releases/item/127http://www.syriancouncil.org/en/press-releases/item/1277/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
38/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h 3?
O Ia|k I{sc{jo| Ea|knh` Vajnc~
T r
HCC ) O
~
[ S T
A HCC* ~
S O*
~ ~ B Im>3 E
S* Im K~
~ V Im
N V
~* ~*
~ E q m S O* ~
Im *
* S O
T [ S*
* ~
* ) ~
r H I *
[ S HCC ~
B* O *S O [ S
~ * *
~ O
L
N I * [ S m
m
S) N m*
[S O S~ S G~ E
>3 T * m HCC)* _r X _ ~ HCC * m ) S O HCC H)~* _ )~ * K~ T N _ m N* ) m ~ T * J~ S~* HCC * _*
L >4
T S* g* [S
HCC V S E q
N [S * S
O
~
m T *
*
S O [OK ~ *
r* N*
m X
[ S
L ~ * S
N S w
H N * * r
*
m* m
L N
O M O ~ * S
O S L
>; T ~* w
S K ~
N *
~ ~* *
* q *
~
* [OK*
r N )N
w
T [ S* m H *
m~ ~
* * *
>4 I A~* L7 L [ S SO* C C~* O 4*
>; IS N~m* MH J* IK AB* LB~ Lm A E V~* X* LmN V* * ;5
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
39/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks35 T ~
~ H
C ~ [S
1 T [ S* ~ *
~ ~ ~ O I N~m* M J* I
AB 7 ]T S O
[OKY r ~
[ S= m m *
*
O
~>8 N I~ * @ A* S
*
~ T X
V
[S)S >2 A
X ] NY
~ m
m ~ ~ ~
X* m
~
V ~ ~
T HCC ~
N
"
>5 E V A )
~ O * S B* VwD~7 B @r V S \ [S V~ I K* Cv 8 IS N~m* MH J* IK AB* LB~* * 42
>2 @ A* O O S* [S)S S* TX V* I~ 5*
~ m N. D
~ *
HCC
O @ Vm * H
~ ~ ~
>>
T O
H
T N
[S
H C C
E* HCC $
m A L N
m )~ w J~
[ S * _ [OK
g I* S~* S O*
_ ~
S~
O
T HCC*
J~* * *
H [ S [
r \~ D
3 HCC S N O 2* *
V S )E* S *
7 N ~*
r HCC ~
~ ~
w
X r HCC ~
*
>> @ Vm* T HCC7 H S N JC* JSK M{x V \ Vv* @ >*@ * 2
3 HCC S E S \~ D)* D * * 7 7!!!!!!3))))))~)
http://www.susris.com/2011/12/21/32nd-gcc-summit-final-statement-and-riyadh-declarationhttp://www.susris.com/2011/12/21/32nd-gcc-summit-final-statement-and-riyadh-declarationhttp://www.susris.com/2011/12/21/32nd-gcc-summit-final-statement-and-riyadh-declarationhttp://www.susris.com/2011/12/21/32nd-gcc-summit-final-statement-and-riyadh-declarationhttp://www.susris.com/2011/12/21/32nd-gcc-summit-final-statement-and-riyadh-declarationhttp://www.susris.com/2011/12/21/32nd-gcc-summit-final-statement-and-riyadh-declaration7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
40/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h 33
~ ~ ] Y ]Y
S *
*
* m A* S
I* _* *
~ ~* m~
)m ~ S O
~
~ *
* HCC ~
~
Tbk [`ntkd Stotks o`d tbk H{je
T [ S ~
H O O
S~ E
~ * A
L *
[S E
E I N I~ * [ S
L3 T A
S
)
T * ~* ~
L
X* * [S S~ D
\ H M O O 5*
S
O ~ L4 T
V S )E* T [ E* O 2** 7 7!!!!4!3!)))))))))
S ]>Y _ ~ HCC )
3 [S \ L O S D \ C*\{* I~ * S C Lm* [S S C L \* E V~ I KC* G~ 3*
4 IS N~m* MH J* IK AB* LB~* * ;8
L ~
[ S S
O * * [S
~
T [ S
H *
~ r
~ w r ~
T ~ [
S H ~
O N *
H m [S
N
O * [ S
~ [
O K* M* _ N G~ *
[ S
M $4 ~*
;
@* [
S H O
~ ~ T HCC
[ S
O *
HCC *
* ~ A
L S O r
m
G I* *
)X
N I~ * HCC r
g *
~ H T
C
H * G I ~
* q~
~ D
; T Sm* [S H O V I SO N Om* T @x ^m T* O 2*
http://www.susris.com/2012/04/30/toward-a-union-formula---prince-saud-al-faisalhttp://www.susris.com/2012/04/30/toward-a-union-formula---prince-saud-al-faisalhttp://www.susris.com/2012/04/30/toward-a-union-formula---prince-saud-al-faisalhttp://www.susris.com/2012/04/30/toward-a-union-formula---prince-saud-al-faisal7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
41/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks34
* I G m~ T *
HCC ~
)
) * *
O D
* HCC
$;
~* r
S
O ~
* *
~5
G I
G
) [S
* I )~ $5>2
I C C
[ S
S O ~
~ [S " K. ~
X [ S m I G *
~ m
S~
[S *
S O m E
~ * [S *
m N *
[S S
* ~ *
5 T H * ~ m O S Em~ ]Y 2 HCC HDV S N S \ Em~* J H T Sm* C N K L{*E~ 5*
q O
m~ q H
Tbk Ojj{|k ae H{je E{`dn`h
N~* [ S* ~
I
K * m HCC
K~* T* J~ S
* ~
m r [S E r* $8
m* S O $
K~ C Lm I~ 8
N ~ T* K~*
J~* H * ~*
~ " r.
* ~ m
L
~ "E r* K~
~ N*
S O ~ w . N r S
O [OK
~ I L
* L
~ "T
r D
K~ L
. B* ~ N
~* ~ m~
N H
~ * [S *
B* S O [OK
8 K~ $ S * \{* I~ *
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
42/44
Tbk HCC n` tbk Ikdntk||o`ko` n` Jnhbt ae tbk O|ol Sv|n`h 3;
w I G
w
Tbk Cbojjk`hk ae Ond Ca`dntna`ojnt~
N O
~ [S K[
O S~ J~
* X
*
*
^* HCC *
[ S
~ r 2 T
q O S
~ ~
* *
w O w
N [S K *
~*
~> T A
IK@O N E
K [ S V* \*
N H "SV\N@H.
~ "
~ .
T
* $3
~ T ~
r
2
E [S ~ O* S IN~* T E L O) E ^ 37 D~* H* B\ I K @ O* Vg IK D~ \v* G~
> S Sm S B* L N O)7 T V N S K~* T* J~*
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
43/44
Tbk Hk|io` Io|sbojj E{`d ae tbk [`ntkd Stotks35
S [S ~ ~ H *
~ C
\ X ~
* C \
~
[ S *
r* K O * H
~ [ S
[ S T [
S ~ ~
S O*
~ g S L
* w
N * *
S O HCC
~ [S H S~ J~* S O*
[OK* _ ~ g
T ~
[ S
I K
~ X * [ S
HCC* *
~ m
*
@* * [~* *
~ [S
w * ~
L* I*
G
7/30/2019 The GCC in the Mediterranean in Light of the Arab Spring
44/44
Aee n c k s