“THE QUESTION THAT DRIVES US…”

Theories to Guide our Thinking

“The Question That Drives Us”

What aspects of humanity make us human?FamiliarityOriginality/Individuality (i.e. “Uniqueness”)

Familiarity Things strike us as

strange when they are unfamiliar.

Personal example: My parent’s

reaction of looking like this for 5 years and then showing up one day looking like this.

Familiarity Quick write (2 minutes)

Describe a time when you were “weirded out” by something/someone that you thought you knew/understood.

Uncanny Sigmund Freud “[T]he uncanny is that class of the

frightening which leads back to what is known of old and long familiar.” Translation: For something to be “uncanny” there

must be something familiar about the unfamiliar thing that is scaring you.

I.e. My haircut was “uncanny” to my parents because I was recognizable, but it had been so many years since they had seen me with short hair that they associated my long hair with me, and forgot what I looked like without it.

Uncanny Valley

-Mori (Robotics)

Considering the Uncanny Valley

Reasons why—familiarity

Robotics and the Uncanny The idea is that

something that is clearly not human strikes us as normal Such as C3PO from

Star Wars. But something that

is nearly human (or was once human) is familiar and uncanny So a Prosthetic hand

= something semi-alive

Cyberpunk and the Uncanny Valley (What’s New?)

Cyberpunk Uncanny Terms Post-human: aka a “Cyborg”—Clynes and

Kline define Cyborg as “a self-regulating man-machine system, supposed to be more flexible than the human organism thanks to the fusion of organic and mechanical parts.”

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-pzSnE3IkTw

Cyberpunk Uncanny Terms Trans-human: The level of evolution

between human and post-human. This is the level seen as uncanny, as it is clearly not human, and yet it still looks eerily human. Examples:

Prosthetics Reconstructive Surgery

Prosthetic Robot

Plastic Surgery

Prosthetic Human

Understanding Check Questions?

Ranking Activity

One last thing… Looking back at “post human.” While clearly a cyborg, what did

Schwarzenegger look like? A HUMAN He was a “copy” of human life…

Had he come in fully clothed and not beat everyone up as he did, could he have passed for human?

Originality/Individuality Humans like to think of themselves as

unique Only creatures with higher order thinking Advanced Society

What happens to this perception when you add cyborgs to the picture?

What becomes the basis of “human?”

Originality/Individuality Ever tried to be like someone else? Personal Example Daren Patrick = Epic Fail

Couldn’t be like him physically Tried to be like him mentally

Liked what he liked Hated what he hated Etc. Etc.

Originality/Individuality Think-Pair-Share

Take a minute to think of a time where you copied something someone did/someone copied something you did/or an example that you observed in real life or in the media.

Share with a partner.

Simulacrum Plato: A copy of

something real (intended to be no more than a copy). Example: Reproduction

of Mona Lisa

Baudrillard: Not a just a copy of reality, but something that is real in its own right. Example: Disney World:

Cinderalla’s Castle

Simulacrum Paradox Jango Fett and His Clones

Simulacrum Paradox Consider the following quote:

“They are totally obedient, taking any order without question. We modified their genetic structure to make them less independent than their original host.” (Prime Minster of Kamino, Star Wars Ep II)

Question: The clones are now different from their original. No longer an attempt at being an exact copy (like the Mona Lisa reproduction)—are they still an imitation of their host’s life, or are they now their own separate life form. Agree or Disagree.

Simulacrum Paradox In the first Terminator movie, the Terminator model

T-800 is sent to kill Sarah Connor. In the second Terminator movie, the same Terminator model is sent to protect John Connor, Sarah Connor’s son.

Question: The Terminator model is identical, yet they have been programmed with different functions. However, they are still identical entities because the way in which they function (shoot, kill, obey instructions programmed with, etc.) remains the same, regardless of their functions being different. Agree/Disagree.

Simulacrum Paradox Thirty years from now, I am able to buy

organically grown body parts on a mainstream market. One day, I feel like I want to be taller and stronger, so I go and purchase longer legs and burlier arms.

Question: Even though these body parts belonged to someone else, because I have now incorporated them as part of my body they are now distinctly mine, and I am still a completely “original” individual. Agree or Disagree.

Closing Argument Looking at Cyberpunk’s central question

of “What aspect of humanity makes us human,” consider the following question:

Is there such a thing as a truly “original” human? Defend your answer.