32
Aaron Lapinski

Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

  • Upload
    linus

  • View
    73

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Aaron Lapinski. Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds. Purpose. To prove to Industry that using a temperature controlled mold helps improve cycle consistency and part dimensions. Goals. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Citation preview

Page 1: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

Aaron Lapinski

Page 2: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

To prove to Industry that using a temperature controlled mold helps improve cycle consistency and part dimensions

Page 3: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

To determine how a temperature controlled aluminum mold and non-temperature controlled Ren Shape mold of the same dimensions will affect shrinkage of a thermoformed ABS part.

To gain experience on the set up and operation of the industrial scale MAAC thermoformer

To develop a thermoforming lab experiment on the MAAC thermoformer for student education in Pennsylvania College of Technology’s BPS program.

To demonstrate to the thermoforming industry that a temperature controlled mold is essential for maintaining consistency in the finished product.

Page 4: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

MAAC ThermoformerREN MoldAluminum temperature controlled

moldCirculator

Sterlco VISION 4410-C 250°F max temp

 

Hardness Density Density Tensile Compressive Compressive Modulus Flexural Flexural Glass Coefficient

Colorg/cc lbs/ft.3 Strength Strength Elasticity (psi) Strength Modulus Trans. Thermal      psi psi   psi psi Temp (°F) Expansion                  (in/in/°F)

Ren Shape 472 81 0.88 55 7,000 10,900 460,000 9,540 416,000 248 25.8 x 10-6 Lt. Gray

Page 5: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

Spartech ABS Amorphous Terpolymer .125 x 40 (W) x 22.5 (L) inches Premium Grade Natural Polished Finish

Page 6: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

Sheet temperature 285-400of 340oF

Circulator settings 175-215oF 200oF

De-molding temperature 180-190oF

Page 7: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

Dry ABS 180°F 24 hours

Hang the Mold Placement Center

Form partsCollect DimensionsPerform Mechanical Testing

Page 8: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

Turn on Main Power Turn on Air Turn on Vacuum Turn on Fume Hood Enter MAAC software

PC62 Log in

Load or Build Program

Choose set up Turn on Vacuum

Pumps and Oven Index Clamps into

Oven on Diagnostics screen

Page 9: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

Remove preheated clamps from oven

Open clampsPlace sheetStart cycle

Page 10: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

Ren Shape Mold Production Trial

Aluminum Mold Production Trial

DOE

Page 11: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

TimersOvensEncoders I.R. EyeMAACFlex

Page 12: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

380°F55 Second Forming Time

Page 13: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds
Page 14: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

HumidityRoom TemperatureMold Temperatures

Front Back TopClamp Temperature

Sheet Temperature De-molding Molding

Page 15: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

B             8(Y1) 7(Y2) 6(Y3)

9 (X2) 5 (X2)

10 (X1) 4 (X1)

F             1(Y1) 2(Y2) 3(Y3)

Jig Dimensions

 Y Direction (MD) 15.875

X Direction (TD) 33.500

Mold Dimensions

 Y Direction (MD) 15.25

X Direction (TD) 31.125

Page 16: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

Mold Dimensions

 Y Direction (MD) 15.25

X Direction (TD) 31.125

Page 17: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

Mold Dimensions

 Y Direction (MD) 15.25

X Direction (TD) 31.125

Page 18: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds
Page 19: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds
Page 20: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds
Page 21: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

Run Cooling Time Circulator Temp I.R. Eye Temp

1 - - -2 - - +3 - + -4 - + +5 + - -6 + + -7 + - +8 + + +

  High Low

Cooling Time 100 40

Circulator Temp 205 170

I.R. Eye Temp 400 340

Page 22: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds
Page 23: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds
Page 24: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

HolesStuck to mold

Page 25: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

cost/hr ($)

# of hours

Number of sheets

cost per sheet

Material Cost n/a n/a 75 $40.00 $3,000.00 Mentor 50 20 n/a n/a $1,000.00

Consultant 50 10 n/a n/a $500.00 Labor 18 100 n/a n/a $1,800.00

Thermoformer cost 100 85 n/a n/a $8,500.00

Testing Equipment 100 15 n/a n/a $1,500.00

REN Mold Cost n/a n/a n/a n/a $3,800.00 Aluminum Mold

Cost n/a n/a n/a n/a $7,500.00

Total cost $27,600.00

Page 26: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

More Predictable dimensionsHigher mechanical propertiesShorter cycle times

Forming time from 100 to 55 seconds

Page 27: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

  Ren Shape Aluminum

Heating Time (seconds) 120 120Forming Time (seconds) 100 55Ejection Time (seconds) 2 2

Remove and load next part 30 30Total (seconds) 252 207

Time saving (seconds)/Part 45Time saving (seconds) /24 hour

day 1080Extra Parts/day 4.3

Extra Parts/ 5 day week 21.4Extra Parts/20 day month 85.7Extra Parts/50 week year 1071.4

Cost ($) / Sheet $40.00Extra Production / Year ($) $42,857.14

REN Mold Cost $3,800.00 Aluminum Mold Cost $7,500.00

Total Profit $39,157.14

Page 28: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

Lack of KnowledgeMeasurement DeviceDryingGridsMold PositionCirculator Machine access

Page 29: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

To determine how a temperature controlled aluminum mold and non-temperature controlled Ren Shape mold of the same dimensions will affect shrinkage of a thermoformed ABS part.

To gain experience on the set up and operation of the industrial scale MAAC thermoformer

To develop a thermoforming lab experiment on the MAAC thermoformer for student education in Pennsylvania College of Technology’s BPS program.

To demonstrate to the thermoforming industry that a temperature controlled mold is essential for maintaining consistency in the finished product.

Page 30: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

Mr. Roger Kipp Mr. John Bartolomucci Mr. Gary McQuay Mr. Howard Troup Mr. Todd Kennedy Mr. Todd Crismer Mr. Brett Braker Mr. Chris Denmon McClarin Plastics Inc. Spartech Plastics Tooling Technology KYDEX LLC.

Page 31: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds

  "Acrylonitrile, Butadiene and Styrene (ABS) - FormTight Plastic

Thermoforming." Custom Packaging - Clamshells, Food Packaging, Blister Packaging - FormTight Plastic Thermoforming. Web. 27 Oct. 2010. <http://www.formtightinc.com/materials/ABS/default.html>.

  "Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene." Wikipedia, the Free

Encyclopedia. Web. 27 Oct. 2010. <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acrylonitrile_butadiene_styrene>.

  "Acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene Copolymer (ABS) (chemical

Compound) -- Britannica Online Encyclopedia." Encyclopedia - Britannica Online Encyclopedia. Web. 27 Oct. 2010. <http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/4259/acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene-copolymer>.

  "ASTM D638 - 10 Standard Test Method for Tensile Properties of

Plastics." ASTM International - Standards Worldwide. Web. 24 Apr. 2011. <http://www.astm.org/Standards/D638.htm>.

Page 32: Thermoforming Mold Comparison: Temperature vs. Non -Temperature Controlled Molds