21
THINKING THINKING THROUGH THROUGH BHOPAL BHOPAL

THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

THINKINGTHINKINGTHROUGHTHROUGH““BHOPALBHOPAL””

Page 2: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

BHOPALBHOPAL

Page 3: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

BHOPALBHOPAL

Page 4: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

BHOPAL,BHOPAL,DECEMBER 1984DECEMBER 1984

Page 5: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

BHOPAL,BHOPAL,DECEMBER 1984DECEMBER 1984

Page 6: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

BHOPAL,BHOPAL,DECEMBER 1984DECEMBER 1984

Page 7: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

profiling profiling ““BhopalBhopal””

HISTORICAL CONTEXTHISTORICAL CONTEXT

1984,December 3

The BhopalDisaster

Page 8: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

profiling profiling ““BhopalBhopal””

CATALYSTCATALYSTfaith in the faith in the ““Green RevolutionGreen Revolution””

Page 9: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

profiling profiling ““BhopalBhopal””

CATALYSTCATALYSTpoor plant designpoor plant design

Page 10: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

profiling profiling ““BhopalBhopal””CATALYSTCATALYST

poor plant maintenancepoor plant maintenance

Page 11: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

profiling profiling ““BhopalBhopal””

IMPACTIMPACTstakeholder antagonismstakeholder antagonism

ßß Gas victimsGas victims

ßß Former plant workersFormer plant workers

ßß Union Carbide IndiaUnion Carbide India

ßß Union Carbide Corporation / DowUnion Carbide Corporation / Dow

ßß Government of IndiaGovernment of India

ßß Government of United StatesGovernment of United States

ßß Chemical communities around the worldChemical communities around the world

Page 12: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

profiling profiling ““BhopalBhopal””

IMPACTIMPACTcommunity activismcommunity activism

Page 13: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

““profiling Bhopalprofiling Bhopal””

IMPACTIMPACTmobilization of womenmobilization of women

Page 14: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

profiling profiling ““BhopalBhopal””

IMPACTIMPACTinternational activist coalitioninternational activist coalition

International Coalition for Justice in Bhopal

Page 15: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

profilingprofiling ““BhopalBhopal””

IMPACTIMPACTthe the ““right-to-knowright-to-know””

Page 16: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

profiling profiling ““BhopalBhopal””

IMPACTIMPACTcomparative understandingcomparative understanding

www.scorecard.org

Page 17: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

profiling profiling ““BhopalBhopal””

IMPACTIMPACT““worst-case scenariosworst-case scenarios”” and and ““chemical securitychemical security””

Page 18: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

profiling profiling ““BhopalBhopal””

IMPACTIMPACTadvocacy projectsadvocacy projects

SAMBHAVNA CLINIC

Page 19: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

profiling profiling ““BhopalBhopal””

IMPACTIMPACTadvocacy projectsadvocacy projects

Rashida Bee &Champa Devi Shukla

Bhopal gas leaksurvivors and winnersof the 2004 GoldmanPrize

Page 20: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

profiling profiling ““BhopalBhopal””

IMPACTIMPACTadvocacy projectsadvocacy projects

http://www.studentsforbhopal.org

Page 21: THINKING THROUGH “BHOPAL” - University of Chicagocis.uchicago.edu/.../04summerwkshp/KFortunBhopalSlides2004.pdf · profiling “Bhopal” IMPACT need for systemic ethics Requiring

profiling profiling ““BhopalBhopal””

IMPACTIMPACTneed for systemic ethicsneed for systemic ethics

Requiring changesRequiring changes……in policy (local, national, international)?in policy (local, national, international)?in legal systems?in legal systems?in media coverage?in media coverage?in the way political decisions are made?in the way political decisions are made?in the way organizations function?in the way organizations function?in the way people behave?in the way people behave?in the way people think?in the way people think?in educational systems?in educational systems?in the way technology is designed and used?in the way technology is designed and used?in the material, biological world?in the material, biological world?