Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 1
Urban Underground Space and Benefits of Going Underground
Jean-Paul GODARDPast Vice-President, ITA
France
World Tunnel Congress 2004 and 30th ITA General Assembly
Singapore, 22-27 May 2004
ITA OPEN SESSION
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 2
The Urban Problems
• 3 Billions in 2003 – 5 Billions in 2030• 50% of the World’s Population in 2007• Will double in 38 years• Mainly in less developed regions• Very slow in the more developed regions
(1) Growth of the Urban Population
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 3
The Urban Problems(2) Allocating the « Urban Space »
to the various urban functions
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 4
The Urban Problems(2) Allocating the « Urban Space »
to the various urban functions
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 5
The Urban Problems(3) Necessity of favouring
economic development
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 6
The Urban Problems(4) Pressures on the urban environment
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 7
The Urban Problems(5) Impacts on global environment
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 8
The RELATIONSHIPbetween the CITY and its
UNDERGROUND SPACE
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 9
The Relationship between the City and its Underground Space
(1) Immediate underground level or « sub-surface »
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 10
The Relationship between the City and its Underground Space
(2) Deep level or « underground »
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 11
The Relationship between the City and its Underground Space
(3) The reliefs
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 12
BENEFITSresulting from the use of the
URBAN UNDERGROUND SPACE
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 13
UndergroundSpace
Characteristics
Protection
Opacity
Space
Containment
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 14
BENEFITSas regards
LAND USEAND LOCATION PROBLEMS
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 15
Benefits as regardsLAND USE AND LOCATION PROBLEMS
PARIS – « AUBER » Station – RER Line A
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 16
Benefits as regardsLAND USE AND LOCATION PROBLEMS
SYDNEY – Underground Opera House car park
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 17
Benefits as regardsLAND USE AND LOCATION PROBLEMS
PARIS Metro – « Meteor » Line 14
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 18
Benefits as regardsLAND USE AND LOCATION PROBLEMS
« Separate conflicting transport activities »
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 19
Benefits as regardsLAND USE AND LOCATION PROBLEMS
PARIS – Several levelsof transport facilities
below the « Nation » Square
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 20
BENEFITSas regards
ISOLATION
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 21
Benefits as regards ISOLATION(1) Climate
The « Santa Claus Village » on the Arctic Circle - Finland
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 22
Benefits as regards ISOLATION(1) Climate
Underground storage facilities- Kansas City - USA
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 23
Benefits as regards ISOLATION(2) Earthquakes
Kobe earthquake – Japan - 1995
Severe damage to the City Hall Almost no damage to the underground shopping mall
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 24
Benefits as regards ISOLATION(3) Noise and vibration
Church in the rock – Helsinki - Finland
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 25
Benefits as regards ISOLATION(4) Multi-purpose
service tunnels
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 26
BENEFITSas regards
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 27
Benefits as regardsENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
(1) Aesthetics
Car park in Marseilles - France
BEFORE AFTER
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 28
Benefits as regardsENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
(2) Public utilities
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 29
Benefits as regardsENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
(3) Traffic tunnels
The « Central Artery » - Boston - USA
BEFORE AFTER
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 30
Benefits as regardsENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
(4) Underground car parks
Underground car park below a schoolyard – Stockholm - Sweden
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 31
BENEFITSas regards
TOPOGRAPHY
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 32
Benefits as regardsTOPOGRAPHY CONSTRAINTS
Metro Line crossing the « Butte Montmartre » - Paris
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 33
The Trans-Tokyo Bay Highwyay
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 34
Benefits as regardsTOPOGRAPHY CONSTRAINTS
« 3D Planning »
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 35
How to getMORE BENEFITS
from the use of theURBAN UNDERGROUND SPACE ?
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 36
How to get more benefits from the use of the urban underground space ?
(1) Safety, psychological and health aspects
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 37
How to get more benefits from the use of the urban underground space ?
(2) Protection of the underground environment
Paris - Catacombs Paris – « Grand Louvre »
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 38
How to get more benefits from the use of the urban underground space ?
(3) Relations between underground structures and the ground surface
Paris – Metro Line 1 in Neuilly Lyon – Portal of the Fourviere Tunnel
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 39
How to get more benefits from the use of the urban underground space ?
(3) Relations between underground structures and the ground surface
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 40
How to get more benefits from the use of the urban underground space ?
(3) Relations between underground structures and the ground surface
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 41
How to get more benefits from the use of the urban underground space ?
(4) Construction techniques
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 42
Paris - Champs Elysées Avenue
Maintaining treesduring the construction
of an underground car park
How to get more benefits from the use of the urban underground space ?
(4) Construction techniques
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 43
Construction disruption with Cut & Cover methods
How to get more benefits from the use of the urban underground space ?
(4) Construction techniques
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 44
How to get more benefits from the use of the urban underground space ?
• Site investigation• Location and features of existing underground
structures, facilities and public utilities• Economical considerations• Assessment of the projects• Risk analysis
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 45
Risk analysis• Financial risks
• Public acceptance for the facility
• Changed ground conditions
• Construction risks
• Contractual risks
• Environmental risks
• Risks in operation
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 46
Criteria for an optimum useof Urban Underground Space
Source : R.Sterling & J-P.Godard
• Take into account the needs of the Community• Maximize the benefits from the use of the
underground as developable space• Reinforce the positive features of the surface urban
environment• Make the most effective use of the features and
properties of the geologic setting• Design for « sustainability » in the use of the
subsurface space
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 47
FromUrban Underground Space
Usetowards
Urban Underground Space Development
ITA Open Session - Singapore - 25 May 2004 48
Expanded Use of Underground Space
Henard’s Project - France (1903)
Urban Underground Space Development