Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    1/44

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    2/44

    ARC H

     

    VOL. 34 , NO.3

    2 6

    ONTENTS

    1

    Straight and Level

    by Geoff Robison

    2 VAA News

    4

    Aeromail

    6 A Silver Eag le

    Part II - Hightlights of 1930

    A

    biography

    of

    E.

    M.

    Matty Laird

    by Robert

    G.

    E

    ll

    io

    tt

    and

    Ed Esca ll

    on

    2

    Type Clubs to Oshkosh

    Row after row after row

    by Tim Fox

    4 Din

    nd

    orf, Doolittle, & Their Stinson

    Nearly lost to the ages, a historic airplane makes a comeback

    by Budd Davisson

    20 54 Days With

    the Blue

    Pho

    enix

    [s

    it

    an

    end, or a begi

    nni

    ng?

    by Gl

    en

    Scott

    25 Pass I t to Bu ck

    Here's the dri

    ll

    by Buck Hilbert

    26 100

    Years

    at Huffman Prairie

    The Wrights' home

    fie

    ld advant age is celebrated

    by Scotty Markl

    and

    28

    Books a

    nd

    Movie Review

    by H.G. Fra utschy

    32

    The Vin

    ta

    ge Ins

    tructor

    CRM

    by Doug Stewart

    STAFF

    E

    Publisher Tom Poberezny

    E Editor·in·Chief Scott Spangler

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    3/44

    GEOFF

    ROBISON

    PRESIDENT, VINTAGE AIRCRAFT AS

    SO

    CIATION

    V

    ging

    ircr ft

    propos l

    By

    now a large segment

    of

    our

    membership

    has had an opportu

    nity

    to review

    the proposed

    aging

    aircraft initiatives developed by EAA

    and the Vintage Aircraft Association

    (VAA). Most would certainly agree

    the

    time

    is

    upon

    us

    to

    recognize

    the

    need for some resolution to these

    long-term issues. The intent here

    is to create a new,

    optional

    aircraft

    certification category

    that

    will give

    owners

    and their mechanics the

    ability to maintain vintage aircraft

    using

    safety-based

    forms,

    with

    fit

    and function

    criteria,

    as

    opposed

    to

    unavailable

    or outdated type

    certificate data.

    Contrary

    to some

    misinformed

    opinions

    I've heard, it

    is no t an

    owner

    maintenance pro

    gram like the

    one

    in Canada.

    Within 24 hours of the announce

    ment

    of this initiative we began

    to

    hear from

    the

    membership

    and

    rep

    resentatives of the various type clubs.

    Some

    of

    the immediate concerns we

    heard: "What is the potential impact

    on the value of my aircraft?" "What

    impact can I anticipate from my in

    point,

    but

    I believe these concerns

    can be sufficiently addressed in an

    appropriately structured rule.

    We

    probably

    all know of at least

    one

    restoration project

    in our

    in

    dividual

    regional area

    th a

    t has se

    rious

    issues

    because of

    the

    lack

    of

    available data

    to

    get it restored and

    signed off for flight , not to

    men

    tion

    those aircraft

    that

    will remain

    EAA/VAA

    proposed initiative

    will be

    presented

    at the aging aircraft

    public meeting on

    March 22-23 in

    Kansas City,

    Missouri

    in "basket"

    status until the

    owner

    has at least some assurance

    that

    his

    or her monetary resources and per

    sonal efforts will

    not

    be wasted .

    We

    have

    also

    heard some great

    Click on 2006 - 02/08 -

    EAA

    Set to

    Advance Vintage Aircraft Proposal

    Next Month.

    This jOint EAA/VAA-proposed ini

    tiative will be presented at the aging

    aircraft public

    meeting

    on

    March

    22-23

    in

    Kansas City,

    Missouri

    .

    The proposa l, which conceptually

    met with approval by key

    mem

    bers

    of the FAA

    management

    team

    during

    the

    EAA/FAA

    Recreational

    Aviation

    Summit, was presented

    Tuesday,

    February

    7, in

    Washing

    ton,

    D.C.,

    to representatives

    from

    the

    National

    Air

    Transportation

    As

    sociation (NATA), General Aviation

    Manufacturers Association

    (GAMA),

    Professional Aviation

    Maintenance

    Association (PAMA), Aircraft Own

    ers

    and

    Pilots Association (AOPA),

    the

    Aircraft Electronics Association

    (AEA),

    and others.

    In

    other

    news,

    the

    VAA

    was

    deeply saddened to hear

    of the

    re

    cent death of

    Daryl Lenz

    in

    a traffic

    accident near his home. Daryl served

    as the director

    of

    aircraft

    mainte

    nance

    at

    the

    Kermit

    Weeks

    Han

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    4/44

    Lawrence to Speak

    on

    Aging

    Aircraft

    EAA Vice

    President of Industry and

    Regulatory

    Affairs

    Earl

    Lawrence will

    speak at a two-day public meeting

    on

    aging aircraft, scheduled for March

    22-23 in Kansas City, Missouri. The

    meeting will emphasize what can be

    done to mitigate the effects of fatigue,

    corrosion, and deterioration

    on

    aging

    general aviation airplanes.

    PartiCipants will share informa

    tion, resolve questions, and discuss

    potential

    solutions

    regarding

    the

    continued airworthiness of older

    GA

    airplanes. The current fleet average is

    approximately 35 years old and will

    increase to

    SO

    years old by 2020.

    Vintage Aircraft Association Ex-

    ecutive Director H.G.

    Frautschy

    also plans to share expertise at the

    meeting, which

    is

    slated to begin at

    8 a.m. each day, with registration at

    8 a.m. on March 22.

    Individuals may submit a request

    to present a statement at the meet

    ing.

    If

    unable to attend, either mail

    a

    statement to FAA

    Small Airplane

    Directorate, FAA Central Region, At

    tention: Mr. Marv Nuss, 901 Locust,

    Room 301, Kansas City, MO 64106,

    or e-mail marvin.nuss@{aa.gov. 

    VAA Board Members Retire

    Bob Brauer, of Chicago, Illinois,

    and Roger Gomoll, of Blaine, Min

    nesota, decided to step down from

    the

    VAA

    board last year, and during

    V

    Ques

    ti

    on

    of

    the

    onth

    Q

      fly a neat old biplane, and sometimes need to extend my day

    a bit on the trip home. y take on the required lights needed for

    : ~ y i n

    at n i ~ t

    are position lights plus an anti-collision light,

    eIther a rotating beacon and/or strobes. My friend says antiques are

    grandfathered in here and that they don't need anything but position lights.

    Can you shed some, er light, on this subject?

    A

    An

    Antique

    Flier

    (the airplane, not the pilot )

    : Antiques and classics are definitely reqUired to have an

    anti-collision lighting system as well as navigation lights if they want to

    fly at night . The only grandfathered part

    is

    they have to meet the ear

    lier requirements for the placement and coverage of the anti-collision

    beacon, rather than having to meet the most current requirements. It

    basically comes down to having a strobe or rotating beacon on either

    the

    top

    or

    the bottom

    of

    the

    aircraft (belly, tip of

    the

    vertical, or wher

    ever); that s sufficient for aircraft that wete type-certificated before April

    I, 1957. These aircraft

    can t

    get by without

    anything

    or just position

    lights, but they don t need as extensive a system as a more modern air

    plane would need.

    Since

    you

    asked,

    here s

    a

    bit

    more

    on requirements

    for flying at

    night:

    CFR

    4

    Part

    91 205

    c)

    Visual flight rules (night). For

    VFR

    flight

    at

    night,

    the

    following

    in

    struments

    and equipment

    are required:

    1)

    Instruments and equipment specified in paragraph (b) of this section.

    2) Approved pOSition lights.

    3)

    An approved

    aviation

    red

    or

    aviation

    white

    anti-collision light

    system

    on

    all U.S .-registered civil aircraft. Anti-collision

    light

    systems

    initially installed after August 11, 1971,

    on

    aircraft for which a type cer

    tificate was issued or applied for before August 11, 1971,

    must

    at

    least

    meet

    the anti-collision light standards of

    part

    23, 25, 27, or 29 of this

    chapter, as applicable, that were in effect

    on

    August 10, 1971, except

    that the color may be either aviation red or aviation white. In

    the

    event

    of failure of

    any

    light of

    the

    anti-collision light system, operations with

    http:///reader/full/marvin.nuss@%7Baa.govhttp:///reader/full/marvin.nuss@%7Baa.gov

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    5/44

    nance chairman for many years. For

    well more than a decade, Bob worked

    with Roger's father, the late Stan Go

    moll, as they kept the VAA's build

    ings in good repair and oversaw the

    updating of some structures on the

    VAA grounds. He's worn a number of

    hats as chairman, including co-chair

    of the Parking committee

    and

    he

    served for more than a decade as the

    board's point of contact man for

    VAA

    Chapters and the EAA Chapter Office.

    Bob was asked to come on board as

    an adviser to the

    VAA

    board in 1986,

    and became a director in 1988, a po

    sition he held until his retirement in

    the summer of 200S. Bob is still ac

    tive

    as

    a volunteer, and if you make it

    to any of the VAA work parties during

    this spring, he'll be happy to find you

    some work to

    do

    Roger

    comes

    by

    his

    work

    for

    VAA naturally;

    his father, Stan,

    was a longtime

    board member

    and

    active

    vol

    unteer who

    en-

    couraged his

    son's love of avi

    ation. Roger has served

    EAA as

    a vol

    unteer for

    many

    years, including his

    time at

    EAA's

    Pioneer Airport, where

    Roger can

    often

    be

    found

    grinning

    as

    he gives another ride

    to

    a paying

    customer

    in

    EAA's

    Travel

    Air

    biplane.

    Appointed to the VAA board after his

    father's untimely passing, Roger has

    been right in the thick

    of

    things, serv

    ing as

    the

    Type Club chairman,

    and

    during

    the

    year he served

    the

    board

    atnIP.nrHM_nrtl for complete details.

    M AlrVenture

    Planning Guide

    What

    Do

    You

    Want

    t

    Know

    Forums and

    workshops

    te ch aviation

    A wise man once said, If it has

    Once you've made the decision

    to

    attend

    EAA

    AirVenture Oshkosh

    2006, you can't

    just

    wait for July,

    hop into the cockpit, and show up.

    You need to start planning, and

    now

    A great way to start is by download

    ing the

    EAA

    AirVenture 2006 Plan

    ning Guide, now available at www

    airventure.org.

    The

    handy document includes es

    sential information about admission,

    lodging, driving directions, commer

    cial flights, vehicle rental, ground

    transportation services, and a lot

    more. Get your copy today and start

    http:///reader/full/airventure.orghttp:///reader/full/airventure.org

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    6/44

    Helio ourier Notes

    If your Helio H-391-B, H-250, or

    H-295 has in excess of 3,600 hours

    and needs

    to

    be

    upgraded per

    Air

    worthiness Directive 82-16-08

    Amendment

    39-4427, parts are be

    coming an issue with older airplanes

    in

    the

    field.

    Several Helio owners have asked

    us recently about the availabil

    ity of

    new

    parts, the current

    own

    ers of Helio Aircraft.

    LLC

    are

    not

    presently manufacturing replace

    ment

    items

    such

    as

    leading-edge

    slats

    and

    wing

    carry-through

    as

    semblies. With the current fleet at

    around

    200

    airplanes, those

    older

    models that have 4,500

    hours

    plus

    are in need of replacement items.

    We

    can at this point direct you to

    rebuilders with an excellent reputa

    tion and knowledge in Helio Couriers

    based upon many years of experience.

    The following individuals

    and/

    or organizations

    may

    be of

    some

    assistance.

    JAARS Aviation

    Div.

    Jim Metzler,

    Head of

    Maintenance

    Waxhaw, North Carolina

    www jaars org 

    Aero Pacific

    Steve Murray

    Carlsbad, California

    760-931-0022

    A complete list of

    Helio

    main

    tenance personnel

    is

    to

    be

    made

    available March

    I,

    2006.

    For additional information visit

    www heliocourier net 

    International Young

    Eagles Day

    GIVING BACK

    EAA Vintage

    Chapter

    27

    in

    Delaware,

    Ohio

    (DLZ),

    is

    a small but busy

    group.

    Chapter 27

    had

    a very successful air show in August of 2004 and

    is

    planning another

    for August 2006.

    We

    also

    have

    a

    pancake

    breakfast

    on

    the third

    Saturday

    of

    each month

    from May through September.

    As

    a result, for the first time since the

    Chapter

    was organized in the early

    1990s, we have some assets in the bank.

    We

    wanted

    to give

    back to the community that has

    supported

    our

    organization. As

    a result,

    the

    city

    has

    donated land on

    the

    airport

    for

    us to build a shelter house to be available to the public and we have

    enclosed

    one end

    of

    it

    for the VAA kitchen for our pancake

    breakfast

    and

    meetings.

    Chapter 27

    and donations

    from local businesses have supported the

    shelter costs. The city

    assisted

    us with trusses and some heavy work,

    and

    our

    members

    have

    done the rest. We have

    had

    a lot of fun

    with the

    construction

    project and

    plan to

    finish

    the interior this

    winter and be

    ready in May for our pancake breakfasts.

    Sincerely,

    Roger

    R.

    Brown

    VAA

    Chapter

    27 President

    http:///reader/full/www.jaars.orghttp:///reader/full/www.heliocourier.nethttp:///reader/full/www.heliocourier.nethttp:///reader/full/www.heliocourier.nethttp:///reader/full/www.jaars.orghttp:///reader/full/www.heliocourier.net

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    7/44

    Friends of

    the

    Red Barn

    Campaign

    Many services are provided to vintage aircraft en

    thusiasts at EAA AirVenture Oshkosh. From parking

    airplanes to feeding people

    at

    the

    Tall Pines Cafe

    and

    Red Barn, more

    than

    400 volunteers do it all. Some

    may ask, If volunteers are providing the services,

    where

    is

    the expense?"

    Glad you asked. The scooters for the flight line crew

    need repair and batteries, and the

    Red

    Barn needs

    paint, new windowsills, updated wiring, and other

    sundry repairs, plus we love to care for

    our

    volun teers

    with special recognition caps

    and

    a pizza party.

    The

    list really could go

    on

    and

    on,

    but

    no matter how

    many expenses we can point out, the need remains

    constant . The Friends of the Red Barn fund helps pay

    for the VAA expenses at EAA AirVenture, and is a cru

    cial part of the Vintage Aircraft Association budget.

    Please help the VAA and our 400-plus dedicated

    volunteers make this an unforgettable experience for

    our many

    EAA

    AirVenture guests. We've

    made

    it even

    more fun to give this year, with more giving levels to

    fit each person's budget, and more interesting activi

    ties for donors to be a part of.

    Your

    contribution

    now really does make a differ

    ence. There are six levels of gifts and gift recognit ion .

    Thank

    yo u for whatever you

    can

    do.

    Here are some of

    th

    e many activities the Friends of

    the

    Red Barn

    fund

    underwrites:

    • Red Barn Informat ion Desk Supplies

    • Participant Plaques and Supplies

    Toni

    's Red Carpet Express Repairs and Radios

    • Caps for VAA Volunteers

    • Pizza

    Party for

    VAA

    Volunteers

    • Flightline Parking Scooters and Supplies

    • Breakfast for Past Grand Champions

    • Volunteer Booth Administrative Supplies

    • Membership Booth Administrative Supplies

    • Signs Throughout the Vintage Area

    • Red Barn and Other Buildings' Maintenance

    And More

    Th ank·

    You

    Items

    by Level

    Name Listed:

    Vintage, Web

    & Sign

    at

    Red

    Barn

    Donor

    Appreciation

    Certificate

    Access to

    Volunteer

    Center

    Special

    FORB

    Badge

    Two P

    asses

    to

    VAA

    Volunteer

    Party

    Special

    FORB

    Cap

    Breakfast

    at

    Tall

    Pines

    Cafe

    Tr i·Motor

    Ride

    Certificate

    Two Tickets

    toVAA

    Pi

    cnic

    Close Auto

    Parking

    Diamond,

    1,000

    X X X X X X

    2

    People

    /

    Full Wk

    2 Tickets

    X

    Full Week

    Platinum,

    750

    X X X X X X

    2 People/

    Full

    Wk

    2 Ticke

    ts

    X 2 Days

    Gold,

    500

    X X X

    X X

    X

    1

    Person

    / Full Wk

    1 Ticket

    Silver.

    250

    X

    X X X X X

    Bronze

    100

    X

    X

    X

    X

    Loyal Supporter,

    99

    &

    Under

    X X

    VAA

    Friends

    of the Red

    Barn

    Name

     

    EAA

    ____ VAA ___

    _

    Address  _

    City/State/Zip  __

     

    _

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    8/44

    PART

    II

    HIGHLIGHTS

    OF

    1930

    A

    biography of

    E

    .M. Matty

     

    Laird

    y ROBERT

    G

    ELLIOTT

    AND

    ED

    ESCALLON

    The highlight of 1930 proved to

    be the design

    and construction of

    the

    Solution

    racer,

    which

    became

    the first and only biplane to win the

    coveted

    Thompson

    Trophy

    Race

    for

    the fastest aircraft of the day. The

    Solution had been built in a record

    30 days

    and was completed just one

    hour before the race. In the follow

    ing year, Matty s newest racer, the

    Super Solution became

    the

    first air

    craft

    to win the

    new

    Bendix Tro

    phy, setting

    the

    trans-continental

    speed record of 11 hours, 15 min

    Matty and Elsie Laird enjoy

    their

    mountain

    retreat

    on the shores of Lake Tox-

    utes, under the capable pilotage of

    away North Carolina

    and sat

    momentarily for this photograph in July 1975.

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    9/44

    Laird

    Solution

    in which Speed Holman

    won

    the Thompson Trophy Race in 1930.

    This

    aircraft was 30 days old the day of the race having been

    completed

    about one hour

    before

    the race

    began

      allowing time

    enough

    for a

    short

    test hop and refueling

    due

    to a

    short

    postponement of the Thompson Race

    start.

    LEFT: Speed Holman.

    Full view

    o completed

    Laird Sesquiwing.

    of-a-kind Laird was

    not

    preserved

    instead of being destroyed.

    The middle '30s saw the develop

    ment of a huge airline

    industry

    in

    this country. Chicago became a ma

    jor airline hub and drew heavily on

    the aviation talent in the area. Many

    of Matty's employees went with the

    airlines during the lean year that en

    veloped the Laird Co., and a few are

    still involved in the

    management

    of

    this industry today.

    After a few years of

    operation,

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    10/44

    Photograph taken at

    the 1930

    Chicago

    National Air

    Races which

    were conducted at

    Curtiss-Reynolds Airport

    Chicago. Speed

    Holman is shown

    at

    right rounding

    a

    pylon

    in

    the

    Laird

    Solution. Upper

    center

    is

    what

    is

    believed to

    be

    the

    plane

    of Arthur Page  who

    was

    pulling out

    of

    the

    race. Page made

    a

    crash

    landing and died of injuries while Holman went

    continued into

    1937,

    when

    Roscoe

    Turner brought in two projects just

    two

    months

    before

    the

    National

    Air

    Races. They were his damaged

    We-

    dell-Williams

    and

    a partially com

    on

    to

    win the

    Thompson Trophy

    Race.

    ment with Roscoe.

    Obsolescence

    and

    technical problems

    prevented

    it from ever again placing in a ma

    jor event.

    Roscoe s second major project was

    built with

    the

    internal drag bracing

    lightened, and

    a greatly

    improved

    fuselage

    attach method

    was incor

    porated. Existing ailerons were used,

    with

    the

    flaps extended to cover the

    span added to

    the

    wing. The result

    ing loading of 50 pounds per square

    foot was

    among

    the

    highest used

    in

    aircraft at

    the

    time,

    and much

    tech

    nical

    comment centered

    about it.

    Actually,

    the

    wing

    turned

    out to be

    one of

    the really

    outstanding

    as

    pects of

    the

    racer,

    and

    its configu

    ration

    was widely copied

    in

    World

    War

    II

    fighters.

    Additionally, Matty added about

    a

    square foot

    to

    the elevator

    sur

    face

    area

    and completely outfit

    ted the

    fuselage

    structure almost

    from scratch. Larger fuel tanks

    than

    Brown

    had planned

    on using were

    included. In

    many

    respects

    the

    ren

    ovation

    of

    the

    Laird-Turner Racer

    was

    more

    difficult

    than building

    a

    completely new aircraft.

    When

    finished, a

    weight check

    confirmed Matty had

    eliminated

    more

    than

    400 pounds of weight just

    from

    the

    parts Brown had shipped

    him. The

    LTR 14

    was tested success

    fully

    and

    accepted

    by

    Roscoe,

    who

    proceeded to California in it on

    its second flight.

    In

    succeeding years the

    Laird

    Turner Racer served

    to change

    the

    fortunes of tough-luck Roscoe. Dur

    ing the

    1937

    Thompson,

    Roscoe,

    who

    was leading

    the

    race, was mo

    mentarily blinded by

    the

    sun while

    rounding

    a pylon. Turning back to

    re-circle

    the

    pylon, he lost his lead

    to

    Earl

    Ortman and

    Rudy Kling. In

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    11/44

    Jimmy

    Doolittle

    . _ . ~

    i

    n

    UJ

    ti

    >

    8

    /)

    5

    ::t:

    is

    congratulated

    by

    Ma

    tty

    Laird

    after

    winning

    the

    Bend

    ix Race 

    September

    1931.

    occasion

    had become Miss ham-

    pion

    This

    victory made him the

    only man to

    ever win the coveted

    Thompson Trophy three times. De-

    spite

    the

    credit

    due

    Matty, Roscoe

    never properly recognized

    him.

    Matty, however, never pressed

    the

    issue, saying, That 's just

    the

    way

    Roscoe was.

    Turner's victories plus

    those

    ear

    lier

    in

    the

    decades by the

    Solu

    tion

    and

    Super Solution gave Laird

    planes three first

    and

    two third

    places

    in

    the Thompson

    Races,

    one irst

    in

    the

    Bendix,

    and

    a trans

    continental and

    tri-Capitol speed

    record, in addition to at least

    a

    dozen different inter-city records.

    For a small civil-based aircraft fac

    tory,

    the E M

    Laird Co.

    had won

    a

    large share of

    the

    records

    and

    races

    of

    the

    '30s,

    due to the

    skill of

    the

    employees

    and the

    genius of E.M.

    Matty Laird.

    As

    this country's involvement in

    the

    World War

    II

    became more im

    minent,

    Matty

    realized

    i t

    was go

    ~ ~

    ~ ~ ~  

    Laird Turner

    on

    the

    line after

    being rebuiH

    by

    the E. fam

    il-

    iar Laird

    trademark on the tail

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    12/44

    successfully

    met

    the challenges of

    wartime

    materials

    shortages with

    a labor force

    consisting

    mostly of

    women

    .

    Although untrained,

    and

    faced

    with

    schedules

    that doubled

    every

    month

    , they rapidly grew into

    a skilled team

    under the

    able guid

    ance of Matty.

    His

    talents in produc

    tion were directed to the product ion

    of B-24 and

    SB2C

    vertical fins, com

    plete empennage groups for Martin

    B-26s,

    and numerous other

    items,

    such

    as

    wing flaps, radio cabinets,

    crew bunks, and de-icer

    tanks

    for

    the Martin

    PBM

    .

    Matty never

    had any

    interest in

    military aircraft, with the possible

    ex

    ception of building a trainer for

    the

    armed services.

    He

    had lost an early

    bid for a trainer in the Laird Swallow

    days, when Maj. Reuben Fleet, a pro

    curement officer

    for

    the

    Army,

    vetoed

    the purchase.

    Fleet

    later resigned from

    the Army and organized the Consoli

    dated Aircraft Co. , which received the

    verted engine

    that Continental

    was

    developing. In considering

    the

    cap

    italization costs involved that

    had

    doubled since the '30s, and know

    ing firsthand

    the boom-bust

    mar

    ket that followed

    the

    previous war,

    Matty

    decided

    to

    retire from the

    aviation business.

    An

    additional factor tha t prompted

    his

    decision

    was the fact

    that his

    daughter

    had

    contracted

    polio. At

    the

    time, the only known treatment

    was

    frequent immersions in warm

    water combined with physical ther

    apy. Consequently, Matty decided to

    move to a warmer climate, choosing

    Boca Raton, a small

    community on

    the lower east coast of Florida. There,

    he and

    his l

    ovely

    Elsie,

    whom he

    married in 1933, devoted themselves

    to raising their son and daughter.

    In later years the Lairds purchased

    some

    land in the

    Lake

    Toxaway

    area of

    North

    Carolina

    and

    built a

    home

    . The lake had been a million

    The Laird Speedwing

    olution

    (Pratt Whitney

    Wasp Junior

    engine)

    Winner First Place

    -Thompson

    Trophy ace-

    Chicago

    , Illinois, September 1, 1930

    Average

    speed

    201.91 mph

    for 100-mile race

    (20 laps around a

    5-mile

    course)

    Piloted

    y

    C.W.

    Speed

    Holman

    organization of pilots who made

    their

    first flight

    before December

    17, 1916. Matty also became active

    in the

    Connecticut

    Aeronautical

    Historical Association's restoration

    of

    the

    Solution beginning in 1964.

    He first became acquainted with

    the

    Florida Sport Antique

    and

    Clas

    sic

    Association at the Remuda Ranch

    Fly-In during

    November 1974,

    where he was

    an

    honored

    guest.

    There

    he

    joined

    the EAA.

    In recog

    nition of

    his many

    achievements

    prior

    to

    1940,

    Matty

    was awarded

    the

    coveted

    Silver Eagle

    member

    ship

    in

    the

    association. Since

    then

    the

    Lairds have been active in

    EAA

    ,

    being

    honored

    among

    the

    avia

    tion

    greats

    at

    Oshkosh, 1975,

    and

    appearing

    at

    many

    EAA

    functions

    throughout the

    state of Florida.

    His

    present

    work

    on

    EAA s

    res

    toration

    of the Super Solution has

    brought him back, full circle, to the

    work to which he began devoting his

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    13/44

    The

    2 6 Mercury

    Mariner

    Provides

    Hybrid Ingenuity

    with

    Premium

    Appeal

    The

    Mariner Hybrid is compact SUV that

    blends

    the

    best

    features

    of gasoline

    engine

    and an electric motor to achieve nearly

    50 percent higher city driving efficiency and lower emissions

    with no loss of functionality or performance.

    Mercury Mariner Hybrid is

    also

    the

    first

    full-hybrid premium

    compact SUV to be honored by Green

    Car

    Journal

    as "Green Car of the Year."

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    14/44

    H.G. FR UTSCHY

    D

    d you notice the rows of the

    same aircraft parked together

    at

    Oshkosh thi s year? There

    were Cessna 170s, Aeroncas,

    Taylorcrafts,

    and

    Swifts. Last year i t

    was Stinsons and Helio Couriers. Ever

    wonder

    how they

    all got to park to

    gether in such a great spot? It 's simple.

    The Vintage Aircraft Association

    provides a limited reserved parking

    area for type clubs. The type clubs are

    a part of Vintage activities, and year

    round

    they support their particular

    aircraft

    through

    activities such

    as fo-

    rums, chat rooms,

    and

    newsletters on

    topics that range from historic infor

    mation to the latest maintenance is-

    sues. Type clubs can be found during

    the convention in

    the

    large tent just

    BY TIM

    Fox

    VAA

    TYPE CLUB PARKING

    COORDI

    NATOR

    the members

    as

    well. Nothing is worse

    than doing all the work, planning, and

    publicity, only to have

    no

    one show up.

    It had been several years since the Stin

    sons had been in a group at Oshkosh,

    and the club directors were excited

    about the possibilities. You have to start

    early in your planning efforts, and we

    started right after Oshkosh 2003 with

    announcements in the club newsletter.

    This past year's type club groups were

    organized and had their spots set up

    before the end of 2004.

    You should estimate

    the

    attendance

    potential of

    your group

    so you

    can

    request space in the type club area.

    Space is limited, and to reserve space,

    VAA

    is looking

    for a solid commit-

    ment

    from

    your

    group. You should

    accommodate a few different types

    every year), the wingspan of the air

    craft, and a contact person who will

    be

    coordinating the

    event.

    Your re

    quest should be forwarded

    to VAA

    and they will forward it to the type

    club parking coordinator.

    lanning

    Several steps are necessary to en

    sure a successful

    event

    for your club.

    Developing interest and enthusiasm

    will ensure that you have a good turn

    out

    and provide a good

    time

    for all.

    Many

    of your

    members may have

    never been to Oshkosh or have not

    come for many years. Some

    may

    at

    tend

    every year

    but

    park randomly,

    and not with a group.

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    15/44

    for

    the

    event in every

    month's

    issue

    of the

    club newsletter. I

    wanted

    to

    be sure that all

    the

    pilots knew

    what

    was going to happen

    and

    what

    they

    could expect. It's important for pilots

    to make

    the commitment early so

    other summertime activities don't use

    up available leisure time. This

    can't

    be done on a last-minute basis. Also,

    when

    planned

    ahead, variables such

    as fuel costs, meals,

    and

    lodging do

    not playas big a role.

    Arrival

    Many

    of

    you

    have

    seen the large

    group

    arrivals

    of

    the Bonanzas and

    Mooneys. Almost all pilots come in

    through

    the

    normal NOTAM

    arrival

    from Ripon,

    but

    if your group is large

    enough, you may qualify for a special

    arrival. The type club parking coor

    dinator can help you find out if your

    group

    qualifies.

    With special type

    club parking reserved, how

    and

    when

    your group arrives does not matter, as

    they are assured that their parking is

    reserved together.

    Parking

    When

    most people arrive at Osh

    kosh

    they

    hold up placards that say

    VAC for

    vintage

    aircraft

    parking.

    They

    are

    directed to

    Papa

    taxiway

    and head south into

    the

    Vintage area.

    Once they arrive

    they

    are parked in

    the next available open spot,

    in

    rows

    going south. The sooner you get there,

    the closer you are to the action. As

    many

    of you know, a late arrival can

    find you closer to Fond du Lac than

    Oshkosh Type club reserved aircraft

    ter

    your aircraft, pay for camping if

    you're camping on the field,

    and

    get

    admission wris tbands for your stay.

    Shortly after your arrival and regis

    tration, Vintage volunteers will come

    out and take a picture

    of

    your plane

    and it will be placed on a participant

    plaque. This

    is

    available free

    to VAA

    members, courtesy of the Vintage Air-

    craft Association in the Vintage Red

    Barn Headquarters building.

    You

    are

    also entitled to a free participant mug.

    If

    you ask

    the

    participant plaque staff

    in the back of the hospitality center in

    the Red Barn, they can come out

    and

    take a special picture of you with your

    aircraft for

    the

    plaque. This plaque is

    available for all

    VAA participants at

    Oshkosh. While at the Red Barn you

    can check out the activities, browse

    the

    VAA

    store,

    or

    check

    out the

    type

    club

    and

    workshop tents.

    Activities

    This is

    the

    cornerstone of your type

    club event. Plan activities for

    your

    group. The type club parking coordi

    nator can help you with suggestions

    and

    arrangements for

    ground

    trans

    portation, restaurant reservations,

    or

    group activities. This should all be set

    up

    as

    soon

    as possible, as you

    need

    plenty

    of

    time

    to

    advertise

    in your

    club newsletter.

    If

    you're stuck for ideas on what to

    do, here's some good

    news-the VAA

    already has things scheduled that you

    can participate in as a group, such as

    the

    VAA

    picnic. It's a great

    time

    for

    your type club to get together and

    have dinner at

    the

    EAA Nature Center

    bus to transport everyone. The turn

    out

    was so large we had to charter

    an

    additional

    bus to handle the group

    Stinson owners from all over the field

    wanted

    to

    join in,

    and

    hopefully we

    gained some new membership. The

    type club rented a van so the mem

    bers

    had

    a way

    to

    travel into town to

    resupply and get items not available

    on field.

    With the heavy

    airspace

    traffic

    around Oshkosh

    and

    the

    problems of

    moving and parking aircraft, daily

    fly-

    outs are

    not

    encouraged, but

    on

    Satur

    day there is a fly-out to Shawano, Wis-

    consin, that your group can participate

    in. Shawano is approximately

    S

    miles

    north of Oshkosh, so it's a short flight.

    There is a signup list at

    the

    Vintage

    Red

    Barn,

    and

    a briefing is held early

    Saturday

    morning

    for

    participants.

    This is a

    great fl

    y-in hosted by the

    town,

    and they

    really enjoy

    the

    vin

    tage aircraft coming from Oshkosh. If

    you provide a list

    of

    your pilots

    they

    will send

    an

    invitation. All arriving pi

    lots get a free breakfast, ice cream, and

    some Wisconsin cheese. Of course,

    your parking places are saved back in

    Oshkosh, so you can leave your camp

    setup and come back at your leisure.

    There's really a lot for your group

    to

    do

    Parking within your aircraft group

    is fun and a learning experience. Com

    mon interests and experiences

    are

    shared by owners with the same type

    of

    plane. It's also

    an opportunity to

    look at other aircraft to

    see

    how things

    were done. It's any easy way to see what

    modifications may be available

    and

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    16/44

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    17/44

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    18/44

    time, a pilot leaves something behind

    in the airplane's soul. Tom Dinndorf

    of Baudette,

    Minnesota,

    is

    acutely

    aware of that,

    and

    he

    doesn't

    take

    the responsibility lightly.

    I've

    owned this airplane

    for

    over 30 years

    and

    carted its remains

    around

    to

    various

    locations as I

    moved, he said. Eventually, I re

    alized I

    wasn't

    going

    to

    get

    the

    air

    plane done in my lifetime, and that

    just wasn't right. lowed

    it

    to the

    airplane

    and to

    history

    to

    get it fin

    ished.

    Thank

    goodness I found Rod

    and

    Dottie Roy. They are the only

    reason the airplane is finished, and

    they should get all of

    the

    credit. 

    As

    Dinndorf got

    into

    the

    project,

    researching its history became a near

    obsession, but just as it's difficult

    to

    prove Washington Slept Here, it's

    often impossible to prove a given pi

    lot has flown a given airplane. Unless,

    could take a look at the logbooks

    and

    get back to him. I

    didn

    't expect

    him

    to

    drop

    what

    he was

    doing

    and

    search,

    but that

    was exactly

    what he

    did.

    He had

    me

    hold on while he

    got the logbook and

    thumbed

    back

    to

    August '38. He said,

    'Yes,

    on

    Au

    gust 13th it says 'acceptance flight,

    new Stinson, 15 minutes.' I can't tell

    you

    how

    that

    made

    me

    feel. Today, I

    have copies of all of Doolittle's Stin

    son log entries , and I periodically

    pull them out and look at them

    to

    convince

    myself the Doolittle con

    nection is real. It's

    almost

    scary to

    own and fly an airplane with that

    much history

    to

    it.

    Although

    the

    Stinson

    is

    a work of

    art today, it wasn't always

    that

    way. In

    fact, it has spent far more time in der

    elict and/or project condition

    than it

    did in flying condition.

    The last

    time

    the airplane flew,

    The luxurious front

    office

    of

    the tin-

    son

    and

    its massive control wheels  

    a thread: The dual vandals of weather

    and

    human

    nature can

    reduce

    an

    airplane in this situation

    to

    junk in

    nothing flat unless a savior rides over

    the horizon. NC21104 was lucky. Its

    savior was named Luke Youngren.

    Dinndorf

    said, In 1971 I heard

    about

    the

    airplane and thought I'd

    like to restore an antique. I went over

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    19/44

    this. I put the

    fu

    selage in my base

    ment shop and

    the wings in the

    garage, thinking

    I'd start

    restor

    ing it. I bought a

    compressor and

    sandblaster

    and

    started cleaning

    the fuselage and I

    think that's when

    the lights started

    coming

    on

    that

    this was going to

    be a much big

    ger project than I

    thought it

    was."

    Dinndorf had worked in his father's

    pharmacy as a youngster and, when

    he went to college, continued in that

    direction. Eventually

    he

    was in the

    manufacturing end of the pharma

    ceutical business and found himself

    leaving Minnesota for Atlanta.

    "I trailered the fuselage down be

    hind a little 2-liter Oldsmobile. We

    were so marginal

    on

    power that we

    couldn't run the air conditioner and

    climb even

    the

    slightest hill, so

    we

    just rolled

    the

    windows down and

    sweated all the way.

    When I got to Atlanta, life took

    over

    and

    I barely

    touched

    the air

    plane. It was sad. And I

    was

    getting

    really frustrated.

    Here

    I had this amaz

    ing historical artifact and I couldn't

    do anything with

    it "

    Life

    eventually

    seems to work

    things out, and after he moved back

    to Minnesota, he met Rod Roy and

    Roy's

    wife,

    Dottie. "I

    was

    at Oshkosh

    service FBO in

    that

    we do every type

    of maintenance except avionics. The

    restoration projects are part of that.

    His first rebuild project was the

    ratty C-140 he and Dottie had

    bought. We took it

    to

    Oshkosh

    as

    part of that 150 or so C-140 gaggle,

    and ours was the airplane the EAA

    singled

    out

    for photos when they

    were covering the event.

    Rod's

    first big project was a pair of

    Christen Eagles,

    one

    of which won

    a grand champion Lindy at Osh

    kosh. Along the

    way,

    Dottie, who

    is

    a trained and experienced nurse, be

    came part of the restoration team.

    Almost from the beginning,

    Rod

    remembered, she'd do all of the rib

    stitching and got really good at it. At

    the time, I didn't do upholstery and

    usually bought a kit and installed it.

    We

    were in

    the

    process of installing

    one of those when Dottie said, 'Hey, I

    can do that.' She took a trade school

    course in upholstery

    at

    night for a

    year and has been doing all of our in

    teriors since.

    Almost since the beginning,

    Rod

    had been doing the motors for his

    re

    builds,

    so

    adding upholstery rounded

    out his in-house capabilities.

    We usually spend a little more

    time with a restoration than other

    shops,

    but

    that's deceiving because

    we aren't farming anything out. We're

    a one-stop restoration operation, and

    the

    airplane never leaves our build

    ing. Plus, I have to give credit to my

    shop crew. They're a group of really

    motivated and talented guys.

    Our first restoration that gained

    any notoriety

    was

    the red-and-black

    ized

    that

    as negative as I had been, I

    had underestimated it badly. It

    was

    far

    from being a hopeless basket case,

    but it was far worse than I initially

    thought it was. It took us about a

    week

    to

    figure out what we had, but

    then it took over three years before

    we figured out what we didn't have.

    While

    Rod was banging on

    the

    airplane, Tom continued scroung

    ing, splitting his time between dig

    ging up historical information and

    missing parts.

    Tom said, We

    had

    a lot of peo

    ple really help us on this, including

    George Alleman, president of the

    Na

    tional Stinson Club, but finding and

    visiting Jerry Arnold,

    another

    Gull

    wing restorer up in Winnipeg, got us

    some of the hardest-to-find parts, in

    cluding the front seats. The back seats

    are just slings, so

    Rod

    could fabricate

    those, but the front seats are very

    unique. Jerry has a trucking company

    and a nose for wrecked Stinsons. Since

    the airplane

    was

    sort of a 'poor man's

    Beaver,' lots of them

    were

    used in Ca

    nadian bush

    flying

    and many

    were

    torn up in the process. Many were

    just

    abandoned

    or

    pushed

    against

    hangars. Jerry scouted

    them

    out and

    backhauled them to his hangar.

    The front seats I got still had the

    original leather

    on

    them, which was

    good because we could then do a bet

    ter job of duplicating the material and

    the pattern

    . He also

    had

    a vacuum

    tank that

    I

    had

    just about given up

    on finding.

    The original concept Eddie Stinson

    had, when it came to building his air

    planes, was that they should be lim

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    20/44

    The Great Doolittle/Porta

    Potti

    Ambush

    Tom Dinndorf admits to being a

    Doo

    little nut. Which is actually a huge

    un

    derstatement.

    " I'm a little frustrated that so many

    people only remember him for the To

    kyo

    raid when there are so many other

    things he should be remembered for.

    Besides his achievements in air racing,

    he

    pioneered instrument flight, did the

    first outside loop, and if he hadn 't read

    Hitler's mind

    and

    talked Shell into set

    ting up production o f 100-0ctane fuel

    in

    the 1930s,

    we

    would have been

    in

    real

    trouble in the early days of WW II.

    "During the four years

    we

    worked

    on

    this airplane, Doolittle was never more

    than a millimeter from

    my

    mind or from

    the heart of this project. I had read

    ev- Tom

    Dinndorf,

    proud caretaker of

    erything I could

    on

    him and searched

    the DooliHlelSheli

    Stinson.

    the

    archives in every museum you

    could think of looking for things that would tie him to our airplane.

    "During one search at the Smithsonian , I stumbled

    on

    a really nice 8

    by-10 of our airplane

    in

    the original Shell paint job, and I wanted

    e s p ~ r

    ately to not only meet Doolittle, but to show him the picture.

    My ~ p p o r ~ u n l t y

    came some years ago at Oshkosh when he chaired a panel

    on

    air racing.

    " I won't say that I was actually 'stalking' him.

    Well

    maybe I was.

    Anyway

    I spotted him

    in

    the crowd just as

    he

    stepped into a Porta Potti. I waited.

    un

    til he came out, and introduced myself. I should also say that I was a little

    nervous but

    he

    could not

    have

    been more congenial or gracious.

    We

    talked

    about airplane and him having flown it. Then I showed him the picture ,

    and

    without asking,

    he

    took it

    away

    for a few minutes and came back

    hav

    ing signed it for me. I'm too old to do double back flips, but if I could have,

    I would have.

    He

    was just so nice about it.

    "Later, I saw a Discovery Channel program

    on

    him that featured his sec

    ond son, John P I Googled the name for a phone number and hit him on the

    first call. I explained the airplane thing to him , and he was just as gracious

    as his father had been. Plus, he led me to Jonna Doolittle Hoppes, the

    granddaughter, who was doing

    an

    insider book on Jimmy, Calculated Risk

    He also introduced me to Jimmy Doolittle III, grandson and namesake.

    wings were split between feeder air

    lines, corporations and very rich

    sportsmen. Although Eddie Stinson

    had died in 1932, the result of a crash

    at the end of a forced landing in Chi

    cago's Jackson Park, the company

    policy was well

    entrenched

    and no

    corners were cut in building his air

    planes. The outline of his airplanes

    was very distinctive not only because

    of the gull at the wing root where

    it went into the fuselage, but also the

    finely shaped, bumped cowls all

    the

    civilian Gullwings sported (military

    Reliants had smooth cowls). Unfor

    tunately, the

    bumped

    cowl loomed

    large

    on

    Dinndorf's missing list.

    It's difficult to describe how much

    effort we put into trying,

    and I

    em

    phasize 'trying,' to find the right cowl

    for the airplane. I had a cowling, but

    it was a smooth one, and I had de

    cided very early on

    that

    the airplane

    was going

    to

    be exactly,

    and I

    mean

    exactly, the way it was

    on

    August 13 ,

    1938, when Doolittle first

    flew

    the air

    plane. Going with a smooth cowl sim

    ply wasn't an option.

    The airplane had already become

    as

    much a fabrication project

    as

    a

    res-

    toration

    because, as Rod put it, ...

    there was practically nothing on the

    airplane, ei ther wood or metal, that

    was rebuildable.

    So

    the logical solu

    tion for

    the

    missing cowling was to

    build a new one-no small project.

    The bumps, rather than being formed

    separately and riveted to a base cowl

    ing, were part of the primary surface.

    To make matters worse, the cowl ta

    pered slightly toward the

    rear

    Tom found a metal smith, Larry

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    21/44

    rust,

    but nothing

    catastrophic,

    and

    luckily, the steel

    truss

    wing spars

    weren't bad at all.

    We

    had to do a lit

    tle welding on it, but since this was a

    300-hp airplane, not a 450,

    the

    spars

    weren't heat-treated.

    If

    they had been

    heat-treated it would have made re

    pairs much more difficult.

    The very first

    time

    I saw

    the

    fu

    selage, Tom remembered,

    my

    first

    thought

    was, 'This isn't made

    to

    fly;

    all

    the

    tubing

    is

    too stout.' It's abso

    lutely massive in some areas.

    The steel tube spars of the Gull

    wing are streamlined

    with

    ribs built

    up from small, square aluminum tub

    ing

    that

    is

    gusseted

    and

    riveted to

    gether.

    What

    makes

    the

    process of

    restoring them so interesting

    is

    that

    they use square aluminum tubing

    that was manufactured spedfically for

    Stinson. Luckily, according

    to

    Tom,

    getting a supply of it turned out to be

    no problem.

    Charlie

    Near,

    yet another Stinson

    restorer, this one from Nebraska, han

    dled irrigation pipe, and he apparently

    found the original dies for the rib tub

    ing and had some made for his Stin

    the

    process

    much

    easier.

    When it came

    to

    doing

    the

    inte

    rior, they were in

    trouble because

    nothing of the original remained and

    they were unsuccessful in finding su

    f

    ficient photos to use

    as

    a guide. They

    did, however, luck out when discover

    ing a series of detailed drawings.

    We used

    the

    drawings

    done

    by

    William Wylam,

    which

    were incred

    ible in their detail and were drawn

    from Stinsons back when they were

    still in their heyday.

    We

    judged them

    as being accurate because we looked

    at his drawings of

    other

    airplanes for

    which there were photographs to use

    as

    comparisons, and he was dead on.

    So we

    felt safe in using his work.

    Dottie laid in a

    supply of whole

    hides and started cutting and stitch

    ing, using both the original, rotting

    seat upholstery and the Wylam draw

    ings

    as

    guides.

    One thing we'd like

    to

    ask Dottie

    is

    about rib stitching

    the

    wings:

    t

    the

    root, they are at least 16 inches deep.

    Running

    a

    stitching

    needle that far

    and being

    that

    accurate must be a real

    art. Or does she have some tricks she

    Rod Roy ace restorer from the shore

    of

    Lake

    Superior in

    Grand Mara is 

    Minnesota.

    and was looking for a way to exactly

    duplicate the colors

    and the

    logo. He

    in

    tum

    plugged me

    into

    someone in

    Shell, who not only gave us permis

    sion to paint

    the

    logo on the airplane,

    but also got us a color chip for us to

    match. It's

    kind

    of funny because

    when we gave the chip to PPG, they

    found it was identified

    as

    Shell

    Yellow

    .

    I guess we

    could

    have asked them

    first,

    but

    we probably

    wouldn't

    have

    trusted them anyway.

    Rod is justifiably proud that every

    single bit of trim, except the Stinson

    logo,

    is

    masked paint.

    Although Rod

    usually does

    his

    own engines, he was up to his hips in

    Stinson parts

    and both he and

    Tom

    wanted to

    get

    the

    airplane

    done

    in

    time for Oshkosh.

    So the

    R-680, 300

    hp

    Lycoming was sent out

    to

    Radials

    Inc., in Guthrie, Oklahoma.

    So how did Tom feel

    the

    first time

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    22/44

      s

    it an end, or a beginning?

    F

    ew airplanes deserve a bi

    ography more than 1 Blue.

    She started

    out in Octo-

    ber of 1934

    as

    a Fairchild

    22C7D, built at the Fairch

    ild factory in Hagerstown, Maryland.

    This Fairchild

    had character

    from

    the start and has touched many lives

    over the past 71 years. I can tell the

    story for 01 Blue 

    as

    I have

    had

    the

    Y GLEN

    S OTT

    afternoon of October 20,

    2005, when Jon Bartell

    and

    his

    son

    Louis arrived

    at

    Ar-

    lington, Texas Airport in the

    afternoon.

    This was a

    mo-

    mentous day as I waited with

    friends for

    their

    1,000-mile

    journey

    to terminate

    at

    my

    hangar.

    Bartell

    had

    agreed to part

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    23/44

    Left: NC14302  28

    years

    after a

    Jim

    Dewey

    restoration. This

    is

    the very

    same

    airpla

    ne

    featured in the 2006 V calen-

    dar as published by Turner Publishing.

    and blueprints. A

    lO

    -foot length of

    sectional chart was starched on

    the

    wall for the crew to au tograph at

    the end of their flight from Ohio.

    The last 12 days

    of

    October

    of

    fered few daylight hours to fly af

    ter a day of work, so enjoyed my

    evenings

    making

    small

    improve

    ments and learning

    the

    aircraft .

    managed to squeeze in a

    few

    flights

    before the

    annua

    l inspection came

    due . was on cloud nine

    The entire month

    of

    Novem

    ber was spent learning

    the

    aircraft

    and performing the

    annual

    on this

    Ralph

    Schmidt  retired presi-

    dent of Menasco checks out the

    Fairchild.

    rare gem.

    couldn t

    believe

    the

    incredible craftsmanship

    that

    Jim Dewey and his crew

    had lavished

    on

    the restora

    tion of 01 Blue in 1977.

    Jim

    was

    the original owner of this

    The day

    after

    the

    fire

    . No

    wood

     

    fabric

    and

    very little

    sheet

    metal survived. The

    annual

    inspection consumed

    the

    month of Novem-

    ber. The fire consumed everything else.

    my well-equipped hangar. The

    wings were

    awesome to

    in

    -

    gj

    spect,

    as

    the woodwork was su-

    b

     £

    perb and there

    re

    no

    cables

    pulleys or moving parts in

    them. A simple push rod from

    the stick to the

    aileron

    does

    U

    the job very well. The IS-foot

    ailerons were damage free and

    reflected Dewey's work,

    as

    did

    the cowling

    and metal

    wheel

    pants. Metal never fit so well

    enjoyed much of getting acquainted

    with

    Ole Blue and

    it was as if making

    a new friend . realized that had a

    thoroughbred that could enjoy for

    many years to come.

    My

    next and

    last flight

    in

    the

    Fairchild was

    on

    December 3 with

    my wife

    Rosa,

    when we flew locally

    for

    an hour and

    experienced a stiff

    crosswind. The controls and han-

    ing edges and repainted the tips, but

    now

    had to put her to bed without

    her cowling. Later would touch up

    the

    paint and

    detail

    that

    gorgeous

    Menasco engine.

    The evening of December 12 was

    going to visit 1 u

    e

    at the hangar.

    As

    my wife and arrived at

    the

    air

    port in the dark, so did the fire trucks

    They were also going to the T-han

    gars.

    Then

    saw

    the black smoke boil

    ing from the end of a

    row

    of hangars.

    Our row

    The smoke was coming from a

    spot only eight to 10 spaces from my

    hangar,

    but

    the firemen wouldn' t let

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    24/44

    became truly interested in

    aviation when my father

    and I

    started building

    and

    flying radio-controlled mod

    els in 1970. In 1977, at

    the

    age of 16, I

    started to

    take

    flying lessons, flying Grumman Tr-2

    trainers and

    Cessna

    lS0s

    . Due

    to

    cars, motorcycles, girls,

    and

    the as

    sociated costs of those

    aforemen

    tioned items, I got

    out

    of flying for

    a while, even though I had passed

    my

    FAA written

    and

    had about

    30

    hours  flying time.

    A childhood friend of mine, Mike

    George, with

    whom

    I had flown ra

    dio-controlled planes, had started

    flying full-sized planes about the

    same time I did. He continued

    on

    and

    currently

    owns many planes,

    including a P-S1 Mustang and F4U

    Flying as a

    r t

    Bec

    oming

    th

    e first

    certificated sport pilot

    in

    Illinois

    BY MARTY TOWSLEY

    t

    that time

    un eknownst to

    me I had

    ecome the fi

    rs

    t

    certificated sport

    pilot

    in

    Illinois.

    well it flies. As a side note, both of

    my parents

    had

    flown 1941 Taylor

    clean l,3S0-hour example. While it

    wasn t

    a showplane, it flew nicely.

    Exactly one week later, October 16,

    2004, it was mine.

    Mike had introduced

    me

    to

    an

    instructor who was a friend of his ,

    Denny Taft . Denny was a former F-16

    pilot,

    is

    a

    current

    airline pilot,

    and

    also had tailwheel time in a friend  s

    newer Taylorcraft that was based at

    Taylorville, Illinois, where I was go

    ing to base my aircraft. Denny and I

    flew my Taylorcraft to its new home

    in a stiff breeze, where I saw the cars

    on the two-lane roads making better

    headway

    than

    us.

    As I had decided to become a

    sport pilot

    and the

    rating was so

    new, Denn y and I had to

    liter

    ally rewrite

    the

    book . Many of

    th

    e

    signoffs

    had to be re-created, as

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    25/44

    aspect

    was

    landing in

    a

    taildrag

    ger, especially crosswind landings.

    t one point, while walking from

    the

    hangar after a particularly gru

    eling landing session, I dejectedly

    encouraged Denny

    to

    let me know

    if I needed to sell

    the

    T-craft. I told

    him I completely understood if he

    told me

    to

    sell it. He

    informed

    me

    everyone had

    the

    occasional bad

    day, and

    even

    though

    there were

    still rough days ahead, I was finally

    successful in soloing for the second

    time in my life.

    I started building time and prac

    ticing for

    the

    flight exam, but this

    was where

    another

    stumbling block

    was encountered. No one could

    be located

    who

    could

    conduct

    the

    flight exam in a fixed-wing cer

    tificated aircraft, so I did some re

    s

    I left

    the

    building

    I called

    my instruc

    tor, Denny,

    and

    told

    him

    of

    my

    conversa

    tion with Don. Denny

    advised

    me he

    had re

    cently heard

    of

    Don

    and had wanted me

    to

    speak

    to him about

    being a sport

    pilot

    examiner. I retraced

    my steps and

    spoke

    with

    Don about this. s

    most

    of

    this was new

    to him and

    the local

    FSDO, several calls and conversa

    tions were made by him and the

    FSDO

    personnel to confirm what

    was needed for him to become a

    sport pilot examiner.

    Finally the day arrived, and I met

    a well-prepared Don for the ground

    no is spoke of this event.

    For the most part every

    one I have come into contact

    with has been supportive.

    There seemed

    to

    be

    inter

    est and questions whenever

    someone learned I was sport

    pilot certificated, and I have

    encouraged

    them

    to

    inves

    tigate this avenue of flying.

    Though one or two have be

    littled

    the

    certificate, I know

    those

    one or

    two will

    prob

    ably be

    looking

    at this cer

    tificate

    when

    perhaps

    minor

    health issues start to ap

    pear and

    they want to

    con

    tinue flying. Though I could

    have

    gone

    on and received

    my private pilot certificate, for the

    time

    being

    I

    am

    happy with

    my

    plane

    and

    the type of flying I do .

    I have the signoffs for Class C

    and

    D airspace,

    and

    I make

    the

    Sunday

    morning fly-in breakfasts

    with

    my

    friends,

    as

    well

    as

    lunch

    and

    dinner

    dates with my supportive wife.

    t seems many people I have

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    26/44

    Dear Fam ii t

    1

    NASA

    is

    going

    to e

    t

    i

    nRIN.

    'can't

    wait

    v ~

    Your

    Pilot

    In

    Command

    Make plans today to at tend this week-long event filled

    with aviation seminars, workshops, daily airshows,

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    27/44

    E  . BUCK 

    HILB E

    RT

    Here s the drill

    Most of us

    amateur

    metal bend

    ers and

    wood

    butchers

    reach

    for

    a drill and use it with

    little

    or no

    regard to

    whether

    or not

    the

    work

    calls for a special bit for

    the

    particu

    lar job.

    Oftentimes , we re

    in

    a hurry,

    in

    the

    middle of a job

    that can t

    wait,

    so we grab a

    hand

    drill,

    search

    through

    the

    available bits, grab

    the

    one

    closest to

    the

    size we need,

    and

    punch the

    hole.

    Hey

    I t works. I

    can

    see daylight

    coming through the hole. What

    more

    do

    you want?

    Well, if

    you

    go by

    the book and

    do the

    job

    as required, you take

    your time, analyze the job and the

    needs, find

    the proper

    bi t

    ,

    make

    sure

    everything

    is

    in place,

    and

    then drill

    the

    hole.

    The job s done, but

    not the

    way

    the

    book says.

    Before we

    talk

    about

    bits, let s

    look at the

    drill

    motor

    who

    prefers mobility, you use

    one

    of

    the new

    rechargeable battery-

    powered, variable-speed jobs that

    The tip does the

    actual cutting

    work; the flutes al-

    low transport of

    first. What

    type of

    drill

    LIP

    OR

    CUTTING EDGE

    is

    safest

    to

    use

    around

    aircraft?

    Pneumatic

    or

    electric?

    FLUTE

    I guess this question

    can be answered by the

    mechanic himself. Some

    learned using the pneu-

    matic,

    others the

    elec

    tric. And if

    you

    are one

    th

    chops away

    from

    th

    work

    doesn t have cords or hoses to get

    tangled up, snag

    on

    the job, or trip

    people.

    Whatever

    the choice, the

    end result is

    about the

    same. Your

    comfort level is

    the

    concern here.

    continued on p

    g

    6

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    28/44

    EAIS

    at Huffman Prairie

    The Wrights' ho

    m

    field advantage is celebrated

    ARTICLE AND PHOTOS Y

    SCOTTY MARKLAND

    CHAPTER

    610

    COUNSELOR

    We had a remark the engine.

    Pilot

    able experience on

    Mark Dusenberry re-

    Monday, October 3, leased the weight on

    2005.

    We watched

    as

    the

    catapult,

    the

    bi

    a

    replica

    Wright

    III

    plane moved down

    1905 biplane was cat the track, and

    then

    apulted

    into the sky the Flyer rose from

    as a re-enactment

    of

    the track after a

    run

    Orville and Wilbur s of about 50 feet. We

    flights

    from historic

    could hear

    the clat-

    Huffman

    Prairie,

    at

    Mark usenberry

    Wright-Patterson Air

    skims the surface

    of

    Force Base

    in

    Greene

    Huffman

    Prairie in his

    County, Ohio . We

    Wrigbt lyer III replica  

    were standing 500 feet

    away

    when

    mechanics

    a

    few days before the

    official

    celebration

    .

    for the Flyer

    III

    started

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    29/44

    ter

    of

    the engine

    clearly

    and

    saw

    the

    slowly

    turning

    propellers rotat-

    ing

    at

    400

    to

    450 rpm. Except for

    the

    engine noise, it was very quiet.

    It

    was early

    morning, the

    fog

    had

    lifted,

    and

    the grass was

    wet with

    dew.

    The

    pilot

    made

    a leisurely

    flight

    at

    25 feet of

    altitude.

    Time

    aloft was 5

    to

    7 minutes, covering

    a mile or less.

    t

    the

    southwest

    end

    of

    the

    prai-

    rie

    the pilot

    made a

    ISO-degree

    shallow bank and

    turned

    around

    a small tree before returning

    to the

    launching

    point and

    landing

    on

    its

    skids. It was eerie; it was like going

    back 100 years

    and

    watching a 1905

    Wright

    airplane

    flying from the

    same field on a

    beautiful October

    morning. In your imagination you

    could see

    the

    brothers

    out

    there fly-

    ing their

    invention,

    dressed

    in the

    clothing of

    the

    day.

    The group from EAA Chapter

    610 was invited

    to

    static display our

    1911 Wright B replica (more later).

    There were two

    other

    Wright B air-

    craft on display as well, the Day-

    ton

    Wright B

    and

    the

    Utah College

    Wright B.

    There

    were a

    total of three

    fly-

    ing

    Wright airplanes , and one on

    static display. That's

    a remark

    able assembly

    in

    itself. During this

    demonstration, there were

    only

    20

    or 30 people present.

    On

    Wednes-

    day, October 5

    an

    official dedica-

    tion

    marking

    the

    100

    th

    anniversary

    of

    the

    Wrights' flights

    at Huffman

    Prairie was made,

    with

    many

    digni-

    taries present. Speeches were made,

    general aviation airplanes over

    the

    prairie. Most

    of these pilots

    were

    from Chapter 610.

    A

    little information about the

    EAA

    Chapter

    610

    Wright

    Model

    warping,

    but

    we

    have

    a

    different

    control system. Mark is an

    inter

    esting

    guy. He

    built the airplane

    and engine, and learned to

    fly

    it

    on

    a

    student permit.

    All of

    the

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    30/44

      ne

    ix Right

    A movie by Brian Terwilliger

    This

    is

    a love story.

    Really.

    Sure, the title leads you to believe

    it s about

    the

    people

    and

    planes of gen

    eral aviation

    as

    manifested in Van Nuys

    Airport near

    Los

    Angeles, but it s really

    all

    about

    the love affair so many of us

    have

    with

    aviation. It just

    happens to

    be

    wrapped

    around

    the story of

    Van

    Nuys and the many

    people

    who ve

    brought

    it

    to

    life over

    the

    past decades.

    It s about every airport and every pilot

    who ever loved his local airport

    and

    his fellow pilots. Twenty-nine-year-old

    Brian Terwilliger, the director

    and

    pro

    ducer of this

    terrific film,

    and

    a

    pilot

    himself,

    understands

    that

    underlying

    theme

    well; he subtitled his film

    The

    Romance ofFlying 

    With

    the

    exception of

    the

    IMAX for

    mat

    films

    shot

    with

    an

    aviation theme,

    few movies have

    captured the

    visceral

    essence

    of

    flying as well and as

    pro

    fessionally as Terwilliger

    and

    his crew

    have in One Six Right Told

    through

    the

    voices of those who keep the airport

    alive (you may watch the entire film

    before you realize there is no

    narra

    tor) the passion these men and women

    have for flying and general aviation is

    highlighted by some of

    the best foot

    age ever

    shot

    of aircraft

    in

    flight.

    Steven Miles,

    the

    director of photog

    raphy, and aerial directors of

    photog

    raphy Carston

    Bell

    and

    Doug Holgate

    all get a

    standing ovation

    from

    me

    for

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    31/44

    Flying

    Thoughts:

    An Aviator s Flight

    Through

    Life

    A

    book by

    Richard Ward

    Dick Ward's

    expert

    ise when it comes to the Twin

    Bonanza

    and

    its

    brethren

    is well known

    to

    Beech

    crafters, but I didn't

    know

    much else

    about

    this eru

    dite fellow Midwesterner until I read his self-pub

    li

    shed

    book.

    That's too bad,

    because

    he

    strikes

    me

    as

    the

    kind

    of fellow

    yo

    u 'd like to

    get to

    know. He's like

    many

    of

    us-nuts

    about

    airplanes since

    h e

    was

    a

    youngster

    building

    stick-and-tissue

    mode

    ls of his fa-

    vorites and then

    gathering

    as many

    ratings

    as

    time

    and

    circumstances

    would

    allow.

    Sprinkled with

    Dick's poems

    and wide-

    r

    anging

    thoughts on

    subjects as diverse as politiCS and l

    earn

    ing to

    fly float -eq u

    ipped

    J-3 Cubs on the Allegheny

    river

    in

    Pittsburgh,

    you'll

    never

    wonder where

    Dick

    Ward

    stands on

    subjects

    near and

    dear

    to

    his h

    eart

    .

    As a pilot,

    he

    shares

    how the

    diScipline

    and

    s

    tru

    cture

    we're all

    taught

    can

    be applied

    to

    everyday life. It 's a

    ll

    here,

    and quite entertaining to

    read. Flying Thoughts

    can be purchased

    through

    the Twin Bonanza Associ

    ation at

    www.twinbonanza.com click on the

    Market

    place tab. Or you

    can

    write

    to them

    at: Twin Bonanza

    Association

    ,

    19684

    Lakeshore

    Drive,

    Three

    Rivers,

    MI

    49093

    USA

    . The 156-page

    book

    costs $18.95 plus

    shipping

    for addresses

    in

    the

    United

    States.

    Katherine

    Stinson:

    The Flying

    Schoolgirl

    A book by Debra

    L.

    Winegarten

    Published by

    Eakin Press, this

    133-page

    book is

    written primarily

    for teens

    and preteens,

    but

    th

    e

    story is timeless and will

    be

    enjoyed

    by

    aviation

    enthusiasts of

    all ages . Ms.

    Winegarten has

    t

    aken

    the

    time to

    fill

    in many

    details

    of

    Stinson's

    life,

    and

    while

    adding

    fictiona l d ialogue

    to history

      books

    is

    not

    among my

    favorite literary devices,

    Winegarten

    does her

    best

    to

    restrain herself

    and doesn ' t

    allow

    manulacturers

    colors

    are available

    .

    U W l l r u l \ n n t r l g O

    d

    Time finishwith unllmlt d

    color

    choices.

    problem wit th. superfine

    Billy '

    Dopel

    AERO

    CLASSIC

    COLLECTOR SERIES

    Vintage Tires

    New USA Production

    S

    ho

    w off y

    our

    pride and joy with a

    fresh set of Vintage Rubber. These

    ne

    wl

    y minted

    ti r

    es

    ar

    e FAA-TSO'd

    and sp

    ee

    d rated to 120 MPH. Some

    things are better left the way th ey

    were and in the 40's and 50 's, these tires were perfectly

    in

    tune to the ex

    ci

    ting tim

    es

    in aviation.

    Not only do these ti res set y

    our

    vinta

    ge

    plane a

    part

    from

    http://www.twinbonanza.com-click/http://www.twinbonanza.com-click/

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    32/44

    The

    Spectacle ofFlight

    A book

    by

    Robert Wohl

    Published by

    Yale

    University Press

    This

    beautifully

    printed volume

    of

    the history of

    flight

    during

    the past

    century (it still

    seems

    odd to

    write that ) starts off with a photograph of a crowd in

    front of a building

    that

    I

    instantly

    recognized; it was

    the St. Louis Art Museum, with thousands of spectators

    looking up

    at

    Lindbergh's

    Spirit o

    st.

    Louis

    after his re

    turn

    to

    the United States.

    I d been on

    Art Hill dozens

    of times

    during

    my

    college

    career

    and

    have

    always

    marveled

    at the

    tre

    mendous crowds

    that

    gathered

    all over North Amer

    ica wherever Lindbergh flew

    after

    his record-setting

    flight. His impact is highlighted by the choice of au

    thor Robert Wohl

    to

    begin this 364-page book with 40

    the many

    photographs and

    illustrations

    that

    comple

    ment the text. There are a couple of layout errors, most

    notably

    an upside-down reproduction

    of a still

    from

    the movie Hell s Angels of the zeppelin emerging from

    the

    clouds,

    but then

    it's

    not

    as

    i f

    anyone today

    who s

    not an aviation enthusiast would recognize an upside

    down zeppelin

    Wohl is a professor of

    history

    at the

    University

    of

    California at Los Angeles.

    The

    Spectacle

    o

    Flight, pub

    lished by Yale University Press, is available from book

    stores, identified as ISBN 0-300-10692-0.

    Flights

    F

    orgotten

    nd

    Remembere

    d

    Lt

    Col. Boardman

    C.

    Reed

    USAF

    Ret

    .)

    Boardman Reed has

    been

    a VAA member for

    de

    cades and was, for

    many

    years, a faithful responder

    to

    our Mystery Plane

    column.

    His military career, which

    offiCially started

    just

    before World War II, actually

    starts in 1928, when

    he began

    logging

    each

    flight ex

    perience in meticulous detail. Boardman maintained

    his

    very

    detailed

    logs

    until

    he

    was

    an

    aviation

    cadet,

    when he simply

    no

    longer had the time to dedicate

    to

    such detailed entries.

    I ve enjoyed

    reading Tom

    Brokaw's The Greatest Generation,

    but

    there s simply

    nothing

    like

    hearing

    it

    from one

    who s been

    there,

    and Reed certainly was present and active

    flying

    so

    many of the remark

    able aircraft of

    the

    30s,

    '40s,

    and

    '50s.

    As

    a career military

    man, he

    started

    life

    We re

    lucky

    to

    have

    had

    in the

    Army

    Air

    Corps, transitioning

    men like

    to

    the newly formed

    U .S. Air

    Force

    af

    ter the war. Later,

    him

    when

    he

    flew all

    manner

    of civilian aircraft,

    we

    needed

    including

    his

    good

    friend

    Pete Bower's

    Fly

    Baby and Curtiss

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    33/44

     Purchased AUA, Inc. years go but left for better rates.

    Have since returned to AUA, Inc. for their reliable,

    courteous, and now economic policy. Also appreciate

    their pilot-friendly exclusions.

    - Peter

    Novak

    Peter

    ovak

    Bloomington,

    L

    • Soloed

    1969

    private same year

    Commercial

    197

    • Instrument MEL 1971

    • FI 1972;

    ATP

    1973

    • Captain United Airlines 8 777

    - 23 000

    hours

    total

    time

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    34/44

      YDOUG STEWART

    CRM.

    In

    the

    airlines

    i t stands for crew

    resource

    management.

    In

    the

    airplanes you

    and

    I

    fly

    it stands

    for cockpit resource management. And

    unfortunately

    for me, it so

    often

    seems to

    stand

    for can't remember

    much.

    (Bear

    with

    me

    a

    moment and

    I'll

    remember

    why

    I started to write

    this

    article )

    RM

    of

    distractions

    from passengers, air

    traffic control

    ATC)

    ,

    or

    aircraft anomalies.

    Suppose you select gear down

    as

    you enter the down

    wind leg of the traffic pattern,

    and

    you

    don't

    see

    thr

    ee

    in the

    green.

    Is

    this an emergency situation? Do you

    need to have

    the

    manual

    gear

    extension procedure

    Oh

    right

    I

    remember

    now.

    CRM

    . It's

    an

    initialism that

    many

    of us

    have

    heard, but it's

    possible that you really don 't un

    derstand how

    a

    term that's

    used

    by the airlines could be applied

    to the cockpits

    of

    our personal

    airplanes.

    If

    we

    consider

    that

    it

    refers

    to

    using all available tools,

    it could make a bit more sense.

    Let's take a look

    at

    those tools

    and

    how we

    can

    use

    them

    , espe

    cially when the

    yogurt

    starts to

    creep

    up

    above

    the

    eyeballs. My

    list

    is not prioritized; because

    of

    my can't remember m uch,

    they ' re listed

    as

    I think of

    them.

    Let's see

    now

    checklists . .

    .

    they're

    a

    good

    tool (especially

    for my personal CRM). I have

    If your sectional is

    back

    in

    the luggage

    compartment, it isn t

    g

    oing to do you mu h

    good when the

    batteries

    in

    your

    handheld PS die.

    memorized? The answer

    to

    both

    questions

    is

    no.

    What

    should you

    do? The answer

    is

    simple . leave

    the traffic pattern, climb to a safe

    altitude,

    and get out the checklist

    This is

    not

    a procedure that you

    have to have memorized. I t

    is

    not

    an

    emergency situation ... yet.

    Us-

    ing

    the

    checklist will ensure that

    you

    don't

    miss

    anything.

    Check

    lists are one

    of

    the best tools in

    our

    CRM

    flight bag.

    Passengers .

    they

    sometimes

    can be one heck of

    a

    distrac-

    tion,

    especially if they have not

    been

    briefed

    on the

    sterile cock

    pit concept, which is no talking

    about

    anything

    (the

    wife

    and

    kids, the ball game

    ,

    the great

    joke

    they

    just heard, etc.) except

    What

    about

    all the possible resources for informa ceiling. About 10 miles before

    reaching

    Emporia,

  • 8/20/2019 Vintage Airplane - Mar 2006

    35/44

    tion that you, or

    your

    passengers,

    might

    be referenc

    ing? I certainly

    hope

    you have brought along all the

    current and proper charts

    that

    you might need,

    but

    I

    have

    noticed

    that many pilots forget

    to bring along

    a

    current

    Airport/Facility Directory

    AFO) or

    other

    suit

    able reference for airport, NAVAID, and other related

    information.

    Many pilots

    are

    now tending

    to rely

    solely on their

    GPS

    for

    this

    information (as well as

    the daily lunch special

    at

    the

    airport

    restaurant)

    but

    forget that

    i f

    the database in the GPS

    is not

    current,

    then the information might

    very

    well not be reli

    able, and if the

    batteries

    die, that