Upload
stephanie-watson
View
218
Download
6
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
This paper explores the pros and cons of virtual high schools and online learning options for high school students.
Citation preview
RUNNING HEAD: VIRTUAL HIGH SCHOOLS 1
Stephanie Watson
Virtual High Schools
and
Online Learning Options
Simpson College
November 14, 2011
VIRTUAL HIGH SCHOOLS 2
Time for a new model
In a time of back to the basics education driven by standardized testing and cuts in school
budgets and resources, it may seem counterintuitive to think of adding more course options and
more technology to current academic menus. In spite of these facts, the number of K-12 students
taking online courses is on the rise (Davis, 2009, para. 1). In 2008 Massachusetts based
researchers Sloan Consortium estimated that more than 1 million students were taking classes
online, a 47 percent increase(?) from the previous school year (Davis, 2009, para. 2). Seventy-
five percent of the polled districts offering an online component also had at least one student
taking a class completely online, and two out of three school districts surveyed expect their
online-course enrollments to climb (Davis, 2009, para. 3). No doubt those numbers have risen
even higher since the date of that poll. Statistics like these prove that schools are looking for a
new model for the classroom—one that can “serve both students and teachers” by shifting our
focus “from the three R’s to an education system that builds skills in the three C’s: content,
collaboration, and community” (Pape, 2005, p. 12). By offering online courses and virtual
schools, educators can “focus on building students’ literacy skills so they can ask questions,
define inquiry, research multiple sources, authenticate sources of information, process and
synthesize data and information, draw conclusions, and develop action plans based on their
newfound knowledge [. . .] while filtering the vast quantity of information they receive and
determining what is authentic, useful, and of value” (Pape, 2005, p. 12). High schools are and
should offer online courses not only because it increases the number of classes a school can
offer, but also because it prepares students to thrive in a global economy where collaborating,
communicating, and connecting through digital forms is essential.
VIRTUAL HIGH SCHOOLS 3
Models of K-12 online education
While the model for virtual high schools can vary as much as the student populations
they strive to serve, today most virtual high schools are state or district funded and designed to
meet an individual state or district’s needs. Virtual high school programs often include a
combination of college courses offered to high school students online and high school level
courses offered to meet a variety of needs. Podoll and Randle (2005) give the example of South
Dakota's Rapid City Academy, an alternative high school program for South Dakota’s Rapid
City Area Schools. This virtual high school is funded by the Rapid City Area School district and
is almost devoted entirely to providing a largely at-risk student population with flexible learning
options—a population they noticed needing special attention in their district, although each
district can specialize course offerings as they see fit for their student body. At Rapid City
Academy, students dealing with teenage parenthood, high absentee rates, low socioeconomic
status, and medical and/or personal challenges that impact their ability to succeed in the
traditional classroom setting are able to obtain their high school diploma despite difficult
circumstances (para. 1). The academy is also able to use the online learning forum to
differentiate instruction for these students through instructional methods such as smaller student-
teacher ratios, individualized learning plans, strategy-based learning, flexible schedules, and
independent and group-led classes” (para. 1). Other online course options allow students who
wish to graduate early, remediate classes to catch up with their original graduating class, or
simply take additional course work in an area in which they are interested. “But not all
participants fit the archetype of the typical high school-aged learner” Podoll and Randle say. One
non-traditional student was able to return and complete his high school diploma after more than
50 years—a feat that would probably be unfathomable for an adult that age in the traditional
VIRTUAL HIGH SCHOOLS 4
classroom setting (Podoll and Randle, 2005, para. 3).
Another emerging trend in online education is nonprofit virtual cooperatives such as The
Virtual High School (VHS) that serves 250 high schools nationally and abroad. Out of the three
opt-in models VHS offers, the most popular option is one of give and take: for every teacher the
school “donates” the school receives 25 spots for students per semester in any of the 425 courses
currently offered (VHS, 2011). The teachers at this school are licensed employees of the state in
which their home school resides, and they design their own innovative courses with the help of
VHS mentors and instructional technology experts (VHS, 2011). Other options include a Student
Only membership with options beginning at 10 students per semester and individual student
enrollment based on an application process and individual tuition fee (VHS, 2011). For students
involved in VHS this means that they now have access to instruction that is not otherwise
available to them and interaction with students they probably would have never had the chance
to meet had they not taken these courses. Hudson High School’s principal John Stapefeld, for
example, says that offering online coursework ‘broadens curriculum in a way beyond what we’d
normally be able to offer” (Trotter, 2002, para. 8). Andrew Trotter reported in his 2002 interview
with Stapefeld that this small Massachusetts town has been able to offer students a learning
experience unimaginable before:
“One student, for example, is taking a media studies course online from a teacher in
Malaysia. Another is studying technology and multimedia from a teacher in Georgia. A
third is taking honors American studies from a teacher in Clinton, Mass. Classmates
enroll from throughout the nation, and some from as far away as Asia, Europe, and South
America.”
Hudson High School is a great example of a growing number of high schools that are looking to
VIRTUAL HIGH SCHOOLS 5
e-learning and virtual classrooms as a way “to poke holes in traditional classroom and
curriculum boxes and let new information, perspectives, and options pour in” (Trotter, 2002,
para. 7). Important to note, however, is that neither Rapid City Academy nor Hudson High are
looking to replace regular core curriculum classes. Their hope is to supplement those classes in a
way that allows schools to differentiate curriculum for diverse learners and offer additional ways
for students to build digital literacy skills.
Meeting the needs of a diverse student body
Educational psychology has been telling us for a long time now that a one-size-fits-all
model for education does not meet the needs of a diverse student body. Yet, one of the foremost
frustrations teachers voice today is the difficulty they face in providing the right kind of
instruction to students with varying needs. Recent studies suggest that online education may be
just one of the answers our schools need to address this problem. Michelle Davis’s 2009
Education Week article on web-based classrooms reports that, "survey results indicate that online
learning is meeting a wide range of student needs from remedial to accelerated instruction [. . .]
It provides the ability to offer coursework that is otherwise unavailable at a child's school, which
we find to be especially significant in rural counties" (para. 4). Not only are schools now
providing more options, though, they are providing them and seeing students excel. Podoll and
Randle (2005) offer an interesting look at qualified research on instructor and student
experiences with online course. They write that while studying the Rapid Area Academy’s online
programs the Illinois Online Network found that “asynchronous discussions in an online course
allowed the learner time to think and reflect on presented content material.” It was reported that
the students seemed more engaged in learning when they were given more time to consider
responses and students’ learning seemed deeper because they were having to discuss and be
VIRTUAL HIGH SCHOOLS 6
active participants in the learning processes rather than passively receive facts. Because of this
“88 percent of academy instructors identified reflective learning, student engagement, and
student-centered instruction as advantages of online instruction.” In addition to positive
instructor observations, student feedback regarding their experiences taking online courses
indicated that they actually did feel a personal connectedness to the instructor through the use of
e-mail, threaded discussions, and journaling. Students also noted enjoying learning to use new
forms of technology (Podoll and Randle, 2005, para. 7-8).
Concerns
Despite findings such as these, many educators still say the idea of online course work for
middle and high schools raises some questions in their mind. The two of the most common
concerns deal with what happens to “real” teachers when learning goes online and the isolated
environment of online learning might limit students’ opportunities to build speaking, listening,
and social skills. In response to the latter concern, it should be reiterated that none of the
programs surveyed for this paper were attempting to replace or take students away from the core
curriculum their schools were offering—programs that do so should raise serious concerns.
Students do need to engage in conversations with each other and with teachers face-to-face in
real time. Virtual learning, at least at this point in time, seems to be an attempt to very practically
supplement our high school course offerings and our students’ global experiences in a way that
the traditional classroom has not been able to do on its own. Our students need both sets of
communication skills. In response to the former question, educators should be reassured by the
fact that real teachers are teaching these courses. No one is being pushed out of a job. In fact,
over 85 percent of VHS teachers hold master’s degrees in education, 19 percent of VHS teachers
hold master’s degrees plus additional credits, or doctorate degrees, and VHS teachers have an
VIRTUAL HIGH SCHOOLS 7
average of 16 years of teaching experience (VHS, 2011). Of those with over 10 years of teaching
experience, almost fifty percent of those individuals have been educators for more than 20 years
(VHS, 2011). It is interesting that teachers for the most part have been spared the technology
transition that those in the private sector had to adjust to quite a while ago. Real teachers will not
be losing any jobs because schools offer online courses, but if schools are going to offer the
online options our students need, they will have to start evolving with the system.
Other concerns about offering online courses in K-12 include technical difficulties such
as limited access to the Internet, computer failures, time management, and access to resources.
Housekeeping issues like these are valid concerns, but should be tackled as kinks to work out in
providing the options our students need, not roadblocks keep us from moving into the future.
Schools will need to reallocate resources to keep computers and systems updated, but they
should be doing this anyway. Denying our students the chance to use the technology they need to
be familiar with when they graduate because we cannot find a way to work the kinks out a
system that could be better is a poor excuse for providing inadequate education. Many
proponents of offering online course work would say should be the biggest concern for educators
is the standardization and accountability of these courses. While this topic goes beyond the scope
of this paper, it seems to be the most recent thought on online educators’ minds as online courses
surely warrant being held to the same standards we hold our traditional classrooms.
Concluding thoughts
Our students are growing up in a world unfettered by time and local. They have the
ability to, and often are, connected globally every waking moment of their day. The truth is, no
one’s job is restricted to his or her cubical anymore–the 21st century workplace is one with global
connections. If our schools are going to prepare our students for their future, they should be
VIRTUAL HIGH SCHOOLS 8
striving to prepare students to communicate, collaborate, and connect in a global economy. It is
imperative that we ensure they can start building those skills before leaving our classrooms. At
the same time, our schools are struggling to meet the needs of an increasingly diverse students
population. Imagine a school being able to offer and additional 425 courses—that’s the
possibility to meet 425 different students’ individual needs. While there are still kinks to be
worked out, the educational model is shifting whether we like it or not. The question is: will you
be moving with it?
From Rose,
I agree with Kerri
A fascinating topic well developed. All criteria met. Cerri’s comment about needing
clarification holds for me also.
On a personal note: it certainly is not a time saver for T’s!
Grade = 48/50.
VIRTUAL HIGH SCHOOLS 9
References
Davis, M. R. (2009). Web-Based Classes Booming in Schools. Education Week 28(19), n. p.
Retrieved from http://0-search.ebscohost.com.dunnlib.simpson.edu
/login.aspx?
direct=true&AuthType=ip,url,uid,cookie&db=aph&AN=36386801&site=ehostlive&scop
e=site
Pape, Liz (2005). High School on the Web: What you need to know about offering online
courses. American School Board Journal 192(7), 12-16. Retrieved from http://0-
web.ebscohost.com.dunnlib.simpson.edu/ehost/detail?vid=4&hid=110&sid=a528dcc8-
3b72-4fd4-8d14-8d2e6d9d95b0%40sessionmgr104&bdata=JkF1dGhUeXBlPWlw
LHVybCx1aWQsY29va2llJnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZSZzY29wZT1zaXRl#db=f5h&A
N=17307710
Podoll, S., & Randle, D. (2005). BUILDING A VIRTUAL HIGH SCHOOL …CLICK BY
CLICK. T H E Journal 33(2), 14-19. Retrieved from
http://0search.ebscohost.com.dunnlib.simpson.edu/login.aspx?direct=true&Auth
Type=ip,url,uid,cookie&db=aph&AN=18404151&site=ehostlive&scope=site
Trotter, A. (2002). E-Learning Goes to School. Education Week 21(35) n. p. Retrieved from
VIRTUAL HIGH SCHOOLS 10
http://0search.ebscohost.com.dunnlib.simpson.edu/login.aspx?
direct=true&AuthType=ip,url,uid,cookie&db=aph&AN=6953208&site=ehostlive
&scope=site
Virtual High School (2011). Membership. Retrieved from http://www.govhs.org/Pages/JoinUs-
Home