Upload
vivekananda-kendra
View
230
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
1/36
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
2/36
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
3/36
RNI NO. 46869 / 85, "{ddoH {dMma' ho_m{gH _mbH , "{ddoH mZX H| _amRr H meZ {d^mJ' `mMogmRr _wH d H meHYZO` gy`der `mZr {{gOZ qQg, X{ZH VU ^maV, 19/20, Ammo{JH dgmhV, hmoQJr amoS, gmobmnya `oWoNmnyZ, {ddoH mZX
H| , 165, aodobmBg, gmobmnya `oWyZ {g Hobo. gnmXH - {gmam_ ^anm nmQrb
{Z_i Am{U ew _ZmVM g` H meVo. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
{ddoH mZX H| mMo gmH{VH _m{gH
{ddoH {dMmadf 28 do- AH 7 dm
\ mJwZ-M>/`wJmX 5114/15
04 E{b 2013
_w` gnmXH lr. nr. na_odaZ
gnmXH {gmam_ ^. nmQ>rb
n`dhmamMm nmm
{ddoH {dMmamam - {ddoH mZX H|,
165, aodobmBg, gmobmnya-413 001.Xy 0217 - 2315949 (gm 7 Vo8.30)
email : [email protected]
bmJ
www.vkvivekvichar.blogspot.com
_y` - 10 n`o
boImZwH _
Amn`mbm `oUm`m {ddoH {dMma`m nm{H Q>mdarb n`m`mn{h`m AmoirMm eodQ> '201306'Agm Agob Va Vw_Mr dJUr OyZ2013 _ ognV Amho. Hn`m nwT>rb dfmMr dJUr _ZrAmS>aZoAWdmOdirb H|emIoV am. _{ZAmS>a`m "_ogoO ~mg'_`oAmnbonyUZmd Am{U n`mMm CboI Amd`H Amho.
`mdoir Amnbm dJUrXma H_mH (nm{H Q>mdarb n`mMr n{hbrAmoi) Ad` H idm.
... `mMr dJUr gnV Amho
3 gnmXH s` ...
4 {ddoH mZX Am{U Am~oS>H a _w` boI
8 _yb{Zdmgr {d S>m. Am~oS>H a qMVZ
11 AmOM `moJ gw H m! KS>dy`m OrdZ...
14. A_VdMZ Zr{VeVH
15 AdbmoH Z 5000 dfmMo ^maVmMm B{Vhmg
18 ^y{_-nyOZ nanam_mJrb AW
20 amQ >OmJaUmMo Ad`w oaUmmoV
25 KarXmar BYZy Mm nyb
28 H|dm ...
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
4/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *2
gm_m` _mUgoM Agm_m` H m`KS>dyZ AmUVmV. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
dMm[aH AmXmobZm`m {dVmamgmR>r...
dm_r {ddoH mZXm`m eVrXm`r {dMmamMo AmH bZ H Z Ko`mgmR>r...
^maVr` OrdZ_y o Am{U gH VrMr AZw^yVr Ko`mgmR>r
amQr`Q`m _hdmMo {df` g_OyZ Ko`mgmR>r...
Vwhr {ddoH {dMmaMo dmMH Agmb Va Xa_hm {H _mZ EH m `Vrg {ddoH {dMmaMo gX` ~Zdm...
{ddoH {dMma{ddoH mZX H| mMo gmH {VH _m{gH
{ddoH mZX H|m`m H moU`mhr emIoV dJUr ^ eH Vm. AWdm "{ddoH {dMma' mam {ddoH mZX H|, 165,aodo bmBg, gmobmnya Zmdo _[ZAmS>a, S>rS>r nmR>dy eH Vm. dJUrgmo~V Amnbo gnyUZmd, nmm nmR>{dUo Amd`H .dJUr m Pm`mZVa`m _{h`mnmgyZ "{ddoH {dMma' {_iy bmJob. H moU`mhr _{h`mnmgyZ dJUrXma hmoVm `oVo.n``dhma H aVmZm Amnbm dJUrXma H _mH Ad` {bhm. ~Xbbobm nmm XmoZ _{hZo AmYr {b{IV/B-_ob ZoH idmdm (XyadZrZo Zmhr). gnH : 9422649239
_m{gH _mJ{d`mMm nmm ({nZH moSgh){ddoH {dMma _bm gX` hm`M`!
XyadZr H _mH
B-_ob
(H n`m BJOr H {nQ>b boQ>a_`o {bhm.)
_r nwT>rb H maMm gX` hmoDBpN>Vmo/BpN>Vo.
IyUH am
gX`VmH ma
dJUr/XoUJr
gdYHAmOrdnMdm{fH
dm{f H
...
.
3,000/-1,500/-
450/-
100/-
Amn m{ OZm mZmdo
dJUr Z dmT{Xdg
AWdmBVa{Z{_mmZo {ddoH
{dMmaMr oQ> nmR>dy eHVm .
AmdmhZ
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
5/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *3
OodV:bm ghm` H aVmV, `mZmM Bda ghm` H aVmo. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
^maVr` p`m nmpM_m`m_mUoM {dMmaj_ hm`mV, naVw `m`m Mm[a`mMrqH _V XoD Z _m Zho ! {dMmaj_Vm hoH mhr lo>V_ BpgV Zmhr. Z{VH ~b Am{UA`m_~b Amhmbm A{YH _hdmMo dmQ>Vo. Am_`mH S>rb p`m H mhr \ ma{eH bo`m ZmhrV, nU `mMo AmMaU A`V n{d AgVo.
r, nwf hm ^oX {dg Z AmnU Ho di _mUgo AmhmoV, Aem ^y{_HoVyZ H m_H am`bm {eH `m{edm` p`mMm Iam {dH mg hmoUma Zmhr. Eadr p`mH S>o^moJdVy hUyZM nm{hboOmVo. KQ>\ moQ>mMo_w` H maU hoM Amho.
Omon`V p`mMr pWVr gwYmaV Zmhr, Vmon`V OJmMo H `mU hmoUo e` Zmhr.njr H YrM EH m nImZo CSy eH V Zmhr.
- dm_r {ddoH mZXdmMH ~Yy-^{JZr,g`m Amn`m XoemVrb KS>m_moS>r Am{U XoemMr Ywam dmh`mMr O~m~Xmar Agbo`mMo
dVZ nmhm. Xoem`m {hVmbm ZI bmdUm`m eVr ~i Pm`mMo {XgyZ `oV Amho. gH maAm{U ZrVr_y`o `mnmgyZ Xa Jo`mZo g_mOmMr hmoV Agbobr KgaU amoI`mEodOr ^maVgaH ma_`o ~gbo`m _wIS>mZr AY:nVZmMr n[agr_mM JmR>`mMo {XgyZ `oV Amho. And`rZ_wbtda hmoUmao b{JH A`mMma amoI`mgmR>r b{JH g~Y R>od`mgmR>r {H _mZ d` 16 df}H a`mMo {dYo`H ggXog_moa AmUboJobo. amoJmnojm BbmO ^`H a hUVmV, Vgbm hm H ma.g_mOmV AZmMma _mOd`mMmM hm `Z.
^maVm_`o b{JH gh_VrgmR>r mYm`mMr AQ> Amho {ddmh. {ddmhmbm ^maVr`gH VrV gH ma _mZbo Jobo Amho. naH s` AmH _U H mimV ~mb{ddmhgma`m Wm T>
Pm`m. ZVa`m H mimV `mMo Xn[aUm_ `mZmV KoD Z {ddmhmgmR>rMo d` 18 df} H a`mVAmbo. ^maVr` g_mOmV b{JH gh_VrgmR>r _w` AQ> (AndmX dJiVm) {ddmhM am{hbrAmho. `mV Amamo`emmMm {dMma H Z 18 df} d`m`m AQ>rMm g_mOmZo drH ma Ho bm.Ago AgVmZm b{JH g~YmgmR>r {ddmhmEodOr \ V 16 df} nyU Ag`mbm mYm` XoUog_mOmbm CXdV H a`mgmR>rMrM Mmb Agbr nm{hOo. AZoH ehamVrb_hm{dmb`mZOrH `m bmO_`o _hm{dmb`rZ VU-VUr Hw H _ H aVmZm AmT>i`m`m~mV`m AmVm ZdrZ am{h`m ZmhrV. b{JH A`mMma Am{U ^moJdmXmda {Z`U AmU`mgmR>rgH mamMr VgoM H R>moa H m`mMr Amd`H Vm AgVo. `mEodOr ^moJdmXmbm mogmhZ XoUoAm{U `mbm H m`Xoera AmYma {_idyZ XoUo `mgmR>r H| gaH ma nwT>mH ma KoV Amho. gaH maMr_Vr Aem H mao^Q> H a`mMoH m_ H aUmar _S>ir H moU AmhoV `mH S>oXbj hmoVm H m_m Z`o.
Hw Qw~`dWm Am{U ^maVr` g_mO CXdV H aUm`m dmr, ^moJdmXmbm dm H aUmaoCmoJ MmbdUm`m {dMmaYmam `mZm CKS>o nmS>`mMo H m_ {d`mV H ZS> boIH S>m. Eg. Eb.^anm `mZr "VS>m' `m H mX~arVyZ A`V ^mdrnUo Ho bo Amho. ZwH VoM H m{eV Pmbobo_ohVmnpbHoeZZo H m{eV Ho bobo ho _amR>r nwVH AmdOyZ dmMboM nm{hOo, Ago `m{Z{_mmZogwMdmdodmQ>Vo.
gnmXH s`
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
6/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *4
`oH _hH m`hohiyhiyM hmoV AgVo. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
_w` boI
dm_r {ddoH mZXm`m OrdZH m`mMm I`m AWmZoma Pmbm Vmo A_o[aHo V. A_o[aHo Vrb {eH mJmo ehamV^abo`m gdY_n[afXogmR>r Vo OmVmV Am{U VoWo 11gQ>|~a 1893 gmbr `mMo AOam_a ^mfU hmoVo. `mEH mM ^mfUmZo Vo OJV{d`mV hmoVmV. nwT>o VrZ df}`mMo dmV` A_o[aHo V AgVo d VoWo Vo nmMm`mZmdoXmVXeZ g_OmdyZ gmJVmV. 1897 gmbr `mMo^maVmV nwZamJ_Z hmoVo. ^maVmV _m `mZr doXmVOJm`Mm H gm, gm_m{OH OrdZmV Vmo H gm AmUm`MmhoM gm{JVboAmho. ^maVmV H m` H aUm`mgmR>r 1897bm `mZr am_HU {_eZMr WmnZm Ho br.
S>m. ~m~mgmho~m`m OrdZH m`mMr gwdmV"~{hH V {hVH maUr g^m' `m gWo`m WmnZoZo Pmbr.
{ddoH mZXAm{U
Am~oS>H a
hr gWm 20 Owb 1924 amoOr WmnZ H a`mV Ambr.`m gWo`m H m`H mar _S>imMo A`j dV: S>m.~m~mgmho~ hmoVo. dm_r {ddoH mZX Am{U S>m. ~m~mgmho~Am~oS>H a `m`m gmdO{ZH H m`mV OdiOdiA>mdrg dfmMo AVa Amho. S>m. ~m~mgmho~m`m OrdZH m`mMm ma Oohm Pmbm Vohm {ddoH mZXmMo XohmdgmZhmoD Z EH drg df} Pmbr hmoVr. Ago Agbo VarXmoKm`m Or{dV H m`m`mdoir XoemMr n[apWVr,amOH s` nmaV`, gm_m{OH Xmof, Y_mMr AdZVr hrOdiOdi gmaIrM hmoVr. ^maVmV BJOmMoemgZ hmoVohUOo amOH s`Q>m ^maV Jwbm_ Xoe hmoVm. Om{V^oX,An`Vm `mZo qhXy g_mOmMo gm_m{OH OrdZ Am{UgKQ>Z CXdV Pmbo hmoVo. qhXy Y_mMr CXmm Vdo \ V
a_oe nVJoXmoKohr A_o[aHo V hmoVo nU XmoKohr A_o[aH Z OrdZ, gH Vr, {dMma `mMo Xmg Pmbo
ZmhrV. Amn`mbm Oo Cn`w Amho `mMm `mZr drH ma Ho bm nU Amnbr Ap_Vm
OnyZ R>odbr. ^maVmZoOJmbm Y_kmZ {Xbonm{hOod OJmH Sy>Z ^m{VH kmZ gnmXZ Hobo
nm{hOo, Agodm_rOtZr gm{JVbo. "OJmbm ~wmMr JaO AmhohUOo^maVr` Y_kmZmMr
JaO Amho' hoS>m. ~m~mgmho~mZr gm{JVbo.
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
7/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *5
eya bmoH M gMonUmZo`dhma H eH VmV. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
_w` boI
JWmVM am{hbr hmoVr. Ym{_H AmMaU `m CXmmVdm`m {d hmoVo. qhXy OZVm dV:bm hrZ-XrZ,Xw~i g_OV hmoVr. BJOm`m dkm{ZH kmZmZogw{e{jVmMo S>moio {XnyZ Jobo hmoVo. {MZ Y_mVrb
EHodadmX, gKQ>Zm AZoH mZm lo> dmQy bmJbr hmoVr.Amnbm Y_, AmnboVdkmZ, Amnbr gH Vr, Amnbogm{h` A`V {ZH > Amho Aer ^mdZm AZoH~w{dmmMr Pmbr hmoVr. `mbmM Am_bmZr,Am_{d_Vr, Ap_Vm/{d_aU Ago hUVmV. `m_mZ{gH Vobm MS> YH m Xo`mMo H m_ EH mo{Ugm`meVH m`m CmamYmV dm_r {ddoH mZXmZr Ho bo Am{U{dgm`m eVH mV S>m. ~m~mgmho~mZr Ho bo.
XmoKohr A_o[aHo V hmoVo nU XmoKohr A_o[aH Z OrdZ,gHVr, {dMma mMo Xmg Pmbo ZmhrV. Amn`mbm Oo OoCn`wV Amho `mMm `mZr drH ma Ho bm nU AmnbrAp_Vm OnyZ R>odbr. ^maVmZo OJmbm Y_kmZ {Xbonm{hOo d OJmH SyZ ^m{VH kmZ gnmXZ Hobo nm{hOo,Ago dm_rOtZr gm{JVbo. "OJmbm ~wmMr JaO AmhohUOo ^maVr` Y_kmZmMr JaO Amho', ho S>m.~m~mgmho~mZr gm{JVbo.
XoemMr n[aH_m H aVmZm dm_rOtZr XoemVrb^`mZH Xm[a nm{hbo. XwH mimV AmdmMyZ VS>\ SyZ_aUmar _mUgo nm{hbr. XddmX, AYlm nm{h`m.lr_VmMr Jar~m{df`rMr CXmgrZVm nm{hbr. gw{e{jVdJmMr dmWnam`UVm nm{hbr. amOo-_hmamOmMr{dbmgrVm nm{hbr. ^maVmVrb J[a~mZm H moUr dmbrZmhr, ho `m`m bjmV Ambo. `mMr X`Zr` AdWmnmhZ `mZm aSy `oB. `mMoCWmZ H go H aVm `oBb,`m`mV H _MoVZm H er {Z_mU H aVm `oBb, `m`mV
Am_{ddmg H gm OmJ{dVm `oBb, `m`mV {Z^ VmH er {Z_mU H aVm `oBb B`mXr {df` `m`m AhmoamqMVZmMo {df` hmoVo. ""^wHo `m _mUgmMm Y_ `m`m^mH arV AgVmo'' Ago VohUV. Aem _mUgmbm CXmmdoXmV gmJyZ H mhr Cn`moJmMo Zmhr ho `mZr OmUbo. S>m.~m~mgmho~mMm O_M _wir An` OmVrV Pmbm.
An`Vm {H Vr ^`mZH AgVo hm `m`m AZw yVrMm{df` Amho. An`VoZo _mUgmVrb _mUygnU H go_mabo Jobo Amho ho `mZr AZw^dbo hmoVo. An`VoZogm_m{OH Jwbm_r H er AmUbr Amho, Am{WH Jwbm_r
H er AmUbr Amho, Ap_VoMm Zme H gm Ho bm Amho,hrZdmMr ^mdZm H er {Z_mU Ho br Amho `m gdJmo>r`m`m amoO`m AZw dm`m hmo`m. Amn`mg_mOmVrb An` ~mYdmMo Xw:I nmhZ `mMoAV:H aU Vri-Vri VwQ>o. `mMr J[a~r, X`mdWm`mZm ghZ hmoV Zgo. `m ~mYdmMr Xw:IonmhZ `mZmhraSy `oB. `mZm Xw:I_wV H go H aVm `oBb `mMrM VoAhmoam qMVm H arV. `mgmR>rM `mZr CJ kmZVn`m
Ho br.dm_r {ddoH mZXmZr Amn`m AdZVrMrH maU_r_mgm Aer Ho br Amho-
gm_m` OZVoMo Xm[a- AmnU BVa ammer{_giV Zmhr hoM Amn`m amr` AY:nVZmMo _yiH maU Amho; Zho VoM EH _m H maU Amho, Ago _rg_OVmo. ^maVmVrb Vmo Cno{jV ImbMm dJ- VoeoVH ar, Vo {dUH a Am{U Vo BVa bmoH . H m` hr `mMrpWVr ! naH s`mZr `mZm qOH bo. `m`mM XoemVrblo> OmVtZr `mZm hrZ boIbo. \ ma mMrZ H mimnmgyZVo emVnUo A{daV Inbo; `mZm nwar _Owarhr {_imbrZmhr ! ^maVmVrb gm`m XwXeoMo_yi H maU Oa H moUVoAgob Va Vo hUOo gdgmYmaU OZVoMo Xm[a...nwamo{hVmZr Am{U {dXoer {dOo`mZr eoH S>mo df} `mZmnm`mImbr VwS>{dboAm{U `mMm n[aUm_ hmM Pmbm H sAmnU _mUyg AmhmoV ho XoIrb ^maVmVrb ho Jar~ bmoH{dg Z Jobo. (_mPm ^maV A_a ^maV- dm_r
{ddoH mZX n> H . -21)qhXy Y_ _hmZ Amho, hr Jmo> Iar naVwY_mMo VdkmZ
AmnU AmMaUmV AmUrV Zmhr, `m_wio Y_M_mUgmbm H gm VwS>{dVmo `m{df`r {ddoH mZX hUVmV,""qhXy Y_mBVH m BVa H moUVmhr Y_ H R>admZo_mZdVo`m_{h`mMm Mma H arV Zmhr; Am{U qhXy Y_ Jar~ Am{U
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
8/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *6
Xg`mMo{hV gmY`mZoM dV:Mo{hV gmYVo. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
_w` boI
Imb`m OmVr`m bmoH mZm {OVHo nm`mImbr VwS>{dVmo{VVHo OJmVrb BVa H moUVmhr Y_VwS>{dV Zmhr.''
""Amhr Jar~ AmhmoV, Amhr Jar~ AmhmoV'' Aer^maVmV AmoaS> EoHy `oVo, naVw `oWrb J[a~mZm _XV
H a`mgmR>r {H Vr Y_mW gWm AmhoV? bmImo-H amoS>moAZmWmgmR>r, AnJmgmR>r {H Vr bmoH mMo mU IamoIaH idiVmV? ^JdVm, Amhr _mUgo H m AmhmoV!Amn`m XoemV MmohmoH S>o Oo An` g_Obo OmVmV`m`m CVrgmR>r, `mZm XmoZ Kmg A Xo`mgmR>rAmnU H m` H arV AmhmoV? AmnU `mZm ne H arVZmhr, AmnU `mZm ""Xya hm, Xya hm'' Ago hUVmo!AmnU H m` _mUgoAmhmoV? ho Oo hOmamo gmYy, ~mU
AmhoV, VoAmn`m AdZV, X{bV, Jar~ ~mYdmgmR>rH m` H arV AmhoV? Ho di ""_bm {edyZH m'', ""_bm{edy ZH m'' hmM Kmof! EdT>m MmJ`m gZmVZ Y_mMr`mZr H m` Xem H Z Q>mH br Amho! AmVm Y_ AmhoH moR>o? Vm oAmVm Ho di ""_bm {edy ZH m'' `m eXmVMgmR>bm Amho! (_mPm ^maV A_a ^maV-dm_r{ddoH mZX n> H. 23)
gdgm_m` _mUgmg amm`m OrdZmV gh^mJrH Z Z KoV`mZoH m` Pmbo Amho `m{df`r {ddoH mZXhUVmV, ""^maVmMm Omo g`mZme Pmbm Amho `mMo_yi H maU hQ>bo hUOo, amOgmm Am{U dUm{^_mZ`m`m Omoamda XoemVrb g_V {dm-~wr H mhr _yR>^abmoH m_`o S>m~yZ R>odUo hoM hmo .''
""BJOmZm ^maVmda O` mV H aUo BVHo gmono H mJobo? `mMo H maU hoM H s `mMoam ho Iao gK{Q>V amAmho, AmnboVgo Zmhr. Amn`m XoemVrb EImXr Wmoa`Vr Oa {ZYZ nmdbr Va {VMr OmJm ^ Z
H mT>`mgmR>r eoH S>mo dfo Amn`mbm dmQ> nmhmdrbmJVo; `m`m CbQ> BH S>rb XoemV Wmoa `VtMr OmJmVjUrM ^ Z {ZKVo... Amn`m XoemV IamoIaM_moR>m _mUgmMm A^md Amho. Ago H m? `mMoH maUhoM H s, BH S>rb XoemV `mo` Am{U Wmoa `VtMr{Z{_Vr hmo`mgmR>r {H VrVar {dVV jo Amho. nU
Amn`m XoemV Vo \ maM _`m{XV Amho. BH S>rb XoemVgw{e{jV r-nwfmMr g`m IynM OmV Amho;hUyZM Vrg H moQ>r bmoH g`m Agbo`m Amn`m^maVmnojm VrZ, Mma qH dm ghm H moQ>r bmoH g`m
Agbo`m BH S>rb XoemV gw mo` _mUgm`m{Z{_VrgmR>r A{YH {dVV jo Amho... Amn`m XoemVhrM _moR>r CUrd Amho Am{U Amn`mbm Vr Xya Ho brMnm{hOo.'' (_mPm ^maV A_a ^maV- dm_r {ddoH mZXn> H. 24)
^maVmVrb gm_m{OH , amOH s`, Ym{_H AemHw R>`mhr g_`m `m. `m m_w`mZo qhXy g_mOm`mg_`m AmhoV. EH Va qhXy g_mO hm ~hg` g_mO
Amho Am{U mMrZ H mimnmgyZ qhXy g_mOm`m CVqH dm AdZV AdWoMo n[aUm_ gd ammda hmoVAgVmV. hUyZ `mZm Xoe ~bdmZ H am`Mm AgVmo`mZm W_V: qhXy g_mOmMm {dMma H amdm bmJVmo.{ddoH mZXmZrhr AgmM {dMma Hobobm Amho Am{U S>m.~m~mgmho~mZrhr AgmM {dMma Ho bobm Amho.
S>m. ~m~mgmho~mMo `m gX^mVrb _V gm_m{OHH mVrMr dmQ>Mmb Am{U S>m. Am~oS>H a, XmmonV R>|JS>r`m`m nwVH mV n> H . 90,91 `mda Aem H maoZm|X{dbo Jobobo Amho - `mVd qhXy g_mO g_WH amd`mMm Agob Va MmVwd` d Ag_mZVm `mMoCmQ>Z H Z qhXyg_mOmMr aMZm EH dUd d g_Vm`m XmoZ Vdm`m nm`mda Ho br nm{hOo. An`Vm{Zdma`mMm _mJ hm qhXy g_mO g_W H a`m`m_mJmnmgyZ {^ Zmhr. hUyZ _r hUVmo, Amnbo H m`{OVHo d{hVmMo Amho {VVHo M Vo am{hVmMo Amho, `mVH mhr qH Vy Zmhr.
qhXy g_mOmV amhZM Mmbbobo Amnbo qhXy g_mOn[adVZmMo d `mgmR>rMo An`momamMoH m` ho A{IbqhXy g_mO gwYmaUoMo H m` Amho, hr `mMr YmaUmAg`m_wio Jmob_oO n[afXoV S>m. ~m~mgmho~ dlr{Zdmg `mZr gmXa Hobo`m {ZdoXZmV An` dJmgAdU qhXy, mQ>oQ>Q> qhXydm ZmZ H \ m{_Q> qhXyhUmdo
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
9/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *7
Aerhr _mJUr `mZr Ho bobr hmoVr. `mMo _hdmMoH maU qhXy Y_m`m VdkmZm`m CXmmVo{df`r `mMrImr hmoVr. AJXr moQ>H CoI H amd`mMm Va EHo{R>H mUr qhXy Y_mMoVdkmZ g_Vobm H go nmofH Amho ho
gmJVmZm ~m~mgmho~ hUVmV, ""qhXy Y_mMm {gmV{Vr d _h_Xr Y_m`m {gmVmnojm {H VrVar nQ>rZog_Vo`m Vdmbm nmofH Amho - gmarM BdamMr noAmhoV. `oWoH moUr C H moUr ZrM Agm ^oX^md H aUoe` Zmhr, ho `m Y_mMo _hmZ AmoOg Vd Amho.g_mZVoMo gm_m` WmnZ hmo`mg `mnojm Xwgam AmYmagmnS>Uo H R>rU {XgVo.''
~m~mgmho~ hUVmV H s, "~ hUOo gJwU gmH ma
Ago_mZUo MwH sMo Amho d _wimV Aer H nZm Zmhrhr._wimV ~ hr EH dmMm gXoe XoUmar gmpVHgH nZm Amho. {ZJwU, {ZamH ma, gJwU gmH ma Zmhr.'~m~mgmho~mMr YmaUm hmoVr H s ~m`m gJwU gmH maH nZoMr ~wmZoqZXm Ho br Amho Am{U {ZJwU, {ZamH magH nZoMr egm Ho br Amho, `mV AV{damoY Zmhr.~dmXmMr VrZ _hmdm`o AmhoV Ago ~m~mgmho~gmJVmV. EH -gd ~M Amho. XmoZ-hUyZ _r ~MAmho. VrZ- hUyZ Vwhrhr ~ AmhmV - ho gmaoEH OrdVoMo hUOoM g_Vm d dmV`mMo Vd Amho,Ago Vo hUVmV. `mZr Ago hQ>bo H s, ~ hoAZmH bZr` Agob, nU bmoH emhrMo A{Y>mZ hUyZ~VdmBVHo^ _ Ago Xwgao H moUVohr Vd Agy eH VZmhr `m~b {Vi_m eH m Zmhr. nU VdkmZ Oar lo>Agbo Var qhXy g_mO `m Y_emm_mUo MmbVmo VoY_em _m qhXy g_mOm`m EH m_Vobm ~mYmAmUUmao AmhoAgo ~m~mgmho~mMo _V hmoVo.
{X. 21 gQ>|~a 1928 amoOr "~{hHV ^maVm'V`mZr "qhXyMo Y_em' hm AJboI {b{hbm. `mV~m~mgmho~ {b{hVmV, "A`V mMrZH mir CX`mgAmbo`m ammnH s qhXwam hoEH Amho, hr Jmo> BVH s_eha Amho H s, {VMr H moUmbmhr AmR>dU H ZXo`mMo H maU Zmhr. `m`m ~amo~arMr B{O,
Agr[a`m, amo_, Jrg dJao amo Zm_eof Pmbr hohr IaoAmho. naVw qhXyMo am BVHo {Xdg Ord Y Z am{hbohUyZ Vo ~bdmZ Amho, Ago hUUoAm_bmKoMoVgoM{dMmaey`VoMo bjU Amho, AgoM Amhmg dmQ>Vo.
qhXwamm`m An`e-nanaoMo H maU `mMr {dnarV KQ>ZmAmho, ho {Z{ddmX Amho Am{U `m AWu `mMr KQ>ZmY_emmZw n Amho, `mAWu qhXwammMm AY:nmV`m`m Y_emm_wio Pmbm Amho, ho AmoKmZoM R>aVo.'
qhXy`m Y_emmV H mbmZw n ~Xb Pmbo nm{hOoV`mgmR>r ~m~mgmho~mZr VrZ H maMobT>o {Xbobo AmhoV,Vo Ago - gm_m{OH , amOH s` Am{U Ym{_H . S>m.~m~mgmho~ Ho di {dMma _mSyZ Wm~V ZmhrV Va Vo
Midi H aVmV. bmoH OmJVrMm `Z H aVmV.bmoH m_`o VoO {Z_mU H a`mMm `Z H aVmV. `mMohUUo Ago Amho H s, "OJUo hmM H mhr OJmVbmnwfmW Zho, OJ`m`m ZmZmnar AmhoV, H mH ~irImD Z H mdiohr nwH i dfo OJVmV. naVw `m`mOrdZmV nwfmW Amho Ago H moUrhr hUUma Zmhr._`y~b aS> qH dm S>a H embm? ZmedV Xoh IMuKmbyZ `mnojmhr emdV Aer EImXr dVy m H ZKo`mgmR>r CXmhaUmW - XoemgmR>r, g`mgmR>r,~rXmgmR>r, `emgmR>r, A~ygmR>r AWdm ^yV_mmgmR>rAZoH _hmnwfmZr AZoH gJr H V`m`m ArVAmn`m nMmUmMr AmhVr {Xbr Amho. _hm^maVmVdranZr {dXwbm {hZoAmn`m nwmg Hw OV qH dm e^adfo{ZaWH Or{dV Mmb{d`mnojm KQ>H m^a namH _mMr`moV XmIdyZ _obmg Va ~ao Agm CnXoe Ho bm. VerXaoH An` _mVoZo Amn`m nwmg gmJ`mMr doi`oD Z R>onbr Amho. (gm_m{OH HmVrMr dmQ>Mmb Am{U
S>m. Am~oS>H a, n> H . 74)
dm_r {ddoH mZX Am{U S>m. ~m~mgmho~Am~oS>H a `m nwVH mVyZ
* * *
Amig BVH m gmdH me MmbVmoH s Xm[a`mbm Vm~S>Vmo~ JmR>Vo. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
_w` boI
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
10/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *8
kmZmMm Pam nwVH mV ZgyZ AZw d d {dMmaeVrV Amho. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
qMVZ
_yb{Zdmgr {dS>m . Am~oS>H a
_Yy H m~ioAmanrAm`_mUoMAmVm ~m_go\ _`o~aoM JQ>
nS>bo AmhoV. `m gd JQ>mZr nwhm EH `mdo `mgmR>r~m_go\ `m _yi {dMmagaUrbm _mZUm`m H mhr
H m`H `mZr `Z gw Hobo AmhoV. `mgmR>r bmoH emhrnVrZo gKQ>ZoMr nwZaMZm H a`mMm {ZU Ko`mVAmbm. `mbm {H VnV `e `oBb, hm doJim Amho.naVwAbrH S>`m H mimV ~m_go\ ZoOr _yb{Zdmgr hrgH nZm _mS>`mg gwdmV Hobr Amho, VrM _wimV\wbo-Am~oS>H a {dMmaYmao`m {damoYmV OmUmar Amho.
amOH maUmV CVam`MoAgob Am{U `edr hm`MoAgob Va `m amOH s` njmOdi _Zw`~i Am{U
`~i AgUo Amd`H Amho. `m{edm` njmMr^y{_H m _VXmamn`V nmohmoM{d`mgmR>r ~w{OrdrH m`H `mMr EH \ irhr Agmdr bmJVo. 1970 Vo80`m XeH mV hmM {dMma H Z H meram_ `mZr"~H dS> bmg AS> _m`Zm[aQ>r H `w{ZQ>r EbmBO\o S>aoeZ' AWmV "~m_go\ ' `m gKQ>ZoMr WmnZm Hobr.S>m. Am~oS>H a `mZr _moRm gKfmZo {_idyZ {Xbo`m
KQ>Zm_H AmajUm_wio H| d am` gaH ma_`oZmoH `m {_imbo`m Am{U Wm oSm _mUmV _`_dJu`OrdZmH So dmQ>Mmb H bmJbo`m gK{Q>V Aem
ZmoH aXma dJm^modVr ~m_go\ Zo OmioQ>mH bo.[anpbH Z njmVrb JQ>~mOrbm H Q>mibo`mX{bV, _mJmgdJu` A{YH mar d H _Mm`mZr amOH s`gmoMr dZo XmI{dUm`m H meram_ `m`m ~m_go\ bmVZ-_Z-YZmZo drH mabo. Xwgar Jmo> Aer H s, `mZmoH aXma dJmbm gwa{jVVm hdr hmoVr. Vwhr \ V dJUrm`Mr, ~X ImobrVrb {e{~amV gh^mJr hm`Mo,dfmVyZ EImX Xwgao A{YdoeZ `m`Mo, ~g. Xwgao
hUOo a`mda CV Z gKfdJao H mhr H am`Mm Zmhr,EdT>oM H am`Mo hQ>`mda gm_m{OH F U \o S>`mgmaIoXmI{d`mgmR>r H mVS>r~MmD ZmoH aXma dJmbm ~m_go\hm Cm_ n`m` dmQ>bm. X{bV-_mJmgdJu`m`m `m`h mgmR>r, `m`mdarb A`m`-A`mMmam`m{damoYmV a`mda CV Z bT>Um`m Am~oS>H arH m`H `mH So hm "~m_go\ \o _' ~ydm ZmoH aXma dJ
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
11/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *9
Amnbm Iam eyhUOoVm|S>mg_moa VwVr H aUmam _mUyg. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
qMVZ
HwMo>oZo~Ky bmJbm. a`mda bT>Umam H m`H Vm ZgVmVa, gaH mar godoVrb _mJmgdJu` A{YH mar dmH _Mmar `m`m ZmoH `m gwa{jV am{h`m Ag`m H m?AZoH H m`H `mZr Amnbo Am`w` nUmbm bmdbo, naVw
AmO hm ZmoH aXma dJ Amn`m ZmoH `m H em em~yVamhVrb, PQ>nQ> ~T>`m H em {_iVrb `mMmM \ {dMma H aV Amho. Aem AnbnmoQ>r ZmoH aXmamZmAm~oS>H admXr hUVm `oBb H m? Agmo. nU Varhr~KVm-~KVm Xoe^a ~m_go\ \ mo\ mdbr. `mM ^ _nm`mda H meram_ `mZr ZVa ~hOZ g_mO njmMrWmnZm Hobr. `mZVaMr ~gnMr Cma XoemVrbgmoMr dmQ>Mmb gdlwVM Amho. AWmV ~m_go\ Mm d
~gnMm H mhr g~Y Zmhr, Agm AbrH So Xmdm HobmOmVmo. `mV H mhr _mUmV V` Amho. H maU ~gn`mgd}gdm _m`mdVr `mZm AmVm Ver ~m_go\ `m_Zw`~imMr d `~imMr JaO Cabobr Zmhr. naVw~m_go\ Mm gX` H moU`m amOH s` njmMm g_WH dmghmZw yVrYmaH Amho, Va Vmo\ ~gnMmM. ~gnbmhrAmVm "^maV _wVr _moMm' ZmdmZoZdm amOH s` n`m`Xo`mMm `Z gw Pm`mZo _yi ~m_go\ _`o
\ mQ>m\w Q>rbm gwdmV Pmbr. AmanrAm`_mUoM AmVm~m_go\ _`o ~aoM JQ> nS>boAmhoV. `m gd JQ>mZr nwhmEH `mdo `mgmR>r ~m_go\ `m _yi {dMmagaUrbm_mZUm`m H mhr H m`H `mZr `Z gw Ho bo AmhoV.`mMmM EH ^mJ hUyZ _w~BV 2 d 3 _mMbm {d{dYJQ>mVrb H m`H `mMr ~R>H Pmbr. `m ~R>H sV g`m^mdr Agbo`m ~m_go\ `m EH m JQ>m`m Zo`mdagKQ>ZoV hHy_emhr nVrZo dmJV Ag`m~b Q>rH mH a`mV Ambr. bmoH emhr nVrZo gKQ>ZoMr nwZaMZmH a`mMm {ZU` Ko`mV Ambm. `mbm {H VnV `e`oBb, hm doJim Amho. naVw AbrH S>`m H mimV~m_go\ ZoOr _yb{Zdmgr hr gH nZm _mS>`mg gwdmVHobr Amho, VrM _wimV \w bo-Am~oS>H a {dMmaYmao`m{damoYmV OmUmar Amho. ~m_go\ Mo gX` EH _oH mZm^oQ>`mZVa qH dm g^m-~R>H m_`o"O` _yb{Zdmgr'
hUyZ EH _oH mMo dmJV H aVmV. "O`^r_'`m OmJr"O` _yb{Zdmgr' hm eX Ambm. AmVm hr _yb{ZdmgrH m` ^mZJS> Amho, ho OmUyZ Ko`mMm `Z Ho bm._yb{Zdmgr `m {dMmamMm g`m OmoamV Mma gw Amho.
`mda Img nwpVH m {b{h`m AmhoV, "_yb{ZdmgrZm`H ' ZmdmMo EH nmZr dmnhr Mmb{dbo OmVo._yb{Zdmgr hr _mS>UrM _yimV ofmda AmYm[aV Amho,hUyZ Vr _hm^`H a Amho. CXmhaUmW, ~m_go\ MoC{>H m` Va, _yb{Zdmgr `m VWmH {WV {gmVm`mAmYmamda `m XoemVrb ~mU dJgmoSyZ gmSoghm hOmaOmVtZm OmoS>Uo. `m gmSoghm hOma OmVrMo H S>~moio~mYyZ H m` H am`Mo Va, hUo amr` AmXmobZ! hUOo
H m`, Va H mhrM Zmhr. Va _J `m _yb{ZdmgrMo BVHoVmo_ H m _mO{d`mV Ambo Amho? \wbo-Am~oS>H ar{dMmamZm ~Jb XoD Z amOH s` dmWgmY`mgmR>rM hmgmam IQ>mQ>mon Mmbbm Amho, AgohQ>bo Va Vo MwH sMoR>aUma Zmhr. hUOo CXmhaUmW, _yb{Zdmgr Zm`Hdmnm`m 5 gQ>|~a 12 `m AH mV ~m_go\ `m EH mMmaH mMo ^mfU {g H a`mV AmboAmho. `mV VohUVmV, naXoer `wao{e`Z ~mUmMr `dWm CXdV
H Z _yb{Zdmgr `dWm Wm{nV H a`mgmR>r~m_go\ Mr {Z{_Vr H a`mV Ambr Amho. hUOo `mXoemVrb ~mU ho naHo AmhoV d gmao A~mUr _yi^maVr` AmhoV, Aer `mMr _mS>Ur Amho. `mgmR>rVWmH {WH HwUmVar EH m H mn{ZH_mZddeemkmMm AmYma KoVmV. `mZohUo Ho bo`mH mhr S>rEZE MmMUrV ~mU naH s` Ag`mMo Am{UBVa gmSoghm hOma OmVrM \ _yi ^maVr` Ag`mMmemoY bmdbm Amho. hUOo ~mU gmoSyZ gmao_yb{Zdmgr. Omo{V~m \w bo `mMr `m {R>H mUr AmR>dUhmoVo. AmnU {MaOrd Ag`mMm d Am{XZmam`UmMmAdVma Ag`mMm Xmdm H aUm`m H mn{ZHnaewam_mbm Omo{V~mZr Oer `mbm ghm _{h`m`mAmV hOa amh`mMr ZmoQ>rg ~Omdbr hmoVr, VerMZmoQ>rg `m VWmH {WV _mZddeemkmbm ~Omdmdr
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
12/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *10
eara nm`m_wio, _Z g`m_wioAm{U Am_m kmZm_wUon{d hmoVmo. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
amoO`m OodUmMr Mr dmT>dUmao,ew gmpdH VoMr OmoS> Agbobod 50 dfmnmgyZ
gmobmnyaH am`m X`mV WmZ Agbobo
11/12/13, BS>pQ>`b BQ>oQ>, hmoQ>Jr amoS>, gmobmnya - 413003.
{ddoH {dMmaAH mg Am_`m
hm{XH ew oN>m!
bmJUma Amho.dmV{dH nmhVm S>m. ~m~mgmho~ Am~oS>H a `mZr
^maVr` g_mO`dWoMr, gHVrMr, Y_JWmMr H R>moa{M{H gm Ho br Amho. _mZddeemm`m AmYmamZo
`mZr OmVr` `dWoMo gm{VH {dbofU Ho bo Amho.Am` ~mho Z Ambo d `mZr _yi`m AZm`mZm qOHy ZXm` qH dm Jwbm_ ~Z{dbo. Am` hUOo ~mU Am{U~mH sMo AZm` hUo ey dm ~hOZ Aem AmOda`mVH bmXy B{Vhmgmbm Am~oS>H amZr ey nydu H moU hmoVoAm{U An` _yiMoH moU hmoVo, `m XmoZ emoY~YmVN>oX XoUmao Zdo {ZH f H mT>boAmhoV. ey ho nydu Am`MhmoVo, eymMo qhXy-Am` g_mOmV _yiMo WmZ Xwg`m
hUOo j{` dUmV hmoVo. ~mU d j{``m`mVrb dMddmXmVyZ eymZm Mm`m dUmVQ>mHy Z `mZm ImbMm XOm Xo`mV Ambm, Ago~m~mgmho~ gmJVmV. AmVm Am`mZm naH s`g_Om`Mo Va _J nydml_r`m eymZm Am{UAmVm`m ~hOZmZmM Cnao R>a{d`mgmaIo Amho.`mZVa An` _yiMo H moU, `mMmhr ~m~mgmho~mZremoY KoVbm Amho. _yiMo Am{U naHo Agbo ^oXmMoamOH maU H aUm`mZr ~m~mgmho~ H m` hUVmV VoZrQ>EH Xm g_OyZ `mdo. VohUVmV, {d{^ demMm {ZU`H a`mMo dm{eH earaaMZmem hoM Iao em Agob,Va qhXy g_mOmVrb {d{^ OmVrZm `m emmMr H gmoQ>rbmdyZ nm{h`mg An` hoAm` Am{U {dS> demnojm{^ demMo bmoH AmhoV, hm {gmV H mob_SyZ nS>Vmo.`m _moO_mnmd Z ho {g hmoV AmhoH s, ~mU dAn` hoEH mM demMobmoH AmhoV. Oa ~mU
Am`AgVrb Va An`hr Am`M AmhoV. ~mUOa {dS> AgVrb Va An`hr {dS>M AmhoV.~mU ZmJ demMo AgVrb Va An`hr ZmJdemMo AmhoV. `m AmYmamda An`Vobm
de^oXmMm AmYma Zmhr, Agm {ZH f~m~mgmho~mZr H mT>bm Amho. MmVwd` `dWoVAn` `m AdUmMr Cnnmr H er Pmbr, `mbmhrH moUVm gKfH maUr^yV Amho , hm EH dV MM}Mm{df` Amho. naVw ~m~mgmho~mZr `oWrb gdg_mO`dWoMo_yi emoYyZ H mT>boAmho, ey nydu H moUhmoVo ho gm{JVbo, An` _yiMo H moU hmoVo, `mMrhrgm{VH CH b H Z XmI{dbr. _J ~m_go\ AmVm
H moU`m _yb{ZdmgrMm emoY KoV AmhoV?~m~mgmho~m`m gemoYZmda-{gmVmda `mMm {dmgAmho H s Zmhr? Xwgao Ago H s, ~m~mgmho~mZr AmhrH moU `mMo _yi emoYyZ `m g_mOm`m hmVmV OJmZodrH mabobm ~w {Xbm. ~w ofmbm _yR>_mVr m`bmgmJVmo. ~w g_Vm, `m`, ~Yw md, _r, H UoMmAmJh YaVmo. ~w OJm`m - _mZdm`m H `mUmMr^mfm H aVmo. _J EImm XoemV de^oXm`m AmYmamda_yiMo H moU d Cnao H moU Aer {d^mJUr H aUo {H VnV`mo` Amho? ~m~mgmho~mZm Om{V`dWm _moS>m`MrhmoVr. ~m_go\ bm OmVr _moS>m``m AmhoV H sOmoS>m``m AmhoV? \ V OmVr OmoS>m``mM AgVrbVa Vo Am~oS>H ar {dMmam`m {damoYmV AmhoV, AgohUmdo bmJob.
(gm^ma : X. bmoH gmm, 18 _mM 2013)
qMVZ
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
13/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *11
`em`m _mJoYmdyZH m, `embm Vw_`m _mJoYmdym. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
KS dy`m OrdZ Amnw bo
_wHw b H m{ZQ>H aAmOM `moJ gw H m!
X{jUoda _{Xam`m npM_og JJm_mBMm KmQ>Amho. _{XamV _m gmaXmMr Imobr Amho Am{U `m`mCO`m hmVmbm Agbo`m KmQ>m`m nm``mda ~gyZMhm boI {b{h`mMm `moJ Ambm. _m gmaXmMr N>moQ>rerImobr nmhZ Zoh_rM _Z ^mamdyZ OmV. `m gVrZo `mN>moQ>mem OmJoV nmM XeH R>mHy agodm Ho br. ^maVr`n{VdVoMm CmwJ AmXe Agbob `mM gma OrdZhUOo EH VnM! Zoh_r \ V Xo`mMmM {dMma,dV:gmR>r H mhrM ZH mo. am_HUmMm ggma Var Ho dT>mA\ mQ>! amoO H _rV H _r 25-30 bmoH mgmR>r gmJ-^mV amYmdm bmJV AgUma, nU _mCbrZ A`V o_mZR>mHw am`m IQ>mi nmoamZm gm mib. no_m_wio `mJAm{U dam` H gAmZXXm`r hmoD Z OmV, `mM ho CXmmCXmhaUM Amho.
lram_H UmZr dam`mMr gmYZm Ho br hmoVr. `mZr
`mM KmQ>mda AZoH `moJ H Z _Zmbm gH ma {XbmhmoVm. R>mHw amZr H Xm{MV BWoM Q>mH m-_mQ>rMm`moJgwm Ho bm hmoVm. S>m`m hmVmV EH n`mM ZmU-~JmbrV "Q>mH m' hUOo n`m Am{U CO`m hmVmV_mVr KoD Z- "Q>mH m-_mQ>r' Agm On H am`Mm. ngmAm{U _mVr Xmohr g_mZM AmhoV, Agm gH ma _ZmdaOdm`Mm Am{U Xmohr EH mM doir JJm_mBV \o Hy Zm`Mo. amoO-amoO Ag H Z nemMm _m oh nma Xya Jobm.Ho di BVH M Zmhr, Va nem~b _ZmV MS> {VaH maC^m am{hbm. Ag hUm`Mo H s, R>mHw amZm Zm`mMmneM ghZ hmoV Zgo. Vo Ago H mhr H am`Mo Ogo H s{dOoMm PQ>H mM bmJbm OUy.
Za| Oohm X{jUodambm {Z`{_V `oD bmJbm Vohm`mbmhr ho bmoH m`m ~mob`mVyZ EoHy Amb H s,lram_H UmZm nemMm ne MmbV Zmhr. nU, Za|
`moJmVyZM Amnbr j_Vm H iVo Am{U dV:da lm T> hmoVo. AmO`m `wdH m_`o hr
Am_lm Zg`m_wioH emdaM `mMr lm am{hbobr Zmhr. `oH `wdH mZo`moJmnmgyZ
gwdmV H am`bm hdr. `moJmVyZ Oo{ZH f{ZKVrb `mVyZ dV:Mr Agr_, AZV j_Vm
bjmV oBb. AmnU OoR>adVmoVoH eH Vmo, hm {ddmg {Z_mU hmoBb. dm_r {ddoH mZXmZm
AgoM {ddmgy`wdH Ano{jV AmhoV.
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
14/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *12
`mZ H a`mZoEH mJVm dmT>Vo. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
Hw R>`mhr Jmo>rda ghOnUo H gm H m` {ddmgR>odUma? `mZ narjm `m`M R>adb. R>mHy a ZmZmbmJobo AgVmZm `mZo `m`m MmXarImbr EH n`mMZmU R>odb. R>mHy aOr AmKmoi H Z Ambo Am{U
nbJmda ~g`m ~g`mM OmoamV CMH bo, ""H mhr VarAmho BWo! H mhr Var Amho!'' Za| Im~mAmSyZ nmhVhmoVm. Vmo `moJm`m n[aUm_mM {ZarjU H aUm`memkmgmaIm Vna hmoVm. R>mHw am`m godoV `mMm ^mMmAgm`Mm. `mZo MmXa PQ>H br Am{U n`mM ZmUO{_Zrda nSyZ IUH b.
R>mHy a emoYy bmJbo, Za| Hw R> bnbm`? Im~m_mJyZnwT>o `oV Amoemibo`m Za|ZoR>mHw amMo nm` Yabo. `mZo
KoVbo`m narjo~b IoX `V Ho bm. nU,lram_H UmZr `mbm C^o Hobo. K> H dQ>mibo Am{UA{^_mZmZo ~mobbo, ""Aao! IoX H gbm? Vy Va MmJbMHo bg. Jw bm `dpWV nmhm`bm hd. {Xdgm COoS>r,amr AYmamV nmaIyZ _JM lm R>odmdr Jw da.'' Y`Vmo Jw AZ Y` Vmo {e`! `moJ hm lm OmJ`mMm_hdmMm _mJ Amho. Ho di Jw daM Zmhr,dV:daXoIrb `moJ H am`bm hdm. `moJmVyZMAmnbr j_Vm H iVo Am{U dV:da lm T> hmoVo.
AmO`m `wdH m_`o hr Am_lm Zg`m_wioH emdaM `mMr lm am{hbobr Zmhr. `oH `wdH mZo`moJmnmgyZ gwdmV H am`bm hdr. `moJmVyZ Oo {ZH f{ZKVrb `mVyZ dV:Mr Agr_, AZV j_Vm bjmV
`oBb. AmnU Oo R>adVmo Vo H eH Vmo, hm {ddmg{Z_mU hmoBb. dm_r {ddoH mZXmZm AgoM {ddmgy `wdHAno{jV AmhoV.
Mbm, _J AmOM `moJ gw H m! emar[aH ,
_mZ{gH d ~m{H j_Vobm nmaIUmao `moJ H am`bmhdo. CXmhaUmW, amoO 100 gy Z_H ma KmbUo. hm`moJ e{ narjUmgmo~VM Amn`m j_VmMm H gbmdUmam `moJ Amho. dmMVmZm Ae` dmQ>Umam hm`moJ AZoH `wdH mZr H Z nm{hbm`. `mZr OgodV:bm M{H V Ho bo Vgo VwhrXoIrb H eH Vm._mZ{gH j_VogmR>r Amn`m AmdS>r-{ZdS>rda `moJH am`bm hdo. Oo AmdS>V Vo gmoS>m`M Am{U Oo AmdS>V
Zmhr Vo _wm_ H am`M. gH mir bdH a CR>Uo, WS>nm`mZo AmKmoi H aUo, Amn`m AmdS>rMm nXmW EH_{h`mH [aVm gmoSyZ XoUo, ho gmono gmono _mZ{gH `moJAmhoV. `m `moJm_wio dV:Mr j_Vm AmoiIVm ddmT>dVm `oVo. ~m{H `moJmH [aVm dm`m` gdm}m_AmhoV. Ae`m` dmQ>Um`m {df`mM nwVH{ZdS>m`M. amoO H mhr R>amdrH nmZ dmMm`Mr ddV:`m ^mfoV {Q>nU H mT>m`Mr. _m, `m nwVHdmM`m`m `moJmgmR>r dV:`m ej{UHA`mgm`{V[aV nwVH {ZdS>m`M. hm gamd _JA`mgmV Am{U nwT>o `mdgm{`H OrdZmVXoIrb H aVm`oD eH Vmo. Mbm, _J gw H m `moJ! AmOM!
(gnH : 9497472232)
nMZgWo`m {d{dY VH mar dmadma hm oUmar A{g[S>Q>r, AnMZ, nmoQ>mVrb Aga
X_m, dMm{dH ma, nmR>XwIr, AJXwIr, gmYoXwIr, _b~Vm {`mMo {d{dY AmOma, gmX`g_`m `mgmR>r {deof nMH _CnMma.
S>m.gm. {H aU nmR>H (E_.S r. Am`wd}X _o{S grZ)gw~`_ H mbog, dZJJm-H Um Jm_rU ~Ho`mda, _wamaOr noR>,
gmobmnya. \ moZ 0217 - 2740631 _mo. 9372144434
* gnyUAm`wd}X nVrZo VnmgUr* gdH ma`m nMH _mMr gmo`* A`mdV nMH _ H|
* B_Ogr ~H An* Ho air` CnMmamMr gmo`*
gw{dYm*
KS>dy`m OrdZ Amnwbo
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
15/36
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
16/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *14
`Xm qH {MPmo@h {n Bd _XmY: g_^d&VXm gdkmo@_r`^dXd{bV __ _Z:&&`Xm qH {MpH {MX~wYOZgH memXdJV &VXm _yImo@_r{V da Bd _Xmo_o`nJV: &&
OYt H mhr H mhr h[a H {d Ago eX {eH bm|&
VYr _r gdk {ng_ _X| `mM ^abm| &&OYt H mhr ZoU| hUy{Z dXbo n{S>V _bm &VXm _mPm Jdda gH ihr hm CVabm &&
^VharZ `m bmoH m_`o kmZmM {dd {H Vr AJmY Amho mMM dUZ Hobob Amho. kmZ ho {H VrAn[a{_V Amho `mMr OmUrd gdmZm ZgVo. H mhr H mhr bmoH `m kmZm`m gr_maofo`m OdigwXm OmV ZmhrV.^m{VH emmVboWmoS>ogo {gXmV Vohr AYdQ> OmUyZ KoVmV Am{U VodT>mdaM kmZrnUmMm Q>o m {_adm`bmbmJVmV. EImXm IamM kmZr ^oQ>VmoOmo MS> kmZ AgyZgwXm A{Ve` Z_ AgVmo honm{h`mda `m Ank_mUgmbm Amn`m An_VrMr OmUrd hmoVo Am{U `mM JdhaU hmoV.
kmZm`m gr_m `m H moUr AmIbo`m ZmhrV. OgOg AmnU kmZm`m ZdZ`m mVmV doe H aVmoVgVem `m`m H jm jr[VOmgma`m bm~ bm~ Om`bm bmJVmV Am{U kmZ hoAgr_ Amho `mMr H nZm`m`bm bmJVo. Hw R>`m Var emmV`m Mma Jmo>r _mhrV AgU hUOo kmZ Zho. kmZ hoAgr_ Amho ho _mhrVhmoU hUOo kmZ.
emk A~Q> AmBQ>mBZ ~gMr dmQ> nhmV EH m PmS>mImbr C^m hmoVm. {VW EH {derVbm VUAmbm. AmBQ>mBZZ`mMr AmoiI H Z KoVbr. Vohm VmoVU hUmbm, _r {dkmZmMm m`mnH Amho Am{UAmVm S>mQ>aoQ H aV Amho. AmBQ>mBZ `mbm n[aM` H Z XoVmZm hUmbm, _mPZmd A~Q> AmBQ>mBZ. _r{dkmZmMm {dmWuAmho.
`mbm kmZm`m H jm Agr_ AmhoV hoH iV Vmo O_^a dV:bm {dmWr g_OV AgVmo . naVw `mbm`m gr_mMr OmUrd ZgVoVmo dV:bm ~aM H mhr g_OV AgVmo. kmZodamZr kmZodar {bhZ Pm`mZVa qH ~hZmVw_MoHobo&Y_ H sVZ Vo {gXrg Jobo& `oW _mPo Or Cabo & nmBH nU && Ag Z_nUmZhQ>bo Amho. Iao{dmZZoh_r Z_M AgVmV. Vo \ imZr bJS>bo`m PmS>mgmaIo AgVmV. Ag bJS>bobPmS> \ im`m Amo`mZImbr dmH V AgV. nU `m PmS>mbm \ iM bmJV ZmhrV. Vo PmS> _m kmZ Zgbo`m nU kmZmMm JddmhUm`m Ank MT>ob _mUgmgmaIVmR>M AgV.
A_VdMZ 7AaqdX Omoer, gmobmnya 9370408926
Zr{VeVH
dmdb~Z _Zmo~b dmT>dVo. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
17/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *15
Amn`m _ZmMoJwbm_ hmoD ZH m. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
{gHXaMm {dO` Iw`m _ZmZo_m` H Zhr `mOJmo`mMm ^maVmVbm {dO` nOm~_Yrb N>moQ>o amOo dgaXmamn`V _`m{XV hmoVm. EH `yZmZr (JrH ) boIH{b{hVmo H s, qgYy ZXr AmobmSyZ `m XoemVrb 80
hOma ^maVr` _mabo Jobo, {ZX Vm, aVnmV `mZr^abo`m EH m naH s` dmarbm ^maVr`mZr Vm|S> {Xbo.{gHXa _obm nU `mZo _mJo Zo_bo`m go`yH gbm gZnyd305 _`o VU _JY g_mQ d MmU` {e` MJw_m` `mZo nam^yV Hobo. go`yH gZo A\ Jm{UVmZ,~bw{MVmZ ho Xoe MJwmg ~hmb Ho bod da Amnbr_wbJr MJwmg {Xbr.
`mM nmQ>brnw _JY am`mMm H mb gZnyd300 VogZnyd 200. Vmo g_mQ> AemoH m`m _`yZo gnbm.AemoH hm ^maVmVbm \ ma _moR>m {dVmam`m am`mMmg_mQ> hmoVm. gZnyd 184 Vo gZnyd 72 _`o nw`{_ewJ, ZVa H md de `mZr nmQ>brnwMoam` Ho bo. gZnyd
n{h`m eVH mV {V>mZ (nR>U) `oWrb gmVdmhZm`mam`mMm Ama Pmbm Vmo gZ 225 n`V, VrZeo df}am` H Z gnbm. `m~amo~a gZnyd B{VhmgmMm eodQ>Pmbm.
g_mQ> AemoH mZVa `yZmZr (JrH ) am`H V}qhXwWmZmda nwhm dm`m H bmJbo. nw`{_ ewJm`mH mimV {S>{_{Q g MmbyZ Ambm. nwT>o `mMm deO_Z|S>a ({_qbX) MmbyZ Ambm. gZnyd Xg`m eVmXrV
eH , BS>monm{e Z `m`m dm`m Pm`m. eH dgmVdmhZ `m`mV Iyn df} bT>m`m Pm`m. Hw emUdemMm H {ZH , M>Z `mMohr H mhr H mi Wm{ZHamOmer `w Pmbo. nU, `m`m demVbm Xm_m hmeodQ>Mm amOm habm. EH Va Vo ^maVm`m dm``og ~mhoaWm{`H Pmbo qH dm `m`mVbo ~hVoH bmoH ^maVr`g_mOmV {_giyZ Jobo. ^maVr` g_mOmZo`mZm Amn`mgHVrV gm_mdyZ KoVbo.
gZ 200 n`V hm gJim _m_bm MmbyZ gnbm.{Vgao eVH _m, AY:H ma_` _mZbo OmVo. `mH mimVrb H mhrhr KS>m_moS>r AmT>iV ZmhrV. `mZVa^maVr` B{VhmgmV EH gwdU`wJ AdVabo. MJwn{hbm g_wJw, MJw Xgam hUOoM {dH_m{X``mZr gZ 300 Vo 500 `m H mimV ^maVmV Oo`mgwIg_XrZo`wV Ago \ ma _moR>o gm_m` C^o Ho bo.
_mohZ ^mJdV, Zm{eH
^maVmMm B{Vhmg ^mJ 2
AdbmoH Z 5000 dfmMo
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
18/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *16
ZH mam_H {dMmamZm _ZmV Wmam XoD ZH m. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
{dH_ gdV gw H aUmam amOm hm {dH_m{X`M hmo`,Ago ~`mM B{VhmgH mamMo _V Amho. ho _V JmYa`mg {dH _m{X`mMm H mi gZnyd n{h`m eVH mVnmohmoMVmo. {dH_ gdVH mbJUZoMm {dMma H aVm `mbm
nwQ>r {_iVo. eH mMm namO` H aUmam hUyZ `mbm"eH m[a' nXdr m Pmbr. CmZMm g_mQ> {dH _m{X``m`m Xa~mamV H m{bXmg hmoVm VmohmM {dH _ gdVeH gw H aUmam amOm Aer OZ_mZgmV {V_m Amho.eodQ>Mm Jw H XJw `mbm hadyZ hUmMm amOm Vmoa_mU,{_{haHw b `mZr Jw gm_m` gndbo.
gZ 530 _`o`m hwUmZm WmZoa`m ^mH adYZ`mZo gndbo. nwT>o `m`m HwimV am`dYZ, hfdYZ ho
amOo Pmbo. gZ 647 _`o hfm`m _`yZVa ho am`b`mg Jobo.gZ 350 Vo1200 n`V AZoH Cma ^maVmVboamOo
am` H aV, nanamer _r, bT>mB H aV am{hbo. `mVm_w`mZo {Vhma, MXobo, H bMwar, na_ma (_midm)Mmbw`, MmhmZ, Jhadma (H ZmoO), H N>nKQ>(Mmbw` hoM gmoiIr). MmhmZm_`o ndramO VVr` hmCma ^maVmVbm gdmV {gX g_mQ> hmo . 1200 _`o
_h_X KmoarZo gndbobm hm eodQ>Mm qhXg_mQ XIbKo`mOmoJm hmoVm. 712 _`o _h_X {~ZMo qgY`mXmhra amOmda Pmbo`m AmH _UmZVa nyU qgY mVmda`mMm H Om Pmbm.
`m H mbmdYrV X{jU ^maVmV AZoH amOde ZmXVhmoVo. Mmbw`, H X~, amHw Q,> `mXd H _mZo_hmammV,AmYmV H mH Vr` dmaJi, AOyZ X{jUoH S>o hmo gi,Moa, Mmob , nmS> AZoH am`o. gdWm{ZH qhX am`o .nU, nana o_ Zmhr. XiUdiU Zmhr. \ ma XrKXb`AVam_wio CmaoVrb KS>m_moS>r H im`bm _mJ Zmhr,Aem amr`Vm{dhrZ AdWoV KmoaV nS>bo hmoVo.
_h_wX JOZdr hm A\ Jm{UVmZ`m JOZrMm.1000 Vo 1026 _Yrb gmo_ZmWdarb `mMr dmarH_mZo 18 dr hmoVr. Xadfu dmarMm aVr~ Kmbmdm Vgm.Vmo JOZrhyZ gmo_ZmW bwQ>m`bm na`m XoemV `oVmo. naVw
_hmam, X{jU ^maVm`m amOmZm gmo_ZmW Xa dmQ>VhmoVo. amOm, _r, YmZ, goZmnVr, gmJma, ^yJmob kmZrOUy H moUr _mUygM `m am mV, XoemV, ^y_rV {Z_mUPmbm Zmhr. VWmH {WV Ym{_H , gmH{VH Eo` hmoVo
nU amOH s`, EH amr`dmMr OmUrd H moUmbmhrZhVr.
_h_wX JOZr `oD Z Jobm, ZVa Ambm _h_yX Kmoar.JOZr {dX EH Q>m AZJnmb bT>bm, Kmoar{dXndramO MmhmZ bT>bm. H mhr aOnyV amOo gmo~V hmoVo,H ZmoO`m O`MX amR>moSgmaIo Kar Jn ~gbo. `mZoMKmoarbm ~mobmdUo Hobo hmoVo. "O`MX VyZo XoeH mo ~a~mXH a {X`m, Jam|H mo bmH a Xoe_o Am~mX H a {X`m.'
1193, 1194 _`o KmoarZo W_ ndramO, ZVaO`MXbm gn{dbo. Kmoar 1207 _`o _aU nmdbm.1206 Vo 1210 Jwbm_ demMm HwVw~rZ Eo~H ,1211 Vo 1236 e_gwrZ BVwV{Ve, 1266 ~b~Z{XrMm gwbVmZ Pmbm. 1286 _`o Vmo _aU nmdbm.{IbOr de dmQM nmhV hmoVm
ObmbwrZ, AbmCrZ 1296 Vo 1316. ho{XrhZ X{jUoV Imobda Kwgbo. 8000 dmam{Zer
`mZo Xod{Jar gndbr, daJi gndbo, hmo gi,nmS>{dX _{bH H m\y abm YmS>bo, Vmo am_oamn`VMmbyZ Jobm. VoWo `mZo _moR>r _erX C^mabr. 1361 bm{IbOr de gnbm. VwKbH de AmbmM. 1320 Vo1412 `mVbmM Vmo doS>m _h_X Xod{Jarbm amOYmZrAmUyZ naV ZoUmam. Mm_S>mMo, Vm`mMo {e o , ZmUrH aUmam. _wh_X VwKbH `m _`yZoVmo de AmQ>monbm.
hgZ JJy `mZo Jwb~Jm (H b~wJu) `oWo ~hm_Zram` Wmnbo. Vo gZ 1347 Vo 1482 _`o gnbo. hoam` X{jU ^maVmV WmnZ Pmbo hmoVo. `mMm {Xrer,Cmaoer H mhr g~Y ZhVm. 1498 _`o ZJaMr{ZOm_emhr, dhmS>mV E{bMnyaMr B_mXemhr,{dOmnyaMr Am{Xbemhr, ~rXaMr ~arXemhr AZJmodiH m|S>mMr Hw Vw~emhr Ago ~hm_Zr am`mMo 5VwH S>o Pmbo. hUOo 1 gwbVmZ hmoVm AmVm 5 Pmbo.
^maVmMm B{Vhmg ^mJ 2
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
19/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *17
`m`mV gdm`m {hVmMr ^mdZm AgVoVona_m_Vdmbm mV hmoVmV. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
am` H am`bm gJim X{jU ^maV _moH imM hmoVm. hram`o EH _oH mV {_gibr, doJir am{hbr d eodQ>r1686 _`o AmaJOo~mZo {dOmnya, JmodiH m|S>m_moJbemhrV AmUbr. ZJa ehmOhmZZo gndbohmoVo.
1336 Vo 1565 `m 229 dfmV {dO`ZJagm_m` EH m {dwbVo_mUo M_HyZ Jobo. `mgm_m`mMr VwJ^mH mR>r 9 bmI dVrMr amOYmZrhmoVr. h[aha d ~w `mZr ~hm_Zr`m d ZVa 5 emm`mCamda ho am` Wmnbobo hmoVo. `m ~bembr amOmZo_wgb_mZr am`H `mZm bJm_ KmVbm. `mZm HUm,VwJ^o`m Imbr OmD {Xbo Zmhr.
nU, XdmMm KmV Pmbm. Vm{bH moQ (amjgVmJS>r)
(a gJr-VJS>Jr hr Jmdo) `oWo 1565 _`o{dO`ZJagm_m`mMm AV Pmbm. `m`m {damoYmV ZJa, {dOmnya,JmodiH m|S>m `oWrb gd gwbVmZ EH Ambo. ZJaMr_wbwI _XmZ Vmo\ gmo~V KoVbr. AZ{dO`ZJa AVmgZobo. 6 _{hZo amOYmZrMr byQ> Mmby hmoVr AZ OiVhmoVr. qhX am` hmo`mg Xdhr AmS> Ambo.
_wh_X VwKbH mMm _`yd demMm eodQ hm o`mnyduM^maVmV AZoH dmYrZ am`o {Z_mU Pmbr. `mV
~Jmb, OmZnya, _mbdm, JwOamW, _odmS>, Amo[agm hr_wI hmoVr Am{U ~hm_Zr`m nmZo nyam X{jU ^maV{Xr gwbVmZmnmgyZ {d^V Pmbm.
1343 _`o daJi`m H mH Vr` H UZm`H Zo qhXamOmMm EH gK {Z_mU Hobm. `mV mag_w, H{nbam`o gm_rb Pmbr. ~hm_ZrMo ~S> VwKbH `mZo gnw>mVAmUbo. `mV 1388 _`o {XrMr H _Omoar nmhZV_yabJmZo ^maVdfmda AmH _U Ho bo. hm VwH hmoVm.`m`m dmarZo Pmbobr qhX OoMr hmZr _moOVm`o`mOmoJr Zmhr. `mZo OmVmZm ^maVr` H bmH ma,{enH ma ~amo~a Zobo d g_aH X_`o ^maVmgma`m{gX B_maVr ~mY`m.
VwKbH mZVa {XrV g X d bmoXr demMo gwbVmZAmbo. 1526 _`o nm{ZnV`m n{h`m bT>mBV`mVrb B~m{h_ bmoXrnwT>o ~m~a C^m R>mH bm. bmoXr
habm Am{U ~m~a _moJb gm_m`mMm n{hbm ~mXehmPmbm. `oWyZ {Xrmam qhXWmZda gnyU hH _V _moJbam`mMr Pmbr. Vr Ver 1862 _`o eodQ>Mm {ZOud~mXehm ~hmXaehm O\ a`m _aUmZo gnbr. aJyZbm
BJOmZr `mbm hnma Ho bohmoVo.AbrH S>bm hUOo 1526 ZVaMm _moJb A_b
H mi Iyn n> Amho. H maU H s, _moJb Xa~maMo amoOModm {bhZ R>odUmao ZmoH a {XrV d ~mXehmgmo~V_mo{h_oda AgV. _moJb amOdQ> gw Pmbr ~m~amnmgyZ d{VMm AV BJOmMo qhXWmZmda am` Am`mZo Pmbm.15 dm ~mXehm ~hmXaehm O\ a Xoem~mhoa aJyZ `oWodXnUr _aU nmdbm. BJOm`m >rZo~S Agbo`m
1857 `m g_amV gh^mJr `m AmamonmImbr `m`m_wbmZm BJOmZr {dZmMmH er Jmo`m KmbyZ R>ma Ho bohmoVo. "ey eof C XoD Z`o ' hogw m{fV BJOmZm nmR>hmoVo. NnVr emhbm, `mMm noedm ~mOramd `mZm`mMm {dga nS>bm hmoVm hUyZ {ZOm_mgma`m gmnmMm`mZr {Zde Ho bm Zmhr, AgoB{Vhmg gmJVmo, Agmo.
eya, H V~Jma, Bbm_Mo go nmBH Ago ZmdKo`mOmoJo _moJb ~mXehm n{hbo \ V 6 ~mXehm Pmbo.
1526 Vo 1857 hUOo 331 df} _moJb Kam`mZo `mIS>m` Xoemda am` Hobo. BN>o_mUo,Amd`H Vo_mUo qhX Ooda, Y_mda, _{Xamda Owby_O~XaVr Ho br. `m{dX 1630 _`o O_bobm EHqghmMm N>mdm N>nVr {edmOr amOm C^m R>mH bm. hoam` hmdo, hr lrMr BN>m, Ago g~moYyZ `m N>m`mZodam` Wm{nbo. _moJb, X{jUoVrb emm, BJO,{gr `mZm nwZ CZ `mZoqhXY_, am `mMo ajU Ho bo.`m`m nwT>rb AZw m`mZr dam`mMo gm_m` Ho bo.nU, H mbmKmV 1818 _`o ^maVmda BJOmMo am`Ambo. 1947 _`o ^maV dV Pmbm. nU, I{S>VhmoD Z. `m XXeoZo H moUmhr qhX _mUgmbm doXZmPm`m{edm` amhUma ZmhrV.
(H _e:)
***
^maVmMm B{Vhmg ^mJ 2
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
20/36
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
21/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *19
Xm~` Am{U oH S>nUm hm AY_hmo`. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
Xa _{h`m`m 4 VmaIobm nmoQ>mZo "{ddoH {dMma' nmR>{dbm OmVmo. 25VmaIon`V AH {_imbm Zmhr Va Amhmbm B-_ob([email protected]) qH dm SMS (9422649239) qH dmnmoQ>H mS>ZoH idm. (\ moZ d Z ZH mo). Xgam AH nmR>dbm OmBb.
nmdVr H_mH , qH dm dJUrXma H _mH ({ddoH {dMma`m nm{H Q>mdarbn{hbr Amoi) H idUo A`md`H Amho.
doioV AH Z {_im`mg...
aU^y_r`m `m WmZr `wXoPmbr Vr y_r hr aU^y_r hUyZ
bmoH _mZgmV WmZ {_idVoAm{U `m y_rMohr XeZ bmoH_moRm lXoZoKoVmV.
Hw jo ho aUjo Ag`m_wio `mMo XeZ AmOhr^maVr`m`m _ZmV ^mdbhar CR>dVo. hoM WmZOJV{d`mV ^JdV JrV oM o O_WmZ Amho. `oWoM^JdVmZoAOyZmbm JrVmonXoe Hobm hmoVm. m y_rMoAm{UWmZmMo_mhm` AmoiIyZ `oWoAmVm JrVm _{Xa C^oHoboAmho.
Hw jomOdi nm{ZnV ho aUjo Amho. Wm oS >mnpM_oH S>o {MmmoS>Mm _hmamUm Vmn `mMr gw{gX
aU^y_r hXrKmQ hr gwXm n{d aU y_r Amho._hmammV {ed^yZr dam` {Z{_VrgmRr AZoH WmZr`wXo Hobr. `m`m dm_r{Z godH mZr {H `oH WmZrmUmnU Ho bo. VoWrb aU^y_r aU`kmMo WmZ hUyZAmhmg n{d dmQ>Vo. qghJS>, nmdZqIS>, AeraU`kmMr ^y_r kmV AmhoM.
`m ^y_rda Mm\oH amZr aSMm dY Hobm `m y_rdae a dfmZVahr VmogJ JmOdUmaoZmQ `wdH -`wdVtZrgmXa Hobo. ghmdYr bmoH mZr `m amo_mMH ZmQH mMm`moJ nm{hbm. Vr aU y_r HodTr n{d _mZbr OmVo `mMr`m ZmQmZoH nZm Ambr.
gV^y_rgVmMoOrdZ OoWo`{VV Pmbo Vr y_r bmoH _mZgmV
lmWmZ {_idVo. AmiXr, Xoh, nTanya, nRU, _JidoTo,
gmZJS>, {edWaKi Aer {H VrVar gVnXmZr nmdZPmbo`m y_r _hmammV AmhoV. kmZXod, VwH mam_, Zm_Xod,MmoIm _hma, Xm_mOr nV, g_Wam_Xmg m`m nmdZ nXmZrnwZrV Pmbobr ^y_r hr na_n{d _mZbr OmVo. _hmammV
`m ZVa`mhr H mimV AZoH gV hmoD Z Jobo. gV JmSJo_hmamO, A bH moQMo dm_r, Zqgh gadVr, nmdgModnmZX Aem {H VrVar gVm`m H _ y_rbm VrWjomMo_mhm` m PmboAmho. `mM Z`mZoCX`mg Ambo`mVrWjomnH s gmB~m~mMo {eSu hohr EH VrWjo Amho.^maVm`m mVmmVmV AgoAZoH gV_mhm_ohmoD Z Jobo.`mMr JmdoAmVm VrWjooPmbr AmhoV.
gJ_^y_r
^maVr` gH VrV nm`mbm OrdZ hUVmV. XmoZZmMm gJ_ hUOoXmoZ OrdZ dmhmMm gJ_ hmo`. AgmgJ_ n{d _mZ`mMr Amnbr nanam Amho. hUyZMH moU`mhr XmoZ Zm`m gJ_mda Amhr _{Xa ~mYboboAgVo. JJm-`_wZm, HUm-H mo`Zm, Aem VhoMr eoH SmogJ_WmZoAmhoV. gJ_mda ZmZ Amhr A`V n{d_mZVmo. XmoZ Zm`m gJ_m_mUoM ZXr gmJambm {_iVoVoWmZhr Amhr n{d _mZVmo d VoWohr Amhr _{XaoC^rHobr AmhoV. H mHw_marbm VrZ gmJamMm gJ_ Amho.
H mVrW}{O o{ wdZr & {V`| KSVr g_wmdJmhZr &Ago Ag`m_wio H `mHw _marMo g_wZmZ ho
Abm{H H M _mZm`bm hdo. Aem arVrZo H mhr ^y_tZm^maVr` _ZmZona_nm{d` {XboAmho Am{U `m y_r`mXeZmgmRr Vo {Z` AmgwgboboAgVo.
nanam_mJrb AW
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
22/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *20
`m ZXrVrb nmUr dhmV AgVo, Vr ZXr n{d hmo`. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
oaUmmoV
EH mo{Ugmdo Am{U {dgmdo eVH hrZdOmJaUmMr eVHo hUyZ ^maVr` B{Vhmgm_`oZm|Xdbr Jobr. 1757 `m bmgr`m {dO`mZo BJOramOdQ> ~Jmb_`o gw Pmbr. `mZVa Hodi nYamdfmZr O_mbm Ambo`m amOm am__mohZ `mZr qhXyg_mOmVrb, _w`V: ~Jmb_Yrb gVr Wm ~X hmdrhUyZ Ho bo`m `ZmVyZ gVr ~XrMm H m`Xm Pmbm.
qhXy g_mOm`m gwYmaUoMm, qhXy _mUgmZo, BJOramOdQ>rH SyZ H adyZ KoVbobm hm _hdmMm H m`Xm.
qhXyWmZ`m nyd}g Aem [aVrZo g_mOn[adVZmMo`Zmg `e `oD bmJbo`m_mUo n{_og JwOamV_`o1824 _`o O_mbm Ambo`m X`mZXmZr _moR>m
_mUmV doXm`m AmYmao g_mOn[adVZmMo H m_ gwHobo Vo 1877 `m Am` g_mOm`m WmnZonmgyZ. r-nwf g_mZVm, bmoH emhr, _y{VnyOm {ZfoY, ewrH aUAm{U g_mOgKQ>Z `m Zd`wJmZwHyb Jmo>tMm MmaAm{U gma X`mZXmZr nOm~, amOWmZ `m ^mJmVyZ gwHo bm. r {ejUmgmR>rhr X`mZX `Zerb am{hbo.`wdH mZr XoeH maUmV gh^mJr hmo`mMm AmJhX`mZXmZr Yabm. gd OmVrn{W`mZm Xrjm Xo`mg `mZr
ma Va Ho bmM, nU {`mZmhr Xrjm Xo`mgmR>r `mZr{`mZmM A{YH mahr {Xbm.^maVm`m X{jU Q>moH mg Hoai_`o `mM H mimV
X{bV g_mOmV O_mbm Ambo`m lr Zmam`U Jw `mZrAZoH _{Xao C^mabr. gd OmVr ~mYdmgmR>r gHVnmR>emim CKS>Uo ho `mMo {deof H m`. `mZrgHV_`o _hmH m` {b{hbo. `m`m Kar {`mhr
am>OmJaUmMo Ad wdm_r {ddoH mZX
o`dmXmZo mMr _ZoXr Pmbr AmhoV, Aer HwemJ~wrMr VU _S>ir dm_r emoYV hmoVo. gmYr
ZhoV Va namH_r! Amn`m gH ma gm mV KmbyZ m mV {dwgMmaM H am bm hdm, m mmao
gmao{d {dwV marV hm`bm hdo. Aer oaUmgn XmoZ hOma, Xhm hOma, N>o! N>o! drg gh wdH
`wdVrMr Amd`H Vm Amho. `mZr gd Ii~i _mOdbr nm{hOo Ago `mMo dZ hmoVo.
`.e.bobo (kmZ~mo{YZr)
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
23/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *21
oaUmmoV
Mm[a` KS>d`mV gwI Am{U X:I Xmohm|Mm gmaImM dmQ>m Amho. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
gHV OmUV hmo`m. Zmam`U Jw`m `m g_mOH m`mMoH mVwH Ho ai_`oOmD Z dm_r {ddoH mZXmZr Ho bo hmoVo.Eidm OmVr`m `m Jw Zo _{hbm`m g~brH aUmMoH m` Va Ho boM; nU AmH_H pVr _VmMo IS>Z
H aUmam JWhr `mZr {b{hbm.1863 _`o {dZmW~m~y Xm `m`m Kar O_
Pmbobo Za|ZmW nwT>oam_H U na_hgmMo n>{e` Pmbo.`mZr g`mg Va KoVbmM; nU ^maV n[aH_m H Z`mZr ^maVr` g_mO OdiyZ nm{hbm. AIoaH `mHw _mar `oWo g_w gJ_WmZr VrZ {Xdg `mZ H ZAmn`m Jw Zr {Xbo`m AmXoemZwgma {dXoer WmZR>odbo. `m`m nydu amOm am__mohZ hohr {dXoemV Jobo
hmoVo; nU `mZm {VH So {deof H mhr H m` H aUo e`Pmbo Zmhr. ~mmo g_mOmMo H m`H V}hr {dXoer Jobo,`mZrhr dVd JmOdbo; nU dm_r {ddoH mZXmZrAmn`m kmZmZo, ~w{MmVw`mZo Am{U Mm[a`m`mYdbVoZo A_o[aH m d `wamonmVrb BbS>gh AZoH XoeqOH bo. AZr ~oPQ> `mZr `m`m `{V_dmMo dUZ`mom g`mgr AgoHo bo Vo `WmW Amho.
^maVmMo {V{Z{Yd H aUm`m _mUgmZo, hUOo
EH m Jwbm_ ammVrb _mUgmZo, {dOo`m XoemgMAmn`m ~w{d dmZo AZ {ZH bH Mm[a`mZoqOH mdohr Jmo A^yVnydAerM hmoVr. dm_rOrZr gdY_n[afXVa qOH brM, nU AZoH m`m aQ>mi ^mfUmZo lmoVoCRyZOmD Z`oV hUyZ eodQ>r dm_r {ddoH mZX ~mobUmaAmhoV ho gmJyZ g moOH dm_rMm bmoH {`VoMm bm^hrCR>dV hmoVo. {d{dO`mgmR>r Vwhr OJ qOH boMnm{hOo, Ago^maVr` VUmZm gmJVmZm Vo H go qOH mdo`mMm dVwnmR> dV: {ddoH mZXmZr gdmg_moa R>odbobmMhmoVm. dm_rOsZr OJ qOH bo Vo `m`m kmZmZo! `m`mMS> A`mgmMo d AOmoS> dVdmMo Vo\ i hmoVo!
gKQ>Zm ho gydoMH JwUdV _mUgo emoYUo, Vr Amn`m gVZmZo,
gw{dMmamZo Am{U {~ZVmoS> `wpVdmXmZo Amnbrer H aUoAer hmoVr dm_rOtMr qOH `mMr nV! Amn`m
OrdZmV gVV Amn`m~amo~a amhVrb Aer IarIwar_mUwgH s AgUmar EHoH `Vr dm_r {_idV Jobo.`mZm ^VmMr _m{X`mir ZH mohmoVr. namH _r qghm`md {ghrUr`m emoYmV Vo hmoVo. Aer _mUgo {_idV
amh`mgmR>r `mMo OrdZ hmoVo. H _mH _mZo gmao {d`mnyZ Q>mH `mMo `mMo dZ hmoVo. Aer EH `UmH m`aV H a`mMm `mMm `mg hmoVm H s {O`mmao`oH m`m Kar CXmm H nZm nmohmoM{d`mMo H m`KSo >b.
H dVmo {d_m`_`o dmXmZo `mMr _Zo Xr Pmbr AmhoV Aer
Hw emJ ~wrMr VU _S>ir dm_r emoYV hmoVo. gmYr
ZhoV Va namH _r! Amn`m gH ma gm`mV KmbyZ`m`mV {dwgMmaM H am`bm hdm, `m`mmam gmao{d {dwV^marV hm`bm hdo. Aer oaUmgn XmoZhOma, Xhm hOma, N>o! N>o! drg gh `wdH `wdVrMrAmd`H Vm Amho. `mZr gd Ii~i _mOdbrnm{hOo Ago `mMo dZ hmoVo. `mgmR>r {Z:dmW AerHw brZ VU _S>ir ZoVonU H a`mg hdr AmhoV, Ago~mam {e` _bm m, AmnU OJ qOHy ! nU `mgmR>r
_mPr Z b ZH mo, _r gmJVmo` VgoH am, _m`m >rZoXw~bVm hUOonmn Ago `mMo eX AmhoV.{dkmZmMm drH maA_o[aHo Vrb {dwV emmMm UoVm hUOo
{ZH mobg Q> obm. VmogVV `moJ H m`mV ~wS>mbobm Ago.nU dm_r`m `m`mZmgmR>r Vmo h_Img doi H mT>VAgo. doXmVm_Yrb mU Am{U AmH me `m H nZmdm_rH Sy>Z `mbm g_OyZ `m``m hmo`m. VgoM^maVr`mMr H n (100 `wJmZr ~ZUmam ~XodmMm{Xdg) hr H nZm `mbm AmH {fV H aV Ago. `mH nZmMm A`mg AmYw{ZH {dkmZmZo H am`bm hdm,Ago Q>obmMo hUUo hmoVo. `m H mimV gmam ~ZhmQ> hrgdgm_m` A_o[aH ZmMr OUyH bmXodVm ~Zbr hmoVr VaQ>obm hUOo {Vna_oa! Vmo {dOoMm PJ_JmQ> H ZXmIdo Am{U Am{gboQ>a`m gmmZoYaVr H er hmXaVo
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
24/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *22
Vohr `j XmIdo.`m gdm_mUoM dZr_wUmMm emoY {VH So ZwH VmM
bmJV hmoVm. dV:Mm AmdmO _w{V Hobobr V~H S>rdm_rZr Ior`m _hmamOmZm nmR>dyZ XoV Ag`mMm
CoI `m`m EH m nmV Ambm Amho. {dkmZ Am{UVkmZmV ^maVmZo OJm~amo~a `m`bm hdo, hm dm_rMm{>H moZ Xoem`m JVrgmR>r 100 dfmZVa AmO {H VrCn`wV R>abm Amho ho AmnU nmhVmoM. dm_rZr EH mdH s` {Z`VH m{bH mV H m{eV Hobobm boIhrdm_r`m dmL>>_`mV CnbY Amho. gmam ~ZhmQ>, Q>obmAm{U dm_rMr EH m AmhmaJhmV ~R>H Pmbr hmoVr,`mdoir {dkmZ, VdkmZ Am{U H bm `m VrZ {df`mda
H m` MMm Pmbr Agob, `mMr H nZm H a`mgmaIr
Amho. VrZ jomVrb VrZ {XJO Aer hr VrZ`{ _do.
pZ gm`gpZ gm`g hUyZ EH CnMmanVr A_o[aHo V
dmnabr OmB. dm_rZr dV: `mMm AZw d KoVbm hmoVm.`moJ hr maVr` _mZgem emIm. `m_wioA{V_mZgmMm{dMmahr AaqdXm`m nyduM dm_rOrZr Ho bobm {XgVmo.
`m {dMmajonUmZo amoJ{ZdmaU hmoVo Vmo {dMma hUOohrEH mUmV Cn hmoUmam VaJM AgUma. {dMmambmBN>meVrMr OmoS> {_imbr H s EH m _moR>m mVrMr{Z{_Vr hmoVo. _J Vmo {dMma ZhoVa Vr EH _hmeVrMH m`H aVo Ago dm_rMohUUohmoVo. {dmVrb Ym{_H ,dkm{ZH Am{U VdkmZ{df`H , dXoemVrbM ZhoVa
gm`m OJmVrb gm{h`mMm, {ddoH mZXmMm gImobA`mg hmoVm, AgoAnrb AhobmM `m A_o[aHo VrbdmnmZo hQ>boAmho.
H sS>mnQw>d
_hm{dmb`rZ OrdZmnmgyZM _w{>`w, nm`M|Sy(\w Q>~mb) Aem AZoH H sS>mH mamV drU AgUmamZa| OrdZmVrb HsSoMo WmZ Cm_ H mao OmUV hmoVm.`m_wio H Vr R>rH ZgVmZm, Amn`m AnemOrdZm`m gm`H mir Amn`m Kam`m pIS>H sVyZH sS>m nYmMo XeZ Ko`mMm Cgmh `m`m R>m`r hmoVm.~amo~a hmoVr Omogo\ mBZ _bmBS> Am{U _XmZmda {XgVhmo`m ^{JZr {Zdo{XVm. `m nYmMr ~{jgo XoV hmo`m
Am{U `m`m g_doV hmo`m gabm Kmofmb! `mZr
Am`mo{OV Hobo`m (H Xm{MV) `m n{h`m A{Ib^maVr` H sS>m Agm`mV. {dXoemV AgVmZm dm_rZrZXrVyZ dmhV OmUm`m b`mda AMyH Zo_ gmYyZVoWrb _wbmZm Am`M{H V Hobo hmoVo. MS>\w `mImbrb Q>monbrV(hmQ> ~bwZ) ~gyZ, {OZohmVrbAmH memV C>mU H a`mMo gmhg `mZr Ho bo hmoVo.{J`mamohU Va `mZm IynM {` hmoVo. EH m nmV AmnU
Jmo\ IoimMm AmZX KoV`mMm CoI `mZr Ho bmAmho. ho{bQ>aA`m ~amo~a dm_rZr Amn`mH \ Zr`m ~mm gmda`m d dOmH So EH >r Q>mHyZM|Syg Agm \ Q>H m _mabm H s M|Sy Zo_H m nS>bm! `mdalr. boJoQ>Zo {dMmabo, dm_r Vw_`m `moJm_wio H m hoO_bo (IS> H .2) `mda dm_r Hodi hgbo.
gwI Am{U X:I hoAmnbo_hmZ {ejH AmhoV. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
oaUmmoV
aU{OVqgJ `m {d{d`mV ^maVr` {H HoQ>dramMm H|{~O_`oVoWrb nXdrnyd N>mmZr
gH ma `moObm hmoVm, `mdoir dm_rOrZm Img {Z_U hmoVo. Jrg_`ondVmda OmD Z
Amqb{n`Z XodVoMo_{Xa nmh mMm _moh dm_r Amd eH boZmhrV. Ymd`mV `m H mir
VwH sdm A_o[aH Zmnojm JrH AJoga R>aV. eara gwT> R>od`mg S>~ogMm `m`m_ AmnU
H aV Ag`mMo EH m {e`mg dm_rOrZr gm{JVboAmho.
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
25/36
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
26/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *24
Jm_{dH gZAmn`m `wdH AZw`m`mZr IoS>monmS>r OmD Z ndrMm
Jmob, ZH mem B. {ejUgmYZodmnZ VoWo {ejU Mma,IoS>mMm {dH mg IoSwVm`m _XVrZo H am`bm hdm.
~mhoZ bmXbobm {dH mg Zgmdm, Zmhr Va OJmVrb gmargnXm XoIrb EImm N>moQ>m IoS>mg Cn`moJr nS>UmaZmhr- Omoda VoWrb IoSwVmZm AmnU dmdb~Z {eH dVZmhr.
{ejU_mUgmMr BN>meVr {Z`{V H Z Vr OrdZ
gm\ `mgmR>r H m`dU H aUo hUOo {ejU Ago EHo{R>H mUr dm_rZr hUyZ R>odbo Amho. nU EH mJVoMo
{ejU ho Iao {ejU Ago AZoH Xm Vo gmJVmV.Mm[a`KS>U H aVo Ago {ejU {_im`bm hdo.dmdb~r ~ZdVoVoM dVwV: {ejU hohr Iao Amho nU`VrMo R>m`r AgUmao n[anyUd H Q> H aUo hUOo{ejU hr gH nZm dm_rOtZr AmYw{ZH{ejUemkmZmhr qMVZ H am`bm bmdob AemdnmV gmJyZ R>odbobr Amho. {VMm {dMma H aVmZm`oH `Vr`m ~rOJwUmMmhr _wm `mZr `oVmo.am_H U Aml_mmam Xoe^a AZoH {ejU gWmMmbVmV. {ed^mdoOrdgodm ho `o R>odUm`m dH s`jomVrb gWmhr MmbVmV. dm_rOrZm {`mMo _R>AgmdoV Ago dmQ>V hmoVo nU `mMr {Z{_Vrhr `m`mnmV d `m`m Img {e`m ^{JZr {Zdo{XVm `m`m{ZdmUmZVa emaXm _R> ZmdmZo AZoH {R>H mUr PmbobrAmho. g`m{gZr `m _R>mMo gMmbZ H aVmV. AmOdm_rOrZm `m XoemV O_mg `oD Z XrS>eo df} nyUPmbr. dm_rOrH SyZ oaUm KoD Z H m`mg C`m
am{hbo`m eVmdYr gWm d gKQ>Zm AmO H m`aVAmhoV. Amnmn`m narZodm_rOrMo H m`M Aem gWm,gKQ>Zm MmbdV AmhoV. {ddoH mZX H| hohr dm_rOrMo_maH hUyZ H `mHw_marV AmO C^o am{hbo Amho. VoHodi OS> _maH Zmhr, dm_rOrMm nwVim Amho,`mZ_S>n Amho, dm_rOrMo {MXeZhr C^o am{hbo
Amho. nU gm{h`nmZo AZoH ^mfm_YyZ dm_rOrAmOhr Amn`mer ~mobV AmhoV, nwT>o eVH mZweVHo hrVo Amn`mer ~mobV amhUma AmhoV. godmdVr H m`H VmhUyZ AZoH nVr - nZr Xoe^a dZdmgr_`o OmD Z
H m_ H aV AmhoV. ^{JZr {Zdo{XVmZr hUyZ R>odbo AmhoH s nwT>`m VrZ ghdfmMo {V{ZYr dm_r {ddoH mZXAgUma AmhoV.
dm_rMo AnwaoH m`^maVr` rMo _Zmohmar dn H m`_ R>oD Z {VMr
~m{H CMrhr ^{d`mV dmT>ob Va OJm`m >rZo^maVr` _{hbm hr AmXe r R>aob Ago dm_rMogdY_n[afXoVrb CXJma AmhoV. {d{dY jomV AmO
rZo Adb WmZ m H Z KoVbo Amho. ~m{HjomVhr Vr _mJo Zmhr. naVwgmH {VH jomV, ^maVr`nanam{df`rMr AmWm dmT>`mg Vr AmXe R> eHobAgo dmQ>Vo. ^maVr` ^mfm, ^yfm, ^moOZ `mMm dmnaH a`mMo dmV` Z J_mdVm {dmVrb AZoH_mZd{hVH mar JmorMm {ddoH nyUdrH ma H a`mMm _mJ{VZo drH mabm Va Vr gmH {VH _y`m`m AmYmaoAmXe r ~Zy eHob. ^maVr` nwZOmJaUmMo UoVonwH i Agbo Var dm_r {ddoH mZX `mMo `m_YrbWmZ AOmoS> R>aboAmho Am{U nwT>ohr gwXrK H mi `mMo{dMma AmMmamV CVad`mgmR>r AmnUmbm bmJUmaAmhoV. `m_wio ^maVr` nwZWmZmMo AmOMo Ad`yhrdm_r {ddoH mZXM AmhoV Am{U nwT>ohr amhUma AmhoV.
***
Mm[a` H _mZr KS>dboOmV AgVo. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
oaUmmoV
_mJrb AH mVrb XVr_mM 2013 `m {ddoH {dMma`m
_bnR>mdarb gm_y{hH gy Z_H ma H aVmZmMon{hbo N>m`m{M H UmdVr (Ah_Xm~mX) `oWrbAmho. MwH sZo {VWo A_Vga Ago N>mnbo Jobo.MwH s~b j_d. - gnmXH
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
27/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *25
Am_Mo_w` H V` hoM dV:Mr KUm Z H aUo. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
BYZyMm nyb
{namoO AmZXH a
BYZyMm nybboImH : 13
""_JOmAyH m _r ghbrbm ?''""ghb H s da {dhma ?''""Ag H m {dMmaVo J ?''"" H m {dMm Z`o ? _mJo AmnU Amn`m
HwQw~mMr ghb H mT>br hmoVr nmMJUrbm.Vohm Am_`m~amo~a `m`bm Vy Hw a~ya H aVhmoVrg {Z AmVm emio`m ghbrMm VyH mbnmgyZ h> KoVbm Amho! Am{U _r `m
H mhr ghbr nm{hbo`m AmhoV `mdZ Vwhm_wbtZm ghbt`m _hdmnojm da {dhmamMmM A{YH_moh nS>V Agmdm Ag _bm dmQ>V. dmV{dH `mV JaAg H mhr Zmhr, Amn`m emiH ar _{Ut`mghdmgmV H mhr H mi H mT>mdm, Amn`m XoemVrbEo{Vhm{gH WimM XeZ `md `mV H mhr dmBQ> Zmhr.Xoem{^_mZmMr OmonmgZm hm`bm XoemM gnyU XeZ
KarXmar
KS>m`bmM nm{hOo. ghbr_YyZ VoghOM KS>V.{edm` hoVw_M d`M AgAmho, H s Vwhmbm dmQ>VAgV, Ka`m ~YZmVyZ H mhr jU Var XaOmd, Amnb `pVd Var H Q> H amd,AmnU Hw UrVar {deof AmhmoV Ag XmIdmd.Amn`mnojm bhmZ _wbtda VmB{JarJmOdmdr, {eQ>r dmOdyZ _wbr EH H a`mV,^moOZmda XoIaoI H a`mV Aem `oH
Jmo>rV nwT>mH ma Amn`mbm {_imdm hr Vw_MrYS>nS>! ghbrV Aer gYr Vwhmbm {_iVohr nU hmoVVo ^bVM! Kam~mhoa H ghr dmdab Var Mmbob AgVwhmbm dmQ>V. dmV{dH Kam~mhoa g_mOmVM Vwhmbm~YZ gm mibr nm{hOoV. KaJwVr dVUyH d gm_m{OHdVUyH `m {^Z Jmo>r AmhoV.
J{UVmV n{hbm H _mH Ambm Amho `m
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
28/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *26
Amnmn`m H m jomV H moUrM H {ZR> Zmhr. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
AmZXmogdm`m ^amV Kar bmS>mV `oD Z Vwhr bm-bm-bm-bm hUyZ qH Mmimb, nU g_mOmVMmaMmKmV Ag~aimb Va gdm`m {hVmW doS>m`mhmpnQ>bmV Vw_Mr admZJr hmo`mMm g d Amho.
gm_m{OH dVUwH sM {ejU {_imd hUyZhr ghbtMmAwm_ Cn`moJ Vwhr H Z `m`bm nm{hOo. Aem{ejUmgmR>r Amnb gaH mahr {dm`mZm _XV H arVAgV nU Vw_`m ghbr hUOo JO~Obo`m ~mob`mN>md`m! Vwhr H moU, H moU`m Hw imbm, H moU`memiobm Vwhr ^wf{db Amho ho Z {dMmaVmMAmOw~mOy`m _mUgmZm H iyZ MwH V.
{e>mMma hUOo H m` `mMr H nZmM Vwhmbm HwUr
H Z {Xbobr ZgVo. qH ~hZm Amn`mH S>o {e>mMmamMAg emM Zmhr. hUyZ gdmMr m ~m~VrVEH dm`Vm Zmhr. Amn`m mMrZ _VrJWmVyZ XZ{XZdmJUyH sMm gy_ Vnerb AmT>iVmo, VgoM AZoH{d{Y{ZfoYhr AmT>iVmV; nU ZdrZ S>mo`mda Vr OwZrQ>monr H moU Kmbrb!
gmYr AmdmOmMr Jmo> `m. MmaMmKmV Hw UrH gmhr AmdmO H mT>mdm - Vm|S>mVyZ ZmH mVyZ, nmoQ>mVyZ -AmdmOmbm {Z`UM Zmhr. ho H m` ~mB ZdrZ H aU.Vy {dMmaerb, AmdmOmM {Z`U? hmo , H aU AmhonU ZdrZ Zmhr. ghO ~mobVmZm AmnU VmemMm AmdmOH mT>rV AgVmo. nZmg `mS>mdZ ~mobVmZm AmdmOmMrCMr d nbm dmT>dmdm bmJVmo Vgm Odi`m_mUgmer ~mobVmZm Vmo H _rhr H amdm bmJVmo.dV:`m AmdmOm`m {Z`UmM _hd _m{hV Zg`mZnwH iXm ao{S>Amo`m AmdmOm`m bm~rXrM _hdAmnU OmUV Zmhr. _J eoOm`mMr {M>r `oVo.ao{S>AmoMm AmdmO H nm H Z H _r H am. ~mir, AmOmarAmho. {XZy A`mg H aVmo Amho.
gmdO{ZH dmhZmVyZ Vw_`m AmdmOmMo d{ZjonEoH VmZm AmOy~mOyMo dmgr H m` H mZ ~X H ZKoVrb? _wbtMr OmV _wimVM dmMmi g_Obr OmVo.H bH bmQ> H aU hm Va Amnbm d^mdY_! Mma _wbr
ghbrV EH {V Am`m H s _Xy ^mfUmbm "JwS>~m`'!_w`m _wbtZmhr _J dmMm \w Q>Vo. _J [hXr {MnQ>gJrVmM gm{KH JOZm-Jm`Z gw hmoV. Aem doir _mBVa dmemZm H mZmV ~moQ> KmbyZ ~g`mMr nmir `oVo d
emiH ar {dm{WZr~b EH H maMr KUm {Z_mUhmoVo.
eo`m_|T>mMm EImXm H in EImm a`mdZJobm H s `m {R>H mUr b|S>mMr ~agmV Pmbobr {XgyZ`oVo. `m_mUo {dm`mMoH in ghbrV OmV AgVmZmH mJXmMo ~moio, \ imMr gmbnQ>, {~`m, eod-{MdS>m`mMm gS>m gmdO{ZH dmhZmV d BVa gmdO{ZH Wir{XgyZ `oVmo. hm Xoe Amnbm Amho, `mVrb dmhZo
AmnbrM AmhoV. Vr Amn`m Kam_mUodN> amImdrAgm Am_^mZ Vw_`mV {Z_mU hm`bm nm{hOo. `mXoemVrb gmdO{ZH dmhZ, aVo, CmZ BVH s J{bN>AgVmV `m XoemVbr bmoH mMr amhUrgwm J{bN>MAgbr nm{hOo Ag EImm naoXer dmemZ hQ>b VaMyH hmoBb H m`? {H emoar, Vwhr emiH ar _wbtZrMAer dN>VoMr gd` Amn`mbm bmdyZ KoVbrnm{hOo. Or _wbJr Kar dN>Vm, Q>mnQ>rn R>od`mV Zoh_rVna AgVo {Vbm gmdO{ZH dN>Vm R>od`mV BVam ZmVg H Z Xo`mMr {dZVr H a`mV H _rnUm dmQ>UmaZmhr.
gmdO{ZH AdN>Vm hm Amn`mdarb H bHAmho. `m`m {Z_ybZmMr V`mar Vwhr _wbtZr H am`bmgwdmV Hobr H s _moR>r _mUghr dMHyZ amhVrb.
Eo{Vhm{gH Wi, B_maVr, {H bo, boUr, _{Xa`m`m gmX`mMr hmZr {dm`m`m Q>mo`mH SyZM Ho brOmVo, H maU Aem {R>H mUr H moiemZ, ISyZ , Mw`mZqH dm _mVrZ Amnb Zmd, nmm, de, emioM Zmd,AmJ_ZmMr {ZdmUmMr VmarI, doi `mMm Vnerb{b{h`mV H m` gmYm`M AgV ~a! Amn`m nydOmMrH Vr AmMaVm Ambr Zmhr Var _Vr OmJV R>odUma H sZmhr Vw_Mm {dmWu dJ?
gmdO{ZH dmhZ ho gdmgmR>r AgV. AmnUM nm`
BYZyMm nyb
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
29/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *27
JhWml_ g_mOOrdZmMm nm`m Amho. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
ngZ Mma _mUgmMr OmJm AmS>dU hm AnbnmoQ>onUmVa AmhoM nU Jwhmhr Amho. dmgmV ^a {XdgmAmOmamM, PmonoM gm|J KoD Z OmJm AmS>dUm`m_wbtMr g`m H mhr WmoS>r Zmhr. `m A{e>mMmamM
CMmQ>Z H a`mMVwhrM _Zmda KoVb nm{hOo. {Z Vohr`mM H mimV. embo OrdZmVM gm_m{OH dgmdO{ZH dN>VoM Vwhr H H U ~mYb nm{hOo.
BbS>-A_o[aHo Vrb gmdO{ZH dmhZmVyZ OmVmZmemiH mar-_wbr W_ Amn`mnojm dS>rb, nJw, dX,AeV _mUgmZm ~gm`bm OmJm {_im`mZVaMAmnU OmJoda ~gVmV; ZmhrVa C`mC`mM dmgH aVmV. hrM _wb Xoemda Ia o_ H aVmV hUm`Mr.
H maU XoemVrb Am~mbdXmZm Vr Hw Qy~dV g_OVmV.Amn`mM XoemVrb gmdO{ZH dmhZmV OmJogmR>rVw_`m `m gJrV IwMuMm Ioi Ioimdm bmJVmo.
EImm`m KamV {eaVmZm AmV `oD H m? Ag{dMmaU hm {e>mMma Amho. ZmhrVa _yfH -doe Pmbm.CXra H Yr Hw Umbm {dMmZ AmV doe H aVmV H m?nU _J `mZm H R>rZ hgH mdyZ Q>mH `mMr nmir `oVo.Vg gw{d _mUgm`m ~m~VrV hmoVm H m_m Z`o. VwPr VrYwg_wgir H mVm Zmhr `m {Xder Vwbm emoYV `oVAmKmoir`m Imobrn`V _Ybo gJio Q>nogmoSyZ YmdVgwQ>br. KamV Hw Ur H mhr ImgJr `dhma H arVAgVmZm `m`m EH mVmV ^J nydgyMZm Z XoVmH a`mMm Amn`mbm H m` A{YH ma AgVmo?
Hw UmMrhr ^oQ> KoU Pm`mg Vr `m`m g_VrZoM`m`bm hdr, Zmhr H m? AWmV Amn`mH S>o AgoH {_ {eQ>mMma Zgbo - Am{U Zgmdohr - Var `mVrbVd AmoiIyZ EH _oH m`m gmo rJagmo rMm {dMmaH amd`mg {eH b nm{hOo.
gmdO{ZH {R>H mUr H g ~gmd hrgwXm {dMmaH a`mgmaIr Jmo> Amho. IwMugma`m CM AmgZmda~g`mda VJS>m hb{dUAJa nm` da KoD Z ~gU hmEH A{e> H ma Amho. _wbtZr CM AmgZmda qH dmHw R>hr ~gVmZm _mS>m Odi KoD Z ~g`mMr gd`
Ho br nm{hOo. Vw_`m e[aamMr KS>UM Aer Amho H sVg ~g`mMm Oa Vwhr n[anmR> R> odbm Zmhr Va Vw_`m{ZV~mMm ^mJ ^mon`mgmaIm \w Job d {demo{^V hmoBbAm{U _J Vmo H _r H a`mgmR>r hbm-hn JmS>mMr
H gaV H amdr bmJob Vwhmbm.AmJJmS>r, ~g, Qm_ dJao dmhZ Wm`mda Ambr H s
`yMo {Z`_ hUOo amJmV amh`m~bMo gd {Z`_JwS>miyZ R>odbobo {XgVmV. bhmZ _wb, `m`m _mVm,d _mUg `mZm T>H byZ _mJo Q>mH sV dmhZmV doeH Z KoU hm ew amZQ>rnUm Amho. gwYmabo`mZmJ[aH mZm Vo bmN>Z Amho. {deofV: Vw_`mgma`m_wbtZr Amn`m dmJUwH sZ BVamZm YS>m md`mg
{eH b nm{hOo.Vwhr \ V Amn`m earagmX`mMm VodT>m {dMmaH aVm. Amn`m XoemVrb ZwgVo aodoMo bQ>\ m_ KoVboVar Amn`m H _mb J{bN>nUmMr Vo gmj XoVrb.`oH JmS>r Jo`mda Vo PmSyZ dN> H a`mgmR>rPmSydm`mM dV ImVM {Z_mU H amd bmJb Amhoaodobm. bS>Z, `y mH , dmqeQ>Z, n[ag, ~{bZ`mgmaIr OJmVrb {gX d d dgn eha AV~mgwXa AmhoV, Vr VoWrb bmoH m`m gmX`>r`mAm{dH mamZ "hmV {\ ao {VWo b_r {\ ao' hUVmV. hrhU ` s`m OrdZmV VerM g_mOOrdZmVhr ^mdrR>aUmar Amho. {OWo {Z_bVm, {OWo _mJ` {VWo H _bmg!
{H emoar, Vy {dMmaerb, m gm`m gm_m{OHXmofmMm amoI Amhm _wbtH S>o H gm nmoMVmo? Vwhrhrg_mOmMm EH ^mJM AmhmV. {edm` H moU`mhrgXJwUmMr, arVr[admOmMr ~rOo AHw [aV hm`bm{H emoamdWonojm Xgam MmJbm H mi Zmhr. _Z EH XmQ>UH Pmbr H s Vr H moUVmhr gH ma H Z Ko`mgV`ma ZgVmV. hUyZM g_mOmMr Anojm Vw_`m H mZrKmVbr Amho.
gH bZ : gJrVm gmo_U(H _e:) ***
BYZyMm nyb
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
30/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *28
_mUgmbm Am`mp_H ~bmZognZ H am. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
5000 {dm`mZr KmVbogy`Z_H ma
S>m|{~dbrVhr gm_wXm{`H gy`Z_H maS>m|{~dbr - dm_r {ddoH mZX `m`m 150 `m
O`Vr{Z{_m dm_r {ddoH mZX gmY eVr g_mamoh
g{_Vr`m dVrZo `oWrb {O_Im`mda VrZ hOma{dm`mZr gm_wXm{`H gy Z_H ma KmVbo. A{Ve`{eV~, gw{Z`mo{OV d Cgmhr dmVmdaUmV hmH m`H_ nma nS>bm. J{V_X gWo`m 20 {dm`mZrhr`mV gh^mJ Zm|X{dbm.
`m H m`H _mg CmoOH _mYd Omoer `mMr _wICnpWVr hmoVr. `mdoir g{_VrMo g{Md gwYraOmoJioH a, Am_Xma adt MhmU, gwa| dmOno`r,MH Xod, H sS>m^maVrMo _wI H _bmH a jragmJaCnpWV hmoVo.
XmXa, {dbonmb}`oWogy`Z_H ma_w~B- dm_r {ddoH mZX gmYeVr g_mamoh g{_Vr`m
dVrZo `oWrb XmXa d {dbonmb} n[agamV gy Z_H ma_hm`kmMo Am`moOZ H a`mV Ambo hmoVo. XmXa `oWrb{edmOr nmH darb H m`H _ mV 25 emim d_hm {dmb`m`m 3500 {dm`m Z r gm_wX m{`Hgy`Z_H ma KmVbo. _m{h_ oWohr hm H m`H_ nma nSbm.`mdoir Cmo{OH m _rZb _mohmSrH a, g{_VrMoghg{MdA^` ~mnQ, amQr` d`godH gKmMoghH m dmh H ZZ`mMr _wI CnpWVr hmoVr. VgoM {dbonmb} `oWo 12emim`m 900 {dm`mZr gm_ wXm{`H gy Z_H maKmVbo. m H m`H_mg {g gJrVH ma lrYa \ SHo `mMr
_wI CnpWVr hmoVr.
H|dm
Ho br. `mgnrR>mda gmobmnya {dmnrR>mMo Hw bJw
S>m. EZ. EZ. _mbXma, {ejUVk S>m. dUbVm{^erH a, _Znm g^mJh ZoVo _hoe H moR>oAmXr _m`daCnpWV hmoVo. mVm{dH m. {edamO nmQ>rb,gygMmbZ gmX {OamH bJrH a Va Am^ma XeZamOoe H i_UH a `mZr Hobo.
{ddoH mZXmMr oaUm hZw_mZ^maV ~bembr ~Z`mgmR>r AmYr Vwhr geV
~Zm, Ago AmdmhZ S>m. dUbVm {^erH a `mZr
{dm`mZm Ho bo. _hm~br hZw_mZ ho dm_r {ddoH mZXmMooaUmWmZ hmoVo. Xw~bmZm OJmV H moUrM {dMmaV Zmhr,hUyZ _Z dO hdo AZ _ZJQ> Vo nmobmX Agm gXoedm_rOtZr {Xbm.
gmobmnya - gm_y{hH gy Z_H ma _hm`kmV 5 hOma
831 {dm`mZr 40 hOma 817 gy`Z_H mamMrAmhVr {Xbr. nmH _XmZ `oWo gH mir 10 dmOVmPmbo`m `m H m`H _mV ehamVrb 75 emimVrb{dm`mZr gHV _mgh gy Z_H mamMr gmV AmdVZo
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
31/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *29
AZmgV hm. H m Mmbym. {ZaVa H m`H am. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
{ddoH mZXm`m {dMmamMr JaO
Zm{eH - dm_r {ddoH mZXmMo {dMma {H mbmVrVAmhoV. `m_wio AmOhr g_mOmbm `m`m {dMmamMrJaO Amho. `m`m {dMmamZrM g_mOmMr CZVr hmoDeHo b, Ago {VnmXZ {ddoH mZX H|, H `mHw _mar`m_mOr A`jm S>m. b_rHw _mar `mZr Hobo. gmY eVrg_mamoh g{_VrZo `m`m `m`mZmMo Am`moOZ HobohmoVo. g{_VrMo g`moOH {dZm`H gmobmnwao, mV gKQ>H{ddmg bnmbH a, _Joe qnJio `mMr CnpWVr hmoVr.mV `dWm _wI O`Vamd Xr{jV `m`m hVo doX_yVuemVmam_emr ^mZmogo `mMm gH ma Pmbm. gygMmbZAS>. _Zrf qMYS>o `mZr Ho bo Va ghg moOH JOmZZhmoS>o `mZr Am^ma _mZbo.
H `mU_ o{d{dY H m H_
H `mU - dm_r {ddoH mZX O`Vr{Z{_m {d{dYH m`H _ Ko`mV Ambo. H m` {H aU _S>imZoKoVbo`mamQ Vrna JrVmZr CnpWVmZm MoV{dbo. {H aU
OmoJioH a, H dr `moJoe Omoer, H dr ^mH a ZododmUrCnpWV hmoVo. gygMmbZ m. dmVr ZmVy, {dO`{MniyUH a `mZr Ho bo. drU Xoe_wI `mZr Jm{`bo`mdXo_mVa_Zo H m`H _mMr gmJVm Pmbr.
grVmam_ Ho Xrbm` `m`m Jm_OmJVr nX`moMoH adbo `oWo _YwH a MH Xod `mZr dmJV Hobo. {dZ`dobUH a CnpWV hmoVo. _h| nmQ>rb `m`m nwT>mH amZo
hoXnQ>Uo `oWo dm[_H s am_m`UH Wm Pmbr. {ZiOo`oWrb gdm}X` {dmb`mV dm_r {ddoH mZX H WmgVmh gmOam H a`mV Ambm. OJZmW _hmamO nmQ>rb`mZr _mJXeZ Ho bo. nmaZmH m `oWrb A{^Zd {dm_{XamV VriJyi H m`H _ Pmbm. gd{YZr _wI_JbmVmB AmoH `mZr _mJXeZ Ho bo.
g` ^aVr _mJXeZ {e{~aH `mU - g`mV ^aVr Pmbo hUOo gahrdaM
bT>mdo bmJVo Ago ZgyZ Xoem`m gajUm`m {d{dYO~m~Xm`m nma nmS>m`m bmJVmV. `mgmR>r {e{jV
_Zw`~imMr Amd`H Vm AgVo. `oH g{ZH mbmHodi BVa gaH mar H _Mm`mEdT>m nJmaM {_iVmo AgoZmhr Va BVa AZoH godm-gw{dYm {_iVmV. _mZhr{_iVmo. g`mV H [aAa H aUo hr Cm_ JmoQ> Amho, Ago{VnmXZ dm_r {ddoH mZX gmY eVr g_mamoh g{_VrMo`wdm Am`m_ _wI, {Zdm _oOa {dZ` XoJmdH a `mZr
Hobo. gmY eVr g_mamoh g{_Vr, H `mU {Om`mdVrZo S>m|{~dbr `oWo Am`mo{OV g` ^aVr _mJXeZ{e{~amV Vo ~mobV hmoVo. `mdoir gw oXma Oo. Ho. qgJ`mZrhr _mJXeZ Ho bo.
`mdoir MH mV Omoer `mZr dm_r {ddoH mZXmMo{dMma gdXya nmohmoM{d`mgmR>r hmoUm`m H m`H_mV`wdH mZr gh^mJr hmdo, Ago AmdmhZ Ho bo. `mgJrg{_VrMo mV g moOH AS>. {dO` Zamo{S>`m, g{MdgwYra OmoJioH a, S>m. {dZ` dobUH a, _JbmVmB AmoH`mMr _wI CnpWVr hmoVr.
H| dm
gd{YZrV\} {d{dY nYmSm|[~dbr - OmJ{VH _{hbm {XZm{Z{_m _{hbmgmRr
doe^yfm d am sna g_yhJrV nYoMoAm`moOZ HobohmoVo.doe^yfm nY}V 25 _{hbmZr gh^mJ KoVbm. `mVyZ
~moYZm_H gXoe {Xbm. g_yhJrV nY}V 21 JQmZr mJKoVbm. narjH hUyZ mWZm Xidr, p_Vm H amio, ew XmamZSo, gwIXm ^mdo`mZr H m_ nm{hbo. gygMmbZ A{_VmMH Xod `mZr Ho bo. nm[aVmo{fH {dVaU S>m. AZwamYmamHwbH Uu, amgo{dH m g{_Vr`m H moH U mV H m`dm{hH mgwZXm XodWir Am{U gd{YZr`m H moH U mV_wI_Jbm AmoH `m`m hVoPmbo.
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
32/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *30
H m`AIS> H am, naVwJwbm_mgmaIoZho. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
KQ>ZmMH
Hw mV ZmZ H a`mgmR>r H moU Hw RyZ Ambm, H moU`mOmVrMm Amho, `mMm aJ H moUVm, nW H moUVm, `mMr _m{hVr
Hw Umbm Ag`mMo H maUM H m`? H moUr Vm{_iZmSyMmAmho, Va Hw Ur AUmMb qH dm JwOamVMm. H moUrAX_mZhZ Ambobm, Va H moUr Zonmi, A_o[aHoVyZ XmIbPmbobm... Vmo ~mU Amho H s R>mHy a, `mXd Amho H sdm_r{H Am{U VmJ AmhoH s {_Pmo qH dm _{UnyaMm AmhoH s ~Va`m OZOmVsMm, HwUmbm H mhrM R>mdyH Zmhr.{doUr gm`mZm n{d ZmZ KS>dVo. g_agVoMm gdmV _moR>mgJ_ _ {doUrVM {_iVmo.
AmnU {H Vr lr_V AmhmV Am{U {H Vr Jar~ `mMo`oWo
Hw UmbmM XoUoKoUo ZgVo. Vwhr {MnQ> H bmH mamgmo~VHw ZmZ H a`mgmR>r A{bemZ Aem drg V~y_`o_ w m_R>moH bm AmhoH s {doUr KmQ>m`m Amgnmg gVaOr AW ZY_mXm` V~y_`o am^a ^OZ-H sVZ H Z, nw`H _md`mgmR>r XJ Pmbm AmhmV, ho{dMmam`bm `oWo Hw Umbm\wagV Zmhr. ho nmhZ `mMo {dbofU H aob, EdT>mdoiXoIrb Hw UmOdi Zmhr. MrZ, OnmZ, H mo[a`m AWdmA_o[aHoVyZ AmboboN>m`m{MH ma N>m`m{Mo H mT>V AgVrb,Va `mZm Vr H mTy mV. g`mgr `VtMoAYZ phS>rAmoVo H mT>V AgVrb Va VoXoIrb `mZm H m. H moUm`m>rbm H m` Zm|XdyZ `m`MoAmho, hoAmnU H m` OmUmdo?
Hw mV Ambo`m H moQ>dYr qhXyH So H moU H moU`m^mdZoZo ~KV Amho, ho dV `mMm na_odaM OmUyeH Vmo.Amhr Va Hodi Am_Mr JJm_mVm, Am_Mo grVmam_, Amnbo{edeH a ^moboZmW `mMr mWZm H a`mVM _ AmhmoV.`oWrb Hw hoM Am_Mo {dd AmhoAm{U hmM Hw Am_`mX`mV gm_mdbobm Amho. Vmo `oH `moH , Omo loZo `oWoAmbm Vmo dVM Hw hmoD Z OmVmo, ^maV_` hmoD Z OmVmo.
hOmamo dfmnmgyZ hr nanam MmbV Ambobr Amho. `m
nanaoZw n JV Pmbo`m `m ^maV XoemV doX AmhoV, n wamUoAmhoV, _mVm OmZH s Amho, dZdmgr am_ Amho, JmodYZYmarH h`m Amho Am{U earamda ^_ bmdbobo OQ>mYmar{nZmH nm{U ^moboZmWXoIrb AmhoV. `mM _mVrVyZ ~w Am{U_hmdramZr Ogm O_ KoVbm, VgmM Vmo Am{XeH amZrhrKoVbm. `mM _mVrV Vwhmbm dm_rqH Mo Ogo XeZ hmoVoVgoMVo AhH mar ~mUmMo JdhaU H Z, H Umbm q^V VmoSyZ
XeZ Xo`mg ^mJ nmS>Um`m H ZH XmgmMohr XeZ hmoVo. `oWoOgo MmS>mb Am{U dmZmV `mM JmoqdXmMm dmg Ag`mMr
_m`Vm AgUmao eH amMm`mMr nanam _mZUmao gVnwfAmT>iVmV, VgoM `oWo JwZmZH Am{U VsWH aXoIrbAmT>iVmV.
`oWo _WZ Amho, qMVZ Amho, {Okmgm Amho Am{U`mdarb CmaoXoIrb `oWoM {_iVmV. `oWo `_mMog` OgoApVdmV Amho, VgoM `m g`mbm AmhmZ XoUm`mZ{MHo VmModra dam`XoIrb ~Km`bm {_iVo. `oWo ^maVmbm^maV ~Z{d`mgmR>r Amd`H Agbobogmao H mhr AmT>iVo.^maVmMo maVr`d hoM Hw ^mMo A{V_ g` Amho. oWo Omo oVmo
Vmo nmdZ hmoD Z OmVmo, `mMo `oWo `oUo O_V Zmhr, `mZoHo di _ZmV AmUyZ _aU Oar Ho boVar `mbm nmnjmbZmMogwI {_iVo. `mZo Ho di loZo Hw ^ nm{hbm `mbmXoIrbgd mr Pmbr hUyZ g_Om; Am{U `mZo Ho di {ZYm{_HHw VwhbmnmoQ>r Hw nm{hbm, Vmo OmUyZ Ko`mMm `Z Ho bmVar, `m`m {h`mbm OodT>o gd `oUo {ZYm[aV hmoVoo, Vo`mbm m PmbohUyZ g_Om.
gaH maMr nyUV AZwnpWVr AgVr Var Hw hmo`mMoH mhr Q>ibo ZgVoAm{U Vmo Zoho_rgmaImM Pmbmhr AgVm.dfmZwdfmnmgyZ Vmo Hw UmMr _XV Agmo dm Zgmo, Zo_mZodmOVJmOVM hmoV Ambm Amho. Amhr BV`m _moR>m_mUmV aodo gmoS>`m, nmo{bgmMm MS> ~Xmo~V bmdbm,V~yMr `dWm Ho br, hr gw{dYm {Xbr, `m gmo r Ho `m,Aer \wemaH s _maUmao {H Vr J{d>, jw, gHw {MV Am{UIwOo amOH maUr AmhoV, hoH iyZ MwH bo. qhXy lmiyVwhrHo bo`m KmofUm Am{U gmo r-gw{dYmZm wbyZ WmoS>rMHw _o`mV gh^mJr hmo`mgmR>r `oVmV? `mH mao hOmamodfmnmgyZ ^maVmMr _mVr Am{U hdm HwR>bmhr IS> Z nS>Vmho _hmMS> Am`moOZ H aV Amho, `mH maMo H {_
Am`moOZ gm`m OJmVrb gaH mao Am{U e s EH Am`mVar `mZm Vo O_Uma Zmhr.
hr qhXyMr e s Amho. hr `m ^maVmMr e s Amho, OmogZmVZ Y_u Amho. go`wbadmXm`m ogi`w bmpQ>H -nm{b{WZ {ne`m`m {dfm MH mH snmgyZ Xya Agbo`mJJm, `_wZm Am{U qgYyMr gHVr OJUm`m O{_ZrMr hrVmH X Amho. Amnbo dmX, {ddmX, MMm Amn`mbmM
_hmHw^mV ^maV_mVoMoXeZ
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
33/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *31
Xg`m`m H V`mH S>oAmnU `m`mM Q>rVyZ ~{KVbonm{hOo. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
bIbm^ hmodmoV. Amn`m P|S>m~b Amn`mbmew H m_Zm. Amhr Va gJ_mda ZmZ H am`bm {ZKmbmo.
Mmahr ~mOyZm ApIboe `mXd `mMo hmo{SO {XgV hmoVo.JdmZo \wbbobm Mohoam Am{U J{d> KmofUm. Hw mV gh^mJrhmoUm`m ^m{dH mMo dmJV H aUmar _moh_X AmP_ ImZ`mMr \ bHo gwm {R>H {R>H mUr C^mabobr {XgV hmoVr. XmohrhmVmV ChmMm JmJb nH S>bobm Am{U ZOa HwUrH So hog_Om`bm _mJZmhr, Aer `m \ bH mdarb AmP_ ImZ`mMr Q>mBb Ag`w{ H M hUm`bm hdr. AmhrXoIrb `m^mdnyU dmJVmV hmD Z {ZKmbmo. VoqhXyM Agy eH VmV,`m`m EImm _moR>m Am`moOZmMm gaH mar ^mar H moUrpMZ AWdm Hw Ur _wgb_mZ Agbm, Var Vo gJ_m`m{XeoZo Ago _mJH _U H aVmV, OUwH mhr Amhmbm Vw_`mgaH mar ^mamer H m` KoUo XoUoAmho? AgoM `mZm hUm`Mo
Amho. Vwhr HwUmbmhr ^mar H am Amhr JJm ZmZmbmOmUma hUOo OmUmaM. `m gm`m ~m~r amOH maUm`m\ mBggmR>r AgVmV, Hw mMm `m`mer H mhrEH g~YZgVmo. Hw m_`o Vo `mMr N>m`m{Mo bmdVmV, Vr `m`m`{ JV dmWmgmR>r, `mZo Hw mbm WmoSoM H mhr bm^hmoVmo? AmhrXoIrb _hmHw mMoZmZ H Z Ambmo. 144dfmZVa hm _hmHw Ambm Amho. nwT>`m 144 dfmZr Oohmhm _hmHw hmoBb, `mdoir Amhmbm ^maVdmgr hUyZMO_ Xoerb, Aer mWZm Amhr JJm_`mbm H Z Ambmo.
EImm nmaS>mV gm`m OJmVrb gwI, g_r, {dm Am{Ug`e s EH sH So R>odmdr Am{U XwgarH So Amn`m^maVmVrb ho nmUr, hr hdm Am{U Amn`m nanaoMo hogZmVZ gwI R>odmdo, Vohm Vo g_g_mZ hmoBb. Amn`m^maVm`m _mVrMmM H U BVa gm`m OJm`m nwT>o Ag`mMoAmT>iyZ `oBb. Oo `oWo Amho, Vo BVa Hw R>ohr AmT>iUmaZmhr. Oo `oWo Zmhr `mMr Amhmbm AmgXoIrb Zmhr. hr{damQ>Vm, Or ^maVm`m AmB`m S>mo`mV ~Km`bm {_iVo,Vr BVa Hw R>o ~Km`bm {_iUma?
Hw mbm O_m Pmbo`m JXubm _VXmZm`m VamOyVVmob`mMm `Z H aUmao, ^m{dH mMm ^md g_OyeH `mgAg_WAmhoV, `mZm An[an Am{U IwOoM hUm`bm hdo.`Xm Hw m_`o BVH s A`dWm hmoVr H s {dMmam`bmM ZH mo._ZmV {dMma Ambm nU MwHyZ XodmZoAer n[apWVr AmUyZ`o. EImXo _wpb_ gaH ma Oar AgVo, Va `mZoXoIrb mnojm{H VrVar MmJbr `dWm Hw _o`mgmR>r Ho br AgVr.gm`m ehamV H M`mMo T>rJ gmMbobo {XgV hmoVo. Omo
KQ>ZmMH
`mJMm Hw g_mQ> hfdYZm`m XmZezaVoZo gwJ{YV Pmbobm~Km`bm {_iV Ago, AmO `mM g_mQ>mMr {V_m `mJMogdmV KmUoaSo ZmZH| Aer hmoD Z Jobr Amho. g_mQ>m`m
wOm JwS>miyZ nmo{bgmgmR>r {ZJamUr MmH s WmnZ H a`mVAmbr Amho. Hw ZJarV {R>H {R>H mUr H Mam Am{U {MIbgmMbobm {XgV Amho. H Yr H moU`m nwbmd Z ^m{dH mMoAmdmJ_Z ~X Hobo OmVo Va H Yr Hw R>`m nwbmd Z. nUEH mhr dra nmo{bgmOdi `mMr _m{hVr Zmhr dm `m~m~VMogmYZ Zmhr H s Xwga m nwbmd Z dmhVyH H Yr gw hmoUma,hoVmo gmJy eHo b. 14 Z~a`m qH dm 16 Z~a`m nwbmdaMmbboOm, H Xm{MV Vo nyb gw Ag`mMr e`Vm Amho,EdT>oM Cma `m`mH SyZ {_iV Ago. nU `mZo^m{dH mMmZ WmoS>rM gwQ>Uma Amho? YwirZo _mIbobo, V PmboboAm{U ChmV Vmnbobo `moH emVVoV nwT>o MmbboOmV. aodo
WmZH mda M|JamM|JarV 36 ^m{dH mMm _`y Pm`mZVaWmoS>r~hV gwajm Am{U gmhm`Vm `dWm {XgybmJbr. 12dfmnyduM _m{hVr hmoVo H s `m VmaIobm, `m {Xder Hw _oimhmoUma Amho, _J VohmnmgyZ `mMr V`mar H m Ho br JobrZmhr? qhXy`m OJmVrb gdmV _moR>m Cgdm`mAm`moOZmbm qhXw~hb XoemV gdm} WmZr R>od`mV AmboAmho, Ago dmQ>Umar H moUVrhr `dWm gaH maV\o Ho brJobr Zmhr, `m~b IoX dmQ>Vmo. `mnojm OmV Jm s`mZo hobmoH g\o B _hmogd Am{U H mJog A{YdoeZ gmOao H Z
Q>mH VmV.^maVmda go`wbadmXr hma H a`mMr hr _mZ{gH VmAmho. `m`m {damQ> nmZo ghmodfmnydu {VaH ma {MaSyZQ>mHyZ, A_mZwfVoZo {dOoVo Pmbo`mMm Xn R>oMyZ H mT>`mMr{eH dU {Xbr, `mM qhXyZm ho bmoH go`wbadmX {eH dm`bm{ZKmbo AmhoV. `mZr `mJMo Zmd Bbmhm~mX hmoVmZmnm{hbo Am{U Vohr ` ghZ Hobo `mdoir Bbmhm~mXMoZm_H aU nwhm `mJ R>od`mMm Vmd R>odbm Jobm, Vohm`m VmdmMm `mM go`wbadmmZr, AgoHo bo Va _wgb_mZ
ZmamO hmoVrb hUyZ {damoY Hobm. `m ^maVmV AmUIr H mhrH mi `m Am_X` Am{U Xm`dm`m _mZ{gH Vo`mgo`wba amOmMo am`gwm ghZ Ho bo OmBb, Vo `m {damQ>^maVm`m gZmVZH mim`m dmhmV AUy`mghmemnojmhr H _r Am{U ZJ` amhrb.
(boIH VU {dO` ho am`g^m gX` AmhoV)
AZwdmX : MmXm H h****
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
34/36
{ddoH {dMma *E{b 2013 *32
H moUVoM H _HwpgV Zmhr, H moUVoM H _An{d Zmhr. - dm_r {ddoH mZX
dXVwgHV_
e -{ddoH {dMmadmMmAmVmEHm pbHda...
Ad` oQ> m-www.vkvivekvichar.blogspot.com
Qrn {ddoH {dMmaMo _mJrb AH hr bdH aM
AmZbmBZ CnbY hmoVrb.
{h_mew^mB nQ>ZmBH `mMoX`{dH mamZo 9 _mM amoOr gm`H mir
7.30 dmOVm {ZYZ Pmbo. {h_mew mB ho{ddoH mZX H| mMo Amo{S>em mV_wIhmoVo. `dgm`mZo A{^`Vm AgUmao{h_mew mB Amo{S>em emgZm`mgmdO{ZH ~mYH m_ Im`mV H m`aVhmoVo. {ddoH mZX H| mMo CH b godmH n, H| XPmaJS> `oWrb H m`C^maUrV `mMm gh^mJ hmoVm. dm_r
{ddoH mZX gmYeVr g_mamoh g{_Vr`mH m`mVhr Vo g{H` hmoVo. H| H m`mda`mMr JmT> {ZR>m hmoVr. g`mH mi`mdm`m` dJ Am{U ^OZg`og VoAmdOyZ CnpWV Agm`Mo. H| XPmaJS>`oWrb H m`H `mZm H mhr AS>MU VaZmhr Zm, ^moOZmMr `dWm Pmbr Zm,`mH S>o `mMo amoO bj Agm`Mo.AgVrb {VWo H| ~R>H mZm CnpWVamhm`Mo. `m`m Am`mg emVr bm^mo,Aer dm_rOt`m MaUr mWZm.
* lmObr* lr _h|Or ggoZm (d` 76) `mMo{ZYZ Pmbo. `dgm`mZoVo dH sb hmoVo. 2007 _`oH| mV dmZWr H m`H Vm hUyZ Vogh^mJr Pmbo hmoVo. {ddoH mZX H|mMo qhXr _m{gH H| ^maVrMoghgnmXH hUyZ `mZr H m`Ho bo. H| mV Am`mZVa H m`H Vm{ejU {e{~am_YyZ `mZr dV:bm H|m`m H m`nVr_mUoKS>dbo. H| mMr {dMmaYmam Am_gmV Ho br. n`dhma H Z Vo^mdrar`m gdmX/gnHgmYV. `m`m Am`mg emVr bm^mo.
***
lr gwI|X Xmg (Xmg~m~y) `mMo 28 \o ~wdmar amoOrgm`H mir {ZYZ Pmbo. 1987 _`o H mobH mVm `oWo Vo H| merOmoS>bo Jobo. H| gaH ma`m ObggmYZ {d^mJmVrb H m_mMm
`mZm AZw d hmoVm. Vogai_mJu hmoVo. dm_r {ddoH mZX Am{U{ddoH mZX H|m`m H m`mVr `m`m _ZmV {ZVmV lm hmoVr.{ddoH mZX ^maV n[aH _o`m gh} H m_mnmgyZ ZVa`m n[aH_oVhrVo g{H hmoVo. {Xbr `oWo H| gaH maMr {d{dY _mb`o,gr~rEgB, EZgrBAmaQ>r Am{U A` gWmVyZ nadmZJr{_i{d`mMo H m_ `mZr nm{hbo. d`m`m 84 `m dfuhr VoVUmB`m CgmhmZo H m` H am`Mo. 7 Zmoh|~a 2012 n`V VoH m_mV g{H hmoVo.
&& ^mdnyU lmObr &&
{ZHmobgQ>obmAm{U{ddoHmZX{dOoMm emoY E{S>gZZo Zho Va \ mgMo {d`mV
emk {ZH mobg Q>obm `mZr bmdbm. Q>obmMo gemoYZE{S>gZZo hS>nbo. `m gX^mV IQ>bm gw Amho. gd_wI _mZdr emoY {ddoH mZXm`m VdkmZmda
bmJ`mMr Zm|X {ZH mobg `mZr H Z R>odbr Amho.A_o[aHoV Am`mo{OV XeZmV dm_rOrZr {dMmabo`m_mZdr OrdZmer {ZJ{S>V gemoYZ gX^mVrb Zm`m"ZmoQg' {ZH mobg `mZr KoV`m hmo`m. (dm_r{ddoH mZX Am{U Q>obm `m`mVrb dkm{ZH g~Ym~bA{YH _m{hVr dmMmhttp://www.teslasociety.com/tesla_and_swami.htm)da
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
35/36
8/13/2019 Vivek Vichar : April 2013
36/36