157

Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management (JATM) is a techno-scientific publication serialized, published by Departamento de Ciência e Tecnologia Aeroespacial (DCTA) and aims to serve the international aerospace community. It contains articles that have been selected by an Editorial Committee composed of researchers and technologists from the scientific community. The journal is quarterly published, and its main objective is to provide an archival form of presenting scientific and technological research results related to the aerospace field, as well as promote an additional source of diffusion and interaction, providing public access to all of its contents, following the principle of making free access to research and generate a greater global exchange of knowledge.

Citation preview

Page 1: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management
Page 2: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management
Page 3: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management
Page 4: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&#'()*%++#$$!!

!"#$%&)#,)*-#!.

!"#$%&'()'"#$!*+,#&$-$.!/$-$012$32(4$52($%#672(809$-$:&#;',+5')2&<=#)6>?26>@&

!/!*0$#1!)!"#$%&

!"#$A#&,+"+$B>$A2&#'($-$.!/$-$012$32(4$52($%#672(809$-$:&#;',(+?&+)#&C<=#)6>?26>@&

2*#!,$#.#*)*%0,*#(

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

'22%*#'$!)!"#$%&2

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

3456789)4:)';64<=8>;)$;>?7494@A)87B)+878@;C;7D!"#$%&'()"#*%+,-'."#/0-01"]2,>`a$J2$ba$3I,>c0+7>a$defd

!"#

Page 5: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

/5(2"$%2??O'+&'$:2)+,O2$-$B/R8LJ/09$-$RI#&#)'"DI+)Q809$-$:&#;',/,';#@+)O$5#$%2()#$A#))2($-$.!/$-$012$32(4$52($%#672(809-$:&#;',B#@'#"2$B&I+))$-$LJ.%!A9$-$%#67'"#(809$-$:&#;',B#@&'?+$:I&+,$-$.J0!$-$M'2"$-$B&#"?+B,#6^"'2$M+*C$J+)2$-$L":$-$:&#(^,'#8EB$-$:&#;',B&#"?'(?2$32(4$5+$02I;#$-$LBL$-$L@+&,g"5'#8AR$-$:&#;',R',@+&)2$B'(?O$-$.!/$-$012$32(4$52($%#672(809-$:&#;',R',(2"$5#$0',*#$-$.J9.$-$N'2$5+$3#"+'&28N3$-$:&#;',XID2$X>$B'DI+&2#$-$LJ.%!A9$-$%#67'"#(809$-$:&#;',3212$MI';$B>$!;+*+52$-$.!/$-$012$32(4$52($%#672(809$-$:&#;',32(4$!,@+&)2$%I6'"#)2$-$.%A%8L09$-$012$%#&,2(809-$:&#;',32(4$!)^,'2$B&');$B>$N2??2$-$.K!$-$012$32(4$52($%#672(809$-$:&#;',32(4$M+#"5&2$!"5&#5+$%#672($-$L%$-$%2'6@&#$-$92&)ID#,$32(4$NI@+"($R>$%#&"+'&2$-$9L%$A'"#($-$:+,2$X2&';2")+$-$:&#;',32(4$AQ&?'2$A#?O#52$-$.@',?+8LJ/09$-$012$32(4$52$N'2$9&+)2809$-$:&#;',32(4$A#&'#$B2")+$B+&&+'&#$-$L!$-$!*+'&2$-$92&)ID#,32(4$9'((2,#)2$B',O2$-$LJ.%!A9$-$%#67'"#(809$-$:&#;',32(4$N2@+&)2$5+$B&#"P#$!&&I5#$-$LJ.%!A9$-$%#67'"#(809$-$:&#;',MI^($%#&,2($5+$%#()&2$0#")2($-$/A:N!/N-$012$32(4$52($%#672(809-$:&#;',MI';$%,#I5'2$9#&5'"'$-$.!/$-$012$32(4$52($%#672(809-$:&#;',A#&?+,,2$B#&#?2$5+$A+5+'&2($$-$//0%8L09$-$012$%#&,2(809$-$:&#;',AQ&?'#$:>$X>$A#")+,,'$-$LB0%-$B,2&'#"h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i2UU$-$/98L09$-$012$9#I,2809$-$:&#;',04&D'2$B&#(?'"2$A>$!,6+'5#$-$.K!$-$012$32(4$52($%#672(809$-$:&#;',L,&'?O$K+'7+,$-$R+2&D$0'62"$\XA$-$Jj&"@+&D$-$R+&6#"C]#,5+&$0)+UU+"$3I"'2&$-$LBL$-$L@+&,g"5'#8AR$-$:&#;',

S#,5+6#&$5+$%#()&2$M+')+$B',O2$-$.!/$-$012$32(4$52($%#672(809$-$:&#;',S',,'#"$N2@+&)2$S2,U$-$.!/-$012$32(4$52($%#672(809$-$:&#;',$S'6$9>$%>$5+$H,+&i$-$KJ\$-$N'=(_'=i80X$-$KO+$J+)O+&,#"5(

!"#$%&#'()E&%"0*$#%,

R,#I?2$5#$0',*#$-$.!/$-$012$32(4$52($%#672(809-$:&#;',X+,+"#$9&#52$!>0',*#$-$.!/$-$012$32(4$52($%#672(809-$:&#;',3#"#'"#$9#&5'$A2&+'&#$-$.!/$-$012$32(4$52($%#672(809-$:&#;',MI?'#$X+,+"#$5+$\,'*+'&#$-$E%K!$-$012$32(4$52($%#672(809-$:&#;',AG"'?#$/>$N2?O#$5+$\,'*+'&#$-$.J9/$-$012$32(4$52($%#672(809-:&#;',

!$%

Page 6: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%#$&

' %()$"*)+,-./' )0012345106'*7895:7;704<'=1:'#7>'+?70@3'! "#$%&'!()*$+,&!-#,./,&

' *%A)%B'+*$)!,%-..' +'*7257>'1='B7C@50?'$7DE01C1?57<'=1:'$E7:;1FC3<45D'!1;F1<547<'50'+7:1<F3D7'+FFC5D34510<! (0#.+!-/$/+$#!1#!"&'2#3!41'&0!"&,,.+/$+!5&2/%.&3!6+,./%%/!7/#%+!"&'2#3!8+%'&0!4+9+!8#$+2#3!:&'*!;+,#$1&!<#$=#0+

' "*)G)#+,'H+H%*&

! :&'+#0/!1/!"#'2$&!>+#'3!?0@,+&!6#%)&0A/!6#$2+03!6+$#B/%!"/$CD/+$#!;/E/01/

! 6#$,/%&!7F!;+B/+$&3!G&%0/+!<+2#

! (1+H+!I+J#+#.

! K#0#LM!6&.#))#1!N)#$

! O%@J+&!4%/$!1/!6/%&3!P#%1/)#$!1/!"#'2$&!7/+2/!O+%.&3!K+%2&0!"%/B/$!-+/2$&B&)

! -/1$&!7D+E!Q#%/1!>#!"@'3!"$+'2+#0&!RD/+$&E!G+%#0&J#3!6#0D/%!8#',+)/02&!>+#'!5#$,/%&'!:$F3!"#$%&'!(%B/$2&!SD$A/%!G/$#'

)&&#'IJKL'M'JNKL)&&#'-IO.'M'JIKN'P10C507Q

G&%FTU3!8VW3!:D%F!X!I/=F3!YTZY

!$&

Page 7: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

! KD)B/$2&!($#D9&!6#,.#1&

/KI! (0#!-#D%#!I#02&'3!"%@D1+#!;F!(01$#1/

! 5/02&!I+%J#!1/!6#22&'

/LI! <+#A&!:&'*!6/0/E/'!S&0[#%J/'3!6+',./%!"#$)/0!8/M$#!5/%1/$$#+0

! (10#0!6#C'&&1

! -#D%#!"$+'2+#0/!-+02&!6/'CD+2#!-#$1#%

! Q#$+0#!O/$$/+$#!1/!8&$&0.#

! :D%+#0#!6#,.#1&!1#!6&2#

/JN %**+$+

!$!

Page 8: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&#'()**%+'$#%*,-./01#&/2/*$3-4%&-5/6-78/*"'9'&(%3-72:&#;%-<';=/;%>!"#$%!&#$'()!

+,,%-'$#%,*#.*'*$!",/0*1%!/*#,*2!'3#4(*+,*,'$#%,'4*4#5"6*!'!"40*7'.*$7"!"*)"",*'*8%,.",.9.*%,*$7"*,""/*$%*$!#::"!*#$(*;"'/"!.*)%$7*

5!%<*$7"*=!#-'$"*',/*$7"*=9)4#8*."8$%!*7'-"*)"",*1%!>#,:*%,*$7#.*':",/'(*?7#.*/#':,%.#.*<%.$40*!"4#".*%,*$7"*,""/*$%*#,8!"'."*

$7"*8%<="$#$#-","..*#,*2!'3#4*',/*%,*$7"*5'8$*$7'$*#,,%-'$#%,*#.*89!!",$40*$7"*<'#,*/"$"!<#,',$*%5*=!%/98$#-#$0(

* @=#,#%,.*8%,-"!:"*%,*$7"*5'8$*$7'$6*#,*$7"*4%,:*$"!<6*$7"!"*1#44*)"*<',0*%==%!$9,#$#".*5%!*:!%1$7(*29$*$7"!"*#.*'4.%*:!"'$*

8%,8"!,*$7'$*$7#.*:!%1$7*.7%94/*)"*5%89."/*%,*$7"*#,$"!,'4*<'!>"$*',/*%,*$7"*"A=%!$'$#%,*%5*8%<<%/#$#".6*4"'/#,:*$%*7#:7"!*

"A$"!,'4*/" 8#$*#,*8%<='!#.%,*$%*$7"*89!!",$*,9<)"!.*%)."!-"/*#,*$"87,%4%:0*#,$",.#-"*."8$%!.(*?7'$*#.*170*$7"*"<=7'.#.*#.*%,*

#,,%-'$#%,6*%,*$"87,%4%:#8'4*/"-"4%=<",$*',/*%,*#,/9.$!#'4*=%4#80(

* 29$*$7"!"*#.*'*79:"*/#55"!",8"*)"$1"",*$7"*8%,.",.9.*',/*'8$9'440*87',:#,:*!"'4#$0(*B,/*/".=#$"*$7"*"55%!$.*$7'$*7'-"*)"",*<'/"*

=!%)')40*5%!*<%!"*$7',*$",*0"'!.*$%*#,$!%/98"*$7"*#..9"*%5*#,,%-'$#%,*#,*$7"*':",/'*%5*$7"*C$'$"6*$7"!"*7'-"*)"",*5"1*'/-',8".(

'!$*%5*%9!*/#5 894$#".*#.*!"4'$"/*$%*!".%9!8".(* 7",*$7"*!"5%!<*%5*#,8",$#-"*#,.$!9<",$.*%5*$7"* '$#%,'4*+,,%-'$#%,*C0.$"<*$%%>*

=4'8"6*<%!"*$7',*$",*0"'!.*':%6*1#$7*$7"*8!"'$#%,*%5*$7"*C"8$%!'4*D9,/.6*$7"!"*1"!"*:!"'$*"A="8$'$#%,.*$7'$*$7"."*!".%9!8".*8%94/*=9$*

2!'3#4*#,*'*/#55"!",$*4"-"4*#,*$"!<.*%5*.8#",8"6*$"87,%4%:0*',/*#,,%-'$#%,(*?7"."*!".%9!8".*'!"*.#:,# 8',$*',/*89!!",$40*!'#."*'!%9,/*

( *)#44#%,*'*0"'!(*+5*$7"!"*1"!"*,%$*.%*<',0*4#<#$.*',/*/#.="!.#%,6*#$*1%94/*)"*=%..#)4"*$%*.$!98$9!"*'*!"'.%,')4"*.8#",$# 8*=%4#80(

* 29$*$7"."*!".%9!8".*'!"*,%$*.95 8#",$*#,*%!/"!*5%!*2!'3#4*$%*)"*')4"*$%*)9#4/*'*!"'.%,')4"*$"87,%4%:0*=%4#80*$7'$*.9==%!$.*

#,,%-'$#%,(*@,"*"A'<=4"*#.*-'4#/*$%*9,/"!.$',/*$7'$* $7#.*1%94/*!"E9#!"*<987*7#:7"!*"55%!$.F* #,/9.$!#'4*.8'4"G9=(*?'>#,:*'*

.%49$#%,*$%*$7"*<'!>"$*9.9'440*<"',.*$%*=!%/98"*<',0*=!%$%$0=".6*$%*="!5%!<*$!#'4.6*$%*#<=!%-"*"'87*.$"=*%5*$7"*=!%/98$*',/*#$.

<',95'8$9!#,:(*+,*$7"*=!%8"..#,:*#,/9.$!0*H*17#87*8%<=!"7",/.*<',0*%5*$7"*."8$%!.*#,*17#87*2!'3#4*#.*<%!"*8%<="$#$#-"*H6*$7"*

.8'4"G9=*#<=4#".*#,-".$<",$.*#,*/"<%,.$!'$#%,*',/*=#4%$*=4',$.(*?7"."*"A=",.".6*#,*$"!<.*%5*:!"'$,"..6*'!"*9.9'440*%,"*%!*<%!"*

$#<".*7#:7"!*#,*!"4'$#%,*$%*$7"*"'!40*.$':".*%5*!"."'!87(*+,*$7"*'"!%.='8"*',/*/"5",."*."8$%!6*$'>#,:*'*.%49$#%,*$%*$7"*<'!>"$*7'.*

)"",*=%..#)4"*#,*8%9,$!#".*$7'$*'!"*.$!%,:40*=%.#$#%,"/*#,*$7"*#,$"!,'$#%,'4*.8",'!#%*)0*<"',.*%5*:%-"!,<",$'4*=!%89!"<",$(*

?7"."*%!/"!.*='0*5%!*$7"*,%,!"89!!#,:*8%.$.*%5*/"-"4%=<",$*',/*",')4"*'*<#,#<9<*.8'4"*%5*=!%/98$#%,(

* 29$*)".#/".*!".%9!8".6*%9!*/#5 894$#".*$%*<'>"*=!%:!"..*#,*$7"*8%,.$#$9$#%,*%5*17'$*7'.*)"",*8'44"/*',*"55"8$#-"* '$#%,'4*

+,,%-'$#%,*C0.$"<*'!"*'4.%*#,*$7"*.%*8'44"/*#,.$#$9$#%,'4*'.="8$.(*?7"*=!#-'$"G=9)4#8*#,$"!5'8"*H*17#87*#.*.%*"<=7'.#3"/*#,*$7"

1%!4/*H*#.*0"$*',*%).$'84"*5%!*#,,%-'$#%,*#,*2!'3#4(

* ?7"*;'1*%5*+,,%-'$#%,*1'.*',*'/-',8"*$%1'!/.*$7#.*/#!"8$#%,(*+,*8%,8"=$6*$7#.*4'1*8%,.#.$"/*%5*'*=!#-'$"G=9)4#8*='!$,"!.7#=*

1#$7*!":'!/.* $%* $7"* #,,%-'$#%,*.0.$"<(*+$* #.* #,$"!".$#,:* $%*,%$#8"* $7'$* $7"*I!"",*2%%>*%5*J?K+*/"/#8'$"/*%,"*87'=$"!* $%*

$7"*.%*8'44"/*#,.$#$9$#%,'4*87'44",:".(*+$*.$'!$.*1#$7*$7"*.$'$"<",$F*L!"#$%&$'(#$)*#+'#,'$-(+..#")#,$'%$/"-%*0%*+'#$1-/#"-#2$3#-("%.%)4$+"5$6""%7+'/%"$'%$'(#$+)#"5+$%&$'(#$8*+9/./+"$,%-/#'4$/,$/",'/':'/%"+.;<*M%!"*"<=7'.#.*%,*='$",$.6*8!"'$#%,*%5*

$"87,%4%:0*#,,%-'$#%,*$"'<.6*#,8",$#-".*$%*$7"*8%%="!'$#%,*)"$1"",*9,#-"!.#$#".6*#,.$#$9$".*',/*8%<=',#".*"$8(6*'!"*='!$*%5*

17'$*7'==","/*#,*2!'3#4*'5$"!*$7#.*/")'$"(

NI!'/9'$"/*#,*O4"8$!%,#8*O,:#,""!#,:*)0*$7"*?"87,%4%:#8'4*+,.$#$9$"*%5*B"!%,'9$#8.*H*+?B*PQRSRT6*U7V*#,*O8%,%<#8.*'$*="/7#,/5+5#$>,'+5:+.$5#$?+@0/"+,*H* +JBMU*PQRR T*',/*U%.$/%8*'$*J%49<)#'* ,#-"!.#$0*P T(*U!%5"..%!*'$* +JBMU6*B/-#.%!*%5*$7"*2%'!/*%5*+,/9.$!#'4*

U%4#8#".*',/*?"87,%4%:0*%5*$7"* '$#%,'4*J%,5"/"!'$#%,*%5*+,/9.$!0*H*J +*',/*<"<)"!*%5*$7"*?"87,%4%:0*J%9,8#4*%5*$7"*D"/"!'$#%,*%5*+,/9.$!#".*

%5*C %*U'94%*H*D+OCU(* #8"G<#,#.$"!*%5*C8#",8"*',/*?"87,%4%:0*%5*2!'3#4*PQRRRG T*',/* #8"*C"8!"$'!0*5%!*O8%,%<#8*V"-"4%=<",$*%5*C %*

U'94%*P ST(*M"<)"!*%5*$7"*2%'!/*%5*V#!"8$%!.*',/*I9#/',8"*%5*$7"*5%44%1#,:*%!:',#3'$#%,.F*M',':"<",$*',/*C$!'$":#8*C$9/#".*J",$"!*H*

JIOO6* '$#%,'4*+,.$#$9$"*5%!*C='8"* "."'!87*H*+ UO6*+,.$#$9$%*+,.$#$9$"*%5*?"87,%4%:#8'4* "."'!87*%5*C %*U'94%*H*+U?6*D#,',8#"!*%5*C$9/#".*

',/*U!% "8$.*H*D+ OU6*'<%,:*%$7"!.(*V!(*U'87"8%*7'.*"A="!#",8"*#,*#,/9.$!#'4*',/*$"87,%4%:#8'4*"8%,%<#8.*',/*'4.%*#,*.8#",$# 86*$"87,%4%:#8'4*

',/*#,,%-'$#%,*=%4#8#".(*W"*#.*89!!",$40*$7"*X"8$%!*%5*+?B(

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!$AB!$"8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !$A

Page 9: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

* 29$*#$* #.*'4.%*1%!$7*$%*<",$#%,*$7'$*$",*0"'!.*'5$"!*$7"*J?K+*J%,5"!",8"6*17#87*)!%9:7$*$7"*/#.89..#%,*')%9$*$7"* !.$*

-"!.#%,*%5*$7'$*;'16*$7"*",-#!%,<",$*%5*8%%="!'$#%,*)"$1"",*=9)4#8*',/*=!#-'$"*",$#$#".*#.*.$#44*.$%=="/(*M%.$40*)"8'9."*%5*$7"

%!:',#3'$#%,'4*<%/"4.*',/*!94".*$7'$*4#<#$*=9)4#8*!"."'!87*#,.$#$9$#%,.(

* @,8"*':'#,6*$7"*"A'<=4"*%5*$7"*'"!%.='8"*."8$%!*#.*"<)4"<'$#8(*@,"*%5*$7"*<%.$*8!"'$#-"*#,.$#$9$#%,'4*.%49$#%,.*$7'$*2!'3#4*

7'.*7"'!/*%5*17",*#$*8%<".*$%*$"'87#,:*',/*'==4#"/*!"."'!87*'8$#-#$#".*1'.*8%,8"#-"/*7"!"(*?7"*8!"'$#%,*%5*$7"*B"!%.='8"*

?"87,#8'4*J",$"!*<%!"*$7',*.#A$0*0"'!.*':%*1'.*,%$*%,40*)!'-"6*)9$*').%49$"40*#,,%-'$#-"(

* ?%/'06*$7#.*':",/'*#.*)'8>(*?7"*#,#$#'$#-"*%5*$7"* '$#%,'4*J%,:!"..*$%*/#.89..*'*,"1* '$#%,'4*J%/"*%5*J?K+6*17#87*1%94/*

)"*',*9=/'$"/*-"!.#%,*%5*$7"*+,,%-'$#%,*;'16*)!#,:.*$7#.*%==%!$9,#$0(*+$*#.*'*8%<=4"A6*:#:',$#8*',/*7'!/*$'.>(*29$*$7#.*1#44*)"6*

1#$7%9$*'*/%9)$6*%,"*%5*%9!*87'44",:".*5%!*$7"*,"A$*5"1*0"'!.(

* ?7"*",4'!:"<",$*%5*$7"*?"87,%4%:#8'4*+,.$#$9$"*%5*B"!%,'9$#8.*P+?BT*',/*$7"*%==%!$9,#$#".*$7'$*#$*)!#,:.*$%*$7"*!"-#$'4#3'$#%,

%5* $7"*V"='!$<",$* %5* C8#",8"* ',/*B"!%.='8"*?"87,%4%:0* PVJ?BT* 8%<=%."* '* -"!0* '==!%=!#'$"*<%<",$* $%* !"$7#,>* %9!*

%!:',#3'$#%,.6*$7"#!*<%/"4.*',/*/#5 894$#".6*17#87*84"'!40*=!"-",$*9.*5!%<*/%#,:*17'$*.%8#"$0*"A="8$.*5!%<*9.(*J7',:#,:*$7#.*

!"'4#$0*#.*.%<"$7#,:*1"*.7%94/*/%6*',/6*9,/%9)$"/406*1"*1#44(

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!$AB!$"8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!$"

Page 10: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&'%()*+&,#

!! ! ! ! "#$%!&#'#($%)*'"! ! ! ! ! +,#-%()-$,!-.((#'%#!! ! ! ! /01)-!(#2)2%$'-#$! ! ! ! ! 3)1#"#! ! ! ! 4'5($(#6"%&! ! ! 4'2%)%.%*!3#-'*,7&)-*!6#!8#(*'9.%)-$'()!! ! :$2#(!;#$1!<#,6)'&*!! ! ! ! =(#22.(#*++,!! =*,>?#%0#(#%0#(@#%*'#*+-! ! ! =*,>?#%0#(2.,A0*'#**-! ! ! =*,>?A0#'>,#'#2.,A0)6#*+"! ! ! =*,>?#%0#()1)6#%!! ! ! ! 3#1A#($%.(#

%.! ! ! ! B,$22!%($'2)%)*'!%#1A#($%.(#%/! ! ! ! C#,%)'&!%#1A#($%.(#01+-*!D')E#(2)6$6#!+2%$6.$,!=$.,)2%$!FG,)*!6#!C#2H.)%$!I),0*0-*!! ! D')E#(2)6$6#!6#!JK*!=$.,*

-./01234/-1.

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

6*)\!VP[]POXN^$%1[OPVO[P_PYYWVO

5%067"68%&'%96,:";<%/6=>;&,&<"6#%'&?%/>6?*&@,A#$"=%4&*@&#"$6#%";%56?&#@A=6%5@@,"=A$"&;#5;A>"%B6?6"?A%:A%4&#$ACD%E:#&;%4&==>"6?"%F&$6,>&CDGD%H"=>6,,6%!6A,"%4&#$AID%.",#&;%E"J"%.A?"$AKD%L&#M%0"=A?:&%/A?@A;"N

V!I$-.,6$6#!6#!+'&#'0$()$!6#!B.$($%)'&.#%9`!B.$($%)'&.#%9NJ=!`!;($S),O!4'2%)%.%*!6#!8#(*'9.%)-$!#!+2A$T*!`!JK*!F*2a!6*2!b$1A*2NJ=M!;($S),Y!+C;c8+c`!JK*!F*2a!6*2!b$1A*2NJ=M!;($S),_!D')E#(2)6$6#!6#!JK*!=$.,*!`!JK*!b$(,*2NJ=M!;($S),

!"#$%&'$(3 #2789:;<2=3 $>2;/:?54@$7<3 @$;A<$A;453 =2$4753 ?4;$@3 48=3 4@@2/B572@3 4;23 B278.3 =2C25:?2=3 $:3 B23 78<5A=2=3 783<A;;28$342;:84A$7<3?;:.;4/@63%>2;/:?54@$7<3<:/?:@7$23$2<>8:5:.D378$28=@3$:34<>72C237/?;:C2=3?;:?2;$72@348=35:E3<:@$3?;:<2@@2@63)25=78.3:93=2$4753?4;$@3?2;/7$@3$:3:B$47834@@2/B572@3E7$>3E27.>$3;2=A<$7:8348=3<:@[email protected];;28$5DG3H:7878.3<:/?:@7$23/4$2;745@37@343/4$$2;3:9378$28@23;2@24;<>3B2<4A@23$;4=7$7:8453H:7878.3$2<>8:5:.72@34;238:$3=7;2<$5D3$;48@92;I4B523$:3<:/?:@7$23@$;A<$A;2@63JA@7:83B:8=78.348=3$>23A@23:93$>2;/:?54@$7<34@3>:$3/25$34=>2@7C2@3:992;348345$2;84$7C23$:3/2<>487<45394@$2878.348=3$>2;/:@2$$78.34=>2@7C23B:8=78.63JA@7:83B:8=78.3$2<>8:5:.DG3E>7<>3:;7.784$2=39;:/3$>23$>2;/:?54@$7<3?:5D/2;378=A@$;DG3>[email protected]=34382E378$2;2@$3E7$>3$>2378$;:=A<$7:83:93$>2;/:?54@$7<3/4$;7K3<:/?:@7$2@G3E>7<>34;23<A;;28$5D3;2.4;=2=34@3<48=7=4$239:;3?;7/4;D347;<;49$3@$;A<$A;2@63%>7@3?4?2;3;2C72E2=3$>23@$4$23:93$>234;$3:93$>23E25=78.3$2<>8:5:.72@3=2C7@2=3$:342;:@?4<2378=A@$;DG378<5A=78.3$>23 25=@3$>4$3- :3*4A5:3-$4$23087C2;@7$D348=3087C2;@7$D3:93- :3*4A5:34;23=22?5D378C:5C2=6

)*+,-%.#(3&7;<;49$3@$;A<$A;453H:78$G3%>2;/:?54@$7<3<:/?:@7$2G3)25=78.3$2<>8:5:.D6

c#-#)E#6\!P]NPQNVO! 8--#A%#6\!PYNPXNVO$.%0*(!5*(!-*((#2A*'6#'-#\!# *%#,0* 5#&[.'#2A[ (#A$(%$1#'%*! 6#! C$%#()$)2! #! 3#-'*,*&)$!N!I+B?! 8E[! 8() #(%*!

=#(#)($! 6$! b.'0$M! YYY! ;$)((*! =#6(#&.,0*!N!b+=\VO[]VU?_VP! `!B.$($%)'&.#%9NJ=!`!;($S),

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!$$B!D$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !$$

Page 11: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

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

1#%0*62!2.-0!$2!#,#-%()-!(#2)2%$'-#M!.,%($2*')-!E) ($%)*'M!0*%!A,$%#M!#,#-%(*1$&'#%)-!)'6.-%)*'M!6)#,#-%()-N1)-(*L$E#!$'6!4c!L#,6)'&! C*.S$@)2!2$3456M!OPPXR!;*%#,0*!$'6!c#S#'6#M!OPPQR!<$'&!$'6!"$0'M!OPPQR!F*'#2M!VWW_R!:**2!2$3456M!VWXVZ[! c#2#$(-0#2!)'E*,E)'&!L#,6)'&!)'!-*1A*2)%#2!)'!;($S),!L#(#!)')%)$%#6!)'!OPPU! >!I$-.,6$6#!6#!+'&#'0$()$!6#!B.$($%)'&.#%9!*5!D +J=M!438!$'6!+2-*,$!6#!+'&#'0$()$!6#!JK*!b$(,*2!*5!DJ=[!30#!L*(@!2%$(%#6!)'!%0#2#!.')E#(2)%)#2!L)%0!-**A#($%)*'!*5!+1A(#2$!;($2),#)($!6#!8#(*'9.%)-$! +C;c8+cM!$-(*1>'!)'! =*(%.&.#2#Z! 5*-.2#6! *'! %0#! 1#-0$')-$,! $'6! %0#(1$,!-0$($-%#()S$%)*'!*5!L#,6#6!,$1)'$%#2!*5!==J! 2#1)?-(>2%$,,)'#!==J! %0#(1*A,$2%)-! A*,>1#(Z! (#)'5*(-#6! L)%0! -*'%)'.*.2!0)&0?A#(5*(1$'-#! #(2[! *L$6$>2M!D +J=! )2!6#E#,*A)'&!(#2)2%$'-#!L#,6)'&!%#-0'*,*&>!L0#(#$2!DJ=!)2!$6E$'-)'&!)'!4c!,$1A!L#,6)'&!1#%0*6*,*&>[! 30)2! A$A#(! $)1#6! %*! # $1)'#!6)55#(#'%!L#,6)'&! %#-0?')H.#2! 5*(! %0#(1*A,$2%)-! -*1A*2)%#! ,$1)'$%#2! 6#E)2#6!%*! 2%(.-%.($,! $#(*2A$-#! $AA,)-$%)*'2M! 5*-.2)'&! *'! (#-#'%!6#E#,*A1#'%2!)'!%0)2!$(#$[

O-PO%BE0Q10H5.4E%/OE0H1B!5(/-441HB1(-/E(%Q10%5E01(B54E%5BB!-45/-1.(

! 30#!$.%*1*%)E#!)'6.2%(>!0$2!%($6)%)*'$,,>!A(*6.-#6!$!L)6#!($'&#!*5! %0#(1*A,$2%)-!A$(%2!L)%0! %0#! $6E$'%$&#!*5! 20*(%#(!A(*-#22)'&!%)1#2!$'6!5.,,>!$.%*1$%#6!#H.)A1#'%2! c$>M!OPPUR!;*%#,0*!2$3456M!OPP]R!;*%#,0*!2$3456M!OPPOR!;*%#,0*!2$3456M!OPPVR!3*6*!2$3456M!OPPPZ[! 4'!%0#!,$%#!VWXP2M!&,$22!$'6!-$( *'!(#)'5*(-#6!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!=+4!,$1)'$%#2!L#(#! (2%!.2#6!)'!I*@@#(!VPP!̂ #%A,$'#M!B.,52%(#$1!B_PP! $'6!B]PP! .2)'#22! ^#%2M! $'6!8)( .2! ;#,.&$! %($'2A*(%!$)(-($5%!$2! %0#(1*5*(1#6! **()'&!A$'#,2! b*2%$!2$3456M!OPVPR!d)#),,#!2$3456M!OPPWR!e*.'&!$'6!e#M!OPP]R!;*%#,0*!2$3456M!OPPYZ[! C*(#!(#-#'%,>M!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!-*1A*2)%#2!0$E#!5*.'6!.%),)S$?%)*'!)'!,$'6)'&!&#$(!6**(2M!L)'&,#%2M!#,#E$%*(2M!$),#(*'2M! $A2M!

2A*),#(2M!2A##6! ($@#2M!2,$%2M!%*!-)%#!$!5#L!$AA,)-$%)*'2! #!I$()$!2$3456M!OPVVR!c#S#'6#!2$3456M!OPVVR!b0#E$,)!2$3456M!OPVPR!;$%#2!2$3456M!OPPWR!8()-)M!OPPQR!+2A#(%!2$3456M!OPP_R!:##!2$3456M!VWWYZ[! 8!L)6#!($'&#!*5!0)&0!A#(5*(1$'-#!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!1$%()-#2!)2!$E$),$ ,#!'*L$6$>2M!L)%0!=++ !$'6!==J!%0#!1*2%!L)6#,>!2%.6)#6!$'6!(#A*(%#6[!;*%0!*5!%0#1!$(#!2#1)?-(>2%$,,)'#!A*,>?1#(2M!$'6!-(>2%$,,)')%>!)'!0)&0?A#(5*(1$'-#!A*,>1#(2!)2!H.)%#!)1A*(%$'%!$2! )%!0$2!$!2%(*'&! )' .#'-#!*'! %0#)(!-0#1)-$,!$'6!1#-0$')-$,!A(*A#(%)#2[!b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

9E!2-.P%B014E((E(

! 4'!-0**2)'&!$!2%(.-%.($,!#'&)'##(#6!1$%#()$,!5*(!$#(*2A$-#!$AA,)-$%)*'M!$'!)1A*(%$'%!-*'2)6#($%)*'!)2!0*L!#$2>!)2!%*!1$'.?5$-%.(#M!^*)'M!)'2A#-%M!(#A$)(!$'6!(#A,$-#!)%!)'!2#(E)-#[!/'#!*5!%0#!1$'>!$6E$'%$&#2!*5!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!*E#(!%0#(1*2#%!-*1A*2)%#2!)'!%0#2#!-$2#2!)2!%0$%!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!1$%()-#2!-$'! #!1#,%#6!$'6!(#5*(1#6[!4'!%0#*(>M!.2)'&!$6#H.$%#!%#1A#($%.(#!$'6!=!,#E#,2M!$!-*1A*2)%#!,$1)'$%#!-$'! #!(#20$A#6!)'6# ')%#,>[! C$'>! '*E#,! ^*)')'&! %#-0')H.#2! 0$E#! ##'! A(*A*2#6M!6#E#,*A#6!$'6!#E$,.$%#6!5*(!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!$AA,)-$%)*'2!)'!%0#!,$2%!OP!>#$(2[!4'!(#&$(6!%*!5.2)*'! *'6)'&!1#%0*6*,*&)#2M!%0#>!-$'! #!2.11$()S#6!$2!5*,,*L2!)'!I)&[!V[

b*2%$M!8[=[!2$3456

!"#$%&'(%&)$&*

! $ %& ' &* % *& ' &* " ' &* ' &$ " #

$&' )$&*'$( %&' )$&*

#%&$ ' )$&*

&)" %&' )$&*$ % ' )$&*$ $ ' )$&*'#$# & ' )$&*

% ' ' ) #$ #" ' #$&'(%&)$&*

% ' ' )$&*% '* #' )$&*)$ & ' )$&*

& )' )$&*'# ' )$&*'

I)&.(#!V[!b,$22) -$%)*'!*5!A*%#'%)$,!5.2)*'!L#,6)'&!%#-0')H.#2!5*(!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!-*1A*2)%#2! 8&#*(&#2!2$3456M!OPPVZ[

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!$$B!D$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!$D

Page 12: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

! J#E#'!1$)'!L#,6)'&!%#-0')H.#2!$(#!6#2-() #6! #,*LM!$--*(6?)'&!%0#!*(6#(!%0#>!$AA#$(!)'!%0#!2-0#1$%)-!A(*E)6#6!)'!I)&[!V[

3,$?A#&;"=%86,:";<

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e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e*.2#5?A*.(!2$3456M!OPP_R!J)66)H!$'6!B0$22#1)#0M!OPPXR!:#E>!2$3456M!OPPXR!8&#*(&#2!$'6!e#M!OPPOZ[! 30#!$AA,)-$%)*'!*5!.,%($2*')-!L#,6)'&!)2!H.)%#!# %#'2)E#!)'!1$'>! )'6.2%()$,! ($'-0#2! )'-,.6)'&!#,#-%()-$,M!-*1A.%#(M!

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b?VYP!"#(-.,#2!$)(-($5%! :#E>!2$3456M!OPPXZ[

-;:R=$"&;%86,:";<

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

!3L3"3M3 3#3 3$! VZ

! 30#!$ *E#!#H.$%)*'!#2%$ ,)20#2!%0$%!0#$%)'&!6#A#'62!*'!%)1#! $ZM!*01)-!(#2)2%$'-#! #ZM!$'6!%0#!2H.$(#!*5!%0#!)'6.-#6!#,#-%()-$,!-.((#'%! "Z[!30#!-.((#'%!)2!)'6.-#6! >!$'!$,%#('$%?)'&!1$&'#%)-! #,6M! 2*! )%! %0#(#5*(#!6#A#'62!*'! %0#! )'6.-%*(!&#*1#%(>M!%0#!-*),!-.((#'%M!$'6!%0#!6)2%$'-#!%*!%0#!1$%#()$,! )'!%0#!-$2#!*5!%0#!1$%#()$,!%*! #!L#,6#6!)2!'*%!)'2)6#!%0#!-*),ZM!$2!6#A)-%#6!)'!I)&[!Y! C*2#(!2$3456!OPPXR! $&$'!$'6! )-0*,2MOPP]R!e*.2#5A*.(!2$3456M!OPP_R!J%*@#2M!OPPYR!d#,%0.)2!$'6!C)%2-0$'&M!OPPYR!"*.!2$3456M!VWWWZ[

$&$'! $'6! )-0*,2! OPP]Z! (#5#(! %*! %0(##! -$%#&*()#2! *5!0#$%)'&!2*.(-#2!6.()'&!)'6.-%)*'!L#,6)'&!*5! #(!(#)'5*(-#6!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!-*1A*2)%#2\

! #(!0#$%)'&\!0#$%)'&!)2!%0#!(#2.,%!*5!F*.,#!,*22#2!6.#!%*!%0#!)'0#(#'%!(#2)2%$'-#!0#$%)'&!*5! #(2! C*2#(!2$3456M!OPPXZR

8!c#E)#L!*5!<#,6)'&!3#-0'*,*&)#2!5*(!30#(1*A,$2%)-!b*1A*2)%#2!)'!8#(*2A$-#!8AA,)-$%)*'2

I)&.(#!O[!J-0#1$%)-!*5!$'!.,%($2*')-!L#,6)'&!1$-0)'#! e*.2#5A*.(!2$3456M!OPP_R!8&#*(&#2!2$3456M!OPPVR!8&#*(&#2!2$3456M!OPPPZ[

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!$$B!D$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !$E

Page 13: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

! 6)#,#-%()-!0>2%#(#2)2!0#$%)'&\!%0)'!,$>#(!*5!1$%() !1$%#()$,!$%!%0#! *'6)'&!,)'#!2#A$($%#2! #(2!5(*1!%0#!-*'2*,)6$%#6!,$1)'$%#2[!8!-$A$-)%*(!)2!%0#'!-(#$%#6!$'6!6)#,#-%()-!0#$%?)'&!*--.(2!6.#!%*!%0#!1*E#1#'%!*5!-0$(&#!$'6!(*%$%)*'!*5!%0#!1*,#-.,#2! #%L##'!%0#! #(2! J%*@#2M!OPPYZR

! -*'%$-%! (#2)2%$'-#! 0#$%)'&\! 0#$%)'&! *--.(2! *'! ,*-$%)*'2!L0#(#! %0#! #(? #(! -*'%$-%! )2! 0)&0! -(*22*E#(! A*)'%2!)'!%0#!-$2#!*5!L*E#'!5$ ()-2Z[!30)2!%0#*(>!# A,$)'2!L0>!2#E#($,! 5$ ()-! %>A#2!0$E#!$!6)55#(#'%!0#$%)'&!&#'#($%)*'!d#,%0.)2!$'6!C)%2-0$'&M!OPPYZ[

I)&.(#!Y[!J-0#1$%)-! ),,.2%($%)*'! *5! $! 1$&'#%)-! #,6! $'6! #66>!-.((#'%!&#'#($%#6! >!$!#,#-%(*1$&'#%)-!-*),! $&$'!$'6!)-0*,2M!OPP]Z[

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

-*1A*'#'%M!.2)'&!%0#!&($A0)%#! #(2!$2!%0#!-*'6.-%)'&!#,#1#'%[!J%(.-%.($,!#,#1#'%2!A(*6.-#6! >!%0)2!1#%0*6!-*1A$(#6!5$E*(?$ ,>!%*!%0*2#!1$'.5$-%.(#2! >!$.%*-,$E#!-*?-*'2*,)6$%)*'[! 30#!# $1A,#2!$ *E#!20*L!%0$%!)'6.-%)*'!0#$%)'&!-$'! #!.2#6!5*(!L#,6)'&!*5!%0#(1*A,$2%)-! #(!(#)'5*(-#6!-*1A*2)%#2!$'6!$--#A%$ ,#! *'6)'&!A(*A#(%)#2!$(#!* %$)'#6[

H"=?&8A76%86,:";<

! 30#! A*22) ),)%>! *5! .2)'&! 1)-(*L$E#! %*! L#,6! A$(%2! 0$2!# )2%#6!2)'-#!%0#!6#E#,*A1#'%!*5!%0#!1$&'#%(*'!)'!%0#!VW_P2[!4%2!.2$&#!)'!%0#!5(#H.#'->!($'&#!5(*1!V!%*!VPP!B"S!0$2! ##'!(#A*(%#6! )'! %0#! ,)%#($%.(#! %*!L#,6! %0#(1*A,$2%)-!-*1A*2)%#2!.!2$3456M!OPPYR!<)2#!$'6!I(*1#'%M!OPPVR!b0.'&?e.$'!2$3456M!

VWWWR!d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e*.2#5A*.(!2$3456M!OPP_R! .!2$3456M!OPPYR!<)2#!$'6!I(*1#'%M!OPPVR!b0.'&?e.$'!2$3456M!VWWWR!d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

b0.'&?e.$'!2$3456M!VWWWR!d*6)-@$M!VWWUZ[! "#$%)'&!)'!$!1)-(*L$E#! #,6!#22#'%)$,,>!%$@#2!A,$-#! >!%0#!5*,,*L)'&!A0>2)-$,!A(*-#22#2M!6#A#'6)'&!*'!%0#!%$(&#%!1$%#()$,\!A*,$()S$%)*'!0#$%)'&! A*,$(!1$%#()$,ZM!#,#-%()-$,!(#2)2%$'-#!0#$%)'&!#,#-%()-$,,>!-*'6.-%)E#!1$%#()$,2ZM!0#$%)'&!%0(*.&0!%0#!C$ L#,,?<$&'#(!#55#-%! 1.,%)?A0$2#!1$%#()$,2R! ,#'62M! ,,#6!1$%#()$,2ZM!)*'!A*,$()S$%)*'! #,#-%(*,>%#2M!2$,)'#!2*,.%)*'2!$'6!-#($1)-2!$%!0)&0!%#1A#($%.(#2ZM!#,#-%(*'!A*,$()S$%)*'! .!2$3456M!OPPYR!<)2#!$'6!I(*1#'%M!OPPVR!b0.'&?e.$'!2$3456M!VWWWR!d*6)-@$M!VWWUZ[! b*'%)'.*.2!1)-(*L$E#!L#,6)'&! -$'! #! .2#6! 5*(! .%%?L#,6)'&! *5! ^*)'%! #,#1#'%2! L)%0! ,*LM! 1#6).1! $'6! 0)&0!

b*2%$M!8[=[!2$3456

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!$$B!D$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!$F

Page 14: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

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b/M! /M!$'6! "! *'62!$(#! %>A)-$,!#,#-%(*1$&'#%)-! $ 2*( #'%!1$%#()$,2[! .()'&! %0#!L#,6)'&!A(*-#22M!2*1#!*5!%0#2#!1$%#()$,2!#E$A*($%#!$'6!2*1#!(#1$)'!)'!%0#!L#,6!$(#$! .!2$3456M!OPPYR!<)2#!$'6!I(*1#'%M!OPPVR!b0.'&?e.$'!2$3456M!VWWWR!d*6)-@$M!VWWUZ[

I)&.(#!_[!J-0#1$%)-! 2#%?.A! 5*(! 1)-(*L$E#! 0#$%)'&! e*.2#5A*.(!2$3456G!OPP_Z[

! 30#!%#-0')H.#!)2!2%),,! )'!%0#!6#E#,*A1#'%!2%$&#2!$'6M!$2!2.-0M!%0#(#!$(#!-.((#'%,>!'*!(#A*(%#6!)'6.2%()$,!$AA,)-$%)*'2[!"*L#E#(M!)%!)2!$'%)-)A$%#6!%0$%!1)-(*L$E#!L#,6)'&!1$>!A(*E#!%*! #!2.)%$ ,#!5*(!^*)')'&!$.%*1*%)E#!.'6#(? *6>!-*1A*'#'%2!$'6!$#(*2A$-#!A$(%2[

06#"#$A;=6%86,:";<

! c#2)2%$'-#!L#,6)'&!0$2! ##'!-*'2)6#(#6!$!E#(>!A(*1)2)'&!^*)')'&!%#-0')H.#!5*(!$#(*2A$-#!$AA,)-$%)*'[!30)2!A(*-#22!)2!(#,$%)E#,>!5$2%! L#,6)'&!%)1#2!5(*1!V!%*!_!1)'.%#2ZM!(#H.)(#2!

,)%%,#!$1*.'%!*5!1$%#()$,!$'6!-$'! #!$AA,)#6!%*!,$(&#!2%(.-?%.(#2[!B**6!%0#(1$,!)'2.,$%)*'!$'6!$!-*((#-%!$1*.'%!*5!)'A.%!#'#(&>!-$'!(#6.-#!%0#!L#,6)'&!%)1#!$'6!#'0$'-#!L#,6!H.$,?)%>! 8&#*(&#2!$'6!e#M!OPVVR!b*2%$M!OPVPR!e*.2#5A*.(!2$3456M!OPP_R!e$'&!$'6!=)%-0.1$')M!OPPO$M!e$'&!$'6!=)%-0.1$')M!OPPO R!8&#*(&#2!$'6!e#M!OPPOR! )$*!2$3456M!VWWOZ[! 4'! %0)2!A(*-#22M!$!-*'6.-%)E#!#,#1#'%! &#'#($,,>!$!2%##,!1#20!*(!$!-$( *'!2%()AZ!)2!A,$-#6!$%!%0#!)'%#(5$-#! #%L##'!%0#!,$1)'$%#2!%*! #! ^*)'#6[! 30)2! -*'6.-%)E#! #,#1#'%! )2! -*''#-%#6! %*! $!A*L#(!2.AA,>M!$'6!%0#'!$!2.5 -)#'%!"!)2!$AA,)#6!2*!%0$%!F*.,#!,*22!&#'#($%#2!0#$%!#'*.&0!%*!-(#$%#!$! *'6,)'#! J%$E(*E!;#(2##M!OPP]R!J%$E(*E!2$3456M!OPPYR!e$'&!$'6!=)%-0.1$')M!OPPO8M!e$'&!$'6!=)%-0.1$')M!OPPO;R!f*'!2$3456M!VWWOR! )$*!2$3456M!VWWOZ[!I)&.(#!]!20*L2!$!2-0#1$%)-!*5! %0#!(#2)2%$'-#!L#,6)'&!A(*-#22[

I)&.(#!][!J-0#1$%)-!2#%?.A!5*(!(#2)2%$'-#!L#,6)'&!A(*-#22! 8&#*(&#2!$'6!e#M!OPPOZ[

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

8!c#E)#L!*5!<#,6)'&!3#-0'*,*&)#2!5*(!30#(1*A,$2%)-!b*1A*2)%#2!)'!8#(*2A$-#!8AA,)-$%)*'2

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!$$B!D$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !$#

Page 15: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

O&$%@,A$6%86,:";<

! 30#(1$,!L#,6)'&!)2!$!5.2)*'! *'6)'&!1#%0*6*,*&>!%0$%! $2)?-$,,>!-*'2)2%2!)'!0#$%)'&!A*,>1#(!1$%() !-*1A*2)%#2!A)#-#2!$%!%0#)(!)'%#(5$-#!-$.2)'&!$!6#-(#$2#!*5!E)2-*2)%>!%0.2!$,,*L)'&!A*,>1#(!-0$)'2!%*!)'%#(6)5.2#!$2!%0#!2.(5$-#2!$(#!0#,6!%)&0%,>!%*&#%0#(M!L)%0!5.(%0#(!2,*L!-**,)'&!5*(!^*)'%!-*'2*,)6$%)*'! e*.2#5A*.(!2$3456M!OPP_R!8&#*(&#2!2$3456M!OPPVR!8&#*(&#2!2$3456M!OPPPZ[! 4'2)6#!*5!%0)2!-*'-#A%M!0*%!A,$%#!*(!0*%?%**,!L#,6)'&!)2!*'#!*5!%0#!1*2%!A*A.,$(!1#%0*62!5*(!^*)')'&!%0#(1*A,$2%)-2! #-$.2#!)%!)2!$!2)1A,#M!(#,)$ ,#M!$'6!#-*'*1)-$,!L$>!*5!A(*6.-)'&!2%(*'&!L#,62[!30)2!L#,6)'&!A(*-#22!-$'! #!6)E)6#6!)'%*!0#$%)'&M!̂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g[!4'!-$2#!*5!%**!,)%%,#!A(#22.(#M!5.,,!-*'%$-%!$'6!%0.2!&**6!0#$%!-*'6.-%)*'! #%L##'!0*%!A,$%#!$'6!^*)')'&!A$(%2!1)&0%!'*%!#!#'2.(#6[!30#!$AA,)#6!A(#22.(#!20*.,6! #!1$)'%$)'#6!.'%),!%0#!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!1$%() #&)'2!%*!2*5%#'!$'6! *L[!85%#(!%0)2M!%0#!0*%!#,#1#'%!)2!(#1*E#6!$'6!1#,%#6!2.(5$-#2!$(#!A(#22#6!$&$)'2%!#$-0! *%0#(! .'%),! -*'2*,)6$%)*'! *--.(2[! J1$,,! A$(%2! 6#1$'6!#%L##'!]!%*!UP!2#-*'62!%*! #!L#,6#6M!L0#(#$2!,$(&#!A$(%2!%$@#!$%!,#$2%!YP!1)'.%#2!%*!&.$($'%##!$!&**6!-*''#-%)*'[!c)2@2!*5!2.(5$-#!-*'%$1)'$%)*'!$(#!$1*'&2%!%0#!1$)'!6($L $-@2!*5!%0)2!%#-0')H.#! 8&#*(&#2!2$3456M!OPPVR!8&#*(&#2!2$3456M!OPPPZ[

-0%86,:";<

! 4c!L#,6)'&! )2!$'*%0#(!2*1#L0$%!'#L-*1#(! %*! %0#! #,6!*5! '*'?-*'%$-%! %#-0')H.#2! 5*(! ^*)')'&! 5) #(! (#)'5*(-#6!

%0#(1*A,$2%)-!A*,>1#(!1$%() !-*1A*2)%#2! e*.2#5A*.(!2$3456M!OPP_R!8&#*(&#2!2$3456M!OPPVZ[! C$)'!$6E$'%$&#2!*5!4c!2*.(-#2!$(#!%0#)(!$ ),)%>!%*!5$2%!0#$%?)'&! %>A)-$,,>!]!2#-*'62ZM!-$A$-)%>!%*!$%%#'.$%#!-*'%$1)'$%)*'!()2@2M! %0.2!$,,*L)'&!0)&0!A(*6.-%)E)%>!($%#2!*5!(#A(*6.-) ,#!2%(*'&! ^*)'%2! )'!$.%*1$%#6!2>2%#12[!I*(! )'2%$'-#M! (#%#'%)*'!*5!X_ !*5!A*,>1#(! .,@!2%(#'&%0!0$2! ##'!(#A*(%#6!5*(!OP)'!E*,.1#!*5!20*(%!&,$22! #(!)'!=+J!1$%() b0#'M!OPPPZ[!;#2)6#2!0)&0!-*'2)2%#'%M!,*L!2-$%%#(#6!1#-0$')-$,!A(*A#(%)#2!*5! 4c!L#,6#6! ^*)'%2M!L0)-0! )2! %($'2,$%#6! )'! 0)&0! 2%(.-%.($,!(#,)$ ),)%>!$2!-(.-)$,,>! (#H.)(#6! )'!0)&0?6#1$'6)'&!-*1A*?'#'%!6#E)2#6!%*!$#(*'$.%)-$,!)'6.2%(>M!0.&#!A*%#'%)$,!*5!%0)2!1$'.5$-%.()'&!%#-0')H.#!-$'! #!5*(#-$2%!)'!%0#!$#(*'$.%)-$,!#'E)(*'1#'%! >!E)(%.#!*5!)%2!&(#$%! # ) ),)%>!$'6!-$A$ ),)%>!%*!^*)'!,$(&#! $%!$'6!-.(E#6!$(#$2! =*%#'%#!2$3456M!VWWYR!b0#'M!OPPPR!C),,#(M!OPPUZ[!4'!%0#!*%0#(!0$'6M!$!1$)'!20*(%-*1)'&!*5!4c!L#,6)'&!)2!%0#!6#%()1#'%$,!#55#-%!*5!-*,*($'%2!$'6!A)&1#'%2!)'! -0$'&)'&! A*,>1#(! $ 2*(A%)*'! A(*A#(%)#2! %0.2! (#6.-)'&!%0#! H.$,)%>! *5! %0#! #'6!A(*6.-%[!f$(@#(! A*,>1#(2! $(#! #2A#?-)$,,>!A(*'#!%*!6)2A,$>!*E#(0#$%)'&!2.(5$-#!6#&($6$%)*'!6.#!%*!,*L!4c!#'#(&>!%($'25#(!($%#2!6*L'!%0(*.&0!1#,%)'&!S*'#M!'#E#(%0#,#22!6##A!0#$%!A#'#%($%)*'!1$>! #!$!-*'-#('!6.#!%*!A*22) ,#!,$1)'$%#!6#-*'2*,)6$%)*'!$'6!L$(A)'&!6.()'&!0#$%)'&!2%$&#M!$2!L#,,!$2!%0#(1$,!(#2)6.$,!2%(#22#2!6#E#,*A1#'%!$,*'&!-**,)'&!2%$&#! JL$(%S! !JL$(%SM!VWXWR!=*%#'%#!2$3456G!VWWYR!b0#'M!OPPPR!8&#*(&#2!2$3456M!OPPVR $&$' !;($>M!OPPYR!B(#L#,,!2$3456M!OPPYR!B(#L#,,! !;#'$%$(M!OPPQZ[!! ;$2)-$,,>M! %0#! %#-0')H.#! -*1A()2#2! %0(##! 2. 2#H.#'%!A0$2#2! J),E#(1$'!$'6!B()#2#M!VWXWR!J-0L$(%SM!VWW_R!b0#'!$'6!;#'$%$(M!VWW]Z[!I)&.(#2!Q! %*!W! 5#$%.(#!2*1#! )1A*(%$'%!$2A#-%2!(#,$%#6!%*!4c!($6)$%)*'!L#,6)'&M!A$(%)-.,$(,>!)'!(#&$(6!%*!%0#!L#,6)'&!2>2%#1!*A#($%)*'M!$AA,)#6!%0#(1*1#-0$')-$,!->-,#!$'6!-*'%$-%!)'%#(5$-#! #0$E)*(!*5!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!^*)'%[

!A#6?%86,:";<

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

b*2%$M!8[=[!2$3456

I)&.(#!U[!J-0#1$%)-!*5!%0#!0*%?A,$%#!L#,6)'&! e*.2#5A*.(!2$3456M!OPP_Z[

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!$$B!D$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!D%

Page 16: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

! :;<! 0$2! ##'! #'E)2)*'#6! $2! $! 2.)%$ ,#! %#-0')H.#! 5*(!^*)')'&! %0)'M! $2! L#,,! $2! 1#6).1! %*! %0)-@! %0#(1*A,$2%)-!-*1A*'#'%2! .2#6! )'! %0#! $#(*'$.%)-! 2#-%*([!C*(#*E#(M! 2)S#M!&#*1#%()-$,! (#H.)(#1#'%2M! $'6! 2A#-) -$%)*'2! *5! $#(*'$.%)?-$,!A$(%2!$(#!-,$)1#6!%*! #!1*(#!#$2),>!5., ,,#6! >!$AA,>)'&!

:;<!%#-0')H.#!($%0#(!%0$'!$,%#('$%)E#!%#-0'*,*&)#2! :$ #$2!2$3456M!OPVPZ[!:;<!$,,*L2!^*)')'&!%0#(1*A,$2%)-2M!A(*E)6#6!%0$%!*'#!*5!%0#!1$%#()$,2! %*A!1$%#()$,Z!)2!%($'2A$(#'%!%*!,$2#(!($6)$%)*'!$'6!%0#!*%0#(! *%%*1!1$%#()$,Z!)2!$ 2*( #'%!#'*.&0!5*(!%0#!L#,6)'&!%*!%$@#!A,$-#M!*%0#(L)2#!*',>! .%%!̂ *)'%2!L),,! #!$,,*L#6M!L0)-0!)2!'*%!$'!$%%($-%)E#!A*22) ),)%>!5*(!-*'%)'.*.2!#(!(#)'5*(-#6!2%(.-%.(#2[

! 4'!%0#! (2%!$AA(*$-0M!A$(%2!%*! #!^*)'#6!$(#! (*.&0%!)'%*!6)(#-%!-*'%$-%!A()*(!%*!L#,6)'&[!30#!,$2#(! #$1!)2!%($'21)%%#6!%0(*.&0!%0#! (2%!1$%#()$,!$'6!)2!%*%$,,>!$ 2*( #6!L)%0)'!%0#!2.(5$-#!*5! %0#!$ 2*( )'&!1$%#()$,[!f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

0EH50S5F!E%41.4!3(-1.(

! I(*1!%0)2!1$'.2-()A%!)%!-$'! #!-*'-,.6#6!%0$%!'*%!*',>!*'#!^*)')'&!%#-0'*,*&>!-$'! #!$AA,)-$ ,#!%*!$,,!2)%.$%)*'2[!8,,!^*)'?)'&!1#%0*6*,*&)#2!20*L#6!)'!%0)2!L*(@!A(#2#'%!$6E$'%$&#2!$'6!6($L $-@2M!$'6!%0#>!1$>! #!1*(#!*(!,#22!2.)%$ ,#!%*!$!A$(%)-.,$(!

8!c#E)#L!*5!<#,6)'&!3#-0'*,*&)#2!5*(!30#(1*A,$2%)-!b*1A*2)%#2!)'!8#(*2A$-#!8AA,)-$%)*'2

I)&.(#!Q[!J-0#1$%)-! *5! )'5($(#6! ,$1A! L#,6)'&! 2>2%#1! -*'-#)E#6!%*! ^*)'! %0#(1*A,$2%)-! ,$1)'$%#2!0)&0,)&0%)'&! %0#! )'5($(#6!($6)$%)*'!2*.(-#M!A*,>1#(!A$(%2!6#A,*>1#'%!$'6!A(#22)'&!A,$%#2! e*.2#5A*.(!2$3456M!OPP_R!8&#*(&#2!2$3456M!OPPVR!=*%#'%#!2$3456M!VWWYZ[

I)&.(#!X[!3>A)-$,! %0#(1*1#-0$')-$,!->-,#!*5! %0#! )'5($(#6!L#,6)'&!2>2%#1! 6#A)-%#6! )'! I)&[! Q! e*.2#5A*.(! 2$3 456M! OPP_R!8&#*(&#2!2$3456M!OPPVR!=*%#'%#!2$3456M!VWWYZ[

I)&.(#!W[!C$-(*1*,#-.,$(! )'%#(6)55.2)*'!1#-0$')21! *--.(()'&! )'!#%L##'!%L*!-*'%$-%)'&!A$(%2!6.()'&!%0#!)'5($(#6!L#,6)'&!A(*-#22!A*(%($>#6!)'!I)&2[!Q!$'6!X! e*.2#5A*.(!2$3456M!OPP_R!8&#*(&#2!2$3456M!OPPVR!=*%#'%#!2$3456M!VWWYZ[ I)&.(#!VP[! :$2#(!%($'21)22)*'!L#,6)'&!%#-0')H.#! :$ #$2!2$3456M!OPVPZ[

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!$$B!D$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !D&

Page 17: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

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̂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c!,$1A!L#,6)'&!1#%0*6*,*&>!$'6!$6E$'-#6!6#2%(.-%)E#!$'6!'*'6#2%(.-%)E#!-0$($-%#()S$%)*'!*5!%0#!^*)'%2[! C*2%! *5! %0#! 6$%$! )'! %0)2! A$A#(!L#(#! * %$)'#6! 5(*1! %0#!,)%#($%.(#M!2)'-#!%0)2!1$'.2-()A%! )2!$!2%$%#?*5?%0#?$(%!(#E)#L[!30#(#5*(#M!2.-0!6$%$!6*!'*%!A(*E)6#!)'5*(1$%)*'!5*(!6#$,2!*5!(#A#$%$ ),)%>!*(!(#A(*6.-) ),)%>M!$'6!%0#>!$(#!.2#5.,!*',>!5*(!$'!)')%)$,!1$AA)'&!*5!A*%#'%)$,!%#-0')H.#2!*E#(!$!L)6#!($'&#!*5!L#,6!A(*-#22)'&!-*'6)%)*'2!$'6!A$($1#%#(2!%*! #!.2#6!)'!$#(*2A$-#! #,6[

5=T;&8,6:<6*6;$#

! 30#!$.%0*(2!%0$'@5.,,>!$-@'*L,#6&#!%0#! '$'-)$,!2.AA*(%!5(*1!I.'6$TK*!6#!81A$(*!h!=#2H.)2$!6*!+2%$6*!6#!JK*!=$.,*!!I8=+J=ZM!b*'2#,0*! $-)*'$,!6#!f#2#'E*,E)1#'%*!b)#'% -*!#!3#-'*,7&)-*! b =HZ!$'6!b**(6#'$TK*!6#!8A#(5#)T*$1#'%*!6#!=#22*$,!6#! E#,!J.A#()*(! b8=+JZ[

0EQE0E.4E(

8&#*(&#2M!b[M!e#M!:[M!OPPVM!iJ)1.,$%)*'!*5!)1A.,2#!(#2)2%$'-#!L#,6)'&! 5*(! %0#(1*A,$2%)-! 1$%() ! -*1A*2)%#2 M! 8AA,)#6!b*1A*2)%#!C$%#()$,2M!d*,[!XM! *[!OM!AA[!VYY?V_Q[

8&#*(&#2M! b[M!e#M! :[M! OPPOM! iI.2)*'! *'6)'&! *5! A*,>1#(!-*1A*2)%#2\!5(*1! $2)-!1#-0$')212!%*!A(*-#22!*A%)1)2$%)*' [!JA()'&#(M!:*'6*'[

8&#*(&#2M! b[! 2$3 456M! ! OPPVM! i86E$'-#2! )'! 5.2)*'! *'6)'&!%#-0')H.#2! 5*(! ^*)')'&! %0#(1*A,$2%)-!1$%() ! -*1A*2)%#2\! $!(#E)#L M!b*1A*2)%#2\!=$(%!8M!d*,[!YOM! *[!UM!AA[!XYW?X]Q[

8&#*(&#2M!b[!2$3456M!OPPPM!i+ A#()1#'%$,!)'E#2%)&$%)*'!*5!%0#!(#2)2%$'-#!L#,6)'&!5*(!%0#(1*A,$2%)-?1$%() !-*1A*2)%#2[!=$(%!4\!0#$%)'&!#,#1#'%!$'6!0#$%!%($'25#( M!b*1A*2)%#2!J-)#'-#!$'6!3#-0'*,*&>M!d*,[!UPM! *[!QM!AA[!VPOQ!`!VPYW[

8()-)M!8[8[M! OPPQM! i+55#-%!*5!0>&(*%0#(1$,! $&)'&!*'!A*,>?#%0#()1)6#!-*1A*2)%#2 M!F*.('$,!*5!c#)'5*(-#6!=,$2%)-2!$'6!b*1A*2)%#2M!d*,[!OUM! *[!VXM!AA[!VWYQ?VW_O[

;$,,#M!I[!2$3456M!OPPWM!iD,%($2*')-!1#%$,!L#,6)'&!*5!$,.1)').1!20##%2!%*!-$( *'! (#!(#)'5*(-#6!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!-*1A*2)%#2 M!86E$'-#6!+'&)'##()'&!C$%#()$,M!d*,[!VVM! *[!VM!AA[!V?O[

;$%#2M!=[F[!2$3456M!OPPWM!iJ0#$(!2%(#'&%0!$'6!1#,%6*L'! #0$E?)*(! *5! (#)'5*(-#6! A*,>A(*A>,#'#! $22#1 ,)#2 M! b*1A*2)%#2\!=$(%!8[M!d*,[!_PM! *[!VM!AA[!OX?Y][

;*%#,0*M!+[b[!2$3456M!OPP]!i=(*-#22)'&!$'6!0>&(*%0#(1$,!#55#-%2!*'! E)2-*#,$2%)-! #0$E)*(! *5! &,$22! #(N#A* >! -*1A*2)%#2 M!F*.('$,!*5!C$%#()$,!J-)#'-#M!d*,[!_PM! *!V_M!AA[!YUV]?YUOY[

;*%#,0*M!+[b[!2$3456M!OPPYM!iC#-0$')-$,! #0$E)*(!*5!-$( *'!#(!(#)'5*(-#6!A*,>$1)6#!-*1A*2)%#2 M!b*1A*2)%#2!J-)#'-#!

$'6!3#-0'*,*&>M!d*,[!UYM! *[!VYM!AA[!VX_Y?VX]][

;*%#,0*M! +[b[! $'6!c#S#'6#M!C[bM! OPPQM! if$1A)'&! #0$E?)*(! *5! 0>&(*%0#(1$,,>! -*'6)%)*'#6! -$( *'! 5) #(N#A* >!,$1)'$%#2 M! F*.('$,! *5!8AA,)#6!=*,>1#(!J-)#'-#M!d*,[! VPUM!*[!]M!AA[!YV_Y!`!YV_X[

;*%#,0*M!+[b[!2$3456M!OPPOM!iJ%.6>!*5!A*,>$1)6#!UNU!2>'%0#2)2!-$(()#6!*.%! >! )'%#(5$-)$,! A*,>1#()S$%)*'!*'! -$( *'! #( M!=*,>1#(!4'%#('$%)*'$,M!d*,[!]VM! *[!VVM!AA[!VOUV?VOUQ[

;*%#,0*M!+[b[!2$3456M! OPPV!iJ>'%0#2)2!*5!A*,>$1)6#!UNU! >!)'%#(5$-)$,!A*,>-*'6#'2$%)*'!L)%0!%0#!2)1.,%$'#*.2!)1A(#&'$?%)*'!*5!-$( *'! #(2 M!C$-(*1*,#-.,#2M!d*,[!Y_M! *[!VPM!AA[!YYUQ?YYQ][

b0#'M!e[J[M!OPPPM!i4c!L#,6)'&!*5!&,$22! ,,#6!A*,>#%0#(!2.,5*'#!-*1A*2)%# M!3$1@$'&!F*.('$,!*5!J-)#'-#!$'6!+'&)'##()'&M!d*,[!OM! *[!OM!AA[!OOW?OY_[

b*2%$M!8[=[!2$3456

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!$$B!D$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!D!

Page 18: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

b0#'M!e[J[!$'6!;#'$%$(M!8[M!VWW]M!i4'5($(#6!L#,6)'&!*5!A*,>?A(*A>,#'# M!8''.$,!3#-0')-$,!b*'5#(#'-#!N!J*-)#%>!*5!=,$2%)-2!+'&)'##(2M!d*,[VM!AA[VOY]?VOYX[

b0#E$,)M!d[J[!2$3456M!OPVPM!i+55#-%!*5!#'E)(*'1#'%$,!L#$%0#()'&!*'! # .($,!-(##A! #0$E)*(!*5! ,*'&! #(?(#)'5*(-#6!%0#(1*?A,$2%)-!-*1A*2)%#2 M!=*,>1#(!f#&($6$%)*'!$'6!J%$ ),)%>R!d*,[!W]M! *[!VOM!AA[!OUOX?OU_P[

b0.'&?e.$'M!<[!2$3456MVWWWM!iC)-(*L$E#!L#,6)'&!*5!"f=+!.2)'&! )1A#6$'-#!1$%-0)'&!2>2%#1 M! F*.('$,!*5!c#)'5*(-#6!=,$2%)-2!$'6!b*1A*2)%#2M!d*,[!VXM! *[!VM!AA[!OQ[

b*2%$M!8[=[M!OPVPM!i+5#)%*!6*!-*'6)-)*'$1#'%*!$1 )#'%$,!#1!-*1A72)%*2! 2*,6$6*2! 6#!==JN ($2! -*'% '.$2 M! 6)22#(%$TK*!6#! 1#2%($6*M! D')E#(2)6$6#! +2%$6.$,! =$.,)2%$! D +J=ZM!B.$($%)'&.#%9M!J=[!

b*2%$M!8[=[!2$3456M!OPVPM!i4' .#'-#!*5!#'E)(*'1#'%$,!-*'6)?%)*')'&!*'!%0#!20#$(! #0$E)*(!*5!A*,> A0#'>,#'#!2., 6#ZN&,$22!#(!-*1A*2)%#2 M!F*.('$,!*5!8AA,)#6!=*,>1#(!J-)#'-#M!d*,[!

VVXM! *[!VM!AA[!VXP?VXQ[

f#!I$()$M!C[b[C[!2$3456MM!OPVVM!i30#!#55#-%!*5!%0#!*-#$'!L$%#(!)11#(2)*'!$'6!Dd!$&#)'&!*'!%0#!6>'$1)-!1#-0$')-$,!A(*A#(?%)#2!*5!%0#!==JN&,$22! #(!-*1A*2)%#2 M!F*.('$,!*5!c#)'5*(-#6!=,$2%)-2!$'6!b*1A*2)%#2M!d*,[!YPM! *[!OPM!AA[!VQOW?VQYQ[

f*'M! c[b[! 2$3 456M! VWWOM! i+ A#()1#'%$,! -0$($-%#()S$%)*'! *5!A(*-#22)'&?A#(5*(1$'-#! (#,$%)*'20)A2! *5! (#2)2%$'-#!L#,6#6!&($A0)%#NA*,>#%0#(#%0#(@#%*'#! -*1A*2)%#! ^*)'%2 M! =*,>1#(!+'&)'##()'&!J-)#'-#M!d*,[!YOM! *[!WM!AA[!UOP?UYV[

+2A#(%M!8[!2$3456M!OPP_M!ib*1A$()2*'!*5!L$%#(!$ 2*(A%)*'! )'!'$%.($,! -#,,.,*2)-! (#2! 5(*1! L**6! $'6! *'#?>#$(! -(*A2! )'!A*,>A(*A>,#'#!-*1A*2)%#2!$'6!)%2!)' .#'-#!*'!%0#)(!1#-0$')-$,!A(*A#(%)#2 M!b*1A*2)%#2!=$(%!8M!d*,[!Y]M! *[!VVM!AA[!VOUQ?VOQU[

B(#L#,,M! f[! $'6! ;#'$%$(M!8[M! OPPQM! i<#,6)'&! *5! A,$2%)-2\!5.'6$1#'%$,2!$'6!'#L!6#E#,*A1#'%2 M!4'%#('$%)*'$,!=*,>1#(!=(*-#22)'&M!d*,[!OXM! *[!VM!AA[!_Y?]V[

B(#L#,,M!f[8[!2$3456M!OPPYM!i=,$2%)-!$'6!-*1A*2)%#!L#,6)'&!0$'6 **@ M!d*,[!VPM!"$'2#(!=. ,)20#(2M!C.')-0M!_PQ!A[

B(#L#,,M! f[! 2$3 456M! OPP_M! ic#,$%)*'20)A! #%L##'! *A%)?-$,! A(*A#(%)#2! $'6! *A%)1)S#6! A(*-#22)'&! A$($1#%#(2! 5*(!%0(*.&0?%($'21)22)*'! ,$2#(! L#,6)'&! *5! %0#(1*A,$2%)-2 M!F*.('$,! *5!c#)'5*(-#6!=,$2%)-2! $'6!b*1A*2)%#2M!d*,[! OYM!*[!YM!AA[!OYW?O_Q[

"*.M!C[!2$3456M!VWWWM!i8'!# A#()1#'%$,!2%.6>!*5!(#2)2%$'-#!L#,6)'&!*5!-$( *'! (#!5$ ()-!(#)'5*(-#6!A*,>#%0#()1)6#! bI!5$ ()-N=+4Z!-*1A*2)%#!1$%#()$, M!8AA,)#6!b*1A*2)%#!C$%#()?$,2M!d*,[!UM! *[!UM!AA[!Y]?_W[

F$>$1*,M!B[!2$3456M!VWWXM!i+55#-%2!*5!#'E)(*'1#'%!*'!%0#!A(*A?#(%)#2! *5! :*L?6#'2)%>! A*,>#%0>,#'#! -*1A*2)%#2! (#)'5*(-#6!L)%0!A)'#$AA,#?,#$5! (# M!b*1A*2)%#2!J-)#'-#!$'6!3#-0'*,?*&>M!d*,[!]XM! *[!WM!AA[!V_QV?V_X][

F*'#2!I[c[M!VWW_M!iC*)2%.(#!$ 2*(A%)*'!?!$'*1$,*.2!#55#-%2 [!4'\!"$'6 **@!*5!A*,>1#(! (#!-*1A*2)%#2[!:*'&1$'!J-)#'?%) -!$'6!3#-0')-$,M!D M!AA[!YQV?YQ][

$&$'M!d[!$'6!;($>M!c[M!OPPYM!iI*(L$(6!%*! #%%#(!.'6#(2%$'6?)'&!*5!*A%)-$,!-0$($-%#()S$%)*'!$'6!6#E#,*A1#'%!*5!-*,*(#6!A*,>$1)6#2!5*(!%0#!)'5($?(#6N,$2#(!L#,6)'&\!A$(%!4!?!#5 -)#'->!*5!A*,>$1)6#2!5*(!)'5($?(#6!L#,6)'& M!F*.('$,!*5!c#)'5*(-#6!=,$2%)-2!$'6!b*1A*2)%#2M!d*,[!OOM! *[!UM!AA[!]YY?]_Q[

$&$'M!d[! $'6! )-0*,2M!c[F[M! OPP]M! i;#'# %2! *5! )'6.-%)*'!L#,6)'&! *5! (#)'5*(-#6! %0#(1*A,$2%)-2! )'! 0)&0! A#(5*(1$'-#!$AA,)-$%)*'2 M!F*.('$,!*5!c#)'5*(-#6!=,$2%)-2!$'6!b*1A*2)%#2M!d*,[!O_M! *[!VYM!AA[!VY_]?VY]O[

( &#(M!J[!2$3456M!OPP_M!iD,%($2*')-!L#,6)'&!*5!1#%$,N-*1A*2?)%#!^*)'%2 M!86E$'-#6!+'&)'##()'&!C$%#()$,2M!d*,[!UM! *[!YM!AA[!V]Q?V]W[

.M!"[J[!2$3456M!OPPYM!id$()$ ,#!5(#H.#'->!1)-(*L$E#! dICZ!A(*-#22)'&! 5$-),)%)#2! $'6!$AA,)-$%)*'! )'!A(*-#22)'&! %0#(1*?A,$2%)-!1$%() !-*1A*2)%#2 M!F*.('$,!*5!C$%#()$,2!=(*-#22)'&!3#-0'*,*&>M!d*,[!VYWM! *[!V?YM!AA[!OWV?OW][

:$ #$2M!B[ [!2$3456M!OPVPM!i/A%)1)S$%)*'!*5!,$2#(!%($'21)2?2)*'!L#,6)'&!A(*-#22!5*(!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!-*1A*2)%#!A$(%2!.2)'&!%0#(1*?1#-0$')-$,!2)1.,$%)*' M!F*.('$,!*5!b*1A*2)%#!C$%#?()$,2M!d*,[!__M! *[!VM!AA[!VVY?VVX[

8!c#E)#L!*5!<#,6)'&!3#-0'*,*&)#2!5*(!30#(1*A,$2%)-!b*1A*2)%#2!)'!8#(*2A$-#!8AA,)-$%)*'2

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!$$B!D$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !DA

Page 19: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

:##M! ["[!2$3456M!VWWYM!ib(>2%$,,)S$%)*'! #0$E)*(!*5!A*,>A0#'?>,#'#!2., 6#! ==JZ!$'6!==JN-$( *'! #(!-*1A*2)%#2\!+55#-%!*5!-.(# M!=*,>1#(!;.,,#%)'M!d*,[!YPM! *[!]M!AA[!_UW?_Q][

:#E>M!8[!2$3456M!OPPXM!iD,%($2*')-!L#,6)'&!*5!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!-*1A*2)%#2\!1*6#,)'&!*5!%0#!A(*-#22 M!4'%#('$%)*'$,!F*.('$,!*5!C$%#()$,!I*(1)'&M!d*,[!WM! *[!VM!AA[!XXQ?XWP[

:**2M!8[b[!2$3456M!VWXVM!iC*)2%.(#!$ 2*(A%)*'!*5!A*,>#2%#(?+!&,$22!-*1A*2)%#2 !)'\!JA()'&#(M!B[J[M!#6)%*([!+'E)(*'1#'%$,!#55#-%2! *'! -*1A*2)%#! 1$%#()$,2[! 3#-0'*1)-! =. ,)20)'&!b*1A$'>M! #L!e*(@[!

C$,,)-@M!=[ [M!VWWYM!iI) #(?(#)'5*(-#6!-*1A*2)%#2\!1$%#()$,2M!1$'.5$-%.()'&M!$'6!6#2)&' [!C$(-#,!f#@@#(M! #L!e*(@M!XXV!A[

C$S.(M!c[:[!2$3456M!OPPXM!i8E$,)$Tj#2!%a(1)-$!#!(#*,7&)-$!6$!1$%()S!%#(1*A,92%)-$!=+ !.%),)S$6$!#1!-*1A72)%*2!$#(*'9.?%)-*2 M! =*, 1#(*2\! b) '-)$! #! 3#-'*,*&)$M! d*,[! VXM! *[! YM!AA[!OYQ?O_Y[

C),,#(M! c[M! OPPUM! iC#%0*6! $'6! $AA$($%.2! 5*(! )'5($(#6!L#,6)'&! *5! %0#(1*A,$2%)-! A$(%2 M! D')%#6! J%$%#2! =$%#'%!.1 #(! QPPUQUYM! 5(*1\! 0%%A\NNLLL[5(##A$%#'%2*',)'#[

-*1NQPPUQUY[0%1,!

C*2#(M!:[!2$3456M!OPPXM!i4'6.-%)*'!L#,6)'&!*5!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!A*,>1#(!-*1A*2)%#2!.2)'&!(* *%)-!%#-0')H.#2 M!J8C=+!F*.(?'$,M!d*,[!__M! *[!]M!AA[!_Y?_X[

C*.S$@)2M! f[+[! 2$3 456M! OPPXM! i8--#,#($%#6! #'E)(*'1#'%$,!$&#)'&!2%.6>!*5!A*,>#2%#(N&,$22! #(!(#)'5*(-#6!-*1A*2)%#2!BIc=b2Z M!b*1A*2)%#2\!=$(%!;M!d*,[!YWM! *[!YM!AA[!_UQ?_Q][

)'&M!"[!2$3456MM!OPPQM!if#2)&'M!1$'.5$-%.(#!$'6!$'$,>2)2!*5!$!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!-*1A*2)%#!5($1#!2%(.-%.(#!5*(!1$22!%($'2)% M!b*1A*2)%#!J%(.-%.(#2M!d*,[!XPM! *[!VM!AA[!VP]?VVU[

)'*M!B[I[!2$3456M!OPPWM!i30#(1$,! f4!*5!(#2)2%$'-#!L#,6#6!-*1A*2)%#!2%(.-%.(#2 M!b*1A*2)%#2\!=$(%!;[M!d*,[!_PM! *!YM!AA[!OYQ?O_X[

=*%#'%#M!"[!2$3456M!VWWYM!ib*1A$($%)E#!)'E#2%)&$%)*'!)'%*!%0#!L#,6)'&!*5!&,$22? (#?(#)'5*(-#6!=+J M!F*.('$,!*5!30#(1*?A,$2%)-!b*1A*2)%#!C$%#()$,2M!d*,[UM! *[!OM!AA[V_Q?V]W[

=($ 0$@$($'M!c[!2$3456M!OPPUM!ib*'%*.(!,$2#(!?!,$2#(?%($'21)22)*'!L#,6)'&!*5!&,$22!(#)'5*(-#6!'>,*'!U M!F*.('$,!*5!30#(1*A,$2%)-!b*1A*2)%#!C$%#()$,2M!d*,[!VWM! *[!_M!AA[!_OQ?_YW[

c$>M!;[b[M!OPPUM!i3#1A#($%.(#!#55#-%!6.()'&!0.1)6!$&#)'&!*'! )'%#(5$-#2! *5! &,$22! $'6! -$( *'! #(2! (#)'5*(-#6! #A* >!-*1A*2)%#2 M!F*.('$,!*5!b*,,*)6!$'6!4'%#(5$-#!J-)#'-#M!d*,[!OWXM! *[!VM!AA[!VVV?VVQ[

c#S#'6#M!C[b[!2$3456M!OPVVM!ib*1A72)%*2!#2%(.%.($)2!`!%#-'*?,*&)$!#!A(9%)-$ M!+6)%*($!8(%:) #(M!JK*!=$.,*M!;($2),[!

J-0L$(%SM!C[C[M!VWW_M!iF*)')'&!*5!-*1A*2)%#!1$%() !1$%#()?$,2 M!8JC!"$'6 **@M!8JC!4'%#('$%)*'$,M!/0)*M!VXO!A[

J)66)HM!8[! $'6!B0$22#1)#0M!+[M!OPPXM! i30#(1*1#-0$')-$,!$'$,>2#2! *5! .,%($2*')-! L#,6)'&! A(*-#22! .2)'&! %0#(1$,! $'6!$-*.2%)-!2*5%#')'&!#55#-%2 M!C#-0$')-2!*5!C$%#()$,2M!d*,[!_PM!*[!VOM!AA[!WXO?VPPP[

J),E#(1$'M!+[C[!$'6!B()#2#M!c[8[M!VWXWM!iF*)')'&!1#%0*62!5*(!&($A0)%#N=++ !%0#(1*A,$2%)-!-*1A*2)%#2 M!J8C=+!F*.('$,M!d*,[!O]M! *[!]M!AA[!Y_?YX[

J)'1$ST#,)@M!3[M! OPPUM! i $%.($,!L#$%0#()'&! #55#-%2! *'! %0#!1#-0$')-$,!$'6!2.(5$-#!A(*A#(%)#2!*5!A*,>A0#'>,#'#!2.,A0)6#!==JZ! -*1A*2)%#2 M!C$%#()$,2! $'6!f#2)&'M!d*,[! OQM! *[! _M!AA[!OQP?OQQ[

J%$E(*EM!f[!$'6!;#(2##M!"[+[ [M!OPP]M!ic#2)2%$'-#!L#,6)'&!*5!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!-*1A*2)%#2?$'!*E#(E)#L M!b*1A*2)%#2!=$(%!8\!8AA,)#6!J-)#'-#!$'6!C$'.5$-%.()'&M!d*,[!YUM! *[!VM!AA[!YW?]_[

J%$E(*EM! f[! 2$3 456M! OPPYM! i+ A#()1#'%$,! )'E#2%)&$%)*'! *5!,$(&#?2-$,#!L#,6)'&!*5!-$( *'! #(!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!-*1A*2)%#!1$%#()$,2 M!4'\!=(*-##6)'&2!*5!4bbC?V_!b*'5#(#'-#M!OPPYM!J$'!f)#&*[

J%*@#2M!d[ [M!OPPYM!i+ A#()1#'%2!*'!%0#!)'6.-%)*'!L#,6)'&!*5!%0#(1*A,$2%)-2 M!=*,>1#(!+'&)'##()'&!$'6!J-)#'-#M!d*,[!_YM!*[!WM!AA[!V]OY?V]_V[

JL$(%SM!"[f[!$'6!!JL$(%SM!F[:[M!VWXWM!iI*-.2#6!)'5($(#6!1#,%!5.2)*'\!$'*%0#(!*A%)*'!5*(!L#,6)'&!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!-*1A*2)%#2 M!JC+!3#-0')-$,!=$A#(\!F*)')'&!b*1A*2)%#2[!+CXW?VQ]?VU[

b*2%$M!8[=[!2$3456

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!$$B!D$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!D"

Page 20: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

3*6*M!C[!2$3456M!OPPPM!iJ%($)'?($%#!6#A#'6#'-#!*5!%0#!%#'2),#!5($-%.(#! #0$E)*.(! *5! L*E#'?-,*%0! (#)'5*(-#6! A*,>$1)6#!-*1A*2)%#2 M!b*1A*2)%#2!J-)#'-#!$'6!3#-0'*,*&>M!d*,[!UPM!*[!]M!AA[!QUY?QQV[

d#,%0.)2M! c[! $'6!C)%2-0$'&M! =[M! OPPYM! i4'6.-%)*'! L#,6)'&!%#-0'*,*&>!?!^*)')'&! (#!(#)'5*(-#6!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!A*,>1#(2!-*1A*2)%#2Z!5*(!$#(*2A$-#!$AA,)-$%)*'2 M!C#-0$')-$,!+'&)?'##()'&!=$A#(2M!d*,[!YUM! *[!VM!AA[!VQOQ?VQY_[

d)#),,#M! ;[! 2$3 456M! OPPWM! i4' .#'-#! *5! %#1A#($%.(#! *'! %0#!#0$E)*(!*5!-$( *'! #(!5$ ()-2!(#)'5*(-#6!==J!,$1)'$%#2 M!C$%#()$,2! J-)#'-#! $'6! +'&)'##()'&!8M!d*,[! ]VQM! *[! V?OM!AA[!]V?UP[

d*6)-@$M!c[M!VWWUM!i30#(1*A,$2%)-2!5*(!$)(5($1#!8AA,)-$%)*'2M!$!(#E)#L!*5!%0#!A(*A#(%)#2!$'6!(#A$)(!1#%0*62!5*(!%0#(1*A,$2?%)-!-*1A*2)%#2 M!8.2%($,)$'!f#A$(%1#'%!*5!f#5#'-#M!fJ3/!8#(*'$.%)-$,!$'6!C$()%)1#!c#2#$(-0!:$ *($%*(>M!8.2%($,)$[

<$'&M!e[!$'6!"$0'M!3["[M!OPPQM!i8IC!-0$($-%#()S$%)*'!*5!%0#!)'%#(5$-)$,!A(*A#(%)#2!*5!-$( *'! #(!(#)'5*(-#6!A*,>1#(!-*1A*2)%#2!2. ^#-%#6!%*!0>&(*%0#(1$,!%(#$%1#'%2 [!b*1A*2?)%#2!J-)#'-#!$'6!3#-0'*,*&>M!d*,[!UQM! *[!VM!AA[!WO?VPV[

<$'&M! [!2$3456M!OPPUM!iI+C!)'E#2%)&$%)*'!*5!%0#!%#1A#($%.(#!#,6!*5!#'#(&>!6)(#-%*(!6.()'&!.,%($2*')-!L#,6)'&!*5!=++

-*1A*2)%#2 M!F*.('$,!*5!30#(1*A,$2%)-!b*1A*2)%#!C$%#()$,2M!d*,[!VWM! *[!]M!AA[!]WY?UPQ[

<)2#M!c[F[!$'6!I(*1#'%M!4[f[M!OPPVM!iC)-(*L$E#!L#,6)'&!*5!%0#(1*A,$2%)-2 M!F*.('$,!*5!C$%#()$,2!J-)#'-#M!d*,[!YUM! *[!O_M!AA[!]WY]?]W]_[

)$*M! [c[!2$3456MVWWOM!i=(*-#22)'&!$'6!1*6#,,)'&!*5!(#2)2?%$'-#!L#,6)'&!*5!8=b?O!-*1A*2)%# M!F*.('$,!*5!b*1A*2)%#!C$%#()$,2M!d*,[!OUM! *[!QM!AA[!VPYV?VP_W[

e$'&M!I[$'6!=)%-0.1$')M!c[M!OPPO$M!i"#$,)'&!*5!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!A*,>1#(2! $%! $'! )'%#(5$-#! .'6#(! '*')2*%0#(1$,! -*'6)%)*'2 M!C$-(*1*,#-.,#2M!d*,[!Y]M! *[!XM!AA[!YOVY?YOO_[

e$'&M!I[! $'6!=)%-0.1$')M!c[M! OPPO M! i4'%#(,$1)'$(! -*'%$-%!6#E#,*A1#'%!6.()'&!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!5.2)*'! *'6)'& M!=*,>1#(!+'&)'##()'&! !J-)#'-#[M!d*,[!_OM! *[!OM!AA[!_O_?_YX[

e*.'&M! [!$'6!e#M!:[M!OPP]M!i4' .#'-#!*5!1$%() !$'6!)'%#(5$-#!*'!%($'2E#(2#!1#-0$')-$,!A(*A#(%)#2!*5!bI?=+4!%0#(1*A,$2%)-!-*1A*2)%#2!$%!#,#E$%#6!%#1A#($%.(#2 M!F*.('$,!*5!c#)'5*(-#6!=,$2%)-2!b*1A*2)%#2M!d*,[!O_M! *[!_M!AA[!_OW?__][

e*.2#5A*.(M!8[!2$3456M!OPP_M!iI.2)*'! *'6)'&NL#,6)'&!*5!%0#(?1*A,$2%)-!-*1A*2)%#2 M!F*.('$,!*5!30#(1*A,$2%)-!b*1A*2)%#!C$%#()$,2M!d*,[VQM! *[!_M!AA[!YPY?Y_V[

8!c#E)#L!*5!<#,6)'&!3#-0'*,*&)#2!5*(!30#(1*A,$2%)-!b*1A*2)%#2!)'!8#(*2A$-#!8AA,)-$%)*'2

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!$$B!D$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !D$

Page 21: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management
Page 22: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&'(#!%"

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

6-0%-!$4(!$7.(!,&!,4$'#+&45!,-(!(.(%,4&5$/'(,0%!4$10$,0&'!0'!

-($,3! 0'!1(,(450'(1!+4()*('%8!7$'1#9!:-(!$,,('*$,0&'!&+!,-(!(.(%,4&5$/'(,0%!6$2(!%$'!$.#&!7(! +$2&4(1!78! ,-(!$1()*$,(!%&570'$,0&'!&+!,-(!=-$#(!%$'%(.0'/!=-('&5('&'!78!$1H*#,0'/!,-(!(.(%,40%$.!,-0%G'(##!&+!E"F!@I$(J!!"#$%&3!BCCKL!A0$#3!!"#$%&3!BCCKL!I&./*(4$#3!!"#$%&3!BCCML!N$5$!!"#$%&3!BCOOL!P0',&!$'1!E(J('1(3!BCOBD9!:-(!+&..&60'/!$==.0%$,0&'#!$4(!$5&'/!,-(!5&#,!05=&4,$',!+&4!,-(!E"F!$4($>!@$D!,&!05=4&2(!=$,,(4'#!&+!

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

1&0>!OC9KCBW?H$,59BCOB9CXCYBKOB

) ) *+,O!U'#,0,*,&!:(%'&.Z/0%&!1(!"(4&'[*,0%$!;!T\&!]&#^!1&#!S$5=&#?TP!_!`4$J0.B!U'#,0,*,&!1(!"(4&'[*,0%$!(!a#=$b&!;!T\&!]&#^!1&#!S$5=&#?TP!_!`4$J0.

!"#$%&'$(#'()*#*"+,-#($,#$*#.$)/#012!3")4!#"0#*(05#"($"#"(!#$,!6+$"!#30.1)/$")0/#07#.$8/!")3#$/,#,)!%!3"9)3#:$9")3%!*#3$/#).:904!#"(!#9$,$9#$1*091)/8#.$"!9)$%*#:!9709.$/3!&#;09# "()*<# 709.+%$")0/*#07#:0%-+9!"($/!#9!*)/#%0$,!,#5)"(#3$910/#1%$3=#$/,#>)?/#7!99)"!<#5)"(#8!/!9$%#30.:0*)")0/#@;!ABC<#5(!9!#@#D#>)<#?/#09#10"(#!%!.!/"*<#(0.08!/)E!,#

F*#.$)/#9!*+%"<#"()*#*"+,-#*(05*#"($"#"(!#$,!6+$"!#30.1)/$")0/#07#3$910/#1%$3=#$/,#>)?/#7!99)"!#).:904!*#"(!#:903!**!,#9$,$9#$1*091)/8#.$"!9)$%*#:!9709.$/3!#,+!#"0#"(!#$,!6+$"!#$,2+*".!/"#07#"(!#).:!,$/3!#.$"3()/8<#5()3(#7$409*#"(!#

)*+,-%.#(#G0$")/8*<#H$,$9#$1*091)/8#.$"!9)$%*<#HF@<#>)?/#7!99)"!*<#G$910/#1%$3=&

E(%(02(1>!BX?CX?OB! "%%(=,(1>!CX?CM?OBc$*,-&4!+&4!%&44(#=&'1('%(>!504$7(.5%4d0$(9%,$974Pb9!F$.9! a1*$41&!N&5(#3! KC9! SaP>! OB9BBW;eCO! _! T\&! ]&#^! 1&#!S$5=&#?TP!_!`4$J0.

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!DEB!E"8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !DE

Page 23: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

%0,(19!V#*$..83! ,-(#(!5$,(40$.#!'((1!,&!$,,('1!,-(!+&..&60'/!;

070.0,83!50'05*5!,-0%G'(##3!601(!&=(4$,0&'$.!7$'1!60,-!.&6!

.&6!%&#,!@A0$#!!"#$%&3!BCCKL!N$5$!$'1!E(J('1(3!BCOCD9

! V'0)*(!5$,(40$.#!$'1!(.(%,40%$.!1(#0/'#!$4(!*#(1!,&!$,,('*;$,(!&4!(##(',0$..8!,4$=!4$1$4!#0/'$.#9!:-(!4$1$4!,4$'#=$4('%8!

7*,!$.#&!&+!,-(!(.(%,40%$.!$'1!5$/'(,0%!=4&=(4,0(#!&+!,-(!*#(1!5$,(40$.!$'1!,-(!%-$4$%,(40#,0%#!4(.$,(1!,&!,-(!0'%01(',!4$1$4!#0/'$.9!:-(!.&6!1(,(%,0&'!@fgD!%-$4$%,(40#,0%#!&+!$!#,4*%,*4(!1(=('1!&'!,-(!5$,(40$.!=4&=(4,0(#3!=$4,0%*.$4.8!,-(04!5$/'(,0%!@=(45($70.0,8D!$'1!10(.(%,40%!@=(450,,020,8D!=4&=(4,0(#9!a<=(40;5(',$..8! ,-0#! #,*18!%&'#01(4#! ,-(!%*5*.$,02(!(++(%,#!&+! ,-(!.&##(#3!4(.$,0'/!0'104(%,.8!,-(!$7#&4=,0&'!=-('&5('$!60,-!,-(!

*#0'/!,-(!h$2$.!E(#($4%-!f$7&4$,&48!@hEfD!$4%-!,(%-'0)*(9!:-(#(!=-8#0%$.!=$4$5(,(4#!$4(!/02('!78!a)9!O!$'1!B!@S*..0,83!OeMBL!f((3!OeeOL!A0$#3!BCCCD>

9#D# I9J#)# K9#<! @OD

9#D# I9#J#)# K9! @BD

6-(4(! 9!$'1! 9!$4(!,-(!4(.$,02(!=(450,,020,8!$'1!=(45($70.;0,83!4(#=(%,02(.83!6-0%-!$4(!'&45$.0J(1!78!,-(!2$.*(#!0'!,-(!2$%**5! !(! 9

! :-(!4($.!=$4,#3! I9!$'1! I93!$4(!4(.$,(1!,&!,-(!#,&4(1!('(4/83!6-0.(!,-(!05$/0'$48!=$4,#! K9!$'1! K9!,&!,-(!.&##(#9!S&'#01(4;0'/!,-$,!0'!10(.(%,40%!$7#&47(4#!,-(!.&##!5(%-$'0#5#!$4(!4(.$,(1!,&!,-(!5$,(40$.!%&'1*%,020,83! 3!0#!%&'2('0(',!,&!(<=4(##! K93!$#!@S*..0,83!OeMBL!A0$#3!BCCCD>

K9#D# ! @YD

6-(4(! !0#!,-(!4$10$,0&'!$'/*.$4!+4()*('%89

! :-(! 10(.(%,40%! $'1!5$/'(,0%! .&##! ,$'/(',#! $4(! /02('! $#!a)9!X!$'1!K3!4(#=(%,02(.8>

,$'! #D# K9 I9! @XD

,$'! .#D# K9 I9! @KD

! :-(!4(+4$%,0&'!0'1(<3!/<!0#!,-(!4(.$,0&'!7(,6(('!,-(!6$2(!'*57(4!=3!%-$4$%,(40#,0%!&+!,-(!6$2(!=4&=$/$,0&'!60,-0'!,-(!5$,(40$.3!$'1!,-(!6$2(!'*57(4!= !4(.$,(1!,&!,-(!6$2(!=4&=$/$;,0&'!0'!2$%**53!a)9!i!@S*..0,83!OeMBL!A0$#3!BCCCD>

!! " " # #" � �# # @iD

6-(4(!" $ $$ � ��%

,-(!0',40'#0%!05=(1$'%(!?!&+!,-(!5$,(40$.3!a)9!M>

!? ? 9 9" � �# ! @MD

6-(4(!jC!0#!,-(!05=(1$'%(!0'!2$%**53!()*$.!,&!YMM! 9

(.(%,4&5$/'(,0%!6$2(3!,-$,!05=0'/(#!,-(!5$,(40$.!#*4+$%(!0'!'&45$.!0'%01('%(9!U'!=4$%,0%$.!$==.0%$,0&'#!$!10(.(%,40%!5$,(;40$.! 0#! $==.0(1! &'! $! %&'1*%,&4! #*4+$%(! $'1! ,-(! '&45$.0J(1!05=(1$'%(! !0#!/02('!78!a)9!W!@S*..0,83!OeMBL!A0$#3!BCCCD>

! &' " (# # # #" � � � �# $! " @WD

6-(4(!,!0#!,-(!10(.(%,40%!.$8(4!,-0%G'(##!&+!5$,(40$.9

! :-(!'&45$.0J(1!05=(1$'%(!5$8!7(!*#(1!,&!%$.%*.$,(!,-(!H<#a)9!e9

)%

%

#&

$@eD

6-(4(!H!0#!$!%&5=.(<!'*57(4!7(,6(('!C!$'1!O9

;7(.#!@1`D3!a)9!OC9

'()* (+ )*" %"#! " @OCD

! :-*#3! E"F! ,(%-'&.&/8! 0'%.*1(#! ,-(! %&570'$,0&'! &+!5$,(40$.#! 0'! #*%-!6$8! ,-$,! H ! 7(!$#! #5$..! $#!=&##07.(! 0'!$!601(! +4()*('%8! 4$'/(9! :-0#! %&'10,0&'! 0#! *#*$..8! $,,('1(1!#$,0#+$%,&40.8!78!$##&%0$,0'/!=&.85(40%!#*7#,4$,(#!.&$1(1!60,-!50%4&6$2(! $7#&47(4! %(',(4#3! $#!50%4&6$2(! +(440,(#! $'1?&4!%&'1*%,0'/! =&.85(4#! $'1!?!&4! %$47&'!?!04&'! =$4,0%.(#9! k-('!E"F! $,('*$,(#! #05*.,$'(&*#.8! ,-(! 5$/'(,0%! $'1! (.(%,40%!

A0$#3!]9S9!!"#$%&

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!DEB!E"8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!DF

Page 24: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&L!BCCXL!A0$#!!"#$%&3!BCCKL!F$4,0'#!!"#$%&3!BCCiD9

,-(!hEf!$4%-!,(%-'0)*(!@T50,-!!"#$%&3!OeeXL!A0$#3!BCCCD9!:-(!

%&44(.$,(1!60,-!,-(!=(4%(',$/(!&+!$7#&47(1!('(4/83!$#!#-&6'!0'!:$7.(!O!@f((3!OeeOL!A0$#3!BCCCD9

('(4/8!@f((3!OeeOD9

"7#&47(1!('(4/83!lC C;Y KC;OC eC;OK ei9e;BC ee;YC ee9e;XC ee9ee

! ".,-&*/-!=(450,,020,8!$'1!=(45($70.0,8!5($#*4(5(',#!$4(! *#(+*.! ,&! #*==&4,! ,-(! E"F! =4&%(##0'/3! $#! #-&6'!=4(20&*#.8! 0'! a)9! i! ,&! W3! ,-(! =4(#(',! #,*18! 0#! 7$#(1! &'!

:-0#!,8=(!&+!5($#*4(5(',#!-$#!$!104(%,!%&44(.$,0&'!60,-!,-(!=(450,,020,83!=(45($70.0,8!$'1!05=(1$'%(!=$4$5(,(4#!&+!,-(!#,*10(1!5$,(40$.3!$#!1(=0%,(1!=4(20&*#.8! @a)9!i! ,&!OCD9! U'!

*#0'/! ,-(!hEf!$4%-! ,(%-'0)*(3! 0'! ,-(!m;7$'1! +4()*('%8!4$'/(3!&+!10++(4(',! +&45*.$,0&'#!&+!-87401!E"F!7$#(1!&'!h0j'! +(440,(! $'1! %$47&'! 7.$%G! @S`D! .&$1(1! 0'!PV! 4(#0'9!:-*#3!,-(!5$0'!&7H(%,02(!&+!,-0#!#,*18!6$#!,&!(2$.*$,(!,-(!50<,*4(!&+!10(.(%,40%!@S`D!$'1!5$/'(,0%!@h0j'!+(440,(D!&'!,-(!E"F!=(4+&45$'%(9

! I&45*.$,0&'#!&+! $! %&55(4%0$.! =&.8(#,(4!PV! 4(#0'! @,6&!%&5=&'(',#>! 4(#0'!$'1!%$,$.8#,3!7&,-!%&.&4.(##3!$,!O!>!O! 4$,(D!

1(=0%,(1!0'!:$7.(!B9

:$7.(!B9! :-(!%&$,0'/!+&45*.$,0&'#!=4(=$4(19

I&45*.$,0&'P&.8*4(,-$'(!5$,40<!@6,9lD

S$47&'!7.$%G!S`!@6,9lD

I(440,(!@6,9lD

O ! OCC C CB ! ee O CY ! WX O OKX ! ie O YCK ! KX O XKi ! Xe O KCM ! KC C KC

! F(%-$'0%$.! #,0440'/! $,! KCC! 4=5! 6(4(! *#(19! :-(! *#(1!

#0J(! &+! OB! '5! $'1! 7*.G! 1('#0,8! &+! C9Bi! /?%5Y3! #*==.0(1!78!S$7&,!S&5=$'83! *#(1! $#! 4(%(02(1! @S$7&,3! BCCXD9!:-(!

U'1*#,48!&+!I(440,(#3!60,-!'&50'$.!+&45*.$!h0O;<j'<g9I(BgY3!60,-!<!n!C9KC3!1('#0,8!&+!K9CO!/?%5Y!$'1!=$4,0%.(!$2(4$/(!#0J(!&+!X9X! 53!1(,(450'(1!78!*#0'/!$!T-$4=.(#!F0%4&5(4&/4$=-!()*0=5(',9!"+,(4!5(%-$'0%$.!#,0440'/!-&5&/('0J$,0&'3! ,-(!

@YC!o!YC!%5D3!=&#0,0&'(1! 0'! ,-(!-&40J&',$.3!*#0'/!%&'2(';,0&'$.!=$0',0'/!,(%-'0)*(#9!:-(!%&5=.(,(!=&.85(40J$,0&'!&+!%&$,0'/#!6$#!&7,$0'(1!$,!iCpS3!+&4!XC!50'*,(#9!:-(!$2(4$/(!,-0%G'(##!&+!%&$,0'/#!6$#!O9C!q!C9O!559

! :-(!%48#,$..&/4$=-0%! #,4*%,*4(!&+! ,-(!h0j'! +(440,(!6$#!1(,(450'(1!78!m;4$8!10++4$%,0&'!$'$.8#(#3!*#0'/!$!P-0.0=#!10++4$%,&5(,(4!5&1(.!Pk!OWYC3!&=(4$,(1!$,!XC!Gr!,('#0&'!$'1!BC!5"!%*44(',9!:-(!5$/'(,0%!#*#%(=,070.0,8!(2&.*,0&'!&+! ,-(!h0j'!+(440,(!6$#!%$440(1!&*,!*#0'/!,-(45$.;5$/'(,0%!

+4()*('%8!&+!YYY!sJ3!0'!$4/&'!$,5&#=-(4(9

;5(',!#8#,(5!6$#!5$1(!@A0$#3!BCCCL!E(J('1(!!"#$%&3!BCCYD9!:-0#!#8#,(5!*#(#!,6&!%$.074$,(1!-&4'!,8=(!$',(''$#!0'!,-(!50%4&6$2(!4$'/(9!g'(!$',(''$!0#!%&''(%,(1!,&!$!50%4&6$2(!,4$'#50,,(4!$'1!,-(!&,-(4!&'(!,&!$!50%4&6$2(!4(%(02(49!:-(!50%4&6$2(!('(4/8!

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!DEB!E"8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !D#

Page 25: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

.$*'%-(1!+4&5!,-(!,4$'#50,,(4!-&4'!,4$2(.#!$'1!05=0'/(#!,-(!

#*4+$%(!,4$2(.#!$'1!0#!%&..(%,(1!78!,-(!4(%(02(4!-&4'9!:-(!+$4!

P84$501$.!$7#&47(4!0#!=.$%(1!$4&*'1!,-(!hEf!$4%-!,&!(.050'$,(!*'1(#04$7.(!#=*40&*#!50%4&6$2(!('(4/8!,-$,!,4$2(.#!$4&*'1!,-(!#$5=.(9!F($#*4(5(',#!6(4(!%$440(1!&*,!$,!4&&5!,(5=(4$,*4(!

;!"#$%&3!OeeYL!

#,$'1$410J(1! *#0'/! 4(+(4('%(;$7#&470'/!5$,(40$.#! =*4%-$#(1!+4&5!a5(4#&'!t!S*550'/!U'%9!:-(#(!$7#&47(4#!%&'#0#,!&+!B!,&!BC!55;,-0%G'(##!PV!+&$5!=.$,(#3!.&$1(1!60,-!%$47&'!=$4,0%.(#!@]$*5$'!$7#&47(4#D9!:-(#(!50%4&6$2(!$7#&47(4#!$4(!*#*$..8!*#(1!,&!4(%&2(4!,-(!0',(40&4!&+!$'(%-&0%!%-$57(4#9!:-(!(44&4#!&+!

&'(! +*4'0#-(1! 78! a5(4#&'!t! S*550'/! U'%9! #*==.0(49! :-(!1(,(450'(1!(44&4#!#,$8!7(.&6!Ol!0'!,-(!+4()*('%8!4$'/(!&+!W!,&!OB!NsJ!@A0$#3!BCCCL!E(J('1(!!"#$%&3!BCCYD9

! I0/*4(!O!#-&6#!,-(!m;4$8!=$,,(4'#!&+!,-(!h0j'!+(440,(!*#(1!0'!,-(!=4(#(',!#,*189!:$7.(!Y!%&5=$4(#!,-(!=$,,(4'!&7,$0'(1!+&4!,-(!h0j'!+(440,(!60,-!,-&#(!&+!j'I(BgX!$'1!h0I(BgX!+(440,(#!+4&5!,-(!.0,(4$,*4(!@]SPAT3!BCCWD9! S&5=$40'/! ,-(!m;4$8! =$,,(4'#! &+! j'I(BgX! $'1!h0I(BgX

+(440,(#3!+4&5!.0,(4$,*4(3!0,!0#!=&##07.(!,&!&7#(42(!,-$,!,-(!1@uD!

$'1!-G.!2$.*(#!$4(!2(48!%.&#(3!#-&60'/!,-$,!,-(#(!+(440,(#!%$'!=4(#(',!10++(4(',!=-$#(#!60,-!#050.$4!%48#,$..&/4$=-0%!=$4$5;(,(4#9!S&44(.$,0'/! ,-(#(!2$.*(#!60,-! ,-&#(!&7,$0'(1!+4&5!,-(!,(#,(1!h0j'!+(440,(3!0,!0#!=&##07.(!,&!&7#(42(!,-$,!,-0#!#$5=.(!-$#!

#,4&'/(#,!.0'(#!0'!,-(!=$,,(4'!&+!,-(!$'$.8J(1!#$5=.(!$4(!1*(!,&!,-(!h0j'I(BgX9!I4&5!,-(#(!$'$.8#(#3!0,!%$'!7(!%&'%.*1(1!,-$,!,-(!+(440,(!*#(1!0'!,-0#!#,*18!=4(#(',#!,-(!/('(4$.!+&45*.$!FI(BgX3!6-(4(!F!%$'!7(!#*7#,0,*,(1!+&4!h03!j'!&4!7&,-!(.(5(',#9! "%%&410'/!,&!,-(!.0,(4$,*4(!@r(46(8!$'1!s(.5$''3!OeXML!S*..0,83!OeMBL!F$4%(.!A(GG(43!OeeCL!r$.('J*(.$3!OeeXL!A0$#3!BCCCD3!,-(!%-(50%$.!%&5=&#0,0&'!&+!,-(!#,*10(1!h0j'!+(440,(!0'10%$,(#! ,-$,! ,-0#!&'(!7(.&'/#! ,&! ,-(!#=0'(.!%.$##3!60,-! ,-(!=&##070.0,8!&+!$==.0%$,0&'!$#!50%4&6$2(!$7#&470'/!%(',(4!0'!E"F!=4&%(##0'/!@S-&!!"#$%&3!OeeiL!A0$#3!BCCCD9

I0/*4(!O9!m;4$8!=$,,(4'!&+!h0j'!+(440,(!#,*10(19

! I0/*4(! B! #-&6#! ,-(! 5$/'(,0%! #*#%(=,070.0,8! (2&.*,0&'!%*42(#!&+!,-(!#,*10(1!h0j'!+(440,(9!U,!0#!&7#(42(1!,-$,!,-(!h0j'!

A0$#3!]9S9!!"#$%&

:$7.(!Y9!S&5=$40#&'!&+!,-(!=$,,(4'#!&+!h0j'3!j'!$'1!h0!+(440,(#9

I(440,( j'I(BgXc h0I(BgXc h0j'!+(440,(!@,-0#!#,*18D

h$5( U4&'!J0'%!&<01(!@I4$'G.0'0,(D U4&'!@UUUD!'0%G(.!&<01(!@:4(2&40,(D

h0j'!+(440,(!@%&55(4%0$.!'$5(D

T8#,(5 S*70% S*70% S*70%U'1(<!'*57(4! BB!_!OCOB OC!_!YBK ! _:8=( T=0'(.! T=0'(.! T=0'(.!

@U?U&D!!@1@[email protected]

@OCCD!!@B9KXD!!@YOOD@YKD!!@O9XeD!!@XXCD@YKD!!@B9eWD!!@BBCD@MD!!@X9WMD!!@OOOD

@OCCD!!@B9KOD!!@YOOD@XCD!!@O9XWD!!@XXCD@YCD!!@B9eKD!!@BBCD@BCD!!@X9WBD!!@OOOD

@OCCD!!@_D!!@YOOD@YiD!!@_D!!@BBCD@YBD!!@_D!!@XXCD@WD!!@_D!!@OOOD

P4(=$4$,0&'!%&'10,0&'# :(5=(4$,*4(>!MCC!;!WCCvS :(5=(4$,*4(>!OXCCvS3!&<01$',!$,5&#=-(4(

:(5=(4$,*4(>!OCBCvS3!&<01$',!$,5&#=-(4(

cI4&5!@]SPAT3!BCCWD9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!DEB!E"8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!E%

Page 26: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

+(440,(!1&(#!'&,!#-&6!5$/'(,0%!,4$'#0,0&'#9!:-('3!,-(!S*40(!

#$5=.(!0#!%&'#,0,*,(1!&+!$!50<,*4(!&+!10++(4(',!=-$#(#9

I0/*4(!B9!F$/'(,0%!#*#%(=,070.0,8!(2&.*,0&'!%*42(#!&+!h0j'!+(440,(!#,*10(19

@+&45*.$,0&'!O3!:$7.(!BD!$==.0(1!&'!".!=.$,(!$'1!$.#&!,-(!".!=.$,(!%*42(!*#(1!$#!4(+(4('%(9!:-(#(!%*42(#!$4(!'($4.8!%&2(4;0'/!&'(!$'&,-(43!#-&60'/!,-$,!,-(!=*4(!PV!5$,40<!$==.0(1!&'!,-(!".!=.$,(!1&(#!'&,!%&',407*,(!,&!4(1*%(!,-(!0'%01(',!#0/'$.3!0'!,-(!W!,&!OB!NsJ!4$'/(9!:-0#!7(-$20&4!/*$4$',((#!,-$,!,-(!PV!4(#0'!*#(1!0'!%&$,0'/!+&45*.$,0&'#!1&(#!'&,!0',(4+(4(!0'!

&7,$0'(13!0'!,-(!0',(42$.!&+!W!,&!OB!NsJ3!60,-!XCC!=&0',#9

;

#-&6#! ,-$,! ,-(! PV?S`! +&45*.$,0&'3! 0'! =4&=&4,0&'! &+!ee?O!@6,9lD3! 4(#=(%,02(.83!1&(#!'&,!%&',407*,(! ,&!$,,('*$,(!,-(!0'%01(',!(.(%,4&5$/'(,0%!6$2(9!I0/*4(!X73!4(=4(#(',$,02(!&+! ,-(! PV!?!S`!?!h0j'! +(440,(! @WX!?!O!?!OK3! 6,9lD! +&45*.$,0&'3!#-&6#!$!#.0/-,!10#=.$%(5(',!7(,6(('!,-(!4(+(4('%(!%*42(!$'1!

,-$,!&'(!&7,$0'(1!+&4!,-0#!+&45*.$,0&'9!I0/*4(!X%!,&!I0/9!X(!#-&6!,-$,!,-(!+(440,(!$5&*',!0'%4($#(!+4&5!YC!,&!KCl!@6,9lD!0'!,-(!PV!+&45*.$,0&'!=4&5&,(#!,-(!%*42(#!1(7&'10'/!60,-!,-(!%&'#()*(',!0'%4($#(!&+!,-(!$,,('*$,0&'!2$.*(#3!+4&5!O!,&!X!1`3! 0'! ,-(!+4()*('%8!4$'/(!&+!W! ,&OB!NsJ3!4(#=(%,02(.89!I0/*4(!X1!#-&6#!-0/-(4!$,,('*$,0&'!2$.*(#!+&4!+4()*('%0(#!$7&2(!e!NsJ9!I0/*4(!X(! 0#! ,8=0%$.!+&4!E"F!'$5(1!74&$1;7$'1! ,8=(! @"+#$4! !"# $%&3! OeWiL! A0$#3! BCCCD9! I0/*4(! X+!@+&45*.$,0&'!M!7$#(1!&'!PV?+(440,(3!KC?KC!6,9lD!#-&6#!,-(!$,,('*$,0&'!2$.*(#!1(%4($#0'/!@ !B!1`D3!6-('!%&5=$4(1!,&!,-&#(!1(,(450'(1!+&4!+&45*.$,0&'!i3!6-0%-!%&',$0'#!#05*.,$;'(&*#.8!S`!$'1!+(440,(9! S&44(.$,0'/! ,-(! 4(#*.,#3! 0,! 0#! =&##07.(! ,&! %&'%.*1(! ,-$,!,-(! +&45*.$,0&'! %&',$0'0'/! &'.8! S`! =$4,0%.(#! 1&(#! '&,!%&',407*,(! ,&!$,,('*$,(! ,-(!0'%01(',!4$10$,0&'!0'! ,-(!W! ,&!OB!NsJ! 4$'/(9!T050.$4! 7(-$20&4! 0#! &7#(42(1! +&4! +&45*.$,0&'!M3!%&',$0'0'/!&'.8!,-(!#,*10(1!h0j'!+(440,(9!S&5=$40'/!,-(!

!"#$%&3!BCCOL!T&,&;g20(1&!!"#$%&,-(!=4&%(##(1!E"F!#$5=.(#!=4(#(',!.&6!=(4+&45$'%(!@*=!,&!X!1`D9!:-0#!7(-$20&4!0#!$,,407*,(1!=4&7$7.8!,&!,-(!=4(#('%(!&+!10++(4(',!=-$#(#!0'!,-(!h0j'!+(440,(3!$#!1(,(450'(1!78!m;4$8!10++4$%,0&'!$'1!5$/'(,0%!#*#%(=,070.0,8!(2&.*,0&'!$'$.8#(#!$'13!$.#&3!,&!,-(!+4()*('%8!4$'/(!@W!,&!OB!NsJD!$1&=,(1!0'!

$110,02(#!%&'%(',4$,0&'!*#(19! s0/-(4!$,,('*$,0&'!2$.*(#!$4(!&7,$0'(1!6-('!7&,-!$110;,02(#!@+(440,(!$'1!S`D!$4(!.&$1(1!#05*.,$'(&*#.8!60,-0'!,-(!PV!5$,40<9!:-0#!7(-$20&4!0#!$,,407*,(1!,&!,-(!/4($,!10++(4('%(!7(,6(('!,-(!1('#0,8!2$.*(#!&+!7&,-!$110,02(#!@C9OX!$'1!K9CO!/!?!%5Y!+&4!S`!$'1!h0j'!+(440,(3!4(#=(%,02(.8D9!:-0#!1('#0,8!10++(4('%(! =4&5&,(#! $! -(,(4&/('(&*#! 10#,407*,0&'! &+! ,-(!

S&'#01(40'/!,-$,!,-(!".!=.$,(!6$#!G(=,!-&40J&',$.!1*40'/!,-(!$==.0%$,0&'!&+!,-(!+&45*.$,0&'#3!,-(!-($20(4!=$4,0%.(#!@h0j'!+(440,(D! 5&2(1! ,&6$41#! ,-(!".! =.$,(9! S&'#()*(',.83! ,-(!&*,(4!#*4+$%(!&+!,-(!%&$,0'/!5$G(#!40%-(4!0'!.0/-,(4!=$4,0%.(#!@S`D9!:-0#! +($,*4(!&7#(42(1! 0'!-87401!%&$,0'/! 0'1*%(1!$!7(,,(4!$1H*#,5(',!&+!,-(!05=(1$'%(!&+!,-(!5$,(40$.!60,-!,-(!$049!U'!,-0#!%&'10,0&'3!,-(!6$2(!=4&=$/$,0&'!0',&!,-(!5$,(;

5(',0&'(1!=4(20&*#.8!0'!a)9!M!$'1!W!@S*..0,83!OeMBL!A0$#3!BCCCD9! I4&5!,-0#!0'0,0$.!%&'10,0&'3!10++(4(',!5(%-$'0%#!&+!6$2(!('(4/8! .&##! %$'! &%%*49!"#! %0,(1! =4(20&*#.83! E"F!5$G(#!

5$/'(,0%! 04&'! %&5=&*'1#! 6-0%-! $4(! $7.(! ,&! ,4$'#+&45!

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!DEB!E"8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !E&

Page 27: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

,-(! (.(%,4&5$/'(,0%! 4$10$,0&'! 0'! -($,9!g-50%! .&##! %$'! 7(!=4&5&,(1!78!%$47&'!=$4,0%.(#!$'1! ,-(! +(440,(!=$4,0%.(#!%$'!+$2&4!#=0'! 0'2(4#0&'3!$'1!0,! 0#!G'&6'!,-$,!7&,-!=-('&5('$!.($1! ,&! ,-(!6$2(!('(4/8!$,,('*$,0&'9!:-(!(.(%,4&5$/'(,0%!6$2(!$,,('*$,0&'!%$'!$.#&!7(!05=4&2(1!78!$1H*#,0'/!,-(!(.(%;,40%!,-0%G'(##!&+!,-(!E"F!6-0%-!+$2&4#!,-(!6$2(!$,,('*$,0&'!

!"# $%&3! OeeYL!E(J('1(!!"#$%&3!BCCOL!E(J('1(!!"#$%&3!BCCBD9

! :-0#! #,*18! #-&6(1! ,-$,! ,-(! $1()*$,(! %&570'$,0&'! &+!S`!$'1!h0j'! +(440,(! 0'!PV!+&45*.$,0&'#!$..&6(1!&7,$0'0'/!E"F!60,-!7(,,(4!=(4+&45$'%(!%&5=$4(1! ,&! ,-&#(!=4(=$4(1!60,-!S`!&4!h0j'!+(440,(!#(=$4$,(.89!:-(!7(,,(4!=(4+&45$'%(!&+! ,-(!-87401!E"F!0#!$,,407*,(1! ,&!$'!$1()*$,(!$1H*#,5(',!&+! ,-(! 05=(1$'%(!&+! ,-(!5$,(40$.!60,-! ,-(!$043!6-0%-!+$2&4#!

A0$#3!]9S9!!"#$%&

@$D!! ! ! @7D!

@%D!! ! ! @1D!

@(D!! ! ! @+D!

$#!+&..&6!S`?h0j'!+(440,(!0'!=(4%(',$/(!0'!5$##3!4(#=(%,02(.8>!@$D!O?C3!@7D!@O?OKD3!@%D!O?YC3!@1D!@O?XKD3!@(D!O?KC!$'1!@+D!C?KC9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!DEB!E"8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!E!

Page 28: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

,-(!E"F;(.(%,4&5$/'(,0%!6$2(! 0',(4$%,0&'9!:-0#!&=,050J(1!%&'10,0&'!0#!$!%&'#()*('%(!&+!,-(!-(,(4&/('(&*#!10#,407*,0&'!&+!,-(!=$4,0%.(#!@60,-!10++(4(',!1('#0,8!2$.*(#D!0'!,-(!%&$,0'/!.$8(49!",,('*$,0&'!2$.*(#!&+!wX!1`!+&4!,-(!PV!4(#0'?S`?h0j'!+(440,(!+&45*.$,0&'#!@Xe?O?KC!6,9l3!4(#=(%,02(.8D!6(4(!&7,$0'(19

! :-(! $*,-&4#! ,-$'G! T\&! P$*.&! E(#($4%-! I&*'1$,0&'!@I"PaTPD! _! =4&H(%,!hv9! eM?OXCKK;M3!h$,0&'$.! S&*'#(.! &+!

hv9! YCKXMW?BCCe;K3! ,-(!

+&4!,-(!2$.*$7.(!10#%*##0&'#!&'!,-(!#*7H(%,9

"+#$43!F9!h9!!"#$%&3!OeWi3!Q:-(!5($#*4(5(',!&+!,-(!=4&=(4;,0(#!&+!5$,(40$.#R9!P4&%((10'/#!&+!,-(!Uaaa3!r&.9!MX3!hv9!O3!==9!OWY;Oee9

`$.$'0#3!S9!"93!OeeM3!Q"12$'%(1!a'/0'((40'/!a.(,4&5$/'(,;0%#R9!h(6!x&4G>!]&-'!k0.(8!T&'#9

S$7&,!S&93!VT"3!BCCX3!QA$,$!T-((,>!r*.%$'!mSMBR9!-,,=>??6669%$7&,;%&4=9%&5?6%5?1&6'.&$1?(';*#?#7?rVfS"hymSMB;a'/.0#-9=1+3!0'!CM?OY?BCOB9

S-&3!T9`9!!"#$%&3!Oeei3!QE(.$,0&'#-0=!7(,6('!5$/'(,0%#!=4&=;(4,0(#! $'1!50%4&6$2(;$7#&470'/! %-$4$%,(40#,0%#! &+!h0j'S&!+(440,(#!%&5=&#0,(#R9!]&*4'$.!&+!F$,(40$.#!T%0('%(3!r&.9!YO3!==9!XMOe;XMBB9

S*..0,83!`9!A93!OeMB3!QU',4&1*%,0&'!,&!F$/'(,0%!F$,(40$.#R9!"110#&';k(#.(8!P*7.0#-0'/!S&5=$'83!UhS3!V'0,(1!T,$,(!&+!"5(40%$9

A0$#3!]9!S93!BCCC3!Qg7,('b\&!1(!4(2(#,05(',&#!$7#&42(1&4(#!1(!4$10$b\&!(.(,4&5$/'^,0%$!@B;BC!NsJD!$=.0%$1&#!'&!#(,&4!$(4&'[*,0%&R3!P-A!:-(#0#3!U'#,0,*,&!:(%'&.Z/0%&!1(!"(4&'[*;,0%$3!T\&!]&#^!1&#!S$5=&#3!TP3!`4$J0.9

A0$#3!]9!S9!!"#$%&:0',$#!P&.0*4(,z'0%$#!"10,$1$#!%&5!I(440,$#!1(!h0j'!(!F'j'R9!E(20#,$!I{#0%$!"=.0%$1$!(!U'#,4*5(',$b\&3!r&.9!OW3!hv9!O3!==9!BX;YY9

I$(J3!E9!!"#$%&3!BCCK3!QF0%4&6$2(!"7#&470'/!S&$,0'/#!`$#(1!&'!$!̀ .('1!&+!h0,40.(!E*77(43!aPAF!E*77(4!$'1!P&.8$'0.0'(R9!P&.85(4!`*..(,0'3!r&.9!KK3!hv9!O3!==9!Bee;YCM9

I&./*(4$#3!f9!S9!!"#$%&3!BCCM3!QA0(.(%,40%!50%4&6$2(!$7#&470'/!

60,-!=&.8$'0.0'(R9!F$,(40$.#!E(#($4%-3!r&.9!OC3!==9!eK;ee9

N$5$3!"9!F9!$'1!E(J('1(3!F9!S93!BCOC3!QS&5=.(<!=(45(;$70.0,8!$'1!=(450,,020,8!2$40$,0&'!&+!%$47&'8.!04&'!4*77(4!0'!,-(!+4()*('%8!4$'/(!&+!B!,&!OW!NsJR9!]&*4'$.!&+!"(4&#=$%(!:(%-'&.&/8!$'1!F$'$/(5(',3!r&.9!B3!hp!O3!==9!Ke;iB9

N$5$3!"9F9!!"#$%&3!BCOO3!QA(=('1('%(!&+!50%4&6$2(!$7#&4=;,0&'!=4&=(4,0(#!&'!+(440,(!2&.*5(!+4$%,0&'! 0'!F'j'!+(440,(?4*77(4!50%4&6$2(!$7#&470'/!5$,(40$.#R9!]&*4'$.!&+!F$/'(;,0#5!$'1!F$/'(,0%!F$,(40$.#3!r&.9!YBY3!==9!BMWB;BMWK9

]SPAT3!BCCW3!U',(4'$,0&'$.!S(',4(!A0++4$%,0&'!A$,(3!PSPA;IkUh! 29! O9YC3! S$41#! +&4! h0I(BgX3! h0%G(.! U4&'! g<01(3!j'I(BgX3!j0'%!U4&'!g<01(!$'1!h0j'I(BgX3!h0%G(.!j0'%!U4&'!g<01(3!"5(40%$'!S(4$50%!T&%0(,83!VT"9

!"#$%&3!OeeY3!QE$1$4!S4&##!T(%,0&'R9!B|!a10,0&'3!"4,(%-!s&*#(3!U'%93!h&46&&13!VT"9

f((3!T9!F93!OeeO3!QU',(4'$,0&'$.!a'%8%.&=(10$.!&+!S&5=&#;0,(#R9!h(6!x&4G>!rsS!P*7.0#-(4#3!r&.9!i3!==9!XCX;XYC9

F$4%(.! A(GG(4! U'%93! OeeC3! Qs$'17&&G! &+! S(4$50%#! $'1!S&5=&#0,(#R3!h0%-&.$#!P9!S-(4(50#0'&++3!r&.9!O3!h(6!x&4G9

F$4,0'#3! S9! E9! !"# $%&3! BCCi3! QE($%,02(! =4&%(##0'/! $'1!(2$.*$,0&'! &+! 7*,$10('(;#,84('(! %&=&.85(4?=&.8$'0.0'(!%&'1*%,02(!7.('1#R9! ]&*4'$.!&+!"==.0(1!P&.85(4!T%0('%(3!r&.9!OCC3!==9!iWO;iWK9

P0',&3!T9!T9!$'1!E(J('1(3!F9!S93!BCOB3!Qa#,*1&!1$!$=.0%$b\&!1$!=&.0@&;5(,&<0$'0.0'$D!(!1(!#(*#!%&5=Z#0,&#!%&5!'(/4&!1(!+*5&! '&! =4&%(##$5(',&! 1(! $7#&42(1&4(#! 1(!50%4&;&'1$#R9!P&.{5(4&#3!S0}'%0$!(!:(%'&.&/0$9!r&.9!mmUU3!hv9!B3!==9!)/#:9!**9

E(J('1(3!F9S9!!"#$%&3!BCCO3!QF0%4&6$2(!=4&=(4,0(#!&+!aPAF?P"'0;A`T"!7.('1#R9!T8',-(,0%!F(,$.#3!r&.9!OOe3!==9!XYK;XYi9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!DEB!E"8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !EA

Page 29: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

E(J('1(3!F9S9!!"#$%&3!BCCB3!QE$1$4!%4&##!#(%,0&'!5($#*4(5(',#!@W;OB!NsJD!&+!5$/'(,0%!$'1!10(.(%,40%!50%4&6$2(!$7#&470'/!,-0'! #-((,#R9! E(20#,$! 1(! I{#0%$!"=.0%$1$! (! U'#,4*5(',$b\&3!r&.9!O3!hv9!O3!==9!O;OC9

E(J('1(3!F9!S93!!"#$%&3!BCCX3!QF0%4&6$2(!$7#&4=,0&'!=4&=(4;,0(#!&+!$!%&'1*%,02(!,-(45&=.$#,0%!7.('1!7$#(1!&'!=&.8$'0.0'(R9!P&.85(4!`*..(,0'3!r&.9!KO3!==9!YBO;YBi9

E(J('1(3!F9!S93!!"#$%&5$,(40$0#!$7#&42(1&4(#!1(!4$10$b\&!(.(,4&5$/'^,0%$!*#$'1&!$#!,^%'0%$#!EST!(!hEfR9!E(20#,$!I{#0%$!"=.0%$1$!(!U'#,4*5(',$;b\&3!r&.9!Oi3!hv9!O3!==9!YC;Yi9

T50,-3!I9S9!!"#$%&3!OeeX3!QF(,-&1&.&/8!+&4!$%%*4$,(!+4((;#=$%(!%-$4$%,(40J$,0&'!&+!4$1$4!$7#&470'/!5$,(40$.#R9!Uaa!P4&%9!T%9!F($#9!:(%-'&.93!r&.9!X3!hv!i3!==9!KYW;KXi9

T&,&;g20(1&3!F9"9!!"#$%&3!BCCi3!Q"',0(#,$,0%!%&$,0'/!$'1!(.(%;,4&5$/'(,0%!#-0(.10'/!=4&=(4,0(#!&+!$!-87401!5$,(40$.!7$#(1!&'!=&.8$'0.0'(?&4/$'&%.$8!'$'&%&5=&#0,(!$'1!aPAF!4*77(4R9!T8',-(,0%!F(,$.#3!r&.9!OKi3!==9!OBXe;OBKK9

r$.('J*(.$3!E93!OeeX3!QF$/'(,0%!S(4$50%#!@#(40(#!S-(50#,48!&+!#&.01!5$,(40$.#DR3!V'02(4#0,8!P4(##3!h(6!x&4G9

r(46(83!a9!]9!k9!$'1!s(.5$''3!a9!f93!OeXM3!QP-8#0%$.!=4&=(4;,0(#!$'1!%$,0&'!$44$/(5(',(!&+!&<01(#!60,-!#=0'(.!(#,4*%,*4(#9!U9! %$,0&'!$44$'/(5(',! 0'! #=0'(.#R9! ]9!S-(59!P-8#93!r&.9!OK3!hv9!X3!==9!OMX;OWM9

A0$#3!]9S9!!"#$%&

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!DEB!E"8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!E"

Page 30: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&!'()!**!+(,#*-./!(!01/+#02!3(45-0-0.(1-66-$-&#+($#*!+-#&63()!**!+(-06/&#*-503(6$55*7(6/+,#2!(#01(&58!+(8!-.7*9(:58!;!+<(*7!+!(#+!(#&65(0!.#*-;!(#6%!2*6<(,5+(!"#$%&!'(05(%566-)-&-*=(*5(1-6#66!$)&!(*7!(45-0*63(%!!&-0.(6*+!66(675/&1()!($-0-$->!1(#01(*7!(%+!%#+#*-50(5,(*7!(6/+,#2!6(,5+()501-0.($/6*()!(150!(2#+!?

6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0()501!1(45-0*6(#01($#0=(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(

( @!.#+1-0.(*7-6(62!0#+-5<($#0=(+!6!#+27!+6(7#;!(2501/2*!1(6*/1-!6(#)5/*()501!1(45-0*6<(*+=-0.(*5(%+!1-2*(*7!-+($!27#0-?

!"%!+-$!0*#&(*!6*6(5+(7=)+-1(#%%+5#27!6<(25$)-0-0.(*7!5+!*-?

45-0*6(8!+!( 2#++-!1(5/*( )=(A5&B!+6!0( -0( CDEF( GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(A5&B!+6!0($51!&!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(#6(67!#+(6%+-0.(

?/+#&(!,,!2*6(GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(J7!(+!6/&*6(5)*#-0!1()=(*7!(+!6!#+27!+(6758!1(*7#*(*7!(&5#1(*+#06,!+(#*(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6(05*(/0-,5+$9(K5&#01(#01(@!-660!+( GCDLLI( -$%+5;!1(A5&B?!+6!0M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.( *7!(#17!+!0*( &-B!()!#$6(#01(*7!(#17!6-;!(&-B!(6%+-0.6(-0(*!06-50(#01(67!#+(&5#1-0.9(J7#*($51!&(25/&1(#0#&=>!(*7!(1-6*+-)/*-50(5,(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(&5#1?-0.(-01/2!1()=(*7!(6!2501#+=($5$!0*<(87-27(522/+6(-0(6-0.&!(&#%(45-0*69(:#+*?N$-*7(GCDOP3(CDOEI<()#6!1(50(*7!(&#6*($51!&6<(

$#*!+-#&69(:#+*?N$-*7(6-$/&#*!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(+!6%506!<(/6-0.(#0(!&#6*-2?%&#6*-2($#*!+-#&($51!&9(Q*( -6( -$%5+*#0*(*5($!0*-50(

*7!($#-0(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(-0(*7!(6*+/2*/+#&(%!+,5+$#02!(5,(*7!(45-0*( *559(:58!;!+<(65$!(5,(*756!($51!&6(#66/$!1(*7#*(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(8!+!(-65*+5%-2(5+(6=$$!*+-2(G50&=(8-*7(*!06-50(

?-0.(#%%#+!0*(%+5%!+*-!6(,5+(*7!(&#$-0#*!69(Q0(CDOR<(S/2!5.&/(#01(T%1-B!(-$%+5;!1(:#+*?N$-*7M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(!,,!2*6( -0(*7!(#17!+!0*9(J7!=(6758!1(*7#*(

?-*=(-0(67!#+(&5#1-0.<( *7!(05+$#&(6*+#-06(2#0(#,,!2*( *7!(6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!9(J75$6!0(GCDDUI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(-0(*7!(5;!+&#%(&!0.*7(+!1/2!6(*7!(6*+!66(&!;!&(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+9(J7!(+!6!#+27!+(2502&/1!1(*7#*(*7!(#%%&-2#*-50(5,(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(8-*7(&58!+(!&#6*-2(67!#+(#01(*!06-&!($51/&-(

-6()!**!+(*5(/6!(-1!0*-2#&(5+(0!#+&=(-1!0*-2#&(#17!+!0*6(-0()501?!1(45-0*6<(-9!9<(#17!+!0*6(8-*7(6-$-&#+(6*-,,0!669(V+56*-.(!"#$%9(GCDDFI(%+5%56!1(#0(#%%+5#27(/6-0.(7-.7?5+1!+(*7!5+=9(Q0(*7!-+(#0#&=6-6<(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6($51!&!1(#6(#0(!&#6*-2(250*-0//$($!1-#(GUW(#01(EWI9(N5<(*7!(#17!6-;!(25/&1(*+#06,!+(05+$#&(

6*+!66!6<(-0?%&#0!(#01(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(6*+!66!69(J7!6!(+!6/&*6(6758!1(*7#*(*7!+!(8#6(#(.+!#*(;#+-#*-50(5,(*7!(05+$#&(6*+!66(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(2&56!(*5(*7!(!1.!69

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

*7!(#1;#0*#.!6(5,(/6-0.(#(6=$$!*+-2(25$%56-*!(%#*27(-0(5+1!+(*5(+!%#-+(*7!(1#$#.!(%#+*63(#&65<(*7#*(15/)&!(%#*27(7#1(&58!+(6*+!66(87!0(25$%#+!1(8-*7(6-0.&!(%#*27(+!%#-+9(@!.#+1-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(%#+#$!*!+6<(N!50.(!"#$%9(GUPPFI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(5,()501-0.(%+!66/+!(1/+-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(&!#16(*5(7-.7!+(6*+!0.*7()501!1(45-0*69(J7!(+!6!#+27?

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̀ #+%!&50(GUPPFI(2#++-!1(5/*(

#0#&=6!6(*5(!;#&/#*!(*7!($!27#0-2#&()!7#;-5+(5,(6-0.&!(#01(6*!%%!1(45-0*69(`#+%!&50(2502&/1!1(*7#*(H5+*!06!0M6($51!&(%+51/2!6(.551(+!6/&*6(,5+(6=$$!*+-2(&#$-0#*!6<()/*(,5+(&#$-?0#*!6(8-*7(7-.7!+(#6=$$!*+=<(*7!($51!&(675/&1()!(-$%+5;!19(

7=%5*7!6-6<(87-27(-6(05*(#1!\/#*!(*5(6-$/&#*!(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(

@-)!-+5<(H9Y9<(J-*#<(A9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!E$B!FF8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !E$

Page 31: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&!'()!**!+(,#*-./!(!01/+#02!3(45-0-0.(1-66-$-&#+($#*!+-#&63()!**!+(-06/&#*-503(6$55*7(6/+,#2!(#01(&58!+(8!-.7*9(:58!;!+<(*7!+!(#+!(#&65(0!.#*-;!(#6%!2*6<(,5+(!"#$%&!'(05(%566-)-&-*=(*5(1-6#66!$)&!(*7!(45-0*63(%!!&-0.(6*+!66(675/&1()!($-0-$->!1(#01(*7!(%+!%#+#*-50(5,(*7!(6/+,#2!6(,5+()501-0.($/6*()!(150!(2#+!?

6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0()501!1(45-0*6(#01($#0=(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(

( @!.#+1-0.(*7-6(62!0#+-5<($#0=(+!6!#+27!+6(7#;!(2501/2*!1(6*/1-!6(#)5/*()501!1(45-0*6<(*+=-0.(*5(%+!1-2*(*7!-+($!27#0-?

!"%!+-$!0*#&(*!6*6(5+(7=)+-1(#%%+5#27!6<(25$)-0-0.(*7!5+!*-?

45-0*6(8!+!( 2#++-!1(5/*( )=(A5&B!+6!0( -0( CDEF( GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(A5&B!+6!0($51!&!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(#6(67!#+(6%+-0.(

?/+#&(!,,!2*6(GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(J7!(+!6/&*6(5)*#-0!1()=(*7!(+!6!#+27!+(6758!1(*7#*(*7!(&5#1(*+#06,!+(#*(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6(05*(/0-,5+$9(K5&#01(#01(@!-660!+( GCDLLI( -$%+5;!1(A5&B?!+6!0M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.( *7!(#17!+!0*( &-B!()!#$6(#01(*7!(#17!6-;!(&-B!(6%+-0.6(-0(*!06-50(#01(67!#+(&5#1-0.9(J7#*($51!&(25/&1(#0#&=>!(*7!(1-6*+-)/*-50(5,(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(&5#1?-0.(-01/2!1()=(*7!(6!2501#+=($5$!0*<(87-27(522/+6(-0(6-0.&!(&#%(45-0*69(:#+*?N$-*7(GCDOP3(CDOEI<()#6!1(50(*7!(&#6*($51!&6<(

$#*!+-#&69(:#+*?N$-*7(6-$/&#*!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(+!6%506!<(/6-0.(#0(!&#6*-2?%&#6*-2($#*!+-#&($51!&9(Q*( -6( -$%5+*#0*(*5($!0*-50(

*7!($#-0(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(-0(*7!(6*+/2*/+#&(%!+,5+$#02!(5,(*7!(45-0*( *559(:58!;!+<(65$!(5,(*756!($51!&6(#66/$!1(*7#*(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(8!+!(-65*+5%-2(5+(6=$$!*+-2(G50&=(8-*7(*!06-50(

?-0.(#%%#+!0*(%+5%!+*-!6(,5+(*7!(&#$-0#*!69(Q0(CDOR<(S/2!5.&/(#01(T%1-B!(-$%+5;!1(:#+*?N$-*7M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(!,,!2*6( -0(*7!(#17!+!0*9(J7!=(6758!1(*7#*(

?-*=(-0(67!#+(&5#1-0.<( *7!(05+$#&(6*+#-06(2#0(#,,!2*( *7!(6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!9(J75$6!0(GCDDUI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(-0(*7!(5;!+&#%(&!0.*7(+!1/2!6(*7!(6*+!66(&!;!&(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+9(J7!(+!6!#+27!+(2502&/1!1(*7#*(*7!(#%%&-2#*-50(5,(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(8-*7(&58!+(!&#6*-2(67!#+(#01(*!06-&!($51/&-(

-6()!**!+(*5(/6!(-1!0*-2#&(5+(0!#+&=(-1!0*-2#&(#17!+!0*6(-0()501?!1(45-0*6<(-9!9<(#17!+!0*6(8-*7(6-$-&#+(6*-,,0!669(V+56*-.(!"#$%9(GCDDFI(%+5%56!1(#0(#%%+5#27(/6-0.(7-.7?5+1!+(*7!5+=9(Q0(*7!-+(#0#&=6-6<(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6($51!&!1(#6(#0(!&#6*-2(250*-0//$($!1-#(GUW(#01(EWI9(N5<(*7!(#17!6-;!(25/&1(*+#06,!+(05+$#&(

6*+!66!6<(-0?%&#0!(#01(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(6*+!66!69(J7!6!(+!6/&*6(6758!1(*7#*(*7!+!(8#6(#(.+!#*(;#+-#*-50(5,(*7!(05+$#&(6*+!66(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(2&56!(*5(*7!(!1.!69

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

*7!(#1;#0*#.!6(5,(/6-0.(#(6=$$!*+-2(25$%56-*!(%#*27(-0(5+1!+(*5(+!%#-+(*7!(1#$#.!(%#+*63(#&65<(*7#*(15/)&!(%#*27(7#1(&58!+(6*+!66(87!0(25$%#+!1(8-*7(6-0.&!(%#*27(+!%#-+9(@!.#+1-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(%#+#$!*!+6<(N!50.(!"#$%9(GUPPFI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(5,()501-0.(%+!66/+!(1/+-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(&!#16(*5(7-.7!+(6*+!0.*7()501!1(45-0*69(J7!(+!6!#+27?

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̀ #+%!&50(GUPPFI(2#++-!1(5/*(

#0#&=6!6(*5(!;#&/#*!(*7!($!27#0-2#&()!7#;-5+(5,(6-0.&!(#01(6*!%%!1(45-0*69(`#+%!&50(2502&/1!1(*7#*(H5+*!06!0M6($51!&(%+51/2!6(.551(+!6/&*6(,5+(6=$$!*+-2(&#$-0#*!6<()/*(,5+(&#$-?0#*!6(8-*7(7-.7!+(#6=$$!*+=<(*7!($51!&(675/&1()!(-$%+5;!19(

7=%5*7!6-6<(87-27(-6(05*(#1!\/#*!(*5(6-$/&#*!(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(

@-)!-+5<(H9Y9<(J-*#<(A9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!E$B!FF8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!ED

Page 32: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&!'()!**!+(,#*-./!(!01/+#02!3(45-0-0.(1-66-$-&#+($#*!+-#&63()!**!+(-06/&#*-503(6$55*7(6/+,#2!(#01(&58!+(8!-.7*9(:58!;!+<(*7!+!(#+!(#&65(0!.#*-;!(#6%!2*6<(,5+(!"#$%&!'(05(%566-)-&-*=(*5(1-6#66!$)&!(*7!(45-0*63(%!!&-0.(6*+!66(675/&1()!($-0-$->!1(#01(*7!(%+!%#+#*-50(5,(*7!(6/+,#2!6(,5+()501-0.($/6*()!(150!(2#+!?

6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0()501!1(45-0*6(#01($#0=(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(

( @!.#+1-0.(*7-6(62!0#+-5<($#0=(+!6!#+27!+6(7#;!(2501/2*!1(6*/1-!6(#)5/*()501!1(45-0*6<(*+=-0.(*5(%+!1-2*(*7!-+($!27#0-?

!"%!+-$!0*#&(*!6*6(5+(7=)+-1(#%%+5#27!6<(25$)-0-0.(*7!5+!*-?

45-0*6(8!+!( 2#++-!1(5/*( )=(A5&B!+6!0( -0( CDEF( GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(A5&B!+6!0($51!&!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(#6(67!#+(6%+-0.(

?/+#&(!,,!2*6(GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(J7!(+!6/&*6(5)*#-0!1()=(*7!(+!6!#+27!+(6758!1(*7#*(*7!(&5#1(*+#06,!+(#*(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6(05*(/0-,5+$9(K5&#01(#01(@!-660!+( GCDLLI( -$%+5;!1(A5&B?!+6!0M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.( *7!(#17!+!0*( &-B!()!#$6(#01(*7!(#17!6-;!(&-B!(6%+-0.6(-0(*!06-50(#01(67!#+(&5#1-0.9(J7#*($51!&(25/&1(#0#&=>!(*7!(1-6*+-)/*-50(5,(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(&5#1?-0.(-01/2!1()=(*7!(6!2501#+=($5$!0*<(87-27(522/+6(-0(6-0.&!(&#%(45-0*69(:#+*?N$-*7(GCDOP3(CDOEI<()#6!1(50(*7!(&#6*($51!&6<(

$#*!+-#&69(:#+*?N$-*7(6-$/&#*!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(+!6%506!<(/6-0.(#0(!&#6*-2?%&#6*-2($#*!+-#&($51!&9(Q*( -6( -$%5+*#0*(*5($!0*-50(

*7!($#-0(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(-0(*7!(6*+/2*/+#&(%!+,5+$#02!(5,(*7!(45-0*( *559(:58!;!+<(65$!(5,(*756!($51!&6(#66/$!1(*7#*(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(8!+!(-65*+5%-2(5+(6=$$!*+-2(G50&=(8-*7(*!06-50(

?-0.(#%%#+!0*(%+5%!+*-!6(,5+(*7!(&#$-0#*!69(Q0(CDOR<(S/2!5.&/(#01(T%1-B!(-$%+5;!1(:#+*?N$-*7M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(!,,!2*6( -0(*7!(#17!+!0*9(J7!=(6758!1(*7#*(

?-*=(-0(67!#+(&5#1-0.<( *7!(05+$#&(6*+#-06(2#0(#,,!2*( *7!(6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!9(J75$6!0(GCDDUI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(-0(*7!(5;!+&#%(&!0.*7(+!1/2!6(*7!(6*+!66(&!;!&(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+9(J7!(+!6!#+27!+(2502&/1!1(*7#*(*7!(#%%&-2#*-50(5,(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(8-*7(&58!+(!&#6*-2(67!#+(#01(*!06-&!($51/&-(

-6()!**!+(*5(/6!(-1!0*-2#&(5+(0!#+&=(-1!0*-2#&(#17!+!0*6(-0()501?!1(45-0*6<(-9!9<(#17!+!0*6(8-*7(6-$-&#+(6*-,,0!669(V+56*-.(!"#$%9(GCDDFI(%+5%56!1(#0(#%%+5#27(/6-0.(7-.7?5+1!+(*7!5+=9(Q0(*7!-+(#0#&=6-6<(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6($51!&!1(#6(#0(!&#6*-2(250*-0//$($!1-#(GUW(#01(EWI9(N5<(*7!(#17!6-;!(25/&1(*+#06,!+(05+$#&(

6*+!66!6<(-0?%&#0!(#01(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(6*+!66!69(J7!6!(+!6/&*6(6758!1(*7#*(*7!+!(8#6(#(.+!#*(;#+-#*-50(5,(*7!(05+$#&(6*+!66(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(2&56!(*5(*7!(!1.!69

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

*7!(#1;#0*#.!6(5,(/6-0.(#(6=$$!*+-2(25$%56-*!(%#*27(-0(5+1!+(*5(+!%#-+(*7!(1#$#.!(%#+*63(#&65<(*7#*(15/)&!(%#*27(7#1(&58!+(6*+!66(87!0(25$%#+!1(8-*7(6-0.&!(%#*27(+!%#-+9(@!.#+1-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(%#+#$!*!+6<(N!50.(!"#$%9(GUPPFI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(5,()501-0.(%+!66/+!(1/+-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(&!#16(*5(7-.7!+(6*+!0.*7()501!1(45-0*69(J7!(+!6!#+27?

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̀ #+%!&50(GUPPFI(2#++-!1(5/*(

#0#&=6!6(*5(!;#&/#*!(*7!($!27#0-2#&()!7#;-5+(5,(6-0.&!(#01(6*!%%!1(45-0*69(`#+%!&50(2502&/1!1(*7#*(H5+*!06!0M6($51!&(%+51/2!6(.551(+!6/&*6(,5+(6=$$!*+-2(&#$-0#*!6<()/*(,5+(&#$-?0#*!6(8-*7(7-.7!+(#6=$$!*+=<(*7!($51!&(675/&1()!(-$%+5;!19(

7=%5*7!6-6<(87-27(-6(05*(#1!\/#*!(*5(6-$/&#*!(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(

@-)!-+5<(H9Y9<(J-*#<(A9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!E$B!FF8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !EE

Page 33: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&!'()!**!+(,#*-./!(!01/+#02!3(45-0-0.(1-66-$-&#+($#*!+-#&63()!**!+(-06/&#*-503(6$55*7(6/+,#2!(#01(&58!+(8!-.7*9(:58!;!+<(*7!+!(#+!(#&65(0!.#*-;!(#6%!2*6<(,5+(!"#$%&!'(05(%566-)-&-*=(*5(1-6#66!$)&!(*7!(45-0*63(%!!&-0.(6*+!66(675/&1()!($-0-$->!1(#01(*7!(%+!%#+#*-50(5,(*7!(6/+,#2!6(,5+()501-0.($/6*()!(150!(2#+!?

6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0()501!1(45-0*6(#01($#0=(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(

( @!.#+1-0.(*7-6(62!0#+-5<($#0=(+!6!#+27!+6(7#;!(2501/2*!1(6*/1-!6(#)5/*()501!1(45-0*6<(*+=-0.(*5(%+!1-2*(*7!-+($!27#0-?

!"%!+-$!0*#&(*!6*6(5+(7=)+-1(#%%+5#27!6<(25$)-0-0.(*7!5+!*-?

45-0*6(8!+!( 2#++-!1(5/*( )=(A5&B!+6!0( -0( CDEF( GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(A5&B!+6!0($51!&!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(#6(67!#+(6%+-0.(

?/+#&(!,,!2*6(GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(J7!(+!6/&*6(5)*#-0!1()=(*7!(+!6!#+27!+(6758!1(*7#*(*7!(&5#1(*+#06,!+(#*(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6(05*(/0-,5+$9(K5&#01(#01(@!-660!+( GCDLLI( -$%+5;!1(A5&B?!+6!0M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.( *7!(#17!+!0*( &-B!()!#$6(#01(*7!(#17!6-;!(&-B!(6%+-0.6(-0(*!06-50(#01(67!#+(&5#1-0.9(J7#*($51!&(25/&1(#0#&=>!(*7!(1-6*+-)/*-50(5,(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(&5#1?-0.(-01/2!1()=(*7!(6!2501#+=($5$!0*<(87-27(522/+6(-0(6-0.&!(&#%(45-0*69(:#+*?N$-*7(GCDOP3(CDOEI<()#6!1(50(*7!(&#6*($51!&6<(

$#*!+-#&69(:#+*?N$-*7(6-$/&#*!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(+!6%506!<(/6-0.(#0(!&#6*-2?%&#6*-2($#*!+-#&($51!&9(Q*( -6( -$%5+*#0*(*5($!0*-50(

*7!($#-0(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(-0(*7!(6*+/2*/+#&(%!+,5+$#02!(5,(*7!(45-0*( *559(:58!;!+<(65$!(5,(*756!($51!&6(#66/$!1(*7#*(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(8!+!(-65*+5%-2(5+(6=$$!*+-2(G50&=(8-*7(*!06-50(

?-0.(#%%#+!0*(%+5%!+*-!6(,5+(*7!(&#$-0#*!69(Q0(CDOR<(S/2!5.&/(#01(T%1-B!(-$%+5;!1(:#+*?N$-*7M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(!,,!2*6( -0(*7!(#17!+!0*9(J7!=(6758!1(*7#*(

?-*=(-0(67!#+(&5#1-0.<( *7!(05+$#&(6*+#-06(2#0(#,,!2*( *7!(6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!9(J75$6!0(GCDDUI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(-0(*7!(5;!+&#%(&!0.*7(+!1/2!6(*7!(6*+!66(&!;!&(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+9(J7!(+!6!#+27!+(2502&/1!1(*7#*(*7!(#%%&-2#*-50(5,(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(8-*7(&58!+(!&#6*-2(67!#+(#01(*!06-&!($51/&-(

-6()!**!+(*5(/6!(-1!0*-2#&(5+(0!#+&=(-1!0*-2#&(#17!+!0*6(-0()501?!1(45-0*6<(-9!9<(#17!+!0*6(8-*7(6-$-&#+(6*-,,0!669(V+56*-.(!"#$%9(GCDDFI(%+5%56!1(#0(#%%+5#27(/6-0.(7-.7?5+1!+(*7!5+=9(Q0(*7!-+(#0#&=6-6<(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6($51!&!1(#6(#0(!&#6*-2(250*-0//$($!1-#(GUW(#01(EWI9(N5<(*7!(#17!6-;!(25/&1(*+#06,!+(05+$#&(

6*+!66!6<(-0?%&#0!(#01(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(6*+!66!69(J7!6!(+!6/&*6(6758!1(*7#*(*7!+!(8#6(#(.+!#*(;#+-#*-50(5,(*7!(05+$#&(6*+!66(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(2&56!(*5(*7!(!1.!69

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

*7!(#1;#0*#.!6(5,(/6-0.(#(6=$$!*+-2(25$%56-*!(%#*27(-0(5+1!+(*5(+!%#-+(*7!(1#$#.!(%#+*63(#&65<(*7#*(15/)&!(%#*27(7#1(&58!+(6*+!66(87!0(25$%#+!1(8-*7(6-0.&!(%#*27(+!%#-+9(@!.#+1-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(%#+#$!*!+6<(N!50.(!"#$%9(GUPPFI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(5,()501-0.(%+!66/+!(1/+-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(&!#16(*5(7-.7!+(6*+!0.*7()501!1(45-0*69(J7!(+!6!#+27?

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̀ #+%!&50(GUPPFI(2#++-!1(5/*(

#0#&=6!6(*5(!;#&/#*!(*7!($!27#0-2#&()!7#;-5+(5,(6-0.&!(#01(6*!%%!1(45-0*69(`#+%!&50(2502&/1!1(*7#*(H5+*!06!0M6($51!&(%+51/2!6(.551(+!6/&*6(,5+(6=$$!*+-2(&#$-0#*!6<()/*(,5+(&#$-?0#*!6(8-*7(7-.7!+(#6=$$!*+=<(*7!($51!&(675/&1()!(-$%+5;!19(

7=%5*7!6-6<(87-27(-6(05*(#1!\/#*!(*5(6-$/&#*!(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(

@-)!-+5<(H9Y9<(J-*#<(A9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!E$B!FF8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!EF

Page 34: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&!'()!**!+(,#*-./!(!01/+#02!3(45-0-0.(1-66-$-&#+($#*!+-#&63()!**!+(-06/&#*-503(6$55*7(6/+,#2!(#01(&58!+(8!-.7*9(:58!;!+<(*7!+!(#+!(#&65(0!.#*-;!(#6%!2*6<(,5+(!"#$%&!'(05(%566-)-&-*=(*5(1-6#66!$)&!(*7!(45-0*63(%!!&-0.(6*+!66(675/&1()!($-0-$->!1(#01(*7!(%+!%#+#*-50(5,(*7!(6/+,#2!6(,5+()501-0.($/6*()!(150!(2#+!?

6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0()501!1(45-0*6(#01($#0=(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(

( @!.#+1-0.(*7-6(62!0#+-5<($#0=(+!6!#+27!+6(7#;!(2501/2*!1(6*/1-!6(#)5/*()501!1(45-0*6<(*+=-0.(*5(%+!1-2*(*7!-+($!27#0-?

!"%!+-$!0*#&(*!6*6(5+(7=)+-1(#%%+5#27!6<(25$)-0-0.(*7!5+!*-?

45-0*6(8!+!( 2#++-!1(5/*( )=(A5&B!+6!0( -0( CDEF( GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(A5&B!+6!0($51!&!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(#6(67!#+(6%+-0.(

?/+#&(!,,!2*6(GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(J7!(+!6/&*6(5)*#-0!1()=(*7!(+!6!#+27!+(6758!1(*7#*(*7!(&5#1(*+#06,!+(#*(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6(05*(/0-,5+$9(K5&#01(#01(@!-660!+( GCDLLI( -$%+5;!1(A5&B?!+6!0M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.( *7!(#17!+!0*( &-B!()!#$6(#01(*7!(#17!6-;!(&-B!(6%+-0.6(-0(*!06-50(#01(67!#+(&5#1-0.9(J7#*($51!&(25/&1(#0#&=>!(*7!(1-6*+-)/*-50(5,(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(&5#1?-0.(-01/2!1()=(*7!(6!2501#+=($5$!0*<(87-27(522/+6(-0(6-0.&!(&#%(45-0*69(:#+*?N$-*7(GCDOP3(CDOEI<()#6!1(50(*7!(&#6*($51!&6<(

$#*!+-#&69(:#+*?N$-*7(6-$/&#*!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(+!6%506!<(/6-0.(#0(!&#6*-2?%&#6*-2($#*!+-#&($51!&9(Q*( -6( -$%5+*#0*(*5($!0*-50(

*7!($#-0(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(-0(*7!(6*+/2*/+#&(%!+,5+$#02!(5,(*7!(45-0*( *559(:58!;!+<(65$!(5,(*756!($51!&6(#66/$!1(*7#*(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(8!+!(-65*+5%-2(5+(6=$$!*+-2(G50&=(8-*7(*!06-50(

?-0.(#%%#+!0*(%+5%!+*-!6(,5+(*7!(&#$-0#*!69(Q0(CDOR<(S/2!5.&/(#01(T%1-B!(-$%+5;!1(:#+*?N$-*7M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(!,,!2*6( -0(*7!(#17!+!0*9(J7!=(6758!1(*7#*(

?-*=(-0(67!#+(&5#1-0.<( *7!(05+$#&(6*+#-06(2#0(#,,!2*( *7!(6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!9(J75$6!0(GCDDUI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(-0(*7!(5;!+&#%(&!0.*7(+!1/2!6(*7!(6*+!66(&!;!&(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+9(J7!(+!6!#+27!+(2502&/1!1(*7#*(*7!(#%%&-2#*-50(5,(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(8-*7(&58!+(!&#6*-2(67!#+(#01(*!06-&!($51/&-(

-6()!**!+(*5(/6!(-1!0*-2#&(5+(0!#+&=(-1!0*-2#&(#17!+!0*6(-0()501?!1(45-0*6<(-9!9<(#17!+!0*6(8-*7(6-$-&#+(6*-,,0!669(V+56*-.(!"#$%9(GCDDFI(%+5%56!1(#0(#%%+5#27(/6-0.(7-.7?5+1!+(*7!5+=9(Q0(*7!-+(#0#&=6-6<(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6($51!&!1(#6(#0(!&#6*-2(250*-0//$($!1-#(GUW(#01(EWI9(N5<(*7!(#17!6-;!(25/&1(*+#06,!+(05+$#&(

6*+!66!6<(-0?%&#0!(#01(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(6*+!66!69(J7!6!(+!6/&*6(6758!1(*7#*(*7!+!(8#6(#(.+!#*(;#+-#*-50(5,(*7!(05+$#&(6*+!66(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(2&56!(*5(*7!(!1.!69

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

*7!(#1;#0*#.!6(5,(/6-0.(#(6=$$!*+-2(25$%56-*!(%#*27(-0(5+1!+(*5(+!%#-+(*7!(1#$#.!(%#+*63(#&65<(*7#*(15/)&!(%#*27(7#1(&58!+(6*+!66(87!0(25$%#+!1(8-*7(6-0.&!(%#*27(+!%#-+9(@!.#+1-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(%#+#$!*!+6<(N!50.(!"#$%9(GUPPFI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(5,()501-0.(%+!66/+!(1/+-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(&!#16(*5(7-.7!+(6*+!0.*7()501!1(45-0*69(J7!(+!6!#+27?

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̀ #+%!&50(GUPPFI(2#++-!1(5/*(

#0#&=6!6(*5(!;#&/#*!(*7!($!27#0-2#&()!7#;-5+(5,(6-0.&!(#01(6*!%%!1(45-0*69(`#+%!&50(2502&/1!1(*7#*(H5+*!06!0M6($51!&(%+51/2!6(.551(+!6/&*6(,5+(6=$$!*+-2(&#$-0#*!6<()/*(,5+(&#$-?0#*!6(8-*7(7-.7!+(#6=$$!*+=<(*7!($51!&(675/&1()!(-$%+5;!19(

7=%5*7!6-6<(87-27(-6(05*(#1!\/#*!(*5(6-$/&#*!(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(

@-)!-+5<(H9Y9<(J-*#<(A9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!E$B!FF8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !E#

Page 35: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&!'()!**!+(,#*-./!(!01/+#02!3(45-0-0.(1-66-$-&#+($#*!+-#&63()!**!+(-06/&#*-503(6$55*7(6/+,#2!(#01(&58!+(8!-.7*9(:58!;!+<(*7!+!(#+!(#&65(0!.#*-;!(#6%!2*6<(,5+(!"#$%&!'(05(%566-)-&-*=(*5(1-6#66!$)&!(*7!(45-0*63(%!!&-0.(6*+!66(675/&1()!($-0-$->!1(#01(*7!(%+!%#+#*-50(5,(*7!(6/+,#2!6(,5+()501-0.($/6*()!(150!(2#+!?

6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0()501!1(45-0*6(#01($#0=(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(

( @!.#+1-0.(*7-6(62!0#+-5<($#0=(+!6!#+27!+6(7#;!(2501/2*!1(6*/1-!6(#)5/*()501!1(45-0*6<(*+=-0.(*5(%+!1-2*(*7!-+($!27#0-?

!"%!+-$!0*#&(*!6*6(5+(7=)+-1(#%%+5#27!6<(25$)-0-0.(*7!5+!*-?

45-0*6(8!+!( 2#++-!1(5/*( )=(A5&B!+6!0( -0( CDEF( GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(A5&B!+6!0($51!&!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(#6(67!#+(6%+-0.(

?/+#&(!,,!2*6(GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(J7!(+!6/&*6(5)*#-0!1()=(*7!(+!6!#+27!+(6758!1(*7#*(*7!(&5#1(*+#06,!+(#*(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6(05*(/0-,5+$9(K5&#01(#01(@!-660!+( GCDLLI( -$%+5;!1(A5&B?!+6!0M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.( *7!(#17!+!0*( &-B!()!#$6(#01(*7!(#17!6-;!(&-B!(6%+-0.6(-0(*!06-50(#01(67!#+(&5#1-0.9(J7#*($51!&(25/&1(#0#&=>!(*7!(1-6*+-)/*-50(5,(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(&5#1?-0.(-01/2!1()=(*7!(6!2501#+=($5$!0*<(87-27(522/+6(-0(6-0.&!(&#%(45-0*69(:#+*?N$-*7(GCDOP3(CDOEI<()#6!1(50(*7!(&#6*($51!&6<(

$#*!+-#&69(:#+*?N$-*7(6-$/&#*!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(+!6%506!<(/6-0.(#0(!&#6*-2?%&#6*-2($#*!+-#&($51!&9(Q*( -6( -$%5+*#0*(*5($!0*-50(

*7!($#-0(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(-0(*7!(6*+/2*/+#&(%!+,5+$#02!(5,(*7!(45-0*( *559(:58!;!+<(65$!(5,(*756!($51!&6(#66/$!1(*7#*(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(8!+!(-65*+5%-2(5+(6=$$!*+-2(G50&=(8-*7(*!06-50(

?-0.(#%%#+!0*(%+5%!+*-!6(,5+(*7!(&#$-0#*!69(Q0(CDOR<(S/2!5.&/(#01(T%1-B!(-$%+5;!1(:#+*?N$-*7M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(!,,!2*6( -0(*7!(#17!+!0*9(J7!=(6758!1(*7#*(

?-*=(-0(67!#+(&5#1-0.<( *7!(05+$#&(6*+#-06(2#0(#,,!2*( *7!(6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!9(J75$6!0(GCDDUI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(-0(*7!(5;!+&#%(&!0.*7(+!1/2!6(*7!(6*+!66(&!;!&(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+9(J7!(+!6!#+27!+(2502&/1!1(*7#*(*7!(#%%&-2#*-50(5,(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(8-*7(&58!+(!&#6*-2(67!#+(#01(*!06-&!($51/&-(

-6()!**!+(*5(/6!(-1!0*-2#&(5+(0!#+&=(-1!0*-2#&(#17!+!0*6(-0()501?!1(45-0*6<(-9!9<(#17!+!0*6(8-*7(6-$-&#+(6*-,,0!669(V+56*-.(!"#$%9(GCDDFI(%+5%56!1(#0(#%%+5#27(/6-0.(7-.7?5+1!+(*7!5+=9(Q0(*7!-+(#0#&=6-6<(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6($51!&!1(#6(#0(!&#6*-2(250*-0//$($!1-#(GUW(#01(EWI9(N5<(*7!(#17!6-;!(25/&1(*+#06,!+(05+$#&(

6*+!66!6<(-0?%&#0!(#01(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(6*+!66!69(J7!6!(+!6/&*6(6758!1(*7#*(*7!+!(8#6(#(.+!#*(;#+-#*-50(5,(*7!(05+$#&(6*+!66(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(2&56!(*5(*7!(!1.!69

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

*7!(#1;#0*#.!6(5,(/6-0.(#(6=$$!*+-2(25$%56-*!(%#*27(-0(5+1!+(*5(+!%#-+(*7!(1#$#.!(%#+*63(#&65<(*7#*(15/)&!(%#*27(7#1(&58!+(6*+!66(87!0(25$%#+!1(8-*7(6-0.&!(%#*27(+!%#-+9(@!.#+1-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(%#+#$!*!+6<(N!50.(!"#$%9(GUPPFI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(5,()501-0.(%+!66/+!(1/+-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(&!#16(*5(7-.7!+(6*+!0.*7()501!1(45-0*69(J7!(+!6!#+27?

7-.7!+(6*+!0.*7()501!1(45-0*6<(#01(*7!($#45+(,#-&/+!($51!(,5+(6-0.&!(&#%(25$%56-*!?#&/$-0/$(45-0*6(-6(*7!(1!&#$-0#*-50(5,(*7!(25$%56-*!(#17!+!0*9(Q0(*7!(6#$!(=!#+<()#6!1(50(!"%!+-$!0*#&(#0#&=6!6<(^-$(!"#$%5;!+&#%(&!0.*7(#01(5)6!+;!1(*7#*(*7!(05+$#&(#01(67!#+(6*+!66!6(#*(*7!(#17!6-;!(+!.-50(+!1/2!(87!0(*7!(5;!+&#%(-02+!#6!69( :58!;!+<(-*( -6(-$%5+*#0*(*5($!0*-50(*7#*(5*7!+(+!6!#+27?!+6(%+!,!++!1(*5(#0#&=>!()501!1(45-0*6()=(*7!(V-0-*!(_&!$!0*(H!*751<( ,5+( !"#$%&!'(X7#+#&#$)-1!6(!"# $%9( GCDDFI3(K5=#&(!"#$%9(GUPPFI9(]!6-1!6<(65$!(+!6!#+27!+6(25$%#+!1(#0#&=*-2#&($!*7516(*5(0/$!+-2#&(#%%+5#27!69(̀ #+%!&50(GUPPFI(2#++-!1(5/*(

#0#&=6!6(*5(!;#&/#*!(*7!($!27#0-2#&()!7#;-5+(5,(6-0.&!(#01(6*!%%!1(45-0*69(`#+%!&50(2502&/1!1(*7#*(H5+*!06!0M6($51!&(%+51/2!6(.551(+!6/&*6(,5+(6=$$!*+-2(&#$-0#*!6<()/*(,5+(&#$-?0#*!6(8-*7(7-.7!+(#6=$$!*+=<(*7!($51!&(675/&1()!(-$%+5;!19(

7=%5*7!6-6<(87-27(-6(05*(#1!\/#*!(*5(6-$/&#*!(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(

@-)!-+5<(H9Y9<(J-*#<(A9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!E$B!FF8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!F%

Page 36: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&!'()!**!+(,#*-./!(!01/+#02!3(45-0-0.(1-66-$-&#+($#*!+-#&63()!**!+(-06/&#*-503(6$55*7(6/+,#2!(#01(&58!+(8!-.7*9(:58!;!+<(*7!+!(#+!(#&65(0!.#*-;!(#6%!2*6<(,5+(!"#$%&!'(05(%566-)-&-*=(*5(1-6#66!$)&!(*7!(45-0*63(%!!&-0.(6*+!66(675/&1()!($-0-$->!1(#01(*7!(%+!%#+#*-50(5,(*7!(6/+,#2!6(,5+()501-0.($/6*()!(150!(2#+!?

6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0()501!1(45-0*6(#01($#0=(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(

( @!.#+1-0.(*7-6(62!0#+-5<($#0=(+!6!#+27!+6(7#;!(2501/2*!1(6*/1-!6(#)5/*()501!1(45-0*6<(*+=-0.(*5(%+!1-2*(*7!-+($!27#0-?

!"%!+-$!0*#&(*!6*6(5+(7=)+-1(#%%+5#27!6<(25$)-0-0.(*7!5+!*-?

45-0*6(8!+!( 2#++-!1(5/*( )=(A5&B!+6!0( -0( CDEF( GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(A5&B!+6!0($51!&!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(#6(67!#+(6%+-0.(

?/+#&(!,,!2*6(GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(J7!(+!6/&*6(5)*#-0!1()=(*7!(+!6!#+27!+(6758!1(*7#*(*7!(&5#1(*+#06,!+(#*(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6(05*(/0-,5+$9(K5&#01(#01(@!-660!+( GCDLLI( -$%+5;!1(A5&B?!+6!0M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.( *7!(#17!+!0*( &-B!()!#$6(#01(*7!(#17!6-;!(&-B!(6%+-0.6(-0(*!06-50(#01(67!#+(&5#1-0.9(J7#*($51!&(25/&1(#0#&=>!(*7!(1-6*+-)/*-50(5,(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(&5#1?-0.(-01/2!1()=(*7!(6!2501#+=($5$!0*<(87-27(522/+6(-0(6-0.&!(&#%(45-0*69(:#+*?N$-*7(GCDOP3(CDOEI<()#6!1(50(*7!(&#6*($51!&6<(

$#*!+-#&69(:#+*?N$-*7(6-$/&#*!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(+!6%506!<(/6-0.(#0(!&#6*-2?%&#6*-2($#*!+-#&($51!&9(Q*( -6( -$%5+*#0*(*5($!0*-50(

*7!($#-0(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(-0(*7!(6*+/2*/+#&(%!+,5+$#02!(5,(*7!(45-0*( *559(:58!;!+<(65$!(5,(*756!($51!&6(#66/$!1(*7#*(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(8!+!(-65*+5%-2(5+(6=$$!*+-2(G50&=(8-*7(*!06-50(

?-0.(#%%#+!0*(%+5%!+*-!6(,5+(*7!(&#$-0#*!69(Q0(CDOR<(S/2!5.&/(#01(T%1-B!(-$%+5;!1(:#+*?N$-*7M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(!,,!2*6( -0(*7!(#17!+!0*9(J7!=(6758!1(*7#*(

?-*=(-0(67!#+(&5#1-0.<( *7!(05+$#&(6*+#-06(2#0(#,,!2*( *7!(6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!9(J75$6!0(GCDDUI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(-0(*7!(5;!+&#%(&!0.*7(+!1/2!6(*7!(6*+!66(&!;!&(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+9(J7!(+!6!#+27!+(2502&/1!1(*7#*(*7!(#%%&-2#*-50(5,(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(8-*7(&58!+(!&#6*-2(67!#+(#01(*!06-&!($51/&-(

-6()!**!+(*5(/6!(-1!0*-2#&(5+(0!#+&=(-1!0*-2#&(#17!+!0*6(-0()501?!1(45-0*6<(-9!9<(#17!+!0*6(8-*7(6-$-&#+(6*-,,0!669(V+56*-.(!"#$%9(GCDDFI(%+5%56!1(#0(#%%+5#27(/6-0.(7-.7?5+1!+(*7!5+=9(Q0(*7!-+(#0#&=6-6<(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6($51!&!1(#6(#0(!&#6*-2(250*-0//$($!1-#(GUW(#01(EWI9(N5<(*7!(#17!6-;!(25/&1(*+#06,!+(05+$#&(

6*+!66!6<(-0?%&#0!(#01(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(6*+!66!69(J7!6!(+!6/&*6(6758!1(*7#*(*7!+!(8#6(#(.+!#*(;#+-#*-50(5,(*7!(05+$#&(6*+!66(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(2&56!(*5(*7!(!1.!69

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

*7!(#1;#0*#.!6(5,(/6-0.(#(6=$$!*+-2(25$%56-*!(%#*27(-0(5+1!+(*5(+!%#-+(*7!(1#$#.!(%#+*63(#&65<(*7#*(15/)&!(%#*27(7#1(&58!+(6*+!66(87!0(25$%#+!1(8-*7(6-0.&!(%#*27(+!%#-+9(@!.#+1-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(%#+#$!*!+6<(N!50.(!"#$%9(GUPPFI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(5,()501-0.(%+!66/+!(1/+-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(&!#16(*5(7-.7!+(6*+!0.*7()501!1(45-0*69(J7!(+!6!#+27?

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̀ #+%!&50(GUPPFI(2#++-!1(5/*(

#0#&=6!6(*5(!;#&/#*!(*7!($!27#0-2#&()!7#;-5+(5,(6-0.&!(#01(6*!%%!1(45-0*69(`#+%!&50(2502&/1!1(*7#*(H5+*!06!0M6($51!&(%+51/2!6(.551(+!6/&*6(,5+(6=$$!*+-2(&#$-0#*!6<()/*(,5+(&#$-?0#*!6(8-*7(7-.7!+(#6=$$!*+=<(*7!($51!&(675/&1()!(-$%+5;!19(

7=%5*7!6-6<(87-27(-6(05*(#1!\/#*!(*5(6-$/&#*!(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(

@-)!-+5<(H9Y9<(J-*#<(A9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!E$B!FF8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !F&

Page 37: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&!'()!**!+(,#*-./!(!01/+#02!3(45-0-0.(1-66-$-&#+($#*!+-#&63()!**!+(-06/&#*-503(6$55*7(6/+,#2!(#01(&58!+(8!-.7*9(:58!;!+<(*7!+!(#+!(#&65(0!.#*-;!(#6%!2*6<(,5+(!"#$%&!'(05(%566-)-&-*=(*5(1-6#66!$)&!(*7!(45-0*63(%!!&-0.(6*+!66(675/&1()!($-0-$->!1(#01(*7!(%+!%#+#*-50(5,(*7!(6/+,#2!6(,5+()501-0.($/6*()!(150!(2#+!?

6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0()501!1(45-0*6(#01($#0=(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(

( @!.#+1-0.(*7-6(62!0#+-5<($#0=(+!6!#+27!+6(7#;!(2501/2*!1(6*/1-!6(#)5/*()501!1(45-0*6<(*+=-0.(*5(%+!1-2*(*7!-+($!27#0-?

!"%!+-$!0*#&(*!6*6(5+(7=)+-1(#%%+5#27!6<(25$)-0-0.(*7!5+!*-?

45-0*6(8!+!( 2#++-!1(5/*( )=(A5&B!+6!0( -0( CDEF( GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(A5&B!+6!0($51!&!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(#6(67!#+(6%+-0.(

?/+#&(!,,!2*6(GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(J7!(+!6/&*6(5)*#-0!1()=(*7!(+!6!#+27!+(6758!1(*7#*(*7!(&5#1(*+#06,!+(#*(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6(05*(/0-,5+$9(K5&#01(#01(@!-660!+( GCDLLI( -$%+5;!1(A5&B?!+6!0M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.( *7!(#17!+!0*( &-B!()!#$6(#01(*7!(#17!6-;!(&-B!(6%+-0.6(-0(*!06-50(#01(67!#+(&5#1-0.9(J7#*($51!&(25/&1(#0#&=>!(*7!(1-6*+-)/*-50(5,(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(&5#1?-0.(-01/2!1()=(*7!(6!2501#+=($5$!0*<(87-27(522/+6(-0(6-0.&!(&#%(45-0*69(:#+*?N$-*7(GCDOP3(CDOEI<()#6!1(50(*7!(&#6*($51!&6<(

$#*!+-#&69(:#+*?N$-*7(6-$/&#*!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(+!6%506!<(/6-0.(#0(!&#6*-2?%&#6*-2($#*!+-#&($51!&9(Q*( -6( -$%5+*#0*(*5($!0*-50(

*7!($#-0(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(-0(*7!(6*+/2*/+#&(%!+,5+$#02!(5,(*7!(45-0*( *559(:58!;!+<(65$!(5,(*756!($51!&6(#66/$!1(*7#*(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(8!+!(-65*+5%-2(5+(6=$$!*+-2(G50&=(8-*7(*!06-50(

?-0.(#%%#+!0*(%+5%!+*-!6(,5+(*7!(&#$-0#*!69(Q0(CDOR<(S/2!5.&/(#01(T%1-B!(-$%+5;!1(:#+*?N$-*7M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(!,,!2*6( -0(*7!(#17!+!0*9(J7!=(6758!1(*7#*(

?-*=(-0(67!#+(&5#1-0.<( *7!(05+$#&(6*+#-06(2#0(#,,!2*( *7!(6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!9(J75$6!0(GCDDUI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(-0(*7!(5;!+&#%(&!0.*7(+!1/2!6(*7!(6*+!66(&!;!&(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+9(J7!(+!6!#+27!+(2502&/1!1(*7#*(*7!(#%%&-2#*-50(5,(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(8-*7(&58!+(!&#6*-2(67!#+(#01(*!06-&!($51/&-(

-6()!**!+(*5(/6!(-1!0*-2#&(5+(0!#+&=(-1!0*-2#&(#17!+!0*6(-0()501?!1(45-0*6<(-9!9<(#17!+!0*6(8-*7(6-$-&#+(6*-,,0!669(V+56*-.(!"#$%9(GCDDFI(%+5%56!1(#0(#%%+5#27(/6-0.(7-.7?5+1!+(*7!5+=9(Q0(*7!-+(#0#&=6-6<(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6($51!&!1(#6(#0(!&#6*-2(250*-0//$($!1-#(GUW(#01(EWI9(N5<(*7!(#17!6-;!(25/&1(*+#06,!+(05+$#&(

6*+!66!6<(-0?%&#0!(#01(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(6*+!66!69(J7!6!(+!6/&*6(6758!1(*7#*(*7!+!(8#6(#(.+!#*(;#+-#*-50(5,(*7!(05+$#&(6*+!66(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(2&56!(*5(*7!(!1.!69

#%%&=-0.(*7!(X&#66-2#&(Y#$-0#*!(J7!5+=(GXYJI9(V5+(*7!(-0-*-#&(#0#&=6!6<(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(8#6(2506-1!+!1(#6(75$5.!0!5/6<(-65*+5%-2( #01( &-0!#+&=( !&#6*-2<( )/*( *7!( #17!6-;!6( /6!1( #*(#!+50#/*-2#&(-01/6*+=(7#;!(050?&-0!#+()!7#;-5+9(J7/6<(,5+(*7!(,5&&58?/%(#0#&=6!6<(*7!(N%+-0.!+(#01(Z70M6($51!&(2506-1!+!1(*7!( !&#6*-2?%&#6*-2( +!6%506!( ,5+( *7!( #17!6-;!6( GN%+-0.!+( #01(Z70<(CDDFI9(H5+*!06!0(GCDDFI<(-0(7-6([79W9(*7!6-6<(%+!6!0*!1(#(1!;!&5%$!0*(5,(#(25$%/*#*-50#&(*55&(,5+(#0#&=6-6(5,()501!1(45-0*6<(6758-0.(*7!(!\/#*-506(#01(7=%5*7!6-6(,5+(;#+-5/6(*=%!6(5,(45-0*69(J7!(#/*75+(6758!1(*7!(65&;-0.(%+52!66(5,(1-,,!+!0*-#&(!\/#*-506<( /6-0.( *7!( $/&*-?6!.$!0*( $!*751( 5,( -0*!.+#*-509(V5/+(=!#+6(&#*!+<(K#0!67(#01(X755(GUPPUI(6758!1(*7!(!,,!2*(5,(6%#*-#&(.+#1-0.(5,(#17!+!0*(!&#6*-2($51/&/6(50(*7!(%!#B(5,(6*+!66(#01(6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0(*7!(6-0.&!(&#%(45-0*9(J7-6(!,,!2*(1!2+!#6!6(*7!(6*+!66(%!#B(#01(%+5;-1!6(#($5+!(/0-,5+$(67!#+(6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0(*7!(45-0*9(Z,*!+(*7#*<(]!&75/#+-(!"#$%9(GUPPLI(6758!1(#(25$%#+-650()!*8!!0(6-0.&!(#01(15/)&!(&#%(45-0*(/6-0.(

*7!(#1;#0*#.!6(5,(/6-0.(#(6=$$!*+-2(25$%56-*!(%#*27(-0(5+1!+(*5(+!%#-+(*7!(1#$#.!(%#+*63(#&65<(*7#*(15/)&!(%#*27(7#1(&58!+(6*+!66(87!0(25$%#+!1(8-*7(6-0.&!(%#*27(+!%#-+9(@!.#+1-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(%#+#$!*!+6<(N!50.(!"#$%9(GUPPFI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(5,()501-0.(%+!66/+!(1/+-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(&!#16(*5(7-.7!+(6*+!0.*7()501!1(45-0*69(J7!(+!6!#+27?

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̀ #+%!&50(GUPPFI(2#++-!1(5/*(

#0#&=6!6(*5(!;#&/#*!(*7!($!27#0-2#&()!7#;-5+(5,(6-0.&!(#01(6*!%%!1(45-0*69(`#+%!&50(2502&/1!1(*7#*(H5+*!06!0M6($51!&(%+51/2!6(.551(+!6/&*6(,5+(6=$$!*+-2(&#$-0#*!6<()/*(,5+(&#$-?0#*!6(8-*7(7-.7!+(#6=$$!*+=<(*7!($51!&(675/&1()!(-$%+5;!19(

7=%5*7!6-6<(87-27(-6(05*(#1!\/#*!(*5(6-$/&#*!(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(

@-)!-+5<(H9Y9<(J-*#<(A9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!E$B!FF8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!F!

Page 38: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&!'()!**!+(,#*-./!(!01/+#02!3(45-0-0.(1-66-$-&#+($#*!+-#&63()!**!+(-06/&#*-503(6$55*7(6/+,#2!(#01(&58!+(8!-.7*9(:58!;!+<(*7!+!(#+!(#&65(0!.#*-;!(#6%!2*6<(,5+(!"#$%&!'(05(%566-)-&-*=(*5(1-6#66!$)&!(*7!(45-0*63(%!!&-0.(6*+!66(675/&1()!($-0-$->!1(#01(*7!(%+!%#+#*-50(5,(*7!(6/+,#2!6(,5+()501-0.($/6*()!(150!(2#+!?

6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0()501!1(45-0*6(#01($#0=(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(

( @!.#+1-0.(*7-6(62!0#+-5<($#0=(+!6!#+27!+6(7#;!(2501/2*!1(6*/1-!6(#)5/*()501!1(45-0*6<(*+=-0.(*5(%+!1-2*(*7!-+($!27#0-?

!"%!+-$!0*#&(*!6*6(5+(7=)+-1(#%%+5#27!6<(25$)-0-0.(*7!5+!*-?

45-0*6(8!+!( 2#++-!1(5/*( )=(A5&B!+6!0( -0( CDEF( GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(A5&B!+6!0($51!&!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(#6(67!#+(6%+-0.(

?/+#&(!,,!2*6(GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(J7!(+!6/&*6(5)*#-0!1()=(*7!(+!6!#+27!+(6758!1(*7#*(*7!(&5#1(*+#06,!+(#*(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6(05*(/0-,5+$9(K5&#01(#01(@!-660!+( GCDLLI( -$%+5;!1(A5&B?!+6!0M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.( *7!(#17!+!0*( &-B!()!#$6(#01(*7!(#17!6-;!(&-B!(6%+-0.6(-0(*!06-50(#01(67!#+(&5#1-0.9(J7#*($51!&(25/&1(#0#&=>!(*7!(1-6*+-)/*-50(5,(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(&5#1?-0.(-01/2!1()=(*7!(6!2501#+=($5$!0*<(87-27(522/+6(-0(6-0.&!(&#%(45-0*69(:#+*?N$-*7(GCDOP3(CDOEI<()#6!1(50(*7!(&#6*($51!&6<(

$#*!+-#&69(:#+*?N$-*7(6-$/&#*!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(+!6%506!<(/6-0.(#0(!&#6*-2?%&#6*-2($#*!+-#&($51!&9(Q*( -6( -$%5+*#0*(*5($!0*-50(

*7!($#-0(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(-0(*7!(6*+/2*/+#&(%!+,5+$#02!(5,(*7!(45-0*( *559(:58!;!+<(65$!(5,(*756!($51!&6(#66/$!1(*7#*(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(8!+!(-65*+5%-2(5+(6=$$!*+-2(G50&=(8-*7(*!06-50(

?-0.(#%%#+!0*(%+5%!+*-!6(,5+(*7!(&#$-0#*!69(Q0(CDOR<(S/2!5.&/(#01(T%1-B!(-$%+5;!1(:#+*?N$-*7M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(!,,!2*6( -0(*7!(#17!+!0*9(J7!=(6758!1(*7#*(

?-*=(-0(67!#+(&5#1-0.<( *7!(05+$#&(6*+#-06(2#0(#,,!2*( *7!(6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!9(J75$6!0(GCDDUI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(-0(*7!(5;!+&#%(&!0.*7(+!1/2!6(*7!(6*+!66(&!;!&(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+9(J7!(+!6!#+27!+(2502&/1!1(*7#*(*7!(#%%&-2#*-50(5,(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(8-*7(&58!+(!&#6*-2(67!#+(#01(*!06-&!($51/&-(

-6()!**!+(*5(/6!(-1!0*-2#&(5+(0!#+&=(-1!0*-2#&(#17!+!0*6(-0()501?!1(45-0*6<(-9!9<(#17!+!0*6(8-*7(6-$-&#+(6*-,,0!669(V+56*-.(!"#$%9(GCDDFI(%+5%56!1(#0(#%%+5#27(/6-0.(7-.7?5+1!+(*7!5+=9(Q0(*7!-+(#0#&=6-6<(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6($51!&!1(#6(#0(!&#6*-2(250*-0//$($!1-#(GUW(#01(EWI9(N5<(*7!(#17!6-;!(25/&1(*+#06,!+(05+$#&(

6*+!66!6<(-0?%&#0!(#01(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(6*+!66!69(J7!6!(+!6/&*6(6758!1(*7#*(*7!+!(8#6(#(.+!#*(;#+-#*-50(5,(*7!(05+$#&(6*+!66(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(2&56!(*5(*7!(!1.!69

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

*7!(#1;#0*#.!6(5,(/6-0.(#(6=$$!*+-2(25$%56-*!(%#*27(-0(5+1!+(*5(+!%#-+(*7!(1#$#.!(%#+*63(#&65<(*7#*(15/)&!(%#*27(7#1(&58!+(6*+!66(87!0(25$%#+!1(8-*7(6-0.&!(%#*27(+!%#-+9(@!.#+1-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(%#+#$!*!+6<(N!50.(!"#$%9(GUPPFI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(5,()501-0.(%+!66/+!(1/+-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(&!#16(*5(7-.7!+(6*+!0.*7()501!1(45-0*69(J7!(+!6!#+27?

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̀ #+%!&50(GUPPFI(2#++-!1(5/*(

#0#&=6!6(*5(!;#&/#*!(*7!($!27#0-2#&()!7#;-5+(5,(6-0.&!(#01(6*!%%!1(45-0*69(`#+%!&50(2502&/1!1(*7#*(H5+*!06!0M6($51!&(%+51/2!6(.551(+!6/&*6(,5+(6=$$!*+-2(&#$-0#*!6<()/*(,5+(&#$-?0#*!6(8-*7(7-.7!+(#6=$$!*+=<(*7!($51!&(675/&1()!(-$%+5;!19(

7=%5*7!6-6<(87-27(-6(05*(#1!\/#*!(*5(6-$/&#*!(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(

@-)!-+5<(H9Y9<(J-*#<(A9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!E$B!FF8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !FA

Page 39: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&!'()!**!+(,#*-./!(!01/+#02!3(45-0-0.(1-66-$-&#+($#*!+-#&63()!**!+(-06/&#*-503(6$55*7(6/+,#2!(#01(&58!+(8!-.7*9(:58!;!+<(*7!+!(#+!(#&65(0!.#*-;!(#6%!2*6<(,5+(!"#$%&!'(05(%566-)-&-*=(*5(1-6#66!$)&!(*7!(45-0*63(%!!&-0.(6*+!66(675/&1()!($-0-$->!1(#01(*7!(%+!%#+#*-50(5,(*7!(6/+,#2!6(,5+()501-0.($/6*()!(150!(2#+!?

6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0()501!1(45-0*6(#01($#0=(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(

( @!.#+1-0.(*7-6(62!0#+-5<($#0=(+!6!#+27!+6(7#;!(2501/2*!1(6*/1-!6(#)5/*()501!1(45-0*6<(*+=-0.(*5(%+!1-2*(*7!-+($!27#0-?

!"%!+-$!0*#&(*!6*6(5+(7=)+-1(#%%+5#27!6<(25$)-0-0.(*7!5+!*-?

45-0*6(8!+!( 2#++-!1(5/*( )=(A5&B!+6!0( -0( CDEF( GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(A5&B!+6!0($51!&!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(#6(67!#+(6%+-0.(

?/+#&(!,,!2*6(GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(J7!(+!6/&*6(5)*#-0!1()=(*7!(+!6!#+27!+(6758!1(*7#*(*7!(&5#1(*+#06,!+(#*(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6(05*(/0-,5+$9(K5&#01(#01(@!-660!+( GCDLLI( -$%+5;!1(A5&B?!+6!0M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.( *7!(#17!+!0*( &-B!()!#$6(#01(*7!(#17!6-;!(&-B!(6%+-0.6(-0(*!06-50(#01(67!#+(&5#1-0.9(J7#*($51!&(25/&1(#0#&=>!(*7!(1-6*+-)/*-50(5,(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(&5#1?-0.(-01/2!1()=(*7!(6!2501#+=($5$!0*<(87-27(522/+6(-0(6-0.&!(&#%(45-0*69(:#+*?N$-*7(GCDOP3(CDOEI<()#6!1(50(*7!(&#6*($51!&6<(

$#*!+-#&69(:#+*?N$-*7(6-$/&#*!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(+!6%506!<(/6-0.(#0(!&#6*-2?%&#6*-2($#*!+-#&($51!&9(Q*( -6( -$%5+*#0*(*5($!0*-50(

*7!($#-0(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(-0(*7!(6*+/2*/+#&(%!+,5+$#02!(5,(*7!(45-0*( *559(:58!;!+<(65$!(5,(*756!($51!&6(#66/$!1(*7#*(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(8!+!(-65*+5%-2(5+(6=$$!*+-2(G50&=(8-*7(*!06-50(

?-0.(#%%#+!0*(%+5%!+*-!6(,5+(*7!(&#$-0#*!69(Q0(CDOR<(S/2!5.&/(#01(T%1-B!(-$%+5;!1(:#+*?N$-*7M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(!,,!2*6( -0(*7!(#17!+!0*9(J7!=(6758!1(*7#*(

?-*=(-0(67!#+(&5#1-0.<( *7!(05+$#&(6*+#-06(2#0(#,,!2*( *7!(6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!9(J75$6!0(GCDDUI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(-0(*7!(5;!+&#%(&!0.*7(+!1/2!6(*7!(6*+!66(&!;!&(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+9(J7!(+!6!#+27!+(2502&/1!1(*7#*(*7!(#%%&-2#*-50(5,(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(8-*7(&58!+(!&#6*-2(67!#+(#01(*!06-&!($51/&-(

-6()!**!+(*5(/6!(-1!0*-2#&(5+(0!#+&=(-1!0*-2#&(#17!+!0*6(-0()501?!1(45-0*6<(-9!9<(#17!+!0*6(8-*7(6-$-&#+(6*-,,0!669(V+56*-.(!"#$%9(GCDDFI(%+5%56!1(#0(#%%+5#27(/6-0.(7-.7?5+1!+(*7!5+=9(Q0(*7!-+(#0#&=6-6<(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6($51!&!1(#6(#0(!&#6*-2(250*-0//$($!1-#(GUW(#01(EWI9(N5<(*7!(#17!6-;!(25/&1(*+#06,!+(05+$#&(

6*+!66!6<(-0?%&#0!(#01(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(6*+!66!69(J7!6!(+!6/&*6(6758!1(*7#*(*7!+!(8#6(#(.+!#*(;#+-#*-50(5,(*7!(05+$#&(6*+!66(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(2&56!(*5(*7!(!1.!69

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

*7!(#1;#0*#.!6(5,(/6-0.(#(6=$$!*+-2(25$%56-*!(%#*27(-0(5+1!+(*5(+!%#-+(*7!(1#$#.!(%#+*63(#&65<(*7#*(15/)&!(%#*27(7#1(&58!+(6*+!66(87!0(25$%#+!1(8-*7(6-0.&!(%#*27(+!%#-+9(@!.#+1-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(%#+#$!*!+6<(N!50.(!"#$%9(GUPPFI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(5,()501-0.(%+!66/+!(1/+-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(&!#16(*5(7-.7!+(6*+!0.*7()501!1(45-0*69(J7!(+!6!#+27?

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̀ #+%!&50(GUPPFI(2#++-!1(5/*(

#0#&=6!6(*5(!;#&/#*!(*7!($!27#0-2#&()!7#;-5+(5,(6-0.&!(#01(6*!%%!1(45-0*69(`#+%!&50(2502&/1!1(*7#*(H5+*!06!0M6($51!&(%+51/2!6(.551(+!6/&*6(,5+(6=$$!*+-2(&#$-0#*!6<()/*(,5+(&#$-?0#*!6(8-*7(7-.7!+(#6=$$!*+=<(*7!($51!&(675/&1()!(-$%+5;!19(

7=%5*7!6-6<(87-27(-6(05*(#1!\/#*!(*5(6-$/&#*!(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(

@-)!-+5<(H9Y9<(J-*#<(A9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!E$B!FF8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!F"

Page 40: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&!'()!**!+(,#*-./!(!01/+#02!3(45-0-0.(1-66-$-&#+($#*!+-#&63()!**!+(-06/&#*-503(6$55*7(6/+,#2!(#01(&58!+(8!-.7*9(:58!;!+<(*7!+!(#+!(#&65(0!.#*-;!(#6%!2*6<(,5+(!"#$%&!'(05(%566-)-&-*=(*5(1-6#66!$)&!(*7!(45-0*63(%!!&-0.(6*+!66(675/&1()!($-0-$->!1(#01(*7!(%+!%#+#*-50(5,(*7!(6/+,#2!6(,5+()501-0.($/6*()!(150!(2#+!?

6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0()501!1(45-0*6(#01($#0=(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(

( @!.#+1-0.(*7-6(62!0#+-5<($#0=(+!6!#+27!+6(7#;!(2501/2*!1(6*/1-!6(#)5/*()501!1(45-0*6<(*+=-0.(*5(%+!1-2*(*7!-+($!27#0-?

!"%!+-$!0*#&(*!6*6(5+(7=)+-1(#%%+5#27!6<(25$)-0-0.(*7!5+!*-?

45-0*6(8!+!( 2#++-!1(5/*( )=(A5&B!+6!0( -0( CDEF( GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(A5&B!+6!0($51!&!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(#6(67!#+(6%+-0.(

?/+#&(!,,!2*6(GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(J7!(+!6/&*6(5)*#-0!1()=(*7!(+!6!#+27!+(6758!1(*7#*(*7!(&5#1(*+#06,!+(#*(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6(05*(/0-,5+$9(K5&#01(#01(@!-660!+( GCDLLI( -$%+5;!1(A5&B?!+6!0M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.( *7!(#17!+!0*( &-B!()!#$6(#01(*7!(#17!6-;!(&-B!(6%+-0.6(-0(*!06-50(#01(67!#+(&5#1-0.9(J7#*($51!&(25/&1(#0#&=>!(*7!(1-6*+-)/*-50(5,(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(&5#1?-0.(-01/2!1()=(*7!(6!2501#+=($5$!0*<(87-27(522/+6(-0(6-0.&!(&#%(45-0*69(:#+*?N$-*7(GCDOP3(CDOEI<()#6!1(50(*7!(&#6*($51!&6<(

$#*!+-#&69(:#+*?N$-*7(6-$/&#*!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(+!6%506!<(/6-0.(#0(!&#6*-2?%&#6*-2($#*!+-#&($51!&9(Q*( -6( -$%5+*#0*(*5($!0*-50(

*7!($#-0(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(-0(*7!(6*+/2*/+#&(%!+,5+$#02!(5,(*7!(45-0*( *559(:58!;!+<(65$!(5,(*756!($51!&6(#66/$!1(*7#*(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(8!+!(-65*+5%-2(5+(6=$$!*+-2(G50&=(8-*7(*!06-50(

?-0.(#%%#+!0*(%+5%!+*-!6(,5+(*7!(&#$-0#*!69(Q0(CDOR<(S/2!5.&/(#01(T%1-B!(-$%+5;!1(:#+*?N$-*7M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(!,,!2*6( -0(*7!(#17!+!0*9(J7!=(6758!1(*7#*(

?-*=(-0(67!#+(&5#1-0.<( *7!(05+$#&(6*+#-06(2#0(#,,!2*( *7!(6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!9(J75$6!0(GCDDUI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(-0(*7!(5;!+&#%(&!0.*7(+!1/2!6(*7!(6*+!66(&!;!&(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+9(J7!(+!6!#+27!+(2502&/1!1(*7#*(*7!(#%%&-2#*-50(5,(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(8-*7(&58!+(!&#6*-2(67!#+(#01(*!06-&!($51/&-(

-6()!**!+(*5(/6!(-1!0*-2#&(5+(0!#+&=(-1!0*-2#&(#17!+!0*6(-0()501?!1(45-0*6<(-9!9<(#17!+!0*6(8-*7(6-$-&#+(6*-,,0!669(V+56*-.(!"#$%9(GCDDFI(%+5%56!1(#0(#%%+5#27(/6-0.(7-.7?5+1!+(*7!5+=9(Q0(*7!-+(#0#&=6-6<(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6($51!&!1(#6(#0(!&#6*-2(250*-0//$($!1-#(GUW(#01(EWI9(N5<(*7!(#17!6-;!(25/&1(*+#06,!+(05+$#&(

6*+!66!6<(-0?%&#0!(#01(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(6*+!66!69(J7!6!(+!6/&*6(6758!1(*7#*(*7!+!(8#6(#(.+!#*(;#+-#*-50(5,(*7!(05+$#&(6*+!66(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(2&56!(*5(*7!(!1.!69

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

*7!(#1;#0*#.!6(5,(/6-0.(#(6=$$!*+-2(25$%56-*!(%#*27(-0(5+1!+(*5(+!%#-+(*7!(1#$#.!(%#+*63(#&65<(*7#*(15/)&!(%#*27(7#1(&58!+(6*+!66(87!0(25$%#+!1(8-*7(6-0.&!(%#*27(+!%#-+9(@!.#+1-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(%#+#$!*!+6<(N!50.(!"#$%9(GUPPFI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(5,()501-0.(%+!66/+!(1/+-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(&!#16(*5(7-.7!+(6*+!0.*7()501!1(45-0*69(J7!(+!6!#+27?

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̀ #+%!&50(GUPPFI(2#++-!1(5/*(

#0#&=6!6(*5(!;#&/#*!(*7!($!27#0-2#&()!7#;-5+(5,(6-0.&!(#01(6*!%%!1(45-0*69(`#+%!&50(2502&/1!1(*7#*(H5+*!06!0M6($51!&(%+51/2!6(.551(+!6/&*6(,5+(6=$$!*+-2(&#$-0#*!6<()/*(,5+(&#$-?0#*!6(8-*7(7-.7!+(#6=$$!*+=<(*7!($51!&(675/&1()!(-$%+5;!19(

7=%5*7!6-6<(87-27(-6(05*(#1!\/#*!(*5(6-$/&#*!(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(

@-)!-+5<(H9Y9<(J-*#<(A9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!E$B!FF8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !F$

Page 41: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&!'()!**!+(,#*-./!(!01/+#02!3(45-0-0.(1-66-$-&#+($#*!+-#&63()!**!+(-06/&#*-503(6$55*7(6/+,#2!(#01(&58!+(8!-.7*9(:58!;!+<(*7!+!(#+!(#&65(0!.#*-;!(#6%!2*6<(,5+(!"#$%&!'(05(%566-)-&-*=(*5(1-6#66!$)&!(*7!(45-0*63(%!!&-0.(6*+!66(675/&1()!($-0-$->!1(#01(*7!(%+!%#+#*-50(5,(*7!(6/+,#2!6(,5+()501-0.($/6*()!(150!(2#+!?

6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0()501!1(45-0*6(#01($#0=(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(

( @!.#+1-0.(*7-6(62!0#+-5<($#0=(+!6!#+27!+6(7#;!(2501/2*!1(6*/1-!6(#)5/*()501!1(45-0*6<(*+=-0.(*5(%+!1-2*(*7!-+($!27#0-?

!"%!+-$!0*#&(*!6*6(5+(7=)+-1(#%%+5#27!6<(25$)-0-0.(*7!5+!*-?

45-0*6(8!+!( 2#++-!1(5/*( )=(A5&B!+6!0( -0( CDEF( GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(A5&B!+6!0($51!&!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(#6(67!#+(6%+-0.(

?/+#&(!,,!2*6(GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(J7!(+!6/&*6(5)*#-0!1()=(*7!(+!6!#+27!+(6758!1(*7#*(*7!(&5#1(*+#06,!+(#*(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6(05*(/0-,5+$9(K5&#01(#01(@!-660!+( GCDLLI( -$%+5;!1(A5&B?!+6!0M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.( *7!(#17!+!0*( &-B!()!#$6(#01(*7!(#17!6-;!(&-B!(6%+-0.6(-0(*!06-50(#01(67!#+(&5#1-0.9(J7#*($51!&(25/&1(#0#&=>!(*7!(1-6*+-)/*-50(5,(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(&5#1?-0.(-01/2!1()=(*7!(6!2501#+=($5$!0*<(87-27(522/+6(-0(6-0.&!(&#%(45-0*69(:#+*?N$-*7(GCDOP3(CDOEI<()#6!1(50(*7!(&#6*($51!&6<(

$#*!+-#&69(:#+*?N$-*7(6-$/&#*!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(+!6%506!<(/6-0.(#0(!&#6*-2?%&#6*-2($#*!+-#&($51!&9(Q*( -6( -$%5+*#0*(*5($!0*-50(

*7!($#-0(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(-0(*7!(6*+/2*/+#&(%!+,5+$#02!(5,(*7!(45-0*( *559(:58!;!+<(65$!(5,(*756!($51!&6(#66/$!1(*7#*(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(8!+!(-65*+5%-2(5+(6=$$!*+-2(G50&=(8-*7(*!06-50(

?-0.(#%%#+!0*(%+5%!+*-!6(,5+(*7!(&#$-0#*!69(Q0(CDOR<(S/2!5.&/(#01(T%1-B!(-$%+5;!1(:#+*?N$-*7M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(!,,!2*6( -0(*7!(#17!+!0*9(J7!=(6758!1(*7#*(

?-*=(-0(67!#+(&5#1-0.<( *7!(05+$#&(6*+#-06(2#0(#,,!2*( *7!(6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!9(J75$6!0(GCDDUI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(-0(*7!(5;!+&#%(&!0.*7(+!1/2!6(*7!(6*+!66(&!;!&(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+9(J7!(+!6!#+27!+(2502&/1!1(*7#*(*7!(#%%&-2#*-50(5,(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(8-*7(&58!+(!&#6*-2(67!#+(#01(*!06-&!($51/&-(

-6()!**!+(*5(/6!(-1!0*-2#&(5+(0!#+&=(-1!0*-2#&(#17!+!0*6(-0()501?!1(45-0*6<(-9!9<(#17!+!0*6(8-*7(6-$-&#+(6*-,,0!669(V+56*-.(!"#$%9(GCDDFI(%+5%56!1(#0(#%%+5#27(/6-0.(7-.7?5+1!+(*7!5+=9(Q0(*7!-+(#0#&=6-6<(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6($51!&!1(#6(#0(!&#6*-2(250*-0//$($!1-#(GUW(#01(EWI9(N5<(*7!(#17!6-;!(25/&1(*+#06,!+(05+$#&(

6*+!66!6<(-0?%&#0!(#01(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(6*+!66!69(J7!6!(+!6/&*6(6758!1(*7#*(*7!+!(8#6(#(.+!#*(;#+-#*-50(5,(*7!(05+$#&(6*+!66(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(2&56!(*5(*7!(!1.!69

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

*7!(#1;#0*#.!6(5,(/6-0.(#(6=$$!*+-2(25$%56-*!(%#*27(-0(5+1!+(*5(+!%#-+(*7!(1#$#.!(%#+*63(#&65<(*7#*(15/)&!(%#*27(7#1(&58!+(6*+!66(87!0(25$%#+!1(8-*7(6-0.&!(%#*27(+!%#-+9(@!.#+1-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(%#+#$!*!+6<(N!50.(!"#$%9(GUPPFI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(5,()501-0.(%+!66/+!(1/+-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(&!#16(*5(7-.7!+(6*+!0.*7()501!1(45-0*69(J7!(+!6!#+27?

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̀ #+%!&50(GUPPFI(2#++-!1(5/*(

#0#&=6!6(*5(!;#&/#*!(*7!($!27#0-2#&()!7#;-5+(5,(6-0.&!(#01(6*!%%!1(45-0*69(`#+%!&50(2502&/1!1(*7#*(H5+*!06!0M6($51!&(%+51/2!6(.551(+!6/&*6(,5+(6=$$!*+-2(&#$-0#*!6<()/*(,5+(&#$-?0#*!6(8-*7(7-.7!+(#6=$$!*+=<(*7!($51!&(675/&1()!(-$%+5;!19(

7=%5*7!6-6<(87-27(-6(05*(#1!\/#*!(*5(6-$/&#*!(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(

@-)!-+5<(H9Y9<(J-*#<(A9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!E$B!FF8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!FD

Page 42: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&!'()!**!+(,#*-./!(!01/+#02!3(45-0-0.(1-66-$-&#+($#*!+-#&63()!**!+(-06/&#*-503(6$55*7(6/+,#2!(#01(&58!+(8!-.7*9(:58!;!+<(*7!+!(#+!(#&65(0!.#*-;!(#6%!2*6<(,5+(!"#$%&!'(05(%566-)-&-*=(*5(1-6#66!$)&!(*7!(45-0*63(%!!&-0.(6*+!66(675/&1()!($-0-$->!1(#01(*7!(%+!%#+#*-50(5,(*7!(6/+,#2!6(,5+()501-0.($/6*()!(150!(2#+!?

6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0()501!1(45-0*6(#01($#0=(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(

( @!.#+1-0.(*7-6(62!0#+-5<($#0=(+!6!#+27!+6(7#;!(2501/2*!1(6*/1-!6(#)5/*()501!1(45-0*6<(*+=-0.(*5(%+!1-2*(*7!-+($!27#0-?

!"%!+-$!0*#&(*!6*6(5+(7=)+-1(#%%+5#27!6<(25$)-0-0.(*7!5+!*-?

45-0*6(8!+!( 2#++-!1(5/*( )=(A5&B!+6!0( -0( CDEF( GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(A5&B!+6!0($51!&!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(#6(67!#+(6%+-0.(

?/+#&(!,,!2*6(GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(J7!(+!6/&*6(5)*#-0!1()=(*7!(+!6!#+27!+(6758!1(*7#*(*7!(&5#1(*+#06,!+(#*(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6(05*(/0-,5+$9(K5&#01(#01(@!-660!+( GCDLLI( -$%+5;!1(A5&B?!+6!0M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.( *7!(#17!+!0*( &-B!()!#$6(#01(*7!(#17!6-;!(&-B!(6%+-0.6(-0(*!06-50(#01(67!#+(&5#1-0.9(J7#*($51!&(25/&1(#0#&=>!(*7!(1-6*+-)/*-50(5,(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(&5#1?-0.(-01/2!1()=(*7!(6!2501#+=($5$!0*<(87-27(522/+6(-0(6-0.&!(&#%(45-0*69(:#+*?N$-*7(GCDOP3(CDOEI<()#6!1(50(*7!(&#6*($51!&6<(

$#*!+-#&69(:#+*?N$-*7(6-$/&#*!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(+!6%506!<(/6-0.(#0(!&#6*-2?%&#6*-2($#*!+-#&($51!&9(Q*( -6( -$%5+*#0*(*5($!0*-50(

*7!($#-0(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(-0(*7!(6*+/2*/+#&(%!+,5+$#02!(5,(*7!(45-0*( *559(:58!;!+<(65$!(5,(*756!($51!&6(#66/$!1(*7#*(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(8!+!(-65*+5%-2(5+(6=$$!*+-2(G50&=(8-*7(*!06-50(

?-0.(#%%#+!0*(%+5%!+*-!6(,5+(*7!(&#$-0#*!69(Q0(CDOR<(S/2!5.&/(#01(T%1-B!(-$%+5;!1(:#+*?N$-*7M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(!,,!2*6( -0(*7!(#17!+!0*9(J7!=(6758!1(*7#*(

?-*=(-0(67!#+(&5#1-0.<( *7!(05+$#&(6*+#-06(2#0(#,,!2*( *7!(6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!9(J75$6!0(GCDDUI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(-0(*7!(5;!+&#%(&!0.*7(+!1/2!6(*7!(6*+!66(&!;!&(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+9(J7!(+!6!#+27!+(2502&/1!1(*7#*(*7!(#%%&-2#*-50(5,(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(8-*7(&58!+(!&#6*-2(67!#+(#01(*!06-&!($51/&-(

-6()!**!+(*5(/6!(-1!0*-2#&(5+(0!#+&=(-1!0*-2#&(#17!+!0*6(-0()501?!1(45-0*6<(-9!9<(#17!+!0*6(8-*7(6-$-&#+(6*-,,0!669(V+56*-.(!"#$%9(GCDDFI(%+5%56!1(#0(#%%+5#27(/6-0.(7-.7?5+1!+(*7!5+=9(Q0(*7!-+(#0#&=6-6<(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6($51!&!1(#6(#0(!&#6*-2(250*-0//$($!1-#(GUW(#01(EWI9(N5<(*7!(#17!6-;!(25/&1(*+#06,!+(05+$#&(

6*+!66!6<(-0?%&#0!(#01(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(6*+!66!69(J7!6!(+!6/&*6(6758!1(*7#*(*7!+!(8#6(#(.+!#*(;#+-#*-50(5,(*7!(05+$#&(6*+!66(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(2&56!(*5(*7!(!1.!69

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

*7!(#1;#0*#.!6(5,(/6-0.(#(6=$$!*+-2(25$%56-*!(%#*27(-0(5+1!+(*5(+!%#-+(*7!(1#$#.!(%#+*63(#&65<(*7#*(15/)&!(%#*27(7#1(&58!+(6*+!66(87!0(25$%#+!1(8-*7(6-0.&!(%#*27(+!%#-+9(@!.#+1-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(%#+#$!*!+6<(N!50.(!"#$%9(GUPPFI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(5,()501-0.(%+!66/+!(1/+-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(&!#16(*5(7-.7!+(6*+!0.*7()501!1(45-0*69(J7!(+!6!#+27?

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̀ #+%!&50(GUPPFI(2#++-!1(5/*(

#0#&=6!6(*5(!;#&/#*!(*7!($!27#0-2#&()!7#;-5+(5,(6-0.&!(#01(6*!%%!1(45-0*69(`#+%!&50(2502&/1!1(*7#*(H5+*!06!0M6($51!&(%+51/2!6(.551(+!6/&*6(,5+(6=$$!*+-2(&#$-0#*!6<()/*(,5+(&#$-?0#*!6(8-*7(7-.7!+(#6=$$!*+=<(*7!($51!&(675/&1()!(-$%+5;!19(

7=%5*7!6-6<(87-27(-6(05*(#1!\/#*!(*5(6-$/&#*!(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(

@-)!-+5<(H9Y9<(J-*#<(A9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!E$B!FF8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !FE

Page 43: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&!'()!**!+(,#*-./!(!01/+#02!3(45-0-0.(1-66-$-&#+($#*!+-#&63()!**!+(-06/&#*-503(6$55*7(6/+,#2!(#01(&58!+(8!-.7*9(:58!;!+<(*7!+!(#+!(#&65(0!.#*-;!(#6%!2*6<(,5+(!"#$%&!'(05(%566-)-&-*=(*5(1-6#66!$)&!(*7!(45-0*63(%!!&-0.(6*+!66(675/&1()!($-0-$->!1(#01(*7!(%+!%#+#*-50(5,(*7!(6/+,#2!6(,5+()501-0.($/6*()!(150!(2#+!?

6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0()501!1(45-0*6(#01($#0=(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(

( @!.#+1-0.(*7-6(62!0#+-5<($#0=(+!6!#+27!+6(7#;!(2501/2*!1(6*/1-!6(#)5/*()501!1(45-0*6<(*+=-0.(*5(%+!1-2*(*7!-+($!27#0-?

!"%!+-$!0*#&(*!6*6(5+(7=)+-1(#%%+5#27!6<(25$)-0-0.(*7!5+!*-?

45-0*6(8!+!( 2#++-!1(5/*( )=(A5&B!+6!0( -0( CDEF( GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(A5&B!+6!0($51!&!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(#6(67!#+(6%+-0.(

?/+#&(!,,!2*6(GH5+*!06!0<(CDDFI9(J7!(+!6/&*6(5)*#-0!1()=(*7!(+!6!#+27!+(6758!1(*7#*(*7!(&5#1(*+#06,!+(#*(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6(05*(/0-,5+$9(K5&#01(#01(@!-660!+( GCDLLI( -$%+5;!1(A5&B?!+6!0M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.( *7!(#17!+!0*( &-B!()!#$6(#01(*7!(#17!6-;!(&-B!(6%+-0.6(-0(*!06-50(#01(67!#+(&5#1-0.9(J7#*($51!&(25/&1(#0#&=>!(*7!(1-6*+-)/*-50(5,(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(&5#1?-0.(-01/2!1()=(*7!(6!2501#+=($5$!0*<(87-27(522/+6(-0(6-0.&!(&#%(45-0*69(:#+*?N$-*7(GCDOP3(CDOEI<()#6!1(50(*7!(&#6*($51!&6<(

$#*!+-#&69(:#+*?N$-*7(6-$/&#*!1(*7!(#17!6-;!(+!6%506!<(/6-0.(#0(!&#6*-2?%&#6*-2($#*!+-#&($51!&9(Q*( -6( -$%5+*#0*(*5($!0*-50(

*7!($#-0(1!6-.0(%#+#$!*!+6(-0(*7!(6*+/2*/+#&(%!+,5+$#02!(5,(*7!(45-0*( *559(:58!;!+<(65$!(5,(*756!($51!&6(#66/$!1(*7#*(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(8!+!(-65*+5%-2(5+(6=$$!*+-2(G50&=(8-*7(*!06-50(

?-0.(#%%#+!0*(%+5%!+*-!6(,5+(*7!(&#$-0#*!69(Q0(CDOR<(S/2!5.&/(#01(T%1-B!(-$%+5;!1(:#+*?N$-*7M6($51!&()=(2506-1!+-0.(*7!(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(!,,!2*6( -0(*7!(#17!+!0*9(J7!=(6758!1(*7#*(

?-*=(-0(67!#+(&5#1-0.<( *7!(05+$#&(6*+#-06(2#0(#,,!2*( *7!(6*+!66(1-6*+-)/*-50(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!9(J75$6!0(GCDDUI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(-0(*7!(5;!+&#%(&!0.*7(+!1/2!6(*7!(6*+!66(&!;!&(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(&#=!+9(J7!(+!6!#+27!+(2502&/1!1(*7#*(*7!(#%%&-2#*-50(5,(#17!6-;!(&#=!+(8-*7(&58!+(!&#6*-2(67!#+(#01(*!06-&!($51/&-(

-6()!**!+(*5(/6!(-1!0*-2#&(5+(0!#+&=(-1!0*-2#&(#17!+!0*6(-0()501?!1(45-0*6<(-9!9<(#17!+!0*6(8-*7(6-$-&#+(6*-,,0!669(V+56*-.(!"#$%9(GCDDFI(%+5%56!1(#0(#%%+5#27(/6-0.(7-.7?5+1!+(*7!5+=9(Q0(*7!-+(#0#&=6-6<(*7!(#17!6-;!(8#6($51!&!1(#6(#0(!&#6*-2(250*-0//$($!1-#(GUW(#01(EWI9(N5<(*7!(#17!6-;!(25/&1(*+#06,!+(05+$#&(

6*+!66!6<(-0?%&#0!(#01(*+#06;!+6#&(67!#+(6*+!66!69(J7!6!(+!6/&*6(6758!1(*7#*(*7!+!(8#6(#(.+!#*(;#+-#*-50(5,(*7!(05+$#&(6*+!66(-0(*7!(#17!6-;!(2&56!(*5(*7!(!1.!69

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

*7!(#1;#0*#.!6(5,(/6-0.(#(6=$$!*+-2(25$%56-*!(%#*27(-0(5+1!+(*5(+!%#-+(*7!(1#$#.!(%#+*63(#&65<(*7#*(15/)&!(%#*27(7#1(&58!+(6*+!66(87!0(25$%#+!1(8-*7(6-0.&!(%#*27(+!%#-+9(@!.#+1-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(%#+#$!*!+6<(N!50.(!"#$%9(GUPPFI(6758!1(*7#*(#0(-02+!#6!(5,()501-0.(%+!66/+!(1/+-0.(*7!($#0/,#2*/+-0.(%+52!66(&!#16(*5(7-.7!+(6*+!0.*7()501!1(45-0*69(J7!(+!6!#+27?

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̀ #+%!&50(GUPPFI(2#++-!1(5/*(

#0#&=6!6(*5(!;#&/#*!(*7!($!27#0-2#&()!7#;-5+(5,(6-0.&!(#01(6*!%%!1(45-0*69(`#+%!&50(2502&/1!1(*7#*(H5+*!06!0M6($51!&(%+51/2!6(.551(+!6/&*6(,5+(6=$$!*+-2(&#$-0#*!6<()/*(,5+(&#$-?0#*!6(8-*7(7-.7!+(#6=$$!*+=<(*7!($51!&(675/&1()!(-$%+5;!19(

7=%5*7!6-6<(87-27(-6(05*(#1!\/#*!(*5(6-$/&#*!(*7!(&#$-0#*!6(

@-)!-+5<(H9Y9<(J-*#<(A9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!E$B!FF8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!FF

Page 44: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&'%()*&+,-#

!"#$ $ $ $ $ !%&'&()*!+!$$ $ $ $ !%&$+&(,-./&*(*%/,$!--/'%(*%/,!01$$ $ $ $ !'&23/,%*&%34$56*(7%4,4$-*2&4,48+$942-$$ $ 84-%:,$*%;4$942-<#1$$ $ $ $ <,=%&/,;4,*(3$#/,*&/3$12-*4;-

"+$*&./)$"&+

$ >,4$/)$/6&$-*&(*4:%'$'6-*/;4&-$?(-$(..&/('?47$6-$%,$74=43@>,4$/)$/6&$-*&(*4:%'$'6-*/;4&-$?(-$(..&/('?47$6-$%,$74=43@/.%,:$%,,/=(*%=4$5&('94*$74-%:,$'/,'4.*-$)/&$*?4$%,-*(33(*%/,$/)$(%&'&()*$-2-*4;-A$1%,'4$*?4$5&('94*$%,-*(33(*%/,$B/,4$%-$(&/6,7$*?4$)&(;4$(&4($CD%:A$E(F$5G$(**('?47$*/$)6-43(:4$-*&6'*6&4F$ %*$

%-$,4'4--(&2$ */$9,/H$(5/6*$-/;4$5(-%'$-*&6'*6&(3$434;4,*-$*?&/6:?$H?%'?$*?4$&/6*%,:$/)$(%&$76'*-$(,7$'(534$56,734-$*(94-$.3('4A$+?4$-*67%47$B/,4$%-$4I*4,747$/,$)6-43(:4$(&4($'/=4&%,:$%*-$4,*%&4$-4'*%/,-$)/&$*?4$(..3%'(*%/,$/)$5&('94*$%,-*(33(*%/,A

(0121345%6517257186

)6-43(:4F$H%,:-F$4;.4,,(:4$C-*(5%3%B4&-F$&6774&F$(,7$434=(@

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

"99:;350;8% <132=85% .860>9% ):928?56% 4:1% 5@8% "9653AA350:9% :4%(0121345%#B658C6(D0=0%#0;303@EL,)/*4'?$<,*4&.&%-4-$M%;%*47F$0(,:(3/&4$@$L,7%(

!"#$%&'$(!

!

)*+,-%.#(

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!F#B!#$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !F#

Page 45: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

;/-*$'&%*%'(3$-*&6'*6&4$-%,'4$ %*$'(&&%4-$(33$ *?4$.&%;(&2$ 3/(7-$764$ */$)6-43(:4$54,7%,:F$-?4(&F$ */&-%/,F$(,7$'(5%,$.&4--6&4$

$ D&(;4-$ CD%:A$KG$ (&4$ &43(*%=432$ 3%:?*$ -*&6'*6&(3$ 434;4,*-F$H?%'?$(&4$:4,4&(332$;(74$6.$/)$&/3347$/&$-*&4*'?$)/&;47$-?44*$/&$4I*&6747$-4'*%/,-A$+?4$)6-43(:4$3/,:%*67%,(3$;4;54&-$.(--$*?&/6:?$'6*/6*-$%,$*?4$)&(;4-$(,7$(&4$(**('?47$52$'34(*-$*/$*?4$)&(;4-$H45-A$+?4$3/,:%*67%,(3$;4;54&-$*4&;%,(*4$(*$*?4$)/&H(&7$(,7$&4(&$)('4-$/)$*?4$;(N/&$5639?4(7-A$ +?4$3/,:4&/,-$(&4$/)$&43(*%=432$?4(=2$-4'*%/,-$'/;.(&47$*/$*?4$-*&%,:4&-A$0/*?$/)$*?4;$H4&4$;(74$6.$/)$&/3347$/&$4I*&('*47$

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

(01%$1396?:15%(66:20350:9%2@3?5816

$ +?4$ (%&'&()*$ -2-*4;-$ (&4$ .&/=%747$ H%*?$ -4=4&(3$ !+!$

&4)4&4,'%,:$-*(,7(&7-$)/&$(33$'/;;4&'%(3$(%&'&()*$7/'6;4,*(@*%/,A$+?%-$-*(,7(&7%B(*%/,$(33/H-$:&4(*4&$4(-4$/)$34(&,%,:$(,7$6,74&-*(,7%,:$)/&$(33$ *4'?,%'(3$-*(94?/374&-$/)$ *?4$(%&'&()*F$-6'?$(-$.%3/*-F$(%&'&()*$;(%,*4,(,'4$ *4'?,%'%(,-F$(,7$4,:%@,44&-A$ +?4$ -*(,7(&7$ ,6;54&%,:$ -2-*4;$ %-$ '/,*&/3347$ (,7$.653%-?47$52$*?4$!+!A

!+!@JE$'?(.*4&A$+?4$(%&$'/,7%*%/,%,:$-2-*4;$%-$'/;./-47$/)$6,%*-$(,7$'/;./,4,*-F$H?%'?$)6&,%-?$;4(,-$/)$.&4--6&%B%,:F$

*?4$(%&$6-47$*/$=4,*%3(*4$*?4$(&4(-$/)$*?4$)6-43(:4$H%*?%,$*?4$.&4--6&4$-4(3-A$+?4$-2-*4;$%,'3674-$'(5%,$-6.4&'?(&:4&F$4O6%.@;4,*$'//3%,:F$?4(*4&F$?4(*4&$)643$-2-*4;F$4I.(,-%/,$*6&5%,4F$=(3=4-F$-'//.-F$76'*-F$(,7$-/$/,A

1%=(%(?F$!A

D%:6&4$KA$D6-43(:4$434;4,*-

C(G

$ $ $ $ $ $$$$$C5G

D%:6&4$EA$C(G$1*67%47$(&4(P$C5G$L,-*(33(*%/,$B/,4A

D%:6&4$JA$D6-43(:4$'&/--@-4'*%/,

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!F#B!#$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!#%

Page 46: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

(--4;532$7&(H%,:F$-.('4$(33/'(*%/,F$(,7$5&('94*$%,-*(33(*%/,A$L*$%-$'/;./-47$/)$434'*&%'(3$'(534-$(,7$56,734-$(**('?47$*/$*?4$-*&6'*6&4A

):9;8950:93A%F018%G79DA8%2A3C?09>%C85@:D6

@'(3$'(534-$(,7$(%&$76'*$56,734-$ %-$($.(%,-*(9%,:$.&/'4--$(,7$'/,-6;4-$?6:4$%,-*(33(*%/,$*%;4F$H?%'?$74;(,7-$-9%3347$3(5/&$

*?4$*H/$;/-*$'/;;/,$*2.4-$6-47$)/&$H%&4$56,734$'3(;.%,:$H%*?$

'3(;.-$(&4$;(74$/)$;4*(33%'$-*&%.$H%*?$($&6554&$'6-?%/,$(*$*?4$H%&4;(*%,:$-6&)('4$%,$/&74&$*/$(=/%7$*?4$.%,'?%,:$/)$'&6-?%,:$*?4$H%&4-A$+?4$'3(;.-$(&4$;/6,*47$*/$*?4$-*&6'*6&(3$434;4,*-$%,$-4=4&(3$7%&4'*%/,-$)/33/H%,:$*?4$H%&4$56,734$./-%*%/,-A

@%B47$ (**('?;4,*$ 5&('94*-$H%*?$ -.4'%(3$ )4(*6&4-A$+?4$ -.4'%(3$5&('94*-$*?6-$74-%:,47$?(=4$34--$%,-*(33(*%/,$*%;4$(,7$(&4$4(-2$*/$;(%,*(%,A$1*(,7(&7%B(*%/,$/)$5&('94*-$%,'/&./&(*4-$)4(*6&4-$)/&$O6%'94&$'3(;.%,:F$(=/%7%,:$*?4$6-4$/)$-*(,7(&7$(--4;532"-4&=%'4$*//3-A$+?6-F$/,32$/,4$9%,7$/)$5&('94*$%-$6-47$/,$(33$*?4$B/,4-$

5&('94*$-2-*4;-$(3-/$(=/%7$%;.('*-$3%94$.6,'*6&%,:$/)$%,-63(@*%/,$53(,94*$(,7$7&%33%,:$?/34-$/,$*?4$-6../&*%,:$-*&6'*6&4A

<*()HI$%.I#"J+

$ +?4$-*&6'*6&(3$434;4,*-$'/,-%74&47F$H?%34$74-%:,%,:$*?4$5&('94*-F$(&4$-9%,F$-*&%,:4&-F$'3%.-F$(,7$)&(;4-$CD%:A$JGA$0&('94*$

56,734F$'(534F$(,7$53(,94*$944.%,:$*?4;$%,$*?4$%,*4,747$./-%@*%/,-A$Q4,4&(332F$*?4$5&('94*-$(&4$;(74$)&/;$-*443$-?44*$-*&%.$

52$54,7%,:$/.4&(*%/,A$+?4$5&('94*-$(&4$?4(*@*&4(*47$*/$/5*(%,$*?4$74-%&47$-6&)('4$.&/.4&*%4-A

$B?86%:4%G132=856

.4&;(,4,*$)(-*4,4&-P

/&$7%&4'*32$/,$*/$*?4$-*&6'*6&4P

L,,/=(*%=4$0&('94*$84-%:,$#/,'4.*-$)/&$*?4$L,-*(33(*%/,$/)$!%&'&()*$12-*4;-

� � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � �

C(G

C5G

C'G

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!F#B!#$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !#&

Page 47: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

(&4$:3647$/,$*/$*?4$!$(,7$0$5&('94*-A

<*()HI$%.I#"J+%*IK/"*I-I+$#

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

-*&%'*32$(=/%747$)/&$%,-*(33%,:$*?4$5&('94*-F$*?6-$43%;%,(*%,:$

*?4$74-%:,A$+?%-$?43.-$*?4$5&('94*$*/$54$.3('47$4(-%32$(*$ %*-$

747%'(*47$./-%*%/,A$+?4$5&('94*$(--4;532$H%33$,/*$54$./--%534$%,$(,/*?4&$3/'(*%/,$*?(,$%,$*?4$%,*4,747$./-%*%/,A$+?4$:4,4&(3$:6%743%,4-$ '/,-%74&47$ H?%34$ 74-%:,%,:$ *?4$ 5&('94*-$ (&4$)6&*?4&$3%-*47A

LA36502%?315%D860>9%2:960D81350:96

$ +?4$5(-%'$H(33$*?%'9,4--$-?(33$54$94.*$6,%)/&;$*/$)('%3%*(*4$

$ 0(-%'$7&()*$(,:34$%-$&4O6%&47$)/&$4(-4$/)$4N4'*%/,A$ 8&()*$(,:34$%-$.&/=%747$%,$*?4$74-%:,$-/$*?(*$.(&*-$'(,$54$4(-%32$4N4'*47$)&/;$*?4$;/37A$S4,'4F$*?4$H(33-$(&4$74-%:,47$

(,:34$/)$ET$.4&$-%74$ %-$'/,-%74&47$(-$ *?4$-*(,7(&7$.&('*%'4A$+?4$ -;(334&$ 7&()*$ (,:34-$ '(6-4$ .&/534;$ %,$ &4;/=%,:$ *?4$'/;.34*47$.(&*-$ )&/;$ *?4$;/37A$S/H4=4&F$ ($ 3%**34$ 7&()*$ %-$54**4&$*?(,$,/$7&()*$(*$(33A

1%=(%(?F$!A

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!F#B!#$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!#!

Page 48: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

$ #/&,4&-$-?(33$54$&/6,747$*/$&476'4$-*&4--$'/,'4,*&(*%/,-$(,7$)&('*6&4A$L,,4&$&(7%6-$-?/637$54$/)$(*$34(-*$*?4$*?%'9,4--$/)$*?4$H(33-A$ !77$&%5-$)/&$-*&6'*6&(3$-6../&*F$ %,-*4(7$/)$%,'&4(-%,:$*?4$

*?4$H(33-$*/$H?%'?$*?42$(&4$(**('?47A$+?4%&$?4%:?*$-?/637$54$34--$*?(,$*?&44$*%;4-$*?4$H(33$*?%'9,4--A

;(%,$H(33$*?%'9,4--A$0/--4-$-?/637$54$-6../&*47$52$&%5-$*?(*$

$ <I*4&,(3$6,74&'6*-$&4O6%&4$-%74$'/&4-$*?(*$(&4$(7747$*/$*?4$*//3%,:$'/-*F$-/;4$-%;.34$'(,$54$;/3747$52$&43/'(*%,:$ *?4$.(&*%,:$3%,4A

$ +?&4(7%,:$ )4(*6&4-$ %,$ *?4$ 5&('94*-$ H4&4$ ,/*$ (33/H47$

"+#/!($"&+%<!(+HI$%*IK/"*I-I+$#

$ +?4$5&('94*$-?/637$,4=4&$7%-*6&5$*?4$)&(;4$53(,94*$./-%@

'/;.&4--%/,$B/,4-$(&4$;%,%;%B47$%,$*?4$74-%:,$,/*$4I'447%,:$

;6-*$54$&4-.4'*47A$S/H4=4&F$?/34-$(,7$'6*/6*-$%,$*?4$53(,94*$(&4$(''4.*47$%)$*?42$(&4$'/;.34*432$-4(347A

)!(-L%"+$I*'()I%*IK/"*I-I+$#

$ +?4$ %,*4&)('4-$ /)$ *?4$ '3(;.-$ /&$ #@5&('94*-$ -?(33$ (33/H$

?/37$*?&44$%,*4&)('%,:$./%,*-$-%;63*(,4/6-32A$+?4$-2-*4;$%,*4&@)('4-$-?(33$54$%,*4&'?(,:4(534F$(,7$*?42$-?/637$(33/H$7%))4&4,*$

@

(,2$*//3-$/,$*?4$5&('94*F$*?/6:?$-3%7%,:$;4'?(,%-;$764$*/$*?4$4(-4$/)$%*-$%,-*(33(*%/,A

L,,/=(*%=4$0&('94*$84-%:,$#/,'4.*-$)/&$*?4$L,-*(33(*%/,$/)$!%&'&()*$12-*4;-

D%:6&4$EEA$ !+!@JE$-2-*4;$%,-*(33(*%/,$.&/'4--

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!F#B!#$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !#A

Page 49: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

$ +?4$ 5&('94*$ -?/637$ ,/*$ 4I4&*$ 4I'4--%=4$ .&4--6&4$ /,$*?4$<#1U$76'*-A$+?4-4$(&4$,/,-*&6'*6&(3F$.&[email protected]:F$'(&5/,$)%54&$'/;./-%*4$76'*-$6-47$)/&$(%&$'%&'63(*%/,$%,$*?4$)3%:?*$74'9A$<#1$76'*-$?43.$%,$;(%,*(%,%,:$*?4$'(5%,$(%&$O6(3%*2$%,$ '/;;4&'%(3$ (%&'&()*-F$ 4,(53%,:$ -6&=%=(3F$ -()4*2F$ (,7$'/;)/&*$/)$.(--4,:4&-A$+?4$<#1$76'*-$(&4$%,-*(3347$H%*?%,$.&4--6&%B47$ (,7$ 6,.&4--6&%B47$ -4'*%/,-$ /)$ )6-43(:4$ (,7$H%,:A$+?4$&4O6%&47$'34(&(,'4-$H%*?$*?4$(7N('4,*$-*&6'*6&4-$;6-*$54$;(%,*(%,47$ )/&$.&/.4&$ %,-*(33(*%/,$(,7$ &4;/=(3$)/&$;(%,*(%,(5%3%*2A

-($I*"(!%#I!I)$"&+%'&*%<*()HI$#

$ 0&('94*-$(&4$.&/76'47$52$*?4$%,N4'*%/,$;/37%,:$.&/'4--A$S4,'4F$ !01$ /&$ ./32(;%74-$ (&4$ *?4$ .&4)4&&47$ ;(*4&%(3-A$L,N4'*%/,$;/37%,:$%-$*?4$;/-*$'/;;/,32$6-47$;(,6)('*6&%,:$

!$H%74$ =(&%4*2$ /)$ 5&('94*-$ %-$;(,6)('*6&47F$H?%'?$ =(&%4-$:&4(*32$%,$*?4%&$-%B4F$'/;.34I%*2F$(,7$(..3%'(*%/,A

<I#$%L*()$")I#

H%*?/6*$'&6-?%,:$*?4$H%&4-$(,7$24*$ *%:?*$4,/6:?$*/$.&4=4,*$;/=4;4,*$ H%*?%,$ *?4$ '3(;.A$R%&4-$ (,7$ H%&4$ 56,734-$ (&4$

(=/%7%,:$*?4$H%&4$.%,'?%,:A$ #3(;.-$/,$H%&4$56,734-$ -?/637$,/*$ (33/H$ *?4$56,734$ */$;/=4$*?&/6:?$*?4$'3(;.$(:(%,-*$*?4$.633%,:$)/&'4$H?4,$(..3%47A$#3(;.-$ ;6-*$ 54$ %,-*(3347$ H%*?$ *?4%&$ (**('?;4,*$ ?(&7H(&4$./-%*%/,47$(5/=4$*?4;F$H?4&4=4&$%-$.&('*%'(534$-/$*?(*$*?42$(&4$

$ #3(;.-$;6-*$54$%,-*(3347$%,$-6'?$($;(,,4&$*?(*$*?4$434'*&%@'(3$H%&4-$7/$,/*$'/;4$%,$'/,*('*$H%*?$/*?4&$.(&*-$/)$*?4$(%&'&()*$H?4,$-65N4'*47$*/$=%5&(*%/,A

.I#"J+%#&!/$"&+%L*&)I##

$ S(=%,:$ %,$ ;%,7$ (33$ /)$ *?4$ 74-%:,$ &4O6%&4;4,*-$ (,7$&4'/;;4,7(*%/,-F$*?4$)/33/H%,:$74-%:,$'?(&*4&$%-$)&(;47$%,$*?4$74=43/.;4,*$/)$%,,/=(*%=4$5&('94*-$74-%:,A$ 14=4&(3$'/,'4.*-$H4&4$74=43/.47$H%*?$($'&%*4&%($3%-*$'/,-%-*@%,:$/)$74-%:,$942$7&%=4&-F$%A4AF$-2-*4;-$%,*4:&(*%/,F$-*&6'*6&4$%;.('*F$(--4;532F$;(%,*4,(,'4F$(,7$;(,6)('*6&(5%3%*2A$+?4$

=(&%/6-$ '/,'4.*-$ 74=43/.47$ H4&4$ 4=(36(*47$ (:(%,-*$ *?4$(7=(,*(:4-F$ 7%-(7=(,*(:4-$ (,7$ &%-9-$ (--/'%(*47$H%*?$ 4('?$'/,'4.*F$*?6-$4=/3=%,:$*?4$54-*$'/,'4.*-$-'/&%,:$?%:?$/,$(33$*?4$7&%=%,:$)('*/&-A$ +(534$ E$ %336-*&(*4-$ *?4$ 942$ 7&%=%,:$ )('*/&-$ (7/.*47$ )/&$74-%:,$=(3%7(*%/,$*/$/,4$/)$*?4$74-%:,$'/,'4.*-A

H(-$'?4'947$(:(%,-*$*?4$;%,%;6;$&4O6%&4;4,*-$3%-*47$%,$%*A$+?%-$4,-6&4-$*?(*$*?4$74-%:,$'&%*4&%($?(=4$544,$)/33/H47$(33$*?&/6:?$ *?4$74-%:,$'2'34$ (,7$ *?4&4$ (&4$,/$74=%(*%/,-$ )&/;$*?4$-'/.4$/)$*?4$.&/N4'*A$1/;4$/)$*?4$942$'?4'9./%,*-$(&4$*?4$

@(*%/,$(,7$(=/%7$6-4$/)$-.4'%(3$*//3-P

%,*4:&(*%/,P

;(,6)('*6&%,:F$(,7$-/$/,A

&<#I*M($"&+#N% (.M(+$(JI#N% (+.% M(!/I%(.."$"&+

$ +?4$.&/./-47$74-%:,$'/,'4.*-$.&/=%74$*?4$)4(*6&4-$/)$(,$4(-4$(--4;532$(,7$%,*4&'?(,:4(5%3%*2A$+?4$74-%:,-$4,-6&4$*?(*$,/$?/34-$(&4$.&/=%747$%,$,4%*?4&$/)$*?4$5&('94*-F$*?6-$(=/%7%,:$*?4$H4(9$-4'*%/,-$/&$-*&4--$'/,'4,*&(*%/,$/,$*?4$53(,94*-$(,7$)&(;4-A$+?4$74-%:,-$(3-/$4,-6&4$*?(*$,/$-*(,7(&7$/&$-.4'%(3$

1%=(%(?F$!A

+(534$EA$ #/,'4.*$74-%:,$7&%=%,:$)('*/&-A

#/&4$(&4(- V4&%*- 84;4&%*- #?(334,:4-$%,=/3=47

12-*4;-

L,*4&'?(,:4(5%3%*2

W%3

!7N6-*;4,*$*/$54$;(74$*/$&4-.4'*$*/34&(,'4$54*H44,$)&(;4-

W/$?/34-$%,$53(,94*F$?4,'4$,/$'6-*/;%B(*%/,

52$*?4$'3%.-

1*&6'*6&4$%;.('*

W/$?/34-F$*?4&4@)/&4$34--$-*&4--$'/,'4,*&(*%/,$/,$*?4$-*&6'*6&4$

X4O6%&4$:36%,:

[email protected](*4$,/*$:3647$(*$&%:?*$(,:34$./-%*%/,

V(%,*4,(,'4 <(-2$&4;/=(3$(,7$&4.3('4;4,*$

$ X4;/=%,:$*?4$'3%.-$'(&4)6332$

!--4;532

<(-4$/)$(--4;532$ $ !**('?;4,*$54*H44,[email protected](*4$(,7$-*(5%3%B4&$'(,$54$7/,4$'(&4@)6332A

W/$-.4'%(3$*//3-$&4O6%&47$

X476'47$(--4;532$*%;4$

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!F#B!#$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!#"

Page 50: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

(--4;532$*//3-$(&4$&4O6%&47$)/&$*?4$5&('94*$%,-*(33(*%/,F$H?%'?$-(=4$($3/*$/)$(--4;532$*%;4A$L*$ %-$4(-2$*/$&4.3('4$*?4$-.(&4-$52$*?4$;(%,*4,(,'4$-*())$76&%,:$*?4$.4&%/7%'$;(%,*4,(,'4A$L*$%-$(3-/$=4&2$;/74&(*4$/,$;(,6)('*6&%,:$(-.4'*-$/)$*?4$,4H$'/,'4.*-A$+?4$H4%:?*$*/$'/-*$&(*%/F$H?%'?$%-$(,$%;.3%47$74-%:,$'&%*4&%/,F$H(-$(3-/$*(94,$'(&4$%,$*?4$5(-%'$74-%:,A

)&+)!/#"&+#

$ +?4$'/,'4.*-$(&4$-%;.34$%,$74-%:,$(,7$?(=4$34--$,6;54&$/)$.(&*-F$944.%,:$*?4$;(,6)('*6&%,:$'/-*$;%,%;6;A$+?4$;(,6@)('*6&%,:$ '/-*$ 74.4,7-$ /,$ :4/;4*&%'(3$ -%;.3%'%*2$ H%*?/6*$6,74&'6*-$(-$;6'?$(-$./--%534$*?(*$43%;%,(*4$*?4$%,'/&./&(*%/,$/)$-.4'%(3$;/637$%,-4&*-$%,*/$*?4$*//3F$%,$(77%*%/,$*/$;('?%,%,:$*%;4$(,7$'/-*A$ +?4$74-%:,$'/,'4.*-$/))4&47$-%,:34$-/36*%/,$)/&$(33$%,-*(3@

'/,=4,*%/,(3$74-%:,$;4*?/7-$(7/.*$%,74.4,74,*$'3(;.-$)/&$*?4$%,-*(33(*%/,$/)$4('?$-2-*4;$*?(*$&4O6%&4$;/&4$4))/&*$(,7$*%;4$52$*?&44$*%;4-A$ +?4$ %,,/=(*%=4$ -/36*%/,-$ /))4&47$ ?(=4$ (,$ (7=(,*(:4$ /,$

,6;54&$ /)$ -*(,7(&7$ *//3-$ 6-47$ )/&$ (--4;532$ /&$ 7%-;(,*34$

'/,-6;47$)/&$*?4$(--4;532$(,7$7%-(--4;532$-4O64,'4$.&/'4--A

D%:6&4$EJA$ 1%,:34$-/36*%/,$74-%:,

$ L*$%-$=4&2$4(-2$*/$&4.3('4$*?4$5&('94*-$76&%,:$*?4$.4&%/7%'$;(%,*4,(,'4$764$*/$%*-$-%;.34$74-%:,$%,$,(*6&4$3%94$6-4$/)$-3%7@

$ +?4$ '/,'4.*-$H4&4$ (--4--47$ 54*H44,$ *?4$ 3%-*$ /)$;4&%*-$(,7$74;4&%*-$(:(%,-*$4('?$)6,'*%/,$7&%=4&-F$-6'?$(-$-2-*4;-$

74-%:,F$-*&6'*6&4$74-%:,F$;(,6)('*6&%,:F$(--4;532F$8+$942-$

.(&(;4*4&-$%,$*?4$-434'*%/,$/)$*?4$;/-*$(..&/.&%(*4$'/,'4.*F$H?%'?$?(7$($?%:?$-'/&4$/,$(=4&(:4$.(&(;4*4&-A$ !;/,:$*?4$=(&%47$74-%:,$-/36*%/,-$/))4&47$*/$*?4$'6-*/;4&F$-%I$5&('94*-$?(=4$544,$.(*4,*@&4:%-*4&47$-65-4O64,*32$ *?42$)/6,7$($.3('4$%,$'6-*/;4&Y-$3%5&(&2$/)$-*(,7(&7$5&('94*-A

()H+&O!I.JI-I+$#

$ +?4$(6*?/&$:&(*4)6332$('9,/H347:4-$L,)/*4'?$;(,(:4;4,*$)/&$*?4$.4&;%--%/,$:%=4,$*/$.653%-?$*?%-$.(.4&A$S4$%-$-.4'%(332$:&(*4)63$ */$V%-*4&$X(;('?(,7&(,$QF$+4'?,%'(3$V(,(:4&$(*$L,)/*4'?$<,*4&.&%-4-$M*7AF$)/&$?%-$*?/&/6:?$-6../&*$*/$(33$*?4$;4;54&-$/)$*?4$*4(;$H?/$?(=4$'/,*&%56*47$%;;4,-432$*/$*?4$-6''4--)63$4I4'6*%/,$/)$*?%-$.&/N4'*A$!$-.4'%(3$*?(,9-$%-$:%=4,$*/$V%-*4&$165&(;(,2($1(-*&2F$!QV@+4'?,%'(3F$)/&$=(36(534$*?4$%,.6*-A

*I'I*I+)I#

+4'?,%'(3$ 0//9$ #/;.(,2F$ M/-$!,:434-F$ Z,%*47$ 1*(*4-$ /)$

84.(&*;4,*$/)$+&(,-./&*(*%/,A

L,7%(F$[(.4&5('9A

<(-*@R4-*$.&4--$47%*%/,A

,6;54&-A

L,,/=(*%=4$0&('94*$84-%:,$#/,'4.*-$)/&$*?4$L,-*(33(*%/,$/)$!%&'&()*$12-*4;-

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!F#B!#$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !#$

Page 51: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management
Page 52: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&'%#()*&!#%+,-%+./&,()#

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

'1 '! ! ! :1)'!-.#+/!)+/(%-

)!! ! ! ! ! "#$%!'%()*

:1 ;!! ! ! >?@!(%)2+#+/!4)0,12-

",$/&-0.$"&,

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

.#,5!-(=+/!(1)'-!.)-!01+'=0,%'!8*!P1(91C#,05!)+'!X15+-,1+!QKLMYRI!"5%!-#+/(%&0)8(%!'*+)$#0!$1'%(!.)-!'%C%(16%'!#+!)!-,2)#/5,412.)2'!)66(#0),#1+!14!,5%!:)/2)+/%!%H=),#1+-I

'1#ZKNIYNT[\]),$ITNKTIN^N_KYKT

+123456317%.81298::;9%*<5;=%81%$3>;4=;:<?;=%';;=@<AB% C89%D;:3A8E2;9%#:F17%!8<=%#?52;>%1;<9%D8G;9D<1<C?%)8H<>><=%&><9I`)--#$!a+#C%2-#,*!&!S=2)*')5!b!?)='#!c2)8#)

!"#$%&'$( >= >0?0<31>?> <6>? = 6 =3 @@<3> 3> <@ 0=<3> @4 >@ ?)> 8 =<*> <?3> 5<3> => >03 0 <)A>=3 @@<3> ? <)> >= *< )<@?8<)> <<) ? (> >= <>@ ?)> 6 >? @< A> <> 4=04=> 3 *>= =3 @@<3> >?)) = ?@>

)BC0@?D<*<E=>=F?=>6?C>?))<)>=G>=F<>F<@BDG0=<3>=3?H<D=G38>BE>=F<>@GEIB=4)BE?@>?E)>@?=<3?@>)B3<D=BGECA>&<ED<1>B=C>B*0@<*<E=?J=BGE>BC>CB*0@<>?E)>B=>GE@8>E<<)C>?>C*?@@>*G)B D?=BGE>=G>=F<>CG =6?3<>G >F<@BDG0=<3>0GCB=BGE>DGE=3G@@<3A> F<>0?3?*<=<3C>G=F<>DGE=3G@@<3C>?3<>)<=<3*BE<)>4CBEI>=F<>*<=FG)>GK>0?3=BD@<>C6?3*C>L8>*BEB*B9BEI>?E>BE)<71>6FBDF>BC>?>K4ED=BGE>GK>=F<>@G?)>C6BEI>FBC=G38A> F<>CB*4@?=BGE>3<C4@=C>CFG6>=F<><KK<D=B5<E<CC>GK>=F<>03G0GC<)>DGE=3G@@<3>BE>C4003<CCBEI>=F<>C6BEI>GK>=F<>C4C0<E)<)>@G?)>?E)>=F<>C=?LB@B9?=BGE>GK>=F<>F<@BDG0=<3A

)*+,-%.#(>&<@BDG0=<31>#@4EI>@G?)1>-?3=BD@<>C6?3*C1>#6BEIA

d%0%#C%'Z!KN\N_\KT! c00%6,%'Z!K_\NY\KTe)=,512!412!0122%-61+'%+0%Z!5)+)4*fH%0I%'=I-);%05)+#0)(!F+/#+%%2#+/!g%6)2,$%+,G!`)--#$!a#+C%2-#,*G!S=22#*')5G!?)='#!c2)8#)

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!#EBA%$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !#E

Page 53: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

! c8A=/!QKLONR!(),%2!%E6)+'%'!1+!,5#-!$1'%(! ,1!01+-#'%2!,5%!0)-%!14!,.1!,)+'%$!0)8(%-I!B1.%C%2G!5#-!412$=(),#1+!.)-!8)-%'! 1+! ,5%!<%.,1+&F=(%2! %H=),#1+-! 14!$1,#1+! 412! -$)((!6%2,=28),#1+-G! -%6)2),%'! #+,1! (1+/#,='#+)(! )+'! (),%2)(! -%,-I!c%21'*+)$#0!4120%-!1+!,5%!0)8(%-!)+'!,5%!(1)'!.%2%!+%/(%0,%'G!)-!.%2%!,5%!21,12!'*+)$#0!$1'%-I! S2#0A#+-9#!)+'!W)2)-!QKLOKR!#+C1(C%'!,5%!01$6=,%2#A%'!-#$=(),#1+!14!)!5%(#016,%2!)+'!%E,%2+)(!(1)'!#+!2%)(!,#$%!.#,5!)!6#(1,!#+!,5%!(116I!:1)'!)%21'*+)$#0-!.)-!#+012612),%'!#+,1!,5%!$1'%(G!)-!.%((!)-!21,12&'1.+.)-5!%44%0,-!#+!,5%!51C%2I! c--%1!)+'!P5#,8%09!QKLO_R!1+!,5%#2!6)6%2!1+!,5%!01+,21(!2%H=#2%$%+,-!412!-(=+/&(1)'!-,)8#(#A),#1+!=-%'!,5%!(#+%)2#A%'!%H=),#1+-! 14! $1,#1+! 14! ,5%! 5%(#016,%2G! .#+05G! 0)8(%G! )+'!(1)'! 412!C)2#)8(%!-=-6%+-#1+!/%1$%,2*!)+'! ,5%+!=-%'! ,5%$!#+!01+]=+0,#1+!.#,5!$1'%2+!01+,21(!,5%12*!,1!'%-#/+!-%C%2)(!01+,21(!-*-,%$-!412!%)05!,*6%!14!-=-6%+-#1+I! V%2)!)+'!3)2$%2!QKLO^R!%E)$#+%'!,5%!4%)-#8#(#,*!14!-,)8#&

,1! ,5%!0)2/1I!J+! ,5%#2!-#$6(%! (#+%)2!$1'%(!2%62%-%+,#+/! ,5%!*).#+/! )+'! ,5%! 6%+'=(1=-! 1-0#((),#1+-! 14! ,5%! -(=+/&(1)'!-*-,%$G!#,!.)-!)--=$%'!,5),!,5%!5%(#016,%2!$1,#1+!.)-!=+)4&4%0,%'!8*!,5%!(1)'I! d)A! <=> ?@A! QKL[LR! #+C%-,#/),%'! ,5%! =-%! 14! )+! )0,#C%!)%21'*+)$#0! (1)'! -,)8#(#A),#1+! -*-,%$! 412! )! 5%(#016,%2!-(=+/&(1)'!-*-,%$I! c((! ,5%-%! -,='#%-! )2%! 8)-%'! 1+! ,5%! 0()--#0)(! 01+,21(!,%05+#H=%-I!J+!,5#-!6)6%2G!)!+%.!)+,#&-.#+/!01+,21((%2!412!5%(#&

1+!,#$%&'%()*%'!4%%'8)09!14!,5%!(1)'!-.#+/!)+/(%-!Q;)-1='!<=>?@AG!TNNTG!@$)2!)+'!<)*4%5G!TNNYRI!"5%!1=,6=,!421$!,5#-!01+,21((%2!.)-!)''#,#1+)(!'#-6()0%$%+,-!,5),!)2%!)''%'!,1!,5%!5%(#016,%2!,2)]%0,12*!#+!,5%!(1+/#,='#+)(!)+'!(),%2)(!'#2%0,#1+-I!B%+0%G!#,-!#$6(%$%+,),#1+!#-!-#$6(%!)+'!#,!]=-,!+%%'%'!-$)((!

"5%! 6)2)$%,%2-! 14! ,5%! 01+,21((%2-! .%2%! '%,%2$#+%'! =-#+/!6)2,#0(%! -.)2$-! 16,#$#A),#1+! ,%05+#H=%! 8*!$#+#$#A#+/! )+!#+'%EG!.5#05!#-!)!4=+0,#1+!14!,5%!(1)'!-.#+/!5#-,12*I! >)2,#0(%!-.)2$!16,#$#A),#1+!Q>?@R!#-!)!616=(),#1+&8)-%'!-,105)-,#0!16,#$#A),#1+! ,%05+#H=%G!.5#05! #-! #+-6#2%'!8*! ,5%!

$)+*!-#$#()2#,#%-!.#,5!%C1(=,#1+)2*!01$6=,),#1+!,%05+#H=%-G!-=05!)-!/%+%,#0!)(/12#,5$-!Q7cR!QW%++%'*G!KLLORI!"5%!-*-,%$!#-! #+#,#)(#A%'!.#,5! )! 616=(),#1+!14! 2)+'1$! -1(=,#1+-! )+'! #,!-%)205%-!412!16,#$)!8*!=6'),#+/!/%+%2),#1+-I!B1.%C%2G!=+(#9%!7cG!,5%!>?@!5)-!+1!%C1(=,#1+!16%2),12-!-=05!)-!021--1C%2!)+'!

,521=/5!,5%!6218(%$!-6)0%!8*!41((1.#+/!,5%!0=22%+,!16,#$=$!

6)2,#0(%-I!V1$6)2%'!,1!7cG!,5%!)'C)+,)/%-!14!>?@!)2%!,5),!#,!#-!%)-*!,1!#$6(%$%+,!)+'!,5%2%!)2%!4%.!6)2)$%,%2-!,1!)']=-,I!;12%1C%2G!>?@G!(#9%!)((!%C1(=,#1+)2*!)(/12#,5$-G!16,#$#A%-!)!6%2412$)+0%!#+'%E!8)-%'!1+(*!1+!#+6=,\1=,6=,!2%(),#1+-5#6-I!"5%2%412%G!$#+#$)(!9+1.(%'/%!14!,5%!6()+,!=+'%2!#+C%-,#/)&,#1+!#-!2%H=#2%'I!J+!)''#,#1+G!8%0)=-%!'%2#C),#C%!#+412$),#1+!#-!+1,!+%%'%'!#+!,5%!%E%0=,#1+!14!,5%!)(/12#,5$G!$)+*!6#,4)((-!,5),!/2)'#%+,!-%)205!$%,51'-!-=44%2!0)+!8%!1C%201$%I

)+$DJ)+$".+!%)&-J!

! "5%!5%(#016,%2!.#,5!)!-(=+/!-*-,%$!0)+!8%!01+-#'%2%'!)-!)!$=(,#&81'*!'*+)$#0)(!1+%I!"5%!$1,#1+!%H=),#1+-!14!%)05!

,5%!#+,%2)0,#1+!4120%-!8%,.%%+!,5%$!Q3=-),1G!KLLLG!>1(#!)+'!V21$)09G!KLO_RI

)8=;:317%2H;%H;:3A8E2;9

! J+!,5#-!-,='*G!,5%!5%(#016,%2!.)-!$1'%(%'!)-!)!2#/#'!81'*!.#,5!-#E!'%/2%%-!14!42%%'1$I!P#,5!F=(%2!)+/(%-G!,5%!5%(#016,%2!-,),%-! )2%! KTG! #+0(='#+/! ,2)+-(),#1+)(! Q41> 51>6R! )+'! )+/=()2!C%(10#,#%-!Q01>21>3RG!F=(%2!)+/(%-!Q 1> 1> RG!)+'!5%(#016,%2!61-#&,#1+!Q71>81>9R!Q>21=,*G!TNN_RI

)8=;:317%2H;%5:F17%:8<=

! "5%! %E,%2+)(! (1)'! #-! $1'%(%'! )-! )! 61#+,! $)--G! .5#05!8%5)C%-!(#9%!)!-65%2#0)(!6%+'=(=$!-=-6%+'%'!421$!)!-#+/(%!61#+,I!"5%!0)8(%!#-!)--=$%'!,1!8%!#+%()-,#0!)+'!.#,51=,!$)--I!"5%!/%1$%,2*!)+'!,5%!2%(%C)+,!0112'#+),%!-*-,%$-!)2%!-51.+!#+!3#/I!KI!"5%!=+#,!C%0,12-! B&>1> H&>1>(&!14!,5%!5119!0112'#+),%!-*-,%$! )(.)*-! 2%$)#+! 6)2)((%(! ,1! ,51-%! 14! ,5%! 81'*! )E#-!-*-,%$I!"5%!61-#,#1+!14! ,5%! (1)'!.)-!'%-02#8%'!8*! ,5%! ,.1!)+/(%-! '!)+'! 'G!.5%2%! '!#-!)!(1)'!)+/(%!#+!,5%!79!6()+%G!)+'!

'!#-!,5%!(1)'!1-0#((),#1+!)+/(%!1=,!14!,5%!79!6()+%I!"5%2%412%G!,5%!61-#,#1+!C%0,12!/'!14!,5%!(1)'!.#,5!2%-6%0,!,1!,5%!-=-6%+&-#1+!61#+,!#-!/#C%+!8*!FHI!KZ

� � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � �� � � � � � � � �� � � � �� � � ! QKR

! "5%!61-#,#1+!C%0,12!/&!14!,5%!5119!.#,5!2%-6%0,!,1!,5%!5%(#&016,%2!0%+,%2!14!/2)C#,*!QV7R!#-!/#C%+!8*!3=-),1!<=>?@A!QKLLLRG!)-!-%%+!#+!FHI!TZ

� ) � * � + �� � � � � � �� � � ! QTR

@$)2G!BI;I

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!#EBA%$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!!#F

Page 54: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

3

"5%!)8-1(=,%!C%(10#,*!M'!14!,5%!(1)'!#-!/#C%+!8*!FHI _Z

� � � �� � � �� #� �� Q_R

.5%2%G!"##-!,5%!)8-1(=,%!C%(10#,*!14!,5%!5%(#016,%2!$)--!0%+,%2G

/ N /'>O /&>> #-!,5%!61-#,#1+!C%0,12!14!,5%!(1)'!.#,5!2%-6%0,!,1!,5%!5%(#016,%2!$)--!0%+,%2G!)+'

0 B&>O 2 H& O 3 (& #-!,5%!)+/=()2!C%(10#,*!14!,5%!5%(#016,%2I

"5%!)8-1(=,%!)00%(%2),#1+!?'!14!,5%!(1)'!#-!QFHI ^RZ

� � �� � �� #� �� Q^R

"5%!=+#,!C%0,12!#+!,5%!'#2%0,#1+!14!,5%!/2)C#,*!4120%!#-!/#C%+!8*!FHI YZ

� � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � �� � � �� � � �� � � � �� � � QYR

S%-#'%-!,5%!/2)C#,*G!,5%2%!#-!)+!)%21'*+)$#0!4120%!)66(#%'!1+!,5%!61#+,!$)--!(1)'I!?#+0%!,5%!)+)(*-#-!#+!,5#-!.129!.)-!2%-,2#0,%'!,1!,5%!5%(#016,%2!$1,#1+!+%)2!51C%2G!,5%!)%21'*+)$#0-!(1)'-!1+!,5%!(1)'!.%2%!+%/(%0,%'I!"5%!%H=),#1+-!14!(1)'!$1,#1+!.%2%!.2#,,%+!8*!%+4120#+/!$1$%+,!%H=#(#82#=$!1+!,5%!-=-6%+-#1+!61#+,G!QFHI MRZ

� � �� ! � ! � �� � � � � � �# QMR

FH=),#1+ M! 621C#'%-! ,52%%! -0)()2! %H=),#1+-! 14! -%01+'!12'%2-G!1+(*!,5%!%H=),#1+-!#+!,5%!7!)+'!8!'#2%0,#1+-!)2%!2%,)#+%'G!.5#05!2%62%-%+,!,5%!%H=),#1+-!14!(1)'!$1,#1+I

!8<=%A81293@F23815%28%H;:3A8E2;9%C89A;5

"5%! -=-6%+'%'! (1)'! #+,21'=0%-! )''#,#1+)(! ,%2$-!1+! ,5%!2#/#'!81'*!4120%!)+'!$1$%+,!%H=),#1+-!14!5%(#016,%2!$1,#1+!

Q3#/I TRI!"5%!4120%!%&'!,5),!,5%!(1)'!%E%2,-!1+!,5%!5%(#016,%2!#-!/#C%+!8*!FHI OZ

! � � ! � �� � � � � �� � � � QOR

"5%!)''#,#1+)(!$1$%+,!+&'!#-!,5%2%412%!/#C%+!8*!FHI [Z

� � �� � � � �� ! Q[R

FH=),#1+-!O!)+'![!)2%!'%2#C%'!=-#+/!;),5%$),#0)G!.5#05!/#C%-!5#/5(*!+1+(#+%)2!%E62%--#1+-I!"5%-%!%H=),#1+-!0)++1,!8%!=-%'!412!-,)8#(#,*!)+)(*-#-I!"5%2%412%G!,5%*!$=-,!8%!(#+%)2#A%'!)21=+'!,5%!,2#$!01+'#,#1+I!J+!12'%2!,1!8%!)8(%!,1!6%2412$!,5%!(#+%)2#A),#1+!6210%--G!,5%!,2#$!C)(=%-!14!,5%!5%(#016,%2!)+'!,5%!(1)'!$=-,!8%!'%,%2$#+%'I

!3#/=2%!TI!:1)'!01+,2#8=,#1+!,1!5%(#016,%2!4120%-!Q3=-),1!<= ?@AG!KLLLRI

!31;<93K317%2H;%>82381%;LF<23815

"5%!$1,#1+!%H=),#1+-!18,)#+%'!.%2%!5#/5(*!+1+(#+%)2I!P%!+%%'%'! ,1! (#+%)2#A%! ,5%$! #+!12'%2! ,1!-1(C%!)+'!)+)(*A%! ,5%!5%(#016,%2!$1,#1+I!"1!'1!,5),G!.%!=-%'!,5%!-$)((&'#-,=28)+0%!,5%12*I!"1!)66(*!,5#-!,5%12*!.%!)--=$%'!,5),!,5%!$1,#1+!14!,5%!5%(#016,%2!)+'!,5%!(1)'!01+-#-,%'!14!-$)((!'%C#),#1+-!)81=,!)!

,5%12*G!.%!/1,!,5%!5%(#016,%2!(#+%)2#A%'!%H=),#1+-!14!$1,#1+I"5%!18,)#+%'!%H=),#1+-!.%2%!+1+(#+%)2!)+'!01$6(#0),%'I!

312!,5%!'%-#/+!6=261-%G!,5%-%!%H=),#1+-!)2%!(#+%)2#A%'!)81=,!,5%! 51C%2#+/! 01+'#,#1+-I!<%)2! 51C%2G! ,5%! 412.)2'! -6%%'! #-!+%)2(*!A%21!Q#I%I!4G

21((!)+/(%!#-!)(-1!A%21!%C%+!.#,5!,5%!%44%0,!14!,5%!(1)'!1+!,5%!5%(#016,%2!Q P RI!c,!,5#-!01+'#,#1+G!,5%!(1)'!,2#$!%H=),#1+-!621C#'%'!,5%!41((1.#+/!,2#$!C)(=%-!Q@$)2G!TNNYRG!)-!#+!FHI LZ

� �� � ## #� � �� � QLR

c+,#&-.#+/!V1+,21((%2!S)-%'!1+!"#$%&'%()*%'!3%%'8)09!412!B%(#016,%2!?(=+/!:1)'!?*-,%$!+%)2!B1C%2

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!#EBA%$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! !##

Page 55: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

! S*!#$61-#+/!-=05!2%-=(,-!,1!,5%!(#+%)2#A%'!(1)'!%H=),#1+-G!

(1)'!QFH-I!KN!,1!KTRZ

� � � � � � � � � � � �� �� ' � ' * % ' � ' � ' �� ��� � � � � � � �� � � ! QKNR

! QKKR

! "5%!4120%-!%E%2,%'!8*!,5%!(1)'!1+!,5%!5%(#016,%2!)2%Z

! QKTR

! "5%!$1$%+,-!#+!,5%!7J8J9!'#2%0,#1+-!)2%!QFHI!K_RZ

! QK_R� � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � �

� � � �

� �

� �

� !

� * ' � ) ' ) * $ '

� * $ ' ) * % ' * � ' ) � '

� ) ' � * '

+ �

� �

� �

� � � �

� � �

� �

� � � �

� �

���

���

� � � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � �

� � � �

� � � �

� � � �

� !

� + ' � ) ! ' ) +! $ ' '

� + $ ' ) +& ' � ) & ' +� '

) � ' � + ' � ) '� �

* �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� � � �

� �

� � � �

� � �

� �

� � � �

� � �

���

���

� � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � �

� � � � � �

� � � �

� �

� �

� !

� * ' � + ' * +% '

* + � * & ' +� ' * � '

� + ' � * '

� �

) �

� �

� � � �

� � �

� �

� � �

� �

���

���

! "5%-%! %H=),#1+-! )2%! (#+%)2! )+'! 0)+! 8%! 412$=(),%'!

) � � � � �

�� � � �� � �� � G! ,5%!(1)'!%H=),#1+-!#+!-,),%!-6)0%!0)+!

8%!.2#,,%+!)-!FHI!K^Z

� ) )� �� ! QK^R

.5%2%G7! #-! ,5%! -,),%! C%0,12! 412! ,5%! (1)'! )+'! ,5%! 5%(#016,%2!Q#I%IG!7 7&>>>7'hRI

! ?#$#()2(*G! ,5%!%44%0,!14! ,5%! (1)'!1+! ,5%!5%(#016,%2! 4120%!,%2$-!0)+!8%!.2#,,%+!)(-1!)-!FHI!KYZ

�� ) )

� �

� �� � � �� ��� � ! QKYR

! "5%!(#+%)2#A%'!%H=),#1+-!14!5%(#016,%2!$1,#1+!)+'!,5%!(1)'!0)+!8%!.2#,,%+!#+!,5%!41((1.#+/!-,),%!-6)0%!412$-!QFHI!KMRZ)

)

) )

� � ����

� � ! QKMR

M/&M&#J-%+,$"4#N",O%.&,$/&!!J/

3#/I!_I!J,!01+-#-,-!14!,.1!01+,21(!-*-,%$-Z!)!,2)09#+/!)+'!)+!)+,#&-.#+/!1+%I

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � � �� � � � �

� � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � �� � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� �� � � � � � �

� � � � � � �

! P%!+%%'%'!,1!'%-#/+!)!,2)09#+/!01+,21((%2!412!,5%!5%(#016,%2!,1!41((1.!,5%!,2)]%0,12*!/%+%2),%'!8*!,5%!)+,#&-.#+/!01+,21((%2I!"5%2%412%G!,5%!01+,21((%2!'%-#/+!14!,5%!.51(%!-*-,%$!01=('!8%!

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� ) )� �& � �� I!a-#+/!-,),%!4%%'8)09!,%05+#H=%G!,5%!5%(#016,%2!01+,21(!#+6=,!0)+!8%!.2#,,%+!)-!FHI!KOZ

� �� ) ) � � & � � � ! QKOR

! "5%!4%%'8)09!/)#+!$),2#E!Q!.)-!051-%+!-=05!,5),!,5%!%2212!5#-,12*!#-!$#+#$=$I!"5%!4%%'8)09!/)#+!QQR!0)+!8%!'%,%2$#+%'!=-#+/!,5%!(#+%)2!H=)'2),#0!2%/=(),12!,%05+#H=%!Q:`dRG!.5#05!

@$)2G!BI;I

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!#EBA%$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A%%

Page 56: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

'%6%+'-!1+!$#+#$#A#+/!)!H=)'2),#0!4=+0,#1+!,5),!0)+!8%!.2#,&,%+!)-!FHI!K[Z

� " � ) � � � � � '� �

'

� �� �� ! QK[R

! ?#+0%! ,5%! /1)(! .)-! ,1!$#+#$#A%! ,5%! %2212! -#/+)(G!R! #-!051-%+!.#,5!5#/5!/)#+-!01$6)2%'!,1!/I!c4,%2!'%,%2$#+#+/!QG!,5%!5%(#016,%2!-,),%!-6)0%!$1'%(!0)+!8%!2%.2#,,%+!)-!FHI!KLZ

� �) � ) � )

) )

� � � � �

� � �

� �

� �

� � & � �

� & � � ! QKLR

! FH=),#1+!KL!#+'#0),%-!,5),!,5%!2%4%2%+0%!-,),%-!8%01$%!,5%!+%.!#+6=,-!412!,5%!5%(#016,%2I! J+!,5%!-%01+'!-,)/%G!,5%!)+,#&-.#+/!01+,21((%2!.)-!'%-#/+%'I!c4,%2!$1'#4*#+/!,5%!5%(#016,%2!'*+)$#0-!8*!#+012612),#+/!,5%!-,)8#(#,*!)+'!,2)09#+/!01+,21((%2G!,5%!%44%0,!14!,5%!(1)'!-.#+/!4120%-!.%2%!)''%'!,1!,5%!-,),%!-6)0%!$1'%(!#+!FHI!KMI!S%412%!,5#-!-,%6G!.%!+%%'%'!,1!%E62%--!FHI!KL!#+!,%2$-!14!,5%!,1,)(!-,),%!C%0,12G!.5#05!#+0(='%!,5%!5%(#016,%2!)+'!,5%!(1)'!-,),%-I!J+!,5#-!0)-%G!,5%!5%(#016,%2!'*+)$#0-!0)+!8%!.2#,,%+!)-!FHI!TNZ

! QTNR) )

)

)

) )

� ��

� �

��

& � �� �

� �

� �

� � � � �� � � �� & � �

%H=),#1+-! #+! ,5%!5%(#016,%2! %H=),#1+-!14!$1,#1+I!d%0)((#+/!FHI!KMG!,5%!4120%-!)+'!$1$%+,-!421$!,5%!-(=+/!(1)'!0)+!8%!.2#,,%+!)-!FHI!TKZ

�� ) )

� �

� �� � � �� ��� �

! QTKR

! c''#+/!-=05!4120%-!,1!,5%!5%(#016,%2!'*+)$#0-G!,5%!+%.!$1'%(!0)+!8%!.2#,,%+!)-!FHI!TTZ

! QTTR� �

� � �

� � �

� � �

� � �� � �

� )

)

) � )

)

� ) ) � ) )

� ��

� � �

� � �

� � � � & � �

� & � �

� � �

� � �

� � �

� � �

� � �

� � � �

� � �

#

#

#

#

##

��

� �

� �

� � � � � �� � � � � �

! "5%!(1)'!'*+)$#0-!0)+!8%!.2#,,%+!)-!FHI!T_Z

� ) )� ��� ! QT_R

-6)0%!$1'%(!412!,5%!01$8#+%'!-*-,%$-!Q5%(#016,%2!)+'!-(=+/!

(1)'RG!)-!#+!FHI!T^Z

! QT^R� � � �

� � � � � �

� � � ) ) )

) � � � ) � � � )

) ) )

� � �

��

� ��

� � & � �

� � � & � �

� � & � �

� � � �

� � � � �

� �

! "5%!)+,#&-.#+/!01+,21((%2!412!,5%!#+&6()+%!)+'!1=,&14&6()+%!$1,#1+-!0)+!8%!%E62%--%'!)-!FHI!TYZ

� �

� �

) � � '

* � � '

� � ) � � )

� � * � � *

� �

� �

� ! QTYR

.5%2%G7C! )+'!8C! )2%! )''#,#1+)(!'#-6()0%$%+,! ,5),! )2%! )''%'! ,1! ,5%!5%(#016,%2!,2)]%0,12*!#+!,5%!(1+/#,='#+)(!)+'!(),%2)(!'#2%0,#1+-G!2%-6%0,#C%(*U()!#-!,5%!4%%'8)09!/)#+G!)+'! #-! ,5%! ,#$%! '%()*! #+,21'=0%'! #+! ,5%! 4%%'8)09! 14! ,5%! (1)'!-.#+/!)+/(%-I

! "5%-%!6)2)$%,%2-!)2%!051-%+! ,1!$)E#$#A%! ,5%!')$6#+/!14!,5%!-(=+/!(1)'!-*-,%$!8*!$#+#$#A#+/!,5%!41((1.#+/!#+'%EG!.5#05!#-!%E62%--%'!#+!,%2$-!14!,5%!,#$%!5#-,12*!14!,5%!(1)'!-.#+/!QFHI!TMRZ

� � � � '� � � �� � � �

'

� � � �� � � �� �� ��

! QTMR

M+/$".!J%#N+/)%+!O&/"$D)

,5%!41((1.#+/!-0%+)2#1Z!)!/21=6!14!8#2'-!#-!2)+'1$(*!-%)205#+/!411'!#+!)+!)2%)I!"5%2%!#-!1+(*!1+%!6#%0%!14!411'!#+!,5%!)2%)!8%#+/!-%)205%'I!"5%!8#2'-!'1!+1,!9+1.!.5%2%!,5%!411'!#-I!B1.%C%2G!,5%*!9+1.!51.!4)2!,5%!411'!#-!#+!%)05!#,%2),#1+I!"5%2%412%G!.5),!

,5%!8#2'!,5),!#-!+%)2%-,!,1!,5%!411'!QW%++%'*G!KLLORI! >?@!(%)2+%'!421$!,5%!-0%+)2#1!)+'!=-%'! #,! ,1!-1(C%! ,5%!16,#$#A),#1+!6218(%$-I!J+!>?@G!%)05!-#+/(%!-1(=,#1+!#-!)!i8#2'j!#+! ,5%!-%)205!-6)0%G!.5#05!#-!0)((%'!i6)2,#0(%jI!c((!6)2,#0(%-!

41((1.#+/!,5%!0=22%+,!16,#$=$!6)2,#0(%-I! >?@!#-!#+#,#)(#A%'!.#,5!)!/21=6!14!2)+'1$!6)2,#0(%-!Q-1(=&,#1+-R!)+'!,5%+!#,!-%)205%-!412!16,#$)!8*!=6'),#+/!/%+%2),#1+-I!J+!%C%2*!#,%2),#1+G!%)05!6)2,#0(%!#-!=6'),%'!8*!41((1.#+/!,5%!

c+,#&-.#+/!V1+,21((%2!S)-%'!1+!"#$%&'%()*%'!3%%'8)09!412!B%(#016,%2!?(=+/!:1)'!?*-,%$!+%)2!B1C%2

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!#EBA%$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A%&

Page 57: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

,.1!i8%-,j!C)(=%-I!"5%!8%-,!C)(=%-!2%62%-%+,!,5%!(1.%-,!1+%-!412!,5%!18]%0,#C%!4=+0,#1+!-#+0%!1=2!6218(%$!#-!)!$#+#$#A),#1+!

)05#%C%'!-1!4)2!)+'!#,!#-!0)((%'!68%-,I!c+1,5%2!8%-,!C)(=%!,5),!#-! ,2)09%'!8*!,5%!>?@!#-! ,5%!8%-,!C)(=%G!18,)#+%'!-1!4)2!8*!)+*!6)2,#0(%!#+!,5%!616=(),#1+I!"5#-!8%-,!C)(=%!#-!)!/(18)(!8%-,!

=6'),%-!#,-!C%(10#,*!)+'!61-#,#1+-!41((1.#+/!FH-I!TO!)+'!T[Z

� � � � � � � � � � � �( � ( � $ ) � � ) �� � �� � � � � � �� �� � � ! QTOR

� � � � � �) � ) � ( �� �� � �� � � � ! QT[R

.5%2%G5!#-!,5%!6)2,#0(%!C%(10#,*G!)+'7!#-!,5%!0=22%+,!6)2,#0(%!61-#,#1+!Q-1(=,#1+RUj-!)2%!.%#/5,#+/!6)2)$%,%2-!,5),!01+,21(!,5%!6%2412$)+0%!14!,5%!>?@!)(/12#,5$!Q?5#!)+'!F8%25)2,G!KLL[RI

! "5%!6-%='1!01'%!14!,5%!6210%'=2%!#-!)-!41((1.-Z

> > /?E)G*@8>BEB=B?@B9<>,>0?3=BD@<C!G%G3><?DF>0?3=BD@<> > $?@D4@?=<> =E<CC>5?@4<> BA<A>GLH<D=B5<>K4ED=BGE

K>=F<> =E<CC>5?@4<>BC>L<==<3>=F?E>=F<>L<C=> =E<CC>5?@4<>>0 <C= >BE>FBC=G381>

> > C<=>D433<E=>5?@4<>?C>=F<>E<6>0 <C=> > <E)SE)9$FGGC<> =F<> 0?3=BD@<> 6B=F> =F<> L<C=> =E<CC> 5?@4<> GK> ?@@> =F<>0?3=BD@<C>?C>=F<>I <C=> > %G3><?DF>0?3=BD@<> > $?@D4@?=<>0?3=BD@<>5<@GDB=8>?DDG3)BEI><24?=BGE> ;

0)?=<>0?3=BD@<>0GCB=BGE>?DDG3)BEI><24?=BGE> ;> > SE)TFB@<>*?7B*4*>B=<3?=BGEC>G3>*BEB*4*><33G3>D3B=<3B?>BC>EG=>?==?BE<)

,0)J/".+!%/J#0!$#

! P%!051-%! ,5%!V5#+19!5%(#016,%2! #+! ,5#-! -,='*! -#+0%! ,5%!)%21'*+)$#0-!'%2#C),#C%-!+%)2!51C%2!.)-!)C)#()8(%!#+!?,=09%*!QTNNKRI!P#,51=,!(1--!14!/%+%2)(#,*G!.%!)--=$%'!,5%!41((1.#+/!'),)!412!+=$%2#0)(!-#$=(),#1+I

! "5%!,2)09#+/!01+,21((%2!.)-!)-!#+!FHI!TLZ! QTLR

! "5%!(1)'!.)-!)-!#+!FHI!_NZ

! Q_NR

! "1!0511-%!,5%!01+,21(!6)2)$%,%2-!14!,5%!,#$%&'%()*%'!)+,#&-.#+/!01+,21((%2!Qgc?VRG!.%!)--=$%'!,5),!()7>N>()8>)+'! )7>N> )8

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

� � � � �

� � � � �

� � � �

� � � � �

� � � �

� � � � �

� � � �� �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

����

���

� � �

� � �

� � �

� � �

� � �

� �

� �

� � �

� � � � � � � � � � �

3#/=2%!^I!g)$6#+/!$)6!14!,5%!(1)'!-.#+/!QK\J?BR!=-#+/!gc?VI

! "5%!5#/5%-,!')$6#+/!(%C%(!0)+!8%!)05#%C%'!),!,5%!41((1.&#+/!C)(=%-!QFHI!_KRZ

� � �� � � � �� � � � � �� � ) � * � ) � * �� � �� � � � � � ! Q_KR

.5%2%G! ! �� � �� � #-! ,5%! 6%2#1'! 14! 1-0#((),#1+! 14! ,5%!-=-6%+'%'!(1)'I! "1! /%,! ,5%! 16,#$)(! C)(=%-! 14! ,5%! 41=2! 6)2)$%,%2-! ,5),!$#+#$#A%! ,5%! -.#+/! #+'%E! U#&G! .%! =-%'! ,5%! $%,51'! 14!6)2,#0(%! -.)2$-I!"5%! 41((1.#+/! C)(=%-!.%2%! =-%'! 412! ,5%!>?@!01'%!QFHI!_TRZ

� �� �� � � �� �� � � � �� � � � ! Q_TR

@$)2G!BI;I

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!#EBA%$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A%!

Page 58: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

! "5%!%C1(=,#1+!14!,5%!-.#+/!#+'%E!QK\U#&R!),!%)05!#,%2),#1+!#-!-51.%'!#+!3#/I!YI!"5%!16,#$)(!6)2)$%,%2-!18,)#+%'!=-#+/!,5#-!,%05+#H=%!.%2%!)-!#+!FHI!__Z

! Q__R

� � �

� � �

� � �

� � �

� � �

� � �

� � �

��"�

� "

����

����

#��

���

�!"�

���

���

� � � � " � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

3#/=2%!YI!FC1(=,#1+!14!,5%!>?@!01'%I

! "5%!$#+#$=$!C)(=%!412!U#&!0122%-61+'#+/!,1!,5%-%!6)2)$&%,%2-!.)-!41=+'!,1!8%!T[[G!.5#(%!#,!.)-!TL^!.5%+!.%!)--=$%'!,5%!-)$%!/)#+-!412!,5%!(1+/#,='#+)(!)+'!(),%2)(!$1,#1+-I!"5#-!2%-=(,!#-!%E6%0,%'!-#+0%!.%!5)C%!$12%!42%%'1$!,5)+!,5%!0)-%!.5%+!.%!5)C%!1+(*!,.1!6)2)$%,%2-I! "5%! ,#$%!5#-,12*!14! ,5%!5%(#016,%2!V7G!-=-6%+'%'!(1)'!-.#+/! )+/(%-G! )+'! ,5%! F=(%2! )+/(%-! )2%! -51.+! #+! 3#/-I! M!,1! LG! =-#+/! ,5%! 16,#$)(! /)#+-! 18,)#+%'! 421$! >?@I!"5%-%!

#+! -=662%--#+/! ,5%! (1)'! -.#+/I!"5%! )+,#&-.#+/! 01+,21((%2!6%2,=28-!,5%!5%(#016,%2!412$!#,-!#+#,#)(!61-#,#1+G!8=,!#,!2%,=2+-!#,!8)09!'=%!,1!,5%!-,)8#(#,*!14!,5%!.51(%!-*-,%$I!"5%!$)E#&$=$!'%C#),#1+! #+!5%(#016,%2!61-#,#1+! #-!+%)2(*!Y!4,G!.5#05!0)+!8%!01+-#'%2%'!-$)((I!B1.%C%2G! ,5#-!C)(=%!0)+!8%!$12%!'%02%)-%'!8*!0511-#+/!-$)((!C)(=%-!14! ,5%!)+,#&-.#+/!/)#+!Q() &#+/I!"5%!')$6#+/!$)6!0)+!5%(6!#+!0511-#+/!,5%!C)(=%!14!-=05!/)#+I!c-!-51.+!#+! ,5%!$)6G!.#,5!Q>N>PAV!)+'! >N>PA;G!.%!0)+!/%,!5#/5!(%C%(!14!')$6#+/G!.5#05!#-!01$6)2)8(%!,1!,5),!1+%!18,)#+%'!=-#+/!,5%!16,#$)(!/)#+-!8=,!.#,5!-$)((!C)(=%!412!,5%!,2)C%(#+/!'#-,)+0%!14!,5%!5%(#016,%2I!"5%!C)(=%!14!U#&!2%012'%'!#+!,5#-!0)-%!#-!^TNI

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

��

���"

�#��

��� �

���!

� � � � � � � � � � � �� � �

'

&

%

3#/=2%!MI!"#$%!5#-,12*!14!,5%!5%(#016,%2!V7!=-#+/!gc?V!.#,5!,5%! ! ! ! ! 16,#$)(!/)#+-I

� � �

� � �

� � �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

���

��$

���

��

���

� ��

� � � � � � � � � � � �� � �

!

!

3#/=2%!OI!"#$%!5#-,12*!14!,5%!(1)'!-.#+/!)+/(%-!=-#+/!gc?V!.#,5! ! ! ! ! 16,#$)(!/)#+-I

� �

� � � �

� �

� � � �

� �

� � � �

� � �

� � �

����

�" �

#����

� ��

��! �

� � �� � � � � � � � � � � �

%

&

'

3#/=2%![I!"#$%! 5#-,12*! 14! ,5%! 5%(#016,%2! V7! =-#+/! gc?V! .#,5Q) 'I

c+,#&-.#+/!V1+,21((%2!S)-%'!1+!"#$%&'%()*%'!3%%'8)09!412!B%(#016,%2!?(=+/!:1)'!?*-,%$!+%)2!B1C%2

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!#EBA%$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A%A

Page 59: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

� � � � � � � � � � � �� � �

� � �

� � �

� � �

� � �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� ���

� ��

$�

���

��

���

���

!

!

3#/=2%!LI!"#$%!5#-,12*!14!,5%!(1)'!-.#+/!)+/(%-!=-#+/!gc?V!.#,5!Q) ) 'I

/8@F521;55

! J,!0)+!8%!-51.+!8*!-#$=(),#1+!,5),!,5%!'%-#/+%'!-*-,%$!#-!218=-,!.#,5!,5%!05)+/%-!14!,5%!(1)'!$)--!)-!#+'#0),%'!#+!")8(%!KI!;12%1C%2G! ,5%!01+,21(!6)2)$%,%2-!14!,5%!01+,21((%2!)2%!4=+0,#1+-!14!,5%!(1)'!0)8(%!(%+/,5I!"5#-!218=-,+%--!#-!'=%!,1!,5%!#+,%/2),#1+!14!,5%!,2)09#+/!01+,21((%2G!.5#05!#-!8)-%'!1+!:`d!,%05+#H=%!)+'!,5%!,#$%&'%()*%'!)+,#&-.#+/!01+,21((%2I

")8(%!KI! >%2412$)+0%!14!gc?V!.#,5!C)2#),#1+!14!(1)'!.%#/5,I*3 NI_ NIY NIO NILU#& __L T[[ TYK TTK

")8(%!TI! >%2412$)+0%!14!gc?V!.#,5!C)2#),#1+!14!,5%!-=-6%+-#1+!! ! ! ! ! 61#+,!(10),#1+I

:10),#1+7F!8F!9F!

7F!8F!9F!

7F!8F!9F!

7F!8F!9F!

U#& TMO TOT _TN _KM

.&,.!0#"&,#

! c! +%.! )+,#&-.#+/! 01+,21((%2! 412! 5%(#016,%2! -(=+/! (1)'!

8)-%'!1+!,#$%&'%()*%'!4%%'8)09!14!,5%!(1)'!-.#+/!)+/(%-I!"5%!1=,6=,!421$!,5#-!01+,21((%2!.)-!)+!)''#,#1+)(!'#-6()0%$%+,G!.5#05!.)-!)''%'!,1!,5%!5%(#016,%2!,2)]%0,12*!#+!,5%!(1+/#,='#+)(!)+'!(),%2)(!'#2%0,#1+-I!B%+0%G!#,-!#$6(%$%+,),#1+!#-!-#$6(%!)+'!

61-#,#1+!01+,21((%2I

! "1! #$6(%$%+,! ,5%! 62161-%'! )+,#&-.#+/! 01+,21((%2-G! )!,2)09#+/!01+,21((%2!412!,5%!5%(#016,%2!.)-!'%-#/+%'!=-#+/!,5%!:`d!,%05+#H=%I!"5%!4=+0,#1+!14!,5%!,2)09#+/!01+,21((%2!#-!,1!-,)8#(#A%!,5%!5%(#016,%2!)+'!,2)09!,5%!,2)]%0,12*!/%+%2),%'!8*!,5%!)+,#&-.#+/!01+,21((%2I! c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

+.P,&N!J-O)J,$#

! "5%!)=,512!)09+1.(%'/%-!,5%!-=6612,!14!W#+/!3)5'!a+#C%2&-#,*!14!>%,21(%=$!)+'!;#+%2)(-G!=+'%2!72)+,!?SN[NNT^I

/J'J/J,.J#

c8A=/G! ;IG! KLONG! kg*+)$#0-! )+'! 01+,21(! 14! 5%(#016,%2-!.#,5! ,.1!0)8(%! -(#+/! (1)'-lG! J+!cJcc!T+'!c#202)4,!g%-#/+!)+'!@6%2),#1+-!;%%,#+/G! +=$8%2!cJcc&ON&LTLG!c$%2#0)+!J+-,#,=,%!14!c%21+)=,#0-!)+'!c-,21+)=,#0-I

c--%1G!?I!)+'!P5#,8%09G!dIG!KLO_G!kV1+,21(!2%H=#2%$%+,-!412!-(#+/&(1)'!-,)8#(#A),#1+!#+!5%)C*!(#4,!5%(#016,%2-lG!X1=2+)(!14!,5%!c$%2#0)+!B%(#016,%2!?10#%,*G!D1(I!K[G!66I!T_&_KI

S#-/))2'G!;I!<=>?@AG!TNNMG!k;1'%(#+/!14!)!7%+%2#0!?(=+/!:1)'!?*-,%$lG! J+!cJcc!;1'%(#+/! )+'! ?#$=(),#1+! V1+4%2%+0%G!V1(12)'1I

S2#0A#+-9#G!?I!)+'!W)2)-G!7IG!KLOKG!kV2#,%2#)!412!FE,%2+)((*!?=-6%+'%'! B%(#016,%2! :1)'-lG! "%05+#0)(! d%612,!a?cc;dg:&"d&OK&MKG!aI?I!c2$*!c#2!;18#(#,*!d%-%)205!)+'!g%C%(16$%+,!:)812),12*I

@$)2G!BI;I

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!#EBA%$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A%"

Page 60: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

V%2)G!XI!)+'!3)2$%2G!?IPI!XIG!KLO^G!kc!;%,51'!14!c=,1$),#0)((*!?,)8#(#A#+/!B%(#016,%2!?(#+/!:1)'-lG!"%05+#0)(!<1,%!<c?c&"<&g&OYL_G!<c?c!:)+/(%*!d%-%)205!V%+,%2I

V#01()+#G!:I!)+'!W)++#+/G!7IG!KLLTG!kFH=),#1+-!14!;1,#1+!14!?(=+/&(1)'!?*-,%$-lG!J+0(='#+/!;=(,#(#4,!?*-,%$-G!"%05+#0)(!>)6%2!<c?c&">&_T[NG!<c?c!c$%-!d%-%)205!V%+,%2I

3=-),1G!gI!<=>?@AG!KLLLG!k3(#/5,!g*+)$#0-!@4!c+!c2,#0=(),%'!d1,12!B%(#016,%2!.#,5!)+!FE,%2+)(!?(=+/!:1)'lG!c$%2#0)+!B%(#016,%2!?10#%,*!YY,5!c++=)(!312=$G!;1+,2%)(G!V)+)')I

W%++%'*G!XIG!KLLOG!k"5%!>)2,#0(%!?.)2$Z!?10#)(!c')6,),#1+!14!W+1.(%'/%lG!J+!>210%%'#+/-!14!,5%!KLLO!JFFF!#+,%2+),#1+)(!V1+4%2%+0%! 1+! FC1(=,#1+)2*! V1$6=,),#1+! JVFVjLOG!J+'#)+)61(#-G!J+'#)+)G!a?cG!66I!_N_&_N[I

;)-1='G! mI<I! <=> ?@AG! TNNTG! k?.)*! 2%'=0,#1+! 1+! 01+,)#+%2!02)+%-! =-#+/! '%()*%'! 4%%'8)09! 01+,21((%2lG! J+!>210%%'#+/-!14! ,5%! ^_2'! cJcc\c?;F\c?VF\cB?\c?V! ?,2=0,=2%-G!?,2=0,=2)(!g*+)$#0-G!)+'!;),%2#)(-!V1+4%2%+0%G!g%+C%2G!V@G!cJcc&TNNT&KTOLI

@$)2!BI!;I!)+'!<)*4%5G!cIBIG!TNNYG! kc+,#&-.#+/!01+,21(!14! /)+,2*! )+'! ,1.%2! 02)+%-! =-#+/! 4=AA*! )+'! ,#$%&'%()*%'!4%%'8)09!.#,5!42#0,#1+!01$6%+-),#1+l!G!?5109!c+'!D#82),#1+G!D1(I!KTG!<1I!TG!66I!O_&[LI

@$)2G!BI;IG!TNNYG!kg*+)$#0-!14!5%(#016,%2!-(=+/!(1)'!-*-,%$!+%)2!51C%2l!"%05+#0)(!d%612,G!c%21-6)0%!g%6)2,$%+,G!W3a>;I

>1(#G!VI!)+'!V21$)09G!gIG!KLO_G!kg*+)$#0-!14!?(=+/!S1'#%-!a-#+/!)!?#+/(%&>1#+,!?=-6%+-#1+!?*-,%$lG!X1=2+)(!14!c#202)4,G!D1(I!KNG!<1I!TG!66I![N&[MI

>21=,*G!dIPIG!TNN_G!kB%(#016,%2!>%2412$)+0%G!?,)8#(#,*G!)+'!V1+,21(lG!W2%#/%2!>=8(#-5#+/!V1$6)+*I

d)AG!dI!<=>?@AG!KL[LG!kc0,#C%!)%21'*+)$#0!-,)8#(#A),#1+!14!)!5%(#016,%2\-(#+/&(1)'!-*-,%$lG!cJcc!X1=2+)(!14!c#202)4,G!D1(I!TMG!66I![TT&[T[I

?5#G!nI!)+'!F8%25)2,G!dIG!KLL[G!k>)2)$%,%2!?%(%0,#1+!#+!>)2,#0(%!?.)2$! @6,#$#A),#1+lG! J+! >210%%'#+/-! 14! ,5%! O,5!c++=)(!V1+4%2%+0%!1+!FC1(=,#1+)2*!>21/2)$$#+/G!66I!YLK&MNNI

?,=09%*G!dIcIG!TNNKG!k;),5%$),#0)(!;1'%(#+/!14!B%(#016,%2!?(=+/&:1)'! ?*-,%$-lG! "%05+#0)(! d%612,G! c#2! @6%2),#1+-!g#C#-#1+G!c%21+)=,#0)(! )+'!;)2#,#$%!d%-%)205!:)812),12*G!c=-,2)(#)I

P1(91C#,05G!XI!)+'!X15+-,1+G!gIG!KLMYG!kc=,1$),#0!V1+,21(!V1+-#'%2),#1+-!412!B%(#016,%2!)+'!D"@:!c#202)4,!P#,5!)+'!P#,51=,! ?(#+/! :1)'-lG! "%05+#0)(! d%612,! K_[&KG! ?*-,%$-!"%05+1(1/*!J+0I

c+,#&-.#+/!V1+,21((%2!S)-%'!1+!"#$%&'%()*%'!3%%'8)09!412!B%(#016,%2!?(=+/!:1)'!?*-,%$!+%)2!B1C%2

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()!#EBA%$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A%$

Page 61: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management
Page 62: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&'(#!%"

! "#$%!&%%'(&)!%*+%&,$%'(-!.#&!,'/%-(,01(,'0!1%&#(2%&$#3)4

5%%'!6#'376(%3!(#!+&#/,3%!3%-,0'!07,3%8,'%-!.#&!.7(7&%!&%7-4158%!-+16%!(&1'-+#&(1(,#'!-)-(%$-!#&!2)+%&-#',6!/%2,68%-9!"762!-(73,%-!%/1871(%3!(2%!3%-,0'!1-+%6(-!#.!1%&#(2%&$#3)'1$,6-!

:2%!"21&+!;30%!<8,02(!;*+%&,$%'(!=">;<;?@!+&#0&1$!,-!(2%!$1,'!,'-(1'6%!#.!-762!&%%'(&)!$,--,#'-9!A!817'62!/%2,68%!.#&!1!&%%'(&)!#5B%6(!,-!()+,6188)!6#$+#-%3!#.!(C#!#&!$#&%!-(10%-9!

+&#+%881'(!&#6D%(!E"4FG!=:2%,8!!"#$%&! H,--,#'-!1&%!+&#0&1$$%3!C,(2!-%I7%'6%3!%/%'(-!1'3!(2%)!1&%!07,3%3!51-%3!#'!'#$,'18!(&1B%6(#&,%-9!J'!1'!7'6#'(&#88%3!

! K'8)!5%(C%%'!(2%!+%'78(,$1(%!-(10%!57&'#7(!1'3!(2%!81-(!

$1'%7/%&@!1'3!-+,'47+!$1'%7/%&-!-2188!21++%'9!:2%!,0',(,#'!

/%2,68%!,'(#!1!3%-6%'(!#'%!.#&!(2%!&%%'(&)9! :2%! +#,'(,'0! 180#&,(2$! 3%-6&,5%3! 2%&%! ,-! 51-%3! #'! (2%!

3%/%8#+%3! 1'! 180#&,(2$! (#!#5(1,'! 1!+&#+%&! (&1'-.%&! .&#$!1!

)*+,-+,./01.*2+-34/5*2/$66,-27/%28+-/!,96:-+*,/;+-3/

',:*,-2*116</=>?-/@->.6

A1BC+*/D162/<6/E61*FGHG/I>1<64>2/<6/(>?-2*/=6+-6/A+13*JG/K+1-*,/(16862/)+6-2*8*4J

L

M

!"#$%&'$(#'(#!))!(*+$%#,!-.+,!/!("#01,#$#%$.(*2!,#3+"2#.(*1(",1%%!4#%$)"#)"$5!#+)#"1#*1/6."!#"2!#+5(+"+1(#"+/!#10##"2$"#)"$5!#$(4#+")#$""+".4!7#+(#1,4!,#"1#18"$+(#$#6,16!,#1,8+"# ",$()0!,#0,1/#$#(1(6,16!%%!4#",$9!*"1,:#"1#$#4!)+,!4#1,8+"7#

$*2+!;+(5#"2!#6,16!,#*1(4+"+1()#"1#+(9!*"#$#;!2+*%!#3+"2#.(*1(",1%%!4#%$)"#)"$5!#+("1#$#4!)*!("#<!6%!,+$(#",$9!*"1,:7#+(#

+(9!*"+1(&#=/6.%)+;!#+5(+"+1(#"+/!#$(4#(!*!))$,:#$""+".4!#01,#"2!#%$)"#)"$5!#$,!#18"$+(!4#8$)!4#1(#1,8+"$%#6$,$/!"!,)7#2$;+(5#$#/$"*2#8!"3!!(#"2!#(1(6,16!%%!4#$(4#,!!(",:#1,8+")7#$(4#81.(4$,:#*1(4+"+1()#$"#"2!#+(+"+$%#)"$"!#$(4#$"#"2!#!(",:#+("!,0$*!&#=/6.%)+;!#+5(+"+1(#"+/!#3$)#*1,,!*"!4#01,#*1/6!()$"+(5#"2!#+/6.%)+;!#$))./6"+1(#$(4#"2!#*$%*.%$"!4#

3+"2#.(*1(",1%%!4#%$)"#)"$5!7#$)#"2!#>2$,6#?45!#@%+52"#?A6!,+/!("#B>C?@?DE#6,15,$/&

)*+,-%.#($($%:)+)&

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A%EBA&$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A%E

Page 63: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

,'B%6(,#'!18(,(73%!#.!(2%!-1(%88,(%!6#&&%-+#'3%3!(#!(2%!+%&,0%%!

+#,'(,'0!-(&1(%0)!(#!+%&$,(!(2%!&%%'(&)!#.!(2%!-1(%88,(%!(2&#702!

! A!+#,'(,'0! 180#&,(2$!61'!5%! &7'! ,'! (2%!5%0,'','0!#.! (2%!6#1-(!+21-%!(#!#5(1,'!1!+&#+%&!(&1'-.%&!.&#$!(2%!16(718!#&5,(!(#!(2%!3%-,&%3!#'%9!:2%!#&5,(!(&1'-.%&!,-!1--7$%3!1-!1'!,$+78-,/%!

,'6&%$%'(!#.!+#-,(,#'!1'3!/%8#6,()!37%!(#!,(-!57&','0@!1'3!&%%'(&)!

(21(!(2%!81-(!-(10%!$7-(!5%!+,'+#,'(%3!,'!(2,-!(,$%!1&%!6186781(%39!J$+78-,/%!,0',(,#'!(,$%!,-!(2%'!6#&&%6(%3!.#&!6#$+%'-1(,'0!(2%!

4$1(%!-(10%!-%+1&1(,#'!(#!1/#,3!(21(!(2%!,'6&%1-,'0!,'%&(,18!-%'-#&!

! "#$%! (&13%#..-!$7-(! 5%! (1D%'! ,'(#! 6#'-,3%&1(,#'!C2%'!-%8%6(,'0!#'%!#.! (2%!+#--,58%!#&5,(! (&1'-.%&-9!:2%!,$+78-,/%!#&5,(! (&1'-.%&!$1)!#667&! ,'! (2%! 1-6%'(! -%6(,#'!#.! (2%! 6#1-(!

<#&!+&%/%'(,'0!3,-(7&51'6%-!(21(!$1)!3%0&13%!(2%!1667&16)!

,'B%6(,#'!#667&-!,'!(2%!1-6%'(!-%6(,#'!#.!(2%!6#1-(!+21-%!#&5,(9!

C2,62!$%1'-!(21(!8%--!+&#+%881'(!C#783!5%!'%6%--1&)!.#&!1'!,'B%6(,#'!.&#$!(2%!3%-6%'(!-%6(,#'9

LD"D$0=/A%$E'=0#!%"

! :2%!0%'%&18!+&#58%$!.#&$781(,#'!(#!%-(158,-2!(2%!'%6%-4-1&)!6#'3,(,#'-!.#&!1'!#&5,(! (&1'-.%&!1(! "F"=!C,88!5%!&%6188%3!.&#$!N%,(%!<,82#!=LOOF@9!:2%!,'-(1'(!"=!,-!(2%!,0',(,#'!(,$%!#.!(2%!81-(!-(10%!.#&!1'!2)+#(2%(,618!,$+78-,/%!#&5,(!(&1'-.%&9! :2%!$#(,#'!#.!(2%!/%2,68%P-!6%'(%&!#.!0&1/,()!37&,'0!(2%!

1-!,'!;I9!LQ

! " ! " # $! " ! # !�% &!" ! ! ! =L@

C2%&%!"!! ,-! (2%! 0&1/,(1(,#'18! 166%8%&1(,#'! 1'3! ! ,-! (2%! 7',(!,-!(2%!+&#+78-,/%!166%8%&1(,#'!

0,/%'!5)!;I9!MQ

! "! "

! "$#

$ $ # #

% # #

& ' ("

("� %

& '

'! =M@

C2%&%! ="G"+5 /)! ,-! (2%! -(&76(7&18! $1--! 1'3!/6="#G#"+5@!,-!(2%!+&#+%881'(!$1--!#.!(2%!81-(!-(10%!C,(2!,0',(,#'!(,$%! "+59! =9@!1'3!/6=9@!1&%!D'#C'!.7'6(,#'-9!:2%!-#87(,#'!(#!

# () * * *"(" ! ! !% & &! ! ! !

! " # # (! ! # # * ! !"(" (" (" ! ! !% & ' & &! ! ! ! ! ! =F@

! " $* +#

#

("

! � ��% ! ! =R@

! " $! * +#

#

("

! ! � �% !

! "! "

$*!!

+"#

#

)("

!�

� ��%!

!!

! " $! * +" "#

#

("

! ! � �%! !!

H I 1&%!,'6&%$%'(-!#.!/%8#6,()!1'3!+#-,(,#'!37%!

!1'3! !1&%!,'6&%$%'(-!

! :2%!,'6&%$%'(!#.!1'0781&!$#$%'(7$!37%!(#!(2%!81-(!-(10%!57&','0!,-!+&#/,3%3!5)!;I9!OQ

!"#$%&

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

<,07&%!L9!J$+78-,/%!#&5,(!(&1'-.%&!.#&!1!&%%'(&)!$,--,#'9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A%EBA&$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A%F

Page 64: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

, ! $* ! $ * #(" (" ("! !! % '! ! ! ! ! ! =O@

(2%!-1$%!3,&%6(,#'!1-!I+5!1'3!(2%!3,-(1'6%!(&1/%88%3!37&,'0!(2%!

!" # # *- (" "!� �'! !! "

! =LG@

"0!,-!(2%!57&'#7(!(,$%!#.!(2%!81-(!-(10%9!;I71(,#'!LG!61'!5%!&%1&&1'0%3!1-!;I9!LLQ

# ! ", $! * $ $ ! *. (" (" ."! !! ! !% & '! ! ! ! ! ! =LL@

#! ! # #*!

* *. (" - (" (" "!!

!% & ' ' &! ! ! !! !" "! " ! =LM@

! ;I71(,#'!LL!,-!,'(%&+&%(%3!1-!1'!#&5,(18!621'0%!37%!(#!1'!,$+78-,/%!(2&7-(!1++8,%3!1(!I=9!S)!(2%!+&,'6,+8%!#.!6#'-%&/1(,#'!

#, $! * * $ ! *. . (" (" ("! !! ! !% & '! ! ! ! ! !! "! ;I71(,#'!LM!-2#C-!(21(!I=!C,88!#667&! !-%6#'3-!1.(%&!"+5

$# #*!

- (" !!

% ' '! " ! =LF@

1'3!,(!-2#C-!(21(!(2%!,$+78-,#'18!-2#(!,'!I=#

,-!%I7,/18%'(!(#!(2%!16(718!(2&7-(!-(1&(%3!,'! "+5!C,(2!(2%!-1$%!3,&%6(,#'9!:2,-!%I7,/18%'6%!,-!6#&&%6(%3!5)!(2%!.16(#&!6#$+%'-1(%-! (2%! ,$+78-,#'18! 1--7$+(,#'! .#&! (2%! ,0',(,#'!(,$%!"=(,$%!=;I-9!LF!1'3!LR@Q

## #(" . % ' ! =LR@

(%"&!#!%"@/A%$/!E)'=@!MD/%$N!#/#$0"@AD$

81-(!-(10%!.&#$!(2%!6#1-(!+21-%!(#!(2%!&%%'(&)!#&5,(!$,02(!5%!H!,'!1!3,&%6(,#'!

3%-6&,5%3!5)!6#'3,(,#'!#.!&13,7-!=IG HG G@!1(!(2%!5%0,','0!#.!(2%!6#1-(!+21-%!1'3!(#!(2%!&%%'(&)!6#'3,(,#'-!

#.!&13,7-!=II HI I@9! T2%'!1++8),'0!(2%!,'6&%$%'(!#.!/%8#6,()!,'!(2%!3,&%6(,#'!3%-6&,5%3!5)!

(*+, *+, *+,) * *- - . .� � ��& %

#/0* /0* /0** * *- - . .� � ��& %

!"# $%& ;+)# ;+;$! %I71(,#'!1'3!(2%!1'0781&!$#$%'(7$!6#'-%&/1(,#'!+&,'6,+8%!+&#376%-!

/0* /0*!* ! *- - 1 1 1� �%

1'3

$*! /.

-.

-

� �% ' =LO@

##23/*+,

! *

! *1

1 1

1 1

"� % ! !

! !# $ =MG@

! :2%!+1&1$%(%&! ! ,-!(2%!+&#376(!#.!(2%!;1&(2P-!$1--!C,(2!(2%!0&1/,(1(,#'18!6#'-(1'(9!:2%!&%-78(,'0!&%%'(&)!#&5,(!,-!18-#!

/0* /0*!* ! *! ! !. .� �% ! =ML@

#*! /.

..

.

� �% ' ! =MM@

N#618!2#&,U

#'(18EV

EL

EM

EG

VVVG VJ

E

L M

G

V

<,07&%!M9!E%6(#&!3,10&1$!#.!(2%!#&5,(!(&1'-.%&9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A%EBA&$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A%#

Page 65: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

40 , $( ( (% !

(/0* /0*0 !* ! *- - - 1 1 1� �% %

/0* /0*0 !* ! *! ! !. . .� �% % ! =MF@

H

#/0* /0* *+, *+,* * * * *. ..-.

..

- . - . -� � � �� % & ' &! " ! =MR@

$1',+781(%3!5)!+&#6%%3,'0!(2%!-75-(,(7(,#'-! 4/0** 0 !- - -� %!

4/0** 0 !. . .� % 4*+,* * 0 !.

- - -.

-� % ' ! "4*+,* * 0 !. . .

..

.� % ' ! "

#* *!0 0

* *!0

*!0

. .-.

..

.- . .

-. -

.

.. .

.

�& ' ' % ' '% %& &

I! ,-!#5(1,'%3!1-!-2#C%3!

# # #1 ! 2 ! 3 ! 4 1) .& & & %� � � �

#4/ /

/ / 0 / / 0 0 / / 05 -6 5

-.

.

.

-.

.

.-.

-.

.

.- . -

...

.

.� � �%

' &�

(

3/ /

/ / 0 / / 0 0 / / 0 0

/ /* / / 0 0 / / 0

3

7 7 7

7 7

-.

.

.

-.

. -.

-.

. - . - ..

- .

-.

.

.

.-.

.

.- . - .

...

� � �

��

%' & &

&'

%

(2 *5 . ��%'�

(

1/ /

/ / / * / / /

/ /* / / * / /

1

. .

.

-.

.

.

.-. .

- ..

-.

..

.

.

-.

.

.

.- .

. 7-.

.

.

� � � �

� �

%' & &

&&

%

4

4$%(&,6!-#87(,#'!=;I9!MO@Q

/0* 23//0*!12 '

3)-

.) )

-.

5

5" " "%' & !% "& ! =MO@

!8(

8(

#

'13

12

61

2 314

12

3 6'

)-

) .

.9-

: .9 .

.- )

.

.

. )

)

)

"

% '

% ' '

%

� �

''

'

((

(

&##(-! 1&%! 6186781(%3!51-%3!#'! (2%! 2)+%&5#8,646#-,'%! (&,+8%4

8%13,'0!(#!(2%!-#87(,#'!3%-6&,5%3!5)!;I9!MO9

I=9!:2,-!&1'0%!,-!#5(1,'%3!51-%3!#'!(2%!.16(!(21(!I=!61''#(!5%!-$188%&!(21'!(2%!&13,7-!#.!

(21'!(2%!-#87(,#'!C2%&%!(2%!&%%'(&)!#&5,(! 8#67-!21-!#'8)!#'%!6#,'6,3%'(!+#,'(!C,(2!(2%!6#1-(!+21-%!#&5,(!8#67-9!:2%!+&16(,618!&1'0%!.#&!(2%!I=

! ! ! ! / 7-; ;$(8 $/91 - -% % &! "

3%+%'3!#'!2M!1(!(2%!8,$,(!&13,7-!.#&!1!-766%--.78!#&5,(!(&1'-.%&9!2M!

1'3!$1*,$7$!2M! 1(! (2%! 8,$,(&13,7-! 61'!5%! 6186781(%3!5)!1!

# #1 0 2 0 3 1.0 0 0.. & & %

3 *!*

/ /*

/

// *

!! / 0

3

5 .

.. .

$<+, <2=

0

! ! !0

7

.

-.

.

-

.

.

.

. ..

)

. -.

� � � �

��

��

% ' & & '

& & ''

%%

%!

&"# $) *

(2! / /

! / / ! ! * / 07 7

$<+, <2=0

! ! !)

- .

. -.

. -� � ��%

& & '

%

! "% &+ ,(1

/!

!7 .

-

$<+, <2=

0

! ! !-)�% '

%

' (

#23//0*! *

0$

$

<+, <2=

<2= <+,

!! !

.

� % ' (

!"#$%&

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A%EBA&$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A&%

Page 66: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

I=

5%! 61&&,%3!#7(! 1(! ,(! (#! ,'B%6(! (2%! 81-(! -(10%! ,'(#! (2%! &%%'(&)!

M9!:2%!3,&%6(,#'!#.!(2%!,$+78-,/%!-2#(!,-!

#23//0*! *

0 0-.

. -#��

%'' (

(&1B%6(#&,%-!(21(!-1(,-.)!(2%!-1$%!6#'3,(,#'-9!K'%!-#87(,#'!,-!.#&!

(2%!#(2%&!#'%!,-!.#&!(2%!(&1'-.%&!.&#$!(2%!3%-6%'(!-%6(,#'9!J(!,-!C#&(2!(#!'#(%!(21(!(2,-!-(73)!61'!-7++#&(!1'18)-%-!.#&!-%8%6(,'0!

H(2%!%'(&)!,'(%&.16%!3%+%'3-!#'!(2%!%'%&0)!#.!(2%!817'62!/%2,68%!

H H#+#--,58%!&13,7-!.#&!(2%!#&5,(!(&1'-.%&!61'!5%!#5(1,'%3!5)!7-,'0!

# #1 * 2 * 3 1) ) )7 .� �& & %

.

5 -6 7

5

3! / /

! / ! / / ! /

/ / 0 / / 0 0 ! / / 0 0 0

/ / 0 ! / / 0 0 0

3

3

-

7 $<+, <2=

)

! ! !

)

)

)-.

.

.) .

-. ) .

- .) .

.

.

-.

.

.-.

-.

.

.- . - .

.. .

-.

.

...

-.

. - . -

-

"

� � �

� � �

� �

% ' &

& ' & '

& & '

%

% %

!!

""

%

&

(1 -) %

,'!(2%!1-6%'(!-%6(,#'!#.!(2%!6#1-(!+21-%!(&1B%6(#&)!#&!,'!(2%!3%-6%'(!

,$+78-,/%!-2#(!,'!(2%!1-6%'(!-%6(,#'!C#783!5%!(2%!5%-(!#+(,#'9

!L"!#!%"/#!ED

C2%'!(2%!,$+78-,/%!-2#(!,-!61&&,%3!#7(!,-!&%81(%3!(#!(2%!(,$%!,'(%&/18!(21(!(2%!/%2,68%!81-(!-(10%!(1D%-!.&#$!IG!(#!I=9!;*+&%--4,'0! (2%! ,0',(,#'! (,$%! ,'! (%&$-! #.! (2%! %66%'(&,6! 1'#$18)!?

=W#&'%8,--%!!"#$%&

$*+, *+,#/

: : 7 : :*!

#(" . .)-

1 - 1 1��

��% ' ' ' & ' &! !" "% &

0#G# "+5! ,-! (2%!57&','0! (,$%!#.! (2%! 81-(! -(10%9!:2%!

$23//0*:/ 7

/ !

$;

;

; .- -

-

1

%'

%

' ((2%!%66%'(&,6,()!#.!(2%!6#1-(!+21-%!1-6%'(!(&1B%6(#&)!,-!-2#C%3!5)!;I9!FGQ

$/0* *+,7 7! *

-.

- 11 1

..

1.

1

""

�� �% % ' &' ( ! =FG@

1'3!,(-!-%$,4$1B#&!1*,-!,-!3%-6&,5%3!5)!;I9!FLQ

#/ /

!*

.- 1

11.�

�% %

' ! =FL@

$D=0#!%"/#%/#KD/!"D$#!0=/A$0ED

:2%!/%2,68%!+,(62!1'08%!

1-!;I9!FMQ

#. � �� � �%' & ' ' ! =FM@

J

*

VG

<8,02(!X81'%

U

V

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A%EBA&$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A&&

Page 67: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

! :2%!1'08%!5%(C%%'!(2%!8#618!/%&(,618!3,&%6(,#'!1(!(2%!817'62!-,(%!1'3!(2%!#'%!1(!(2%!!(2%!6#1-(!+21-%!5%0,'','0!61'!5%!618674

$23//0*! !

! !

</=8>0

</=8>0

1

1

"

"� % ! !

! !# $

! ! 0 (</=8>0 7 </=8>0 9% &! #! " ! ,-! (2%! &13,7-! =+#-,(,#'@! 1(! (2%!817'62!-,(%!6#'-,3%&,'0!(2%!$%1'!;1&(2P-!&13,7-!I!

(2%!817'62!-,(%!2%$.(*2 A!1(!(2%!( 9# 9

! S)! 6186781(,'0! (2%! 1'0781&! 1&07$%'(! /1&,1(,#'! #.! (2%!

!61'!5%!#5(1,'%3!5)!;I9!FFQ

! =FF@

&%81(,#'!5%(C%%'!5#(2!.&1$%-!$7-(!5%!6#'-,3%&%3!1-!.#88#C-9!!(#!C2,62!(2%!

4 (23/>2, % %? 9� % ' '! " ! =FR@! "(23/*+, %@� %

$

$

$

/0* /0* /0* *+, *+,

*+, /0*

/0* *+, /0* /0* *+,

% (

% (

% (

9

@

A

" " "

"

" " "

� � � �

� � � �

% '

%

%' '

4'1(,#'!+!=W#&'%8,--%!!"#$%&

(/0* (4

= 4

4

4@ @"% %!

! !

!

(>2,44

9

@� % ! =FO@

4 * !!%! ! !9

)%!"#!"L/0=L%$!#KE

"+5!1'3!(2%!3,&%6(,#'!= !1'3! @!#.!(2%!-2#(!.#&!,'B%6(,'0!(2%!/%2,68%!

8,-(%3!1-!.#88#C,'0Q"G IG HG!,'!'1/,01(,#'!.&1$%!

1'3!1--,0'$%'(!#.!&%%'(&)!6#'3,(,#'-!II HI!1'3! IY

G# $L !L?= $M!=;I9!FL!.#&!II HI@Y

I=

"+5

.&1$%! !1'3! !=;I9!FR!(#!FO@9

! :2,-!180#&,(2$!-2188!(&1'-.%&!(2%!/%2,68%!(#!(2%!&%I7,&%3!&%%'4(&)!#&5,(!$%%(,'0!6#'3,(,#'-!II HI!1'3! I#1(!(2%!%'(&)!,'(%&.16%9

@!E'=0#!%"/$D@'=#@

! ",$781(,#'-! (#! /%&,.)! (2%! 6#$+8,1'6%! #.! #&5,(! ,'B%6(,#'!

+%&.#&$%3!.#&!(2&%%!3,..%&%'(!-%(-!#.!%-(158,-2%3!&%%'(&)!6#'3,4

! :2%!,',(,18!&13,7-!IG

!"#$%& HG# G!C%&%!3%(%&$,'%3!5)!&%6188,'0!(2&%%!-,$781(,#'!61-%-!%*%67(%3!5)!

4

-,$,81&!(#!(2%!#'%-!7-%3!.#&!(2%!">;<;?4M!817'62!/%2,68%9

621&16(%&,-(,6-!#.!(2%!&%%'(&),'0!#5B%6(!3%(%&$,'%!(2%!/%8#6,()!HI!1'3!(2%!&%%'(&)!1'08%! I#1(!(2%!%'(&)!,'(%&.16%9!:2%!&%%'(&)!

!"#$%&

:158%!L9! <8,02(!31(19

<8,02(!A <8,02(!S <8,02(!WJ',(,18!6#'3,(,#'-

IG!=D$@HG

G=Z@V%%'(&)!6#'3,(,#'-

II=D$@HI

I=Z@ MR9GG FR9GG

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A%EBA&$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A&!

Page 68: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

&13,7-!II

4$7$!-+%%3!&1'0%!#.!(2%!">;<;?4M!$,--,#'Q!H162!=JI

(#!(%-(!(2%!%..%6(,/,()!#.!(2%!180#&,(2$Q! I#

H!C1-!%-(,$1(%3!.&#$!(%$+#&18!$1--!1'3!(2&7-(!67&/%-!.#&!

-,$,81&!(#!(2%!-%6#'3!-(10%!#.!(2%!">;<;?4M!%*+%&,$%'(9! :2%!&%-78(-!#.! (2%!180#&,(2$!1++8,61(,#'!.#&!6186781(,'0!(2%! &13,7-! (#! (2%!#&5,(! (&1'-.%&!I=

"=

,'(#!&%%'(&)!(&1B%6(#&,%-!5)!(2%!1++8,61(,#'!#.!(2%!180#&,(2$!

:2%!&%-78(-!68%1&8)!-2#C!(21(!(2%!+#,'(,'0!180#&,(2$!+&#376%-!

%'-7&,'0! (21(! (2%! &%I7,&%3! 6#'3,(,#'-! 1&%!$%(! 1(! (2%! %'(&)!

1-6%'(!#&!3%-6%'(!-%6(,#'-!#.!(2%!6#1-(!+21-%!(&1B%6(#&)9! :2%!6186781(%3!8,$,(-!.#&!I= I# H!+&#/,3%!$%1'-!(#!

37&,'0!(2%!+&%8,$,'1&)!$,--,#'!3%-,0'!1'3!+&#0&1$$,'0!(#!

! <,07&%! F! -2#C-! (2%! -,$781(,#'! &%-78(-! .#&! ,'B%6(,#'-! ,'(#!

6#'3,(,#'-!%-(158,-2%3!,'!:158%!L9!<,07&%!R!-2#C-!(2%!#&5,(!(&1'-4.%&!.#&!JI [!LL!1'3! I

%-(158,-2%3!,',(,18!6#'3,(,#'-!1(!(2%!5%0,'','0!#.!(2%!6#1-(!+21-%9

(%"(='@!%"@

! \,..%&%'(8)!#.!(2%!+#,'(,'0!180#&,(2$-!3%-6&,5%3!,'!N%,(%!(2,-!+1+%&!

+&%-%'(%3!1'!180#&,(2$!(21(!+%&$,(-!(2%!&%%'(&)!#.!1!/%2,68%!

+1(2!1'08%!1(!(2%!%'(&)!,'(%&.16%9! ",$781(,#'-!-2#C%3!(21(!(2%!+#,'(,'0!180#&,(2$!+&#/,3%-!

#.!(2%!180#&,(2$!5)!+&#/,3,'0!,$+#&(1'(!%'0,'%%&,'0!&%-78(-!

">;<;?!&%-%1&62!+&#0&1$9! K(2%&! ,$+#&(1'(! &%-78(-! 1&%! (2%! 6#'3,(,#'! 1'18)-%-! 1'3!8,$,(-!.#&!(2%!#&5,(!(&1'-.%&9!:2%-%!1'18)-%-!188#C%3!1!+&%8,$,4'1&)! %/1871(,#'! 37&,'0! (2%!$,--,#'! 3%-,0'! 1'3! +&#/,3%3! 1!

817'62!/%2,68%9!

+%&$,(!,(-!&%18!(,$%!,$+8%$%'(1(,#'!,'(#!(2%!#'5#1&3!6#$+7(%&!1'3!(#!+&#/,3%!1!-766%--.78!$,--,#'9

A+#0%% MGG!D$\#C'&1'0% LLRG!D$H1*,$7$!-+%%3"(10%- MV%%'(&)!1'08% MRZ

<8,02(!A <8,02(!S <8,02(!WV%-78(-

I=!=D$@"=#]$)*!("#62$)!!=)@"=#]4!)*!("#62$)!!=)@=Z@

HL

L!=Z@HM

M!=Z@ ^F9FMN,$,(-

I/+(!=D$@I/$A!=D$@

I !=Z@

I !=Z@H/+(]I/+(H/+(]I/$A

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A%EBA&$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A&A

Page 69: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&

MRGG MGGG LRGG LGGG RGG G RGG LGGG LRGG MGGG MRGGR_GG

`GGG

`MGG

`FGG

``GG

`_GG

aGGG

aMGG

aFGG

<8,02(!AQ!K&5,(!(&1'-.%&!.#&!&%%'(&)!1(!HV![!LG9GGb! V![!MR9GG!3%0&%%-

J',(,18!&13,7-;'(&)!,'(%&.16%W#1-(!+21-%!#&5,(V%%'(&)!#&5,(!.&#$!1-6%'(!-%6(,#'b!!! ![! LLa9OO!3%0b! M![! F9FM!3%0

V%%'(&)!#&5,(!.&#$!3%-6%'(!-%6(,#'b! ![!cLLa9OO!3%0b! M![!cF9FM!3%0

=1@!<8,02(!A

J',(,18!&13,7-;'(&)!,'(%&.16%W#1-(!+21-%!#&5,(V%%'(&)!#&5,(!.&#$!1-6%'(!-%6(,#'b!!!

V%%'(&)!#&5,(!.&#$!3%-6%'(!-%6(,#'b!

![! LM`9FM!3%0b! M _9``!3%0

![!cLM`9FM!3%0b! M![!c_9``!3%0

![!

MRGG MGGG LRGG LGGG RGG G RGG LGGG LRGG MGGG MRGGR_GG

`GGG

`MGG

`FGG

``GG

`_GG

aGGG

aMGG

aFGG

<8,02(!SQ!K&5,(!(&1'-.%&!.#&!&%%'(&)!1(!HV![!LL9GGb! V![!FR9GG!3%0&%%-

=5@!<8,02(!S

J',(,18!&13,7-;'(&)!,'(%&.16%W#1-(!+21-%!#&5,(V%%'(&)!#&5,(!.&#$!1-6%'(!-%6(,#'b!!! ![! LRd9`O!3%0b! M![! Rd9Gd!3%0

V%%'(&)!#&5,(!.&#$!3%-6%'(!-%6(,#'b! ![!cLRd9`O!3%0b! M![!cRd9Gd!3%0

MRGG MGGG LRGG LGGG RGG G RGG LGGG LRGG MGGG MRGGR_GG

`GGG

`MGG

`FGG

``GG

`_GG

aGGG

aMGG

aFGG

<8,02(!WQ!K&5,(!(&1'-.%&!.#&!&%%'(&)!1(!HV![!LM9GGb! V![!aG9GG!3%0&%%-

=6@!<8,02(!W<,07&%!F9!",$781(%3!#&5,(!(&1'-.%&-9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A%EBA&$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A&"

Page 70: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

$DAD$D"(D@

!"#$%&

#!"#$%& 4

(2!;7&#+%1'!W#'.%&%'6%!.#&!

V7--,19

A80#&,($#!3%!A+#'(1$%'(#!+1&1!J'B%ef#!3%!"1(g8,(%!%$!h&5,(1 J'Q!?!

!"# $%&

L G9_ G9` G9F G9M G G9M G9F G9` G9_ L

*!LG F

`GGG

FGGG

MGGG

MGGG

FGGG

`GGG

_GGG

<8,02(!SQ!K&5,(!(&1'-.%&!.#&!&%%'(&)!1(!H!V![!LL9GGb! V![!FR9GG!3%0&%%-

G

J',(,18!&13,7-;'(&)!,'(%&.16%W#1-(!+21-%!#&5,(V%%'(&)!#&5,(!.&#$!1-6%'(!-%6(,#'b!!!

V%%'(&)!#&5,(!.&#$!3%-6%'(!-%6(,#'b!M

M

<,07&%!R9!K&5,(!(&1'-.%&!.#&!JI [!LL!1'3! I![!FRZ9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A%EBA&$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A&$

Page 71: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management
Page 72: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&'(#!%"

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

HII!F3!:4/3!*#$!+)80.#!(,*$A!"#$!(6(*$3!(#/8+2!7$!)..$+$4)*$2!76!)!;4)<,+,)0!P%LQI!(/802,05!4/.F$*!>B,5A!C7@A! "/!2)*$D!(/+,2!)02!+,R8,2!4/.F$*!94/98+(,/0!(6(*$3(!-$4$!*#$! /0+6! *$.#0/+/5,.)+! 3$)0(! ./0(,2$4$2! :/4! *#$! 2$7//(*!

!2/,S!CIAEITUVK)*3ATICTAIQIHTHCT

)*+%,-./.012+3456.2+$7891-+:7-76+;76+-<1+=)$)+>?@-;76/+$11*-64+=4A-1/>1267+BC.0+D@?12+&@+(EAF+(6.A-.@*7+GC1.670+H.?@*7I@F+:@*C1?+"@A8./1*-7+&.@A+J@681?7A+K6LMF+(@6?7A+)?516-7+NC6O1?+H16@AW0,1$4(,2)2$!2$!;4)(X+,)!L!;4)(X+,)VYB!Z!;4)<,+

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

EFE

'1*!%(58G&)(%%4)$6$10!HE

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

)*+,-%.#(

'$.$,1$2S!CUVIQVCT! &..$9*$2S!TCVI[VCT\)8*#/4!:/4!./44$(9/02$0.$S!3)08$+7)4.$+/(]53),+A./3B).8+2)2$! W0;L^)3)L! _4$)! ?(9$.,)+! TD! `/*$! CQD! %$*/4! a$0*4)+!^)3)LYBV!a?bS!OTQIEL[CIL!;4)<,+

!>)@! >7@B,584$!CA!"#$! %&'&! 9+)*:/43! )*3/(9#$4,.! 4$$0*46A! >)@! )4*,(*c(!

,394$((,/0d! >7@! *#$! P%LQI! 4/.F$*A! %/84.$S! ;4)<,+,)0!=0(*,*8*$!/:!&$4/0)8*,.(!)02!%9).$A

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A&EBAA%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A&E

Page 73: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

3/*/4! >P,++)(!;e)(!(.! '5:D! TII[@A!f674,2! 94/9$++)0*! 4/.F$*!$05,0$(D!#/-$1$4D!./8+2!7$!)!./39$*,*,1$!)+*$40)*,1$!:/4!*#$!4$$0*46!(6(*$3!,0!+,5#*!/:!*#$!4$.$0*!4$9/4*$2!*$.#0/+/5,.)+!)21)0.$(D!+)45$+6!*/!*#/($!./0.$40$2!-,*#!,394/1$3$0*(!,0!(/+,2!:8$+!4$54$((,/0!4)*$A! "#$!W0,1$4(,2)2$!2$!;4)(X+,)!#674,2!94/98+(,/0! *$)3!>fb"!L!W0;@!#)(!)!./0(,2$4)7+$!#,(*/46!,0!2$1$+/9,05!)02!*$(*,05!#674,2!4/.F$*!$05,0$(!)02!(3)++!(/802,05!4/.F$*(D!,0!-#,.#! *#$! *#48(*!)02!7840,05! *,3$(! >,398+($@!)4$!R8,*$!(,3,+)4! */! *#/($! .+),3$2! 76! *#$! %&'&! 2$7//(*! (6(*$3!>P,$5)(!)02!%)+$3,D!TIIId!%)0*/(D!TII[d!a/0*),:$4D!TII[@A!f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e)(!(.!'5:!>TII[@A!"#$! /9*,3,<)*,/0! ./2$! 7)($2! /0! )! 5$0$*,.! )+5/4,*#3D! )(!94$($0*$2!,0!*#,(!-/4FD!(#/8+2!7$!./0(,2$4$2!)!3/2$40!)02!$(($0*,)+!2$(,50!)((,(*)0.$! *//+! :/4!)!74/)2!8*,+,<)*,/0!/:!#674,2!94/9$++)0*!4/.F$*!$05,0$(A

3PJ$!&+>$%>QBB)"#+$%(DQ#+Q"N!"Q=

! =0!(9,*$!/:!)++!.+),3$2!)21)0*)5$(!/:!#674,2!4/.F$*!$05,0$(!/1$4!*#$!(/+,2!)02!+,R8,2!./80*$49)4*(D!*#$!4$+)*$2!-$)F0$(($(!(#/8+2!7$!)0)+6<$2!,0!3/4$!2$*),+(!)(!*/!)((84$!*#$!*$.#0/+/56!-/8+2!0/*!7$!2,(4$5)42$2!:/++/-,05!)! 4(*!)(($((3$0*!:/4!*#$!94/9/($2!)99+,.)*,/0!>2$7//(*$4@A! '$.$0*+6D!M)4)7$6/5+8!>TIIU@!#,5#+,5#*$2!(/3$!0/0*$.#L0,.)+!.#)++$05$(!*#)*!#674,2!4/.F$*(!:).$!,0!*#$!94$($0*!2)6(S!+).F!/:!*$.#0/+/5,.)+!3)*84,*6d!./39$*,*,/0!)5),0(*!$(*)7+,(#$2!(/+,2! )02! +,R8,2! *$.#0/+/5,$(d!94/98+(,/0! ,028(*46! 0$0$((!-,*#!*#$!%.'.4%!742d!)02!(3)++$4!54/89(!/:!4/.F$*!94/:$((,/0)+(!4$5)42,05!(/+,2!)02!+,R8,2!4/.F$*(A! g$!)22!*/!*#/($!0/0*$.#0,.)+!.#)++$05$(!(/3$!F$6!*$.#L0/+/5,.)+!2,()21)0*)5$(!/:!#674,2!94/98+(,/0D!./39)4$2!*/!(/+,2!)02!+,R8,2!./44$(9/02,05!(6(*$3(!)(!9/,0*$2!76!&+*3)0!)02!f/+<3)0!>TIIO@S! +/-!4$54$((,/0!4)*$!/:! *#$!(/+,2!:8$+!(84:).$d!+/-!78+F!2$0(,*6d!./378(*,/0!$: .,$0.6d! VB!(#,:*d!)02!(+/-$4!*4)0(,$0*(A

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d

! 4$+,)7,+,*6!>28$!*/!*#$!+)45$4!3)45,0!/:!*/+$4)0.$!,0!54),0!,39$4:$.*,/0(!)(!-$++!)(!)37,$0*!./02,*,/0(@d$G,7,+,*6!>76!1,4*8$!/:!(*/9L4$(*)4*!.)9)7,+,*,$(!)02!*#48(*!3/28+)*,/0@d

! ./(*(!>28$!*/!+/-!,01$(*3$0*(!./(*(!:/4!2$1$+/93$0*!)02!/9$4)*,/0!)(!-$++!)(!*#/($!./(*(!)((/.,)*$2!-,*#!*#$!3)*$4,L)+(!*/!:)74,.)*$!*#$!3/*/4D!)02!5$0$4)+!)1),+)7,+,*6!/:!*#$!4$R8,4$2!3)*$4,)+(!)02!*$.#0/+/5,$(@d

! $01,4/03$0*!>(,0.$!./378(*,/0!94/28.*(!)4$!/:*$0!0/0*/G,.!5)($(! )02!94/9$++)0*(! )4$!0/*! #)<)42/8(! */! (*/4)5$! )02!*4)0(9/4*@A

! a/39)4$2! */! +,R8,2! 4/.F$*! $05,0$(D! Y)162$0F/! (.! '5:!>TIIO@! )22$2! *#)*! *#$! 8($! /:! #674,2! 4/.F$*! *$.#0/+/56D! )(!(855$(*$2!,0!*#,(!(*826D!-/8+2!,0.4$)($!(6(*$3!4$+,)7,+,*6!/0!)../80*!/:!4$28.*,/0!,0S! 94/98+(,/0!(6(*$3!2$1$+/93$0*!9$4,/2(D!:4/3!)7/8*!:/84!6$)4(!*/!+$((!*#)0!*$0!3/0*#(d

! :)74,.)*,/0!./(*D!76!)!:).*/4!/:!)7/8*! *-/D!/-,05! */! *#$!)99+,.)*,/0! /:! *#$43)+! 94/*$.*,1$! .)47/0L./0*),0,05!./39/(,*$!3)*$4,)+(d

! /9$4)*,05!./(*(D!76!QI!*/!EI d! ./(*!/:! 4$L)02L$G9+/(,/0!():$*6!(6(*$3(A

! "#$!4$R8,4$2! *#48(*! +$1$+!:/4! *#$!%&'&!4$$0*46!(6(*$3!,(! :)4! +$((! *#)0! *#)*! :/4! )! (3)++! +)80.#! 1$#,.+$D! *#$4$:/4$!(/+,2!4$54$((,/0!4)*$!.)0!7$!./0(,2$4$2!($./02)46!,0!9$4:/4L3)0.$! .#)4).*$4,(*,.(A!"#$!3),0! 2,()21)0*)5$(D! +,(*$2! 76!&+*3)0!)02!f/+<3)0!>TIIO@D!($$3!)+(/!0/*!(/!,39$4)*,1$!*/!

ah(!bA`AaA!(.!'5:

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A&EBAA%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A&F

Page 74: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

2,(4$5)42!#674,2!4/.F$*!:/4! *#$!2$7//(*!(6(*$3A!;4)<,+!(*,++!+).F(!)0!$(*)7+,(#$2!4/.F$*!94/98+(,/0! ,028(*46d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

:'B#!&!=(!>B!")$P+ &Q=!N"+ %>#!:!R)#!%"+(%&!"N

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d! )$4/260)3,.(d! 38+*,2,(.,9+,0)46!2$(,50d!94/98+(,/0d!(*48.*84$(d!(.#$28+,05!)02!./0*4/+d! ,5#*!*$(*!2)*)!$G*4).*,/0D!)3/05!/*#$4(A!^&!.)0!7$!)99+,$2!,0!*#$!./0.$9*8)+!9#)($!/:!2$(,50!)(!)!(87(*,*8*$!*/!3/4$!*4)2,*,/0)+!*4,)+!)02!$44/4!3$*#/2(A!&(!9/,0*$2!76!&F#*)4!)02!`,0L(#!>TIIO@D!^&D!./39)4$2! */!54)2,$0*L7)($2!3$*#/2(D!)++/-(!/9*,3,<)*,/0L+,F$! *//+(! */!(899/4*! *#$!./0.$9*8)+!9#)($!/:!2$(,50!76!./37,0,05!2,(.4$*$D!,0*$5$4D!)02!./0*,08/8(!1)4,L)7+$(!-,*#!0/!4$R8,4$3$0*!:/4!)0!,0,*,)+!2$(,50A!"#$!3$*#/2!#)(! )+(/! *#$! )7,+,*6! */! )224$((! 0/0./01$GD! 38+*,3/2)+D!)02! 2,(./0*,08/8(! :80.*,/0(! /:! )! 5,1$0! 94/7+$3! >&F#*)4!)02!`,0L(#D!TIIO@A!J/4$!4$.$0*+6D!/9*,3,<)*,/0!)0)+6(,(!/:!#674,2!4/.F$*!$05,0$(!#)(!7$$0!)99+,$2! */! +)80.#!1$#,.+$(!>'#$$!(.!'5:D!TIIUd!Y)`,0!(.!'5:D!TICT@A! &0!/9*,3,<)*,/0!94/7+$3!.)0!7$!$G94$(($2!)(!*#$!3,0,L3,<)*,/0!/:!)0!/7K$.*,1$!:80.*,/0!802$4!.$4*),0!$R8)+,*6!)02!,0$R8)+,*6!./0(*4),0*(A!"#$!:/438+)*,/0!/:!)!5$0$4,.!/9*,3,<)L*,/0!94/7+$3!,(!2$ 0$2!)(!?R(A!C!*/!QS

!"#$ ! " # "$ $! !! ""! >C@! !% " # " % &% %!& !! "" ! >T@! !' " # " ' &%' '! !! "" ! >H@

($ " & $ $ $( )$! " "& # $ ! >Q@

-#$4$D6!,(!*#$!/7K$.*,1$!:80.*,/0D%!,(!*#$!($*!/:!2$(,50!1)4,)7+$(D7!,(!*#$!($*!/:!2$(,50!.4,*$4,)D!)02#!)02!0!)4$!4$(9$.*,1$+6!$R8)+,*6!)02!,0$R8)+,*6!./0(*4),0*(A

! "#$!2$(,50!1)4,)7+$(!)02!./0(*4),0*(!7$+/05!*/!)!($*!/:!4$)+!0837$4(D!-#/($!2,3$0(,/0(!)4$! 4$94$($0*$2!76!1%D!1#

)02!10D! 4$(9$.*,1$+6A!"#$!1)+8$(!/:! *#$!2$(,50!1)4,)7+$(!)4$!+,3,*$2!76! +/-$4!)02!899$4!7/802(! >i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

>$%JBQ:+=#)#Q:Q"#+)"&+:Q#3%&=

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

&0! 9*,3,<$2!f674,2!'/.F$*!J/*/4!:/4!*#$!%&'&!b+)*:/43!'$$0*46!%6(*$3

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A&EBAA%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A&#

Page 75: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

$05,0$!4$+,$(!/0!)!($+:L94$((84,<,05!jT !)02!9)4): 0L7)($2!(/+,2! :8$+! >&+3$,2)! )02! %)0*/(D! TIIE@A! &! 94$((84,<,05!(87(6(*$3!,(! *#$4$:/4$!0/*!0$.$(()46D!(,39+,:6,05!*#$! 0)+!2$(,50! ./39+$G,*6! )02! ./(*! :/4! *#$! 4$$0*46! 3/*/4A! "#$!%&'&! (9).$.4):*!-)(! )+(/! ./0.$,1$2! */! #)1$! )0! )**,*82$!./0*4/+!(6(*$3A!=:!0,*4/8(!/G,2$!,(!*#$!94$:$44$2!/G,2,<$4D!*#$!(6(*$3!./8+2!7$!7)($2!7/*#!/0!./+2!5)(!/4!*#$43/!.)*)+6*,.!2$./39/(,*,/0!/:!jT D!80,:6,05!)++!*#$!(9).$.4):*!94/98+(,1$!4$R8,4$3$0*(!)../42,05+6!>a)397$++!(.!'5:D!TIIU@A! "#$!($./02!94/9/(,*,/0!,(!3/4$!./01$0*,/0)+D!)(!,*!,(!7)($2!/0!#624/5$0!9$4/G,2$!)02!/0!)!94$((84,<)*,/0!(87(6(*$3A!=0!7/*#!.)($(D!9)4): 0!-)(!./0(,2$4$2!)(!*#$!(/+,2!:8$+A!&0!,0K$.L*/4!9+)*$!7)($2!/0!94$((84$!(-,4+!)*/3,<$4(!-)(!.#/($0!:/4!/G,2,<$4!,0K$.*,/0!,0*/!*#$!./378(*,/0!.#)37$4A!"#,(!(6(*$3!-/8+2!(,50, .)0*+6!,0.4$)($!*#$!(/+,2!:8$+!4$54$((,/0!4)*$!)(!./39)4$2!*/!)!(#/-$4#$)2!,0K$.*/4!*69$A!"#$!#674,2!3/*/4!-/8+2!7$!3)2$!/:!)!.6+,024,.)+!./0*),0$4!-,*#!(9#$4,.)+!$02(A!"#$!0/<<+$!-/8+2!7$!/:!./0,.!(#)9$D!3)2$!/:!)+83,083!-,*#!.)47/0!9#$0/+,.!,0($4*!:/4!*#$43)+!94/*$.*,/0A!"#$!./378(*,/0!

.#)37$4!(#/8+2!)+(/!7$!3)2$!/:!)+83,083!-,*#!)22$2!*#$4L3)+!,0(8+)*,/0!:/4!*#$!9/(*./378(*,/0!.#)37$4A! "#$! 3),0! 4$$0*46! 3,((,/0! )(9$.*(! -$4$! 94$($0*$2! )02!2,(.8(($2! 76! P,++)(! ;e)(! (.! '5:! >TIII@D! 0)3$+6S! 2$7//(*!,398+($!(#/8+2!94/28.$!)!1$+/.,*6!4$28.*,/0!/:!*#$!/42$4!/:!THE!*/!TEI!3V(d!)02!*/*)+!7840,05!*,3$!/:!*#$!3/*/4!(#/8+2!7$!7$*-$$0!EI!)02!TII!($./02(A! "#$($!9$4:/43)0.$!.#)4).*$4,(*,.(D! *#/85#D! )4$!0/*! (*)02L)+/0$A! "#$! 94/98+(,1$! (6(*$3! (#/8+2! )+(/! 7$! (87K$.*$2! */!5$/3$*4,.!./0(*4),0*(D!)(!-$++!)(!*/*)+!3)((!+,3,*)*,/0D!/0!)../80*!/:!*#$!+)80.#!1$#,.+$!/9$4)*,/0)+!$01$+/9$!)02!/1$4)++!3,((,/0!$: .,$0.6A!B/++/-,05!*#)*D!P,++)(!;e)(!(.!'5:! >TIII@!94/9/($2!*#4$$!2,::$4$0*!./0 584)*,/0(!:/4!*#$!$05,0$!>2$7//(*$4@S!+,R8,2!7,94/9$++)0*! >`;b@D! +,R8,2!3/0/94/9$++)0*! >`Jb@D! )02! (/+,2!94/9$++)0*!>%b@A!"#$!`;b!)+*$40)*,1$!-)(!./39/($2!/:!)!+,R8,2!4/.F$*!$05,0$!(6(*$3!7)($2!/0!80(633$*4,.)+!2,3$*#6+#624)<,0$!>WYJf@!)02!0,*4/5$0!*$*4/G,2$!>j" @D!-,*#!$05,0$!.#)37$4!:$$2,05!94/1,2$2!76!3$)0(!/:!)0!,0$4*!5)(!>0,*4/5$0@!94$((84L,<)*,/0!(87(6(*$3A!"#$!($./02!/9*,/0!>`Jb@!-)(!)!#624)<,0$!3/0/94/9$++)0*!(6(*$3A!&(!:/4!*#$!`;bD!$05,0$!.#)37$4!:$$2,05!(#/8+2!)+(/!7$!94/1,2$2!76!)0!,0$4*!5)(!>0,*4/5$0@!94$((84,<)*,/0!(87(6(*$3A!"#$!+)(*!./0 584)*,/0!>%b@!(#/8+2!7$!7)($2!/0!*#$!*$.#0/+/56!2$1$+/9$2!)*!*#$!=&?!:/4!*#$!'/++!a/0*4/+!%6(*$3!>ba'V%L=P@! /:! *#$! (/802,05! 4/.F$*! %/02)L=PA! ?05,0$! *#48(*!-/8+2!./3$!:4/3!*#$!(/+,2!94/9$++)0*!$02L7840!54),0!*69$A!"#$!94/9$++)0*!54),0!-)(!./0.$,1$2!)(!)!1)4,)7+$!7840,05!)4$)d! 0)+!*#48(*!-)(!)7/8*! 1$!*/!(,G!*,3$(!+/-$4!*#)0!*#$!,0,*,)+!*#48(*A! B,584$!T!(#/-(!)!./0.$9*8)+!2$(,50!/:!*#$!(9).$.4):*!)02!,*(!3),0!./39/0$0*(A!&(!,*!.)0!7$!($$0D!*#$!$05,0$!:/4!2$7//(*,05!38(*!3$$*!(/3$!2,3$0(,/0)+!4$R8,4$3$0*(A!"#$!(*826!./028.*L$2!76!P,++)(!;e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

ah(!bA`AaA!(.!'5:

B,584$!TA! a/0.$9*8)+!2$(,50!/:!*#$!%&'&!9+)*:/43!>-,*#!#674,2!2$7//(*!3/*/4@D! -#,.#! -)(! 7)($2! /0! )! ./0.$9*! 76! *#$! ;4)<,+,)0!=0(*,*8*$!/:!&$4/0)8*,.(!)02!%9).$!-,*#!*#$!3),0!(87(6(*$3(A

!"#"

$$%&

!"#"

$$%&

'%(#)*+,-.%/01)&$%2*#"(%)&

34/#)20&,!0#).%/01)&$%2*#"(%)&

'5- '5- 35-5 35-5

30 30

B,584$!HA!b4/.$(($(!2,)54)3D!J/2$B' j"=?'!./2,05A

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A&EBAA%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A!%

Page 76: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

2,)3$*$4A!&22,*,/0)++6D!*#$,4!($0(,*,1,*6!)0)+6($(!:/4!38+*,9/4*!#674,2!$05,0$(!(#/-$2!*#$!:/++/-,05S

! ,0,*,)+!/G,2,<$4! 8G!./8+2!2/3,0)0*+6!)::$.*!*#$!+$05*#!)02!2,)3$*$4!/:!4/.F$*!(,38+*)0$/8(+6d

! 0/<<+$!$G,*!2,)3$*$4!-)(!3),0+6!)::$.*$2!76!*#$!./378(L*,/0!.#)37$4!94$((84$!)02!0/<<+$!$G9)0(,/0!4)*,/d

! *#$!)1$4)5$!4)*,/!#)2!)!(3)++! ,0 8$0.$!/0!*#$!4$(9/0($!9)4)3$*$4(! +,F$!4/.F$*! +$05*#!)02!2,)3$*$4D!)02!0/<<+$!$G,*!2,)3$*$4A

! Y$(,50!1)4,)7+$(!-$4$!($+$.*$2!,0!/42$4!*/!F$$9!*#$!,0#$4L$0*!(,39+,.,*6!/:!#674,2!94/98+(,/0!(6(*$3(A!̀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

! (/+,2!:8$+!$G*$40)+!2,)3$*$4!>3@!Z!IAIE! !Y:! !IATd! (/+,2!:8$+!+$05*#!>3@!Z!IAIE! J0 !IAE!d! ,0*$40)+!9/4*!2,)3$*$4!>3@!Z!IAITE! !Y,! !IATd! ,0,*,)+! ./378(*,/0! .#)37$4! 94$((84$(! >Jb)@! Z! .)($! CD!!CAI! &+$ !EAId!.)($!TD!HAI! &+$ !EAId!)02

! ,0,*,)+!/G,2,<$4!3)((! /-!4)*$!>F5V(@!Z!IAIE! / ! !TAIA

! "#$! (/+,2! :8$+! $G*$40)+! 2,)3$*$4!-)(! .#/($0! )(! )!3),0!2$(,50!1)4,)7+$D!28$!*/!,*(! ,0*4,0(,.!4$+)*,/0!-,*#!*#$!1/+83$!/:!*#$!./378(*,/0!.#)37$4A!=0!/42$4!*/!$1)+8)*$!)!74/)2!4)05$!/:!./0 584)*,/0(D!*#$!54),0!$G*$40)+!2,)3$*$4!-)(!($*!*/!1)46!:4/3!IAIE!*/!IAT!3D!-#,.#!,(!38.#!+/-$4! *#)0!*#$!2,)3$*$4!/:! *#$!P%LQI!(/802,05! 4/.F$*! >kCAI!3@A!"#,(!-,2$! 4)05$! ,0!2,)3$*$4!-)(!($+$.*$2!*/!)++/-!)!#,5#!2$54$$!/:!:4$$2/3D!(,0.$!./398*)*,/0)+!./(*!-)(!)!3,0/4!./0.$40A!^4),0!+$05*#!-)(!)+(/!($+$.*$2!)(!)!3)K/4!2$(,50!1)4,)7+$!28$!*/!,*(!2,4$.*!,0 8$0.$!/0!3,G*84$!4)*,/!)02!(,<$!./0(*4),0*!/:!*#$!(6(*$3A!"#$!54),0!,0,*,)+!9/4*!2,)3$*$4!/4!*#,.F0$((!,(!)!3$)(84$!/:!*#$!)1),+)7+$!7840,05!4)2,8(D!/4!7840,05!*,3$!2$9$02,05!/0!*#$!)1$4)5$!/G,2,<$4!3)((!8GA!&!./0(*4),0*!-)(!,39/($2!*/!*#$!,0,*,)+!9/4*!2,)3$*$4!)(!*/!)1/,2!$4/(,1$!7840A!&../42,05+6D!,0,*,)+!/G,2,<$4!3)((! 8G!(#/8+2!0/*!$G.$$2!QII!F5V>3T(@!:/4!(*)02)42! /-!./02,*,/0(!

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a c(!J/2$B' j"=?'!(/:*-)4$!>J/2$B' j"=?'1Q@!-)(!8($2! */!#$+9!5$0$4)*$D!$1)+8)*$D!)02! ($+$.*! ,02,1,28)+(! )+/05! *#$!/9*,3,<)*,/0!94/.$((A!"#$!J/2$B' j"=?'!-/4F /-!(#/-$2!,0!B,5A!Q!./0(,(*(!/:!)!9$4:/43)0.$!94$2,.*,/0!3/28+$!>7)++,(*,.!3/2$+@D!)!($*!/:!,098*!1)4,)7+$(D!)02!)!7+/.F!-,*#!*#4$$!l=Bm!(*48.*84$(!:/4!*#$!2$(,50!./0(*4),0*(!$1)+8)*/4D!/0$!l=Bm!0/2$D!)!^&!(.#$28+$4D!4$(9/0L(,7+$!:/4!./0*4/++,05!*#$!̂ &!-/4FD!)02!)!2$(,50!/:!$G9$4,3$0*(!>Y ?@!7+/.F!4$(9/0(,7+$!:/4!./0*4/++,05!*#$!,02,1,28)+(!7$,05!5$0$4)*$2!)02!*$(*$2A!"#$!9$4:/43)0.$!94$2,.*,/0!3/28+$!-)(!,39+$3$0*$2!,0!*#$!J&"`&;!'TICI)!?05,0$$4,05!?R8)*,/0!%/+1$4!>??%!&.)2$3,.!b4/:$((,/0)+!PULHY@A!"#,(!3/28+$!#)(!*#$!,0*$40)+!7)++,(*,.!3/2$+!94/9/($2!,0!*#,(!-/4FA!"#$! 1$!,098*!1)4,)7+$(!7+/.F!4$94$($0*!*#$!4$(9$.*,1$!2$(,50!1)4,)7+$(!2$(.4,7$2!94$1,/8(+6A!"#$!*-/!2$(,50!./0(*4),0*!0/2$(!4$94$L($0*!*#$!*,3$!)02!1$+/.,*6!1)4,)*,/0!./0(*4),0*(D!EI!n!.!n!TII!)02!D(5.'GM!N!EOPD!4$(9$.*,1$+6A!"#$!=B!0/2$!,0*$0*(!)*!$+,3,L0)*,05!,02,1,28)+(!*#)*!:)++!/8*(,2$!*#$!+,3,*)*,/0(!,39/($2!76!*#$!7)++,(*,.!3/2$+A!"-/!+,3,*)*,/0(!-$4$!$1)+8)*$2!Y!o!D$!)02!Q!n!FL!n!CCD!-#$4$!D!-)(!*#$!,0(*)0*)0$/8(!9/4*!2,)3$*$4!)*!)06!5,1$0!*,3$A

&0! 9*,3,<$2!f674,2!'/.F$*!J/*/4!:/4!*#$!%&'&!b+)*:/43!'$$0*46!%6(*$3

B,584$!QA!J/*/4!./0 584)*,/0(S!fT TV9)4): 0!)02!jT V9)4): 0A

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A&EBAA%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A!&

Page 77: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

! "#$!.#/($0!^&!:/4! *#,(!/9*,3,<)*,/0!-)(! *#$!&2)9*,1$!')05$!J8+*,L 7K$.*,1$!^&!>&'J ^&@!>%)()F,!)02! 7)6)(L#,D!TIIE@A!"#,(!,(!)!*69$!/:!^&!2$(,50$2!:/4!4)9,2!./01$4(,/0!/4!b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

!"#Q$")B+ J)BB!=#!(=+ )"&+ Q"N!"QQ$!"N+:%&QB=

! "#$! 7)++,(*,.! 3/2$+! :/4! *#$! #674,2!3/*/4! /9*,3,<)*,/0!94/.$((! #)(! ,*(! 4//*(! /0! *#)*! 94/9/($2! 76! a)()+,0/! )02!b)(*4/0$!>TIIE@A!"#$!3),0!9)4)3$*$4(!)4$!(#/-0!,0!B,5A![A!

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

)* +,-./0&! ! >E@

! P)+8$(! /:! '! )02! 1! 9)4)3$*$4(D! )99$)4,05! ,0! ?RA! CD! )(!94/9/($2!76!/84!4$($)4.#!54/89!>;$4*/+2,D!TIIO@!)02!*#/($!/:!M)4)7$6/5+8!(.!'5:!>TIIQ@!.)0!7$!($$0!,0!")7+$!TD!:/4!0,*4/8(!/G,2$!)02!9)4): 0A!"#$!#,5#$4! 4$54$((,/0! 4)*$!/7*),0$2!76!>;$4*/+2,D!TIIO@!./39)4$2!*/!*#$!+)**$4!3)6!7$!$G9+),0$2!76!*#$!8($!/:!94$((84$!(-,4+!)*/3,<$4(A!B/4!#624/5$0!9$4/G,2$!)02!9)4): 0D!)(!*#$!94/9$++)0*(D!-$!*//F!4$54$((,/0!9)4)3$*$4(!:/802!,0!;4/-0!)02!`62/0!>TIIE@A

")7+$!TA! P)+8$(!/:!'!)02!1D!:/4!Q!,0!F5V>3T(@!)02!)!,0!33V(Ab4/9$++)0*( 1 '$:$4$0.$

jT V9)4): 0 IAOTT IA[O ;$4*/+2,!>TIIO@

jT V9)4): 0 IAQUU IA[T M)4)7$6/5+8!(.!'5:!>TIIQ@

fT TV9)4): 0 IAIHQ IAN[ ;4/-0!)02!`62/0!>TIIE@

! Y8$!*/!*#$!#,5#!9)4): 0!4$54$((,/0!4)*$!./39)4$2!*/!/*#$4!*4)2,*,/0)+!(/+,2!:8$+(!:/4!#674,2!94/98+(,/0!(6(*$3(D!/0+6!/0$!./378(*,/0!9/4*! ,(! 0$$2$2A!"#$4$:/4$D! *#$! 1)4,)*,/0!/:! *#$!,0*$40)+!54),0!2,)3$*$4!>'@!;()%4%!*,3$!,(!5,1$0!76!?RA![S

* )1& 12 *& ! ! >[@

! B/4!94$((84$!1)4,)*,/0!,0(,2$!*#$!./378(*,/0!.#)37$4D!-$!8($2!*#$!:/++/-,05!4$+)*,/0!,0!?RA!OS

ah(!bA`AaA!(.!'5:

B,584$!EA! 1$41,$-!/:!4)05$!)2)9*)*,/0!>2$(,50!4)05$@!$39+/6$2!76!*#$!&'J ^&!)+5/4,*#3!>%)()F,!)02! 7)6)(#,D!TIIE@A

B,584$![A! b4$((84$!+/.)*,/0(!)02!)4$)(!:/4!*#$!7)++,(*,.!3/2$+A

")7+$!CA! =0,*,)+!($**,05!/:!*#$!&'J ^&!)+5/4,*#3Ab)4)3$*$4 P)+8$j837$4!/:!5$0$4)*,/0( CTI%*)4!5$0$4)*,/0!/:!4)05$!)2)9*)*,/0 TI=0*$41)+!5$0$4)*,/0!/:!4)05$!)2)9*)*,/0 TIb4/7)7,+,*6!/:!.4/((/1$4 IANb4/7)7,+,*6!/:!38*)*,/0 IAC')*,/!/:!/8*$4!4$5,/0!,0!4)05$!)2)9*)*,/0 IAQa4/((!/1$4!*69$ ;+$02$2b)4)3$*$4!/:!.4/((/1$4 IAEJ8*)*,/0!*69$ b/+60/3,)+b)4)3$*$4!/:!38*)*,/0 EAI')02/3!5$0$4)*/4!($$2 C

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A&EBAA%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A!!

Page 78: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

) * )3 4 4 3+ % , 2 3 5+,& - ! "! " ! >O@

! =0!?RA!OD!&C!,(!*#$!#$)2!$02!94$((84$!>/G,2,<$4!,0K$.*,/0!9+)*$@!)02!&.!*#$!./378(*,/0!.#)37$4!94$((84$!K8(*!7$:/4$!*#$!$G9)0L(,/0!94/.$((!>):*$47840$4@A!&+(/D!?.!)02!?&!4$:$4!*/!*#$!)4$)!/:!*#$!*#4/)*!)02!54),0!9/4*D!4$(9$.*,1$+6A! G,2,<$4!3)((! /-!4)*$!,(!)!:80.*,/0!/:!*#$!94$((84$!2,::$4$0.$!*#4/85#!*#$!,0K$.*,/0!9+)*$D!)02!,*(!#624)8+,.!4$(,(*)0.$!>R$1S@!.)0!7$!$(*,3)*$2!76!?RA!US

*6 3 3 7-./ 2 /08+& .! ! " ! >U@

-#$4$D&.!,(!*#$!/G,2,<$4!*)0F!94$((84$A

! "#$!:8$+!3)((! /-!4)*$!.)0!7$!.)+.8+)*$2!76!?RA!NS

)6 *49 9 :&! ! ! >N@

! "#$!:8$+!3)((! /-!4)*$!,0!?RA!N!,(!)!:80.*,/0!/:!*#$!9)4):L0!2$0(,*6!> 8!@D!4$54$((,/0!4)*$D!)02!,0*$40)+!7840,05!)4$)!/:!*#$!./378(*,/0!9/4*!>?,@D!4$(9$.*,1$+6A!"#$!4)*,/!7$*-$$0!/)02!94/1,2$(!*#$!3,G*84$!4)*,/!/:!/G,2,<$4!)02!:8$+D!)../42L,05!*/!?RA!CIS

* );< 6 6-./ 9& ! ! ! >CI@

! "#$! *#4/)*! )4$)D! )((83,05! ,($0*4/9,.! $G9)0(,/0D! )(! )!:80.*,/0!/:!*#$!.#)37$4!94$((84$!,0!*#$!):*$47840$4!($.*,/0!,(!2$*$43,0$2!-,*#!*#$!#$+9!/:!?RA!CCS

/ * )4 6 6 5 32 -./ 9 5& -! !! " ! >CC@

! =0! ?RA! CCD! *#$! .#)4).*$4,(*,.! 1$+/.,*6! -)(! .)+.8+)*$2!*#4/85#!?RA!CTS

! >CT@/

*)5

=

& > ?

+, =

=

' 5

+

+

�&

-

-

-

! !!

" ""

# $

! "#$!94/28.*(!/:!./378(*,/0!)02!4$+$1)0*!*#$43/260)3,.!94/9$4*,$(!-$4$!$(*,3)*$2!)((83,05!.#$3,.)+!$R8,+,74,83A!"#$!3),0!9)4)3$*$4(!-$4$!/7*),0$2!):*$4!4800,05!*#$!4/.F$*!94/98+(,/0! )0)+6(,(! >'b&@! ./2$! >b/0/3)4$0F/D! TICI@A!a#$3,.)+!$R8,+,74,83!-)(!)99+,$2! :/4! *#$!.#/($0!9),4!/:!94/9$++)0*(! jT V9)4): 0! )02! fT TV9)4): 0! (6(*$3(! :/4!2,::$4$0*! 4)*,/! )02!94$((84$! +$1$+(A!"#$! ($0(,*,1,*6! /:! *#$!

4$).*)0*! 94/28.*(! */! 94$((84$! -)(! ./0(,2$4$2! (/3$#/-!-$)F!)02!)!3$)0!94$((84$!/:!TE!7)4(!-)(!.#/($0! :/4! )++!.)($(A!"#$!2)*)!-$4$! ,0*$49/+)*$2!)../42,05+6!5,1$0! *#4$$!9/+60/3,)+(!*/!4$94$($0*!*#$!./378(*,/0!.#)37$4!*$39$4)L*84$D!"+>FL @d! *#$! )1$4)5$!3/+)4!3)((! /:! *#$! ./378(*,/0!94/28.*(d! +>FL @!)02!*#$!(9$., .!#$)*!4)*,/D! >FL @!)(!)!:80.*,/0!/:!*#$!3,G*84$!4)*,/!:/4!*#$!94/9$++)0*(!./37,0)*,/0!/:! ,0*$4$(*A!"#$($!9/+60/3,)+(!)++/-!)0!$(*,3)*,/0!/:! *#$!*#48(*!./$: .,$0*!76!?RA!CHS

)@=

=

= A5AB

AA

AA

+

,

+,

+<

=

=

==

@

B

@

,+

+ +

%!&. -

. - .-

. .% & %' ( '# $ ! >CH@

! "#$!9)4)3$*$4(!0$$2$2!*/!,0:$4!*#$!*#48(*!./$: .,$0*!)4$S!(9$., .! #$)*! 4)*,/! > @D! 0/<<+$! $G#)8(*! 9+)0$! 94$((84$! >&(@D!)37,$0*!94$((84$!>&I@D!)02!0/<<+$!$G9)0(,/0!4)*,/!> @A! "#$! ,0,*,)+! 5$/3$*46! /:! *#$! $05,0$! -)(! /7*),0$2! ):*$4!,0:$44,05! *#$! ,0,*,)+!3)((! /-!4)*$!/:!./378(*,/0!94/28.*(!)02!,0,*,)+!*#48(*!>L$!@!)+/05!-,*#!*#$!.)+.8+)*$2!.#)4).*$4,(*,.!1$+/.,*6!)02!*#48(*!./$: .,$0*!*#4/85#!?RA!CQS

/6 6 6

5 @<

!2 / 9 -./ /<

/& - &! ! !! !" " ! >CQ@

! "#$!*#4/)*!)4$)!-)(!*#$0!.)+.8+)*$2!76!?RA!CES

* / )4 6 3 5! !2 2 / 5 /& ! ! " ! >CE@

! "#$!*#4/)*!)4$)!-)(!)((83$2!./0(*)0*!284,05!4/.F$*!3,((,/0A!"#$!,0,*,)+!9/4*!)4$)!-)(!$(*,3)*$2!5$/3$*4,.)++6!>?RA!C[@S

* )C 4 4 !/ 2 3 /& ! >C[@

! "#,(!9)4)3$*$4! 4$+)*$(! *#$! *#4/)*!)4$)! */! *#$! ,0,*,)+!9/4*!/0$! 4 D 0!3 / /

,! &! "!/:!*#$!(/+,2!:8$+!)(!3$)0!*/!$01$+/9$!*#$!/G,2,<$4!3)((! 8GA!"#$!$G,*!)4$)!-)(!.)+.8+)*$2!:/4!)37,$0*!94$((84$!/:!IAIE!7)4!)02!:/4!)!3$)0!1)+8$!/:! A!"#$0D!)! G$2!1)+8$!/:! !-)(!($*A!"#$!3)G,383!)++/-$2!1)+8$!:/4! !-)(!HIA! B4/3!*#$!,0,*,)+!7840,05!)4$)D!,*!-)(!9/((,7+$!*/!,0:$4!*#$!+$05*#!/:!*#$!(/+,2!:8$+!54),0D!*#8(!.#)4).*$4,<,05!*#$!-#/+$!$05,0$A! "#$!,0(*)0*)0$/8(!*#48(*!/:!*#$!3/*/4!.)0!7$!,0:$44$2!8(,05!3)((! /-!4)*$!)(!,0!?RA!COS

/ 1 2 )< 5 @ 6 6< 9 -./& -! ! ! >CO@

! "#$!./39+$*$!7840!*,3$!.)0!7$!$(*,3)*$2!76!F0/-,05!*#$!,0(*)0*)0$/8(!4$54$((,/0!4)*$D!*#$!,0,*,)+!9/4*!4)2,8(D!)02!*#$!0)+!9/4*!4)2,8(!-,*#!*#$!#$+9!/:!?RA!CUS

&0! 9*,3,<$2!f674,2!'/.F$*!J/*/4!:/4!*#$!%&'&!b+)*:/43!'$$0*46!%6(*$3

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A&EBAA%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A!A

Page 79: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

)2*1&

+

&

&

/

9

& !! ! >CU@

! "#$!9+)00$2!1$+/.,*6!1)4,)*,/0!/:!*#$!(9).$.4):*D!#/-$1$4D!(#/8+2!7$!./39+$*$2!7$:/4$!*#$!(6(*$3!4$).#$(!*#$!+,3,*!(*)*$D!)(! )!-)6! */! )1/,2! ./394/3,(,05! *#$!3,((,/0A!"#$!2$(,4$2!1$+/.,*6!1)4,)*,/0!,(!/7*),0$2!76!,0*$54)*,05!*#$!*#48(*V3)((!/1$4!*,3$!>?RA!CN@S

)E6<12

2

2

/

� & ! ! >CN@

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f$0.$D!-$!./0(,2$4$2!)!TI !)22,*,/0!/:!*#$!/9*,3,<$2!$05,0$!.)02,2)*$! 3)((! )458,05! *#)*! *#$! 3)((! /:! *#$! (87(6(*$3(!>.)*)+6*,.! 7$)2! :/4! )02! /*#$4! ./39/0$0*(! :/4! *#$! ,50,*,/0!(6(*$3D!9+837,05D!1)+1$(!$*.@!,(!94/9/4*,/0)+!*/!*#$!3)((!/:!*#$!(6(*$3A!"#,(! 584$!,(!*-,.$!)(!38.#!/:!*#)*!94/9/($2!76!a/(*)!)02!P,$,4)!>TICI@!/0!)../80*!/:!*#$!+).F!/:!4$+,)7+$!2)*)!/:!*#$!./39/0$0*(!/:!*#$!94/98+(,1$!(6(*$3A!&++!*#$!*)0F(!)02!./378(*,/0!.#)37$4!-/8+2!7$!3)2$!/:!)+83,083!4$,0:/4.$2!-,*#!.)47/0! 7$4A!J$)0!94/9$4*,$(!/:!(8.#!./39/(,*$!3)*$4,L)+(!-$4$!$39+/6$2!,0!*#$!3)((!3/2$+A!"#$!*)0F(!/:!/G,2)0*D!94$((84,<)*,/0! (87(6(*$3D! )02! (*48.*84$! /:! *#$! ./378(*,/0!.#)37$4!-$4$!2$(,50$2!8(,05!./39/(,*$!3)*$4,)+D!)+83,083!4$,0:/4.$2!-,*#!.)47/0D!-,*#!/1$4)++!2$0(,*6!/:!CAU!F5V3H!)02!*$0(,+$!(*4$05*#!+,3,*!/:!NH!Jb)A!"#$($!(*48.*84)+!3)*$4,)+(!-$4$!.#/($0!*/!)++/-!94/28.*,/0!:/++/-,05!*#$!.844$0*!*$.#L0/+/5,.)+!2/3),0!/:!*#$!;4)<,+,)0!(9).$!,028(*46A! ;/*#!*#$!/G,2,<$4!)02!94$((84,<,05!*)0F(!-$4$!(9#$4,.)+D!)02!*#$6!-$4$!./0(,2$4$2!)(!*#,0!-)++$2!94$((84$!1$(($+(A!"#$!3)((!/:!)!(9#$4,.)+!94$((84$!1$(($+!,(!5,1$0!76!*#$!?RA!TIS

)F 3 E,3

!G G G+ ��

& ! >TI@

-#$4$D!)02! !)4$!*#$!(9$., .!3)((!)02!*#$!6,$+2,05!*$0(,/0!/:!*#$!*)0Fc(!3)*$4,)+D

&;!)02!M;!)4$! *#$!2$(,50!94$((84$!)02!1/+83$!/:! *#$!(*/4$2!8,2!>1$(($+@A"#$!./2$!)22(!)!CI !1/+83$!:/4!*#$!$(*,3)*$2!1)+8$!/:!*#,(!9)4)3$*$4! */!)../33/2)*$!.#)05$(! ,0! *#$!(9$., .!1/+83$!28$!*/!*$39$4)*84$!1)4,)*,/0(A

! "#$!./378(*,/0!.#)37$4!,(!)!.6+,024,.)+!94$((84$!1$(($+!-,*#!(9#$4,.)+!$02(D!,0!-#,.#!*#$!3)((!,(!$(*,3)*$2!76!?RA!TCS

F & ( & 3,!G G G G G,,

��

& .! " ! >TC@

-#$4$D@;! ,(! *#$!4)2,8(!/:!*#$!1$(($+!)02!J;! ,*(! +$05*#A!"#$!,0*$40)+!2,)3$*$4! /:! *#$! ./378(*,/0! .#)37$4! ,(! $R8)+! */! *#$! 54),0!$G*$40)+!2,)3$*$4!)02!*#$!1$(($+c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f$@!-)(!)((83$2!*/!7$!(*/4$2!,0!)!(9#$4,.)+!.)47/0!4$,0:/4.$2!*)0F!)02!-)(!3/2$+$2!)(!*#,0!-)++!94$((84$!1$(($+A!"#$!(*/4)5$!94$((84$!)02!*$39$4)*84$!/:!*#$!5)(!-$4$!($*!)*!QII!7)4(!)02!HII!MD!4$(9$.*,1$+6A! '$.$0*+6D! )! 3/2$+! -)(! 94/9/($2! */! .)+.8+)*$! *#$! /G,2,<$4!*)0F!94$((84$!#,(*/46!:/4!0,*4/8(!/G,2$!,0!*#$!7+/-2/-0!3/2$!/:!/9$4)*,/0!>g#,*3/4$!)02!a#)02+$4D!TICI@A!"#$!3/2$+!-)(!7)($2!/0!)0!$0*4/96!)02!3)((!7)+)0.$!8(,05!*-/L9#)($!*#$43/260)3,.(!*)7+$(!:/4!2,0,*4/5$0!3/0/G,2$A!"#$!3/2$+!94/9/($2!76!g#,*3/4$!)02!a#)02+$4!>TICI@!-)(!1)+,2)*$2!,0!4)9,2!2$9+$*,/0!/:!/G,2,<$4!*)0FD! *69,.)+! /:! (3)++! (/802,05! 4/.F$*(! /9$4)*,05! -,*#/8*! *#$!#$+9!/:!)!94$((84,<)*,/0! (87(6(*$3A! =0! *#,(! (*826D!#/-$1$4D! *#$!(855$(*$2!/9$4)*,05!*,3$!/:!*#$!3/*/4!-)(!+/05!$0/85#!*/!)++/-!./0(,2$4)*,/0!/:!$R8,+,74,83!./02,*,/0(!> 8,2!()*84)*,/0!)*!(/3$!5,1$0!*$39$4)*84$@A!"#$4$:/4$D!*#$!94$((84$!#,(*/46!-)(!.)+.8+)*$2!:4/3!*#$!$0$456!7)+)0.$!)99+,$2!*/!*#$! 8,2D!)((83,05!*#$!*)0F!)(!)0!)2,)7)*,.!1$(($+A!&:*$4!)!5,1$0!*,3$!(*$9D!*#$!).*8)+!3)((!,0!5)(!9#)($!-)(!./44$.*$2!76!)!.$4*),0!)3/80*!/:!0,*4/8(!/G,2$!$1)9/L4)*$2!:4/3!*#$!+,R8,2!9#)($A!"#$!$0*#)+96!0$.$(()46!*/!$1)9/4)*$!*#)*!3)((!2$*$43,0$(!*#$!0$-!*$39$4)*84$!/:!*#$!(6(*$3(!)02!)(!)!./0($R8$0.$!*#$!+)*$(*!*)0F!94$((84$A!=0!)!:8*84$!-/4F!-$!-,++!3)F$!8($!/:!*#$!3/2$+!94$($0*$2!76!g#,*3/4$!)02!a#)02+$4!>TICI@A

ah(!bA`AaA!(.!'5:

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A&EBAA%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A!"

Page 80: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

$Q='B#=+)"&+&!=('==!%"

! "#$!/9*,3,<)*,/0!./2$!-)(!*#$0!)99+,$2!*/!#$+9!2$(,50!*#$!2$7//(*!$05,0$!7)($2!/0!*#$!94/9/($2!./0 584)*,/0(A!"#$!*$(*!.)($(!)4$!(833)4,<$2!,0!")7+$!HA!B/4!)!5,1$0!/9*,3,<$2!2$(,50D!*#$!./2$!2$*$43,0$(!*#$!,0,*,)+!)02! 0)+!54),0!2,)3$*$4(D!*#$!(/+,2!:8$+!+$05*#D!*#$!.#)37$4!94$((84$D!)02!*#$!/G,2,<$4!3)((!/-!4)*$A!"#$!4$(8+*(!(#/8+2!7$!($$0!)(!)!7)(,(!:/4!94$+,3,0)46!?05,0$$4,05!2$(,50A

")7+$!HA! 9*,3,<$2!3/*/4!./0 584)*,/0(A

"$(*!.)($

"69$!/:!/G,2)0*

%.#$3$!/:!/G,2)0*!,0K$.*,/0 &+!i7)4p &.!i7)4p

C f624/5$0!9$4/G,2$ b4$((84,<$2!-,*#!f$ !CI !CAH!&+

T f624/5$0!9$4/G,2$ b4$((84,<$2!-,*#!f$ !HI !CAH!&+

H j,*4/8(!/G,2$ ;+/-2/-0 !CI !CAC!&+

#1A-+8@A1+S! g$! (*)4*! 94$($0*,05! *#$! *$(*! .)($!CD! 7)($2!/0!#624/5$0!9$4/G,2$!>NI @!-,*#!CIL7)4!3,0,383!./378(*,/0!.#)37$4!94$((84$A!"#,(!+/-L94$((84$!+$1$+!-)(!($*!:4/3!)!94$+,3,0)46!,01$(*,5)*,/0D!-#,.#!(#/-$2!*#)*!(*48.*84)+!3)((!-/8+2!9$0)+L,<$!*#$!/1$4)++!3)((!/:!*#$!(6(*$3!>3),0!/7K$.*,1$!:80.*,/0@A!`/-L94$((84$!$05,0$!-/8+2!5,1$!)!9//4!(9$., .!,398+($D!78*!*#$!3,((,/0! >2$7//(*,05@! 4$R8,4$(! )! +/05! *,3$!2$.$+$4)*,/0!*/!,394/1$!4$$0*46!94$.,(,/0D!*#$4$:/4$D!)!#,5#L*#48(*!+$1$+!,(!0/*!4$R8,4$2!)02!3/*/4!9$4:/43)0.$!-/8+2!0/*!7$!)!94,3)46!./0.$40A!"#$!/9*,3,<)*,/0!94/.$((!*#$0!74,05(!*#$!94$((84$!/:! *#$! (6(*$3! >k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

)../80*!/:!*#$!1/+83$!0$$2$2!*/!)../33/2)*$!*#$!1)9/4,<)*,/0!.#)37$4D!):*$4!/G,2,<$4!,0K$.*,/0D!*#$!9/(*./378(*,/0!.#)37$4!)(!-$++!)(!*#$!$05,0$!0/<<+$A!a/0($R8$0*+6D!*#$!3/*/4!-/8+2!9/($!(/3$!2,: .8+*,$(!,0! **,05!*#$!%&'&!4$$0*46!$05,0$!7)6D!,:!*#,(!*69$!/:!+,3,*)*,/0!-)(!98*!,0*/!./0(,2$4)*,/0A!=0!)!2,::$4$0*!)44)05$3$0*D!,0!-#,.#!0,*4/8(!/G,2$!,(!*#$!/G,2,<$4D!*#,(!9)4)3L$*$4!(#/8+2!0/*!7$!)!./0.$40D!)(!-$!-,++!($$!+)*$4!,0!*#,(!($.*,/0A! B,0)++6D! )(! )! 2$(,50! 1)4,)7+$D! *#$! 4$(8+*! :/4! *#$! ,0,*,)+!

&0! 9*,3,<$2!f674,2!'/.F$*!J/*/4!:/4!*#$!%&'&!b+)*:/43!'$$0*46!%6(*$3

B,584$!OA!a/01$45$0.$!#,(*/46!/:!*#$!./378(*,/0!.#)37$4!94$((84$!:/4!.)($!CA

B,584$!UA!a/01$45$0.$!#,(*/46!/:!*#$!(/+,2!:8$+!$G*$40)+!2,)3$*$4!:/4!.)($!CA

B,584$!NA!a/01$45$0.$!#,(*/46!/:!*#$!(/+,2!:8$+!,0*$40)+!2,)3$*$4!:/4!.)($!CA

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A&EBAA%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A!$

Page 81: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

/G,2,<$4!3)((! /-!4)*$!,(!94$($0*$2!,0!B,5A!CCA!a/01$45$0.$!)994/).#$(!)!1)+8$!0$)4!*/!T[I!5V(!/:!*#$!#624/5$0!9$4/G,2$A!"#,(!.)0!7$!$)(,+6!)**),0$2!-,*#!:$-!94$((84$!(-,4+!)*/3,<$4(!9+).$2!)*!*#$!/G,2,<$4!,0K$.*,/0!9+)*$A! &(! :/4! 3,((,/0! 4$R8,4$3$0*(! )02! )((83$2! ./0(*4),0*(D!B,5A!CT!94$($0*(!*#$!./01$45$0.$!:/4!(9).$.4):*!1$+/.,*6!4$28.L*,/0A!B,584$!CH!(#/-(!*#$!/9*,3,<$2!3/*/4!/9$4)*,05!*,3$!)02!B,5A!CQD!*#$!/1$4)++!3)((!/:!*#$!(6(*$3A!"#$!/9*,3,<$2!/1$4)++!3)((!/:! *#$!$05,0$!-)(!.+/($! */!TT!F5A!"#,(!$05,0$!-/8+2!)../39+,(#!*#$!3,((,/0!-,*#!)!1$+/.,*6!4$28.*,/0!/:!THE!3V(!

)**),0$2!,0!0$)4!EE!($./02(!/:!7840,05!*,3$A!"#,(!/9*,3,<$2!$05,0$!3)((!,(!38.#!+/-$4!*#)0!*#/($!.)+.8+)*$2!:/4!+,R8,2!)02!(/+,2!94/9$++)0*!4/.F$*(!>P,++)(!;e)(!(.!'5:D!TIII@A!"#$($!4$(8+*(! ,39+6! *#)*! #,5#L$05,0$! (9$., .! ,398+($! ./8+2! 7$!./0(,2$4$2!/:!($./02)46!4$+$1)0.6!:/4!*#$!4$$0*46!3,((,/0A! B,584$!CE!(#/-(!*#$!,0 8$0.$!/:!)++!*#$!2$(,50!1)4,)7+$(!/0!*#$!$05,0$!./0(*4),0*(!)02!3,((,/0!4$R8,4$3$0*(A!&!(,50, L.)0*! ,0 8$0.$! /0! *#$! 1$+/.,*6! 4$28.*,/0! >D(5.'GM@! ./3$(!:4/3! *#$! ,0,*,)+! /G,2,<$4!3)((! /-! 4)*$! )02! *#$!5$/3$*4,.!9)4)3$*$4(! /:! *#$!3/*/4! ,0! *#$! :/++/-,05! /42$4S! (/+,2! :8$+!$G*$40)+!2,)3$*$4d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a/378(*,/0! .#)37$4! 94$((84$! )+(/!.)8($(!-$)F!,0 8$0.$!/0!*#$!/1$4)++!3)((!/:!*#$!94/98+(,1$!

ah(!bA`AaA!(.!'5:

B,584$!CIA! a/01$45$0.$!#,(*/46!/:!*#$!(/+,2!:8$+!+$05*#!:/4!a)($!CA

B,584$!CCA! a/01$45$0.$! #,(*/46! /:! *#$! ,0,*,)+! 3)((! /-! 4)*$! /:!/G,2,<$4!:/4!.)($!CA

B,584$!CTA! a/01$45$0.$!#,(*/46!/:!*#$!1$+/.,*6!4$28.*,/0!:/4!.)($!CA

B,584$!CHA! a/01$45$0.$!#,(*/46!/:!*#$!$05,0$!7840,05!*,3$!:/4!.)($!CA

B,584$!CQA! a/01$45$0.$!#,(*/46!/:!*#$!$05,0$!/1$4)++!3)((!>-,*#/8*!./44$.*,/0@!:/4!.)($!CA

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A&EBAA%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A!D

Page 82: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

(6(*$3A!B/4!*#$!/7K$.*,1$!:80.*,/0!>/1$4)++!3)((@D!./378(*,/0!.#)37$4!94$((84$!#)(!)!(*4/05$4!,0 8$0.$!/0!7840,05!*,3$!)02!/0!1$+/.,*6!4$28.*,/0A!"#$!/9$4)*,/0)+!$01$+/9$!/:!*#$!$05,0$D!)(!:)4!)(!FL!4)*,/!,(!./0.$40$2D!,(!+)45$+6!,0 8$0.$2!76!*#$!,0,*,)+!/G,2,<$4!3)((! /-!4)*$!)02!*#$!54),0!$G*$40)+!2,)3$*$4A!a/01$4($+6D!*#$!,0 8$0.$!/0!*#$!FL!4)*,/!,(!(/3$#/-!(#)4$2!)3/05!*#$!4$3),0,05!5$/3$*4,.!9)4)3$*$4(D!,0!)22,*,/0!*/!*#$!./378(*,/0!.#)37$4!94$((84$A!B,0)++6D!*#$!,0 8$0.$!/:!,0,*,)+!/G,2,<$4!3)((! /-!4)*$!)+/05!-,*#!*#$!5$/3$*4,.!9)4)3$*$4(!/:!*#$!3/*/4!/0!*#$!7840,05!*,3$!(#/-!4$+)*,1$+6!./39)4)7+$!+$1$+(A!"#$!,0 8$0.$!/:!*#$!./378(*,/0!.#)37$4!94$((84$!/0!*#$!(/+,2!:8$+!7840,05!*,3$!.)0!7$!./0(,2$4$2!0$5+,5,7+$A

#1A-+8@A1+T! =0!/42$4! */!$1)+8)*$! *#$!$05,0$!2$(,50! ,0 8$0.$!/0! *#$!/1$4)++! 3)((! /:! *#$! 94/98+(,1$! (6(*$3D! :/++/-,05!3,((,/0!4$R8,4$3$0*(D!)!38.#!#,5#$4!./378(*,/0!.#)37$4!94$((84$!-)(! ,39/($2!*/! *#$!./0(*4),0*!/:!3,0,383!/9$4)*,05!94$(L(84$!/:!*#$!$05,0$D!7)($2!/0!#624/5$0!9$4/G,2$!>NI @A!"#$!/9*,3,<$2!(/+8*,/0!94$($0*$2!*#$!:/++/-,05!2$(,50!1)4,)7+$(!)02!/9$4)*,05!./02,*,/0(!/:!*#$!$05,0$S! (/+,2!:8$+!$G*$40)+!2,)3$*$4!Z!D8!q!COT!33d! (/+,2!:8$+!+$05*#!Z!J0!q!QI[!33d! ,0*$40)+!9/4*!2,)3$*$4!Z!D$!q!CTH!33d! ,0,*,)+!./378(*,/0!.#)37$4!94$((84$(!Z!&+3$ !HI!7)4d!)02! ,0,*,)+!/G,2,<$4!3)((! /-!4)*$!/ !q!T[I!5V(A

! "#$($! 584$(!)4$!(/3$#/-!.+/($!*/!*#/($!/:!*$(*!.)($!CD!$G.$9*!*#$!*#4$$L:/+2!#,5#$4!3,0,383!/9$4)*,/0)+!./378(*,/0!.#)37$4!94$((84$A!&(!)!./0($R8$0.$D!)!3,0/4!4$28.*,/0!,0!*#$!7840,05!*,3$!>CAT @!/..844$2D!:/++/-$2!76!)!./44$(9/02,05!,0.4$)($!:/4!*#$!*#48(*!$05,0$!+$1$+!>kCQ @D!)!0$5+,5,7+$!4$28.L*,/0!,0!*#$!(9$., .!,398+($!>HAQ @!)02D!)*! +$)(*D!)!*-/L:/+2!

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

#1A-+8@A1+U! j,*4/8(!/G,2$!#)(!)!#,5#!()*84)*,/0!94$((84$!)*!)37,$0*!*$39$4)*84$! >TEra@A! "#,(! ($+:L94$((84,<)*,/0! .#)4).*$4,(*,.!/:!*#$!/G,2,<$4!./8+2!7$!$G9+/4$2!,0!*#,(!2$(,50!)(($((3$0*A!"#$4$:/4$D!"$(*! .)($! H! ,01$(*,5)*$(! )! (6(*$3! ./0 584)*,/0!7)($2! /0! 0,*4/8(! /G,2$! )02! /0! (/+,2! 9)4): 0! 94/9$++)0*(!:/4!*#$!4$$0*46!$05,0$!/:!*#$!%&'&!9+)*:/43A!;)(,.)++6D!*#$!./0(*4),0*(!:/4!*#,(!.)($!)4$!*#$!()3$!)(!*#/($!,39/($2!*/!*#$!.)($!C!(*826D!-,*#!*#$!$G.$9*,/0!/:!)!*/*)+!)7($0.$!/:!)06!94$(L(84,<)*,/0!(87(6(*$3A! G,2,<$4! ,0K$.*,/0!-,++! *)F$!9+).$!/0!)../80*!/:!*#$!jT !($+:L94$((84,<)*,/0!,0(,2$!*#$!/G,2,<$4!*)0F!76!3$)0(!/:!)!($4,$(!/:!94$((84$!(-,4+!)*/3,<$4(A!&(!/G,2,<$4!2$9+$*,/0!*)F$(!9+).$D!)!(,50, .)0*!2$.)6!,0!*#$!*)0F!94$((84$!,(!$G9$.*$2A!"#,(!7+/-2/-0!94/.$((!-)(!3/2$+$2!7)($2!/0!*#$!)((839*,/0!/:!R8)(,L(*$)26!(*)*$!:/4! 8,2!$G#)8(*,/0A! B,584$! CO! (#/-(! *#$! ,0 8$0.$! /:! 2$(,50! 9)4)3$*$4(! /0!3,((,/0! 4$R8,4$3$0*(! )02! *#$! /7K$.*,1$! :80.*,/0A! B/4! *#,(!

&0! 9*,3,<$2!f674,2!'/.F$*!J/*/4!:/4!*#$!%&'&!b+)*:/43!'$$0*46!%6(*$3

B,584$!CEA! =0 8$0.$!/:!2$(,50!1)4,)7+$(!/0!$05,0$!./0(*4),0*(!)02!/7K$.*,1$!:80.*,/0!:/4!.)($!CA

B,584$!C[A! =0 8$0.$!/:!2$(,50!1)4,)7+$(!/0!$05,0$!./0(*4),0*(!)02!/7K$.*,1$!:80.*,/0!:/4!.)($!TA

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A&EBAA%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A!E

Page 83: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

./0 584)*,/0D!*#$!,0 8$0.$!/:!94$((84$!/0!/1$4)++!3)((!/:!*#$!$05,0$D!1$+/.,*6!4$28.*,/0!)(!-$++!)(!7840,05!*,3$D!,(!/:!*#$!()3$!/42$4!)(!*#/($!:4/3!*#$!5$/3$*4,.!9)4)3$*$4(!/:!*#$!$05,0$A

! "#,(!./0 584)*,/0!.)8($(!)!(*4/05!2,::$4$0.$!/0!*#$!3,((,/0!$G$.8*,/0! )02! (6(*$3!2$(,50!-#$0! ./39)4$2! */! *#$! 8($! /:!#624/5$0!9$4/G,2$!(899/4*$2!76!)!94$((84,<)*,/0!(87(6(*$3A! ")7+$!Q!94$($0*(! *#$!3),0!9)4)3$*$4(!/:! *#,(!/9*,3,<$2!./0 584)*,/0!)+/05!-,*#! *#$!4$(8+*(! :/4!.)($(!C!)02!TA!"#$!,39/4*)0*!2,::$4$0.$(!./8+2!7$!/7($41$2!:/4!(/+,2!:8$+!+$05*#D!7840,05!*,3$D!(9$., .!,398+($D!*#48(*D!3)((!/:!/G,2)0*D!)02!*/*)+!3)((!/:!*#$!$05,0$A!"#$!4$3),0,05!9)4)3$*$4(D!)(!(#/-!,0!")7+$!ED!)4$!(/3$-#)*!(,3,+)4!)3/05!)06!/:!*#$!#624/5$0!9$4/G,2$!./0 584)*,/0(A

! ")7+$!E!(833)4,<$(!*#$!$G9+/4$2!*$.#0/+/5,$(!*#)*!3)6!$G$.8*$!*#$!4$$0*46!3)0$81$4!/:!*#$!%&'&!9+)*:/43A!'$+$1)0*!9)4)3$*$4(!-$4$!,01$(*,5)*$2!)02!./39)4$2!)3/05!2,::$4$0*!3/*/4!./0 584)*,/0(D!*#4$$!:4/3!)!94$1,/8(!(*826!>P,++)(!;e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

ah(!bA`AaA!(.!'5:

")7+$!QA!Y$7//(*!$05,0$!(6(*$3!:/4!*#$!*#4$$!*$(*!.)($(A

P)+8$( "$(*!.)($!C "$(*!.)($!T "$(*!.)($!H

>3@ IACNE IACOT IACEO>3@ IAQUU IAQI[ IACIU>3@ IACQE IACTH IACIQ>7)4@ CIAIU[ HI CI>F5V(@ IAT[I IAT[I IATT[D(5.'GM!>3V(@ THEACH THEAI THEAI*!>(@ EEAHQ EQA[E CICAQTB OAUI OAUH[ UAHCT"#48(*!./$: .,$0* CAUIH CANIQ CAUCH%9$., .!,398+($!>(@ TUIAEU TNIATO TTUAN?G9)0(,/0!4)*$ CTAO[ HIA[N CTA[N"#48(*!>j@ OHHAE UHEAI[ QNQACHG,2)0*!3)((!>F5@ CQAQ[ CQACU CUATCb)4): 0!3)((!>F5@ CAUTN CAOU TAIHTJ)((!/:!*#$!/G,2)0*!*)0F!>F5@ IAQQN CAHCO HAUTTJ)((!/:!*#$!./378(*,/0.#)37$4!>F5@ IA[NE CAH[I IACQI

J)((!/:!*#$!94$((84,<)*,/0*)0F!>F5@ IA[EU TACTI Z

J)((!/:!*#$!94$((84,<)*,/05)(!>F5@ IAT[C IAUQT Z

j/<<+$!3)((!>F5@ IAIOO IAC[T IAIUI"#4/)*!4)2,8(!>3@ IAICT IAII[U IAICINj/<<+$!$G,*!4)2,8(!>3@ IAIQT IAIHOQ IAIHNIj/<<+$!+$05*#!>3@ IACEO IACHNO IACQEE%6(*$3!*/*)+!3)((!>F5@ CUAHU TCAOO TQATIa/44$.*$2!(6(*$3!3)((!>F5@ TTAIE T[ACTU TNAIQ

")7+$!EA! &0)+6(,(! /:! *#$! 94/9/($2! *$.#0/+/5,$(! :/4! *#$! %&'&!9+)*:/43!4$$0*46!(6(*$3A

b)4)3$*$4 `;b!$05,0$\

`Jb!$05,0$\

%b!$05,0$\ fb!$05,0$

J)(( f,5#!Z!QO!F5

J,22+$!Z!QI!F5

`/-!Z!HEAC!F5

`/-!Z!TI!F5

"$.#0,.)+!.#)++$05$( f,5# f,5# `/- `/-

Y$1$+/93$0*!(*)*8( `/- J,22+$ f,5# J,22+$

b4/28.*,/0!./(* f,5# J,22+$ `/- `/-

9$4)*,05!94$.,(,/0 f,5# f,5# `/- f,5#

f)02+,05D!():$*6D!)02!*/G,.,*6 f,5#!.)4$ f,5#!.)4$ J,22+$!

.)4$ `/-!.)4$

`;bS!+,R8,2!7,94/9$++)0*d!`JbS! +,R8,2!3/0/94/9$++)0*d!%bS! (/+,2!94/9$++)0*d!fbS!#674,2!94/9$++)0*A!\P,++)(!;e)(!(.!'5:!>TIII@A

B,584$!COA!=0 8$0.$!/:!2$(,50!1)4,)7+$(!/0!$05,0$!./0(*4),0*(!)02!/7K$.*,1$!:80.*,/0!:/4!.)($!HA

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A&EBAA%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A!F

Page 84: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

(%"(B'=!%"=

9*,3,<$2! #674,2! 94/9$++)0*! 4/.F$*! $05,0$(D! 7)($2!/0! *#4$$!2,::$4$0*!./0 584)*,/0(D!-$4$!94/9/($2!)(!3),0!./39/0$0*(!/:!*#$!2$7//(*!(6(*$3!/:!*#$!;4)<,+,)0!%&'&!9+)*:/43A! &++! *#4$$! ./0 584)*,/0(! 4$(8+*$2! ,0! $05,0$(!+,5#*$4!*#)0!*#$!+,R8,2!)02!(/+,2!3/*/4(!94$1,/8(+6!(*82,$2A!"#$!,0#$4$0*!)21)0*)5$(!/:!#674,2!94/98+(,/0!(6(*$3D!/1$4!3/4$!*4)2,*,/0)+!./80*$49)4*(D!(#/8+2!7$!*)F,05!,0*/!./0(,2L$4)*,/0!:/++/-,05!*#,(!)(($((3$0*A!f674,2!4/.F$*!*$.#0/+/56!-/8+2!,0.4$)($!(6(*$3!4$+,)7,+,*6!:/4!*#$!4$R8,4$2!3,((,/0D!./0(,2$4,05! *#)*! *#$! 94/98+(,1$! ./39/0$0*(! )4$! 4$)2,+6!)1),+)7+$! ,0! *#$!;4)<,+,)0!(9).$! ,028(*46!)*!1$46!./39$*,L*,1$!./(*A!"#$!/9*,3,<)*,/0!94/.$((!2,(.8(($2!,0!*#,(!-/4F!.)0! 7$! ./0(,2$4$2! )0! $(($0*,)+! *//+! :/4! *#$! 94$+,3,0)46!9#)($! 2$(,50! /:! #674,2! 4/.F$*! 94/98+(,1$! (6(*$3(! :/4! )!5,1$0!)99+,.)*,/0A

)(D"%VBQ&NQ:Q"#=

! "#$! )8*#/4(! *#)0F! *#$! &5s0.,)! ?(9).,)+! ;4)(,+$,4)!>b4/54)3)!W0,$(9)t/@!)02!a/0($+#/!j).,/0)+!2$!Y$($01/+1,L3$0*/!a,$0*X ./!$!"$.0/+ 5,./!>ajbR@!:/4!*#$,4!(899/4*A

$QWQ$Q"(Q=

&F#*)4D!%A)02!`,0L(#8D!fAD!TIIOD!T 9*,3,<)*,/0!)02!%,<,05!:/4!b4/98+(,/0!%6(*$3!/:!̀ ,R8,2!'/.F$*!W(,05!̂ $0$*,.!&+5/4,*#3U3!a#,0$($!u/840)+!/:!&$4/0)8*,.(D!P/+A!TID!j/A!CD!99A!QILQ[A

&+3$,2)D! `A!&A!'A! )02! %)0*/(D! `A!JA!aAD! TIIED! lY$(,50D!:)74,.)*,/0! )02! +)80.#! /:! )! #674,2! 4/.F$*! -,*#! 9)4): 0!)02!jT !94/9$++)0*(m!>=0!b/4*858$($@D ^4)28)*,/0!b4/K$.*D!J$.#)0,.)+!?05,0$$4,05!Y$9)4*3$0*D!W0,1$4(,*6!/:!;4)(X+,)D!;4)(X+,)D!YA!BAD!;4)<,+D!UH9A

&+*3)0D!YA!)02!f/+<3)0D!&AD!TIIOD!l 1$41,$-!)02!f,(*/46!/:! f674,2! '/.F$*! b4/98+(,/0Am! =0! a#,)1$4,0,D! JAuAD! M8/D!MAMA!>$2A@D!B802)3$0*)+(!/:!f674,2!'/.F$*!a/378(*,/0!)02!b4/98+(,/0D!&3$4,.)0!=0(*,*8*$!/:!&$4/0)8*,.(!)02!&(*4/0)8L*,.(D!=0.AD!'$(*/0D!P,45,0,)D!P/+A!TCUD!a#)9*$4!CD!99A!ICLH[A

&02$4(/0D!JA;AD! TIITD! l^$0$*,.!&+5/4,*#3(! =0!&$4/(9).$!Y$(,50S!%87(*)0*,)+!b4/54$((!"4$3$02/8(!b/*$0*,)+Am!b)9$4!94$($0*$2!)*!*#$!'" !&P"!a/84($!/0!l=0*$++,5$0*!%6(*$3(!:/4!&$4/0)8*,.(mD!#$+2!,0!'#/2$L%),0*L^$0v($D!;$+5,83D!CHLCO!J)6!TIITD!)02!987+,(#$2!,0!'" L?jLITTA

;$4*/+2,D!&A! ?A!JAD! TIIOD! l?G9$4,3$0*)+! ,01$(*,5)*,/0! /:!*#$!7840,05!/:!9)4): 0!)02!0,*4/8(L/G,2$! ,0!#674,2!4/.F$*!$05,0$(!>=0!b/4*858$($@D!J)(*$4!"#$(,(D!J$.#)0,.)+!?05,L0$$4,05!Y$9)4*3$0*D!W0,1$4(,*6!/:!;4)(X+,)D!;4)(X+,)D!YA!BAD!;4)<,+D!CCE9A

;4/-0D!"A!'A!)02!`62/0D!JA!aAD!TIIED!l"$(*,05!/:!b)4): 0L;)($2!f674,2!'/.F$*!B8$+!W(,05!f624/5$0!b$4/G,2$! G,2,<$4mD!&=&&!'$5,/0!E!%*82$0*!a/0:$4$0.$D!g,.#,*)D!W%&A

a)397$++D!uA(.!'5:D!TIIUD!lf)02+,05!./0(,2$4)*,/0(!/:!0,*4/8(!/G,2$!,0!#674,2!4/.F$*!3/*/4!*$(*,05mD!b4/.$$2,05(!/:!&=&&!TIIULQUHI!QQ*#!&=&&V&%J?V%&?V&%??!u/,0*!b4/98+(,/0!a/0:$4$0.$!w!?G#,7,*D!b/-)6D!a)+,:/40,)D!99A!HCOOLHCUHA

a)()+,0/D!`A!)02!b)(*4/0$D!YAD!TIIED!l G,2,<$4!a/0*4/+!)02!9*,3)+! Y$(,50! /:! f674,2! '/.F$*(! :/4! %3)++! %)*$++,*$(Am!

u/840)+!/:!b4/98+(,/0!)02!b/-$4D!P/+A!TCD!99A!THILTHUA

a/0*),:$4D!'A!&AD!TII[D!l 8)+, .)*,/0!)02! ,5#*!*$(*(!/:!*#$!%YLC!(/802,05!4/.F$*m!>=0!b/4*858$($@D!^4)28)*,/0!b4/K$.*D!J$.#)0,.)+!?05,0$$4,05!Y$9)4*3$0*D!W0,1$4(,*6!/:!;4)(X+,)D!;4)(X+,)D!YA!BAD!;4)<,+D!OE9A

&0! 9*,3,<$2!f674,2!'/.F$*!J/*/4!:/4!*#$!%&'&!b+)*:/43!'$$0*46!%6(*$3

B,584$!CUA!&! 9)4): 0VjT ! #674,2! 4/.F$*! 4,05! *$(*! )*! *#$!W0,1$4(,*6!/:!;4)(X+,)A

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A&EBAA%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A!#

Page 85: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

a/(*)D!BA%A! )02!P,$,4)D!'AD! TICID! lb4$+,3,0)46!&0)+6(,(! /:!f674,2!'/.F$*(!:/4!`)80.#,05!j)0/()*(!,0*/!`? UD!&;aJD!P/+A!HTD!j/A!QD!99A!EITLEINA

Y)`,0D!'A!(.!'5:D!TICTD!lY$(,50!)02! 9*,3,<)*,/0!/:!P)4,)7+$!"#48(*!f674,2!'/.F$*!J/*/4(!:/4!%/802,05!'/.F$*(D!%.,$0.$!a#,0)mD!"$.#0/+/5,.)+!%.,$0.$(D!P/+A!EED!j/A!CD!99A!CTELCHEA

Y)162$0F/D!jA!&A!(.!'5:D!TIIOD!lf674,2!4/.F$*!$05,0$(!Z!*#$!7$0$ *(!)02!94/(9$.*(mD!&$4/(9).$!%.,$0.$!)02!"$.#0/+/56D!P/+A!CCD!99A!EEL[IA

^4$)*4,GD! YA'AD! TIIND! l'$54$((,/0! 4)*$! $(*,3)*,/0! :/4!(*)02)42L /-!#674,2!4/.F$*!$05,0$(mD!&$4/(9).$!%.,$0.$!)02!"$.#0/+/56D!P/+A!CHD!99A!HEULH[HA

M)4)7$6/5+8D!JA!&A! (.! '5:D! TIIQD! l%.)+$L89!"$(*(! /:!f,5#!'$54$((,/0!')*$!b)4): 0L;)($2f674,2!'/.F$*!B8$+(AmD!u/84L0)+!/:!b4/98+(,/0!)02!b/-$4D!P/+A!TID!j/A![D!99A!CIHOLCIQEA

M)4)7$6/5+8D!JA!&AD! TIIUD! lf674,2! 94/98+(,/0! :/4! :8*84$!(9).$!+)80.#mD!EI*#!&00,1$4()46!%639/(,83!)02!a$+$74)*,/0D!W0,1$4(,*6! /:! %*)0:/42!&$4/V&(*4/!%639/(,83D!b)+/!&+*/D!a)+,:/40,)A

M/+2)$1D!PA!)02!J/4)$(D!bA!u4AD!CNNOD!lY$(,50!/:!)!4$./1$46!(6(*$3!:/4!(3)++!/47,*)+!9)6+/)2(mD!b4/.$$2,05(!/:!*#$!CQ*#!;4)<,+,)0!a/054$((!/:!J$.#)0,.)+!?05,0$$4,05D!;)848D!%x/!b)8+/D!;4)<,+A

M-/0D!%A!"A!(.!'5:D!TIIHD!l 9*,3)+!2$(,50!/:!#674,2!3/*/4!:/4!*#$! 4(*!(*)5$!/:!),4!+)80.#!1$#,.+$mD!b4/.$$2,05(!/:!*#$!HN*#!&=&&V&%J?V%&?V&%??!u/,0*!b4/98+(,/0!a/0:$4$0.$!)02!?G#,7,*D!f80*(1,++$D!&+)7)3)A

,F0,0$D!aAD!TII[D!lj$-!9$4(9$.*,1$(!:/4!#674,2!94/98+(,/0mD!b4/.$$2,05(! /:! *#$! &=&&! 9)9$4! TII[LQ[OQD! QT02! &=&&V&%J?V%&?V&%??!u/,0*!b4/98+(,/0!a/0:$4$0.$!)02!?G#,7,*D!%).4)3$0/D!a)+,:/40,)A

'#$$D!=:(.!'5:D!TIIUD!l 9*,3)+!Y$(,50!:/4!f674,2!'/.F$*!$05,0$!:/4!&,4!`)80.#!P$#,.+$mD!u/840)+!/:!J$.#)0,.)+!%.,$0.$!)02!"$.#0/+/56D!P/+A!TTD!99A!CEO[LCEUEA

%)0*/(D!`A!JAD!aA!(.!'5:D!TII[D!l?G9$4,3$0*)+!,01$(*,5)*,/0!/:!)!9)4): 0!7)($2!#674,2!4/.F$*UD!"#$43)+!?05,0$$4,05D!P/+A!ED!j/A!CD!99A!IULCTA

%)()F,D! YA! )02! 7)6)(#,D! %AD! TIIED!G

)$.#/%U3!V/840)+!/:!&$4/(9).$D!a/398*,05D!=0:/43)*,/0!)02!a/3380,.)*,/0D!P/+A!TD!99A!QQL[QA

%8**/0D!^A!bAD!TIICD!l'/.F$*!94/98+(,/0!$+$3$0*(S!)0!,0*4/L28.*,/0!*/!*#$!$05,0$$4,05!/:!4/.F$*(mD!O*#!$2,*,/0D!j$-!y/4FD!W%&D!u/#0!g,+$6!w!%/0(D

P,$5)(D!BA!`A!)02!%)+$3,D!`A!aAD!TIIID!lY$(,50!)02!)(($3L7+,05! /:! )! (*)*,.! *$(*! 7$0.#! :/4! #674,2! 4/.F$*! $05,0$(m! >=0!b/4*858$($@D! ^4)28)*,/0! b4/K$.*D! J$.#)0,.)+! ?05,0$$4,05!Y$9)4*3$0*D!W0,1$4(,*6!/:!;4)(X+,)D!;4)(X+,)D!YABA

P,++)(!;e)(D!YA!uA!BA(.!'5:D!TIIID!l%*82,$(!/0!*#$!.#)4).*$4,(*,.(!/:!2$L7//(*!3/*/4(!:/4!)!(3)++!4$./1$4)7+$!/47,*)+!9+)*:/43mD!b4/.$$2,05(!/:!*#$!j)*,/0)+!a/054$((!/:!J$.#)0,.)+!?05,L0$$4,05D!j)*)+D!'AjAD!;4)<,+A

g#,*3/4$D!%A!&A!)02!a#)02+$4D!%A!jAD!TICID!l?05,0$$4,05!J/2$+!:/4!%$+:Lb4$((84,<,05!%)*84)*$2LjT Lb4/9$++)0*!B$$2!%6(*$3(mD!u/840)+!/:!94/98+(,/0!)02!b/-$4D!P/+A!T[D!j/A!QD!99A!OI[LOCQA

ah(!bA`AaA!(.!'5:

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A&EBAA%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AA%

Page 86: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&'%#()*&!#

!"#$%&'!(

"+$,&-./$"&+

!

!

)'*+,!

!

!

#012345067% 68%9:345067% 07% 4% /61;6<05=% $>=?143% @?65=A5067%#B<5=1%C04%47%"75=?84A=%$?4AD07E%)=5>6FG21:=?56%9?42H6%)4A>4F6I

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

*+,-.&/$)*F=,+'03.6*!39"310')6*G3>0.@*=3;.8+4?6*!39";'+'03.+,*109;,+'03.A

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AA&BA"%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AA&

Page 87: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!

!

)'*+,

!"#$%&'()"*

!"#

R280

R300 20

!

!

@G(#"/9!%@,&*!J)

!

!

! " ## #

!" #

$ # %&

!! �

$ %

# H

! "% ' ( ( )**

+$ &!

B B*7*B<*

B<*6*8F% !

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AA&BA"%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AA!

Page 88: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

! "' ,- ' # ! #. /' '� � �$ % % & "! "

!&I

&$%)

' , -&�$

$J

!

# # (/ *$ $

&F

#6325067%)=5>6F

!

!

"75=?84A=%5?4AD07E%1=5>6F%86?%67=%16C07E%075=?84A=

K ;

8/

!"

+,-.,'-&,'/0("'1,1/"'1&.2,*&$#%#&

'

(

)

*

+ ,345/

L B

! " ! "0 ( 1 2 ( ( )*+

*

# $ $ &!

. B*7*B<*

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AA&BA"%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AAA

Page 89: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

B5B06D

!

B0D*7*B5

! ")! "* + # )! "* +

3 (4

+ ( ( 4 + 5 5 4,6 7 8

8 6 8 7

-$& &

M0 D 5B0*6?D*

/

</

! "

! "

* ! "+ (

+ (

+ (

6+ (

6+ (

6+ (

. - -

(

.

. -

-

.

. !

!

"

$ & &!

! "/ -# . '#

+ (( ( (

0'

.

-

$& % % &

676 678 679 67: 67; <76=

676

678

679

67:

67;

<76

<78

<79

<7:

23=5

#1 0- ## $

!" #

! " ! " ! , "( 1 ( !( . (� � � �$ % &

N

! " #% ' 3 ( 9, ,6 7 8 6 7 8

8

8"$"

! "# 4 # 3 (, ,

,

8 6 7 6 7 8

6 7

-$"

5

5 B5B5

M0 6 D

K ;!

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AA&BA"%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AA"

Page 90: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

O

O*.P* 8B<**Q*8' A..

!

O*.RN

%!

.RN&I

O*.RN

# ! "- - : #2 2. �$ &%

K &

K &

JK5=7<067%56%C4?062<%16C07E%075=?84A=<

!-9

9

1;< <

<

=/"

.

� �$$

"

SI!!

/ 8K9 ; -@0

*9

1; 1 1< < <.$ &&

. (1 11 =/"( $ $

678 679 67: 67; <

#8

#<7:

#<78

#67;

#679

6

>"315

#8

#<7:

#<78

#67;

#679

6

1"?&

678 679 67: 67; <

6

678

679

67:

67;

<

@"315

6

678

679

67:

67;

<

1"?&

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AA&BA"%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AA$

Page 91: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

H9 !

! "% ' ( ( )*,< < < /< 8 <*8

$ &" !

% %<

<

$"

,J#.!$#%9+-%-"#/.##"&+

#!"

! !! !

! !! !

! !

! !

!

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AA&BA"%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AAD

Page 92: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!

!

AB(#2.('1/

C=0&."?&'1,)/D'&#2.('1/

6 <6 86 E6 96 F6 :6 G6 ;6 H6 <661"?&I/J

6

6769

676;

67<8

67<:

678

K,JJ/)(JJ/.,

1&I/L-M?

8 7J

6 <6 86 E6 96 F6 :6 G6 ;6 H6 <661"?&I/J

6

676F

67<

67<F

678

678F

K,JJ/)(JJ/.,1&I/L-M?

8 7J

C=0&."?&'1,)/D'&#2.('1/AB(#2.('1/

6 <6 86 E6 96 F6 :6 G6 ;6 H6 <661"?&I/J

6

676F

67<

67<F

678

678F

K,JJ/)(JJ/.,

1&I/L-M?

8 7J

C=0&."?&'1,)/D'&#2.('1/AB(#2.('1/

6 <6 86 E6 96 F6 :6 G6 ;6 H6 <661"?&I/J

6

67<

678

67E

K,JJ/)(JJ/.,1&I/L-M?

8 7J

C=0&."?&'1,)/D'&#2.('1/AB(#2.('1/

6 <6 86 E6 96 F6 :6 G6 ;6 H6 <661"?&I/J

6

67<

678

67E

679

K,JJ/)(JJ/.,

1&I/L-M?

8 7J

AB(#2.('1/D'&#2.('1/C=0&."?&'1,)/

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AA&BA"%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AAE

Page 93: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

491 !

><92

<66 1

2 -"$ $"

<<

< <6

.

. 9" $&

9) 91

491H 491

491 !

!

1B(/"'1&.2,*&J/?(N&)6I9F/KOM?86I:9/KOM?86IH6/KOM?8<I88/KOM?88I<;/KOM?8

P,..(J/3866;5

6 <6 86 E6 96 F61"?&/3J5

6

866

966

:66

;66

<666

<866

<966

<:66

<;66

8666

8866

8966

A&?0&

.,14.&/3(Q5

!

6F66

<666<F6686668F66

-%./

67666F6766<'% 0 6

6766F

676<

(% 0

123."2454 63.78% 8 9 :/+;3 4<36;=>

123."2454 63.78% 8 9 ?: 4

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AA&BA"%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AAF

Page 94: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!

!

/&+/!.#"&+#

!

!

9/L+&M!J-NJ)J+$#

!3.1),/3*S+:03.+,*

,J'J,J+/J#

!

)'*+,

)'*+,

!

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AA&BA"%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AA#

Page 95: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

! )'*+,A

!

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AA&BA"%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A"%

Page 96: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&'%#()*&!#%+,-%,&).,/!+$01.

!""#$%&'(&)*+!"#$ !%&'(%)&*+%),$#(-)%*.)&*+%$/+($"&)%0)(0*.)&*+%1!1$ 12(3*%'$!%,'&$1'45'()&2('1!6$ 12(3*%'$!%,'&$6++,*%-

,-.")/+ 0*&(+!" 789:8-;6<

!#$ 7=<

%&' 789:8-<( 789:8-<&) >')&$()&'*$ 7?)<

7?)<+ 78@<, 7=<- 1'45'()&2(' 7;6<-. 7;6<-/ @'&=32,3$&'45'()&2(' 7;6<0 ?+A'($+2&52& 7B@<12!

0+*C$DEFGEHI:J)&4FHEDHFEKELHEDH

+2345676%89%:36%$;<=72>%?><98<@32A>%B7CD%"24>C%+7<%/88472E%

$>AD27F;>6%+GG47>H%C8%*<3I74732%#7C>6

+23%?3;43%#32C86JK%/4L;H73%1M%+2H<3H>NKOD$

H$

!"+(#'1(2

3

3$-4)#5+2

M,)20*)N*&)F3(

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A"&BA$A8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A"&

Page 97: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

7=<7=<7=<7=<78-A)&'(:8-)*(<

,6"+1#&7(+E

4

!5!!% 6++,*%-$,+)0

678 !%52&9 O'&

12(3*%'- 1+&),

/ A)&'(

",$1&-0/$"&,

=

=

=

$ 9)3'($

=

=

)%0$

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A"&BA$A8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A"!

Page 98: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

:+#%$01*",.%/(/!.

=

!"#�

!

!"

!#!$!%

!"#$%&'()*+#',,)#

-%#./*$%'&0

(1/*$'#

! !! !"#

$EK

! " !!$ !"!#

=

-EK

%%

##

#&$

!$!"

!"

!$

&

!"# ' (

�� '! "! "

% & ' # #)' ( )( (*+ !$ !"!# '! ! # $*4 !"4:

=$EG

! ! !*,&-./0,"!+ !$ �# '

1 & ' # #)23 ( )+ (*+ !+ !$! !# '! ! # $!"6

%&'

,&

1 4567

',&-./0,"

23

#!

!

,# # #

! !&

&0!- !+ !$

!+ !-

&

!# ' '�� '! "! "

$

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A"&BA$A8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A"A

Page 99: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

% & ' # #)0 # )+ (*+ !+ !-!# '! ! # $*-

& & &# ( 7# (! ! !

)%0$!"6

% % %8 # '# '! ! !

9:'%

&"-!!

8

7!# !

!

5; 9:' 456!#

9:' 456"-!!

0< ! #

",!.$%+"1%/&&!",:%#(#$.)#

=

!"#�

!&

!'

!!"

!#!$!%

()*+ )#

()) %&23 *

.P3G8<3C7P>%A88472E

�&&#

"% �

$��

"�

� " ( � � & & # � �� $ � " � %* � � " (

# #- #- #=!" !. !. !.�# ' '# $

& &= ( !. !"! � �# '! ! # $

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A"&BA$A8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A""

Page 100: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

*4 EH EL

=

1 & ' # #)'4 ( )( (*+ !. !"! !# '! ! # $*4 ! $

+=68<GC782%32H%@>AD327A34%AD744><%656C>@6

=&*+%$M++,*%-F

P43*'%&$)*(

6Q*,,'0$A)&'(

P*($M++,'0$&+-)R$&2(3*%'$*%,'&

1 & < < < )'4 ( =!. !" !" !. !"! ! � �# ' ' '! ! # #$ $# $(EH$)%0$(EL

& &= ( !. !"! � �# '! ! # $=

=

=

=

%'>!1

?'

'4#!

!

=

% % % %8 0 ' ?'# ' '! ! ! !

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A"&BA$A8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A"$

Page 101: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

=

� � � � � � �

� � � � � �

� � � � �

� � � � � �

� � � � � �

� %# � * � � ! " # # " % � ( & � � ) )

� %* ! � # ' -� * + � � � ( � � & + %�

& � � � ( - � � " (

� , � ' & ( � * " , �� & & # " % � � ( & � � ) )

� ' � � " . �� + $ " � " * -

� ( - � � + # � � � � $ ' � ( � * + ( �

� �

� �

� � � � � �� � � �

� � �

� � � �

� � �

� � � �

/ �

1.#0!$#%+,-%-"#/0##"&,#

=

=&)*%*%-$

DD$7=<12(3*%'$*%,'&$&'45'()&2('

&2(3*%'

DEE$744>H#<HEE$744>H#<$

=

=

!"

!#

$%

$&

$$

'"

'#

(%%

(%&

(%$

(("

((#

!"#

& $ (" (# "% "& "$ )" )# &% && &$

$%&'() &)*+),'&-,) !./#

*+, -./0121./345 6 (7 8-6 #% 9

5*5 6 ()$7 :;<=2 >=2<?.@<> .A2BA2

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A"&BA$A8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A"D

Page 102: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

=

=

& $ (" (# "% "& "$ )" )# &% && &$

$%&'() &)*+),'&-,) !./#

"C7

)C%

)C7

&C%

&C7

7C%

7C7

#C%

#C7

!C%

!C7

$C%

0!./

#

5*5 6 ()$7 :6 #%9

6 %C'76 %C'%6 %C$7

&'45'()&2('$0(+5F

& $ (" (# "% "& "$ )" )# &% && &$

$%&'() &)*+),'&-,) !./#

"!

"$

"'

)%

)(

)"

))

)&

)7

)#

)!

)$

)'

&%

&(

&"

123),

2-&+

-&!4

5#

5*5 6 ()$7 :6 %C'%

6 ($96 #%9

D=3<EF=3<

& $ (" (# "% "& "$ )" )# &% && &$

$%&'() &)*+),'&-,) !./#

"7C7

"#C%

"#C7

"!C%

"!C7

"$C%

"$C7

"'C%

"'C7

)%C%

)%C7

)(C%06

) ,*

'7)8

89:9)

%:;

!"#

5*5 6 ()$7 :6 %C'%

6 ($96 #%9

D=3<E-=3<

& $ (" (# "% "& "$ )" )# &% && &$E&

%

&

$

("

(#

"%

"&

"$

)"

)#

&%

0!./

#

$%&'() &)*+),'&-,)!./#

5*5 6 ()$7 :GH3.>B21./ FI1JJ<>4 6 ($9 =/0 #%9KL=B.>=21L< F..J1/M4 6 %C'% =/0 6 ($9KL=B.>=21L< F..J1/M4 6 %C'% =/0 6 #%9

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A"&BA$A8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A"E

Page 103: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

=

& $ (" (# "% "& "$ )" )# &% && &$

$%&'() &)*+),'&-,)!./#

"!

"$

"'

)%

)(

)"

))

)&

)7

)#

)!

)$

)'

&%

123),

<2-&

+-&!

45

#

5*5 6 ()$7 :GH3.>B21./ FI1JJ<>4 6 ($9GH3.>B21./ FI1JJ<>4 6 #%9D=3<EF=3<

& $ (" (# "% "& "$ )" )# &% && &$

$%&'() &)*+),'&-,)!./#

"7C7

"#C%

"#C7

"!C%

"!C7

"$C%

"$C7

"'C%

"'C7

)%C%

)%C7

06),

*'7

)889:

9)%:

;!"

#

5*5 6 ()$7 :GH3.>B21./ FI1JJ<>4 6 ($9GH3.>B21./ FI1JJ<>4 6 #%9D=3<EF=3<

& $ (" (# "% "& "$ )" )# &% && &$

$%&'() &)*+),'&-,) !./#

)%

)(

)"

))

)&

)7

)#

)!

)$

)'

123),

2-&+

-&!4

5#

5*5 6 ()$7 :6 #% 9

-,? 6 !C%-,? 6 &C7-,? 6 "C%

& $ (" (# "% "& "$ )" )# &% && &$

$%&'() &)*+),'&-,) !./#

)%

)(

)"

))

)&

)7

)#

)!

)$

)'

123),

2-&+

-&!4

5#

5*5 6 ()$7 :6 #% 9

-,? 6 !C%-,? 6 &C7-,? 6 "C%

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A"&BA$A8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A"F

Page 104: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

=

+3&)*%'0$)&$

=

=

& $ (" (# "% "& "$ )" )# &% && &$

$%&'() &)*+),'&-,) !./#

)&C7

)7C%

)7C7

)#C%

)#C7

)!C%

)!C7

)$C%

)$C7

)'C%

123),

2-&+

-&!4

5#

5*5 6 ()$7 :-,? 6 &C7

6 ($96 #%9

& $ (" (# "% "& "$ )" )# &% && &$

$%&'() &)*+),'&-,) !./#

E%C(

%C%

%C(

%C"

%C)

%C&

%C7

%C#

%C!

%C$

%C'

(C%

(C(

(C"

4'=

=872

33'&

) ,!(

>?=#

N= 6 (&(C(# OMP35K5 6 ()$7 8-6 ($9

KL=B.>=21L< F..J1/M4 6 %C'%GH3.>B21./ FI1JJ<>Q<FI=/1F=J FI1JJ<>4 -,? 6 &C7

& $ (" (# "% "& "$ )" )# &% && &$

$%&'() &)*+),'&-,) !./#

E%C7

%C%

%C7

(C%

(C7

"C%

"C7

)C%

)C7

&C%

&C7

7C%

7C7

#C%

#C7

/227

9%>

72'@

!45

#

5*5 6 ()$7 :6 ($ 9

Q<FI=/1F=J FI1JJ<>4 -,? 6 &C7GH3.>B21./ FI1JJ<>KL=B.>=21L< F..J1/M4 6 %C'%

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A"&BA$A8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A"#

Page 105: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

=

=

1)3,'$HF

"*&'HGFE

S)&*&20'$7;<S+%-*&20'$7;< =$KDFLK

DEDFHG

=

& $ (" (# "% "& "$ )" )# &% && &$

$%&'() &)*+),'&-,) !./#

"#

"$

)%

)"

)&

)#

)$

&%

&"

123),

2-&+

-&!4

5#

5*5 6 ()$7 :6 ($9

KL=B.>=21L< F..J1/M4GH3.>B21./ FI1JJ<>-.NB><331./ FI1JJ<>4 -,? 6 &C7D=3< F=3<

6 %C'%

& $ (" (# "% "& "$ )" )# &% && &$

$%&'() &)*+),'&-,) !./#

"7C7

"#C%

"#C7

"!C%

"!C7

"$C%

"$C7

"'C%

"'C7

)%C%

)%C7

)(C%

06) ,

*'7

) 889:

9)%:

;!"

#

5*5 6 ()$7 :6 ($ 9

KL=B.>=21L< F..J1/M4GH3.>B21./ FI1JJ<>-.NB><331./ FI1JJ<>4 -,? 6 &C7D=3<EF=3<

6 %C'%

"!C%

"!C7

"$C%

"$C7

"'C%

"'C7

)%C%

)%C7

)(C%

)(C7

)"C%

)"C7

))C%

))C7

)&C%

Q./2I3

RK-,-5+K?GSTUSVUSWQGXG?Y W,ZQGY[KDUGW

GNH1</2\2<NB<>=2A><\]8-^

!%

!(

!"

!)

!&

!7

!#

!!

!$

!'

$%

$(

RK-W,Z,-5+K?GSTUSVUSWQGXG?YQGY[KDUGW

Y<J=21L<\IAN1012_\]9

^

Q./2I3

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A"&BA$A8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A$%

Page 106: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

=

=

"'C%

"'C7

)%C%

)%C7

)(C%

)(C7

)"C%

)"C7

))C%

))C7

)&C%

)&C7

)7C%

Q./2I3

RK-,-5+K?GSTUSVUSWQGXG?Y W,ZQGY[KDUGW

GNH1</2\2<NB<>=2A><\]8-^

RK-W,Z,-5+K?GSTUSVUSWQGXG?YQGY[KDUGW

Q./2I3

"7

)%

)7

&%

&7

7%

77

#%

#7

!%

!7

$%

$7

Y<J=21L<\IAN1012_\]9

^

\KL=B.>=21L<\F..J1/M4\ \6\%C'%\GH3.>B21./\FI1JJ<>\Q<FI=/1F=J\FI1JJ<>4\-,?\6\&C7

RK-,S5+K?GSTUSV W,Z

Q./2I3

%

&%%

$%%

(`"%%

(`#%%

"`%%%

"`&%%

"`$%%

)`"%%

)`#%%

&`%%%

&`&%%

*/F><N</2=J\<J<F2>1F\</<>M_\M</<>=21./\]QaI^

%

&%%

$%%

(`"%%

(`#%%

"`%%%

"`&%%

"`$%%

)`"%%

)`#%%

&`%%%

&`&%%

&`$%%

7`"%%

Q.A/2I3

RK-,S5+K?GSTUSV W,Z

\KL=B.>=21L<\F..J1/M4\ \6\%C'%\GH3.>B21./\FI1JJ<>\Q<FI=/1F=J\FI1JJ<>4\-,?\6\&C7

*/F><N</2=J\<J<F2>1F\</<>M_\M</<>=21./\]QaI^

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A"&BA$A8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A$&

Page 107: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

=

=

/&,/!0#"&,#

-E

=

+/Q,&R!.-:).,$#

1)3,'$LF$ !

KLFHI

LHFEHKLFHKGLFEE

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A"&BA$A8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A$!

Page 108: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

1.'.1.,/.#

=

=

=

=

=

=

=

=

=

=

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A"&BA$A8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A$A

Page 109: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management
Page 110: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&'(#!%"

#)*+,-.*+/0+1//2*,34-/5

! "#$!%&$'$()!%*%$&!+*'!,-(,$&($.!+/)#!)#$!*(*01'/'!-2!34/*5)/-(!.$4$0-%6$()!/(!)#$!$*&01!78)#!,$()9&1:!"#$!6*/(!2-,9'!-2!)#$!*(*01'/'!+*'!)#$!./22$&$()!+-&;/(<!*6=/$(,$'!)#*)!+$&$!$')*=0/'#$.!/(!)#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'!*(.!/(!@9&-%$A!(-)/,$*=01!/(!B&*(,$:!"#$'$!*6=/$(,$'!#*.!*!,&9,/*0!/6%*,)!-(!)#$!-9),-6$!-2!)#$!*/&%0*($!%$&2-&6*(,$!*(.!34/*)/-(!6/0$')-($'!/(!=-)#!

,-()/($()':!"#$!+-&;!-2!/(./4/.9*0'!*(.!)#$!/(.9')&/*0!.$4$05-%6$()!/(!&$<*&.!)-!34/*)/-(!+$&$!*(*01C$.!)-!29(.*6$()!)#$!#1%-)#$'/'!)#*)!)#$!B&$(,#!*(.!D(.9')&/*0!E$4-09)/-('!%0*1$.!*!6*F-&!&-0$!/(!)#$!.$4$0-%6$()!-2!34/*)/-(:! D(/)/*001A! +$! ,*(! ,-('/.$&! )#$! 6*')$&%/$,$! -2! 30=$&)-!?*()-'5G96-()A!*!H&*C/0/*(!*4/*)/-(!%/-($$&!+#-!'%$()!6-')!

*/&%0*($'! /(! )#$!$*&01!78)#!,$()9&1:!I-')!H&*C/0/*('!=$0/$4$!?*()-'5G96-()! +*'! *! '/(<0$! <--.! '-90! =$,*9'$! #$! <*4$!*(1-($! #/'! .$'/<('! *(.! /(4$()/-('! 2-&! 2&$$:! J(! )#$! -)#$&!#*(.A! 6-')! H&*C/0/*('! *&$! (-)! *+*&$! )#*)! ?*()-'5G96-()!9)/0/C$.!/(!#/'!*/&,&*2)!/.$*'!*(.!$4$(!,-6%-($()'!2&-6!-)#$&!%$-%0$:!D(!2*,)A!(-)!-(01!?*()-'5G96-()!)--;!)#/'!*%%&-*,#A!=9)!)#$!6*F-&/)1!-2!34/*)/-(!%/-($$&'!/(!B&*(,$!*)!)#*)!)/6$!*'!+$00:!"#$1!+$&$!$(0/<#)$($.!=1!)#$!/.$*'!2&-6!)#$!B&$(,#!

.-/KL8:M87NOF*)6:78L7:8P8Q8NL7

%2*5+6/7,1*+8)-9/./2):+35;+4)*+&3<5+/0+=>-34-/5

?*54/+6-9>3+;*+@344/.AD(')/)9)-!"$,(-0R</,-!.$!3$&-(S9)/,*!5!?T-!U-'V!.-'!W*6%-'O?X!Y!H&*C/0

!"#$%&'$(!"#!$%&!&'()*!+,$%!-&#$.(*/!012'$23#!423#&&(5!2#!63($%!07&(2-'!'#8!9.(34&!&:4&(2&#-&8!;.2$&!82<<&(&#$!=3(>2#?!'7@2&#-&5A!B%&!9.(34&'#5/!&:-&4$!<3(!$%35&!)212#?!2#!9#?)'#8/!&7@382&8!$%&!542(2$!3<!$%&!C(&#-%!D&13).$23#E!$%&!07&(2F-'#5!2#-3(43('$&8!$%&!28&'5!<(37!$%&!"#8.5$(2')!D&13).$23#!3(/!'--3(82#?!$3!7'#*!%25$3(2'#5/!$%&!9#?)25%!D&13).$23#A!G.&!$3!$%25!<'-$/!012'$23#!2#!9.(34&!'#8!2#!$%&!H#2$&8!I$'$&5!&13)1&8!;.2$&!82<<&(&#$)*A!"#!3(8&(!$3!J.5$2<*!$%&!&5$'@)25%7&#$!3<!$%35&!-3##&-$23#5/!$%&!4(&5&#$!=3(>!%'5!8&5-(2@&8!$%&!='*!'12'$23#!423#&&(5!8&52?#&8!'#[email protected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

)*+,-%.#(!012'$23#/!02(-('<$!8&52?#/!02(!$('#543($'$23#/!C(&#-%!D&13).$23#/!"#8.5$(2')!D&13).$23#/!N4&#!53.(-&A

E$,$/4$.K!8MO87OL7!3,,$%)$.K!7PO8MOL7Z*9)#-&!2-&!,-&&$'%-(.$(,$K!=6*))-'[/)*:=&X\[email protected]*&.-!]-6$'A!M85! /̂0*!.*'!3,S,/*'W@X!L7:77N5_8L5?T-!U-'V!.-'!W*6%-'O?X5H&*C/0

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A$$

Page 111: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

E$4-09)/-(:!"#$!.$4$0-%6$()!-2!)#$!*/&'#/%!(96=$&!Q!2&-6!?*()-'5G96-()!/'!*!<--.!$`*6%0$A!=$,*9'$!/)!+*'!=*'$.!-(!*(!$*&0/$&!.$'/<(!2&-6!)#$!"/''*(./$&!=&-)#$&':! D(!LNNLA!)#$!B&$(,#!=&-)#$&'!30=$&)!*(.!]*')-(!"/''*(./$&!

$0$,)&/,/)1! $`%-'/)/-(! =1! *))*,#/(<! *(! $0$,)&/,!6-)-&! )-! *(!

a?*()-'5G96-()A! L_8Pb:! "#$! '*6$! =&-)#$&'! *0'-! 6*.$! *!'$,-(.!*))$6%)!-(!?$%)$6=$&!7cA!LNNPA!+#/,#!%$&2-&6$.!*'!)#$1!#*.!$`%$,)$.!2-&:!D(!)#$!0*)$!LP)#!,$()9&1A!?*()-'5G96-()!=9/0)A!*6-(<!-)#$&!.$'/<('A!)+-!,/<*&5'#*%$.!*/&'#/%':!B/<9&$!L!'#-+'!#/'!(96=$&!7!,-(,$%)A!+#/,#!+$()!)#&-9<#!*(!*,,/.$()!+#$(!/)'!<*'!,-()*/($&!.-9=0$.!9%!a?*()-'5G96-()A!L_8Pb:!B&-6!)#/'!%-/()!-(A!?*()-'5G96-()!a?*()-'5G96-()A!L_8Pb!

5)/-(!2&-6!#/'!2&/$(.!"/''*(./$&!2-&!)#$!(96=$&!Q!*/&'#/%A!+#/,#!

30)#-9<#!?*()-'5G96-()!./.!(-)!6$()/-(!)#*)!#$!)--;!-4$&!)#$!"/''*(./$&!.$'/<(!/(!)#$!=--;'!#$!+&-)$A!)#$!'/6/0*&/)/$'!=$)+$$(!=-)#!.$'/<('!*&$!-=4/-9'!aB/<:!7b:

B/<9&$!L:!"#$!,/<*&5'#*%$.!?*()-'5G96-()!(96=$&!7!&$,-&.$.!'-6$!! ! ! ! ! *,,/.$()':

B/<9&$!7:!?*()-'5G96-()!(96=$&!Q!a0$2)b!+*'!4$&1!'/6/0*&!/(!'#*%$!! ! ! ! ! +#$(!,-6%*&$.! )-!-($!-2! /)'! %&$.$,$''-&'A! )#$! $0$,)&/,5

! W-()&*&1!)-!+#*)!#*%%$($.!/(!B&*(,$A!*!4$&1!,-6%$)/)/4$!*)6-'%#$&$!+*'!$')*=0/'#$.!/(!)#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'A!+/)#!*06-')!(-! ,-00*=-&*)/4$! +-&;! *6-(<! )#$! *4/*)/-(! %/-($$&'! =$/(<!&$</')$&$.:!"-!$`$6%0/21! )#/'A!+$!*..&$''! )#$!+-&;!,*&&/$.!

-2! )#$!=-0-6$)$&!*(.!%/-($$&!-2!34/*)/-(:!d$!*))$6%)$.! )-!6*;$!*!+-&;/(<!%/0-)$.!#$*4/$&5)#*(5*/&!*/&,&*2):!d$!=$<*(!$`%$&/6$()/(<!+/)#!&9==$&5=*(.!%-+$&$.!6-.$0'!*(.!<0/.$&'!

&-)*)/(<!*&6!a29(,)/-(/(<!'/6/0*&!)-!*!+/(.!)9(($0b!*(.!6*.$!

0*9(,#!2&-6!*!=-*)!-(!)#$!X-)-6*,!E/4$&:!"#$!./')*(,$!+*'!)$(!)/6$'!0-(<$&!)#*(!*(1!%&$4/-9'!$`%$&/6$()!+/)#!*!#$*4/$&5

<&*()!-2!>?e!M8A888!*(.!>?e!78A888!2&-6!)#$!?6/)#'-(/*(!)-!.$4$0-%!*!%/0-)$.!*/&%0*($A!+#/,#!+*'!,#&/')$($.!3$&-.&-6$!

+/)#!)#$/&!L_87!<0/.$&A!#$!*))$6%)$.!)-!6$$)!)#$6A!=9)!)#$1!%-0/)$01!$4*.$.!#/'!&$f9$'):

=9/0)A! )#$!/()$&(*0!,-6=9')/-(!$(</($!+*'!,-()&*,)$.!-9)!)-!

)#$!.$'/<(:!"#/'!$(</($!+*'!*=0$!)-!.$0/4$&!M8!#%A!2*&!6-&$!

%&-=*=01! )#$! 6*/(! ,-()&/=9)/-(! )-! *4/*)/-(! /(! )#$! >(/)$.!?)*)$':!"#$!%/0-)$.!6*,#/($!#*.!+/&$5=&*,$.!)*(.$6!+/(<':!D)!#*.!*!XV(*9.!)*/0!2-&!%/),#!*(.!1*+!,-()&-0A!=9)!(-!&-00!,-()&-0A!.$%$(./(<!/(')$*.!-(!)#$!./#$.&*0!*(<0$!-2!)#$!+/(<'A!*'!./.!

+#/,#!,-90.!0*(.!-(!'-0/.!<&-9(.!aW90/,;A!788Lb!*(.!?*()-'5

-4$&!)#$!X-)-6*,!E/4$&:!"#/'!&$f9/&$.!*!,*)*%90)!2-&!0*9(,#/(<!5

I*))-'A!H:?:

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A$D

Page 112: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

9%!)#$!%&-F$,)!*2)$&!)+-!,&*'#$'!-(!)*;$5-22!-(!J,)-=$&!g!*(.!G$,$6=$&!NA!=-)#!/(!L_8Q:

)#$!/6%&$''/4$!M85#%!$(</($!)#*)!+*'!.$4$0-%$.!2-&!)#$!3$&-5.&-6$!*/&%0*($:!"#/'!+-90.!#*4$!%&-4/.$.!)#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'!+/)#!*!</*()!0$*%!/(!34/*)/-(!*)!)#*)!)/6$:! W-(,$&(/(<!)#$!3$&-.&-6$A!/)!+*'!&$=9/0)!=1!)#$!36$&/,*(!*4/*)/-(!%/-($$&!]0$((!W9&)/''A!+#-!')&9<<0$.!/(!,-9&)!*<*/(')!

+/)#!)#$!*/&%0*($!a?,#6/))A!L__8b:!32)$&+*&.'A!)#$!?6/)#'-(/*(!

-2!*!#$*4/$&5)#*(5*/&!4$#/,0$:!"#$!./'%9)$!+*'!)$&6/(*)$.!/(!L_P7!*2)$&!)#$!D(')/)9)$!+/)#.&$+!/)'!&$f9$')!a?,#6/))A!L__8b:!

/'!,9&&$()01!-(!./'%0*1!/(!)#$!?6/)#'-(/*(!I9'$96:! "#$'$!$`*6%0$'!2&-6!@9&-%$!*(.!)#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'!*&$!&$/(2-&,$.!=1!-)#$&'!*0-(<!)#$!%&$'$()!%*%$&A!/(!-&.$&!)-!'9')*/(!)#$!)#$'/'!)#*)!@9&-%$!+*'!6-&$!'9,,$''290!/(!)#$!.$4$0-%6$()!-2!*4/*)/-(!/(!)#$!$*&01!78)#!,$()9&1!=$,*9'$!*(!-%$(!'-9&,$!%#/0-'-%#1!+*'!$')*=0/'#$.!)#$&$:!D(!*../)/-(A!*(!-4$&4/$+!-2!34/*)/-(!/(!=-)#!,-()/($()'!/'!%&-4/.$.!2-&!)#$!'*6$!%9&%-'$:

8,/B,*..+,*2/,4+/0+/2*5+./7,1*+2)-9/./2):

! "#$!,-(,$%)!-2!-%$(!'-9&,$!*(.!)#$!2&$$!'#*&/(<!-2!)$,#5(-0-</,*0!/(2-&6*)/-(!$`/')$.!0-(<!=$2-&$!,-6%9)$&'!=$,*6$!%&$'$()! /(!-9&!$4$&1.*1! 0/2$:!B-&!$`*6%0$A!,--;/(<!&$,/%$'!#*4$!=$$(!'#*&$.!'/(,$!)#$!=$</((/(<!-2!#96*(!,90)9&$:!J%$(!'-9&,$!,*(!=$!%&$'$()!/(!=9'/($''A!'-2)+*&$A!*(.!*(1!;/(.!-2!)$,#(-0-</,*0!;(-+0$.<$:! "#$!*.4$()!-2! )#$!D()$&($)!#*'!&$'#*%$.! )#$!+*1!%$-%0$!

D()$&($)! ,-(($,)/-('! #*4$! =$$(!6*.$! *4*/0*=0$! )-! -&./(*&1!%$-%0$A!)#$!D()$&($)!2-9(.!/)'!%*)#!)-!<$($&*0/C$.!=9'/($''!*(.!<&$+!$`%-($()/*001:!D(!*(!-%%-'/)$!./&$,)/-(!)-!)#$!=9'/($''!'/.$A!*!0-)!-2!-%$(!'-9&,$!%&-F$,)'A!$(,-6%*''/(<!)#$!+-&0.!-(0/($!,-669(/)1A!$6$&<$.:!I-')!-2!)#-'$!4$()9&$'!*&$!#/<#01!

/'!0*&<$01!.&/4$(!=1!/)'!.$4$0-%$&'!*(.!9'$&!,-669(/)/$':!?-6$!4$(.-&'!.$4$0-%!*(.!29(.!)#$/&!./')&/=9)/-('!-(!*!4-09()*&1!=*'/'A!G$=/*(!/'!*!+$005;(-+(!$`*6%0$!-2!)#/':!J)#$&'!6*/(5)*/(!*!,-669(/)1!4$&'/-(!-2!)#$/&!,-66$&,/*0!./')&/=9)/-('A!*'!E$.!d*)!.-$'!+/)#!B$.-&*:!@4$(!)#$!D()$&(*)/-(*0!H9'/($''!I*,#/($!W-&%-&*)/-(! aDHIb!'9&&$(.$&$.! )-! /)'! *%%$*0'!*(.!

690)/0/(<9*0!2&$$!$(,1,0-%$./*!-2!)#$!#/<#$')!f9*0/)1!)-!$4$&1!'/(<0$!%$&'-(!-(!)#$!%0*($)!/(!#/'!-&!#$&!-+(!0*(<9*<$:h!?9,#!+$='/)$!$`/')'! )-!=&/(<!;(-+0$.<$! )-!$4$&1-($!+#-!'$$;'!

#-')$.!-(! )#/'!'/)$!*&$!&$0$*'$.!=1! )#$/&!*9)#-&'!9(.$&! )#$!

*&)/,0$'!*&$!2&$$!,-()$()!*(.!6*1!=$!&$%&-.9,$.!2&$$01A!9(.$&!)#$!'*6$!0/,$('$:! 3! <$($&*0/C$.! /(/)/*)/4$! 2-&! )#$! .$4$0-%6$()! -2! -%$(!'-9&,$!%&-F$,)'!/'!)#$!?-9&,$B-&<$!-($!a?-9&,$B-&<$A!78L7b:!?-9&,$B-&<$:($)!/'!)#$!+-&0.i'!0*&<$')!-%$(!'-9&,$!'-2)+*&$!.$4$0-%6$()!+$='/)$:! D)! #-')'!6-&$! )#*(! Q7PA888! %&-F$,)'!a')*)9'!2&-6!U*(9*&1!78L7b!*(.!-4$&!L!6/00/-(!&$</')$&$.!9'$&'!+/)#! *! ,$()&*0/C$.! &$'-9&,$! 2-&!6*(*</(<! %&-F$,)'A! /''9$'A!,-669(/,*)/-('A!*(.!,-.$':!?-9&,$B-&<$:($)!#*'!)#$!0*&<$')!&$%-'/)-&1!-2!-%$(!'-9&,$!,-.$!*(.!*%%0/,*)/-('!*4*/0*=0$!-(!)#$!D()$&($)!*(.!#-')'!6-&$!-%$(!'-9&,$!.$4$0-%6$()!%&-.9,)'!)#*(!*(1!-)#$&!'/)$!-&!($)+-&;!+-&0.+/.$:!D)!*0'-!%&-4/.$'!*!+/.$!4*&/$)1!-2!'$&4/,$'!)-!%&-F$,)'!)#$1!#-')A!*(.!)-!)#$!J%$(!?-9&,$!,-669(/)1:! 3(-)#$&!%&-F$,)!)#*)!'$$;'!#$0%!2&-6!)#$!-(0/($!,-669(/)1!

D()$&($)5,-(($,)$.!,-6%9)$&'!/(!)#$!'$*&,#!2-&!$`)&*)$&&$')&/*0!/()$00/<$(,$!a?@"Db:!3(1-($!,*(!%*&)/,/%*)$!=1!&9((/(<!*!2&$$!%&-<&*6!)#*)!.-+(0-*.'!*(.!*(*01C$'!&*./-!)$0$',-%$!.*)*:!E*./-! )$0$',-%$! '/<(*0'! ,-('/')! %&/6*&/01! -2! (-/'$! a2&-6!,$0$')/*0! '-9&,$'!*(.!&$,$/4$&i'!$0$,)&-(/,'b!*(.!6*(56*.$!'/<(*0'A!'9,#!*'!"^!')*)/-('A!&*.*&A!*(.!'*)$00/)$':!"#$!6-.$&(!&*./-!?@"D!%&-F$,)'!*(*01C$!)#$!.*)*!./</)*001:!I-&$!,-6%9)5/(<!%-+$&!$(*=0$'!'$*&,#$'!)-!,-4$&!<&$*)$&!2&$f9$(,1!&*(<$'!+/)#!6-&$!'$('/)/4/)1:!E*./-!?@"DA!)#$&$2-&$A!#*'!*(!/('*)/*=0$!*%%$)/)$!2-&!,-6%9)/(<!%-+$&:!X&$4/-9'!&*./-!?@"D!%&-F$,)'!#*4$! 9'$.! '%$,/*05%9&%-'$! '9%$&,-6%9)$&'A! 0-,*)$.! *)! )#$!)$0$',-%$A!)-!.-!)#$!=90;!-2!.*)*!*(*01'/':! D(!L__MA!G*4/.!]$.1$!%&-%-'$.!.-/(<!&*./-!?@"D!9'/(<!*!4/&)9*0!'9%$&,-6%9)$&!,-6%-'$.!-2!0*&<$!(96=$&'!-2!D()$&($)5,-(($,)$.! ,-6%9)$&'A! *(.! #$! -&<*(/C$.! )#$! ?@"D[#-6$!%&-F$,)!)-!$`%0-&$!)#/'!/.$*A!+#/,#!+*'!-&/</(*001!0*9(,#$.!/(!I*1!L___:!"#$!&$*'-(!2-&!*';/(<!)#$!-(0/($!,-669(/)1!2-&!#$0%/(<!)-!%&-,$''!&*./-!)$0$',-%$!'/<(*0'!/'!,*9'$.!=$,*9'$!)#$!&$'$*&,#$&'!*&$!0/6/)$.!=1!)#$!*6-9()!-2!,-6%9)$&!%-+$&!*4*/0*=0$!2-&!.*)*!*(*01'/':!"-!)$*'$!-9)!)#$!+$*;$')!'/<(*0'A!*!

J%$(!?-9&,$!X#/0-'-%#1!*(.!)#$!G*+(!-2!34/*)/-(

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A$E

Page 113: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

<&$*)!*6-9()!-2!,-6%9)$&!%-+$&!/'!($,$''*&1:!D)!+-90.!)*;$!*!6-(')&-9'!'9%$&,-6%9)$&!)-!<$)!)#$!F-=!.-($:!?@"D!%&-<&*6'!,-90.!($4$&!*22-&.! )-!=9/0.!-&!=91!'9,#!,-6%9)/(<!%-+$&:!

,-6=/($.!6*,#/($'!%&-4/.$.!6-&$!)#*(!)#$!$f9/4*0$()!)-!)+-!6/00/-(!1$*&'!-2!,-6%9)/(<! )/6$! 0--;/(<! 2-&! 2*/()! '/<('!-2!/()$00/<$()!0/2$!=$1-(.!$*&)#:! "#$&$!*&$!9(,-9()*=0$!/(/)/*)/4$'!2-&!)#$!.$4$0-%6$()!-2!-%$(!'-9&,$!$(</($$&/(<! '-2)+*&$!%*,;*<$':! D(.$$.A! /)! ,*(!&$</')$&!'9,#!/(/)/*)/4$'!-(!*00!2&-()'!-2!$(</($$&/(<!'9=F$,)'!

'1')$6!'/690*)/-(A!2-&!(*6/(<!F9')!*!2$+!-2!)#$6:!D)!/'!+-&)#1!

%*,;*<$!2-&!(96$&/,*0!,-6%9)*)/-('!)#*)!%&-4/.$'!*!%-+$&290!

*%%0/,*)/-(':!?/(,$!L__P!/)!#*'!=$$(!./')&/=9)$.!2&$$01!*0-(<!+/)#!)#$!'-9&,$!,-.$!4/*!)#$!D()$&($):!D)! /'!,9&&$()01!9'$.!/(!$.9,*)/-(*0!*(.!/(.9')&/*0!$(4/&-(6$()'!*&-9(.!)#$!+-&0.:

#)*+C,*51)+35;+D5B9-.)+$*>/974-/5.

! "#$!B&$(,#!E$4-09)/-(!/(!LgN_A!+#/,#!,*9'$.!)#$!2*00!-2!)#$!6-(*&,#1!/(!B&*(,$A!/'!-($!-2!)#$!6-')!/6%-&)*()!2*,)'!-2!

)#!&$,$/4$.!2&-6!#/'!%&$.$,$''-&!*!,-9()&1!5

)/-(A!+#/,#!2*,$.!*!#/<#!0-*.!-2! )*`$':!B&*(,$!')/00!;$%)! /)'!6$./*$4*0!'-,/*0!')&9,)9&$A!,-9()/(<!)#&$$!,0*''$'K!(-=/0/)1A!

*%%&-`/6*)$01!)+-5)#/&.'!-2!/)'!%&-.9,)/-(!2-&!)#$!%*16$()!-2!)*`$'!aI*/-&A!L_ccb:

E-9''$*9!,-()&/=9)$.!)-!)#$!<-*0'!-2!&$4-09)/-(:!D(!*../)/-(!)-!)#$'$!%#/0-'-%#$&'A!)#$!$,-(-6/')'!j9$'(*1!*(.!3.*6!?6/)#!,-()&/=9)$.!/.$-0-</,*001!)-!)#$!<&$*)!)&*('2-&6*)/-(!-2!LgN_!aI*/-&A!L_ccb:! D(!<$($&*0A!2-9&!,*9'$'!,*(!=$!$(96$&*)$.!)-!$`%0*/(!)#$!B&$(,#!E$4-09)/-(! aG*&()-(A!L_N7b:!B/&')01A! )#$!@(0/<#)$(56$()!,-()&/=9)$.!)-!*(!$(4/&-(6$()!/(!+#/,#!&$4-09)/-(!+*'!%-''/=0$!=1!/)'!/('/')$(,$!-(!&$2-&6/(<!/(')/)9)/-('!)-!,-6%01!+/)#!')*(.*&.'!-2!&$*'-(!*(.!9)/0/)1:!B9&)#$&6-&$A!/)!,-/(,/.$.!+/)#! %9=0/,! -%/(/-(! &/'$A!+#/,#! 9(.$&6/($.! )#$! *='-09)/')!(-)/-(! )#*)! %-0/)/,*0! .$,/'/-('! &$f9/&$.! (-! ,-('90)*)/-(! -&!)-0$&*)$.!(-!-%%-'/)/-(:!?$,-(.01A!)#$!B&$(,#!')*)$!2*,$.!=*(;5

"#/&.01A!B&*(,$!+/)($''$.!$(.$6/,!%-0/)/,*0!')&/2$!/(!)#$!LN)#

,$()9&1:! "$,#(/,*001A! *='-09)/')! 6-(*&,#'! &90$.! =1! ./4/($!&/<#)!*(.!$`$&,/'$.!'-4$&$/<()1!+/)#-9)! )#$! /()$&2$&$(,$!-2!&$%&$'$()*)/4$!/(')/)9)/-(':!B&$(,#!;/(<'!/(!&$*0/)1!6$)!+/)#!-%%-'/)/-(!)-!)#$/&!%-0/,/$'!2&-6!)#$!(-=0$!6*</')&*)$'!-2!)#$!

)#$!(*6$!-2!%&-)$,)/(<!)&*./)/-(*0!&/<#)'!2&-6!*&=/)&*&1!*9)#-&5

+$&$!')&$''!C-($'!/(!B&$(,#!'-,/$)1A!*'!*!<&-+/(<!%-%90*)/-(!)#&$*)$($.! 6*(1! %$-%0$! +/)#! .$')/)9)/-(! *(.! *'! )*0$()$.!

*2)$&!=*.!+$*)#$&!.-9=0$.!)#$!%&/,$!-2!=&$*.!/(!LgN_:! @(0/<#)$(6$()!+*'!*!6-4$6$()!+#/,#!')*)$.!)#*)!',/$(,$!,-90.!$`%0*/(!$4$&1)#/(<!/(!(*)9&$:!>()/0! )#$(A!6-')!%$-%0$!

6*(($&:!I$)*%#1'/,*0!6$*('!=$1-(.!%#1'/,*0A!*(.!'9<<$')'!)#*)! /)! /'! /6%-''/=0$!2-&!#96*('! )-!,-6%&$#$(.!)#/(<'! )#*)!#*%%$(!/(!-9&!$(4/&-(6$():!?/(,$!/)!+*'!.$4$0-%$.!6-&$!-&!0$''!'/690)*($-9'01! /(!]$&6*(1A!B&*(,$A!]&$*)!H&/)*/(A! )#$!

)#&-9<#!69,#!-2!@9&-%$A!E9''/*!*(.!?,*(./(*4/*!*'!+$00!*'!

)#$!'/<(*)-&/$'!-2!)#$!36$&/,*(!G$,0*&*)/-(!-2!D(.$%$(.$(,$A!)#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'!H/00!-2!E/<#)'A!*(.!)#$!B&$(,#!G$,0*&*)/-(!-2!)#$!E/<#)'!-2!I*(!*(.!-2!)#$!W/)/C$(A!+$&$!6-)/4*)$.!=1!@(0/<#)$(6$()!%&/(,/%0$'!aD'&*$0A!788Lb:

]*0/0$-!9'$.!*!&$2&*,)/(<!)$0$',-%$!)-!'$*&,#!)#$!';/$'A!'-6$!

)-!-='$&4$!?*)9&(i'!&/(<'A!)#-9<#!#$!,-90.!(-)!'$$!)#$6!+$00!$(-9<#!)-!./',$&(!)#$/&!)&9$!(*)9&$:!H*'$.!-(!#/'!-='$&4*)/-('A!

*&-9(.!)#$!'9(:! @(0/<#)$(6$()!)#/(;$&'!$(,-9&*<$.!%$-%0$!)-!9'$!',/$(,$!)-! $`%0-&$! (*)9&$! *(.! )-! f9$')/-(! +#*)! )#$1! #*.! *0+*1'!*,,$%)$.!+/)#-9)!f9$')/-(/(<:!"#$!@(0/<#)$(6$()!')/690*)$.!%$-%0$! )-!%*&)/,/%*)$! /(! )#$!<-4$&(6$()! *(.! )-! &$)#/(;!-0.!/.$*'A!'9,#!*'!2$9.*0/'6!*(.!%&/6-<$(/)9&$:!"#$!36$&/,*(!E$4-09)/-(!*(.!)#$!B&$(,#!E$%9=0/,!*&$!'$$(!=1!6*(1!*'!#9<$!*,#/$4$6$()'!2-&!)#$!@(0/<#)$(6$():

2&-6!)#$!6-6$()'!=$2-&$!/):!"#$!B&$(,#!E$4-09)/-(!*(.!/)'!*2)$&6*)#!+$&$! (-! $`,$%)/-('A! =$/(<! &$,-&.$.! *'! *! %$&/-.!-2!%-0/)/,*0!*(.!'-,/*0!9%#$*4*0!/(!)#$!#/')-&1!-2!B&*(,$:!D(!6*(1!+*1'! /)! '%&*(<! 2&-6! )#$!9(.$(/*=0$!*(.!9('+*1*=0$!2-&,$'!-2!6-.$&(/C*)/-(A! )-%%0/(<!*! '1')$6! )#*)!+*'!.1/(<!9(.$&! /)'!-+(!+$/<#)!*(.! /()&/('/,*001!9(*=0$! )-!*.*%)!*(.!

I*))-'A!H:?:

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A$F

Page 114: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

'9&4/4$!/(!)#$!($+!$,-(-6/,!*(.!%#/0-'-%#/,*0!&$*0/)1:!"#$!B&$(,#! <-4$&(6$()*0! ')&9,)9&$A! +#/,#! +*'! %&$4/-9'01! *(!*='-09)$!6-(*&,#1!+/)#!2$9.*0!%&/4/0$<$'!2-&!)#$!*&/')-,&*,1!*(.!W*)#-0/,!,0$&<1A!9(.$&+$()!&*./,*0!,#*(<$!)-!2-&6'!=*'$.!-(! @(0/<#)$(6$()! %&/(,/%0$'! -2! (*)/-(*0/'6A! ,/)/C$('#/%A!*(.!/(*0/$(*=0$!&/<#)':!"#$'$!,#*(<$'!+$&$!*,,-6%*(/$.!=1!4/-0$()!)9&6-/0A! /(,09./(<!$`$,9)/-('!*(.!&$%&$''/-(!.9&/(<!)#$!E$/<(!-2!"$&&-&A!*(.!+*&2*&$!/(4-04/(<!$4$&1!-)#$&!6*F-&!@9&-%$*(!%-+$&:!?9='$f9$()!$4$()'!)#*)!,*(!=$!)&*,$.!)-!)#$!

5&*)/-('!-2! )#$!6-(*&,#1A!*(.! )+-!*../)/-(*0! &$4-09)/-('!*'!6-.$&(!B&*(,$!)--;!'#*%$:!"#$!/.$*0'!=&-9<#)!=1!)#$!B&$(,#!E$4-09)/-(!2-&!*!6-&$!$f9*0!'-,/$)1!&*%/.01!'%&$*.!*0-(<!)#$!

X-4$&)1!-2!X#/0-'-%#1h!/(!LNPgA!*!&$'%-('$!)-!X/$&&$5U-'$%#!

/.$*0'!-2!)#$!B&$(,#!E$4-09)/-(:! "#$! D(.9')&/*0!E$4-09)/-(!+*'! *! %$&/-.! /(! )#$! 0*)$! LN)#

*(.!$*&01!L_)#!,$()9&/$'!+#$(!6*F-&!,#*(<$'!/(!*<&/,90)9&$A!6*(92*,)9&/(<A! *(.! )&*('%-&)*)/-(! +/)#! *! %&-2-9(.! $22$,)!-(! )#$! '-,/-$,-(-6/,! *(.! ,90)9&*0! ,-(./)/-('! /(! H&/)*/(!#*%%$($.:!"#$!D(.9')&/*0!-&!@(<0/'#!E$4-09)/-(!,&1')*00/C$.!'-6$!%&/(,/%0$'!)#*)!+$&$!,-()&*&1!/(!6*(1!+*1'!)-!)#$!/.$*0'!-2!)#$!B&$(,#!E$4-09)/-(:!>(.$&!)#$!96=&$00*!-2!)#$!@(<0/'#!E$4-09)/-(A!)#$!#96*(!=$/(<!+*'!(-)!)#$!,$()$&!-2!6*))$&':!I-($1A!-&!6-&$!$`*,)01!)#$!,*%/)*0/')A!+*'!)#$!<&*4/)1!,$()$&!-2! )#$! '1')$6!+/)#! 2$+!-&! (-! &$<*&.! )-!+-&;$&'i! 0/2$:!"#$!,#*(<$'!=&-9<#)!=1! )#$!D(.9')&/*0!E$4-09)/-(!'9='$f9$()01!

+-&0.A!*!%&-,$''!)#*)!,-()/(9$.!*'!/(.9')&/*0/C*)/-(:!"#$!-('$)!-2!)#$!D(.9')&/*0!E$4-09)/-(!6*&;$.!*!6*F-&!)9&(/(<!%-/()!/(!#96*(!'-,/$)1k!*06-')!$4$&1!*'%$,)!-2!.*/01!0/2$!+*'!$4$()95

! D(!)#$!0*)$&!%*&)!-2!)#$!Lg88'A!)#$&$!+*'!*!)&*('/)/-(!/(!%*&)'!-2!]&$*)!H&/)*/(i'!%&$4/-9'01!6*(9*050*=-&5=*'$.!$,-(-61!)-+*&.'!6*,#/($5=*'$.!6*(92*,)9&/(<:! D)! ')*&)$.!+/)#! )#$!6$,#*(/C*)/-(!-2! )#$!)$`)/0$! /(.9')&/$'A! )#$!.$4$0-%6$()!-2!

"&*.$!$`%*('/-(!+*'!$(*=0$.!=1!)#$!/()&-.9,)/-(!-2!,*(*0'A!/6%&-4$.! &-*.'A! *(.! &*/0+*1':! "#$! /()&-.9,)/-(! -2! ')$*6!%-+$&! a29$00$.!%&/6*&/01! =1! ,-*0b! *(.!%-+$&$.!6*,#/($&1!a6*/(01!/(!)$`)/0$!6*(92*,)9&/(<b!9(.$&%/(($.!)#$!.&*6*)/,!/(,&$*'$'! /(! %&-.9,)/-(! ,*%*,/)1:!"#$! .$4$0-%6$()! -2! *005

)#!,$()9&1!2*,/0/)*)$.! )#$! 6*(92*,)9&$! -2! 6-&$! %&-.9,)/-(! 6*,#/($'!

)#!,$()9&1A!$4$()9*001!*22$,)/(<!6-')!-2! )#$!+-&0.:!"#$! /6%*,)!-2! )#/'!,#*(<$!-(!'-,/$)1!+*'!$(-&6-9':

D'$%8D="+=E!=#!%"+?DC%$D+F%$G&+F3,+!

DH2*,-I*54.+<-4)+J399//5.

! W-6%*&$.!)-!)#$!,/4/0/C*)/-(!#/')-&1!*(.!(*4*0!+*&2*&$A!)#$!#/')-&1!-2!34/*)/-(!/'!4$&1!&$,$()A!-(01!*=-9)!*!,$()9&1!-0.:!

5

+$005&$,-&.$.:!H$,*9'$!)#$!#/')-&1!-2!)#$!*$&-')*)!')*&)$.!0-(<!=$2-&$!)#*)!-2!)#$!*/&%0*($A!/)!/'!0$''!;(-+(:! 3(,/$()! /(',&/%)/-('!*(.! )$`)'! /(./,*)$! )#*)! )#$!W#/($'$!9'$.!#-)!*/&!=*00--('!*(.!</<*()/,!;/)$'!=$2-&$!)#$!W#&/')/*(!

I-(<-0'!9'$.!/0096/(*)$.!;/)$'!)-!,-669(/,*)$!.9&/(<!)#$!

-($! -2! )#$! 6-')! %-+$&290! (*)/-('! /(! )#$! +-&0.A! +#/,#!

*(! /()$&(*0! ,&9'*.$! *<*/(')! )#$6:!J(!B&/.*1A!J,)-=$&! LQA!LQ8g!a*!.*)$!%-''/=01!0/(;$.!)-!)#$!-&/</(!-2!)#$!B&/.*1!)#$!LQ)#!0$<$(.bA!X#/0/%!#*.!*00!B&$(,#!"$6%0*&'!'/690)*($-9'01!*&&$')$.A!,#*&<$.!+/)#!(96$&-9'!#$&$'/$'A!*(.! )-&)9&$.!=1!B&$(,#! *9)#-&/)/$'! (-6/(*001! 9(.$&! )#$! D(f9/'/)/-(A! 9()/0!)#$1!*00$<$.01!,-(2$''$.:!"#/'!*,)/-(!&$0$*'$.!X#/0/%!2&-6!#/'!-=0/<*)/-(! )-!&$%*1!#9<$! 0-*('!2&-6!)#$!"$6%0*&'!*(.!

X#/0/%! a+#-! #*.! =$$(! &$'%-('/=0$! 2-&!6*($94$&/(<! X-%$!

)#$!-&.$&!*)! )#$!W-9(,/0!-2! /̂$((*:!@4$(!)#-9<#!*00! 0*(.'!+$&$!'9%%-'$.!)-!=$!)9&($.!-4$&!)-!)#$!d-'%/)*00$&'A!X#/00/%!&$)*/($.!*!<&$*)!.$*0!-2!)#$!"$6%0*&!*''$)'!/(!B&*(,$:!?-6$!-)#$&!@9&-%$*(!0$*.$&'!2-00-+$.!'9/)! /(!*(!$22-&)! )-!&$.9,$!)#$!*6-9()!-2!W#9&,#5-+($.!0*(.'!*(.!%&-%$&)1:! D(!LQLPA!)#&$$!"$6%0*&!0$*.$&'A! /(,09./(<!]&*(.!I*')$&!U*,f9$'! G$! I-0*1A! d9<#! G$! X$&*90)A! *(.! ]-.2&$1! G$!]-($4/00$!+$&$!=9&($.!*0/4$!*)!)#$!')*;$!=1!B&$(,#!*9)#-&/5)/$'!*2)$&!%9=0/,01!&$(-9(,/(<!*(1!<9/0):!E$6*/(/(<!"$6%0*&'!*&-9(.! @9&-%$A! #*4/(<! =$$(! *&&$')$.! *(.! )&/$.! 9(.$&! )#$!

J%$(!?-9&,$!X#/0-'-%#1!*(.!)#$!G*+(!-2!34/*)/-(

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A$#

Page 115: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

X*%*0!/(4$')/<*)/-(A!+$&$!$/)#$&!*='-&=$.!/()-!-)#$&!6/0/)*&1!5

)*00$&!-&!,-()$6%0*)/4$!H$($./,)/($!-&!39<9')/(/*(!-($':!D(!X-&)9<*0A! )#$1!2-9(.!&$29<$!9(.$&!)#$!J&.$&!-2!W#&/'):!"#$!"$6%0*&'!=&-9<#)!)-!X-&)9<*0!)&$*'9&$'A!;(-+0$.<$!-2!*(,/$()!,/4/0/C*)/-('A!*(.!(*4*0!)$,#(-0-<1!2&-6!)#$!3&*=/*('A!+#/,#!)&/<<$&$.!)#$!(*4*0!(*4/<*)/-(!$&*A!6*;/(<!X-&)9<*0!-($!-2!)#$!6-')!%-+$&290!(*)/-('!/(!)#$!+-&0.:! >(.$&!)#$!@9&-%$*(!$`%*('/-(!=&-9<#)!=1!)#$!(*4/<*)/-(!$&*A!H&*C/0!+*'!./',-4$&$.!=1!X-&)9<*0! /(!LM88:!H&*C/0/*(!U$'9/)!H*&)-0-6$9!.$!]9'6T-A!=-&(!/(!H&*C/0!)-!X-&)9<9$'$!%*&$()'A!*.-%)$.!*!&$0/</-9'!,*&$$&!*(.!6-4$.!)-!X-&)9<*0!+#$(! #$! +*'! LM! 1$*&'5-0.:! H1! &$*./(<! *()/f9$! +&/)/(<'!%-''/=01!=&-9<#)! )-!X-&)9<*0!=1!"$6%0*&'A!#$!&$./',-4$&$.!)#$!%&/(,/%0$!-2!)#$!#-)5*/&!=*00--(:!D(!39<9')!Lg8_A!]9'6T-!=9/0)!*!'6*00!*(.!9(6*(($.!=*00--(!*(.!%$&2-&6$.!*!.$6-(5

)#*)!]9'6T-!=9/0)!*(!9(6*(($.!0*&<$&!=*00--(! )#*)! 2&$$01!*',$(.$.!-9).--&'!'-6$!)/6$!0*)$&:!H*&)-0-6$9!.$!]9'6T-!%&-,$$.$.!+/)#! #/'! $`%$&/6$()'!+/)#! 0*&<$&! =*00--('! *(.!

+*'!0*9(,#$.!2&-6!?*/()!U-&<$!W*')0$A!-(!)#$!)-%!-2!-($!-2!

.-!X*\-:!d-+$4$&A! )#$&$! /'!(-!$4/.$(,$! )#*)! )#/'!*,)9*001!

*(.! 0$2)!X-&)9<*0:!H$2-&$! 0$*4/(<! )#$!,-9()&1A!#$!<*4$!#/'!=&-)#$&!'$4$&*0!.&*+/(<'!-2!#/'!=*00--(':!32)$&!'-6$!)/6$A!#/'! =&-)#$&! +-&;$.! *)! X-&)9<*0i'! @6=*''1! /(! X*&/'! *(.!$')*=0/'#$.!'-6$!,-()*,)'!)-!U-'V!.$!H*&&-'A!*!',/$()/')!,0-'$!

! ?#-&)!=$2-&$!)#$!B&$(,#!E$4-09)/-(A!)#$!=&-)#$&'!U-'$%#5

=*00--(!-2!'*,;,0-)#!+/)#!)#&$$!)#/(!0*1$&'!-2!%*%$&!/('/.$:!"#$!$(4$0-%$!,-90.!#*4$!($*&01!g_8!6Q!-2!*/&!*(.!+$/<#$.!77M!;<:!D)! +*'! ,-(')&9,)$.! -2! 2-9&! %/$,$'! a.-6$! *(.! )#&$$! 0*)$&*0!=*(.'bA! *(.! #$0.! )-<$)#$&! =1! LAN88! =9))-(':!3! &$/(2-&,/(<!

! D(!U9($!P)#

%9=0/,!.$6-(')&*)/-(!*)!3((-(*1!/(!2&-()!-2!*!<&-9%!-2!./<(/5

7!;6A! 0*')$.!)$(!6/(9)$'A!*(.!#*.!*(!$')/6*)$.!*0)/)9.$!-2!

@)/$(($!+$()!)-!)#$!,*%/)*0! )-!6*;$!29&)#$&!.$6-(')&*)/-('!

U-'$%#A!</4$(!#/'!9(;$6%)!*%%$*&*(,$!*(.!'#1($''A!&$6*/($.!+/)#!)#$!2*6/01:

! B&-6! )#$! 20/<#)'! +/)#! I-()<-02/$&'i! =*00--('! -(A!=*00--(/(<!=$,*6$!0*&<$01!+/.$'%&$*.:!D(!LgNMA!U$*(5X/$&&$!H0*(,#*&.! *(.! U-#(! U$22&/$'! .$%*&)$.! 2&-6! @(<0*(.! -(! *!=*00--(!*(.!,&-''$.! )#$!@(<0/'#!W#*(($0:! D(!Lg_PA!B&*(,$!-%$($.!*!=*00--(/(<!',#--0:!D)!*0'-!9'$.!)+-!=*00--(!,-&%'!/(!)#$!=*))0$'!-2!I*9=$9<$!*(.!B0$9&9'!*(.!/(!)#$!I*/(C!'/$<$!/(!)#$!2-00-+/(<!1$*&:!D(!U901!-2!LNP_A!39')&/*(!)&--%'!9'$.!

! @(<0/'#!*$&-(*9)!W#*&0$'!]&$$(!aLgNM5LNg8b!9'$.!*!,-*0!

/(!LNQc:!D)!+*'!-(!)#/'!4-1*<$A!*0-(<!+/)#!%*''$(<$&'!E-=$&)!d-00*(.!*(.!"#-6*'!I-(,;!I*'-(!)#*)!]&$$(!'9,,$''29001!

gg8!;6!/(!LN!#-9&':!32)$&!*,#/$4/(<!)#/'!2$*)A!]&$$(!#*.!*(!$(.0$''!'9%%01!-2!'%-('-&'A!+#-!+$&$!$*<$&!)-!*',$()!/(!)#$!2*6-9'!=*00--(:

$(</($'!*(.!%&-%$00$&'!aB/<:!7b:!?*()-'5G96-()!,-66$()$.!-(!]/22*&.i'!$`%$&/6$()*)/-(!+/)#!*/&'#/%'!a?*()-'5G96-()A!

)-!/)'!+$/<#)A!'%/))/(<!&$.5#-)!'%*&;'!2&-6!/)'!,-*0!29$0A!#*.!*22-&.$.!)#*)!,-9&*<$-9'!/((-4*)-&!(-!2*/&!,#*(,$A!D!*&<9$.:!D!./.!(-)!.*001!*!'/(<0$!6-6$()!+/)#!)#$!/.$*!-2!*(!$0$,)&/,!6-)-&A!+#/,#!%&-6/'$'!0/))0$!.*(<$&A!/)!/'!)&9$A!=9)!+#/,#!#*'!)#$! ,*%/)*0! =*00--(/(<! .$2$,)! -2! =$/(<! )#$! #$*4/$')! ;(-+(!$(</($A!,-9()/(<!)#$!+$/<#)!-2!/)'!=*))$&1:!D(.$$.A!D!#*4$!'-!0/))0$!%*)/$(,$!+/)#! )#$! /.$*! )#*)! D! '#*00! '*1!(-!6-&$!*=-9)!/)!$`,$%)!)-!&$%$*)!+#*)!I&:!@./'-(!'*/.!)-!6$!-(!)#/'!#$*.!

%$)&-0$96!6-)-&i:h! B&-6! ]/22*&.i'! ')$*65%-+$&$.! */&'#/%! -(A! (96$&-9'!4$#/,0$'!+$&$!.$4$0-%$.A! /(,09./(<!)#*)!=$0-(</(<!)-!X*90!dl0$/(A! /(! LNg7! aB/<:! QbA! *(.! )#$! -($! -2!W#*&0$'!E/),#$0A!

/()$&(*0!,-6=9')/-(!$(</($'!-(!*(!*/&'#/%:!d1.&-<$(!+*'!9'$.!*'! )#$!29$0! )-! 0/2)! )#$!*/&'#/%A!')-&$.! /(!*!'/(<0$! )*(;:!D(! )#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'A!W#*&0$'!E/),#$0!6*.$!.$6-(')&*)/-('!-2!*!0/<#)$&5)#*(5*/&,&*2)!=9/0)!+/)#!/6%$&6$*=0$!2*=&/,!*(.!)9=90*&!')&9,)9&$!+/)#!&--6!2-&!)#$!%/0-)!*(.!*(!$(</($A!*(.!

)9&(!-2!)#$!,$()9&1:

I*))-'A!H:?:

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AD%

Page 116: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

D(!LNNQA!)#$!=&-)#$&'!30=$&)!*(.!]*')-(!"/''*(./$&!2&-6!

$0$,)&/,/)1:!"#$!,9&&$()!+*'!'9%%0/$.!=1!7P!%-)*'#!,$00'!)-!*!

%$&! 6/(9)$:! "#$! $(</($! .&-4$! *! 0*&<$! )+-5=0*.$.! %9'#$&!%&-%$00$&A! )#&-9<#!*!&$.9,)/-(!<$*&=-`:!"#$!'%$$.!*,#/$4$.!*)!(-!+/(.!,-(./)/-('!+*'!')/00!-(01!P:N ;6O#A!'/(,$!)#$!&*)/-!-2!%-+$&!)-!+$/<#)!+*'!(-!=$))$&!)#*(!)#*)!-2!]/22*&.i'!*/&'#/%!a?*()-'5G96-()A!L_8Pb:

B&$(,#!3&61!W-&%'!-2!@(</($$&'A!=9/0)!*(!$0-(<*)$.!*/&'#/%A!

,-90.!&$)9&(!)-!/)'!')*&)/(<!%-/()!/(!*!0/<#)!+/(.:!D)!+*'!M8:Q 6!0-(<A!/)'!6*`/696!./*6$)$&!+*'!N:7!6A!*(.!/)!#*.!*!,*%*,5/)1!-2!LANc_!6Q

"#/'!6-)-&!+*'!0*)$&!&$%0*,$.!+/)#!*(-)#$&!-($!)#*)!.$0/4$&$.!

,-4$&$.!=*6=--!2&*6$+-&;A!0/($.!+/)#!,*(4*'!#9(<!=$0-+!)#$!=*00--(:!"#$!')&9,)9&$! )#*)!*,,-66-.*)$.! )#$!=*))$&/$'!*(.!$(</($!+*'!QQ 6!0-(<A!L:P 6!+/.$A!*(.!L:N 6!.$$%:!"#$!$(</($!.&-4$!*!2-9&5=0*.$.!+--.$(!)&*,)-&!%&-%$00$&!)#*)!+*'!g 6!/(!./*6$)$&A!=9)!+#/,#!,-90.!=$!/(,0/($.!9%+*&.'!+#$(!

0*(./(<!)-!*4-/.!.*6*<$'!)-!)#$!=0*.$':!E$(*&.!*0'-!%&-4/.$.!&9..$&!*(.!$0$4*)-&A!=*00-($)'!a)-!;$$%!)#$!'#*%$!-2!)#$!<*'!,-()*/($&bA!'0/./(<!+$/<#)!)-!,-6%$('*)$!2-&!*(1!'#/2)!/(!)#$!<&*4/)1!,$()$&A!*(.!*!#$*41!<9/.$!&-%$!)-!*''/')!/(!0*(./(<A!*00!)#/'!+-90.!=$,-6$!')*(.*&.!$f9/%6$()!2-&!)#$!($`)!<$($&*5)/-('!-2!*/&'#/%'!)-!,-6$:

-($!.9&/(<!+#/,#!)#$1!#*.!=$$(!/(!,-()&-0!)#&-9<#-9):!D(!LNNP!

0/<#)+$/<#)!$(</($:

*/&'#/%!%-/()$.01!(*6$.!G$9)',#0*(.:!"#$!<-(.-0*!+*'!./&$,)01!,-(($,)$.! )-! )#$!#900! *(.!*(!N5#%!G*/60$&! $(</($!%-+$&$.!

/(!W*((')*))A!,0-'$!)-!)#$!,/)1!-2!?)9))<*&):!D(!LN_gA!)#$!*/&'#/%!

*(.! #/'!6$,#*(/,! ./$.! /(! )#$! *,,/.$():! @',*%/(<! #1.&-<$(!2&-6!)#$!$(4$0-%$!#*.!%&-=*=01!,-6$!/()-!,-()*,)!+/)#!)#$!#-)!

J%$(!?-9&,$!X#/0-'-%#1!*(.!)#$!G*+(!-2!34/*)/-(

B/<9&$!Q:!?-6$!*/&'#/%'!=9/0)!/(!)#$!'$,-(.!#*02!-2!)#$!LN)#!,$()9&1:

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AD&

Page 117: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

%-+$&5.&/4$(!34/*)/-(:!B9)9&$!.$'/<($&'!+-90.!*4-/.!%0*,/(<!

39')&/*(! $(</($$&! G*4/.! ?,#+*&C! +*'! *0'-! *))$6%)5/(<! )-!#*&($''! )#$!%$)&-0! $(</($! )-! *(!*/&'#/%A!+#/,#!+*'!#/<#01!9(9'9*0!*(.!*#$*.!-2!/)'!)/6$!/(!=$/(<!6*.$!-2!'#$$)!*096/(96A!*(!$/<#)!)#-9'*(.)#!-2!*(!/(,#!)#/,;A!+#/,#!+*'!'9%%-&)$.! /()$&(*001! =1! *(! *096/(96! 2&*6$! =&*,$.! +/)#!+/&$'!aB/<:!Qb:!"#$!*/&'#/%!+*'!Pg:M 6!0-(<!*(.!#*.!*!,*%*,5/)1!-2!QAg88!6Q:!X-+$&!+*'!%&-4/.$.!=1!*!L75#%!G*/60$&!$(</($A!.&/4/(<!2-9&!%&-%$00$&'A!)+-!-2!+#/,#!+$&$!2-&!')$$&5/(<!*(.!)#$!&$6*/(/(<!-)#$&! )+-!2-&!%&-%90'/-(:!?,#+*&Ci'!6$,#*(/,!#*.!)#$!.9=/-9'!#-(-&!-2! )$')/(<!#/'!$6%0-1$&i'!(-4$0!=&*/(,#/0.:!"#$!*/&'#/%!6*.$!/)'!6*/.$(!4-1*<$!2&-6!

'9,,$''290!,/&,0$'A!=9)!)#$(!')*&)$.!)-!.$',$(.!&*%/.01!=$2-&$!/)!')&9,;!)#$!<&-9(.!*(.!=&-;$!9%:!"#/'! )/6$A! )#$!%/0-)!+*'!*=0$!)-!+*0;!*+*1A!+/)#-9)!*(1!=&9/'$':

8,314-139+3-,.)-2.

=9/0)!=1!?*()-'5G96-()!*(.!+*'!*#$*.!-2!/)'! )/6$:!D(')$*.!-2!W#/($'$!'/0;A!#$!$6%0-1$.!/(!/)'!,-(')&9,)/-(!)#$!U*%*($'$!-($!a?*()-'5G96-()A!L_8Pb:!"#/'!&$'90)$.!/(!*!69,#!'6*00$&!*(.! 0/<#)$&!=*00--(!,-6%*&$.! )-! )#$!$`/')/(<!-($'!+/)#! )#$!'*6$!%*10-*.:!"#$!,-66-(!'$('$!*)!)#*)!)/6$!*.4/'$.!)#$!9'$!-2!W#/($'$!'/0;A!=9)!?*()-'5G96-()!,-&&$,)01!,*0,90*)$.!)#*)!U*%*($'$!'/0;!+-90.!$(*=0$!*!0/<#)$&!=*00--(:32)$&!#/'!=&/$2!$`%$&/6$()'!+/)#!=*00--('A!30=$&)-!?*()-'5

G*4/.! ?,#+*&Ci'! ,&*'#:! d$! ,#&/')$($.! /)! ?*()-'5G96-()!(96=$&L!aB/<:!Pb:!D)!+*'!6*.$!-2!0/<#)+$/<#)!U*%*($'$!'/0;A!#*.! *! ,*%*,/)1! -2! LNc! 6QA! *(.! +*'! %-+$&$.! =1! *! Q:M5#%!/()$&(*0!,-6=9')/-(!$(</($:!?/6/0*&! )-!6*(1!-)#$&!?*()-'5G96-()!.$'/<('A!)#$!(96=$&!L!+*'!(-!=/<<$&!)#*(!+*'!')&/,)01!($,$''*&1!)-!0/2)! /)'!%/0-):!?*()-'5G96-()!./.!(-)!$4$(!#*4$!&--6!)-!'/)!.-+(!/(!)#$!)/(1!+/,;$&!=*';$):!32)$&!*!)*;$-22!*))$6%)A!G96-()i'!(96=$&!L!,&*'#$.!-(!?$%)$6=$&!LNA!LN_N!a?*()-'5G96-()A!L_8Pb:!"#$!*/&'#/%!#/)! )#$! )&$$'!-2! U*&./(!Gi3,,0/6*)*)/-(! /(!H-/'!.$!H-90-<($!*(.!+*'!$`)$('/4$01!.*6*<$.:! ?*()-'5G96-()! &$%*/&$.! /)! *(.! )--;! -22! *<*/(! *!,-9%0$!-2!.*1'!0*)$&:!>'/(<!)#$!/(,/.$(,$5,#*(</(<!6$,#*(/'6!#$!#*.!.$'/<($.A!#$!+*'!*=0$!)-!&$*,#!*!P88 6!#$/<#):!3)!)#$!#/<#$')!*0)/)9.$!*))*/($.!=1!?*()-'5G96-()A!)#$!%&$''9&$!.&-%!*,,-9()$.!=1!#1.&-<$(! 0$*;*<$A!+#/,#!+*'! ,*9'$.!=1! )#$!%-&-'/)1!-2!)#$!#900A!,-90.!(-)!=$!,-6%$('*)$.!=1!G96-()i'!6$,#*(/'6!*(16-&$:!"#$!<&*,$290!./&/</=0$!+*'!-9)!-2!,-()&-0!

'#-9)$.!-9)!2-&!'-6$!=-1'!=$0-+!)-!,*),#!)#$!#*(</(<!&-%$!*(.!6*($94$&$.!)#$!*/&'#/%!*<*/(')!)#$!+/(.!a?*()-'5G96-()A!L_8Pb:!"#$!0*(./(<!+*'!)#$(!*06-')!%$&2$,):

?*()-'5G96-()i'!'$,-(.!*/&'#/%!+*'!')&-(<01!=*'$.!-(!)#$!

)#&$+!)#$!*/&'#/%!*<*/(')!)#$!)&$$':

B/<9&$!P: ?-6$!*/&'#/%'!.$'/<($.!*(.!=9/0)!=1!?*()-'5G96-():

+*'!0/2)$.!=1!#1.&-<$(!*(.!%-+$&$.!=1!*(!/()$&(*0!,-6=9')/-(!

$(4$0-%$!2*/09&$:!D(!)#/'!)/6$A!*!0-(<!'*9'*<$!'#*%$!+*'!&$F$,)$.!/(!2*4-&!-2!*(!$00/%)/,*0!$(4$0-%$A!'/6/0*&! )-! )#$!-($!]/22*&.!*(.!#/'!2&/$(.!"/''*(./$&!aB/<:!Pb!#*.!9'$.!0-(<!=$2-&$:!?/(,$!/)!+*'!)#/,;$&!/(!)#$!6/..0$!-2!/)'!0$(<)#A!/)!+*'!9(*=0$!)-!2-0.!

%&-%$00$.!=1!*(!/()$&(*0!,-6=9')/-(!$(</($:!H$'/.$'!#1.&-<$(A!?*()-'5G96-()!*0'-!,-('/.$&$.!)-!$6%0-1!/0096/(*)/-(!<*'!2-&!0/2)/(<!)#$!(96=$&!Q!*/&'#/%:!"#$!6*/(!/.$*!=$#/(.!)#/'!+*'!)-!.$'/<(!*!0-+5,-')!*/&,&*2)A!+#/,#!,-90.!=$!$*'/01!6*(92*,)9&$.!)-!=$!$6%0-1$.!*'!*!<$($&*0!)&*('%-&)*)/-(:d$(&/!G$9)',#!.$!0*!I$9&)#$!$')*=0/'#$.!)#$!G$9)',#!.$!0*!

I$9&)#$!X&/C$!-2!L88!888!2&*(,'!a>?e!78!888A!/(!L_8L!.-00*&b!

6/(9)$':!"#$!$()/&$!,/)1!-2!X*&/'!+*),#$.!*'!?*()-'5G96-()!%$&2-&6$.!#/'!*4/*)/-(!6/0$')-($!/(!J,)-=$&!L_8LA!%/0-)/(<!#/'!*/&'#/%!(96=$&!c!aB/<:!Mb:

I*))-'A!H:?:

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AD!

Page 118: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

B/<9&$!M: 3!6/0$')-($!2-&!*$&-(*9)/,*0!$(</($$&/(<K!G96-()i'!*/&'#/%'!

<*'!0$*;*<$!*2)$&!)9&(/(<!)#$!@/22$0!"-+$&:!"#/'!%/,)9&$!/'!$&&-($-9'01!6/'/()$&%&$)$.!=1!6*(1!#/')-&/*('!Y!)#$1!&$2$&!)#*)!)#$!*/&'#/%!/(!)#$!%/,)9&$!/'!)#$!(96=$&!c:!E/<#)!Y!)#$!(96=$&!c!/(!)#$!%*)#!)-!+/(!)#$!G$9)',#!.$!0*!I$9&)#$!X&/C$:

?*()-'5G96-()!$(4/'/-($.!*!29)9&$!/(!+#/,#!*/&!)&*('%-&5

G96-()i'!0*&<$')!.$'/<(A!+*'!,-(,$/4$.!+/)#!%*''$(<$&!)&*('5

L8!+*'!9('9,,$''290A!G96-()i'!.&$*6!,*6$!)&9$!*'!$*&01!*'!

2*6-9'!2-&!9'/(<!*/&'#/%'!)-!,*&&1!%*''$(<$&'!-4$&'$*':

,0-)#5,-4$&$.! ./&/</=0$A!+#/,#!+*'! )#$! %&-)-)1%$! -2!6*(1!'9='$f9$()!6-.$0'A!#*.!L!*096/(96!')&9,)9&$A!Lg!#1.&-<$(!,-()*/($&'!2-&!0/2)/(<!<*'!')-&*<$A!*(.!7!LM5#%!G*/60$&!/()$&(*0!,-6=9')/-(!$(</($'A!$*,#!)9&(/(<!)+-!%&-%$00$&':!32)$&!)+-!

*(.!6-&$!%-+$&290!$(</($'k!6-&$!*,,9&*)$!,-66*(.'k!*(.!

-($!-2!)#$!$(</($'!6*029(,)/-($.!*(.!)#$!*/&'#/%!%&-,$$.$.!)-!*(!$6$&<$(,1!0*(./(<:!32)$&+*&.'A!*!)#9(.$&')-&6!,*9<#)!

+*'!*0'-!.$')&-1$.!=1!*!)#9(.$&')-&6!/(!L_8NA!)#$!]$&6*('!

6354/.K&7I/54+I**4.+#)/I3.+D;-./5

=$,*6$!+-&0.+/.$!2*6-9':!d$!+*'!,*&)--($.A!=/-<&*%#/$'!*=-9)! #/6!+$&$!+&/))$(A! %-'),*&.'! 2$*)9&$.! #/6A! '9/)'! *(.!'#-$'!+$&$!'-0.!&$6$6=$&/(<!#/'!+*1!-2!.&$''/(<A!*(.!$4$(!W*&(/4*0!,-')96$'!/(!H&*C/0!/6/)*)$.!#/'!*/&'#/%'!aU-&<$A!L_ggb:!?*()-'5G96-()!$,,$()&/,/)/$'!*(.!*.4$()9&-9'!0/2$!#*4$!*0'-!/('%/&$.!0-)'!*(.!0-)'!-2!*.4$()9&$&'!*(.!+&/)$&':!E/<#)!*2)$&!#/'!)&/%!)-!)#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'!/(!L_87!*(.!#/'!&$)9&(!)-!X*&/'A!<&$*)!(96=$&!-2! )-1'!*(.!%9=0/,*)/-('!*%%$*&$.:!X&-=*=01A!"-6!?+/2)!+*'! )#$!6-')!$`%&$''/4$!,#*&*,)$&!$4$&!,&$*)$.!=*'$.!-(!?*()-'5G96-()!&$*0!0/2$!aX*<*(-A!78L7b:!I-')!-2!)#$!/(4$()/-('!/(!)#$!"-6!?+/2)!'$&/$'!*&$!$(#*(,$6$()'!-2!)#$!&$*0! /(4$()-&i'!,&$*)/-(A! )#$!,-6=/($.!*/&%0*($5*/&'#/%!+*'!%$&2$,)01!/('%/&$.!/(!?*()-'5G96-()!(96=$&!LP!aB/<:!cb:

B/<9&$!c: B/,)/-(*0!,#*&*,)$&'!+$&$!/('%/&$.!/(!?*()-'5G96-():

?*()-'5G96-()! &$,$/4$.! *! <&$$)/(<! ,*&.! 2&-6!"#-6*'!@./'-(!+/)#!,-(<&*)90*)/-('!2-&!#/'!*,#/$4$6$()'!+/)#!*/&'#/%'!aX*<*(-A!78L7b:!"#$!*4/*)/-(!%/-($$&!+*'!)-9,#$.!=1!@./'-(i'!,*&.A!)#$&$2-&$!=-)#!/(4$()-&'!6$)!.9&/(<!G96-()i'!)&/%!)-!)#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'A!/(!L_87:J($!-2!)#$!%9&%-'$'!-2!)#$/&!,-(4$&'*)/-(!+*'!)#$!*$&-(*9)/5

"/6$'A!L_87b:!"#/'!$(,-9()$&!+*'!%9=0/'#$.!=1!'-6$!($+'%*%$&!*)!)#*)!)/6$!aX*<*(-A!78L7b:!@66*(9$0!3/6VA!$`5'$,&$)*&1!-2!)#$!3V&-5W09=!.$!B&*(,$A!)--;!%*&)!/(!)#$!6$$)/(<:D(! )#$! =$</((/(<! -2! )#$!6$$)/(<A! @./'-(! .$,0*&$.! )#*)!

6*(;/(.! -9<#)! )-! =$! *'#*6$.! -2! )#$6'$04$'! =$,*9'$! )#$!%&-=0$6! -2! *$&/*0! (*4/<*)/-(! =1! #96*(! =$/(<'! #*.! (-)!=$$(!'-04$.:!d$!*0'-!6*.$!,0$*&!)#*)!+#/0$!?*()-'5G96-()!%$&2-&6$.!*!<&$*)!F-=!/(!')$$&/(<!*/&'#/%'!)#&-9<#!)#$!*/&A! /)!+-90.!)*;$!*!0-(<!)/6$!=$2-&$!34/*)/-(!+*'!.9$!)-!=$,-6$!,-66$&,/*001!%-''/=0$:!"#$!&$*'-('!+$&$!.9$!)-!)#$!2*,)!)#*)!(-!/(4$()-&!+*'!*=0$!)-!'$,9&$!*(1!&$+*&.!2-&!#/'!0*=-&!9(.$&!)#$!%*)$()! 0*+'!*)! )#*)! )/6$:!d$!,*00$.!2-&!*!'-&)!-2!%&-)$,5)/4$!/(')/)9)$!-2!/(4$()/-(A!+#/,#!'#-90.!#*4$!&$+*&.$.!)#$!

J%$(!?-9&,$!X#/0-'-%#1!*(.!)#$!G*+(!-2!34/*)/-(

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! ADA

Page 119: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

'9,,$''290!/(4$()-&!-2!)#$!,-66$&,/*0!*/&'#/%!aX*<*(-A!78L7b:! "#$!($`)!,-()$()'!-2!)#$!)*0;!=$)+$$(!?*()-'5G96-()!*(.!"#-6*'!@./'-(!+$&$!$`)&*,)$.!2&-6!*!($+'%*%$&!&$%-&)!*4*/05*=0$!*)!X*<*(-i'!=0-<!aX*<*(-A!78L7b:! @./'-(!+*'!69,#!/()$&$')$.!/(!)#$!1-9(<!6*(!+#-!#*.!+-(.$&$.! X*&/'! *(.! )#$!+-&0.! =1! ')$$&/(<! *(! */&'#/%! -4$&!

#*4$! ($4$&! +-&;$.! -(! )#$! %&-=0$6! -2! *$&/*0! (*4/<*)/-(Ah!

1$*&'!*<-!6-&$!)#*(!D!#*4$!.-($!(-+:h!"#$!*$&-(*9)!+*'!(-)!)&1/(<!)-!=$!,-6%0/6$()*&1k!#$!#*.!)#$!=/<<$')!*.6/&*)/-(!2-&!"#-6*'!@./'-(!*(.!#/'!/(4$()/4$!<$(/9':!3)!)#/'!%-/()A!@./'-(!

$`%0-./(<!<9(%-+.$&:!d$!$`%$&/$(,$.!*!0-)!/(!0/2)/(<!+$/<#)'!+/)#!/)A!=9)!+-&;$.!+/)#!*!'6*00!6-.$0!*(.!./.!(-)!*))$6%)!)-!

)#$!@(<0/'#!E$4-09)/-(:! "#$!)*0;!,-()/(9$.!*(.!@./'-(!*..&$''$.!)#*)!)#$!*/&,&*2)!+-90.!=$,-6$! $4$(! 0/<#)$&! )#*(! )#-'$! *0&$*.1!.$4$0-%$.!=1!G96-():!I&:!@./'-(!=$0/$4$.!)#*)!)#$!%&-=0$6!-2!*$&/*0!

*(.!(-)!=1!)#$!*/&'#/%:!J(01!+/)#!)#$!6*,#/($!,*(!*/&!(*4/5

&$2$&&$.!)-!*!,-()&/4*(,$!#$*4/$&!)#*(!)#$!*/&A!/)!/'!/()$(.$.!

.9$!)-!)#$!#/<#$&!'%$$.!*)!+#/,#!/)!6-4$':!D(!@./'-(i'!6/(.A!

%-+$&A!%&-%$&01!*%%0/$.A!)-!-4$&,-6$!)#$!0*,;!-2!=9-1*(,1!

6-)/-(!/(!-&.$&!)-!#-0.!/)!/(!%-'/)/-(!*)!*!,$&)*/(!*0)/)9.$:!d$!

! 3)!*!,$&)*/(!%-/()A!'-6$-($!*';$.!I&:!@./'-(!+#$)#$&!#/'!($+!')-&*<$!=*))$&1!+-90.!=$!9'$290!/(!'-04/(<!)#$!%&-=0$6!

%-+$&:!"#9'A! )#$!<&$*)$')!2*,)-&!-2! )#/'!%&-=0$6!/'! )-!<$)!*!4$&1!0/<#)!6-)-&A!+#/,#!+/00!=$!%-+$&290!$(-9<#!)-!-%$&*)$!

<*'-0/($!-&!<9(%-+.$&!$(</($'!+$&$!)#$!=$')!'9/)$.!2-&!)#$!

6*,#/($!(-)!*/&'#/%':!32)$&+*&.'A!?*()-'5G96-()!*';$.!I&:!

,*((-)!=$!%&-)$,)$.!2&-6!)#$!%/&*)$'!+#-!0/4$!-22!)#$!+-&;!-2! /(4$()/-('A!*(.!D!.-!(-)!=$0/$4$! /)!+-90.!=$!%-''/=0$! )-!

%*&)!-2!-($!)#*)!+-90.!')*(.!)#$!)$')!-2!)#$!,-9&)':!D2!'-6$-($!

.-C$('!+-90.!*)!-(,$!,-%1!)#$!6-.$0'!*(.! )*;$!*+*1!)#$!2&9/)'!-2! )#$!-&/</(*0! /(4$()-&i'! 0*=-&:!"#$&$! /'!(-)!*! F9.<$!/(! )#$!,-9()&1!+#-!+-90.!#-0.'! )#*)! )#$&$!+*'!&$*001!*(1!/(4$()/-(!/(!'9,#!*(!*%%*&*)9'A!=$,*9'$!'-!69,#!#*'!=$$(!.-($!*(.!+&/))$(!*=-9)! /)! )#*)! )#$!-(01!./22$&$(,$!=$)+$$(!)#$!'9,,$''290!6*,#/($A!+#/,#!#*4$!=$$(A!+/00!=$!4$&1!*0/<#):!D! .-9=)!+#$)#$&! *(1!($+!%&/(,/%0$!+/00! =$!./',-4$&$.!-(!+#/,#!$4$(!*!,0*/6!2-&!*!%*)$()!6*1!=$!6*.$:h! "#$! *4/*)-&! =$0/$4$.! )#*)! )#$&$! +*'! (-! =/<! =*&&/$&! )-!

3,,-&./(<!)-!#/6A! 0/<#)!*(.!,-6%*,)!')&9,)9&$'!*'!+$00!*'!

*4*/0*=0$!/(!*!($*&!29)9&$:!"#$!'9,,$''290!)$')!+/)#!9(6*(($.!

*..&$''$.!=1!#/6!*(.!#$!6*(/2$')$.!*<*/(!#/'!./'&$<*&.!2-&!*/&'#/%'!2-&!'-04/(<!)#$!%&-=0$6!-2!*$&/*0!(*4/<*)/-(:

)#!,$()9&1A!?*()-'5G96-()!

*!,-()&-00$.!2*'#/-(:!@66*(9$0!3/6VA!+#-!+*'!%&$'$()! /(!'9,#!6$$)/(<A!-(,$!.$,0*&$.!aI9'*!&$!')A*00!*/&'#/%!.$'/<('A!-%$(01!-&!'$,&$)01!')9./$.!/(!)#$!0*')!2$+!1$*&'A!)#$!-($!=1!?*()-'5G96-()!/'!)#$!-(01!-($!,*%*=0$!-2!

*&$!(-!*/&'#/%'!/(!)#$!+-&0.A!)#$&$!/'!-(01!-($!*(.!1-9!#*4$!)-!,-6$!)-!X*&/'!/(!-&.$&!)-!'$$!/):h

"/+)322-5*..+<-4)+.4*3I

! ?/(,$!*! 0-(<! )/6$A!$`%$&/6$()*0!.$4$0-%6$()! /(!B09/.!I$,#*(/,'! +*'! %$&2-&6$.! '/.$5=15'/.$! +/)#! )#$-&$)/,*0!+-&;! ,*&&/$.! -9)! =1! ',/$()/')'! *(.! &$'$*&,#$&':! D(! LgQNA!

@90$&A! %9=0/'#$.! '-6$! *&)/,0$'! /(! LgM8! +/)#! #/'! 2*6-9'!

'%$$.!*(.!%&$''9&$:

I*))-'A!H:?:

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AD"

Page 120: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

'-04$!@90$&i'!$f9*)/-(':!D)!/'!')/00!9'$.!/(!I-.$&(!3$&-.1(*65/,'!*(.!X#1'/,':!d$!*0'-!'9,,$''29001!,*0,90*)$.!)#$!'%$$.!-2!'-9(.:!D(!*../)/-(!)-!)#$'$!)#$-&$)/,*0!*.4*(,$6$()'A!$`%$&/56$()'!/(!3$&-.1(*6/,'!+$&$!*0'-!%&-.9,/(<!6-&$!%&*,)/,*0!&$'90)':!D(!LgQ7A!)#$!B&$(,#!,#$6/')!d$(&/!X/)-)!/(4$()$.!)#$!%/)-)!)9=$A!*!.$4/,$!)#*)!$(*=0$'!)#$!'%$$.!,*0,90*)/-(!*)!*!%-/()!

$`%$&/6$()'!/(!LgPc!9'/(<!*!+#/&0/(<!*&6!.$4/,$!*(.!*!%$(.95096!)-!6$*'9&$!.&*<!*)!0-+!*(.!#/<#!'%$$.':! D(! LgM_A! @(<0/'#! $(</($$&! U-#(! ?6$*)-(! *0'-! 9'$.! *!+#/&0/(<!*&6!.$4/,$!)-!6$*'9&$!)#$!.&*<!$`$&)$.!-(!*!'9&2*,$!=1!6-4/(<!*/&:!d$!%&-%-'$.!)#$!$f9*)/-(!G!m!;?^7A!+#$&$!G!/'!)#$!.&*<A!?!/'!)#$!'9&2*,$!*&$*A!^!/'!)#$!*/&!'%$$.A!*(.!;!/'!*!,-(')*()A!+#/,#!?6$*)-(!,0*/6$.!+*'!($,$''*&1!2-&!/):!"#/'!

4*09$!-2!)#/'!,-(')*()!+*'!.$=*)$.!2-&!1$*&':!"#-'$!6*;/(<!

%9=0/'#$.!)#$!&$'90)'!-2!#/'!-+(!+#/&0/(<!*&6!$`%$&/6$()'!

3$&-.1(*6/,!)#$-&/$'A!=$/(<!*=0$!)-!'#-+!)#$!$22$,)!)#*)!)#$!6-4$6$()!-2! -($!-=F$,)! #*.!-(! *(-)#$&!($*&=1!-($:!"#$!

)#$!=$</((/(<!-2! )#$!L_)#!,$()9&1:!d-+$4$&A! )#/'!'1')$6!-2!$f9*)/-('!+*'!'-04$.!-(01!#*02+*1!)#&-9<#!)#$!78)#!,$()9&1:!"#$&$2-&$A!34/*)/-(!%/-($$&'! 0*&<$01!9'$.!$`%$&/6$()*)/-(!*(.!$6%0-1$.!0$''!,-6%0$`!)#$-&$)/,*0!6-.$0'! /(!-&.$&! )-!*,#/$4$!)#$/&!<-*0':!3'!-2!)#$!6/..0$!-2!L_)#!,$()9&1A!)+-!($+!

0/<#)$&5)#*(5*/&!*/&'#/%!+/)#!$(</($'!*(.!./&$,)/-(*0!,-()&-0A!

*/&%0*($!=$<*(!)-!)*;$!-(!*!2*6/0/*&!'#*%$:! D(!Lg__A!7c51$*&5-0.!]$-&<$!W*10$1!';$),#$.!+#*)!/)!/'!

*(!*/&%0*($K!*!,*6=$&$.!+/(<!#*4/(<!./#$.&*0k!*(!*2)!4$&)/,*0!)*/0k!*(.!*(!*2)!#-&/C-()*0!)*/0:!W*10$1i'!,#-/,$!2-&!)#$!*/&2-/0!+*'!=*'$.!-(! )#$/&!3$&-.1(*6/,!,#*&*,)$&/')/,'! )$')$.!=1!#/6!*(.!#/'!%&$.$,$''-&'!9'/(<!*!+#/&0/(<!*&6!*%%*&*)9':!d$!#/6'$02! /(4$()$.!./#$.&*0! *'! *!6$*('! 2-&!6*/()*/(/(<!$f9/0/=&/96! /(! &-00:!"#$! 4$&)/,*0! )*/0! %&-4/.$.! ./&$,)/-(*0!')*=/0/)1A!0/;$!)#$!2$*)#$&'!-(!*(!*&&-+A!*(.!/(!W*10$1i'!4/$+A!+-90.!*0'-!=$!9'$.!2-&!')$$&/(<A!*'!*!=-*)i'!&9..$&!'$&4$':!H1!*(*0-<1A!)#$!#-&/C-()*0!)*/0!<*4$!')*=/0/)1!/(!%/),#:!D)!)9&($.!-9)! )#*)!W*10$1!+*'!#*02! &/<#)!-(!=-)#!,-9()':!d$!./.!(-)!

6-)/-('!-2!*(!*/&,&*2)!+$&$!%&-.9,$.!*(.A! )#$&$2-&$A! /)!#*'!

#$!#*.!)#/(<'!&/<#)!*)!)#$!0$4$0!#$!+-&;$.:!30&$*.1!+/)#!#/'!

)#-&-9<#01!/(!*!'$&/$'!-2!%*%$&'K!)#$!6$*('!-2!%&-.9,/(<!0/2)!)-! ,-6%$('*)$!+$/<#)!69')! =$! ./')/(,)! 2&-6! )#$! -($'! 2-&!<$($&*)/(<! )#&9')k!*! &$4-09)/-(*&1! /.$*!*)! )#*)! )/6$!a]&*()!

*(.!W*10$1!+&-)$!=--;'!*(.!*&)/,0$'!*=-9)!0/<#)!)#$-&1A!+#/,#!

*!'9,,$''290!/(.9')&/*0/')!/(!)#$!0*,$6*;/(<!=9'/($''!/(!?-6$&5

+&/)/(<'A!d$('-(!*(.!*(!$(</($$&!+#-!*0'-!+-&;$.!/(!)#$!0*,$56*;/(<!/(.9')&1A!U-#(!?)&/(<2$00-+A!.$'/<($.!*!')$*65.&/4$(!*/&%0*($!,*00$.!*(!*$&/*0!')$*6!,*&&/*<$:!?*69$0!d$('-(A!U-#(!?)&/(<2$00-+A!B&$.$&/,;!I*&&/-))A!*(.!G:@:!W-0-6=/($!/(,-&5%-&*)$.!*'!)#$!3$&/*0!"&*('/)!W-6%*(1!/(!LNPQ!/(!@(<0*(.A!

%*''$(<$&'! 2&-6!%0*,$! )-!%0*,$! )#&-9<#! )#$!*/&Ah!*,,-&./(<!

+#/,#!+*'! ,#&/')$($.!3&/$0! *(.!+*'! *0'-!;(-+(!*'!3$&/*0!?)$*6!W*&&/*<$!a?,#6/))A!L__8b:

5)/-(! +*'! ,-6%&/'$.! -2! *! 0*(./(<! <$*&A! )*/0! '9&2*,$'A! *(.!$(</($'! 6-9()$.! =$#/(.! )#$! +/(<k! %*''$(<$&'! +-90.! =$!)&*('%-&)$.! /(!*(!$(,0-'$.! 29'$0*<$:!"+-!,-9()$&5&-)*)/(<!'/`5=0*.$.!%&-%$00$&'!+-90.!.&/4$!)#$!*/&%0*($:!d-+$4$&A!)#$!

*! F-9&(*0/')!+#-'$! 4*09$!+*'! )#*)! #$! ;($+! *!I$6=$&! -2!X*&0/*6$()k!*(.!I&:!E-$=9,;A!+#-!+*'!$`%$,)$.!)-!%&-6-)$!*!=/00!/(!X*&0/*6$()!2-&!*!'#*&$#-0.$&'!,-6%*(1!)-!-%$&*)$!*(!3$&/*0!?)$*6!W*&&/*<$:!d$('-(!*(.!?)&/(<2$00-+!$(<*<$.!/(!6-.$0! )$')/(<!/(!-&.$&! )-!6*;$!)#$/&!*/&%0*($!=$,-6$!)&9$:!D(!LNPQA! )#$1!-=)*/($.! )#$!#$0%!-2!U-$!W#*%6*(A!*!6*)#5$6*)/,/*(A!+#-!*0'-!#*.!*!+#/&0/(<!*&6!.$4/,$:!W#*%6*(!6*.$!6-&$! )#*(!7A888!&$,-&.$.!*$&-.1(*6/,!$`%$&/6$()'!

J%$(!?-9&,$!X#/0-'-%#1!*(.!)#$!G*+(!-2!34/*)/-(

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AD$

Page 121: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

-(!)#$!+#/&0/(<!*&6!2-&!d$('-(!*(.!?)&/(<2$00-+:!"#/'! 0$.!)-!*(!*/&%0*($!+/)#!*!'%*(!+/(<!-2!c!6!*(.!*(!*&$*!-2!M:NP!67A!%-+$&$.!=1!*!'6*00!')$*6!$(</($!.$'/<($.!%&/6*&/01!=1!d$('-(!=9)! /6%&-4$.!=1!?)&/(<2$00-+:!?-6$!9('9,,$''290!

(-)!*=0$! )-!<$)!*/&=-&($!*2)$&!=$/(<!0*9(,#$.!=1!*!,*)*%90)!

,-(')&9,)/-(!-2! 0/<#)+$/<#)!')&9,)9&$'!+$&$! )#$!&$*'-('!2-&!)#$!3$&/*0!?)$*6!W*&&/*<$!2*/09&$:! G9$! )-! )#$! 2*/09&$! -2! #/'! %&-%-'$.! $()$&%&/'$A! /(! LNPNA!

#$!'%$()!)#$!0*')!P8!1$*&'!-2!#/'!0/2$:!d$('-(!#*.!*%%*&$()01!,$*'$.!#/'!*$&/*0!&$'$*&,#!2-&!<--.A!*(.!($4$&!*<*/(!)--;!9%!)#$!6*))$&:!?)&/(<2$00-+!')*1$.!-(!*(.!/(!LNPN!)&/$.!-(,$!6-&$!)-!

./'*%%-/()/(<A!(-)#/(<!6-&$!)#*(!*!'#-&)A!9(,-()&-00$.!#-%:!3)!)#/'!%-/()A!?)&/(<2$00-+!*0'-!<*4$!9%A!*(.!)#$!$()/&$!$%/'-.$!+*'!2-&<-))$(:!d-+$4$&A!)#$!3&/$0!#*.!'-6$!%-'/)/4$!$22$,)'K!

,-6$!9%!+/)#!)#$!690)/%0$5+/(<!.$'/<(A!*!2$*)9&$!-2!($*&01!*00! )#$! $*&01! '9,,$''290! */&,&*2):!"#$!%0*($! /)'$02!+*'! 0-</5

,*6=$&$.!*/&2-/0':!"#$!6*)$&/*0'!+$&$!)-!=$!'%*&'!-2!=*6=--!*(.!#-00-+!+--.A!+/)#!./*<-(*0!+/&$!=&*,/(<:

9('9,,$''290!'/(,$!'9,#!$(</($'!%&$'$()$.!#/<#5+$/<#)5)-5%-+$&!&*)/-!*)!)#*)!)/6$:!J(01!*2)$&!)#$!/()$&(*0!,-6=9')/-(!

=$,*6$!%-''/=0$:

8744-5B+35+3-,2935*+3-,J/,5*

! D(! B&*(,$A! *(!34/*)/-(! ,-669(/)1!+*'! $')*=0/'#$.! /(!)#$!)9&(!-2!L_)#!)-!78)#!,$()9&1:!I-')!-2!%$-%0$!+$&$!2&/$(.'A!

-̂/'/(A!*(.!?*()-'5G96-():!"#$!0*))$&!+*'!(-)!*!)#$-&$)/,/*(!-&!*! ',/$()/')A!=9)!#$!'9%$&=01! /()$<&*)$.! )#$! )$,#(-0-</$'!*)! #/'! ./'%-'*0! *)! )#*)! )/6$A! /(! -)#$&!+-&.'! *! )$,#(-0-<1!/()$<&*)-&:! D(!*../)/-(A!#$! /6%&-4$.!$`/')/(<!)$,#(-0-<1!/(!6*(1!*'%$,)'A!2-&!$`*6%0$A!09=&/,*)/-(!-2!-%%-'$.5,10/(.$&'!$(</($':! d$! *0'-! /(4$()$.! .$4/,$'! *(.! 6$,#*(/'6'! )-!/6%&-4$!*/&'#/%!')*=/0/)1!*(.!6*($94$&*=/0/)1:! ?*()-'5G96-()!#*.!=$$(!)#/(;/(<!*=-9)!*!#$*4/$&5)#*(5*/&!

*/&,&*2)!2-&!*!0-(<!)/6$!a?*()-'5G96-()A!L_8Pb:!d$!/(/)/*001!

H*&&-'A!788Qb:!3!,-9()$&5&-)*)/(<!.9*0!&-)-&!#$0/,-%)$&!+*'!

%-'$.!=1!*!4$&)/,*0! )*;$-22!,-(,$&(/(<!)#$!&$f9/&$.!#/<#$&!%-+$&5)-5+$/<#)!&*)/-A!)#$&$2-&$!#$!*=*(.-($.!)#$!,-(,$%):!d$!)&/$.!'-6$!./22$&$()!,-(,$%)'!)#*)!'/6%01!./.!(-)!+-&;:! n$*&'!=$2-&$! )#$!+-&;!)-! )#$!,-(')&9,)/-(!-2! )#$!6-(-5%0*($!=$<*(A!G96-()!+*'!,-(4/(,$.!=1!)#$! -̂/'/(!=&-)#$&'!

=-`!;/)$A!0/(;$.!2-9&!-2!#/'!;/)$'!)-<$)#$&A!*..$.!*!'0/(<!'$*)A!

d*&<&*4$!-%$($.!)#$!.--&! )-!-)#$&! /(4$()-&'!*(.!%/-($$&':!"#$!d*&<&*4$5.$'/<($.!=-`!;/)$A!+/)#! /)'! /6%&-4$.!0/2)5)-5.&*<!&*)/-A!+*'! )-!%&-4/.$! )#$! )#$-&$)/,*0!+/(<!6-.$0! )#*)!

*(.!36$&/,*(!*/&%0*($':! D(!L_8MA! )#$! -̂/'/(!=&-)#$&'!&*(!*!<0/.$&!6*(92*,)9&/(<!

)#$/&!<0/.$&!.$'/<('!aB/<:!gb:!G9&/(<!'-6$!)&/*0'!-(!)#$!?$/($!E/4$&A! ?*()-'5G96-()! %$&,$/4$.! )#*)! )#$!3()-/($))$! =-*)!$(</($A!+#/,#!+*'!$6%0-1$.! )-!=&/(<! )#$!<0/.$&!*/&=-&($A!

+*1A!)#$!LP5=/'!+*'!,-(,$/4$.:!3<*/(A!+$!)$')/21!)#*)!)#$&$!+*'!*(!$`,#*(<$!-2! /(2-&6*)/-(A! /.$*'A! *(.!$4$(!.$'/<('!*6-(<!)#$!6$6=$&'!-2!)#$!*4/*)/-(!,-669(/)1!/(!B&*(,$:! ?*()-'5G96-()! %&-%$&01! ./.! (-)! 2-00-+! $()/&$01! )#$!d*&<&*4$5=-`!;/)$!,-(,$%):!d$!)&*('2-&6$.!*!%*/&!-2!+/(<'!

)#$!-9)';/&)'!-2!X*&/'!*(.!+*'!$`#*9')/4$01!)$')$.!aB/<:!Nb:!3)!

$4*09*)/(<!)#$!')*=/0/)1!-2! )#$!*/&%0*($!*(.A!2-&! )#/'!&$*'-(A!/)!+*'!,*00$.!LP=/'!a@(,-&$b:!"#9'A!G96-()!*0'-!/(4$()$.!)#$!

+#-!*))$(.$.!2-&!)#$!-,,*'/-(:! ?-6$!6-()#'!$*&0/$&A!-(!39<9')!7LA!L_8cA!?*()-'5G96-()!

LP=/'!*/&%0*($!+*'!9(.$&%-+$&$.!*)!)#/'!)/6$:!d/'!($`)!6-4$A!/)!

I*))-'A!H:?:

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!ADD

Page 122: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

*,,-9()'b!*=-4$!)#$!<&-9(.A!+#/,#!$(.$.!+/)#!*!4/-0$()!0*(.5/(<A!.*6*</(<!)#$!%&-%$00$&!*(.!0*(./(<!<$*&:!J(!7Q!J,)-=$&!L_8cA!LP=/'

! ?*()-'5G96-()!+-(!)#$!QA888!B&*(,'!X&/C$!3&,#.$*,-(A!/(')/)9)$.!/(!U901!L_8c!=1!)#$!36$&/,*(!@&($')!3&,#.$*,-(A!

=/'

=1!)#$!*../)/-(!-2!0*&<$!-,)*<-(*0!*/0$&-('!)-!%&-4/.$!'-6$!&-00!,-()&-0:!30)#-9<#!*/0$&-('!#*.!=$$(!9'$.! /(!'*/0%0*($'!=$2-&$A!G96-()!%/-($$&$.!)#$!*%%0/,*)/-(!2-&!*/&%0*($':!?/(,$!#$!*0&$*.1!#*.!#/'!#*(.'!=9'1!+/)#!)#$!&9..$&!*(.!$0$4*)-&!,-()&-0'!a*(.!,-90.!(-)!9'$!%$..0$'!*'!#$!+*'!')*(./(<bA!#$!-%$&*)$.!)#$!,-66*(.'!4/*!*!#*&($''!*))*,#$.!)-!#/'!,#$'):!D2! #$!+*()$.! )-! &-00! &/<#)A! #$!+-90.! 0$*(! )-! #/'! &/<#)A! *(.!

J%$(!?-9&,$!X#/0-'-%#1!*(.!)#$!G*+(!-2!34/*)/-(

!

!

!

!

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! ADE

Page 123: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

+/((/(<!)#$!%&/C$:!"#$/&!6*,#/($!%&$'$()$.!*(!$00/%)/,*0!+/(<!*(.!*!%*/&!-2!)&*%$C-/.*0!-($':!32)$&!'-6$!)*;$-22!*))$6%)'A!

)*;$-22!&9(!=9)!.*6*<$.!)#$!0*(./(<!<$*&:!32)$&!&$%*/&/(<!)#$!LP=/'

c!6A!*))*/($.!*2)$&!)*;/(<!-22!*<*/(')!)#$!+/(.!aB/<:!_b:

! ?*()-'5G96-()! #*.! '#-+(! )#$! +-&0.! )#*)! )#$! .&$*6!

6*(1!*4/*)/-(!$()#9'/*')'!*(.!$`%$&/6$()$&'! )&/$.! )-!=9/0.!-(!#/'!*,#/$4$6$():!B$+!-2!)#$6A!#-+$4$&A!6$)!+/)#!69,#!

*(.!E-6*(/*(!"&*F*(!^9/*:!I$*(+#/0$A!X*90!W-&(9!*(.!)#$!H&$<9$)! =&-)#$&'! $`%$&/6$()$.!+/)#! #$0/,-%)$&! .$'/<(':! D(!

+/)#!2-9&!'$)'!-2!+/(<'A!?*69$0!W-.1!=$<*(!)#$!,-(')&9,)/-(!-2!*!=/%0*($!2-&!)#$!3&61A!*(.!U-#(!G9(($!+*'!,-66/''/-($.!=1!)#$!]-4$&(6$()!)-!.$'/<(!*(!*/&%0*($!/(!'$,&$,1:!"#$!6-')!'9,,$''290! */&,&*2)! -2! L_8g!+*'! -($!6*.$! =1! )#$! =&-)#$&'!W#*&0$'!*(.!]*=&/$0! -̂/'/(A!(-+!&9((/(<!*!%0*()!2-&!*/&%0*($!

=&-)#$&'!*(.!)#$/&!$(</($$&!*(.!+-&;'!6*(*<$&!I:!W-00/$`!6*;$!(-!'$,&$)!-2!)#$!2*,)!)#*)!)#$1!#*4$!=*'$.!)#$/&!+-&;!-(!

2*,)!)#$1!'*1!)#*)!)#$1!($4$&!6/''!*(!-%%-&)9(/)1!-2!9)/0/C/(<!*(!/(2-&6*)/-(!-&!.*)*!-(!+#/,#!)#*)!,*(!0*1!#*(.':h! 3!=/%0*($!$0$4*)-&!*)!)#$!2&-()!+*'!=*'$.!-(!)#$!d*&<&*4$!=-`;/)$!,-(')&9,)/-(A!*(.!/)!,*&&/$.!*!#9<$!'f9*&$!)*/0!*''$65=01!*)!)#$!&$*&:!X-+$&!+*'!%&-4/.$.!=1!)#$!M85#%!3()-/($))$!$(</($:!D)!+*'!*!,&9.$!*(.!#$*41!6*,#/($!+/)#!(-!,-()&-0!/(!&-00!*)!*00A!=9)!/)!+*'!,*%*=0$!-2!')*1/(<!/(!)#$!*/&!2-&!'$4$&*0!'$,-(.'!*)!*!)/6$A!*(.!-(!)#/'!=*'/'!)#$!=&-)#$&'!'$)!9%!*!+-&;5'#-%!)-!/)'!6*(92*,)9&$:!D(!)#$!'966$&!-2!L_8gA!)#$/&!)#/&.!%&-.9,)/-(!6*,#/($!+*'!-&.$&$.!=1!d$(&1!B*&6*(:! d$(&1! B*&6*(!+*'! =-&(! /(! LNgQ:! d$(&1! )&*/($.! *'! *!%*/()$&!*)! )#$!o,-0$!.$'!H$*9`!3&)$'A!=9)!f9/,;01!=$,-6$!-='$''$.! +/)#! )#$! ($+! 6$,#*(/,*0! /(4$()/-('! )#*)! +$&$!&*%/.01!*%%$*&/(<!*)! )#$!$(.!-2! )#$!L_)#!,$()9&1:!?/(,$! )#$!B*&6*('!+$&$!+$005-22A!#$!+*'!*=0$!)-!%9&'9$!)#/'!/()$&$')!*'!

)#$!2$$0/(<!-2!*!%/$,$!-2!6*,#/($&1A!*(.!$(F-1$.!,-('/.$&*=0$!'9,,$'':! D(! )#$!LN_8'A!#$!=$,*6$!*!,#*6%/-('#/%!,1,0/')A!*(.!*)! )#$! )9&(!-2! )#$!,$()9&1!#$!./',-4$&$.!6-)-&!&*,/(<:!

6$,#*(/,A!#$!,-4$&$.!)#$!cLM!6/0$'!a__8!;6b!)-!)#$!39')&/*(!,*%/)*0!/(!F9')!Lc!#-9&'!*0-(<!9(6*.$!&-*.':!B*&6*(!#/6'$02!=$,*6$!*!,*'9*0)1!-2! )#$!'%-&)!+#$(!#$!+*'! /(4-04$.!/(!*!'$&/-9'! *,,/.$():! d$! 29001! &$,-4$&$.A! =9)! )#$! $`%$&/$(,$!

5)/-(!+/)#!6*,#/($&1!$(.9&$.:!d$!+*'!*+*&$!-2! )#$! -̂/'/(!

)#$! -̂/'/('!=$<*(!)-!%&-.9,$!*!%-+$&$.!*/&%0*($!2-&!'*0$!/(!

2$$0!2-&!6*,#/($'A!+*'!'--(!*=0$!)-!')*1!/(!)#$!*/&!0-(<$&!)#*(!

)9&('!-9)!-2! )#$! -̂/'/(A!.$'%/)$! /)!=$/(<!=9/0)!+/)#-9)!*(1!&-00!,-()&-0:!"#/'!6$*()! )#*)!*00! )9&('!+$&$!*!.$0/,*)$!';/.!&-9(.!-(! &9..$&!*0-($:! D2! )#$!-9)'/.$!+/(<!%/,;$.!9%! )--!69,#!*/&'%$$.A!/)!+-90.!&/'$A!*(.!/2!)#$!)9&(!+*'!%$&'/')$.!/(A!)#$!%0*($!+-90.!=$!/(!.*(<$&!-2!'/.$5'0/%%/(<!/()-!)#$!<&-9(.!

5)/-('!-2!#/'!-+(!)-!)#$! -̂/'/(!.9&/(<!)#$!*9)96(A!/(,09./(<!*!&$.9,)/-(!/(!)#$!'/C$!-2!)#$!)*/0!'9&2*,$'A!&$6-4/(<!-($!-2!)#$!2-&+*&.!$0$4*)-&'A!*(.!&/<</(<!*!'0/<#)!./#$.&*0!*(<0$!/()-!)#$!+/(<':!"#9'A!)#$! -̂/'/(5B*&6*(!D!=$,*6$!)#$! -̂/'/(5B*&6*(!D5=/':!D)!+*'!,0$*&!)-!6$6=$&'!-2!)#$!3V&-5W09=!)#*)!B*&6*(!+-90.!'--(!*))$6%)!)-!+/(!)#$!0*')!*(.!0*&<$')!3&,#.$*,-(!%&/C$A!)#$!'-5,*00$.!]&*(.!X&/`!-2!34/*)/-(:!"#/'!,-6%&/'$.!*!%9&'$!-2!M8A888!2&*(,'!a-2!+#/,#!#*02!#*.!=$$(!,-()&/=9)$.!

,/&,0$!6*.$! .9&/(<! )#$! 0*')! 2$+! .*1'! -2! L_8gA! /(!+#/,#!B*&6*(!6*(*<$.!)-!,-4$&!)#/'!./')*(,$A!)#-9<#!(-)!+/)#-9)!)#$!+#$$0'!-2!#/'!6*,#/($! 0/<#)01! )-9,#/(<! )#$!<&-9(.!*)!

<&-9(.!$`,$%)!*)! )#$! )*;$5-22!*(.! 0*(./(<:!"+-!.*1'! 0*)$&!

W09=!.$!B&*(,$A!#$! &$%$*)$.! )#/'!%$&2-&6*(,$! 2-&!*! )#/&.!)/6$A! *(.!+-(! )#$!G$9)',#53&,#.$*,-(! %&/C$! -2! M8A888!

6*,#/($!-2!-($!;/0-6$)$&!/(!*!,0-'$.!,/&,9/):!"#$!+$*)#$&!+*'! %$&2$,)A! )#$&$! =$/(<! %&*,)/,*001! (-!+/(.! *(.! )#$! */&!

I*))-'A!H:?:

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!ADF

Page 124: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

X*&/'A!*)!L8KL7!3I:!3)! )#*)! )/6$A! )#$!*/&%0*($!+*'!')*&)$.!*(.!&*(!*0-(<!)#$!<&-9(.!2-&!_8!-&!L78 6!*(.!*))*/($.!/)'!9'9*0!'%$$.!-2!*=-9)!Q8!6/0$'!*(!#-9&A!*(.!f9/,;01!*',$(.$.!/()-!)#$!*/&! )-!*!#$/<#)!-2!Q:c!-&!P:M!6:!D)!%*''$.!=$)+$$(!

*=-9)!#*02!+*1!)-!)#/'!%-')A!B*&6*(!-%$&*)$.!#/'!#-&/C-()*0!&9..$&A!*(.!,*9'$.!)#$!6*,#/($!)-!&/'$!)-!*!#$/<#)!-2!*=-9)!g:M!6:!"#$!*/&%0*($!'+$%)!*&-9(.!)#$!#*02+*1!%-')!*06-')!-(!*(!$4$(!;$$0A!*(.! )#$(! )--;!*!')&*/<#)!,-9&'$!=*,;! )-!)#$!<-*0A!+#/,#!/)!%*''$.!)#&-9<#!*)!*=-9)!)#$!'*6$!#$/<#)!*'!=$2-&$A!.$',$(./(<!Q8 6!-&!'-!=$1-(.!/(!%&*,)/,*001!)#$!

+*'!L!6/(9)$!*(.!7N!'$,-(.'A!+#/,#!,-&&$'%-(.'!+/)#!*(!*4$&*<$!'%$$.!-2!*=-9)!7M!p!6/0$'!*(!#-9&:

0-*.$.! /)!+/)#!cc!%-9(.'!.$*.!+$/<#)A!=9)!#$! 2-9(.! )#*)!

')&9,;!=1!*! '9..$(!')&-(<!<9')!-2!+/(.A!+#/,#!,*9'$.! /)!)-!+#$$0!*&-9(.!*06-')!*)!&/<#)!*(<0$'A!*(.!*0'-!)-!/(,0/($!/(+*&.! 4$&1! '#*&%01:!32)$&!6*;/(<! )#$! )9&(A! #-+$4$&A! /)!

L:M 6!*=-4$!)#$!<&-9(.:

+#/,#!#*.!)#9'!2*&!=$$(!6*.$:!B*&6*(!$`%&$''$.!#/6'$02!*'!

*'!2*&!*'!/)'!0/2)/(<!%-+$&!/'!,-(,$&($.:!D(!*00!%&-=*=/0/)1!#/'!($`)!')$%!+/00!=$!)-!$f9/%!/)!+/)#!*!6-&$!%-+$&290!*(.!0/<#)$&!

1$*&'!*<-!#*'!/(!)#/'!&$'%$,)!=$$(!.9%0/,*)$.k!#-+$4$&!)#$&$!*&$!6*(1!-)#$&!%-/()'!)-!=$!,-('/.$&$.!+#$(!-($!&$4/$+'!)#$!

)#*)!#/'!6*,#/($! /(! )#*)!,-(./)/-(!+*'! /(,*%*=0$!-2! 0-(<5

f9*()/)1!-2!29$0k!'$,-(.01A!#$!#*'!(-)!.$6-(')&*)$.!/)'!,*%*5

B*&6*(i'! */&%0*($!#*.! *%%&-`/6*)$01! )#$! '*6$!+$/<#)! *'!

)/6$'!)#$!#-&'$5%-+$&A!*(.!-2!*=-9)!-($5f9*&)$&!)#$!+$/<#)!%$&! #-&'$5%-+$&! .$4$0-%$.:! D(! '%/)$! -2! )#$/&! #*(./,*%! /(!)#$!'#*%$!-2!0$''!#-&'$5%-+$&!*(.!*!69,#!+$/<#)/$&!6-)-&A!

*<*/(')!M7 ;6O#!'#-+(!=1!B*&6*(i':!"#$&$2-&$A!)#$!36$&/5,*(!/(4$()-&'A!=1!,-(')&9,)/(<!*!'0/<#)01!0*&<$&!6*,#/($!*(.!

6-)-&A!'#-90.!#*4$!=$$(!&$*./01!*=0$!)-!,*&&1!)+-!6$(!*(.!

D(!I*&,#!L_8NA!B*&6*(!&$,-4$&$.!)#$!6*,#/($!/(!&9==$&5/C$.!2*=&/,!*(.!,#*(<$.!)#$!$(</($!2-&!*!M85#%!E$(*90):!"#$!-̂/'/(5B*&6*(!D5=/'!=$,*6$!)#$!d$(&/!B*&6*(!D5=/':!"#$!($+!$(</($!./.!(-)!0*')!0-(<!*(.!#$!/(')*00$.!=*,;!)#$!3()-/($))$!-($:!d-+$4$&A! B*&6*(i'! ,-(')*()! )/(;$&/(<!+/)#! #/'! %0*($!

3$&-(*9)/,':!G9&/(<!)#$!?966$&A!#$!*..$.!'/.$5,9&)*/('!)-!)#$!+/(<'A!)-!6*;$!)#$6!)&9$!=-`!;/)$'A!*(.!/6%-&)*()01!%9)!/(!*/0$&-('!-2!#/'!-+(!.$'/<(!'-!)#*)! )#$!6*,#/($!,-90.!=$!

@9&-%$!/()-!)#$!*/&:!3%%&-%&/*)$01!$(-9<#!/)!+*'!@&($')!3&,#5.$*,-(A!)#$!6*(!+#-!#*.!=$$(!.-/(<!'-!69,#!)-!$(,-9&*<$!34/*)/-(!/(!B&*(,$!'/(,$!L_8Q:"#$! -(01! -)#$&! %&-6/($()! *4/*)-&! .9&/(<! )#/'! %$&/-.!

')*(.*&.! -̂/'/(!/(!L_8g:!d-+$4$&A!#$!+*'!0$''!)$,#(/,*0015

)-!)#$!=*'/,!.$'/<(!aB/<:!L8b:!]*=&/$0! -̂/'/(!&$6*&;$.!)#*)A!

*! '%-&)/(<! &/4*0&1!'$$6'! )-!#*4$!=$$(!.$4$0-%$.!=$)+$$(!

J%$(!?-9&,$!X#/0-'-%#1!*(.!)#$!G*+(!-2!34/*)/-(

B/<9&$!L8: "#$!G$0*<&*(<$5 -̂/'/(!*/&%0*($:

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AD#

Page 125: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

(.A!G$0*<&*(<$!'$)!*(!$(.9&*(,$!&$,-&.!-2!LN!6/(9)$'A!Q8!'$,-(.'!*)!I/0*(K!B*&6*(!&$)*0/*)$.!+/)#!78!6/(9)$'A!78!'$,-(.'!*)!]#$()A!-(!U901!c)#:!J(!?$%)$6=$&!c)#

=$')$.!)#*)!+/)#!P8!;6!*)!W#*6%!.$!W#*0-('!-(!J,)-=$&!7(.:!

)+-! %0*,$'A! &*)#$&! )#*(! '/6%01!6*;/(<!6$*'9&$.! ,/&,9/)'!-4$&! )#$!'*2$)1!-2!*(!*$&-.&-6$:!J(!L_8N!J,)-=$&!Q8A!#$!

*)!E#$/6'!/(!F9')!9(.$&!78!6/(9)$':

*(-)#$&!2-&!B*&6*(A!=9)!)#$1!'-0.!/)!)-!U:":W!I--&$5H&*=*C-(:!"#/'! /(29&/*)$.!B*&6*(!'-!69,#! )#*)!#$!$')*=0/'#$.!#/'!-+(!

B*&6*(!3/&0/($'A!+#/,#!-%$&*)$.!)#$!0$<$(.*&1!B*&6*(!]-0/*)#!*/&0/($&! /(! )#$!.$,*.$!-2!L_78:! D(!L_L8A! )#$! -̂/'/(!,-6%*(1!($$.$.!*!&$%0*,$6$()!2-&!)#$/&!2*6-9'A!=9)!(-+!-='-0$)$A!=-`!;/)$50/;$!')*(.*&.!,-(')&9,)/-(:!"#$!=-`!;/)$!+*'!6-.$&(/C$.A!

5)-&!+*'!./',*&.$.:!"#/'!6-.$0!)#$(!=$,*6$!)#$!./&$,)!%&-<$(/)-&!

*0'-!$`%$&/$(,$.!($+!)1%$':!J($!-2!)#$'$A!+#/,#!=$,*6$!f9/)$!

+*'!)$')$.!/(!0*)$!L_L8A!*(.!/)!#*.!=$$(!%9)!)-<$)#$&!2&-6!$`/')5/(<!%*&)'A!)#$!29'$0*<$!&$%-&)$.01!,-6/(<!2&-6!*(!-0.!)&/%0*($:!D)!+*'!%-+$&$.!=1!*!M8!#%!E-''$05X$9<$-)!&-)*&1!$(</($:

"#9'A!]*=&/$0! -̂/'/(!)9&($.!#/'!*))$()/-(!)-!)#$!*9)-6-)/4$!+-&0.:!d/'!=&-)#$&!W#*&0$'!./$.! /(!*! ,*&! *,,/.$()! /(!L_L7:!]*=&/$0!#*.!*!<&$*)!.$*0!-2!)$,#(/,*0!*(.!$(</($$&/(<!$`%$&)/'$!

d$!')*&)$.!=1!=91/(<!&/<#)'!)-!W/)&-q(!6-.$0'A!9'/(<!.$'/<('!)#*)!#*.!9(.$&<-($!)$')/(<A!&*)#$&!)#*(!')*&)/(<!2&-6!',&*),#:!d/'!$`%$&)/'$!*,f9/&$.!/(!)#$!34/*)/-(!+-&0.!#$0%$.!)-!.$'/<(!<&-9(.!4$#/,0$'A!+#/,#!*&$!*$&-.1(*6/,!=9)!*0'-!0/<#):!"#$!-(01!.-+(2*00! )-! )#/'! 2-&690*! /'! )#*)! )#$!4$#/,0$'!+$&$!(-)!*0+*1'! 4/'9*001! *%%$*0/(<A! +#/,#! 0$.! )-! %--&! '*0$':!I-')!

'1')$6'!a3H?b:

! D(!L_8gA!?*()-'5G96-()i'!+*'!+-&;/(<!/(!*!&$4-09)/-(5

)#*)! '#*%$.! )#/(<'! )#*)! +-90.! ,-6$:! "#$! '/(<0$5$(</($!

"#$!*4/*)-&!%$&2-&6$.!*! 0*&<$!(96=$&!-2!$`%$&/6$()*)/-(!+/)#!G$6-/'$00$A!+#/,#!&$,$/4$.!'9,,$''/4$!.$'/<(*)/-('!Y!(96=$&'!L_! )-!77:!"#$!G$6-/'$00$!+*'!*!<&-9(.=&$*;/(<!

%&-.9,$.!/(!./22$&$()!,-9()&/$'A!/(,09./(<!]$&6*(1A!B&*(,$A!d-00*(.A!*(.!)#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'!a?,#6/))A!L__8b:!"#/'!*/&,&*2)!+*'!$6%0-1$.!*'!G96-()i'!%$&'-(*0! )&*('%-&)*)/-(!*(.!#$!+/00/(<01! 0$)! -)#$&'!6*;$!9'$!-2!#/'!.$'/<(:!"#$! 29'$0*<$!,-('/')$.!-2!*!'%$,/*001!&$/(2-&,$.!=*6=--!=--6A!*(.!)#$!%/0-)!'*)!=$($*)#!=$)+$$(!)#$!6*/(!+#$$0'!-2!*!)&/,1,0$!0*(.5

*!)*/0!9(/)A!+#/,#!29(,)/-($.!*'!=-)#!$0$4*)-&!*(.!&9..$&!*(.!=1!+/(<!+*&%/(<!a(96=$&!78b:

! D)! %&$'$()$.! *! +/(<'%*(! -2! M:L8! 6! *(.! *(! -4$&*00!0$(<)#!-2!N!6:!D)'!+$/<#)!+*'!0/))0$!6-&$!)#*(!LL8!;<!+/)#!?*()-'5G96-()!*)!)#$!,-()&-0':!"#$!%/0-)!+*'!'$*)$.!=$0-+!)#$! 29'$0*<$5+/(<! F9(,)/-(A! F9')! =$#/(.! )#$!+#$$0'A! *(.!,-66*(.$.! )#$! )*/0! '9&2*,$'!9'/(<!*!')$$&/(<!+#$$0:!"#$!'9')$()*)/-(!,*=0$'!-2!)#$!+/(<!+$&$!6*.$!-2!%/*(-!&-%$':!G$6-/'$00$! 2$*)9&$.!*/&2-/0'!+/)#!,-('/.$&*=0$!,*6=$&!*)!)#$!+/(<!0$*./(<!$.<$:!D(/)/*001A!?*()-'5G96-()!$6%0-1$.!*! 0/f9/.5,--0$.!G9)#$/0!r!W#*06$&'! $(</($!+/)#! 78! #%:!

0-,*)/-(A!%0*,/(<! /)! /(! 2&-()!-2! )#$!%/0-):!d$!*0'-! &$%0*,$.!

I*))-'A!H:?:

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AE%

Page 126: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

)#$!2-&6$&!785#%!$(</($!=1!*!7P5#%!3()-(/$))$!*(.!,*&&/$.!-9)! '-6$!+/(<! &$/(2-&,$6$()':!"#/'!4$&'/-(! &$,$/4$.! )#$!.$'/<(*)/-(!(96=$&!78:! G9$! )-! ')&9,)9&*0! %&-=0$6'! *(.! ,-()/(9/(<! 0*,;! -2!

/()-! )#$!G$6-/'$00$i'! .$'/<(K! *! )&/*(<90*&! *(.! '#-&)$($.!29'$0*<$!6*.$!-2!=*6=--k! )#$!$(</($!+*'!6-4$.!=*,;! )-!/)'! -&/</(*0! %-'/)/-(A! /(! 2&-()! -2! )#$!+/(<k! *(.! /(,&$*'$.!+/(<'%*(:! "#9'A! (96=$&! 7L! +*'! =-&(:! "#$! .$'/<(! -2!(96=$&! 77!+*'! =*'/,*001! '/6/0*&! )-! (96=$&! 7L:! ?*()-'5G96-()!)$')$.!-%%-'$.5,10/(.$&!a#$!%*)$()$.!*!'-09)/-(!2-&!,--0/(<!)#/'!;/(.!-2!$(</($b!*(.!,--0$.5+*)$&!$(</($'A!+/)#!%-+$&!'$))/(<'!&*(</(<!2&-6!78!)-!P8!#%A!/(!=-)#!4*&/*()':!3(!/()$&$')/(<!2$*)9&$!-2!)#$!+*)$&5,--0$.!4*&/*()!+*'!)#$!0/f9/.5,--0*()!%/%$0/($! )#*)! 2-00-+$.! )#$!+/(<! 0-+$&!'/.$!0-2)/(<!)-!/6%&-4$!)#$!*/&,&*2)!*$&-.1(*6/,':! G96-()i'!6-(-%0*($! ,-90.!=$! ,-(')&9,)$.! /(!-(01!LM!.*1':!X-''$''/(<!-9)')*(./(<!%$&2-&6*(,$A!$*'/01!,-4$&/(<!

-2!6-&$!)#*(!L88!;6O#A!)#$!G$6-/'$00$!+*'!)#$!0*')!*/&,&*2)!

)#$!*/&%0*($!/(!X*&/'!*(.!'-6$!'6*00!)&/%'!)-!($*&=1!%0*,$':!B0/<#)'!+$&$!,-()/(9$.!*)!4*&/-9'!)/6$'!)#&-9<#!L_8_A!/(,09.5

?*/()!W1&!)-!H9,!-(!?$%)$6=$&!LQA!&$)9&(/(<!)#$!2-00-+/(<!.*1A!*(.!*(-)#$&!-(! )#$!Lg)#A!-2!LN!;6!/(!Lc!6/(9)$':!"#$!

&*)#$&! %-%90*&:! ?*()-'5G96-()!+*'! '-! $()#9'/*')/,! *=-9)!34/*)/-(! )#*)! #$! &$0$*'$.! )#$! .&*+/(<'! -2!G$6-/'$00$! 2-&!2&$$A!=$0/$4/(<!)#*)!*4/*)/-(!+-90.!=$! )#$!6*/(')&$*6!-2!*!($+!%&-'%$&-9'!$&*!2-&!6*(;/(.!aB/<:!L7b:!W0V6$()!H*1*&.A!*(!*9)-6-)/4$!*(.!=/,1,0$!6*;$&A!,-(')&9,)$.!'$4$&*0!9(/)'!-2! G$6-/'$00$'A! +#/,#! +*'! '-0.! 2-&! M8A888! B&*(,':! "#$!

c)#

)#$!H&/)/'#!W#*(($0!,&-''/(<A!/(!L_8_:

)#$!X-%90*&!I$,#*(/,'!6*<*C/($!%9=0/'#$.!.&*+/(<'!-2! )#$!

)#*(!*(1!-)#$&!)#*)!#*.!=$$(!=9/0)!9%!)-!)#*)!.*)$A!2-&!)#-'$!+#-!+/'#!)-!&$*,#!&$'90)'!+/)#!)#$!0$*')!%-''/=0$!$`%$('$'!*(.!+/)#!6/(/696!-2!$`%$&/6$()/(<:!36$&/,*(!,-6%*(/$'!'-0.!.&*+5/(<'!*(.!%*&)'!-2!G$6-/'$00$!2-&!'$4$&*0!1$*&'!)#$&$*2)$&:

)#$!"*9=$!a%/<$-(b!*(.!+*'!*!6-(-%0*($!+/)#!=/&.50/;$!+/(<':!

)#$!34&-!"1%$!B!aB/<:!LQbA!)#$!0*))$&!#*'!=$$(!,-('/.$&$.!*'!)#$!

! "#$!)-%!'%$$.!-2! )#$!@)&/,#!*/&,&*2)!+/)#!)#&$$!%*''$(5

J%$(!?-9&,$!X#/0-'-%#1!*(.!)#$!G*+(!-2!34/*)/-(

%9&,#*'$!-2!G$6-/'$00$!.&*+/(<':

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AE&

Page 127: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

($'6=&D+C%$+#LD+C!$6#+CG!ML#+!"+#LD+'"!#D&+

6#=#D6

"#$!@(<0/'#!d/<#!?,#--0A!*(.!)#$(!#$!+*'!*(!*''/')*()!/(!)#$!

#$!+*'!(-6/(*)$.!./&$,)-&!-2! )#$!300$<#$(1!J='$&4*)-&1!

X$(('104*(/*A!+#/,#! /'! (-+!;(-+(!*'! )#$!>(/4$&'/)1! -2!X/))'=9&<#A! *! %-'/)/-(!#$!;$%)! 9()/0! LN_LA! $4$(!+#/0$! #$!=$,*6$! )#$! )#/&.!?$,&$)*&1!-2! )#$!?6/)#'-(/*(! D(')/)9)/-(!

3')&-%#1'/,*0!J='$&4*)-&1:

)#*(5*/&!*/&,&*2)!=9)!#/'! )+-!*))$6%)'!+/)#!6*(($.!*/&,&*2)!+$&$!(-)!'9,,$''290:!"#$&$2-&$A!#$!=$<*(!$`%$&/6$()/(<!+/)#!&9==$&5=*(.!%-+$&$.!6-.$0'!*(.!<0/.$&'!/(!LNNg:!d$!=9/0)!*!&-)*)/(<!*&6!a29(,)/-(/(<!'/6/0*&!)-!*!+/(.!)9(($0b!*(.!6*.$!

*!=-*)!-(! )#$!X-)-6*,!E/4$&:!"#$!./')*(,$!+*'! )$(! )/6$'!0-(<$&!)#*(!*(1!%&$4/-9'!$`%$&/6$()!+/)#!*!#$*4/$&5)#*(5*/&!

J(!=-)#!-,,*'/-('A!)#$!3$&-.&-6$!(96=$&!M!0*(.$.!/(!)#$!+*)$&A!*'!%0*(($.A!=$,*9'$A!/(!-&.$&!)-!'*4$!+$/<#)A!/)!+*'!(-)!$f9/%%$.!+/)#!0*(./(<!<$*&:

78:888!2&-6!)#$!?6/)#'-(/*(!)-!.$4$0-%!*!%/0-)$.!*/&%0*($A!

=&-)#$&'i! '9,,$''!+/)#! )#$/&!L_87!<0/.$&A!#$!*))$6%)$.! )-!6$$)!'9,#!=&-)#$&'A!=9)!)#$1!%-0/)$01!$4*.$.!#/'!&$f9$'):

=9/0)A! )#$!/()$&(*0!,-6=9')/-(!$(</($!+*'!,-()&*,)$.!-9)!)-!

)#$!.$'/<(:!"#/'!$(</($!#*.!2*&!6-&$!%-+$&!)#*(!./.!)#$!$(</($!

I*))-'A!H:?:

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AE!

Page 128: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

#%:!"#$!$(</($A!6-')01!)#$!)$,#(/,*0!+-&;!-2!6$(!-)#$&!)#*(!

34/*)/-(:!d-+$4$&A!)#$!36$&/,*(!*$&-'%*,$!,-669(/)1!./.!

(-!/(2-&6*)/-(!$`,#*(</(<!*6-(<!)#$!*4/*)/-(!%/-($$&':"#$!%/0-)$.!6*,#/($!#*.!+/&$5=&*,$.!)*(.$6!+/(<'!a-($!

=$#/(.!)#$!-)#$&bA!*!XV(*9.!)*/0!2-&!%/),#!*(.!1*+!,-()&-0!=9)!(-!&-00!,-()&-0A!.$%$(./(<!/(')$*.!-(!)#$!./#$.&*0!*(<0$!-2!)#$!

)#$! X-)-6*,!E/4$&:!"#/'! &$f9/&$.! *! ,*)*%90)! 2-&! 0*9(,#/(<!aB/<:!LPb:!"#$!,&*2)!#*.!(-!0*(./(<!<$*&A!*(.!)#$!%0*(!+*'!)-!

<*4$!9%!)#$!%&-F$,)!*2)$&!)+-!,&*'#$'!-(!)*;$5-22!-(!J,)-=$&!g!*(.!G$,$6=$&!NA!=-)#!/(!L_8Q:

+*'! )*;$(A! -(!G$,$6=$&!N!L_8QA!6*(($.! )$')'! -2! )#$!3$&-.&-6$!$(.$.!*=&9%)01!/(!2*/09&$A!*'!/)!2$00! /()-!)#$!

'5-4*;+?,/4)*,.+/0+=I*,-13

3,,-&./(<!)-!)#$/&!-+(!&$%-&)A!-(!G$,$6=$&!Lg)#A!L_8QA!)#$!

6*,#/($!+*'!$f9/%%$.!+/)#!)+-!,-9()$&5&-)*)/(<!%&-%$00$&'A!+#/,#!+$&$!.&/4$(!=1!*!'/(<0$!L75#%!2-9&5,10/(.$&!&$,/%&-,*)5

$(</($!*(.!#*.!*! )*;$-22!+$/<#)!-2!P8N ;<A!+#/,#!&$'90)$.!/(!*!+$/<#)5)-5%-+$&!&*)/-!-2!7M:M ;<O#%:!3=-9)!Q8!&$%-&)$&'!

'#-+$.!9%!*)!d9226*(!X&*/&/$!-(!I*1!7Q&.A!L_8P:!d-+$4$&A!

*(.!$4$&1-($!+$()!#-6$!./'*%%-/()$.:!3!#*(.290!,*6$!=*,;!

+/(.!,-(./)/-('!+$&$!(-)!%&$'$():!d-+$4$&A!)#$&$!*&$!'-6$!5

)#*)!,-4$&$.!*!./')*(,$!-2!*')-(/'#/(<!L7!6/0$'!+$&$!'*/.!)-!=$!

'*/.!)#*)!)#$1!+$&$!*00!)#$!)/6$!=9'1!*%%01/(<!2-&!%*)$()':D(!L_8LA! )#$!B&$(,#6*(!B$&./(*(.!B$&=$&!#$*&.!-2! )#$!

=$<*(!)-!,-&&$'%-(.!+/)#!)#$6:!"+-!1$*&'!0*)$&A!B$&=$&!=9/0)!*!

G$,$6=$&!L_8MA!B$&=$&!%9=0/'#$.!)#$!0$))$&'!#$!#*.!&$,$/4$.!

,/&,9/):!B$&=$&!#*.!*!'%$,/*0!/()$&$')!/(!./',0-'/(<!'9,#!;/(.!-2!/(2-&6*)/-(K!#$!/()$(.$.!)-!,-(4/(,$!)#$!B&$(,#!3&61!)-!%9&,#*'$!)#$!=&-)#$&'i!,&$*)/-(:!I-')!B&$(,#!%$-%0$!/()$&$')$.!/(!34/*)/-(!./.!(-)!=$0/$4$!)#*)!)#$!36$&/,*('!#*.!-=)*/($.!

d$!$4$(!-22$&$.!,*'#!2-&!)#*):!d-+$4$&A!#$!<-)!*!'/(<0$!&$%0*1!2-&6!)#$!36$&/,*(':

J%$(!?-9&,$!X#/0-'-%#1!*(.!)#$!G*+(!-2!34/*)/-(

7_A!L_8M!+/)#!B01$&!DDD:!D)!/'!)#-9<#)!)#*)!)#/'!*(.!-)#$&!'/6/0*&! %/,)9&$'! '922$&$.! 2&-6! +*)$&! ,-()*6/(*)/-(!

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AEA

Page 129: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

G96-():!J&4/00$!&$6*/($.!/(!)#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'! )-!,-()/(9$!)#$!%9&'9/)!-2!*!,-()&*,)! )-!'$00!3&6$.!B-&,$'!%0*($':!"#$1!/()$(.$.!)-!/6%&-4$!)#$/&!%0*($!*(.!'$,9&$!@9&-%$*(!/(4$'5

-(!)#$!%0*($'!)#$1!#*.!'#/%%$.!)-!B&*(,$!*)!)#$!$(.!-2!L_8g:!"#$1!+$&$!/(!)$&&/=0$!'#*%$!Y!B&$(,#!W9')-6'!#*.!&$%*,;$.!)#$6!%--&01:!D)!)--;!#/6!'/`!+$$;'!)-!*''$6=0$!*(!*/&%0*($A!$4$(!+/)#! )#$! #$0%! -2! )#$!6$,#*(/,'! %&-4/.$.! =1!H-00V$:!

"#$!($+!*/&%0*($!+$/<#$.!MPP!;<A!,#*&*,)$&/C$.!=1!*!+$/<#)5

.9$!)-!=*.!+$*)#$&:!B/(*001A!-(!39<9')!NA!L_8NA!)#$!+$*)#$&!,0$*&$.:!D(!2&-()!-2!*!'6*00!,&-+.A!+#/,#!/(,09.$.!)#$!*4/*5

/6%&$''/4$:!H1!J,)-=$&!LMA!#$!#*.!)*;$(!9%!Q8!%*''$(<$&':!

56$()!+*'!6*.$!=$)+$$(!)#$!?-,/V)V!3&/$0!*(.!/(!H&/)*/(!+/)#!?#-&)!H&-)#$&'!-2!@*'),#9&,#:!H-)#!,-6%*(/$'!%&-.9,$.!)#$!

#*.!.-9=0$!$0$4*)-&'A!6*/(!%0*/('A!*(.!&9..$&':!"#$!&9..$&'!+$&$!%0*,$.!29&)#$&!*2)!)#*(!/(!)#$!=&-)#$&'i!L_8M!.$'/<(!2-&!=$))$&!,-()&-00*=/0/)1:!"#$!%/0-)!'*)!-(!)#$!+/(<!$.<$!+/)#!)#$!$0$4*)-&!,-()&-0!-(!#/'!0$2):!J(!#/'!&/<#)A! )#$&$!+*'!*(-)#$&!')/,;!)#*)!,-()&-00$.!=-)#!)#$!&9..$&'!*(.!+/(<5+*&%/(<!a/(.$5

+#$$0'A!*(.!'-!)*;$-22'!,-()/(9$.!)-!=$!2&-6!*!+--.$(!&*/0A!*''/')$.!=1!*!+$/<#)!*(.!.$&&/,;!6$,#*(/'6:!32)$&!0*(./(<A!)#$!6*,#/($!#*.!)-!=$!,*&&/$.!=*,;!)-!)#$!&*/0!-(!*!+#$$0$.!

5

'$)! 9%! *! 2*,)-&1! /(!G*1)-(A!J#/-:!"#$1! *0'-! $')*=0/'#$.! *!

L_L8A!+#$&$!I*`+$00!3/&!B-&,$!H*'$!+-90.!0*)$&!=$!0-,*)$.:!

! I$*(+#/0$!/(!)#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'A!-(!G$,$6=$&!7QA!L_8gA!

'#-90.!=$!*=0$!)-!,*&&1!)+-!6$(!2-&!*!./')*(,$!-2!78L!;6!*)!*!6/(/696!'%$$.!-2!cP!;6O#:!D)!'#-90.!=$!*=0$!)-!')*1!*0-2)!2-&!-($!#-9&!=$)+$$(!&$29$0/(<A!0*(.!+/)#-9)!.*6*<$A!=$!)&*('5%-&)*=0$!-(!*(!3&61!+*<-(A!$*'/01!')$$&*=0$!/(!*00!./&$,)/-('A!*(.! *)! *00! )/6$'! =$! 9(.$&! %$&2$,)! ,-()&-0! *(.! $f9/0/=&/96:!

G$%*&)6$()!2-&!-($!*/&,&*2)!)#*)!+-90.!,-')!>?e!7MA888:!"#/'!+*'!,-('/.$&*=01!0$''!)#*(!)#$!>?e!788A888!)#$1!#*.!+*()$.!)-!,#*&<$!)#$!B&$(,#!<-4$&(6$()!)#$!1$*&!=$2-&$:!J(01!-($!-)#$&!=/.!+-90.!=$!,-('/.$&$.A!)#$!-($!2&-6!J,)*4$!W#*(9)$i'!-0.!%*&)($&!*(.!)#$/&!*,f9*/()*(,$A!39<9')9'!d$&&/(<:!H*,;!/(!G*1)-(A!J&4/00$!+*'!=9'/01!+-&;/(<!-(!)#$!%0*($!2-&!)#$!?/<(*0! W-&%'! +/)#! #/'! )+-! #$0%$&'! Y! W#*&0/$! "*10-&! *(.!W#*&0/$!B9&(*':!d$!+*'!*0'-!+&/)/(<!0$))$&'!*(.!*&)/,0$'!2-&!

*(.!-)#$&!F-9&(*0':!J(!I*1!LPA!L_8NA!)#$!6$,#*(/,!W#*&0/$!

-($A!J&4/00$!6*.$!*(!$&&-&!+/)#! )#$!$0$4*)-&! 0$4$&A!*(.! )#$!%0*($!.-4$!/()-!)#$!<&-9(.!*)!cP!;6O#:!d$!+*'!9(#9&)A!=9)!)#$!%0*($!+*'!+&$,;$.:!?-6$!6-()#'!0*)$&!J&4/00$!.$6-(')&*)$.!*!I-.$0!3!)-!)#$!>?!3&61!*)!B-&)!I1$&:!B&-6!?$%)$6=$&!QA!

"#-6*'!?$02&/.<$!+*'!2*)*001!/(F9&$.!*(.!J&4/00$!'922$&$.!*!=&-;$(!#/%:!I/0/)*&1!)&/*0'!+$&$!%-')%-($.!9()/0!)#$!2-00-+/(<!1$*&A!+#$(!*! &$%0*,$6$()! */&,&*2)!+-90.!=$!*4*/0*=0$:!"#$!L_8_!?/<(*0!W-&%'!B01$&!'9,,$''29001!,-6%0$)$.!)#$!3&61i'!

5)*&1!*/&%0*($!*,,$%)$.!/()-!6/0/)*&1!'$&4/,$:

I*))-'A!H:?:

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AE"

Page 130: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

#)*+834*54+<3,

! D(!L_8NA!)#$!=&-)#$&'!+*&($.!]0$((!W9&)/''!(-)!)-!/(2&/(<$!

9'$.!*/0$&-('!a?*()-'5G96-()!#*.!*0&$*.1!$6%0-1$.!*/0$&-('!

$`#/=/)/-(':! "#$! =&-)#$&'i! 0/,$('$.! @9&-%$*(! ,-6%*(/$'A!

6*(92*,)9&$&'!/(!)#$/&!,-9()&/$':!"#$!@9&-%$*(!0*+'9/)'!+$&$!

0$<*0!6*($94$&/(<! .&*<<$.! -(! 9()/0! )#$! %*)$()! $`%/&$.! /(!L_Lg:!3!]$&6*(!,-9&)!&90$.!)#$!%*)$()!/(4*0/.!.9$!)-!%&/-&!

>:?:!<&-9%'!)#*)!'%-('-&$.!*/&!'#-+'!*(.!,-00$,)$.!0/,$('$!2$$'!2&-6!)#$6:!"#$1!+-(!)#$/&!/(/)/*0!,*'$!*<*/(')!W9&)/''!/(!B$=&9*&1!L_LQA!=9)!!)#$!.$,/'/-(!+*'!*%%$*0$.:! B&-6! L_L8! 9()/0! #/'! .$*)#! 2&-6! )1%#-/.! 2$4$&! /(! L_L7A!

/(,$''*()01!)-!,-('90)!+/)#!0*+1$&'!*(.!)-!)$')/21!/(!+#*)!#$!2$0)!+*'!*!6-&*0!,*9'$A!%*&)/,90*&01!*<*/(')!W9&)/''A!+#-!+*'!

+-&&1!+/)#!)#$!0$<*0!/''9$!#/(.$&$.!)#$/&!.$4$0-%6$()!-2!($+!

/(2$&/-&!)-!)#-'$!6*.$!=1!-)#$&!,-6%*(/$'!/(!@9&-%$:!J&4/00$!

$`#*9')/(<!)&*4$0'!*(.!)#$!')&$''!-2!)#$!0$<*0!=*))0$:! "#$! 0*+'9/)'! *<*/(')! 36$&/,*('! ,-6%*(/$'! )#*)! +$&$!)&1/(<!)-!6*(92*,)9&$!*/&%0*($'!,*9'$.!*!#9<$!'$)=*,;!)-!)#$!

! D(!U*(9*&1!L_LPA!*!>:?:!W/&,9/)!W-9&)!-2!3%%$*0'!9%#$0.!

,-6%*(1! ,-()/(9$.! )-! *4-/.! %$(*0)/$'! )#&-9<#! 0$<*0! )*,)/,'!

,&-''50/,$('/(<!-&<*(/C*)/-(!/(!+#/,#!6$6=$&!,-6%*(/$'!%*/.!*!=0*(;$)!2$$!2-&!9'/(<!34/*)/-(!%*)$()'A!/(,09./(<!)#$!-&/</(*0!

*!(96=$&!-2!/)'!-+(!%*)$()'b!$*,#!&$,$/4$.!*!>?e!7!6/00/-(!%*16$():!"#$!%*)$()!+*&!$(.$.A!*0)#-9<#!'/.$!/''9$'!0/(<$&$.!

3$&-(*9)/,*0! ,-6%*(1! a*(-)#$&! '9,,$''-&b! *(.! )#$! W9&)/''!

,-&%-&*)/-(A!+#/,#!&$6*/('!/(!=9'/($''!)-.*1!%&-.9,/(<!#/<#5)$,#(-0-<1!,-6%-($()'!2-&!)#$!*$&-'%*,$!/(.9')&1:

=&-)#$&'A! +#-! +$&$! <$($&*001! &$<*&.$.! *'! #$&-$':! W&/)/,'!'*/.!)#$!=&-)#$&'!+$&$!<&$$.1!*(.!9(2*/&:!?9%%-&)$&'!'*/.!)#$!

$`%$,)/(<!2*/&!,-6%$('*)/-(!2-&!'$,&$)'!-2!)#$/&!/(4$()/-(:!"#$!=&-)#$&'!0-(<!2&/$(.'#/%!+/)#!J,)*4$!W#*(9)$!,-00*%'$.!*2)$&!#$!%9=0/,01!,&/)/,/C$.!)#$/&!*,)/-(':

&*I/-.*99*+35;+C3,I35+3-,2935*.+-5+4)*+'5-4*;+6434*.

! "#$!G$6-/'$00$!)--;!%*&)!/(!'-6$!*/&!'#-+'!/(!)#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'!aB/<:!Lcb!/(!$*&01!L_L8':!I-')!-2!)#$!%0*($'!./'%0*1$.!/(!)#-'$!$4$()'!+$&$!B&$(,#:!"#$1!,-()&/=9)$.!)-!)#$!.$4$0-%5

+/)($''$.!*(!*/&!'#-+!/(!L_L8A!+#$&$!B*&6*(!*/&%0*($'!%0*1$.!

J%$(!?-9&,$!X#/0-'-%#1!*(.!)#$!G*+(!-2!34/*)/-(

B/<9&$!Lc:! G$6-/'$00$!*(.!H0V&/-)'!*/&%0*($'!)*;/(<!%*&)!/(!*(!*/&!'#-+!/(!"$`*'A!>(/)$.!?)*)$'A!U*(9*&1!L_L8:

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AE$

Page 131: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

*!6*F-&!&-0$A!34/*)/-(!=$,*6$!*(!/(')*()!-='$''/-(:!"#$!'#-+!+*'!*!,*)*01')!)#*)!+-90.!0$*.!#/6!)-!=9/0.!#/'!-+(!%0*($!*(.!

"#/'!,-6%*(1!$4-04$.!/()-!)#$!+-&0.+/.$!;(-+(!H-$/(<!W-:

C=(#6+="&+C!M'$D6

! "*=0$!L!./'%0*1'!)#$!/6%&$''/4$!%&-<&$''!-2!)#$!'-09)/-(!

300! *,#/$4$6$()'!+$&$! &$,-&.$.! =1!3V&-5W09=! .$! B&*(,$:!

#$!+*'!-(01!*=0$!)-!.$0/4$&!*!&$6*&;*=0$!%$&2-&6*(,$!/(!0*)$!L_8NA! *2)$&! #$! /(,-&%-&*)$.! )#$!@9&-%$*(! )$,#(-0-<1:!"#$!=&-)#$&'!./.!(-)!)*;$!%*&)!/(!)#$!)&-%#1!-&<*(/C$.!=1!)#$!?,/$(5

! B/<9&$!Lg!/'!*!./*<&*6!/009')&*)/(<!)#$!&$0*)/-('#/%!=$)+$$(!+$/<#)5)-5+/(<! *&$*! *(.! +$/<#)5)-5%-+$&! &*)/-! 2-&! '$4$&*0!

/6%&-4$.!)#$!+$/<#)5)-5%-+$&!&*)/-!-2!)#$/&!6*,#/($':!d-+$45

'/(<0$5$(</($!%/')-(5%-+$&$.!*/&,&*2)!-2!*00!)/6$:!"#/'!$`%0*/('!)#$! ($$.! 2-&! *! ,*)*%90)50*9(,#/(<! '1')$6! -&! '9/)*=0$! +/(.!

,*(!=$!,-('/.$&$.!*(!9(.$&%-+$&$.!<0/.$&:!@4$(!,-('/.$&/(<!

$(</($A!+$!#*4$!-=)*/($.!4*09$'!f9/)$!./22$&$()!2-&!)#*)!2&-6!*!

! B&*(,$A!)#$!%/-($$&!-2!+-&0.!34/*)/-(A!0$.!)#$!+*1!2-&!)#$!

/(.9')&1!+*'!)#$!6-')!*.4*(,$.!/(!)#$!+-&0.A!*(.!/)'!,-()&/=95)/-(!+*'!,&9,/*0!)-!)#$!$')*=0/'#6$()!*(.!6*/()$(*(,$!-2!*/&!%-+$&!)-!,-(2&-()!)#*)!-2!)#$!W$()&*0!X-+$&':!D(!)#$!$*&01!1$*&'!-2!)#$!+*&A!B&*(,$!'9%%0/$.!*/&,&*2)!*(.!$(</($'!)-!#$&!*00/$':!B&$(,#!*'!2-&$&9(($&!-2!)#$!f9$')!2-&!)$,#(-0-<1!,*(!=$!,&$./)$.!)-!)#$!-%$(5'-9&,$!*6=/$(,$A!+#/,#!%&$4*/0$.!/(!)#$!*$&-(*9)/5

%&-.9,)/-(!/'!(*)9&*001!.9$!)-!)#$!'#*.-+!-2!)#$!+*&!)-!,-6$:! D(!L_LLA!)#$!)&*./)/-(!-2!6/0/)*&1!*/&!'#-+'!+*'!')*&)$.A!*(.!(-)!-(01!+*'!)#/'!/.$*!)*;$(!9%!=1!-)#$&!(*)/-('A!=9)!/)!%&-4$.!*!<&$*)!')/6909'!2-&!)#$!34/*)/-(!/(.9')&1:!"#$!/(.9')&/*0!*/&,&*2)!%&-.9,5

L_LLA!LAP7M!/(!L_L7!*(.!LA7_P!/(!L_LQ!a3(<$09,,/A!788Lb:! ]$&6*(1i'! *,#/$4$6$()'! /(! '$))/(<! 9%! *(.! .$4$0-%/(<!)#$!2&*6$+-&;!($$.$.!2-&!*$&/*0!+*&2*&$!,*(!=$!,-('/.$&$.!

*'!/6%&$''/4$:!3)!)#$!=$</((/(<!-2!)#$!+*&A!]$&6*(!*/&%0*($'!+$&$!'0-+!*(.!9(*&6$.A!/()$(.$.!-(01!)-!=$!9'$.!2-&!*$&/*0!-='$&4*)/-(!*(.!&$,-((*/''*(,$!-2!<&-9(.!2-&,$':!32)$&!,#*(<5/(<!)#$!+*1!*/&,&*2)!,-90.!=$!9'$290($''!/(!*!+*&!',$(*&/-A!)#$!

($+!+$*%-(:!"#$!*/&,&*2)!%&-.9,)/-(!/(!L_L7!)-%%$.!LQc!9(/)'A!+#/,#!/'!*!,-('/.$&*=0$!/(,&$*'$!2&-6!F9')!7P!=9/0)! /(!L_LL:!D(!L_LQA!]$&6*(1!*/&,&*2)! %&-.9,)/-(! &-'$! )-!PPc:!3!#9<$!

"*=0$!L:!X&-<&$''/4$!&$,-&.'!aB0/<#)]0-=*0A!L_8_=b:34/*)-& X0*,$ G*)$ G/')*(,$O"/6$

?*()-'5G96-() H*<*)$00$ 39<9')!77A!L_8c B$+!'$,-(.'

?*()-'5G96-() H*<*)$00$ ?$%)$6=$&!LPA!L_8c g5N!6

?*()-'5G96-() H*<*)$00$ J,)-=$&!7QA!L_8c M8!6

?*()-'5G96-() H*<*)$00$ 778!6

d$(&1!B*&6*( D''1 J,)-=$&!7cA!L_8g ggL!6

d$(&1!B*&6*( D''1 U*(9*&1!LQA!L_8N LAM88!6

d$(&1!B*&6*( D''1 I*&,#!7LA!L_8N 7A88P!6

G$0*<&*(<$ D''1 3%&/0!L8A!L_8N 7AM88!6

G$0*<&*(<$ D''1 3%&/0!LLAL_8N QA_7M!6

G$0*<&*(<$ E-6$ I*1!7gA!L_8N M!;6

G$0*<&*(<$ E-6$ I*1!7gA!L_8N _!;6

G$0*<&*(<$ E-6$ I*1!Q8A!L_8N L7AM!;6

G$0*<&*(<$ I/0*( U9($!77A!L_8N Lg!;6

d$(&1!B*&6*( ]*(. U901!cA!L_8N L_Ag!;6

G$0*<&*(<$ D''1 ?$%)$6=$&!cA!L_8N 7PAg7g!;6

B-&)!I$1$& ?$%)$6=$&!_A!L_8N L!#!7!6/(!Q8!'

B-&)!I$1$& ?$%)$6=$&!L8A!L_8N L!#!M!6/(!Mg!'

B-&)!I$1$& ?$%)$6=$&!LLA!L_8N L#!L8!6/(!M8!'

B-&)!I$1$& ?$%)$6=$&!L7A!L_8N L#!LM!6/(!78!'

394-9&' ?$%)$6=$&!7LA!L_8N L!#!QL!6/(!7M!'

G$,$6=$&!LNA!L_8N L!#!MP!6/(!77!'

!"#

!##

$"#

$##

"#

## " $# $" !# !" %#

&'()*+,-*./0/123'+45/,/+4'+/126'07089)

:/'4;),)*,-*./0208)'*

:/'4;),)*,.'+4280/8208

)'*

</2$#=

&>?,!#@

$AB'(

B5C0'*)2D> E5F/026E5F/02>>2G$=#AH

E5F/02>

B/<9&$!Lg:! W-6%*&/(<!<&*%#!,-()*/(/(<!)+-!/6%-&)*()!%*&*6$)$&'!2-&!'/(<0$5$(</($!%/')-(5%-+$&$.!*/&%0*($':

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AED

Page 132: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

/(,&$*'$!+*'!'$$(!/(!L_LPK!LAQPN!*/&%0*($'!+$&$!%&-.9,$.:!]$&6*(1!6*')$&$.! )#$!.$'/<(!-2! 0*&<$!*/&'#/%'A!+#/,#!'*+!

E9''/*!%0*1$.!*!6/(-&!&-0$!/(!)#$!34/*)/-(!.$4$0-%6$()!

E9''/*!/(!)#$!%&$5+*&!%$&/-.:!"#$!/()$&(*0!)9&6-/0!,*9'$.!=1!)#$!&$4-09)/-(!-2!L_Lg!#*6%$&$.!)#$!.$4$0-%6$()!-2!)#$!34/*5)/-(!/(!)#$!2-&6$&!?-4/$)!>(/-(:"#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'! 2$0)! )#$! ,-('$f9$(,$'!-2! )#$!.$0*1! /(!

/6%0$6$()/(<!-&<*(/C*)/-(!*(.!.$4$0-%6$()!%0*('!/(!6/0/)*&1!34/*)/-(:!>()/0!L_LL! )#$!-(01!*/&%0*($!+*'! )#$!B01$&!3! )#*)!

/(!39<9')A!L_8_:!J(!U901!LNA!L_LPA!6/0/)*&1!*4/*)/-(!6-4$.!2-&+*&.!+/)#!)#$!,&$*)/-(!-2!)#$!34/*)/-(!?$,)/-(!-2!)#$!?/<(*0!

/)'!3/&!B-&,$!,-9()$.! 0$''! )#*(!7M8!*/&%0*($'A!6-')!-2! )#$6!9('9/)*=0$!2-&!,-6=*):!J(01!/(!L_LNA!)#$!36$&/,*(!@`%$./)/-(5*&1!B-&,$i'! */&! *&6!,-90.!=$!-&<*(/C$.! /(! *! %&-%$&!6*(($&!

$f9/%6$():!3)! )#$!$(.!-2! )#$!+*&A! )#$&$!+$&$!PM!'f9*.&-('A!/(,09./(<!gP8!*/&%0*($'A!N88!%/0-)'A!*(.!M88!-='$&4$&':"*=0$!7!'966*&/C$'!)#$!(96=$&!-2!6/0/)*&1!*/&%0*($'!)#*)!

$*,#!,-9()&1!%9)!/()-!'$&4/,$!/(!L_LP!*(.!L_LN:!"#$!')&-(<$')!(*)/-(!+*'!]$&6*(1A!*(.!)#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'!&$,-&.$.!*!4$&1!

(96=$&!-2!H&/)/'#!.$'/<($.!*/&,&*2)!*(.!$(</($':!36-(<!)#$6!+*'!)#$!6*''5%&-.9,$.!3/&,-!Gd:P!aB/<:!LNb:!"#$!)1%$!+*'!*! H&/)/'#! )+-5'$*)! =/%0*($! .*15=-6=$&! *(.! +*'! .$'/<($.!

)+-5'$*)! 0/<#)! .*15=-6=$&! )-! #*4$! *(! $22$,)/4$! .$2$('/4$!

$()$&$.!'$&4/,$!+/)#!)#$!E-1*0!B01/(<!W-&%'!/(!I*&,#A!L_Lg:!"#$!6*F-&/)1!-2!Gd:P'!+*'!*,)9*001!=9/0)!*'!<$($&*0!%9&%-'$!

)+-5'$*)$&'!/(!)#$!>?3A!2-&!'$&4/,$!+/)#!)#$!36$&/,*(!2-&,$'!/(!B&*(,$:!"#$!Gd:P!+*'!)&/$.!+/)#!'$4$&*0!$(</($'A!-2!+#/,#!

G9$!)-!)#$!,#&-(/,!'#-&)*<$!-2!E-00'5E-1,$!*$&-!$(</($'!/(!<$($&*0A!*(.!@*<0$'!/(!%*&)/,90*&A!*0)$&(*)/4$!$(</($'!+$&$!*0'-!

E-00'5E-1,$!@*<0$!/(!%$&2-&6*(,$!*(.!&$0/*=/0/)1:!d-+$4$&A!)#$&$!+$&$!'/6%01!(-)!$(-9<#!@*<0$'!*4*/0*=0$:!D(!)#$!>?3A!

/(2$&/-&!%$&2-&6*(,$!)-!)#*)!%&-4/.$.!=1!)#$!@*<0$:

+$&$!,-()&*,)$.!=1!)#$!>?!3&61!)-!&$56*(92*,)9&$!'9&%09'!

.$0/4$&/$'!-2!LLL!*/&,&*2)'!2&-6!)#/'!6*(92*,)9&$&!)--;!%0*,$!=$)+$$(!I*&,#!*(.!U901!L_78A!+/)#!M8!-2!)#$6!=$/(<!&$)9&($.!2-&!29&)#$&!&$29&=/'#6$()'!)#&$$!1$*&'!0*)$&:

a3(<$09,,/A!788Lb:

W-9()&13/&,&*2)!/(!

'$&4/,$!/(!L_LP3/&,&*2)!/(!

'$&4/,$!/(!L_LNB&*(,$ LQN PAM88]&$*)!H&/)*/( LLQ QAQ88]$&6*(1 7Q7 7AQ_8D)*01 LM8 LA788>?3 MM gP8B-&6$&!?-4/$)!>(/-(

7PP 5

39')&-5d9(<*&/*(!@6%/&$

Nc 5

H$0</96 7P 5

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AEE

Page 133: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

(%"(G'&!"M+$D@=$N6

?*()-'5G96-()! /(!L_8c!&$')'!-(!)$,#(-0-</,*0!*.4*(,$'! /(!

$f9*)/-('!)#*)!6-.$0!)#$!=$#*4/-&!-2!*!=-.1!/(!&$0*)/4$!6-)/-(!)#!,$()9&1:!d-+$4$&A!)#$'$!

$f9*)/-('!,-90.!-(01!=$!%&-%$&01!'-04$.!+/)#!)#$!*.4$()!-2!)#$!./</)*0!,-6%9)$&:! D(! )#$! =$</((/(<A!34/*)/-(! .$4$0-%6$()! +*'! /(! 6*(1!

6/0/)*&1!*4/*)-&'A!*(.!+$*0)#1!#-==1/')':!"#$/&!$`%0-/)'!6*1!#*4$!)#&/00$.!)#$!6*''$'A!=9)!2-&!6-')!34/*)/-(!+*'!*!'%$,)*5)-&!*,)/4/)1A!(-)!*!%*&)!-2!$4$&1.*1!0/2$:!@`,$%)/-(!+*'!6*.$!2-&! ?*()-'5G96-()A! B*&6*(A! -̂/'/(! =&-)#$&'A! H0V&/-)A! *(.!

$(0/')$.!#$&$!$(4/'*<$.!)#$!34/*)/-(!)*;/(<!*(!/6%-&)*()!&-0$!/(!6*(;/(.!0/2$:!?*()-'5G96-()!+*'!)#$!-(01!-($!+#-!./.!(-)!0--;!*)!34/*)/-(!*'!*!%$&'-(*0!,-66$&,/*0!$()$&%&/'$:!30)#-9<#!)#$!&/,#!G96-()!#/6'$02!./.!(-)!)*;$!%*&)!/(!*(1!,-66$&,/*0!$()$&%&/'$A!#$!+*'!*+*&$!-2!)#$!,-66$&,/*0!/6%*,)!-2!34/*)/-(!-(!)#$!+-&0.i'!$,-(-61!*(.!-2!/)'!%-)$()/*0!*'!+*&2*&$:! "#$&$2-&$A! /)! /'! $*'1! )-! &$,-<(/C$! )#*)! )#$! D()$&($)! #*'!$(*=0$.!*!0*&<$!*6-9()!-2!,-00*=-&*)/4$!%&-F$,)'!-(!*!<0-=*0!',*0$:!d-+$4$&A!,-00*=-&*)/4$!+-&;!/(!*(!-%$(!'-9&,$!2*'#/-(!/'!(-)!($+:!D(.$$.A!/)!*0&$*.1!)--;!%0*,$!/(!@9&-%$!*)!)#$!.*+(!-2!34/*)/-(A!(*6$01!/(!B&*(,$:!"#*)!;/(.!-2!*6=/$(,$!*)!)#*)!)/6$!,*(!=$!,&$./)$.!)-!)#$!/.$*0'!-2!)#$!B&$(,#!E$4-09)/-(:!W-()&*&1!)-!)#/'A!/(!)#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'A!)#$!.$4$0-%6$()!-2!)#$!34/*)/-(!$(,-6%*''$.!)#$!'%/&/)!-2!)#$!@(<0/'#!E$4-09)/-(:!D)!+*'!=9'/($''5-&/$()$.!+/)#!%$-%0$!+-&;/(<!/(!'$,&$,1!+/)#!(-!-&!2$+!$`,#*(</(<!-2!/.$*'!*(.!/(2-&6*)/-(:!"#*)!/'!)#$!&$*'-(!+#1!@9&-%$!+*'!*#$*.!-2!36$&/,*!,-(,$&(/(<!*/&,&*2)!

')*&)$.! /(! )#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'!*6-(<!)#$/&!34/*)/-(!%/-($$&':!"#$!6$$)/(<!=$)+$$(!?*()-'5G96-()! *(.!"#-6*'!@./'-(!,*(!=$!,-('/.$&$.!,-(2&-()!=1!@(<0/'#!4$&'9'!B&$(,#!&$4-095)/-(':!30)#-9<#!&$'90)/(<!/(,-(,09'/4$A!)#$!6$$)/(<!&$4$*0$.!

36$&/,*!*(.!@9&-%$:!X&-=*=01A!)#/'!)*0;!#*.!$`$&,/'$.!'-6$!

! 30)#-9<#!*!,--%$&*)/4$!*)6-'%#$&$!/(!@9&-%$!/(!)#$!.*+(!-2!34/*)/-(!+*'! $')*=0/'#$.! *(.!+/.$'%&$*.A! (-! ,-00$,)/4$!.$,/'/-(!,-(,$&(/(<!)#$!.$'/<(!-2!*/&%0*($'!+*'!6*.$:!I-')!-2!*4/*)/-(!%/-($$&'!2&$$01!'#*&$.!)#$/&!,-(,$%)'!*(.!$4$(!$()/&$!

.$'/<('!=9)!*,)$.!'-6$+*1!/(.$%$(.$()01:!3!,-6=/(*)/-(!-2!-%$(5'-9&,$!%#/0-'-%#1!*(.!,-00$,)/4$!.$,/'/-(!&$*001!./.!(-)!)*;$!%0*,$!/(!@9&-%$:

/(!)#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'!)-!$')*=0/'#!=9'/($''!+/)#!)#$!36$&/,*(!

5*('!+$()!*!')$%!*#$*.!-2!)#/'K!/(!U*(9*&1!L_8NA!d$(&/!B*&6*(!

*(.!)#$/&!6*,#/($A!*(.!)#$1!./.!(-)!.$0/4$&!)#$!%$&2-&6*(,$!)#$! =&-)#$&'! #*.! %&-6/'$.:!32)$&! /(,-&%-&*)/(<! @9&-%$*(!

5

*/&%0*($!)#$1!+$&$!*=0$!)-!'$00!)-!)#$!>?!*&6$.!2-&,$'!/(!L_8_:!D(!*../)/-(A!36$&/,*(!%/0-)'!+$&$!*)!,-()&-0'!-2!B&$(,#!*(.!

%&-.9,$.!H&/)/'#!*/&%0*($'!9(.$&!0/,$('$!/(!)#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$'!

)#/'!/'!)#$!H&/)/'#!=-6=$&!G$d*4/00*(.!Gd!PA!-2!+#/,#!PAQPc!$`$6%0*&'!0$2)!*''$6=01!0/($'!/(!)#$!>(/)$.!?)*)$':! d-+!+*'!)#$!'%/&/)!-2!B&$(,#!E$4-09)/-(!%9)!/()-!%&*,)/,$!

,-6/(<! -(! )#$! ',$($! -2! )#$!3V&-5W09=! .$! B&*(,$! aB&$(,#!3/&!W09=b:!"#$!3V&-5W09=!.$!B&*(,$!+*'!2-9(.$.!/(!LN_N!)-!-&<*(/C$A!'9%%-&)A!*(.!&$<90*)$!*00!$22-&)'!)-!6*;$!34/*)/-(!*(!

*))$6%)'! ,-(,$&(/(<! *! #$*4/$&5)#*(5*/&! 6*,#/($A! =*00--('!5

%&/'$'!=9/0./(<!*(.!6*(92*,)9&/(<!*/&'#/%':!"#$(A!%$-%0$!)#*)!2-9(.$.!)#$!3V&-5W09=!.$!B&*(,$!%&-6%)01!$0*=-&*)$.!&90$'!

.$!B&*(,$!+*'!*!=*'/,!,-(,$%)!)#*)!*00!-)#$&!'/6/0*&!*/&!,09='!

+*'!*!)1,--(!-2!)#$!%$)&-0$96!'$,)-&!*(.!=$,*6$!*!'%-('-&!

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AEF

Page 134: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

-2!)#$!34/*)/-(A!,0-'/(<!/()$&*,)/(<!+/)#!3V&-5W09=!.$!B&*(,$!2-9(.$&':!30)#-9<#!)#$&$!+*'!*!,-6%$)/)/-(!2-&!<0-&1!*6-(<!/)'!6$6=$&'A!)&901!/(2-&6*)/-(!$`,#*(<$!+*'!%*&)!-2!$4$&1.*1!

5&$''!/(!34/*)/-(!*(.!3$&-(*9)/,*0!@(</($$&/(<!+$&$!&$%-&)$.A!*(*01C$.!*(.!./',9''$.!/(!)#*)!%0*,$:

$DCD$D"(D6

@(</($$&'!*(.!"$')!X/0-)'Ah!PM)#!3((9*0!?16%-'/96!-2!)#$!?-,/5

>(/4$&'/)1!X&$''A!I*''*,#9'$))'A!>?3A!7g7!%:

I*,#/($'hA! E$)&/$4$.! /(! ?$%)$6=$&A! 78LLA! 2&-6! #))%KOO+++:

5

5

-2!I-.$&(/)1hA!%:!LcM85LgM8A!J`2-&.!>(/4$&'/)1!X&$''A!>?3:

G96-()hA!I,]&*+5d/00A!M)#!$./)/-(A!?T-!X*90-A!Qc7!%:

E$)&/$4$.!/(!?$%)$6=$&A!78LLA!#))%KOO+++:0-,:<-4O%/,)9&$'O:

^s-hA!L')

I*/-&A!3:!?:A!L_ccA!P)#!@./)/-(A!?T-!X*90-A!P_N!%:

&$!')AA!LcN!%:

&$)&/$4$.! /(!I*1! 78L7! 2&-6! #))%KOO+++:(*'*:<-4O,$()$&'O0*(<0$1O#-6$O/(.$`:#)60:

BcQHM_LHg7NGGG3G8__PGWP8MHN7NWBLGQ:

E$)&/$4$.! /(! 3%&/0A! 78L7A! 2&-6! #))%KOO'*()-'.96-()0/2$:=0-<'%-):,-6:=&O78L7O8QO)-65$./'-(5*/&'#/%'5)*0;5+/)#5'*()-':#)6:

h! $̂&0*<!2t&! $̂&;$#&'+$'$(A!H$&0/(A!L_7!%:

W-6%9)*)/-(Ah!E$)&/$4$.!/(!I*&,#A!78L7A!2&-6!#))%KOO+++:',/0*=:-&<:

?-2)+*&$!2-&!B&$$Ah!E$)&/$4$.!/(!U*(9*&1A!78L7A!2&-6!#))%KOO+++:'-9&,$2-&<$:($):

?$%)$6=$&A! 78LLA! 2&-6! #))%KOO$(:+/;/%$./*:-&<O+/;/O@/&/5

5

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A$$BAE#8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AE#

Page 135: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management
Page 136: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&'(#!%"

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

#$(#.%('()! *6.! @9.! $:! %.9$@%#.9A!"'-'()! ,*!-,(,)'()! *6'9!9'*@,*'$(5! $(.! $:! *6.! *$$/9! *$! $;.%,*.! 9@#6! F,%',>/.9! '9! *6.!;.%:$%-,(#.!.F,/@,*'$(!*6,*!.(,>/.9!*6.!-,(,).%!*$!'&.(*':?!

76'#6!,9;.#*9!$:!,!;%$<.#*!(..&!*$!>.!'-;%$F.&AC

F,%',>/.9! *$! >.! *,8.(! '(*$! ,##$@(*! &@%'()! *6.!;.%:$%-,(#.!

*$! 9.,%#6! :$%!-.*6$&9! *6,*!7$@/&! .(,>/.! *6.! 9'-@/*,(.$@9!.F,/@,*'$(!$:!-@/*';/.!#%'*.%',5! *6@9!@9'()!*6.!-@/*'C#%'*.%',!

!"# $%&

012IIJ!12I245!K,//$(!!"#$%&!012II45!L,9#'-.(*$!!"#$%&#012II45!H(99/'(!!"#$%&

C

+.*6$&!:$%!H(%'#6-.(*!HF,/@,*'$(9!M!K%$@;!N.#'9'$(!O@;;$%*!O?9*.-!0PBE+HQRHH!KNOO4! 0+,#6,%'9!!"#$%&5!ISS34!,(&!K%,;6'#,/!"(,/?9'9!:$%!T(*.%,#*'F.!"99'9*,(#.!0K"T"4!0R,?.9!!"#$%&5! 122S4! *$!.F,/@,*.! *6.!;.%:$%-,(#.! '(! *6.! 9@>9?9*.-9!

! T(!*6'9!9*@&?5!,!)%$@;!&.#'9'$(C-,8'()!-.*6$&!7,9!#6$9.(!*[email protected]!&@.!*$!*6.!(..&!:$%!*6.!*.,-!-.->.%9!*$!;,%*'#';,*.!'(!

'(#$%;$%,*.9!*6.'%!F,/@.9!,(&!;%.:.%.(#.9A

&$'=!I2AU213V<,*-A12I1A2W2XXWII

)*+,-+./01*234/56/78-02987:2)$%;3#<332=&>>2/0?2=@!@A2@2>76?B2-027:*2!#@C>@#2>/7*5587*2)+-D*17#8/E-2F-GH2;*0*I*G2=-0J/54*GKL2;8G1:*52(/+.*02"*B+/2M*5?*++/80

!"#$%&'$(#'(!#)*+,!$-!.#+/01%!2)"3#/4#/,5$*)6$")/*$%#+/*"!2"-#)*#"(!#!*.#/4#"(!#78"(#+!*"9,3#$*.#:!5)**)*5#/4#"(!#7;-"

+!*"9,3#($-#,!-9%"!.#)*#"(!#)*+,!0!*"#/4#"(!#<$,)$:%!-#*90:!,##"/#:!#+/*-).!,!.#.9,)*5#$#1!,4/,0$*+!#!<$%9$")/*&#

'(!,!4/,!=#0$*3#1,/4!--)/*$%-#:!5$*#"/#-!$,+(#0!"(/.-#"($"#>/9%.#!*$:%!#"(!#-)09%"$*!/9-#$*$%3-)-#/4#09%")1%!#+,)"!?

,)$&#'(9-=#"()-#1$1!,#($-#)*<!-")5$"!.#"(!#$11%)+$")/*#/4#$#09%")+,)"!,)$#$11,/$+(#"/#!<$%9$"!#"(!#1!,4/,0$*+!#)*#"(!#

.!<!%/10!*"#/4#-9:-3-"!0-#.9,)*5#"(!#.!<!%/10!*"#/4#+/01%!2#1,/.9+"-=#:3#9-)*5#"(!#@ABCD'EDD#FGHH#$*.#"(!#

FIJI#0!"(/.-&#'/#$+()!<!#"()-#/:K!+")<!=#$#-"9.3#/*#"(!#J'I?HI'#-$"!%%)"!#1,/K!+"#>$-#1!,4/,0!.=#)*#>()+(#$#1!,+!1")/*#

$*$%3-)-#/4# "(!#0!0:!,-#/4# "(!#1,/K!+"#,!5$,.)*5#"(!#.!<!%/10!*"#/4#!$+(#-9:-3-"!0#>$-#+$,,)!.#/9"&#B*+!#"(!-!#

1!,+!1")/*-#>!,!#+$1"9,!.=#"(!#1,/1/-!.#$11,/$+(#>$-#9-!.#"/#).!*")43#-9:-3-"!0-#>)"(#%!--#-$")-4$+"/,3#1!,4/,0$*+!-&#

L)*$%%3=#"(!#,!-9%"-#>!,!#$*$%36!.#$*.#:,/95("#"/#.)-+9--)/*#$"#$#0!!")*5#>)"(#0$*$5!,-#$*.#1,/K!+"#0!0:!,-#>)"(#$#

4!!.:$+M#"/#"(!#+/*+%9-)/*-#/4#"()-#-"9.3&

)*+,-%.#(#@ABCD'EDD#FGHH=#FIJI=#J'I?HI'#H$"!%%)"!&

B.#.'F.&=!2IV23VII! "##.;*.&=!2IV2YVI1Z,@*6$%!:$%!#$%%.9;$(&.(#.=!*',)$<-)['*,A>%P\!H&@,%&$!K$-.95!U2C!]'/,!&,9!"#^#',9C!GHP!I1A113CS2ICO_$!`$9a!

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AF&BA#!8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AF&

Page 137: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

#<3%$3#!(@N2M@>!>

;(&@

! +$9*!&.#'9'$(C%./,*.&!;%$>/.-9!#$(9'9*!$:!'[email protected]!'(F$/FC'()!#$(*%,&'#*$%?!-@/*';/.!#%'*.%',5!76'#6!%.;%.9.(*!$(.!$:!*6.!#6,%,#*.%'9*'#9!$:!,!;%$>/.-!,;;%$,#6.&!>?!+GN"A!O'(#.!*6.%.!'9!%,%./?!$(.!,#*'$(!*6,*!#,(!9'-@/*,(.$@9/?!;%.9.(*!*6.!>.9*!;.%:$%-,(#.!'(!*6.!#$(9'&.%.&!#%'*.%',5!*6.!+GN"!#,(!

#%'*.%',!0b./.(?5!IS314A! T*!'(F$/F.9!,!9.*!$:!-.*6$&9!*6,*!#,(!>.!:$@(&!'(!/'*.%,*@%.!7'*6!&'::.%.(*!(,-.95!9@#6!,9=!+@/*'C"**%'>@*.!N.#'9'$(!+,8'()!0+"N+45!+@/*'CG%'*.%',!N.#'9'$(!+,8'()!0+GN+45!+@/*'CE><.#*'F.!N.#'9'$(!+,8'()!0+EN+4!$%!+@/*';/.!E><.#*'F.!N.#'9'$(!"'&'()!0+EN"4!0K$-.9!,(&!K$-.95!122I4A! "##$%&'()!*$!B$?!0ISSY45!+GN"!#,(!>.!@9.&!*$!:,#.!:$@%!8'(&9!$:!&.#'9'$(C%./,*.&!'[email protected]!,9!:$//$79=

,-$()!*6.!$(.9!>.'()!*,8.(!'(*$!,##$@(*J

'(*$!#/,99.95!,##$%&'()!*$!*6.!;.%:$%-,(#.J

,##$%&'()!*$!*6.!;.%:$%-,(#.J

;%$>/.-!>?!&.9#%'>'()!'*A

-.*6$&9!PBE+HQRHH!KNOO!0+,#6,%'9!!"#$%&5!ISS34!,(&!K"T"!0R,?.9!!"#$%&5!122S45!76'#6!7.%.!@9.&!'(!*6'9!9*@&?A

)$%;3#<332=&>>

! Q6.! PBE+HQRHH! KNOO! >./$()9! *$! *6.! $@*%,(8'()!-.*6$&95! ,/9$! @(&.%9*$$&! ,9! 9@>$%&'(,*'$(5! ;%.F,/.(#.5! $%!$@*%,(8'()A!O@#6!-.*6$&9!,'-!,*!>@'/&'()!,(!$@*%,(8'()!%./,C*'$(!*$!%.;%.9.(*!*6.!;%.:.%.(#.9!$:!*6.!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%9!,(&!*$!

! "##$%&'()! *$!c.!Qa($!,(&!+,%.9#6,/! 0ISS345! *6.!>,9'#!;%'(#';/.!$:!$@*%,(8'()!-.*6$&9!'9!*6,*!':!$(.!,#*'$(!;.%:$%-9!>.**.%!*6,(!,($*6.%!'(!-$9*!$:!*6.!#%'*.%',!,(&!'*!&$.9!($*!;%.9C

>.!*6.!#6$9.(!$(.A!d.9'&.95!*6.9.!-.*6$&9!#$(9'&.%!*6,*!9-,//!

'-;,#*!$(!*6.!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%!0]'(#8.5!ISS14A! "##$%&'()!*$!O'/F,!!"#$%&!012I245!$(.!$:!*6.!,&F,(*,).9!$:!*6.!PBE+HQRHH!-.*6$&!0T5!TT5!TTT5!T]5!]5!]T5!,(&!KNOO4!

'9!6$7!.,#6!#%'*.%'$(!'9!,99.99.&!>?!*6.!;%.:.%.(#.!:@(#*'$(9A!Q6'9! /.,&9! *$! ,!-$%.! %./',>/.! @(&.%9*,(&'()! $:! ;.%#.;*'$(!&'::.%.(#.9! ,-$()! *6.! &.#'9'$(C-,8.%9! ,*! .F,/@,*'()! .,#6!,#*'$(5!,(&!'*!,/9$!&$.9!($*!,//$7!,(!@(/'-'*.&!#$-;.(9,*'$(!$:!-,<$%!,&F,(*,).9!>.*7..(!*6.!,#*'$(9A! e$%!d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fNg!%.;%.9.(*9!*6.!*6%.96$/&!$:!'(&'::.%.(#.5!f-g!%.;%.9.(*9!*6.!*6%.96$/&!$:!9*%'#*!;%.:.%.(#.5!,(&!f g!%.;%.9.(*9!,!F,/@.!>.*7..(!fNg!,(&!f-g!0d%,(9!,(&!+,%.9#6,/5!122U4A

C.(#.!:@(#*'$(9!:$%!.,#6!#%'*.%'$(!0,9!7.//!,9!*6.!;,%,-.*.%945!*6.!#,/#@/,*'$(!$:!&.F',*'$(!-$&@/.9!&8!0,'5!,<4!>.*7..(!<@&)C-.(*9!480,'4!,(&!480,<4!:$%!.,#6!;,'%!$:!,#*'$(9!f,'g!,(&!f,<g!7..!;.%:$%-.&5!,##$%&'()!*$!.,#6!#$(9'&.%.&!#%'*.%'$(!fMg!,(&!*$!*6.!.D@,*'$(=!&8!0,'5!,<4!h#480,'4!M#480,<4A!Q6.!%.9@/*9!$:!9@#6!.D@,C

!"#$%& 8i2A!"#$%&!012I245!:$%!.,#6!F,/@.!%.9@/*C

'()!:%$-!&8!0,'5!,<45!,!;%.:.%.(#.!:@(#*'$(!'9!@9.&!*6,*!*%,(9/,*.9!*6.!&'::.%.(#.!>.*7..(!*6.!.F,/@,*'$(9!$>*,'(.&!>?!*7$!,#*'$(9!f,'g!,(&!f,<g!$F.%!,!#%'*.%'$(!M!'(!,!F,/@.!$:!;80&845!76'#6!%,().9!

C*'$(9!,%.!#,//.&!'(*.(9'*'.9!$:!;%.:.%.(#.5!,(&!*6.?!,%.!*6.!>,9'9!

7'*6!76'#6!,(!,#*'$(!f,'g!'9!;%.:.%%.&!$F.%!,(!f,<g5!#$(9'&.%'()!

8!$:!.,#6!#%'*.%'$(!fMg!:$%!*6.!f*

d./&.%%,'(5!+AGALA5!K$(\,/F.95!QA`A

G6,%*!IA!`@&)-.(*!9#,/.A

].%>,/!9#,/. L@-.%'#!9#,/.].%?!)$$&!0]K4 UK$$&!0K4 W+.&'@-!0+4 XP$$%!0P4 1].%?!;$$%!0]P4 I

0O$@%#.=!e%.'*,9!!"#$%&!122S4

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AF&BA#!8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AF!

Page 138: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

T*9!#,/#@/,*'$(!'9!;.%:$%-.&!,##$%&'()!*$!HDA!I=

! 0I4!! !

" #

$ %

&

&

'

&

&

& &

"

" �

�#

#

#! !" "!

!

C

,##$%&'()!*$!HD9A!15!X!,(&!W5!%.9;.#*'F./?5!76.%.!f,)g!%.;%.9.(*9!

$Kg!

F,%'.9!%.;%.9.(*'()!*6.!-CI!&'::.%.(*!,#*'$(9!$:!f$)gA

!

!(

! !

"$ $

&

$ %

"�

#$

% #! !" "!! 014

!

!(

! !

"$ $

%

% $

"�

#

$! !$!

!"

"!! 0X4

! ! !$ $ $ $ $ $� � �# $% $! ! !" " " ! 0W4

%.;%.9.(*9!*6.!'(*.(9'*?!7'*6!76'#6!,(!,#*'$(!'9!#6$9.(!$F.%!

76'#6!,(!,#*'$(!'9!$F.%#$-.!>?!$*6.%9A

!"#$%&5!12II4A

KNOO!#,(!>.!#$(&@#*.&A! "##$%&'()!*$!+,#6,%'9!!"#$%&!0ISS345!'(!*6.!PBE+HQRHH!

.,#6!$:! *6.-5!,9!&.-$(9*%,*.&! '(!e')A!I! :$%! :$@%!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%9!,(&!9.F.(!,#*'$(9A

%.9@/*'()!'(!*6.!)%$@;!.F,/@,*'$(!0d%,(9!,(&!+,%.9#6,/5!122U4A

=@!@

! E(.!$:!*6.!,&F,(*,).9!*$!@9.!*6.!PBE+HQRHH!:,-'/?!-.*6$&9! '9! *6.!;$99'>'/'*?!$:! '(*.%;%.*'()!).$-.*%'#,//?! *6.!%.9@/*9!>?!*6.!K"T"!-.*6$&!0+,%.9#6,/!,(&!d%,(95!IS334A

#%'*.%'$(!f%O! '9!#,/#@/,*.&!,##$%&'()! *$!HDA!U5!76.%.!f$)g!

%.;%.9.(*9!*6.!,#*'$(!f) C/,*.&!0R,?.9!!"#$%&5!122S4A

! !!(

" # ! ! " # ! !"

") $ ) $ % ) % $

%

(

"

� #$

$#

! ! !" " "! !" "# $! ! 0U4

%$75!,(!,#*'$(A

!

!

!

!(

'

' (

" "

"

"

"

#

$

#

"

� #

!!

!!

""

""# $! 0Y4

! j9'()! *6.! >';/$*! -.*6$&! 0k$6/.%! ,(&! c@(',85! 122U4! '(!5!*6.!,#*'$(9!,(&!#%'*.%',!,%.!;%$<.#*.&!'(!,!;/,(.!96,;.&!

! T(! K"T"! ;/,(.5! ,#*'$(9! ,%.! %.;%.9.(*.&! >?! ;$'(*9!,(&!#%'*.%',!>?!F.#*$%9A!+$%.$F.%5! *6.!F.#*$%!$:!7.')6*9!l0 I 1 (4!'(!*6.!8C&'-.(9'$(,/!9;,#.!#,(!>.!;%$<.#*.&!$(!*6.!K"T"!;/,(.5!,9!&.-$(9*%,*.&!'(!e')A!1A!Q6.!;%$<.#C*'$(! $:! *6.! 7.')6*! F.#*$%! $(! *6.! K"T"! ;/,(.! '9! #,//.&!

! "##$%&'()! *$!"/.(#,%! ,(&!"/-.'&,! 012I245! *6.!K"T"!

,9;.#*9! #$(#.%('()! *6.! #%'*.%',! ,(&! ,>$@*! *6.! '-;,#*! $:!

&.#'9'$(C-,8.%9!$(.!*6.!'[email protected]! d%,(9!,(&!+,%.9#6,/!0122U4!9*,*.!*6,*!*6.!,(,/?9'9!$:!*6.!K"T"!;/,(.!6./;9!,*!@(&.%9*,(&'()!*6.!9*%@#*@%.!$:!*6.!;%$>/.-=

P.%:$%-,(#.!HF,/@,*'$(!7'*6!PBE+HQRHH!KNOO!,(&!K"T"=!"!O*@&?!$(!*6.!TQ"CO"Q!O,*.//'*.!P%$<.#*

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

e')@%.!IA!e@(#*'$('()!$:!PBE+HQRHH!KNOOA!0"&,;*.&!$:!d%,(9!,(&!+,%.9#6,/5!122U4A!

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AF&BA#!8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AFA

Page 139: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

'(&'#,*.!-$%.!F,%',>/.!#%'*.%',J

&'%.#*'$(9!(.,%!*$!*6,*!$:!*6.!&.#'9'$(!9*'#8J

>?!F.#*$%9!'(!$%*6$)$(,/!&'%.#*'$(9J

$(.!,($*6.%J!,(&

,%.!%.;%.9.(*.&!>?!;$'(*9!/$#,*.&!'(!*6.!&'%.#*'$(!$:!*6.!F.#*$%!#$(#.%('()!*6.!#%'*.%'$(!'([email protected]*'$(A

! T(!$%&.%!*$!-..*!*6.!$><.#*'F.9!$:!*6'9!9*@&?5!*6'9!,;;%$,#6!7,9! ,;;/'.&! *$! .F,/@,*.! *6.! &.F./$;-.(*! $:! *6.! TQ"CO"Q!9,*.//'*.!;%$<.#*A

!#@C>@#2>@#3NN!#32)$%F3(#

! Q6.!TQ"CO"Q!9,*.//'*.!;%$<.#*!'9!;,%*!$:!*6.!;/@%'C,((@,/!;/,(!$:!fG!-!*</%<)0!*"/#!#P$*Q$0!*"/#.!#H$"R%)"!-#'!+*/%S5)+/-#

.!#@!N9!*/#@/,"!g5!#$(#.%('()!*6.!&.F./$;-.(*!,(&!/,@(#6!$:!9-,//!*.#6($/$)'#,/!9,*.//'*.9A!T*!7,9!#%.,*.&!>?!"#*'$(!(@->.%!

,(&!*.9*!*.#6($/$)'#,/!'(($F,*'$(9!$:!9,*.//'*.9!,(&!*$!.(6,(#.!

#$(#.%('()!-'#%$!,(&!(,($C9,*.//'*.9A! Q6'9!,#*'F'*?!'(F$/F.9!"Hd5!*6.!L,*'$(,/!T(9*'*@*.!:$%!O;,#.!B.9.,%#6!0TLPH45!,(&!*6.!Q.#6($/$)'#,/!T(9*'*@*.!$:!".%$(,@C*'#9!0TQ"4A!E*6.%!@;;.%!.&@#,*'$(!'(9*'*@*'$(9!-,?!>.!,99$#',*.&!7'*6!*6.!;%$<.#*!>?!-.,(9!$:!,!#$$;.%,*'$(!*.%-!7'*6!TQ"A

! Q6.!TQ"CO"Q!;%$<.#*!7,9!9@>&'F'&.&!'(*$!9*,).95!,##$%&'()!*$!*6.!O*,(&,%&9!$:!*6.!H@%$;.,(!O;,#.!").(#?=!024!-'99'$(!

.,#6!9*,).!#,(!>.!$>9.%F.&!'(!*6.!9*,(&,%&!HGOOC+COQCI2G!$:!*6.!H@%$;.,(!O;,#.!").(#?!0HO"4!0HO"5!122S4A! Q6.!TQ"CO"Q!;%$<.#*!>.),(!'(!122S5!,(&!9*,).9!25!"!,(&!d! ,%.! #$(#/@&.&5! 7'*6! *6.'%! %.9;.#*'F.! %.F'9'$(95!+'99'$(!

0PBB45!O?9*.-!B.D@'%.-.(*9!B.F'.7!0OBB45!,(&!P%./'-'(,%?!N.9')(!B.F'.7!0PNB4A!N.*,'/9!-,?!,/9$!>.!9..(!'(!*6.!9*,(C&,%&!HGOOC+COQCI2G!$:!*6.!HO"A! N@%'()! *6.! ;.%:$%-,(#.! $:! *6'9! 9*@&?5! *6.! TQ"CO"Q!9,*.//'*.! ;%$<.#*! 7,9! :,#'()! -,(?! ;%$>/.-95! '(#/@&'()!

;%$<.#*A!Q6.! *?;.9!$:!,#*'F'*'.9! *6,*! 96$@/&!>.!;.%:$%-.&!7.%.!($*!;%.F'$@9/?!8($7(5!9$!*6.!9#$;.!7,9!;.%'$&'#,//?!

-$%.!8($7/.&).!$(! *6.!;%$&@#*! *6,*!7,9!>.'()!&.9')(.&A!G$(#.%('()!&.,&/'(.9!,(&!$><.#*'F.95!*6.!;,#.!$:!&.F./$;C-.(*! '(! *6.!;%$<.#*!7,9!&'::.%.(*! '(! 9.F.%,/! 9@>9?9*.-95!,(&!-,(?!,#*'F'*'.9!7.%.!$(!6$/&!>.#,@9.! *6.?!&.;.(&.&!$(!*6.!#$(#/@9'$(!$:!$*6.%95!76'#6!7.%.!($*!#$(#/@&.&!$(!*'-.A!"/9$5! *6.!#$--@('#,*'$(!,(&!&$#@-.(*,*'$(!$:! *6.!

$:! *6.!8($7/.&).! *6,*! %.9@/*.&! :%$-!,(!,#*'F'*?!7,9! /$9*!76.(!,!-.->.%!$:!*6.!*.,-!/.:*!*6.!;%$<.#*A!O@#6!;%$>/.-9!

.D@';-.(*!'(!*6.!TQ"CO"Q!9,*.//'*.!;%$<.#*A!0O,*$!!"#$%&5!12II4

2

l

K"T"!;/,(.

e')@%.!1A!].#*$%!$:!7.')6*9!;%$<.#*.&!$(!K"T"!;/,(.A! 0d%,(9!,(&!+,%.9#6,/5!ISSW4A

d./&.%%,'(5!+AGALA5!K$(\,/F.95!QA`A

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AF&BA#!8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AF"

Page 140: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

TQ"CO"Q! 9,*.//'*.! ;%$<.#*! '(! $%&.%! *$! 9.,%#6! :$%!7,?9! *$!'-;%$F.5!9$/F.5!$%!.,9.!*6$9.!'[email protected]

!?*078 1/78-02/0?2/0/5BG8G2-,27:*2?*18G8-021-07* 7

! Q6.! TQ"CO"Q! 9,*.//'*.! ;%$<.#*5! 76$9.! ;%./'-'(,%?!

$:!9@>9?9*.-9!:$%!,**'*@&.!#$(*%$/!0"G45!$(C>$,%&!#$-;@*.%!0EdG45!;$*.(#?!0PQ45!*6.%-,/!#$(*%$/!0QG45!9*%@#*@%.!0OQ45!,(&!*./.#$--,(&!,(&!*./.-.*%?!0QQ4A! Q6.!:@(#*'$(9!$:!*6.9.!9@>9?9*.-95!,##$%&'()!*$!c,%9$(!,(&!l.%*9!0ISSS4!$19.!O,*$!!"#$%&

IT

# T*!#$(*%$/9!*6.!&'%.#*'$(!*6.!9,*.//'*.!96$@/&!>.!;$'(*.&!,*5!9'(#.!'*!'9!(.#.99,%?!*6,*!9$-.!$:!'*9!'(9*%@-.(*9!,%.!;$'(*.&!,*!

BUT

T*! #$(*%$/9! '(*.%(,/! #$--@('#,*'$(5! *6.! 9,*.//'*.5! ,(&!$(C>$,%&!&,*,!;%$#.99'()A!Q7$!*?;.9!$:!&,*,!,%.!;%$#.99.&!>?!

*6.!,#*'F.!9@>9?9*.-95!*.-;.%,*@%.!.*#A5!76'#6!,%.!@9.&!>?!*6.!)%$@(&!9.)-.(*!*$!7$%8!$(!*6.!9@>9?9*.-9m!:@(#*'$(A!O#'.(C

9*@&'.95!9@#6!,9!'-,).9!,(&!%,&',*'$(!-.,9@%.-.(*9A!N@.!*$!*6.!&'::.%.(*!(,*@%.!$:!*6.!,#*'F'*'.9!'(!9@>9?9*.-!EdG5!7.!&'F'&.&! *6.! 9@>9?9*.-! '(*$!EdG!M!O$:*7,%.! 0EdGCO4!,(&!R,%&7,%.!0EdOCR4A

@'

# T*!).(.%,*.95!9*$%.95!#$(&'*'$(95!,(&!&'9*%'>@*.9!.(.%)?!:$%!*6.!9,*.//'*.!9@>9?9*.-9A

'T

! T*!.(9@%.9!*6,*!,//!9@>9?9*.-9!,(&!#$-;$(.(*9!$:!*6.!9,*./C

;%$<.#*A

H'

# T*! %.;%.9.(*9! *6.! -.#6,('#,/! #$((.#*'$(! >.*7..(! *6.!&'::.%.(*!9@>9?9*.-9!,(&!#$-;$(.(*9!'(!*6.!9,*.//'*.A!T*!96$@/&!>.!,>/.!*$!9@9*,'(!*6.!.::$%*9!&@%'()!/,@(#6!,(&!,*!*6.!-$-.(*!$:!@(#$@;/'()!*6.!/,@(#6!F.6'#/.5!#$(9'9*'()!$:!,!9@%:,#.!$(!76'#6!*6.!.D@';-.(*!'9!;@*!*$).*6.%A!"/9$5!'*!96$@/&!;%$F'&.!

;%$*.#*'$(!,),'(9*!%,&',*'$(5!'*!96$@/&!6,F.!,!#$@;/'()!'(*.%:,#.!7'*6!*6.!/,@(#6!F.6'#/.5!>.9'&.9!>.'()!'(!#6,%).!$:!)%$@(&'()!:$%!*6.%-,/!,(&!./.#*%'#,/!.(&9A

''

,(&!*6.!)%$@(&!#$(*%$/!9*,*'$(A!"9!*$!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%95!:$@%!%.;%.9.(*,*'F.9!7.%.!9./.#*.&!,-$()!*6.!;,%*'#';,(*9!$:!*6.!;%$<.#*A!Q6.!).(.%,/!-,(,).%!#$(9'&.%.&!*6.-!,9!*6$9.!76$!6,&!-$%.!8($7/.&).!$(!*6.!9@><.#*A

>7+6176+80E27:*2O+-P5*.2/0?27:*2.65781+87*+8/2.-?*5

C/'*.5!-,(?! *%,&'*'$(,/!-,(,).-.(*!-.*6$&9! .9*,>/'96.&! '(!/'*.%,*@%.5!9@#6!,9!*6$9.!-.(*'$(.&!'(!*6.!P%$<.#*!+,(,).-.(*!d$&?!$:!k($7/.&).!0P+dEk4!0P+T5!122345!7.%.!($*!@9.&!'(! *6'9!;%$<.#*A!Q6.%.:$%.5!($!&.F./$;-.(*! '(&'#,*$%9!7.%.!;%.;,%.&!76.(!*6'9!%.9.,%#6!7,9!#,%%'.&!$@*A! e@%*6.%-$%.5!*6.!'(&'#,*$%9!@9.&!*$!,99.99!.,#6!9@>9?9*.-!7.%.!$>*,'(.&!>?!/'*.%,*@%.!,(,/?9.9!$(!-,(,).-.(*!&.F./$;C-.(*!'(&'#,*$%9!$:!;%$<.#*9A!l.!6,F.!#6$9.(!*$!@9.!*6.!$(.9!&.9#%'>.&!'(!P+dEk!,(&!*6$9.!>?!Q.%%'>'/'!e'/6$!012I24A

')0!#0$*$5!0!*"

(.#.99,%?! %.9$@%#.95! *$!&.F./$;5! ,(&! *$!#$(*%$/! *6.!;%$<.#*!*'-.*,>/.A

T/009*)+$")/*#!44!+")<!*!--

-,8.!9@%.!*6.!'(:$%-,*'$(!'9!;%$;.%/?!).(.%,*.&5!#$//.#*.&5!

A)-M#0$*$5!0!*"

7.//!,9!%.9;$(9.!;/,(('()5!-$('*$%'()5!,(&!%'98!#$(*%$/A

J*"!5,$")/*#0$*$5!0!*"

#

#$->'(.5! ),*6.%5! ,(&! #$$%&'(,*.! *6.! ;%$#.99.9! $:! &'::.%.(*!9@>9?9*.-9!*6,*!#$-;$9.!*6.!;%$<.#*A

P.%:$%-,(#.!HF,/@,*'$(!7'*6!PBE+HQRHH!KNOO!,(&!K"T"=!"!O*@&?!$(!*6.!TQ"CO"Q!O,*.//'*.!P%$<.#*

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AF&BA#!8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AF$

Page 141: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

T/-"#0$*$5!0!*"

.9*'-,*.5!>@&).*5!,(&!#$(*%$/!#$9*9!'(!$%&.%!*$!#$(#/@&.!*6.!

V9$%)"3#0$*$5!0!*"

*6,*!*6.!(..&9!:$%!76'#6!*6.!;%$<.#*!7,9!'('*',*.&!#$@/&!>.!-.*A

! "-$()!*6.!-.(*'$(.&!#%'*.%',5!7.!$>9.%F.&!*6,*!9'(#.!*6'9!

*6.!(.#.99,%?!*.#6($/$)'.9!96$@/&!>.!&.F./$;.&A!Q6'9!:,#*!&'&!($*!,//$7!@9! *$!;%.&'#*! *6.!,9;.#*9!%./,*.&! *$!#$9*!$%! *$! *6.!D@,/'*?!$:!*6.!;%$<.#*5!9'(#.!7.!#$@/&!($*!*.//!76'#6!*?;.!$:!

d.#,@9.!$:!*6,*5!*6.!#$9*!-,(,).-.(*!#%'*.%',5!,9!7.//!,9!*6.!

! T(!*6'9!9*@&?5!7.!*%'.&!*$!.F,/@,*.!*6.!;.%:$%-,(#.!>,9.&!$(!*6.!;.%#.;*'$(!$:!*6.!;%$<.#*m9!*.,-5!@9'()!,!<@&)-.(*!9#,/.!

!"#$%&

)$$&45!,(&!'*!'9!&.*,'/.&!'(!G6,%*!IA! T(!$%&.%!*$!&.*.%-'(.!*6.!;%.:.%.(#.!:@(#*'$(95! *6.!$(.9!&.-$(9*%,*.&! '(! G6,%*! 1! 7.%.! ;%.9.(*.&! *$! *6.! &.#'9'$(C-,8.%95!,(&!*6.!@9@,/!:@(#*'$(!7,9!#$(9'&.%.&!,9!*6.!-$9*!,&.D@,*.!:$%!*6.!@9.&!#%'*.%',!,(&!>?!*6.!&.#'9'$(!-,8.%9!'(!*6'9!9*@&?A!N@%'()! *6.! '(*.%F'.795! *6.?!9,'&! *6,*5!,##$%&'()!*$!*6.!,&$;*.&!9#,/.5!,(?!&'::.%.(#.!>.*7..(!<@&)-.(*9!7,9!

*6.!;%.:.%.(#.!:@(#*'$(95!.,#6!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%!7,9!,98.&!*$!;$(&.%!*6.!#%'*.%',A!d.9'&.95!*6.!).(.%,/!-,(,).%!7,9!,98.&!*$!;$(&.%!*6.!8($7/.&).!$:!.,#6!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%!#$(#.%('()!*6.!

!0?848?6/52/0/5BG8G

! l'*6! *6.! $><.#*'F.! $:! .F,/@,*'()! *6.! &.F./$;-.(*!;.%:$%-,(#.!$:! *6.!;%$<.#*m9!9@>9?9*.-95! '(&'F'&@,/!.F,/@C,*'$(9!7'*6! *6.! ;.%#.;*'$(9! $:! .,#6! &.#'9'$(C-,8.%!7.%.!

PBE+HQRHH!-.*6$&5! *6.! F.%>,/! ,(&! (@-.%'#! 9#,/.9! '(!G6,%*!I!7.%.!;%.9.(*.&A!":*.%7,%&95!.F.%?!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%!7,9!,98.&!*$!*6'(8!$:!,(!,/*.%(,*'F.!*6,*!%.;%.9.(*.&5!'(!*6.'%!

d,9.&!$(!*6'9!6?;$*6.*'#,/!,/*.%(,*'F.5!.,#6!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%!6,&!*$!,(97.%!6$7!-@#6!>.**.%!*6.?!#$(9'&.%.&!*6.!TQ"CO"Q!9,*.//'*.! ;%$<.#*! '(! *6.! .F,/@,*.&! #%'*.%'$(A!+,(?!$:! *6.-!,(97.%.&!*6.?!6,&!;'#*@%.&!*6.!TQ"CO"Q!;%$<.#*!,9!,!nF.%?!;$$%m!,/*.%(,*'F.5!*6@9!$>*,'('()!$(.!'(!*6.!(@-.%'#!9#,/.A!T(!$*6.%!$##,9'$(95! *6.?!9,'&! *6.!TQ"CO"Q!;%$<.#*!;.%:$%-.&!*7'#.5! *6%..! *'-.9!$%! :$@%! *'-.9!>.**.%! *6,(! *6.!F.%?!;$$%!6?;$*6.*'#,/!,/*.%(,*'F.A!T*! '9! '-;$%*,(*! *$!-.(*'$(!*6,*!($!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%!#$(9'&.%.&!*6.!;.%:$%-,(#.!$:!*6.!TQ"CO"Q!

C*6.*'#,/!,/*.%(,*'F.A!l'*6!*[email protected]*'$(95!*6.!.F,/@,*'$(9!$:!*6.!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%9!,>$@*!*6.!;.%:$%-,(#.!$:!.,#6!9@>9?9C

! ":*.%!#$//.#*'()!<@&)-.(*95!*6.!9@>9?9*.-9!7.%.!'(&'F'&@C,//?!,99.99.&!7'*6!*6.!9$:*7,%.!NCO')6*!0+,#6,%'9!!"#$%&5!12I24A!

.,#6! &.#'9'$(C-,8.%! N+'! 0'hI515X5W4! ,%.! &.-$(9*%,*.&! '(!Q,>/.!I5!7'*6! *6.!$%&.%!$:!;%'$%'*?!$:!.,#6!9@>9?9*.-A! T*! '9!

(@->.%!#$%%.9;$(&'()!*$!*6.!$%&.%!$:!;%'$%'*?!7,9!%.;.,*.&!:$%!*6.!*'.&!9@>9?9*.-9A! H,#6! &.#'9'$(C-,8.%! ,(,/?9'9! #$(#.%('()! *6.! K"T"!;/,(.! '9! ;%.9.(*.&! '(! G6,%*! XA! T(! *6.9.! ;/,(.95! F.#*$%9!

%.;%.9.(*.&! *6.! ,#*'$(9J! ,(&! *6.!F.#*$%!7'*6! *6.! #'%#@/,%!

O@>9?9*.-9 N+I E%&.% N+1 E%&.% N+X E%&.% N+W E%&.%

"**'*@&.!G$(*%$/!0"G4 C2AX3XX Y C2ASIYo o C2AWXXX X C2A3XXX WQ6.%-,/!G$(*%$/!0QG4 2AIYYo X 2A3YYo I 2AoXXX I 2AUWIo IO*%@#*@%.!0OQ4 C2AW3XX o C2AIIYo W C2AWXXX X C2A23XX XEdG!M!R,%&7,%.!0EdGCR4 2AUYYo I 2AoIYo 1 2AoXXX I 2AUWIo IEdG!M!O$:*7,%.!0EdGCO4 2A2IYo W 2A1IYo X 2A1YYo 1 2AUWIo IP$*.(#?!0PQ4 C2AIIYo U C2AU3XX Y C2AWXXX X C2A3XXX 1QQ!0QQ4 2A1XXX 1 C2AI3XX U C2AWXXX X 2AI1U2 X

d./&.%%,'(5!+AGALA5!K$(\,/F.95!QA`A

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AF&BA#!8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AFD

Page 142: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

! e$%!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%!I! 0N+I45! *6.!,(,/?9'9!$:! *6.!K"T"!;/,(.! 96$7.&! *6,*! #%'*.%',!7'*6!-$%.! 6.*.%$).(.$@9! <@&)C-.(*9!7.%.=! '(*.)%,*'$(!-,(,).-.(*!0T+45!#$--@('#,*'$(!.::.#*'F.(.99! 0GH45! ,(&! *'-.! -,(,).-.(*! 0Q+4A! "/9$5!

*'-.!-,(,).-.(*! 0Q+4! ,(&! #$--@('#,*'$(! .::.#*'F.(.99!0GH4!7.%.!$>9.%F.&A!Q6'9!-.,(9!*6,*!,##$%&'()!*$!N+I5!*6.!

#%'*.%'$(!&'&!($*!6,F.!)$$&!%.9@/*9!'(!*6.!/,9*!*7$!$(.95!,(&!F'#.CF.%9,A

I!,9!%./,*.&!*$!%.9$@%#.!,//$#,*'$(A!Q6.!9@>9?9*.-9!6,F.!/'-'*.&!%.9$@%#.9!*$!'(F.9*!'(!-,(,).%',/!,9;.#*9!%./,*.&!*$!.,#6!#%'*.C

,9!*$!*6.!,&$;*'$(!$:!-,(,).%',/!.F,/@,*'$(9J!*6'9!'9!76?!*6.!;.%:$%-,(#.9!&'::.%!'(!*6.!9@>)%$@;9A

;$'(*.&! *$! *6.! %')6*A! d.9'&.95! *6.! 9@>9?9*.-9!"G5! OQ! ,(&!PQ!,%.!,/7,?9!/$#,*.&!'(!,(!$;;$9'*.!&'%.#*'$(!*$!*6,*!$:!*6.!

0<@&)-.(*9!$:! /$7.%!F,/@.4!,(&5!#$(9.D@.(*/?5!6')6.%!#%'*'C#,/'*?5!76'#6!#,(!>.!$>9.%F.&!'(!*6%..!$@*!$:!*6.!:$@%!$%&.%9!

C-,*.!&'%.#*'$(95! ,9!7.//! ,9! *6$9.! %.:.%%'()! *$!GH!,(&!Q+5!

#%'*.%',!,%.!#$-;,%.&A! T(!%./,*'$(!*$!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%!X5!7.!$>9.%F.&!*6.!;%.9.(#.!$:!*7$!)%$@;9!$:!#%'*.%',!7'*6!*6.!9,-.!<@&)-.(*95!,(&!*6$9.!

P.%:$%-,(#.!HF,/@,*'$(!7'*6!PBE+HQRHH!KNOO!,(&!K"T"=!"!O*@&?!$(!*6.!TQ"CO"Q!O,*.//'*.!P%$<.#*

G6,%*!1A!P%.:.%.(#.!:@(#*'$(9!@9.&!>?!*6.!PBE+HQRHH!-.*6$&9A

G%'*.%'$( P%.:.%.(#.!:@(#*'$( K%,;6'#!%.;%.9.(*,*'$( G%'*.%'$( P%.:.%.(#.!:@(#*'$( K%,;6'#!%.;%.9.(*,*'$(

j9@,/ ;0&4 25 9. & 2I5 9. & p 2

# #%

1W.X

.2

I

c'(.,% & '

*;0&4

25 9. & D

D 5 9. D & 9

I5 9. & 9

!

"

!

!$

#$

"

#

$

%%

%%

1W.X

.-N2

I

j!e$%- ;0&4 25 9. & DI5 9. & D"

!# %

1W.X

.N2

I

K,@99',((

" ()*+;0&4

25 9. &

1& 59. &1

1

"

#

#$ $& '(

1W.X

.2

I

]!e$%-&

(;0&4

25 9. & D

9 5 9. & 9

I5 9. & 9

!

"

!#

#"

#

$

%%

%%

1W.X

.-2

I

+@/*'9*,).

(

!

!

!

"! " ,-./0*

#

#

#

* # *

"( "

1" 1;0&4

25 9. &

9 9.

9 9.

99 I 9. 9 1 9 I

9. %<

%

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! !

#

#

$$ $

$

"

#

$

%%%%%

%%%%%

1W.X

.1I 99CI2

I

IV-

l'*6!/.F./9

(!2;0&425 9. & D

5 9. D & 9I5 9. & 9

!

"

!

!# (1W.X

.-N2

I

2AUG!e$%-

(

!

"!

# *(;0&4

25 9. &

9& 9.

9. & 9

!

"

!#

#"

#

$

%%

%%

1W.X

.-2

I

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AF&BA#!8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AFE

Page 143: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

%.:.%%'()!*$!B+!7.%.!9'-'/,%!*$!*6$9.!$:!Q+J!*6.!$(.9!%.:.%C%'()!*$!GH!,%.!*6.!9,-.!,9!*6.!<@&)-.(*9!$:!T+A!d.9'&.95!*7$!

QQ5!OQ!,(&!"G5!,(&!*6.!9.#$(&!$(.!'9!#$-;%'9.&!$:!QG!,(&!EdGCRA!O$-.*6'()!9'-'/,%!6,;;.(.&!'(!%./,*'$(!*$!*6.!K"T"!;/,(.!$:!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%!W5!7'*6!9'-'/,%! <@&)-.(*9! :$%! *7$!#%'*.%',!0B+!,(&!Q+4!,(&!*7$!)%$@;9!$:!,#*'$(!7'*6!*6.!9,-.!

9.#$(&!PQ!,(&!"GA

*6,*!*6.!;/,(.9!>?!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%9!15!X!,(&!W!,%.!F.%?!9'-'/,%A!Q6.!)%$@;9!$:!#%'*.%',!$>9.%F.&! '(! *6.9.!;/,(.9! /.,&! *$! *6.!#$(#/@9'$(!*6,*!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%9!X!,(&!W!,99$#',*.&!B+!7'*6!Q+5!76'#6!,/9$!>%'()9!9'-'/,%'*'.9!>.*7..(!GH!,(&!T+A

=5-P/52/0/5BG8G

! ":*.%!*6.!'(&'F'&@,/!.F,/@,*'$(95!*6.!)/$>,/!,(,/?9'9!7,9!

$:!.,#6!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%!;%.9.(*.&!'(!Q,>/.!I!7.%.!@9.&!*$!-,8.!

$:!PBE+HQRHH!TT!7.%.!@9.&!7'*6!&,*,!'(!*6'9!;.%:$%-,(#.!

%.9@/*'()!'(!*6.!)%$@;!.F,/@,*'$(A! T*! '9!7$%*6! *$!-.(*'$(! *6,*!9@>9?9*.-9!"G5!OQ!,(&!PQ!7.%.! #$(9'&.%.&! ,9! *6.! -$9*! #%'*'#,/! $(.9! '(! *6.! )/$>,/!.F,/@,*'$(5!76'#6!'9!'(!,##$%&,(#.!7'*6!-,(?!$:!*6.!%.9@/*9!

9@>9?9*.-95!,!9.(9'*'F'*?!,(,/?9'9!7,9!;.%:$%-.&!7'*6! *6.!

G6,%*!XA! K"T"!;/,(.!$:!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%9!0'hI5!15!X5W4A

d./&.%%,'(5!+AGALA5!K$(\,/F.95!QA`A

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AF&BA#!8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!AFF

Page 144: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

'(*.%F,/9J! '(!>.*7..(5! *6.!7.')6*!F,/@.9!$:!.,#6!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%!#,(!F,%?!7'*6$@*!#6,()'()!*6.!;%'$%'*?!$%&.%!$:! *6.!9@>9?9*.-9A!"9!&.-$(9*%,*.&!'(!Q,>/.!X5! *6.!;%'$%'*?!$%&.%!'9!($*!.F.(!#6,().&!,:*.%!1Uq!,/*.%,*'$(9!0$%!-$%.4! '(! *6.!;$(&.%'()!$:!*6.!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%95!76'#6!-,8.9!*6.!;%'$%'*?!$:!*6.!9@>9?9*.-9!-$%.!,##.;*,>/.!:$%!*6'9!9*@&?A

! G6,%*!W!;%.9.(*9! *6.!K"T"!;/,(.!$:! *6.!)%$@;!&.#'9'$(5!

>.*7..(!N+I!,(&!*6.!$*6.%9A!"9!9..(5!N+I!'9!*6.!9,-.!*6,*!6,&!

,9;.#*!7,9!9..(!,9!,(!'(&'#,*'$(!*6,*!*6'9!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%!8(.7!-$%.!,>$@*!*6.!;%$<.#*!,(&5!#$(9.D@.(*/?5!6'9V6.%!<@&)-.(*!7,9!&'::.%.(*!:%$-!*6.!$*6.%95!9'(#.!*6.!).(.%,/!-,(,).%!;$(&.%.&!'*!,9!>.'()!*6.!-$9*!'-;$%*,(*!$(.!0,##$%&'()!*$!G6,%*!"W4A

-,8.%95!7.!($*'#.&!*6,*!N+I!;%.9.(*.&!*6.!*6%..!9@>9?9*.-9!OQ5!"G!,(&!PQ!,9!*6$9.!7'*6!*6.!7$%9*!;.%:$%-,(#.95!76'/.!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%9!1!,(&!X!#$(9'&.%!9@>9?9*.-9!"G5!PQ!,(&!QQ!

-,8.%!W5!76$!;%.9.(*9!0>.#,@9.!$:!*'.94!*6.!:$@%!9@>9?9*.-9!;%.F'$@9/?!;%.9.(*.&!0"G5!OQ!,(&!QQ4!,9!*6$9.!7'*6!*6.!7$%9*!;.%:$%-,(#.9A!O@#6!&'9#%.;,(#?!7,9!&'9#@99.&!'(!,!7$%896$;!7'*6! *6.! ).(.%,/! -,(,).%5! 7'*6! *6.! &.#'9'$(C-,8.%95! ,(&!*6.!$*6.%!-.->.%9!$:!*6.!*.,-A!Q6.!#$(9.(9@9!7,9!*6,*!*6.!

#$(9'&.%,*'$(9!$:!N+I!7.%.!-$%.!#$6.%.(*!*$!*6.!%.,/'*?!$:!*6.!;%$<.#*A!T*! '9! '-;$%*,(*!*$!9,?!*6,*!*6.!*6%..!9@>9?9*.-9!%.),%&.&!,9!6,F'()! *6.!7$%9*!;.%:$%-,(#.!>?! *6.!)%$@;!$:!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%9!#$'(#'&.&!7'*6!*6.!#6$'#.!$:!N+IA! l'*6!*6.!$><.#*'F.!$:!,&&%.99'()!*6.!,#*'$(9!,(&!'-;%$FC'()!*6.!;.%:$%-,(#.!7'*6'(!*6.!9@>9?9*.-9!*6,*!6,&!*6.!7$%9*!;.%:$%-,(#.5!,!#$-;/.-.(*,%?!,(,/?9'9!*$$8!;/,#.!*$!'&.(*':?!

#$(9'&.%,*'$(9! $:! .,#6! &.#'9'$(C-,8.%! '(! %./,*'$(! *$! .,#6!'(&'#,*$%!,(&!9@>9?9*.-!7.%.!,&&.&5!,9!;%.9.(*.&!'(!Q,>/.!WA!

"G5!'(!%./,*'$(!*$!*6.!#%'*.%'$(!Q+5!*6.!<@&)-.(*9!$:!&.#'C9'$(C-,8.%9!I5!15!X!,(&!W!'(!*6'9!#%'*.%'$(!7.%.!,&&.&5!,(&5!

! l'*6! *6'9! ;%$#.&@%.5! *6.! ;%'$%'*?! $%&.%9! *$! ;.%:$%-! *6.!'-;%$F.-.(*!,#*'$(9!'(!.,#6!9@>9?9*.-!7.%.!$>*,'(.&A!Q6.!-$9*!#%'*'#!9'*@,*'$(9!7.%.!'(!9@>9?9*.-9!"G!,(&!PQ5!#$(#.%(C'()!'(&'#,*$%!GH5!,(&!'(!*6.!9@>9?9*.-!OQ5!*6.!'(&'#,*$%!B+A!l'*6!*6'9!%.9@/*5!*6.!,@&'*'()!$:!*6.!'(&'#,*$%9!*6,*!;%.9.(*.&!7$%9.!;.%:$%-,(#.! '(! *6.! 9@>9?9*.-9!7,9!;%$;$9.&! *$! *6.!).(.%,/!-,(,).%A

P.%:$%-,(#.!HF,/@,*'$(!7'*6!PBE+HQRHH!KNOO!,(&!K"T"=!"!O*@&?!$(!*6.!TQ"CO"Q!O,*.//'*.!P%$<.#*

O@>9?9*.-9 N+I N+1 N+X N+W E%&.%

"**'*@&.!G$(*%$/!0"G4 C2AX3XX C2ASIYo C2AWXXX C2A3XXX C2AoIX oQ6.%-,/!G$(*%$/!0QG4 2AIYYo 2A3YYo 2AoXXX 2AUWIo 2AYWX 1O*%@#*@%.!0OQ4 C2AW3XX C2AIIYo C2AWXXX C2A23XX C2AUo2 UEdG!M!R,%&7,%.0EdG!C!R4 2AUYYo 2AoIYo 2AoXXX 2AUWIo 2A3Xo I

EdG!M!O$:*7,%.0EdG!C!O4 2A2IYo 2A1IYo 2A1YYo 2AUWIo 2A1Yo X

P$*.(#?!0PQ4 C2AIIYo C2AU3XX C2AWXXX C2A3XXX C2AU1o YQQ!0QQ4 2A1XXX C2AI3XX C2AWXXX 2AI1U2 2A2YX W

Q,>/.!XA! B,().!$:!F,%',*'$(!$:!*6.!7.')6*9A

N.#'9'$(C-,8.%9 +'('-@-!7.')6*!0q4

G@%%.(*!7.')6*!0q4 7.')6*!0q4

I I1AY3 X3A22 I22A22

1 2A22 I3A22 W3AI2

X 2A22 1YA22 I22A22

W 2A22 I3A22 I22A22

O@>9?9*.-9VG%'*.%', Q+ GH B+ T+

"**'*@&.!#$(*%$/!0"G4 U W Y U

O*%@#*@%.!0OQ4 o I2 Y I2

P$*.(#?!0PQ4 Y U Y o

G6,%*!WA!K"T"!;/,(.!$:!*6.!)%$@;!$:!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%9A

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AF&BA#!8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! AF#

Page 145: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

Q!"@N2(%">!&3$@#!%">

! Q6'9! 9*@&?! ,'-.&! ,*! '(F.9*'),*'()! *6.! ,;;/'#,*'$(! $:!PBE+HQRHH!KNOO! ,(&!K"T"!-.*6$&9! :$%! *6.! ;.%:$%C-,(#.!.F,/@,*'$(!'(!*6.!9@>9?9*.-9!$:!*6.!TQ"CO"Q!;%$<.#*A!d,9.&!$(!*6.!9*@&?5!,&F,(*,).9!7.%.!$>9.%F.&!,9!*$!*6.!@9.!$:!9@#6!-.*6$&9A

PBE+HQRHH!KNOO!.(,>/.&! *6.!6')6.%! ,&6.%.(#.!$:! *6.!*.,-!*$!*6.!$>*,'(.&!%.9@/*95!&@.!*$!*6.!;,%*'#';,*'$(!$:!&'::.%C.(*!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%95!.,#6!$(.!%.;%.9.(*'()!&'::.%.(*!'(*.%.9*9!'(9'&.!*6.!;%$<.#*A

$:! ;%.:.%.(#.! :@(#*'$(95! *6.! >.6,F'$%! $:! *6.! F,/@.9! )'F.(!>?! &.#'9'$(C-,8.%9! '(! %./,*'$(! *$! &'::.%.(*! ;.%:$%-,(#.9!;%.9.(*.&!>?!,!#%'*.%'$(!#,(!>.!96,;.&!'(!,!7,?!*$!).*!>.**.%!,##@%,#?!,9!*$!*6.!#6,%,#*.%'9*'#95!76'#6!,%.!%.,//?!F,/@,>/.!:$%!*6.!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%9A

;%.:.%.(#.!>.*7..(!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%9!,(&!#%'*.%',5!76'#6!#,(!>.!@9.&!*$!#6.#8!,!#$(9.(9@9!,-$()!*6.-A

*$! >.! .99.(*',/!76.(! *6.! %.9@/*9!7.%.! ;%.9.(*.&! &@%'()! ,!-..*'()! :$%! *6.!$*6.%!;%$<.#*!-.->.%9A!Q6.%.:$%.5! '*!7,[email protected]*'$(.&!':! *6.%.!7,9! *6.!;,%*'#';,*'$(!$:!-.->.%9!7'*6!

HF.(! *6$@)6! *6.! PBE+HQRHH!KNOO!-.*6$&! &$.9! ($*!%.9*%'#*!*6.!(@->.%!$:!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%9!:$%!*6.!;.%:$%-,(#.!$:! <@&)-.(*95! *6.'%!(@->.%!#,(!>.! /'-'*.&!&@.! *$! *6.! /,#8!$:! ,##.99'>'/'*?! $:! *6.! :,#'/'*,*$%! ,(&V$%! >.#,@9.! $:! *6.'%!

Q6.%.:$%.5! *6.!).(.%,/!-,(,).%!7,9!,98.&!*$!;$'(*!$@*! *6.!-$9*! '-;$%*,(*! &.#'9'$(C-,8.%95! '(&'#,*'()! *6.! :$@%!$(.9!-.(*'$(.&!'(!*6'9!9*@&?A! T(! $%&.%! *$! ,99'9*! *6.! ).(.%,/! -,(,).%! '(! :,#'()! *6.!;%$>/.-9!$:!*6.!;%$<.#*5!'-;%$F.-.(*!,#*'$(9!7.%.!;%$;$9.&!$(! *6.! 9@>9?9*.-9! ,(&! '(&'#,*$%9! *6,*! ;%.9.(*.&! 7$%9.!;.%:$%-,(#.9A!O@#6!,#*'$(9!#$(9'9*.&!$:!#%.,*'()!$%!'-;%$FC

C-.(*!;/,(!'9!%.F'9.&!,(&!@;&,*.&J!@;&,*'()!*6.!-,(,).-.(*!;/,(5!'(!$%&.%!*$!'(F$/F.!*6.!%.;%.9.(*,*'F.9!$:!*6.!;%$<.#*m9!9@>9?9*.-9J! '-;/.-.(*'()!-.#6,('9-9!$:! /.,%(.&!/.99$(9J!#$(9$/'&,*'()! ,! 9?9*.-! $:! ;.%'$&'#! .F,/@,*'$(V,@&'*'()J!&.F./$;'()!-.*6$&9!*$!-,8.!9@%.!.,#6!-.->.%!$:!*6.!*.,-!

'9!>.'()!'(9*%@#*.&!,9!*$!*6.!,#*'F'*'.9!*$!>.!;.%:$%-.&5!,(&5!

*6.!;%$<.#*!6,F.!:..&>,#8!$(!*6.'%!;.%:$%-,(#.A! T(!%./,*'$(!*$!*6.!/'-'*,*'$(9!$:!*6'9!9*@&?5!'*!'9!'-;$%*,(*!*$!9,?!*6,*!7.!&'&!($*!#$(9'&.%!*6.!#%'*.%',!G+!,(&!r+5!76'#6!

C-,(#.!%,(8'()!$:!*6.!9@>9?9*.-9A!T(!*6'9!9.(9.5!'*!'9!#/.,%!*6,*!*6.!%.9@/*9!$>*,'(.&!'(!*6'9!9*@&?!&$!($*!#$-;/.*./?!96$7!*6.!).(.%,/!;.%:$%-,(#.!$:!.,#6!9@>9?9*.-5!>@*!*6.'%!;.%:$%-,(#.!'(!%./,*'$(!*$!*6.!#%'*.%',!Q+5!GH5!B+!,(&!T+A!d.9'&.95!*6.!,&$;*.&!9#,/[email protected]!D@,/'*,*'F.!/.F./9!0#$(#.%('()!*6.!:$//$7'()!

76'#6!;$99'>/?!%.9@/*.&!'(!*6.!'-;%.#'9'$(!$:!<@&)-.(*9A! e'(,//?5! *6.!9@)).9*'$(!'9! *6,*!:@*@%.!%.9.,%#6.%9!;.%:$%-!9*@&'.9!7'*6!*6.!$><.#*'F.!$:!6,(&/'()!*6.!;%.9.(*.&!/'-'*,*'$(95!

*6.'%! <@&)-.(*9! #$(#.%('()! #$9*! ,(&! D@,/'*?! '(&'#,*$%9! '(!'(($F,*'$(!;%$<.#*95!>.!'*!7'*6!*6.!#$(9*%@#*'$(!$:!9#,/.!$:!<@&)C

e@%*6.%-$%.5!'*!'9!;$99'>/.!*$!'(F.9*'),*.!*6.!@9.!$:!$*6.%!+GN"!-.*6$&9!*$!.F,/@,*.!*6.!;.%:$%-,(#.!$:!.,#6!9@>9?9*.-A

$3Q3$3"(3>

"/.(#,%5!+A!RA!,(&!"/-.'&,5!"A!QA5!12I25!f"!-$&./!:$%!9./.#*C'()!;%$<.#*!*.,-!-.->.%9!@9'()!-@/*'#%'*.%',!)%$@;!&.#'9'$(!-,8'()g5!P.9D@'9,!E;.%,#'$(,/5!]$/A!X25!L$A!I5!;;A!11ICXYA!NET=!I2AIUS2VO2I2ICoWX312I2222I222II

!"#$%&5!12I25!fPBE+HQRHH=!"!#$-;%.6.(C9'F.! /'*.%,*@%.! %.F'.7!$(!-.*6$&$/$)'.9! ,(&! ,;;/'#,*'$(9g5!H@%$;.,(!`$@%(,/!$:!E;.%,*'$(,/!B.9.,%#65!]$/A!1225!L$A!I5!;;A!IS3C1IUA!NET=!I2AI2IYV<A.<$%A122SA2IA21I

!"#$%&5!12II5!fPBE+HQRHH!K%$@;!N.#'9'$(!O@;;$%*!O?9*.-!,(&!*6.!R$@9.!$:!r@,/'*?g5!K%$@;!N.#'9'$(!,(&!L.)$*',*'$(5!;;A!ICIoA!NET=!I2AI22oV9I2o1YC2IICS1UoCX

d./*$(5!]A!,(&!O*.7,%*5!QA!`A5!12215!f+@/*';/.!#%'*.%',!&.#'C9'$(! ,(,/?9'9g5! H&A! k/@7.%!"#,&.-'#! P@>/'96.%95! j('*.&!k'()&$-5!Xo1!;A

!"# $%&5! 12II5! f"F,/',\_$! &.! &.9.-;.(6$!-@/*'#%'*a%'$!#$-$!,;$'$!s!).9*_$!&.!.-;%.9,9=!,;/'#,\_$!.-!@-,!.-;%.9,!&.!9.%F'\$9g5!K.9*_$!t!P%$&@\_$5!]$/A!I35!L$A!X5!;;A!YXXCU2A!NET=!I2AIUS2VO2I2WCUX2u12II222X222IW

d./&.%%,'(5!+AGALA5!K$(\,/F.95!QA`A

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AF&BA#!8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A#%

Page 146: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&5!12I25!f"F,/',\_$!&.!&.9.-;.(6$!&$9!,9;.#*$9!*,()vF.'9!.!'(*,()vF.'9!&,!̂ %.,!&.!-.%#,&$=!H9*@&$!&.!#,9$!.-!@-,!-a&',!.-;%.9,!'(&@9*%',/g5!B.F'9*,!d%,9'/.'%,!&.!K.9*_$!&.!L.)w#'$95!]$/A!I15!L$A!Xo5!;;A!WXUCWYA

d%,(95! `A! PA! ,(&!+,%.9#6,/5! dA5! ISSW5! fQ6.! PBE+G"cG!t!K"T"!&.#'9'$(!9@;;$%*!9?9*.-!:$%!-@/*'#%'*.%',!&.#'9'$(!,'&g5!N.#'9'$(!O@;;$%*!O?9*.-95!]$/A!I15!;;A!1SoCXI2A!NET=!I2AI2IYV2IYoCS1XY0SW4S22W3CU

H(99/'(5!cA#!"#$%&5!12I25!f"F,/',\_$!&$!&.9.-;.(6$!&.!.-;%.C

,;$'$!s!&.#'9_$!M!#$(9*%@*'F'9*,g5!P.9D@'9,!E;.%,#'$(,/5!]$/A!X25!L$A!I5!;;A!I1UCU1A

HO"! M! H@%$;.,(! O;,#.!").(#?5! 122S5! fHGOOC+COQCI2G!M!O;,#.!;%$<.#*!-,(,).-.(*=!P%$<.#*!;/,(('()!,(&! T-;/.C-.(*,*'$(g5!B.*%'.F.&!'(!12I1!e.>A!o5!:%$-!6**;=VV777A.#99A(/V:$%@-9V.#99Vx*.-;/,*.9V&.:,@/*A6*-y*,%).*h6**;=VV777A.#99A(/VA

N@*%,5! "A5! 12235! fO'9*.-,! &.! "F,/',\_$! &.! N.9.-;.(6$!&,9!O.#%.*,%',9! &.!N.9.(F$/F'-.(*$!B.)'$(,/! &$!K$F.%($!&$! H9*,&$! &.! O,(*,! G,*,%'(,=! B.9@/*,&$9! P%./'-'(,%.9! &,!";/'#,\_$!&.!@-!+$&./$!G$(9*%@*'F'9*,g5!P%$#..&'()9!$:!*6.!H(#$(*%$! &.!"&-'('9*%,\_$!Pz>/'#,! .!K$F.%(,(\,5!]$/A! I5!O,/F,&$%5!d%,9'/5!;;A!ICIYA

e%.'*,95!"A!cA!PA!!"#$%&=!122S5!fH-;%.)$!&.!@-,!,>$%&,).-!

&.!H(9'($!O@;.%'$%g5!H(9,'$=!"F,/',\_$!&.!P$/v*'#,9!Pz>/'#,9!.-!H&@#,\_$5!]$/A!Io5!L$A!YU5!;;A!YUUCoWA!NET=!I2AIUS2VO2I2WCW2XY122S222W2222Y

K,//$(5!"A!]A!!"#$%& C#'$(,/!.-!'(#@>,&$%,9!&.!.-;%.9,9!;$%!-.'$!&,!-.*$&$/$)',!-@/*'#%'*a%'$!&.!,;$'$!s!&.#'9_$!#$(9*%@*'F'9*,!0+GN"CG4=!,!

T($F,\_$5!]$/A!35!L$A!I5!;;A!XoCYXA

K$-.95!GA!eA!OA!,(&!K$-.95!cA!eA!"A!+A5!122I5!f"!:@(\_$!&.!&.#'9_$!-@/*'#%'*a%'$!M!P,%*.! T=!N$9!#$(#.'*$9!>^9'#$9!s!-$&./,).-!-@/*'#%'*a%'$g5!B.F'9*,!&$!+.9*%,&$!.-!"&-'('9*C%,\_$!.!N.9.(F$/F'-.(*$!H-;%.9,%',/5!]$/A!15!L$A!X5!B.*%'.F.&!'(!12I1!e.>A!o5!:%$-!6**;=VV777A.9*,#'$A>%V%.F'9*,-,&.V2XVA

R,?.95!rA!!"#$%&

P%$#..&'()9!$:!*6.!IX*6!T(*.%(,*'$(,/!G$(:.%.(#.!T(:$%-,*'$(!]'9@,/'9,*'$(5!]$/A!I5!d,%#./$(,5!;;A!1WoCUIA!NET=!I2AII2SVT]A122SAIU

k$6/.%5! jA! ,(&! c@(',85!+A5! 122U5! fN,*,! '(9;.#*'$(! @9'()!>';/$*g5!Q6.!O*,*,!`$@%(,/5!FA!U5!(A!15!;;A!123C11XA

,(&! N.9')(g5! XA! .&A5! H&A! +'#%$#$9-5! P.((9?/F,(',! O*,*.!j('F.%9'*?5!j('*.&!O*,*.95!SYS!;A

c.!Qa($5!`A!eA!,(&!+,%.9#6,/5!dA5!ISS35!f"(!'(*.%F,/!F.%9'$(!$:!PBE+HQRHH!:$%! *6.!#$-;,%'9$(!$:!>@'/&'()!;%$&@#*9m!

C;.,(!`$@%(,/!$:!E;.%,*'$(9!B.9.,%#65!]$/A!I2S5!;;A!U11CU1SA!NET=!I2AI2IYVO2XooC11Io0S34222oWCU

+,#6,%'95!GA!!"#$%&5!12I25!fPBE+HQRHH!'(!,!-@/*'!,#*$%9!9.**'()=! *6.! @9.! $:! *6.! -@/*'! ,#*$%! -@/*'! #%'*.%',! ,(,/?9'9!0+"+G"4!-.*6$&$/$)?!7'*6!NCOTKRQg5!P%$#..&'()9!$:!*6.!EBU1!G$(:.%.(#.5!c$(&$(5!H()/,(&A

+,#6,%'95!GA!!"#$%&=!ISS35!fQ6.!KNOO!PBE+HQRHH!;%$#.&@%.=!,!PBE+HQRHHCK"T"!>,9.&!;%$#.&@%.! :$%!)%$@;!&.#'9'$(!9@;;$%*g5!`$@%(,/!$:!N.#'9'$(!O?9*.-95!]$/A!o5!;;A!13XCX2oA

+,#6,%'95! GA! !"# $%&5! 122W5! fPBE+HQRHH! ,(&!"RP=!Q6.!&.9')(! $:! $;.%,*'$(,/! 9?(.%)'.9! '(!-@/*'#%'*.%',! ,(,/?9'9! M!O*%.()*6.('()!PBE+HQRHH!7'*6!'&.,9!$:!"RPg5!H@%$;.,(!`$@%(,/!$:!E;.%,*'$(,/!B.9.,%#65!]$/A!IUX5!;;A!X2oCXIoA!NET=!I2AI2IYVO2XooC11Io02X422IUXCu

+,%.9#6,/5!dA!,(&!d%,(95!̀ A!PA5!IS335!fK.$-.*%'#,/!%.;%.9.(*,C*'$(9!:$%!+GN"g5!H@%$;.,(!`$@%(,/!$:!E;.%,*'$(,/!B.9.,%#65!]$/A!XW5!;;A!YSCooA!NET=!I2AI2IYV2XooC11Io0334S2WUYC2

H&A!"/*,!d$$895!B'$!&.!`,(.'%$5!d%,9'/5!SY2!;A

L,9#'-.(*$5!OA!!"#$%&5!12II5!f+,;.,-.(*$!&$9!'(&'#,&$%.9!&.!C

1223g5!B.F'9*,!&.!"&-'('9*%,\_$5!]$/A!WY5!L$A!W5!;;A!XoXCXSIA!NET=!I2AUo22V%,@9;I2I3

P.%:$%-,(#.!HF,/@,*'$(!7'*6!PBE+HQRHH!KNOO!,(&!K"T"=!"!O*@&?!$(!*6.!TQ"CO"Q!O,*.//'*.!P%$<.#*

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AF&BA#!8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A#&

Page 147: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&5!12II5!f+@/*'C#%'*.%',!,(,/?9'9!$:!9$'/!;$//@C*'$(!>?!6.,F?!-.*,/9!'(!*6.!F'#'('*?!$:!*6.!G$;;.%!O-./*'()!P/,(*! '(!d$%! 0O.%>',4g5!]$/A! oY5!L$A! W5! ;;A! Y1UCYWIA!NET=!I2A11S3V`OGI2231X2UW

P+T!M!P%$<.#*!+,(,).-.(*! T(9*'*@*.5!12235!fP+dEk!M!"!K@'&.!*$!*6.!P%$<.#*!+,(,).-.(*!d$&?!$:!k($7/.&).g5!H&A!P%$<.#*!+,(,).-.(*!T(9*'*@*.5!P.((9?/F,(',5!j('*.&!O*,*.9A

#%'*.%',!.F,/@,*'$(! %.9@/*!$(!#6$'#.!$:!;%.:.%.(#.! :@(#*'$(9!,(&!*6.'%!;,%,-.*.%9g5!Q.#6($/$)'#,/!,(&!H#$($-'#!N.F./$;C-.(*!$:!H#$($-?5!]$/A!IY5!L$A!I5!;;A!IWXCIU3A!NET=!I2AX3WYV*.&.A12I2A2S

B$?5!dA5!ISSY5!f+@/*'#%'*.%',!-.*6$&$/$)?!:$%!&.#'9'$(!,'&'()g5!H&A!k/@7.%!"#,&.-'#!P@>/'96.%95!c$(&$(5!H()/,(&5!1S1!;A

O,*$5!cA!RA!OA!!"#$%&5!122S5!fTQ"O"Q!M!N.9.(F$/F'-.(*$!&.!@-!#$-;@*,&$%!&.!>$%&$!*$/.%,(*.!,!:,/6,9!#$-!#$-@('#,\_$!;,&%_$!

H()'(..%'()!t!";;/'#,*'$(95!O_$!`$9a!&$9!G,-;$95!d%,9'/A

O,*$5! cA! RA! OA! !"# $%&5! 12II5! fTQ"O"QCI=! @-,! ;%$;$9*,! &.!#$(*'(@'&,&.!&$!9'9*.-,!>%,9'/.'%$!&.!#$/.*,!&.!&,&$9!,->'C.(*,'9g5! T(! P%$#..&'()9! $:! *6.!u]!O'-;w9'$!d%,9'/.'%$! &.!O.(9$%',-.(*$!B.-$*$5!G@%'*'>,5!d%,9'/A

O'/F,5!]A!dA!OA5!!"#$%&5!12I25!f"!-@/*'#%'*.%',!)%$@;!&.#'9'$(!

B.9$@%#.!+,(,).-.(*5!]$/A!1W5!L$A!IW5!;A!W2oUCSIA!NET=!I2AI22oV9II1YSC2I2CSYW3C1

Q.%%'>'/'!e'/6$5!"A5!12I25!fT(&'#,&$%.9!&.!).%.(#',-.(*$!&.!;%$<.*$9=!+$('*$%,\_$!#$(*v(@,g5!H&A!+A!d$$895!O_$!P,@/$5!d%,9'/5!IXY!;A

C./,95!da/)'#,5!IUW!;A

b./.(?5! +A5! IS315! +@/*';/.! #%'*.%',! &.#'9'$(! -,8'()5!H&A+#K%,7!R'//5!L$F,!{$%85!j('*.&!O*,*.95!IS31A!UYX!;A

@OO*0?8 2 F6?E.*07G2/0?29*8E:7G2-,27:*2?*18G8-0C./ *+G

G6,%*!"I=! N.#'9'$(C-,8.%!IG%'*.%', Q+ GH B+ T+"**'*@&.!G$(*%$/!0"G4 1 I X 1Q6.%-,/!G$(*%$/!0QG4 W W I 1O*%@#*@%.!0OQ4 1 1 I WEdG!M!R,%&7,%.!0EdGCR4 X W X WEdG!M!O$:*7,%.!0EdGCO4 X 1 1 WP$*.(#?!0PQ4 1 1 X XQQ!0QQ4 X W 1 X

G6,%*!"1=! N.#'9'$(C-,8.%!1G%'*.%', Q+! GH B+ T+"**'*@&.!G$(*%$/!0"G4 I I I IQ6.%-,/!G$(*%$/!0QG4 W W X WO*%@#*@%.!0OQ4 1 X 1 1EdG!M!R,%&7,%.!0EdGCR4 X W W WEdG!M!O$:*7,%.!0EdGCO4 X X 1 1P$*.(#?!0PQ4 1 I I 1QQ!0QQ4 1 1 X X

G6,%*!"X=! N.#'9'$(C-,8.%!XG%'*.%', Q+ GH B+ T+"**'*@&.!G$(*%$/!0"G4 I I I IQ6.%-,/!G$(*%$/!0QG4 1 1 1 1O*%@#*@%.!0OQ4 I I I IEdG!M!R,%&7,%.!0EdGCR4 1 1 1 1EdG!M!O$:*7,%.!0EdGCO4 1 I 1 IP$*.(#?!0PQ4 I I I IQQ!0QQ4 I I I I

G6,%*!"W=! N.#'9'$(C-,8.%!WG%'*.%', Q+ GH B+ T+"**'*@&.!G$(*%$/!0"G4 I I I IQ6.%-,/!G$(*%$/!0QG4 X W X WO*%@#*@%.!0OQ4 1 W 1 XEdG!M!R,%&7,%.!0EdGCR4 X W X WEdG!M!O$:*7,%.!0EdGCO4 X W X WP$*.(#?!0PQ4 I I I IQQ!0QQ4 X X X X

G6,%*!"U=! l.')6*9!$:!#%'*.%',!,(&!&.#'9'$(C-,8.%9

N.#'9'$(!-,8.% Q+ GH B+ T+ l.')6*9!$:!

&.#'9'$(!-,8.%9N+I 2AX2 2AX2 2AX2 2AI2 2AX3N+1 2AW2 2AW2 2AI2 2AI2 2AI3N+X 2A12 2AX2 2AW2 2AI2 2A1YN+W 2A1U 2A1U 2A1U 2A1U 2AI3

!

d./&.%%,'(5!+AGALA5!K$(\,/F.95!QA`A

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()AF&BA#!8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A#!

Page 148: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&'(%#)*+ ,-#).%/01+ 23&%.%4)&%"#+)#(+ 5"#&6"*+ "7+ 8%6/6)7&+ 96)#0%&%"#+:)#;'<;6+=0%#$+8;6"(-#).%/+>;/&"6%#$

!"#$#%&$'())"*$#+$#,%-./0#)1),2/$1%3#24.5(26+78%*$#+$#,%!4.#9.%:%;2#,$<)5.&8=888>?.@#69@."9@(,

-0.(2(%(9AB266."%C)5%D0E%".,5..%2#%&./0$#2/$1%$#"%!.5)(<$/.%F#,2#..52#,%$6%*$#+$#,%-./0#)1),2/$1%3#24.5(26+G%;2#,$<)5.G%2#%H8IH@

8(<%0"6?%E)/6)5%-2$9J%K2)#,%L)

@;-A"6(0?%!.5)"+#$B2/%4./6)52#,G%M$52$A1.N2#/2".#/.%J2#,G%-5$#(262)#% B$#.94.5(G% K)4.5N6)N/592(.G% O592(.N6)N0)4.5G%P12,06%"+#$B2/(@

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

9C;0%0+)B0&6)/&0!"#$%$&'(#)*%+,&$&*($%("&%-.$(,-'(%)/%0)$(%,&'&*(%1-$(&,%),%2"3%("&$#$%,&4-(&5%()%-&,)$+-'&%(&'"*)4)67%-*5%0-*-6&0&*(

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A#ABA#$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A#A

Page 149: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

D;)*+9%.;+26B%&+,;&;6.%#)&%"#+&C6"'$C+E"#*%#;)6+F%$.)GH"%#&+@)*.)#+I%*&;6

D$91$%O52(62$#.%D2#6)%&.('926$%D$5"$1X#(62696)%*$/2)#$1%".%D.('92($(%F(<$/2$2(;^)%_)(`%")(%O$B<)(Y;D%:%\5$[21<$91$/52(62$#.?,B$21@/)B

-0.(2(%(9AB266."%C)5%D0E%".,5..%2#%!.5)(<$/.%-./0#)1),+%$6% X#(62696)%*$/2)#$1%".%D.('92($(%F(<$/2$2(G%;^)% _)(`%")(%O$B<)(G%;^)%D$91)%;6$6.G%\5$[21G%2#%H8II@

8(<%0"60?%E)/6)5(%K.12)%a)262%a9,$%$#"%])")1<0)%M210.#$%".%&)5$.(

@;-A"6(0?%;6$6.%.(62B$62)#% 60.)5+G%*)#12#.$5%(2,B$N<)2#6%C216.5(G% b5A26% ".6.5B2#$62)#G% LD;% B.$(95.B.#6(G% b5A26%<.5695A$62)#(@

8B0&6)/&?% X#% 602(%J)5T% 60.%)5A26%)C% $#%$562 /2$1% ($6.1126.% 2(%".6.5B2#."G%2#%5.$1%62B.G%9(2#,%(2,#$1(%C5)B%LD;%/)#(6.11$62)#%$#"%B)".5#%.(62B$62)#%6./0#2'9.(@%-0.%B$2#%)AZ./624.%2(%6)%2B<5)4.%60.%<.5C)5B$#/.%)C%)5A26%".6.5B2#$62)#%<5)/."95.(G%$#"G%/)#/)B26$#61+G%6)%B2#2B2[.%60.%/)B<96$62)#$1%<5)/."95.%/)(6G% $(()/2$6."% J260% 60.% $<<12/$62)#% )C% (9/0% B)".5#%.(62B$62)#% 6./0#2'9.(% 6)% 60.% <5)A1.B% )C% ($6.1126.(% )5A26%".6.5B2#$62)#@%!%#)#12#.$5% 16.5G%A$(."%)#%60.%;2,B$ND)2#6%B.60)"G%0$(%A..#%".4.1)<."G%6)%.(62B$6.%60.%(6$6.%4./6)5%60$6%".(/52A.(%60.%($6.1126.%)5A26G%A$(."%9<%)#%$%(.6%)C%B.$(95.B.#6(%C5)B% 60.% LD;% (+(6.B@% !<<12/$62)#(G% <.5C)5B$#/.% $#"%$//95$/+%6.(6(%0$4.%A..#%")#.G%9(2#,%5.$1%"$6$%C5)B%-bDFcYD)(.2")#%($6.1126.@%].(916(%C5)B%)5A26%<5)<$,$62)#%$#"%)5A26%".6.5B2#$62)#%0$4.%A..#%$#$1+[."@%X#%)5A26%<5)<$,$62)#G%60.%B$2#% .CC./6(% 60$6% $CC./6% 60.% )5A26% )C% 60.% 6.(6% ($6.1126.%J.5.%.4$19$6."W%F$560 (%,5$426$62)#$1% .1" %;9#N&))#%,5$426$62)#$1%$665$/62)# % $#"% "25./6% ()1$5% 5$"2$62)#% <5.((95.@% -0.% )5A26%".6.5B2#$62)#% ()1962)#(% )A6$2#."% C)5% 60.% #)#12#.$5% (2,B$N<)2#6%a$1B$#% 16.5G%2#%26(%9#(/.#6."%4.5(2)#G%J.5.%/)B<$5."%J260% $% 5.C.5.#/.% ()1962)#G% )A6$2#."% 605)9,0% 60.% .S6.#"."%a$1B$#% 16.5@%X#%)5A26%".6.5B2#$62)#G%60.%<.5C)5B$#/.(%)C%60.%.(62B$6)5(%J.5.%.'924$1.#6%J0.#%60.%2#262$1%/)#"262)#(%J.5.%$//95$6.@%!#"%B)5.G%60.%#)#12#.$5%9#(/.#6."% 16.5%0$(%(0)J#%B)5.%5)A9(6#.((%2#%60.%(269$62)#(%2#%J02/0%60.%62B.%A.6J..#%6J)%)A(.54$62)#(%J$(%B)5.%(<$/."%)5%60.%2#262$1%/)#"262)#(%)C%60.%(6$6.%4./6)5%".,5$"."@%].,$5"2#,%60.%<5)/.((2#,%62B.%/)(6G%)#.%4.52 ."%60$6%60.%#)#12#.$5%9#(/.#6."%a$1B$#% 16.5%".B$#"(%B)5.%OD3% 62B.% 60$#% 60.% .S6.#"."%a$1B$#% 16.5G%

A./$9(.%)C%60.%A$(2/%#$695.%)C%60.%$1,)5260B@%\.(2".(G%60.%B)5.%/)B<1.S%2(%60.%"+#$B2/$1%B)".1G%60.%,5.$6.5%26%J211%A.%60.%62B.%#.."."% 6)%<5)/.((% 60.% (6$6.%4./6)5% 60$6%".(/52A.(% 60.%)5A26@%-0.%5))6%B.$#%('9$5.%.55)5(%)C%60.%<)(262)#%.(62B$6.(G%J02/0%/)B<)#.#6(%J.5.%65$#(1$6."%6)%60.%)5A26$1%5.C.5.#/.%C5$B.G%$5.%$5)9#"%I=%B.6.5(%/)4.52#,%Hd%0)95(%)C%)5A26%".6.5B2#$62)#G%C)5%60.%B)(6%<5./2(.%"+#$B2/$1%B)".1%$")<6."@%;9/0%.(62B$6.(%J.5.%)A6$2#."%C)5%60.%5.(916(%C5)B%60.%9#(/.#6."%a$1B$#% 16.5%$(%J.11%$(%60.%.S6.#"."%a$1B$#% 16.5@

J-B6%(+ F&6'/&'6;0+ 7"6+ K)**%0&%/+ 86."6?+F&'(%;0+"#+5;6).%/LH"*-.;6+M#&;67)/;

a$52#$%P.55.25$%".%*)5)#0$X#(62696)%-./#)1e,2/)%".%!.5)#f962/$;^)%_)(`%")(%O$B<)(Y;D%:%\5$[21#$gT$52#$?+$0))@/)B@A5

-0.(2(% (9AB266."% C)5% &$(6.5% ".,5..% 2#% !.5)#$962/$1% $#"%&./0$#2/$1% F#,2#..52#,% $6% X#(62696)% -./#)1e,2/)% ".%!.5)#f962/$G%;^)%_)(`%")(%O$B<)(G%;^)%D$91)%;6$6.G%\5$[21G%2#%H8IH@

8(<%0"6?%E)/6)5%O52(62#$%&)#2[%!5$9Z)%h)<.(

@;-A"6(0?% !5B)5% (02.1"2#,G% !"0.(24.% 2#6.5C$/.G% K+A52"%1$B2#$6.(

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a.41$5 RY$19B2#$% <$#.1(@%-0.%/0$5$/6.52[$62)#%)C%60.%A)#"2#,%2#6.5C$/.%J$(%<.5C)5B."%A+%B.$#(%)C%60.%<..1%(65.#,60%Q-ND..1R%$#"%<)(6N6.(6%(95C$/.%/0$5$/6.52[$62)#%J$(%<.5C)5B."%A+%)<62/$1%B2/5)(/)<+%$#"%P)952.5%-5$#(C)5B%X#C5$5."%QP-NX]R%(<./65)(/)<+@%-0.(.%6.(6(%(0)J."% 60$6G% 2#% 60.% /)B<)(26.% 9(2#,%E+#..B$ G% 60.% <..1%(65.#,60%J$(% (2B21$5% C)5% $11% 60.% $"0.(24.(% 9(."G% 2#"2/$62#,%60$6% C$2195.%)//955."%J2602#% 60.%<)1+B.52/%(9A(65$6.% 1$+.5(@%K)J.4.5G% 2#% 60.% a.41$5 % ($B<1.(G% 60.% <.5C)5B$#/.% )C%

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A#ABA#$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A#"

Page 150: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

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

2#+&C;+,;<;*"3.;#&+"7+J-B6%(+H"*-.;6L5;6).%/+5".3"0%&;0+7"6+K)**%0&%/+86."6

_912$#$%&$/0$")%"$%&)6$X#(62696)%-./#)1e,2/)%".%!.5)#f962/$;^)%_)(`%")(%O$B<)(Y;D%:%\5$[21Z912$#$?$116.//)B<)(26.(@/)B@A5

-0.(2(% (9AB266."% C)5% &$(6.5% ".,5..% 2#% !.5)#$962/$1% $#"%&./0$#2/$1%F#,2#..52#,%$6%X#(62696)%-./#)1e,2/)%".%!.5)#f962/$G%;^)%_)(`%")(%O$B<)(G%;^)%D$91)%;6$6.G%\5$[21G%2#%H8II@

8(<%0"60?%E)/6)5(%P5$#/2(/)%O52(6)4^)%h)95.#i)%".%&.1)%$#"%O52(62#$%&)#2[%!5$9Z)%h)<.(

@;-A"6(0?%!5B)5G%K+A52"%/)B<)(26.(G%O)B<12$#6%1$B2#$6.(@

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a.41$5 R% $#"% 9165$% 02,0%B)1./91$5% J.2,06% <)1+.60+1.#.% Q3K&jDFR% C2A.5(%QE+#..B$ R@%&)2(695.%$A()5<62)#G% 1)J%(<.."%B./0$#2/$1%6.(6G%A$112(62/%5.(2(6$#/.%Q=@k%S%7I%BB%$BB9#262)#R%$#"%<)(6N2B<$/6%"$B$,.%$#$1+(2(%J.5.%9(."%6)%.4$19$6.%60.%.CC./6%)C%/)# ,95$62)#%2#%60.%0+A52"%<$#.1(@%X#%$""262)#G%60.%/)(6%$#"%J.2,06%)C%60.%<$#.1(%J.5.%$1()%6$T.#%2#6)%/)#(2".5$62)#@%-0.%.4$19$62)#%)C% 60.%)4.5$11%<.5C)5B$#/.%)C%0+A52"(%(0)J."%60$6% /)# ,95$62)#% EaE/% :% $% ($#"J2/0% 12T.% $5/026./695.%J260% a.41$5 % QaR% $(% /)5.% B$6.52$1G% E+#..B$ % QER% $(%(T2#% 1$+.5(%J260%$19B2#$Y#2)A2$Q/R%$(% 2B<$/6% C5)#6% C$/.%:%<5.(.#6."%60.%A.(6%/)BA2#$62)#%)C%$5.$1%".#(26+G%/)(6%)C%60.%<$#.1G%.#425)#B.#6$1% 5.(2(6$#/.%$#"%A$112(62/%.C /2.#/+@% X#%60.% /)# ,95$62)#%EaE/G% 26%J$(%<)((2A1.% 6)% $((.BA1.% 60.%<5)<.562.(% )C%a.41$5 % Q,))"% 6.B<.5$695.% 5.(2(6$#/.G% 1)J%<1$(62/% ".C)5B$62)#% $#"% 1)J% /)(6R%J260% 60.% <5)<.562.(% )C%E+#..B$ % QA.66.5% 2B<$/6% 5.(2(6$#/.G% 1)J.5% ".#(26+% $#"%B)2(695.%5.(2(6$#/.R@

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A#ABA#$8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A#$

Page 151: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!""#$#!"#$%&#'()*#+%&'()'*+,-&.&/+01+23),.)(.4%5.'&-&3/&'.1,6&'.&71+2)'3+0.8-3,2300+23),,-#.(/01-2304-#56/0#7#8&90-#4::;-#<<0#1;=-#$%&#9())&9$#9><$?("#?"#@?A6)&#4#?BC@?A6)&4C#DE6>$()?>/#F(6"$>?"#$%>$#A?G&B#)?B&#$(#$%&#&E6>$()?>/#>"(H>/I#JK>#L&>6M>)N?&)&-#O0#!"#$%&'#4::=P0

!"#$%&#'()*#+%&'()'*+,-&.&/+01+23),.)(.4%5.'&-&3/&'.1,6&'.&71+2)'3+0.8-3,2300+23),,#-#.(/01-2304-#56/0#7#8&90-#4::;-#<<0#4::-#$%&#Q&F&)&"9&#/?B$#B%(6/N#?"9/6N&CK>#L&>6M>)N?&)&-#O0-#!"#$%&'#4::=-#RST2O@UC#V#H?BB?("#$(#F()&9>B$#B9?"$?//>$?("B,-#5(6)">/#(F#V$H(B<%&)?9#>"N#U(/>)#W&))&B$)?>/#X%IB?9B-#.(/0#YY-#2Z#1[-#<<0#1\[]71\;10

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A#DBA#D8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A#D

Page 152: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

!"#$%&'$!("#)$()*&$+(%#!"#$%&#'(%)(*+,-./(01203

#'(,-)*".)-.!$(%!*/),(/!'0

!"#$%&$'"(&)*+"*,-.(/-$*"*0"/()1)2-$*3"%)"4#$/-$1( !45673/( %)(89:(;:&<(':&(5+=>:&/(89:(?+@A:(8B+B#/(C,+D%AE(6.#( F:@,)+A( %&(G@+,B#,AH(

&#A#-B#'(I,:=(B.#(I:AA:J%)K(B:>%-&L

,*,-%)#&12!##!("

:I(B.#(=+)@&-,%>B/(B.#(+@B.:,(=@&B(&#)'(+('#-A+,+B%:)(%)'%-+B%)K(B.#(,#+&:)&(&:(B.+B(B.#(,#$%#J(>,:-#&&(:--@,&(I+%,AHE(

+AA:J#'/(%B(%&(=+)'+B:,H(B:(=#)B%:)(B.#(;76*E(6.#(+@B.:,(+A&:('#-A+,#&(B.+B(B.#(=+)@&-,%>B(%&(+)(:,%K%)+A(>+>#,/(%B&(-:)B#)B(%&():B(

5(4&-&6&)*+"*3"%)(76&-/$*"*84#$9)

+,B%-A#&(I,:=(:B.#,(F:@,)+A&E

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A#EB"%%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A#E

Page 153: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

,--%)%-3!-4

+>>,:$#(+IB#,($#,%IH%)K(%)(B.#()#J($#,&%:)(B.#(+'.#,#)-#(B:(B.#(,#$%#J#,&M(&@KK#&B%:)&(:,(J%AA(&#)'(B:(+):B.#,(#$+A@+B%:)(,:@)'

2*"&#'%!,$)'*$-5(%!-#

-6789:7;<=

%>?7>@);:87A<>B=

(:7C7D;<)E;E>:B=

'9FFGD7A;879DB=(6.#H(&.:@A'(,#>:,B(>,#$%:@&(,#&@AB&(:I(:)K:%)K(,#&#+,-.(+)'(&.:@A'():B(#N-##'(#%K.B(>+K#&E

$H>B7B);IB8:;A8B=

2*"&#'%!,$)#$%&'$&%-

@&@+A(I:,=+BE

$78<>);D6)D;F>B)9J);G8H9:B=

*IB8:;A8=

):B(>#,=%BB#'E

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A#EB"%%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!A#F

Page 154: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

K>L@9:6B=

!D8:96GA879D=

2>8H969<9CL=

%>BG<8B=

.7BAGBB79D=

*AMD9@<>6C>F>D8B=

%>J>:>DA>B=

+)'(-:=>A#B#)#&&(:I(B.#%,(,#I#,#)-#&E

%>J>:>DA>B)7D)8>N8=

)+=#&/(@&#(B.#(I:,=(O8=%B.("&*$1

B.#H(':():B()##'(B:(+>>#+,(%)(B.#(,#I#,#)-#(A%&BE

%>J>:>DA>)<7B8=

+,#(+&(B.#(I:AA:J%)K(:)#&L

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A#EB"%%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&! A##

Page 155: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management

$;I<>B=

O7CG:>B=

-PG;879DB=

'()*+,-./()0+123-4()56367(8)9:-)'-.;)<-.)=6>/-.8)?-4("8)@-)A8)//()A#EB"%%8)'C4(B9+/(8)!%&!"%%

Page 156: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management
Page 157: Vol. 4 N.3 - Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management