10
__ __ C I __ · I ___ Vol. 89_ No.8 I , -I -- g -- I I -- I. -I , There will be a public debate among all UAP candidates and supporters of constitu- tional proposals Wednesday in Kresge. _aea I~p ~ lll Ilr m I I i I I i I i I I i i I 1 E ! I II Official newspaper of the undergraduate bod-y of the Massachusetts Instifute of Technology since 1881 Weather Cloudy, clearing in the afternoon. High in the 30's. MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Friday, March 7, 1969 .. Five Cents .9 By Harvey Baker The Selective Service System has cut sharply into the enrollment of MIT's graduate schools, Irwin Sizer, Dean of the Graduate School, noted in an interview a few days ago. In fact, he pointed out, MIT has lost about 600 graduate students in the last year for reasons directly or indirectly related to the draft and the students' fear of it. Background. information on the problem shows that all graduate school deferments with the exception of those for students in medical school were cancelled in the Draft Act of July 1, 1967. In addition, punitive clauses were added to the 2-S deferment which state that the deferred student is liable for the draft until age thirty-five; he cannot claim a 3-A fatherhood defer- ment should he become a father, and no matter what his actual age upon graduation from college, he is to be placed in the prime age group for the draft. The prime age group is defined as "the age group from which selections for induction into the Armed Forces are first to be made after delinquents and volunteers." College grads drafted It is primarily as a result of this restriction that college graduates are unable to continue their education. Consequently, whereas about a year and a half ago, among draftees non- college graduates outnumbered college grads about 25-1, today the ratio is. down to a frightening 2-1 and is still moving in the same direction. -Thus MIT, like other graduate schools, is. being bereaved of its potential stu- dents. "Only more so," says Dean Sizer though. Over recent years, MIT has been consistently increasing the size of its entering graduate class by five per cent. This past year, desiring the same increase, in order to reckon with the effect of the draft, the school over- admitted its entering class, hoping that after a small percentage had been lost to tne S.S;, the desired five per cent increase would still materialize. How- ever, the latest statistics show that, in fact, total enrollment as of Feb. 1969 is actually down 5.9%o as compared to this same period last year. Thus the percentage difference between desired increase and actual increase is about eleven per cent In reality though, the grad school, with an enrollment of about 3000 has actually been hit har- der than just this figure would tend to indicate. Ruina qi Grad school loses Earlier this year, each department was asked how many students it thought it had lost due to the draft. 1he total for all 23 departments was 600. The reason for this increased figure is that some students opt to leave school to take jobs which they know will guarantee them 2-A occupa- tional deferments rather than run the risk of going to graduate school and being drafted. Hence, contrary to what one might have expected, the Human- ities departments. have not been re- duced in size too much, while the School of Engineering has been really screwed, dropping from 1608 students in September 1967 to a level of 1376 students in February 1969. In general, the Dean and the Grad- uate School as a whole are very unhap- py about the large loss of students, not just for reasons relative-to MIT, but because as Dean Sizer put it, 'It is not in the national interest." He explained as follows. Contrary to what many people believe, most graduate students do not go on to take jobs in industry or government, but in fact over 60% of them go into university or high school teaching. With the population explosion and the increasing number of students more and more high quality teachers are heeded. If these graduate students axe removed to the Army, undergraduates and high school students will suffer too. Students lose Once a student is drafted into the Armnned Services'for two years, only seldom does he return to school to pick up where he left off, for by now he is two years older, possiblymarried, pos- sibly has children, and probably wants and needs a job. A return to school to obtain a masters or doctorate may not be desirable or possible. Besides, the Dean added, science is changing so fast today, that in the period during which two years have elapsed, the student might have fallen irreparably far be- hind. Summing it all up, he said, '"The present draft law is vicious in terms of its long range applications." By Jay Kunin Although Kresge Auditorium was continually filled, research at the Insti- tute did not seem to be severely crip- pled Tuesday. A survey made by The Tech indi- cated business was about 'normal in most laboratories contacted. Labora- tory heads seemed to feel that there was no great exodus to Kresge during the day, although in many cases people spent an hour or two at the activities in addition to their work. In one case (Instrumentation Laboratory), the pro- posed work stoppage had so little effect that no real count was taken. Regardless of their effect upon re- search, the panels drew considerable audiences. Chairing a discussion group concerning "The Responsibilities of In- tellectuals" Monday night, Professor Francis Low of the Physics Department opened with what could be considered the focal point of all the panels plan- ned for this week: "Pure research is good, but we may not remain uncon- cerned with the consequences of our work." Professor Noam Chomsky of the Department of Mo- dern Languages and Linguistics next spoke of a person's responsibilities "for the foreseeable consequences of his acts and his failure to act," and des- cribed the Defense Department as a "last resort" for engineers, adding, "so long as the ABM subsidizes industry it doesn't really matter whether or not it works." Professor Victor Weiskopf noted that "it -is important to have intelligent scientists in influential posi- S-y" r One of the many panels which drew large audiences on March 4. tions, " and that in addition, much could and should be done outside government. March 4 itself began with a dis- cussion on "reconversion and non- military research opportunities." Later, Professor Salvadore Luria of the De- partment of Life Sciences, chaired a panel concerning itself with the aca- demic community and its relationships to the government. Others involved in the Kresge activities Tuesday afternoon were Congressman George Brown (D-Cal.), Professor George Wald of Har- vard, Father Anthony Mullaney of the "Milwaukee 14", and other speakers concerning themselves with related topics. The final panel discussion of the day took place at Rindge in the even- ing. Nobel Laureate Hans Bethe (Co- rnell), Professor M. Meselson (Harvard, and Historian Gar Alperowitz of the Cambridgp-Institute for Policy Studies participated in a discussion of "Arms (Please turrn to page S) was back in the race, I withdrew." The decision to enter was apparent- ly a difficult one for Evans. He took out his petition and orginally entered himself as a candidate seeking to avoid a one-choice election. At that time there was only one other serious can- didate. After additional students took out petitions, Evans withdrew, only to re-enter Monday, evening after recon- sideration. Michael Albert, the other write-in candidate, entered the race Wednesday afternoon. He isrunning on a platform of support for the SACC proposals, the Black Student Union proposals, and academic reform. Albert has been active in Resistance and the Ad hoc Committee for Change, a student group working on the Institute requirements. Class offices Also being elected March 13 are class officers. Appearing on the ballot for Permanent President of the Class of 1969 is Mark Jay Mathis. The positions of Permanent Secretary-Treasurer and Permanent Executive Committee are apparently left blank on the ballot. Candidates for president of the Class of 1970 include Valentin Livada, Don Riley, and Pamela Whitman. Can- didates for the Executive Committee are Michael A. Bromberg, Robert A. Dennis, Jeff Gale, Julian James, and laura Malin. Ray B. Huey and Louis Tsien are campaigning for the presidency of the Class of 1971. Executive Committee candidates include Diane L Feldman, Jack L. Goodstein, David E. Hodges, Samuel List, Kenneth A. Lord, R. Hal Moorman, Thomas F.J. Pipal, Zane Segal, and Howard Jay Siegal. Class of 1972 candidates for pre- sident are John Kavazanjian, Dennis M. Lynch, Jose Pian, Leonard H. Sigal, and Dave Slesinger. Executive Com- mittee candidates are Thomas Alan Bergan, Richard deBronkart, Jr., Richard M. King, and Gerald Tolman. A. Barsa, Harold Federow, John Head, Stephen H. Loeb, James A. Smith, and Daniel Paul Wiener. Mike Albert and Dick Evans have begun write-in cam- paigns. Since the release of the list, James A. Smith has withdrawn. His name will still appear on the ballot because the list had already been sent to the printer when he announced his withdrawal. In withdrawing from the race, Smith explained, "I decided in the beginning"not to oppose Dick Evans if he entered. I entered only when he pledged Saturday not to run. When he called me late Monday night to say he By Greg Bernhardt The confusion over the slate of candidates in .the ace for Under- graduate Association President appears to have settled after a week of false starts and withdrawals. The names of six students will appear on the March 13 ballot while two more have started write-in cam- paigns for the office. One of the six on the ballot has withdrawn, leaving seven active candidates. Statements from all the candidates appear in another part of this paper. Those listed on the ballot according to the Inscomm office include Edward By Joseph Kashi The Nixon Administration's deci- sion to begin deployment of the Sen- tinal ABM system was criticized Tues- day by Dr. Jack Ruina, in charge of special research at MIT, including the Lincoln Lab's ABM-oriented projects. Dr. Ruina, Vice President in charge of Special Laboratories, termed the ABM deployment a mistake, for it does not offer an acceptable amount of protection for the cost involved. Dr. Ruina noted that this was the first time that Congress and the public ever questioned the need for an entire military project. Previously critics would focus upon certain aspects of a project, but never question the wisdom of its implementation. He considers controversy a healthy sign of a national re-evaluation. The Sentinal system is designed to provide a thin coverage of the con- tinental U.S. In order to provide rea- sonable confidence in an ABM system, It. Ruina believes that the U.S. would have to spend an amount far in excess of what the Russians would spend for the penetration devices needed to nul- lify the ABM system. In addition, quoting-a study by former Defense Secretary McNarnara, he stated that the "quality of defense must become al- most air-tight for it to be effective." 'The cost of overcoming Sentinal wuuld be small in comparison to the cost of deploying it." For this reason, Dr. Ruina believes that Sentinal is "hardly worth the cost". He noted that it would be very hard to find a situa- tion in which an unproven ABM system would be a deterent to Russia or China. Thus, it would be a serious error for the U.S. to embark upon the presently proposed thin system. However, Dr. Ruina stated that it is imperative that the U.S. continue to develop ABM technology. He is con- vinced that if the U.S. does not con- tinue ABM research, the fear caused by our lack of knowledge of other ad- vances in the field would prompt the U.S. escalate the arms race. In addition, there is a stability of nuclear force and deterrence between the U.S. and Kussia. A first strike now is un- attractive , as either country would suffer greatly from the second-strike capability of the other. Vice-President Ruina, Vice-President in charge of special labs, as he spoke on the prospects of the ABM system. 6Cb8 -tu~~et loMarch 4 activities fill Kresge, Graduate enrollment falls _ asdeu t elossis felt ot research goes on as usual as deferment loss is felt I :::2: ifi, ·· es, .; 1: 5 /, 6'c' i i j , i I . > I s I 4 UAP candidate slate includes six on ballot, two as write-ins uestions ABM cost, feasibility

Vol. 89 No.8 MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Friday, March 7, …tech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N8.pdf · 2007-12-22 · no matter what his actual age upon graduation from college, he is

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Vol. 89 No.8 MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Friday, March 7, …tech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N8.pdf · 2007-12-22 · no matter what his actual age upon graduation from college, he is

__ __ C I __ · I ___

Vol. 89_ No.8I , -I -- g -- I I --

I. -I ,

There will be a public debateamong all UAP candidatesand supporters of constitu-tional proposals Wednesdayin Kresge._aea I~p ~ lll Ilr m I

IiII

i

IiII

i

i

I

1

E

!

I

II

Official newspaper of theundergraduate bod-y ofthe Massachusetts Instifuteof Technology since 1881

WeatherCloudy, clearingin the afternoon.

High in the 30's.

MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Friday, March 7, 1969 .. Five Cents

.9By Harvey Baker

The Selective Service System hascut sharply into the enrollment ofMIT's graduate schools, Irwin Sizer,Dean of the Graduate School, noted inan interview a few days ago. In fact, hepointed out, MIT has lost about 600graduate students in the last year forreasons directly or indirectly related tothe draft and the students' fear of it.

Background. information on theproblem shows that all graduate schooldeferments with the exception of thosefor students in medical school werecancelled in the Draft Act of July 1,1967. In addition, punitive clauseswere added to the 2-S deferment whichstate that the deferred student is liablefor the draft until age thirty-five; hecannot claim a 3-A fatherhood defer-ment should he become a father, andno matter what his actual age upongraduation from college, he is to beplaced in the prime age group for thedraft. The prime age group is defined as"the age group from which selectionsfor induction into the Armed Forcesare first to be made after delinquentsand volunteers."

College grads draftedIt is primarily as a result of this

restriction that college graduates areunable to continue their education.Consequently, whereas about a yearand a half ago, among draftees non-college graduates outnumbered collegegrads about 25-1, today the ratio is.down to a frightening 2-1 and is stillmoving in the same direction. -ThusMIT, like other graduate schools, is.being bereaved of its potential stu-dents.

"Only more so," says Dean Sizerthough. Over recent years, MIT hasbeen consistently increasing the size ofits entering graduate class by five percent. This past year, desiring the sameincrease, in order to reckon with theeffect of the draft, the school over-admitted its entering class, hoping thatafter a small percentage had been lostto tne S.S;, the desired five per centincrease would still materialize. How-ever, the latest statistics show that, infact, total enrollment as of Feb. 1969is actually down 5.9%o as compared tothis same period last year. Thus thepercentage difference between desiredincrease and actual increase is abouteleven per cent In reality though, thegrad school, with an enrollment ofabout 3000 has actually been hit har-der than just this figure would tend toindicate.

Ruina qi

Grad school losesEarlier this year, each department

was asked how many students itthought it had lost due to the draft.1he total for all 23 departments was600. The reason for this increasedfigure is that some students opt toleave school to take jobs which theyknow will guarantee them 2-A occupa-tional deferments rather than run therisk of going to graduate school andbeing drafted. Hence, contrary to whatone might have expected, the Human-ities departments. have not been re-duced in size too much, while theSchool of Engineering has been reallyscrewed, dropping from 1608 studentsin September 1967 to a level of 1376students in February 1969.

In general, the Dean and the Grad-uate School as a whole are very unhap-py about the large loss of students, notjust for reasons relative-to MIT, butbecause as Dean Sizer put it, 'It is notin the national interest." He explainedas follows. Contrary to what manypeople believe, most graduate studentsdo not go on to take jobs in industry orgovernment, but in fact over 60% ofthem go into university or high schoolteaching.

With the population explosion andthe increasing number of students moreand more high quality teachers areheeded. If these graduate students axeremoved to the Army, undergraduatesand high school students will suffertoo.

Students loseOnce a student is drafted into the

Armnned Services'for two years, onlyseldom does he return to school to pickup where he left off, for by now he istwo years older, possiblymarried, pos-sibly has children, and probably wantsand needs a job. A return to school toobtain a masters or doctorate may notbe desirable or possible. Besides, theDean added, science is changing so fasttoday, that in the period during whichtwo years have elapsed, the studentmight have fallen irreparably far be-hind. Summing it all up, he said, '"Thepresent draft law is vicious in terms ofits long range applications."

By Jay KuninAlthough Kresge Auditorium was

continually filled, research at the Insti-tute did not seem to be severely crip-pled Tuesday.

A survey made by The Tech indi-cated business was about 'normal inmost laboratories contacted. Labora-tory heads seemed to feel that therewas no great exodus to Kresge duringthe day, although in many cases peoplespent an hour or two at the activities inaddition to their work. In one case(Instrumentation Laboratory), the pro-posed work stoppage had so littleeffect that no real count was taken.

Regardless of their effect upon re-search, the panels drew considerableaudiences. Chairing a discussion groupconcerning "The Responsibilities of In-tellectuals" Monday night, ProfessorFrancis Low of the Physics Departmentopened with what could be consideredthe focal point of all the panels plan-ned for this week: "Pure research isgood, but we may not remain uncon-cerned with the consequences of ourwork." Professor NoamChomsky of the Department of Mo-dern Languages and Linguistics nextspoke of a person's responsibilities "forthe foreseeable consequences of hisacts and his failure to act," and des-cribed the Defense Department as a"last resort" for engineers, adding, "solong as the ABM subsidizes industry itdoesn't really matter whether or not itworks." Professor Victor Weiskopfnoted that "it -is important to haveintelligent scientists in influential posi-

S-y" r

One of the many panels which drew large audiences on March 4.

tions, " and that in addition, muchcould and should be done outsidegovernment.

March 4 itself began with a dis-cussion on "reconversion and non-

military research opportunities." Later,Professor Salvadore Luria of the De-partment of Life Sciences, chaired apanel concerning itself with the aca-demic community and its relationshipsto the government. Others involved inthe Kresge activities Tuesday afternoonwere Congressman George Brown

(D-Cal.), Professor George Wald of Har-vard, Father Anthony Mullaney of the"Milwaukee 14", and other speakersconcerning themselves with relatedtopics.

The final panel discussion of theday took place at Rindge in the even-ing. Nobel Laureate Hans Bethe (Co-

rnell), Professor M. Meselson (Harvard,and Historian Gar Alperowitz of theCambridgp-Institute for Policy Studiesparticipated in a discussion of "Arms

(Please turrn to page S)

was back in the race, I withdrew."The decision to enter was apparent-

ly a difficult one for Evans. He tookout his petition and orginally enteredhimself as a candidate seeking to avoida one-choice election. At that timethere was only one other serious can-didate. After additional students tookout petitions, Evans withdrew, only tore-enter Monday, evening after recon-sideration.

Michael Albert, the other write-incandidate, entered the race Wednesdayafternoon. He isrunning on a platformof support for the SACC proposals, theBlack Student Union proposals, andacademic reform. Albert has beenactive in Resistance and the Ad hocCommittee for Change, a student groupworking on the Institute requirements.

Class officesAlso being elected March 13 are

class officers. Appearing on the ballotfor Permanent President of the Class of1969 is Mark Jay Mathis. The positionsof Permanent Secretary-Treasurer andPermanent Executive Committee areapparently left blank on the ballot.

Candidates for president of theClass of 1970 include Valentin Livada,Don Riley, and Pamela Whitman. Can-didates for the Executive Committeeare Michael A. Bromberg, Robert A.Dennis, Jeff Gale, Julian James, andlaura Malin.

Ray B. Huey and Louis Tsien arecampaigning for the presidency of theClass of 1971. Executive Committeecandidates include Diane L Feldman,Jack L. Goodstein, David E. Hodges,Samuel List, Kenneth A. Lord, R. HalMoorman, Thomas F.J. Pipal, ZaneSegal, and Howard Jay Siegal.

Class of 1972 candidates for pre-sident are John Kavazanjian, Dennis M.Lynch, Jose Pian, Leonard H. Sigal,and Dave Slesinger. Executive Com-mittee candidates are Thomas AlanBergan, Richard deBronkart, Jr.,Richard M. King, and Gerald Tolman.

A. Barsa, Harold Federow, John Head,Stephen H. Loeb, James A. Smith, andDaniel Paul Wiener. Mike Albert andDick Evans have begun write-in cam-paigns. Since the release of the list,James A. Smith has withdrawn. Hisname will still appear on the ballotbecause the list had already been sentto the printer when he announced hiswithdrawal.

In withdrawing from the race,Smith explained, "I decided in thebeginning"not to oppose Dick Evans ifhe entered. I entered only when hepledged Saturday not to run. When hecalled me late Monday night to say he

By Greg BernhardtThe confusion over the slate of

candidates in .the ace for Under-graduate Association President appearsto have settled after a week of falsestarts and withdrawals.

The names of six students willappear on the March 13 ballot whiletwo more have started write-in cam-paigns for the office. One of the six onthe ballot has withdrawn, leaving sevenactive candidates. Statements from allthe candidates appear in another partof this paper.

Those listed on the ballot accordingto the Inscomm office include Edward

By Joseph KashiThe Nixon Administration's deci-

sion to begin deployment of the Sen-tinal ABM system was criticized Tues-day by Dr. Jack Ruina, in charge ofspecial research at MIT, including theLincoln Lab's ABM-oriented projects.

Dr. Ruina, Vice President in chargeof Special Laboratories, termed theABM deployment a mistake, for it doesnot offer an acceptable amount ofprotection for the cost involved.

Dr. Ruina noted that this was thefirst time that Congress and the publicever questioned the need for an entiremilitary project. Previously criticswould focus upon certain aspects of aproject, but never question the wisdomof its implementation. He considerscontroversy a healthy sign of a nationalre-evaluation.

The Sentinal system is designed toprovide a thin coverage of the con-tinental U.S. In order to provide rea-sonable confidence in an ABM system,It. Ruina believes that the U.S. wouldhave to spend an amount far in excessof what the Russians would spend forthe penetration devices needed to nul-lify the ABM system. In addition,

quoting-a study by former DefenseSecretary McNarnara, he stated that the"quality of defense must become al-most air-tight for it to be effective."

'The cost of overcoming Sentinalwuuld be small in comparison to thecost of deploying it." For this reason,Dr. Ruina believes that Sentinal is"hardly worth the cost". He noted thatit would be very hard to find a situa-tion in which an unproven ABM systemwould be a deterent to Russia or China.Thus, it would be a serious error forthe U.S. to embark upon the presentlyproposed thin system.

However, Dr. Ruina stated that it isimperative that the U.S. continue todevelop ABM technology. He is con-vinced that if the U.S. does not con-tinue ABM research, the fear caused byour lack of knowledge of other ad-vances in the field would prompt theU.S. escalate the arms race. Inaddition, there is a stability of nuclearforce and deterrence between the U.S.and Kussia. A first strike now is un-attractive , as either country wouldsuffer greatly from the second-strikecapability of the other.

Vice-President Ruina, Vice-President in charge of special labs, ashe spoke on the prospects of the ABM system.

6Cb8 -tu~~et loMarch 4 activities fill Kresge,Graduate enrollment falls_ asdeu t elossis felt ot research goes on as usualas deferment loss is felt

I

:::2:

ifi, ··es, .;1: 5

/, 6'c'i ij, iI. >I s

I 4

UAP candidate slate includessix on ballot, two as write-ins

uestions ABM cost, feasibility

Page 2: Vol. 89 No.8 MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Friday, March 7, …tech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N8.pdf · 2007-12-22 · no matter what his actual age upon graduation from college, he is

PAGE 2 FRIDAY, MARCH 7, 1969 THE TECH

Undergraduate Association President candidatesUndergraduate Association President candidatesJ.

C L '-· I I r---s~ I llU I--· -- ~ I-- II- I-I- r I I I I I

Daniel WienerAt this supremely critical moment

in the history of the universe, I feel itimcumbent upon myself to step for-ward and heroically save MIT (and,indirectly, the human race) from thefollies of student government. I do nottake this action lightly, involving as itdoes at least a temporary renunciationof my sacred vow of apathy. However,even I occasionally feel some residualconcern for the outside world. Studentgoventment constantly does nothing,which is of course what it is expectedto do. If it did so honestly and withoutbothering anyone, I would have nocomplaint. It is the recent sordid at-tempts to pretend that student govern-ment should do something: and, worse,that if only its structure was shiftedaround that it could do something, thathave raised the disgust level beyond thelimits of toleration.The time has cornmfor the undergraduate student body tobreak the shackles that have for toolong bound it; to rise up and smite thisevil Undergraduate Association so thatfuture generations at MIT might live inpeace. It is for such a crusade that Inow offer my leadership by running forUAP. We must raze the structure ofstudent government to the ground,wipe it out utterly, destroy it so totallythat never in all the future eons of theInstitute will it ever again be able tobecome a menace.

How to preserve this liberty for ourposterity is a difficult question. Con-

· ' . .._....._S..-.,= .I I . __ i m . .. ... .' . .I - -- r _sSsI I 1 I II . , 1 1

Budweiser isthe King of Beers.(But you know that.)

I -- --- -I II r- - -aI I P------ - I I-Ill I ·r I Iaa I s I I -·r �--·p 1 aaIl - Iali -'· --�IP�C-

I · I YIC·4IC II Illllb Lu ____ _ _---a�--- - I -

A=

i=St

i

I

tuition are only a few of the issueswhich concern us every day, and theUAP should seek to have the studentsfees he is concerned with and con-fronting these issues daily.

FULL-TIME JOB: How is he goingto accomplish this? Above all, he musthimself be active, and I propose thatthe next UAP make his post a full-timejob. I recommendthat he carry only 24hours of acadenic work, getting ano-ther 24 hours through existing SpecialTopics courses, e.g. 17.71, 21.392.

Second, however, our full-time UAPmust be capable of mobilizing others,both within and without student gov-ernment. The proposed "HAC" consti-tution will allow him to internalize

~~~~., ' ..... . ' ' ' >d v' ?R,:,';,-,-"' f,' .-,

:,''" ,'.~~'

,:. ;,_ E' l, > '

fers. Another commission could investi-gate alternatives to erratic tuition leaps(I myself advocate more gradual riseswhich could be applied annually, butonly to entering students.)

TASK FORCES BY STUDENTSTOO: Similarly, student government(and the UAP) should not continuallyabdicate to faculty "task forces" onsuch topics as curriculum reform. TheUAP could appoint his own task forceto conduct hearings (which would-pro-bably be better attended) and submitits own reccomendation. Instead of thefragmented proposals-which we wit-nessed last month, there would be onereport which would carry the fullprestige of the student body.

The key to increasing student influ-ence on faculty decisions is not acquir-ing a seat here and a seat there onfaculty committees (who will select thestudents?) but the development of so-ber, respected parallel authority. Com-missions and task forces are two me-thods of mobilizing such authority.

THEUNCOMFORTABLE UAP:Finally, the next UAP must be uncom-fortable with the minor problemswhich nevertheless set the atmosphereof a place. Maybe he can by his merepersistence replace the bulbs in thestudent center elevators, place woodencomfortable benches in McDermottCourt near the Great Sail rejuvenateWalker Memorial's office space, or doany of the thousand other things thatare now ignored.

At the same time, the next UAPmust aboveiall not act in any manner(e.g. '"laming') that might serve tojeopardize his own legtimacyand credi-bility.

I am talking of a new type of UAP.Another Maria, another Horvitz, oreven another March will not do. Thenext UAP must be a political leaderrather than a bureaucrat or one-trackidealist. In the next week I will endorsethe opponent whofn I feel comes clos-est to being that kind of UAP

Steve LoebI want to construct a student gov-

ernment for improvement of the edu-cational and extracurricular aspects ofundergraduate life at MIT. I believe thispossible if students in government takeconcrete 'action, rather than usestudent government as a plaything. Thepreferable merhanism for this, theUnified University proposal, in, itselfwill not assure a viable and productivestructure. It depends, critically, uponthe initiatives taken by the individualsinvolved in elective position.

It is my aim that student govern-ment exist to assist all formal andinformal student activities, be theyrecognized at present or exist as ad hoccommittees. For too long the studentgovernment at MIT has been structuredto mold the interests of students into

tinual vigilance, founded upon the solidframework of dynamic indifference,must be the principle that guides us.The agency for doing this must be ofsuch a nature as to make it inherentlyimpossible that it might ever take onthe characteristics of that from whichit is supposed to protect us. It musthave no money, no power, and aboveall, no pretense of efficacy. After longand careful consideration (approx-imately two minutes staring intospace), I have decided that electing ahereditary monarch will be the mosteffective method of achieving this goal.Observe the resulting advantages: By

. electing a monarch we appear to be· bowing to. the currently fashionable

"democracy" 'fad, thus placating thegreat unwashed multitudes. By makingthemonarchy hereditary and for life,.we simultaneously remove it fromthose obvious dangers and pressuresemanating from a democratic rabble.And at the end of every school year wesymbolically assassinate the king bytossing him in the Charles, thus resolv-ing the previous paradox while pro-viding a useful outlet for the pent-upenergies and frustrations and fears ofthe average Tech tool. History hasshown that monarchs can fulfill thefigurehead function quite well and quiteharmlessly. By acting now, boldly andcourageously, secure in the knowledgeof the justice of oui cause, to vote forme on March 13, the students at MITcan cure forever the student govern-nient cancer in their midst, and thejudgement of history shall inevitablyread: "This was their finest hour."'

Jim SmithAlthough my name is on the ballot

or UAP, I have for all intents andpurposes withdrawn from that race. I·. ::hall, nevertheless, use this invitation toexpress what I feel the next UAPshould be like and the issues I thinkmust be raised.

LEGITIMACY: The first task ofthe next UAP will be to restore thelegitimacy of his office in the eyes of usstudents. The most immediate methodof doing so is, simply, to concentrateon the direct interests of the stu-dents-and to do so quite visibly.

The curriculum, commons, theprices in the Tech COop, grades and

t

~~~~~~~~~~~..Jinert, formalized activities with per-manent status.

The recent proliferation of ad hoccommittees in the fields of living stan-dards, pass-fail registration and re-quired commons, circumventing theexisting student government, attests tothe significance and need for govern-ement to assist such activities through:

1. Common, available publicity fa-cilities- the undergraduate associationowns an offset press which would be ofgreat use to anyone wishing to do a lotof publicity work. This press, which ispresently in the LSC office and therebyinaccessable to most people, should bemoved to a room in which it can beused by all.

2. Fair and equitable scheduling offacilities- the facilities on this campusfor meetings, theater events and filmsare in very. short supply. Thfls thestudent government should press foradded space as well as try to maximizethe use of the available facilities.

3. Financing- the undergradu:ateassociation has a budget of over$90,000. This money is for use instudent activities. Thus, I believe Fi-nance Board should hold open meet-ings on the matters it considers. Thesehearings would allow students to ex-press their opinions and ask questionsab'iouith e llocation of fimances. ...

4. Publication of a weekly news;2

letter- student organizations on thiscampus have a sufficient number ofactivities to warrant the publication ofa newsletter that lists these eventsalong with .descriptions, similar innature to the Institute Calendar. If thedelay for publication was two days,then more events of interest could beincluded.

5. Committee to deal with studentproblems- I would create a specialcommittee, to consist of the UAP, theUAVP, and the Chairman of the Activi-ties Council, the Finance Board, andthe Secretariat, to aid any under-graduate or undergraduate organizationin the solution of a problem. Thesepeople will be in touch with the admin-

TPlease turn to page 3)

such committees as SCUP and SCE,having them consist ot voting Assem-blymen as well as staff workers.

STUDENT COMMISSIONS: Stan-ding committees, however, are poormeans of dealing with the ad hocproblems which confront us or willarise. On such matters (commons, tui-tion, etc.) the UAP should take thelead in coordinating and mobilizingstudent power. From among the verycompetent management students atMIT, the UAP could appoint "blue-rib-bon" commissions (with academiccredit) to do the research for him. Thecommission's report (like that of aWhite House commission) could thenmerely be edited and released by theUAP, and thus given the full authorityof the student body. Such a commis-sion could put solid facts behind oragainst criticisms of the Coop or Stouf-

of trouble and expense to letBudweiser create its own bub-bles with the natural carbona-tion of Beechwood Ageing. Soyou really can't blame us forwanting you to get it at its

best, can you?'/ Just for fun, pour your

0a W next four or five bot-tles of Buds into a

> pzglass. If you don'tagree that the extra

taste, clarity andaromna make a big difference,go back to the bottle.

We wdn't say another word.

If you're on a blanket partyor something, carrying along aglass is pretty clumsy. Butwhen it's convenient, we thinkit's a shame not to use one.RAP;,ni, 'Riidwinqr A11a%insF/ 1id, uuh e bvr,.L

inside the bottle or Acan is missing half

·the fu n .sThose tiny bubbles

getting organized at the ttop of your glass have a lotto do with taste'and aroma.Most beers have carbonationpumped in mechanically. NotBudweiser. We go to a barrel

ANHEUSER-BUSCH, INC. e ST. LOUIS * NEWARK · LOS ANGELES · TAMPA * HOUSTON ·COLUMBUS UNDERWRITERS AND INVESTMENT BANKERS

Should ou drik been

straight from the botde?~Im~

IMMEDIATEVENTURE CAPITAL

AVAILABLEfor new businesses

We are looking for graduate students who have soundideas for new products or services as well as the capa-bilities to head up as principals new organizations tosee the projects culminated.Reply only in writing, submitting detail plans. Do notinclude confidential information.

~]ObUS, inc.

25 Broadway, New York, N.Y. 10004

Page 3: Vol. 89 No.8 MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Friday, March 7, …tech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N8.pdf · 2007-12-22 · no matter what his actual age upon graduation from college, he is

vm m- , ----- -- ' ---- I-t-- - , ~~ - -I- -·_, ---

II -I -- L1 I-i15 y I I

I

I I

THE TECH FRIDAY, MARCH 7, 1969 PAGE 3

trenching our racist attitudes; we mustnot give out implicit support to policieswhich are racist in nature. If theInstitute adopts a racist policy it isinfringing on me as well as on theBlacks. It is forcing me to accept arelationship which is unnatural anddetrimental to me and of course theBlacks. My stand on the implement-ation of the BSU demands is identicalto my stand on the implemei:ntation ofthe SACC proposals. In addition myplatform includes the implementationof a program parallel to that developedby the Blacks but focused around thegrievances of other exploited groups.One aspect of such an approach wouldbe a recruitment program in Cam-bridge, South Boston, and the NorthEnd.

My views on academic reform are inthe report of the Ad Hoc Committeefor Change, which I had a large part inwriting.

The housing crisis - high rents, andpoor and insufficient housing for theresidents of Cambridge - is in partcaused by the refusal of MIT andHarvard to build sufficient housing fortheir students. A number of The Techarticles have made this point clear. MIT

fAii.j-: A ;!*Y"'*'b,*~~

(continued from page 2)

istration and will know what channels; should be used for the quickest pos-sible action.

1, therefore, feel that student gov-ernment can be meaningful; if it is heldat a minimum, takes concrete action onissues, and is responsive to studentneeds.

Jolm HeadThe aim of the Undergraduate Asso-

ciation President should be to haveparticipatory student governmentbased on living group affiliations. Acrucial problem of student governmentis the inability of interested people towirk and to express their opinions onissues that directly concern them. Anystudent who wishes to spend timeworking on educational policy reformshould be a member of SCEP. Theprocess of electing people to studentcommittees only discourages studentparticipation.

Parallel student and faculty com-mittees with students selecting studentsto represent them should be encoraged.Dialogue between students and facul-ty-administration has to be increased.Only then will student governmentwork toward genuine community go-vernment.

Living group government is verystrong and active compared to Institutestudent goverunent. Institute govern-ment should deal only With problemsthat cross living group affiliations suchas discussions on student-faculty deal-ings.,

r aI. ¢:,.

Harold FederowIn the coming year student govern-,

ment will face two major problems.The first will be to implement the newform of student government chosen in'the referendum.

It will not be sufficient to merelyset up the structures. In the past, it hasoverly concerned itself with such pettydetails and lost itself in irrelevance. Itwill be the task of the UAP to see thatissues that come before the governmentfor discussion should be relevant to thelife of the students - the entrance ofstudents to faculty meetings, forexample, could have been debatedprior to the actual vote of the faculty.

It is only by making the studentswho comprise the government, as wellas their constituency, see that theissues being discussed are relevant totheir lives, then the student governm-ment will be able to avoid the chargesof being useless and irrelevant

The second problem to be faced istaking advantage of the increasedwillingness cf the faculty and adminis-tration to involve students in the policymaking process. In the past year, wehave seen students on several commit-tees where previously there.were nomeans at all for student input. I wouldlike to continue this trend. I would liketo see a provision for at least studentobservers, if not voting members, atmeetings of the Academic Council,which is the top policy making groupat the Institute.

The. main choice facing the studentswill be that of leadership. InstituteCommittee was allowed to die this yearby a lack of leadership on the part ofthe UAP. To get any kind of viableform, it is essential that the UAP be aperson who is willing to lead and totake the.initiative in guiding studentgovernment where it should go so thatthe new student government does notdie before it has a chance to live.

Student government administers abudget of about $100,000. One of the

first things that should be done is totake a look at the priorities used toallocate moneys.

In the coming year, I hope to beworking to implement the above goalsand to convince students that in factstudent government is not irrelevant totheirlives, and can influence their,livesprofoundly.

· :..~-'-~',~,*, " > " , : . ,-;

as student government is concerned, I feel that such groups as Dormcon, theIFC, class governments, SCEP,SCE,AEB,and Finboard, should besomewhat autonomous, self-perpetuating groups. The function ofInscomm as a 'ruling' body is notnecessary. In fact, Inscomm itself is not.necessary as long as there is some sortof representative Executive Committee,possibly elected at large by the student body, to arbitrate conflicts between the above groups.

I do not feel that any of the threereferendum proposals will completelysolve the problems they were designedto solve.

Edward BarsaThe time has come for a change.

Student government at MIT is finallymaking the long-awaited change in itsstructure. But this should not be the'sole source of modification. Far toooften candidates for the office of UAPhave been the stereotyped student poli-tician who claims to have a completeoverview of the Institute and his ownsolution to virtually every problem.Now that the decision has been madeto start afresh, it would be best to alterthe character of the position of UAP.With this in mind, we set out in searchof a new type of student leader, anaverage student. We sought someonewho was personable and subtlycharismatic without being oppressiveand obnoxious, and in so doing, wefound our man-Easy Ed Barsa.

Having never run for any politicaloffice, Easy Ed has not been spoiled-bya gluttonous desire for power. All hewould like to see is an effective studentgovernment striving to meet the needsof its undergraduate population. Eddoes not feel that the cumbersomeburden of endless trivia which was thealbatross about the neck of many aformer UAP should remain the singularresponsibility' of the next student ex-ecutive. It is our desire to recreate thisoffice in the form of an executive-amanager of student government, a bro-ker of responsibility.

It is with this thought that wewould like to propose an addtionalmeasure of innovation to the nextgovernmental system at MIT. We be-lieve that the UAP should be assistedby a five-man cabinet composed ofindividuals chosen at his discretion.These students would share the burdenof the office, possibly with specificduties. The cabinet would be easilyaccessible to anyone and the ever-serious problem of communicationwould be at least somewhat lessened.These individuals would also constitutea quasi-ombudsman and could enableth'e bureaucracy of student governmentto function more freely. We believethat this plan fits well into the Unified

i;' -%''"x- 11 ': 9 , '';it42 j.'/ ' ,-

University proposal (HAC) which westrongly endorse on its own merits.

Thus we hope that you will agreewith us that the nel era of studentgovernment commencing at this timeshould also mark the start of a newtype of student leader and that EasyEd Barsa is the type of individual whoshould serve you in this capacity, forthe purpose of student government toto serve you, the students.

Students for Easy Ed Barsa

Mike Albert1. An end to war related research atMIT and affiliated institutions and thediscontinuation of co-operative war re-search programs with other corpor-ations, as outlined by SACC. 2. Thedemands of the Black Student Union,including increased admission andscholarships for Blacks, and the imple-mentation of a parallel program focus-ing upon the grievances of poor Whites.3. Academic reform beginning withthe abolition of allcourse requirements,the enrichment of the advksory pro-gram, and the institution of the pro-gressive grading program (e.g. pass-norecord) 4. The immediate establish-ment of an open committee to form-ulate a program of action that wouldalleviate the housing crisis in Cam-bridge.

I am running with three goals.inmind:implementing the platform,furthering public debate and contin-uing to engage student, in politicalprograms. During this week we willdistribute position papers in support ofeach plank in the platform. A verybrief summary of my opinions follows:

The implementation of a programlike SACC's is long overdue. The ad-ministration should administer the de-cisions of the students and faculty. Ifthey do not respond to our deci§ions,as registered by petitions and discus-sions, we will be forced to determinenew strategies. Iri this situation, as UAPI would attempt to enlist the supportof the student body for such strategies.

The demands of the Black StudentUnion are the concern of every Whitestudent at MIT. We must avoid en-

,·~-. * , ,·'., - ·, -,, ,,'L,

Dick Evans IAs a write-in candidate, I would like I

to apologize for not deciding to runsooner. The decision to run for Under-graduate Association President is notan easy one: you have to feel that youhave a reasonable amount of ex-perience in a variety of areas, that youknow enough people in all livinggroups, including NRSA, to understandat least some of their problems, andmost importantly, that you have thetime to devote to do a good job (atleast 30 hours a week). Having beenpersuaded that the other candidatesrunning do not meet these qualifica-tions, I find myself in the disadvant-ageous position of being a write-incandidate.

Where do I stand? When decisionsare being made concerning students'educations and students' lives, veryoften students are not there to offertheir own insights as to what problemsexist and where possible solutionsmight lie. I have worked, and wish to

SO~n- 'S ; t vtj2 7

·*·U ,,-% t 1and Harvard must build sufficient*housing for their own students and inmy opinion they should join with otherlarge local institutions in financingcommunity-controlled housing in Cambridge. Once a program were formula-ted by the proposed committee, theextent of student support for it woulddetermine the type of tactics whichwould be employed by the studentgovernment in seeking to implement it.

It-should be understood that I amrunning with the goal of implementingthe above platform and injecting anumber of new and relevant ideas intothe political forum at MIT. I willattempt to act on my progr- . lmyeffort is to win' peopl- Jer to myplatform - but to ':o so by debate anddiscussion, not manipulation. I realizethat there is nothing gained by anyprocedure that does not include theadoption of our programs by largenumbers of people.

\ -s~c- -is~ a s~ l as WIW Lv

, continue to work, towards more stu-dent "power" in the sense that stu-dents are aware of what decisions arebeing made, and by whom, and in thesense that these people are open to

I student help in making these decisions.What does this entail? I feel that a

strong Public Relations Committeeand/or Secretariat and/or The Tech areneeded to help publicize to studentswhat decisions are being made, who ismaking them, and when these peopleare meeting to discuss such issues. Inrelation to this, I feel that The Techshould be delivered free to all students,thereby increasing both its circulationand its ability to communicate infor-niation and issues. I am aware of theproblems involved in doing this, but Ithink these problems can be overcome.

I also believe that it is necessary tohave student representatives on allfaculty and administration committeeswhich are responsible for making de-cisions having an effect on students. ido not feel that students should S0%voting power, I only feel that we needa voice in our affairs that is heard andrespected.

In conjunction with the studentrepresentatives, I also feel that it isnecessary to have wholly studentgroups both discussing student issuesand handling student problems. As far

. | - I l , ., ~~~~~~I I

"The Alamo"San Antonio style

Mexican Food

25 Market Street

Northampton, Mass. 01060

586-0634

Beef Tacos-Tomales

Enchaladas-Re-Fried Beans

Chie-Mexican Rice

GUACAMOLE SALAD

OPEN 5:30 pm

i

-.r,, i M AP 5u -d. 01 ., , ,_____

issues and goalsoffer statements on campaign

Paxton Quigley went to collegeto learn about Love.

Page 4: Vol. 89 No.8 MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Friday, March 7, …tech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N8.pdf · 2007-12-22 · no matter what his actual age upon graduation from college, he is

I1 1 m-

- - Th'e Observer-Bfy 3ony f-ima.-

--- A em-M --- -

i

I

II

MARCH 7, 1969.

·* .m' · e:· · · ·- e ·v 7

............. ....Stm.. Cashart '70

.......... . Julin James '70..................... .Reid Ashe '70. Carson Agnew '70, Robert Dennis '70·. . Jeff Gale '70, Bruce Wemibe '71

andy Hawthoe-'71, Cadiss Baldwin '72... Greg Bernhardt '71, Jay Kunin '71............ Kaen Wattel '70............. e eRon Cline '71,........ ........ .. Steve Grant '70

........ v e * * o v *Craig Davis '71,. . .e. . . .. ... Dave DeWitte '69

. Geozge Flynn '69, Tony Lima '69Tom Thomnas '69, Mickey Warren '69.

Steve Kinney '70, George Wood '70

Second-class -ostage paid at Boston, Massachusetts. The Tech is published everyTuesday and Friday during the college year, except during college vacations, byThe- Tech, Room W20483, MIT Student Center, 84 Massachusetts Ave.,Cambridge, Massachusetts, 02139. Telephone: Area Code 617, 876-S8SS, or864-6900, extension 2731. United States Mail subscription rates: $4.25 for oneyear, $8.00 for two yeas'

.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ i

kA-l ' v;\ .iRT

THE TECHf_, .'PAGE 4 FRIDAY, MARCH 7,1969

History will no doubt record onlytwo official versions of what occurredin Chicago during the Democratic Con-vention. This is unfortunate, for theWalker Report and Norman Mailer arecertainly not up to the standard of athird publication put out by the Amer-ican Civil Liberties Union.

Tided "Law and Disorder", theACLU report claims to not expoundany philosophy which would representthe beliefs of that organization. Ins-tead, the editor has produced a collage-of articles by eyewitnesses and otherconcerned individuals, ranging fromHuntley and Brinkley to Hugh Hefner.In terms of coverage, it manages to givethe essential details without becomingbogged down by the weight of statisticsor quoted reports. It is interesting tonote, for example, in perusing theWalker Report that each night readslike a slightly modified version of thenight before. The ACLU avoids this byreporting more on specific incidentsand less on historical overview.

Mailer, on the other hand, is dis-appointing to a large degree. Claimingto have "covered" the demonstrations,it quickly becomes apparent that dur-ing most of the action; he was either inhis room or in one of the local bars.The difference between his coveragesof Miami and Chicago is that in the

: former, the action was in those places.Such was not the case, however, inChicago.

The Walker Report, while it wasperhaps slightly hard on the police,

Today is the day that all the big black Cadillaclimousines pull up in front of 77 MassachusettsAvenue and crowd around Kresge. The averagestudent will look once and continue on to class. Hemay or may not know that the MIT Corporation isin town for its quarterly meeting.

Who are these men who come to Cambridge fortheir meeting in Kresge and then exit, laughing andtalking in groups of four-and six to eat lunch in theStudent Center? Are they people who were studentsat the Institute long ago? Are they leaders of themilitary-industrial complex who make nasty wea-pons and kick little children? Are they, in the wordsof the catalog, "distinguished leaders of science,engineering, industry and education?" Are theypeople who care deeply about the Institute and thepeople who work here? Are they "legitimate?" Itseems to us that they are a little of all these andmore besides.

From a functional standpoint, the Corporationhas enormous power over the Institute which itgenerally delegates to its Executive Committee, thefaculty, and the administration. If it chooses to do

so, the Cooration can be an effective "outside"influence which can overcome inertia and resistanceto needed changes in the Institute.

While most Corporation visiting committees dothe best they can in the limited time they have, theyare not accessible to a large number of people on aregular basis. It seems to us thai it might bedesirable to have a member of the Corporation oncampus who did not have a large number ofadministrative tasks to concern him. Although mostmembers of the Corporation are very busy withother work, a retired member might find it stimula-ting and worthwhile to spend time talking to manypeople on campus as an unofficial ombudsman forthe MIT community. An independent participant-inthe solving of the Institute's problems, he wouldhave no administrative duties. He would thus be anaccessible member of the power structure whowould be freer than the overworked administrationto promote innovations. He might bring- new andindependent views into many discussions. Anytakers, gentlemen?

gave entirely too much weight to suchistatistics as injuries to individual police-men, while not giving nearly thatamount of attention to demonstratorinjuries. The lack of concrete figureswould not have prevented publication

:of lists of estimates by the variousorganizations involved. This sort ofdetail is presented' for the policemen incompact form in one of the appen-dices; however, no such 'effort wasmade for the demonstrators, who un-doubtedly suffered many more injuriesthan did the police.

It is interesting to notice that theACLU report. gave accounts of oneincid6nt, which neither Mailer nor Wal-ker's committee found, involving asquad of black policemen in LincolnPark who were apparently movingfreely in the crowd in an effort to keepthings cool. The ACLU reports that.this group was moderately successful,but that they withdrew when the whitepolice arrived. Although it is neverexplicitly stated, the reader is left withthe distinct impression that there was abattle plan (so to speak) drawn upwhich would first lull the demonstra-tors into a sense of security, thenattack them. This is, of course, only animpression.

For anyone desirng a momento ofthe Chicago Convention, I would re-

commend with Walker or the ACLU.Mailer seems to be hung up on the ideaof the "novel as history" and in theprocess loses sight of the novel as aninteresting piece of reading or art form.

decentralized dining facilities to searchfor these subsidies.

Corrections please?Kenneth R. Wadleigh

Dean of Student Affairs

Commons...again.................. j __ .. the .. it

well written and clearly expresses my To thoe Edi tMor:views presented in the interview. Sine - L. Bishof and D.Tc Moore have

,issued -a letter announcing the "clubthe matter is confused and controver- -insial at best, all the more credit is due plan of commons meals descrbed

Mr. Baker for his fine presentation. your story of February 28. The mostbasic objection to compulsoryVery truly yours,commons is that one is forced to pay,Irwin W. Sizerfor food whether or not one wishes toDean

eat it or does eat it. Under the new-"club plan," one has the option of

... and not so good paying $145.00 per term and gettingno food at all for this money. Instead,

one gets the privilege of paying forTo the Editor: meals in the dorms at the "reduced

In view of the accuracy of recent rate" of $.50 for each breakfast, $.75The Tech news coverage of several for each lunch; and $.95 for eachissues about which I happened to have dinner. So, if someone on the "clubintimate knowledge, I am surprised and plan" ate every commons meal, he

chagrined to find so many mistakes in would pay about $70 per term moreJoe Kashi's article on the Baker House than someone on straight commons.commons meeting which appeared in Can this be serously intended? Can

today's (February 28) The Tech. Wadleigh, Bishoff, and Moore believeFirst, an a la carte system is not that anyone regar ds ts as a better

"inconceivable." It is "conceivable" if - alternative than compulsory commons?we wish to abandon the notion Of A few weeks ago, Bishoff was quotedindividual house dining rooms and go in The Tech as saying that shifting theto a large refectory system, or if we can entire financial burden of commonscharge high a la carte prices in indivi- onto those who choose voluntarily todual house dining rooms and still get eat it would be "unfair." To my mindenough patronage to cover costs. Per- it seems the most elementary kind ofhaps a better word than "incon- fairness, entirely consistent with the

ceivable" would be "unfeasible" or ideals of free enterprise and the"unlikely." American Way of Life- you get what

Second, contrary to what is report- you pay for, and vice versa. I may beed, those meals purchased by a student wrong, though. On the other hand, the

who participates in the new expert- previously-mentioned gentlemenmental "club" plan will be on an believe that charging dorm residents

unlimited seconds basis. who don't want to eat commonsThird- a comparatively .small point, $145.00 per term for the privilege is all

perhaps- the renovated capacity of right.Burton-Conner will be about 360, not I refuse to believe -that these people

325 as reported. are serious. No, they are having a littleFourth, the lead "Centralized joke at our expense. How humorous it

Kitchen May Go Up" and the para. must seem to them.graph headed '%Vest Campus Change" Sometimes I have trouble laughing.were misleading. The fact is that the D.E. Jodrey, Jr.kitchen for MacGregor House will also Editor, Buton House Walrusserve as the kitchen for the second newWest Campus House to be built ad- In the ld days.jacent to MacGregor House, but thiskitchen will not serve the entire WestCampus. Each of these new houses will Te «e has

~~~~On severala occasions, Ihe Tech hasaccommodate about 325 under- commented upon student unrest, ingraduates, and each house will have itsown dining room. "May be built," ishardly descriptive; this kitchen is under , AAXA1N construction right now. WANT METI~~ OM I REa gFinally, in discussing the Institute's X MAR I

policy of not providing subsidies from' BE eAcrothe general budget to the operatingcosts of commons, I did make thepoint several times that the Institutedoes provide a very large subsidy incapital investments in the dining and kkitchen facilities. In short, we feel with me on this subiect. T~ article-7strongly enough about the value of

the guiding genius and founder ofro L XX N d 8MIT. However, this was when he was, _ . ; . ...Professor of Natu"al Philosophy at the -i Ulfivetsity ofVirgtaia;-~ > -- '-ai '10 "BOARD OF D

"Life 'at the Univeirity, although it Charm - ....... :.....had begun so auspiciously, became Eitor ..........more complicated and at times burden- Buies MaagerManaings Mnnator......some to William as th6e years passed. Amain source of distress was a long series Editorial Assis . . . . . . . . . .of outbreaks by disorderly and undis- Po on M e ... . .....ciplined students. Violence was not Night Editors .,. .. Ra

uncommon. Riots, in one of which the News EditorsChairman of 'the Faculty was killed in Features lEditor ............his own dooryard, continued sporad- Spo.Editorically over several years, greatly injured Entetainment Editor . . . . . .. . .

the morale and the reputation of the AvriigEio Be orae m He rputtin o fiee Photography Editor .... e......University, and made life in Charlottes- A eg Edito ...... *..

ville unhappy for professors and cit-izens. William was deeply disturbed by Editor Consultants . . . . . . . *them." - (circa 1836-1839).

Was it Aristotle who said, "HistoryRepeats Itself?."

(Mrs.) Roberta Burns Coniroller .. . .. ..Treasurer ......Accounts Receivable . .Accounts Payable . . .Advertising Associate .Associate Sports Editors

...... ........................ Stan Gilbert '71

....... ............. Steve Tbarp '71

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .... . Doug Coonley '72. ...... . ............... Pete W hite '72

. . . . . . . . . . . .. .... Steve Bailey '72.......... t .... Ray Kwasnick '71

George Novosielski '71, Don Arkin '72

Elections

'ro the Editor:In the past few weeks and days two

factors have be.aome increasinglyevident to me- the present crisis instudent government (this observation isnot particularly acute) and, perhapsmore tragically, the lack of sensitivityto this fact in those offering themselvesup for various important offices. Itseems that most of the people whom Ihave spoken with, who are candidatesfor vanious offices, are more interestedin the offices then in actually doingsomething. I say this because I havefound people in student government

just as petty and backward as MIT'sadnfinistration is sometimes criticizedas being. These people come to yousaying, "Sign my petition." They areall ready to fit right into the presentway of doing things as long as they canbe on some Executive Committee.

Another thing- look at the posters

-- v

you see in the halls for these people;they have little more than the person'sname, class, and the office he is inter-ested in. Oh yes, and maybe a catchyphrase like, '7'fink positive!". Moststudents running for positions can'toffe a stronger one characteristic thatwould differentiate .them.fom anothercandidate. All they can hope for is that

they have enough "friends" and thatthe dorm or IFC will vote for them.

I have no definite solutions to theabove problems, and perhaps there arenone; i.e., that -the characteristics ofstudents result naturally in the morass

we now have. However, I do think it isimportant for every student to beaware of the amount of bullshit thatgoes on in- student government,especially at election time.

Stephen Schwartz '71

'71 Message

To the Editor:

TO THE MEMBERS OF THE CLASSOF 1971:

This is a personal letter. I have(Please turn to page 5)

On the Corporation ...

LettersGood Reporting ...

To the Editor:I wish to compliment The Tech on

the article in the February 25, 1969,issue entitled Classified GraduateTheses and Research Are Curtailed byHarvey Baker, based on an interviewwith me on this subiect. The article is

The Tec-h- .

common with other news media. Ithought that you would be interestedin knowing how badly university u-dents are deteriorating, especially inmatters of self-discipline - over thepast 130 odd years.

The following excerpt is taken fromthe late Professor Samuel C. Prescott'sbook, When M.I.T. was Boston Tech,(The Technology Press, 1954). Inci-dentaily, the 'Wi'liam" referred to wasWilliam Barton Rogers later to become

11 0

TffHE ¢CH

Page 5: Vol. 89 No.8 MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Friday, March 7, …tech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N8.pdf · 2007-12-22 · no matter what his actual age upon graduation from college, he is

THE TECH FRIDAY. MARCH 7. 1969 PAGE 5

: Letters to The Tech

---m - - - - --NW

I I I! 11111

I S 0-

-- "1I

13~ ~ ~ ~'Patricia Neal in" THE SUBJECT WAS ROSES" Ct2.5s, 6:15, 9:30p lptus Marcello Mastroianni in,9iSS THE OTHtER SHlEIK a" 1:30, 4:50, 8:10

Cj jTHIEMARXBROTHERS

A , '*ATHE CIRCUS" Starting Sunday:

' Jean Renoirt's C

Z, "RULES OF THE GAME" AS 'hows daily 5:30, 7:30, 9:30Matinees Saturday and Sunday *-

C4i ItJgU6l, Illu it u·nnlaltp·umue umo

,,!o. J CAMPUS CUEguarantee 590 Commonwealth Ave.

(Opposife B. U. Towers)m~~m l ~erseaDelivery "'' o~f lcur~se.P keBlerPocket B iiardsMOTOR AES

Ize 11 Rte. 1, Dedham "Great for a329-1 Date"

.~~~~~~~~~~~~ m.I m

CHARLIEThe Tech Tailor

e'CLEANING' PRESSING· REPAIRING

.LAUNDRYAlways At Your Service In The

MIT SM[#NT CENTER84 MASS. AVENUE

EL 4,2a Dom L* g,350I I

-Il

iiIIII

II

iII

I6

II

LI

m []

w

II

I

II

IN

9I

I

iIiI

i

I

III

II

I

iiIi

i5

5

ig

I

I

I

I

f

Electioneeringreading-period i1

-By Craig Gordon tion orSchool makes strange bedfellows of that you

situations. Campaigning for elections is, for thefor many, like cramming desperately -conscienand intensely for an exam. with bot

The commitment to run is made above, bafter weighing carefully whether the ideas abcwork is worth the rewards of the will beexperiences of the term. Would doing constituesomething else be 'more profitable or that seemmore pleasant? Even

Getting into the work is a period of son, orgetting psyched up and into the proper doubts rmood. Reassurance from friends is as was reallnecessary for a positive start as the (or vote)effect of getting a good teacher, enthu- two orsiastic and knowledgable. Painlessly the needed?remaining doubts are smoothed away Doubiin the excitement of getting involved. elements

What follows is involvement in a What ifdeep sense. Aesthetically, eating, sleep- your idaing, and living campaigning is more make thexciting than eating, sleeping, and liv- losing.ing formulas. But in each case there is a Losin,tenseness of commitment, a feeling of final. Thbeing tied to a way of action for each .time lostgiven hour, the worry of whether the significantwork will be finished when the night sudden rends.. id) indiv

Seeing each person to get more dared tosignatures on the petition of candidacy Winniisn't bad; it's as simple as turning the everythinpages of a reading assignment to check everyone,it off the reading list. But seeing each who callperson to. win a vote is a more abstract congratuland time-consuming affair. who coM

It's a toss-up as to whether it's dump yoeasier to get one's own brain to grasp even havewhy force equals mass times accelera- to join th

!Panrels hi fight(continued from page Ie c

Control, Disarmament, and Nationali t 9lcSecurity," chaired 'by Professor B;T.

afternoon.Feld of the Department of Physics. BotrisoonBethe, a noted opponent of the

ABM, discussed both the technological ment of land political aspects of the ABM de- veonpmoiployment, and concluded that , arinms- Pesorcontrol treaty is a necessity. Referring'to the role of the scientific community, Computellie said that the current opposition to SocicABM could not have arisen "If there Problehad not been informed opinion amongscientists."

Meselson discussed the effects andstrategies associated with chemical and INbiological warfare, as well as its ramifi- Our repucations in international law. He asked is y- for a coherent US stand against the useof any chemical or biological weaponsand asked concerned scientists to speakout.

W.G. McMillan of UCLA and theRand Corp. expressed disappointmentin the meeting, saying he had heard nospeakers representing those whose deci-sions were under attack, saying "Iwould caution against making a one-sided view."

The remaining scheduled' events will

(continued from page 4)£

just a few things to say.'The followingpeople have given extensively of theirtime and talents this past year;

THE EXECUTIVE COMMIT-.TEE: Marya Sieminsid, Louis Tsien,Ken Weisel

SOCIAL COMMITTEE:-LeslieHorwitz, Mark Gilman, Sam List, ZaneSegal

DOUGHNUT STALWARTS:Kerry Mull, Cathy Buckley, Leah Ja-mieson, Janet Koch, Dale Schain, An-drea 'Sanders, Eric Darling, GeorgeGudz, Bill Haggerty

'71ER: Howard J. Siegel, BettyDeakin, Elliot Kanter

RESEARCH COMMITTEE: KenVogel, Art Gerphkoff, Dave Kaufman,Gary Olhoeft, Paul Palmer

THING '68: Gary Felser, MikeOnorato

FIELD DAY: Del Knarr

RING COMM1ITEE: Ray Huey,Diane Feldman, Jack Goodstein, FredKumm,;r, Pete Rossow

Institute. I know how much you havedone. I just don't know how to thankyou. I hope that by publicly displayingyour names, more people will appre-ciate what you have done.

I do not intend to rn forre-election, but that decision has no-thing to do with the tremendous sup-port which I have received or with thehonor that it has been to work withyou. Thank you.

Stephen C. EhrmannPresident, Class of 1971

FRESHMAN ORIENTATION:Nancy Page, Jerry BushneU

SOPHOMORE COUNCIL LIA-SON: Joe Angland

FEEDBACK: Jim Sholer, DickMyrick

All of you gave more than any-one had a right to ask. Your work wasfor the class and your own enjoyment,but affected almost everyone in the

Gnomon Copy Service, 319 Mass.Ave., Cambridge, is offering a"Gnomon Privilege Card" which per-mits the purchase of Xerox Copies forthree cents each without limit. Thecard operates on the user's signature,like a credit card, and is available freeto anyone who takes the trouble towrite for one. Available to companies,departments, groups, etc. as well asindividuals, the card applies to chargeor cash orders but credit must beapplied for separately. Gnomon Privi-

lege Card orders may also be chargedto MIT P. O. numbers.

The three cent price includes freecollating, and a choice of regular,3-hole, or legal size paper. Other'papers extra. Gnomon is a seven min-ute walk from MIT and uses theXerox 3600-111 machine which has thehighest quality of any Xerox machine.Gnomon's machine even reproducessolids and halftones.

* Additional information may be ob-tained by phoning 868-2715.

The following are corrections to theconstiutions printed in the Tuesdayissue of The Tech . Unified Univer-sity,: Article VI, Section V of theGeneral Assembly Bylaws shouldread: "The General 'Assembly shallelect three (3) undergraduates to serveon the Executive Committee at theMarch meeting of each year.

Senate: Article 11, Section IB of theenate Bylaws should read: "A repre-intative from each undergraduatedornntoy who shall be elected by and

Prom his place of residence in accord-unce %ith the Constitutional Bylawsf his dormitory, except that he shallot become the representative byirtue of holding any other office."

.1.

.1i

'-"'"I' leamre: on'-m 'p uvgnmng.-. q -

reachesntensityto get one's neighbor to graspa are better than your opponentoffice because you are moreitious, because you work betterth your peers and the powersDecause you have lots of goodtout the post. and because youdeeply devoted to both the

lency and the job -all factsm intuitively obvious to you.after 45 minutes with a per-three hours with a poster,

remain as to whether the timely productive. Even if the idea) is there now, will it be therethree days hence when it is

bts arise over the unknowns;which go into the final result.your friends like you but noteas? Will you know? It mayhe difference in winning or

ig is as frightening as failing ahere is a frustrating sense oft. There is, more importantly, ant loss of self-esteem. All of ayou are an unwanted (or stup-vidual. Hou could you havethink otherwise?sing is exhilarating. Once againng is worthwhile. You like, from the elections chairmanIs you on your dormline tolate you, to the herd of friendsne pounding on yuur door to)u in a cold shower. You don'te to partake of the champagnehe mood of the group.

March 4ie tomorrow in 10-250, start-:15 and continuing 'until latet. Featurexd will be Professorgasanik, Head of the Depart-Life Sciences, chairing a paneld! Consequences of new De-its in Biology and Medicine;

Jerome Lettvin on Uses of,rs and Data Storage in theciences; and a discussion on[on of Technology to Urban

Gnomon offers 3¢ Xerox copy

Your newboy~fiend has anewgsirlfriend?

Thin itover over coffee.TheTh,' < Drinkc. ii

ForyourownThinkDrink Mugsend 75C andyournameandeaddressto:ThinkDrink Mug, Dept.N, P.O.Box559,NewYork, N.Y. 10046.TheInternationalCoffeeOrganistion.

d inking VOLVO Relax and Divert

-~CL REE-AAEEk

Page 6: Vol. 89 No.8 MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Friday, March 7, …tech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N8.pdf · 2007-12-22 · no matter what his actual age upon graduation from college, he is

PAGE 6 FRI DAY, MARCH 7, 1969 T- THE TECH

movie... ooe.1968 political documentary , - .-p , . .

| S nIehlre.^lse 's~lib. elf limp Pretty Poison sloppy but solid flick

By Mike MillerIn the Year of the Pig is arn interest-

*ing title. It carries oriental overtones ofthe Confucianist calendar, and is alsoslightly derogatory. The question thatis left at the end of the film is: whomdoes it intend to denigrate? A numberof possible villians are given - NgoDinh Diem, Curtis LeMay, Mark Clark,Madame Nhu - and there is even astretch featuring the ubiquitous JoeMcCarthy. The film presents a clearer,less emotional opinion on the war thanany other of recent years. The filmdoes not use emotion-ridden propagan-da shots of American Knights-errantgallantly saving a poor ignorant popula-tion, or dead Vietnamese, but letspeople who are directly involved withthe war speak.

Kenneth Langdon of the State De-partment under Roosevelt describes thememo in which FDR stated his inten-tion to prevent the French return toIndochina after World War Il. ProfessorPaul Mus of Yale talks about hismeeting with Ho Chi Minh as a rep-resentative of the French government.Mark Clark states at a press conferencethat he wouldn't trade one dead Amer-ican for fifty dead Chinamen. MadameNhu decries the burning of the Budd-hist monks as action instigated by theAmericans. More and more people talk- Harrison Salisbury of the New YorkTimes, John Foster Dulles, RichardNixon, Lyndon Johnson. SenatorThurston Morton tells of the secretmeeting held during the battle of DienBien Phu where Admiral Radford advo-cated immediate deployment of allavailable forces to aid the Frencheffort.

Mostly factThe greatest portion of the film is

fact, stated as it appeared to the peopleinvolved. If it were a simple. documeri-.tary, it would deserve consideration;

sarqpa�Prr IPrP1 RII la -"- a.aa 'I�l�E ��--'-�' � � -- - - - - - - -- - - - -- -

I

I

By Robert FourerPretty Pokson is a modest attempt

at making an interesting, intelligentthriller-one where the charactersaren't stereotypes, the situations aren'tpredictable, and the surprise ending isreally a surprise. Such attempts beingas rare as they are, this alone would beenough to recommend it. However,while originality does eventually bringsuccess, it's not without some problemsalong the way.

On the better side, to begir with,the story line is at least undeniablyoriginal. The film's central character, ayoung man, has just been released onprobation after several years' detentionas a juvenile delinquent. As soonbecomes clear, he- is unable to acceptthe idea of being an ordinary laborer;he fancies he's a CIA agent, working toprevent the pollution of the nation'sentire water supply. His self-scofidencein this assumed role soon attracts atten-tion, especially that of a flirtatious highschool-age gil fascinated by his terse,mysterious instructions. He in turnbecomes increasingly attached to her,and begins to incorporate her into hisschemes.

Surprising character changesTo describe things further would

ruin the effect. However, it may be saidthat neither character ends up what heappears to be in the beginning, and thedifferences are shocking indeed. Theplot resolution, as well, is clever: it

avoids an ordinary cops and robberschase finale, and keeps attention whereit belongs-on the character develop-ment. As always, changes in people aremore frightening than changes in theirsurroundings.

Unfortunately, however, the exposi-tion of these changes is often erratic,mainly because the narration has nopoint of view. Were it centered aroudthe young man, the truth could berevealed naturally as -he realized it.Instead, facts turn up haphazardly, sothat at first one might be led to inter-pret things the wrong way, or formsympathies, especially with the girl,that later prove unfounded. As a result,the build-up is usually more perplexingthan tense, and the film only becomesreally impressive when it's over, and

everything can finally be sorted out.Treatment sloppy

Furthermore, many routine mattersare treated sloppily. While the plot as awhole is consistent enough to bebelievable, some details are left annoy-ingly contradictory or unexplained. Inaddition, there is nothing very clevercinematically-only the stock scenesand camera tricks. -It's the attention todetail that makes a film great; thisone's creators were obviously aimingfor something less.

Still, as enjoyable and moderatelystimulating entertainment, PrettyPoison is a good deal better than mostof what else has been able to fight itsway to Boston, especially among thosethat aren't expensive big deals. More ofthe same would be welcome.

but it is much more. The film iscoherent, the camera work is excellent.The acting is by real people, which isfar superior to reconstruction of actualevents by professional actors. Emile deAntonio, who did the great film of theMcCarthy hearings Point of Order usedthe same technique, letting importantfacts speak for themselves without edi-torial comment. It is just as effectiveon Vietnam as it was on McCarthy.

Viewers will disagree about theviewpoint that comes out of the movie,for there is a viewpoint. Since no onethese days talk's about Vietnam inobjective terms, it would be unreason-able to expect filmmakcers to be anydifferent from the rest of the popula-tion. The greatest quality of the film,though, is thle openess it leaves todiscussion- discussion based on logicand a knowledge of recent historywhich, hopefully, is what the Paristalks are all about It -is highly xecom-mended to see the filin, preferably wvitha friend or group of friends with whomyou can take up the loose ends of thefilm and, discuss the points raied.Discussion is the prime purpose ofdocumentary, and it is admirably ful^filled by de Antonio in The Year of thePig.

a

E:ri

r

z

t�gb

1a

7,jZ

zs;

i1;4;d

r.;

-.2

I

NEXT TO CUSTOMER SElRVICE IN BOOK DEPARTMENTSunglasses. tailormade to your prescription in the finest of

Bausch and Lomb and American optical lensesQuality and Service is Our Byword-Patronage.Refund

Opthalmologists prescriptions are filled promptly -accurately.Excellent selection of frames for Men, Women, Children.

Office Houts: Monday-Friday, 8:50 to 5:30-Lunch 2-3 (Closed)Saturday, 9:20 to 1:00

Phone 491 42 30, Ext. 50 or from MIT dial 8950

T0eETECH COOP In the MIT Student Center

M " L.7JLAL'4L/%-' 'O.F L -ALJ AL %-.' M

2ime is

Each. minute you spend inindecision is a minute wasted.. a1 minute that adds tip toa.- hour or a day that hasvanished forever.

That minute may have beenspent as Paulists do, counsel-ing a questioning youth at asecular university, workingin ghettos, saving a potential"dropout" or promoting bet-ter understanding of theChurch and all religions.

How do your minutes stackup?

If you have given somethought to becoming a priest,why not find out how thePaulists spend their time andsend for an illustrated bro-chure and a summary of thePaulist effort for renewal inthe Church.

Write to:

Vocation Director

91au&ist(ataihei

Room 222B415 West 59th Street

New York, N.Y. 10019

AA

Page 7: Vol. 89 No.8 MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Friday, March 7, …tech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N8.pdf · 2007-12-22 · no matter what his actual age upon graduation from college, he is

THETECH FRIDAY, MARCH 7, 1969 PAGE 7II --~P-~c IB-~~"P· ~ . ... ~ -p·~C~ CDII -Y1 . . ..... II ,I 'l---· - i-_. i--- · _IJ� -ILI --· I- -- 1

I

IIiI

II

1

-II-IPrsarrs�~�-- �larrCI�"C"II·�-3�1Ir_·�

�u �s LL B�k is Ln - ·- ..- I IIL-·LIYI ·· -� --·I)--I -

--- - -

ag

Llb11II

IIIIII1i

4

1

1

1

1

1

1

4

brightenvictory in Rockwell Cage by good forLowell Tech 85-76. Two scoring ats completed the 6-15 season. additionthe records indicate other- Steve Gaswas probably a successful who wasI-MIT. When a college does the seasort to recruit athletes, it often per game,f with a team that just shot.ve the skills needed to be If onea with the teams it plays "year ofr many years, Tech basket- for next yore than fortunate with guysWilson and Dave Jansson Andrair talents. This year, thereson or Jansson, and Coach 1in ked harder.ts for next year's team are nextiof this year's starters will

vill Bruce Wheeler, who willnore years of eligibility left. , l; lack of height will more '"1 teade up for with the additions says,'reshman team. Ben Wilson, instance,brother of Alex, is a rugged esting toathlete who was personally absorbedbig Alex. On this year's At ot

wrestling.eam, he scored at a 14.8 per wre'stlinme rate, while pulling down " lt sIds in 18 games. Rod Reigier stregtsix-foot-seven, and he was _s" ngth.

nine rebounds a game, whilet a 12.1 rate. A third valuablefrom the freshman squad isss, a six-foot-three forward,forced to play guard most ofn. Steve hit for 12.4 points, mostly on a strong outside

would consider this year as arebuilding", then watch outear's rebuilt squad.

ree to wrestle{CAA tourneyweek in Calif.

Cagers lack i kht

Frosh stars(continued from page 8)

breaking his hand. This left the MIT up its final ,experience quotient at zero. Fortunate- defeating Ily, Steve missed only five games. His more lossesreturn to the team was a welcome While tbreak, as he scored almost twelve wise, thispoints per game for the remainder of season forthe season. Against Tufts, in the not attemptColonial Tournament, he almostsingle- finds itselfhandedly led MIT to a comeback which doesn't havfell short. The remainder of the squad -competitivefeatured Captain Bob Listfield '69, and against. Fora bullk of sophomores led by Dennis ball was meFlaherty, John Bell, and Frank Taylor. like Alex

After the amazing 92-90 win over lending theTrinity, MIT stood at 3-2, and many was no Wilpeople didn't expect Tech to win that Barry workmany games all season. They were Prospectalmost right. Tech lost their next seven bright. Allgames, one of which was- a 63-60 return, as wdouble overtime loss to Colby, and it. have two mtook the yearly New York trip to hault This year'sthe slide. In the Big City, Tech soundly than be ma,defeated Yeshiva and Brooklyn Poly- from the fitech, two teams in the Knickerbocker the "little"Conference. Tech returned to Cam- six-foot-sixbridge to play in the Colonial Tourna- trained byment against a strong Northeastern freshman teteam. The squad was soundly beaten cent per galby an 81-56 count. After losing the 215 rebounconsolation game to Tufts, Tech picked stands at s

Atuuomtremennts* Dormcon elections will be held at the next meeting, to be held Thursday

at 7:30 in McCormick Hall. Officers to be elected are Chairman, Secretary-Treasurer:, Freshman Orientation Chairman, and Judicial Committee Chair-

man. Prospective candidates should see their House Presidents for details.* A debate between candidates for President of the Class of '72 will be

held Monday at 8 PM in the Sala.* Physics Department Ombudsmen, avaiable to any student, faculty, or

staff member, employee, or "associate" of the Physics Department, areProfessor Jerome Friedman C24-512) x 7585, and Professor Henry Kendall(24-514) x 7584.

* Tryouts for Dramashop's next set of one-act plays will take placeMonday at 7:30 in Kresge Little Theatre. The three plays, which include anoriginal, will be performed on March 21 and 22.

* Professor Cheatham of Harvard will address the Student ComputerSociety on "The Art and Science of Compilers" at a meeting Monday at 8 PMin room W20-473 in the Student Center. Refreshments will be served.

future

PARTHENON RESTAURANTAUIENIC GREEK CoSUN

E:X EUROEA AND AMRIIUCAN lNEALL KUDS OFLIUQR.R

tN(IE HEBEUJ ATM9OSPER FEAhTURIGTHE AUlNT GREE PARIT

OPEN EVERY DAY11 A.M. to 11 P.M./

Extremely Moderate PricesFor Reservations Call 491-9592

924 .Mass. Aveei4 xff^ | (BETWEEN HARVARD AND

CENTRAL SQUARES)

Page 8: Vol. 89 No.8 MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Friday, March 7, …tech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N8.pdf · 2007-12-22 · no matter what his actual age upon graduation from college, he is

PAGE 6 FRI-DAY, MARCH 7, 1969 - THE TECH_ _ -

._-

_ .1.__ ,,,_

- --· C-__ C Il bll OM I

chase finale, and keeps attention whereit belongs-on the character development. As always, changes in people aremore frightening than changes in theirsurroundings.

Unfortunately, however, the exposi-tion of these changes is often erratic,mainly because the narration has nopoint of view. Were it centered aroudthe young man, the truth could berevealed naturally as-he realized it.Instead, factsturn up haphazardly, sothat at first one might be led to inter-pret things the wrong way, or formsympathies, especially with the girl,that later prove unfounded. As a result,the build-up is usually more perplexingthan tense; and the film only becomesreally impressive when it's over, 'and

_ . -d_

I

|

g

,

I

i

X

X

I

I

1

I

L0.1

Pretty Poison is a modest attemptat making an interesting, intelligentthriller-one where the charactersaren't stereotypes, the situations aren'tpredictable, and the surprise ending isreally a surprise. Such attempts beingas rare as they are, this alone would beenough to recommend it. However,while originality does eventually bringsuccess, it's not without some problemsalong the way.

On the better side, to begirt with,the story line is at leas; undeniablyoriginal. The film's central character, ayoung man, has just been released onprobation after several years' detentionas a juvenile delinquent. As soonbecomes clear, he is unable to acceptthe idea of being an ordinary laborer;he fancies he's a CIA agent, working toprevent the pollution of the nation'sentire water supply. His self-confidencein this assumed role soon attracts atten-tion, especially that of a flirtatious highschool-age girl fascinated by his terse,mysterious instructions. He in turnbecomes increasingly attached to her,and begins to incorporate her into hisschemes.

Treatment sloppyFurthermore, many routine matters

are treated sloppily. While the plot as awhole is consistent enough to bebelievable, some details are left annov-ingly contradictory or unexplained. Inaddition, there is nothing very clevercinematically-only thte stock scenesand camera tricks. It's the attention todetail that makes a film great; thisone's creators were obviously aimingfor something less.

Still, as enjoyable and moderatelystimulating. entertainment, PrettyPoison is a good deal better than mostof what else has been able to fight itsway to Boston, especially among thosethat aren't expensive big deals. More ofthe same would be welcome.

By Mike MillerIn the Year of the Pig is an interest-

'ing title. It carries oriental overtones ofthe Confucianist calendar, and is alsoslightly derogatory. The question thatis left at the end of the film is: whomdoes it intend to denigrate? A numberof possible villians are given - NgoDinh Diem, Curtis' LeMay, Mark Clark,Madame Nhu - and there is even astretch featuring the ubiquitous JoeMcCarthy. The film presents a clearer,less emotional opinion on the war thanany other of recent years. The filmdoes not use emotion-ridden propagan-da shots of American Knights-errantgallantly saving a poor ignorant popula-tion, or dead Vietnamese, but letspeople who are directly involved withthe war speak.

Kenneth Langdon of the State De-partment under Roosevelt describes thememo in which FDR stated his inten-tion to prevent the French return toIndochina after World War II. ProfessorPaul Mus of Yale talks about hismeeting with Ho Chi Minh as a rep-resentative of the French governmentMark Clark states at a press conferencethat he wouldn't trade one dead Amer-ican for fifty dead Chinamen. MadameNhu decries the burning of the Budd-hist monks as action instigated by theAmericans. More and more people talk- Harrison Salisbury of the New YorkTimes, John Foster Dulles, RichardNixon, Lyndon Johnson. SenatorThurston Morton tells of the secretmeeting held during the battle of DienBien Phu where Admiral Radford advo-cated immediate deployment of allavailable forces to aid the Frencheffort.

Mostly factThe greatest portion of the film is

fact, stated as it appeared to the peopleinvolved. If it were a simple. documen-.tary, it would deserve consideration;

, .. 1

Crne iscl Inning

OutEach. minute you spend inindecision is a minute wasted... a minuie that adds Up toa., hour or a day that hasvanished forever.

That minute may have beenspent as Paulists do, counsel-ing a questioning youth at asecular university, workingin ghettos, saving a potential"dropout" or promoting bet-ter understanding of theChurch and all religions.

How do your minutes stackup?

If you have given somethought to becoming a priest,why not find out how thePaulists spend their time andsend for an illustrated bro-chure and a summary of thePaulist effort for renewal inthe Church.

Write to:

but it is much more. The film iscoherent, the camera work is excellentThe acting is by real people, which isfar superior to reconstruction of actualevents by professional actors. Emile deAntonio, who did the great film of theMcCarthy hearings Point of Order usedthe same technique, letting importantfacts speak for themselves without edi-torial comment. It is just as effectiveon Vietnam as it was on McCarthy.

Viewers will disagree about theviewpoint that comes out of the movie,for there is a viewpoint. Since no onethese days talks about Vietnam inobjective terms, it would be unreason-able to expect filmmakers to be anydifferent from the rest of the popula-tion. The greatest quality of the film,though, is the openess it leaves todiscussion- discussion based on logicand a knowledge of recent historywhich, hopefully, is what the Paristalks are all about It .is highly recom-mended to see the film, preferably witha friend or group of friends with whomyou can take up the loose ends of thefilm and- discuss the points raised.Discussion is the prime purpose ofdocumentary, and it is admirably ful-filled by de Antonio in The Year of thePig.

NEXT TO CUSTOMER SERVICE IN BOOK DEPARTMENTSunglasses, tailormade to your prescription in the finest of

Bausch and Lomb and American optical lenses· Quality and Service is Our Byword-Patronage Refund

Opthalmoiogists prescriptions are filled promptly-accurately.Excellent selection of frames for Men, Women, Children.

Office Hours: Monday-Friday, 8:50 to 5:30-Lunch 2-3 (Closed)Saturday, 9:20 to 1:00

Phone'491-4230, Exct. 50 or from MIT dial 8950

I, TECH COOPIn the MIT Student Center

84 Mwsachusetts Avenue Cambridge, Mass. 02139 .

Vocation Director

",*Faukli sFathe.

Room 222B415 West 59th Street

New York, N.Y. 10019XJ

..

I

movie...moi....1968 political documentary I , . ,- .1968. poe 'litia documenta 'Pretty Poison' sloppy but solid flick

~~~~a picturesque 'slice of life'By Robert Fourer avoids an ordinary cops and robbers evernthin, can finallvy henorteA nlt

Page 9: Vol. 89 No.8 MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Friday, March 7, …tech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N8.pdf · 2007-12-22 · no matter what his actual age upon graduation from college, he is

THE TECH FRIDAY, MARCH 7, 1969 PAGE 7I CWI [ [[ .... · );Cibrr, [- - ---

'- Il Z~~ I II I I I I- I~

-- '- - [ -%g-

-- I -I=I -I I�----' ---------- II IIL II I --.- I�I · I - -.-L -s L

L1

I

w

{continued from page 8)breaking his hand. This left the MITexperience quotient at zero. Fortunate-ly, Steve missed only five games. Hisreturn to the team was a welcomebreak, as he scored almost twelvepoints per ganle for the remainder ofthe season. Against Tufts, in theColonial Tournament, he almost single-handedly led MIT to a comeback whichfell short. The remainder of the squad,featured Captain Bob Listfield '69, anda bulk of sophomores led by DennisFlaherty, John Bell, and Frank Taylor.

After the amazing 92-90 win overTrinity, MIT stood at 3-2, and manypeople didn't expect Tech to win thatmany games all season. They werealmost right Tech lost their next sevengames, one of which was a 63-60double overtime loss to Colby, and it-took the yearly New York trip to haultthe slide. In the Big City, Tech soundlydefeated Yeshiva and Brooklyn Poly-tech, two teams in the KnickerbockerConference. Tech returned to Cam-bridge to play in the Colonial Tourna-ment against a strong Northeasternteam. The squad was soundly-beatenby an 81-56 count. After losing theconsolation game to Tufts, Tech picked

good for nine rebounds a game, whilescoring at a 12.1 rate. A third valuableaddition from the freshman squad isSteve Gass, a six-foot-three forward,who was forced to play guard most ofthe season. Steve hit for 12.4 pointsper game, mostly on a strong outsideshot.

If one would consider this year as a"year of rebuilding", then watch outfor next year's rebuilt squad.

Andree to wrestlein NCAA tourneynext week in Calif.

up its final victory in Rockwell Cage bydefeating Lowell Tech 85-76. Twomore losses completed the 6-15 season.

While the records indicate other-wise, this was probably a successfulseason for MIT. When a college doesnot attempt to recruit athletes, it oftenfinds itself with a team that justdoesn't have the skills needed to becompetitive with the teams it playsagainst. For many years, Tech basket-ball was more than fortunate with guyslike Alex Wilson and Dave Janssonlending their talents. This year, therewas no Wilson or Jansson, and CoachBarry worked harder.

Prospects for next year's team arebright All of this year's starters willreturn, as will Bruce Wheeler, who willhave two more years of eligibility leftThis year's lack of height will morethan be made up for with the additionsfrom the freshman team. Ben Wilson,the "little" brother of Alex, is a ruggedsix-foot-six athlete who was personallytrained by, big Alex. On this year'sfreshman team, he scored at a 14.8 percent per game rate, while pulling down215 rebounds in 18 games. Rod Reigierstands at six-foot-seven, and he was

Cagers lack he' ht

Frosh stars brighten fitureC7

ABlnnu tteten i.* Dormcon elections will be held at the next meeting, to be held Thursday

at 7:30 in McCormick Hall. Officers to be elected are Chairmnnan, Secretary-Treasurer, Freshman Orientation Chairman, and Judicial Committee Chair-man, Prospective candidates should see their House Presidents for details

* A debate between candidates for President of the Class of '72 will beheld Monday at 8 PM in the Sala.

* Physics Department Ombudsmen, avaiable to any student, faculty, orstaff member, employee, or "associate", of the Physics Department, areProfessor Jerome Friedman (24-512) x 7585, and Professor Henry Kendall(24-514) x 7584.

* Tryouts for Dramashop's next set of oneact plays will take placeMonday at 7:30 in Kresge Little Theatre. The three plays, which include anoriginal, will be performed on March 21 and 22.

* Professor Cheatham of Harvard will address the Student ComputerSociety on '"The Art and Science of Compilers" at a meeting Monday at 8 PMin room W20-473 in the SOrdent Center. Refreshments will be served. -

PARTHENON RESTAURANTAUMBNC GREEK CUSMME

aEXCEL EUOR PEAN AND AMERICAN We. AIL UNDIS F UQUOR

Jc~E - HEIISIC ATIMDE VEAURMN .THE AC r GREEK PARTIHENON

OPEN EVERY DAy11 A.M. to 11 P.M./

Extremely Moderate PricesFor Reservations Call 491-9592

9124 Mass. Av*.(BE.TWEEN HARVARD AND

CENTRAL SQUaRES)

Page 10: Vol. 89 No.8 MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Friday, March 7, …tech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N8.pdf · 2007-12-22 · no matter what his actual age upon graduation from college, he is

PAGE 8 FRIDAY, MARCH 7, 1969 NE TECH,

AZncree runnirg out of foesFinal mark 6-15-

Tiny Cleveland brightensdismal basketball season (The f~o~oing story is. reprinted

cortesy of the Boston -Globe.By B~( aes9

Nobody wants to play with FredAfidree. The 6-foot-2, 225 poundheavyweight wrestler for thie Mqqsachu-setis Institute of Technology goes topractice everyday. He does calisthenics.exercises, works with weights. -But hedoes not wrestle.

"Trhere's this guy named Mike- Idon't know his second name," saysAndree. "H~e's in the merchant marinesand he wrestled in college. He's around240 pounds, and every once in a while,he comes in - and wants a wo~rkoutSometimes I wrestle with him. 'When Iget an opponent, I have to take advan-tage of it." -

Andree, a Junior who is undefeatedin 42 dual meets for MIT durng thepast two. seasons, pinning 24 of hisopponents, started this year working_with Bruce Davies, MIT's 191-poundwrestler. But Davies }1urt-his knee andis finished for the season.

For awhile, Andree worked outwith Harvard's wrestlers. At times, hegoes over to Boston University to workcout with Larry Hawkcins, a freshman atBU, These sessions are few and farbetween.

Someone at MIT recently had thebright idea of having Andree wrestlewith,,Jim Nance, the Boston Patriot's,fullback, wh o was a wrestlingchampion in college. Nance's bad ankleprevents him from wrestling. Baut hesuggested that Andree invite HoustonAlntwvine, the. Pats' 281? pound defen-sive tackle, to work with him. Anothe.possibility is Dick Arigton, the Pats'No. I draft choice several years ago,who also was a wrestler at Notre Dame.' Andree would like to grapple with

people like Antwine or Arrington orNance. *They're bigger than he isi andthey're stronger than he is. It might beeducational

"I thik," he' says, "that I realycould improve if I wrestled with a guy

'~--who-could reatrttici*ito mu." Andree got turned onto wrestling as

a 13 year-old kid in Baraboo, Wiscon-sin. He was first in line when the sport

Lwas introduced."-Fooling around," he explained, "4I

Lalways liked to wrestle."H e went on to compile a 6&10-l

record in high school, and also played_tackle on the football team. During

vacations, he worked at physical jobs:logging, construction, stacking100-pound castings in a factory. Hethrived on the work.

(Please turn to page 7).

.A rally for the golf team will be heldWednesday at 5 PM in the VarsityClub lounge. The team will be touringthe south duringspring vacation.

In an effort to sound out feelingstoward possibly adding soccer to theIM fist,-The Tech would like to invitecomment from its readers on theissue. Opinions should be sent to:Sports EditorThe Tech, W20483,MIT.

VA rAV 5 Vif/ E . .

es. The season starts on Tuesday, TOnDeckan open practice is scheduled from Gymnass- Fr., New Englands atD seven pm on Monday. Lowell Tech

he IMa squash season openedw'ues Wrestling (V&F)- Fri., Sat, New Englands'he M suas seson pend Tes-Rifle- Frid., Harvard, away

wi~th seven matches at the duPont^ w ith seven matches at the du~ont Squash (V- Fri., Sat, Sun., Nationals

Aluni oolsqushcouts.Fory-Swimming (V&F)- Thurs., Fri.; Satteam~s of three players each wil Indoor Track- Sat., IC4A's, at New Yorkan expanded number of games Rifle- Sat., Coast Guard, home

r the new system of leagues. Clas-tions such as A or B leagues have >°dropped and replaced by seven

ions of six teams each, which are r s c^¢ hly equal in strength. eeven matches are played on every , ->day, Wednesday, and Thursday oo~ >2 3t, allowing each team to play once . f ek. Teams play each other in their v w, ;): 5,ctive leagues once for a total ofaxa(-ofitests. The regular season will be o;* Mwed by a 16 tear., double eliminar -D tournament consisting of the top :>x;X 2.s

finishers in each leaguie plus thea: ° Asurvivors of a play-off among the ,"c. JrSC

place finishers. Last year'schamp, Ugnd a

,is the solid favorite, having im- E=v) :!d at the same time that its chief u n- X >mangers have been weakened by ar 2 T <o tation losses. 6sco .

I

Something like this could onlyhappen to Minot, who played in all butone varsity contest, and scored an even300 points, for a game average of 15per cent. In the process, he broke anall-time MMIT'record by hitting on 66 of75 free throws for an 88 per cent mark.He even contributed an average of tworebounds per game, reflecting histremendous desire to overcome hisshort height with tough and aggressivebasketball. Yet, despite his brand ofplay, he never fouled out of a game. Allin all, it was an amazing season for ayoung man who wasn't even consideredgood enough to start on the freshmanteam.

It became quite obvious early in theseason that the loss of Dave Janssoncould not be made up. Dave had always

'been counted on for twenty points andtwelve rebounds. Try as they might,juniors Nick Murlfold and Bob Vegelexcould not fill his shoes. Nick played inall twenty-one games, and scored 212points for a 10.1 average. His 152rebounds, which represented d gameaverage of 7.2, was-second only toVegeler's 158. Vegeler averaged 7.5rebounds a game and scored at an 8.4:clip.

Steve Chamberlain combined withBruce Wheeler to give MIT a toughbackcourt scoring punch on last year'swinning squad. But Wheeler took ayear off to study at Princeton, andChamberlain complicated matters by

tPlease turn to page 7)

By Jay ZagerMinot Clevland could never really

be mistaken for a basketball player. Ina game where a six-footer is consideredthe "little man", there is no room foranyone who stands five-foot-six. But ifthere was a bright spot in this year'sdismal 6-1 season, it would -have to bethe young sophomore from Anderson,Indiana, who took over as a starteronly because junior Steve Chamberlainbroke his wrist in the first week ofpractice, and who led MIT in everyoffensive department (except rebound-ing).

Coach Jack Barry approached histenth season at Tech with apprehen-sion; gone from last year's 16-9 squadwas -small college AUl-American DaveJanssen, and only one returning starterwas around to play for the inexper-ienced cagers. MIT opened the seasonwith a surprising one-point win overTufts; a week later, they found them-selves with a respectable 2-2 record anda big game against Trinity in front ofthem.

That game was destined to be thehighlight of one of the most amazingnights in Tech sports history. Fiveminutes before the bus was supposedto leave, Coach Barry called assistant-coach Fran O'Brian toinform him thathe (Barry) would not be able to makethe trip, and that O'Brian, who foryears was a successful baseball andbasketball coach at Stonehill College,would be in command.

On the way to Trinity, the busbroke down, and it was an hour beforea mechanic could repair the damage.When the bus Dally reachfd Hartford,the transmission locked, and aftertrying to push the bus, the team wasforced to walk a mile, in the rain, tothe gym.

When they reached the gym, theywere greeted with the news that thefE iehman ball teiaii hiiiaid9 won tIheir firstgame of the season, but prospects for adouble victory seemed remote against apowerful Trinity squad. At the half,the home team led by fifteenn points.The lead reached 22 with only fifteenminutes to play. Coach O'Brian called'time and decided to gamble- he calledfor a full-court press, figuring to makethe game interesting, if nothing else.Amazingly, the press worked, and thelead was slowly cut. Witl less than aminute to play, MIT tied the score, andthen with fie seconds to play, MinotCleveland hit on two free throws togive the engineers, an amazing 92-90upset victory.

Just the sight of Fred Andree '70 seems to shake his foes. Andree, whoboasted a 68-10-1 record during his high school career is undefeated in42 dual meets for MI T.

atCaptain Doug Cale '69, fully recoveredfrom last week, placed fifth and led-hTTs strong second place finish. UNHbeat everybody Cith a 1-2-3 sweep.Right behind Doug was Max Daamer'70 in eighth and Hans Rasmussen '70in 11th. This was Tech's best crosscountry race ever, with all three skiershaving their best race of the year.

By Saturday morning, Tech was 30points ahead of Yale in fiffth place. Thefirst event of the day was the slalom.John Schultz's strong second run wasmarred by his fall in the first runsTech's fist finisher was Miles Wagner,wlro placed 14th. Once again JohnCary and Chuck McIsaac did well androunded out the scoring for MIT. Inthe jumping which was the last event

I; tnurn o

hodabrloafo

UP

'~C L ''vxa,-=0e Q-W sC )NoM_H4~d .;

zir~o;

-_. _e *.- i *I a,-r_-t VI bttum I ar -

- I-

A

pi

c

Volleyballolleyball also opened its seasoniay in duPont. Eighty, teams havefitted rosters and are divided upthree divisions. Voleyball has the)us distinction of having the fist.male team ever to play an IM

McCormack has a team enteredvision 3 -

Skiers end mediocre seasonnis in0

By Bill MichelsLast weekend, MIT closed out its

varsity season with-its-best meet of-theyear at the Norwich Carnival. Tech didbetter than ever in all four events, andbeat Yale, who had beaten them severalplaces at the Division II Championshipsthe week before. UNHi; who qualifiedfor the Division land placed fourththere, won easily here.

The first event of the now filledmeet was the downhill Friday morning.Once again Tech's top Alpine skIer,Cohis Schultz '71, won our only medalof the weekend with an excellent thirdplace finish. John Cary '69 and ChuckMclsaac '71 were Tech's othier twoscorers. The next event was the crosscountry, which is Tech's strongest.

fifth aNorwiclhof the carnival, Tech had its bestshowing 6s the year. Rich Fieyberg '70paced-the team with a-leap-o-f-CIveg0-feet off the 40 meter hill.

The Norwich Carnival performanceenabled MIT to end its disappointingseason on a goqd note. Next year Techwill lose only two skiers and will be-looking forward to its top position inDivision III and a possible comeback inthe Division 1l Championships

Snowv delays intramural hockeyRosenfeld '69 continued his habit of wereno SAM rbserves. league

By George Novosielski scoring the decisive goal by notching Kappa Sigma downed ATO 5-2 be- and aSnow again caused a delay in the his eighth goal in the last fire games hind the five goal effort of center Mike six to

Dckey play-off, as all games on Mon- (three of which were game winners). Perry '69. The Kappa Sigs had a 3-tay were cancelled. Four consolation Ted Kaplan tallied in the first period lead in the third period before a two Tbracket matches were played with the for SAM and Mark Ablowitz tied it up goal burst by Chad Carpenter"'71 put day %isers dropping from the tournament with the only AEPi marker in the the ATO's only one goal back. Two and AMlowingtheir second losses. middle period. Further credit goes to more 'markers by Perry throttled the two t

In the most exciting game SAM the six SAM starters who played the ATO rally and gave Kappa Sigma its playpset AEPi 2-1 in triple overtime. I)on enftre game without any rest as there -final edge. under

The Busby brothers, Bob and sificatGeorge, led DU to its first win of the beenseason, a 4 2 come from behind tri- divisicumph over East Campus. Their three roughgoals. plus a single tally by Anrton SeReisch '72, offset markers by Lewis TuesdReich-'70 and Glenn Sachar '?0 for night,

_ 1 East Campus. Burton House thrashed a weeDTD 7-1 as four players took turns respec

_;· lighting the lamps. five cThe play-offs have been unusually follow

r;`_ , '',rough with two players already sent to ton b~( the infummuy with head injuries. M nor to f

i··lacerations and bruises have become a two siregular occurlence as play continues- thirdn into the quarter d m LCA,

Consolation bracket encallnter .~ ~~~~~~spr two alfour-team b ineausnd team as inadu