Upload
kbarn389
View
236
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/19/2019 Wang Ping Methods of Human Sacrifice in Shang New Edition
1/14
Methods of killing Human Sacrifice in Shang-dynasty Oracle-bone Inscriptions
Wang ping
Abstract
Records on human sacrifice have been revealed by the oracle-bone inscriptions of
Shang Dynasty. Human sacrifices carry special symbolic significance in Shang
Dynasty for worshipping spirits. Different methods of killing were used in worship
rituals. As the inscription reveals, some words are used as the methods of killing of
human beings in general. n the meantime, some special characters are used to refer
to specific killing methods through analysis of the characters and structures of the
language. !he lecture will focus on "# different methods of killing human sacrifice.
!he methods include beheading, splitting the body into halves, dismembering
bodies, beating to death, chopping to death, e$tracting blood, burying alive,drowning, burning to death, boiling, corpse displaying, e$posing body part to hot
sun. %ith the analysis of the different methods of human sacrifice, it is easy to
conclude that human sacrifice was a very common religious practice in Shang
dynasty. !hese practices reflect the cruelty of the rulers to their sub&ects and their
piety towards the spirits they worship.
1 Introduction:
Records centered on human sacrifice are called rénjì bǔcí 人祭卜辞 in Shang
dynasty oracle-bone inscriptions. Ré njì 人祭 refers to the ritual of killing living
human individuals to worship spirits. Accordingly, the term r é nshē ng 人牲 refers to
living human individuals offered to the spirits as a sacrificeA. Actually, during the
process of the ritual of rénjì人祭 , the human sacrificial victims 'rénshēng 人牲( had
a special symbolic significance and were considered the best medium . !he methods
of killing human sacrifice refer to the way of killing living human individuals for
worshipping spirits. According to our study, though yòng 用 was used to designate
methods of killing human sacrifice in general), the use of special terminology
referring to the different methods of killing living human sacrifice was more
common. !he specific characters and structures used in the pictograms of these
terms allow us to infer information about the process of killing living humanvictims. *n the basis of Jiǎgǔwén Héjí 《甲骨文合集》+, we have selected " terms,
e$emplifying "# different methods of killing human sacrifice. !hese methods are
beheading, splitting the body into halves, dismember bodies, beating to death,
chopping to death, taking blood, burning, burying alive, drowning, e$posing and
drying.
Methods of killing human sacrifice:
!1 "eheading
ASee Hung h/nyu0. 黄展岳. Zhōngguó gǔdài dē rénshēng rénxùn中国古代的人牲人殉 ')1i&2ng3 %4nw5+h6b7nshè, !""#, $% !&%)'(( ()*+$( -é./ 0"1,232%+'(( 456 78958:;&% ?@ABCDén -é./% 甲骨文合集 [email protected] 'hK.L MNnBOìnPFn 中QRSTUV, !"W#X!"W1&%
"
8/19/2019 Wang Ping Methods of Human Sacrifice in Shang New Edition
2/14
)eheading means to cut off a human sacrifice8s head and then offer it to the spirits.
!he technicalterms to record this method include !" Y and x# D.!he character of !" Y in Shang-dynasty oracle bone inscriptions depicts a dagger put
on the neck of a person. t was not only used to designate a method of killing living
human victims, but also as the name of a sacrificial ritual
9
. !he character of !"Y
shows the specific operational process of killing living human sacrifice, i.e. using a
dagger to cut off human sacrifice8s head for worship. !his method of killing human
sacrifice was :uite common in the sacrificial activities. Human sacrifices killed this
way were mostly male victims from alien tribes and they were offered mainly to
worship male ancestors;. !he officiant used the !" Y method to kill human victims to
show piety to the spirits and at the same time scare the alien tribes. Since this method
was used in the sacrificial activities very fre:uently, !" Y was also used for the name
of the sacrifice. ;or e$ample,
Z[Y
8/19/2019 Wang Ping Methods of Human Sacrifice in Shang New Edition
3/14
?
&"ng'( jk was the name of recipients of sacrificial act.
According to our study, the method of !" Y was mainly used for worshipping male
ancestors8 spirits, but rarely for female ancestors8 and natural spirits. !he reason for
this may be that the generals who fought the wars were usually male.
Another point of interest is, that from the number of the human sacrifices killed in the
sacrifice, we can deduce the status of a recipient of a sacrifice during his live-time.
!hus, for e$ample the high status of the former emperors ZǔyN y] , )àji* z甲 ,
+hàngji* {甲 , when they were alive, is evident since they were usually offered ten
human sacrifices by !" Y sacrifice at each sacrifice.
!he character of x# consists of x# | and yu }. -# like !" Y means to cut off
human sacrifice8s head for worship@. -# | was a kind of servant, yu } was a kind of
weapon in ancient times, similar to an a$eH. !his kind of a$e was unearthed in manyShang dynasty archaeological sites and tombs. n rénjì bǔcí 人祭卜辞 , x#
designates the same method of killing human sacrifice as !" Y. both of them imply
the use of a weapon, dagger or a$e, to cut off a human sacrifice8s head for the
sacrificial act.
! Splitting the body into hal#es
Splitting the body into halves refers to killing human sacrifice by splitting it into
halves for worshipping spirits. !he word /*0 a was used for recording this method
of killing human sacrifice in rénjì bǔcí 人祭卜辞 . !he character /*0 a looks like a
circle split by two verticals. Hng BiCy thought the meaning of /*0 a , to split
human sacrifice8s body into halvesB, could be deduced from its character clearlyE .
;or e$ample,
a~•€fg a•~fg =-é./ 10#"1& =l@B59( 1&%
@n,!"W0H!03&H'(( I†nB „èhé *n> ‰JnB Ž/nB% 'h56 Dén .@Fì ˆGn>GnB [email protected] Ih6nBh5J 'hK.L, 0##0HW2!&… ”\‘’ %'(( ()*+$( -é./ 32,W#Wvwx,W#"vwx%B'(( ()*+$( -é./ 10!#W%E '(( -ƒnB ?@†Oì% ‚ìnB+ìnB >ē lēnh5% “>@o(> PO ML ˆŒnBDL %?@*B” Dénì BK,/n % [email protected] 'hK.L,!""H 122#X1220%&
F
8/19/2019 Wang Ping Methods of Human Sacrifice in Shang New Edition
4/14
spirits> Should 'we( split five 1i2ng • human sacrifices and three cattle and then
offer them to spirits>?
1i2ng • here refers to the captives used as sacrifice from 1i2ng • tribe. !he human
sacrifices killed by this method mainly were male victims and were offered to male
ancestors8 spirits.
!$ %ismember "odies
Dismember bodies means to dismember human sacrifice8 s body to kill them for
worshipping. %ords for recording this kind of method include suì – and 32 .
!he character of suì – in oracle-bone inscriptions depicts an a$e. !he word suì – in
rénjì bǔcí 人祭卜辞 is used like the word guì — in the written recordsG. !he character
of 32 in oracle-bone inscriptions is composed of 32 ˜ and 45 ™ . t refers to
dismember human sacrifice for worship.
n oracle-bone inscriptions, the human sacrifice killed by this method were
predominantly 1i2ng • , but also sometimes 45 š etc.;or e$ample,
›卜,œ: •žŸg=-é./ 21W& =l@B59(
2&%
?
Zhēng œ is the name of a man who held the office of oracle priest under Eing
9:d(ng ¡¢ during the first period of oracle-bone inscriptions. 6;g ‰JnB Ž/nB % 'h56 Dén .@Fì ˆGn>GnB [email protected] Ih6nBh5J 'hK.L, 0##0H0uW& …—, ¦§’% ¨
”©–ª % '(( l9 ()*+$( -é./0032W \ 003u0\003u1%='(( -é./ 1#3,W0"\"u2u%
J'(( 7« ?ìlJn , …'h†nB>*ì h6nB¬G >( 9én.ì hì> OJn.@K OŒ hènBh65 )@«sh5†nB¬@Jsh†nB>*ì O/hŒ >ē 9én.ì O/pLn Dé@ìŠ, ‹nH h6nBOL*n DénD =0##2H1&%
K
8/19/2019 Wang Ping Methods of Human Sacrifice in Shang New Edition
5/14
!he character of 3óu consists of dòu ® and +h5 ¯ in oracle-bone inscriptions. sh5
¯ was also written as ° sometimes. According to the structure of 3óu , >u#
H é ngshēng ±²³ thinks the method of 3óu was using sticks to beat human sacrifice
to death for worshipping spirits*. !he human sacrifices killed by this method were
mainly captives from LiCng•
tribes and female slaves
M
. !he character of 3"nconsists of gōng ́ and 45 °, 45 ° was written also as yòu µ sometimes. 7ōng ´ is
like a point on the bowN 45 ° is like a hand beating something with a stick. hOo
+héng e$plained 3"n as 3"n ¶. He thinks 3"n is the original character of 3"n ¶L.
!he methods of 3"n and 3óu were alike, in both of them the human sacrifice
was beaten with sticks to death for worshipping spirits. According to the rénjì bǔcí 人
祭卜辞 , the number of human sacrifice killed by 3"n sacrifice was large. ;or
e$ample,
€·人[ g~·人\z¸g=-é./ 0u#!u& =l@B59(
3&%
@«n =ºnh5G% ºnh5G ?@O phKP«nshè , 0##!H3!W&%M '(( -é./ 0"3 ,131!%L'(( Ih thénB% ?@ABCDén ?@An+/nB t/>@An [email protected] 'hK.L,!"WWH02!&%R See PQ IngwQ. Ji*g: wén'ì g5@ín.')i&2ng3 hTnghu Sh6&Q."UUV3#UV-#UVW(.SSee Héjí WWV\U"X\###F"\#VUFV\F#"W#\F#"V#\KXU"K.
Y
8/19/2019 Wang Ping Methods of Human Sacrifice in Shang New Edition
6/14
»:¼勿 父乙十 十 , 十。 =-é./ u#0& =l@B59( &
n rénjì bǔcí 人祭卜辞 , the number of human victims killed by this method was the
largest one. ;or e$ample, there is a record in Héjí "X# 3
8/19/2019 Wang Ping Methods of Human Sacrifice in Shang New Edition
7/14
ÀÁ[
8/19/2019 Wang Ping Methods of Human Sacrifice in Shang New Edition
8/14
3 %ill there be ensuing rain if we sacrifice a ci female human sacrifice on
b(ngx5 丙戌 d ay by burning >?
;rom the inscriptions about this method of sacrificial killing we know that in thesacrificial activities aimed at praying for rain, female victims were considered most
efficientP. n ancient +hina, people8s livelihood depended on agriculture, so climate
was of utmost importance. Drought and floods would be a fundamental threat to
people8s lives. n ancient +hina, people relied on agriculture for a living. !hus, the
weather had a great influence on people8s lives. Droughts or floods could create
deathly threats. !herefore, the ji20 Ã sacrifice, aimed at praying for rain and avoiding
the drought, was a very important sacrificial activity in Shang dynasty. According to a
statistic by HQ H^u$uCn and HQ h0ny_, in the oracle-bone inscriptions there are "#W
records, which refer to sacrifices of praying for rain. !he victims killed by this
method were usually female. !he purpose of this kind of sacrificial act was to worship
natural spirits, especially the river and rain deities. ;emale victims were offered to
river deities to prevent floods and to rain deities to induce timely rain. !he fact, that
the Shang people used female victims so fre:uently indicates that female victims were
considered the best medium to communicate with the river and rain deities.
!he character @i"0 in oracle bone inscriptions depicts putting a person on a pyre. n
rénjì bǔcí 人祭卜辞 , the specific way of killing human sacrifice by this method was
to put human sacrifice on a pyre to worship spiritsAA. Ci"0 was written as @i"0 Í in
the written recordsA). n ancient people8s mind, the deities lived above the sky, the
smoke rosed up there and then could be received by them easily. !o burn humanvictims originated under such kind of thought. At the first beginning of the sacrificial
act, the human victims mainly were the people who held the sacrificial activities A+ .
!he self-devotion indicated the worshipper8s great piety with a kind of solemn
atmosphere on the original meaning. Seeing from rénjì bǔcí 人祭卜辞 , the human
victims killed by this method were mainly w5 ÎÏBi2ng • and nD Ð. Ji20 Ã and @i"0 sometimes were used together in rénjì bǔcí AD人祭卜辞 . )oth of the methods of
ji20 Ã and @i"0 were important ways of killing human sacrifice in the time of
Shang. Although there were similarities, the two methods were essentially different.
*ne of their similarities is that both of them were related to farming. !he main
difference is the gender of the victimsN the ji20 Ã sacrifice used mainly female
victims while the @i"0 sacrifice used male victimsA9. ;urthermore, their purpose
was different. !he ji20 Ã sacrifice had a specific purpose of praying for rainN the
PSee Héjí ""#"vwx, FX"VU\F##WU , F##UX.See HQ H^u$uCn and HQ h0ny_. A#n sh2ngsh( 'ShOngh7i. ShOngh7i r4nm\n ch6b7nsh0.#XXF3"F(. Apart from
praying for rain, there are records about conducting ji20 sacrifice which aimed at prevent floods. See e$amplein H4&\ F##UU. AASee PQ IngwQ. Ji*g: wén'ì g5@ín. ')i&2ng3 hTnghu Sh6&Q,"UUV3"KV(.A)See Cng E0h4 and %ng M\ng . +huō wén ji8'ì -#nd#ng ')1i&2ng3 hTnghu Sh6&Q, #XX#3VVK(3…Í\Ñ祭Ò
”’g A+See Héjí ""#"\""FX\""F#.ADSee Héjí FX"VU.A9See Héjí #FYKX, "XFU.
W
8/19/2019 Wang Ping Methods of Human Sacrifice in Shang New Edition
9/14
purpose of @i"0 sacrifice was to pray for rain or for a good harvest year.
!, "oiling
)oiling refers to boil human sacrifice for worshipping spirits. !he special word for
recording this method is Er Ó which e:uated with Er Ô in the books been handed
down from the ancient times
A;
.
ÕÕ貍 羌,隻 二十 五 而二 。v-é./ 2"" x =l@B59(
!#&%
hén Ö is e:uivalent to chén × in the books been handed down
from the ancient timesA@. n rénjì bǔcí 人祭卜辞 , chén Ö sacrifice was used very
fre:uently, the sacrifices including both of animals and human sacrifices. ;or
e$ample,
A;See PQ IngwQ. Ji*g: wén'ì gǔ@ín. ')i&2ng3 hTnghu Sh6&Q,"UUV3FKKY(. Also u`huOn IuCngTng 9rnin
8/19/2019 Wang Ping Methods of Human Sacrifice in Shang New Edition
10/14
丁巳卜 , 其 于河牢 ,沈 。v- é./ 10!! x =l@B59(
!!&%
8/19/2019 Wang Ping Methods of Human Sacrifice in Shang New Edition
11/14
for rain.
;or e$ample,
甲› ðå人 .ÅñÇ%v-é./ !#u" x =l@B59(
!0&%
8/19/2019 Wang Ping Methods of Human Sacrifice in Shang New Edition
12/14
ø^卜, , Hò,h# ú was
used as a method of killing human sacrifice refers to carve open human victims8
bodies and then e$pose the body to become like dried meatA=.
û ú. v Héjí KX#Yx 'figure "K(.
8/19/2019 Wang Ping Methods of Human Sacrifice in Shang New Edition
13/14
sacrifices and the rulers8 great piety toward spirits. +oncluded from the rénjì bǔcí 人
祭卜辞, the methods of killing human sacrifices had the following characteristics3
;irst, the methods of killing human sacrifices not only had various categories but also
were very cruel and barbarous. !he most common way of killing human sacrifice was
beheading since among all the words we have studied, !"Y
was used most fre:uently.Archaeologist had found many signs of beheading for worship at Ii7o ShuCng:io
and An Png relics of Pin dynasty. =any skulls were found separated from the bones.
!his might indicate that the human victims had been killed for sacrificial activities.
!he victims killed by beheading mostly were captives, many of them were from the
1i2ng • tribe. At the time of Shang, the 1i2ng • tribe lived in the northwest of
Shang lands, leading a nomadic life. !he people of the 1i2ng • tribe rebelled against
the Shang Dynasty from time to time. !herefore, the Eing %uding declared wars
against the 1i2ng • tribe many times. According to the records of rénjì bǔcí 人祭卜
辞 , the largest war against the 1i2ng • tribe included more than "F,XXX warriors
from Shang Dynasty. Since Shang people often fought with the 1i2ng • people, theycaptured a lot of captives from them, which were mainly used as human sacrifices.
Second, !he selecting of killing methods was dependent on the recipients and the
purpose of the worship. +ommon methods of killing human sacrifices for
worshipping ancestral spirits were beheading, dismembering, beating, cutting off feet,
taking blood, boiling, displaying, drying etc. !he purpose mainly was to pray for
blessings and support from ancestral spirits and ward off misfortunes. !he methods of
killing human sacrifices for worshipping natural spirits were burning, burying,
drowning etc. !he main purpose was to pray for a good harvest year and timely rain.
Ancestral worship originated under specific social conditionsN in the mind of the
Shang people, the blessing of their ancestors8 spirits alone could guarantee that the
whole clan would last forever. Ancestors were holy and unreachable. 9specially the
ancestors8 protection for their country and family8s dignity were valued and highly
thought of. !herefore, when they were worshipping their ancestors, they selected
various drastic killing methods. Ancient +hina was an agricultural society, timely rain
was of ma&or importance. !o satisfy the natural spirits who were in charge of rain, the
people selected appropriate methods, such as burying, burning, drowning.
;urthermore, the methods of killing human sacrifices for worshipping ancestral spirits
were many more than those for worshipping natural spirits. !his indicates that the
reverence for their ancestors was much higher than the veneration of natural spirits.!hird, the methods of killing female victims were not as cruel as male victims. !he
killing methods of female victims mainly were c sacrifice and 32 sacrifice.
;urthermore, the number of female victims was much smaller than the number of
male victims, since the ma$imum number of the former was up to FX while the latter
amounted to hundreds.
;ourth, the words recording the killing methods also were used as the name of the
sacrifice. )ecause of the fre:uent use of killing human sacrifice in sacrificial
activities, it had been a custom with a fi$ed name. ;or e$ample, !" Y refers to cutting
victiming heads down, apart from this, it was used as the name of sacrificial activity
means killing human sacrifice by way of cutting their heads down for worship. !he
"F
8/19/2019 Wang Ping Methods of Human Sacrifice in Shang New Edition
14/14
former one was the way of killing human sacrifice while the latter one was the name
of sacrificial act. !his indicates that the sacrificial name and the method were closely
connected.
n conclusion, to kill living human beings and offer to spirits was the cruelest custom
in rénjì bǔcí 人祭卜辞
Jearly all the methods to kill animals could be applied also tohuman sacrifices. !his reflected the low status of slaves and the rulers8 great despise
toward the common people. !he e$tremely cruel sacrificial activity showed the rulers8
great piety towards the spirits too. t was the specific representation of religion beliefs
at that time. !his is a worldwide religious phenomenon.
"K