WGT1 / Classificatie - BIMportal · ALIGNED to ISO 12006 -2: 2015 KEY CHARACTERISTICS / SYSTEMS VMSW CLEAR UNIQUE CODE for type of object UNIQUE CODE for single object USEABLE in

06-06-17

1

Vergadering 31 mei 2017

WGT1 / Classificatie

Klik om de stijl te bewerkenWG 1

Vergadering 31 mei 2017 – WG1 Cluster –

Agenda

0) Inleiding1) Werking & kalender - WG 12) Analysemethode van bestaande classificaties in BIM context 3 - 8) VMSW & STABU Theorie & PraktijkvoorbeeldenArchicad (S. Boeykens) / Revit (J. Vandamme) / STABU (P. Bovens) (3x20’)9) Enkele kritische bemerkingen > discussie

06-06-17

2



2 0 1 6 2 0 1 7

02/02

2 0 1 6 2 0 1 7

2 0 1 6 2 0 1 7

R424/11

R0 04/11

R2 R3 13/03

R1 11/01

BB/SfBCCS

BB/SfBCCS

BB/SfBCCS

R4 24/04

1x/m

UniClassOmniClassUniClass

OmniClassUniClass

OmniClass

R5 31/05

Bestekken(Stabu; VMSW ) Bestekken

(Stabu; VMSW ) Bestekken

(Stabu; VMSW ) KICK OFFKICK OFFKICK OFF

R5

R6 26/06

SyntheseSyntheseSynthese

Validatie

R622/06

CCSGezamenlijke Vergadering

1. Werking en kalender WG 1_Cluster



1. Werking en kalender WG 1_Cluster

2 0 1 6 2 0 1 7

02/02

2 0 1 6 2 0 1 7

2 0 1 6 2 0 1 7

R424/11

R0 04/11

R2 R3 13/03

R1 11/01

BB/SfBCCS

BB/SfBCCS

BB/SfBCCS

R4 24/04

1x/m

UniClassOmniClassUniClass

OmniClassUniClass

OmniClass

R5 31/05

Bestekken(Stabu; VMSW ) Bestekken

(Stabu; VMSW ) Bestekken

(Stabu; VMSW ) KICK OFFKICK OFFKICK OFF

R5

R6 26/06

SyntheseSyntheseSynthese

Validatie

R622/06

CCSGezamenlijke Vergadering

06-06-17

3



W E B S I T E S

P L U G I N s

I M P L E M E N T I N S O F T WA R EI D E N T I T Y C A R D

B I M K E Y C H A R A C T E R I S T I C S

U S E

2. Analyse methode

F O R EA C H C L A SSIF IC AT IO N . . . .



W E B S I T E S

P L U G I N s


K E Y C H A R A C T E R I S T I C S

U S E

2. Analyse methode

06-06-17

4



8. Websites & Tools – VMSW

VMSW > Professionelen > ABC > Bouwtechnisch bestek > Artikellijst

WEBSITES to inform about classification

Handleiding

Artikellijst

Bestek



8. Websites & Tools – STABU

General information & contextwww.stabu.org > Producten > STABU Bouwbreed

Why? VisieHow? Practical example: Leeswijzer

Help: Helpdesk

Tableswww.stabu.nl

Stabu2-SystematiekBouwystemen & InstallatiesNL/SfB


06-06-17

5



Questions?



GENERAL INFORMATION

Founding organization(s): VMSW

Date of publication + last update: (…B2005: 2005)Bouwtechnisch Bestek: 2015

Countries where used: Belgium (Flemish Region)

Languages in which available: Dutch

3. ID - Create an IDENTITY CARD for each classification system

VMSW (Bouwtechnisch bestek)

06-06-17

6



GENERAL INFORMATION

References: National: VMSW documents

Others:

International Standards:

VMSW




PRACTICAL USE OF THE SYSTEM

In which sector(s) ? BuildingsDeveloped for residential buildings (social housing)

In which discipline(s) ? ArchitectureMEP

In which phase(s)? DesignProduction

Used as a framework for building specifications & cost calculations


VMSW

06-06-17

7



STRUCTURE OF THE SYSTEM

Type of system : Enumerative classification system

Number of tables : 1 (10 parts, from 0 to 9)

Name of the tables +number of level(s) in each table : Table « artikels »: 5

Example: Level 0 (“part”): 3. DakwerkenLevel 1: 36. DaklichtopeningenLevel 2: 36.10 Dakvlakramen – algemeenLevel 3: 36.11. dakvlakramen – houtLevel 4: 36.11.10. dakvlakramen - hout/wentel


VMSW



STRUCTURE OF THE CODE

Type of code : Numeric

36_11_10Level 1 Level 2-3 Level 4(Level 0 = “Part”)

VMSW


(3)

06-06-17

8



GENERAL INFORMATION

Founding organization(s): Stichting STABU

Date of publication + last update: (STABU: 1986 (paper) )STABU2: 1990 (new content, computer) (still used & updated)(STABU element: 2009 (linking STABU & NL/Sfb, table 0 & 1) )STABU Bouwbreed: 2015 (“BIM-ready”)

Countries where used: Netherlands, (Belgium)

Languages in which available: Dutch


STABU (Bouwbreed)



GENERAL INFORMATION


STABU (Bouwbreed)

STABU-Element: 2009 < > STABU Bouwbreed: 2015 (“BIM-ready”)

06-06-17

9



GENERAL INFORMATION


STABU (Bouwbreed)

STABU2: 1990 < > STABU Bouwbreed: 2015 Tabel “Bouwsystemen & Installaties” (“BIM-ready”)

only technical articles(administrative articles > UAV 2012)

Technical and administrative articles

2 levels 3 levels

Structure modified



GENERAL INFORMATION


STABU (Bouwbreed)

06-06-17

10



GENERAL INFORMATION

References: National: STABU documents

Others:

International Standards:


STABU



PRACTICAL USE OF THE SYSTEM

In which sector(s) ? Mostly used for buildings:

In which discipline(s) ? ArchitectureMEP

In which phase(s)? All: (according to STABU)Pre-designDesignProductionOperation and Maintenance


STABU

06-06-17

11



STRUCTURE OF THE SYSTEM

Type of system : Enumerative classification system

Number of tables : 5 (3 parts, of which part 1 has 3 tables)

Name of the tables +number of level(s) in each table : Part 1 : Ruimten Systematiek /? (*) | 3 tables: gebieden / gebouwtypen / ruimten

Part 2 : Contracts /? (*)Part 3 : Bouwsystemen & Installaties (“BS&I”) / 3

! This part has 7 subtables, which are not mentioned in the code !

(*) not accessible for free; asked for a demo version but not received up to now


STABU



STRUCTURE OF THE CODE

Type of code : Numeric

13.01.0001Level 1 Level 2 Level 3Table

“Bouwsystemen & Installaties”;Subtable “02 Bouwkunde”


STABU

STABU²

BOUWBREED

30.41

06-06-17

12



Questions?



W E B S I T E S

P L U G I N s



U S E

Analyse methode

06-06-17

13



ALIGNED to ISO 12006-2: 2015

KEY CHARACTERISTICS / SYSTEMS

CLEAR

UNIQUE CODE for type of objectUNIQUE CODE for single object

USEABLE in a detailed level

ADAPTABLE / FLEXIBLE

STABLE / USEABLE over entire life cycleREADABLE / UNDERSTANDABLE

NEUTRAL (independent of software)

CL

AS

S.

CO

DIF

.C

LA

SS

IFIC

AT

ION

CO

DIF

ICA

TIO

N

4. BIM Key characteristics - Comparison

STABU VMSW

UNIQUE CODE for single object



TABLE A.13 PROPERTIES

CONSTRUCTION RESULTS

TABLE A.10 Built Space

TABLE A.8 Construction complex

TABLE A.9 Construction entity

TABLE A.11 Construction element

Types of results:

CONSTRUCTION RESOURCES

TABLE A.3 Construction product

TABLE A.5 Construction aid

TABLE A.4 Construction agent

TABLE A.2 Construction information

Types of resources:

TABLE A.7 CONSTRUCTION PROCESSES

Pre-design process

Design process

Production process

Maintenance process

Types of processes:


4. BIM Key characteristics

06-06-17

14







ISO 12006-2: 2015 VMSW STABU

Tables Tables TablesResourceA.2 Construction information - -A.3 Construction product - -A.4 Construction agent - -A.5 Construction aid - -

- -ProcessA.6 Management - -A.7 Construction Process - -ResultA.8 Construction complex - Construction complex (part of "BWBRD Ruimten")A.9 Construction entity - Construction entity (part of "BWBRD Ruimten")- - -- - -A.10 Built space - Built space (part of "BWBRD Ruimten")A.11 Construction element - -

- -- -

A.12 Work result Work result Work resultPropertyA.13 Construction property - -



06-06-17

15





Complexes Entities Elements Systems Products

House + garage + garden(project in overall terms)

House Wall including all layers 1 layer Components of the layer

No table Systems in ISO

Table Work Results

Terminology



4. BIM Key characteristics – VMSW & STABU

VMSW

STABU

Complexes Entities Elements Systems Products

House + garage + garden(project in overall terms)

House Wall including all layers 1 layer Components of the layer

v v v v vv v v v v


in table BS&I: some elements and some systems

in same table: some elements, some systems, some products

System

Element

STABU Bouwsystemen & Installaties

06-06-17

16




STABU


KEY CHARACTERISTICS / SYSTEMS VMSW

CLEAR



v v




CL

AS

SIF

ICA

TIO

NC

OD

IFIC

AT

ION

CL

AS

S.

CO

DIF

.




CLEAR?

- Structure of classification- Only 1 table (VMSW) or few (STABU-Bouwbreed)- STABU-Bouwbreed: 7 subclasses, not mentioned in name!

- Definitions of classes - Building specifications = description of classes

(VMSW & STABU)

- Coherent subdivision criteria- Building specifications: hierarchically structured

- X0 general- XX specific

- VMSW: not always clearly hierarchically structured- X0 general- XX specific

4. BIM Key characteristics – VMSW

06-06-17

17





CLEAR






CL

AS

S.

CO

DIF

.C

LA

SS

IFIC

AT

ION

CO

DIF

ICA

TIO

N

v vv v


STABUVSMW

CLEAR (structure of classification)





CLEAR






CL

AS

S.

CO

DIF

.C

LA

SS

IFIC

AT

ION

CO

DIF

ICA

TIO

N

v vv vv v


STABUVMSW

Focus on work resultsFocus on work results


06-06-17

18





CLEAR






CL

AS

S.

CO

DIF

.C

LA

SS

IFIC

AT

ION

CO

DIF

ICA

TIO

N

v v


STABUVMSW


v vv vv v Focus on work resultsFocus on work results

User can add (project-specific) classes






CLEAR






CL

AS

S.

CO

DIF

.C

LA

SS

IFIC

AT

ION

CO

DIF

ICA

TIO

N


STABUVMSW


v vv v




06-06-17

19





CLEAR






CL

AS

S.

CO

DIF

.C

LA

SS

IFIC

AT

ION

CO

DIF

ICA

TIO

N

v


v

STABUVMSW

STABLE / USEABLE over entire lifecycle

v vv v

Difficult in early phases (pre-design,…)Main purpose = tool for specific phase









CLEAR






CL

AS

S.

CO

DIF

.C

LA

SS

IFIC

AT

ION

CO

DIF

ICA

TIO

N


READABLE / UNDERSTANDABLE

vv

STABUVMSW

v vv v



Difficult in early phases (pre-design,…)Main purpose = tool for specific phasev v



06-06-17

20





CLEAR






CL

AS

S.

CO

DIF

.C

LA

SS

IFIC

AT

ION

CO

DIF

ICA

TIO

N


UNIQUE CODE for type of object

vv

STABUVMSW

v vv v




v v







CLEAR






CL

AS

S.

CO

DIF

.C

LA

SS

IFIC

AT

ION

CO

DIF

ICA

TIO

N


UNIQUE CODE for single object

vv

STABUVMSW

v vv v




v vv v



06-06-17

21



Questions?



W E B S I T E S

P L U G I N s



U S E

2. Analyse methode

06-06-17

22



USE classification in a case study

5. Use – VMSW

26.26 Draagvloerenbeton, ter plaatse gestortwithout openings

10. Grondwerken

20. Metselwerkwithout openings

30. Dakopbouwhellend dakwithout openings

…

68. Ventilatie

(Table Complexes) (Table Entities)TABLE

(Table Elements)No tableavailable

for this level

No tableavailable

for this level

Not last level

Not last level

Not last level

Not last level

Not last level



No code for Walls with openings

/ (Table Elements) (Table Systems) (Table Products)

20. Metselwerk

40 Buitenschrijnwerk

22. Gevelmetselwerk

21 Spouwmuurisolatie

29.10 Binnenspouwblad - algemeen

50 Binnenpleisterwerken

80 Binnenschilderwerken

? Vensters ?

? Deuren ?

5. Use – VMSW


22.21.20 gevelstenen - bakstenen/handvorm- envormbakstenen21.11.11 materialen - mortel/metselmortel - voor algemene toepassing

20.23.10 binnenspouwblad - betonsteen met gewone granulaten/dikte 14 cm20.11.10 materialen - metselmortel/voor algemene toepassing (G)

80.11 Binnenschilderwerken op pleisterwerk - acrylaathars

40.71 Omkaderingselementen - hout

40.61 raamdorpels - aluminium

…

40.21 Hang- en sluitwerk - standaard40.51 Vulpanelen - kunststof

06-06-17

23



5. Use – STABU

USE classification in a case studyhttp://www.stabu.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Project_woonhuis_3d_model.pdf

Example of STABU used in BIMgiven by Stichting STABU itself



5. Use – STABU

?

“Spaces” – table 1 “Spaces” – table 2

09 VloerenWithout openings

01 Funderingen

12 DakenWithout openings

…

Table “BS&I”


07.11 Ventilatie-installaties

03 BuitenwandenWithout openings

Not last level

?

?

Not last level

Not last level

Not last level

Not last levelIn other subtable!“03 Werktuigbouwkunde”i.p.v. “02 Bouwkunde”

06-06-17

24



03 Buitenwand

No code for Walls with openings

03.10.0001 Baksteen metselsteen – met mortel/ Table “BS&I” Table “BS&I” Table “BS&I”

04.08 Toegangsvoorzieningen, buitendeuren

03.10 Gemetselde buitenwand- baksteen/

03.12 Gemetselde buitenwand- betonsteen

08.01 Binnenpleistersystemen

19 Beschermlagen

Only available as combination “stone & mortar”

03.12.0001 Betonsteen metselsteen – met mortel

Only available as combination “stone & mortar”

Not available

08.01.0001 Binnenpleistersysteem - baksteen

19.21 Verfsystemen, steenachtige materialen

…

04.08. 002 … metalen buitendeur04.08.0001 … houten buitendeur

5. Use – STABU

21- 02 20 20 10 Exterior Operating Windows


Not last level

No clear differentiation between inner wall, outer wall and wall as a whole

Lack of consistency: finish of an exterior wall only available under “Finish of interior walls” (“08. Binnenwandafwerkingen”)

Not clear: is “pleister” a “steenachtig materiaal”?Differentiation to painting on masonry, stone…?

Not clear: how to chose between “04.08, … buitendeuren”, “04.09, … buitendeursets”, “04.10, … industriële deuren”, “04.12, … commerciële deuren” ?

No possibility to classify more in detail;only differentiation between type of doors based on main material



5. Use – Comparison

OmniClass

Element including all layers(Ex: Wall including structure, insulation,…)

vv

UniClass2015CCSBB/SfB

Entire project(Ex: House + garage + garden)

Element including openings(Ex: Wall + windows + doors)

Each layer (Systems)(Ex: structuring part of wall)

vv

vv vv

vv vv

vv vv


Need BB/SfB +

Need BB/SfB +

Not allNeed of BB/SfB+

Components of layer (Products)(Ex: Blocks)

v v(CCS properties)

vNot all

v

Entity(Ex: House)

vv vv

Not all

STABU

v

VMSW

v

v v

v v

v v

v v

v v

1 tab

le for

diffe

rent

levels

06-06-17

25



USE classification in a case studyProduct (block)System (structural leaf)Element (wall assembly)Facade Block, part of structural leaf, part of wall

assembly, part of facade

B3

OmniClass

UniClass2015

CCS

BB/SfB (21)++

EF_25_10

21-02 20 10

Need of BB/SfB+

Not last level of table

Need of propertiesBD5 ULH4 [L]§B3. AD5. BD5. ULH4AD5

(21/2) (21)++. (21)+. (21/2). Ff2(21)+ Ff2

EF_25_10. Ss_25_13_50_51. Pr_20_93_52_01Ss_25_13_50_51 Pr_20_93_52_01

21-02 20 10 20 21-02 20 10. 21-02 20 10 20. 23-13 21 11 1123-13 21 11 11

/

/

5. Use – Comparison

VMSWSTABU

/ 29.10 /20.23.10/

/ 03.12 ///




5. Use – Practical example

Use of STABU as a framework for cost calculationsP. Bovens, PB Calc & Consult

06-06-17

26



Questions?



W E B S I T E S

P L U G I N s



U S E

2. Analyse methode

06-06-17

27



IMPLEMENT classification IN SOFTWARE

6. Implementation in software – VMSW & STABU




Table En (Entities)Table EF (Elements) Table Ss (Systems) Table Pr (Products)

Table 21 (Elements)Table 23 (Products)Apply Predefined Rules

Manage IFC Properties

06-06-17

28



6. Implementation in software –STABU



6. Implementation in software –STABU

06-06-17

29



To see the parts of the wall


The code for the entire wall

Assembly code

Keynote



Finishing (brick cladding)Air layerInsulationBlocks layerInterior finsishing


06-06-17

30



The code for the part of the wall can be written in Keynote


Keynote



6. Implementation in software – Conclusion

Revit Archicad

Classification always exported as: IfcClassificationReference

If we write the code in Identity Data - Assembly Code, classification exported as:IfcClassificationReferenceProperty Set


If we write the code in Identity Data – Keynote, classification exported as:Property Set

If we use Classification Manager, the code is in Data, classification exported as:Property Set

Not possible to export classification of parts of the wall (?)

06-06-17

31



6. Implementation in software – Conclusion

2 similar objects can be classified with 2 different classification systems within the model

Can be applied to the same object with the PLUGINClassification Manager

NOT possible to classify the parts of an element (systems)

Standard use: classify the parts of an element (systems) in Keynote


Revit Archicad



6. Implementation in software – Practical example

Linking BIM-objects to the VMSW-classification in ArchicadS. Boeykens, KUL & D-Studio

06-06-17

32



Questions?



W E B S I T E S

P L U G I N s



U S E

2. Analyse methode

06-06-17

33



Existing PLUGINs to implement classification in softwares

7. PLUGINs – VMSW & STABU

No PLUGINs ? PLUGIN C3Ahttp://www.c3a.be/software/autodesk-revit/c3a-extensies



7. PLUGINs – VMSW & STABU

Classification Manager

Add-Ins

Classification Manager

06-06-17

34



7. PLUGINs – VMSW

Linking BIM-objects to the VMSW-classification via the C3A-plugin J. Vandamme, C3A



Questions?

06-06-17

35



9. Critical remarks & discussion

DISCUSSION




06-06-17

36




KUBUSinfo.nl > KUBUS Spexx > Resultaten enquête





STABU > Nieuws > STABU luistert naar de markt (19/05/2017)


1. NL/SfB integrated in STABU Bouwbreed

2. BS&I online published as free standard

06-06-17

37








06-06-17

38




Atlas van Open BIM-standaardenhttp://www.bimloket.nl/Atlasvan-open-BIM-standaarden





Generieke lessen m.b.t. classificatie voor BIM?

06-06-17

39



Questions?

Documents

WGT1 / Classificatie - BIMportal · ALIGNED to ISO 12006 -2: 2015 KEY CHARACTERISTICS / SYSTEMS VMSW CLEAR UNIQUE CODE for type of object UNIQUE CODE for single object USEABLE in