8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 1/35

 

 C`aa! 4800

 Ska& EEE! Fk& 4 Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr

Ierswk I`rswsmer`! G}xktr Okfrtka kc F`rwt`a Tgskwtogs>ZRK X`fga Twaefj kf rmg Omefgsg G}xktr Tgsrteorekfs kc F`rwt`a Tgskwtogs

Be`fg Bgsegtrk! Bggakxigfr `s `f Efrgtf`rekf`a Tejmr>Efgsrigfr ef rmg fgz Rt`bg)D`sgb EE@s

X`rteol Zega`fb! Zmu rmg @ieows Owte` Efsrerwrekf es Eaa)swergb rk `bbtgss Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Tejmrs dgcktg Efgsrkt)_r`rg @tdert`rekf Rtedwf`as> Ja`ies Jkab `fb rmg Tejmr kc Efrgtgfrekf

Xgrtks O& I`tkebes! Bkm`! Bkm`ac kt Bkm`m`; Rmg ZRKAeols ers Zkwfbs 

Oa`ws ^eiigti`ff! Rkagt`rekf kc Rgixkt`tu Fkf)Okixae`fog> Rmg _usrgieo _`cgru S`ag kc ZRK Besxwrg_grragigfr Tgesergb

Igaess` Dawg _lu! Bggakxefj Okwfrtegs `fb Efrgaagorw`aXtkxgtru Gfcktogigfr Ig`swtgs> Eixtkefj @oogss rk Igbeoefgs rmtkwjm ZRK Besxwrg _grragigfr

 @TREOAG_ 

FKRG_ @FB

O KIIGFR_ 

E__F > 85:3 ) 4?45

gE__F > 85:7 ) ??23

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 2/35

Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bggakxigfr 

  Ska& ?! Fk& 4 4800

X@RTKF 

 Nwsreog F& F& I`rmwt  

C@OWARU)EF)OM@TJG

Ukjgsm X`e 

GBERKT_)EF)OMEGC   Xt`rggl Dm`rr`om`tu` N`u`fr T`jmw T`i

GBERKT_ 

-I@F@JEFJ%

_mtgu` Iwfkrm-_GFEKT OKFRGFR%

 @i`f Dm`rr`om`tu`  A`lsmie Fgga`l`fr`f

@__KOE@RG GBERKT_ 

 Igjm`f` Om`fbt` Xte`fl` Ikm`f Fgm` Tgbbu

OKXU GBERKT_

 F`it`r` @i`tf`rm @ae @igtngg

 F`lwa F`u`l X``trm _efjm 

OKF_WAREFJ GBERKT_ 

_m`sm`fl X& Lwi`t Jkx`a`ltesmf`f T& Igjm`f` _m`t`cwbggf

DK@TB KC @BSE_KT_  T`n Dm`a`  Jagff Zesgt    N`jbesm Dm`jz`re

 B`fega I`jt`z   D& _& Omeife   I& _ktf`t`n`m 

 Teo`tbk T`iétg~ Mgtfàfbg~ S`wjm`f Akzg Z& Ieom`ga Tgesi`f

Xwdaesmgb du 

Rmg Tgjesrt`t! F`rekf`a A`z Wfegtseru! Nkbmxwt

E__F > 85:3)4?45 q gE__F > 85:7)??23

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 3/35

Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr

X`rteol Zega`fb! Zmu rmg @ieows Owte` Efsrerwrekf es Eaa)_wergb rk `bbtgss Efbejgfkws 

Xgkxag―s Tejmrs dgcktg Efgsrkt)_r`rg @tdert`rekf Rtedwf`as> Ja`ies Jkab `fb rmg Tejmr kc Efrgtgfrekf  ?-4% RT@BG A& # BGS & ??2 -4800% 

 Z MU RMG @IEOW_ OWTE@ EF_RERWREKF E_ EAA)_WERGB

 RK @BBTG__ EFBEJGFKW_ XGKXAG_― T EJMR_ DGCKTG

EFSG_RKT )_ R@RG @TDERT@REKF RTEDWF@A_> JA@IE_ JKAB 

 @FB RMG T EJMR KC EFRGTSGFREKF 

X @RTEOL  ZEGA@FB√ 

Kgt rmg a`sr bgo`bg! efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf rtedwf`as m`g smkzf iktg zeaaefjfgss rk xtkebg fkf)besxwrefj x`tregs zerm skig xkssedeaeru rk x`treoex`rg rmtkwjm zterrgf `ieows dtegcs& Mkzggt! `ieows x`treoex`rekf es fkr ` x`f`og` rk owtg `aa kc rmg g}esrefj smktrokiefjs ef efgsrigfr a`z `s tgj`tbs rt`fsx`tgfou `fb `oogss rk nwsreog& Ef c`or!

`ieows m`s fkr ugr dggf tgokjfe~gb `s ` tejmr `fb es sreaa swdngor rk ` sgtegs kc aeier`rekfs! `aa kc zmeom tgsrteor ers gccgoregfgss& Rmes `treoag `tjwgs rm`r swom tgsrteorekfs smkwab dg rgixgtgb ef rmg o`sg kc efbejgfkws xgkxags! ef rmg aejmr kc rmget besrefor owarwt`a ebgfreru `fb rmg tejmr rk sgac)bgrgtief`rekf& Rk `keb rmg bgcgfsgagssfgss kc efbejgfkws 

 xgkxags `fb xkrgfre`a `tg`s kc kgta`x zerm rmget mwi`f tejmrs! rmes `treoag xtkxksgs rmg efoktxkt`rekf efrk efrgtf`rekf`a `tdert`rekf kc rmg xtkogbwt`a efsrerwrekf kc ‑efrgtgfrekf’ ∔`s kxxksgb rk `ieows ∔ ctki iwfeoex`a a`z&

√ N&B& gpwe`agfr! Xkfreceoe` Wfegtseb`b O`rkaeo` bga Xgtw -4887%! I`srgt kc A`zs-AA&I&%! U`ag A`z _omkka -Nwfg 4800%! I`srgt kc _oegfog ef Gfetkfigfr`a Om`fjg `fbI`f`jgigfr! Wfegtseru kc K}cktb -O`fbeb`rg 4804%& E zesm rk rm`fl Xtkcgsskt Z&Ieom`ga Tgesi`f -U`ag A`z _omkka% ckt mes `aw`dag cggbd`ol `fb swxxktr rmtkwjmkwr rmestgsg`tom xtkngor& E `i jt`rgcwa rk Xtkcgsskt B`fega Dkfeaa` -Wfegtseb`b bg aks @fbgs!Dkjkrà)Okakide`% ckt mes okiigfrs `fb swjjgsrekfs kf `f g`taegt bt`cr& Cef`aau! Edgfgcergb ctki iu besowssekfs zerm I`té` Jw`b`awxg I`tréfg~! Awo`s I`oOawtg `fb N`eigKa`é~)Jkf~àag~& Rmg `wrmkt o`f dg okfr`orgb `r> xzega`fbc\`rYji`ea&oki& Rmg wsw`abesoa`eigt ̀ xxaegs&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 4/35

 C`aa! 4800Y  @ieows Owte`g # Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Trs& ef Ef& @td& ??7  R @DAG KC OKFRGFR_ 

E& EFRTKBWOREKF EE& K  SGTSEGZ KC RMG @IEOW_ OWTE@ EF_RERWREKF EF EFRGTF@REKF@A EFSG_RIGFR

A @Z   @& Rmg _xeaa)kgt Gccgors kc Efgsrkt)_r`rg @tdert`rekf D& Rmg Tkag `fb Aeier`rekfs kc rmg @ieows Owte` Efsrerwrekf O& @ieoe Dtegcs ef Efrgtf`rekf`a Efgsrigfr A`z 

EEE& EFBEJGFKW_ XGKXAG_ @FB EFRGTF@REKF@A A @Z    @& Jgfgt`a Xtkrgorekf Ct`igzktlD& Cktgejf Betgor Efgsrigfr `fb xkrgfre`a `tg`s kc Kgta`x zerm Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Tejmrs 

0& Tejmr rk A`fbs! Rgtterktegs ̀ fb Tgskwtogs4& Tgaejekws `fb _xeterw`a Tejmrs

?& Efrgaagorw`a Xtkxgtru Tejmrs2& _wii`tu O& Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― _r`rws ef Efrgtf`rekf`a A`z 

ES& T GOKJFE^EFJ DTK@BGT X @TREOEX@REKF T EJMR_ RK EFBEJGFKW_ JTKWX_  @& Ja`ies Jkab! Arb& & Wfergb _r`rgs D& @f`auses kc Ja`ies Jkab `fb ers T`ieceo`rekfs O& Efoktxkt`refj rmg Twags kc Efrgtgfrekf `s ` X`f`og` 

0& Beccgtgfre`rgb Owarwt`a Ebgfreru 4& _gac)Bgrgtief`rekf?& Krmgt Okfsebgt`rekfs2& _wii`tu 

  S& OKFOAW_EKF 

E& EFRTKBWOREKF 

Efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf es ` xte`rg besxwrg tgskawrekf igom`fesi dgrzggfefgsrkts `fb sr`rgs& Mkzggt! `tdert`rekf `z`tbs i`u `ccgor ` dtk`bgt t`fjg kc `orkts rm`f rmg rzk x`tregs efkagb ef rmg besxwrg! eixefjefj kf rmg efrgtgsrs kc rmg xwdaeo ef jgfgt`a kt rmetb x`tregs! zmk tgi`ef wftgxtgsgfrgb bwtefj rmgxtkogbwtg& Rmes es zmu efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf m`s dggf otereoe~gb ckt a`olefj rt`fsx`tgfou! agjerei`ou! `fb bgikot`reo `ookwfr`deaeru& Ef rmes okfrg}r! rmg `ieowsowte` efsrerwrekf kccgts ` z`u rk kgtokig rmg sxeaakgt gccgors kc `tdert`rekf`z`tbs& Efbggb! du jeefj ` keog rk rmg wftgxtgsgfrgb! fkf)besxwrefj x`tregs!`ieows dtegcs rgfb rk bessex`rg rmg sgotgou `fb okfrtedwrg rk rmg xtkogbwt`aagjerei`ou `fb pw`aeru kc rmg `z`tbs Mkzggt! rmg efsrerwrekf kc `ieows owte`g esdgefj wsgb ef ` tgsrteorgb c`smekf& Kf rmg kfg m`fb! `ieows swdiessekfs m`g fkrugr dggf tgokjfe~gb `s ` tejmr> rmgu `tg ` xtkogbwt`a xtgtkj`reg swdngor rk rmgrtedwf`a―s besotgrekf& Kf rmg krmgt m`fb! efrgtf`rekf`a `tdert`rekf rtedwf`as wsw`aau eixksg ` sgr kc tgsrteorekfs kf `ieoe> rmgu `tg aeiergb rk zterrgf dtegcs! rmgu iwsrokixau zerm x`jg aeiers! `fb rmgu `tg jgfgt`aau fkr jt`frgb `oogss rk rmg `tdert`atgoktbs kt rmg `tdert`rekf xtkoggbefjs germgt&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 5/35

??3 Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr \Ska& ?> ??2

Ef rmes tgj`tb! er es eixgt`reg rk besrefjwesm rmksg o`sgs zmgtg rmetb x`tregssggl rk efrgtgfg `s eix`tre`a ‑ctegfbs kc rmg okwtr’ tgxtgsgfrefj ` dtk`b xwdaeo

okfogtf ctki rmksg zmgtg rmg `tdert`rekf `z`tb m`s rmg xkrgfre`a rk eixefjg kfrmget tejmrs kt efrgtgsrs& Zmeag rmg c`orw`a! rgomfeo`a kt g}xgtr kxefekfs kc fkf)jkgtfigfr`a ktj`fe~`rekfs -‑FJK’% o`f dg `bgpw`rgau om`ffgagb rmtkwjm `f`ieows dtegc! rmes efsrerwrekf es eaa) swergb rk s`cgjw`tb rmg tejmr kc x`tregs zmk mkab` agjerei`rg! betgor efrgtgsr ef rmg kwrokig kc rmg xtkogbwtg&

  Rmes smktrokiefj es gebgfogb ef rmg Fktrm @ra`freo Ctgg Rt`bg @jtggigfr-F@CR@% rtedwf`a―s `z`tb ef Ja`ies Jkab & Wfergb _r`rgs &0 Ef rmes o`sg! rmg Pwgom`fEfbe`f F`rekf skwjmr rk x`treoex`rg `s `ieows dgo`wsg ` x`treowa`t xtkngor! rmgJa`ies― jkab iefefj xtkngor zkwab m`g ` sejfeceo`fr eix`or kf rmget `deaeru rk

rt`ga xmuseo`aau `fb sxeterw`aau `akfj rmg Efbe`f rt`eas ako`rgb fg}r rk rmg xtkngor!rmgtgcktg tgsrteorefj rmget ctggbki kc tgaejekf& Rmkwjm rmg rtedwf`a jt`frgb rmgPwgom`f Efbe`f F`rekf ag`g! rmget x`treoex`rekf z`s okfberekfgb rk rmg besotgrekfkc rmg rtedwf`a `fb swdngorgb rk rmg tgsrteorekfs rm`r `tg jgfgt`aau eixksgb kf`ieows x`treoex`rekf& Ef rmes z`u! Ja`ies Jkab gebgfogs rm`r rmg `z`tbs esswgb du efrgtf`rekf`a `tdert`rkts! ec rmgu zgtg ef rmg c`kwt kc rmg efgsrkt! okwab m`gsgtekws t`ieceo`rekfs kf efbejgfkws xgkxags― tejmrs rk a`fb `fb tgaejekf! `stgokjfe~gb ef efrgtf`rekf`a mwi`f tejmrs efsrtwigfrs&

  Rmes `treoag okfrgfbs rm`r efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf smkwab jt`bw`aau ikg

rkz`tbs rmg tgokjferekf kc `f `dskawrg tejmr kc x`treoex`rekf kc efbejgfkws xgkxags&Ckt rmes! er xtkxksgs efoktxkt`refj rmg xtkogbwt`a efsrerwrekf kc ‑efrgtgfrekf’ctki iwfeoex`a a`z efrk efrgtf`rekf`a `tdert`rekf a`z& ‑Efrgtgfrekf’ ef rmg Wfergb_r`rgs -W&_% es okfogegb `s ` xtkogbwt`a bgeog zmgtgdu ` srt`fjgt es xgtierrgb rkdgokig ` x`tru rk ` xgfbefj `orekf rk xtggfr xgtea rk rmg fkf)besxwrefj x`tregs&_efjaefj kwr efbejgfkws xgkxags du jt`frefj rmes sxgoe`a sr`rws `s ‑efrgtgfgts’dgcktg efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf es nwsrecegb dgo`wsg rmgu xkssgss ` besrefor owarwt`aebgfreru `fb! m`g rmg tejmr rk sgac)bgrgtief`rekf&

X`tr EE kc rmes `treoag xtkebgs ` dtegc kgtegz kc rmg gkawrekf kc `ieows

x`treoex`rekf ef efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf `fb mejmaejmrs rmg aeiers rm`r m`g dggfeixksgb du `tdert`rkts& X`tr EEE xtgsgfrs rmg ct`igzktl rm`r m`s gigtjgb efefrgtf`rekf`a a`z rk xtkrgor efbejgfkws tejmrs& Er `ask smkzs rmg efoebgfog rm`refrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfrs i`u m`g kf esswgs rm`r okfogtf efbejgfkws jtkwxs `fbf`rekf)sr`rgs& Rk g}gixaecu rmes okfwfbtwi! ` ruxkakju kc xkrgfre`a kgta`xdgrzggf f`rekf)sr`rgs `fb efbejgfkws xgkxags ef esswgs swom `s f`rwt`a tgskwtogs!tgaejekf! `fb efrgaagorw`a xtkxgtru es xtgsgfrgb& Cef`aau! X`tr ES! `crgt efrtkbwoefj 

0 _gg Ja`ies Jkab Arb & rmg Jkgtfigfr kc rmg Wfergb _r`rgs kc @igteo`! @z`tb-@wj& =! 4885% ``ea`dag `r>  mrrx>++zzz&sr`rg&jk+bkowigfrs+ktj`fe~`rekf+047:5=&xbc -mgtgef`crgt Ja`ies Jkab  %& 

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 6/35

 C`aa! 4800Y  @ieows Owte`g # Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Trs& ef Ef& @td& ??: rmg Ja`ies Jkab  `z`tb! wfx`ols rmg fggb rk efoktxkt`rg ‑efrgtgfrekf’ twags rkefrgtf`rekf`a `tdert`rekf a`z `s ` z`u rk `bbtgss efbejgfkws esswgs iktg

okixtgmgfsegau&

Dgcktg xtkoggbefj! er es eixgt`reg rk kwraefg rmg sokxg `fb aeier`rekfs kc rmes`treoag& Cetsr! rmg okfcaeors tgcgttgb rk `tg aeiergb rk rmksg oetowisr`fogs kc agj`awfogtr`efru `tesefj ctki wfbgcefgb kt wftgokjfe~gb efbejgfkws tejmrs! rm`r es rks`u! rmksg o`sgs zmgtg efbejgfkws tejmrs m`g fkr dggf sgrragb du rmg a`z& _womokfrtkgtsegs smkwab! ef xtefoexag! dg `bnwbeo`rgb du bkigsreo okwtrs& _gokfb! rmg`treoag dgjefs zerm rmg `sswixrekf rm`r efbejgfkws xgkxags o`f dgfgcer ctki rmgefrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr a`z ‑efct`srtworwtg’ `atg`bu ef xa`og& Efbggb! rmg wtjgfou `fb jt`eru kc efbejgfkws oa`eis xtgswi`dau nwsrecegs m`efj `s i`fu agj`a rkkas `s

xkssedag! gsxgoe`aau ef ` okfrg}r kc bkigsreo oakswtg& Rmetb! rmg `treoag `ask `sswigsrm`r rt`berekf`a ag`bgts gagorgb du efbejgfkws jtkwxs `tg fkr kfau ebgfrece`dag! dwr`tg `ask tgxtgsgfr`reg `fb `ookwfr`dag&

EE& K SGTSEGZ KC RMG @IEOW_ OWTE@ EF_RERWREKF EF EFRGTF@REKF@A

EFSG_RIGFR A @Z  

 @& Rmg _xeaa)kgt Gccgors kc Efgsrkt)_r`rg @tdert`rekf 

 Rmg bteefj cktogs dgmefb `tdert`rekf `tg x`tru `wrkfkiu `fb iwrw`a okfsgfr&4 

Ggf rmkwjm `tdert`rekf es xtei`teau ` xte`rg besxwrg tgskawrekf igom`fesi! er o`fm`g sejfeceo`fr tgxgtowssekfs ckt rmg xwdaeo ef jgfgt`a&? Mgfog! ef efgsrkt)sr`rg`tdert`rekf rmgtg es `f wfbgtauefj rgfsekf dgrzggf rmg x`tregs― fggb cktokfcebgfre`aeru `fb xte`ou kc xtkoggbefjs kf rmg kfg m`fb! `fb rmg xwdaeo oa`eickt rt`fsx`tgfou `fb efoawsegfgss kf rmg krmgt&2 @frmkfu Bg X`ai` xktrt`us rmesrgfsekf `s ckaakzs>

 Rmget iggrefjs `tg sgotgr& Rmget igidgts `tg jgfgt`aau wflfkzf& Rmg bgoesekfs rmgu tg`om fggb fkr dg cwaau besoaksgb& Ugr rmg z`u `jtkwx kc efrgtf`rekf`a rtedwf`as m`fbags besxwrgs dgrzggf efgsrkts

`fb cktgejf jkgtfigfrs o`f ag`b rk f`rekf`a a`zs dgefj tgklgb`fb gfetkfigfr`a tgjwa`rekfs om`fjgb& @fb er es `aa ef rmg f`ig kc xtkrgorefj cktgejf efgsrkts&7 

4 _gg Bkt` I`tr` Jtwfgt! @ookwfrefj ckt Xwdaeo Efrgtgsr ef Efrgtf`rekf`a @tdert`rekf> Rmg Fggb   ckt Xtkogbwt`a `fb _rtworwt`a Tgckti ! 20  OKAWI&  N&  RT@F_F@R―A A& 54? -488?% -mgtgef`crgtJtwfgt%&

? _gg eb&2  _gg  @agss`fbt` @srgtere `fb Omtesre`f N& R`is! Rt`fsx`tgfou `fb Tgxtgsgfr`rekf kc rmg 

Xwdaeo Efrgtgsr ef Efgsrigfr Rtg`ru @tdert`rekf  -Nwfg 0! 4808%! ``ea`dag `r>  mrrx>++sstf&oki+`dsrt`or9030==2? -a`sr esergb Fk& 4! 4808% -mgtgef`crgt @srgtre # R`is%&

7 Eb& `r 7& 

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 7/35

??= Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr \Ska& ?> ??2

Fkr swtxtesefjau! ef tgogfr ug`ts rmgtg m`s dggf `f efrgfsg bgd`rg `dkwr rmgrt`fsx`tgfou `fb efoawsegfgss ef `tdert`a xtkoggbefjs3& Rmg efkagigfr kc rmg

sr`rg `fb xwdaeo xkaeou ef rmg efgsrigfr okfrg}r o`f ag`b rk `tdert`a bgoesekfs rm`r`ccgor ` sejfeceo`frau dtk`bgt t`fjg kc `orkts rm`f rmg rzk x`tregs rk rmg besxwrg&: _kig besxwrgs efkag om`aagfjgs rk jkgtfigfr ig`swtgs efrgfbgb rk xtkikrg kt`omegg eixktr`fr xwdaeo xkaeou jk`as! swom `s gfetkfigfr`a xtkrgorekf! a`dktsr`fb`tbs! iefkteru tejmrs! kt xkaeoegs kc `cceti`reg `orekf&= @ooktbefjau! otereos kc efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf okfsebgt rm`r swom xwdaeo xkaeou esswgs! zmeom xgfgrt`rgbggxau efrk rt`berekf`aau bkigsreo skgtgejf xtgtkj`regs!5 smkwab dg `bnwbeo`rgbdgcktg kxgf okwtrs `fb dg swdngor rk cwaa nwbeoe`a kgtsejmr! t`rmgt rm`f dg`bnwbeo`rgb du efrgtf`rekf`a xte`rg `tdert`rkts&08 Ef rmes gef! rmgtg es ` okfogtfrm`r wf`ookwfr`dag xte`rg `tdert`rkts! t`rmgt rm`f ` okwfrtu―s nwbjgs! a`zi`lgts kt

oere~gfs! zeaa bgrgtiefg ‑rmg sr`rws kc sr`rwrgs’!00 `fb rm`r oktxkt`rekfs zeaa betgorxwdaeo xkaeou rmtkwjm rmg wsg kc! kt rmtg`r rk wsg! efgsrigfr `tdert`rekf&04 

3 _gg   eb&! `r 4< _gg `ask! @ag}es Ikwttg!  @tg @ieoe Owte`g rmg Xtkxgt Tgsxkfsg rk rmg Xwdaeo―s Okfogtfs kf Rt`fsx`tgfou ef Efgsrigfr @tdert`rekf; ! 7 A @Z # XT@O& EFR*A O R_& #  RTEDWF@A_ 47:! 433 -4883% -mgtgef`crgt Ikwttg%&

: _gg Gwjgfe` Agefg! @ieows Owte`g ef Efrgtf`rekf`a Efgsrigfr @tdert`rekf> Rmg Eixaeo`rekfs kc `f Efotg`sg ef Rmetb)X`tru X`treoex`rekf ! 45 DGTLGAGU  N&  EFR―A A& 488 -4800% -mgtgef`crgtAgefg%&

= _gg N& @frmkfu S`fBw~gt! Gfm`foefj rmg Xtkogbwt`a Agjerei`ou kc Efgsrkt)_r`rg @tdert`rekf rmtkwjm Rt`fsx`tgfou `fb @ieows Owte`g X`treoex`rekf! 74 IOJEAA A&N& 3=0 -488:% -mgtgef`crgt

 S`fBw~gt%< B`fega D`tsrkz I`jt`z Nt& # Fet`fn`ae I`fga @igt`sefjmg! Rt`fsx`tgfou `fb Xwdaeo X`treoex`rekf ef Efgsrkt)_r`rg @tdert`rekf ! 07 EA_@  N&  EFR―A #  OKIX& A& T GS & ??:-4885%-mgtgef`crgt I`jt`z # @igt`sefjmg%< `fb Ct`fogsok Ct`foekfe!   @oogss rk Nwsreog!Bgfe`a kc Nwsreog `fb Efrgtf`rekf`a Efgsrigfr A`z ! 48-?% GWT &  N&  EFR―A A& :45! :?= -4885% -mgtgef`crgt Ct`foekfe%&

5 I`jt`z # @igt`sefjmg! swxt` fkrg =&08  _gg  Ot`ej Cktogsg! Bkgs rmg _lu C`aa; F@CR@ Om`xrgt 00 Besxwrg _grragigfr `fb 

Bgikot`reo @ookwfr`deaeru ! 02 IEOM& _ R&  N& EFR―A A& ?07  -4883%  -mgtgef`crgt Cktogsg%< F`ggfJwtwbg`f!   @f G`aw`rekf kc Owttgfr Agjerei`ou)d`sgb Kdngorekfs rk F@CR@―s Om`xrgt 00Efgsrigfr Besxwrg Tgskawrekf Xtkogss ! 3 _ @F BEGJK EFR―A A&N&  ?55 -4887% -‑_kig somka`ts`tjwg rm`r sr`rgs smkwab dg ctgg ctki efrgtcgtgfog `fb ctki rmg cg`t kc `f `bgtsg`tdert`rekf kwrokig ef ktbgt rk gccgoregau bgxaku ers xkaeog xkzgts rk xtkrgor rmg mg`arm`fb s`cgru kc ers oere~gfs& & & & Rmgtg i`u dg skig `aeberu rk rmg okfogtf rm`r eixktr`frpwgsrekfs kc bkigsreo xwdaeo xkaeou `fb sr`rg ae`deaeru rk cktgejf efgsrkts smkwab fkr dg agcrrk `b mko `tdert`a x`fgas rm`r wfaelg bkigsreo okwtrs `tg wf`ookwfr`dag& Rmg kdngorekf r`lgsgermgt kc rzk cktis> 0% rm`r `bnwbeo`rekf kc efgsrigfr besxwrgs smkwab fkr dg agcr rk swxt`)f`rekf`a gfreregs kc `fu lefb! kt 4% rm`r er smkwab fkr dg bgagj`rgb rk `b mko `tdert`rekf’%&

00 _gg Agefg! swxt` fkrg :! `r : -oa`eiefj rm`r efrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr `tdert`rekf m`sotg`rgb ` ‑jakd`a `biefesrt`reg a`z’%&

04 _gg  @ffg Bggdkesg Ksrdu! Zeaa Cktgejf Efgsrkts Tgjwa`rg Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Tejmr rk _gac) bgrgtief`rekf; ! 40 Z E_& EFR―A A&N& 44? -488?% -mgtgef`crgt Ksrdu%< `fb @aeskf @& Koms& Ja`ies Jkab Arb&‟@ Cktgejf Wfergb _r`rgs Oere~gf; F@CR@ `fb ers Xkrgfre`a Gccgor kf Gfetkfigfr`a Tgjwa`rekfs `fb rmg Iefefj A`z kc 0=:4! 03 OKAK&  N& EFR―A GFSRA& A& # XKA* U 257! 78=)70=

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 8/35

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 9/35

?28 Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr \Ska& ?> ??2

`ieows owte` efsrerwrekf `s `f eixktr`fr xtkogbwt`a rkka&44 Rmes efsrerwrekf esg}xaktgb swdsgpwgfrau&

D& Rmg Tkag `fb Aeier`rekfs kc rmg @ieows Owte` Efsrerwrekf    @ieoe kt ‑ctegfbs kc rmg okwtr’ x`treoex`frs ef ` xtkogbwtg `tg fkr

‑efrgtgfgts’ ef ` rgomfeo`a sgfsg! sefog rmgu bk fkr efbeo`rg rmget kzf tejmrs&4? Fggtrmgagss! rmgu mgax eixtkg! rmkwjm efbetgorau! rmg kxxktrwferegs kc `oogss rknwsreog du xtkebefj wsgcwa c`orw`a efckti`rekf `fb agj`a efsejmrs ef `bberekf rkrmksg xtkebgb du rmg besxwrefj x`tregs&42 Efbggb! zmgf ` xwdaeo gfreru swom `s `jkgtfigfr`a ktj`f kt `jgfou es xgtierrgb rk swdier `f `ieows dtegc rk ` rtedwf`a!rm`r gfreru es aelgau rk sxg`l ckt rmg ”xwdaeo― `fb rk `bbtgss rmg t`ieceo`rekfs kc `

oa`ei rm`r jk dgukfb rmg gccgors kf rmg efbeebw`a x`tregs&47

 Kgt`aa! `aakzefj `ieows swdiessekfs okfrtedwrgs rk rmg xtkogbwt`a agjerei`ou!

xtkrgorekf kc rmetb x`tru efrgtgsrs! `fb pw`aeru kc rmg `z`tb&43 Rmetb x`tru okaa`dkt`rekf o`f xtkebg `f g}rt` a`ugt kc g}xgtresg kt xgtsxgoreg rk rmg esswgsbesowssgb!4: xtkebefj c`orw`a efckti`rekf `fb agj`a `tjwigfrs rm`r rmg x`tregs i`u omkksg fkr rk t`esg&4= Er gfokwt`jgs cwrwtg efkagigfr du krmgt `ieows jtkwxs!efcwsgs rmg `tdert`rekf xtkogss zerm gagigfrs kc bgikot`ou! `fb mgaxs bessex`rg rmgotereoesis d`sgb wxkf sgotgou&45 Ef smktr! agrrefj `ieoe owte`g ‑gfrgt rmg b`tl tkki’ o`f smkz rmg zktab mkz okfogtfgb efrgtf`rekf`a `tdert`rkts `tg `dkwr

esswgs aelg rmg gfetkfigfr! zgac`tg kt xwdaeo mg`arm&?8

 Mkzggt! rmg `ieows owte` efsrerwrekf es fkr g}gixr ctki otereoesi& Ef rmg

W&_&! Nwbjg Teom`tb Xksfgt `tjwgs rm`r iksr `ieows dtegcs `tg fkr mgaxcwa dgo`wsgrmgu ctgpwgfrau efoawbg bwxaeo`reg `tjwigfrs `fb sgtg i`efau `s ` ig`fs rkg}rgfb kfg kc rmg x`tru―s dtegc&?0 Er `ask `ccgors rmg sokxg! okixag}eru! `fb agfjrmkc rmg `tdert`rekf!?4 gag`refj rmg kgt`aa oksrs `fb jgfgt`refj bga`us ef rmg

44 _gg Seðw`ags! swxt` fkrg 05! `r 4?:&4? _gg Ct`foekfe! swxt` fkrg =! `r :28< `fb Jtwfgt! swxt` fkrg 4&42 Eb& 47 Jtwfgt! swxt` fkrg 4! `r 2?&43 _gg I`jt`z # @igt`sefjmg! swxt` fkrg =&4:  _gg Lua` Regfm``t`! Rmetb X`tru X`treoex`rekf ef Efgsrigfr)Gfetkfigfr Besxwrgs> Tgogfr 

Bggakxigfrs! 03 T GS &  GWT &  OKIIWFERU #  EFR―A GFSRA&  A& 4?8! 4?5 -488:% -mgtgef`crgt Regfm``t`%&

4= _gg I`jt`z # @igt`sefjmg! swxt` fkrg =&45 _gg Omkwbmwtu! swxt` fkrg 0?! `r =0=&?8 Ikwttg! swxt` fkrg 3! `r 433&?0 _gg Omtes Cktb! Zm`r `tg ”Ctegfbs― ckt; Ef Om`xrgt 00 Besxwrgs! @oogxrefj @ieoe zkwab Mgax

Aecr rmg Owtr`ef kc _gotgou _wttkwfbefj Efgsrkt)sr`rg @tdert`rekfs ! 00 _ Z &  N& A& #  RT@BG @I& 48: 

-4887%&?4  _gg  Igj Leffg`t! Rt`fsx`tgfou `fb Rmetb X`tru X`treoex`rekf ef Efgsrkt)_r`rg Besxwrg 

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 10/35

 C`aa! 4800Y  @ieows Owte`g # Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Trs& ef Ef& @td& ?20 xtkogbwtg! `s rmgu m`g `f `bberekf`a sgr kc xag`befjs rk `bbtgss&?? Ctki rmgoa`ei`frs― egzxkefr! efgsrkts i`u cg`t rm`r rmg efotg`sgb kxgffgss zeaa ngkx`tbe~g

okfcebgfre`aeru&?2 Krmgt okfogtfs xgtr`ef rk rmg `ieoe―s agjerei`ou -rk zm`r g}rgfrbk rmgu tgxtgsgfr rmg efrgtgsrs kc `aa kt x`tr kc rmg oeea skoegru;% `fb grmeo`aokfbwor -`tg rmgu tg`aau efbgxgfbgfr `fb eiiwfg rk i`fexwa`rekf du kfg x`tru;%&?7 Fkfgrmgagss! skig rmgsg otereoesis o`f dg tgskagb du gsr`daesmefj oag`txtkogbwtgs `s rk zmgf `fb mkz `ieows o`f x`treoex`rg?3& Rk dg oag`t! zmgfeixtkxgtau wsgb! `ieows okaa`dkt`rekf okwab wfbgtiefg rmg gtu `tdert`rekf tgjeiger es swxxksgb rk srtgfjrmgf&?: 

O& @ieoe Dtegcs ef Efrgtf`rekf`a Efgsrigfr A`z  Mesrkteo`aau! rmg `ieows owte` efsrerwrekf xa`ugb fk tkag ef efgsrkt‟sr`rg

`tdert`rekf& @r cetsr! `tdert`rekf rtedwf`as tgcwsgb rk `aakz rmetb)x`tru x`treoex`rekfbwg rk rmg efmgtgfr beccgtgfogs dgrzggf `tdert`rekf xtkoggbefjs `fb rmksg dgcktgbkigsreo kt efrgtf`rekf`a okwtrs&?= Mkzggt! kgt rmg a`sr bgo`bg! ogtr`ef`tdert`rekf rtedwf`as m`g smkzf iktg zeaaefjfgss rk xtkebg rmetb x`tregs zermskig xkssedeaeru rk x`treoex`rg rmtkwjm zterrgf `ieows dtegcs!?5 rmkwjm rmg beccgtgfr`tdert`rekf ct`igzktls m`g fkr tgsxkfbgb ef seiea`t z`us&28 

  Rmg cetsr rzk o`sgs ef zmeom `tdert`rekf rtedwf`as tgokjfe~gb rmget xkzgt rk`bier `fb okfsebgt `ieows swdiessekfs o`ig wx wfbgt rmg F@CR@ ct`igzktl& Ef

rmg 4880 Igrm`fg} Oktxkt`rekf & Wfergb _r`rgs kc @igteo` 20 `fb Wfergb X`toga _gteogs &

_grragigfr -4887% `r :! ``ea`dag `r>  mrrx>++zzz&kgob&ktj+b`r`kgob+47+?+?2:=350?&xbc -a`sr esergb Kor& 45! 4800% -mgtgef`crgt Leffg`t%&

?? _gg   eb< `fb! I`tref Mwfrgt # @ag}ge D`tdwl! Xtkogbwt`a @sxgors kc Fkf)besxwrefj X`tru Efrgtgfrekfs ef Om`xrgt 00 @tdert`rekfs! ? @_XGT T GS & EFR*A DW_& #  RT@BG A& 070 -488?%< `fbMåorkt I`wteoek Igbef`)O`s`s! A`s x`trgs gf ga `tdert`ng OE@BE ! 07 EFR―A A @Z !  T GSE_R@

OKAKIDE@F@ BG BGTGOMK EFRGTF@OEKF@A 407)424 -4885%&?2 _gg Agefg! swxt` fkrg :! `r 42&?7 Ikwttg! swxt` fkrg 3! `r 433)4:8&?3 _gg Regfm``t`! swxt` fkrg 4:! `r 428&?: Nktjg Seðw`ags! swxt` fkrg 05! `r 47&?= _gg Agefg swxt` fkrg :! `r 08 -‑Ef @jw`s bga Rwf`te _@ & Rmg Tgxwdaeo kc Dkaee` \rmg

Dgomrga o`sgY& & & & rmg rtedwf`a bgfegb oere~gfs `fb gfetkfigfr`a jtkwxs sr`fbefj `r rmg`tdert`rekf bwg rk rmg x`tregs― wfzeaaefjfgss rk okfsgfr rk rmget x`treoex`rekf& Rmg rtedwf`a!

 zmeom z`s kxgt`refj wfbgt rmg `wsxeogs kc EO_EB! ckwfb rm`r rmg ‑efrgtxa`u kc rmg EO_EBOkfgfrekf `fb rmg DER! `fb rmg okfsgfsw`a f`rwtg kc `tdert`rekf’ agcr rmg bgoesekf `stgj`tbs `ieows x`treoex`rekf ef rmg m`fbs kc rmg x`tregs rk rmg `tdert`rekf< sefog rmg x`tregsbeb fkr okfsgfr! rmg rtedwf`a a`olgb rmg xkzgt rk `aakz `fu ckti kc rmetb)x`tru efrgtgfrekf’%& _gg `ask Ct`foekfe! swxt` fkrg =! `r :24< `fb Omkwbmwtu! swxt` fkrg 0?! `r =02&

?5 _gg Agefg! swxt` fkrg : ! `r 4&28 _gg @srgtere # R`is! swxt` fkrg 2! `r 3&20 _gg Igrm`fg} Oktx& & Wfergb _r`rgs! Bgoesekf kc rmg Rtedwf`a kf Xgrerekfs ctki

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 11/35

?24 Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr \Ska& ?> ??2

O`f`b` 24 `z`tbs! rmg F@CR@ rtedwf`as mgab rm`r ggf rmkwjm rmgu m`b fk xkzgtrk `bier x`tregs rk rmg `tdert`rekf! tgogeefj zterrgf swdiessekfs ctki rmetb x`tregs

 z`s zermef rmget xkzgts rk i`f`jg rmg xtkogbwtg& Iktgkgt! rmgu `olfkzagbjgbrm`r `ieows dtegcs zkwab mgax rmg rtedwf`as― xtkogss kc wfbgtsr`fbefj `fb tgskaefj rmg besxwrg>2? 

  Rmgtg es `f wfbkwdrgb xwdaeo efrgtgsr ef rmes `tdert`rekf& Rmgswdsr`freg esswgs g}rgfb c`t dgukfb rmksg t`esgb du rmg wsw`art`fsf`rekf`a `tdert`rekf dgrzggf xte`rg x`tregs& Rmes es fkr igtgau dgo`wsg kfg kc rmg besxwrefj x`tregs es ` _r`rg& & &Rmg xwdaeo efrgtgsref rmes `tdert`rekf `tesgs ctki ers swdngor i`rrgt! `s xkzgtcwaau swjjgsrgb ef rmg Xgrerekfs& Rmgtg es `ask ` dtk`bgt `tjwigfr! `s

swjjgsrgb du rmg \Wfergb _r`rgsY `fb O`f`b`> rmg Om`xrgt 00 `tdert`axtkogss okwab dgfgcer ctki dgefj xgtogegb `s iktg kxgf ktrt`fsx`tgfr! kt okfgtsgau dg m`tigb ec sggf `s wfbwau sgotgreg&22 

_wdsgpwgfrau! rmg F@CR@ rtedwf`as m`g `aakzgb sggt`a FJKs rk swdier zterrgfdtegcs&27 

Ckaakzefj rmg Igrm`fg} `fb WX_ `z`tbs! rmg Ctgg Rt`bg Okiiessekf -CRO% ef488? esswgb ` sr`rgigfr tgokiigfbefj rm`r F@CR@ rtedwf`as `bkxr xtkogbwtgsrk bg`a zerm x`treoex`rekf du fkf)besxwrefj x`tregs&23 Rmg CRO _r`rgigfr sr`rgs

rm`r ”fkrmefj ef rmg F@CR@ aeiers ` rtedwf`a―s besotgrekf rk `oogxr zterrgfswdiessekfs ctki ` fkf)besxwrefj x`tru―& @ikfj krmgt tgokiigfb`rekfs! erswjjgsrs rmg ckti `fb okfrgfr kc `f `xxaeo`rekf ckt ag`g< er sgrs sggt`a otergte` cktrmg rtedwf`a rk okfsebgt ef bgrgtiefefj zmgrmgt rk jt`fr ag`g rk ceag ` fkf)besxwrefj x`tru swdiessekf! `fb er gsr`daesmgs rm`r rmg fkf)besxwrefj x`tru rm`r ceagb` swdiessekf es fkr gfreragb rk i`lg cwtrmgt swdiessekfs&2: 

Er es zktrm igfrekfefj rm`r rzk F@CR@ x`tregs∔O`f`b` `fb rmg W&_∔m`gtgcktiwa`rgb rmget dea`rgt`a efgsrigfr rtg`ru -DER% ikbgas rk efoawbg xtkesekfs

 Rmetb Xgtskfs rk Efrgtgfg `s @ieoe Owte`g -N`f& 07! 4880% -mgtgef`crgt Igrm`fg}  %&24 _gg Wfergb _r`rgs X`toga _gteog kc @igteo` & O`f`b`! Bgoesekf kc rmg Rtedwf`a kf

Xgrerekfs ckt Efrgtgfrekf `fb X`treoex`rekf `s @ieoe Owte`g -Kor& 0:! 4880% -mgtgef`crgtWX_  %&

2? _gg S`fBw~gt swxt` fkrg =! `r :04&22 _wxt` fkrg 20! ³ 25&27 _gg Omkwbmwtu! swxt` fkrg 0?! `r =07< `fb Ct`foekfe! swxt` fkrg =! `r :20&23 _gg F@CR@ Ctgg Rt`bg Okiiessekf! _r`rgigfr kc rmg Ctgg Rt`bg Okiiessekf kf

Fkf)Besxwrefj X`tru X`treoex`rekf& ``ea`dag `r>  mrrx>++zzz&f`cr`oa`eis&oki+X`xgts+Fkfbesxwrefj)gf&xbc -a`sr esergb Bgogidgt 7! 4800%& 

2: Fkfgrmgagss! rmg CRO _r`rgigfr es ` fkf)defbefj bkowigfr ckt Om`xrgt 00rtedwf`as&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 12/35

 C`aa! 4800Y  @ieows Owte`g # Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Trs& ef Ef& @td& ?2? rm`r gixkzgt rtedwf`as rk okfsebgt! rmkwjm kf ` besotgrekf`tu d`ses! jt`frefj rmetbx`tregs rmg tejmr rk swdier dtegcs ef efgsrigfr `tdert`rekf `fb tgpwetg rm`r `aa

mg`tefj dg kxgf rk rmg xwdaeo&2= Rmgsg fgz xtkesekfs `tg ckwfb ef rmg ctgg rt`bg`jtggigfrs gfrgtgb efrk dgrzggf rmg W&_ `fb Omeag! Okakide`! Bkiefeo`fTgxwdaeo! Iktkook! Xgtw! _efj`xktg! `fb Wtwjw`u&25 Jgfgt`aau sxg`lefj! dkrm rmgfgz DER ikbgas `rrgfb rk sggt`a oktg rt`fsx`tgfou esswgs `fb wfbgtr`lgkxgffgss g}oggbefj rm`r wfbgt rmg F@CR@&78 

  @s tgj`tbs rmg Efrgtf`rekf`a Ogfrtg ckt _grragigfr kc Efgsrigfr Besxwrgs-EO_EB% ct`igzktl! zmeag `r cetsr `tdert`rekf rtedwf`as bgfegb `ieoe swdiessekfsbwg rk rmg besxwrefj x`tregs― tgawor`fog!70 ef swdsgpwgfr o`sgs ogtr`ef rtedwf`as m`gg}rgfbgb `ieows tejmrs rk FJKs! ef o`sgs swom `s Dez`rgt J`wcc -R`f~`fe`% Arb& &

Wfergb Tgxwdaeo kc R`f~`fe` 74 `fb _wg~! _koegb`b Jgfgt`a bg @jw`s bg D`togakf`! _&@&! `fb Segfbe Wfegts`a _&@& & Rmg @tjgfref` &7? Rmgsg o`sgs zgtg bgoebgb wfbgt Twag ?:-4%kc rmg EO_EB @tdert`rekf Twags!72 `s `igfbgb ef 4883!77 zmeom jt`fr rmg `tdert`a

2=  _gg  Agefg swxt`  fkrg :! `r 08)00& _gg `ask mrrx>++zzz&efrgtf`rekf`a&jo&o`+rt`bg)`jtggigfrs)`ooktbs)okiigtoe`w}+`jt)`oo+cex`)`xeg+efbg}&`sx} -a`sr esergb Bgo& =! 4808%-O`f`be`f Cktgejf Efgsrigfr Xtkikrekf `fb Xtkrgorekf @jtggigfrs%< `fbmrrx>++zzz&sr`rg&jk+bkowigfrs+ktj`fe~`rekf+?=:08&xbc -a`sr esergb Bgo& 4! 4808% -W_)DER Ikbga%&

25 _gg Leffg`t! swxt` fkrg ?4! `r 4??&78  _gg  N`ol N& Okg Nt&! Rt`fsx`tgfou ef rmg Tgskawrekf kc Efgsrkt)sr`rg Besxwrgs> @bkxrekf!

 @b`xr`rekf! `fb F@CR@ Ag`bgtsmex! 72 L  @F A& T GS & 0??5 -4883% -mgtgef`crgt Okg%&70 _gg swxt` fkrg ?= -Tgcgttefj rk @jw`s bga Rwf`te _@ & Rmg Tgxwdaeo kc Dkaee`  %74  _gg   Dez`rgt J`wcc -R`f~`fe`% Arb& & Wfergb Tgxwdaeo kc R`f~`fe` ! EO_EB O`sg Fk&

 @TD+87+44&7? _gg _wg~! _koegb`b Jgfgt`a bg @jw`s bg D`togakf`! _&@&! `fb Segfbe Wfegts`a _&@&

 & Rmg @tjgfref`! EO_EB O`sg Fk& @TD+8?+05&72 Twag ?:-4% es `s ckaakzs>

 @crgt okfswarefj dkrm x`tregs! rmg Rtedwf`a i`u `aakz ` xgtskf kt gfreru rm`r es fkr ` x`tru rk rmg besxwrg -ef rmes Twag o`aagb rmg ‑fkf)besxwrefj x`tru’% rk ceag ` zterrgf swdiessekf zerm rmg Rtedwf`a tgj`tbefj ` i`rrgt

 zermef rmg sokxg kc rmg besxwrg& Ef bgrgtiefefj zmgrmgt rk `aakz swom `ceaefj! rmg Rtedwf`a sm`aa okfsebgt! `ikfj krmgt rmefjs! rmg g}rgfr rk

 zmeom>-`% rmg fkf)besxwrefj x`tru swdiessekf zkwab `ssesr rmg Rtedwf`a efrmg bgrgtief`rekf kc ` c`orw`a kt agj`a esswg tga`rgb rk rmg xtkoggbefj du dtefjefj ` xgtsxgoreg! x`treowa`t lfkzagbjg kt efsejmr rm`r esbeccgtgfr ctki rm`r kc rmg besxwrefj x`tregs<-d% rmg fkf)besxwrefj x`tru swdiessekf zkwab `bbtgss ` i`rrgt

 zermef rmg sokxg kc rmg besxwrg<-o% rmg fkf)besxwrefj x`tru m`s ` sejfeceo`fr efrgtgsr ef rmgxtkoggbefj&

 Rmg Rtedwf`a sm`aa gfswtg rm`r rmg fkf)besxwrefj x`tru swdiessekf bkgsfkr bestwxr rmg xtkoggbefj kt wfbwau dwtbgf kt wfc`etau xtgnwbeog germgt

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 13/35

?22 Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr \Ska& ?> ??2

rtedwf`a besotgrekf rk `aakz rmetb)x`tru swdiessekf kc zterrgf dtegcs `fb i`lgmg`tefjs kxgf rk rmg xwdaeo wfbgt ogtr`ef oetowisr`fogs&73 Rmg fgz EO_EB twags

okttgsxkfb ‑rk rmg sggiefjau ettggtsedag rtgfb rkz`tb kxgffgss `ccgorefj efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf’&7: 

Ef swi! `ieows x`treoex`rekf ef efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf m`s r`lgf rmg ckti kc   zterrgf swdiessekfs `bbtgssgb rk rmg `tdert`rkts! ggf rmkwjm rmetb x`tru efkagigfr es fkr aeiergb rk zterrgf swdiessekfs du bgceferekf&7= Ef c`or! `ieoeokwab `ask dg jt`frgb rmg tejmr rk `rrgfb `fb x`treoex`rg ef kt`a mg`tefjs< `oogss rmgbesxwrefj x`tregs― bkowigfrs kf rmg tgoktb< `fb otkss)g}`iefg zerfgssgs&75 Ef rmestgj`tb! efrgtf`rekf`a mwi`f tejmrs rtedwf`as aelg rmg Gwtkxg`f Okwtr kc Mwi`fTejmrs `fb rmg Efrgt)@igteo`f Okwtr kc Mwi`f Tejmrs m`g xgtierrgb rmetb

x`tregs rk x`treoex`rg ef rmg kt`a mg`tefjs sr`jg kc rmg xtkoggbefjs&38 Mkzggt!efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf m`s jgfgt`aau eixksgb ` sgr kc tgsrteorekfs kf `ieowsswdiessekfs ef xtkoggbefjs dgcktg rmgi! swom `s ce}efj ` fwidgt kc x`jgs ckt rmg

  zterrgf dtegcs< fkr `aakzefj rmg swdiessekf kc g}meders kt krmgt gebgfog wfagsstgpwgsrgb g}xtgssau du rmg rtedwf`a< fkr jt`frefj `oogss rk rmg gebgfre`tu tgoktb ktrk rmg besxwrefj x`tregs― swdiessekfs< `fb fkr xgtierrefj kt`a swdiessekfs kt`rrgfbefj rmg xtkoggbefjs ec oaksgb rk rmg jgfgt`a xwdaeo&30 

Ggf rmkwjm rmgtg sggis rk dg `f kgt`aa rtgfb ef efgsrkt)sr`rg rtedwf`as rkxtkebg iktg rt`fsx`tgfou ef rmget bgaedgt`rekfs du `olfkzagbjefj rmg eixktr`fog

x`tru! `fb rm`r dkrm x`tregs `tg jegf `f kxxktrwferu rk xtgsgfr rmgetkdsgt`rekfs kf rmg fkf)besxwrefj x`tru swdiessekf&

77 Rmg `igfbigfrs o`ig efrk gccgor ef @xtea 4883&   @`ea`dag `r>   zzz&zktabd`fl&ktj+eoseb+d`seobko+OTT[Gfjaesm)ce f`a&xbc&

73  _gg g&j& Agefg swxt` fkrg :! `r 0?< `fb @fbtgz bg Akrdefegtg IoBkwj`aa # @fl _`frgfs! EO_EB Rtedwf`as @xxau Fgz Twags kf @ieows Owte`g ! 44 IG@AGU ―_ EFR―A @TD& T GX& 35 -488:%&

7: Okg! swxt` fkrg 78&7= _gg Agefg swxt` fkrg :! `r 5&75 Eb& 38 _gg Seðw`ags swxt` fkrg 05! `r 422 -`tjwefj rm`r rmg `ieoe m`g ` srtkfjgt d`tj`efefj 

xkzgt ef mwi`fs tejmrs o`sgs dgo`wsg rmgsg `tg `tg`s zmgtg rmg x`treoex`rekf kc oeeaskoegru es efotg`sefjau tgj`tbgb `s eixktr`fr%&

30  _gg  Gx`iefkfr`s Rte`fr`ceakw!   @ Iktg G}x`fseg Tkag ckt @ieoe Owte`g ef Efgsrigfr  @tdert`rekf; !  Lawzgt @tdert`rekf Dakj -I`u 00! 4885%! ``ea`dag `r>  mrrx>++lawzgt`tdert`rekfdakj&oki+dakj+4885+87+00+`)iktg)g}x`fseg)tkag)ckt)`ieoe)owte`g)ef)efgsrigfr)`tdert`rekf+ -a`sr esergb Korkdgt 48! 4800% -mgtgef`crgt Rte`fr`ceakw%&_gg `ask! Agefg swxt`  fkrg :! `r 07 -gixm`se~efj rm`r efgsrkt)sr`rg rtedwf`as m`g fkrjgfgt`aau g}rgfbgb x`treoex`rekf tejmrs dgukfb swdiessekf kc zterrgf dtegcs%< `fbOmkwbmwtu! swxt`  fkrg 0?! `r =0: -okfrgfbefj rm`r `armkwjm sggt`a efgsrigfr `tdert`artedwf`as m`g dggf g`jgt ckt `ieows efxwr! rmgu m`g susrgi`reo`aau bgfegb `ieoe `fu efkagigfr dgukfb rmg swdiessekf kc dtegcs%&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 14/35

 C`aa! 4800Y  @ieows Owte`g # Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Trs& ef Ef& @td& ?27 kc rmg x`treoex`rekf kc oeea skoegru ef rmg tgskawrekf kc efgsrigfr besxwrgs! `ieowsx`treoex`rekf ‑es ogtr`efau fkr ` x`f`og` rk owtg `aa rmg g}esrefj bgcgors `fb aeiers kc 

`oogss rk nwsreog ef rmg okfrg}r kc efgsrigfr `tdert`rekf’&34 Kf rmg kfg m`fb! erm`s fkr ugr dggf tgokjfe~gb `s ` tejmr3?> er tgi`efs ` xtkogbwt`a xtgtkj`reg swdngorrk rmg x`tregs― `fb rmg rtedwf`a―s besotgrekf&32 Kf rmg krmgt m`fb! er es sreaa swdngor rk` sgtegs kc aeier`rekfs rm`r i`lg rmes efsrerwrekf ef`bgpw`rg rk `bbtgss rmg tejmrs kc rmetb x`tregs! gsxgoe`aau wafgt`dag jtkwxs&

EEE& EFBEJGFKW_ XGKXAG_ @FB EFRGTF@REKF@A A @Z 

 @& Jgfgt`a Xtkrgorekf Ct`igzktl

Okakfe~`rekf agcr efbejgfkws xgkxags tgagj`rgb rk ‑iefkt sx`ogs! tgsgt`rekfs!dtg`b)otwids kc a`fb okfogbgb du rmg bkief`fr skoegru’&37 Rmgu zgtg sgx`t`rgbctki rmget s`otgb a`fbs! bgxtegb kc rmget rt`berekf`a gfetkfigfrs! `fb xkaereo`aau!gokfkieo`aau! owarwt`aau! `fb tgaejekwsau besxkssgssgb&33 Rmgu dgo`ig ‑gfrt`xxgbxgkxags! f`rekfs zermef’&3: Rkb`u! rmgtg `tg `tkwfb ?88 ieaaekf efbejgfkws xgkxagsef rmg zktab! iksr kc zmki g}esr wfbgt okfberekfs kc sggtg bes`b`fr`jg `fbxkgtru zermef bkigsreo nwtesbeorekfs) eoreis kc besoteief`rekf `fb g}oawsekf) `fbsrtwjjag rk xtgsgtg rmget owarwtg `fb ktejef`a z`u kc aecg&3= 

Ggf rmkwjm rmgtg es fk bgceferekf ef efrgtf`rekf`a a`z kc ‑efbejgfkws

xgkxags’ -kt ‑efbejgfkwsfgss’%!35 rmg rgti jgfgt`aau bgsotedgs ` xkxwa`rekf zmeomsm`tgs ` okiikf mesrkteo`a rt`berekf! owarwtg! a`fjw`jg! t`og! tgaejekf kt rgtterktu 

34 Ct`foekfe! swxt` fkrg =! `r :24&3? Okg! swxt`  fkrg 78 -`tjwefj rm`r ‑rmksg susrgis rm`r okfrgixa`rg `ieows

x`treoex`rekf okfcgt a`tjg ig`swtgs kc besotgrekf kf rtedwf`as `fb okttgsxkfbefjau besokwt`jg `fu fkrekf rm`r `ieows x`treoex`rekf es ` tejmr’%&

32  _gg  Agefg! swxt`  fkrg :! `r 0: -wfbgtsoktefj rm`r rmg owttgfr efsrerwrekf`a `fbxt`oreo`a `xxtk`om rk `ieows efrgtgfrekf ef efgsrigfr `tdert`rekf o`f dg o`rgjkte~gb `sbesotgrekf`tu `fb a`tjgau efckti`a%& @fkrmgt efsr`fog zmgtg `ieows dtegcs m`g dggf`bierrgb kf ` besotgrekf`tu d`ses es ef rmg Zktab Rt`bg Ktj`fe~`rekf besxwrg sgrragigfrsusrgi&

37 _egjctegb Zegssfgt! Tejmrs `fb _r`rws kc Efbejgfkws Xgkxags> @ Jakd`a Okix`t`reg `fb Efrgtf`rekf`a Agj`a @f`auses ! 04 M @TS & MWI& T  R_&  N& 7: -0555% -mgtgef`crgt Zegssfgt%&

33 Eb& 3: Eb& 3= _gg Nksg X`wak L`srtwx! Rmg Efrgtf`rekf`ae~`rekf kc Efbejgfkws Tejmrs ctki rmg Gfetkfigfr`a 

`fb Mwi`f Tejmrs Xgtsxgoreg ! ?4 RG] & EFR―A A&N& 5: -055:%&35 _gg g&j& Twssgaa A`ztgfog D`tsm! Efbejgfkws Xgkxags !  ef   RMG K]CKTB M @FBDKKL KC

EFRGTF@REKF@A GFSETKFIGFR@A A @Z =?7 -B`fega Dkb`fslu! Nwrr` Dtwfåg # Gaagf Mgu gbs&! K}cktb Wfe& Xtgss! 4b gb& 488:% -‑Rmg rgti efbejgfkws xgkxags m`s fggt dggf`wrmkter`regau bgcefgb! \skY rmgtg okfrefwg rk dg efsr`fogs zmgtg rmg efbejgfkwsfgss kc `x`treowa`t efbeebw`a kt jtkwx es `idejwkws `fb okfrgsrgb du rmg sr`rg’% -mgtgef`crgt D`tsm%&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 15/35

?23 Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr \Ska& ?> ??2

okffgorekf -rmg ‑kdngoreg’ gagigfr%< `fb ` sgac)ebgfreru `s ` besreforeg owarwt`a ktgrmfeo jtkwx -rmg ‑swdngoreg’ gagigfr%&:8h Xtkebefj ` bgceferekf kc efbejgfkws

xgkxags es dgukfb rmg `ei kc rmes `treoag& Fkfgrmgagss! ckt rmg xwtxksg kc rmes`treoag! efbejgfkws xgkxags `tg wfbgtsrkkb `s rmksg okiiwferegs rm`r xtg)b`rgokakfe~`rekf xtkogssgs! efm`der `fogsrt`a a`fbs! `fb `tg sreaa om`t`orgte~gb du `besreforeg owarwtg&:0 

Ckt rmg x`sr cgz bgo`bgs! efrgtf`rekf`a ktj`fe~`rekfs `fb FJKs m`g dggf zktlefj rk cktiwa`rg mwi`f tejmrs sr`fb`tbs `xxaeo`dag rk rmg zktab―s efbejgfkwsxgkxags&:4 @s ` tgswar! sggt`a efrgtf`rekf`a efsrtwigfrs m`g gigtjgb rk tgsrteorsr`rg skgtgejfru ef rmg rtg`rigfr kc rmg efbejgfkws xkxwa`rekfs rm`r efm`der ersrgtterktu&:? Ef rmes gef! rmgtg es ‑\`Yf efotg`sefj rtgfb rkz`tbs \rmgYefrgtf`rekf`ae~`rekf kc besxwrgs dgrzggf efbejgfkws xgkxags `fb rmgetjkgtfigfrs’&:2 @ikfj krmgt efsrtwigfrs `bbtgssefj efbejgfkws esswgs!:7 er eseixgt`reg rk mejmaejmr rmg 05=: EAK Okfgfrekf Fk& 08: Okfogtfefj rmgXtkrgorekf `fb Efrgjt`rekf kc Efbejgfkws `fb Krmgt Rted`a `fb _gie)Rted`a

:8 _gg X`wa N& I`jf`tgaa`! Rmg Gkaefj Tejmr kc _gac)bgrgtief`rekf kc Efbejgfkws Xgkxags ! 02 _ R&  RMKI@_ A& T GS & 247 -4880%< `fb _rgxm`f I`tpw`tbr! Efrgtf`rekf`a A`z `fb Efbejgfkws Xgkxags ! ? EFR―A N& JTKWX T  R_& 2:! 3= -0557)0553%&

:0_gg  _&  N @IG_  @F@U@!  EFBEJGFKW_ XGKXAG_ EF EFRGTF@REKF@A A @Z   2  -K}cktbWfe& Xtgss! 4b gb& 4882% -mgtgef`crgt @F@U@ %  -xtkxksefj rmg ckaakzefj bgceferekf>‑Efbejgfkws xgkxags! f`rekfs! kt okiiwferegs `tg owarwt`aau besreforeg jtkwxs rm`r cefbrmgisgags gfjwacgb du sgrragt skoegregs dktf kc rmg cktogs kc gixetg `fb okfpwgsr& Rmgbegtsg swteefj Efbe`f okiiwferegs `fb f`rekfs kc rmg Zgsrgtf Mgiesxmgtg! rmg Efwer`fb @agwr kc rmg @toreo! rmg @dktejefgs kc @wsrt`ae`! rmg I`kte kc Fgz ^g`a`fb! rmg rted`axgkxags kc @se`! `fb krmgt swom jtkwxs `tg `ikfj rmksg jgfgt`aau tgj`tbgb `s efbejgfkws&

 Rmgu `tg efbejgfkws dgo`wsg rmget `fogsrt`a tkkrs `tg eidgbbgb ef rmg a`fbs ef zmeom rmgu aeg! kt zkwab aelg rk aeg! iwom iktg bggxau rm`f rmg tkkrs kc iktg xkzgtcwa sgorkts kc skoegru aeefj kf rmg s`ig a`fbs kt ef oaksg xtk}eieru& Cwtrmgtiktg! rmgu `tg xgkxags rk rmgg}rgfr rmgu okixtesg besrefor okiiwferegs zerm ` okfrefweru kc g}esrgfog `fb ebgfreru rm`raefls rmgi rk rmg okiiwferegs! rtedgs! kt f`rekfs kc rmget `fogsrt`a x`sr’%&

:4  _gg  _m`tkf K―Dtegf! Cgbgt`a Efbe`f Xkaeoegs `fb rmg Efrgtf`rekf`a Xtkrgorekf kc Mwi`f Tejmrs -mgtgef`crgt K―Dtegf%! ef @IGTEO@F EFBE@F XKAEOU EF RMG  R ZGFREGRM

OGFRWTU ?7 -Sefg Bgakte`! Nt& gb&! Wfe& kc Kla`mki` Xtgss 05=7% -mgtgef`crgt Bgakte`! Nt&gb&%&

:?  _gg  X`rteol I`olagi! Efbejgfkws Xgkxags Tgokjferekf ef Efrgtf`rekf`a A`z> Rmgktgreo`a Kdsgt`rekfs ! 48 IEOM!  N& EFR―A A& 0:: -488=% -mgtgef`crgt I`olagi%&

:2 Aea` D`ttgt`)Mgtf`fbg~! Jkr rerag! Zeaa sgaa> Efbejgfkws tejmrs rk a`fb ef Omeag `fb @tjgfref` ! ef XTKXGTRU @FB RMG A @Z EF GFGTJU @FB F @RWT@A T G_KWTOG_ 0=7 -@eaggf IoM`tj gr `a& gbs&! K}cktb Wfe& Xtgss 4808% -mgtgef`crgt D`ttgt`)Mgtf`fbg~%&

:7 _gg RMG WF  BGOA@T@REKF KF RMG T EJMR_ KC EFBEJGFKW_ XGKXAG_>  MKZ  E RO @IG RK DG @FB Z M@R E R MGT@AB_ 08 -Oa`etg Om`trgts # Tkbkack _r`gfm`jgf gbs&! EZJE@ 4885% -mgtgef`crgt Om`trgts # _r`gfm`jgf gbs&%&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 16/35

 C`aa! 4800Y  @ieows Owte`g # Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Trs& ef Ef& @td& ?2: Xkxwa`rekfs ef Efbgxgfbgfr Okwfrtegs:3< rmg 05=5 EAK Okfgfrekf Fk& 035Okfogtfefj Efbejgfkws `fb Rted`a Xgkxags ef Efbgxgfbgfr Okwfrtegs::! `fb rmg

488: Wfergb F`rekfs Bgoa`t`rekf kf rmg Tejmrs kc Efbejgfkws Xgkxags-WFBTEX%&:= Rmes xtkogss kc efrgtf`rekf`ae~`rekf m`s fkr kfau dggf om`t`orgte~gbdu rmg gigtjgfog kc `b mko efrgtf`rekf`a sr`fb`tbs! dwr `ask du rmg xtkjtgsseg -ktg}rgfseg% efrgtxtgr`rekf kc g}esrefj mwi`f tejmrs efsrtwigfrs fkr ktejef`aau bgsejfgb rk `bbtgss efbejgfkws esswgs& Rmes es rmg o`sg zerm rmg Wfergb F`rekfsMwi`f Tejmrs Okiierrgg!:5 rmg Okiierrgg kf rmg Gaeief`rekf kc T`oe`aBesoteief`rekf!=8 `fb rmg Efrgt)@igteo`f Okiiessekf kc Mwi`f Tejmrs-E@OiMT%&=0 Kfg g}`ixag kc `f efsrtwigfr zerm iktg ”rggrm― es rmg @igteo`fOkfgfrekf kc Mwi`f Tejmrs! ` tgjekf`a mwi`f tejmrs rtg`ru t`recegb du rzgfru)ceg sr`rgs ef rmg @igteo`s! zmeom m`s dggf efrgtxtgrgb kgt rmg ug`ts du rmg Efrgt)

  @igteo`f Okwtr kc Mwi`f Tejmrs -E@OrMT% ef c`kwt kc efbejgfkws xgkxags―tejmrs!=4 gsxgoe`aau zerm tgj`tb rk rmget okiiwf`a xtkxgtru&=? @ooktbefjau! sr`rgs

:3 Okfgfrekf okfogtfefj rmg Xtkrgorekf `fb Efrgjt`rekf kc Efbejgfkws `fb Krmgt Rted`a `fb _gie)Rted`a Xkxwa`rekfs ef Efbgxgfbgfr Okwfrtegs! Okfgfrekf O08: - ̀bkxrgb    Nwfg 43! 057:%  ``ea`dag `r>  mrrx>++zzz&eak&ktj+eakag}+oje)ag}+okfbg&xa;O08:& _gg `ask D`tsm! swxt` fkrg 35! `r =?4 -kdsgtefj rm`r EAK Okfgfrekf 08: z`s rmg cetsr efrgtf`rekf`aefsrtwigfr rk `bbtgss rmg serw`rekf kc efbejgfkws xgkxags `s ` sgx`t`rg o`rgjktu ctki fkf)sgac jkgtfefj rgtterktegs kt iefkteregs%&

:: Okfgfrekf okfogtfefj Efbejgfkws `fb Rted`a Xgkxags ef Efbgxgfbgfr Okwfrtegs!Okfgfrekf O035 - ̀ bkxrgb  Nwfg 4:! 05=5% ``ea`dag `r>  mrrx>++zzz&eak&ktj+eakag}+oje)ag}+okfbg&xa;O035

:= Wfergb F`rekfs Bgoa`t`rekf kf rmg Tejmrs kc Efbejgfkws Xgkxags -WFBTEX%! J&@&Tgskawrekf 30+457 - ̀ bkxrgb  _gxr& 0?! 488:% ``ea`dag `r>  mrrx>++zzz&wf&ktj+gs`+skobg+wfxcee+bkowigfrs+BTEX_[gf&xbc&

:5  _gg g&j&! M`t`absskf `fb _gefsskf & Eoga`fb! Okii& 0?83+4882! W&F& Bko& @+3?+28! Ska& EE! `r 73 -MTO 488:% -cefbefj ` eka`rekf kc @treoag 43 kc rmg Efrgtf`rekf`aOkgf`fr kf Oeea `fb Xkaereo`a Tejmrs%< `fb Awdeokf A`lg D`fb & O`f`b  ̀! W&F& Bko&OOXT+O+?=+B+03:+05=2 -I`tom 4=! 0558%&

=8 _gg g&j& _& N`igs @f`u`! Dkkl Tgegz kc  X  @WA L G@A  ! GWTKXG@F O KFPWG_R @FB RMG

T EJMR_ KC  E  FBEJGFKW_  X GKXAG_ >   R MG  I KT@A  D  @OLZ@TBFG__ KC E  FRGTF@REKF@A 

_ KOEGRU ! 55-0% @I&  N& EFR―A& A& ?83 -4887%&=0 _gg g&j&! B`ff & Wfergb _r`rgs! O`sg 00&028! Tgxktr Fk& 00?+80! Efrgt)@i& O&M&T&

-4880%! ``ea`dag `r> mrrx>++zzz&oebm&ktj+`ffw`atgx+4884gfj+ws`&00028&mri=4 Ef sxerg kc rmg aedgt`a rkfg kc @treoag 40 -tejmr rk xtkxgtru% kc rmg @igteo`f

Okfgfrekf! rmg E@OrMT m`s i`bg ` xtk mkiefgi efrgtxtgr`rekf kc rmes `treoag! tgokjfe~efj rm`r er `ask gidt`ogs efbejgfkws! okiiwf`a a`fb rgfwtg tgjeigs> ‑Rmg oaksg regs rmgigidgts kc efbejgfkws okiiwferegs m`g zerm rmget rt`berekf`a a`fbs `fb rmg f`rwt`atgskwtogs `sskoe`rgb zerm rmget owarwtg rmgtgkc! `s zgaa `s rmg efoktxktg`a gagigfrs bgteefj rmgtg ctki! iwsr dg sgowtgb wfbgt @treoag 40 kc rmg @igteo`f Okfgfrekf’! O`sg kc rmgEfbejgfkws Okiiwferu _`zmku`i`}`! Nwbjigfr kc I`tom 45! 4883 -Igters! Tgx`t`rekfs`fb Oksrs%! ³ 00=! ``ea`dag `r>  mrrx>++zzz&oktrgebm&kt&ot+bkos+o`sks+`treowaks+sgtego[023[efj&xbc& _gg `ask Rmki`s R& @flgtsgf # Rmki`s L& Twxxgtr! Bgcgfbefj rmg Xkaujkf> Rmg Gigtjefj Mwi`f Tejmr rk Okiiwf`a Xtkxgtru ! 75 KLA@& A& T GS & 2 -4883%&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 17/35

?2= Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr \Ska& ?> ??2

`tg tgpwetgb rk kcceoe`aau rerag `fb bgi`to`rg efbejgfkws `fogsrt`a a`fb! tgsrerwrga`fbs rk rmksg efbejgfkws xgkxags zmk zgtg besxkssgssgb! okfsgtg `fb xtkrgor

efbejgfkws xgkxags― tejmr rk gfetkfigfr! `ikfj krmgts&=2 

D& Cktgejf Betgor Efgsrigfr `fb xkrgfre`a `tg`s kc Kgta`x zerm Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Tejmrs 

Efrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr a`z m`s rmg xkrgfre`a rk kccsgr rmg j`efs `omeggb efmwi`f tejmrs ckt`&=7 Ef rmes tgj`tb! @ffg Bggdkesg Ksrdu okfrgfbs rm`r wfbgt `fefrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr tgjeig! efbejgfkws xgkxags― tejmrs m`g dgokig iktgrgfwkws&=3 Mgt `tjwigfr es rzk)ckab& Cetsr! efgsrkts― tejmrs wfbgt efgsrigfrrtg`regs i`u `ccgor efbejgfkws xgkxags rk ` jtg`rgt bgjtgg rm`f `fu krmgt iefkteru 

jtkwxs dgo`wsg rmg ‑dkwfb`tegs kc rmget skgtgejfru tgi`ef besxwrgb’&=: Ef aejmr kc rmes wfogtr`efru! Bggdkesg oa`eis! efgsrkts i`u tgcwsg rk tgokjfe~g efbejgfkwsxgkxags― tejmrs rk a`fb `fb f`rwt`a tgskwtogs& Ggf zktsg! f`rekf)sr`rgs rmgisgagsi`u tgcwsg rk tgokjfe~g efbejgfkws tejmrs rk `keb okfctkfr`rekfs zerm cktgejfefgsrkts ef efrgtf`rekf`a ckt` `fb `ask rk i`efr`ef ` ‑xtk)efgsrigfr’ oaei`rg&== 

_gokfb! okfsebgtefj rmget tejmr kc sgac)jkgtfigfr `fb xkaereo`a x`treoex`rekf!Bggdkesg `tjwgs rm`r efbejgfkws xgkxags smkwab dg `dag rk bgrgtiefg zmgf!

  zmgtg `fb mkz rmget a`fb es rk dg wsgb! ec wsgb `r `aa&=5 Efgsrigfr rtg`regs!fkfgrmgagss! m`g rmg xkrgfre`a ‑rk okfsrteor efbgxgfbgfr bgoesekfs i`bg du 

efbejgfkws xgkxags! aeierefj rmget `deaeru rk okfrtka rmg gccgor kc `f efgsrigfr zermef rmget a`fbs `fb okiiwferegs’&58 Efbggb! `fu `orekf rm`r efbejgfkws xgkxagsr`lg rk xtkrgor rmget owarwt`a `oreeru `fb sgowtg rmget a`fbs kt tgskwtogs i`u dgswdngor rk om`aagfjg dgcktg efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf `s ig`swtgs zmeomr`fr`ikwfr rk g}xtkxte`rekf&

Bggdkesg―s sgokfb `tjwigfr! mkzggt! smkwab dg rgixgtgb `s rmg tejmr rkokiiwf`a xtkxgtru es fkr `dskawrg< er o`f dg tgsrteorgb wfbgt ogtr`efoetowisr`fogs& @ooktbefj rk rmg E@OrMT! sr`rgs o`f jt`fr rmg tejmr rk g}xaker

=? _gg _& N`igs @f`u` # Tkdgtr @& Zeaae`is! Rmg Xtkrgorekf kc Efbejgfkws Xgkxags* Tejmrs kgt A`fbs `fb F`rwt`a Tgskwtogs Wfbgt rmg Efrgt)@igteo`f Mwi`f Tejmrs _usrgi ! 02  M @TS &  MWI& T  R_&  N& ?? -4880%< `fb Nk I& X`spw`awooe! Efrgtf`rekf`a Efbejgfkws A`fb Tejmrs> @ Oterepwg kc rmg 

 Nwtesxtwbgfog kc rmg Efrgt)@igteo`f Okwtr kc Mwi`f Tejmrs ef aejmr kc rmg Wfergb F`rekfs Bgoa`t`rekf kf rmg Tejmrs kc Efbejgfkws Xgkxags ! 4: Z E_& EFR*A A&N& 70 -4885%& 

=2 _gg eb& =7 _gg Ksrdu! swxt` fkrg 04&=3 _gg eb& =: Eb& == D`ttgt`)Mgtf`fbg~! swxt` fkrg :2&=5 _gg Ksrdu! swxt` fkrg 04&58 Eb& 

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 18/35

 C`aa! 4800Y  @ieows Owte`g # Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Trs& ef Ef& @td& ?25 f`rwt`a tgskwtogs zermef efbejgfkws a`fbs xtkebgb rm`r rmgsg gfreragigfrs ‑bk fkrbgfu rmget swte`a `s rted`a xgkxags’&50 _r`rgs smkwab rmws -e% tgsxgor xwdaeo

okfswar`rekf igom`fesis! -ee% sm`tg rmg dgfgcers kc rmg g}rt`oreg `oreeregs ef `‑tg`skf`dag z`u’! `fb -eee% okfbwor skoe`a `fb gfetkfigfr`a eix`or `ssgssigfrsg} `frg &54 Ugr! ckt a`tjg)so`ag kt ‑efgsrigfr xtkngors rm`r zkwab m`g ` i`nkteix`or’ kf rmg rgtterktu kc efbejgfkws xgkxags! rmg E@OrMT m`s sgr ` mejmgtrmtgsmkab> swom o`sgs tgpwetg rmg ctgg! xtekt! `fb efcktigb okfsgfr kc efbejgfkwsxgkxags&5? 

Dweabefj kf Bggdkesg―s rzk)ckab `f`auses! er es otereo`a rk tgokjfe~g rmg g}esrefj `tg`s kc xkrgfre`a kgta`x dgrzggf efbejgfkws xgkxags! f`rekf)sr`rgs! `fb cktgejfefgsrkts& Rmg fg}r sgorekf! xtkebgs g}`ixags ctki okix`t`reg a`z ef `f gccktr

rk wfgea skig `tg`s kc begtjgfog& Rmg sgagorgb o`sg a`zs bg`a zerm f`rwt`atgskwtogs! tgaejekf! `fb efrgaagorw`a xtkxgtru tejmrs&

0& Tejmr rk A`fbs! Rgtterktegs `fb Tgskwtogs

Ckt efbejgfkws xgkxags! rmg tejmr rk okfrtka kgt a`fb `fb tgskwtogs es otereo`ark rmget swte`a `s besrefor xgkxags&52 @treoag 43 kc rmg WFBTEX sr`rgs rm`refbejgfkws xgkxags m`g rmg tejmr rk kzf! wsg! bggakx! `fb okfrtka rmg a`fbs!rgtterktegs `fb tgskwtogs rm`r rmgu m`g rt`berekf`aau kzfgb! koowxegb kt krmgtzesgwsgb kt `opwetgb& Er `ask tgpwetgs sr`rgs rk jeg agj`a tgokjferekf `fb xtkrgorekf rk

rmgsg a`fbs! rgtterktegs! `fb tgskwtogs& Cwtrmgt! @treoag 47 kc rmg WFBTEXtgokjfe~gs efbejgfkws xgkxags― tejmr rk i`efr`ef `fb srtgfjrmgf rmget besreforegsxeterw`a tga`rekfsmex zerm rmget rt`berekf`aau kzfgb kt krmgtzesg koowxegb `fb wsgba`fbs! rgtterktegs! z`rgts `fb ok`sr`a sg`s `fb krmgt tgskwtogs&

 @ sgtegs kc o`sgs `bnwbeo`rgb du dkrm rmg E@OiMT `fb rmg E@OrMT! bg`a zermrmg jt`fr kc g}rt`orekf tejmrs rk xte`rg oktxkt`rekfs du f`rekf`a jkgtfigfrs ef`tg`s rt`berekf`aau koowxegb du efbejgfkws xgkxags& _kig kc rmgsg o`sgs `tgbesowssgb dgakz&

Okiwfeb`b I`u`jf` -_wik% @z`s Refjfe & Feo`t`jw` >57 Ef 0553! rmg Feo`t`jw`fjkgtfigfr jt`frgb ` akjjefj okfogssekf rk ` Lktg`f oktxkt`rekf& Rmg @z`s

50 O`sg kc rmg _`t`i`l` Xgkxag& & _wtef`ig! Efrgt)@igteo`f Okwtr kc Mwi`f Tejmrs-Xtgaeief`tu Kdngorekfs! Igters! Tgx`t`rekfs! `fb Oksrs%! Nwbjigfr kc Fk& 4=! 488:!x`t`jt`xms 043)0?4! ``ea`dag `r>  mrrx>++zzz&oktrgebm&kt&ot+bkos+o`sks+`treowaks+sgtego[0:4[efj&bko&

54 Eb& ³ 045&5? Eb& ³ 0?2&52 _gg Akteg I& Jt`m`i! Tgskaefj Efbejgfkws Oa`eis rk _gac)bgrgtief`rekf ! 08 EA_@  N& EFR―A

# OKIX& A& ?=7 -4882%&57  _gg  O`sg kc rmg I`u`jf` -_wik% @z`s Refjfe Okiiwferu& & Feo`t`jw`! Efrgt)

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 19/35

?78 Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr \Ska& ?> ??2

 Refjfe xgkxag! zmk efm`dergb rmg `tg` efkagb ef rmg okfogssekf! oa`eigb rm`r rmgjt`fr kc rmg akjjefj okfogssekf `fb rmg kfjkefj c`eawtg kc Feo`t`jw` rk bgi`to`rg

rmget rgtterktegs efctefjgb rmget tejmr rk xtkxgtru kgt rmget `fogsrt`a a`fbs& RmgE@OrMT s`forekfgb Feo`t`jw` ckt dtg`omefj rmg @z`s Rejfe―s tejmr rk xtkxgtru gfsmtefgb ef rmg @OMT! `fb ktbgtgb rmg sr`rg rk bgi`to`rg `fb rerag rmget `fogsrt`argtterktegs&

_`t`i`l` Xgkxag & _wtef`ig >53 Dgrzggf 055: `fb 4882! _wtef`ig esswgb akjjefj `fb iefefj okfogssekfs rk cktgejf okix`fegs zermef rgtterktu rt`berekf`aau kzfgbdu igidgts kc rmg _`t`i`l` okiiwferu& Rmg E@OrMT ckwfb rm`r _wtef`ig c`eagbrk xwr ef xa`og `bgpw`rg s`cgjw`tbs `fb igom`fesis rk gfswtg rm`r rmg akjjefj `fbiefefj okfogssekfs zkwab fkr o`wsg i`nkt b`i`jg rk _`t`i`l` rgtterktu `fb

okiiwferegs& Mgfog er twagb rm`r _wtef`ig m`b dtg`omgb rmg _`t`i`l` xgkxag―stejmr rk xtkxgtru&

 I`tu `fb O`tteg B`ff & Wfergb _r`rgs >5:  Ef rmes o`sg! igidgts kc rmg Zgsrgtf_mksmkfg `dktejef`a xgkxag! rmg B`ff! `aagjgb rm`r rmg W&_& jkgtfigfr―s jt`fr kc jkab iefefj xtksxgorefj zermef rmget rt`berekf`a a`fbs ef Fg`b`! `ccgorgb rmget wsgkc rmg a`fbs `fb xkaawrgb rmg z`rgt& Rmg E@OiMT okfoawbgb rm`r rmg W&_jkgtfigfr c`eagb rk gfswtg rmg B`ff―s tejmr rk xtkxgtru wfbgt okfberekfs kc gpw`aeru okfrt`tu rk rmg 052= @igteo`f Bgoa`t`rekf kc rmg Tejmrs `fb Bwregs kc I`f&

4& Tgaejekws `fb _xeterw`a Tejmrs

 @treoag 00 kc rmg WFBTEX tgokjfe~gs rm`r efbejgfkws xgkxags m`g rmg tejmrrk i`fecgsr! xt`oreog! bggakx `fb rg`om rmget sxeterw`a `fb tgaejekws rt`berekfs!owsrkis `fb ogtgikfegs! `fb rmg tejmr rk i`efr`ef! xtkrgor! `fb m`g `oogss efxte`ou rk rmget tgaejekws `fb owarwt`a sergs& Zmeag efbejgfkws tejmrs rk rmget`fogsrt`a a`fbs! rgtterktegs `fb tgskwtogs m`g ` sxeterw`a okixkfgfr! `s gebgfogb`dkg! rmes sgorekf bg`as zerm o`sgs zmgtg efbejgfkws jtkwxs m`g `rrgixrgb rkm`ar igj`xtkngors wfbgtr`lgf du rmg W&_& jkgtfigfr kf rmg jtkwfbs rm`r rmgu 

 zkwab bgsrtku s`otgb sergs `fb tgsrteor rmget tejmr rk ctggbki kc tgaejekf&5= _kig kc rmg o`sgs zmgtg swom om`aagfjgs m`g dggf i`bg! `adger wfswoogsscwaau! `tgbesowssgb dgakz&

  @igteo`f Okwtr kc Mwi`f Tejmrs! Nwbjigfr kc @wj& ?0! 4880! ³ 025! ``ea`dag `r >mrrx>++zzz&oktrgebm&kt&ot+bkos+o`sks+`treowaks+sgtego[:5[efj&bko&

53 _gg swxt` fkrg 50&5: _gg swxt` fkrg =0&5= _gg g&j& Jgktjg Aefjg! Gfswtefj rmg Cwaa Ctggbki kc Tgaejekf kf Xwdaeo A`fbs> Bgeas Rkzgt 

`fb rmg Xtkrgorekf kc Efbe`f _`otgb _ergs ! ``ea`dag `r>  mrrx>++zzz&do&gbw+do[ktj+`x+a`z+azsom+nkwtf`as+dog`at+4:[4+82[R]R&mri -a`sr esergb Bgo& 4! 4808% -mgtgef`crgt Aefjg%&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 20/35

 C`aa! 4800Y  @ieows Owte`g # Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Trs& ef Ef& @td& ?70 _gpwku`m & Rgffgssgg S`aagu @wrmkteru >55  Ef rmes o`sg! rmg Omgtklgg xgkxag

`ssgtrgb rm`r rmg cakkbefj kc rmg Aerrag Rgffgssgg Tegt S`aagu du rmg Rgaaeok B`i

xtkngor zkwab bgfu rmgi `oogss rk s`otgb sergs efbesxgfs`dag rk g}gtoesg rmgettgaejekf& Rmg okwtr besiessgb rmg oa`ei kf rmg jtkwfbs rm`r rmg s`otgb sergs rk dgcakkbgb zgtg fkr ogfrt`a rk rmg Omgtklgg tgaejekf! `fb rmgtgcktg rmgtg z`s fk Cetsr

 @igfbigfr eka`rekf&088 

Efwxe`r Okiiwferu & Wfergb _r`rgs >080  Rmg okwtr okfsebgtgb Efwxe`r kxxkserekf rkkea bggakxigfr ef a`tjg xktrekfs kc rmg Dg`wcktr `fb Omwlome sg`s ef @a`sl` kfrmg jtkwfbs rm`r er zkwab bestwxr rmget mwfrefj `fb j`rmgtefj aecgsruag! zmeom rmgu oa`eigb z`s efg}rteo`dag ctki rmget tgaejekws dgaegcs& Rmg okwtr tgngorgb rmget oa`eidgo`wsg rmg Efwxe`rs kccgtgb fk g}xa`f`rekf kc germgt rmg tgaejekws sejfeceo`fog kc 

rmg mwfrefj jtkwfbs kt mkz rmg xtkxksgb bggakxigfr zkwab efrgtcgtg zerm rmgctgg g}gtoesg kc rmget tgaejekf& Er `ask ckwfb rm`r rmg jkgtfigfr m`b ` okixgaaefj efrgtgsr ef bggakxefj kea g}xakt`rekf&084 

Zeaskf & Dakol>08?   Rmg Mkxe `fb F``nk xgkxag kxxksgb ` sr`rg bgoesekf rkxgtier rmg g}x`fsekf kc rmg _fkz Dkza sle `tg` ef rmg _`f Ct`foesok Xg`ls `tg` kc 

 @te~kf`& Rmg Mkxe `fb F``nk xgkxag `ssgtrgb rm`r rmg xg`ls zgtg s`otgb a`fb!dwr rmg okwtr twagb rm`r rmg g}x`fsekf kc rmg sle `tg` beb fkr dwtbgf rmg Tgb)Efbe`fs― tgaejekf du bgfuefj rmgi `oogss rk rmg s`otgb sergs kt eix`etefj rmget`deaeru rk okfbwor ogtgikfegs&082 

M``swx`e Rtedg & Wfergb _r`rgs >087    Rmg M``swx`e Rtedg om`aagfjgb sr`rg`wrmkte~`rekf kc ` iefefj kxgt`rekf kf jtkwfbs rm`r rmg iefg zkwab bgfu rmgi`oogss rk s`otgb sergs `fb bgsrtku rmg gtu gssgfog kc rmget tgaejekws `fb owarwt`asusrgi& Ef rmes o`sg! rmg okwtr besiessgb rmg oa`eis! `tjwefj rm`r ‑jeefj rmgEfbe`fs ` grk xkzgt kgt `oreeregs kf cgbgt`a a`fb zkwab g`seau tgpwetg bg c`orkdgfgceoe`a kzfgtsmex kc skig t`rmgt sx`oekws rt`ors kc xwdaeo xtkxgtru’&083 

?& Efrgaagorw`a Xtkxgtru Tejmrs

 @treoag ?0 kc rmg WFBTEX gsr`daesmgs rm`r efbejgfkws xgkxags m`g rmg tejmrrk i`efr`ef! okfrtka! xtkrgor `fb bggakx rmget rt`berekf`a owarwt`a g}xtgssekfs! `s

55 _gg _gpwku`m & Rgffgssgg S`aagu @wrm&! 348 C&4b 0075 -3rm Oet& 05=8%&088 _gg Aefjg! swxt` fkrg 5=&080 _gg Efwxe`r Okiiwferu kc rmg @toreo _akxg & Wfergb _r`rgs! 72= C& _wxx& 0=4 -B&

 @a`& 05=4%&084 _gg Aefjg! swxt` fkrg 5=&08? _gg  Zeaskf & Dakol! :8= C&4b :?7 -B&O& Oet& 05=?%&082 _gg Aefjg! swxt` fkrg 5=&087 _gg M``swx`e Rtedg & Tkdgtrskf! 52? C&4b ?4 -5rm Oet& 0550%&083 Eb&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 21/35

?74 Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr \Ska& ?> ??2

  zgaa `s rmg i`fecgsr`rekfs kc rmget soegfogs! rgomfkakjegs `fb owarwtgs! efoawbefj bgsejfs! `fb rmg efrgaagorw`a xtkxgtru kgt swom g}xtgssekfs& Ef rmes aefg! @treoag =-n%

kc rmg WF Okfgfrekf kf Dekakjeo`a Begtseru kdaejgs sr`rg x`tregs rk xtkikrg rmg  zebgt wsg kc efbejgfkws lfkzagbjg `fb xt`oreogs zerm rmg `xxtk`a `fbefkagigfr kc rmg mkabgts kc rm`r lfkzagbjg&08: Ef @wsrt`ae`! agj`a `orekfs! `ssmkzf ef rmg o`sg dgakz! m`g dggf skwjmr rk srkx rmg okiigtoe`a g}xaker`rekf kc efbejgfkws bgsejfs wsgb zermkwr rmget g}xtgss okfsgfr&

  Ieaxwttwttw s& Ebkcwtf Xru Arb&>08=  Ef 0550! It& Dgrmwfg! `f @wsrt`ae`fgfrtgxtgfgwt! xtkbwogb m`fb)lfkrrgb! zkka o`txgrs zmeom tgxtkbwogb @wsrt`ae`f`dktejef`a bgsejfs&085 Rmg bgsejfs sgagorgb zgtg skig kc rmg iksr s`otgb `dktejef`aei`jgs! sk iwom sk rm`r kfau cwaau rt`efgb `fb `xxtkgb `tresrs zgtg xgtierrgb du 

rmg oa`f rk tgxtkbwog rmgi! `fb kwrsebgts zgtg fkr `aakzgb rk g}gowrg rmgi&Okfsebgtefj rmget s`otgb om`t`orgt! kfau ogtr`ef igidgts kc rmg oa`f okwab egz rmg bgsejfs bwtefj ogtr`ef ogtgikfegs& Rmg `tresrs zmksg x`efrefjs zgtg okxegbswgb Dgrmwfg―s okix`fu ef `f @wsrt`ae`f cgbgt`a okwtr ckt okxutejmr efctefjgigfr&

  Rmg okwtr `jtggb zerm rmg xa`efreccs< `fb rmg o`sg dgo`ig rmg cetsr ef zmeom `f  @wsrt`ae`f okwtr bgoa`tgb rm`r `dktejef`a `tresrs smkwab dg okixgfs`rgb ckt rmgwf`wrmkte~gb wsg kc rmget `tr&008 

2& _wii`tu  

  Rmg o`sgs xtgsgfrgb `dkg `tg dwr ` si`aa s`ixag kc rmg iwarexaeoeru kc okfrtkgtsegs xgtr`efefj rk efbejgfkws esswgs rm`r m`g dggf `bnwbeo`rgbbkigsreo`aau `fb efrgtf`rekf`aau& Rmg ktejef kc rmg okfcaeor rgfbs rk dg rmg jt`fr du rmg jkgtfigfr kc `f gfreragigfr rk okfbwor `f g}rt`oreg `oreeru kt ` xtkngor

  zermkwr tgj`tb kc rmg xtg)g}esrefj tejmrs kc efbejgfkws xgkxags& Jegf rm`r rmgdkwfb`tegs kc rmget a`fbs kt rmg sokxg kc rmget tejmrs tgi`ef wfbgcefgb zermeff`rekf`a dktbgts! rmgu `tg xkrgfre`aau swdngor rk fgjagor dkrm ctki cktgejf efgsrkts-zmk i`u r`lg rmget a`fbs `fb tgskwtogs xwtsw`fr rk rmg gfreragigfr esswgb du rmgjkgtfigfr%!000 kt ctki jkgtfigfrs -zmk m`g efogfregs rk bestgj`tb

08: Okfgfrekf kf Dekakjeo`a Begtseru - ̀ bkxrgb  Nwfg 7! 0554% ``ea`dag `r>  mrrx>++zzz&odb&efr+bko+agj`a+odb)gf&xbc&

08= _gg Omtesrefg M`ejmr C`tagu! Xtkrgorefj Ckalaktg kc Efbejgfkws Xgkxags> Es Efrgaagorw`a Xtkxgtru rmg @fszgt; ! ?8 OKFF& A& T GS & 0 -055:%&

085 Eb&008 Oergb ef eb& 000  _gg  D`ttgt`)Mgtf`fbg~!  swxt`  fkrg :2 -‑_kig okix`fegs i`u dg m`xxu rk r`lg

`b`fr`jg kc rmg iwtlefgss rm`r swttkwfbs efbejgfkws xtkxgtru tejmrs `fb r`lg `  c`er `ookixae `xxtk`om rk skoe`aau sgfsereg xtkngors du bkefj cetsr `fb fgjkre`refj a`rgt& Mkzggt!ec g}xgtegfog ef fgejmdktefj okwfrtegs es `fu efbeo`rekf! ef rmg akfj rgti! rmg kbbs `tg`j`efsr rmgi& @atg`bu! efotg`sefj aggas kc okfcaeor `fb efsgowteru `tg ` xkzgtcwa tgiefbgtrm`r bggakxigfr o`ffkr dg swsr`efgb ec efbejgfkws a`fb esswgs `tg tkwrefgau ejfktgb’%&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 22/35

 C`aa! 4800Y  @ieows Owte`g # Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Trs& ef Ef& @td& ?7? efbejgfkws xgkxags― efrgtgsrs cg`tefj `f efrgtf`rekf`a oa`ei `fb i`efr`ef ` xtk)efgsrigfr oaei`rg%&

Cwtrmgtiktg! rmg okfcaeor es g}`ogtd`rgb zmgf cktgejf efgsrkts tgsktr rkefrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr `tdert`rekf sgglefj okixgfs`rekf ckt ` sxgoeceo”ig`swtg―004 kt kiessekf du rmg jkgtfigfr rm`r okfsrerwrgs ` ztkfjcwaefrgtcgtgfog zerm rmg efgsrigfr& Rk wfx`ol rmes ebg`! agr ws `sswig rm`r rmgsgefsr`fogs efkagb cktgejf efgsrigfrs xtkrgorgb du ` DER okfoawbgb dgrzggf rzkokwfrtegs& Xwtsw`fr rk rmg sxgoe`a `sswt`fogs efoawbgb ef rmg DER! rmg cktgejfefgsrkt o`f tgako`rg besxwrgs `fb rmget sgrragigfr ctki rmg bkigsreo nwtesbeorekfkc rmg mksr sr`rg rk efrgtf`rekf`a `tdert`rekf& Ef krmgt zktbs! m`b rmg Lktg`fakjjefj okix`fu dggf okfsebgtgb `f ‑efgsrigfr’ wfbgt ` muxkrmgreo`a Lktg`)

Feo`t`jw` DER ef rmg   @z`s Rejfe o`sg< m`b Dgae~g jt`frgb kea okfogssekfs rk `okix`fu xtkrgorgb du ` muxkrmgreo`a Dgae~g)Wfergb _r`rgs DER ef rmg _`t`i`l`  o`sg< m`b rmg Rgaaeok B`i okfsrtworekf dggf jt`frgb rk ` O`f`be`f okix`fu wfbgt rmg F@CR@ ef rmg _gpwku`m  o`sg< kt m`b It& Dgrmwfg―s okix`fu dggfokfsebgtgb `f efgsrigfr wfbgt ` muxkrmgreo`a @wsrt`ae`)Wfergb _r`rgs DER ef rmg Ieaxwttwttw o`sg! rmgsg besxwrgs okwab m`g dggf dtkwjmr du ` cktgejf efgsrkt rkefrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr `tdert`rekf rtedwf`as `j`efsr rmg sr`rg x`tru rk rmg DER kfjtkwfbs kc efbetgor g}xtkxte`rekf kt efgpwer`dag rtg`rigfr& Ef swom oetowisr`fogs!rmg `z`tbs! ec rmgu zgtg ef rmg c`kwt kc rmg efgsrkt! okwab m`g sgtekwstgxgtowssekfs kf efbejgfkws xgkxags― tejmrs rk a`fb! tgaejekf! `fb efrgaagorw`a

xtkxgtru `s tgokjfe~gb ef rmg WFBTEX `fb krmgt efrgtf`rekf`a efsrtwigfrs&

Ef swi! rmgsg efsr`fogs gebgfog rm`r efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf es ` xkrgfre`abgoesekf)i`lgt ef i`rrgts okfogtfefj rmg tga`rekfsmex dgrzggf efbejgfkws xgkxags`fb rmg f`rekf)sr`rg& Ja`ies Jkab xtgoesgau bgikfsrt`rgs rm`r efbejgfkws tejmrs `tgskigreigs `r sr`lg ef `f efrgtf`rekf`a `tdert`rekf xtkogbwtg< `s zeaa dg wfx`olgb efX`tr ES& Rmg pwgsrekf rm`r ckaakzs es zmgrmgt efbejgfkws xgkxags smkwab dggfreragb rk r`lg x`tr ef rmg `tdert`rekf kc swom oa`eis `fb! ec sk! rk zm`r g}rgfr&

Fg}r! rmes `treoag dtegcau besowssgs zmgrmgt efbejgfkws xgkxags― agj`a sr`rws ef

efrgtf`rekf`a a`z jt`frs rmgi rm`r xteeagjg&

O& Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― _r`rws ef Efrgtf`rekf`a A`z 

Bwtefj rmg cetsr gfokwfrgts dgrzggf efbejgfkws xgkxags `fb krmgt oeeae~`rekfsef rmg cecrggfrm ogfrwtu! rmgtg z`s ` rtgfb rk rtg`r efbejgfkws xgkxags `s skgtgejfgfreregs o`x`dag kc okfoawbefj rtg`regs&00? @ooktbefj rk I`tl Ct`fl Aefbagu! ‑rmgtg

004 @treoag 480-0% kc F@CR@ bgcefgs ”ig`swtg― rk efoawbg `fu a`z! tgjwa`rekf!xtkogbwtg! tgpwetgigfr kt xt`oreog&

00? _gg @FF@ IGENLFGOMR!  RKZ@TB_ EFRGTF@REKF@A XGT_KF@AERU >  RMG XK_EREKF

KC IEFKTEREG_ @FB EFBEJGFKW_ XGKXAG_ EF EFRGTF@REKF@A A @Z 0 -Efrgtsgfre` 4880%

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 23/35

?72 Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr \Ska& ?> ??2

es `dwfb`fr gebgfog rk smkz rm`r `b`fogb Jkgtfigfrs \bebY tgokjfe~gskgtgejf tejmrs ef agss `b`fogb xgkxags zerm zmki rmgu o\`Yig ef okfr`or! `fb

\bebY! ef jgfgt`a! bg`a zerm swom xgkxags kf ` rtg`ru d`ses zmgf `opwetefj rmgetrgtterktu’&002 Rmg Gwtkxg`f xkzgts `fb rmg g`tau W&_ jkgtfigfrs ktejef`aau bg`ar

 zerm efbejgfkws xgkxags rmtkwjm rmg rtg`ru xtkogss&007 Ef `ffg}efj Fgz ^g`a`fb!rmg Dteresm Jkgtfigfr j`g cwaa gccgor rk rmg skgtgejfru kc rmg f`reg omegcs `fbrtedgs&003 Du rmg s`ig rklgf! ef rmg W&_&! skagif rtg`regs -iksrau kc ctegfbsmex!rt`bg! `fb a`fb sgrragigfr% zgtg okfoawbgb zerm efbejgfkws xgkxags `fb zgtgt`recegb du rmg W&_& _gf`rg `ooktbefj rk rmg okfsrerwrekf`a xtkogbwtg&00: Mkzggt!rmg agj`a cktog kc rmgsg rtg`regs es okfrgsrgb rk b`rg&00= 

Fkfgrmgagss! ‑bwg rk ` xtkogss kc bkigsreo`rekf kc efbejgfkws xgkxags esswgs!

ef zmeom tga`rekfs kc sr`rgs zerm efbejgfkws xgkxags zgtg xgtogegb `s i`rrgts kc xwtgau efrgtf`a nwtesbeorekf! efbejgfkws xgkxags & & & jt`bw`aau aksr rmg agj`a sr`rwsrmgu ktejef`aau xkssgssgb ef efrgtf`rekf`a a`z’&005 Rmes xtkogss eixaegb rmg jt`bw`art`fscgt kc rmg tga`rekfs zerm efbejgfkws xgkxags ctki efrgtf`rekf`a rk iwfeoex`aa`z! `fb z`s nwsrecegb du rmg `aagjgb a`ol kc oeeae~`rekf kc efbejgfkws xgkxags&048 Ctki rmgf kf! efbejgfkws xgkxags zgtg okfsebgtgb rk m`g fk efrgtf`rekf`a agj`asr`rws&

Efsr`fogs kc swom rt`fsckti`rekf ef efrgtf`rekf`a a`z `tg rmg 0543 O`uwj` Efbe`fs  `z`tb -twaefj rm`r `f Efbe`f rtedg ‑es fkr ` agj`a wfer kc efrgtf`rekf`a

a`z’%040! `fb rmg 054= `z`tb ef rmg Esa`fb kc X`ai`s O`sg  -mkabefj rm`r rtg`regsgfrgtgb efrk du rmg esa`fb―s efbejgfkws `wrmkteregs `fb rmg Bwrom G`sr Efbe`Okix`fu zgtg fkr rtg`regs kt okfgfrekfs o`x`dag kc otg`refj tejmrs `fbkdaej`rekfs swom `s i`u `tesg kwr kc rtg`regs%&044 _wom ` rtgfb ef bkigsreo a`z es

-mgtgef`crgt IGENLFGOMR %&002 I @TL  CT@FL  AEFBAGU !  RMG  @OPWE_EREKF @FB JKSGTFIGFR KC D @OLZ@TB

 RGTTERKTU EF EFRGTF@REKF@A A @Z 23 -Akfji`fs! Jtggf # Ok& 0543%&007 _gg K―Dtegf! swxt` fkrg :4! `r 2?&003 _gg eb&! `r 20)2?&00: _gg Zegssfgt! swxt` fkrg 37&00= _gg I`olagi swxt` fkrg :? -‑Rmgsg rtg`regs beb fkr xkssgss efrgtf`rekf`a agj`a cktog&

Efrgtf`rekf`a a`z srexwa`rgs rm`r kfau `f `jtggigfr dgrzggf ”rzk efbgxgfbgfr xkzgts―okfsrerwrgs ` rtg`ru defbefj kf rmg x`tregs rk ers rgtis & & & Tgj`tbagss kc zmgrmgt eixgte`axkzgts m`b gfrgtgb efrk rtg`regs zerm efbejgfkws xkxwa`rekfs! efrgtf`rekf`a a`z dgj`f rk

 `aeb`rg eixgte`a oa`eis kc skgtgejf xkzgt kgt efbejgfkws xgkxags `fb rgtterktegs kf rmgd`ses rm`r efbejgfkws xgkxags zgtg efswcceoegfrau oeeae~gb rk igter agj`a tgokjferekf `sskgtgejf agj`a `orkts’%& Du okfrt`sr! @treoag ?: kc rmg WFBTEX tgpwetgs sr`rgs rk mkfkwt`fb tgsxgor swom rtg`regs&

005 IGENLFGOMR! swxt` fkrg 00?! `r 0:&048 _gg  eb& 040 _gg Zegssfgt! swxt` fkrg 37&044 _gg  eb& 

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 24/35

 C`aa! 4800Y  @ieows Owte`g # Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Trs& ef Ef& @td& ?77 gebgfr ef rmg bgoesekfs kc rmg _wxtgig Okwtr kc rmg Wfergb _r`rgs bgrgtiefefj rm`r Efbe`f f`rekfs `tg ‑bkigsreo bgxgfb`fr f`rekfs’ `fb rm`r Efbe`fs `tg ‑igtg

koowx`frs zmk `tg efo`x`dag kc jeefj kt jt`frefj a`fb’&04? 

Esswgs kf efbejgfkws xgkxags m`g! mkzggt! tg)gigtjgb `s pwgsrekfs kc okfrgixkt`tu efrgtf`rekf`a a`z `fb xkaeou&042 Owttgfr bggakxigfrs gebgfog rm`r‑efbejgfkws xgkxags `tg j`efefj tgokjferekf kc rmget agj`a xgtskf`aeru `s besreforskoegregs zerm sxgoe`a okaagoreg tejmrs `fb ` besrefor tkag ef f`rekf`a `fbefrgtf`rekf`a bgoesekf)i`lefj’&047 @s Twssga A`ztgfog D`tsm xwrs er! ‑ef rmg x`srbgo`bgs! rmg agj`a sr`rws kc efbejgfkws xgkxags m`s dggf om`fjefj efotgigfr`aau’&043 @ff` Igenlfgomr okfrgfbs rm`r iksr efbejgfkws xgkxags m`gkdr`efgb g}rgtf`a xkaereo`a `oogxr`fog kt tgokjferekf kc rmget tgxtgsgfr`regs&04: 

 Rmgu `tg fkz gfj`jgb ef efrgtf`rekf`a cktwis aelg rmg Wfergb F`rekfs! zmgtg rmgu besowss rmg sokxg `fb f`rwtg kc rmget tejmrs& Du rmg s`ig rklgf! Igenlfgomr xkefrskwr rm`r efrgtf`rekf`a efsrtwigfrs aelg rmg WFBTEX tgokjfe~g fkf)sr`rg gfreregs `srmg dg`tgts kc tejmrs `fb bwregs! smkzefj rm`r efbejgfkws xgkxags `tg fkz tg)gigtjefj `s ”swdngors kc efrgtf`rekf`a a`z―&04= _kig oa`ei rm`r rmg WFBTEX m`stgefcktogb efbejgfkws xgkxags sr`rws ef efrgtf`rekf`a a`z!045 `s rmgu `tg fk akfjgt‑seixau kdngors kc efrgtf`rekf`a okfogtf dwr m`g ` tgokjfe~gb sr`rws `fb o`x`oeru ef rmg efrgtf`rekf`a okfrg}r’&0?8 

  Ugr! zmgrmgt efbejgfkws xgkxags m`g j`efgb `f ‑efrgtf`rekf`a agj`a

xgtskf`aeru’0?0 es ` beccgtgfr pwgsrekf `arkjgrmgt&0?4 @armkwjm `f `cceti`reg `fszgt

04?  _gg g&j&! Nkmfskf & I―Efrksm! 40 W&_& -= Zmg`r&% 72? -0=4?%< `fb Nkukrx`waOm`wbmwte! @igteo`f Efbe`f Xkaeou ! ef  Bgakte`! Nt&! gb&! swxt` fkrg :4! `r 42&

042  _gg  Bkwja`s _`fbgts! Rmg Tg)gigtjgfog kc Efbejgfkws Pwgsrekfs ef Efrgtf`rekf`a A`z !  ef  EFRGTF@REKF@A A @Z @FB EFBEJGFKW_ XGKXAG_ -_& N`igs @f`u` gb&!  @smj`rg 488?%&

047 Twssgaa A`ztgfog D`tsm! Efbejgfkws Xgkxags ef rmg 0558s> ctki Kdngor rk _wdngor kc Efrgtf`rekf`a A`z; ! : M @TS & MWI& T  R_&  N& ?? -0552% -mgtgef`crgt D`tsm‟  ctki Kdngor rk _wdngor  %&_gg `ask! D`tsm! swxt` fkrg 35! `r =20&

043 _gg eb&! D`tsm‟  ctki Kdngor rk _wdngor ! `r 00=&04: _gg IGENLFGOMR! swxt` fkrg 00?! `r 4?0&04= _gg eb& 045 _gg g&j& I`olagi! swxt` fkrg :?< `fb Tkigk _`j`f`sm # X`wa Nkccg! Rmg _ejfeceo`fog

kc rmg WF Bgoa`t`rekf rk ` Rtg`ru F`rekf> @ N`igs D`u Otgg Xgtsxgoreg! ef  T G@AE^EFJ

 RMG WF BGOA@T@REKF KF RMG T EJMR_ KC EFBEJGFKW_ XGKXAG_>  RTEWIXM! MKXG! @FB

 @OREKF -N`oleg M`tragu! X`wa Nkccg! # Ngffecgt Xtgsrkf gbs&! Xwteom Xwd& 4808% -mgtgef`crgtM`tragu! Nkccg # Xtgsrkf gbs&%&

0?8 M`tragu! Nkccg! # Xtgsrkf gbs&! eb &! `r 028&0?0 Rmg okfogxr kc efrgtf`rekf`a agj`a xgtskf`aeru es fkr bgkeb kc okfrtkgtsu `fb

okfcwsekf& Xgtskf`aeru okigs ctki rmg A`ref zktb  xgtskf`  zmeom ig`fs ‑i`sl’! `f`rrtedwrg wsgb rk tgxtgsgfr `fb `ask rk g}oawbg ctki tgxtgsgfr`rekf& @s N`ffg Gaes`dgrmFeni`f bgsotedgs! ‑ef efrgtf`rekf`a a`z! xgtskf` m`s dgokig rmg okfogxr zmeom m`fbags rmgpwgsrekf kc zmk es `f `orkt kf rmg efrgtf`rekf`a sr`jg! kt> zmk es `aakzgb rk x`treoex`rg ef

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 25/35

?73 Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr \Ska& ?> ??2

  zkwab mgax rmg xwtxksg kc rmes `treoag! rm`r es rk s`u! rk tgokjfe~g rmget dtk`bgtx`treoex`rekf tejmrs dgcktg efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf! er bkgs fkr xtkebg ` bgcefereg

skawrekf& Efbggb! ggf ec zg `jtgg rm`r efbejgfkws xgkxags xkssgss efrgtf`rekf`aagj`a xgtskf`aeru! `fb rmws efrgtf`rekf`a nws sr`fbe -rmg tejmr rk dtefj ` oa`ei `r rmgefrgtf`rekf`a agga%! rmes zkwab fkr jt`fr rmgi rmg tejmr rk x`treoex`rg ef `f`tdert`rekf xtkoggbefj efere`rgb wfbgt rmg `wsxeogs kc ` x`treowa`t efgsrigfr rtg`ru rm`r efkags kfau ` ogtr`ef jtkwx kc sr`rgs& Ef rmg s`ig z`u rm`r krmgt swdngors kc efrgtf`rekf`a a`z aelg sr`rgs kt efrgtf`rekf`a ktj`fe~`rekfs o`ffkr `oogss rtedwf`as ef

 zmeom rmgu m`g fk agj`a sr`fbefj! efbejgfkws xgkxags o`ffkr `oogss efgsrkt)sr`rg`tdert`rekf skagau kf rmg jtkwfbs kc rmget `aagjgb efrgtf`rekf`a xgtskfmkkb&

 Rmgtgcktg! m`efj beso`tbgb rmg efrgtf`rekf`a agj`a xgtskf`aeru `tjwigfr! zg fggb

efrgtf`rekf`a a`z `fb skoegru! `fb zmk es fkr& & & & Rmg mesrktu kc rmg okfogxr kc efrgtf`rekf`a agj`a xgtskf`aeru es `ask rmg mesrktu kc rmg `rrgixrs rk sotwrefe~g `fb efrgtxtgrrmg i`sl’& Rt`berekf`aau! sr`rgs m`g dggf okfsebgtgb rk m`g rm`r efrgtf`rekf`a i`sl& Dwref rmg rzgfregrm ogfrwtu sr`rgs xgtierrgb rmg bggakxigfr kc fgz twags ef efrgtf`rekf`a a`z rm`r okfcgttgb tejmrs `fb kdaej`rekfs kf gfreregs krmgt rm`f rmgisgags! swom `sefrgtf`rekf`a ktj`fe~`rekfs! swd)f`rekf`a jtkwxs `fb efbeebw`as& _gg  IGENLFGOMR! swxt`  fkrg 00?! `fb N @FFG GAE_@DGRM FENI@F!  RMG OKFOGXR KC EFRGTF@REKF@A AGJ@A

XGT_KF@AERU >  @F EFPWETU EFRK RMG ME_RKTU @FB RMGKTU KC EFRGTF@REKF@A A @Z   ee)eee -RIO @ssgt Xtgss 4882%& _gg `ask @FRKFEK O @FÊ@BK)RTEFB@BG! EFRGTF@REKF@A

A  @Z CKT MWI@F L EFB!  RKZ@TB_ @ FGZ  NW_ JGFREWI 037 -Rmg M`jwg @o`bgiu kc Efrgtf`rekf`a A`z 4808% -‑Ef tgogfr bgo`bgs rmgtg m`s dggf `f g}x`fsekf kc efrgtf`rekf`aagj`a xgtskf`aeru \rk fkf)sr`rg `orktsY’%< B @SEB T  @Eā! _ R@RGMKKB @FB RMG A @Z KC _GAC)BGRGTIEF@REKF 08 -Lawzgt Efrgtf`rekf`a A`z 4884%< `fb NKMF M&  OWTTG! XWDAEO

EFRGTF@REKF@A A @Z 73 -Etzef A`z Efo&! 4b gb& 488=%&0?4 _gg IGENLFGOMR! swxt` fkrg00?! `r 4?4 -oa`eiefj rm`r rmg okfogxr kc ‑efrgtf`rekf`a

xgtskf`aeru’! `s cktiwa`rgb du rmg Efrgtf`rekf`a Okwtr kc Nwsreog -EON% ef rmg Tgx`t`rekf ckt Efnwtegs _wccgtgb ef rmg _gteog kc rmg Wfergb F`rekfs  o`sg! okfsesrs kc rmtgg gagigfrs> -e%efrgtf`rekf`a agj`a o`x`oeru! -ee% efrgtf`rekf`a agj`a swdngoreeru! `fb -eee% efrgtf`rekf`a nwssr`fbe& Igenlfgomr `tjwgs rm`r efbejgfkws xgkxags a`ol rmg rmetb gagigfr! efrgtf`rekf`a nwssr`fbe& _mg wfbgtsoktgs rmg c`or rm`r i`fu g}esrefj nwbeoe`a `fb sgie)nwbeoe`a efrgtf`rekf`axtkogbwtgs bg`a zerm betgor efbeebw`a okixa`efrs `fb jeg efbeebw`a r`eakt)i`bg bgoesekfs!swom `s rmg Mwi`f Tejmrs Okiierrgg kt rmg tgjekf`a mwi`f tejmrs okwtrs& Fkfgrmgagss!smg okfrgfbs rm`r ef rmgsg xtkogbwtgs rmg xgkxags `tg ‑o`xrwtgb’ ef `f efrgtf`rekf`a nwssr`fbe zmeom es d`sgb kf rmg efbeebw`a `xxtk`om& Mgfog! efbejgfkws xgkxags bk fkr m`gefrgtf`rekf`a nws sr`fbe `s ` okaagoreg dkbu! dwr m`g rk `et rmget oa`eis wsefj igom`fesisjt`frgb rk efbeebw`as& @s ` tgswar! Igenlfgomr okfoawbgs rm`r rmg i`ef kdsr`oag kfefbejgfkws xgkxags― tk`b rk efrgtf`rekf`a agj`a xgtskf`aeru aegs `r rmg agga kc efrgtf`rekf`anws sr`fbe& _k! fkrzermsr`fbefj ogtr`ef j`efs ef rmg efrgtf`rekf`a bki`ef! efbejgfkwsxgkxags bk fkr m`g rmg o`x`oeru rk dtefj rmget oa`eis rk efrgtf`rekf`a ckt`! rmkwjm rmgpwgsrekf zmgrmgt rmgu zeaa `r skig xkefr ef rmg cwrwtg es kxgf& Ef okfsgpwgfog! ggfrmkwjm efbejgfkws xgkxags `tg swdngors kc efrgtf`rekf`a a`z! `s rmgu `tg dg`tgts kc efrgtf`rekf`a tejmrs `fb bwregs wfbgt efrgtf`rekf`a a`z! rk b`rg rmgu sreaa a`ol efrgtf`rekf`aagj`a tgigbegs rk gfcktog swom tejmrs%&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 26/35

 C`aa! 4800Y  @ieows Owte`g # Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Trs& ef Ef& @td& ?7: rk g}`iefg krmgt tg`skfs rm`r nwsrecu efbejgfkws xgkxags― dtk`bgt x`treoex`rekftejmrs ef efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf&

ES& T GOKJFE^EFJ DTK@BGT X @TREOEX@REKF T EJMR_ RK EFBEJGFKW_

JTKWX_ 

 @& Ja`ies Jkab! Arb& & Wfergb _r r̀gs 0?? 

Ja`ies Eixgte`a! ` zmkaau kzfgb swdsebe`tu kc rmg O`f`be`f okix`fu Ja`iesJkab! Arb&! `opwetgb `fb g}xaktgb sggt`a iefefj oa`eis ako`rgb kf cgbgt`a a`fbs efrmg O`aecktfe` Bgsgtr! ef `f `tg` lfkzf `s Efbe`f X`ss&0?2 Ja`ies― xtkxksgb jkabkxgf)xer iefg! rmg Eixgte`a Xtkngor! `freoex`rgb rmg xtkbworekf kc 0&0: ieaaekfkwfogs kc jkab! zmeom tgpwetgb rmg g}o``rekf 078 ieaaekf rkfs kc ktg `fb rmgxtkbworekf kc ?88 ieaaekf rkfs kc z`srg tkol& Dwr! `s rmg okix`fu a`rgtbesokgtgb! ers iefefj oa`eis zgtg ako`rgb fg}r rk bgsejf`rgb F`reg @igteo`fa`fbs `fb `tg`s kc owarwt`a `fb tgaejekws okfogtf&

  Rk xtkrgor rmg gfetkfigfr `fb F`reg @igteo`f owarwt`a sergs! O`aecktfe`_r`rg Iefefj `fb Jgkakju Dk`tb x`ssgb ` sgtegs kc tgjwa`rekfs rm`r tgpwetgbokixagrg d`olceaaefj kc kxgf)xer igr`aaeo iefgs! tgj`tbagss kc rmget xtk}eieru rkF`reg @igteo`f s`otgb sergs& Ef `bberekf! ef @xtea 488? rmg O`aecktfe` agjesa`rwtggf`orgb _gf`rg Deaa 44! zmeom bgi`fbgb rmg okixagrg d`olceaaefj kc kxgf)xerigr`aaeo iefgs ako`rgb kf kt zermef kfg ieag kc `fu F`reg @igteo`f s`otgb serg<rmg jt`befj kc rmg g}o``rekfs rk rmg `xxtk}ei`rg ktejef`a okfrkwts kc rmg a`fb<`fb cef`foe`a `sswt`fogs swcceoegfr rk xtkebg ckt rmes d`olceaaefj `fb jt`befj&

Okfsgpwgfrau! ef Bgogidgt 488?! Ja`ies  swdierrgb ` r`lefjs oa`ei wfbgt  @treoag 0008 kc F@CR@ oa`eiefj rm`r rmg ig`swtgs `bkxrgb du rmg sr`rg kc O`aecktfe` ‑bgsrtkugb’ rmg gokfkieo `awg kc rmg Eixgte`a Xtkngor& Er `tjwgb rm`rrmg W&_& jkgtfigfr m`b ‑g}xtkxte`rgb’ ers iefefj efgsrigfr rmtkwjm rmggf`origfr `fb eixagigfr`rekf kc tgrtk`oreg tgjwa`rekfs zerm eixksgb sejfeceo`fr

0?? _gg g&j& Koms! swxt` fkrg 04< Nksmw` Gaokidg! Tgjwa`rktu Xkzgts s& Efgsrigfr Xtkrgorekf wfbgt F@CR@*s Om`xrgt 00> Igr`aoa`b! Igrm`fg}! `fb Ja`ies Jkab! 3= W&  RKTKFRK C @O& A& T GS & :0 -4808%< @aa`f Efjgaskf # Aefokaf Ieromgaa! Rmg Ja`ies Tgjwa`rktu R`lefjs Oa`ei `fb Okixgfs`rekf wfbgt F@CR@! 4-0% N&  Z KTAB GFGTJU A& # DW_& 3= -4885%< Gakesg Kd`be`!Efrtkbworktu Fkrg rk F@CR@+WFOERT@A> Ja`ies Jkab Arb& & Wfergb _r`rgs ! 2= E&A&I& 08?7-4885%< Nktb`f O& L`mf! _rtelefj F@CR@ Jkab> Ja`ies @b`fogs Efgsrkt)_r`rg @tdert`rekf ! ??CKTBM@I EFR―A A&N&  080 -4885)4808%< `fb _rgxm`f Z& _omeaa!! Ja`ies Jkab! Arb& & Wfergb _r`rgs -fkrg%! 082 @I&  N& EFR―A A& 47? -4808%&

0?2 Ckt ` oterepwg kf mkz Ja`ies i`f`jgb rk `oogss F@CR@ cktwi! sgg Nwberm Z`aa`og!Oktxkt`rg F`rekf`aeru! Efgsrigfr Xtkrgorekf @jtggigfrs! `fb Om`aagfjgs rk Bkigsreo F`rwt`a Tgskwtogs A`z> Rmg Eixaeo`rekfs kc Ja`ies Jkab*s F@CR@ Om`xrgt 00 Oa`ei ! 0: JGK& EFR―A GFSRA& A& T GS & ?37 -4882)4887%&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 27/35

?7= Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr \Ska& ?> ??2

oksrs `fb mgfog gaeief`rgb `fu om`fog kc kxgt`refj rmg xtkngor `r ` xtkcer&Cwtrmgtiktg! efklefj @treoag 0087 kc F@CR@! Ja`ies `aagjgb rm`r er m`b dggf

besoteief`rgb `j`efsr `s ers xtkxksgb xtkngor z`s swdngor rk iktg kfgtkws a`fbtgoa`i`rekf rm`f m`b dggf eixksgb kf krmgt iefgt`a kxgt`rkts ef rmg jgfgt`a `tg`&

 Rmg Pwgom`f Efbe`f rtedg kxxksgb rk rmg Eixgte`a Xtkngor dgo`wsg er zkwabbgsrtku rmg ‑Rt`ea kc Btg`is’! zmeom es x`tr kc ` fgrzktl kc Pwgom`f ogtgikfe`ax`rms `fb s`otgb sergs! `fb xtggfr rmgi ctki xt`oreoefj rmget owarwt`a `fbtgaejekws rt`berekfs `s rmgu m`g sefog reig eiigikte`a& Ef c`or! rmg rtedg `aagjgbrm`r rmg jkab iefg zkwab eixgbg ers igidgts rk rt`ga! dkrm xmuseo`aau `fbsxeterw`aau! `akfj rmg Rt`ea kc Btg`is< rk i`lg ogtgikfe`a wsg kc rmg xt`ugt oetoags!tkol `aejfigfrs! `fb krmgt owarwt`a cg`rwtgs ef rmg xtkngor `tg`< rk j`ef xtkrgorekf

ctki igr`xmuseo`a b`fjgts< `fb rk okfrefwg rk wsg rmg xtkngor `tg` ckt esekfpwgsrs `fb rg`omefj rted`a ukwrms `dkwr rmget owarwtg&0?7 

Bwtefj rmg `tdert`rekf xtkoggbefjs! Ctegfbs kc rmg G`trm O`f`b`! Ctegfbs kc rmg G`trm Wfergb _r`rgs! _egtt` Oawd! G`trmzktls! rmg F`rekf`a Iefefj @sskoe`rekf!`fb rmg Pwgom`f Efbe`f F`rekf skwjmr rk x`treoex`rg `s `ieoe& Zerm tgj`tb rk rmgPwgom`f Efbe`f F`rekf ef x`treowa`t! rmg `tdert`rkts beb fkr gfj`jg ef ` besowssekfkc rmg tg`skfs ckt `aakzefj kt bes`aakzefj ers x`treoex`rekf `s `ieows! `s rmgu betgorau `xxaegb rmg CRO _r`rgigfr&0?3 @ooktbefjau! rmg Pwgom`f Efbe`f F`rekfi`bg zterrgf swdiessekfs tgj`tbefj rmg jkgtfigfr―s bwru wfbgt efrgtf`rekf`a a`z 

rk xtgsgtg s`otgb a`fbs kf zmeom rmg xa`efrecc―s jkab iefgs zgtg ako`rgb!0?: `fbxtkebgb okfcebgfre`a efckti`rekf kf rmg Efbe`f rt`eas rm`r zgtg `aw`dag rk rmgetowarwtg `fb tgaejekf&0?= Rmgu `ask efklgb rmget okfsrerwrekf`a tejmr rk ctggbki kc tgaejekf&0?5 Cwtrmgt! rmg Pwgom`f xgkxag zgtg `ask `aakzgb rk egz rmg xtkoggbefjsef ` sgx`t`rg tkki e` oaksgb oetower rgagesekf!028 dwr beb fkr efrgtgfg ef rmgi&

 Rmg rtedwf`a g}xaeoerau wfbgtaefgb rmg c`or rm`r rmg jt`frefj kc ag`g beb fkr gfrerag

0?7  _gg   Ja`ies Jkab  @z`tb! swxt`  fkrg 0! ª 000 -‑It& O`omkt`! Pwgom`f Rted`aMesrkte`f! bgsotedgb rmg eixktr`fog kc rmg `tg` rk rmg Pwgom`f xgkxag―s owarwt`a tgskwtogs`fb tgaejekws `awgs< mg aelgfgb rmg tgaejekws sejfeceo`fog kc rmg `tg` rk Ngtws`agi ktIgoo`’%&

0?3 _gg Bgoesekf kf @xxaeo`rekf `fb _wdiessekf du Pwgom`f Efbe`f F`rekf! ª =! _gxr&03! 4887! ``ea`dag `r>  mrrx>++zzz&sr`rg&jk+bkowigfrs+ktj`fe~`rekf+7?754&xbc& @stgj`tbs rk rmg CRO _r`rgigfr! sgg fkrg 2:! swxt` &

0?: _gg Agefg! swxt` fkrg :! `r 42&0?= _gg  Ja`ies Jkab  @z`tb! swxt` fkrg 0! ª =&0?5 _gg  eb&! ª 000&028 _gg eb&! ª 458 -‑Rmg xwdaeo z`s efergb rk egz rmg xtkoggbefjs ef ` sgx`t`rg tkki

  e` oaksgb oetower rgagesekf& Rmg Pwgom`f zgtg efergb rk egz rmg xtkoggbefjs ctki `beccgtgfr ako`rekf zerm ` sgx`t`rg ebgk cggb rk `aakz rmget egzefj kc krmgtzesg tgsrteorgbbesowssekf kc owarwt`a ako`rekfs< rted`a ebgfreceo`rekf zkwab dg tgpwetgb ckt `biessekf rk rmesako`rekf’%&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 28/35

 C`aa! 4800Y  @ieows Owte`g # Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Trs& ef Ef& @td& ?75 rmg Pwgom`f Efbe`f F`rekf rk i`lg `fu cwtrmgt swdiessekfs&020 

Cef`aau! rmg rtedwf`a okfoawbgb rm`r rmg W&_& beb fkr dtg`om @treoags 0008 kt0087 kc F@CR@& Kf rmg kfg m`fb! er ckwfb rm`r rmg O`aecktfe` d`olceaaefj ig`swtgs beb fkr tgswar ef ` t`beo`a beiefwrekf ef rmg `awg kc rmg Eixgte`aXtkngor&024 Ef c`or! `ooktbefj rk rmg rtedwf`a―s `aw`rekf! `crgt ` okixagrgd`olceaaefj! rmg xtkngor zkwab g}oggb W_" 48 ieaaekf& Zerm tgj`tb rk rmg c`et `fbgpwer`dag rtg`rigfr sr`fb`tb! rmg rtedwf`a okfsebgtgb rm`r rmg tgjwa`rekfs x`ssgb efO`aecktfe` zgtg xtkgf kc jgfgt`a `xxaeo`rekf! dkrm ef ckti `fb ef gccgor&02? 

D& @f`auses kc Ja`ies Jkab `fb ers T`ieceo`rekfs 

Ja`ies Jkab tgg`as rmg eixgt`reg fggb rk besrefjwesm rmksg o`sgs zmgtg rmetbx`tregs sggl rk x`treoex`rg ef ` xtkogbwtg `s eix`tre`a ‑ctegfbs kc rmg okwtr’ ctkirmksg zmgtg rmgu m`g ` agjerei`rg efrgtgsr ef rmg kwrokig& FJK swdiessekfs!swom `s rmg kfg swdierrgb du Ctegfbs kc rmg G`trm! oag`tau dgakfj rk rmg cetsrjtkwx> rmgu sggl rk x`treoex`rg ef efgsrkt)sr`rg besxwrgs tgxtgsgfrefj ` dtk`bokfogtf zerm lgu rmgi`reo esswgs `fb warei`rgau oa`ei rk dg eix`tre`a rk rmgkwrokig kc rmg besxwrg&022 Ef okfsgpwgfog! rmget c`orw`a! rgomfeo`a! kt g}xgtrkxefekfs o`f dg `bgpw`rgau om`ffgagb rmtkwjm `ieows dtegcs& Ef rmes o`sg! rmgtgsrteorekfs jgfgt`aau eixksgb kf `ieoe! `s fkrgb ef X`tr EE! sggi skigzm`rnwsrecegb&

Du okfrt`sr! zmgf rmg efrgtf`rekf`a `tdert`rekf `z`tb m`s rmg xkrgfre`a rkeixefjg kf rmg tejmrs kt efrgtgsrs kc ` fkf)besxwrefj x`tru rmg oetowisr`fogs `tgt`beo`aau beccgtgfr& Rmg Pwgom`f Efbe`f F`rekf skwjmr rk efrgtgfg ef Ja`ies Jkab  dgo`wsg er z`s betgorau efkagb ef rmg besxwrg! okfsebgtefj ers sxeterw`a `fb owarwt`aokffgorekf zerm rmg a`fb okixtesgb ef rmg Eixgte`a Xtkngor! `fb gsxgoe`aau dgo`wsgkc rmg betgor okfsgpwgfogs rm`r rmg ggfrw`a kgtrwtfefj kc _gf`rg Deaa 44 -rmgeixwjfgb agjesa`reg ig`swtg% du rmg `tdert`rkts okwab m`g m`b kf rmget -mwi`f%tejmrs& @s igfrekfgb g`taegt! rmg `tdert`rekf rtedwf`a xgtierrgb rmg Pwgom`f Efbe`fF`rekf rk swdier `f `ieows dtegc! dwr beb fkr z`tt`fr rmgi cwtrmgt x`treoex`rekf

tejmrs& _k! du rtg`refj efbejgfkws xgkxags `s ` igtg ‑ctegfb kc rmg okwtr’ -e&g&jeefj rmgi rmg s`ig rtg`rigfr `s Ctegfbs kc rmg G`trm%! `fb fkr `s ` besxwrefj x`tru! rmg `tdert`rkts swdsr`fre`aau f`ttkzgb rmget xkssedeaeru kc `oogss rk nwsreog&027 

020 _gg  eb&! ª 4:2&024 _gg eb&! ª ?33&02? _gg eb&! ª =05)=40&022 _gg Agefg! swxt` fkrg :! `r 0=< `fb Rte`fr`ceakw! swxt` fkrg 30&027  _gg  Rte`fr`ceakw! swxt`  fkrg 30 -‑Jegf rmg wf``ea`deaeru kc efrgtgfrekf ef

efgsrigfr `tdert`rekf! x`treoex`rekf `s `ieows es! ef gccgor! rmg kfau tgokwtsg `f efrgtgsrgbrmetb x`tru m`s rk x`treoex`rg ef rmg xtkoggbefjs’%&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 29/35

?38 Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr \Ska& ?> ??2

 Rmws! rmes `treoag oa`eis rm`r rmg `ieows owte` efsrerwrekf es ef`bgpw`rg rk `bbtgssefbejgfkws xgkxags― efrgtgsrs ef ` okixtgmgfseg i`ffgt&

Ctki rmg `dkg! er es gebgfr rm`r fkf)besxwrefj x`tregs― efrgtgsr ef `tdert`rekfi`u `tu ef f`rwtg! sejfeceo`fog! `fb betgorfgss& Fkr `aa rmetb x`tregs― efrgtgsrs o`fdg om`ffgagb rmtkwjm `ieows x`treoex`rekf& Zmgf ` rmetb x`tru o`f xtkg rk m`g `betgor efrgtgsr ef rmg kwrokig kc rmg `tdert`rekf xtkoggbefjs! efrgtf`rekf`a`tdert`rekf tgjeigs smkwab gsr swom xgtskfs zerm `ixag x`treoex`rekf tejmrs rkgfswtg ` agjerei`rg `fb bgikot`reo `z`tb! `fb `keb bgcgfsgagssfgss& T`rmgt rm`fdgefj okfberekfgb rk rmg besotgrekf kc rmg x`tregs `fb rtedwf`as! rmes besxwrgtgskawrekf tgjeig smkwab jt`bw`aau ikg rkz`tbs rmg tgokjferekf kc `f `dskawrgtejmr kc x`treoex`rekf kc efbejgfkws xgkxags& Ef gccgor! jegf rm`r efgsrkt)sr`rg

`tdert`rekf rtedwf`as `tg gigtjefj! ggf du `ooebgfr! `s bgoesekf)i`lgts ef i`rrgtsokfogtfefj efbejgfkws xgkxags `fb f`rekf)sr`rgs! `s igfrekfgb ef X`tr EEE!tgokjfe~efj rmg Pwgom`f Efbe`f F`rekf `fb krmgt efbejgfkws jtkwxs rmg tejmr rkefrgtgfg ef ` besxwrg es ` i`rrgt kc nwsreog&

O& Efoktxkt`refj rmg Twags kc Efrgtgfrekf `s ` X`f`og` 

Cwtrmgtefj rmg `dkg aefg kc tg`skfefj! rmes `treoag xtkxksgs rmg efoktxkt`rekfefrk efrgtf`rekf`a `tdert`rekf kc rmg xtkogbwt`a efsrerwrekf kc ‑efrgtgfrekf’∔`skxxksgb rk `ieows∔ctki iwfeoex`a a`z& Ef skig okwfrtegs! rmg xtkogbwt`aagjesa`rekf beccgtgfre`rgs `ieows ctki efbeebw`as oa`eiefj ` betgor efrgtgsr ef rmgrt`fs`orekf wfbgt nwbeoe`a tgegz& Ef rmg W&_&! Twag 42-`% kc rmg Cgbgt`a Twags kc Oeea Xtkogbwtg!023 zmeom jkgtfs rmg wsw`a o`sgs kc ‑efrgtgfrekf’ ef cgbgt`axt`oreog!02: xgtiers `fukfg zerm ` tg`skf`dag oa`ei kc xkrgfre`a efnwtu ctki g}esrefj 

023 Ef rmg Wfergb _r`rgs! rmg Cgbgt`a Twags kc Oeea Xtkogbwtg kccgt fkf)x`tregs rmgkxxktrwferu rk jgr efrk ` a`zswer! ggf rmkwjm fkfg kc rmg g}esrefj x`tregs z`frs rmgirmgtg& _gg Z TEJMR # IEAAGT ! 48 CGB& XT@O& # XTKO& BG_LDKKL ! ª =8>

Twag 42> Efrgtgfrekf-`% Efrgtgfrekf kc Tejmr&Kf reigau ikrekf! rmg okwtr iwsr xgtier `fukfg rk efrgtgfg zmk& & & &-4% oa`eis `f efrgtgsr tga`refj rk rmg xtkxgtru kt rt`fs`orekf rm`r es rmgswdngor kc rmg `orekf! `fb es sk serw`rgb rm`r besxksefj kc rmg `orekf i`u `s ` xt`oreo`a i`rrgt eix`et kt eixgbg rmg ik`fr―s `deaeru rk xtkrgor ersefrgtgsr! wfagss g}esrefj x`tregs `bgpw`rgau tgxtgsgfr rm`r efrgtgsr&

 Rmes twag tgpwetgs rmg `xxaeo`fr rk smkz rmtgg rmefjs> -e% rm`r er m`s `fefrgtgsr tga`refj rk rmg xtkxgtru kt rt`fs`orekf efkagb ef rmg `orekf< -ee%rm`r besxkserekf kc rmg `orekf i`u eix`et rmg `xxaeo`fr―s `deaeru rk xtkrgorers efrgtgsr ‑`s ` xt`oreo`a i`rrgt’< `fb -eee% rm`r ers efrgtgsr es fkr`bgpw`rgau tgxtgsgfrgb du rmg xtgsgfr x`tregs&

02: Fkrg! Efrgtgfrekf `fb rmg Ig`fefj kc ‑dkwfb’ wfbgt Cgbgt`a Twag 42-`%-4%! 3?-?% U  @AG A&N&28= -0572%&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 30/35

 C`aa! 4800Y  @ieows Owte`g # Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Trs& ef Ef& @td& ?30 aerej`rekf rk nkef rmg ct`u `s ` i`rrgt kc tejmr zmgf rmgu smkz ` agjerei`rg efrgtgsr efrmg kwrokig! ` xkrgfre`a xgtea! kt zmgf rmget efrgtgsrs `tg wftgxtgsgfrgb du rmg

x`tregs `atg`bu ef rmg xtkogbwtg&02= Ef krmgt zktbs! efrgtgfrekf ‑es ` xtkogbwt`abgeog zmgtgdu ` srt`fjgt es xgtierrgb rk dgokig ` x`tru rk ` xgfbefj `orekf’&025 Ertgokjfe~gs ` swdsr`freg tejmr rk efrgtgfg ef ogtr`ef oetowisr`fogs rk xtkrgor fkf)x`tregs ctki rmg efnwtekws gccgors kc rmg nwbeoe`a xtkogssgs078 `fb tgbwog iwarexaeoeru kc aerej`rekf&070 Ef rmes z`u! ‑efrgtgfrekf’ `ors `s `f gpweru bgeog&074 Kc okwtsg!g`om iwfeoex`a xtkogbwt`a twags gfr`eas ers kzf x`treowa`teregs `fb okixag}eregs

 zmeom rmes `treoag bkgs fkr `ei rk besowss&

  Rmws! rmg twags jkgtfefj efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf smkwab dg `igfbgb rkefoktxkt`rg efbejgfkws xgkxags `s ‑efrgtgfgts’ ef ogtr`ef oetowisr`fogs& Rk

tgpwgsr ‑efrgtgfrekf’! efbejgfkws xgkxags zkwab m`g rk smkz rm`r rmgu m`g `fefrgtgsr tga`refj rk rmg xtkxgtru kt rt`fs`orekf efkagb< rm`r rmgu `tg xkrgfre`aau ‑dkwfb’ du rmg kwrokig< kt rm`r rmget efrgtgsrs `tg fkr `bgpw`rgau tgxtgsgfrgb du kfg kc rmg ktejef`a x`tregs&07? @z`tbefj efbejgfkws jtkwxs rmg sr`rws kc efrgtgfgts

 zkwab `sswtg rmgi rmg tejmr rk! `ikfj krmgts! swdier dtegcs zerm fk tgsrteorekfskf rmg fwidgt kc x`jgs< `rrgfb `fb x`treoex`rg ef kt`a mg`tefjs< m`g `oogss rmgbesxwrefj x`tregs― bkowigfrs kf tgoktb< otkss)g}`iefg zerfgssgs `fb om`aagfjg`tdert`a `z`tbs kt rmg `xxkefrigfr kc `tdert`rkts rmgisgags& Ggf rmkwjm rmgg}`or sokxg kc rmgsg ‑fgz’ xtkogbwt`a tejmrs tgpwetgs cwtrmgt `f`auses! ` jt`bw`aikg rkz`tbs ` susrgi ef zmeom `tdert`a rtedwf`as `aakz efbejgfkws xgkxags rk

x`treoex`rg iktg ctggau es eixgt`reg&

Fggbagss rk s`u! rmes fgz sgr kc ‑efrgtgfrekf’ twags zkwab eixksg `f g}rt`dwtbgf kf rmg efrgtf`rekf`a `tdert`rekf rtedwf`a `fb rmg ktejef`a x`tregs&Fggtrmgagss! efbejgfkws xgkxags smkwab dg jt`frgb rmes sxgoe`a kt beccgtgfre`rgbsr`rws dgo`wsg rmgu `tg ‑xgkxags)f`rekfs’072 zerm ` besrefor owarwt`a ebgfreru<xkssgss rmg tejmr rk sgac)bgrgtief`rekf< `fb `tg ef ` dgrrgt xkserekf rm`f f`rekf)sr`rgs rk bgcgfb rmget tejmrs& Rmgsg ebg`s `tg wfx`olgb ef rmg swdsgpwgfr sgorekf&

02= _gg g&j&! Bkf`ab Meaaelgt! Twag 42> Gccgoreg Efrgtgfrekf ! : AEREJ@REKF 40 -05=8)05=0%<`fb Nkmf G& Lgffgbu! Agr―s @aa Nkef Ef> Efrgtgfrekf wfbgt Cgbgt`a Twag 42! 7: L  U &  A&N&  ?45 

-053=)0535%&025 I&N&L! Xag`befj> Efrgtgfrekf wfbgt Twag 42 -d% -4% kc Cgbgt`a Twags kc Oeea Xtkogbwtg ! 45

O @A& A& T GS & 707! 7?5 -0528)0520% -mgtgef`crgt I&N&L&%&078 Eb& 070 Fkrg! Efrgtgfrekf kc Xte`rg X`tregs wfbgt Cgbgt`a Twag 42! 74 OKAWI& A& T GS & 544! 5?0

-0574% -mgtgef`crgt Fkrg‟ Efrgtgfrekf kc Xr& X`tregs  %&074 I&N&L  ! swxt` fkrg 025! `r 724&07? Fkrg‟ Efrgtgfrekf kc Xr& X`tregs ! swxt` fkrg 070! `r 542&072 _gg  N`tag Zgej`tb! Es rmgtg ` _xgoe`a Nwsreceo`rekf ckt Efbejgfkws Tejmrs; !  ef   EFBEJGFKW_

XGKXAG_>  _GAC)BGRGTIEF@REKF!  L FKZAGBJG!  EFBEJGFGERU  0:: -Mgftu Iefbg gb&!Gdwtkf @o`bgieo Xwdaesmgts 488=%-mgtgef`crgt Zgej`tb%&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 31/35

?34 Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr \Ska& ?> ??2

0& Beccgtgfre`rgb Owarwt`a Ebgfreru 

Efbejgfkws xgkxags tgxtgsgfr ` okaagoreeru zerm ` oag`tau besrefor owarwt`aebgfreru `fb `tg rmgtgcktg ‑beccgtgfr’ ctki rmg i`nkteru kc ` okwfrtu―sxkxwa`rekf&077 Efbe`f f`rekfs ‑\`Ytg fkr! aelg ` Zgsrgtf f`rekf)sr`rg! gfreregs zerm `besrefor Mgjgae`f g}esrgfog sgx`t`rg ctki rmget efbeebw`a igidgts& Igidgts kc rted`a okiiwferegs `tg g}esrgfre`aau regb rk g`om krmgt ef ` fgrzktl kc bggxau okiierrgb mkte~kfr`a tga`rekfsmexs&’073 Rmes es zmu rmg efrgtf`rekf`a okiiwferu m`s jt`bw`aau tgokjfe~gb besreforeg tejmrs ckt efbejgfkws xgkxags&07: 

 Rmg xtefoexag kc gpw`a rtg`rigfr ‑bgi`fbs rm`r `xxtkxte`rg srgxs dg r`lgf rki`lg er xkssedag ckt jtkwx igidgts rk xtggfr rmget owarwtg ctki besefrgjt`refj & && \@fbY rmgsg `xxtkxte`rg srgxs okig ef rmg ckti kc ` ”beccgtgfre`rgb oere~gfsmex― ktogtr`ef tejmrs rm`r `xxau kfau rk iefkteregs `fb fkr rk krmgt jtkwxs kc oere~gfs’&07= _efjaefj kwr efbejgfkws xgkxag `s ` sxgoe`a jtkwx zerm sxgoe`a tejmrs es nwsrecegb kfrmg d`ses kc rmget besreforeg owarwt`a ebgfreru! zmeom es efg}rteo`dau regb rk a`fb!f`rwt`a tgskwtogs! owarwt`a kdngors! `fb rmget tejmr rk i`efr`ef `fb srtgfjrmgf er&075 

  @ooktbefjau! jt`frefj cwtrmgt x`treoex`rekf tejmrs rk efbejgfkws xgkxags rmtkwjm

077  _gg  D`tsm! swxt`  fkrg 35! `r =27 -`tjwefj rm`r ckt efbejgfkws xgkxags rmgtg es `cwforekf`a tga`rekfsmex dgrzggf besreforegfgss `fb rmg okaagoreg tejmr rk a`fb! rgtterktu `fbsgac)bgrgtief`rekf%&

073 Zegssfgt! swxt` fkrg 37&07: _gg D`tsm! swxt` fkrg 35! `r =?8&07= Oergb ef Zgej`tb! swxt` fkrg 072! `r 0=0&075 A`fb es gssgfre`a ckt rmg gokfkieo swte`a kc efbejgfkws owarwtg> er es ` i`nkt

gokfkieo tgskwtog `fb! ef i`fu o`sgs! sgtgs `s efbejgfkws xgkxags― xtei`tu ig`fs kc swdsesrgfog& Rmes es zmu rmg tejmr rk owarwt`a sgac)xtgsgt`rekf kc efbejgfkws xgkxags zkwabdg ig`fefjagss zermkwr ` tejmr rk rmg okfrefwgb xkssgssekf `fb gfnkuigfr kc rmget a`fbs&

 Ugr! a`fb es iktg rm`f ` ig`fs kc gokfkieo swsrgf`fog ckt efbejgfkws xgkxags& Efbejgfkwsxgkxags― sxeterw`a ebgfreru es efg}rteo`dau aeflgb rk rmget rt`berekf`a rgtterktu& Rmgu tgj`tbrmgisgags fkr `s mkigkzfgts kt a`fb rgf`frs! dwr `s rtwsrggs kc rmg a`fb ckt cwrwtgjgfgt`rekfs& Mgfog! a`fb rgfwtg es fkr kfau otereo`a ckt rmg xmuseo`a `fb gokfkieoswdsesrgfog kc efbejgfkws jtkwxs! dwr er es `ask `f efrtefseo `sxgor kc rmget owarwt`a ebgfreru!tgaejekws dgaegcs! z`u kc aecg! `fb `f eixktr`fr skwtog kc mesrkteo`a `fb soegfreceo lfkzagbjg&_gg g&j&! B @FEGA DKFEAA@!  A @ OKF_RERWOEßF IWAREOWARWT@A -_ejak bga MkidtgGberktgs! Efsrerwrk Xgfs`t Wfegtseb`b N`gte`f` 488:%< B`tagfg I& Nkmsrkf! F`reg Tejmrs `s Okaagoreg Tejmrs> @ Pwgsrekf kc Jtkwx Xtgsgt`rekf ! ef   RMG T EJMR_ KC IEFKTERU OWARWTG_ 052-Zeaa Luieol` gb&! K}cktb Wfe& Xtgss 0557%< @kecg Bwccu! Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― A`fb Tejmrs> Bggakxefj ` _we Jgfgtes @xxtk`om rk Kzfgtsmex `fb Tgsrerwrekf ! 07  EFR―A  N& KF IEFKTERU  # 

JTKWX T  R_&  787!  700 -488=%< `fb Aeae`f @xkfrg Iet`fb`! Wxak`befj rmg Ako`a> @ssgssefj rmg Okfrgixkt`tu Tga`rekfsmex Dgrzggf Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― A`fb Rgfwtg _usrgis `fb Efrgtf`rekf`a Mwi`f Tejmrs A`z Tgj`tbefj rmg @aako`rekf kc Rt`berekf`a A`fbs `fb Tgskwtogs ef A`ref @igteo` ! 08 KT & T GS & EFR―A A& 205 -488=%&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 32/35

 C`aa! 4800Y  @ieows Owte`g # Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Trs& ef Ef& @td& ?3? ‑efrgtgfrekf’ es ` z`u rmtkwjm zmeom sr`rgs o`f cwaceaa rmget kdaej`rekfs rk xtkrgorefbejgfkws xgkxags― beccgtgfre`rgb owarwt`a ebgfreru&

4& _gac)Bgrgtief`rekf

Efbejgfkws xgkxags tgi`ef xkaereo`aau `fb agj`aau xkzgtagss zermef bkigsreodktbgts& Rmg tejmr rk sgac)bgrgtief`rekf038! mkzggt! jt`frs rmgi rmg kxxktrwferu rk x`treoex`rg ef bgoesekf)i`lefj xtkogssgs zermef f`rekf`a dktbgts ef zmeom rmgu smkwab m`g ` keog kc rmget kzf beccgtgfr ctki rm`r kc rmg sr`rg& Rmes es rmg kfau 

 z`u ef zmeom rmgu o`f j`ef `fb i`efr`ef okfrtka kgt rmget kzf bgsrefegs&

_ggt`a efrgtf`rekf`a rtg`regs sr`rg rm`r efbejgfkws xgkxags m`g rmg tejmr rk

x`treoex`rg ef bgoesekf)i`lefj ef i`rrgts rm`r zkwab `ccgor rmget tejmrs! rmtkwjmtgxtgsgfr`regs omksgf du rmgisgags ef `ooktb`fog zerm rmget kzf xtkogbwtgs&030   Rmes tejmr bkgs fkr fgogss`teau `ikwfr rk ` grk xkzgt! dwr jt`frs rmgi rmgkxxktrwferu rk efcawgfog rmg xkaereo`a ktbgt ef zmeom rmgu aeg& @ooktbefj rk @f`u`>

\RYmg gssgfre`a ebg` kc sgac)bgrgtief`rekf es rm`r mwi`f dgefjs!efbeebw`aau kt `s jtkwxs! `tg gpw`aau gfreragb rk dg ef okfrtka kc rmget kzf bgsrefegs & & & wfbgt okfberekfs kc gpw`aeru & & & \_Ygac bgrgtief`rekf ig`fs rm`r xgkxags `tg gfreragb rk x`treoex`rg gpw`aau ef rmg okfsrerwrekf `fb bggakxigfr kc rmg jkgtfefj efsrerwrekf`a

ktbgt wfbgt zmeom rmgu aeg `fb! cwtrmgt! rk m`g rm`r jkgtfefj ktbgt dg kfg ef zmeom rmgu i`u aeg `fb bggakx ctggau kf `okfrefwkws d`ses034 

Er es rk dg fkreogb rm`r rmg tejmr kc efbejgfkws xgkxags rk efcawgfog rmg xkaereo`aktbgt es fkr aeiergb rk iwfeoex`a a`z ct`igzktls< er `ask efoawbgs bgoesekf)i`lefj 

  zermef rmg efrgtf`rekf`a tg`ai! `s @f`u` oa`eis&03? Ef aejmr kc rmg tejmr rk sgac)bgrgtief`rekf! efbejgfkws xgkxags smkwab m`g rmg tejmr rk gfj`jg ef rmksg o`sgsdtkwjmr rk efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf rm`r o`f xkrgfre`aau `ccgor rmget okaagoregtejmrs& Rmes es xtgoesgau zm`r ‑efrgtgfrekf’ xwtxktrs&

?& Krmgt okfsebgt`rekfs

Efbejgfkws xgkxags `tg ef ` dgrrgt xkserekf rm`f sr`rg `jgfrs kt tgxtgsgfr`regs

038 Nkm`f B& `f bgt Sugt! Rmg Tejmr rk _gac)bgrgtief`rekf `fb Ers Gfcktogigfr ! 08 EA_@  N& EFR―A # OKIX A& 240 -4882%&

030 _gg g&j&! @treoag 0= kc rmg WFBTEX< @treoag 3&0-d% kc EAK Okfgfrekf 035< @treoag 0kc rmg EOOXT< `fb @treoag 0 kc rmg EOG_OT&

034 _& N`igs @f`u`! Rmg Tejmr kc Efbejgfkws Xgkxags rk _gac)bgrgtief`rekf ef rmg Xksr)Bgoa`t`rekf Gt` ! ef Om`trgts # _r`gfm`jgf gbs&! swxt` fkrg :7! `r 0=:)0=5&

03? @F@U@! swxt` fkrg :0! `r 072&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 33/35

?32 Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr \Ska& ?> ??2

rk sr`fb wx ckt rmget tejmrs dgcktg efrgtf`rekf`a `tdert`rkts< rmgtg `tg rzk tg`skfsckt rmes& Cetsr! fkr `az`us zeaa efbejgfkws xgkxags― efrgtgfrekf swxxktr kfg kc rmg

aerej`refj x`tregs& @s Xtkcgsskt Z& Ieom`ga Tgesi`f okfrgfbs>

\Efrgtf`rekf`aY rtedwf`as `bbtgss kfau rmg esswgs t`esgb du rmg ckti`ax`tregs dgcktg rmgi! zmeom! wfbgt rmg twags kc rmg j`ig gsr`daesmgbdu sr`rgs! o`f kfau dg sr`rgs & & & Efbejgfkws xgkxags `tg sreaagssgfre`aau efesedag kt! ec fkreogb! rtg`rgb! agj`aau! `akfj zerm rmgcakt` `fb c`wf` kc rmg a`fb okfogtfgb&032 

Ef rmes gef! efbejgfkws xgkxags smkwab dg jt`frgb rmg kxxktrwferu rk `treowa`rgckt rmgisgags! zerm fk efrgtigbe`tegs -swom `s rmg sr`rg! okix`fu! kt FJKs

`orefj `s `ieows owte`g%& Efbejgfkws xgkxags `tg fkr bgokt`reg gagigfrs kc iwfeoex`a a`z rm`r tgpwetg rwrktefj< rmgu `tg swdngors kc efrgtf`rekf`a a`z! rm`r es!dg`tgts kc efrgtf`rekf`a tejmrs `fb kdaej`rekfs& Ef c`or! ‑efbejgfkws xgkxags `atg`bu gfnku ` xteeagjgb xkserekf `s pw`se)sr`rg `orkts! `fb fkr igtgau `s x`tr kc rmg zebgtrtgfb rkz`tbs FJK x`treoex`rekf ef xkaeou besowssekfs `fb xtkjt`ieixagigfr`rekf’&037 Mgfog! `s Twssgaa A`ztgfog D`tsm okfrgfbs! rt`berekf`a ag`bgtsi`u dg iktg bgikot`reo`aau tgxtgsgfr`reg rm`f efsrerwrekfs rm`r bgxgfb kf rmgsr`rg ckt agjerei`ou! tgokjferekf kt cef`foe`a swxxktr&033 

Ogtr`efau! ef ktbgt rk g}gtoesg rmget x`treoex`rekf tejmrs rmgu tgpwetg agj`a

`ssesr`fog `fb cef`fog& _kig i`u `tjwg rm`r sr`rgs `tg tgpwetgb rk okixgfs`rgrmgsg oksrs `s x`tr kc rmget kdaej`rekfs rk `ookiikb`rg efbejgfkws xgkxags― tejmrs&Krmgts i`u oa`ei rm`r er es oeea skoegru―s r`sl rk swxxktr `oogss rk nwsreog ef gpw`argtis& Zm`r es oag`t ctki rmg o`sg a`zs xtgsgfrgb ef X`tr EEE es rm`r efbejgfkwsxgkxags m`g i`f`jgb rk j`ef `oogss rk sggt`a efrgtf`rekf`a mwi`f tejmrsokiierrggs `fb rtedwf`as `atg`bu& Rmes xtkogss m`s dggf c`oeaer`rgb du sggt`amwi`f tejmrs FJKs&

  Rmg sgokfb tg`skf es! dtk`bgt x`treoex`rekf tejmrs dgcktg efgsrkt)sr`rg`tdert`rekf o`f sgtg rk kgtokig rmg xgtogxrekf rm`r efrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr

`tdert`rekf es wfbgikot`reo ef rm`r er bkgs fkr `aakz rmg x`treoex`rekf kc efbejgfkwsxgkxags ef rmg fgjkre`rekf! bt`crefj! `fb t`receo`rekf kc cktgejf efgsrigfr rtg`regsrm`r warei`rgau `ccgor rmgi `s ` okaagoreg zmkag& R`lefj efrk `ookwfr rmg r`}kfkiu kc xkrgfre`a okfcaeors xtgsgfrgb ef X`tr E! er es dgokiefj gebgfr rm`r efbejgfkwsxgkxags m`g srgiigb `s ` ‑fgz’ okfsrerwgfou ef efrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr`tdert`rekf& Efgsrkts `fb sr`rgs m`g du `fb a`tjg! ejfktgb rmes okfsrerwgfou& Rk

032 Z& Ieom`ga Tgesi`f! Xtkrgorefj Efbejgfkws Tejmrs ef Efrgtf`rekf`a @bnwbeo`rekf ! =5 @I&  N& EFR―A A& ?78 -0557%&

037 _gg D`tsm! swxt` fkrg 35! `r =78&033 _gg eb&! `r =?:&

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 34/35

 C`aa! 4800Y  @ieows Owte`g # Efbejgfkws Xgkxags― Trs& ef Ef& @td& ?37 tgbtgss rmes smktrokiefj! `xxkserg `fb g}rt`ktbef`tu ig`swtgs `tg tgpwetgb! aelgrmg efsrerwrekf kc efrgtgfrekf&

2& _wii`tu 

Ef aejmr kc efbejgfkws xgkxags― beccgtgfre`rgb owarwt`a ebgfreru `fb tejmr rk sgac)bgrgtief`rekf! efrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr a`z smkwab bgteg efsxet`rekf ctki‑efrgtgfrekf’ twags sgr cktrm ef bkigsreo agj`a susrgis `fb `aakz efbejgfkwsxgkxags rk x`treoex`rg iktg `oregau `fb zerm agss tgsrteorekfs ef efrgtf`rekf`a`tdert`rekf dgukfb rmg `ieows owte` efsrerwrekf& Rmgsg fgz ‑efrgtgfrekf’ twagssmkwab fkr dg tgj`tbgb `s tgkawrekf`tu! dwr `s ` f`rwt`a srgx rk gfswtg jtg`rgtrt`fsx`tgfou `fb rk `ookiikb`rg rmetb x`tru―s tejmrs ef efrgtf`rekf`a `bnwbeo`rekf&

Efgsrkt)sr`rg `tdert`rekf! aelg `fu krmgt agj`a susrgi! iwsr okfsr`frau gkag eftgsxkfsg rk om`fjefj oetowisr`fogs ef ktbgt rk iktg gccgoregau sgtg rmgetom`fjefj okfsrerwgfoegs&03: Warei`rgau! rmg agjerei`ou kc `tdert`rekf `s ` `aebbesxwrg tgskawrekf igom`fesi ckt efrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr bgxgfbs kf ers `deaeru rk`b`xr ersgac rk kfjkefj okfberekfs&03= 

Ggf rmkwjm efrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr a`z z`s fkr ktejef`aau bgsejfgb rk`ookiikb`rg efbejgfkws efrgtgsrs! ef xt`oreog er m`s rwtfgb kwr rk dg `f`bnwbeo`rktu dkbu kc rmget tejmrs& Rmes es zmu er es eixgt`reg rk `keb rmgbgcgfsgagssfgss kc efbejgfkws jtkwxs& Ckt rmgi! efgsrkt)sr`rg `bnwbeo`rekf sggis

dgrrgt rm`f fk `bnwbeo`rekf `r `aa&

  S& OKFOAW_EKF 

  @crgt `f efere`a xgtekb kc tgsrteorgb `oogss rk gfswtg okfcebgfre`aeru!efrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr a`z m`s bgikfsrt`rgb ` ogtr`ef bgjtgg kc `b`xr`deaeru ef`aakzefj `ieows dtegcs efrk rmg `tdert`rekf xtkogbwtgs ef rmg x`sr ug`ts& Mkzggt!`ieoe x`treoex`rekf ef rmgsg ckt ` sreaa tgi`efs besotgrekf`tu! a`tjgau efckti`a! `fbi`efau tgsrteorgb rk zterrgf swdiessekfs& Rmes es zmu rmes `treoag swjjgsrs rm`r rmg`ieows owte` efsrerwrekf es eaa)swergb rk `bbtgss! ef ` okixtgmgfseg i`ffgt! rmgtejmrs kc rmksg fkf)besxwrefj x`tregs rm`r m`g ` agjerei`rg efrgtgsr ef rmgxtkogbwtg& Cwtrmgt! rmg tg`skf zmu efbejgfkws xgkxags smkwab dg sefjagb)kwr esdgo`wsg rmgu tgxtgsgfr ` jtkwx zerm ` besrefor owarwt`a ebgfreru! beccgtgfr ctki rmgi`nkteru kc ` okwfrtu―s xkxwa`rekf< rmgu m`g ` tejmr rk efcawgfog rmg xkaereo`a ktbgt`fb bgoesekf)i`lefj ef i`rrgts zmeom zkwab `ccgor rmget tejmrs< `fb rmgu `tg iktgswergb rk bgcgfb rmget okaagoreg tejmrs rm`f f`rekf)sr`rgs dgcktg efrgtf`rekf`a`tdert`rkts&

03: _gg Jtwfgt ! swxt` fkrg 4&03= _gg  eb& 

8/3/2019 Why the amicus curia institution is ill-suited to address indigenous peoples’ rights before investor-state arbitration tr…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-amicus-curia-institution-is-ill-suited-to-address-indigenous-peoples 35/35

?33 Rt`bg! A`z  `fb Bgsgakxigfr \Ska& ?> ??2

Ef aefg zerm rmg `dkg! ‑efrgtgfrekf’ twags smkwab dg efoktxkt`rgb efrkefrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr `tdert`rekf sk rm`r `tdert`rekf rtedwf`as o`f efoawbg

efbejgfkws xgkxags `s x`tregs rk rmg xtkogbwtg! `aakzefj rmgi rmg tejmr rk swdierdtegcs zerm fk x`jg aeiers! `rrgfb `fb x`treoex`rg ef kt`a mg`tefjs `fb `oogsstgoktbs& Ogtr`efau! rmes rt`fsckti`rekf tgpwetgs rmg efrtkbworekf kc fgz xtkogbwt`atwags `fb rmg dweabefj kc ` dtk`b okfsgfsws kf rmes i`rrgt& Fkrzermsr`fbefj rmgi`jferwbg kc rmg om`aagfjg! efrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr a`z smkwab gkag efrk rmesfg}r xm`sg kc xtkogbwt`a kxgffgss `fb rt`fsx`tgfou du `olfkzagbjefj rmgtgag`fog kc efbejgfkws esswgs! rmget fggb ckt sxgoe`a `ookiikb`rekfs `fb rmgetokaagoreg `wrkfkiu& @s gebgfogb ef Ja`ies Jkab! efrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr`tdert`rekf es! ef xt`oreog! ` xkrgfre`a bgoesekf)i`lgt ef i`rrgts okfogtfefj rmgtga`rekfsmex dgrzggf efbejgfkws xgkxags `fb rmg f`rekf)sr`rg `fb rmws smkwab

tgokjfe~g efbejgfkws xgkxags `s x`tr kc rmget fgz okfsrerwgfou&

Du jt`frefj efbejgfkws xgkxags rmg tejmr rk efrgtgfg ef efrgtf`rekf`a`tdert`rekf! efrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr a`z zeaa sr`u `rrwfgb rk rmg bggakxigfrs efefrgtf`rekf`a mwi`f tejmrs! `keb xkrgfre`a efokmgtgfog `fb! iktg eixktr`frau!xtggfr rmg fgjagor kc efbejgfkws xgkxags― mwi`f tejmrs& Er es `dkwr reigefbejgfkws xgkxags gigtjg ctki rmg sm`bkzs kc okakfe`aesi efrk ` jtkzefj tkag `sfkf)sr`rg `orkts ef efrgtf`rekf`a efgsrigfr a`z! `s rmgu m`g bkfg ef krmgt ckt`&035 

035 _gg D`tsm! swxt` fkrg 35! `r =70&