34
WIMPs: Status and prospects Giorgio Arcadi MPIK Heidelberg

WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

WIMPs: Status and prospects

Giorgio ArcadiMPIK Heidelberg

Page 2: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Motivation and overview

WIMP paradigm is an elegant solution for the Dark Matter problem.

We provide an overview of the capability of current and future DirectDetection experiments of testing the WIMP paradigmCase of study:‘‘Dark Portals‘‘

Critical assement about the theoretical limitations of ‘‘simplified“ darkmatter models and the possibility of embedding in UV complete setups.

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 3: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

WIMP scenarios feature a strong complementarity between Dark Matter searches.

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 4: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Abdallah et al. arXiv:1506.03316

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 5: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Simplified models: “Dark portals“

Mediator sector

Visible sector

SM states

Trivial dark sector

Only the DM candidateStabilized by a global symmetry

Single state interacting with DM and fermion pairs.Optional: neutral SM mediators(Higgs, Z, might do the job)

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 6: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Simplified vs UV complete models

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

+ Few free parameters: efficient interface with experimentaloutput

- Overconstrained

- Lack of theoreticalconsistency might affect theoretical predictions.

+More solid predictions.

-Potentially high numberof free parameters

Page 7: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Complementarity in simplified models

Relic density / ID

Direct Detection

Light mediators can beproduced on shell.Additional signals(resonances) also fromdecays into SM particles.

Chala et al. 1503.05916

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 8: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Examples of Dark portals

Spin-0 mediator

Spin-1 mediator

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Not present for Majorana fermions

Page 9: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

WIMP Paradigm

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 10: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

DM Direct Detection

Microscopic description through interactions of DM with quarks (or gluons)

Translated as effective interaction with nucleons.

Two kinds of interactions customarily distinguished

Spin Indipendent (SI) interactions: Sum coherently among nucleons of the targetSpin Dependent (SD) interactions: Sensitive to the contributions from protons and nucleonsto the nuclear spin.

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 11: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Spin-0 Mediator

Spin-1 Mediator

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Zero for Majorana fermions

Page 12: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

(Xenon Collaboration, 1512.07501)

Panda-X Collaboration, 1611.06553

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 13: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Higgs portal

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

G.A., M. Dutra, P. Ghosh, M. Lindner, Y. Mambrini, M. Pierre, F. Queiroz, 1703.07364

Page 14: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Z-portal

Page 15: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Spin-0 (real) mediator

Scalar DM

Vector DM

Fermion DM

G.A., M. Dutra, P. Ghosh, M. Lindner, Y. Mambrini, M. Pierre, F. Queiroz, 1703.07364

Page 16: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Spin-1 mediator

Complex scalar DM

Non abelian vector DM

Dirac fermion DM

Page 17: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Dirac vs Majorana

Page 18: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

ψ ψ

q

A A

q

SI cross-section induced only at one loop

S. Ipek, D. Mckenn and A. Nelson, 1404.3716

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Pseudo-scalar portal

Page 19: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Scalar+(light pseudoscalar mediator)

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Pseudoscalar interpreted as pseudo-goldstone boson of a U(1) global symmetry

Enhanchement of DM annihilation cross-section by light final states.

Page 20: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 21: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

RGE Corrections

F. d’Eramo, B. J. Kavanagh, P. Panci 1605.04917

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 22: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

A. Alves, G.A., Y. Mambrini, S. Profumo, F. Queiroz, 1612.07282

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 23: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

In a not gauge invariant setup axial couplings lead tocross-sections which violate perturbative unitarity(Kahlhoefer et al: 1510.02110)

Unitarity bound

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 24: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Towards UV complete models:spin-0 mediators

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 25: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

DM Interactions

Vector DMFermion DM

Scalar DM

Page 26: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 27: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Extra U(1) from Grand Unified theories

Spin-1 as new gauge bosons

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Spin-1 BSM mediators can be interpreted as gauge bosons of extra symmetrygroups

Page 28: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

General implementation:

Han et al. 1308.2738

Vectorial and axial couplings are actuallycombinations of left-handed and right-handedcurrents

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 29: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

G.A., M. Lindner, Y. Mambrini, M. Pierre, F. Queiroz, 1704.023028

XENON1T

LZ

DARWIN

Page 30: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Coupling with the visible sector throught kinetic mixing

Page 31: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 32: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

t-channel mediators

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Mediator is (partially) charged under the SM group. Possible complementaritywith LHC.

Dark Matter stable only if lighter than the mediator.

Coannihilations possibly relevant for the relic density.

Page 33: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

Page 34: WIMPs: Status and prospects · 2018-09-18 · Only the DM candidate Stabilized by a global symmetry Single state interacting with DM ... theoretical predictions. +More solid predictions.-Potentially

Conclusions

Giorgio Arcadi MPIK 08-05-2017

We have provided an overview of current and next generationDirect Detection facilities of probing the WIMP hypothesis.

Simplest realizations suffer increasing experimental pressure.

Definite statements require to go beyond the ‘simplifiedmodels’ level.