Winstone Wallboards Limited Investigation Closure Report 22 December 2014

8/17/2019 Winstone Wallboards Limited Investigation Closure Report 22 December 2014

1/34

1936595

ISBN 9781869454272

P . 11.3/14505

P

D: 22 D 2014

C . I

.


2/34

2

1936595

CE

E F H E...........................................................................................................3

EECE A ................................................................................................................3

OR INESTIGATION ..................................................................................................................... 3

EGA ...................................................................................................................7 EE F HE E EAAD AEBAD D .....................................................8

PARTICLAR FEATRES OF THE NE EALAND PLASTERBOARD MARKET .................................. 8

MANFACTRING/IMPORTING AND HOLESALING ................................................................... 9

DISTRIBTION ............................................................................................................................. 10

ENDSERS .................................................................................................................................. 11

E AGEEE H ECHA ............................................................. 12

EGA FAE F CECE AC E AED ......................................................... 13

SECTION 27 OF THE COMMERCE ACT ......................................................................................... 13 .......................................................................................... 13 A ........................................................... .......... 14

SECTION 36 OF THE COMMERCE ACT ......................................................................................... 14 ................................................................................................. 15 A .... ......................................................................... ..................................... 15 36

A ............................................................... ................................................................ ....................... 15

DE E HAE ECE AGEEE H ECHA HA BAA

EE CE? ............................................................................................................. 16

D E EBAE HAE HE EFFEC E F BAA EEG

CE? ......................................................................................................................... 17

HO CAN REBATES SBSTANTIALL LESSEN COMPETITION? .................................................... 17

HAE THE REBATES HAD THE EFFECT OF SBSTANTIALL LESSENING COMPETITION? ............ 18 ................................................................ ........ 18

A , , ? ...................................................................... ................................................. 20 ......................... 22

CONCLSION ON HETHER THE REBATES SBSTANTIALL LESSEN COMPETITION ................. 26

E AG ADAAGE F BAA AE E F A A

CEE E? ........................................................................................................... 27

HA E EGAGED EDA CG BEACH F EC 27 36? ............. 27

INSTONES AOIDABLE COSTS ................................................................................................. 27 : ................. 28 ............................................................................................................. 28 .................................................................................................................................. 29 ....................................................... 29

TARGETED PREDATION SCENARIO .............................................................................................. 29

CC .................................................................................................................... 31

AACHE A: EDA AAE AEE F BE C CG ................ 32


3/34

3

1936595

1. T C C (

C) L

() F B G

(GIB).

2. I ,

C A 1986 ( A).

3. T ,

. T ,

, ( )

.

4.

T C , 25 A,

C

.

5. T C ,

, . ,

. H, ,

. R, C

.

E

6. I A 2013, :

6.1

;

6.2

;

6.3 ,

.

7. I O 2013 .


4/34

4

1936595

8. B,

A:

8.1 27

36 A, :

8.1.1

/ ;

8.1.2

, ;1

8.2 27 36 A,

:

8.2.1

;

8.2.2

.

C

9.

:

9.1 ITM, M 10, B

C2

GIB; , ,

9.2

.

10. I ,

/ , , ,

.

11. G

GIB,

.

1 3(5) A, 27.

,

.2 PM . F

, PM.


5/34

5

1936595

12. I ,

. S

. I ,

. I ,

, .

?

13. O

GIB.

14.

. S

,

GIB , , % %

.

15. F, .

?

16. T

GIB,

.

17. (

)

.

18. H, :

18.1 GIB

;

18.2

, :

18.2.1 B C (

);

18.2.2 GIB ,

,

;

18.2.3

;


6/34


7/34

7

1936595

23. S, ,

27 36 .

:

24.

T A.

25.

. T , ,

, ,

.

26. R,

,

B C ,

, ,

.

27. I C

.

28. A 2013

.

.

29.

,

:

29.1 ;

29.2 , PM;

29.3 K, E E ( );

29.4 6

;7

29.5 ;8

29.6 BRAN;9

29.7 C C C.

6

7

8

9 BRAN . BRAN

.


8/34

8

1936595

30. B ,

N .

31. A N ,

,

.10

11

I

,

.

32. T ,

B C

. T

BRAN , , .

12 BRAN

. K BRAN

( ),

. O

, , ,

, B C . S

, , .

33. H, BRAN B C.

E, , BRAN

. I

B C.

34. A, BRAN

, (DI)

, ,

.

35.

R , BRAN . F ,

. I

.13

10 N 3604 .

11 L .

12 ...//

//. 17.

13


9/34

9

1936595

36. A ,

N

. T

1 J 2014. I E ,

0% J 2012.14

/

F 1: F

37. N . I

E, K, B. S 2009 B PR

DI

.15

16

17

14 S P K T N N C S AD D I, M E D, J 1, 2014, 1.

(://...////

/. ).15

B PR 2013.16

PR , , B C . A ,

PR . 17 I , A .


10/34

10

1936595

37.1 E N E B,

T S G C,

B L. E N

25 , .

37.2

K K G KG, G . K N 2013,

( )

C .18

19

K

A, A

C. H, A J 2014. K

A

C.

38. D ,

. I 90% N .20 21

39. T N

GIB

. .22

D

40. P

: PM,

23

C,

24

ITM,

25

B

26

M 10.

27

28

N ,

.18

K E N 1 J 2013. E N B

P T 2008 2013.19

20

21 I J 2014, D T, G M,

94% . ://...///.?=3&=11189400 22

23

T 58 PM N . PM

.24

C C H H L. C

.25

ITM . ITM . I 93

N .26

B P L. B 51 N .

B DI .27

M 10 . I 38 M M 10 H H . M 10 DI

.


11/34

11

1936595

41. T N

.29

T 1 , /

2013.

1: /

/

(2013)

PM %

C %

ITM %

M 10 %

B %

O %

S %

S: L (14 O 2013)

42. T ,

( ). B (

PR ),

GIB. A . O

.

E

43. E , ,

DI .

44. GIB ,

, . F

,

30 :

44.1 ;

44.2 ;

44.3 31

45. .

28 T B. I

N I C. BL

.29

, , % GIB

.30

31


12/34

12

1936595

46. . T

, :

46.1

;

46.2 , ;

46.3 ,

.

47. T 2

PM ,

30 J 2013. I , %

$ , % $ .

2: B

30 2013

F E

2013 C 10 B

F R

S

G

A S

S P A

S

F A S

F P

R

F F S

S: L (31 O 2013)

48. R

.


13/34

13

1936595

3:

20102013

C 10 B B

2013

2012

2011

2010

S: L (31 O 2013)

C A

27 C A

49.

27 A.

50. S 27

,

.

51. T . I

( )

( ).

52.

I, . I

.32 S 27 , ,

, . I

27 ,

, .33

53.

. A

.34

54.

O

. M

. T

, ,

.

55. I , ,

( , ).35

32 A A 2006 3 NLR 351 (CA), 242.

33

2007 NCA 302 113.34 HC CI2001485917, 13 D

2007 343.


14/34

14

1936595

56. A

. T

, .36

57. I ,

.37

58. I ,

/

. O (

) .38

A

59. E ,

A. O ,, (

) .39

60.

.

H,

. , ,

, ,

. I ,

, ,

.40

36 C A

61.

36. S 36 A

:

35 A ( 3(2), C A).

36 (CA) 31 562563.

37 & , 1990 2 NLR 731, (HC) 740.

(HC) 25 433; ( ) , (1997)

7 TCLR 463 (HC), 531.38

A , 3(5) A.39

E

. T

36 A.40

A , H C & 1990 2 NLR 731

. T

F & P 75% N

. T C

, 90

.


15/34

15

1936595

61.1 ;

61.2 ;

61.3 .

62. A

.41 R,

.

63. I ,

,

.42

64.

, . A ,

.

A

65. I , (,

) . P

, ,43

.44

36

A

66. A ,

,

. T

.45

67. B

.

68.

C (

) . A

. ,

41 A 2003 195 ALR 609.

42 2010 NSC 111 (0867) 33.

43

S 36B, C A 1990 2 NLR 662 (HC) 709.44 1995 1 NLR 385 (PC).

45 2010 NSC 111, 3435.


16/34

16

1936595

(,

) .46

69. I 36,

(,

),47 . F , ,

.

D

?

70.

GIB. N

,

.

71. T .

B PR GIB. H,

PR GIB.

72. O

.

73. H, 27. T

. A

( % % ).

74. I , .

T 72

GIB ,

. F,

GIB,

.

75.

A ,

, . H,

$ E 30 J 2013.48

46 T P C

2004 11 TCLR PC. T H C

A A 2003

195 ALR 609.47

S B (1996), P L A C T, J L

E 49. T 1995 1 NLR 138 .

48


17/34

17

1936595

D

?

76. T

27 , ,

( ).

77. A ,

.

GIB, ,

B, GIB. I ,

GIB . T

%.49

78.

, , ,

.

79. F ,

. R,

.

H ?

80. A ,

. H,

.

81. T :

81.1 S, A,

,

;

81.2 , , A

;

81.3 A

50

A.51

T

49 T 94% ( 21),

,

. I O 2013,

% .50

S . O

.51 T

A, , 10% 80%


18/34

18

1936595

(,

)

;52

81.4 A

( / ), ( ) ,

;

81.5

,

.

82.

.

83. I , . T ,

27, ,

.

, .

H ?

84. I ,

. R,

.

85. T

. M , ,

,

.

86. H,

. S

A. A, ,

, , 10% 80

A 100

.52

F . F,

, , ,

. S, ,

, , . T,

, .


19/34

19

1936595

.53

T

, GIB,

(

).54

87. O , ,

.

87.1 T

.55

87.2 A

.56

88.

F, 57

. A

,

.

89.

( )

/ GIB.

90.

. A 46, . T

. T

, ,

.58

T

.59

A,

.

53 , .

54 .

55

56

57 C .

58

59


20/34

20

1936595

91. G

27,

.

A , ,

GIB ?

92. T

. T

.

93. B . T

. F ,

.60 I ,

. T ,

, .

94. B, GIB.

H, ,

.

95.

T 61 .

95.1 N

,

.62 I ,

,

.63

95.2 N .

, .

F , .

60

61 .

62 S . T,

, '

.63 F , .


21/34

21

1936595

95.3 N

. M

. ,

, , ,

.

96. H, ( B) . I

.

97. I , :

97.1 ,

.

,

. D ,

.64

97.2

,

. A , (

),

.

97.3 K

:

97.3.1 K' .

A , N

,

.

97.3.2 K ,

,

N .

64

A . A ,

.


22/34

22

1936595

98. G ,

.

S , 93,

.

.

98.1 I J 2013 K , E,

PR B.

B PR

.65

98.2 I J 2014,

K . T .

T

K

, N , .66

98.3 O

E .67

99. O ,

(, B,

).

100.

E , (, 74

75 , ).

T

. I

, , . T ,

.

101. I . P

. I ,

.

102. T , ,

. T

N

65

66

67


23/34

23

1936595

. ,

.

E

103.

E .

103.1 E

, , ( ) . I , E'

BRAN , 2008, 2011.68

S

2011, E '

, B C

. BRAN , E'

% %.

103.2

I E ,

. O E

.69 H,

,

, (

) .

K

104. A K 60

, N .

70

104.1 I BRAN K .

104.2 F K

;71

BRAN

. K

GIB

.72

104.3

A , , N (), K

68

69

70

71

...////. 17.

72


24/34

24

1936595

, , ,

.73

104.4 K A .

A ,

( %) K' N .

74 I GIB

.

104.5 K A

C,

.

104.6

75

104.7 A 97.3, K

.

105. , , K N

, .

105.1

I K BRAN BRAN

.

105.2 K

. T

.76

105.3 K % %

, % %

.77

106. T , K N

. G ,

.

73

74

75

76

77


25/34

25

1936595

78

O

107.

T N . A , K

E

GIB , BRAN

.79

T

GIB N ,

, .80

108. F , :

/

B C, : . T

I , ,

.81

109. GIB . T

/ .82

:

;

. C GIB

.83

110. S

. H,

B C.84

T

B C

.85

78

79

80 MBIE R C S M S

.80

81

82

83

84

85


26/34

26

1936595

111.

, ,

27 A. B , ,

, . B (

) ,

.

112. A, ,

. S

.

112.1

86

112.2 87

113. GIB,

( ).

C

114. O

27.

, . F, K E

.

115. H,

, E

K, ,

'

.

116. ,

. A ,

'

.

86

87


27/34

27

1936595

?

117. I

36. A , 36,

.

118. G ,

. 36

.

H 27 36?

119. T ,

.

120. A

,

.

121.

.

. R,

.88

122. GIB,

. T

; ,

, .

123. T ' , ,

36 27 A. M ,

, ,

.

124. H,

GIB, .

125. T 36 .

. N, ,

, ,

88 2013 A R .


28/34

28

1936595

(,

).

126. I , , .

36

27.

:

127.

( )

. T

.

128. T

.

129. I,

. I ,

K E ( ).

130. A

. B , ,

. T

.

131. O

%, %. T

:

131.1 GIB

94% ;89

131.2 E % ;

131.3

K % %. K N

%,

;

131.4 % B GIB.90

132. D , ,

.

89 S 21.

90


29/34

29

1936595

133. A

,

. M . A

.

134. ,91

.

135. B ,

%,

, .

136. T

% . (A A

.)

137. H, , ,

.

138.

. ; ,

, , .

139. T

. T ,

. I ,

( )

, , , .

140.

/, %.

91 T . T

. T ,

.

T

.


30/34

30

1936595

141. H, , %

.92

142. E K

.93

142.1 E

E . .

E

,

.

142.2 K

K .

.

, .

143. O

, (C C)

.

4: A

C

( GB

10)

/

C A ( ) AC B ( ) A

C C ( ) B

C D ( ) A

C E ( ) A

C F ( ) A

C G ( ) A

C H ( ) A

C I ( ) A

92 O % . T

(C C) T 4.93


31/34

31

1936595

5: A

C

( GB

10)

/

C J ()

A

C K (

)

A

C L ( ) A

144. H,

, ,

. T

.

145.

50% .

146. G ,

. T,

.

147. T A.

148.

. T , ,

, ,

.

149. R,

,

B C ( ), ,

, .

150. I C

.


32/34

32

1936595

A A:

1. T

, . T

122 138 .

2. F , , :

2.1

( );

2.2

(

) ( ).

B

3. B .

4. F B, B

% ,

.

5. T B

F 2.94

F

F 2, :

5.1 ,

;

5.2 ( ),

%.

F 2: E B 95

6. T ITM

F 3.

7. ITM ,

. H, ITM

94

T (, ).

95


33/34

33

1936595

. .

8. F F 3, :

8.1 ,

;

8.2 ,

%.

F 3: E

10

9. T M 10

F

4.

10. M 10 ,

. H,

, M 10

.

11. F F 4, :

11.1 ,

;

11.2 ,

%.

F 4: E 10

C

12. T C

F

5.

13. C ,

. A ,

C

.


34/34

34

14. F F 5, :

14.1 ,

;

14.2

, %.

F 5: E C

Documents

Winstone Wallboards Limited Investigation Closure Report 22 December 2014