Upload
vankhanh
View
214
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
The Hudson Wing was opened in 2008
with a spacious 37-bed Emergency Department,
a 20-bed Critical Care Unit, and a 42-bed
inpatient suite.
Best Practices in Action•Yearbook•
TM
Arts & Culture
Greater Los Angeles Zoo AssociationMoving to a Data Rich Research Environment.................................................................................. 6
The Walters Art MuseumLeveraging WealthEngine to Build Community and Donors............................................................... 8
eduCAtion
Colorado State UniversityFinding New Donors and ROI with Reliable Analytics...................................................................... 12
Duke University, The Fuqua School of BusinessCreates a Routine Screening Process to Feed Monthly Prospect Pipeline ........................................... 14
Le Moyne College’s Research DepartmentClose Relationship with Development Officers Yields High Campaign Returns................................... 16
Northwestern UniversityFive-year Screening Strategy Propels Prospect Pool and Parents’ Fund.............................................. 20
Roanoke CollegeIntegrates WealthEngine Screening Data into Colleague Advancement to Streamline Workflow......... 22
Saint Mary’s CollegeUses Wealth Screening to Segment and Identify New Prospects....................................................... 24
Washington & Lee UniversityUses Peer Screening to Identify Major Gift Prospects........................................................................ 26
HospitAls & HeAltHCAre
Beebe Medical FoundationCreates Seamless Prospecting Workflow......................................................................................... 30
Penn MedicineUses Physicians to Advance Grateful Patient Program..................................................................... 33
Saint Barnabas Healthcare SystemUsing Prospect Research to Target Top Patient Prospects................................................................. 34
nonprofit
Cape Cod Commercial Hook Fisherman’s AssociationPuts Prospect Research to Work in a Tough Economy....................................................................... 38
TABle of ConTenTs
TM
www.wealthengine.com6
The Greater Los Angeles Zoo AssociationMoving to a Data Rich Research Environment
“WealthEngine.has.given.us.so.much.to.work.with,”.explains.Keith.Niles,.senior.database.analyst.for.the.Greater.Los.Angeles.Zoo.Association.(GLAZA),.the.fundraising.arm.of.the.Los.Angeles.Zoo.
and.Botanical.Gardens..“Basically,.we.now.have.a.wealth.of.quality,.actionable.data,.thanks.to.the.screening.we.performed.through.WealthEngine.”
GLAZA.has.traditionally.had.a.sizable.number.of.prospects.and.names;.in.fact,.the.membership.database.alone.holds.64,000.households.and.about.300,000.records..Meanwhile,.the.Zoo.staff.includes.only.one.prospect.researcher,.Michelle.Mesrobian..And,.while.Mesrobian.handles.the.Zoo’s.prospect.research,.she.is.also.responsible.for.donor.relations.and,.most.recently,.was.named.project.manager.for.the.Zoo’s.feasibility.study.in.preparation.for.an.upcoming.capital.campaign.
This.past.spring,.management.began.to.consider.research.approaches.with.two.goals.in.mind:.1).save.time.and.2).deliver.increased.return.on.investment..In.May.
2009,.management.selected.WealthEngine.and.engaged.its.screening.services.
The.Zoo.now.uses.the.results.of.this.screening.in.three.ways:
• To increase gift amounts from direct-mail respondents..The.Zoo.conducts.four.direct.mail.appeals.each.year:.the.President’s.appeal,.a.General.Conservation.appeal,.a.June.appeal.and.a.December.appeal..Mesrobian.says,.“To.date,.the.giving.has.gone.well.and.gift.amounts.have.increased..The.latest.appeal.included.a.match.challenge,.and.results.were.up.”.Niles.reports.the.Zoo.mailed.to.1,340.households.and.achieved.an.average.gift.response.of.$338—more.than.double.the.norm..Niles.adds,.“Our.average.gift.amount.has.typically.been.$150.”.
• To identify interviewees for the upcoming campaign feasibility study. The.Zoo.used.the.WealthEngine.screening.results.to.help.identify.600.potential.donors.that.have.been.invited.to.participate.in.personal.interviews..The.information.collected.from.those.participating.in.the.interviews.will.be.used.to.help.determine.the.fundraising.potential.and.goal.for.the.campaign.
• To help launch a planned giving program.The.Zoo.had.begun.its.planned.giving.program.early.this.year.with.the.first.mailing.of.a.quarterly.planned.giving.newsletter.to.7,400.households..Niles.says,.“The.WealthEngine.screening.helped.us.refine.and.better.focus.our.mailing.efforts..The.age.overlay.alone.was.huge.for.us.because.it.allowed.us.to.add.new.prospects.that.are.more.financially.mature.and.have.high.P2G℠.(Propensity.to.Give).scores..It.also.allowed.us.to.save.money.by.helping.us.clean.and.streamline.our.list,.removing.prospects.not.likely.to.give.to.the.Zoo.”
“The screening results were amazing. For example, we were immediately able to identify one-time small donors of under $100, but who had great capacity to give larger gifts.”
—Michelle Mesrobian, Prospect Researcher, Greater Los Angeles Zoo Association
Client Case Study
www.wealthengine.com7
More Data for Better and Faster Fundraising ResultsNiles.finds.the.WealthEngine.data.invaluable.in.analyzing.past.donor.attributes.and.compiling.profiles.for.new.prospects..He.says,.“I.look.at.past.donors.and.their.attributes.and.then.analyze.the.prospect.profiles.we.receive.from.WealthEngine.for.similar.attributes.”.For.annual.appeals,.Niles.looks.at.charitable.giving.history,.stock.holdings.and.pensions,.real.estate.holdings,.political.campaign.donations,.and.gift.capacity.ranges..Again,.his.goal.is.to.identify.direct-mail.respondents.who.will.make.increasingly.larger.gifts.
WealthEngine.data.also.played.a.significant.role.in.helping.Niles.analyze.planned.giving.prospects..He.says,.“For.our.planned.giving.prospects,.I.look.at.data.from.WealthEngine.
such.as.P2G.scores,.political.donations,.and.age..Also,.gift.capacity.amounts.are.very.important.for.me.when.putting.together.this.prospect.list..WealthEngine.is.able.to.
give.me.all.this.information.and.more.”
WealthEngine: “Always Quick and Easy to Use”Mesrobian.uses.another.WealthEngine.tool,.FindWealth.Online℠,.when.she.needs.to.research.new.prospects..She.says,.“FindWealth.Online.is.the.first.place.
I.go,.when.I’m.given.a.new.name..It.has.a.great.interface.and.is.always.quick.and.easy.to.use.”.Typically,.she.will.use.FindWealth.Online.to.pull.a.profile.on.a.first-time.
donor,.a.new.Zoo.member,.or.an.individual.that.a.board.member.or.the.Director.of.Development.plans.to.meet.with.or.solicit..Both.speed.and.ease.of.use.are.requirements.
for.Mesrobian.in.her.busy.work.day—she.has.found.that.WealthEngine.delivers.both.
TM
www.wealthengine.com8
The Walters Art MuseumLeveraging WealthEngine to Build Community & Donors
“I.use.WealthEngine.almost.every.day,”.says.Julia.Keller,.Manager.of.Individual.and.Corporate.Giving.Circles.at.The.Walters.Art.Museum.in.Baltimore,.MD..A.few.tools.within.WealthEngine’s.product.that.Keller.finds.most.valuable.are.the.LexisNexis.Real.Estate.data,.the.Circle.of.Friends.and.the.Propensity.to.Give.(P2G).ratings.
“WealthEngine.is.the.first.place.I.go.when.museum.leadership.asks.for.information.on.a.prospect,”.explains.Keller..“I’m.able.to.get.a.brief.summary.of.that.individual.easily.and.quickly.”.Keller.regularly.uses.WealthEngine.data.to.prepare.short.biographical.paragraphs.on.prospects,.so.board.members.and.fundraising.volunteers.can.know.more.about.the.prospects..Other.times,.Keller.will.use.WealthEngine.data.for.comprehensive.research.on.a.prospect:.where.he.or.she.lives,.net.worth,.and.how.that.net.worth.was.acquired.
The.mission.of.the.Walters.Art.Museum.is.‘to.bring.art.and.people.together.for.enjoyment,.discovery,.and.learning.’.We.strive.to.create.a.place.where.people.of.every.background.can.be.touched.by.art..Monthly.receptions.are.one.way.the.museum.works.to.achieve.this.mission—and.to.attract.new.donors.and.more.contributions..On.average,.30-40.donors.attend.each.reception,.with.some.drawing.100.guests.
When.Keller.first.came.to.Walters,.the.museum.held.these.receptions.for.current.members.at.the.time.of.their.renewals..While.the.museum.continues.to.invite.current.members.to.the.reception,.they.now.use.these.events.as.a.cultivation.tool.for.new.donors..Keller.says,.“The.receptions.are.designed.to.showcase.particular.parts.of.the.permanent.collection.as.well.as.special.exhibitions.the.museum.hosts.throughout.the.year..Because.of.the.exhibition.variety.and.our.efforts.with.WealthEngine,.we.can.encourage.a.larger,.more.strategic.universe.of.prospects.to.come.out.for.a.night.of.art.and.donor.cultivation.”
Keller.tailors.each.guest.list.to.the.specific.reception.theme..In.2000,.the.museum.had.surveyed.its.membership,.asking.each.member.to.identify.personal.favorites.in.the.collection..Keller.uses.this.information.to.identify.current.members.to.invite.to.a.particular.reception..Then,.using.WealthEngine,.she.works.to.identify.prospects.to.be.invited,.based.on.interests.and.giving.capacity..For.example,.for.the.current.exhibition.focusing.on.an.early.American.artist,.Rembrandt.Peale:.Portrait.of.John.Meer,.Keller.used.WealthEngine’s.FindWealth.Online.to.research.donors.of.nearby.organizations.with.American.art.interests..She.looked.at.each.prospect’s.giving.capacity.as.well.as.their.P2G.score..If.the.prospect.seems.to.be.a.good.match.with.the.museum,.Keller.will.also.use.WealthEngine.to.obtain.the.prospect’s.mailing.address,.so.the.individual.may.be.invited.to.a.particular.reception..Keller.used.this.same.technique.when.a.former.Cardinal.was.speaking.at.the.Walters..She.pulled.names.from.the.local.Catholic.organizations.and.hospital.donor.lists,.and.then.researched.them.in.WealthEngine.
Walters’ Monthly Receptions Increase Contributions by $30,000 and add 20-30 New Donors.
Client Case Study
www.wealthengine.com9
“Any.new.donors.we’ve.attracted.from.these.events.in.the.past.four.years.have.been.vetted.by.WealthEngine,”.says.Keller..Her.work.and.research,.as.well.as.WealthEngine’s.data,.is.paying.off.for.the.Walters...Results.over.the.past.year.include:
•. The.Walters.has.realized.$30,000.in.new.or.increased.donations.from.those.who.attended.the.receptions.
•. 20-30.new.donors.were.acquired.•. The.December.2008.reception.realized.more.than.$2,000.in.sales.at.the.
museum.store.•. Many.individuals.renew.their.memberships.after.receiving.a.reception.invitation,.
even.though.they.do.not.attend.the.event.
Other Everyday Uses of WealthEngineLexisNexis.Real.Estate.data.is.a.powerful.and.versatile.resource.for.Keller..The.Walters.
has.a.current.database.of.about.60,000.names..Keller.uses.LexisNexis.to.update.current.donor.addresses..She.also.uses.it.to.find.the.addresses.of.new.prospects.
“The.P2G.score.is.an.important.analytics.tool.for.me,”.notes.Keller..“I.use.it.to.identify.the.prospects.we.should.target.first.”.Another.initiative.of.the.Museum.is.to.upgrade.members.of.the.Annual.Giving.Circles—moving.their.annual.donations.from.$150.to.$250..Again,.WealthEngine’s.ratings.and.scores.allow.the.Walters’.staff.the.ability.to.prioritize.the.most.likely.prospects.for.the.upgrade..
“When.working.with.the.board.and.fundraising.volunteers.on.peer.screening,.I.first.go.to.FindWealth.Online.to.develop.the.skeleton.of.a.prospect..The.Circle.of.Friends.
helps.us.to.identify.relationships.we.may.not.know.about,”.says.Keller.
The Economy’s ImpactHow.has.the.Walters.Art.Museum.been.responding.to.the.economic.climate?.Keller.responds,.“We’ve.tailored.our.message..In.December,.we.sent.a.‘state.of.the.museum’.letter..We.are.stressing.that.we.are.still.vibrant,.and.there’s.lots.to.do.here..We.are.free,.and.we.will.remain.a.free.museum..In.fact,.more.than.22,000.schoolchildren.were.able.to.visit.our.museum.free.of.charge.last.year.”
“The.Walters.Museum.is.a.community.museum,”.closes.Keller..“Sometimes,.the.economic.climate.prompts.people.to.give.more..In.down.times.I’ve.found.that.donors.want.to.continue.supporting.the.things.that.they.feel.passionate.about—like.our.museum—because.they.want.to.ensure.its.longevity..Many.are.giving.at.higher.levels.to.help.us.weather.this.recession.”
Together,.WealthEngine.and.Keller.are.helping.Walters.reach.more.prospects.and.donors.each.day.so.they.can.continue.to.bring.art.and.learning.to.the.Maryland.community.
TM
www.wealthengine.com12
Colorado State UniversityFinds New Donors & ROI with Reliable Analytics
In.these.tough.economic.times,.prospect.researchers.like.Jim.Beikler.and.the.research.staff.at.Colorado.State.University.are.using.WealthEngine.more.than.ever..Why?..Because.WealthEngine.delivers..Beikler,.who.has.used.a.number.of.screening.services.since.he.entered.the.profession.in.1984,.began.working.with.WealthEngine.in.September.2006.when.the.university.did.a.screening.of.the.more.than.237,000.individuals.in.their.system—the.first.comprehensive.screening.at.CSU.since.1992...The.institution.followed.this.screening.with.three.more.in.2007.and.one.in.November.2008;.systematically.screening.all.new.individuals.entered.into.the.system.
CSU SuccessesSo,.what.are.the.bottom-line.results.to.date?
• Two$1.5millioncommitments.Beikleradds,“And,botharefromindividualswewouldneverhaveconsideredtopprospectswithoutWealthEngine.”
• Oneplannedgift.• AnewpoolofprospectsfromtheNovember2008screening,madeupof6householdswithagivingcapacityof$5
million+,54householdsat$1million+,and186householdsat$.5million+.Onceagain,allnewtopprospects.• And,96ofthosehouseholdsindentifiedsincethefirstscreeningin2006withagivingcapacityof$5million+have
yettobefullycultivatedorsolicited…thinkofthepotentialhere!
Beikler.shares.some.of.CSU’s.strategies.for.effectively.using.WealthEngine.results...He.says,.“We’ve.made.WealthEngine.data.a.part.of.the.environment.for.our.front-line.fundraisers...Now,.whenever.a.gift.officer.signs.on.to.SunGard’s.Advance.to.get.constituent.information,.he.or.she.will.see.the.WealthEngine.data.integrated.right.into.the.constituent’s.record.on.the.front.screen..They.can.also.pull.the.information.into.web-based.user.defined.reports.right.on.their.desktops.or.mobile.devices.”
Data Validation“In.addition,.we.take.the.WealthEngine.data.and.check.it..Overall,.WealthEngine.information.is.on.target.70-80%.of.the.time.as.shown.in.our.manual.verification.of.over.5,400.individual.entities.with.a.high.level.screening.score...In.the.other.minority.of.instances,.we.add.in.our.own.research.and.change.the.rating..Our.front-line.officers.know.we’ve.done.our.homework,.they.see.all.of.the.information.and.they.have.a.stronger.confidence.in.our.prospect.pool,”.continues.Beikler.
Jim Beikler at the 2008 APRA Int’l. Conference.
Client Case Study
www.wealthengine.com13
Not.only.does.CSU.validate.the.data,.so.does.WealthEngine..For.example,.our.analysts.have.found.that.in.the.few.instances.when.the.Estimated.Giving.Capacity.is.off.target,.the.majority.are.identified.as.under-valued.because.of.one.of.the.following.reasons:
• Assetsareheldinatrustorotherwisehiddenfrompublicview• Prospectsaged70+haveconvertedassetstonon-publiclyavailablesources• Addressorotherdatasuppliedbyclientwasinaccurateordated
A.very.small.percentage.is.over-valued,.often.due.to:
• Commonname• Familymemberswiththesamename• Financialservicesrepresentativeholdingothers’assetstemporarilyintheirownname(venture
capitalists,hedgefundmanagers,etc.).
Overall,.the.ratings.are.a.fast.and.essential.guide.to.defining.screening.results..These.analytics.can.be.used.as.the.foundation.for.successful.prospect.research.and.donor.cultivation.
Streamlined Communication StrategyCSU.has.developed.a.streamlined.means.of.communication.between.the.five.prospect.researchers.on.staff.and.the.approximately.50.front-line.fundraisers...Based.on.the.giving.capacity.and.P2G.(Propensity.to.Give).score,.Beikler.and.his.colleagues.will.flag.certain.individuals.as.‘hot.prospects.’.Once.flagged,.a.‘hot.prospect.alert’.is.sent.out.to.all.fundraisers,.so.a.gift.officer.may.request.assignment.to.that.new.contact.as.soon.as.possible...The.prospect.research.team.also.puts.out.an.internal.monthly.newsletter.which.identifies.all.assigned.and.unassigned.hot.prospects.
In.2007,.CSU.began.screening.both.new.parents.and.‘new.friends.of.CSU’.each.semester...Beikler.says,.“The.WealthEngine.screening.identified.dozens.of.high-end.people.we.didn’t.even.know.about.”.Again,.the.pay-off.was.well.worth.the.cost.of.the.screening.
What’s.ahead?..Beikler.sums.up,.“Together,.with.WealthEngine,.we.are.looking.forward.to.expanding.into.new.realms...We.always.look.to.do.what.we.do.best,.and.so.does.WealthEngine...It’s.a.great.partnership...We.know.WealthEngine.listens...They.will.change.to.meet.our.needs.and.to.align.with.our.goals.”
TM
www.wealthengine.com14
The Fuqua School of BusinessCreates a Routine Screening Process to Feed Monthly Prospect Pipeline
Duke.University’s.The.Fuqua.School.of.Business.needed.a.new.approach.to.screening.their.database.of.13,000.alumni.records.during.the.silent.phase.of.their.campaign...Rather.than.screen.all.at.once.and.risk.using.outdated.data.and.ratings.during.validation.and.cultivation,.they.opted.to.categorize.the.alumni.by.state.and.screen.smaller.groups.on.a.monthly.basis...
Creating a ‘Hot List’The.process.is.“very.helpful.to.maintain.fresh.data,.provide.new.prospects.and.keep.us.on.track,”.says.Tracey.Martin,.Prospect.&.Research.Coordinator...“We.take.the.screened.data.and.prioritize.the.list.by.giving.capacity,.starting.from.the.$1M.level.down.to.$100,000,.briefly.scanning.the.bottom.of.the.list.for.anyone.we.know.to.have.a.higher.capacity...Once.we.have.segmented.the.list,.we.look.at.key.features.including.the.P2G.(Propensity.to.Give).score,.stock.holdings.and.quality.of.match.data...We.overlay.inclination.ratings.and.deem.those.with.a.capacity.over.$500,000.as.our.‘hot.list’.”.Anyone.with.a.giving.capacity.under.$100,000.is.forwarded.to.the.Central.office.for.annual.fund.and.reunion.year.development.
A Sustainable Return on InvestmentMartin.has.realized.an.impressive.return.from.the.first.five.states.screened:.
Screening Results Number of Alumni Records
Data from five states 2,647
Number of records returned from screening 1,441
Number of records previously never rated 1,182 = new prospects
Number of records with an increased rating 125
Number of records with a decreased rating 134
Number of records with a rating over $100K 937=65%
“In just a few months of routine screening, we have identified 1,182 new prospects. Our major gift officers are thrilled that we continue to replenish the pipelines with such strong constituents.”
—Tracey Martin, Prospect & Research Coordinator, Duke University’s The Fuqua School of Business
Client Case Study
www.wealthengine.com15
“Comments.from.gift.officers.are.positive;.they.say.that.the.routine.screenings.help.them.identify.whom.they.should.target.first,.meanwhile.I.can.cut.or.lower.codes.on.others,”.notes.Martin...The.ongoing.influx.of.data.leads.to:
• Swiftdeliveryofrecords• Datathatiscurrentanddividedinto“manageablechunks”• AccurateinformationgatheredfromoverlayssuchasNCOA(NationalChangeofAddress)thatfind“lost”alumni• Valuableupdatesincludingemployment,homeandbusinessaddresses,stockandotherbiographicalinformation
Duke.University’s.The.Fuqua.School.of.Business.has.taken.a.proactive.approach.to.wealth.screening.and.uses.monthly.batch.screenings.to.quickly.validate.top.prospects.and.create.routine.workflows.that.feed.development.officers.a.fresh.pipeline.of.new.prospects.on.an.ongoing.basis...Each.month,.an.average.of.187.prospects.with.a.major.gift.rating.over.$100,000.are.pushed.to.development.officers—making.cultivation.a.routine,.actionable.and.manageable.part.of.the.advancement.workflow.
TM
www.wealthengine.com16
Le Moyne College’s Research DepartmentClose Relationship with Development Officers Yields High Campaign Returns
Having.worked.at.Le.Moyne.College.for.over.20.years,.Deborah.Reinhardt.Youmans.has.learned.how.to.build.value.into.a.prospect.research.management.program...When.she.first.started.as.Director.for.Advancement.Research,.the.school.was.spending.significantly.on.prospect.research.and.screening.tools.but.wasn’t.applying.the.information.in.a.strategic.and.team-oriented.approach.to.realize.strong.returns.on.investment...Today,.her.strategy.involves.routine.donor.and.prospect.screenings,.ongoing.prospect.tracking,.and.more.importantly,.prospect.management.meetings.in.close.coordination.and.communication.with.development.officers...“The.bottom.line.is.that.everyone.involved.in.fundraising.has.to.work.as.a.team.and.that.requires.each.individual.to.take.responsibility.for.what.he.or.she.is.here.to.do...You.hold.yourself.accountable.for.the.role.you.play.on.the.team,.as.should.those.around.you,”.says.Reinhardt.Youmans.
At.Le.Moyne,.prior.to.any.solicitation.visit,.the.staff.assigned.(including.the.President.and.Vice.President).meet.with.the.Research.Department.and.agree.on.the.amount.that.will.be.asked...“Yes,.our.profiles.have.the.suggested.ask.and.all.the.data.and.analysis.to.back.it.up,”.says.Reinhardt.Youmans,.“But,.I.have.found.that.this.simple.process.of.meeting.prior.to.a.solicitation.helps.to.build.the.team.atmosphere,.boost.the.confidence.of.those.going.out,.and.forces.a.meeting.of.the.minds...You.may.need.to.role.play.Scenario.A.and.Scenario.B.with.the.staff.assigned,.while.at.the.same.time.trust.their.ability.to.make.the.right.judgment.call.during.the.visit.”
Routine Screenings Keep Campaign on Target from the StartLe.Moyne.screens.their.donor.database.every.two.years.and.freshman.parents.on.an.annual.basis...Reinhardt.Youmans.sets.her.own.internal.gift.capacity.rating.and.then.applies.WealthEngine’s.capacity.and.inclination.ratings.to.validate.matches.and.flag.variances.for.further.investigation...She.is.a.firm.believer.that.“screenings.should.be.used.to.confirm.top.level.prospects.and.identify.those.up.and.comers.for.the.next.campaign...If.you.are.using.a.screening.now.to.identify.new.major.donors.for.your.current.campaign,.you’ve.missed.the.mark.from.a.timing.perspective.”.
“We use routine screenings to identify new prospects and confirm targets. Screening results for our prospects are usually in line with our own gift capacity codes. In reality, there should be no surprises because those at the top of the gift pyramid are monitored closely. On the other hand, screening plays a vital role in the identification of those up and coming.
I would rather have my heart rate accelerate because a development officer on the road contacts me to let me know that the visit resulted in a gift coming in on target with our solicitation strategy, than the alternative. It is an affirmation that our process of calculating gift capacity ratings is right on the money.”
—Deborah Reinhardt Youmans, Director for Advancement Research,
Le Moyne College
Client Case Study
www.wealthengine.com17
Tracking is Key “I.expect.Research.to.continuously.identify,.screen.and.qualify.prospects,”.adds.Reinhardt.Youmans...“But.that.is.only.one.piece.of.the.puzzle,.as.the.most.important.step.is.moving.those.potentials.into.the.pipeline.to.build.relationships...We.have.regularly.scheduled.meetings.where.those.identified.are.added.to.portfolios.based.on.the.region.assignments.of.our.development.staff...Portfolios.are.also.built.based.on.the.level.of.giving,.the.specific.passions.of.the.prospect.and.in.truth,.the.personality.and.skill.level.of.the.development.staff...We.include.all.relevant.development.staff.in.the.meeting,.as.that.heightens.not.only.the.team.atmosphere,.but.forces.open.and.honest.communication...You.learn.when.to.push.and.when.to.pull.as.those.added.to.portfolios.are.tempered.with.those.that.need.to.be.removed...If.you.as.a.researcher.are.credible,.your.involvement.and.advice.during.these.meetings.is.valuable.and.prized.”.
Le.Moyne.uses.two.different.approaches.when.reviewing.high-level.prospects...For.Major.Gift.prospects.($50,000-$249,000),.they.focus.on.the.specific.ask.amount.derived.from.screening.details.and.other.research.data...For.higher.level.Pacesetters.($250,000+),.they.identify.cultivation.and.solicitation.strategies.to.better.determine.“what.makes.them.tick.”
Tracking.helps.Research.evaluate.how.close.their.original.capacity.ratings.were.to.the.final.ask,.which.the.research.team.reviews.and.approves.before.it’s.made...Tracking.the.ask.amount.ensures.that.future.requests.are.well.planned.and.executed...“Close.to.90%.of.the.solicitations.we.make.are.returned.with.a.gift,”.shares.Reinhardt.Youmans,“because.our.donors.have.such.strong.loyalty.to.the.school.and.we’ve.experienced.such.a.high.return.from.our.prospect.tracking.process,.I.want.to.make.sure.that.our.expectations.are.clearly.on.target.with.every.gift.received.”
Le.Moyne’s.success.is.also.due.to.the.donor.relationships.nurtured.by.development.officers...“We.measure.a.development.officer.not.by.the.number.of.donations.they.generate.but.by.the.number.of.visits.they.make.to.a.prospect,.because.we.have.found.a.strong.correlation.between.the.frequency.of.visits.and.resulting.gift,”.says.Reinhardt.Youmans...The.industry.standard.is.generally.one.donor.for.every.three.prospects...Prior.to.May.2009,.development.officers.at.Le.Moyne.had.a.one.to.one.result-oriented.success.ratio.and.their.strategy.is.currently.generating.a.one.gift.per.two.visit.response.among.prospects.
Le.Moyne’s.current.prospect.tracking.process.is.based.on.several.closely.monitored.factors:
• Lengthoftheaveragecultivationcycle• Lengthfrominitialvisittotheask• Proximityofthesuggestedasktothefinalcloseandanyvariables• Commonoccurrencesamongprospects,atvaryinggiftlevels
Client Case Study
www.wealthengine.com19
“In.the.short.term,.it.allows.us.a.snapshot.of.where.we.are.and.where.we.are.headed...In.the.long.term,.it.is.an.invaluable.tool.for.strategic.planning.towards.the.next.campaign,”.explains.Reinhardt.Youmans...“Our.research.and.screening.approach.has.given.us.more.than.2,500.prospects.with.a.gift.capacity.over.$100,000...We.are.fortunate.to.have.more.prospects.than.can.be.assigned.and.since.we’re.in.the.last.year.of.our.campaign.we.aren’t.wasting.time—these.are.the.people.to.visit.now,”.says.Reinhardt.Youmans...“Research.should.always.be.ahead.of.the.curve,.preferably.two.years.out,.and.we.need.to.start.building.the.relationships.now.in.preparation.for.the.next.campaign.”
Build Trust with Your Development TeamLe.Moyne,.established.in.1946,.has.a.relatively.short.history,.compared.to.the.other.28.Jesuit.colleges.and.universities...Le.Moyne.is.just.now.coming.into.its.own.as.a.strong.fundraising.entity.as.prospects.have.reached.the.higher.levels.of.giving...Le.Moyne’s.last.campaign,.Tradition.with.Vision.from.1996-2001,.resulted.in.the.achievement.of.$30.5.million.to.their.goal.of.$25.million.and.garnered.their.first.$1M.gift...Their.current.campaign,.Achieving.New.Heights.from.2004-2010,.has.experienced.far.greater.success,.as.the.tally.of.$90.million.to.their.goal.of.$50.million.is.currently.a.record.and.has.netted.their.first.$5M,.$4M,.$3M.and.$2M.gifts...And,.at.Le.Moyne,.says.Reinhardt.Youmans,.“the.gift.is.not.counted.until.it.is.officially.closed.by.payment.or.by.signed.documentation...We.were.also.fortunate.to.receive.a.$50M.bequest.in.fall.2008,.but.the.moral.of.the.story.is.not.the.amount,.it.is.the.fact.that.in.over.30.years.of.contact.and.stewardship.with.the.prospect,.no.one.dropped.the.ball...That.in.a.nutshell.should.be.the.outcome.of.prospect.management.”
“Against.all.generally-stated.campaign.strategies,”.says.Reinhardt.Youmans,.“we.moved.on.an.inverted.gift.pyramid,.meaning.that.we.hit.the.low-end.and.mid-sections.first...Excluding.board.members,.we.chose.to.leave.our.high-end.prospects.for.the.final.years.of.the.campaign...In.this.time.of.uncertainty,.we.recognized.that.the.‘perception.of.enough’.from.the.donor’s.perspective.can.outweigh.the.actual.reality.of.their.wealth...As.prospects.are.becoming.more.comfortable.with.the.current.economy.and.their.‘perceptions.of.enough’.are.adapting,.we.have.found.that.this.is.the.best.timing.for.solicitations.at.this.level.to.be.made...We.also.kept.moving.forward.during.internal.turnover:.as.our.President.left,.an.Interim.served.and.our.first.lay.President.came.on.board...In.addition,.we.experienced.two.changes.at.the.Vice.Presidential.level.in.our.division...You.have.to.keep.moving.forward.and.remember.the.mission.of.your.organization.”.She.advises,.“The.more.that.you.can.be.a.team.player.and.work.closely.with.your.development.staff,.the.better.your.response.will.be.as.you.build.trust.and.evaluate.whether.the.gift.capacity.and.actual.ask.amount.are.on.target,.time.after.time...The.technical.skills,.art.and.science.required.for.Research.should.never.be.prioritized.above.the.mindset.of.what.you.are.doing.this.for...These.are.some.of.the.tools.to.help.you.get.to.the.finished.product;.they.are.not.in.themselves.the.finished.product...Your.finished.product.is.a.loyal.and.well-stewarded.donor.with.the.recognition.that.it.took.a.team.of.individuals.to.make.it.happen.”
TM
www.wealthengine.com20
Northwestern UniversityFive-Year Screening Strategy Propels Prospect Pool and Parents’ Fund NORTHWESTERN
UNIVERSITY
In.2003,.Northwestern.University.laid.the.groundwork.for.a.systematic.prospect.identification.and.management.program...At.the.time,.the.development.office.struggled.to.define.and.segment.the.university’s.prospect.pool—only.2,200.individuals.carried.any.sort.of.qualification.rating,.and.many.of.the.ratings.were.arbitrary.and.had.not.been.validated.by.the.research.department...As.Northwestern.prepared.for.their.first.major.screening.of.112,000.alumni.records,.they.carefully.defined.two.types.of.qualification.ratings.for.prospects:
1.. An.officer.rating.applied.by.a.development.officer.takes.into.account.the.officer’s.knowledge.of.the.prospect’s.inclination.and.readiness.to.give,.as.well.as.capacity
2.. A.research.capacity.evaluation.determined.by.the.research.department.is.based.on.wealth.and.asset.screening.results.and.other.prospect.data.sources,.and.is.then.validated.by.the.researcher
Following.the.screening,.more.than.10,000.prospects.were.identified,.defined.and.deemed.actionable...Within.three.months,.research.had.identified.and.validated.the.top.1,000.to.target...Today,.they.have.more.than.27,000.in.their.prospect.pool,.the.result.of.a.routine.screening.schedule.and.a.well-planned.system.of.prospect.identification.and.portfolio.management.
Five-Year Screening StrategyWhen.Northwestern.conducted.the.alumni.wealth.and.asset.screening.in.2003,.they.set.in.motion.a.schedule.to.screen.reunion.class.alumni.every.year.(approximately.17,000-20,000.records.annually).to.ensure.that.all.alumni.records.are.refreshed.on.a.five-year.basis...Rather.than.conduct.large.screenings.every.five.years,.this.strategy.ensures.a.live.feed.of.fresh.data,.as.well.as.a.proactive.and.manageable.workflow.for.the.research.team...Jennifer.Fry,.Director.of.Development.Research.and.Prospect.Management.at.Northwestern,.supervises.a.team.of.17.prospect.research.and.information.management.specialists.who.find.these.annual.screenings.“completely.essential.to.our.prospect.identification.strategy.”.
“We.started.by.screening.all.living.alumni.with.accurate.addresses.in.2003,”.explains.Fry...“We.had.some.issues.with.the.results,.so.we.decided.to.switch.screening.vendors,.moving.to.WealthEngine.in.2004.to.re-screen.the.14,360.unvalidated.records.remaining.from.the.larger.screening...That.year,.we.also.conducted.a.“found”.alumni.screening.of.31,000.alumni.with.newly.located.addresses,.to.strengthen.our.alumni.data...As.we.progressed,.we.began.to.venture.beyond.our.alumni.screenings.to.special.projects.that.support.the.requests.and.needs.of.university.initiatives,.such.as.a.grateful.patient.screening.with.the.medical.school.”
“Our return on investment is clear when you consider how we used screenings to double our Parents’ Fund within a year and more than triple it within four years. My advice is to focus on specific groups, rather than overwhelming numbers of records, and plan accordingly. Make sure the data doesn’t sit—allocate an adequate ‘quiet period’ to evaluate results and carefully record your findings. You’ll find that the strategy really works.”
—Jennifer Fry, Director of Development Research & Prospect Management,
Northwestern University
Client Case Study
www.wealthengine.com21
Northwestern’s Screening Strategy Timeline
Adds.Fry,.“We.use.screening.as.our.first.point.of.reference.when.identifying.new.prospects...We.access.current.information.using.WealthEngine’s.FindWealth.Online.tool,.and.then.apply.our.own.formulas.for.the.research.capacity.evaluation.rating.”
Parent Screening ResultsIn.addition.to.alumni,.parent.screenings.are.a.critical.element.to.the.prospect.identification.program;.they.have.shown.a.dramatic.return.on.investment.over.the.past.five.years...Northwestern.only.screens.non-alumni.parents.(alumni.parents.are.picked.up.in.the.routine.alumni.screening),.averaging.approximately.1,600-2,000.per.year...Prior.to.the.first.parent.screening.in.2004,.the.Parents’.Fund.raised.approximately.$500,000.annually...Within.the.first.year.of.screening,.the.Fund.doubled...By.2008,.the.Fund.had.grown.to.$1.75M.and,.despite.tight.economic.times.in.2009,.the.Fund.has.held.steady,.closing.within.1.2%.of.last.year’s.total...
“The.ability.to.identify.new.parents.who.are.capable.of.major.gifts.has.been.a.huge.benefit.for.Northwestern...Prior.to.beginning.the.parent.screening.program,.it.took.much.longer.to.determine.which.parents.were.major.gift.prospects...This.meant.that.sometimes.we.didn’t.start.cultivating.parents.until.their.children.had.been.at.Northwestern.for.a.year.or.two,.or.were.even.about.to.graduate...By.screening.new.parents.of.enrolled.students.annually,.we.can.target.those.who.are.major.gift.prospects.and.connect.with.them.immediately.through.high-level.parent.welcome.events,.rather.than.play.catch-up.with.current.and.past.parents,”.explains.Fry.
Next StepsSpecial.project.screenings.have.supported.other.areas.within.Northwestern,.including.the.Feinberg.School.of.Medicine..Fry.and.the.medical.school.development.office.saw.a.need.for.access.to.hard.asset.data.on.grateful.patients.and.began.screening.in.2007...“Grateful.patient.screenings.have.helped.the.medical.school.become.more.self-sufficient.in.their.prospecting.efforts,.and.my.team’s.research.support.points.them.in.the.right.direction,”.explains.Fry.
Now.that.Northwestern.has.an.efficient.and.effective.program.of.prospect.identification.and.portfolio.management,.they.have.turned.to.analytics.to.broaden.their.scope.of.work...“We’ve.been.screening.since.2003.and.have.a.solid.base.for.our.prospect.research,.as.well.as.a.turnkey.process,”.says.Fry...“Our.next.step.is.to.apply.analytics.to.further.segment.and.clarify.the.prospect.pipeline,.as.well.as.target.our.most.likely.prospective.donors.”
2004-Present1,600-2,000 newparents of students
2005-PresentReunion year alumni
2007-Present18,000 grateful patients initially screened for the medicalschool has led to monthly screenings of new grateful patients as they come through the school’s partner medical group
2003112,000livingalumni
200431,000 “found”alumni with newlylocated addresses
200414,400 unvalidated prospects from the 2003 screening rescreened through new vendor
20097,000 unqualifi ed prospects who had previously been assigned to development offi cers without a research capacity evaluation rating
TM
www.wealthengine.com22
Roanoke CollegeIntegrates WealthEngine Screening Data into Colleague Advancement to Streamline Workflow
Roanoke.College.has.been.a.client.of.Datatel.for.more.than.11.years;.first.using.the.Benefactor.donor.management.system.then.upgrading.to.Colleague.Advancement.in.2008..At.that.time,.Datatel.and.WealthEngine.partnered.to.integrate.WealthEngine.screening.data.into.Colleague.Advancement.which.has.since.created.a.seamless.integration.and.batch.screening.process.that.Roanoke.can.employ.completely.within.their.donor.management.system.
“The.integration.was.very.easy.to.implement,”.says.Robert.Sebesta,.Database.Analyst.at.Roanoke.College..“We.screened.our.complete.database.of.20,000.donor.and.prospect.records;.including.alumni,.parents.and.former.parents.who.have.given.within.the.past.three.years,”.adds.Carolyn.Walter,.Director.of.Development.Research...Walter.manages.the.integrated.upload/download.process.between.Colleague.Advancement.and.WealthEngine.that.has.streamlined.Roanoke’s.data.management.and.created.new,.proactive.research.
opportunities.for.development.staff..The.main.advantage.of.the.integration.is.to.routinely.refresh.donor.
records.to.reflect.current.information.(business.and.real.estate.changes,.stock.
values,.etc.).right.in.the.donor.database..
Fresh Data Leads to New WorkflowWalter.uses.the.screening.results.to.target.major.gift.donors..She.first.identifies.those.individuals.who.WealthEngine.found.to.have.promising.P2G.(Propensity.
to.Give).and.giving.capacity.scores..She.then.compares.these.scores.to.her.own,.pulls.the.matched.list.for.immediate.action.and.then.begins.researching.any.with.
a.variance.between.the.two.scores..From.Colleague.Advancement,.she.can.directly.access.live.updates.from.WealthEngine’s.online.service..
Access.to.fresh.data.has.built.new.workflows.for:
• Special Events—When.an.alumni.chapter.plans.an.event,.Walter.creates.an.expected.attendee.list.for.the.development.officers.who.review.and.plan.cultivation.strategies.
• Freshman Targeting—Parent.screenings.of.incoming.freshman.are.now.performed.every.spring..Walter.shares.the.results.with.development.officers.prior.to.freshman.arrival.and.they.connect.and.cultivate.during.freshman.“move.in”.and.while.parents.are.on.campus..
“The P2G and other ratings gave me a good comparison and were pretty much on target with my own. WealthEngine identified new prospects who turned out to be really great prospects; as well, I found some on my own. Using the two in tandem made my job easier to recognize top prospects, quickly validate and execute an action plan for cultivation, rather than research each one by one.”
—Carolyn Walter, Director of Development
Research, Roanoke College
Client Case Study
www.wealthengine.com23
• Quick Updates—For.freshmen.who.registered.after.the.spring.parent.screening,.Walter.conducts.individual,.online.research.for.quick,.current.information..She.also.uses.the.online.tool.when.she.believes.that.a.parent’s.wealth.may.have.changed.
• New Campaigns—Using.the.P2G.score.from.the.screening.results,.Walter.identified.the.top.freshman.parent.prospects.and.segmented.them.into.groups.for.a.direct.mail.campaign,.sending.personal.invitations.to.major.gift.prospects.to.join.a.special.parent.council..Walter.also.sees.the.possibility.of.using.the.results.for.a.planned.giving.appeal.
• Reporting—A.valued.feature.to.Walter,.she.can.immediately.refresh.and.apply.live.screening.data.to.any.report.she.prepares.within.Colleague.Advancement..The.reports.feature.combines.the.detail.of.the.screening.results.with.key.internal.data.such.as.graduation.year,.school,.etc.,.so.all.relevant.data.is.concise.and.current..
Shared Access Makes Cultivation TimelyUnder.the.new.system,.every.development.officer.has.access.to.the.screening.data.and.can.instantly.view.a.prospect’s.hard.asset.information,.including.analytics.scores..Whether.at.their.desk.or.on.the.road,.the.development.officer.can.research,.target,.and.track.their.best.prospects.from.one.secure.database.with.reliability..Says.Walter,.“I.have.trained.the.development.officers.on.how.to.interpret.the.data,.giving.them.a.base.to.get.started—we.particularly.like.to.see.board.affiliation,.political.donations.and.other.identifiers.of.connections.and.disposable.wealth..The.WealthEngine-Colleague.Advancement.integration.is.very.helpful,.very.robust.and.makes.the.development.officer’s.research,.as.well.as.my.own,.more.timely.and.effective.”
TM
www.wealthengine.com24
Saint Mary’s CollegeUses Wealth Screening to Segment and Identify New Prospects
Saint.Mary’s.College.had.done.a.wealth.screening,.but.it.had.been.years.before.and.no.one.was.involved.in.the.process,.Joni.Warner.explained..So,.Warner,.Director.of.Research.for.Development.at.the.college,.had.a.lot.of.decisions.to.make.as.she.began.to.investigate.the.possibilities.of.a.screening..She.knew.questions.like.these.would.need.to.be.answered:.What.is.our.plan?.What.will.we.find.most.helpful.in.the.results?
Ultimately,.Warner.(with.help.from.Sally.Boucher.from.WealthEngine’s.client.service.team).put.in.place.a.three-step.process.
• StepOne:.Interview.WealthEngine.clients.who.have.recently.completed.screenings.to.find.out.what.data.they.used.and.how.they.used.the.results.
• StepTwo:.Set.goals..Warner’s.goals.included:1.. Eliminate.those.prospects.from.our.pool.who.were.not.(or.did.not).qualify2.. Better.qualify.cultivated.prospects3.. Update.the.database4.. Identify.new.prospects.for.an.upcoming.campaign.
• StepThree:Determine.the.data.and.outcomes.that.the.college.wanted.to.see.as.a.result.of.a.wealth.screening.
Then,.time.for.using.the.results—and.for.success!.They.began.with.a.focus.on.major.gifts.followed.by.the.college’s.annual.fund.and,.finally,.planned.giving..
“A.big.part.of.our.need.was.to.identify.new.prospects,”.explained.Warner..“Weidentified124newprospectsthroughtheWealthEnginescreening..Then,.we.ran.a.report.to.determine.
where.these.prospects.lived..We.distributed.this.data.to.our.gift.officers.based.on.the.regions.to.which.they.were.traveling..This.turned.out.to.be.a.huge.asset.for.our.gift.
officers.”
Next,.Warner.ran.a.report.to.identify.ability.ratings.of.these.new.prospects.as.well..as.the.giving.officers’.existing.prospects..This.proved.even.more.beneficial.to.the.officers..With.only.three.gift.officers.at.Saint.Mary’s.College,.each.has.a.portfolio.of.300-400.prospects.
Saint Mary’s College
Joni Warner is Director of Research for Development at Saint Mary’s College
Client Case Study
www.wealthengine.com25
Saint.Mary’s.College.is.a.Catholic,.residential,.women’s.college.in.the.liberal.arts.tradition..Founded.by.the.Sisters.of.the.Holy.Cross.in.1844,.Saint.Mary’s.promotes.a.life.of.intellectual.vigor,.aesthetic.appreciation,.religious.sensibility,.and.social.responsibility.
Warner.continued,.“We.are.also.looking.at.planned.giving.prospects..Using.the.WealthEngine.planned.giving.model,.we.have.been.able.to.identify.more.prospects.in.our.database.”.Just.over.a.month.ago,.the.Planned.Giving.Officer.sent.a.mailing.out.to.those.prospects.
As.with.any.new.application,.Warner.acknowledged.experiencing.a.learning.curve..Hers.was.“getting.it.into.our.daily.routine..It’sreallyimportantthatyoutouchtheWealthEnginetooleveryday..Also,.if.you.take.training,.you.need.to.start.working.with.your.data.right.away.so.you.can.immediately.try.out.what.you.learned.”
Warner.offers.this.advice.to.others.getting.ready.to.do.a.screening.(whether.for.the.first.or.tenth.time):
• There’s.never.going.to.be.a.“good”.time..Just.do.it!• It’s.in.your.best.interest.to.think.about.the.outcomes.you.want..
How.do.you.plan.to.use.the.data?• Ask.WealthEngine.for.references.similar.to.your.organization..Contact.them.and.ask.why.they.screened.
particular.people.and.how.they.used.their.data.• Determine.your.goals..Then,.develop.your.plan..And,.remember.that.your.plan.is.a.“living.document”.and.
can.be.modified.as.you.go.along.• Determine.what.data.will.be.imported.into.your.system..• Identify.additional.customized.reports.needed,.beyond.the.standard.ones.
When.asked.“Why.WealthEngine?”.Warner.explained,.“Since.we.were.‘first.timers,’.we.wanted.a.simple.product.that.would.offer.us.a.basic.screening..We.knew.we.didn’t.need—and.wouldn’t.use—all.the.bells.and.whistles.of.some.of.the.other.products.”
She.said.she.would.definitely.use.WealthEngine.again..“ThebeautyofWealthEngineisthatitstreamlineswhatwedoinourdevelopmentdepartmentandultimatelysavesthecollegemoney,”.she.said.
Prospect research helped support the construction and endowment of the new Spes Unica Hall, which
was completely funded by gifts and pledges totaling $19.4 million
from nearly 1,000 donors.
Saint Mary’s fundraising programs touch alumnae, current and past parents, faculty, staff, students, and friends; building strong support for their mission—educating women to make a difference in the world.
TM
www.wealthengine.com26
&Washington & Lee UniversityUses Peer Screening to Identify Major Gift Prospects
For.22.years,.Debra.Darling.has.been.conducting.prospect.research—full-time.or.on.her.own.as.a.major.gift.officer...Currently.Director.of.Prospect.Development.at.Washington.&.Lee.University,.Darling.has.found.that.the.ratio.of.proactive.versus.reactive.research.she.chooses.to.use.depends.on.the.stage.of.a.campaign,.current.fundraising.priorities,.or.maturity.of.the.fundraising.program...While.she.believes.that.all.research.shops.should.be.proactive.at.least.50%.of.the.time,.certain.stages.require.a.higher.degree.of.activity.to.ensure.campaign.success...“We.are.at.the.beginning.of.a.capital.campaign.and.our.greatest.need.is.to.screen.our.constituents.and.identify.those.most.capable.of.major.giving.to.begin.strengthening.those.relationships.now...Our.proactive.work.today.will.help.us.determine.what.the.final.campaign.goal,.and.ultimately.the.outcome,.will.be,”.says.Darling...
Recruitment StrategyThis.proactive.research.method.includes.peer.screening.to.identify.new.prospects.with.a.high.capacity.to.give.who.haven’t.yet.been.approached.for.a.major.gift...“To.hold.true.to.a.multi-pronged.approach.for.prospect.identification,.peer.screening.is.important...We.feel.that.one-on-one.sessions.with.peer.screeners,.rather.than.via.groups,.is.the.best.way.to.get.great.information,.especially.given.the.size.of.our.school.which.facilitates.close.relationships.among.classmates.and.alumni,”.notes.Darling.
To.identify.peer.screening.volunteers,.Washington.&.Lee.targets:
•. Alumni.from.specific.professions.with.affluence..and.strong.social.networks:•. Finance.professionals—their.profession.is.to.know.clients’.and.associates’.net.worth•. Corporate.and.philanthropic.board.members•. Attorneys.who.graduated.from.their.law.school
•. Alumni.or.parents.with.gift.histories.and.volunteer.involvement:•. Class.agents.who.have.previously.been.solicited.for.the.annual.fund•. Reunion.committee.members
From.these.sources,.staff.identified.500.potential.screeners,.of.which.160,.approximately.one-third,.were.interviewed.within.the.first.six.months...Of.those.invited.to.participate,.only.two.have.declined.and.they.continue.to.work.through.the.remaining.two.thirds.with.success...Once.screeners.agree.to.be.interviewed,.she.begins.a.careful.coding.and.tracking.process.in.her.donor.management.system.as.peer.screeners.hold.
“Our first six months of peer screening resulted in the identification of 284 completely new prospects with validated gift capacity ratings over $100,000. We were also able to confirm and/or upgrade known prospects at equally high levels.”
—Debra Darling, Director of Prospect Development,
Washington & Lee University
Client Case Study
www.wealthengine.com27
tremendous.potential.both.in.identifying.new.donors.and.in.increasing.their.own.contributions.to.the.school...The.screener’s.own.name.is.included.in.their.list.of.people.to.review.and.they.are.asked.to.rate.their.own.gift.capacity.
Darling.says,.“We.see.peer.screening.as.a.huge.cultivation.step.in.the.campaign...It.reconnects.us.with.people.in.a.way.that.allows.them.to.be.helpful.to.our.school.without.having.to.make.an.outright.donation.and.plants.the.seed.for.our.campaign.message.”
Interview ApproachDevelopment.officers.conduct.the.peer.screenings;.each.lasts.approximately.one.hour.and.includes.a.maximum.of.400.names...The.goal.is.to.get.“very.good”.information.on.individuals.on.the.list.who.are.close.associates.of.the.screener.thereby.creating.a.circle.of.friends...In.those.cases,.they.are.asked.only.to.suggest.gift.capacity.but.often.provide.additonal.clues.regarding.inclination.to.give.and.attitude.towards.philanthropy...For.acquaintances,.general.information.is.collected.on.current.employment,.home.address,.family.relations,.friends,.etc..The.peer.review.list.is.generated.from:
•. Fellow.alumni•. Profession.(i.e...fellow.investment.bankers)•. Undergraduate/graduate.major•. Student.activities.and.clubs.(fraternity/sororities,.
athletics,.etc.)•. Geography.of.friends.and.parents,.including.
seasonal.addresses
•. Parents.of.current.students•. Profession•. Geography.of.alumni,.fellow.parents.and.student’s.
friends,.including.seasonal.addresses•. Fellow.students.from.their.child’s.high.school.who.have.or.are.attending.Washington.&.Lee
Post.interview,.Darling.takes.the.data.collected.and.reviews.four.separate.gift.capacity.ratings.to.determine.the.best.rating.for.each.prospect...The.ratings.come.from:
•. Personal.opinion.of.the.peer.screener•. Knowledge.of.the.prospect.by.the.participating.development.officer•. Validation.from.the.prospect.research.department•. WealthEngine’s.wealth.and.hard.asset.screening.results
“Looking.at.all.four.ratings.is.a.powerful.tool—there.is.more.confidence.and.immediacy.for.action.when.all.are.at.the.same.level...I.know.to.dig.deeper.when.there.is.a.variance,”.says.Darling...“While.peer.screening.can.be.a.labor.intensive.process,.the.results.are.impressive.when.you.consider.that.we.found.284.new.major.gift.prospects.and.the.opportunity.to.successfully.cultivate.screeners.for.future.gifts.”
TM
www.wealthengine.com30
Beebe Medical FoundationCreates Seamless Prospecting Workflow
Beebe.Medical.Foundation.is.a.single,.280.bed.facility.in.Lewes,.DE..Their.implementation.plan.includes.targeting.grateful.patients,.immediate.analysis.of.recent.donors.and.integration.into.their.donor.management.system.(DMS)..Some.of.their.strategies.include:
New PatientsMonthly.screening.of.inpatient,.emergency.care,.cancer,.cardiac,.and.physical-therapy.patients.from.the.previous.month..They.exclude.those.under.30.years.old.and.any.charity.care..The.file.is.de-duped.against.patients.from.last.six.months.so.they.don’t.screen.or.solicit.the.same.patient.twice.and.then.they:
•. Mail.to.all.screened.patients.except.those.without.match.data
•. Track.the.response.rate.from.monthly.mailings.(consistent.at.1.3%.with.average.gift.of.$77)
•. Call.top.five.to.ten.screened.patients.in.addition.to.mailing
DonorsEach.week.the.development.staff.runs.a.report.and.meets.to.discuss.the.previous.week’s.donors.(see.sample.below)..The.report.contains.information.from.their.DMS.system:.donor’s.name,.giving.info.and.other.prospect.information..It.also.includes.their.prospect.research.data—RFM,.inclination.to.give,.giving.capacity,.P2G.(Propensity.to.Give),.influence,.etc.—to.help.identify.future.gift.potential.and.possible.known.relationships...Top.prospects.are.called.for.appreciation,.seeking.appointment,.or.other.action.
The Hudson Wing was opened in 2008
with a spacious 37-bed Emergency Department,
a 20-bed Critical Care Unit, and a 42-bed
inpatient suite.
“DMS integration is a great resource for me; I can find major donor prospects among my annual donors and choose who to call on immediately following their gift. The prospect research ratings are handy—there are many donors who we’ve chosen to reach out to personally after a small annual gift because the gift capacity rating is right in our report. I use a similar report for other prospecting lists, like when I travel out of the area.”
—Alex Sydnor, Executive Director Beebe Medical Foundation
Client Case Study
www.wealthengine.com31
Sample Weekly Report DMS Information WealthEngine Data
Donor AAddressAddress Type: (Home, Business, Other)
Contact Information:
• Home Phone• Work Phone• E-mail
Last Donation: $20Type: Memorial Gift
Date: 7/11/2008
Largest Donation: $500 Date: 5/5/2004First Donation: $500 Date: 5/5/2004Donation Total: $520 No. of Gifts: 2
Giving Capacity: $11,137Inclination Rating: 1Influence Rating: 3RFM Recency: 71RFM Frequency: 60RFM Money: 73
P2G: 4 – 0 = Annual Fund Prospect
Donor BAddressAddress Type: (Home, Business, Other)
Contact Information:
• Home Phone• Work Phone• E-mail
Last Donation: $100Type: Unsolicited
Date: 1/27/2009
Largest Donation: $100 Date: 1/27/2009First Donation: $100 Date: 1/27/2009Donation Total: $100 No. of Gifts: 1
Giving Capacity: $107,827Inclination Rating: 2Influence Rating: 4RFM Recency: 87RFM Frequency: 41RFM Money: 52
P2G: 2 –5 = Major Gift Prospect
Donor CAddressAddress Type: (Home, Business, Other)
Contact Information:
• Home Phone• Work Phone• E-mail
Last Donation: $525Type: Golf Classic
Date: 10/4/2008
Largest Donation: $50,000 Date: 1/4/2007First Donation: $100 Date: 9/24/1999Donation Total: $73,140 No. of Gifts: 7
Giving Capacity: $1,322,000Inclination Rating: 1Influence Rating: 1RFM Recency: 98RFM Frequency: 85RFM Money: 83WE Inner Circle Flag: Y
WE P2G: 1 –0 = Major Gift, Capital Campaign or Planned Giving
Client Case Study
www.wealthengine.com33
Penn MedicineUses Physicians to Advance Grateful Patient Program
The.University.of.Pennsylvania.School.of.Medicine.and.Health.System.(Penn.Medicine).is.a.five.facility.network.with.1,500.beds..In.2003,.Penn.Medicine.received.72.gifts.of.$25,000+.from.grateful.patients..Due.to.their.strategic.use.of.physicians.to.promote.their.grateful.patient.program,.that.number.increased.to.201.in.2008.and.accounted.for.half.of.their.total.gifts.over.$25,000.
Physicians can be excellent fundraisersFrom.Penn.Medicine’s.3,300.physicians,.the.development.department.looks.for.those.who.meet.three.key.characteristics:.they.are.caring,.have.access.to.model.candidates.and.are.interested.in.actively.supporting.Penn.Medicine.in.general..Currently,.75.“key”.physician.partners.are.actively.involved.in.Penn.Medicine’s.development.efforts...All.of.these.physician.partners.have.been.formally.trained.on.how.to.identify.potential.prospects.and.are.asked.to.dedicate.10-15.hours.a.year.to.fundraising...A.senior.physician.“leader”.—appointed.jointly.by.the.Dean.and.CEO—works.closely.with.this.leadership.team.of.physicians.and.strives.to.foster.a.culture.of.education,.interest,.and.support.for.the.grateful.patient.program..
Steps for success with physician involvement:•. Identify.and.engage.a.core.group.of.physicians.as.“philanthropic.partners”•. Support.physician.partners.as.you.would.your.top.volunteers•. Make.the.best.use.of.your.physicians’.time.and.regularly.report.on.development.activity•. Encourage.administrative.leadership.to.promote.and.recognize.physician.
involvement.in.philanthropy•. Create.development.plans.in.close.cooperation.with.physician.leaders•. Focus.physician.attention.on.securing.major.gifts.from.individuals.•. Use.vested.senior.physicians.to.build.culture.among.other.physicians•. Train.physicians.on.the.donor.development.process.in.your.organization
Concierge program helps launch the discussionPenn.Medicine’s.concierge.program.for.major.donors.supports.physician.efforts.by.providing.an.added.level.of.personalized.services.and.amenities.for.VIPs.and.friends...The.program.provides.comfort.and.peace.of.mind.to.patients.that.all.their.needs.are.met.and.that.their.care.is.seamlessly.coordinated.by.expert.staff.and.the.best.physicians...
A.critical.factor.to.success.in.using.physicians.for.prospecting,.however,.rests.with.the.execution.of.development.department.staff..Development.officers.need.to.be.responsive.in.the.cultivation.and.solicitation.of.a.grateful.patient.prospect.after.physician.identification.and.prospect.qualification..Using.quick,.online.research.and/or.frequently.screened.data.can.bypass.long.research.profiles.and.better.position.the.development.officer.and.physician.to.engage.the.prospect.in.a.timely.and.appropriate.manner.
During the past five years, Penn Medicine has found that most of its major donors are motivated by a personal or family experience with a specific disease so certain physicians are better positioned to engage their patients in discussions about philanthropic support.
TM
www.wealthengine.com34
Saint Barnabas Health Care SystemUsing Prospect Research to Target Top Patient Prospects
Fundraising.for.any.nonprofit.organization.comes.with.a.common.set.of.challenges..But.those.faced.by.Laura.R..Tenenbaum.are.pretty.unique.since.she.supports.eight.foundations.at.once.
Tenenbaum.is.Director.of.Planned.Giving.and.Program.Development.at.Saint.Barnabas.Health.Care.System,.“New.Jersey’s.largest.integrated.health.care.delivery.system.”.She.has.been.using.WealthEngine.services.successfully.for.three.years.to.support.SBHCS’s.six.medical.center.foundations,.plus.two.others..
Tenenbaum.faces.special.challenges.in.her.position..First,.she.works.with.each.of.the.eight.foundations.when,.and.if,.they.request.her.services..She.explains,.“I’m.more.like.a.consultant.than.anything.else..I.must.be.brought.in.by.each.foundation’s.vice.president.”
So,.when.Tenenbaum.began.her.search.for.a.prospect.research.tool.in.2005,.she.needed.to.find.a.product.for.which.she.could.gain.consensus.from.all.those.foundations.and.vice.presidents.involved..There,.of.course,.was.also.the.need.for.a.reasonable.price.and.the.new.tool.needed.to.work.well.with.SBHCS’s.donor.management.system,.Raiser’s.Edge..With.its.competitive.pricing.structure.and.ability.to.integrate.with.Raiser’s.Edge,.WealthEngine.was.ultimately.selected.by.the.group.
Time.is.another.challenge.for.Tenenbaum.particularly.since.hers.is.divided.among.these.various.foundations..She.certainly.does.not.have.time.to.research.more.than.a.fraction.of.the.patients.who.are.admitted.to.the.hospital.system..Here’s.how.Tenenbaum.uses.WealthEngine’s.products.and.features.to.target.her.fundraising.efforts:
Routine Screening with WebExpressOn.a.monthly.basis,.SBHCS.submits.the.previous.month’s.patient.records.to.WealthEngine.for.screening..With.the.help.of.WealthEngine’s.Propensity.to.Give.(P2G).score,.Tenenbaum.can.more.effectively.develop.a.targeted.solicitation.approach.for.a.smaller.group.of.more.qualified.prospects..After.monthly.screenings.of.discharged.patients,.Tenenbaum.focuses.efforts.on.patients.with.a.P2G.rating.of.“1”.as.well.as.patients.with.apparent.connections.to.members.of.a.foundation’s.Inner.Circle..This.approach.enables.Laura.to.reduce.a.pool.of.9,000+.patients.a.month.to.a.more.manageable.group.of.100-150.qualified.prospects.
Saint Barnabas Medical Center—Livingston, NJ
What is the
p2G score?The Propensity to Give Score (P2G) prioritizes your prospects so you know who to target and how. These ratings are assigned using a fixed set of criteria and our analysis shows that individuals with better P2G scores (P2G 1’s and P2G 2’s) yield higher] personal contributions.
Client Case Study
www.wealthengine.com35
Segment Best ProspectsTenenbaum’s.tactic.for.approaching.qualified.prospects.starts.with.a.one-page.letter.that.she.writes..The.letter.goes.out.under.the.appropriate.vice.president’s.signature,.focuses.on.the.fact.that.the.medical.center.is.a.community.hospital,.and.includes.an.overview.of.the.hospital.system’s.accomplishments.over.the.past.year..Enclosed.in.each.letter.is.a.four-color.publication.that.Tenenbaum.prepares.which.highlights.successes.of.the.organization.and.its.medical.team,.describes.what.the.foundation.does,.and.details.ways.that.friends.are.helping.the.foundation.
This.initial.letter.goes.out.about.a.month.after.the.patient’s.discharge..Five.weeks.later,.an.actual.solicitation.follows..Our.research.has.shown.that.contacting.the.patient.within.three.months.of.discharge.improves.the.likelihood.of.receiving.a.gift.
Inner Circle TargetingProspect.research.can.also.help.healthcare.organizations.establish.or.build.up.their.grateful.patient.programs.while.honoring.HIPAA.regulations..The.Diplomat.Program.is.an.example.of.how.SBHCS.is.using.WealthEngine’s.Inner.Circle.feature.to.cater.to.patients.and.donors,.while.still.remaining.HIPAA.compliant..The.new.Diplomat.Program.initiative,.launched.by.the.Monmouth.Medical.Center.Foundation,.a.member.of.the.SBHC.system,.was.developed.to.target.major.and.long-time.donors.as.well.as.members.of.the.Foundation’s.Inner.Circle.
When using WealthEngine, the Inner Circle refers to an organization's VIPs–indi-viduals who serve as board members, trustees, prior trustees, major gift donors, etc., who will provide assistance in your major gift fundraising efforts. When you identify your Inner Circle, WealthEngine will generate your Circle of Friends–a network of individuals who sit on corporate or philanthropic boards with your prospects and donors. Use these Inner Circle connections to prospect for new major gifts and to involve your VIPs in your fundraising efforts.
Your Inner Circle Top Donors
Top Volunteers
Trustees
Leadership
Patients.with.connections.to.the.Foundation’s.Inner.Circle.are.sent.a.highly.personalized.thank-you.letter.and.are.then.invited.to.notify.the.Diplomat.Program.manager.whenever.they.might.be.seeking.medical.care.in.the.hospital.system..The.Diplomat.Program.manager.helps.ease.the.patient’s.stay.in.the.medical.center.and.can.make.arrangements.for.the.comfort.of.family.members—little,.non-medical.touches.that.often.make.a.stressful.time.easier.for.a.patient.prospect.
Tenenbaum.summarizes,.“The.Inner.Circle.is.a.great.service.that.WealthEngine.offers..It.gives.us.a.reason.to.contact.an.individual.”.Monmouth.also.uses.a.donor.alert.system.to.identify.donors.when.they.are.admitted.to.the.facility.
Organizations.that.put.prospect.research.to.use.strategically,.as.does.Saint.Barnabas,.can.make.great.strides.at.developing.their.grateful.patient.programs..For.more.information.on.how.WealthEngine.can.help.you.jump.start.your.grateful.patient.program.visit.http://www.wealthengine.com/pub/[email protected].
TM
www.wealthengine.com38
Cape Cod Commercial Hook Fisherman’s AssociationPutting Prospect Research to Work in a Tough Economy
“How.is.the.economy.affecting.your.nonprofit’s.fundraising?”.seems.to.be.a.common.question.as.we.continue.to.see.the.decline.in.the.stock.market.and.home.sales,.while.the.number.of.business.closings.grows..
Olivia.Scozzafava.of.the.Cape.Cod.Commercial.Hook.Fishermen’s.Association.(CCCHFA).says,.“It’s.even.more.important.now,.in.this.economy,.for.organizations.to.continue.to.develop.and.expand.their.circles.of.friends..Right.now,.it’s.not.necessarily.about.that.gift,.but.it.is.about.that.relationship..When.the.time.comes.and.the.economy.turns.around,.we.want.to.be.a.strong.presence.in.our.community.”
Resources.for.nonprofits.are.always.an.issue,.but.in.this.time.of.financial.crunch,.resources.may.be.even.more.limited..Scozzafava.adds,.“Our.resources.here.at.CCCHFA.have.traditionally.been.limited,.so.we’ve.always.strived.for.efficiency..Now,.as.we.increase.our.outreach,.efficiency.is.even.more.important..WealthEngine.is.the.tool.that.ensures.staff.and.volunteers.at.CCCHFA.are.focusing.our.efforts.on.those.who.have.the.greatest.funding.capacity.”
The.Cape.Cod.Commercial.Hook.Fishermen’s.Association.was.founded.in.1991.by.a.small.group.of.commercial.hook.and.line.fishermen..The.organization’s.major.fundraising.effort.is.the.development.of.the.Cape.Cod.Fisheries.Trust.which.works.to.ensure.a.lasting.future.for.sustainable.fishing.on.Cape.Cod.by.purchasing.and.managing.fishing.quota..Specifically,.their.fundraising.goal.is.$10.million.by.2011.
Scozzafava.shares.with.WealthEngine.what.steps.CCCHFA.is.taking.now.to.weather.the.economy.and.meet.its.goals..This.past.summer,.the.organization.hosted.numerous.cultivation.events..Scozzafava.relied.on.both.WealthEngine’s.donor.screening.capability.and.its.online.research.tool.in.an.effort.to.raise.money.and.save.resources.
“Basically,.WealthEngine.did.the.work.for.us..We.gave.them.our.data,.and.they.identified.the.500.top.profiles..Then,.we.knew.where.to.focus.our.efforts..We.were.also.able.to.follow.up.with.targeted.appeals.and.personalized.notes.after.the.events,.based.on.what.we.learned.at.the.events.and.from.WealthEngine,”.explains.Scozzafava..For.a.small.organization,.like.CCCHFA,.which.has.a.staff.of.less.than.10,.this.was.a.huge.savings.and.helped.contribute.to.the.success.of.the.cultivation.events.
And,.these.events.were.successful.beyond.cultivation..Scozzafava.says,.“One.attendee.gave.a.first-time.contribution.of.$10,000—and.we.are.now.in.discussions.about.future.gifts..A.number.of.other.attendees.gave.first-time.gifts.of.$1,000.or.$2,000..Again,.the.WealthEngine.screening.helped.us.focus.our.time.and.money.resources—and.we.got.results.
CCCHFA Board MemberKurt Martin; The Cape Cod Fisheries Trust’s (CCFT) mission is to ensure a lasting future for sustainable
fishing on Cape Cod by purchasing and managing fishing quota.
Client Case Study
www.wealthengine.com39
“Dataquick.has.been.another.WealthEngine.tool.which.has.gotten.great.results.and.also.saved.us.resources,”.adds.Scozzafava..“We.had.street.addresses.for.taxpayers.in.our.area,.but.not.the.mailing.addresses..So,.we.would.constantly.get.returned.appeal.letters..Now,.we.are.able.to.mail.directly.to.local.residents.using.their.P.O..addresses.
“WealthEngine.works,”.continues.Scozzafava..“Other.products.may.appear.to.have.more.bells.and.whistles.and.they.come.with.a.hefty.price.tag.and.longer.learning.process..Our.organization.doesn’t.need.tools.that.use.more.of.our.resources—WealthEngine.is.sophisticated.and.user-friendly..We.need.a.prospect.research.tool.that’s.easy.to.use.and.that.helps.us.bring.in.money..That’s.WealthEngine.”
“When.things.do.turn.around,.it’s.going.to.be.an.absolute.storm.for.donors.and.prospects..At.CCCHFA,.we.want.to.make.sure.we.are.ready,”.sums.up.Scozzafava..“Now.is.the.time.for.networking.and.cultivating.those.relationships.”