2
Issues and Applications
• Global capital markets and the current account
• Debt crisis in developing countries
• Sovereign risk
3
Balance of Payments Accounting: The Current Account (CA)
• The current account (CA): measures a country’s trade in currently produced goods and services
• A negative CA implies that a country is importing more than it is exporting
5
• The capital and financial account (KFA) measures a country’s trade in financial assets
• Note that selling assets (e.g. bonds) is equivalent to borrowing and leads to inflow of capital, that is the rest of the world is lending money to us
The Capital and Financial Account (KFA)
6
• The current account and the capital financial account sum to zero
CA+KFA=0
• This equation is an Accounting Identity!
The Link Between CA and KFA
7
Savings, Investment and the Current Account
• We know from the Introduction that
NX + NFP = CA = S – I
• Focusing on S – I is equivalent to looking at the CA or the KFA
11
Sources of Funds for US borrowing
What finances US current account deficits:
– Sale of US treasury debt
– Sale of Corporate debt
– Equities
13
Global Capital Markets
• Financial markets in New York, London, Frankfurt, Tokyo
• Each country has savings
• All these savings enter global financial markets
• Each country has needs for investment in new plant and equipment
• The job of the global financial markets is to efficiently allocate the global pool of savings to investment opportunities in different countries
14
Determinants of Savings
• Aggregate savings is income minus consumption:
s = y – c – g
• Aggregate savings is the sum of private savings and government savings– Govt. Savings are Net Tax Revenue-Govt. expenditure
s = sp + sg
15
Determinants of National Saving
• An increase in the real interest rate causes desired national saving to rise, as the reward to savings rises, see Fig 1.
• An increase in G causes desired aggregate savings to fall, as overall consumption rises, Fig. 2.
• An temporary increase in Y causes desired national saving to rise, as households spread the rise in income over current and future consumption, Fig. 3.
r
S
r
S
r
S
Fig. 1 Fig. 2
Fig. 3
s1
s1
s2
s1
s2
16
Determination of the Current Account
Variables subscripted by w refer to global variables, and those subscripted by arg refer to Argentina.
17
Current Account
• The global capital markets determine the world real interest rate
• A country’s savings and investment determines its current account
18
Good Prospects and the Current Account
Does a country that experiences a permanent rise in TFP and thereby produces more goods and services respond by on net importing or exporting more goods and services?
20
Recessions and the Current Account
Current account deficit falls during recessions and rises during booms
23
Economic Growth
Average Growth of GNP per Capita, 1965-90
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
HPAEs
South Asia
Middle East and Mediterranean
Sub-Saharan Africa
OECD Economies
Latin America and the Caribbean
GNP per capita growth rate (percent)
OECD refers to Organization of Economic Cooperation and Development. This includes the world’s 24 richest economies.
High performance Asian economies (HPAE) are: Singapore, Hong Kong, Thailand, Indonesia, Taiwan, Malaysia, Korea.
24
Education in HPAEHong Kong Singapore South Korea Taiwan
1966 1991 1966 1990 1966 1990 1966 1990
None 19.2 5.6 55.1 - 31.1 6.4 17.0 4.5
Primary 53.6 22.9 28.2 33.7 42.2 18.5 57.2 28.0
Secondary 27.2 71.4 15.8 66.3 26.5 75.0 25.8 67.6
Educational Attainment of the Working Population (Percent)
Education is the engine of TFP growth
Primary is till eighth grade and secondary is high school
Source: Alwyn Young, ‘The Tyrrany of Numbers: Confronting the Statistical Realities of the East Asian Growth Experience’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1995
26
Current Account in HPAE
Current Account as % of GDP
-11
-6
-1
4
9
14
Ind
on
esia
Ko
rea
Mal
aysi
a
Sin
gap
ore
Th
aila
nd
1975
1985
1994
30
Risk And Sovereign Debt
• Countries cannot be taken to court if they default on their borrowings
• This leads to sovereign risk which is reflected in the cost of borrowing
• Sovereign risk depends on the credibility of not defaulting on the debt
• Sovereign risk ratings are almost entirely determined by the macroeconomics of the country
– Lower Per-Capita income, Higher inflation, and Higher External Debt --- lower the country’s credit rating
– Sovereign debt to GDP is a key measure of the sustainability of government debt (although credible governments can sustain high debt-to-GDP levels)
31
Macro-economy and Sovereign Risk
Fiscal balance and external balance are relative to GDP. External debt refers to foreign currency debt relative to exports.
33
External Debt and Default
• External debt (foreign debt) is debt held by foreigners
• External debt must be paid off with future current account surpluses (excluding the possibility of default)
• External debt to GDP is a key indicator of sustainability of external debt
• External debt to GDP rises – if growth rate of GDP falls – if the cost of external borrowing rises
34
Sovereign Credit Default Swap (CDS) Spreads
The buyer of a CDS receives a payment if the credit instrument goes into default
36
The Lesser-Developed Country (LDC) Debt Crises
• Prior to 1979, a run-up in commodity prices such as coffee and oil led to an investment boom in many Latin American countries
• Consequently, many Latin American borrowed heavily and raised the External Debt to GDP ratios
• Global recession in 1979-82 lowered demand for exports
• Interest rates on dollar denominated adjustable rate debt rose
• Debt to exports and debt to GDP rose dramatically
• In August 1982 Mexico declared a moratorium on interest payments. This led to the debt crises
38
Current Account Reversals
Current account rises (perhaps reverses from deficit to surplus) during a crisis
39
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
1995 1996 1997 1998 1999
Thailand
MalaysiaIndonesia
Percent
Current Account as a share of GDP
42
Global Capital Markets
Variables subscripted by w refer to global variables, and those subscripted by arg refer to Argentina.
43
An Increase in future TFP
Expectations of better growth prospects for the future increase investment today
Investment determined by (i) real interest rate (ii) future prospects