Ellen Galinsky
National Human Services Assembly
August 19, 2008
Making Your Organization an Employer of Choice— Bold Ideas for the Caring Workplace
Part I
What Do We Know About Low-Wage, Low-Income Employees
2
3
Definitions• We define low-wage employees as those whose
earnings fall in the bottom 25% of the earnings distribution, which is less than $9.73 per hour in 2005 dollars
• We define low-income families as those whose total annual income from all sources falls below 200% of (2 times) the federal poverty threshold — $39,612 for a two-parent family with two dependent children in 2005
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 1, 2006
4
Definitions• Over half (54%) of low-wage employees live in
low-income households
• 12 to 13 million employees meet this definition at the time the last National Study of the Changing Workforce was conducted
• This is not a static category. For example, low-wage employees living in middle-income families at or above 200% of the federal poverty level can easily slip into low-income status
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 1, 2006
5
Demographic Comparisons: Age and Gender
• Most low-wage and –income employees are not teenagers, though they are disproportionately younger than more advantaged employees
• Low-wage and –income employees are almost equally likely to be men (48%) as women (52%)
• 70% of low-wage and –income women are the sole wage earners in their families
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 1, 2006
6
Demographic Comparisons: Marital Status and Parental Status
• More than two in five low-wage and –income employees (42%) are married or living in committed, long-term relationships — despite the fact that more than half are less than 30 years old
• While 14% of all low-wage and –income employees are single parents, 86% are not
• The proportion of single parents rises to 25% among women
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 1, 2006
7
Demographic Comparisons: Race/Ethnicity and Immigrant Status• The majority (57%) of low-wage and –income
employees are white and non-Hispanic
• Only one in five low-wage and –income employees (21%) is an immigrant
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 1, 2006
8
Demographic Comparisons: Education Levels• Only 3% of low-wage and –income employees
have a 4-year college degree or more
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 1, 2006
9
Employment Status: Years in Labor Force • Low-wage and –income employees have been in the
labor force for fewer years than other employees
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 1, 2006
10
Employment Status: Size of Employers • 36% of low-wage and –income employees work for
employers with fewer than 25 employees
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 1, 2006
11
Access to Benefits
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 1, 2006
• This group has limited access to benefits
12
Access to Flexibility
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 3, 2006
• Access to flexibility is uneven
13
Access to Flexibility (continued)
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 1, 2006
14
Access to Flexibility (continued)
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 1, 2006
15
Part IIWhy Employers Are Concerned About Creating Effective Workplaces
16
The Economy Is Changing• It has shifted from an industrial to a knowledge
and service base
• It is fast paced and fiercely competitive
• It is global and 24/7
Source: 2004 When Work Works
17
The Demographics of the Workforce Have Changed — with Four Generations Now Working Together• Matures (1922-1943)
Between the ages of 65-86
• Baby Boomers (1944-1963) Between the ages of 45-64
• Generation X (1967-1979) Between the ages of 29-41
• Generation Y (1980-1995) Between the ages of 13-28
Source: 2004 Generation & Gender in the Workplace
18
The Demographics of the Workforce Have Changed Over the Past 25 Years (from 1977 to 2002)• There are more women (from 42% to 49%)
• There are more people of color (from 12% to 21%)
• There are more employees over 40 years old (from 35% to 56%)
Sources: 1977 QES and 2002 NSCW
19
Work Has Changed Over the Past 25 Years
• Work is more demanding and hectic
• Technology is blurring the lines between work and non-work times
• There is an expectation of instant responses and many interruptions: 56% of employees often or very often have these problems
Sources: 1977 QES, 2002 NSCW and Overwork in America 2005
20
Family Life Has Changed Over the Past 25 Years• There are more dual-earner couples
(from 66% to 78%)
• More employees have elder care responsibilities (currently 35%)
• More men are involved in the care of their children — from 24% to 30% take as much or more responsibility for the care of their children as their wives, according to their wives
Sources: 1977 QES and 2002 NSCW
21Source: 2002 NSCW
Today in the U.S., Among All Employees…• 39% are not fully engaged in their jobs
• 54% are less than fully satisfied with their jobs
• 38% are somewhat or very likely to make a concerted effort to find a new job in the coming year
• 33% are exhibiting one or more symptoms of clinical depression
• 46% of men and 41% of women are experiencing some or a lot of conflict in their work and family life
22
• Meet the changing workforce and workplace dynamics
• Increase employee commitment and engagement
• Improve retention
• Improve mental health and productivity of employees
• Continue to meet organizational goals and objectives
Employers Are Looking for New Ways to Make Work “Work” — to Create More Effective Workplaces
Source: 2004 When Work Works
23
Families and Work Institute Has Identified Six Research-Based Criteria for an Effective Workplace for Employees in General1. Providing job autonomy
2. Creating learning opportunities and challenges on the job — where employees can grow, learn and advance
3. Developing environments where supervisors support employees in being successful on the job
Source: 2004 When Work Works
24
4. Developing environments where coworkers support each other for job success
5. Involving employees in management decision making
6. Creating flexible workplaces
Criteria (continued)
Source: 2004 When Work Works
25
There Are Positive Outcomes for Employees in Effective Workplaces
81%18Job
Satisfaction
LMH
2
15
82%15
3
EngagementLMH
77%14
9
RetentionLMH
36%49Mental Health
LMH
Sources: 2002 NSCW, 2004 When Work Works
26
What Is an Effective Workplace for Low-Wage Low-Income
Populations?
27
We Expanded the Definition of an Effective Workplace
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 2, 2006
28
Comparing the Impact of an Effective Workplace
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 2, 2006
29
Comparing the Impact of an Effective Workplace
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 2, 2006
30
• Overall, the characteristics of effective workplaces are significantly associated with positive outcomes — in most instances — for the workforce as a whole
• An effective workplace, however, makes a bigger difference in a number of ways for low-wage and –income employees than their higher wage counterparts
Overall Findings
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 2, 2006
31
• FWI’s 2008 National Study of Employers is the most comprehensive and far-reaching study of practices, policies, programs, and benefits provided by U.S. employers
• It is nationally representative of employers with 50 or more employees and provides trend data on changes over the past 10 years
• In this study, we examined the predictors of employers most likely to provide flexibility, care giving leaves, and child and elder care services — and two predictors consistently emerged: being a non profit and having more racial and ethnic diversity in top positions!
New Findings from the 2008 NSE
Source: Supporting Entry-Level, Hourly Employees Research Brief No. 2, 2006
32
Part III
Turning Research into Action: When Work Works
33
1. See your effort in stages from changing awareness to changing behavior to engaging people in action
2. Know how people see your issue before you begin
3. Know what you want people to do
4. Messages are critical
– Unexpected messages have stopping power– Spell out the costs of not taking action as well as the
benefits of change– Project into the future– There should be different messages for different groups
Eight Lessons for Creating Change that Lasts
Source: Galinsky, 2008, Eight Lessons of Public Engagement
34
5. Unexpected messengers also make a difference
6. Target the people who have the power to bring about change — recognize, connect and assist them
7. Take advantage of opportunities as they arise
8. Detail expected outcomes, assess results and make change
Source: Galinsky, 2008, Eight Lessons of Public Engagement
Eight Lessons for Creating Change that Lasts (continued)
www.familiesandwork.org