A 2009 The eleaming Institute. All rights reserved. Page 2 of 34
Journal of Elementary and Secondary Education 2010 . October. Volume: 1 , Issue: #age 2
Impact of Animal AssistedTherapy Reading Instructionon Reading Performance of
Ilomeschooled StudentsDr. Kelly A. Smith
Semrnole State College
ABSTRACTThis pilot study aimed to determine the impact of AAT reading instruction
on reading performance, within a sample of 26 homeschooled students in
grade 3. An experimental pre/post test control group research design was
utilizedfor this pilot study. The ffict of AAT on reading performance was
determined bqsed on the results of two+ailed two-sample t-test
statistical analysis of participant pre/post test scores of the Gray Oral
Reading Test 4th edition (GORT-Q in the areas of reading rate and overall
reading quotienL The two-tailed two-sample t-test score t(24) : 2.56,
p:.017 confirmed that AAT orql reading instruction significantly impacted
student reading rqte. Due to the small size of this pilot study, the analysis
lacked sfficient power, limitingfindings to this study. However, this
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW_TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co... 9l19l20l1
@ 2009 The eleaming Institute. All rights reserved.
research prepares the foundation for future larger studies that can
explore the instructional ffictiveness of AAT.
Page 3 of34
Journal of Elementary and Secondary Education 2010. October. Volume: I . Issue: Hage 3
Reading challenges can have a lasting impact on students, with most who
experience reading difficulties in elementary school continuing to have reading problems
into adulthood (Felton & Pepper, 1995; Maughan et al., 2009). Reading challenges affect
a large portion of the elementary school population with 30 to 40 percent of all school
children facing significant difficulty leaming to read (National Assessment of
Educational Progress [NAEP], 2003). In addition, the reliance of public schools on the
use of traditional curriculum and structured one-size-fits-all instruction (Bruni, 2004;
Owens & Valesky, 2007) often leads to lack of motivation and lack of skill development
(Barkley, 2007 ; Ehren, 2009).
However, with the application of altemative reading intervention strategies, the
reading skills of struggling readers increased by 90% (Montgomery & Moore-Brown,
2003). Altemative reading instruction methods should be examined and tested to address
the continued deficiencies within the teaching of reading so that student comprehension
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW_TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co. .. 9ll9l20Il
@ 2009 The eleaming Institute. All rights reserved. Page 4 of34
improves. Savage, Carless, and Erten (2009) examined the effectiveness of alternative
reading intervention methods for reading instruction and found that two out of three
participants improved in the area of reading comprehension. The use of animal assisted
therapy (AAT) as an alternative reading instruction method may also be a viable option
for addressing reading deficiencies. Researchers could explore the effectiveness of
altemative reading instruction methods such as AAT reading instruction in improving
reading skills in homeschooled children.
The educational setting of homeschooling is an educational model that is an
alternative to the more highly structured nature of traditional public education, and is one
that embraces self-directed and inquisitive instruction such as AAT (Wasley, 2007).
Journal of Elementary and Secondary Education 2010. October. Volume: I . Issue: Hage +
Homeschooling, by being adaptable, allows for individualization of the learning
experience, instruction and assessment materials that best meets the leaming needs of the
child (Ray, 2009). AAT is an alternative instructional method for reading that
accommodates not only the leaming style of each child but allows for instruction and
presentation of information to be adapted to best fit the individual learning style (Bannier,
2007). Recent research findings support the hypothesis that the inclusion of animals
within the educational process does benefit learners (Beck, 2000; Miller & Lago, 1990).
AAT fits well within the more flexible educational constructs of homeschooling and the
impact of an AAT reading program on reading progress can be explored through a
quantitative research design.
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q=cache:TaW-TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co... 9l19l20Il
@ 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved.
Purpose of the Study
The purpose of this quantitative experimental pre/post test pilot study was to
determine if homeschooled children in Grade 3 who received weekly AAT reading
instruction had improved reading performance as measured by pre/post test results of the
Gray Oral Reading Test 4 m edition (GORT-4) in the areas of reading rate and overall
reading quotient (ORQ), when compared to the pre/post test results of the GORT-4 in the
areas of reading rate and ORQ of a control group, members of which will not receive
AAT reading instruction and will read independently while the experimental group
receives AAT instruction. In this study, the independent variable was the AAT reading
instruction. AAT reading instruction provided within this design was once weekly one-
on-one therapeutic reading instruction sessions between study participant and certified
therapy assistance dog and dog handler. Each session allowed for monitored reading of
grade level selected books by the study participant to the dog, as a part of an AAT
Journal of Elementary and Secondary Education
Page 5 of34
2010. October. Volume: 7 . Issue: Fage 5
reading instruction regiment that focused on improving reading performance. The
dependent variable was reading performance as measured by pre/post difference scores
from the GORT-4 of both the experimental and control groups in the areas of reading rate
and ORQ. The control variable was grade level, with all participants being members of
the third grade. Confounding variables included testing and maturation. Testing as a
confounding variable may exist if participants were affected by taking the pretest as
reouired bv the research desisn. Maturation as a confoundins variable mav be in
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW_TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co... 9lI9l20II
@ 2009 The eleaming Institute. All rights reserved. Page 6 of 34
operation given that children naturally change physically and mentally so quickly, thus it
may difficult to know whether the change observed from pre/post test results were due to
the treatment of AAT reading instruction sessions or were due to maturation.
This study included homeschooled children in Grade 3 from the Volusia Counfy,
Florida area. The sample consisted of 26 participants, l3 within the experimental group
and l3 within the control group. Issues related to sample size are discussed further in the
participant section, in the evaluation of findings section, and in the limitations section of
this manuscript. Members of both the experimental sample and control sample met at the
local public library for either AAT reading instruction or independent reading sessions at
the same time once a week for 6 weeks, The research aimed to determine the exact effect
of oral reading AAT on homeschooled children's reading progress through several
research questions.
Conceptual Framework
The top-down model is an interactive model that relies on cues and reader input to
construct meaning. The whole language approach of reading instruction is categorized
within the top-down model as an instructional model that relies on methods such as
Journal of Elementary and Secondary Education 2010 . October. Volume: I . Issue: fage 6
shared reading experiences. Shared reading experiences allow for student and teacher to
partner in the process of guided reading for fluency and comprehension (Coyne et al.,
2004; Holdaway, 1980). The aim of shared reading experiences within the whole
lanorraoc qnnrnanh is fn allnrrr rcar{erc fn cwncrienne c nnn-fhreafenino leamino
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW_TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co... 9ll9l201l
@ 2009 The eleaming Institute. All rights reserved.
environment in which they can learn to read through experience. This can be done
without fear or shame and with encouragement and guidance from a teacher. AAT
reading instruction is an example of a whole language approach to reading that utilizes
the aspect ofshared reading.
Within the assisted reading theory (Pikulski & Chard, 2005), reading rate is an
essential component of comprehension and fluent reading. When this theory is applied to
reading instruction, students would complete oral reading sessions in which minimal
correction and positive feedback on missed words is provided. The goal of reading
instruction that follows the assisted reading theory is to improve the reading rate and
accuracy ofstudents through reading instruction session in order to develop enhanced
fluency. When applied, students who engaged in assisted reading made significant gains
in reading rate and fluency (Heibert & Fisher, 2002). Such findings illustrate the
practical value of utilizing assisted reading theory as a framework for research that aims
to address reading rate and fluency through reading intervention sessions.
In this study, the assisted reading theory was a guiding construct for the AAT
reading instruction reading sessions provided to members of the experimental group.
One of the aims of the AAT reading session provided within this study was to address the
performance measure of reading rate and fluency, with the intent of improving reading
rate in students. Given that reading comprehension is reliant on reading rate and fluency,
PageT of34
Journal of Elenvntary and Secondary Education 2010. October Volume: 1 . Issue: Hage I
.l-^^^ ^,-^-- :-------^--^ ..-^):.-^ ^^.-^.---^l-^--^:^-^:--^--,-^--^^ ^^,--^11 /o-.----^l- anna\ O--^l-
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW_TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co... 9lI9l20l1
@ 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved. Page9 of34
Journal of Elementary and Seco ndary Education 2010 . October. Volumc: I . Issue: fage g
Q1: What impact does weekly 30-minute AAT reading instruction sessions have
on the reading performance of the experimental group as measured by the pre/post test
reading rate results of the GORT-4 versus the reading performance of the control group,
whose members read independently during the experimental groups AAT instruction
session, as measured by the pre/post test reading rate results of the GORT-4?
Q2: What impact does weekly 30-minute AAT reading instruction sessions have
on the reading performance of the experimental group as measured by the pre/post test
Overall Reading Quotient (ORQ) results of the GORT-4 versus the reading performance
of the control group, whose members read independently during the experimental groups
AAT instruction session, as measured by the pre/post test ORQ results of the GORT-4?
Hypotheses
Hl: The reading performance as measured by reading rate of the experimental
group receiving AAT reading instruction will be statistically equivalent as the reading
rate of third grade homeschooled students not receiving AAT reading instruction.
Hla: The reading performance as measured by reading rate ofthe experimental
group receiving AAT reading instruction will be statistically significantly different than
the reading performance of third grade homeschooled students not receiving AAT
reading instruction.
H2: The reading performance as measured by ORQ of the experimental group
receiving AAT reading instruction will be statistically equivalent as the ORQ of third
grade homeschooled students not receiving AAT reading instruction.
H2a: The reading performance as measured by ORQ of experimental group
receiving AAT reading instruction will be statistically significantly different than the
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW_TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co... 9l19l20Il
@ 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved. Page 8 of34
aS IIICSC aI€aS IIIIpIUVCT I-EaUlIlg CUIIIpIgIreIlslOII lIIrpIUVgs aS Wgll (DaIIlUsrS, z1vz). Jucl
improvements create a larger impact on reading performance in the area of reading
comprehension.
The independent reading experience ofthe control group was modeled on the
wide independent reading theory (cunningham & stanovich,lggg; Ehri, 2005; Kuhn &
Stahl, 2000). The basic tenant ofthis theory is that a strong correlation between
independent reading and reading achievement exists. Within this construct, increases in
reading faculties such as vocabulary, fluency, and comprehension are directly related to
the amount of reading done (Adams, 1990; cunningham & Stanovich, l99g; Ehri, 2005;).
Within this researcher's completed study, the reading experience of the control group was
based upon the theoretical construct that reading in any form might increase reading
skills.
Research into reading fluency performance should not be limited to the
assessment oforal reading rate and oral reading accuracy based upon the assisted and
independent reading fluency theories. The assessment ofreading fluency should also
include the measurement of reading comprehension (pikulski & Chard, 200s). For this
reason, reading theory related to reading comprehension was also utilized as a guiding
theoretical construct for the completed research and its statistical evaluation ofthe overall
reading quotient, which is a combination of fluency and comprehension scores. Guided
fluency instruction theory provided is the additional theoretical building block upon
which the second research question ofreading comprehension though overall reading
quotient was addressed.
Research Questions
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW_TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co... gllgl20ll
O 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved.
Journal of Elementary and Secondary Education
Page 10 of34
2010. October. Volume: 1 . Issue: fage 9
reading performance of third grade homeschooled students not receiving AAT reading
instruction.
Nature of the Study
The pilot study utilized an experimental pre/post test control group research
design to determine the effectiveness of AAT reading instruction on improving the
reading performance of third grade homeschooled students. The independent variable of
AAT reading instruction was used as the intervention method that will impact the
dependent variable of reading performance, which was measured by difference scores
from the pre/post test results in the area ofreading rate and overall reading quotient. The
assessment tool that was utilized to determine reading performance was the Gray Oral
Reading Test 4 m edition (GORT-4). Statistical comparisons were based on pre and
posttest results ofboth the experimental and control groups in the areas ofreading rate
and overall reading quotient (ORQ).
Literature Review
The field of AAT is a new and complex area that must be further researched as a
medical adjunct to patient treatment, as an adjunct to reading instruction, as a component
of reading models, and as a potential therapy for student issues such as low self-esteem,
low motivation, and emotional trauma. AAT has been quantitatively researched in the
medical field, thus illustrating the impact animals, and animal ownership and interaction
can have on humans and their health (Fischman,2005; Shaw, 2005; Souter & Miller,
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW-TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co.'. 9l19l20l1
@ 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved.
2007). The use of AAT within the educational setting is relatively new but research by
Jalongo (2004) and Jalongo (2005) has provided basic statistical support forthe positive
impact AAT intervention and instructional can have on the academic performance and
Page 11 of34
Journal ofElementary and Secondary Education 2010. October. Volume: I . Issaeyltn" 19
educational experience ofstudents. A multitude ofadditional anecdotal support exists
regarding the success AAT reading programs have within the school and library settings.
Programs such as READ, Sit, Stay, Read! and Reading paws each provides personal
success stores for AAT within the educational realm (Bueche, 2003; Kogan , 2008;
Moustaki, 2003). Given the current educational situation within public schools in which/"\,r\*-reading performance continues to decline (Palka, 2008), researching viable alternative
educational methods that may improve academic areas of concem such as reading should
be completed (Bannier, 2007; Bush, 2006; Ehren, 2009; Kame' enui, 2004). AAT as a
reading instruction tool is one such option that should be researched and could prove to
be an extremely valuable educational tool. AAT reading instruction is an area that
necessitates further quantitative research to discern the impact it may have on students
and their leaming.
Research Method
The research was used as a pilot study so that the results could prepare the
foundation for future research into this area. In addition, a quantitative experimental
pre/post test control group design was selected based on the nature ofthis design that
allows for difference scores of both the experimental and control groups to be calculated
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW_TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co... 9l19l20ll
@ 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved. Page 12 of34
based on reading rate and ORQ of the GORT-4. The calculation of difference scores
allowed for a statistical point of comparison of reading performance between the
experimental and control group (Lohr, 1999). Such statistical comparison may verifo the
research hypothesis thus validating the effectiveness ofAAT reading instruction as an
educational tool. In order to complete the study, a sample was selected, from which an
experimental and control group were created. Participants within both the experimental
Journal of Elementary and Secondary Education 2010 . October. Volame: 1 . Issueftn" 11
and control groups were either randomly assigned to the experimental or control group by
simple random sampling without replacement (SRSWOR). The use of quantitative
research allowed for statistical data to be collected that results in mixed results
concerning the effectiveness of AAT reading instruction on reading performance.
An experimental design was chosen based on the fact that statistical data can be
collected through the designed experiment. This data can be utilized to establish
powerful cause-effect relationships between variables (Stanovich, 2000). Also, the
researcher aimed to not only determine if AAT impacts reading progress, but also how
the reading performance of the experimental group compared to the control group
through pre test/post test difference scores in the areas of reading rate and ORQ. Within
this research design, one aspect of the research aimed to measure reading rate. In
addition, this research aimed to measure the overall reading quotient (ORQ), which is a
combination of the measurement of reading fluency and reading comprehension. More
specifically, this pilot study utilized a pre-test/post-test control group design so that
http:/ischolar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW_TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co. .. 9l19l20II
O 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved. Page 14 of34
assumptions associated with grade equivalency scores. In addition, gain scores are
recommended by the authors of the Gray Oral Reading Test 4 * edition (GORT-4)
Wiederholt and Bryant (2001) as the most valid measure of change in performance.
Collection and Processing
This pilot study consisted ofseveral phases ofresearch. Once IRB approval was
received from Northcentral University, a pre-test of the GORT-4 was given to members
of both the experimental and control groups. This was followed by a 6-week research
period during which time once weekly reading sessions were completed by members of
both the experimental and control groups. The experimental group received the treatment
of 6 weekly 30-minute one-on-one reading sessions with the therapy animal. In this case
a therapy dog was utilized, given that studies have found that therapy dogs have been the
most effective animal for AAT use (Nimer & Lundahl, 2007). The second group, acting
ll
Journal of Elerrwntary and Secondary Education 2010. October. Volume: I . Issueyltn" 19
as the control group, did not receive any treatment but was required to read aloud
independently in an established location for 30 minutes once a week for 6 weeks. The
AAT reading sessions were once a week 30 minutes reading sessions in which the
member of the experimental group read aloud to the therapy animal, while being
monitored by a certified educational professional who was acting as the dog handler.
Members of the control group read aloud independently in an assigned area of the public
library, for the same 30 minute length of time as the experimental group. The reading
qsinns took nlace nf fhe local lihrarv siven thaf the lihrarv is an edtrcnfionnl
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW_TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co... 9l19l20ll
O 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved.
relationships were determined between reading performance and reading instruction
method and to develop a foundation for future broader research into this area. Pre and
posttest scores from the GORT-4 for both the experimental and control groups were
compiled. From this data, difference scores were calculated and statistical analysis of
means was completed.
Participants
The 26 sample participants were selected from 500 homeschooled third grade
students in Volusia County, Florida. The 26 participants were split into 2 groups of 1 3 to
create an experimental and control group. Participants were assigned to their respective
Page 13 of34
l0
Journal of Elementary and Secondary Education 2010. October. Volumc: 1 . Issueyltn" 12
groups based on simple random sampling without replacement (SRSWOR). In addition,
all participants had to meet certain criteria to be included. First, they had to live in
Volusia County, Florida and be a third grade homeschooled student. They also had to
have no allergies to dogs and no fear of dogs. The small sample of this pilot study
resulted in limited achieved power for analysis and limited the findings to this study.
Reading performance was measured by difference scores, which are also referred
to as gains cores given that all participants made gains in each tested area. Gain scores
were utilized as the performance measurement because of the shortcomings of using
grade equivalency scores. Grade equivalency scores do not take into account that growth
in leaming is not linear and uniform across age groups (Boyer, 2006; Stahl, 2003). Thus
gain scores were selected to avoid the issues of misinterpretation of scores and
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW-TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co... 9l19l20l1
@ 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved. Page 17 of34
comprehenslon, ancl uKQ. Keadlng rate ls the amount oI trme taKen by a student to reacl a
story. Fluency is the students rate and accuracy scores combined, with accuracy being
the student's ability to pronounce each word correctly. Comprehension is the
appropriateness ofthe student's response to questions about the content ofthe study that
was read. ORQ is a measure of overall reading ability that is calculated from the
combination of fluency and comprehension scores.
Finally, a comparison of mean gain scores between groups was completed to
determine if there was statistically significant difference in performance between the
groups in the area of reading rate andlor ORQ. This analysis was completed through the
use of two tailed two-sample t-tests. Given that two tailed t tests assess whether the
means of two groups are statistically different from each other, the two-tailed t-test
matched with the analysis goals of this pilot study. SPSS software was utilized to
analyze calculated t values to determine p values. Determination of statistical
significance was then based on p value findings.
Results and Findings
Analysis of the findings of the descriptive statistics of participants were similar to
those of the normed sample. The complete table to descriptive statistics is included in
APPENDIX A. In addition, there was no calculated difference in means between the
groups in pre test results, thus allowing for t test calculations to be completed using an
equality of variances. A comparison of mean gain scores based on two-tailed two-sample
t tests was completed in the areas of reading rate and ORQ. In the area of reading rate, a
calculated p<.05, with an actual p:.0172 illustrated a statistically significant difference in
Journal ofElementary and Secondary Etlucation 2010. October. Volume: I . Issuey$no 16
14
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW_TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co... 9l19l20l1
@ 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved.
Sdrrrt' rgrrBtrr ut tltllg d) Lllg n1ll r9491116 JE))lull dllu allsu ulluJg lEdulll5 tllaLgllal llulll lll9
list of pre-approved books.
A post-test of the GORT-4 was then given to members of the experimental and
control groups following the completion of the 6-week research period. The GORT-4
was selected as the main measurement instrument. The GORT-4 measures reading
progress and reading performance that results from reading intervention instruction.
Within this study, the reading intervention instruction was the provided AAT oral reading
session. The GORT-4 is a testing instrument of reliability and validity with test/re-test
reliability between .85 and .95 that illustrates minimal inter-scorer difference. In
addition, the high criterion validity of the GORT-4 illustrates that the GORT-4 is a valid
instrument for a range of ages of abilities, within which the sample falls.
Data Analysis
Statistical analysis was then completed based on GORT-4 pre and post results in
the areas of reading rate mean gain scores and overall reading quotient (ORQ) mean
difference scores. Several levels of data analysis was completed. First, descriptive
statistics were compiled that provided a standard mean score comparison to the normed
sample in the areas of reading rate, fluency, comprehension, and ORQ. A test of equality
of means was also completed to ensure that no statistically significant difference existed
between the pre-test mean gain scores of the experimental and control groups. Standard
Page i6 of34
l3
Journal of Elementary and Secondary Education 2010. October. Volume: I 'Issuet'tn" 15
gain scores for each group were also calculated in four areas: reading rate, fluency,
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW-TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google'co... 9l19l20ll
A 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved.
environment that is normally used by homeschooled children (Willingham, 2008). The
selection of this location as one of familiarity with homeschooled children addressed the
external threat to validity of reactive arrangements.
The AAT reading instruction weekly sessions were uniform in structure so that
extraneous variables and error were controlled as much as possible. Each visit was
conducted in an allotted space in the local public library. Within this space, the child was
seated next to the therapy dog, with the dog handler on the other side of the animal
farthest from the child. The parents was allowed to observe from a distance in an
inconspicuous manner but were not permitted to be so close as to interfere or distract
from the AAT reading instruction session. Each session followed a set timetable. To
begin each session, the dog handler was to spend 3 minutes interacting with the dog and
child to create a comfortable atmosphere with lessened anxiety. This was followed by a 3
minute AAT oral reading session in which the child read aloud to the therapy dog from a
personally selected book from the provided pre-approved books. The pre-approved
books were screened to ensure grade level appropriateness for the selected sample. To
Page 15 of34
t2
Journal of Elementary and Secondary Education 2010. October Volume: I . Issueyltn, 14
reduce threats to validity, activity of members of the control group was predetermined.
While a member of the experimental group was participating in an AAT reading session,
a member of the control group was concurrently reading aloud independently at a pre-
determined location in the library. Members of the control groups read aloud for the
-^ l^-^+L ^.c +:*^ ^- +L^ A A'I. -^^,1:-^ -^-^:^- ^-l ^l^^ ^L^^^ -^^l:-^ *^+^-:^l f-^- +L^
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW-TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co... 9l19l20ll
@ 2009 The eleaming Institute. All rights reserved. Page 18 of34
reading rate gain by the experimental group. The complete table to mean reading rate
scores is included in APPENDIX B. This hnding resulted in the rejection of the null
hypothesis (H1) that stated that the reading performance as measured by reading rate of
the experimental group receiving AAT reading instruction will be statistically equivalent
as the reading rate of third grade homeschooled students not receiving AAT reading
instruction.
In the area of ORQ, a calculated p>.05, with an actual p:.21 illustrated that there
was no statistically significant difference in ORQ gain by the experimental group. The
complete table to mean ORQ scores is included in APPENDIX C. This hnding resulted
in the null hypothesis (H2) that stated that the reading performance as measured by ORQ
of the experimental group receiving AAT reading instruction will be statistically
equivalent as the ORQ of third grade homeschooled student not receiving AAT reading
instruction, not being rejected. It is important to note that given the nature of this pilot
study, these findings are non-generalizable.
Conclusions
Several conclusions can be made based on the findings of this study. The
statistically significant mean gains in reading rate by the experimental group was similar
to findings of other research studies (Kuhn, 2005; Samuels & Farstrup,2006).In one
study, assisted reading practice resulted in improved reading rate of 1.6 grade levels over
the course of 6 months (Stahl & Heubach, 2006). These findings illustrated that there is a
connection between increased oral reading practice and improved reading rate.
The ORQ p value findings of p--.2l illustrated that there was no statistically
significant difference in the gain score ofthe experimental group over the control group.
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW-TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co... 9l19l20ll
@ 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved. Page 19 of34
15
Journal ofElenwntary and Secondary Educalion
In addition, Wiederholt and Bryant (200 I ) stated that a gain score of over 9 was needed
for the gain to be statistically significant. While the gain by the experimental was not
greater than 9, the experimental groups gain score was 6.69. This value does illustrate
that a larger gain in the area of ORQ was made by the experimental group. In addition,
consideration should be made with regards to the percentile gains of the experimental
group in all areas of the GORT-4. Within each category of the GORT-4,the gain by the
experimental group exceeded that ofthe control group especially in the area ofreading
rate and ORQ, with a 9 percentile difference in reading rate, 1 percentile difference in
fluency, 3 percentile difference in comprehension, and a 9 percentile difference in ORQ.
The complete table of percentile gains is included in APPENDIX D. When taken
together, the larger gain score and larger percentile gains ofthe experimental group both
provide an important reflection of the impact AAT reading instruction can have on
reading ability. These findings indicate that reading programs that include a variety of
instructional strategies to improve all aspects ofreading ability can create greater overall
improvement in reading ability (NCES, 2006; Nimer & Lundahl, 2007; Pikulski &
Chard,2005).
Limitations
There were several limitations of this pilot study related to interpretation that
should be addressed. First, while the 6-week length of this study was in line with
previous studies and with suggested length of studies (Prescott, 2005), the completion of
a longer study might have produced more conclusive results. Second, the small sample
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW-TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co. .. 9l19l20lI
2010. October. Volume: I .Issuepltn" 17
@ 2009 The eleaming Institute. All rights reserved. Page22 of34
l8
fournal of Elenuntary and Secondary Edacation 2010 . October. Yolume: I 'Issueftn" 29
References
Adams, M. J. (1990). Beginning to read: Thinking and learning about print. Cambridge,
MA: MIT Press.
Bannier, B. J. (2007). Home schooling and developmental education: Leaming from each
other. Research and Teaching in Developmental Education, 23(2),62'68.
Barkley, S. G. (2007). Tapping student efort: Increasing student achievement.
Performance Leaming Systems Inc. Publications Division.
Beck, A. M. (2000). The use of animals to benefit humans: Animal-assisted therapy. In
A. Fine (Ed.), Handbook on animal-assisted therapy: Theoreticalfoundations and
guidelines for practice, p.2l-40. San Diego, CA: Academic Press.
Boyer, V. E. (2006). Animal-assisted therapy in speechJanguage pathologt: Using an
alternafins treatment desisn to comnare the effects of usins animal-assisted
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW_TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co. .. 9l19l20ll
O 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved.
that personalize instruction and teach to the whole child through avariety of methods,
Further research should also aim to determine which aspect of the AAT instruction
impacts learners the most, the dog, the handler, or both?
The completed research based on two guiding research questions resulted in the
statistical information provided in this chapter. Analysis of the data revealed mixed
Page2l of34
l7
Journal of Elen entary and Secondary Education 2010 . October. Volume: I . Issueyltn, 19
results. Findings from a two-sample t-test of reading rate mean difference scores
illustrated the statistical significance of the reading rate gain of the experimental group.
Results of analysis of the ORQ mean difference scores did not prove any statistical
difference between the groups. The small sample that was utilized to complete the pilot
study was a design flaw and resulted in the insufficient achieved power, which might
explain the lack of statistical difference between the experimental and control groups in
the area of ORQ. However, percentile gains made in each reading area by the
experimental group exceeded those ofthe control group. Even though these findings are
not generalizable, the results do indicate that student reading abilities can be effectively
improved through the utilization of a variety of reading instruction strategies (Gordon,
2002;Kame'enui, 2004). Also, the findings of this research begin to lay a foundation for
future research that should explore AAT within the instructional realm. Such reading
instruction should focus on developing a variety ofreading skills that are learned through
balanced reading instruction like assisted reading focused AAT reading instruction that
embraces varietY.
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW-TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co... 9lI9l20l1
@ 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved. Page20 of34
size of this pilot study resulted in low achieved power, which might have impacted the
interpretation of study results. In addition, this sample issue also limited findings to this
Journal of Etementary and Secontdary Educalion
16
2010 . October. Volume: I . Issuepftn"
study. However, it is hoped that the results of this study might lay the foundation for
future larger studies. Third, while the reading activities of both the experimental and
control groups were controlled, the additional interaction and prompting that was
received only by members of the experimental group very well might have impacted the
findings by confusing what was actually impacting the reading performance results; the
dog, the handler, or both? One way this could have been addressed would be by negating
the human interaction by providing members of both groups with interaction and
prompting, thus making the AAT reading instruction the only differing variable between
the groups. Finally, there was a lack ofregulation or control over reading practice and
activity ofparticipants outside ofthe reading practice completed during the research
sessions. While the activify of both groups during the weekly sessions was dictated, the
reading practice and activity of members of the experimental and control groups
completed outside the research sessions was not controlled. Controlling outside activity
of both groups may have produced more significant results.
Research Recommendations and Summary
Finally, several research recommendations can be made. It is hoped that this pilot
study and its results have laid the foundation for future research into this area. These
findings have illustrated the need to explore the value of alternative instruction methods
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW_TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co... 9l19l20l1
,18
@ 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved.
strsvaralJ. '4,
tvJ t \ ,.
Fischman, J. (2005). The pet prescription; See Spot run. Then see Spot lower your blood
pressure and boost your immunity. U.S. News & World Report, 13982),72'74.
Gordon, J. R. (2002). Organizational behavior a diagnostic approach. Upper Saddle
River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Hiebert, E. H., & Fisher l. C. (2002, April). Text matters in developingfluent
reading.Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Intemational Reading
Association, San Francisco, California.
Holdaway, D. (1980). Independence in reading: A handbook on individualized
procedures. Gosford, Australia: Ashton Scholastic.
Jalongo, M. R. (2004). Stories that teach life lessons. Scholastic Parent &
child, 12(2),36-38, 40- 42.
Page24 of34
-\ Jalongo, M. R. (2005). "What are all these dogs doing at school?": Using therapy dogs to
promote children's reading practice. Childhood Education, 8 l (3), 1 52-1 58.
Kame'enui, E. J. (2004). Differentiated curricula and assessment in reading instruction.
20
Journal ofElementary and Secondary Education 2010. October. Volume: 1 . Issueyltn" 22
Retrieved from http://www.childrenofthecode.ors/interviews/kameenui.htm
t) 6o*un, R. (2008, January 27).Teachers' pets: Students polish their reading skills with an
audience that's all ears. Chicago Tribune. Retrieved from
http ://www. chicasotribune. com
Kuhn, M. R., & Stahl, S. A. (2000). Fluency: A review of developmental and remedial
http:/ischolar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW_TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co. .. 9l19l20ll
@ 2009 The eleaming Institute. All rights reserved.
therapy in working with children with language impairmenls. Retrieved from
ProQuest Dissertations & Theses database. (AAT 3229836)'
Bruni, S. (2004). Choking the life out classrooms. In C. Glickman (Ed.), Letters to the
next president: What we can do about the reql crisis in public education (p. 151-
157). New York, NY: Teachers College Press'
Bueche, S. (2003). Goingto the dogs. ReadingToday, 20(4),46.
Bush, G. (2006). Differentiated instruction. School Library Media Activities
Monthly, 23(3),43-45.
Coyne, M.D., Simmons, D. C., Kame'enui, E. J', & Stoolmiller, M. (2004)' Teaching
vocabulary during shared storybook readings: An examination of differential
effects. Exceptionality, I 2, 145-163.
Page23 of34
t9
Journal of Elementary and Secondary Education 2010. October. Volume: I . Issuepltn" 2t1
Cunningham, A. E., & Stanovich, K. E. (1998)' What reading does for the mind.
American Educator. Spring/Summer, 8- I 5.
Ehren, B. J. (2009). Looking through an adolescent literacy lens at the narrow view of
reading. Language, Speech & hearing Services in Schools. 108)' 192'196.
Ehri, L. C. (2005). Learning to read words: theory, findings, and issues. Scientific Studies
of Reading, 9 Q), 167 -188.
Felton, R. H., & Pepper, P. P. (1995). Early identification and intervention of
phonological deficits in kindergarten and early elementary children at risk for
reerlino rliqehilif\r .lnhnnl Psnhnlnat Pottiottt )/. An\-Ll L
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW-TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co. .. 9l19/2011
@ 2009 The eleaming Institute. All rights reserved. Page27 of34
new frontiers. New York, NY: The Guildford Press.
Wasley, P. (2007).Home-schooled students rise in supply and demand. The Chronicle of
Higher Education, 5 4(7), 2-5.
} wieae*rolt, J. L., &p,ryzrrfi,3. (2001). Gray oral Reading Test. Austin, TX: PR6-ED.
Willingham, T. (2008). Libraries and homeschoolers: Our shared cofirmon ground.
I{nowledge Quest, 3 7(l), 58-63.
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW-TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co. .. 9l19l20l1
@ 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved.
'lTibune Business News,P ts| .
Pikulski, J., & Chard, D. (2005). Fluency: Bridge between decoding and reading
comprehension. Reading Teacher, 58f6), 5 l0-5 19.
f tr"r"on, J. R. (2002) . Current usage and limitations of animal-assisted
therapy.Retieved from ProQuest Dissertations & Theses database. (AAT
14092s6).
Ray, B. D. (2009). Homeschool progress report 2009. Salem, OR: NHERI.
Samuels, S. J. (2002). Reading fluency: Its development and assessment' In A. E.
Farstrup & S. J. Samuels (Eds.), Whqt research has to say about reading
instruction (p. 1 66- I 83), Newark, DE: International Reading Association'
Samuels, S. J., & Farstrup. (Eds.) (2006). What research has to say about fluency
instruction. Newark, DE: International Reading Association.
Savage, R., Carless, S., & Erten, O. (2009). The longer-term effects of reading
interventions delivered by experienced teaching assistants, Supportfor Learning,
248),95.
fr ,nu*, T. S. (2005). The use of pets in therapy with children ' The Therapist, 6,1-3'
Souter, M.A., & Miller, M. D. (2007). Do animal-assisted activities effectivelv treat
depr ession? A meta- analv sis. An t hr oz o o s . ( 2 0 ) 2, I 67 - I 8 I .
Stahl, S. A. (2002). Fluency: Instruction and assessmenr [PowerPoint slides] Retrieved
from www.prel.org/proerams/reVfl uency/Stahl.ppt
Stanovich, K. E. (2000) . Progress in understanding reading: Scientific foundations and
Page26 of34
22
Journal of Elementary and Secondary Education 2010. October. Volume: I . Issuepltn" 24
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW-TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co. .. 9l19l20lI
O 2009 The elearning Institute. All rights reserved.
prucuces. AIrrI AI'UUr, MlCIugaIl; Ucltt€I. lor ule llllProvcllrcrll or Eelrry ncaurllg
Achievement.
Lohr, S. L. (1999). Sampling design and analysls. Pacific Grove, CA: Duxbury Press.
Maughan, B., Messer, J., Collishaw, S., Pickles, A., Snowling, M', Yule, W., & Rutter, M.
(2009). Persistence of literacy problems: Spelling in adolescence and at mid-life.
Journal of Child Psychologt and Psychiarry, 50(8),893.
Miller, M., & Lago, D. (1990). The well-being of older women: The importance of pet and
human relations. Anthrozoos, 3, 245-251.
)Montgo*ery, J. K., & Moore-Brown, B. J. (2003). Last chance to become readers: Pre-
referral interventions . Leadership, 22'24.
Moustaki, N. (2003). Reading is Fun-Dog-Mental. Sporting Dog- Fall, 17-19'
National Assessment of Educational Progress (2003). Report cardfor the nation and the
sfafes. National Center for Education Statistics. Washington, D'C.
National Center for Education Statistics. (2006). Trends in the use of school choice: I 993-
2 00 3. Retrieved from http://nces.ed.eov/oubs2007/2007045.pdf.
7$imer, J., & Lundahl,B. (2007).Animal assisted therapy: A meta-analysis. Anthrozoos,
20p),22s-239.
Owens, R. G., & Valesky, T. C. (2007). Organizational behavior in education: Adaptive
Page25 of34
21
Journal of Elementary and Secondary Education 2010 . October. Volume: 1 . Issueyltn" 29
leadership and school reform. Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon'
palka, M. K. (2009, May 2l). Third grade reading and math FCAT report out. McClatchy-
http://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q:cache:TaW-TXtiVTgJ:scholar.google.co. .. 9l19l20ll