www.khlaw.comWashington, D.C. ● Brussels ● San Francisco ● Shanghai
Kelly R. StarostaAssociate
Keller and Heckman LLP1001 G Street, NW
Washington, DC 20001202-434-4265
Nanotechnology inMulti-Layer Food Packaging
Regulatory Update: Nanotechnology in the European Union
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 20102
Keller and Heckman LLP
San Francisco
Washington DCBrussels
Shanghai
Full service law firm representing both domestic and international clients since 1962 Serving business through law and science® via collaboration between attorneys and in-house scientific staff www.khlaw.com and www.packaginglaw.com
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 20104
What is Nanotechnology?
Depends on who you ask!
“Nanotechnology is the study of phenomena and fine-tuning of materials at atomic, molecular and macromolecular scales, where properties differ significantly from those at a larger scale.”
– European Commission Nanotechnology Website http://ec.europa.eu/nanotechnology/index_en.html
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 20105
Properties of Nanoscale Materials
Increased surface area to mass ratio• Surface area of 100 g of lead:
– Conventional particle size (2.6 cm diameter) = 0.002 m2
– 50 nm particle size = 1,000 m2
Result • Nanoscale materials may be more reactive with
materials around them (chemicals and biological systems)
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 20106
Unique Properties = Unique Regulatory Considerations
Is my product “nano” under the EU regulatory framework?
Is there nano-specific legislation for my application? • Food Packaging• Foods• Cosmetics
What are the relevant nano-specific considerations when preparing dossiers?
• Depends on the nanomaterial and the application
Questions to Ask:
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 20107
Is my product “nano” under the EU regulatory framework?
There is currently no single official definition of “nanomaterial” for regulatory purposes in the EU
Recent Development:• Scientific Committee on Emerging and Newly Identified Health
Risks (SCENIHR) pre-consultation opinion, 6 July 2010, entitled: Scientific Basis for the Definition of the Term “Nanomaterial”
– http://ec.europa.eu/health/scientific_committees/emerging/docs/scenihr_o_030.pdf
• European Commission opened public consultation on 12 July 2010; comments due 15 September 2010
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 20108
Scientific Basis for the Definition of the Term “Nanomaterial”
Purpose of the opinion is to provide European Commission with recommendations for use in the developing a definition for the term “nanomaterial” for regulatory purposes
• Opinion recognizes that a working definition of “nanomaterial” is necessary in order to:
– Ensure consistency of forthcoming regulatory developments– Guide effective implementation of existing regulation
Parameters considered for possible inclusion as elements of the definition:• Size• Size distribution• Specific surface area• Other physico-chemical characteristics, e.g., crystallinity, redox potential, radical
formation potential, water solubility, etc.• Nanocomposites• Persistence• Manufactured versus natural
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 20109
SCENIHR Opinion Recommendations
SCENIHR pre-consultation opinion recommends that the term “nanomaterial” should include:
– A defined size range, i.e., a lower (1 nm) and upper (100 nm?) limit, in one or more dimensions
– Referring to one or more external dimensions or an internal structure within the specified range (to include aggregates, agglomerates and multi-component assemblies)
– Consideration of size distribution and a determination as to the percentage of the material, based on number concentration, that must have a size within the range
– Volume specific surface area (VSSA) limitation as a complimentary qualifier for dry solid powders
– “Engineered/manufactured” may be used to designate purposefully made nanomaterials, but has to include processing (grinding or milling resulting in size reduction) of materials
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 201010
SCENIHR Threshold Approach
Category 1: median size > 500 nm
• Median size of the material > 500 nm – It is assumed that the size distribution at the lower end will always be above
the designated lower threshold of 100 nm.
• No further information regarding possible nanospecific properties needed
• Classical risk assessment can be performed taking into consideration the particulate nature of the material
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 201011
SCENIHR Threshold Approach
Category 2: median size < 500 nm (and > 100 nm)• Median size is < 500 nm and > 100 nm
– Material is considered to be a nanomaterial
– More detailed nanospecific risk assessment is necessary taking into consideration possible nanospecific characteristics of the material if:
• Number size distribution demonstrates > 0.15% (or any specified percentage) of the number size distribution is <100 nm
• For dry materials, the volume specific surface area (VSSA) (>60 m2/cm3) may be used as an additional qualifier
– If these criteria are not met, classical risk assessment can be performed
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 201012
SCENIHR Threshold Approach
Category 3: median size < 100 nm and > 1 nm
• The material is considered to be a nanomaterial and nanospecific risk assessment has to be performed when >0.15% (or a specified percentage) of the number size distribution is <100 nm
• For dry materials, the VSSA (>60 m2/cm3) may be used as an additional qualifier
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 201013
SCENIHR Threshold ApproachFigure 1: Risk Assessment on nanomaterials, tiered approach
SCENIHR (Scientific Committee on Emerging and Newly Identified Health Risks), Scientific basis for the definition of the term “nanomaterial”, Pre-consultation opinion, 6 July 2010.
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 201014
Is There Nano-Specific Legislation For My Application?
Overview of Regulatory Updates Specific to:
• Food Packaging Materials
• Food Additives
• Cosmetics
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 201015
Nanomaterials in Food PackagingFramework Regulation (EC) No 1935/2004• Overarching regulation ensuring the safety of food-contact materials• Article 3: Materials and articles reasonably expected to contact food
must not:– Endanger human health;– Bring about unacceptable changes in composition of food; or– Change the organoleptic characteristics of the food
• No nanospecific provisions; requirements would apply equally to nanomaterials
Plastics Directive 2002/72/EC• Major piece of legislation governing plastics used in contact with food• Positive lists for monomers and additives, overall migration limit,
declaration of compliance, etc.• Does a listing for a conventional scale material allow for use of a
nanoscale material?– No specific provision on nanomaterials – not expressly prohibited– Listings are the result of EFSA risk assessment evaluations– Newer packaging legislation is explicit, nanomaterials treated differently
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 201016
Nanomaterials in Food Packaging
New Active and Intelligent Packaging Regulation (EC) No 450/2009
• Nano-engineered substances must always be included in EU positive list of substances authorized as components of active and intelligent packaging
• Functional barrier exclusion not applicable!– “Substances deliberately engineered to particle size which
exhibit functional physical and chemical properties that significantly differ from those at a larger scale” cannot benefit from the functional barrier exclusion
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 201017
Nanomaterials in Food Packaging
Future Regulation
• Draft Plastics Implementing Measure (PIM)– General Goals of PIM
• Consolidate the Plastics Directive (2002/72/EC) with all of its amendments
• Expansion and clarification on the scope of EU legislation • Updates to migration testing requirements
• Also contains provisions specific to nanoparticles!
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 201018
Nanomaterials in Food Packaging
Draft PIM – Provisions Relevant to Nano
• Excludes nanoparticle and nanoform materials from automatic clearance via conventional scale counterparts
– Preamble• (23) “. . . it should be made clear that authorisations which are based
on the risk assessment of the conventional particle size of a substance do not cover engineered nanoparticles.”
– Article 9, Specific requirements• (2) “Unless explicitly mentioned in the specifications in Annex I the use
of substances in nanoform shall not be authorised.”
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 201019
Nanomaterials in Food Packaging
Draft PIM – Provisions Relevant to Nano• Functional barrier exclusions not applicable!
– Article 12, Plastic multi-layer materials and articles• (2)(b) “a plastic layer which is not in direct contact with food and is
separated from the food by a functional barrier, may be: manufactured with substances other than those included in the Community list or in the provisional list”
• (4)(b) “The substances referred to in paragraph 2(b) shall not belong to substances in nanoform”
– Article 13, Multi-material multi-layer materials and articles• (2) “in a multi-material multi-layer material or article a plastic layer
which is not in direct contact with food and is separated from the food by a functional barrier, may be manufactured with substances other than those included in the Community list or the provisional list.”
• (3)(b) “The substances referred to in paragraph 2 shall not belong to substances in nanoform”
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 201020
Nanomaterials in Food Packaging
Will we see the PIM published in 2010?• Work on the PIM has been finalized at the Commission level
• Member State Committee vote scheduled for 12 July 2010 was postponed until September meeting of the appropriate Standing Committee
– Standing Committee for Food Chain and Animal Health
• Now unlikely that the PIM will be published in the EC Official Journal by the end of the year
– Need time for Parliament review, etc.
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 201021
Nanotechnology in Food
Current Legislation
• EU General Food Law Regulation (EC) No 178/2002– Food must not be placed on the market if considered unsafe– Applies to nano-engineered foods/food ingredients
(implicitly), but not specific provisions on nanomaterials
• Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008 on Food Additives(Article 12)
– Changes to the particle size (e.g., through nanotechnology) of a food additive already appearing on a positive list will result in a different additive
• A new entry or change in specifications will be required prior to marketing
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 201022
Nanotechnology in Food
Future Regulation – New Novel Food Reg• Novel Food Regulation (EC) No 258/97 under revision
• “New Novel Food Regulation” proposed by Commission is currently in front of European Parliament and European Council
• Parliament wants:• Nanotechnologies banned from food until the health and
environmental risks they might pose are better understood • Clear labeling for ingredients present in the form of
nanomaterials [nano]
│ www.khlaw.com │ KELLER AND HECKMAN LLP Copyright © 201023
Nanotechnology in Cosmetic Products
Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 - Cosmetic Products
• Consists of positive and negative lists of ingredients and obligation for manufacturer to conduct a risk assessment
• Defines nanomaterial!– ‘Nanomaterial’ means an insoluble or biopersistent and intentionally
manufactured material with one or more external dimensions, or an internal structure, on the scale from 1 to 100 nm
• Requires labeling for nano-containing products– Article 19, Labeling
• “All ingredients present in the form of nanomaterials shall be clearly indicated in the list of ingredients. The names of such ingredients shall be followed by the word ‘nano’ in brackets”
www.khlaw.comWashington, D.C. ● Brussels ● San Francisco ● Shanghai
Kelly R. StarostaKeller and Heckman LLP
1001 G Street, NWWashington, DC 20001
Thank you!