Texas Forest Service
Pest Management
for Pine Trees
Oscar Mestas, Don Grosman and
Bill Upton.
Texas Forest Service,
Forest Pest Management
Lufkin, Texas
Ph: 936-639-8170;
Email: [email protected],
In the spring of 2008, Pinus
eldarica (Afghan pine) trees
in El Paso, TX were found to
be dying.
Surveys revealed Afghan pines were found to be dying
in several communities in west Texas and southern
New Mexico.
External evidence of
chalcid attacks on
branches of Afghan
pine. Notice the
“donuts” (left) and
“bumpy” bark (above).
Small pits containing insect
larvae were found under the bark
of dying branches.
A reference to similar damage was
found in Western Forest Insects
(Furniss and Carolin) and an adult was
collected by Mr. Mestas. It is believed
to be a tiny chalcid wasp, probably
Eurytoma species, family Eurytomidae.
Texas Forest Service
Control Trial
Fifteen trees were selected in El Paso and ten in Midland.
Five trees were treated in El Paso with a Merit®
(imidacloprid) soil injection in late December 2008.
In early April 2009, five trees each (El Paso and Midland)
were injected with emamectin benzoate
(0.16g AI/cm DBH) using Arborjet’s
Tree IV (below right).
Five trees were selected at each site
and monitored as untreated controls.
Emamectin Benzoate
(TREE-äge)
Developed from avermectin, a product of a
naturally occurring soil-born bacteria,
Streptomyces avermitilis. It was discovered in 1984.
Acts on insect nerves to suppress muscle contraction,
resulting in insect paralysis and death.
After injection into a tree, emamectin benzoate appears to
be stored in the tree’s sugars and proteins, and released
as the tree uses it’s stored energy. This results in
extended tree protection (3 or more years).
Texas Forest ServiceEmergence ‘08 Live Larvae ‘09
A branch was collected from the lower, middle and upper
crown of each study tree. The bark was pealed from 30 cm of
each branch and live larvae and last years emergence was
tallied.
Texas Forest Service
Occurrence of Chalcid Wasp on Untreated Afghan Pine Based on Crown Level, El Paso & Midland, TX: 2009
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Emergence '08 Live Larvae '09
Nu
mb
er o
f C
halc
ids p
er 1
00
cm
2 Low Mid Upper
A
B
A
A
A
A
Texas Forest Service
Pre- and Post-Treatment Occurrence of Chalcid Wasp on Afghan Pine Branches, El Paso, TX: 2009 & 2010
Texas Forest Service
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Pre-Treatment Post-Treatment (6 mo)
Nu
mb
er o
f C
halc
ids p
er 1
00
cm
2 Check EBB
A
A B
Pre- and Post-Treatment Occurrence of Chalcid Wasp on Afghan Pine Branches, Midland, TX: 2009
Texas Forest Service
Skyline Park Comparison tag#1 Check (untreated)
April 2009 September 2010
Texas Forest Service
Skyline Park Comparison tag#13 Imidacloprid
April 2009 September 2010
Texas Forest Service
Skyline Park Comparison tag#8 Emamectin Benzoate
April 2009 September 2010
Texas Forest Service
Relative Condition of Afghan Pine Before and 18 Months After Treatment, El Paso, TX
Acknowledgements
W. Upton and B. Kavanagh provided field and lab
assistance.
J. Pase (TFS) provided SBB emergence data.
S. Calhoun (Skyline Park, El Paso), R. Myers (City of
Midland), T. French (private landowner), D. Moore (City of
Allen) and C. Krajca (City of Mesquite) provided study
trees.
This research was supported, in part, by the
Forest Pest Management Cooperative and USFS-FHP R-8
Invasive Species grant, as well as equipment and product
from Arborjet, Inc. and Syngenta Crop Protection.
PINE ENGRAVER BEETLES
Ips avulsus
Ips grandicollis
Ips calligraphus
Here is what to look for . . . .
Engraver beetles are small and difficult to
identify. The rear end of adults has spines
and is “scooped out.”
Ips Activity Is Often Associated
with Lightening Strikes
Pitch tubes often form
on the bark of a pine
tree where Ips engraver
beetles have attacked
the tree. Attacks tend to
be on the bark plates
rather than in the bark
crevices.
Close-up picture of an
Ips pitch tube on the
bark of a pine tree
(note the color).
Pitch tube photos by Donna Work; all other photos by H. A. (Joe) Pase
Reddish boring dust that collects in bark crevices and at the
base of a pine tree indicates attack by pine engraver beetles.
Engraver beetles tend to select stressed or weakened trees
to attack, which results in scattered tree mortality. Notice
that other adjacent pine trees have not been attacked.
A female beetle lays her eggs along
one side of the vertical egg gallery.
Ips egg galleries typically are kept
free of “sawdust.”
Galleries made by Ips larvae extend
away from the egg gallery and
increase in width as the larvae
grow in size. Ips larval galleries
typically are packed with
“sawdust.”
Vertical egg galleries made by adult Ips beetles are a
constant width because adult beetles never grow any larger.
Typical I-shaped egg galleries made by adult small southern pine
engraver (Ips avulsus) beetles. The circular areas in the bark
are where the larvae pupated before emerging as adult beetles.
• 1. Do nothing
• 2. Cut and remove infested trees
• 3. Chemical control is seldom effective
• 4. Cut-and-leave control is NOT effective
• 5. Maintain healthy stands (prevention)
Control options for pine engraver beetles?
Single Tree Protection
“Standard Method”: Spray entire bole with a hydraulic sprayer. Large trees (>30 ft) may require the use of a bucket truck.
Few Products Available: Carbaryl (Sevin®), permethrin (Astro® & Permethrin Pro®) and bifenthrin (Onyx®). Onyx® most effective, but hard to come by. Permethrin OK. Sevin® reported to be ineffective against southern pine bark beetles.
Few Companies Apply: Called 10 companies in Lufkin area; only two will spray for bark beetles (one will only treat for BTB & I’m skeptical about the second)
Texas Forest Service
Hydraulic sprays can only reach to a height of ~30 feet. For largertrees, the need for a bucket truck increase cost considerably.
Texas Forest Service
Even with a light breeze, pesticide can easily drift off target.
Effects of Emamectin Benzoate on Ips
Colonization 1 Month After Injection
Check EB @ 1 month
0
50
100
150
200
250
Le
ng
th o
f E
gg
Ga
lle
rie
s (
cm
)
Check EB
0.2
EB
0.4
Check EB
0.2
EB
0.4
Check EB
0.2
EB
0.4
Check EB
0.2
EB
0.4
Check EB
0.2
EB
0.4
Treatments / Time After Injection
With Brood
Without Brood
1 Month 5 Months3 Months 13 Months 25 Months
Effects of EB injection treatments on Ips galleries length
and brood development in loblolly pine logs: 2005 - 2007
TREE-äge Proposed Pest Targets
Pine Wood Nematode
Lepidoptera
Pine Coneworm
Western Spruce
Budworm
Winter Moth
Bagworm
Fall Webworm
Gypsy Moth
Tent Caterpillars
Clearwing Borers
Leaf Miners
Oakworm Caterpillar
Hymenoptera
Erythrina Gall Wasp
Sawfly
Coleoptera
Emerald Ash Borer
Bronze Birch Borer
Two Lined Chestnut Borer
Longhorn Borers
Bark Beetles (Scolytids)
White Pine Weevil
Mites
Mites – Eur., Spruce, 2 spotted
Eryiophid Mites
Pine Tip Moth(Nantucket pine tip moth)
(Rhyacionia frustrana)
• The larvae feed in the growing tips of young pines
• Five generations per year in the deep South
• Control is usually not economically feasible
• On intensively-managed sites, treatment may be warranted
• Fond of Virginia pine
• Permethrin, Mimic, and Orthene are used for control
• Once trees reach a height of eight to ten feet, tip moths usually are not a problem
Pine Tip Moth
Pine tip moth attacks (larvae) exhibit
webbing and pitch at or near the growing tip.
Pine tip moth damage to a
young tree (left) and a
plantation (below).
Tip moth larvae pupate
in the infested tip.
Spray applications before each of 3 – 5 generations can be
effective for reducing growth losses but they are difficult to
time properly and not economical for large tracts.
SilvaShield™ Forestry Tablets (imidacloprid +
fertilizer) was registered in 2006.
It can be dropped into the plant hole during
planting or pushed into the soil next to the
seedling after planting.
Tablet can protect seedling for 18 – 24 months.
P37
PTM™ (fipronil) was registered in 2007.
Its applied as a soil injection treatment during
or after planting.
It can protect seedlings for 2 – 3 years.
PTM Spot
Gun
Kioritz Fitted Machine Planter
Effect of fipronil in-furrow and plant hole treatments on
tip moth infestation – TR#1, 3 WG sites: 2004 - 2006
*, a or
£= Means are significantly different from check.
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
F2x F4x F8x F2x +
PH
F4x +
PH
F8x +
PH
PH only Mimic
Spray
Check
Treatment
Me
an
(+
SE
) P
ct.
Sh
oo
ts I
nfe
ste
d
CY 2004 CY 2005 CY 2006
*
*** *
a
aa
aa
₤₤
₤₤
ProtectedUnprotected
Texas Forest Service
Questions?
Thank you
for your
attention!