8/14/2019 The Certainty, The Impossible, and what Lies Between: Investigating Information Theory as a Tool for Shaping Ex
1/11
243
1This study was made possible thanks to a scholarship for PhD studies granted by CAPES, Brazil, to which I am
grateful.2 Shannon (1948).3 Wiener (1948).
8/14/2019 The Certainty, The Impossible, and what Lies Between: Investigating Information Theory as a Tool for Shaping Ex
2/11
8/14/2019 The Certainty, The Impossible, and what Lies Between: Investigating Information Theory as a Tool for Shaping Ex
3/11
245
7 In this article,we will be referring to pitch classes only for practicalitys sake; of course, the alphabet can contain
symbols whose nature is as varied as durations, dynamics, tone colours, articulations, etc. but also specific
behaviours, motifs, scenic gestures, instruments, and so forth. Two or more different categories of symbols can bepaired, establishing direct relationships between specific notes and instruments, for example; this possibility is
generally well addressed by matrices of transitional probabilities in stochastic music. See note 6 above.
8/14/2019 The Certainty, The Impossible, and what Lies Between: Investigating Information Theory as a Tool for Shaping Ex
4/11
246
8
Pignatari (2002, 63).9 It is possible to argue that, since a perfect moto perpetuo is a constant repetition of symbols, Bachs Prelude would
not convey any information at all about note durations. However, while there is a constant rhythmic pattern
8/14/2019 The Certainty, The Impossible, and what Lies Between: Investigating Information Theory as a Tool for Shaping Ex
5/11
247
i
n
ii ppH 21 log
throughout the aforementioned example until the final chord, it must be taken into account that there are other
rhythmic layers in higher structural levels along the piece, such as harmonic progressions and melodies resulting
from voice leading. In addition, no sensible performance ofBachs prelude will treat its continuous flow of chordalmotifs as having mechanically measured durations the flexibility of music expression in performance indeed adds
information to an otherwise completely redundant material.
8/14/2019 The Certainty, The Impossible, and what Lies Between: Investigating Information Theory as a Tool for Shaping Ex
6/11
248
10 3.58, as we have already seen, is the maximum entropy possible with twelve symbols.11 Youngblood (1958, 29).12
Shannon (1948, 14).13 Cohen (1962, 140).14 Meyer (1957, 420).
8/14/2019 The Certainty, The Impossible, and what Lies Between: Investigating Information Theory as a Tool for Shaping Ex
7/11
249
15 Hiller et al. (1966, 102).16 Meyer (1957, 412).
8/14/2019 The Certainty, The Impossible, and what Lies Between: Investigating Information Theory as a Tool for Shaping Ex
8/11
250
1 2 3 45 6 8
Time
EntropyH
8/14/2019 The Certainty, The Impossible, and what Lies Between: Investigating Information Theory as a Tool for Shaping Ex
9/11
251
i
n
i
i ppTH 21
log
17 Pignatari (2002, 65). The translation is mine.18 Meyer (1957, 416).
8/14/2019 The Certainty, The Impossible, and what Lies Between: Investigating Information Theory as a Tool for Shaping Ex
10/11
252
19 Meyer (1957, 421).
8/14/2019 The Certainty, The Impossible, and what Lies Between: Investigating Information Theory as a Tool for Shaping Ex
11/11
253