1
DISCOVERING COMMUNICATION CHANNELS USED TO ADVERTISE ACCEPTANCE OF SNAP BENEFITS AT UTAH FARMERS’ MARKETS DR. KELSEY HALL & KENNA MCMURRAY USDA requests innovative ways for farmers’ markets to accept Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) benefits from eligible low-income residents (U.S. Department of Agriculture, 2013). Lack of awareness about farmers’ markets accepting SNAP benefits keeps low-income residents from shopping (Food Research and Action Center, 2013; The Food Trust, 2014). Address SNAP participants’ lack of awareness through effective marketing and promotion (The Food Trust, 2014). Data from part of larger study with two purposes: (1) examine farmers’ market managers’ and vendors’ experiences with accepting SNAP at farmers’ markets & (2) examine low-income residents’ needs, perceptions, and present behavior of shopping at farmers’ markets in Utah. INTRODUCTION/NEED FOR RESEARCH Administered online survey to 11 managers whose farmers’ markets accepted SNAP EBT cards in Utah during the 2014 market season. Questionnaire reviewed by panel of experts. Used Dillman’s Tailored Design Method to contact farmers’ market managers. Compiled results in IBM SPSS Statistics Version 19. METHODOLOGY Majority of farmers’ market managers were female (n = 9, 82.0%) with a bachelor’s degree (n = 7, 64.0%). Their experience as manager ranged from 2 months to 10 years. Seven respondents (63.6%) earned an income as market manager. Nine managers (82.0%) organized community outreach as job duty. Range of 150 to 13,000 customers attended a farmers’ market per market day. Range of 1 to 30 SNAP participants shopped at a farmers’ market per market day. Bus (n = 7, 64%), light rail (n = 3, 27%), senior transit (n = 2, 18%) & Disabled American Veteran van (n = 1, 9%) located near farmers’ markets. Two farmers’ market managers (n = 18.1%) wanted agencies or organizations to advertise to SNAP participants. FINDINGS Study conducted with funding from a 2014 USU Summer Undergraduate Research and Creative Opportunity Grant and Utah Agricultural Experiment Station Project UTAO-1112. Utah managers used similar communication channels as 635 farmers’ market managers in nationwide survey: printed materials (n = 565, 89.1%), Internet (n = 534, 84.1%), billboards or banners (n = 465, 73.2%), & agencies or word of mouth (n = 32, 5%) (U.S. Department of Agriculture, 2013). Continue displaying posters & flyers at public aid offices, WIC clinics, Cooperative Extension Offices, food banks, places of worship, schools, libraries, senior citizen housing, & child care centers to reach SNAP participants. Local television, radio, & newspapers are efficient & cost-effective ways to inform SNAP participants (U.S. Department of Agriculture, 2015); Utah farmers’ market managers would reach SNAP participants by inviting local TV and radio stations to markets. More Utah managers should display posters or flyers at mass transit stations or stops since advertising on local bus & rail systems reaches SNAP participants (U.S. Department of Agriculture, 2015). 312 farmers’ market managers (49.1%) advertised SNAP participation during workshops, discussions, or presentations at schools or community events. CONCLUSIONS/IMPLICATIONS/RECOMMENDATIONS Communication Channels Used by Managers to Advertise SNAP Acceptance at Farmers’ Market (n = 11) Television (n = 1, 9.1%) Posters or flyers in mass transit stations or stops (n = 1, 9.1%) Printed materials to local businesses (n = 1, 9.1%) Printed materials to healthcare facilities (n = 1, 9.1%) Workshops/presentations at schools or community events (n = 0, 0.0%) Internet/website (other than social media) (n = 6, 54.5%) Printed materials (posters, flyers, brochures, direct mail) (n = 9, 81.8%) Social media (blog, Facebook, Twitter, etc.) (n = 8, 72.7%) Banners (n = 7, 63.6%) Word of mouth (n = 10, 90.9%) Newspaper (n = 4, 36.4%) Press releases (n = 4, 36.4%) Radio (n = 3, 27.3%) Mailers or flyers to personal residences (n = 2, 18.2%) Roadside sign (n = 1, 9.1%) Press Release Community-based social marketing (CBSM) (McKenzie-Mohr & Smith, 2011) THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK Step 1 • Select a sustainable behavior that will be promoted: SNAP participants accessing fresh produce through farmers’ markets accepting SNAP benefits Step 2 • Identify benefits and barriers to the behavior Step 3 • Design strategies that use behavior change tools (social norms, prompts, communication, incentives, & making behavior convenient) Step 4 • Pilot the strategies with a small segment of farmers’ market managers Step 5 • Evaluate the impact of the pilot after implementation NEXT STEPS: Surveyed low-income residents to discover willingness to shop at farmers’ markets, demographics, use of communication channels, attitudes toward buying locally, & barriers & benefits to shopping at farmers’ markets. Develop CBSM plan for managers to use to advertise SNAP acceptance of SNAP benefits at their farmers’ markets to SNAP participants. Pilot test CBSM plan. Measure impact & use of CBSM plan by managers in this study to discover best promotional strategy.

Discovering Communication Channels Used to Advertise Acceptance of SNAP Benefits at Utah Farmers' Markets

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Discovering Communication Channels Used to Advertise Acceptance of SNAP Benefits at Utah Farmers' Markets

DISCOVERING COMMUNICATION CHANNELS USED TO ADVERTISE ACCEPTANCE OF SNAP BENEFITS AT UTAH FARMERS’ MARKETS  

DR. KELSEY HALL & KENNA MCMURRAY

•  USDA requests innovative ways for farmers’ markets to accept Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) benefits from eligible low-income residents (U.S. Department of Agriculture, 2013).

•  Lack of awareness about farmers’ markets accepting SNAP benefits keeps low-income residents from shopping (Food Research and Action Center,

2013; The Food Trust, 2014). •  Address SNAP participants’ lack of awareness through effective

marketing and promotion (The Food Trust, 2014). •  Data from part of larger study with two purposes: (1) examine

farmers’ market managers’ and vendors’ experiences with accepting SNAP at farmers’ markets & (2) examine low-income residents’ needs, perceptions, and present behavior of shopping at farmers’ markets in Utah.

INTRODUCTION/NEED FOR RESEARCH

•  Administered online survey to 11 managers whose farmers’ markets accepted SNAP EBT cards in Utah during the 2014 market season.

•  Questionnaire reviewed by panel of experts. •  Used Dillman’s Tailored Design Method to contact farmers’ market

managers. •  Compiled results in IBM SPSS Statistics Version 19.

METHODOLOGY

•  Majority of farmers’ market managers were female (n = 9, 82.0%) with a bachelor’s degree (n = 7, 64.0%). Their experience as manager ranged from 2 months to 10 years. Seven respondents (63.6%) earned an income as market manager.

•  Nine managers (82.0%) organized community outreach as job duty. •  Range of 150 to 13,000 customers attended a farmers’ market per market day. •  Range of 1 to 30 SNAP participants shopped at a farmers’ market per market day. •  Bus (n = 7, 64%), light rail (n = 3, 27%), senior transit (n = 2, 18%) & Disabled American Veteran van (n = 1, 9%) located near farmers’ markets. •  Two farmers’ market managers (n = 18.1%) wanted agencies or organizations to advertise to SNAP participants.

FINDINGS

Study conducted with funding from a 2014 USU Summer Undergraduate Research and Creative Opportunity Grant and Utah Agricultural Experiment Station Project UTAO-1112.

•  Utah managers used similar communication channels as 635 farmers’ market managers in nationwide survey: printed materials (n = 565, 89.1%), Internet (n = 534, 84.1%), billboards or

banners (n = 465, 73.2%), & agencies or word of mouth (n = 32, 5%) (U.S. Department of Agriculture, 2013). •  Continue displaying posters & flyers at public aid offices, WIC clinics, Cooperative Extension Offices,

food banks, places of worship, schools, libraries, senior citizen housing, & child care centers to reach SNAP participants.

•  Local television, radio, & newspapers are efficient & cost-effective ways to inform SNAP participants (U.S. Department of Agriculture, 2015); Utah farmers’ market managers would reach SNAP participants by inviting local TV and radio stations to markets.

•  More Utah managers should display posters or flyers at mass transit stations or stops since advertising on local bus & rail systems reaches SNAP participants (U.S. Department of Agriculture, 2015).

•  312 farmers’ market managers (49.1%) advertised SNAP participation during workshops, discussions, or presentations at schools or community events.

CONCLUSIONS/IMPLICATIONS/RECOMMENDATIONS

Communication Channels Used by Managers to Advertise SNAP Acceptance at Farmers’ Market (n = 11)

Television (n = 1, 9.1%)

Posters or flyers in mass transit stations or stops

(n = 1, 9.1%)

Printed materials to local businesses

(n = 1, 9.1%)

Printed materials to healthcare facilities

(n = 1, 9.1%)

Workshops/presentations at

schools or community events (n = 0, 0.0%)

Internet/website (other than social media)

(n = 6, 54.5%)

Printed materials (posters, flyers, brochures, direct mail)

(n = 9, 81.8%)

Social media (blog, Facebook, Twitter, etc.)

(n = 8, 72.7%) Banners

(n = 7, 63.6%) Word of mouth (n = 10, 90.9%)

Newspaper (n = 4, 36.4%)

Press releases (n = 4, 36.4%)

Radio (n = 3, 27.3%)

Mailers or flyers to personal residences

(n = 2, 18.2%) Roadside sign (n = 1, 9.1%)

Press Release

Community-based social marketing (CBSM)

(McKenzie-Mohr & Smith, 2011)

THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK

Step 1

• Select a sustainable behavior that will be promoted: SNAP participants accessing fresh produce through farmers’ markets accepting SNAP benefits

Step 2 • Identify benefits and barriers to the behavior

Step 3

• Design strategies that use behavior change tools (social norms, prompts, communication, incentives, & making behavior convenient)

Step 4

• Pilot the strategies with a small segment of farmers’ market managers

Step 5 • Evaluate the impact of the pilot after implementation NEXT STEPS:

•  Surveyed low-income residents to discover willingness to shop at farmers’ markets, demographics, use of communication channels, attitudes toward buying locally, & barriers & benefits to shopping at farmers’ markets.

•  Develop CBSM plan for managers to use to advertise SNAP acceptance of SNAP benefits at their farmers’ markets to SNAP participants.

•  Pilot test CBSM plan. •  Measure impact & use of CBSM plan by

managers in this study to discover best promotional strategy.