ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

Fairfield Community School District

High School Master Plan& HVAC Upgrade Plans

March 15, 2010

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

High School Master Plan

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

Shive-Hattery would like to thank the efforts of the School Board, the recent

Planning and Design Advisory Committee, and preceding committees

of similar missions.

The information and input provided by these Citizens, Educators, Students, and Board Members have

shaped what is being proposed for the High School facility.

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

What determined the proposed work for the Fairfield High School?

Several committees over the years have been charged with looking into the built environment of the high school and what issues and impacts the existing building has upon the school systems mission of providing a valuable educational program to its students and by extension the community as a whole. The most recent of these committees was the FSCD Planning and Design Advisory Group co-chaired by Jennifer Anderson and Troy Seeley.

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

What are some of the issues and concerns relating to the existing high school structure…

Learning spaces – are they effective, flexible, and conducive to the educational programSecurity and Safety for students and employeesVentilation, and interior environmental comfortElectrical and mechanical capacityStudent services, including nurses officeADA, and related accessibility issuesPlumbingEnergy usageGreen initiatives

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

Through the Planning and Design Advisory Group several options were explored…

Status Quo – with occasional repair, and remodeling and repurposing of existing facilities

Addition and Remodeling – All at once and retaining the core building

Phased construction – retaining portions of the existing building and new construction over time

New Construction on a new site

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

The results of the Planning and Design Advisory Group and what it recommended to the School Board…

Pros and Cons of Each option as determined by the advisory committee

What the committee decided

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

More specific tailoring of the proposed building was then applied under the direction of the school board to better reflect the educational program resulting in the building presented to you now…

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community SchoolsHigh School Planning Option C (PH I)

Site PlanNo Scale

N

Property Line

Property Line

Pro

per

ty L

ine

Pro

per

ty L

ine

Railroad Right-of-Way

Res

iden

tial

Trojan StadiumConcourse

ExistingGymnasium

StudentParking

Faculty & StaffParking

Visitor Parking

Pro

per

ty L

ine

Briggs

ExistingAuditorium

Residential

Res

iden

tial

Hempstead

MainEntry

GymEntry

StadiumEntry

ServiceEntry

Residential

Visitor ParkingPACEntry

Bus Queue

ExistingCafeteria

Court

Entry

Practice Fields

Broadway

Legend

New Construction PH I

Existing Remodel PH I

Existing to Remain

Circulation

Roof Area

New Service Corridor

New Student & Visitor Parking

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community SchoolsHigh School Planning Option C (PH I)

Basement Floor PlanNo Scale

N

Ensemble

New Unexcavated

New Unexcavated

New

Un

exca

vate

d

New

Un

exca

vate

dN

ew U

nex

cava

ted

New Unexcavated

New Unexcavated

UnexcavatedUnexcavated

Unexcavated

Unexcavated

Unexcavated

Unexcavated

Unexcavated Unexcavated

Unexcavated

Unexcavated

Stor

Boy’s Lockers

Boy’s Lockers

Legend

New Construction PH I

Existing Remodel PH I

Existing to Remain

Circulation

Roof Area

Locker Rooms

Remodel

Improved Access to

Basement and Service Tunnels

Minor Remodel of Vocal Room to

General Purpose Ensemble Space /

Practice

Minor Remodel to Create Additional

Storage Space

Theatrical Storage Removed From Below

Auditorium for Fire Safety – Relocated to

Ground Floor

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community SchoolsHigh School Planning Option C (PH I)

Ground Floor PlanNo Scale

N

Receiving /Storage

Ofc

Elec

Mech

Cost

PropSt

AdministrationStudent Services

Clinic

DistanceLearning

Servery

Cafeteria

Grounds /Keeper

Wrestling

Shop

ElecLab

Girl’s PE

PE Gym Office

Gymnasium

BusinessComputer

Applications

BusinessLab

Acct /Law

FCS Clothing FCS Food /Nutrition

FitnessCenter

FitnessOffice

FitnessSt

SchlStore

WM Coach

Ofc

Health

Vocal

Auditorium

Mt Ft

Vivarium Prep St

Biology

Biology

AutoShop

AutoShop

Ag / HortAg / Hort

Prep

DrySt

PACEntry

GymEntry

StadiumEntry

ServiceEntry

Entry

Ft Mt

MainEntry

MathClrm

MathClrm

MathClrm

MathClrm

SN Clrm1 SN Clrm

2

SN Clrm3 Self-

Contained

SSClrm

SSClrm

SSClrm

Sgr Elec

PE / AthleticsStorage

Sgr Elec

Finish

Legend

New Construction PH I

Existing Remodel PH I

Existing to Remain

Circulation

Roof Area

New Math Suite Improved Receiving &

Storage Kitchen & Servery Updated to Student

Load

New Biological

Science Suite

New Social Studies

Suite

Student Services &

Administration Suite

Improved Visitor Access Control & ADA Compliance

Former Business Area Repurposed for

Fitness Suite

Media Center Repurposed for New Business Suite

Wrestling Room Relocated to Physical

Education Wing

Vocal Relocated Behind Auditorium

Auditorium HVAC Update & ADA Improvements

Locker Room Remodel

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community SchoolsHigh School Planning Option C (PH I)

First Floor PlanNo Scale

N

MediaCenter

ComputerLab

Open to Gymnasium

Band

Auditorium Open to Below

Ft

MtFt

Mt

Art 2DArt 3D

GraphicsLab

ELL /ESLMech

Prac

Prac

Science

Science

Science

Prep St

Faculty Resource

Faculty Lounge

Kitch Driver’sEd

PE / Athletic St.

LAClrm

LAClrm

LAClrm

LAClrm

LAClrm

SN 6Clrm

SN 5Clrm

WLClrm

WLClrm

WLClrm

SN 4Clrm

WrkRm

Ofc

MP

St

Av

ComputerLabConf

BalconyCADD

Legend

New Construction PH I

Existing Remodel PH I

Existing to Remain

Circulation

Roof Area

New Language Arts Suite

New Sciences Suite

New Language Arts Suite

New Media Center & Technology Suite

Auditorium HVAC, ADA Updates &

Expansion

Faculty Resource Center

Graphical Arts Suite Minimal Remodel

Remodeled Band Suite

Conf

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community SchoolsHigh School Planning Option C (PH I)

Second Floor PlanNo Scale

N

Designated Alternative Use or Unoccupied

Open to Below

Legend

New Construction PH I

Existing Remodel PH I

Existing to Remain

Circulation

Roof Area

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

Mass Model ViewsExisting Building

View from Southwest Corner

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

Mass Model ViewsExisting Building

View from Northwest Corner

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

Mass Model ViewsNew Construction

View from Southwest Corner

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

Mass Model ViewsNew Construction

View from Northwest Corner

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

Mass Model ViewsNew Construction

View from North

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

Mass Model ViewsSite Plan New Construction

Birdseye View from South

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

Fairfield Community School District HVAC Upgrade Plans

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

A Report of theElementary & Middle Schools

HVAC Retrofit Analysis

HVAC Systems Analysis

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

Purpose – To analyze the mechanical systems for the following:

• Fairfield Middle School

• Libertyville Elementary

• Pence Elementary

• Washington Elementary

Goal: Heat and Cool the buildings while improving energy efficiency

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

Overview of existing systems:

• Unit ventilators (classroom)

• Convectors

• Boilers

• Fire protection (sprinklers) are basically non-existent

• Electrical system is 1/3 capacity for cooling

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

Other Considerations:

• Comfort

• Indoor air quality (IAQ)

• Equipment life

• Maintenance

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

Typical age of systems:

• Fans – 25 years

• Boilers – 30 years

• Temperature controls – 25 years

• Unit ventilators – 20 years

• Electrical panels – 30 years

• Air conditioning systems – 10 to 25 years

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

• Geothermal systems (closed loop heat pump system)

• Energy efficiency

• Least invasive

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

System Costs:

• Heat Pump $12,009,200 (typical for office systems)

• VAV $12,379,100 (typical for schools, offices & hospitals)

• Geothermal $12,455,400 (schools)

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

Energy Analysis (Washington Elementary):

First Cost Incremental Cost Energy Savings Simple Payback

Heat Pump $1,832,900 N/A N/A N/A

VAV $1,891,000 $58,100 ($1,086/year) N/A

Geothermal $1,905,100 $72,200 $4,605/year 13.3 years

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

INHERENT BENEFITS

•Air Conditioning•Geothermal Fits•Reduces Carbon Footprint•Reduces Energy Costs•Improved Indoor Environment•Lighting Upgrade•Fire Protection System•Life Safety Upgrade•Security System Upgrade•Improved Data / Communication Capacity

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

STUDENT BENEFITS

•Improved Attendance•Improved Test Scores•Reliable and Safe Environment

ringing Education and Architecture Together - Shive-Hattery Education Practice Team

C R E A T I N G L E A R N I N G E N V I R O N M E N T S

B

Fairfield Community Schools

Thank You For Your Time.

Please Let Us Answer Your Questions!