1
treatment programs that would address specific needs of women. Lack of confidentiality represents the principal problem and there is very little assurance that service providers would not disclose a woman’s drug-using status to others. Various issues related to the structure of programs were mentioned, such as absence of a separate entrance to the building, standing in a line (for agonist medication) at dispensing area together with men patients and taking the preparation in front of them, lack of privacy when speaking with their doctors in the presence of other patients and medical personnel. It is estimated that Georgia has 40,000 adult “problem drug users” (systematic users of hard and/or injecting drugs) 1 of whom approximately 2,000– 3,000 are women. Women-centred drug treatment services are not available in Georgia. The purpose of this study is to explore drug use (e.g., types and patterns), HIV and HCV injection and sexual risk behaviors, comorbid conditions (e.g., interpersonal violence, comorbid psychiatric disorders), and treatment barriers and experiences (e.g., gender discrimination, stigma) among IDU Georgian women. Stigma, violence, and the lack of confidentiality: The need for comprehensive, women-centered drug treatment in Georgia I.KIRTADZE 1 , D. Otiashvili 1 , K. O’Grady 2 , W. Zule 3 , E. Krupitsky 4 , W. Wechsberg 3 H. Jones 5,6 1 – Addiction Research Center, Alternative Georgia, Tbilisi 0177 Georgia (Republic of); 2 -Department of Psychology, University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742, USA; 3 - RTI International, Research Triangle Park, NC 27709, USA; 4 -Department of Addictions, Bekhterev Research Psychoneurological Institute, St. Petersburg 192019, Russia; 5 – UNC Horizons Program, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, School of Medicine, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC 27514, USA; 6 – Departments of Psychiatry and Obstetrics and Gynecology, School of Medicine, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21224, USA Supported by NIDA grant R01 DA029880 3. Study Methods Background Results (continued) A qualitative study was conducted during April- September, 2011 in three cities of Georgia. All participants provided written informed consent prior to participating in an interview. Participants A total of 67 potential participants were contacted. Of these, 4 refused participation during initial assessment and 8 were determined to be ineligible to participate, leaving a final sample of 55 women. Eligibility criteria included: conversant in Georgian; 18 years of age or older; able to provide informed consent; injection of illicit drugs in the past 30 days as verified by venepuncture stigmata; sexually active at least once in the past 30 days. Interviews and Qualitative analysis All individual in-depth interviews were audio-recorded and then transcribed. A qualitative analysis software nVivo9 was used for content and thematic analyses. Methods Women in Georgia experience high levels of guilt and shame in acknowledging their substance use. They feel guilt and fear because they deviate from accepted norms and violate traditional gender role expectations in a country where conservative orthodox Christianity dominates. This guilt and shame is experienced in a society with a judgmental approach towards women who use drugs. This fear of social isolation and rejection causes substance-using women to delay seeking help, not simply for the treatment of their substance use, but also for their general health and psychosocial needs. Factors hindering access to and demand for drug treatment services by drug-using women included: Societal stigma, stigma and vulnerability within drug treatment by men and providers, low awareness regarding available treatment services, fear of confidentiality violations, and cost of drug treatment. Physical, sexual, and emotional violence were common aspects of life for drug-using women, often leading to high vulnerability to HIV risk. Respondents indicated that psychological manipulation and threats by partners and family members related to their children were the most severe forms of violence. Drug-using women were reported to lack negotiation, communication, and general life coping skills. There is a critical need for the development of comprehensive women-centered drug treatment services that are accessible, confidential, receptive, and non-judgmental. Empowering women through education, skills building, vocational development, and strategies for violence reduction will serve to increase self-esteem and the capacity for an independent life. Conclusions Demographic characteristics Participants age range varied 18-55 years of age, and 30 (54.5%) had 11 (equivalent to a high school in the United States) or more years of education. On average, each participant has a child; 12 (%) had no children (but 2 were pregnant at interview); of the 43 participants with children, 5 live with their parents, 11 with partners, 10 with husband and children, 16 with their children only; and 1 lives Results indicated they had even been in medication-assisted treatment (MAT), and only 14 (26%) in a needle and syringe program (NSP). 37 (67%) had never heard about either MAT or NSP. Stigma Most respondents have never been tested for HIV or HCV. Testing appears to be a threat for women and they are afraid to find out the results. Only a few participants indicated that they had been tested regularly for STIs. Respondents believe that having HIV/AIDS is highly stigmatizing in Georgia, and so an HIV- positive person tries to conceal her/his status, as public knowledge of her/his disease status might affect heavily her/his life and devastate relationships with family and friends. W15: ”… some are HIV infected but don’t say it out loud because they are afraid people would look at them differently”. Social stigma and public attitudes towards women who use drugs were viewed as playing a major role in women’s treatment-seeking desire, and was seen as a major barrier for women to seek drug treatment. W19: “Maybe women are afraid of someone finding out about their drug use, they are hiding from family… that’s Georgian mentality. If family finds out about her it depends on a family … Mother will be nervous, father too, who likes to have drug user child. Depends on a family, what is their position; they might banish you or on the contrary support you and talk to you”. Violence Violence towards women who use drugs from male partners, drug dealers, and/or family members occurs on a regular basis. It was also noted that depending on woman’s personality she could be both victims and abuser. Most participants felt that emotional abuse is much harder to overcome than physical abuse. Some were concerned that in many cases a woman did not realize that she was a victim of violence – degrading or abusing treatment becomes a “normal” part of life. Importantly, no respondent who had experienced violence was ever referred to police, a physician, or a psychologist. In many cases, abused women shared their experiences with friends only. W04: “I also had similar situation when police told me that I was not worth being a mother and that they should take away my baby… They would not dare to say that [she can’t raise a child], if you see my child you would never say that her mother is a drug addict because she is well raised and for god’s sake has everything.” Lack of confidentiality Results (continued) Contact Information: Irma Kirtadze, M.D., Senior Researcher Addiction Research Center, Alternative Georgia. Address: 14a Nutsubidze Str., Office 2. 0177

 Stigma, violence, and the lack of confidentiality: The need for comprehensive, women-centered drug treatment in Georgia

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Results from qualitative study

Citation preview

Page 1:  Stigma, violence, and the lack of confidentiality:  The need for comprehensive, women-centered drug treatment in Georgia

treatment programs that would address specific needs of women. Lack of

confidentiality represents the principal problem and there is very little assurance that

service providers would not disclose a woman’s drug-using status to others. Various

issues related to the structure of programs were mentioned, such as absence of a

separate entrance to the building, standing in a line (for agonist medication) at

dispensing area together with men patients and taking the preparation in front of

them, lack of privacy when speaking with their doctors in the presence of other

patients and medical personnel.

It is estimated that Georgia has 40,000 adult “problem drug users”

(systematic users of hard and/or injecting drugs)1 of whom

approximately 2,000–3,000 are women. Women-centred drug

treatment services are not available in Georgia.

The purpose of this study is to explore drug use (e.g., types and

patterns), HIV and HCV injection and sexual risk behaviors, comorbid

conditions (e.g., interpersonal violence, comorbid psychiatric

disorders), and treatment barriers and experiences (e.g., gender

discrimination, stigma) among IDU Georgian women.

 Stigma, violence, and the lack of confidentiality: The need for comprehensive, women-centered drug treatment in Georgia

I.KIRTADZE1, D. Otiashvili1, K. O’Grady2, W. Zule3, E. Krupitsky4, W. Wechsberg3 H. Jones5,6

1 – Addiction Research Center, Alternative Georgia, Tbilisi 0177 Georgia (Republic of); 2 -Department of Psychology, University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742, USA; 3 - RTI International, Research Triangle Park, NC 27709, USA; 4 -Department of Addictions, Bekhterev Research Psychoneurological Institute, St. Petersburg 192019, Russia; 5– UNC Horizons Program, Department of

Obstetrics and Gynecology, School of Medicine, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC 27514, USA; 6 – Departments of Psychiatry and Obstetrics and Gynecology, School of Medicine, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21224, USA

Supported by NIDA grant R01 DA029880

3. Study Methods

Background Results (continued)

A qualitative study was conducted during April-September, 2011 in

three cities of Georgia. All participants provided written informed

consent prior to participating in an interview.

Participants A total of 67 potential participants were contacted. Of

these, 4 refused participation during initial assessment and 8 were

determined to be ineligible to participate, leaving a final sample of 55

women.

Eligibility criteria included: conversant in Georgian; 18 years of age or

older; able to provide informed consent; injection of illicit drugs in the

past 30 days as verified by venepuncture stigmata; sexually active at

least once in the past 30 days.

Interviews and Qualitative analysis All individual in-depth interviews

were audio-recorded and then transcribed. A qualitative analysis

software nVivo9 was used for content and thematic analyses.

MethodsWomen in Georgia experience high levels of guilt and shame in acknowledging their

substance use. They feel guilt and fear because they deviate from accepted norms

and violate traditional gender role expectations in a country where conservative

orthodox Christianity dominates. This guilt and shame is experienced in a society

with a judgmental approach towards women who use drugs. This fear of social

isolation and rejection causes substance-using women to delay seeking help, not

simply for the treatment of their substance use, but also for their general health and

psychosocial needs.

Factors hindering access to and demand for drug treatment services by drug-using

women included: Societal stigma, stigma and vulnerability within drug treatment by

men and providers, low awareness regarding available treatment services, fear of

confidentiality violations, and cost of drug treatment. Physical, sexual, and

emotional violence were common aspects of life for drug-using women, often

leading to high vulnerability to HIV risk. Respondents indicated that psychological

manipulation and threats by partners and family members related to their children

were the most severe forms of violence. Drug-using women were reported to lack

negotiation, communication, and general life coping skills.

There is a critical need for the development of comprehensive women-centered

drug treatment services that are accessible, confidential, receptive, and non-

judgmental. Empowering women through education, skills building, vocational

development, and strategies for violence reduction will serve to increase self-

esteem and the capacity for an independent life.

Conclusions

Demographic characteristics

Participants age range varied 18-55 years of age, and 30 (54.5%) had

11 (equivalent to a high school in the United States) or more years of

education. On average, each participant has a child; 12 (%) had no

children (but 2 were pregnant at interview); of the 43 participants with

children, 5 live with their parents, 11 with partners, 10 with husband

and children, 16 with their children only; and 1 lives alone without her

child. None of respondents had ever been in residential treatment, only

4(7%)

Results

indicated they had even been in medication-assisted treatment (MAT), and only 14 (26%)

in a needle and syringe program (NSP). 37 (67%) had never heard about either MAT or

NSP.

Stigma Most respondents have never been tested for HIV or HCV. Testing appears to be

a threat for women and they are afraid to find out the results. Only a few participants

indicated that they had been tested regularly for STIs. Respondents believe that having

HIV/AIDS is highly stigmatizing in Georgia, and so an HIV-positive person tries to conceal

her/his status, as public knowledge of her/his disease status might affect heavily her/his

life and devastate relationships with family and friends.

W15: ”… some are HIV infected but don’t say it out loud because they are afraid people

would look at them differently”.

Social stigma and public attitudes towards women who use drugs were viewed as playing

a major role in women’s treatment-seeking desire, and was seen as a major barrier for

women to seek drug treatment.

W19: “Maybe women are afraid of someone finding out about their drug use, they are

hiding from family… that’s Georgian mentality. If family finds out about her it depends on

a family … Mother will be nervous, father too, who likes to have drug user child. Depends

on a family, what is their position; they might banish you or on the contrary support you

and talk to you”.

Violence Violence towards women who use drugs from male partners, drug dealers,

and/or family members occurs on a regular basis. It was also noted that depending on

woman’s personality she could be both victims and abuser. Most participants felt that

emotional abuse is much harder to overcome than physical abuse. Some were

concerned that in many cases a woman did not realize that she was a victim of violence

– degrading or abusing treatment becomes a “normal” part of life. Importantly, no

respondent who had experienced violence was ever referred to police, a physician, or a

psychologist. In many cases, abused women shared their experiences with friends only.

W04: “I also had similar situation when police told me that I was not worth being a mother

and that they should take away my baby… They would not dare to say that [she can’t

raise a child], if you see my child you would never say that her mother is a drug addict

because she is well raised and for god’s sake has everything.”

Lack of confidentiality

Few women were knowledgeable about treatment for substance use disorders. Some

participants have fragmented information about either medication-assisted withdrawal or

medication-assisted treatment; others did not even know what types of treatment were

available in Georgia. The majority of respondents indicated that there are no available

Results (continued)

Contact Information: Irma Kirtadze, M.D., Senior Researcher Addiction Research Center, Alternative Georgia.

Address: 14a Nutsubidze Str., Office 2. 0177 Tbilisi, GeorgiaPhone: +995577716711 Email: [email protected]