36
$SUR[LPDQGR VROXz FaRHVGH $; % FRP R 0$7/$%

Aproximando soluções de Ax=b com Matlab

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

$SUR[LPDQGR VROXzFaRHV GH

$; %

FRP R 0$7/$%

+DPLOWRQ /HFNDU H 5XEHQV 6DPSDLR

5LR GH -DQHLUR� ����

u,QGLFH

,QWURGXzFaDR LL

� 6LVWHPDV /LQHDUHV ���� ([HPSORV LOXVWUDWLYRV � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���� $SUR[LPDzFaDR GD 6ROXzFaDR FRP R 0$7/$% � � � � � � � � � � � �

����� 6LVWHPD /LQHDU QD IRUPD 0DWULFLDO � � � � � � � � � � � � ������ $SUR[LPDzFaDR GD 6ROXzFaDR � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� ([WHQVaDR� 6ROXzFaDR QR VHQWLGR GH 0urQLPRV 4XDGUDGRV ����� ,QWHUSUHWDzFaDR *HRPuHWULFD GR &RQMXQWR GH 6ROXzFaRHV GH $; E ����� 'HFRPSRVLzFaDR 9DORU 6LQJXODU H 3VHXGR�LQYHUVD FRP R 0$7/$% ��

����� $SUR[LPDzFaDR GD 6ROXzFaDR GR 3UREOHPD FRP R 0$7�/$%� XVDQGR D 3VHXGR�LQYHUVD� � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��

� &RQFOXVaDR ��

$ 3VHXGR�LQYHUVD H R 3UREOHPD GH 0urQLPRV 4XDGUDGRV ��

% 'HFRPSRVLzFaDR 9DORU 6LQJXODU SDUD 0DWUL]HV 5HDLV ��

& 3URJUDPDV VROVLV FRP R 0$7/$% ��

5HIHUAHQFLDV %LEOLRJUuDnFDV ��

L

,QWURGXzFaDR

(VWDV QRWDV HVWaDR GLYLGLGDV HP GXDV SDUWHV SULQFLSDLV� 1D SULPHLUD SDUWH�FDOFXODPRV FRP R 0$7/$%� XPD DSUR[LPDzFaDR GD VROXzFaDR GH XP VLVWHPDOLQHDU� DWUDYuHV GH DOJXQV H[HPSORV QRV WUAHV FDVRV VHJXLQWHV�

q 2 VLVWHPD WHP XPD uXQLFD VROXzFaDR�

q 2 VLVWHPD WHP XPD LQnQLGDGH GH VROXzFaRHV�

q 2 VLVWHPD QaDR WHP VROXzFaDR�

(P FDGD FDVR� FRPSDUDPRV D UHVSRVWD GDGD XVXDOPHQWH SHOR 0$7/$%� FRPD UHVSRVWD REWLGD SRU XP RXWUR SURJUDPD VROVLV� TXH SURFXUD VLPXODU XPDSRVVurYHO UHVROXzFaDR tD PaDR�

1D VHJXQGD SDUWH� DVVRFLDPRV D TXDOTXHU VLVWHPD OLQHDU� XP QRYR SUREOH�PD �QD YHUGDGH� XPD H[WHQVaDR QaDR OLQHDU�� TXH WHP XPD uXQLFD VROXzFaDR�

7UDWD�VH GR VHJXLQWH SUREOHPD GH RWLPL]DzFaDR� �$FKDU XP YHWRU FROXQD; GH FRRUGHQDGDV [�� � � � � [Q FRP QRUPD� PurQLPD WDO TXH Ee�� � � � � E

eP FRP

Ee� D�� [� � � � � � D�Q [Q� � � � � EeP DP� [� � � � � � DPQ [Q FRPSaRHP R YHWRU

FROXQD Ee PDLV SUuR[LPR� GH E��

(P VHJXLGD� XVDQGR R 0$7/$%� DSUR[LPDPRV D VROXzFaDR GHVVH QRYR SUR�EOHPD� D SDUWLU GD SHXGR�LQYHUVD GD PDWUL] GR VLVWHPD FRUUHVSRQGHQWH�

�2V VROVLV VaDR SURJUDPDV VLPSOHV �$SAHQGLFH &� FRP REMHWLYR GLGuDWLFR� TXH n]HPRVXVDQGR D GHFRPSRVLzFaDR YDORU VLQJXODU GH $ �$SAHQGLFH %��

�D VHU GHnQLGD�VHQWLGR D VHU GHnQLGR

LL

� 6LVWHPDV /LQHDUHV

,QLFLDUHPRV FRP XP VLVWHPD OLQHDU JHUDO

�!!!!�!!!!�

D�� [� � � � � � D�Q [Q E�D�� [� � � � � � D�Q [Q E�

���D�� [� � � � � � D�Q [Q EP

���

GH P HTXDzFaRHV QDV Q LQFuRJQLWDV [�� � � � � [Q �

&ODVVLFDPHQWH R SUREOHPD LPSRUWDQWH TXH VH FRORFD SDUD HVVH VLVWHPD uHR VHJXLQWH�

�'DGDV DV FRQVWDQWHV D��� � � � � D�Q� D��� � � � � D�Q� � � � � DPQ H DV FRQVWDQWHVE�� � � � � EP� DFKDU QuXPHURV [�� � � � � [Q SDUD RV TXDLV WRGDV DV HTXDzFaRHV HP ���VaDR VLPXOWDQHDPHQWH YHUGDGHLUDV��

8P WDO FRQMXQWR [�� � � � � [Q VDWLVID]HQGR ��� uH FKDPDGR VROXzFaDR�

��� ([HPSORV LOXVWUDWLYRV

&RQVLGHUDPRV DOJXQV H[HPSORV TXH VHUYLUaDR FRPR EDVH SDUD LOXVWUDU RV FRQ�FHLWRV GHVHQYROYLGRV QHVWH WUDEDOKR�

6LVWHPD ��� �'XDV HTXDzFaRHV H GXDV LQFuRJQLWDV�

��� �� [� � �� ��[� ��� �� [� � �� ��[� �

$ VROXzFaDR GHVVH VLVWHPD uH [� ���

��� �� �������� H [� �� �� �

6LVWHPD ��� �'XDV HTXDzFaRHV H WUAHV LQFuRJQLWDV�

�����[� � �� �� [� � �� �� [� �����[� � �� �� [� b �� �� [� �

$V VROXzFaRHV GHVVH VLVWHPD VaDR GDGDV SRU [� ���

���� F� [�

��

���b F H

[� F� FRP F UHDO DUELWUuDULR� 7HPRV HQWaDR XPD IDPurOLD GH VROXzFaRHV GHVFULWDVSHOR SDUADPHWUR F�

6LVWHPD ��� �7UAHV HTXDzFaRHV H GXDV LQFuRJQLWDV�

�!�!��� �� [� � ���� [� ��� �� [� � ���� [� ��� �� [� b ���� [� �

(VWH VLVWHPD QaDR WHP VROXzFaDR� 1R HQWDQWR VH D WHUFHLUD HTXDzFaDR IRU VXEVWL�WXurGD SRU

�� �� [� b �� �� [� �

PDQWLGDV DV GHPDLV� WHUHPRV R VLVWHPD

6LVWHPD ��� �!�!��� �� [� � ���� [� ��� �� [� � ���� [� ��� �� [� b ���� [� �

R TXDO WHP [� ���

��� �� �������� H [� �� �� FRPR VROXzFaDR�

6LVWHPD ��� �7UAHV HTXDzFaRHV H WUAHV LQFuRJQLWDV�

�!�!��� �� [� � �� ��[� � �� �� [� ��� �� [� � �� ��[� b �� �� [� ��� �� [� b �� ��[� b �� �� [� �

(VWH VLVWHPD WHP FRPR VROXzFaDR JHUDO [� ���

���� F� [�

��

���b F H [� F�

FRP F UHDO DUELWUuDULR�

3RU RXWUR ODGR� R VLVWHPD

6LVWHPD ��� �!�!��� �� [� � �� ��[� � �� �� [� ��� �� [� � �� ��[� b �� �� [� ��� �� [� b �� ��[� b �� �� [� �

QaDR WHP VROXzFaDR�

7HUPLQRORJLD� 8P VLVWHPD OLQHDU HP JHUDO SRGH VHU SRVVurYHO �FRQ�VLVWHQWH� RX LPSRVVurYHO �LQFRQVLVWHQWH��

6LVWHPD SRVVurYHO uH DTXHOH TXH WHP DR PHQRV XPD VROXzFaDR�

([HPSOR� 6LVWHPDV ���� ���� ��� H ����

$OuHP GLVVR� uH

q SRVVurYHO GHWHUPLQDGR� VH WHP XPD uXQLFD VROXzFaDR�

([HPSOR� 6LVWHPDV ��� H ����

q SRVVurYHO LQGHWHUPLQDGR� VH WHP PDLV GH XPD VROXzFaDR�

([HPSOR� 6LVWHPDV ��� H ����

,PSRVVurYHO uH XP VLVWHPD TXH QaDR WHP VROXzFaDR�

([HPSOR� 6LVWHPDV ��� H ����

2EVHUYDFzaDR 'LYHUVRV VaDR RV PuHWRGRV TXH SRGHPRV HPSUHJDU SDUD HVWXGDUXP GDGR VLVWHPD OLQHDU� 'HQWUH HOHV� H[LVWH XP WHRUHPD FOuDVVLFR GH 5RXFKuH�&DSHOOL� TXH QRV SHUPLWH GHFLGLU TXDQGR XP GDGR VLVWHPD OLQHDU GH WLSRTXDOTXHU uH SRVVurYHO RX LPSRVVurYHO H� VH SRVVurYHO� VDEHU VH uH GHWHUPLQDGR RXQaDR� $LQGD PDLV� QR FDVR GH XP VLVWHPD �TXDGUDGR��TXDQGR R QuXPHUR GHHTXDzFaRHV uH LJXDO DR QuXPHUR GH LQFuRJQLWDV� SRVVurYHO GHWHUPLQDGR� KuD D EHPFRQKHFLGD 5HJUD GH &UDPHU SDUD FDOFXODU H[SOLFLWDPHQWH VXD uXQLFD VROXzFaDR�

+RMH HP GLD� SRU TXHVWaRHV SUuDWLFDV� uH SUHFLVR UHVROYHU VLVWHPDV OLQHDU�HV FRP XP JUDQGH QuXPHUR GH HTXDzFaRHV H LQFuRJQLWDV� 1HVWH FDVR� UHVROXzFaDRDQDOurWLFD uH XPD WDUHID� QR PurQLPR� GHVDQLPDGRUD� 3RU LVVR� SUHFLVDPRV HV�FROKHU XP PuHWRGR DGHTXDGR H XVDU R &RPSXWDGRU��

��� $SUR[LPDzFaDR GD 6ROXzFaDR FRP R 0$7/$%

����� 6LVWHPD /LQHDU QD IRUPD 0DWULFLDO

2 0$7/$% RSHUD HVVHQFLDOPHQWH FRP 0$75,=(6� 'Dur� R SULPHLUR SDVVRuH WUDQVIRUPDU QRVVR VLVWHPD OLQHDU GH P HTXDzFaRHV H Q LQFuRJQLWDV QD IRUPDGH XPD HTXDzFaDR PDWULFLDO HTXLYDOHQWH� 2 VLVWHPD uH HVFULWR FRPR XPD uXQLFD

HTXDzFaDR� RQGH DV RSHUDzFaRHV GH DGLzFaDR H PXOWLSOLFDzFaDR HP FDGD HTXDzFaDR GRVLVWHPD uH WUDGX]LGD FRPR RSHUDzFaRHV FRUUHVSRQGHQWHV FRP PDWUL]HV�

�9HMD SRU H[HPSOR D VHzFaDR ����� GD UHIHUAHQFLD 5XJJLHUR H /RSHV�

'HVWH PRGR� R VLVWHPD ��� VH HVFUHYH QD IRUPD PDWULFLDO FRPR

$; E ���

RQGH

$

������

D�� � � � D�QD�� � � � D�Q���

� � ����

DP� � � � DPQ

������ � ;

������

[�[����[Q

������ H E

������

E�E����EP

������ � ���

$ uH D PDWUL] GR VLVWHPD� SRGHQGR VHU TXDGUDGD RX UHWDQJXODU�

E uH R WHUPR LQGHSHQGHQWH GR VLVWHPD� WHP R PHVPR QuXPHUR GH OLQKDV PTXH $�

; uH D PDWUL] LQFuRJQLWD GR VLVWHPD� WHP WDQWDV OLQKDV TXDQWR QuXPHUR GHFROXQDV Q GH $�

7DEHOD � � )RUPD 0DWULFLDO GRV 6LVWHPDV

6LVWHPD $; E

|�� ��[� � �� ��[� ��� ��[� � �� ��[� �

����� �������� ����

w �[�[�

w

���

w

|�� ��[� � ����[� � �� ��[� ��� ��[� � ����[� b �� ��[� �

��� �� �� �� ������ �� �� �� b����

w�� [�[�[�

�� � �

w

�������[� � �� ��[� �����[� � �� ��[� �����[� b �� ��[� �

�� ���� �� ������ �� ������ b�� ��

��� [�

[�

w

�� ���

��

�������[� � �� ��[� �����[� � �� ��[� �����[� b �� ��[� �

�� ���� �� ������ �� ������ b�� ��

��� [�

[�

w

�� ���

��

����� ��[� � ����[� � ����[� ��� ��[� � ����[� b ����[� ��� ��[� b ����[� b ����[� �

�� ���� �� �� �������� �� �� b�������� b�� �� b����

���� [�

[�[�

��

�� ���

��

����� ��[� � ����[� � ����[� ��� ��[� � ����[� b ����[� ��� ��[� b ����[� b ����[� �

�� ���� �� �� �������� �� �� b�������� b�� �� b����

���� [�

[�[�

��

�� ���

��

����� $SUR[LPDzFaDR GD 6ROXzFaDR

4XDQGR D PDWUL] $ GR VLVWHPD uH TXDGUDGD H LQYHUVurYHO� D VROXzFaDR uH GDGDIRUPDOPHQWH SRU ; $b� E � 1R HQWDQWR� LQYHUWHU D PDWUL] $ QaDR uH XPDWDUHID FRPSXWDFLRQDO PXLWR HVWuDYHO�

$FKDU ; $b� E FRP R 0$7/$% FRUUHVSRQGH tD RSHUDzFaDR ; $ Q ED TXDO XVD HOLPLQDzFaDR *DXVVLDQD H QaDR FDOFXOD D PDWUL] $b� GLUHWDPHQWH�4XDQGR D PDWUL] $ QaDR uH TXDGUDGD� D RSHUDzFaDR $ Q E YDULD GH DFRUGR FRPSURSULHGDGHV GD PDWUL] $� 3RU H[HPSOR� VH DV FROXQDV GH $ VaDR OLQHDUPHQWHLQGHSHQGHQWHV� $ Q E XVD D GHFRPSRVLzFaDR RUWRJRQDO GH $�

9HPRV HP VHJXLGD� D UHVSRVWD REWLGD SDUD FDGD VLVWHPD H[HPSOR� XVDQGRSULPHLUDPHQWH D IXQzFaDR $ Q E H HP VHJXLGD D UHVSRVWD GDGD SHORV VROVLV ��RV TXDLV VaDR SURJUDPDV VLPSOHV� FRP REMHWLYR GLGuDWLFR� TXH n]HPRV XVDQGRD GHFRPSRVLzFaDR YDORU VLQJXODU GH $�� (VVHV UHVXOWDGRV VaDR FRPSDUDGRV FRPDV VROXzFaRHV GH FDGD VLVWHPD QD 7DEHOD ��

6LVWHPD ��� FRP $Q E

$ >��� ����� ���� ���@�

E >���@�

; $?E

;

������

������

6LVWHPD ���� FRP VROVLV�

VROVLV�

;

������

������

�9HMD QR $SAHQGLFH &��9HMD QR $SAHQGLFH %�

2 UHVXOWDGR uH R PHVPR� 1RWH TXH D PDWUL] $ uH LQYHUVurYHO�

6LVWHPD ��� FRP $Q E

$ >��� ���� ���� ���� ��� �����@�

E >���@�

; $?E

;

������

������

6LVWHPD ��� FRP VROVLV�

VROVLV�

\�

������

\�

������

\�

�������

Z�

������

Z�

�������

Z�

������

[� \��F Z�

[� \��F Z�

[� \��F Z�

6LVWHPD ��� FRP $Q E

$ >��� ����� ���� ���� ���� ����@�

E >�����@�

; $?E

;

������

�������

6LVWHPD ��� FRP VROVLV�

VROVLV�

6LVWHPD LPSRVVLYHO

6LVWHPD ��� FRP $Q E

$ >��� ����� ���� ���� ���� ����@�

E >� �� ��@�

; $?E

;

������

������

6LVWHPD ��� FRP VROVLV�

VROVLV�

;

������

������

6LVWHPD ��� FRP $Q E

FOHDU

$ >��� ���� ���� ���� ��� ������ ���� ���� �����@�

E >� �� ��@�

; $?E

:DUQLQJ� 0DWUL[ LV FORVH WR VLQJXODU RU EDGO\ VFDOHG�

5HVXOWV PD\ EH LQDFFXUDWH� 5&21' ��������H����

;

������

������

�������

3RGHPRV REVHUYDU TXH HVWH VLVWHPD uH HTXLYDOHQWH DR 6LVWHPD ��� SRVWR TXHVXD WHUFHLUD OLQKD uH D GLIHUHQzFD HQWUH VXD VHJXQGD H SULPHLUD OLQKDV� $SUR[L�

PDzFaRHV GH VXDV VROXzFaRHV VaDR GDGDV SRU VROVLV � FRPR QR FDVR GR 6LVWHPD����

VROVLV�

\�

������

\�

������

\�

�������

Z�

������

Z�

�������

Z�

������

[� \��F Z�

[� \��F Z�

[� \��F Z�

6LVWHPD ��� FRP $Q E

FOHDU

$ >��� ���� ���� ���� ��� ������ ���� ���� �����@�

E >�����@�

; $?E

:DUQLQJ� 0DWUL[ LV FORVH WR VLQJXODU RU EDGO\ VFDOHG�

5HVXOWV PD\ EH LQDFFXUDWH� 5&21' ��������H����

;

���H����

������

�������

������

6LVWHPD ��� FRP VROVLV �

VROVLV�

6LVWHPD LPSRVVLYHO

5HVXPLPRV RV UHVXOWDGRV DQWHULRUHV QD VHJXLQWH WDEHOD�

��

7DEHOD � � $SUR[LPDzFaDR GD 6ROXzFaDR FRP R 0$7/$%

6LVWHPD 6ROXzFaDR $QE VROVLV

��� ����� � � ��� ����� � � �

�� ������ ����

������������

�� ����� � � � � F

�� ����� � � � b F

� � � � � F

�� ������ ����

������ � F ������������ b F ������

b������ � F ������

� QaDR WHP VROXzFaDR�� ����

b�� ����6LVWHPD LPSRVVurYHO

��� ����� � � ��� ����� � � �

�� ������ ����

������������

�� ����� � � � � F

�� ����� � � � b F

� � � � � F

&XLGDGR�5HV� LPSUHFLVR

������ � F ������������ b F ������

b������ � F ������

� QaDR WHP VROXzFaDR&XLGDGR�5HV� LPSUHFLVR

6LVWHPD LPSRVVurYHO

$OJXPDV &RQFOXVaRHV GD 7DEHOD ��

q $ TXDGUDGD LQYHUVurYHO� $ Q E uH XPD DSUR[LPDzFaDR GD VROXzFaDR�

q $ TXDGUDGD QaDR LQYHUVurYHO� $ Q E uH XPD DSUR[LPDzFaDR GD VROXzFaDR RX QaDR�

q $ QaDR TXDGUDGD FRP PDLV OLQKDV GR TXH FROXQDV H R VLVWHPD SRVVurYHOGHWHUPLQDGR� $Q E uH XPD DSUR[LPDzFaDR GD VROXzFaDR�

� ([WHQVaDR� 6ROXzFaDR QR VHQWLGR GH 0urQLPRV

4XDGUDGRV

2EMHWLYR� 'DU VHQWLGR DQDOurWLFR H FRPSXWDFLRQDO DR VHJXLQWH SUREOHPD GHRWLPL]DzFaDR�

6HMD $ XPD PDWUL] TXDOTXHU H E XP YHWRU FROXQD FXMR QuXPHUR GH OLQKDVuH LJXDO DR QuXPHUR GH OLQKDV GH $�

��

$FKDU XP YHWRU FROXQD ; GH QRUPD �D VHU HVFROKLGD� PurQLPD WDO TXHEe $; uH R YHWRU PDLV SUuR[LPR GH E �QXP VHQWLGR D VHU HVWDEHOHFLGR��

��� ,QWHUSUHWDzFaDR *HRPuHWULFD GR &RQMXQWR GH 6ROXzFaRHV

GH $; E

9DPRV HVFUHYHU FDGD FROXQD GD IRUPD $; FRPR XPD UHVXOWDQWH RX FRPEL�QDzFaDR OLQHDU GRV YHWRUHV FROXQDV GH $� WHQGR DV FRRUGHQDGDV [�� � � � � [Q GRYHWRU FROXQD ; FRPR FRHnFLHQWHV� 2 FRQMXQWR GH WDLV FROXQDV REWLGDV� uHFKDPDGR GH FRQMXQWR LPDJHP GH $� 'HVWH PRGR� XP VLVWHPD $; E WHUuDVROXzFaDR VH D FROXQD GDGD E SHUWHQFHU D LPDJHP GH $� FDVR FRQWUuDULR� QaDR WHPVROXzFaDR� 1D SULPHLUD KLSuRWHVH� R VLVWHPD WHUuD VROXzFaDR uXQLFD VH DV FROXQDV GH$ IRUHP OLQHDUPHQWH LQGHSHQGHQWHV� FDVR FRQWUuDULR� LVWR uH� VH DV FROXQDV GH$ IRUHP OLQHDUPHQWH GHSHQGHQWHV� WHUuD XPD LQnQLGDGH GH VROXzFaRHV�

2 SUREOHPD JHUDO TXH YDPRV DVVRFLDU D XP VLVWHPD OLQHDU TXDOTXHU� WHUuDHP SDUWLFXODU� DV VHJXLQWHV FDUDFWHUurVWLFDV�

7HUuD VROXzFaDR uXQLFD H VXD DSUR[LPDzFaDR QXPuHULFD SRGH VHU GDGD SRU XPDRSHUDzFaDR VLPSOHV FRP R 0$7/$%�

6HUuD D SUuRSULD VROXzFaDR GR VLVWHPD� QR FDVR GH XP VLVWHPD SRVVurYHO GHWHUPL�QDGR�

6HUuD D VROXzFaDR FXMD VRPD GRV TXDGUDGRV GH VXDV FRRUGHQDGDV uH PurQLPD� QRFDVR GH XP VLVWHPD SRVVurYHO LQGHWHUPLQDGR�

6HUuD D VROXzFaDR GR VLVWHPD $; Ee QR FDVR HP TXH R VLVWHPD GDGR uHLPSRVVurYHO� SRUuHP R QRYR VLVWHPD $; Ee� RQGH Ee uH R HOHPHQWRGD LPDJHP GH $ WDO TXH D VRPD GRV TXDGUDGRV GDV GLIHUHQzFDV GDVFRRUGHQDGDV GH Eb Ee uH PurQLPD� uH SRVVurYHO GHWHUPLQDGR�

6HUuD D VROXzFaDR GH $; Ee FXMD VRPD GRV TXDGUDGRV GH VXDV FRRUGHQDGDVuH PurQLPD� QR FDVR HP TXH R VLVWHPD $; E uH LPSRVVurYHO� RQGH Ee uHFRPR QR LWHP DQWHULRU H $; Ee uH SRVVurYHO LQGHWHUPLQDGR�

7RPHPRV GRLV VLVWHPDV SDUWLFXODUHV SDUD DQDOLVDU D VLWXDzFaDR�

6LVWHPD ��� �'H WUAHV HTXDzFaRHV H GXDV LQFuRJQLWDV��!�!�

D�� [� � D�� [� E�D�� [� � D�� [� E�D�� [� � D�� [� E�

��

RX GH RXWUR PRGR HTXLYDOHQWH

[�

��� D��

D��D��

��� � [�

��� D��

D��D��

���

��� E�E�E�

��� �

&RP RV YHWRUHV FROXQD $�

���

D��D��D��

��� � $�

���D��D��D��

��� H <

���\�\�\�

��� � D

IuRUPXOD < [�$� � [�$� FRP [� H [� YDULDQGR DUELWUDULDPHQWH� GHnQHXP GRV VHJXLQWHV VXEFRQMXQWR I<J GR HVSDzFR�

q I<J I�J� uH D RULJHP GR HVSDzFR�

q I<J uH XPD UHWD SDVVDQGR SHOD RULJHP�

q I<J uH XP SODQR SDVVDQGR SHOD RULJHP�

1RWH TXH I<J QaDR SRGHUuD VHU R HVSDzFR ,5� LQWHLUR �VuR WHPRV GRLV YHWRUHV ���

7DEHOD �

I< J YHWRU E 6LVWHPD �

I�J I�J� I�J

SRVVurYHO LQGHWHUPLQDGRLPSRVVurYHO

UHWD {� { � {

SRVVurYHO LQGHWHUPLQDGRLPSRVVurYHO

SODQR m� m � m

SRVVurYHO GHWHUPLQDGRLPSRVVurYHO

6LVWHPD ��� �'H GXDV HTXDzFaRHV H WUAHV LQFuRJQLWDV�

�D�� [� � D�� [� � D�� [� E�D�� [� � D�� [� � D�� [� E� �

��

RX� HTXLYDOHQWHPHQWH

[�

�D��D��

�� [�

�D��D��

�� [�

�D��D��

�E�E�

��

&RP RV YHWRUHV FROXQD $�

�D��D��

�� $�

�D��D��

�� $�

�D��D��

�H

<

�\�\�

�� D IuRUPXOD < [�$� � [�$� � [�$� FRP [� � [� H [�

YDULDQGR DUELWUDULDPHQWH� GHnQH XP GRV VHJXLQWHV VXEFRQMXQWRV GR SODQR�

q I<J I�J uH D RULJHP GR HVSDzFR�

q I<J uH XPD UHWD SDVVDQGR SHOD RULJHP�

q I<J uH R SODQR LQWHLUR�

1RWH TXH SRGHUuD VHU R SODQR ,5� LQWHLUR SRLV WHPRV WUAHV YHWRUHV�

7DEHOD �

I< J YHWRU E 6LVWHPD �

I�J I�J� I�J

SRVVurYHO LQGHWHUPLQDGRLPSRVVurYHO

UHWD {� { � {

SRVVurYHO LQGHWHUPLQDGRLPSRVVurYHO

SODQR ,5� � ,5� SRVVurYHO LQGHWHUPLQDGR

3DVVRV GD ([WHQVaDR

3DVVR ��

(VFROKHU R YHWRU Ee GH I<J PDLV SUuR[LPR GH E� RX VHMD� TXHWRUQD PurQLPD D GLVWADQFLD MMEe b EMM �

��

3DVVR ��

(VFROKHU R YHWRU ; GH QRUPD PurQLPD TXH VDWLVID] R VLVWHPD$; Ee�

$VVLP� FRPELQDQGR HVWHV SURFHGLPHQWRV� FKHJDPRV D XP SUREOHPD EHP GH�WHUPLQDGR�

3UREOHPD� $FKDU R YHWRU FROXQD ; GH QRUPD PurQLPD TXH PLQLPL]D R

HUUR H�=� MM$= b EMM �

2EVHUYDzFaDR� 3RGH DFRQWHFHU QD SUuDWLFD TXH D QRUPD RX QRzFaDR GH GLVWADQFLDPDLV DGHTXDGD DR SUREOHPD HP TXHVWaDR� VHMD GLIHUHQWH GD QRUPD HXFOLGHDQDXVXDO� 3RUWDQWR� WHPRV QHVWH FDVR XP SUREOHPD PDLV JHUDO�

��� 'HFRPSRVLzFaDR 9DORU 6LQJXODU H 3VHXGR�LQYHUVD FRP

R 0$7/$%

u( EDVWDQWH LQWHUHVVDQWH REVHUYDU TXH H[LVWH XPD QRzFaDR GH LQYHUVD JHQHUDOL]D�GD� GH XPD PDWUL] $ GH TXDOTXHU WLSR� TXH UHVROYH SURQWDPHQWH R SUREOHPDDFLPD GHVFULWR�

7UDWD�VH GD LQYHUVD JHQHUDOL]DGD GH 0RRUH�3HQURVH RX SVHXGR�LQYHUVD GDPDWUL] $�

'HnQLzFaDR� 'DGD XPD PDWUL] $� UHWDQJXODU GH WLSRPdQ� FKDPDPRV LQYHUVDJHQHUDOL]DGD GH 0RRUH�3HQURVH RX SVHXGR�LQYHUVD GH $ D TXDOTXHU PDWUL] %GH WLSR QdP WHQGR DV TXDWUR SURSULHGDGHV VHJXLQWHV�

�L� $%$ $ �LLL� �%$�7 %$�LL�%$% % �LY� �$%�7 $%�

3RGH VHU SURYDGR TXH H[LVWH XPD uXQLFD PDWUL] % FRP HVWDV SURSULHGDGHV�

D TXDO GHQRWDUHPRV SRU $\� $ SVHXGR�LQYHUVD $\ SRGH VHU FDOFXODGD FRP DIXQzFaDR LQWHUQD SLQY GR 0$7/$%�

�GHQWUH YuDULDV RXWUDV� 9HMD SRU H[HPSOR HP *ROXE H 9DQ /RDQ��9HMD D IuRUPXOD ��� GR $SAHQGLFH $�

��

����� $SUR[LPDzFaDR GD 6ROXzFaDR GR 3UREOHPD FRP R 0$7/$%� X�VDQGR D 3VHXGR�LQYHUVD�

'DGD XPD PDWUL] $ H XP YHWRU FROXQD E FRP R PHVPR QuXPHUR GH OLQKDV TXH$� ; GH QRUPD PurQLPD TXH PLQLPL]D R HUUR H�;� MM$; b EMM uH GDGR SRU

; $\ E �

0DLV H[SOLFLWDPHQWH� ; $\ E uH R uXQLFR YHWRU FROXQD FRP D VHJXLQWHSURSULHGDGH�

�� �$; b E�7 < �� SDUD WRGR < � I<J

�� 6H �$= b E�7 < �� SDUD WRGR < � I<J� HQWaDR ;7 ; � =7 =�

6ROXzFaDR GRV 6LVWHPDV ([HPSORV FRP R 0$7/$%� XVDQGR SLQY�

6LVWHPD ���

FOHDU

$ >��� ����� ���� ���@�

E >���@�

; SLQY�$� E

;

������

������

6LVWHPD ���

FOHDU

$ >��� ���� ���� ���� ��� �����@�

E >���@�

; SLQY�$� E

��

;

������

������

�������

6LVWHPD ���

FOHDU

$ >��� ����� ���� �������� ����@�

E >�����@�

; SLQY�$� E

;

������

�������

6LVWHPD ���

FOHDU

$ >��� ����� ���� ���@�

FOHDU

$ >��� ����� ���� �������� ����@�

E >�����@�

; SLQY�$� E

;

������

������

6LVWHPD ���

FOHDU

$ >��� ���� ���� ���� ��� ���������� ���� �����@�

��

E >�����@�

; SLQY�$� E

;

������

������

�������

6LVWHPD ���

FOHDU

$ >��� ���� ���� ���� ��� ���������� ���� �����@�

E >�����@�

; SLQY�$� E

;

������

������

�������

1D WDEHOD VHJXLQWH� SRGHPRV FRPSDUDU RV UHVXOWDGRV DQWHULRUHV�

��

7$%(/$ �

6ROXzFaDR $QE VROVLV SLQY

��� ����� � � ��� ����� � � �

������������

�� ������ ����

������������

������� � � � � F

������� � � � b F

� � � � � F

������������

������ � F �� ���������� b F �� ����

b������ � F �� ����

������������

b������

� QaDR WHP VROXzFaDR������

b������6LVWHPD LPSRVVurYHO

������b������

��� ����� � � ��� ����� � � �

������������

�� ������ ����

������������

������� � � � � F

������� � � � b F

� � � � � F

$WHQzFaDR�5HV� LPSUHFLVR

������ � F �� ���������� b F �� ����

b������ � F �� ����

������������

b������

� QaDR WHP VROXzFaDR$WHQzFaDR�5HV� LPSUHFLVR

6LVWHPD LPSRVVurYHO������������

b������

� &RQFOXVaDR

2 SUREOHPD $; E uH XP GRV PDLV LPSRUWDQWHV GD 0DWHPuDWLFD� 2 TXH uHQRUPDOPHQWH HQVLQDGR uH TXH VH $ IRU LQYHUVurYHO HQWaDR $b�E uH D uXQLFD VROXzFaDR�1R FDVR FRQWuDULR GH $ VHU QaDR LQYHUVurYHO� PXLWR SRXFR uH HQVLQDGR�&DOFXODU GLUHWDPHQWH XPD UHVSRVWD SDUD $; E uH XP SURFHVVR SHQRVR�

PHVPR SDUD DSHQDV � YDULuDYHLV� GH PRGR TXH R XVR GH XP SDFRWH� WLSR0$7/$%� VH ID] QHFHVVuDULR�2 TXH SURFXUDPRV PRVWUDU QHVWDV QRWDV uH TXH� PHVPR XVDQGR XP SD�

FRWH SRGHURVR FRPR R 0$7/$%� D UHoH[aDR VREUH R VLJQLnFDGR GD UHVSRVWD uHLPSUHVFLQGurYHO� 1aDR uH SRVVurYHO XVDU SDFRWHV VHP UHoHWLU VREUH R TXH VH HVWuDFDOFXODQGR� u( QHFHVVuDULR FRPSUHHQGHU FRPR DV UHVSRVWDV VaDR FDOFXODGDV HFRP TXH SUHFLVaDR�1D YHUGDGH� VuR uH SRVVurYHO XVDU SDFRWHV FRP VHJXUDQzFD TXDQGR VH FRQKHFH

HP SURIXQGLGDGH DV WHRULDV PDWHPuDWLFDV HQYROYLGDV H DV DSUR[LPDzFaRHV TXH

��

HVWaDR VHQGR IHLWDV�3DFRWHV QaDR VaDR VXEVWLWXWRV SDUD WHRULDV� H VHP HVWDV� RV SDFRWHV QaDR VaDR

FRQnuDYHLV�

��

$ 3VHXGR�LQYHUVD H R 3UREOHPD GH 0urQLPRV

4XDGUDGRV

9HPRV QD nJXUD TXH Ee uH R uXQLFR YHWRU GH I<J TXH WRUQD PurQLPR R HUURH�;� MM$; b EMM� 3RGHPRV FDUDFWHUL]DU Ee SRU PHLR GD FRQGLzFaDR VHJXLQWH

�< � I<J� < 7 �Ee b E� �

TXH WUDGX] R IDWR GH Ee VHU R uXQLFR YHWRU FROXQD GH I<J WDO TXH E b Ee VHMDRUWRJRQDO tD I<J�

'Dur� FRPR < [�$� � [�$� FRP DV YDULuDYHLV [� H [� DUELWUuDULDV �6LV�WHPD ���� H < [�$� � [�$� � [�$� FRP DV YDULuDYHLV [� � [� H [�DUELWUuDULDV �6LVWHPD ����� WHPRV �$��

7 �Ee b E� �$��7 �Ee b E� � QR

SULPHLUR FDVR H �$��7 �Ee b E� �$��

7 �Ee b E� �$��7 �Ee b E� � QR

VHJXQGR� &RP XP SHTXHQR HVIRUzFR� GuD SDUD YHULnFDU TXH HVWDV FRQGLzFaRHVHTXLYDOHP� HP FDGD FDVR� D VHJXLQWH FRQGLzFaDR PDWULFLDO

$7 �Ee b E� � �

$VVLP� VH $; Ee� WHPRV

$7 E $7 $; � ���

��

9DPRV PRVWUDU TXH D LQYHUVD JHQHUDOL]DGD GH 0RRUH�3HQURVH �RX SVHXGR�LQYHUVD� GD PDWUL] $ GHWHUPLQD R YHWRU FROXQD ; GH QRUPD PurQLPD�

'HnQLzFaDR� 'DGD XPD PDWUL] $� UHWDQJXODU GH WLSRPdQ� FKDPDPRV LQYHUVDJHQHUDOL]DGD GH 0RRUH�3HQURVH RX SVHXGR�LQYHUVD GH $ D TXDOTXHU PDWUL] %GH WLSR QdP WHQGR DV TXDWUR SURSULHGDGHV VHJXLQWHV�

�L� $%$ $ �LLL� �%$�7 %$�LL�%$% % �LY� �$%�7 $%�

3RGH VHU SURYDGR TXH H[LVWH XPD uXQLFD PDWUL] % FRP HVWDV SURSULHGDGHV�

D TXDO GHQRWDUHPRV SRU $\� $ SVHXGR�LQYHUVD $\ SRGH VHU FDOFXODGD FRP DIXQzFaDR LQWHUQD SLQY GR 0$7/$%�

5HVROXzFaDR GR 3UREOHPD

'DGD XPD PDWUL] $ H XP YHWRU FROXQD E FRP R PHVPR QuXPHUR GH OLQKDVTXH $� ; GH QRUPD PurQLPD TXH PLQLPL]D R HUUR H�;� MM$; b EMM uH GDGRSRU

; $\ E �

0DLV H[SOLFLWDPHQWH� ; $\ E uH R uXQLFR YHWRU FROXQD FRP D VHJXLQWHSURSULHGDGH�

�� �$; b E�7 < �� SDUD WRGR < � I<J

�� 6H �$= b E�7 < �� SDUD WRGR < � I<J� HQWaDR ;7 ; � =7 =�

'H IDWR� 6HMD ; $\ E � (QWaDR�

$7 $; $7 $ �$\ E� $7 �$$\� E $7 �$$\�7 E $7 �$\�7 $7 E �$$\$�7 E $7 E �

YHULnFDQGR D (T� ���� (P SDUWLFXODU� PRVWUDPRV WDPEuHP TXH $ �$\E� Ee�(P UHVXPR� WHPRV $; Ee H MM$; b EMM PurQ< MM$< b EMM �

)DOWD PRVWUDU TXH ; $\ E WHP QRUPD PurQLPD� 3DUD LVWR� REVHUYDPRVTXH VH < � I<J� LVWR uH� $< Ee� SRGHPRV HVFUHYHU < K � $\ E FRP KVDWLVID]HQGR $K � �

�9HMD D IuRUPXOD ��� GR $SAHQGLFH $�

��

0RVWUHPRV TXH < 7 < w �$\ E�7 $\ E � &RP HIHLWR� PXOWLSOLFDzFaDR GLUHWDQRV OHYD D < 7 < �$\ E�7 $\ E � K7 K � � K7 $\ E �

$V SURSULHGDGHV GH $\ WHPRV TXH K7 $\ E �� 'H IDWR�

�K7 $\ E�7 �K7 �$\$$\� E�7 ��K7 $\$� �$\ E��7 �$\ E�7 �K7 $\$�7

�$\ E�7 �$\$�7 K �$\ E�7 �$\$�K �$\ E�7 $\ �$K� �

RQGH XVDPRV $K � �

3VHXGR�LQYHUVD D SDUWLU GD GHFRPSRVLzFaDR YDORU VLQJXODU�

'D (TXDzFaDR ��� GR $SAHQGLFH %� WHPRV

$ 8 6 9 7 �

$ SHXGR�LQYHUVD $\ uH GHnQLGD SHOD IuRUPXOD

$\ 9 a6 87 ���

VHQGR a6 D PDWUL] Q SRU P REWLGD GD WUDQVSRVWD 67 GH 6� VXEVWLWXLQGR�VH RVHOHPHQWRV QaDR QXORV 6LL GH VXD GLDJRQDO SRU VHXV LQYHUVRV � 6LL �

��

% 'HFRPSRVLzFaDR 9DORU 6LQJXODU SDUD 0DWUL]HV

5HDLV

1HVWD VHzFaDR� HVWXGDPRV XPD GHFRPSRVLzFaDR SDUD XPD PDWUL] UHWDQJXODU� DTXDO WHP JUDQGH LPSRUWADQFLD HP uDOJHEUD OLQHDU FRPSXWDFLRQDO� GHQRPLQDGDGHFRPSRVLzFaDR YDORU VLQJXODU�

7RPHPRV XPD PDWUL] UHWDQJXODU $� GH RUGHP P d Q� H GHQRWHPRV SRUP A Q� R PHQRU GRV LQWHLURV P H Q�

t$ JURVVR PRGR� SRGHPRV GHVFUHYHU D GHFRPSRVLzFaDR YDORU VLQJXODU GH $�GD VHJXLQWH PDQHLUD�

([LVWHP PDWUL]HV XQLWuDULDV 8 H 9 GH RUGHPV P H Q UHVSHFWLYDPHQWH� WDLV

TXH $ VH HVFUHYH QD IRUPD

$9 8 6 � ���

RQGH

6 uH D PDWUL] UHWDQJXODU GH RUGHP P d Q� FXMD GLDJRQDO uH FRQVWLWXurGD

SRU UHDLV QaDR QHJDWLYRV }�� }�� � � � � }PAQ H WRGDV DV VXDV GHPDLV HQWUDGDV VaDR

QXODV�

(P SDUWLFXODU� WHPRV$ 8 6 9 7 � ���

0DLV H[SOLFLWDPHQWH� HVFUHYDPRV 9 >Y�� Y�� � � � � YQ@� DWUDYuHV GH VXDV FROXQDVYL � ,5Q H DQDORJDPHQWH� 8 >X�� X�� � � � � XP@� FRP XL � ,5P� 1HVWH FDVR� DHTXDzFaDR ��� SDUD P A Q Q� VH HVFUHYH FRPR

$Y� }� X�$Y� }� X�

���$YPAQ }PAQ XPAQ

���

6H P A Q P� D HTXDzFaDR ��� HTXLYDOH DV HTXDzFaRHV ��� MXQWDPHQWH FRP DVHTXDzFaRHV VHJXLQWHV

$YP�� �$YP�� �

���$YP �

���

RX VHMD�

��

VaDR QXODV� WRGDV DV FROXQDV HP ���� GD P� � tD Qb uHVLPD�

$ WurWXOR GH LOXVWUDzFaDR� QRWDPRV TXH VH P A Q P� D PDWUL] 6 WHP DIRUPD VHJXLQWH�

>GLDJ�}�� }�� � � � � }P�� �PdIQbPJ@

������}� � � � � � � � � � �� }� � � � � � � � � ����

���� � �

������� � �

���� � � � � }P � � � � �

������ ����

1R FDVR HP TXH P A Q Q� D PDWUL] 6 WHP D IRUPD�

��� GLDJ�}�� }�� � � � � }Q�

�IPbQJdQ

���

��������������

}� � � � � �� }� � � � ����

���� � �

���� � � � � }Q� � � � � ����

���� � �

���� � � � � �

��������������

����

2V UHDLV QaDR QHJDWLYRV }�� }�� � � � � }PAQ VaDR GHQRPLQDGRV YDORUHV VLQJX�

ODUHV GH $� RV YHWRUHV Y�� Y�� � � � � YP VaDR GHQRPLQDGRV YHWRUHV VLQJXODUHV tD

GLUHLWD GH $� HQTXDQWR TXH X�� X�� � � � � XQ GHQRPLQDP�VH YHWRUHV VLQJXODUHV tDHVTXHUGD GH $�

2EVHUYDzFaDR $ SDUWLU GH ���� SRGHPRV GHGX]LU LPHGLDWDPHQWH DV VHJXLQWHVSURSULHGDGHV�

L� 2 SRVWR GD PDWUL] $� SRVWR�$� �GLPHQVaDR GD LPDJHP GH $�� uH LJXDO DRQuXPHUR GH YDORUHV VLQJXODUHV }L HVWULWDPHQWH SRVLWLYRV GH $ �9HMD DV(TXDzFaRHV ���� H ������

LL� 6H GHQRWDPRV� FRQWDQGR PXOWLSOLFLGDGH� RV DXWR�YDORUHV QaDR QXORV GH$7 $� HP RUGHP GHFUHVFHQWH� SRU w� � w� � � � � � wU ! �� WHPRV GH ����

$9 8 6 � 9 7 $7 6787

H GDur�9 7 $7 $9 6787 8 6 67 6 ����

H$$7 $9 9 7 $7 8 6 6787 �

��

RX VHMD�87 $$7 8 6 67 � ����

$VVLP� GH ���� H ����� WHPRV TXH RV DXWR�YDORUHV QaDR QXORV GH $7 $ H$$7 VaDR RV PHVPRV� H QD YHUGDGH FRLQFLGHP FRP RV TXDGUDGRV GRVYDORUHV VLQJXODUHV GH $�

w� }�� � w� }�

� � � � � � wU }U� ! � �

LLL� 2 QuXPHUR GH FRQGLFLRQDPHQWR GH XPD PDWUL] $� Q SRU Q� LQ�YHUVurYHO� FRQG�$�� uH GHnQLGR FRPR

FRQG�$� MM$MM� MM$b�MM�

RQGH

MM$MM� VXS;� �

MM$;MM

MM;MM�

0DV� GH $ 8 6 9 7 � YHP $b� 9 6b� 87 �

6HQGRMM$MM� }� PDLRU YDORU VLQJXODU GH $

HMM$b�MM� � }Q LQYHUVR GR PHQRU YDORU VLQJXODU GH $

WHPRVFRQG�$� }� }Q �

,VWR uH XPD FRQVHTXAHQFLD LPHGLDWD GR WHRUHPD VHJXLQWH�

7HRUHPD �'HFRPSRVLzFaDR YDORU VLQJXODU� 6HMD $ XPD PDWUL] UHWDQJXODU GHRUGHP P d Q FRP FRHnFLHQWHV UHDLV� GDGD DUELWUDULDPHQWH� (QWaDR� H[LVWHPPDWUL]HV 9 GH RUGHP Q H 8 GH RUGHP P RUWRJRQDLV H H[LVWHP QuXPHURV UHDLV}� w }� w � � � w }PAQ w �� WDLV TXH

87 $9 6 ����

RQGH 6 uH D PDWUL] GH RUGHP Pd Q GHnQLGD SRU�!�!�

6LM }L L M

6LM � L� M �

��

3URYD� �,QGXzFaDR VREUH D RUGHP GH $� 6HMD }� � MM$MM� VXSMM; MM �MM$;MM �

&RPR D HVIHUD XQLWuDULD GH ,5Q� 6 I; � ,5Q � MM;MM �J uH FRPSDFWD�VHJXH GR WHRUHPD GH :HLHUVWUDVV TXH H[LVWH XP YHWRU XQLWuDULR Y� � ,5Q VDWLV�ID]HQGR MM$MM� MM$Y�MM� (P SDUWLFXODU� }� ! �� �3RU TXAH"�

2EVHUYDPRV TXH }� FRUUHVSRQGH DR FRPSULPHQWR GR PDLRU VHPL�HL[R GRHOLSVuRLGH JHQHUDOL]DGR ( I$; � ,5P � MM;MM �J�

2EYLDPHQWH HVWDPRV VXSRQGR $ � �� &DVR FRQWUuDULR� D GHFRPSRVLzFaDRYDORU VLQJXODU GH $ SRGH VHU REWLGD� VLPSOHVPHQWH FRP 6 �� 9 GH RUGHPQ H 8 GH RUGHP P� RUWRJRQDLV TXDLVTXHU�

$VVLP� D SULPHLUD HTXDzFaDR HP ���� SRGH VHU LPHGLDWDPHQWH VDWLVIHLWD VH

GHnQLPRV R YHWRU XQLWuDULR X� SRU X� �

}�$Y��

3DUD REWHUPRV R SDVVR GH LQGXzFaDR� SUHFLVDPRV PRVWUDU TXH R VXSOHPHQWDURUWRJRQDO GH ,5 c IY�J ImY� � m � ,5J HP ,5Q� WHP FRPR LPDJHP SRU $ HP,5P� XP VXEHVSDzFR RUWRJRQDO D ,5 c IX�J InX� � n � ,5J�

7RPHPRV Z� � ,5Q XQLWuDULR� RUWRJRQDO D Y� �Y7� Z� �� H PRVWUHPRV TXH

$Z� uH RUWRJRQDO D X��

3DUD LVWR� GHnQDPRV Z }� Y� � �X7� $Z��Z� H GHQRWHPRV X

7� $Z� � p �

1HVWH FDVR� DSOLFDQGR $� REWHPRV $Z }��X��p $Z�� &RPR Z� IRL WRPDGR

XQLWuDULR� YHPRV TXH

MMZMM� }�� � p�MMZ�MM

� }�� � p� �

3RU RXWUR ODGR�

MM$ZMM� }�� � �}�

� p� � p� MM$Z�MM�

w }�� � �}�

� p� � p�

�}�� � p��� �}�� � �X

7� $Z��

����

YLVWR TXH MX7�$Z�M � MM$Z�MM �GHVLJXDOGDGH GH &DXFK\�6FKZDU]��

'D GHnQLzFaDR GH }� WHPRV

}�� w

MM$ZMM�

MMZMM�w }�

� � �X7�$Z��

� ����

H SRUWDQWR� WHPRV X7� $Z� � � RX VHMD� $Z� uH RUWRJRQDO D X��

��

2EVHUYDPRV TXH R PHVPR UHVXOWDGR uH REWLGR VH Z� QaDR uH XQLWuDULR�

$ SDUWLU GHVVH UHVXOWDGR� SRGHPRV SURFHGHU LQGXWLYDPHQWH� SDUD REWHU DGHFRPSRVLzFaDR YDORU VLQJXODU GH $� GHWHUPLQDQGR R VHJXQGR YDORU VLQJXODU}� GH $� $SOLFDPRV R UDFLRFurQLR DQWHULRU tD UHVWULzFaDR GH $� DR FRPSOHPHQWRRUWRJRQDO GH Y� HP ,5Q� FXMD LPDJHP HVWuD FRQWLGD QR FRPSOHPHQWR RUWRJRQDOGH X� HP ,5P�

1RWDPRV GDur TXH }� � }�� H DVVLP VXFHVVLYDPHQWH� $V PDWUL]HV 9 H 8 VaDRWRPDGDV� SRU H[HPSOR� FRPR VHQGR 9 >Y�� Y�� � � � � YQ@ H 8 >X�� X�� � � � � XP@�RQGH VH PAQ P� HQWaDR YP��� � � � � YQ VaDR TXDLVTXHU WDLV TXH 9 uH RUWRJRQDO�H VH P A Q Q� HQWaDR XQ��� � � � � XP VaDR TXDLVTXHU WDLV TXH 8 uH RUWRJRQDO�

2V }L VaDR WRGRV XQLYRFDPHQWH GHWHUPLQDGRV SRU$� HQTXDQWR TXH R PHVPRQaDR RFRUUH FRP DV PDWUL]HV 9 H 8 �

3RGHPRV HQWaDR� GDU SRU HQFHUUDGD D SURYD GR WHRUHPD�

��

& 3URJUDPDV VROVLV FRP R 0$7/$%

8VDPRV R 0$7/$% SDUD DWUDYuHV GD GHFRPSRVLzFaDR YDORU VLQJXODU �VYG�� ID]HUXP SURJUDPD TXH DSUR[LPD D VROXzFaDR GH FDGD XP GRV 6LVWHPDV ([HPSORV�FRP XP SURFHGLPHQWR DQuDORJR DR TXH IDUurDPRV� VH EXVFuDVVHPRV UHVROYAH�ORVDQDOLWLFDPHQWH� VHP R XVR GH XP FRPSXWDGRU� 8VDPRV DLQGD� D VYG DR LQYuHVGH RXWUD GHFRPSRVLzFaDR GH $� SRUTXH HVWD GHFRPSRVLzFaDR VH DSOLFD D PDWUL]HVGH TXDLVTXHU RUGHQV H HVWuD OLJDGD tD SVHXGR�LQYHUVD GH $� DWUDYuHV GD (T� ���GR $SAHQGLFH $� $ LGuHLD GRV SURJUDPDV uH D VHJXLQWH� 8VDQGR D VYG GH $�FRQIRUPH D (T� ��� GR $SAHQGLFH %� HVFUHYHPRV

$ 8 6 9 7

RQGH DV PDWUL]HV 8 H 9 VaDR RUWRJRQDLV� LVWR uH� 87 8 8 87 ,PdP H9 7 9 9 9 7 ,QdQ H DOuHP GLVVR� 6 uH XPD PDWUL] UHWDQJXODU GLDJRQDO�FRQIRUPH (T� ����� ���� GR $SAHQGLFH %� 'Dur� $; E uH HVFULWD FRPR8 6 9 7 ; E� RX DLQGD� 6 9 7 ; 87 E� (QWaDR� UHVROYHPRV SULPHLUR RVLVWHPD 6 = F� RQGH F 87 E H = 9 7 ; H HP VHJXLGD� WHPRV ; 9 = �

��VROVLV �

��UHVROXFDR GH VLVWHPDV JHUDLV XVDQGR VYG

FOHDU

E >���@�

$ >��� ����� ���� ���@�

N UDQN�$��

>8�6�9@ VYG�$��

F 8 E�

]� F����6������

]� F����6������

= >]��]�@�

; 9 =

HQG

��VROVLV �

��UHVROXFDR GH VLVWHPDV JHUDLV XVDQGR VYG

FOHDU

E >���@�

$ >��� ���� ���� ���� ��� �����@�

N UDQN�$��

��

>8�6�9@ VYG�$��

F 8 E�

]� F����6������

]� F����6������

= >]��]�@�

; >9��������� = 9�����@�

\� ;�����

\� ;�����

\� ;�����

Z� 9�����

Z� 9�����

Z� 9�����

GLVS�[� \��F Z��

GLVS�[� \��F Z��

GLVS�[� \��F Z��

HQG

��VROVLV �

��UHVROXFDR GH VLVWHPDV JHUDLV XVDQGR VYG

FOHDU

E >�����@�

$ >��� ����� ���� ���� ���� ����@�

N UDQN�$��

>8�6�9@ VYG�$��

F 8 E�

LI DEV�F����!����������

GLVS�6LVWHPD LPSRVVLYHO�

HOVH

]� F����6������

]� F����6������

= >]��]�@�

; 9��������� =

HQG

��VROVLV �

��UHVROXFDR GH VLVWHPDV JHUDLV XVDQGR VYG

FOHDU

E >�����@�

��

$ >��� ����� ���� ���� ���� ����@�

N UDQN�$��

>8�6�9@ VYG�$��

F 8 E�

LI DEV�F����!����������

GLVS�6LVWHPD LPSRVVLYHO�

HOVH

]� F����6������

]� F����6������

= >]��]�@�

; 9��������� =

HQG

��VROVLV �

��UHVROXFDR GH VLVWHPDV JHUDLV XVDQGR VYG

FOHDU

E >� �� ��@�

$ >��� ���� ���� ���� ��� ������ ���� ���� �����@�

N UDQN�$��

>8�6�9@ VYG�$��

F 8 E�

LI DEV�F����!����������

GLVS�6LVWHPD LPSRVVLYHO�

HOVH

F 8 E�

]� F����6������

]� F����6������

= >]��]�@�

; >9��������� = 9�����@�

\� ;�����

\� ;�����

\� ;�����

Z� 9�����

Z� 9�����

Z� 9�����

GLVS�[� \��F Z��

GLVS�[� \��F Z��

GLVS�[� \��F Z��

��

HQG

��VROVLV �

��UHVROXFDR GH VLVWHPDV JHUDLV XVDQGR VYG

FOHDU

E >� �� ��@�

$ >��� ���� ���� ���� ��� ������ ���� ���� �����@�

N UDQN�$��

>8�6�9@ VYG�$��

F 8 E�

LI DEV�F����!����������

GLVS�6LVWHPD LPSRVVLYHO�

HOVH

F 8 E�

]� F����6������

]� F����6������

= >]��]�@�

; >9��������� = 9�����@�

\� ;�����

\� ;�����

\� ;�����

Z� 9�����

Z� 9�����

Z� 9�����

GLVS�[� \��F Z��

GLVS�[� \��F Z��

GLVS�[� \��F Z��

HQG

��

5HIHUAHQFLDV %LEOLRJUuDnFDV

*�+� *ROXE� &�)� 9DQ /RDQ� 0DWUL[ &RPSXWDWLRQV� -RKQV +RSNLQV 6HULHVLQ WKH 0DWKHPDWLFDO 6FLHQFHV � �������

.� +RmPDQQ� 5� .XQ]H� u$OJHEUD /LQHDU� /7&� 5LR GH -DQHLUR �������

5� $� +RUQ� &� 5� -RKQVRQ� 0DWUL[ $QDO\VLV� &DPEULGJH 8QLY� 3UHVV�������

5� $� +RUQ� &� 5� -RKQVRQ� 7RSLFV LQ 0DWUL[ $QDO\VLV� &DPEULGJH 8QLY�3UHVV �������

+� )� /HFNDU� 5� 6DPSDLR� 3UREOHPDV GH $XWR�YDORUHV *HQHUDOL]DGRV� )D�

WRUDzFaDR GH 0DWUL]HV� 5HODWuRULR 7uHFQLFR� ,/7&� 3uRV�*UDG� 0DWHPuDWLFD�8)) �������

0RRUH� (� +� � 2Q WKH UHFLSURFDO RI WKH JHQHUDO DOJHEUDLF PDWUL[� $EVWUDFW�%XOO� $PHU� 0DWK� 6RF� �� ������� SS� ��������

3HQURVH� 5�� $ JHQHUDOL]HG LQYHUVH IRU PDWULFHV � 3URF� &DPEULGJH 3KLORV�6RF� �� ������� SS� ��������

0� $� *� 5XJJLHUR� 9� /� GD 5� /RSHV� &uDOFXOR 1XPuHULFR� $VSuHFWRV 7HuRULFRV

H &RPSXWDFLRQDLV� 0F*UDZ�+LOO� 6�3DXOR �������

5� 6DPSDLR� (� &DWDOGR� 5� 5LTXHOPH� ,QWURGXzFaDR DR 0$7/$%� /DER�UDWuRULR GH 9LEUDzFaRH� 38&�5LR �������

:DWNLQV� '� � )RXQGDWLRQV IR 0DWUL[ &RPSXWDWLRQV� :LOH\ �������

7KH 0DWK :RUNV� 0$7/$% 8VHUV *XLGH� �������

��