Five Star Home Professionals

SPECIAL ADVERT IS ING SECT ION

JUNE 2015 COLUMBUS MONTHLY FS 1

Five Star Home Professionals2015 Columbus

Find us online:F: Facebook.com/FiveStarProfessional

T: Twitter.com/FiveStarProswww.fivestarprofessional.comTo nominate an outstanding home professional

for next year’s award, go to www.fivestarprofessional.com.

Know a great home professional?

Five Star Professional partnered with Columbus Monthly to identify real estate, mortgage and insurance professionals in the Columbus area who deliver outstanding service and client satisfaction. The Five Star Professional research team contacted thousands of recent homebuyers,

as well as other consumers. Clients may also submit evaluations online. Phone, mail and online respondents rated their service professional on criteria such as overall satisfaction and whether they would recommend the provider to a friend. The research methodology allows no more than 7 percent of professionals in each category to receive the award. This year’s winners are listed and profiled in the following pages (see each award winner’s listing for more details).

1. Received a qualifying client satisfaction rating.

2. Satisfied the applicable state licensing requirements.

3. Act ive ly employed as a l i censed professional for a minimum of three years.

4. Favorable regulatory and complaint history review.

5. Satisfied minimum client volume or production on a one-year and three-year b a s i s ( n u m b e r a n d v o l u m e o f t ransac t ions or number o f c l i ent households served).

Professionals who satisfied each of the following objective criteria were named a 2015 Columbus Five Star Real Estate Agent, Five Star Mortgage Professional or Five Star Home/Auto Insurance Professional:

• The 2015 Five Star Real Estate Agents, Mortgage Professionals and Home/Auto Insurance Professionals do not pay a fee to be included in the research or the final list.

• Each professional is screened against state governing bodies to verify that licenses are current, and no disciplinary actions are pending.

• The inclusion of a real estate agent, mortgage professional or insurance professional on the final lists should not be construed as an endorsement by Five Star Professional or Columbus Monthly.

• The research process incorporates a statistically valid sample in order to identify the professionals in the local market who score highest in overall satisfaction. These professionals are not included on the list unless their score is statistically valid.

For more information on the Five Star award and the research/selection methodology, go to www.fivestarprofessional.com.

DisclosuresResearch of Award Winners

Determination

Real Estate Agents

Mortgage Professionals

Home/Auto Insurance Professionals

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

SPECIAL ADVERT IS ING SECT ION Five Star Real Estate Agents

FS 2 COLUMBUS MONTHLY JUNE 2015

In today’s market, it is essential to work with a real estate specialist who will represent you well. Your home purchase is probably your largest investment, and I will treat it as such. It is truly an honor to once again be recognized for the prestigious Five Star Real Estate Agent award. I would like to thank my clients, as this recognition is made possible by working with such wonderful people. Whether you are a buyer or seller, I would love the opportunity to put my integrity and experience to work for you!

2288 East Main StreetBexley, OH 43209

Office: 614-324-4314Cell: 614-598-4292

[email protected]

• Quality Choice Award

• International President’s Circle (Top 5% of all Coldwell Banker agents)

• Leaders Award

• Five Star Real Estate Agent 2014 and 2015

Two-year winner Jackie Groom

Jackie GroomReal Estate Professional, Lic. 2002009406

Integrity and Experience … Qualities That Matter

TWO-YEAR WINNER

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL



Serving all areas of Columbus and the vicinity, I take pride in providing all of my buyer and seller clients with knowledgeable, responsive, exceptional service that exceeds their expectations. My areas of expertise include buyer and seller representation, contract negotiation and residential construction. I look forward to serving your buying or selling needs in the Columbus market. Thank you to all of my clients who have placed their trust in my service!

Home Central Realty

74 Mill StreetColumbus, OH 43230

Cell: 937-369-7200

[email protected]

• Ranked No. 1 Individual Agent for Transaction and Dollar Volume, 2013 and 2014 (Home Central Realty)

• Ranked No. 1 in Single-Family Homes Closed Transactions in 2013, Columbus CSD 43212 (Columbus MLS)

2015 winner Craig Mayhew

Craig MayhewRealtor

Professional Service … Satisfied Clients

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL



Krysten has been in the real estate industry for over a decade, helping buyers and sellers locally, with one of her specialties being investments.

My main objectives when helping a client buy or sell are simple:

Go above and beyond what is expected while never losing sight of what’s in my clients’ best interest. I believe each task I perform on their behalf molds who I am to them, and my goal is to be everything: an informative agent, an honest friend and a trusted advisor in my fi eld.

I strongly believe that repeat business is to be continually earned, not expected. I want to thank my past and current clients for granting me the opportunity to guide them through the emotional journey of transition into their new home. I am also grateful for my investors’ unwavering trust in my ability to take over their real estate investment portfolio and guide them to the goal of passive income through real estate investment.

4100 Regent Street, Suite BColumbus, OH 43219

Phone : 614-456-9999

[email protected]/in/krystencriss

kendleteam.com

• Volunteering: Current HOA board president in my community. Assistant soccer coach in Westerville four-year-old league

• Favorite activities: Running, snowboarding and spending time with my two daughters and husband

• Favorite quote: Character is how you treat those who can do nothing for you

Left to right: Kendall Criss; Katie Criss; 2015 winner Krysten Criss

Krysten CrissRealtor

#KrystenSellsColumbus

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL



I am honored to have been selected for the Five Star Real Estate Agent award. The best part about being a Realtor is forming partnerships and friendship with my clients. I fi nd it very rewarding when my clients are so happy with my service, they refer me to a friend or family member. I value the confi dentiality of my clients and pride myself on an honest approach to real estate.I am a long-time resident of central Ohio and really enjoy sharing my knowledge of our great city with clients who are relocating to the area.

379 West Olentangy Street | Powell, OH 43065 Phone : 614-245-0900

[email protected] | www.ShannonGrimm.comfacebook.com/ShannonGrimmRealtor

• Skilled negotiator • CSP— Certifi ed New Home Sales Professional• RRS® — Residential Relocation Specialist• CTA® — Certifi ed Tourism Ambassador • Multiple award-winning agent

2015 winner Shannon Taylor Grimm

Forming Partnerships and Friendships for Life

Shannon Taylor GrimmRealtor

4579 North High StreetColumbus, OH 43214

Phone: 614-598-0801

[email protected]

www.Facebook.com/TRMGrealestate

Straight Talk. Intelligent Results.

• Combined 30-plus years of experience incentral Ohio

• Repeat OAR President’s Sales Club award winner• Member, Columbus Realtors $10 Million Club• Home of the #HappyDance

Left to right: Jeff Krider, Lic. 2013003379; 2015 winner Rosalyn Miller, Lic. 434671;Christy Gammon, Lic. 2002021365

Rosalyn has built her business and her team based on excellence and integrity with an emphasis on cultivating client relationships that last for life. As group leader, Rosalyn brings 17 years of experience to the table. She focuses on managing the team, developing client relationships and working with buyers and sellers. Jeff also works with buyers and sellers, and Christy provides administrative support. Visit their website to see what their clients have to say!

The Rosalyn Miller GroupCutler Real Estate

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL



3395 Farm Bank WayGrove City, OH 43123

Phone: 614-560-1229

[email protected]

I Care, and It Shows!

• Multimillion-dollar producer• Full-time, full-service professional• Seniors Real Estate Specialist• Accredited Buyer’s Representative• Recipient of multiple sales awards

Two-year winner Linda Altomare

Thank you to all of my clients who recognized me for the Five Star Real Estate Agent award for a second time! To excel in anything, you must fi rst enjoy doing it, and real estate has been my passion for most of my adult life! My business strategy is to always put the client fi rst and, in doing so, you build relationships of trust and friendship while getting the job done. I strive daily to grow, evolve and keep current in this ever-changing business!

Linda AltomareLic. 250037

TWO-YEAR WINNER

3395 Farm Bank Way Grove City, OH 43123

Art: 614-296-2859Stacey : 614-204-8426

Jeannie: 614-563-0642

[email protected] www.arttravis.com

The Sure-Bet Team

• Serving central Ohio for over 40 years• Representing luxury condos and the

resale market• Certifi ed home stager on team• Designated buyer’s specialist on team• Certifi ed Real Estate Brokerage Manager (CRB)

Left to right: Jeannie Travis; 2015 winner Art Travis; Stacey Travis Long

Our team sincerely appreciates our clients who selected Art for this prestigious award. A real estate career does off er a great opportunity to earn a very good living, but more rewarding is the chance to help people make one of their largest fi nancial decisions — purchasing a home. Lifelong relationships are established. We want our clients to know our fi rst goal is to fi nd them that “perfect” home or sell their home at the highest price with the least inconvenience.

Team Travis

Team Travis

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL



• Professional real estate consultant for 19 years• Multimillion-dollar producer• Honored into the RE/MAX Hall of Fame• Buyer and seller representation• Specializing in residential and residential investment

Licensed in 1996, my No. 1 priority is representing my clients with the highest degree of integrity, professionalism and service available. As a long-time Columbus resident, I have extensive knowledge of the central Ohio market. I am honored to be selected for the Five Star Real Estate Agent award. My humble thanks goes to my wonderful clients who put their trust in me.

Capital Centre, Inc. 3805 N High St. Columbus, OH 43214Cell: [email protected]

Full-Time, Full-Service, Professional Results

Steven HertzReal Estate Consultant, CRS, GRI, ABR®

TWO-YEAR WINNER

Over the past 25 years, Kathleen has developed the knowledge, experience and marketing expertise to not only meet, but exceed the expectations of hundreds of satisfied clients and referrals. Over the past 12 years, Kathleen has honed her skills as a broker and negotiated and facilitated the purchase and sale of investment properties, estate sales, commercial leases/sales and nonprofits. Kathleen has also assisted individuals’ and families’ real estate needs through relocation, divorce, auction, foreclosure and short sales. If you plan on buying or selling, or just need the benefit of an expert in central Ohio that you can trust, you can rely on Kathleen. For an expert that researches and understands real estate trends and current market demands, you can count on Kathleen. Her clients have come to know her as someone who goes above and beyond expectations to get the job done.

200 E Campus View, Ste. 200Worthington, OH 43085Cell : 614-204-5707 Fax: 614-364-7977

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServicesIntegrity One, Realtors

Making Dreams Reality … Through Real Estate

BrokerKathleen Fornes

Off ering superior service and communication, Carolyn Redinger is passionate and committed to helping you achieve your dreams. With a 95-percent referral rate from past clients, Carolyn always treats her clients respectfully, providing professional expertise to buy, sell and make good investments. As a Certifi ed Feng Shui Consultant, she enhances surroundings by creating harmony and balance and combines her expertise in creating focused results through staging, color therapy, maximizing investments and marketability.

106 South High Street | Dublin, OH 43017 Direct: 614-679-1274

[email protected]

• CBR $25 million dollar club• $100 million in sales• Nearly 30 years of experience• Negotiator extraordinaire • Off ering preferred

experienced partners

• Relocation and military veterans• Property management for

quality homes• Feng shui certifi cation• RE/MAX Int’l Hall of Fame and

Lifetime Achievement awards

2015 winner Carolyn Redinger

Helping You Achieve Your Dreams Through Expertise and Extensive Resources

Carolyn RedingerCRS, GRI, ABR®, CSD

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL



Sandra Thomas would like to thank the buyers and sellers who nominated her for the Five Star Real Estate Agent award for the second year in a row. This award recognizes real estate agents who provide quality services to their clients, a skill Sandra has built her business and reputation on. With over 25 years of marketing experience and 15 years of real estate sales, Sandra offers the total solution for your real estate needs.

RE/MAX Achievers7124 Muirfield Dr. Dublin, OH 43017Phone: [email protected]

Sandra Thomas

TWO-YEAR WINNER

Cheryl Godard

Phone: [email protected]

Keller Williams Classic Properties

Your UA Connection!

TWO-YEAR WINNER

Lori Hicks

Sales Consultant, Realtor

Hicks Elite Realty ProfessionalsCell: [email protected]

Making Your Dreamsa Reality

Michael Nacerino

Broker, GRI, CRS

Office: 614-899-2600Cell: [email protected] www.michaelnacerino.net

RE/MAXAssociates Realty

Service You Deserve, More Than You Expect!

TWO-YEAR WINNER

Nikki Gallo

Realtor

Phone : 614-402-9047 [email protected]

Keller Williams Capital Partners

Discover Your Dream Home

TWO-YEAR WINNER

Lois Kellough

Realtor

Kellough GroupKeller Williams Classic PropertiesPhone: [email protected]

TWO-YEAR WINNER

Kate Crager-Tobin

Broker/Owner

Direct: 614-588-3851Office : 614-879-6700 [email protected]

Lic. 2007001852

Karen K. Gorski

Realtor

Phone: [email protected] KarenGorski.com

Specializing in Personalized Service!

Kurt McCurdy

ABR®, CRS, GRI, SFR®

The McCurdy TeamOffice: 614-818-7676Cell: 614-581-5812 www.HERRealtors.com/TheMcCurdyTeam

Sarah Fair

Cell: 614-551-6016Direct: 614-526-5696Office: [email protected]

Coldwell Banker King Thompson

I am honored to have been nominated by my clients for this prestigious award!In this ever-so-challenging real estate market, I will bring to your home selling or buying process the knowledge, innovation and expertise needed for a smooth transaction.

RE/MAX Connection, Realtors

130 Mill St.Gahanna, OH 43230 Office: 614-416-2411Cell: [email protected] www.Homesbyjanis.net

Janis L. FrancisRealtor/Real Estate Consultant

Lic. 429454.

Nancy Poss

The Poss Team100 E Wilson Bridge Rd.Worthington, OH 43085Phone: [email protected] ColumbusOHRealEstate.com

Katie Davis

Realtor

Office: 614-777-1000Direct: [email protected]/katiedavisNamed 2015“Top Ten Under 40” – YPNLic. 2007005475

TWO-YEAR WINNER

Andy Buss

Realtor

Phone : 614-403-2411 [email protected]

Lic. 2005001031

Geri Waterman

Real Estate Consultant

6500 E Main St.Reynoldsburg, OH 43068Cell: 614-832-1347Fax: [email protected]

TWO-YEAR WINNER

“Clients don’t care how much you know until they know how much you care.”

— Five Star award winner

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL



All award winners are sorted by city and listed alphabetically by last name.

Five Star Professional surveyed Columbus-area residents who purchased a home priced at more than $150,000 within a 10-month period (February 2014 to November 2014). The final list of 2015 Columbus Five Star Real Estate Agents is a select group, representing less than 7 percent of real estate agents in the area. Evaluations were collected by mail, phone and online at www.fivestarprofessional.com/homesurvey.

All AreasMarty Ackermann · RE/MAX

Danielle Alexander · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Michael Allardyce · O’Malley Real Estate

Christopher Anderson · RE/MAX Premier Choice

Madeleine Andrews · RE/MAX Achievers

Steven Beaver · RE/MAX Right Now

Tim Bebinger · Keller Williams Consultants Realty

Dala Bishop · Keller Williams

Scott Bookheimer · A List Realty

Robert Brandt · RE/MAX/The Brandt Group, Realtors

Christine Bratka · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Linda Brincks · HER, Realtors/The Raines Group

Terry Bryant · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Andy Buss · Keller Williams Capital Partners Page 8

Kathy Butler · Coldwell Banker

Cynthia Calender · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Jean Campana · RE/MAX Affiliates

Kelly Cantwell · Street Sotheby’s International Realty

Cheryl Chapin · RE/MAX Resource

Amy Conley · Conley & Partners

Ryan Conway · Keller Williams Consultants Realty

Gary Cook · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Monica Cook · Coldwell Banker

Sharon Cook · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Rose Copp · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Laura Corbett · Signature Real Estate

Arthur Covan · Art Covan, Realtor

Joyce Crace · e-Merge Real Estate

Kate Crager-Tobin · Crager Real Estate Page 8

Jack Curtis · Keller Williams Consultants Realty

Katherine Davis · Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Calhoon Company, Realtors Page 8

Julie Dickey · Dickey-Beckley Team, Realtors

Ross DiGiorgio · Ross, Realtors

Susan Dilworth · Keller Williams Classic Properties Realty

Tracy Dozer · Gorsuch Realty Company

Sarah Fair · Coldwell Banker King Thompson Page 8

Jane Falk · RE/MAX Affiliates

Kathy Faust · Keller Williams Consultants

Margaret Fenters · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Barbara Fogal · Keller Williams Classic Properties Realty

Kathleen Fornes · Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Integrity One Realty Page 7

Anthony Fortkamp · Carleton Realty

Janis Francis · RE/MAX Page 8

David Galbreath · Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices

Susan Garbark · EXIT Realty

Jennifer Gary · Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices American Realty Center

Lisa Gibbs · HER, Realtors

Matthew Glanzman · RE/MAX One

Karen Gorski · HER, Realtors Page 8

Anita Graves · RE/MAX

Wendy Grego · RE/MAX Achievers

Tristam Griffith · RE/MAX

Shannon Grimm · HER, Realtors Page 5

Jackie Groom · Coldwell Banker King Thompson Page 2

Justin Gwinn · e-Merge Real Estate

Kim Harmanis · Keller Williams Capital Partners

Robb Harpster · Howard Hanna Realcom Realty

Deborah Harr · Homes That Click Advantage, Realtors

Jerry Harr · Homes That Click Advantage, Realtors

Kevin Hart · Keller Williams

David Hatcher · Champion Asset Advisors

Neal Hauschild · nth Degree

Lisa Heath · Zimmerman Realty

Lori Hicks · HER, Realtors Page 8

Cortnie Horvath · CENTURY 21 Excellence Realty

Darlene Houck · HER, Realtors

Ellen Hudson · Cam Taylor, Realtors

Jan Jedlinsky · Metro II Realty

Jeffrey Jonas · RE/MAX

Terri Jones · Signature Real Estate

Angela Keener · Keller Williams

Brian Kemp · Keller Williams Capital Partners

Jane Kessler Lennox · New Albany Realty

Nancy King · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Diane Koontz · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Daniel Krumm · Howard Hanna Realcom

Darlene Kuzmic · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Erin LaBuda · Keller Williams Capital Partners

Tina Levo · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Al Lindeman · RE/MAX Stars

Dedra Lucas · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Tammy Marquardt · e-Merge Real Estate

Marilyn Mason · RE/MAX Premier Choice

Tara Massuros-Preston · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Jamie Maze · RE/MAX Impact

Michele McClaine · Coldwell Banker

Dorothy McKahan · RE/MAX Achievers

Rosalyn Miller · Cutler Real Estate Page 5

Tom Miller · RE/MAX Connection, Realtors

Theresa Molina · RE/MAX Achievers

Julie Morgan · Howard Hanna Real Estate

Craig Mosier · HER, Realtors

Michael Nacerino · RE/MAX Associates Realty Page 8

Doug Neal · Keller Williams

Scott Noblet · RE/MAX Impact

Ed Nunemaker · Keller Williams

Cheryl Olson · Keller Williams

Vincent Orsatti · Keller Williams Excel Realty

Geoffrey Ortlip · Planned Communities Realty Company

Sue Parrish · Keller Williams Classic Properties Realty

Anneliese Pearson · Realty Executives

Terry Penrod · HER, Realtors

Megan Perkins · RE/MAX Connection, Realtors

Carla Peters · RE/MAX One

Brenda Pitts · Coldwell Banker

Ryan Plowman · Plowman Properties

Nancy Poss · Keller Williams Page 8

Marci Press · Home Central Realty

Bob Price · Keller Williams Greater Columbus Realty

Sandy Raines · The Raines Group

Amy Rawson · Keller Williams

Carolyn Redinger · RE/MAX 24/7 Page 7

Chris Reese · Metro II Realty

Sherri Resnick · RE/MAX Consultant Group

Arica Robbins Worth · HER, Realtors

Julie Rosenblum · HER, Realtors

Jill Rudler · Keller Williams Excel Realty

Linda Schmidt · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Jennifer Seiler · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Carlton Shaffer · RE/MAX

Micky Shaffer · HER, Realtors

Susan Shane-Toothman · RE/MAX Premier Choice

Kim Shea · Coldwell Banker

Sherri Siders · Keller Williams Consultants Realty

Michelle Smith · e-Merge Real Estate

Kirsten Sullivan · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Aftab Syed · RE/MAX Top Producers

Tim Taylor · HER, Realtors

Tony Thomas · New Albany Realty

Doug Thorley · Keller Williams Capital Partners

David Truitt · Keller Williams

Marilyn Vutech · HER, Realtors

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL



All award winners are sorted by city and listed alphabetically by last name.

Barbara Waters · RE/MAX Premier Choice

Cindi Watkins · Preferred Properties Real Estate Services

Mike Whiteman · RE/MAX Achievers

Jim Wilkin · Keller Williams Consultants Realty

Joshua Zimmerman · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Barbara Lach · Coldwell Banker

BexleyTerri Barnett · RE/MAX

Kate Giller · HER, Realtors

Roni Leeman · RE/MAX

Canal WinchesterTammy Elliott · RE/MAX One

ColumbusTondalaya Adiansingh · Faulkner

Realty Group

Corey Barnes · 4 Real Estate

Michele Cleary · HER, Realtors

Jeanne Cousino · HER, Realtors

Jim Deskins · The HomeBuyer’s Advocate

Bruce Dooley · Keller Williams Classic Properties/Dooley and Company Team

Traci Garontakos · Sorrell & Company

Carolyn Gifford · HER, Realtors

Deb Goldach · Keller Williams Classic Properties

Rosalie Goodsell · Coldwell Banker

Molly Hay · RE/MAX Town Center

Benjamin Hemmert · HER, Realtors

Steven Hertz · RE/MAX Captial Centre Page 7

Michael Jones · Coldwell Banker Metro

Pat Kearns-Davis · RE/MAX Captial Centre

Niels Keiper · Abundance Realty

Lois Kellough · Keller Williams Classic Properties Page 8

Donna Leigh-Osborne · Keller Williams Capital Partners

Misty Linn · Core Ohio Realty

Alex Macke · Carriage Trade Realty

Cynthia MacKenzie · Keller Williams Capital Partners/The CyMacK Group

Jeff Mahler · Keller Williams Capital Partners

Michael Marshall · Buyer’s Resource Realty Services

Craig Mayhew · Home Central Realty Page 3

Chad Miller · Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices

Sherrie Miller · RE/MAX

Thomas Nippert · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Dee Nutter · Keller Williams Capital Partners

Kristina Parrish · Keller Williams Classic Properties Realty

Brian Phillips · RE/MAX

Eric Ransom · Keller Williams Capital Partners

Antonio Reese · Reese Realty Group

Lee Ritchie · RE/MAX Metro Plus

James Roehrenbeck · RE/MAX

Kristina Ross · RE/MAX Captial Centre

Bryan Savage · Savage Real Estate

Mary Sguerra · HER, Realtors

Arthur Travis · Cutler Real Estate Page 6

Robert Vincent Duncan · Keller Williams Classic Properties Realty

Ken Wightman · Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices American Realty Center

Tom Wilhelm · Coldwell Banker

Wendy Witker Stahanczyk · Cutler Real Estate

Kevin Woodard · RE/MAX Connection, Realtors

Aaron Wright · iRealty Experts

DublinAlli Close · Coldwell Banker King

Thompson

Chris Close · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Nikki Gallo · Keller Williams Page 8

Bob Hetherington · Keller Williams Consultants Realty

Paula Linehan · Keller Williams Capital Partners/The Paula Group

Neil Mathias · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Virgil Mathias · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Timothy Reil · Keller Williams Consultants Realty

Linda Soller · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Martin Soller · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

GahannaLinda Godby · RE/MAX Consultant

Group

Amy Pape · Keller Williams Greater Columbus Realty

Grove CityLinda Altomare · Cutler Real

Estate Page 6

Rhiannon Ferrari · RE/MAX Elite

Patty Good · RE/MAX

Jerry Hunt · Kassel Real Estate

Jared Lowe · HER, Realtors

Jody McCague · Realty Executives/The Beckett Team

Mark Vennitti · HER, Realtors

Hide Away HillsKaren Parker · Sorrell & Company

HilliardConnie Anzuini · Coldwell Banker

King Thompson

Kristina Murphy · HER, Realtors

Jesse Snodgrass · Coldwell Banker

Sandra Thomas · RE/MAX Page 8

Sue Van Woerkom · Keller Williams

LancasterGay Gatian · Carleton Realty

Lewis CenterJoe Janszen · Keller Williams

Aunda Klopfer · HER, Realtors

Troy Marsh · Keller Williams Capital Partners

New AlbanyMarilyn Davis · RE/MAX

Alan Hinson · New Albany Realty

Robin Lemmons · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Penny Smith · Keller Williams

M. Kate Thomas · New Albany Realty

NewarkJeff Kreager · RE/MAX

PickeringtonGwen Rader · RE/MAX One

Geraldine Waterman · e-Merge Real Estate Page 8

PowellSara Bonnie · Bonnie Realty Services

Jill Freeland · Howard Hanna/Freeland Marketing Group

Brad Fry · RE/MAX Achievers

Darrin Grieves · RE/MAX Achievers

Sara Henson · Keller Williams

Joan King · RE/MAX Achievers

Keith Poss · Keller Williams Capital Partners

Karen Ramsey · RE/MAX Affiliates

Carol Reeves · RE/MAX Achievers

Steven Smith · Keller Williams

ReynoldsburgVanessa Simmons · Coldwell Banker

Upper ArlingtonJan Benadum · Coldwell Banker

Jane Coughlin · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Anne DeVoe · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Julia Fox · RE/MAX

Cheryl Godard · Keller Williams Classic Properties Page 8

Beth Hazard · RE/MAX Premier Choice

Jane Jones · HER, Realtors/The Jane Jones Team

Krystin Macaluso · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Tony Macaluso · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Dave McKinley · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Sara McKinley · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

Hannah Yuhas · Coldwell Banker King Thompson

WestervilleMaggie Chudik · HER, Realtors

Amy Clark · ERA Real Solutions Realty

Krysten Criss · RE/MAX Town Center Page 4

Craig Howells · Keller Williams Excel Reatly

Kurt McCurdy · HER, Realtors Page 8

Sandy McGill · HER, Realtors

Rick Rano · RE/MAX Affiliates

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

SPECIAL ADVERT IS ING SECT ION Five Star Mortgage Professionals


My objective is to give my clients the information, care and time they need to make the best decisions for their family and future. My goal is to be your mortgage loan offi cerfor life.

400 Lazelle Road, Suite 18 | Columbus, OH 43240 Office: 614-396-1885

[email protected] | www.kathiholtz.com

• 16 years of local experience • Business built on referral and repeat clients• Loan options for your individual needs• Mortgage professional you can trust• Conventional, FHA, VA, USDA and jumbo loans available

Two-year winner Kathi Holtz All loans subject to credit approval. Rates and fees subject to change. Mortgage � nancing provided by PrimeLending, a PlainsCapital Company. Equal Housing Lender. ©2015 PrimeLending, a PlainsCapital Company. PrimeLending, a PlainsCapital Company (NMLS 13649) is a wholly owned subsidiary of a state-chartered bank and is an exempt lender in Ohio. V121013.

Your Mortgage Lending Expert

Kathi HoltzNMLS 525331

TWO-YEAR WINNER

Recognized for excellence in mortgage lending, we are thankful to our clients and real estate partners in nominating us for the Five Star Mortgage Professional award.

There is much to consider when financing your home. Our clients make cogent decisions from the financing options we provide, resulting in a very rewarding mortgage experience.

We answer the tough questions such as:• How are current rates related to the economy?• Can new lending conditions be benefi cial or detrimental to

my loan?• Do my circumstances make it diffi cult to get a mortgage?

6089 Frantz Road, Suite 101 | Dublin, OH 43017 Rita: 614-588-0357 | John: 614-588-0359

www.englendingdublin.com

Rita, NMLS 314898; John, NMLS 800403; ENG Lending is a division of Bank of England, est. 1898NMLS 418481. Member FDIC.

Living the American Dream Is Easier With ENG Lending

Rita Kennedy and John HamiltonSenior Mortgage Banker and Production Manager

Liberty Capital Services has been committed to providing clients with the highest quality home loans combined with some of the lowest mortgage rates available in all of Ohio for over the last 12 years.

438 East Wilson Bridge Road | Worthington, OH 43085 Phone: 614-505-0620 | Phone: 614-460-1846

[email protected] | www.golibertyloans.com

Company NMLS 917485, MB 804089.00.

James A. McBainPresident, NMLS 3889

2015 winner James A. McBain, President; Ken G. Wichman, CEO

Great Rates With Integrity

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE

STARPROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TARPROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE

STAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TARPROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE

STAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TARPROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE

STAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TARPROFESSIO

NAL

SPECIAL ADVERT IS ING SECT ION Five Star Mortgage Professionals


As a 22-year veteran of mortgage lending, I have the experience and expertise to take you through the mortgage loan process and on to closing with a smile on your face. Call me today, and let me go to work for you. You’ll see just how easy it can be!

3250 Northwest Blvd.Upper Arlington, OH 43221Phone: 614-545-5626, Ext. 213Cell: [email protected]/wpond

Bill PondNMLS 298535

TWO-YEAR WINNER

Kimberly Althouse · Huntington Bank

David Arocho · PrimeLending

Tamera Atkins · PrimeLending

Chad Beverly · Chase Bank

Erin Bishop · Priority Mortgage

Kathleen Bornhorst · Fifth Third Mortgage

Noah Brader · Concord Mortgage Group

Bruno Capogreco · PrimeLending

Chet Centers · Wells Fargo Home Mortgage

Ryan J. Childress · Talmer Bank and Trust

William Corns · Union Savings Bank

Joseph Cotter · Huntington Bank

Jason Culbertson · Third Federal Savings & Loan

Brent Diebert · First Financial Bank

Doug Dietrich · Thomas Lending

Rick Diso · Union Savings Bank Page 12

Sarah Engstrom · Priority Mortgage

Jeff Gibson · PNC Bank

Peggy Halbrook · The Arlington Bank

Diane Hamilton · Equity Resources

John Hamilton · ENG Lending Page 11

Jason Harris · PNC Mortgage

Brent Hinz · First Federal Lending

Brian Hitchcock · First Financial Bank

Eric Holmes · First Federal Lending

Kathi Holtz · PrimeLending Page 11

Steve Hughes · Huntington Mortgage Group

John Igoe · First Ohio Home Finance

Rita Kennedy · ENG Lending Page 11

Robert Kreuzer · Citizens Bank

Todd Leibold · Civista Bank

Jeff Lichtenstein · Market Mortgage Company

Jeff Lingo, Jr. · Huntington

Peter Loeb · First Federal Lending

Edmund Loomis · Hallmark Home Mortgage

Thomas Louters · Chase Bank

Lori Love · Hallmark Home Mortgage

Joe Marmo · PNC Mortgage

James Martin · Equitable Mortgage Corporation

K. Cody Martin · PNC Mortgage

Robert Martin · The American Eagle Mortgage Company

Dan Mathews · First Federal Lending

James McBain · Liberty Capital Services Page 11

David McKee · Priority Mortgage

Susan McKnight · Wells Fargo Home Mortgage

Christopher Miller · The Arlington Bank

Jeremy Montgomery · Chase Bank

Vicki Morello · PrimeLending

Vernon Morrison · Lighthouse Mortgage Services

April Munroe · Fifth Third Bank

Trisha Murray · MB Financial Bank

Melissa Myers · MCS Mortgage Bankers

Todd Novosel · PrimeLending

Michael Piscioneri · BMI Federal Credit Union

Bill Pond · Union Savings Bank Page 12

Joseph Rosen · Chase Bank

Jonathan Sadler · Bank of America

Sid Shah · Equity Resources

Justus Sharp · PMAC Lending Services

C. Jarrett Shiring · Huntington Mortgage Group

Marc Stock · Union Savings Bank

Lee Struck · Huntington National Bank

Chris Sullivan · Evolve Bank and Trust

Joseph Szymanowski · Fifth Third Bank

Andre Thompson · U.S. Bank

Phyllis Vandyke · Homefide

Scott Voelkel · The American Eagle Mortgage Company

John Wagner · Union Savings Bank

Raub Warner · State Bank

David Weinstein · Concord Mortgage Group

Thomas Wheeler · PNC Mortgage

Jarvis Woodson · Civista Bank

Five Star Professional surveyed more than 8,800 Columbus homeowners. The final list of 2015 Columbus Five Star Mortgage Professionals is a select group, representing less than 2 percent of mortgage professionals in the area. Evaluations were collected by mail, phone and online at www.fivestarprofessional.com/homesurvey.

All award winners are listed alphabetically by last name.

With over 25 years of mortgage lending experience, I am well-versed in all programs, from first-time homebuyers to construction lending, residential or commercial. Applying for a mortgage is an important financial decision. You put time and effort into choosing the right lender. Expect your loan officer to be knowledgeable and professional. Don’t make a financial mistake.Call a Five Star Mortgage Professional.

44 S State St. Westerville, OH 43081Office : 614-882-2286Cell: [email protected]

Rick DisoSenior Loan Officer, NMLS 664551

Do everything you can

to assist your clients and

remember it is all an

investment in your

future success.

— Five Star award winner

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

SPECIAL ADVERT IS ING SECT ION Five Star Home/Auto Insurance Professionals


• Independent agency• Serving central Ohio for 13 years• Meeting all your insurance needs

Our mission is to provide superior advice and service. We place a premium on client satisfaction, including protecting and growing their assets. We are an independent agency and have served central Ohio for the past 13 years. We have five licensed agents and four client service representatives available to answer all your insurance questions and service all your needs. We specialize in personal, commercial, life and health insurance. Not only do we pride ourselves on insurance knowledge, we also pride ourselves on being active in our community through service and volunteering. Why settle for less when you can experience the best? Contact our office for a complimentary review!

107 W Columbus St.Pickerington, OH 43147Office: 614-834-6624Toll-free: [email protected]

The Leader in Insurance Solutions

Mark MatthewsAgency Principal

TWO-YEAR WINNER

Shawn Allman · Liberty Mutual

Bill Alsnauer · State Farm

Chuck Auber · Morley Parren Bright Insurance Agency

Megan Brooks · Liberty Mutual

Anthony Catanzaro · Catanzaro Insurance

Chris Champion · State Farm

Mitch Clouse · Morgan Hubble Smith Insurance

Lisa Diemer · American Family Insurance

Eric Dill · E&M Risk Management

Renee Dutton · State Farm

Mike Flanagan · Flanagan and Associates Insurance Agency

Stuart Gold · Integrated Financial Systems

Dave Gordon · American Family Insurance

Chad Harris · State Farm

Debbie Harris · Trimble Insurance Agency

Amie Kim · State Farm

Stacy Kusma · Liberty Mutual Group

Mark Matthews · MMA Insurance Page 13

Alex McKirnan · Liberty Mutual Insurance

Dee Miller · State Farm

Matthew Milnor · The Milnor Insurance Group Page 13

Martin J. Mitchell · Martin J. Mitchell Insurance Agency

Anne Morgan · Dolbow Insurance

John Neighbarger · John W. Neighbarger Insurance

Karen Niehaus · Niehaus Insurance Services

Penni Overton · Williams Insurance Agency

Jon Pantone · Pantone Insurance Agency

Lonnie Perlman · Farmers Insurance

Eric Rine · Buckeye Benefit Consulting

Jeff Schneider · Allstate/Schneider Financial

Robert Simenz · AAA Insurance

Brandon Stanley · David Stanley & Associates

Allan Staub · Nationwide Insurance

Travis Swain · T. A. Swain Insurance Group

Tom Trainer · Smith Insurance Services

Stacie Wilson · Allstate

Five Star Professional surveyed more than 8,800 Columbus homeowners. The final list of 2015 Columbus Five Star Home/Auto Insurance Professionals is a select group, representing less than 2 percent of insurance professionals in the area. Evaluations were collected by mail, phone and online at www.fivestarprofessional.com/homesurvey.

All award winners are listed alphabetically by last name.

As an independent agency formed in 2002, we specialize in auto, home, life and commercial products. Representing Safeco, Grange, Allstate, Allied, Travelers, MetLife, Progressive and others allows us to tailor coverage to fit anyclient’s needs.

The Milnor Insurance Group

8640 Mallard Cir.Plain City, OH 43064 Phone: 614-504-4093Text: [email protected] milnorinsurancegroup.com

Matthew R. MilnorAgent

Keep up with market conditions, so you are always knowledgeable.

— Five Star award winnerFIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

FIVE S

TAR PROFESSIO

NAL

Documents

Five Star Home Professionals