11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/11/2019 11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

    1/16

    Calculations for 5 & 10 m of Top Water Level

    Distance /

    m

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest Rvsd

    Value VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Values

    Ppsd

    by Pjt

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Values

    Ppsd

    by Pjt

    Values

    Ppsd

    by Pjt

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Values

    Ppsd by Pjt

    Values

    Ppsd by Pjt

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Val

    Pps

    Pj

    350 14984 360 168.08 230.00 5 66.92 1.04 1.65 61.97 130.54 1

    350 14984 360 168.08 230.00 5 66.92 1.04 1.65 61.97 130.54 1

    300 4061 177 168.08 212.23 5 49.15 0.70 1.87 9.56 60.58

    300 4061 354 168.08 212.23 5 49.15 1.39 1.87 34.46 85.48

    400 8273 136 168.08 237.00 5 73.92 0.30 0.85 2.95 77.72

    400 8273 272 168.08 237.00 5 73.92 0.60 0.85 10.64 85.41

    350 10145 109 168.08 255.00 5 91.92 0.31 0.87 4.60 97.39

    350 10145 218 168.08 255.00 5 91.92 0.63 0.87 16.59 109.38 1

    450 5160 245 168.08 196.85 5 33.77 0.43 0.88 3.08 37.73450 5160 490 168.08 196.85 5 33.77 0.86 0.88 11.11 45.76

    450 7420 185 168.08 190.00 5 26.92 0.32 0.46 2.64 30.02

    450 7420 371 168.08 190.00 5 26.92 0.65 0.46 9.55 36.93

    1212.00

    1705.00

    7 Intake 900 659 2960 168.08 175.87 3 10.79 1.29 0.24 1.36 12.39

    250 100 41 190.00 210.00 10 30.00 0.23 0.50 0.04 30.54

    250 100 82 190.00 210.00 10 30.00 0.46 0.50 0.14 30.64

    250 9010 55 190.00 240.00 5 55.00 0.31 1.05 5.92 61.97

    250 9010 109 190.00 240.00 5 55.00 0.62 1.05 21.00 77.05

    350 16822 82 190.00 230.00 5 45.00 0.24 0.90 4.51 50.41

    350 16822 163.6 190.00 230.00 5 45.00 0.47 0.90 16.17 62.07

    Dischrge line 178 65296 0.25 Initial Desig

    Common Header 354.6 8404 12.92 Data as per

    26.00 Latest Rvsd

    Dischrge line 1390.00 Values Ppsd

    Common Header 2059.60 *S

    Sub - Total -- Inamaluwa

    - Total -- Transmission-Common Hea

    - Total -- Transmission - Dischrge li

    Total

    9

    10

    5

    4

    Inamaluwa

    Inamaluwa

    Sigiriya

    Habarana

    Inamaluwa

    GR

    ToE

    T's

    3

    TP

    To

    G

    RESERVOIRS

    Kithulhitiyawa

    2

    1

    8

    6

    Pipe Sizing Analysis Contract No:P&P/WS/EB-INDIA/GDWSS/2011/01

    Velocity /

    ms-1

    Top

    WL @

    Res

    and ETSe.

    NoLocation

    NGL @

    Reservoir

    Gate

    Min.W

    L @

    WTP

    (m)

    Flow

    (m3/Hr)

    Dia.of

    Pipe

    (DN) /

    mm

    Static

    Head /

    (m)

    Galewela

    Dambulla

    Kandalama

    Thittawelgolla

    Frictional

    Loss / (m)

    (fittings)

    Frictional

    Loss / (m) -

    (pipes)

    He

    Requ

    [ba

    Head

    Required

    / (m)

    Sensitivity Analysis with Respect to Pressure

    Total Flow for 22

    Hrs in MainTotal Flow for 22

    Hrs in Inamaluwa

  • 8/11/2019 11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

    2/16

    Sensitivity Analysis with Respect to Pressure

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    New

    (DN)

    mm

    Distanc

    e (m)

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    1 Galewela 350 350 13392 14984 360 360 168.25

    2 Dambulla 300 300 4100 4061 410 354 168.30

    3 Kandalama 400 400 9529 8273 346 272 168.20

    4 Thittawelgolla 350 350 7695 8949 255 218 168.25

    5 Kithulhitiyawa 450 450 6732 5458 532 490 168.20

    6 Inamaluwa 450 450 9770 7420 429 371 168.00

    7 Intake 900 900 700 659 2960 2960 161.96

    8 Inamaluwa 250 250 200 100 109 82 187.00

    9 Sigiriya 250 250 13300 9010 131 109 187.20

    10 Habarana 350 350 17100 16822 190 163.6 187.07

    Total 82518 75736 5722 5380

    95910 6082

    Initial Design Value - Data & Cal as per the First Contractor's Proposal [BEP]

    Data as per the RSC-Central or Head Office comment

    Latest Rvsd Value VW - Data & Cal as per the Latest Contractor's [VT&WBG] Revision

    Values Ppsd by Pjt - Data & Calculations as per the suggested new values by pjt

    * Surge pressure was not incorporated and to be analysed seperately

    Distance (m) Flow (m3/Hr)

    TP

    ToGRESERVOIRS

    InmG

    R

    ToET

    Min.WL @ WT

    Se.

    NoLocation

    Dia.of Pipe (DN)

    / mm

  • 8/11/2019 11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

    3/16

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design Value

    168.25 207.292 230.000 30 30 30 69.04 91.75 1.04

    168.30 212.226 212.226 30 30 30 73.93 73.93 1.61

    168.20 192.718 237.000 30 30 30 54.52 98.80 0.76

    168.25 197.400 255.000 30 30 30 59.15 116.75 0.74

    168.20 158.535 195.000 30 30 30 20.34 56.80 0.93

    168.00 188.453 190.000 30 30 30 50.45 52.00 0.75

    161.96 169.557 169.557 30 30 30 37.60 37.60 1.29

    187.00 188.557 210.000 30 30 30 31.56 53.00 0.62

    187.20 210.242 240.000 30 30 30 53.04 82.80 0.74

    187.07 194.176 230.000 30 30 30 37.11 72.93 0.55

    VelTop WL @ Res and ET Static Head / (m) (m) NGL @ Reservoir Gate

    Pipe Sizing Analysis Contract No:P&P/WS/EB-INDIA/GDWSS/2011/01

  • 8/11/2019 11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

    4/16

    Latest Rvsd

    Value VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    0.00 1.04 1.65 1.65 59.00 61.97 129.69 155.37 13.22

    0.00 1.39 1.87 1.87 39.00 34.46 114.80 110.26 11.70

    0.00 0.60 0.85 0.85 19.40 10.64 74.77 110.29 7.62

    0.00 0.63 0.87 0.87 17.10 14.63 77.12 132.25 7.86

    0.00 0.86 0.88 0.88 12.70 11.76 33.92 69.44 3.46

    0.00 0.65 0.46 0.46 8.30 9.55 59.21 62.01 6.04

    0.00 1.29 0.24 0.24 1.90 1.36 39.74 39.19 4.05

    0.00 0.46 0.50 0.50 0.85 0.14 32.91 53.64 3.35

    0.00 0.62 1.05 1.05 43.60 21.00 97.69 104.85 9.96

    0.00 0.47 0.90 0.90 22.00 16.17 60.01 90.00 6.12

    city / ms-1

    Frictional Loss / (m)

    (fittings)

    Head required / (m)Frictional Loss / (m) -

    (pipes)

    H

  • 8/11/2019 11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

    5/16

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    As per ISO

    2531-2009

    pipe PN 16

    can

    withstand

    15.84 12.71 13.01 15.25 15.62 20.25 20.62 25

    11.24 10.68 10.22 12.82 12.26 17.82 17.26 25

    11.24 6.60 5.71 7.92 6.85 12.92 11.85 25

    13.48 6.84 6.59 8.21 7.91 13.21 12.91 25

    7.08 2.44 2.34 2.93 2.81 7.93 7.81 25

    6.32 5.02 5.14 6.02 6.17 11.02 11.17 25

    4.00 3.03 2.98 3.64 3.57 8.64 8.57 25

    5.47 2.34 2.26 2.80 2.71 7.80 7.71 25

    10.69 8.94 6.64 10.73 7.96 15.73 12.96 25

    9.17 5.10 4.50 6.12 5.40 11.12 10.40 25

    ead / [bar]

    Pressure Classification - Ref ISO 2531:2

    Allowable Site Test

    Pressure = [

    PMA+ 5 bar ] / (bars)

    Allowable Operating

    Pressure [PFA]/ [bar]

    Max Operating Pressure

    [PMA]= [1.2*PFA] / [bar]

  • 8/11/2019 11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

    6/16

    A equacy

    under

    Extream

    condition

    for S/P

    A equacy

    under

    Extream

    condition for

    Flanged pipes

    ok *PN25 required

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    09E ; Pg 07

  • 8/11/2019 11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

    7/16

    Sensitivity Analysis with Respect to Pressure

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    New

    (DN)

    mm

    Distanc

    e (m)

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    1 Galewela 350 350 13392 14984 360 360 168.25

    2 Dambulla 300 300 4100 4061 410 354 168.30

    3 Kandalama 400 400 9529 8273 346 272 168.20

    4 Thittawelgolla 350 350 7695 8949 255 218 168.25

    5 Kithulhitiyawa 450 450 6732 5458 532 490 168.20

    6 Inamaluwa 450 450 9770 7420 429 371 168.00

    7 Intake 900 900 700 659 2960 2960 161.96

    8 Inamaluwa 250 250 200 100 109 82 187.00

    9 Sigiriya 250 250 13300 9010 131 109 187.20

    10 Habarana 350 350 17100 16822 190 163.6 187.07

    Total 82518 75736 5722 5380

    95910 6082

    Initial Design Value - Data & Cal as per the First Contractor's Proposal [BEP]

    Data as per the RSC-Central or Head Office comment

    Latest Rvsd Value VW - Data & Cal as per the Latest Contractor's [VT&WBG] Revision

    Values Ppsd by Pjt - Data & Calculations as per the suggested new values by pjt

    * Surge pressure was not incorporated and to be analysed seperately

    Distance (m) Flow (m3/Hr)

    TP

    ToGRESERVOIRS

    InmG

    R

    ToET

    Min.WL @ WT

    Se.

    NoLocation

    Dia.of Pipe (DN)

    / mm

  • 8/11/2019 11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

    8/16

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design Value

    168.25 207.292 230.000 40 40 40 79.04 101.75 1.04

    168.30 212.226 212.226 40 40 40 83.93 83.93 1.61

    168.20 192.718 237.000 40 40 40 64.52 108.80 0.76

    168.25 197.400 255.000 40 40 40 69.15 126.75 0.74

    168.20 158.535 195.000 40 40 40 30.34 66.80 0.93

    168.00 188.453 190.000 40 40 40 60.45 62.00 0.75

    161.96 169.557 169.557 40 40 40 47.60 47.60 1.29

    187.00 188.557 210.000 40 40 40 41.56 63.00 0.62

    187.20 210.242 240.000 40 40 40 63.04 92.80 0.74

    187.07 194.176 230.000 40 40 40 47.11 82.93 0.55

    VelTop WL @ Res and ET Static Head / (m) (m) NGL @ Reservoir Gate

    Pipe Sizing Analysis Contract No:P&P/WS/EB-INDIA/GDWSS/2011/01

  • 8/11/2019 11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

    9/16

    Latest Rvsd

    Value VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    0.00 1.04 1.65 1.65 59.00 61.97 139.69 165.37 14.24

    0.00 1.39 1.87 1.87 39.00 34.46 124.80 120.26 12.72

    0.00 0.60 0.85 0.85 19.40 10.64 84.77 120.29 8.64

    0.00 0.63 0.87 0.87 17.10 14.63 87.12 142.25 8.88

    0.00 0.86 0.88 0.88 12.70 11.76 43.92 79.44 4.48

    0.00 0.65 0.46 0.46 8.30 9.55 69.21 72.01 7.06

    0.00 1.29 0.24 0.24 1.90 1.36 49.74 49.19 5.07

    0.00 0.46 0.50 0.50 0.85 0.14 42.91 63.64 4.37

    0.00 0.62 1.05 1.05 43.60 21.00 107.69 114.85 10.98

    0.00 0.47 0.90 0.90 22.00 16.17 70.01 100.00 7.14

    city / ms-1

    Frictional Loss / (m)

    (fittings)

    Head required / (m)Frictional Loss / (m) -

    (pipes)

    H

  • 8/11/2019 11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

    10/16

  • 8/11/2019 11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

    11/16

    A equacy

    under

    Extream

    condition

    for S/P

    A equacy

    under

    Extream

    condition for

    Flanged pipes

    ok *PN25 required

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    09E ; Pg 07

  • 8/11/2019 11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

    12/16

    Sensitivity Analysis with Respect to Pressure

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    New

    (DN)

    mm

    Distanc

    e (m)

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    1 Galewela 350 350 13392 14984 360 360 168.25

    2 Dambulla 300 300 4100 4061 410 354 168.30

    3 Kandalama 400 400 9529 8273 346 272 168.20

    4 Thittawelgolla 350 350 7695 8949 255 218 168.25

    5 Kithulhitiyawa 450 450 6732 5458 532 490 168.20

    6 Inamaluwa 450 450 9770 7420 429 371 168.00

    7 Intake 900 900 700 659 2960 2960 161.96

    8 Inamaluwa 250 250 200 100 109 82 187.00

    9 Sigiriya 250 250 13300 9010 131 109 187.20

    10 Habarana 350 350 17100 16822 190 163.6 187.07

    Total 82518 75736 5722 5380

    95910 6082

    Initial Design Value - Data & Cal as per the First Contractor's Proposal [BEP]

    Data as per the RSC-Central or Head Office comment

    Latest Rvsd Value VW - Data & Cal as per the Latest Contractor's [VT&WBG] Revision

    Values Ppsd by Pjt - Data & Calculations as per the suggested new values by pjt

    * Surge pressure was not incorporated and to be analysed seperately

    Distance (m) Flow (m3/Hr)

    TP

    ToGRESERVOIRS

    InmG

    R

    ToET

    Min.WL @ WT

    Se.

    NoLocation

    Dia.of Pipe (DN)

    / mm

  • 8/11/2019 11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

    13/16

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design Value

    168.25 207.292 230.000 50 50 50 89.04 111.75 1.04

    168.30 212.226 212.226 50 50 50 93.93 93.93 1.61

    168.20 192.718 237.000 50 50 50 74.52 118.80 0.76

    168.25 197.400 255.000 50 50 50 79.15 136.75 0.74

    168.20 158.535 195.000 50 50 50 40.34 76.80 0.93

    168.00 188.453 190.000 50 50 50 70.45 72.00 0.75

    161.96 169.557 169.557 50 50 50 57.60 57.60 1.29

    187.00 188.557 210.000 50 50 50 51.56 73.00 0.62

    187.20 210.242 240.000 50 50 50 73.04 102.80 0.74

    187.07 194.176 230.000 50 50 50 57.11 92.93 0.55

    VelTop WL @ Res and ET Static Head / (m) (m) NGL @ Reservoir Gate

    Pipe Sizing Analysis Contract No:P&P/WS/EB-INDIA/GDWSS/2011/01

  • 8/11/2019 11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

    14/16

  • 8/11/2019 11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

    15/16

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    Initial

    Design

    Value

    Latest

    Rvsd

    Value

    VW

    Values

    Ppsd by

    Pjt

    As per ISO

    2531-2009

    pipe PN 16

    can

    withstand

    17.88 12.71 13.01 15.25 15.62 20.25 20.62 25

    13.28 10.68 10.22 12.82 12.26 17.82 17.26 25

    13.28 6.60 5.71 7.92 6.85 12.92 11.85 25

    15.52 6.84 6.59 8.21 7.91 13.21 12.91 25

    9.12 2.44 2.34 2.93 2.81 7.93 7.81 25

    8.36 5.02 5.14 6.02 6.17 11.02 11.17 25

    6.03 3.03 2.98 3.64 3.57 8.64 8.57 25

    7.51 2.34 2.26 2.80 2.71 7.80 7.71 25

    12.73 8.94 6.64 10.73 7.96 15.73 12.96 25

    11.21 5.10 4.50 6.12 5.40 11.12 10.40 25

    ead / [bar]

    Pressure Classification - Ref ISO 2531:2

    Allowable Site Test

    Pressure = [

    PMA+ 5 bar ] / (bars)

    Allowable Operating

    Pressure [PFA]/ [bar]

    Max Operating Pressure

    [PMA]= [1.2*PFA] / [bar]

  • 8/11/2019 11 Sensitivity Pipe Sizing Analysis

    16/16

    A equacy

    under

    Extream

    condition

    for S/P

    A equacy

    under

    Extream

    condition for

    Flanged pipes

    ok *PN25 required

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    ok

    09E ; Pg 07