Upload
biswajit-mohanty
View
213
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
d
Citation preview
Recycling of Environmentally Hazardous Wastage of Integrated Steel Plants
Prince Kumar Singh1, A Lava Kumar2, Rabindra Kr Rai3, and Sanjay Srivastava4
Abstract---- he iron and steel industry generates a great amount of ferrogeneous waste like Blast furnace flue dust and sludge to name a few. Investigation reveals that Blast Furnace sludge creates serious environmental hazard because it is used for landfill only. The recovery of metals and carbon from these flue dust and sludge become very important due to increase of the price of coke breeze and the decrease of the primary sources of metals. At the same time, it makes the environment safer by decreasing pollution. Experiments were conducted as per recent trends in international arena and pellets as well as sinters thus produced were characterized for international standard procedure.
Keywords--- waste, Flue dust, Sintering, Pellets.
I. INTRODUCTION RODUCTION process in iron and steel industry involve the formation of large amounts of by product. These by products cause large volume of waste streams. The by-
products are a concern to the environment and add to the loss of revenue to the iron and steel producers. The steel byproducts for example dust and sludge cause environmental degradation, loss of high value metal, demand legal complication and finally make the world uninhabited for the generation to come [1]. These waste materials are primarily used for landfill but the utilization of these waste materials may reduce the fastly depleted the primary resources. The rising prices of metals make such utilization economically attractive [2]. In an integrated iron and steel plant, several ferrogeneous waste materials are generated. The reduction of iron oxide in Blast Furnace results in generation of number of solid waste. Those are Blast Furnace slag, flue dust and gas cleaning plant sludge (Blast Furnace Sludge). However flue dust and are dumped and hence require process of utilization. Although utilization of plant wastes for production of quality sinters is a recirculation technique [3] but at the same time it adversely affects the property of sinter so in this study we made the pellets [4-8] from the waste and then used these pellets for preparing of sinter. It decreases the fuel rate for the sintering process.
Prince Kumar Singh1, A Lava Kumar2 and Sanjay Srivastava4 are
Assistant Professor, Department of MSME, Maulana Azad National Institute of Technology Bhopal, India- 462051
Rabindra Kr Rai3 is Student, Department of MME, National Institute of Technology Durgapur, India 713209 Email: er.princekumarsingh @gmail. com
Many researchers have worked on recycling of plant waste as sinter. The objective of this work represents possible utilization of blast furnace flue dust and sludge from Durgapur Steel Plant after pelletization of both in a disc pelletizer using bentonite as a binder material through sintering process as a substitute of coke breeze due to high price.
II. EXPERIMENTAL The raw materials used for pelletization are flue dust, sludge
(chemical analysis as shown in (Table II) and binders ( dextrine, bentonite and molasses). The pellets produced after pelletizations are used for sintering with other ingredients iron ore, lime stone, dolomite and coke breeze. The chemical of the raw materials used is shown in the Table I.
The raw material is weighed according to the charge mix using electronic weighing machine. The pellets were prepared in a disc pelletizer with a diameter 56 cm, angle of inclination 36.210, disc rotating speed 29 rpm, and residence time of 10 minutes. Pellets were prepared by using binders (2, 3 and 4 wt%) with varying amount of raw materials. The green pellets were dried in air for two days and then the bentonite made pellets were heated up to 3000C for 1 hr and then isothermally indurated at 9000C for 1 hr at the same time dextrin and molasses made pellets were heated in an air oven at 1500C for 1 hr. The prepared green pellets are shown in the figure 1. Properties of the pellets were determined by using compression test, shatter index test and drop test methods. By using the most appropriate pellets, sintering was performed. The sintering experiments were conducted in a laboratory down draft sinter machine. The dimensions of the sintering pot are total height of pan 26.5 cm, hearth area 306.25 cm2, top area 542.5 cm2, Capacity of the machine 16 kg. By keeping the iron ore and coke percentage fix in the charge mix with varying other ingredient, the basicity (CaO/SiO2) were also fixed for 1.5, 1.7, 2.2.
P
International Conference on Integrated Waste Management and Green Energy Engineering (ICIWMGEE'2013) April 15-16, 2013 Johannesburg (South Africa)
326
III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
3.1 Property of Pellets: The properties of pellets and their strength with respect to
amount of the binder are reported in Fig1- 3. According to which pellets made by mixture of sludge and flue dust with bentonite binder shows the highest strength as shown in shown Fig 3. The same result was also proved by compression test and drop test [9-10].
1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.020
22
24
26
28
Shut
ter I
ndex
Amount of the binder (%)
Bentonite Dextrine Molasses
Fig.1 Pelltes of Flue dust
2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0
24
28
32
36
40
44
Shatt
er In
dex
Amount of the binder (%)
Bentonite Dextrine Molasses
Fig.2 Pellets of Blast Furnace sludge
2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.020
24
28
32
36
40
Shat
ter I
ndex
Amount of the binder (%)
Bentonite Dextrine Molasses
Fig. 3 Pellets of Blast Furnace sludge + flue dust
3.2 Productivity of Disc Pelltiser Fig. 4 shows the variation of the productivity with effect of
the binder. The productivity of the Disc Pelletier depends upon the yield of the pelletistion process [11] and it was found good in case of bentonite as a binder.
2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.035404550556065707580
Prod
uctiv
ity
Amount of the binder(%)
Bentonite Dextrine Molasses
Fig. 4 Effect of binders on productivity of machine
3.3 Effect of waste on coke rate of sinter The coke rate decreases with increase in waste(Fig 5). The waste contains some carbon (Fixed Carbon contained in Flue Dust is 9.05 % and in Sludge is 12.15%) which reduce the coke requirement during actual sintering. More carbon is available during the process.
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
100
120
140
160
180
200
Cok
e ra
te (k
g/to
ne o
f si
nter
)
% of waste
Basicity=1.5 Basicity=1.73 Basicity=2.2
Fig.5 Effect of waste on coke rate
3.4 Effect of waste on sintering strength : The sinter strength increased with increasing flue dust and
Blast Furnace sludge (mixed) pellets (Fig 6). Thisis attributed
International Conference on Integrated Waste Management and Green Energy Engineering (ICIWMGEE'2013) April 15-16, 2013 Johannesburg (South Africa)
327
to increasing amount of melt in the charge with increasing amount of flue dust and Sludge pellets.
0 5 10 15 20 25 3060
62
64
66
68
70
72
74
76Sh
atter
Inde
x
% waste
Basicity=1.5 Basicity=1.73 Basicity=2.2
Fig. 6 Effect of waste on sinter strength
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
3.6
4.0
4.4
4.8
5.2
5.6
Prod
uctiv
ity
% waste
Basicity=1.5 Basicity=1.73 Basicity=2.2
Fig. 7 Effect of waste on productivity
3.5 Effect of waste on Productivity Productivity increases slightly with increase in basicity
(SiO2/CaO) as well as waste addition(Fig. 7). Productivity is directly linked with sintering rate. Addition of CaO increases the sintering rate because it undergoes endothermic dissociation. Microscopic studies showed that the bulk of original material was liquid during sintering. High surface tension and low viscosity of the melt combined with short solidification time and high temperature co-efficient of viscosity have led to rapid sintering
3.6 Effect of waste on reducibility of sinter The reducibility was done in Reduction furnace by carbon mono oxide at the rate of 1.5 ltr / min, at temperature 900 0C and reduction time 90 min. Percentage Weight loss = (Wi Wf) / Wi x 100 where Wi is Initial weight and Wf is Final weight The graph (Fig.8) shows that the percentage of weight loss or reducibility decreased with increase in the waste percent in the sinter mix. This may be due to the fact that the magnetite (Fe3O4) phase which is less reducible than hematite, increases in the sinter mix with increasing the amount of flue dust and sludge pellets in sinter charge and this need more coke to reduce.
0 5 10 15 20 25 3016171819202122232425
the
loss
of
the
wei
ght %
% waste
Basicity=1.5 Basicity=1.73 Basicity=2.2
Fig. 8 effect of waste on reducibility of sinter
3.7 Micro structural analysis of sinter Sinter sample having 20 % waste and 1.7 basicity was
analyzed under the Optical Microscope.The microstructure revels that sample, consisted of re-oxidized hematite and few magnetite phase. Slag phase consist of Calcium silicate and Calcium ferrite are also present. The presence of such phases is confirmed with the XRD pattern.
Fig. 9 Microstructure of sinter sample
3.8 XRD analysis of Sinter The X-ray diffraction of the sinter having 20 % waste and
1.7 basicity, indicates that the sinter consist of hematite phase mainly with magnetite and slag (CaSiO3)phase.
Fig. 10 XRD Pattern of sinter sample
International Conference on Integrated Waste Management and Green Energy Engineering (ICIWMGEE'2013) April 15-16, 2013 Johannesburg (South Africa)
328
IV. CONCLUSION From the above study it can be concluded The most suitable pellets (8-10 mm) of wastes produced were of Blast Furnace sludge and Flue dust (mixed together) using bentonite (4%) as binder in a disc pelletizer at angle of inclination 36.210, rotating speed 29 rpm and residence time of 10 min and these were used in sinter making. Pellets when used in sintering of iron ore
Mechanical properties of sinter improved. Production increases. Coke rate decreases. FeO content decreases but Fe content increases. Reducibility of sinter decreases with increase in waste
amount. Sinter made with waste pellets having basicity 2.2 has a
better mechanical strength. Using waste materials leads to decrease the amount of fluxing material.
REFERENCES [1] Organization of Waste less Technology in Blast Furnace Operations,
Journal of Environmental Control and Rational Utilization of Natural Resources. Donetsk, 1992 vol. 1517, No 2. p 3236
[2] M. Froehling, Otto Rentz, Journal of Cleaner Production 18 (2010) 161. [3] Sintering by recirculation of ferrogenous waste, Ratna Dasgupta and
P.S.R. Reddy. [4] I. Toroglu, The Journal of Ore Dressing, 4 (2002) 10. [5] J. N. Leonard, D.R. Mitchell, Coal preparation 4th Ed AIME, New York,
1979. [6] Coal preparation chemistry of Coal Utilization, Martin A Ellitte Ed,
John Willey and Sons. Inc., A.W. Deurbrouck and R. E. Muck (1981), chapter 10.
[7] N. Cornejo, A. Isidro, J. C. Ruiz, F. Garcia, I. Gmez, I. Covina, Fuel, 75 (1996) 659.
[8] F.M.Mohamed, Ph.D. Thesis, Faculty of Science, Cairo Univ. Beni Suef Branch Egypt, (2000).
[9] An Introduction of modern Iron and steel making by R. H. Tupkary and V. R. Tupkary Khanna Publishers Delhi.
[10] Principles of extractive metallurgy by T. Rosenquest; Mcgraw Hill. [11] Effect of Recycling Blast Furnace Flue Dust as Pellets on the Sintering
Performance N. A. EI, M. E. H. Shalabi (CMRDI)
TABLE I CHEMICAL ANALYSIS OF RAW MATERIAL
TABLE II
CHEMICAL ANALYSIS OF WASTE
Ingredients Fe(t) CaO SiO2 MgO Al2O3 LOI Ash V.M. F.C.
Iron ore 52.8 - 2.94 - 2.45 2.38 - - -
Lime - 72.00 - - - - - - -
Lime stone - 49.24 6.93 1.12 1.28 39.06 - - -
Dolomite - 26.98 3.49 19.82 1.48 - - - -
Coke breeze - - - - - - 22.07 5.10 71.40
Waste Fe(t) CaO SiO2 MgO Al2O3 Na2O K2O
Sludge 26.78 8.50 11.89 4.12 3.85 0.07 0.29
Flue Dust 42.0 5.95 6.83 2.12 3.12 0.22 0.56
International Conference on Integrated Waste Management and Green Energy Engineering (ICIWMGEE'2013) April 15-16, 2013 Johannesburg (South Africa)
329