4/6/2014 ‘I want to use cinema to explore that which escapes you’ | The Indian Express | Page 99

http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/i-want-to-use-cinema-to-explore-that-which-escapes-you/99/ 1/7

Home India India-Others EYE

9 0 Comments

Written by Shubhra Gupta | April 6, 2014 12:27 am Print

RELATED

Secrets of the Valley

Secrets of the Valley

Secrets of the Valley

A tap on the shoulder while I’m engrossed in watching Nainsukh on a

swaying train makes me turn. It is an art historian and teacher who

recognises the frames, and engages me in a brief, intense conversation

about the film and the filmmaker.

She talks of the great delicacy and the meticulous attention to detail in it,

and leaves me marvelling at the coincidence. I take it as a sign. What

are the odds of two strangers bumping into each other and chatting

about an Indian filmmaker whose work is mostly known and admired out

of India? The train is taking me to Kathgodam, from where I will be

transported to Sonapani, a lovely homestead in the Uttarakhand hills.

There waits a stunning view of the Himalayan range and the promise of

a meeting with Amit Dutta, the most famous Indian filmmaker you may

have never heard of.

I have spent the journey brushing up on Dutta’s works (Kra Ma Sha, The

Museum Of Imagination, Aadmi Aur Aurat Aur Anya Kahaniyaan), which

have a growing fan following, and which regularly get programmed at

film festivals outside the country. Marco Mueller, the artistic director of

‘I want to use cinema to explore that whichescapes you’

Cleartrip Hotel Deals

Book Your Hotel Online & Pay At CheckIn + Get Upto 50% Off. Hurry! www.cleartrip.com/hotels

Ads by Google

SUMMARY

A conversation with

Amit Dutta, the

most famous Indian

filmmaker you may

have never heard

of.

Tweet This

ONLY IN THE EXPRESS

The Build-UP: Amit Shah's gameplan toconquer UP for Modi

Shah would take nearly a month to land in

Lucknow for his first meeting with office-bearers at

the state BJP headquarters.

FEATURED AD: Discount Shopping

EDITOR'S PICK

Sports

India vs Sri Lanka LiveCricket Score

Sports

Mahendra Singh Dhoniarranges final ticket forPakistan fan

India

The Build-UP: AmitShah's gameplan toconquer UP for Modi

NATIONSUNDAY, APR 06, 2014

Follow 1.1mLike

Amit Dutta

Express Specials The Numbers Story #Elections2014 ICC T20 World Cup Writings on the Wall E-Paper Today's Paper Astrology

ELECTIONS NATION WORLD BUSINESS CITIES SPORTS ENTERTAINMENT TECHNOLOGY OPINION PHOTOS ARCHIVES ALL SECTIONS

4/6/2014 ‘I want to use cinema to explore that which escapes you’ | The Indian Express | Page 99

http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/i-want-to-use-cinema-to-explore-that-which-escapes-you/99/ 2/7

the Rome Film Festival, is an admirer, and showed Dutta’s dreamy,

drenched-in-music The Seventh Walk (Saatvin Sair) as the closing film

during the last edition (November 2013). So is Paolo Bertolin, who is the

regional correspondent for the Venice Film Festival and programme

advisor to the Doha festival. Bertolin believes that “Dutta is a truly unique

artist, and his rich body of work displays a great deal of creativity and

originality, and [is] at the same time rigorous and uncompromising,

which obviously makes it niche, yet for those who can connect with it, it

is a truly mesmerising experience in images and sound”.

For someone like me who has been fed on a weekly diet of Bollywood

and Hollywood, it requires the wearing of a radically different hat to be

able to enjoy Dutta’s work. You find yourself sloughing off years-old

scales, and you realise just how conditioned you have become to, in

Bertolin’s words, “easy sells”. Dutta is no easy sell. He slows down, he

stops, he lingers. He observes. You enter his universe, immerse

yourself fully, and emerge on the other side, blinking.

Nainsukh (2010), a study of Pahadi miniature paintings and the

relationship of the 18th century Kangra artist with his art and the viewer,

is as riveting as it has been before, despite the rattling and the clacking

that needs me to hold on to the laptop with one hand, and anchor the

earphones with the other. Dutta’s constant referencing of literature (he is

a voracious reader of Hindi sahitya, and is almost done writing his first

book in Hindi) and painting makes his films a very particular pleasure.

Several of his films are, in fact, like paintings, each frame inviting your

eye to linger and to create your own meaning. And uncover the myths

that he is working with.

Part of the myths that have sprung up around the 37-year-old filmmaker,

(he was born and grew up in Jammu), who doesn’t travel, doesn’t like

going to film festivals, doesn’t like interacting with the media, is also that

he likes his films to be seen in a completely controlled environment.

What would he think, I wonder, of my watching, which is being done in a

noisy compartment, with doors opening and closing, and people passing

by in a continuous stream? Is it sacrilegious? Will he frown and not

speak?

I needn’t have worried. A single person viewing a film on a laptop is the

greatest intimacy, he says. That is the future of the movies. Over the

next couple of days, we (a bunch of people who have gathered to see

Dutta present his films, and participate in the discussions after) are led

through a very special experience. He shows a clutch of his films: The

Seventh Walk, Ramkhind, Sonchidi and Jangarh: Film One (some of

which even he hasn’t seen in a while), and listens intently when a

cineaste or a film enthusiast, or a teacher, comments. And then

responds, with as much intentness.

Dutta doesn’t like the term “experimental” to define his work. “I’m not

sure if it sounds pretentious, but I would like to call myself a margi (a

man who looks for a way forward),” he says. Which, of course, it does.

But the danger of damaging self-regard is not something that Dutta

fears because, very simply, he doesn’t think his body of work is the last

word. His is a work in progress. He may have started off experimenting,

but now he has moved forward, in a more formal, organised manner.

His work is still disruptive, but it is also contemplative and deeply

meditative. It takes the viewer and the maker on a continuous journey

forward, “a quest for the unknown”, which he believes cinema has the

capacity for.

We speak over a day and a half, and the conversation includes the

silence of the hills, and the chirruping of the birds, as we find a quiet

Sports

Unruffled Indian teamlets hair down withPS3, selfies, soccer

Entertainment

First look : SonakshiSinha is sensuous,Akshay Kumar on dutyfor 'Holiday'

Entertainment

Rajinijkanth jokestrend, because myfather can doimpossible things:Soundarya

PHOTOS: Juhi Chawla,Raveena Tandon, NitaAmbani and their lovefor art

PHOTOS: Malaika,Jacqueline, Aditi RaoHaydri are high onfashion

India

Lok sabha Polls: Theworker and themanager

Opinion

Fifth column: Reversingroles

India

Copy Capital

Sports

Quiver full of arrows

India

Profile of the youngModi supporter: Male,without a job, andhopeful

Opinion

Gogoi, the onlyCongressman smiling...and a weeping policeofficer in a masjid

India

In Aligarh, SoniaGandhi hardsells Cong'ideal of unity', steersclear of riots

Opinion

4/6/2014 ‘I want to use cinema to explore that which escapes you’ | The Indian Express | Page 99

http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/i-want-to-use-cinema-to-explore-that-which-escapes-you/99/ 3/7

spot in a meadow where you can hear the wind and nothing else — the

elements of nature his cinema is immersed in. Dutta speaks about his

famous reclusiveness, his chief concerns as a filmmaker, what brought

him to filmmaking, and what has changed that he finds himself travelling

from his lair in Jammu across the hills to this adda, his second in

Sonapani, where he has agreed to break his isolation and interact with

people. Edited excerpts from the interview:

When did you know you wanted to be a filmmaker?

I didn’t come to cinema from cinema. In my family, we watched

Bollywood only once a year. I didn’t watch great films and decide I

wanted to make films. I discovered a book on Satyajit Ray, which had a

photograph of his study. I was very struck by his personality, and his

beautiful but functional, not overly decorated study. I thought it was

possible to live a normal, middle-class or upper-middle class life, and

still be a profound filmmaker. That it was possible to make cinema as a

personal activity.

In my growing years, my family never approved of filmmaking. They

wanted me to do the usual medical or engineering degree. My mother

was a teacher and I would borrow books from the library and read all the

time. My father was an accountant. It was a normal middle-class family.

They thought that there was something wrong with me, “ki itna padhega

toh pagal ho jayega”. Ray made us realise that cinema would be a

serious, respectable activity.

We read a lot of Hindi literature as children (he has a younger brother

and sister), and the works of Amrit Lal Nagar was a big influence. He

was also a screenwriter, and I read his diaries. I thought I would be a

writer. I speak Dogri, I know Hindi, have learnt English, but I couldn’t

think of a language I could write in as I had no command over any single

one.

Somehow cinema seemed to fit in. At around the same time,

Doordarshan showed world cinema and, unknowingly, we were

exposed to masterworks. On Saturdays, they used to show FTII diploma

films, and I was intrigued. Someone in school gifted me a book in

Bangla (they thought I was a Bengali because of my surname) and it

turned out to be a book of Ritwik Ghatak’s (who also went to the Film

and Television Institute of India) letters. And I thought does this institute

even exist? That became my ambition. To go to FTII. I started preparing

for the entrance, took the test in 1999 and joined FTII in 2000.

And what did FTII teach you?

I found most teachers and students referring to “the industry”. “Aap aise

mat kariye, aisa industry mein nahin hota hai.” But I had no interest in

“the industry”. I got very disillusioned because the narrative form or the

cinema of communication held no interest for me. It was not something I

could be engaged in for all my life. It did not excite me.

And then I discovered Armenian Georgian filmmaker Sergei Paranjov

and his wonderful film Shadows of Forgotten Ancestors. It opened up a

whole new way of thinking. And then came the works of Robert

Bresson, Mani Kaul, Kumar Shahani, Kamal Swaroop. Both Mani sir and

Kamalji were very generous, very kind to me. They had come to teach a

junior batch, but they got interested in my work. Alain Resnais was a big

influence. I wanted to work in that direction, obviously trying to find my

own voice.

How did you find your voice? What kind of films does Amit Dutta make?

Poll stories

India

Why allow those in jailto contest polls, SC asksgovt

APR 06: LATEST NEWS

Security stepped up inMuzaffarnagar, Shamli for LS polls06:12 pm, Apr 06, 2014

Congress, SP, BSP indulging in“WWF-like fights in UP: Modi06:08 pm, Apr 06, 2014

Selfies: mental disorders or thefunniest things ever?05:38 pm, Apr 06, 2014

Express LOL: The best ICC WorldTwenty20 jokes05:34 pm, Apr 06, 2014

India vs Sri Lanka Live CricketScore: Rain delays final; toss at 7:10 pm, play at 7: 40 pm

(local time)06:18 pm, Apr 06, 2014

50 dummy EVMs displaying BJDsymbol seized05:23 pm, Apr 06, 2014

TMC ramps up its internet presence with ‘DidiDirect’, blogs by IIM grads05:18 pm, Apr 06, 2014

Rahul Gandhi slams BJP overcorruption and communalism06:24 pm, Apr 06, 2014

4/6/2014 ‘I want to use cinema to explore that which escapes you’ | The Indian Express | Page 99

http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/i-want-to-use-cinema-to-explore-that-which-escapes-you/99/ 4/7

You are prolific, and you have made so many films despite financial

constraints.

I have not arrived at the form yet. The prolific bit that you talk about is a

habit I picked up from the institute days. If I am not making a film, I feel

I’m not thinking, that I’m being lazy. My thoughts, not my films, are a

work in progress. For me, making films is like thinking.

Earlier, I didn’t have much to say. I was learning technique at FTII, and

the subjects I wanted to choose came later. I had only childhood and

acquired memories to start with, those I used in my student films when I

was 22. Slowly I started to learn, and that is what I want to make, a

cinema of learning, something I can learn from.

Audiences don’t exist in my films. I’m aware of that. Other directors have

a relationship with their audience. So I thought: mujhe mazaa kismein aa

raha hai? It is the process that I find exhilarating. I also find it very

exciting to use local knowledge systems, what is called the janpadya

knowledge systems, to create imaginative — not didactic — worlds, and

find my voice.

So what is the most important thing for you?

The most important thing I attempt and I haven’t achieved yet is to

create a cinematic rhythm of sound, movement, ideas: pure, beautiful

rhythm, like the works of Bresson and Balthazar. In Nainsukh I only

wanted rhythm, I wanted to attempt to create what I saw in the paintings.

All my formal work is an attempt in that direction.

The rhythm that is in nature, like the pauses between two

breaths?

to help us personalise your reading experience.

Yes, exactly that.

When you say you are conscious that the audiences do not exist in your

film, that absence, how does that work? How important is it for your film

to be seen?

It is very important. As Tarkovsky says, a film is never complete unless

it is seen. Only when a sahriday (of the same heart) sees it, is it fully

realised. I don’t make films for myself, no. I do exactly what I like, but I

make them for sahridays. If my films are introduced and put into context

properly, why not?

Do you ever envisage a theatrical release of your films?

I am not very keen on this collective viewing experience. You only have

that moment, the whole film you are building towards it, and then

someone opens the door. It’s gone. It is very annoyingly disturbing.

Theatres are not controlled conditions.

Watching a film on a laptop, on the other hand, is as controlled as you

can make it. I’m getting very interested in that kind of viewing. This very

intense, one-on-one viewing—that is my ideal viewer. It’s as personal as

reading a book. You pick up a book and read and don’t attend a

collective reading session.

I get very disturbed by the impatience of an audience.

4/6/2014 ‘I want to use cinema to explore that which escapes you’ | The Indian Express | Page 99

http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/i-want-to-use-cinema-to-explore-that-which-escapes-you/99/ 5/7

You burrow into music, literature and painting, and your work is so

deeply rooted in nature and poetry. Would you call yourself an

ethnographer or a filmmaker?

All arts are inter-related. My primary work is filmmaking. I’m fascinated

with cinema. It is the most recent art form and it has to go to other art

forms to learn. It is still very underdeveloped. Filmmaking to me is a

philosophical quest, for lack of a better word, a spiritual quest. I want to

use it to explore that which escapes you.

Do you see other people’s films?

Every day I watch a film. I can’t go to sleep without watching one. I’ve

just finished the complete works of Hitchcock. Watching inspires me a

lot. Ray, Ghatak, Kaul, Resnais, Hiroshi Teshigahara, the early works of

Prabhat Film Company, of which I have a large collection — these films

I watch again and again.

After you started collaborating with your wife, Ayswarya

Sankaranarayanan (whom he met when he was teaching briefly at

NID just after FTII; she worked on the screenplay of Nainsukh, and

then all their subsequent screenplays), has your work changed?

How do the rhythms of people who live together impact their

work?

My early work was wild and exuberant. After we have started working

together, my work has become very heavily research- oriented. She is

meticulous and a patient reader of texts, and brings the whole very

imaginatively to me. I am impatient, I want to use what we call lightning

in chess, which I’ve played all my life. Now I am much calmer.

Have you thrown tantrums on sets?

(Laughs) Many times. But now I have changed.

You don’t watch Bollywood films, but would you ever want to work

with good actors like Irrfan Khan and Nawazuddin Siddiqui?

Irrfan is a wonderful actor (I haven’t seen Nawazuddin) and trained

actors are very fun, very exciting to work with. There are no profanes, no

sacreds in this. No formulas. But it has to come from within.

This reclusiveness of yours, where does it come from?

Festivals are the only place I can be seen, and I’m grateful to festivals,

especially Oberhausen (which practically put him on the global map) but

the whole thing takes away my focus.

Then what brings you here? And this is your second time. Are

things changing a little?

Gurpal (Singh, the man behind Bring Your Own Film Festival or BYOFF

and a filmmaker and curator who has known Dutta since he was a

student at FTII) has been asking me for many years, and I like him. And

this is very informal. I’m really engaged. I am aware that artists do this

reclusive number, but it is not even fashionable for me. If I could

transport myself, I would maybe go to more places. But I live very far

away, and it is not easy for me to reach places. But I am also aware that

my isolation is getting to me. It is no longer nourishing me. I think

anything that becomes too much needs to be broken. I like coming here

because the gathering is small, and the conversations are enriching.

So maybe other people are not so bad? Coming out of your comforting

4/6/2014 ‘I want to use cinema to explore that which escapes you’ | The Indian Express | Page 99

http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/i-want-to-use-cinema-to-explore-that-which-escapes-you/99/ 6/7

TAGS: Amit Dutta Indian Filmmaker Interview Shubhra Gupta

50 dummy EVMs displaying BJDsymbol seized

50 EVMs displaying ruling BJD's election symbol were

seized from a jeep in Kantamal Assembly constituency.

TMC ramps up its internet presence with ‘Didi Direct’,

blogs by IIM grads

Rahul Gandhi slams BJP over corruption

and communalism

AAP moves EC against Vasundhara Raje

Narendra Modi AccusesCong, SP, BSP Of Stage-managing Fights In UP

Big B, Balki, Watch‘Bhoothnath Returns’

Meet Irrfan Khan’s Son Ayan First Look: SensuousSonakshi Sinha, Duty-boundAkshay Kumar In ‘Holiday’

9

cocoon can be hard…

Yes (laughs). And it is wonderful that a younger generation is connecting

with my work, and wants to talk about it.

So what next?

I’m working on a narrative feature, but it will be my kind of narrative. For

the first time, I want to communicate. I’ve broken the narrative so much,

that doing this would be really challenging. It is loosely based on the first

story of Aadmi Aur Aurat, and it brings all my concerns together —

man’s relationship with nature, the idea of prosperity, what is real

richness, what is beauty. I think cinema can lower anxiety. That is its

real contribution.

LATEST NEWS FROM NATION

PHOTOS

4/6/2014 ‘I want to use cinema to explore that which escapes you’ | The Indian Express | Page 99

http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/i-want-to-use-cinema-to-explore-that-which-escapes-you/99/ 7/7

Narendra Modi tears into the dynasticpolitics of Naveen and Rahul, calls …

1 comment • 2 days ago

Himat — Modi should spend 2/3 days in

Odisha to get 10-12 seats . He can do it

and get to 272

Auto driver, advocate in AAP’s list ofcandidates from Andhra Pradesh

4 comments • 2 days ago

Prof Ujjwal K Chowdhury — Very good

strategy of spreading the organization

across the nation, with honest people …

No ‘Modi wave’, only anti-Congress

wave, says AAP candidate V …

2 comments • 7 hours ago

Meghna — The entire Modi wave is a hype.

By repeating one and the same thing loud

and repeatedly they say it is …

Waheeda Rehman was against wearing

bikini and changing name

1 comment • 9 hours ago

Mohansingh Mahadevrao — Great actress of

past still live in past and not believe in

change, her carrier was spotless and …

ALSO ON INDIAN EXPRESS

0 Comments Indian Express Login

Sort by Newest Share

Start the discussion…

Be the first to comment.

WHAT'S THIS?

Subscribe Add Disqus to your site

Favorite

INDIA

Rahul Gandhi slams BJPover corruption andcommunalism

WORLD

Malaysian Airlines MH370:More ships head to probesignals in plane search

SPORTS

India vs Sri Lanka LiveCricket Score: Asian giantsbattle it out for T20supremacy

LIFESTYLE

Selfies: mental disorders orthe funniest things ever?

ENTERTAINMENT

Sonakshi Sinha wants Indiato be corruption free

TECHNOLOGY

When the small USB startsthinking big

The Express Group Expressindia The Indian Express The Financial Express Loksatta Jansatta Exims Ramnath Goenka Aw ards

Express Tow ers Business Publication Division Express Pharma Express Healthcare Express Hospitality Express Travelw orld Express Computers

Privacy Policy Advertise w ith Us Contact Us Subscribe Investors Information

Copyright © 2014 The Indian Express ltd. All Rights Reserved