8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

1/220

i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos

sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof

s`jo` GfGfvf

hvr`pubo lf Whlfrhco\o sfifr\bosodstotutos kfi`ighib`cf

\coboso3=66

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

2/220

wodfilhcfrh dfWr`io hju^dhcf 3=6= whbs ovfdh nfvfxoWvobossfxhb`cos \cobosos sfxhbiwoj` udovhrsothtos ouroloubjfeubthtzh uifSbhso Whjfshco\ (suiif gui bfulh) lfgub

loshrtfgofs mi`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vhb\fe`deurhdgof ehr^` sfifr\fbWo~.

hvr`pubo lf Whlfrhco\osfifr\bos odstotuto

=6;? \coboso[fv[fvf^os kfiz. 8=

rhlfqt`ro> \fifr kfchbfof

OWCD ?;1-???31-;=-1?-6 s`jo` GfGfvf

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

3/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

o

sfrGhvoO. Whsfvfbo ............... ................. ............... ................. ................ ................. ................ ................. ................ .. 6OO. ehr^`sfifr\bhcrovo ur\ohr\`cos i`whsrokhcf lf i`\x`vdoswfri`iW`co ujbhchco ................. ................ ................. ................ ................ ................. ................ .....76. sfi`qfbfq`sfifr\bhcrov d`rif\f sfxhhco....................... ................. ................ ....

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

4/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

oo

3.7 i`sfifr\bos i`qihlhcos \fvosujbhcf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbosWhrGhvosf lf kfi`yhdhcosfs ............... ................ ................. ................ ................ ................. ....... 837. d`rios kfdifrthcos ih\`lhco lf i`sfifr\bos Whjfshco\o\fvosujbhcf ................ ................ ................ ................ ................. ................ ................. ................ .......... 8:7.6 krfiftoeubo kfdifrthcos ioifr\hcf b`koeuro kfdifrthcosih\`l\fd ................ ................ ................. ................ ................. ................ ................ ................. ................ .. 8:7.3 d`rios Wodffrs`crovfl WhizSulfvo lf kfdivrg`co kfdifrthcf :=7.7 i`sfifr\bos Whjfshco\o \fvosujbhcf ................ ................ ................. ............... :6Z. i`\x`vdf\f lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vhb\f e`deurhdgof dfsyol`cossfifr\fbWo ................ ................ ................ ................. ................ ................ ................. ................ ............. :76. i`\x`vdf\f e`deurhdgof ............... ................ ................. ................ ................ ................. ....... :76.6 porvhbfl lf ih`rfl i`\x`vdf\f kfi`irogxfvo e`deurhdgof ........ :76.3 lfifthco\o Whsrubhcos i`\x`vdf, r`k`rg kfi`irogxfvoi`\x`vdf, sxvf ih`rfl i`\x`vdhc\fd ioifr\hco\ ................ ................ ............. :

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

5/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

ooo

ZO. i`\x`vdos sfju^vhb\f e`deurhdgof dfGuqfro dov\os uefdkfi`\x`vos Whi\xvhvfWo ................ ................. ................ ................ ................. ................ ............. ?=6. Guqhcf, r`k`rg i`\x`vdos lfiju^dhchbo xhbWherubhcf ................ .... ?63. Guqhcos xhbWherubhcolfd kfsvbos wodfpor`chco lf Whsfcfiosoi`\x`vdos sfju^vbhco ............... ................ ................. ................ ................ ................. ................ .. ?

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

6/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

ov

3. lhboqtos sphgofburo Whiflkhdb`cos ioifr\hcf lhboqtosz`kfl Whiflkhdb`cfsf lf sfxhbWherubhc` i`\x`vdhc\fd ................ .. 6

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

7/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

v

7. xfdlfziub`cos vflhcos e`deurhdgof lhboqtsf lfsfxhbWherubhc` i`\x`vdhcs W`ros .............. ................. ................ ................. ............. 6187.6 lhboqtos sphgofburo xfdlfziub`cos vflf ................ ................. ................ 6187.3 sfxhbWherubhc` xfdlfziub`cos vflos uporfths`cf .............. ........... 61;

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

8/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

vo

fcrhvofturhcoqfr\ub hdfzh>

kv. kvhrlo (kvhrlhco)

ox. oxobhrhl. rhlfqt`ro

sse sfqfr\vhb`s sfi`qfbfq` e`lhqso

Whfl. Whflfrh

ssse sfqfr\vhb`s sfi`qfbfq` sfpr`ghs` e`lhqso

ugx`ur hdhczh>

Fujb. Fujbfkh

CKC Lfs Crkhrbogah Khshtzcuga

(jr loh Cudlhsrhpucboe Lhutsgabfdl)CKA Cudlhskhrogatsa`j (lhr Cudlhsrhpucboe Lhutsgabfdl)

GOWK XdothlDfto`ds G`dvhdto`d `d G`dtrfgts j`r tah Odthrdfto`dfbWfbh `j K``ls

HKCKC Hodjarudkskhshtz zui Crkhrbogahd Khshtzcugah

Hodb. Hodbhotudk

j. j`bkhdlh

jj. iharhrh j`bkhdlh

Arsk. Ahrfuskhchr

NuW Nurostosgah Wgaubudk

BK Bfdlhskhrogat

DN[ Dhuh Nurostosgah [`gahdsgarojt

@BK @chrbfdlhskhrogat

SlDr. Sfdlduiihr

Z`rchi. Z`rchihreudk

^S ^ovobrhgat.

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

9/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

6

O. Whsfvfbosfifr\fbo odlovol\f \fdfgx`vrhcfs if\o odthrhshcos rhfbozhcossfifr\bofdo jfrkbhcos lflkhdo\f lf odthrhs\f e`djboqtoskflf[ros ihqfdozios Wh\fvfzhco\ fwhsrokhcs.6 xWorfl e`derhtuboodthrhs\f e`djboqtos i`kvfrhcos3 rfilhdoih sfifr\bofdo \u

sfifr\bhcrovo kzf frshc`cs. kfrevhub erothrouihcsf \uprodgophczh lfyrld`co\, Whsf^bhchbof, gfbehub kzfs, sxvfs\fdWhlfrhco\, uporfths`cf iohdo[`s, fd osodo ur\ohr\GfdfgvbhcflflGfo\vfb`s, fd hr\o kzos frshc`cfi srubofl kfi`rogx`s sxvhcosfrGhvf.

wodfilhcfrh dfWr`ios iozfdof e`deurhdgoos sfxhhcosolhdtojogorhcf lf gfbehubo if\kfdos frshc`cosfs i`qihlhcosifr\hcubo kzos WhrGhvos wfri`Ghdf, rfg e`derhtubo i`\x`vdhcosflf i`\x`vdos sfju^vhb\f e`deurhdgoos kfdz`kflhcubo fdfbozo\iooSwhvf. fifs\fd, e`deurhdgoos gfbehubo sfxos kfdxobvfehr^`sfifr\bhcrov ur\ohr\`chcWo kfvrghbhcubo ifkfbo\hcos

sfju^vhbzh x`rgohblhcf.evbhvf hju^dhcf sfqfr\vhb`s ehr^`sfifr\bhcrovefd`dilhcb`cfWo i`whsrokhcubo i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcosf lfsfsfifr\b` prfqtoefWo if\o Whjfrlhcos fdfbozs. Whlfrhcosf\voswfri`Ghdobof Whsfcfioso sfeo\xhcos kflf[ros lfsfvbh\hvr`pubo,uporfthsfl khrifdoos sfifr\fbWo, frshcubo fbthrdftovf.dfWr`iWo Whswfvbobof khrifdub l`qtrodfsf \u sfsfifr\b`prfqtoefWo i`\x`vdhcosf lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vhb\f ioifr\

frshcubo iolk`if, r`ihbog frfhr\o sfueudhf, kfdxobvos sfkfdoflf kfi`evh\obof fi iolk`ihcos \fvshcfl`cf sfqfr\vhb`sefd`dilhcb`cfsf \u sfi`qfbfq`sfifr\bhcrov fzr`vdhcfs\fd.

dfWr`ios OO \fvWo \fvlfporvhbfl kfdxobubof sfi`qfbfq`d`rihcos sfxhhco gfbehubo doWdos ioxhlvo\ lf if\our\ohr\kfionvdf. oiosf\vos, r`i kffdfbozlhs i`\x`vdossfju^vhb\f e`deurhdgoos sfeo\xo lf lflkodlhs, \u rf sfxose`deurhdgof frshc`cs if\o kfi`yhdhcosfs, uporvhbhs y`vbosf,iozfdWhw`dobof i`xlhs i`\x`vdos sfju^vhb\f kfionvdf sxvfsfi`qfbfq`sfifr\bhcrovo d`rihcosfkfd.

fi \fvos ih`rh qvh\fvWo lfsfcu\hcubof i`\x`vdosf lfi`\x`vdos sfju^vbos kfdsxvfvhcf. fi kfdsxvfvhcos wfri`sfGhdfl

6ehrhshbo^h, ehr^` sfifr\bos uz`kflhso sosthiuro gdhchco, 3==?, kv. 6 lf

Whilk`ido.3 Whfl. G`odk/A`dshbb, Wtfulodkhr E`iihdtfr zui CKC, Hodbhotudk, 3==

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

10/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

3

kffdfbozhcubof i`\x`vdos ioifr\hcf ujbhcfs\fd, fshvh mfqgo`s~7odstotut\fd lf ios \fdfihlr`vh idoWvdhb`cfs\fd. i`\x`vdossfju^vhbo kfrevhubo i`qihlhcos kfdx`rgohbhcos fd ioskfd \fvosWhefvhcos i`\x`vdos lfiju^dhcbfl kfdoxobhcf.

dfWr`ios OOO \fvWo kfdxobubof i`\x`vdf\f lf i`\x`vdossfju^vhb\f e`deurhdgoos kfionvdf lf kffdfbozhcubof ioso

gfbehubo sfxh, r`k`rogff kfi`irogxfvo, fbthrdftoubo lfeuiubfgouro e`deurhdgof.

e`deurhdgoos gfbehubo sfxos z`kflo ifxfsof\hcbhcoskfi`evh\f ehr^` sfifr\fbWo frshcubo i`\x`vdhcosur\ohr\ioifr\hcfs b`koeur GfrG`hcWo fqghvs, gfbehuboWhi\xvhvos sosthiuro kflfwyvhtos Whsf^bhcb`cfsf lf i`\x`vdossfju^vhb\f hr\kvfro ohrfrqoos kfdsfzSvros wodfpor`cfs qidos.

dfWr`ios OZ \fvo h\i`cf sfsfifr\b`s r`bos kfdxobvfssfifr\bos Whilk`i kfdvo\frhcfWo lf ifr\bisfnubhcoskfdx`rgohbhcosfs sfxhbi^Svfdhb` prodgophcos ioi`xobvfs, fshvhd`rios kfdifrthcos ih\`lhcosf lf i`sfifr\bos Whjfshco\o

\fvosujbhcos fdfbozs. hs \fvo hisfxurhcf e`deurhdgoosgfbehubo sfxos frshc`cosfs i`sfifr\bos i`qihlhcos\fvosujbhcosf lf ioso jfrkbhcos kfdxobvfs.

dfWr`ios Z lf Whilk`io \fvhco h\i`cf uWufb`l i`\x`vdf\flf i`\x`vdos sfju^vhb\f e`deurhdgoos frshcubo ifkfbo\hcosWhswfvbfs. sosthiurfl ur\ohr\efvWorWo kfdoxobhcf i`\x`vdf\f\u i`\x`vdos sfju^vhb\f e`deurhdgof dfsyol`cos sfifr\fbWo,dfGuqfro dov\os kfi`\x`vosfs, Wr`ios xhbWherubhcos i`Wbosfs,sfxhbWherubhc` lf efd`dosiohro pfsuxosikhcb`cos kfi`rogxvosfs,fshvh sfxhbWherubhc` lf lhboqtur, sfdov\` lf usfju^vb`kfilolrhcos, xfdlfziub`cos vflhcos ur\ohr\ioifr\hcosfs.

fi ifkfbo\hcos kfdz`kflhco\ jfslhcf sfqfr\vhb`s

sfsfifr\b` prfqtoefWo i`\x`vdf\f lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vhb\fe`deurhdgoos ioifr\ \fdfihlr`vh ouroloub fzr`vdhcfWofrshcubo kfi`globhcos kfzofrhcos iozfdWhw`dob`cf, rfg, \fvosixrov, sfqfr\vhb`Wo hr\kvfr`vfdo sfsfifr\b` prfqtoeosGfi`yfbochcos chrehtof.

7fgto`.

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

11/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

7

OO. ehr^`sfifr\bhcrovo ur\ohr\`cos i`whsrokhcf lf i`\x`vdoswfri`iW`co ujbhchcosfi`qfbfq` efd`dilhcb`cf b`koeurfl ur\ohr\lfefvWorhcubogdhchcosf lf odstotuthcos sosthios sfju^vhbzh fwhsrokhcs por\f\fdfsw`r`cfsf lf dhcos fvt`d`iofzh lfiyfrhcub ur\ohr\`chcs.

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

12/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

Hodbhotudk5 fbbkhihodhr \ahob>Shgat lhr Wgaublvhrabtdossh, 61??, W.

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

125/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

66;

Wr`io\ sfifr\fbWog iozfdWhw`dobof kfrevhubo lfigfvod`rihcos kf\vfboswodhcf, ifkfbo\fl, wodfsfxhbWherubhc`ur\ohr\`chcos \fvoshcurhchcos ueh\ i`sfwhsrokhcbfl.8?; fifs\fd,i`qihlhcs xhbWherubhcos gfbehubo lhcubhcos sfh[v``cosfs iosoWodffrsos lfsfqihcubos sfsfrkhcb`l kfdifrthcos fbthrdftovf.8?1

fi \vfbsfzroso\, sfodthrhs`f uvfl`, fdu kfdusfzSvrhbo

vflo\, lflhcubo Wr`ios xhbWherubhcosf lf ioso vflofdxhbWherubhcos lflhcfs\fd ioifr\hco\ fdfbozo. Wr`io\oxhbWherubhcos topuro sfxhf uvfl` xhbWherubhcf,8?? \uigf osWhsf^b`f lfol`s fshvh kfdusfzSvrhbo vflo\. fifs\fd, vfloslfwhshcf fr Gfo\vbhcf dfilvobfl, \u lfisfqihchbo ix`b`loiot`i lhcs fsh\ xhbWherubhcfs, r`i ioso ihWvh`co\ uvfl`xhbWherubhcos jfrkbhcWo i`qihlo lfgvo\o d`rihcos kvhrlosfvbf surs. fSdoWdubo sfxhzhf, r`lhsfg lfisfqihchbskfdsfzSvrubo vflo\ xhbWherubhcos lflhcos `cohqturosfju^vhbo fr fqvs.:==

efd`do\ lflkhdobo ixfrh\f sfxhbWherubhc` \fvosujbhcf:=6

i`Gvhdhco\of,:=3

vodfolfd Wr`io\o xhbWherubhcos i`dfwobhixfrhhco hr\dforfl \fvosujfbdo fr frofd \fvofd\kflfwyvhtobhcfWo. lfsfqihcubo, xWor Whi\xvhvfWo, o^ubhcuboxlhcf, lf\fdxilhs lfisfqihcbos iohr Wh\fvfzhcuboxhbWherubhcos fif \u oi por`cfs, if\ W`ros Wr`iosxhbWherubhcos kfdsfzSvrubo vflo\ lflhcfs, iouxhlfvfl oiosf,i`sw`ds \u frf oko lf fgd`cohrhcs \u frf, rfilhdfl sfzofd`f hspor`cf ios\vos.:=7

Whsfcfiosfl, xhbWherubhcos \fvosujbhcos prodgopo Wr`io\ur\ohr\`cfWo sfxhWhgvbobo j`rio\ i`qihlhcs. ifkfbo\fl,khrifdoos jhlhrfburo Wr`ios sfsfifr\b`s kfdifrthco\, Wr`io\ur\ohr\`cfWo lfrSvhubof sfxhbWherubhc` \fdfsw`r`cf,:=

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

126/220

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

127/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

66?

Whsfcfiosfl, sxvf sfxhbiwoj`\f i`whsrokhcosfkfdkfdsxvfvhco\, sflfg vfblhcubhco\sfifr\bhcrov i`\x`vdhc\fdioifr\hco\ Wr`iossfifr\bhcrov i`\x`vdhcs kfi`irogxfvo judqgoffeosrof\, sfqfr\vhb`Wo if\ W`ros fbthrdftoubo e`deurhdgoosflf, ujr` ihtog, euiubfgouro ur\ohr\ioifr\hcos fSofrhcf udlfi`xlhs.

3. Wr`io\o xhbWherubhcos i`Wbflfisfqihcbosf lf lfsfqihcubos odthrhshcs W`ros flhevfturocfbfdsos lfgvf kfdsfeu\rhcub idoWvdhb`cfs o^hdsWr`io\sfifr\bhcrov ur\ohr\`chcWo xhbWherubhcos i`Wbosodstotutos prfqtoefWo sw`rfl lfdhrkvos e`dthqstWo.xhbWherubhcos i`Wbos ih`rflo i`\x`vdos rhfbozhcosfswfri`W`cobo sfi`qfbfq`sfifr\bhcrovo lf Wr`iossfifr\bhcrovoi`\x`vdos sfju^vhb\f e`deurhdgoosfs ixhlvhb`cfWof iosfShcoWr`iossfifr\bhcrovo i`whsrokhcos WhiuWfvhcos iozfdo

lfsfqihcubos lfgvf ioso odthrhshcos frf\fdfz`iohroWhzSulvoskfd.

3.6 Wr`io\o xhbWherubhcos i`Wbf Wr`ios e`lhqsos \fdfxiflsfqfr\vhb`s Wr`ios e`lhqsos 7;-h iuxbo kfdsfzSvrfvs Wr`iosxhbWherubhcos Whwyvhtos sfju^vbhcs. fi d`riolfd kfi`ilodfrh,xhbWherubhcos Whwyvhtf, r`k`rg sfifr\bhcrovo odstotuto,kubosxi`cs xhbWherubhcos lfsrubhcfs, fdu ixfrh\f dhcosfkfdlfi`ueolhcbfl lfilkfr sfifr\bhcrov Whlhks, h.w. mouroloubjfqts~,:6= xhbWherubhcos Whwyvhtf kfdpor`chcubof sxvflfsxvfsfju^vbo\, if\ W`ros xhbWherubhcos ixfros kfrlfgvfbhco\.:66

sfqfr\vhb`s Wr`ios e`lhqsos 7;-h iuxbos porvhbo dfwobos mk~qvhpudqtos \fdfxifl, Wr`io\o xhbWherubhcf wylhcf fshvhxhbWherubhcos ixfros iohr xhbWherubhcos por`cos lfrSvhvo\,x`b` ml~ qvhpudqtos \fdfxifl, Wr`ios xhbWherubhcos i`Wbossfju^vhbzh. hs `ro sfju^vhbo lhtfbur fdfbozs i`o\x`vs.

cudl`vfdof efd`dilhcbos dhcf sfqfr\vhb`s Wr`ios e`lhqsos7;-h iuxbos porvhbo dfwobos mk~ qvhpudqt\fd ioifr\hco\.

lfefvWorhco\ Whfl. Nhbodhe, Hod Zhrjfssudkskhrogatsa`j jr sthrrhoga, 6118, W. 8:5^othbifdd, Bgehd oi Shgat, 6?=7, W. :, ?.:6= thriod mouroloubo jfqtos~ idoWvdhb`cfs\fd lfefvWorhco\ ox.

ehrhshbo^h, ehr^` sfifr\bos uz`kflhso sosthiuro gdhchco, 3==?, kv. ;:,

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

128/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

63=

xhbWherubhcos hr\-hr\o ixfros iohr vfblhcubhcos lfrSvhvf,ioso sfxos, soi^oiosf lf idoWvdhb`cos kf\vfboswodhco\, wfri`W`csvfblhcubhcos lfrSvhvos kfi` ih`rflo i`\x`vdos wfyhdhcosf lfkfdx`rgohbhcos ujbhcfs. fios sfporospor`l, sfifr\bhcrovflwfri`ulkhdhbof, xhbWherubhcos hr\-hr\o ixfros iohrxhbWherubhcos por`cos lfrSvhvfi mfvt`ifturfl~ kfi`owvo`s

xhbWherubhcos Whwyvhtf, r`k`rg ouroloubo jfqto.vfblhcubhcos lfrSvhvfs xhbWherubhcos Whwyvhtf vhr i`ayvhcf oiporos dhcos kfi`vbhdosfkfd lfi`ueolhcbfl, r`ibos ioifr\fglforSvf vfblhcubhcf.

\u efd`dilhchbif xhbWherubhcos mWhwyvhtf~ ujbhcfi`soboporos dhcos kfi`vbhdfl iooGdof,:63ulfv`l sfxhzhf thriod`b`kourouzust`cf. ixfros dhcos kfi`vbhdf, r`ihbog ioifr\ubofxhbWherubhcos Whwyvhtfzh, x`rgohblhcf xhbWherubhcos i`Wbo\,fdu xhbWherubhcos ih`rh ixfrosf\vos Whty`codhco\. fSdoWduboWr`ios xhbWherubhcos Whwyvhtos lfi`ueolhchbo sfju^vhbofsfqfr\vhb`s Wr`ios e`lhqsos 7;-h iuxbos porvhbo dfwobos ml~

qvhpudqtos Whsfcfiosfl. filhdfl, mk~ qvhpudqtos i`whsrokhcf fzrsi`ebhcubof.sfqfr\vhb`s Wr`ios e`lhqsos 7;-h iuxbos porvhbo dfwobos

k) lf l) qvhpudqthcos kfionvdo\, sfvfrful`l, efd`dilhchbifkfdfsxvfvf xhbWherubhcos i`Wbf vfblhcubhcos lfrSvhvos kfi`xhbWherubhcos i`Wbosfkfd sxvf pftovsflhco sfju^vbo\.:67 fsh\odhcos frshc`cos Whi\xvhvfWog hs kfionvdf frfjrosi`ighiof,vodfolfd Wr`ios xhbWherubhcos Whwyvhtos sfju^vhbo `rovhWhi\xvhvfWo sfqfr\vhb`s Wr`ios e`lhqsos 7;-h iuxbos porvhbodfwobos ml~ qvhpudqto\ kf\vfboswodhcubo xhbWherubhcos i`Wbff.

doWfdl`cbovof, r`i, qu\fosos sffphbfgo` sfsfifr\b`skfdifrthco\, lfsfqihcubos iohr Wr`io\o xhbWherubhcos

por`chcos lfrSvhvf f^bhvs lfisfqihchbs ujbhcfs, sfqfr\vhb`sWr`ios e`lhqsos 7;-h iuxbos porvhbo dfwobos mk~ qvhpudqtos\fdfxifl, mkff\fvosujb`s oko sfiuWf`lfd~,:6

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

129/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

636

sfqfr\vhb`s Wr`ios e`lhqsos 71-h iuxbos porvhbo dfwobokfdsfzSvrfvs, r`i Wr`io\o xhbWherubhcos i`Wbf Whsf^b`f hr\-hr\o ixfros odogoftovo\ fi iuxbo\ lflkhdobo whso\. \uigf,xhbWherubhcos i`Wbos whssf lf wodfpor`chcs fSdoWdubo iuxbofr kfdsfzSvrfvs.

oiosf\vos, r`i ehr^`sfifr\bhcrovo ur\ohr\`cos i`dfwobhi

kfdfx`rgohb`s hsf \u os i`\x`vdf, oko udlf hiyfrhc`lhs efd`do\kfdsfzSvrub i`\x`vdos sfju^vhbs. i`\x`vdos sfifr\bhcrovosfju^vhbo, \fvos ixrov, udlf Whogfvlhs zustfl kfdsfzSvruboWhiflkhdb`cos doWdhcs, fdu wodfpor`chcs. fi wodfpor`chcosfrshc`cosfs ixfrh ujbhcfi`sobof, i`o\x`v`s Whsfcfiosoi`qihlhcos kfdx`rgohbhcf fd ioso gfbixrovo ioShcfsfvfblhcub`dhcos kfi`vbhdo\ kfi`owvo`s efd`do\ kf\vfboswodhcubo Whsfcfiososfifr\bhcrovo Whlhkos lflk`if. Whsfcfiosfl, i`\x`vdos sfju^vhbo`ro dfwobosfkfd Whlkhcf> d`rios Whiflkhdb`cosf lfsfifr\bhcrovo Whlhkosfkfd.:68

sfqfr\vhb`s Wr`ios e`lhqsos 71-h iuxbo fr Whhsfcfihcf

i`\x`vdos ^oro\flo sfju^vbosf\vos wfyhdhcub i`\x`vdhcs. okoflkhds sfifr\bhcrov Whlhks> ujbhcf fqvs, i`Wfb`sxhbWherubhcf,\uigf fr kfdsfzSvrfvs, \u rf sfju^vbo\f lf rfwodfpor`chcos lfgvo\ x`rgohblhcf hs ujbhcf. Whsfcfiosfl, okoWhsf^b`f kfdxobub oqdhs ix`b`l r`k`rg i`\x`vdos lfifthco\osfifr\bhcrovo sfju^vhbo i`\x`vdos ^oro\fl sfju^vhb\fdhr\`cbo`cfWo.

fi sfeo\xzh prfqtoefWo frshcubo i`sfzrhchcowodffSilhk`crovof lf xWorfl sfqfr\vhb`s Wr`ios e`lhqsos 7;-hlf 71-h iuxbhco i`\x`vdos ^oro\fl sfifr\bhcrov sfju^vbflkfdoxobhcf, iouxhlfvfl oiosf, r`i hs iuxbhco fr fwhsrokhcsxhbWherubhcos i`Wbos whssf lf por`chcs.:6:

sfqfr\vhb`s Wr`ios e`lhqsos porvhbo iuxbos \fdfxifl,mWr`io\ ur\ohr\`cfs\fd lfefvWorhcubo sfeo\xhco, r`ihb\fg frfwhsrokhcs hs e`lhqso fd sxvf sphgofburo efd`do, rhkuborlhcfsfqfr\vhb`s sfi`qfbfq` e`lhqso\.~ sfqfr\vhb`s Wr`ios e`lhqsos

:68Whfl., ifkfbo\fl> co`bodko/[fdturof, sfi`qfbfq` sfqihhczh sfsfifr\b`kflfwyvhtobhcf\f ioShcos ih\`loef, ih-3 kfi`ghif, 3==

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

130/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

633

7;-h iuxbos porvhbo dfwobos mk~ qvhpudqtosf lf 71-h iuxbosporvhbo dfwobos rhkuborhcf, ulfv`l, frfsfeifrosof oiosf\vos,r`i osodo i`\x`vdos ^oro\fl \u lfi`ueolhchb sfju^vbfl oqddhdioGdhubdo. Wr`io\o xhbWherubhcos i`Wbos wodfpor`chco lfpr`ghlurf fros sfeo\xhco, mr`ihb\fg fr fwhsrokhcs hs e`lhqso~,rfg, Whsfcfiosfl, sse-o\ i`whsrokhcubo kr^hbvflofdo

xhbWherubhcos i`Wbosf\vos kf\vfboswodhcubo whsosf lfpor`chcos kfi`yhdhcos fugobhcb`cfs kfdfpor`chcs.

3.3 xhbWherubhcos i`Wbos z`kflo whso3.3.6 vfblhcubhcos lfrSvhvf lf kfjr\xobhcos vfblhcubhcfsse-os 7??-h iuxbos ih-3 dfwobos \fdfxifl, kr^hbvflofdsfxhbWherubhc` ur\ohr\`cfWo xhbWherubhcos ixfros iohrvfblhcubhcos lfrSvhvosfs kfi`oyhdhcf sse-os

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

131/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

637

fSevh\os fugobhcb`cosf lf Whsf^b` sfifr\bhcrovo Whlhkhcoskfgd`cohrhcf. oi Whi\xvhvfWo, \u kfjr\xobhcfs sfsurvhbo Whilhkofr i`ayvf, lfisfqihchbo ujbhcfi`sobof, i`Wfb`s Wr`io\oxhbWherubhcf.:61

kfsf\vfboswodhchbof, r`i \vo\ kfjr\xobhcfg udlf nlhc`-lhs \fdfz`iohrhcos GfrG`hcWo, ehr^`l, kfjr\xobhcf, r`ihbog

uidoWvdhb` sfju^vbo\ x`rgohblhcf, fr Gfo\vbhcf dfilvobfl lf,Whsfcfiosfl, fr wfri`W`cs xhbWherubhcos i`Wbos ujbhcfs.:6?

3.3.3 xhbWherubhcos i`Wbfkfjr\xobhcos kfrhWhsse-os

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

132/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

63 qr\fios fShcf, qurl`cf, \fSbo\`cf, e`djolhdgofburoodj`rifgoos kfvrghbhcf:76). fifs\fd, vfblhcubhcos uxhWolfrSvhvos iteoghcos tvor\o xhbWherubhcos i`iWbhb ixfrhsfwhvs.:73

3.7 xhbWherubhcos i`Wbos sfi`qfbfq`sfifr\bhcrovo lfWr`iossfifr\bhcrovo i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos ioifr\hcfWr`ios sfifr\bos d`rihco\, lfsfqihcub\f ujbhchcos lfgvfhe`d`ioeurfl lf s`gofburfl ujr` ^bohro lfisfqihcbos\fvosujbhcos \fdfz`iohr WhzSulvfs hisfxurhcf, lfsfqihcubos

lfgvos Sorso odthrhshcos uzrudvhbsfy`jfl.:77 e`derhtuboWhi\xvhvos ifrhkuborhchbo d`rihcos frfrshc`cos Whi\xvhvfWokfi`oyhdhcf ifs\fd frso\f lf iozdo\ yvhbfzh fxb`s ilk`iosfifr\bos d`rif.

:3:Xrthob v`i 3

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

134/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

63:

3.7.6 sfi`qfbfq`sfifr\bhcrovo d`rihcos kfi`yhdhcosiozfdWhw`dob`cfefd`dos fdfb`kof kfi`oyhdhcf oi Whi\xvhvfWo, r`lhsfg hr\oWhi\xvhvosf\vos efd`dos d`rio\ kf\vfboswodhcubo sfifr\bhcrovoWhlhko udlf kfvrghblhs frshco\fl iskfvs, ifkrfi sfifr\bhcrovfl

i`uwhsrokhchb, Whi\xvhvfzh.:7

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

135/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

63;

Whi\xvhvfWo osfrkhcbhcs fdfb`koos odstotuto\, \u sse-os 7??-hiuxbos kfi`yhdhcfs lffsfcu\hcs Wr`iossfifr\bhcrovo, r`k`rguporfthso lfgvos stfdlfrtos lfilkhdo, d`rios WhiuWfvhcos iozdo\.

gxflof, Wr`io\o xhbWherubhcfvfblhcubhco\sfifr\bhcrovo xhbWherubhcos hr\-hr\o sfxhf lfioso i`iwhsrokhchbo sphgofburo d`rihco\ fi ur\ohr\`cos

\fvoshcurhcos kf\vfboswodhcf udlf i`xlhs. Wr`ios sfifr\bos^oro\flo prodgopo, lfogvfs lfsfqihcubos odthrhshco, kfdfiteoghcsi`sfzrhcfs, r`i lfsfqihcubs ujbhcf fqvs, osfrkhcb`s sse-o\lflkhdobo z`kflo whshco\ lflkhdobo iodoifburo lfgvo\.

sfqfr\vhb`s Wr`ios e`lhqsos 7;-h iuxbos porvhbo dfwobosml~ qvhpudqtosf lf 71-h iuxbos \fdfxifl, Wr`ios xhbWherubhcosWhwyvhtos sfju^vhbof xhbWherubhcos i`Wbf. fifs\fd,sfqfr\vhb`s Wr`ios e`lhqsos porvhbo iuxbos Whsfcfiosfl,Wr`io\ xhbWherubhcfzh udlf kfvrghblhs yvhbf z`kflo, sxvfxhbWherubhchcos ioifr\ i`qihlo, whso, \u Wr`ios e`lhqso\f lfsphgofburo efd`dilhcb`co\ fr fros kf\vfboswodhcubo Wr`io\o

ur\ohr\`cos ifrhkuborhchbo sphgofburo whso. gxflof, hsvrghblhcf fshvh kr^hbvflofdo xhbWherubhcos i`Wbfzh,pftovsflhco iozhzos frshc`cosfs.

fifs\fd, Wr`io\sfifr\bhcrovo ur\ohr\`cos sphgofburoefd`dilhcb`co\ i`whsrokhcos iozdhcolfd kfi`ilodfrh, sphgofburod`rif lfsfWvhcof o\vfboswodhclhs lfsfqihcubos\vos ix`b`lujr` prhjhrhdgoub whss, volrh hs ujr` z`kfloefd`dilhcb`colfd kfi`ilodfrh`cs.

3.7.3 i`Wbos z`kflo lf sphgofburo wodfpor`chcosse-os 7??-h iuxbo, r`k`rg i`\x`vdos ^oro\flo sfju^vhbo,

fwhsrokhcs kr^hbvflofdo xhbWherubhcos i`Wbos z`kfl, x`b`sfqfr\vhb`s Wr`ios e`lhqsos 71-h iuxbos ih-3 lf ih-7 dfwobhcolfifthco\ wodfpor`chcs. ehr^`l, lfisfqihchbo pftovsflhcosfju^vbo\ xhbWherubhcos i`Wbos Whi\xvhvfWo vfblhcubof,lfsfqihcubs iosghs fdfzSfurhcf frfdfebhc hr\o \vos xhbjfsos`lhd`co\. lfsfqihcubo, \fvos ixrov, vfblhcubof, kffjr\xob`slfisfqihchbo xhbWherubhcos i`Wbos Whsfxhc hr\o \vo\ flrh.

sfqfr\vhb`s uzhdfhso sfsfifr\b` iooGdhvs, r`ilfisfqihcbos struqturub hr\hubWo rh`rkfdozfgof,struqturubo gvbobhchco, sfWtft` rogx`vdhcos Whigorhcf,Whsf^b`f, xhbWherubhcos i`Wbos pftovsflhc sfju^vbfl oqdhs

ioGdhubo.:71

sfsfifr\b` fshvh hyrld`cf sfqfr\vhb`s

:71 sfqfr\vhb`s uzhdfhso sfsfifr\b`s sfi`qfbfq`, sfihwfrih` lfkfe`trhcos sfqih\f pfbftos 3==1 wbos 3 fprobos.#fs-:1=-6=6=-=; kfdGodhcf.

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

136/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

631

e`dstotugoos 7=-h iuxbos ih-3 pudqts. fi uefdfsedhbo\kf\vfboswodhcubof sfxhbiwoj`s ixrolfd \fvosujfbo ihwfrih`cosflf e`deurhdgoos kfdvo\frhcos xhbWhwy`cf, r`ihbog, sfsfifr\b`skfdifrthco\, kubosxi`cs ihwfrios ujbhcfs, \fvoso Whxhlubhco\WhfrGo`s e`dtrfahdto, \fvoso iozdhcolfd kfi`ilodfrh lfoqorfv`slf Whwyvot`s por\fd Wr`io\o ur\ohr\`chco.:7?

sfsfifr\b`s kfdifrthco\, sfihwfrih` ujbhcfi`sobhcoskfdx`rgohbhcosfs Wr`io\sfifr\bhcrovo ur\ohr\`chco xfsof\lhcfkfrevhubo \fvoshcurhchco\. sfihwfrih` ouroloubo porhcossfeu\rhcos ujbhcos rhfbozhcos hr\-hr\ ui\fvrhso iozfdofi`khcos ioShcf. \fvos ixrov, fi iozdos rhfbozhcf lfsfqihcub\fWhrGhvos \fvosujbhcfWo vbodlhcf.:

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

137/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

63?

kfgxflhcub ms`gofburo sfxhbiwoj`s lfievolrhcos dhcfs\fd~:

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

138/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

67=

fios sfporospor`l, loseroiodfgofl fr Gfo\vbhcf, Wr`ios e`lhqsosih-3 iuxbos ih-8 dfwobos \fdfxifl, mpor\f kfdsxvfvhcosfugobhcb`cf, r`ihbog kfi`ilodfrh`cs sfiuWf`s frsolfd,sphgojoeolfd fd ioso Whsrubhcos por`chcolfd, hisfxurhcfefd`dohro iozdos ioSwhvfs lf fros ioso ioSwhvos \fdfz`iohro lffugobhchbo sfWufbhcf.~

xhbWherubhcos i`Wbf, r`ihbog fufrhshcs lfsfqihcubosilk`ifrh`cfs fdfb`kour por`chcWo iy`j sxvf por\fd Whlfrhco\,efd`do\ lflkhdob whss, fdu Wr`ios e`lhqsos ih-3 iuxbosloseroiodfgoos fer^fbvfs hwodffSilhkhcf. fifs\fd, kfrokhcf,r`ihbog mefd`do\ lflkhdob whssf lf fer^fbvhcs~ hwodffSilhkhcf,sse-os 8

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

139/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

676

dfilvobo lf, sse-os 7;-h iuxbos porvhbo dfwobos ml~ qvhpudqtosWhsfcfiosfl, fr owvhvs xhbWherubhcos Whwyvhtfs.:86 Whlhkfl,Wr`ios xhbWherubhcf dfilvobof, lfisfqihchbo eo, Wr`iose`lhqsos 73-h iuxbos porvhbo dfwobos \fdfxifl, vfblhcubof, iosiohr kfi`wvhubo (efd`dos lfrSvhvo\ kfdx`rgohbhcuboxhbWherubhcos i`Wbo\, r`ihbog cf\obof) o^ubhco\o i`glhdf

ffdfzSfur`s srubo `lhd`co\.kfrlf fiosf, xhbWherubhcos i`Wbos sfifr\bhcrovo

Whlhkhco vhr lflkhcf, \u lfisfqihchbo lfsfqihcubs vfblhcubhcoslfrSvhvos kfi` fr kfdusfzSvrfvs lfifthco\ vflfs fd fr iosghiskfjr\xobhcfs,

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

140/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

673

efd`dohro ujbhcf lfisfqihchbs ix`b`l oi Whi\xvhvfWo fqvs, \ufr frshc`cs Wr`ios e`lhqsos 7:-h iuxbos porvhbo dfwobo\kf\vfboswodhcubo sfju^vhbo.

kfsfzofrhchbof sfsfifr\b`s kfdifrthcf, r`ibos \fdfxifl,sse-os

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

141/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

677

Whsfcfiosfl, zhi`\ i`yvfdob Whi\xvhvfWo sfsfifr\b`s \fvfludlf hisnhbf, hvr`pos s`gofburo qfrtoos ih-< iuxbos ih-:;7

Whsrubhcfs\fd lfefvWorhcubo frf^oro\flo vfblhcubhcosiozfdof, uzrudvhby`s ^oro\flo vfblhcubhcos i`izflhcf lfWhsrubhcf. Whsfcfiosfl, fSdoWdubo lhcubhco\ lfgubo odthrhso

Xijfdk lhr [oreudk lhr Shsnulogftf, lho G`deurhdz lhr Ebfkhd, udl lfs ]rfhnulogoui, 617?,W. 771.:::Whfl. ]fbfdlt/Ahodrogas, CKC E`iihdtfr,:;. Fujb., 3==1, 3

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

145/220

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

146/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

671

z`kohr\ Whi\xvhvfWo, odj`rifgoos iow`lhcf ixfrhs \fvfl^oro\flo vfblhcubhco\ heosrhcf, kfdsfeu\rhco\, r`lhsfgodj`rifgof Whsrubhcos xfrosxsf \u \voshchcs uefvWorlhcf.gfbehub Whi\xvhvfWo Whsf^bhchbof, dov\\fd ioifr\hco\ ^oro\flovfblhcubhcos lfrSvhvf fifvlr`ubfl odj`rifgoos iow`lhcosvfblhcubhcos lfrSvhvfg oy`s. odj`rifgoos iow`lhcos

vfblhcubhcos lfrSvhvf kfdsfeu\rhco\ idoWvdhb`vfdo xlhcfsw`rhl osh\ Whi\xvhvfWo, r`lhsfg ioso iouw`lhcb`cf ^oro\flvfblhcubhcfs fr frSvhvs, ifkrfi fi odj`rifgoos frq`dos kfi`ujbhcfi`sob pors flkhcf zofdo. fifs\fd, idoWvdhb`vfdof os, r`iWhsfcfioso odj`rifgoos kf\vfboswodhcos Whi\xvhvfWo zofdo frlflkhc`lf,:1= x`b` odj`rifgoos iow`lhcos vfblhcubhcf ixfrhskubosxiohrhcosf \u eh\obsodlosohrhcos prodgophcoskf\vfboswodhco\ ulfv`l heosrhc`lf.

sse-os 761-h iuxbos j`riuborhcf, r`ibos sfju^vhbzhgsfvfblhcub`f odj`rifgoos iow`lhcf, \u oko idoWvdhb`vfdofsfxhbWherubhc` vfblhcubhcos Wodffrsos lflkhdosf\vos,

kfsfzofrhchbof. iouxhlfvfl fiosf, Whilk`io lfe`derhthcfodj`rifgoos iow`lhcos xfrnhcos upor`c`l Whi^hdzh lfeosrhcos\f`cfzh kfuifr\bhchbof. fSdoWdubo oikvfrfl udlf kfdoifrt`s,r`i xfrnhco fdfzSfurhcos odj`rifgoos ioiShcs ix`b`l oiWhi\xvhvfWo lfheosr`s, \u odj`rifgof fr fros idoWvdhb`vfdosfxhbWherubhc` vfblhcubhcos Wodffrsos kfdsfsfzSvrfvfl, \uigfoko sucohqturfl idoWvdhb`vfdof uWufb`l xhbWherubhcosixfrosf\vos.

fSdoWdubo sfwodffSilhk` kfdifrthcf odj`rifgoos iow`lhcosvfblhcubhcos i`whsrokhcfs fzrs lfuefrkfvlf, vodfolfdodj`rifgoos iow`lhcf, z`kohr\ Whi\xvhvfWo, ^oro\flvfblhcubhcfzh ujr` idoWvdhb`vfdof, vodfolfd ios kfrhWh

ioShcubo Whsrubhcos kfi`yhdhcf Whsf^b`f, Whu^bhchbo fdkfdsfeu\rhcubo sfjr\xos Whigvhbo oy`s.:16

6.7 frf^oro\flo vfblhcubhcos mlfgvo\o~ judqgoffrf^oro\flo vfblhcubhcos kfdsxvfvhcubo sfxhf lfgvo\ovfblhcubhchco.:13 fSdoWdubos Whsfcfiosfl, xhbWherubhcosixfrhhco vfblhcubdo frofd, vfblhcubhco\sfifr\bhcrovour\ohr\`cf oikvfrfl wfrifr\`d, r`i fr lfuWvfd ih`rh ixfrosujbhcf\f \u odthrhshcos xhby`jf.

:1=CKA Xrthob v`i 66.=3.3==

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

147/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

67?

gfbehub Whi\xvhvfWo fSdoWdubo vfblhcubhcf kfi`oxfthcfxhbWhievrhbo ixfros nfdir\hb`cosf lf sfeu\rhcos lfgvos fd fiSorhcubhcf\f usfjr\x`hcos uzrudvhby`jos vfblhcubhcfWo.ifkfbo\fl, fsh\ vfblhcubhcfl kfdoxobhcf sfstuir`Woqurl`cosfkfd sfeu\rhcos lfgvos fd sfevhco\f \u sxvf kfrhi`hco\kfi`wvhubo nfdir\hb`cos lfzofdhcoskfd i`ixifrhcbos lfgvos

uzrudvhbsfy`jfl sf\fdfl` z`ihcos ioShcf.:17hs vfblhcubhcf sfqfr\vhb`s efd`dilhcb`cfWo frshco\fl

sse-os 76:-h iuxbos ih-3 dfwobolfd kfi`ilodfrh`cs. e`derhtubovfblhcubhcos Wodffrsosf lf xfsof\os kf\vfboswodhco\,vfblhcubhco\sfifr\bhcrovo ur\ohr\`cos i`dfwobhs heosrhcfmih`rh ixfros ujbhchcosf lf q`dhcosflio kfdsfeu\rhcubokubosxiohrhcos~ vfblhcubhcf.

mkubosxiohrhcos~ vfblhcubhcf, uporvhbhs y`vbosf, sxvfporos fcs`buturo ujbhchcosf lfgvfs hisfxurhcf.:1

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

148/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

6

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

149/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

6

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

150/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

6

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

151/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

6 hodh Wtuloh zur E`deurrhdzjrfkhv`r lhi Aodthrkrudl lhr odthrdfto`dfbhd Zhrhodahotbogaudk lhs Zhrtrfksrhgats, 3==6, W. 6?6,Whilk`io io\o\hchco\.

;==Whfl.Kd`s, Fdsprugase`deurrhdz od sgawhozhrosgahd ]r`luetafjtpjbogatsrhgat, 6??;, W.

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

152/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

6

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

153/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

6

hs Who^bhcf oy`s i`ixifrhchb\f ujbhchcos Whsfxhcefd`dolfd kfi`ilodfrh hr\-hr\o i`\x`vdos sfju^vhbo5

sse-os 6==?-h lf Whilk`io iuxbhco\ i`whsrokhcuboi`\x`vdos sfju^vhbo uxfrosx` pr`luqtos iwfri`hcbosioifr\5

lhboqtos z`kflo Whiflkhdb`cos ifrhkuborhchbo sse-os??3-h iuxbo5

;=;Whfl. [hchr,]r`luetafjtudk oi chbkosgahd Shgat, 6??1, W. 68:.;=1 Wgaiolt-Wfbzhr, Zhrcrfugahrsgautz, ]r`luetafjtudk, Xiwhbtafjtudk,Xdthrdhaihdsvhrfdtw`rtudk, DN[, 6??

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

154/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

6

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

155/220

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

156/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

6

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

157/220

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

158/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

68=

pfsuxosikhcb`cos kfi`rogxvf, \u sfxhzhf i`vfbos kfdzrfxo fduxhWo kfujr\xobhcb`cf.;61

ixfrh\f Wh\fdxihcf, sfxhbWherubhc` pfsuxosikhcb`coskfi`rogxvos Whsfxhc, Whsf^b`f e`debulhdturfl i`ogfvlhslhboqturo pfsuxosikhcb`cos kfi`rogxvfsfg.;6?sse-os ??3-h lf

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

159/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

686

pfsuxosikhcb`cos kfi`rogxvfs oi zofdosf\vos, r`ihbog, z`kflfl,lfgub soeh\hs,;3

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

160/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

683

crudvosf\vos idoWvdhb`vfd \voshcfs.;3?fifs\fd, \u frshc`cs sse-os

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

161/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

687

kfrlf fiosf, sse-os ih-6= iuxbos ih-7 dfwobos Whsfcfiosfl,mujbhcf\f c`r`tfl kfi`yhdhcosfkfd sxvf\f \fvosujbhcfs ogfvsefd`dos oiphrftoubo d`rihco.~ sw`rhl fi iozfds hisfxurhcfpfsuxosikhcb`cos kfi`rogxvos Whsfxhc Wh\fdxihcos porlfporofer^fbvf, r`ihbog i`ixifrhchb\f odthrhshcos lfgvos fdkfdsfeu\rhcubo lfgvos Sorso odthrhshcos uzrudvhbsfy`jfl oqdf

WhiuWfvhcubo.;77fSdoWdubo fer^fbvhcos kf\vfboswodhco\, ixfrh\f iohr

pfsuxosikhcb`cos kfi`rogxvf dfilvobof lf lfsfWvhco, \u osefd`do\ zustfl kfdsfzSvrub fer^fbvfs fr hwodffSilhkhcf. fsh\ofer^fbvf eo, r`k`rg whso, uefvWorlhcf i`vfbos iohr kfdzrfxoi`qihlhco\ vfblhcubhcos lfrSvhvfs.

Whsfcfiosfl, efd`dos i`\x`vdhcos sfwodffSilhk`l lflhcuboWh\fdxihcf zofdos fdfzSfurhcos vfblhcubhcos kfi`rogxvosf \uioso kfrevhubo jfrkbhco\ WhzSulvos Whsfxhc cf\obof fduWufb`l Whsfcfioso sphgofburo d`riolfd kfi`ilodfrh, fd, \uWhsfcfioso d`rif fr frshc`cs, sse-os 8

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

162/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

68 Ffbhd, 6?;7.

J`hrsth, Xbroga, Xdebfrahot oi edjtokhd Wgaublrhgat> Zhrnarudk v`d Efujidkhb-Fdsprgahd od zwho, lrho `lhr 7= Nfarhd0, ^S], 3==6, W. 7

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

209/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

3=6

Ahrzchrk, S`bj L., Erotoe lhr thbh`b`kosgahd Khshtzhsfusbhkudk, DN[, 6??=, 3838-387=

Ahss, [fbthr, Hodjfgah udl aahrh Frchot, Nhdf, 6?=8.

A`jjifdd, Dflnf, Loh E``rlodfto`d lhs Zhrtrfks- udl Lhboetsrhgats od Hur`pf,

\codkhd, 3==:.

Auchr, ]hthr, Orrtuisfdjhgatudk udl Wfgaidkhbafjtudk, hodh Wtuloh zurE`deurhdzjrfkh v`r lhi Aodthrkrudl lhr odthrdfto`dfbhd Zhrhodahotbogaudk lhsZhrtrfksrhgats, 3==6.

Aiihroga Ebfus/C`hgehd [odjrohl/Lwhbb Jrfdz N`shj, Fdwfbtse`iihdtfr,Frchotsrhgat, Cfdl 3, C`dd, 3==;.

Osfy, Ahrifdd, Loh Khsgafhjtsjuharudk dfga lhi Cuhrkhrbogahd Khshtzcugah juhr lfsLhutsgah Shoga, Nhdf, 6?==.

Nkko, ]hthr, ^ui Chkrojj lhr Zhrtrfkbogahd Wgaflhdshrsftzj`rlhrudk, Jhstkfch jr[obahbi Wgadhchrk, Jrhocurk, 6?:1, 616-6?;.

Nfar, Kdtahr, Fdsprugaskrudlbfkhde`deurrhdz udl Hrjbbudkse`ddhxott,Zhrjfarhdsrhgat fi Fuskfdk lhs 3=. Nfaraudlhrts, Jhstsgarojt jr Khrafrl Beh zui;=. Khcurtstfk, 6??;, W. 3?;-733, attp>//www.nurf.udo-sc.lh/pr`nheth/Cocbo`tahe/thxt.pap0ol9688 (6=.=:.3==?).

Nfuhrdok, @taifr/Chrkhr, Garostofd/Ifdshb, Ahodz-]hthr/Wtflbhr, Fstrol/Wtrdhr,S`bj/\hogaifdd, Frdlt, Crkhrbogahs Khshtzcuga, 67. Fujb., Idgahd, 3==?.

Nfhdsga, Iogafhb, Lhr Kbhogabfuj v`d Sgetrott udl Wgaflhdshrsftz, DN[, 3==7, W.7:67-7:68.

Nhbbodhe, Kh`rk, Hod Zhrjfssudkskhrogatsa`j jr sthrrhoga, [ohd, 6118.

Nahrodk, Sul`bj v`d, Wgahrz udl Hrdst od lhr Nurosprulhdz> Hodh [hoadfgatskfch jrlfs nurostosgah ]ucboeui v`d Sul`bj Nahrodk, Bhopzok, 611//www.e`hcbhrkhrafrl.lh/6J`dths/NahrodkLhrEfipjuisShgat.ati (68.=8.3==?).

Nahrodk, Sul`bj v`d, Loh Olhh lhr Khrhgatokehot, Shgat udl Wotth (Fuswfab), Cgahr lhrCobludk, Idgahd, kfi`ghios whbo fr fros io\o\hcubo.

http://www.jura.uni-sb.de/projekte/Bibliothek/text.php?id=155http://www.jura.uni-sb.de/projekte/Bibliothek/text.php?id=155http://beck-online.beck.de/?typ=reference&y=300&z=NJW&b=2003&s=3613http://beck-online.beck.de/?typ=reference&y=300&z=NJW&b=2003&s=3613http://www.jura.uni-sb.de/projekte/Bibliothek/text.php?id=155http://www.jura.uni-sb.de/projekte/Bibliothek/text.php?id=155

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

210/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

3=3

E`ssifdd, A`rst, Lhr Afdlhb oi Wysthi lhr ]r`luetafjtpjbogat, DN[, 6?1

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

211/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

3=7

Bfdkahodhehd, ]fub, Fdspruga udl Hodrhlh dfga lhi Lhutsgahd CrkhrbogahdKhshtzcuga, Bhopzok, 6?=7.

Bfrhdz, Efrb/[`bj, Ifdjrhl, Fbbkhihodhr \hob lhs Crkhrbogahd Shgats, ?. Fujb.,Idgahd, 3==

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

212/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

3= , , 61, 3==1.

, , :, 3==?.

, , ,

, , 3==3.

, . ., , .-,6?=?.

sfqfr\vhb`s sfsfifr\b`hcos kflfwyvhtobhchco>sfqfr\vhb`s sfe`dstotugo` sfsfifr\b`s 3==6 wbos ; ovdosos6/6/6=7.66;.67;.6

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

217/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

3=?

sfqfr\vhb`s uzhdfhso sfsfifr\b`s sfi`qfbfq`, sfihwfrih` lfkfe`trhcos sfqih\f pfbftos 3==7 wbos 76 `qt`icros #fs-38

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

218/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

36=

sfqfr\vhb`s uzhdfhso sfsfifr\b`s sfi`qfbfq`, sfihwfrih` lfkfe`trhcos sfqih\f pfbftos 3==; wbos 67 ifrtos #fs/;86/6661/=:kfdGodhcf.

qu\fosos sffphbfgo` sfsfifr\b`s sfi`qfbfq` sfqih\f pfbftos3==; wbos 37 `qt`icros kfdGodhcf.

uzhdfhso sfsfifr\b`s sfi`qfbfq`, sfihwfrih` lf kfe`trhcossfqih\f pfbftos 3==1 wbos 3 ifosos #fs-8

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

219/220

8/13/2019 Anspruchskonkurrenz - S.Chachava

220/220

s`jo` GfGfvf, i`\x`vdhcos lf i`\x`vdos sfju^vbhcos e`deurhdgof, 3=66

CKA Chsgabu v`i 6:.=3.6??7ZO ^S 383/?3 (@blhdcurk),DN[-SS, 6??7, W. 6667-666