Upload
angela-khermouch
View
233
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
A compilation of my work from the Spring 2012 architecture study abroad program in Paris and across Europe.
Citation preview
bande à partAngela Khermouch
bande à partAngela Khermouch
Introduction00
2 : I
ntro
duct
ion
Bande à PartArchitects are perpetually in-between. Professionally, the architect’s work begins once a client decides there’s a need, but also precedes the act of construction. Disciplinarily, an architect makes material sense of the immaterial, translating the hidden patterns of cultural logic (symbolic, political, pragmatic, economic) into a visible, tangible and operational construct. So, architects are a peculiar band of producers: shifting between observation and projection, between instrumental possibilities and operational realities, between the remote space of the atelier, where maps become plans and models are materials, and the immediate site, where the culmination of work will be evaluated physically and socially.
Students of architecture are also in-between; suspended: practicing to practice. They are expected to interpolate between distinct courses, each pulling in a divergent direction. Within this framework, they must also consider their own values, before entering a global landscape of opportunity.
The Paris Program offers capable students a discrete chance to develop a sense of larger implications, to try on existing approaches to contemporary questions, and to have a glimpse of what it could mean develop their own approach to practice, before returning to the final years of University.
FieldworkFieldwork is an integral part of the pedagogy. In the first, sense, it’s about in-situ activity. Students have the opportunity to experience important buildings and urban patterns in a dynamic physical and cultural continuum. Because students can reinforce theoretical positions with intuitive sensations, they develop a resilient memory and richer understanding. Students learn to recognize meaningful conditions, and record observations upon which other work will be based. Because the field is always in flux, it exposes students to unfamiliar patterns, tests the potency of their ideas, and challenges their ability to translate (into models) for the arena of work. We indulge like tourists, but operate like ethnographers. We immerse in the field as an aid to seeing, but also as a laboratory and instrument of production.
Fieldwork is also an exploration of the discipline. Physically and pedagogically, our atelier is a mixing chamber which encourages students to explore connections between complementary disciplines within the field of architecture: history, urbanism, technique, design. Students may write history to support studio speculation, or use models and drawings as tools of historical analysis. They may refine drawing or modeling techniques as tactics for understanding and speculation, researching the social, cultural or scientific history, or speculate on adapting a technique for a totally new purpose. Students understand and measure the city in various ways, but also use the city to measure the relevance of ideas. So, the design studio becomes a feedback mechanism: the testing ground for speculative activity which allows us to evaluate the viability of results againt contemporary questions.
003
: Int
rodu
ctio
n
BaM Building as Model
Building as Model examines the history of buildings and cities as the autonomous manifestations of ideas. Students are encouraged to explore the writing of history as a creative act, rather than abiding chronological statements of “progress.” Writing may be connected to drawing and modeling as analytic tools. Students compare shifting versions of history, explore the relation between drawing tactics and ideology, evaluate the propagation of ideas as collective rallying points, and examine the influence of parallel cultural movements on paradigm shifts in European architecture, urban design, and urban planning.
AA Architectural Atelier
The design atelier explores architecture within an urban design framework. Its the testing ground for speculative activity, as students appropriate experiences and techniques from other classes applying them to a specific semester-long project.
As a studio platform, students are asked to understand form, rather than speculate on novel shapes, ex nihilo. Because of our unique situation with Europe, we use the rich field of operation as a basis for investigation. We often focus on types: institutional, infrastructural, intermodal, etc. We sepculate on altering a type, or systematically adjusting its components, to profoundly reorganize its significance. We try to identiy ways that architecture operates as a form of media which has the capacity to extend human capability, influence behavior, and transmit economic or political power.
“Bande à Part”
This year projects addressed the Petite Ceinture (PC), a peripheral railway which stitched together independently owned lines, each entering Paris from a different direction. Now mostly abandoned, a 23.5 kilometer band of disengaged territory cuts through the city. A no-man’s land within Paris’ density, and proximate to the Periphérique (a manifest limit) it provokes many contemporary questions, across many scales.
For the first 6 weeks of the semester, the students developed urban design proposals. Then they zoomed-in to examine specific sites, exploring the relation between large scale planning principles and its consequence for a localized architectural proposal.
Students were asked to develop architectural projects according to the terms of their urban design , but model programs on real precedents. This encouraged students make connections in Europe, and several students engaged institutions, interviewing them as though they were real clients.
004
: Int
rodu
ctio
n
UEx Urban Exploration
Urban Exploration exploits the living city as a laboratory, and feedback loop, where reflections on studio work meet the city itself, in a space of free association. Each class begins with an itinerary that introduces the student to distinct territories within Paris, but also harnesses physical immersion as a generator of ideas. The physical nature of the class, and its perpetual state of motion, alters and provokes relationships between conception (or preconceptions) and perception (experience). The class mixes sharp concentration with daydreaming, expectation with surprise, and generates divergent thoughts and possibilities as a complement to studio.
DeS Developed Surface
Developed Surface investigates the significance of techinque. Architectural discourse sometimes struggles to reconcile socio-political agendas with material ones. Whether a result of practice or ideology, focus on one realm often involves suppressing the other. And yet, a constructed building is accountable for both. This course looks at models (2 and 3 dimensional) as operational and instrumental tools which assist an architect to control material and the meaningful. Acting as an advanced seminar and workshop, course sessions juxtapose speculative model making with seminar discussion. Each week, student work is reviewed in direct relation to readings, and short lectures on historical and theoretical precedents in art, architecture, and urban design. Special attention will be paid to intermediate frameworks that architects develop to connect technique to ideology. (Le Modulor, for example).
In mathematics, the word “development” refers to the process of rolling one surface over another. In architecture, this technique is often deployed to model three-dimensional space on paper – to speculate, regulate, and communicate the ordering of material, construction assemblies, and form. So, “surface” is a convenient subject that connects thinking, drawing and construction. It allows the class to examine activity across many scales (urban patterns, building envelopes, programmatic interior).
005
: Int
rodu
ctio
n
27 Jan - Rome / Two “Giants”
Baths of DiocletianTrajan MarketPiazza CampidoglioMusei Capitolini, Piazza CampidoglioRoman ForumColloseoBorromini, San Giovanni in LaeteranoThermae Caracalla
EUR DistrictGiovani Guerini, Pallazo della Civilita
Italiano, (“Colosseo Quadrato”)Museo della Civilita Romano, Palazzo dei Ricevimenti e Congressi
28 Jan - Rome / Baroque Surface
Spanish StepsBorromini, Collegio de Propoganda
FideBorromini, Sant Andrea delle Fratte
(apse)Borromini, Palazzo Barberini
(heliocoidal stair) Galleria Barberini Bernini, Santa Carina della Vittoria (St.
Theresa in Ecstasy)Borromini, San Carlo alle Quattro
Fontane (ceiling)Pantheon Su 9:00-18:00 / M-Sa
8:30-19:30Bernini, Sant’Ivo alla Sapienza
(corkscrew dome)Borromini, Piazza NavonaBorromini, Sant’Agnese in AgoneBorromini, Palazzo Spada (forced
persp. corridor) Galleria Spada Michelangelo, Palazzo FarneseBorromini, Oratorio dei Fillipini,Giorgetti, San Girolamo della Caritá
(Borromini’s pupil)Borromini, Palazzo FalconieriBorromini, Oratorio dei FilippiniBorromini and Ferri, San Giovanni dei
FiorentiniBernini, Piazza Pietro (Vatican)
29 Jan - Rome / New Institutions
Galleria BorgheseViale delle Belle ArtePiano, Auditorio Parco della MusicaNervi, Pallazeto della SportHadid, MAXXI Museum of Art
31 Jan - Venice
Murano IslandTour Vanini Glass FactorySan Michelle Island Cemetery Rialto BridgeCampo Santa Margherita
01 Feb - Venice
Piazza San MarcoPalazzo DucaleCarlo Scarpa, Olivetti ShowroomMarciana LibraryCarlo Scarpa, Querini StampallaScuola Grande di San RoccoIUAV ToletnitiCarlo Scarpa, IAUV Gate / GardenGallerie dell’AccademiaSanta MAria della SaluteCampo San Giacomo
02 Feb - Venice
Giudecca IslandPalladio, Redentore ChurchSan Giorgio Maggiore IslandPeggy Guggenheim CollectionCa’Pesaro Museum of Modern ArtCampo San Polo (ice skating0
RESEARCH: ITALY00
6 : I
ntro
duct
ion
16 Mar - Copenhague
Hasløw & Kjærsgaard, Amager Strandpark
PLOT (BIG+JDS), Maritim Jugend Center
Dorthe Mandrup + B&K, Prism Sports + Kultur Center
Dorthe Mandrup, Holmbladsgade Nachbar Kulturhaus
Lundgaard & Tranberg, Royal Theater Lundgaard & Tranberg, Tietgen
HousingPLOT (JDS+BIG), VM HousesPLOT (JDS+BIG), VM Mountain
HousesØrestad Masterplan Model
17 Mar - Copenhagen
Gruntvig’s ChurchBispegjerg CemeteryActivity CentersBIG, Linear Park
18 Mar - Sweden
Sigurd Lewerent, Sant Petri (Klippan)Tham Videgard Arkitekten, Museum
of Modern Art ( Malmo)
RESEARCH: DENMARK NETHERLANDS SWEDEN
19 Mar - Amsterdam
20 Mar - Day Trip to Rotterdam
Wine or Water RestaurantJL Brinkman, Van Nelle FactoryJo Coenen, NAI (Model Storage)Neutlings Reidijk, SheepvartCafé D’Unie ReconstructionPiet Blom, Kubuswonig (Tree Houses)UN Studio, Erasmus BridgeBolles + Wilson, Erasmus Bridge
HouseOMA, KunsthallJo Coenen, NL Architecture Institute
21 Mar - Day Trip to Utrecht / Hilversum / Almere
Gerrit Rietveld, Schroderhuis and Apartment Block
MVRDV, Villa KBBW (Double House)OMA, EducatoriumUN Studio, ErasmussiumMVRDV, BasketbarWiel AretsSANAA, Kunstlinie (Almere)
007
: Int
rodu
ctio
n
AAu
Tina Bizaca, Angela Khermouch
DormAnT PArisiAnismsReviving the Flâneur within the Petite Ceinture
010
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
In this project, La Petite Ceinture is seen as an opportunity to revive the Flaneur in the Parisian daily routine. By diverting the public’s movement towards the center of the city by taking existing elements of the surrounding arrondissements and amplifying, resituating, or distorting them in some way, creating unexpected experiences within La Petite Ceinture.
La Petite Ceinture is therefore broken up into distinct zones depending on the activity taking place within it, providing a unique atmosphere for each area based on programs that already surround it.
011
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
012
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
013
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
014
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
015
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
016
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
017
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
018
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
019
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
020
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
021
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
022
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
023
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
024
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
025
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
026
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
027
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
028
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
029
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
030
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
031
: AA
u T
ina
Biza
ca, A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
AAa
Angela Khermouch
Le theAtre des excentriquesResituating puppet theater within an abandoned train line to create new excentric performances
034
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
In this project, La Theatre de la Marionnette a Paris, an existing group that promotes pup-petry within Paris is provided with a space from which to broadcast Paris’s strong puppetry culture. Combining with the existing Monfort Theatre, whose spectacles include every-thing from optical theater to interpretive dance, this collaboration creates Le Theatre des Excentriques.
Situated in the programmatically varied Georges Brassens park located in the 15th ar-rondissement, along the abandoned Petite Ceinture train line, this location allows an al-ready excentric program to be heightened by its surroundings.
The organization of the building on the site is such that it allows for moments of unex-pected performance, while the integration of learning, production and entertainment in the building’s program allows for unique relationships to develop across programatic elements.
035
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Proc
ess
Diag
ram
s03
6 : A
Aa
Ang
ela
Kher
mou
ch
Proc
ess
Diag
ram
s03
7 : A
Aa
Ang
ela
Kher
mou
ch
Proc
ess
Mod
els
038
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Proc
ess
Mod
els
039
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Proc
ess
Mod
els
040
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Proc
ess
Mod
els
041
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Conc
ept M
odel
042
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Thea
tre
Des
Exc
entr
ique
sM
ain
Audi
toriu
m (3
00 s
eats
)
700
m2
2 Sm
all T
heat
ers
(240
sea
ts)
2
x 1
70 m
2W
orks
hops
/Tea
chin
g Sp
aces
(4)
4 x
100
m2
Dre
ssin
g Ro
oms
10
0 m
2M
edia
Lib
rary
100
m2
Resi
denc
y fo
r Tra
velin
g A
rtis
ts
20
0 m
2Re
tail
Are
a
35
m2
O
�ce
s/M
eetin
g Sp
ace
100
m2
Cafe
100
m2
Net
SF
2
075
m2
Mec
h sp
ace
210
m2
Oth
er re
quire
men
ts
42
0 m
2
Gro
ss S
F
2
705
m2
Thea
tre
Des
Exc
entr
ique
sM
ain
Audi
toriu
m (3
00 s
eats
)
700
m2
2 Sm
all T
heat
ers
(240
sea
ts)
2
x 1
70 m
2W
orks
hops
/Tea
chin
g Sp
aces
(4)
4 x
100
m2
Dre
ssin
g Ro
oms
10
0 m
2M
edia
Lib
rary
100
m2
Resi
denc
y fo
r Tra
velin
g A
rtis
ts
20
0 m
2Re
tail
Are
a
35
m2
O
�ce
s/M
eetin
g Sp
ace
100
m2
Cafe
100
m2
Net
SF
2
075
m2
Mec
h sp
ace
210
m2
Oth
er re
quire
men
ts
42
0 m
2
Gro
ss S
F
2
705
m2
Prog
ram
Out
line
043
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Site
Mod
el04
4 : A
Aa
Ang
ela
Kher
mou
ch
Site
Mod
el04
5 : A
Aa
Ang
ela
Kher
mou
ch
La Petite Ceinture Puppet Theater Locations George Brassens Park
Puppet TheaterPark
Vineyards
La Petite Ceinture
Playground
SwingsScent Garden
Day Care
Theatre de Polichinelle
Monfort Theatre Ping-pong
Area
Antique Book Fair
Pony Rides
NGeorges Brassens Park Excentriques
AdultsKids
Both
Theatre Des ExcentriquesProgram Provider: Theatre de la Marionnette a ParisOne of the biggest organizers and promoters for the puppet art form in Paris, the Theatre de la Marionnette a Paris, formed in 1992, orga-nizes events dedicated to the art of puppetry, however they lack their own space.
Space Provider: Monfort TheatreSituated within the Georges Brassens park, the Theatre Monfort hosts atypical spectacles including everything from interpretive dance to “theatre optique,” a similar surreal experience to that of puppetry entertainment. Their space is currently underused during the year.
Theatre de la Marionnette
Monfort Theatre Monfort Theatre Usage Theatre Des Excentriques
046
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
La Petite Ceinture Puppet Theater Locations George Brassens Park
Puppet TheaterPark
Vineyards
La Petite Ceinture
Playground
SwingsScent Garden
Day Care
Theatre de Polichinelle
Monfort Theatre Ping-pong
Area
Antique Book Fair
Pony Rides
NGeorges Brassens Park Excentriques
AdultsKids
Both
Theatre Des ExcentriquesProgram Provider: Theatre de la Marionnette a ParisOne of the biggest organizers and promoters for the puppet art form in Paris, the Theatre de la Marionnette a Paris, formed in 1992, orga-nizes events dedicated to the art of puppetry, however they lack their own space.
Space Provider: Monfort TheatreSituated within the Georges Brassens park, the Theatre Monfort hosts atypical spectacles including everything from interpretive dance to “theatre optique,” a similar surreal experience to that of puppetry entertainment. Their space is currently underused during the year.
Theatre de la Marionnette
Monfort Theatre Monfort Theatre Usage Theatre Des Excentriques
Clie
nts
and
Site
047
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
EXPRESSION of puppetry construc-tion in building systems
RESITUATING perfor-mances to create new excentrics
In Theaters:
In Plan:
In Theaters:
In Plan:
DIRECT VIEWS
OBLIQUE VIEWS
Addition of Oblique Views
PerformanceAudience
OVERLAPPING of many artistic disci-plines
Performing
Production
Learning
SupportPetite Ceinture
Theatre de Polichinelle
Monfort Theatre
Puppetry Precedence
Extracted Elements
Architecture Application
048
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
EXPRESSION of puppetry construc-tion in building systems
RESITUATING perfor-mances to create new excentrics
In Theaters:
In Plan:
In Theaters:
In Plan:
DIRECT VIEWS
OBLIQUE VIEWS
Addition of Oblique Views
PerformanceAudience
OVERLAPPING of many artistic disci-plines
Performing
Production
Learning
SupportPetite Ceinture
Theatre de Polichinelle
Monfort Theatre
Puppetry Precedence
Extracted Elements
Architecture ApplicationAp
proa
ch D
iagr
ams
049
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
AA
BB
N
Exis
itng
Site
Pla
n
Site
Pla
n05
0 : A
Aa
Ang
ela
Kher
mou
ch
Sect
ion
A-A
Sect
ion
B-B
Site
Sec
tions
051
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
N
Floo
r 2 P
lan
052
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
NN
Floo
r 1 P
lan
053
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
N
A
A B C D
B C D
Floo
r 0 P
lan
054
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
N
A
A B C D
B C D
Sect
ion
A-A
055
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Sect
ion
B-B
056
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Sect
ion
C-C
057
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Sect
ion
D-D
058
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
1:20
0 M
odel
059
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
1:20
0 M
odel
060
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
1:20
0 M
odel
061
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
1:20
0 M
odel
062
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Sect
ion
Mod
el06
3 : A
Aa
Ang
ela
Kher
mou
ch
Sect
ion
Mod
elSe
ctio
n M
odel
064
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Sect
ion
Mod
elSe
ctio
n M
odel
065
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Sect
ion
Mod
elSe
ctio
n M
odel
066
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Sect
ion
Mod
elSe
ctio
n M
odel
067
: AA
a A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Sect
ion
Mod
el06
8 : A
Aa
Ang
ela
Kher
mou
ch
Sect
ion
Mod
el06
9 : A
Aa
Ang
ela
Kher
mou
ch
Sect
ion
Mod
el07
0 : A
Aa
Ang
ela
Kher
mou
ch
Sect
ion
Mod
el07
1 : A
Aa
Ang
ela
Kher
mou
ch
BaM
Angela Khermouch
Le CorbusierCity grid as density problem
Ville RadieuseRemoval of density from grid, relocationto specific points
American Grid SystemMilitary OriginsAgencies with other objectives
New York CityA system before existing density
Grand Urban RulesBlock Width limited by streets, public spaces, parks, etc. (p. 35)
Squaring of CirclevilleChanging society calls for new system (Grand Urban Rules)
ChicagoEndless growth
opportunities
Burnham PlanUsed to sell an idea
ZoningAs a way to regulate density
Rem KoolhausDelirious New York,
exceptions within the city
SuperblockCity block system within a system
Jane JacobsThe Death and Life of Great American Cities
DecentristsThin out and disperse density
Live-Work movementPeople should live close to work
Public policy should not, “...freeze conditions and uses as they stand. That would be death.”
Robert MosesLarge city projectsHighway infrastructure
Urban RenewalLeveling urban blight for new construction
Setback RegulationsTo aid street lighting
l’Eixample Plan BarcelonaCentral courtyards for light, density relief
Orientation of blockTo maximize sunlight to courtyard
Organic layout of early civilizationsMesopotamia, Egyptian civilizations
Military Layout of CitiesCity layout based on protection
CentralizationRecognization of military, communal, or spiritual power
Breaking The Wall: City Block Planning Before and After Medieval Limits
Preliminary paper topic diagram 074
: BaM
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
While humans have been organizing them-selves into cities as a way of exchanging goods, services, ideas, and generally ad-vancing civilization for many years, urban planning as an organizing system for cities was not present medieval and pre-medi-eval cities, whose urban plans were dic-tated primarily by the location’s geography and a need to defend its citizens from out-side attacks. Paris in particular was a prime example of this medieval city layout, how-ever, as health conditions worsened due to this seemingly haphazard layout, a more organized approach to city planning was called for. In Paris this manifested with the plan laid out by Baron Haussmann, in which the wide boulevards cutting through the existing fabric of the city were particularly straightforward in their intent as well as powerful in creating a new image for Paris which frightened the Parisians even when elements of the new boulevards spoke to elements of city planning that existed be-fore. The boulevardizing of Paris also cre-ated a new image for the Baron himself, rising questions as to how far a human in power can go to change the environment of so many without seeming ruthless and very much inhuman in doing so.
In early medieval cities, urban planning as we think of it now was not present as a discipline. In medieval times, the extent of urban planning involved protecting the people within a town from outside attack. For this reason, cities were often central-ized around an institution such as a church and surrounded by an outer wall from which the city could be defended. In Paris, this existed in the centralized location of Notre Dame, where the city’s coordinate origin lies, and a series of fortifications cen-tered on this point, the earliest of which were built in the 10th and 11th centuries to protect the city of Paris.
Between this centralized space and outer wall, however, cities grew much more hap-hazardly, in many cases as another line of
BOULEVARDS AND POWERBaron Haussmann’s Boulevardizing of Paris
075
: BaM
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
defense so that enemies could not easily navigate the city or know its layout before-hand, as can be seen in Paris’s thick tan-gle of streets enmeshed in what is known as ‘Old Paris.’ However, as Paris became denser, problems regarding hygiene and traffic emerged that were related back to the way the city was laid out. A preoccupa-tion with poverty and cramped living con-ditions caused a call for healthy air, running water, social housing and kitchen gardens to evolve. At the same time, technological advancements in communication from the industrial revolution caused a reaction to manage movement systems within towns and cities. As described in Du Camp’s Paris:
Paris, as we find it in the period fol-lowing the Revolution of 1848, was about to become uninhabitable. Its population had been greatly enlarged and unsettled by the incessant activity of the railroad, and now this population was suf-focating in the narrow, tangled, putrid alleyways in which it was forcibly confined.
As a result, Paris, like many medieval cities, looked to much more regular and spacious layouts giving the chance for “air and men to circulate.”
In Paris, this emerged with the election in 1870 of Napoleon III as president for the Republic of France, who decided to mod-ernize Paris after seeing post-industrial rev-olution London. To head up this new vision of Paris, Napoleon III hired Baron Georges-Eugene Haussmann and together they laid out their plan d’ensemble in which the city was planned as if it was an entire entity, a new approach to city planning that had not been implemented before at this large of a scale. However, this was not a sort of urban planning that had been seen before. What these men intended to do was create a new city from one that already existed, that was well established, and most importantly, had a thoroughly developed fabric that its citizens cherished.
In Haussmann’s transformation of the city layout, the most striking feature was a se-
ries of large boulevards that cut straight through this very developed fabric that the people so cherished, or what was known as ‘Old Paris.’ As opined by Haussmann who was also known as the ‘demolition artist’, it was, ‘easier to cut through a pie’s inside than to break into the crust.’ Programmati-cally, these wide boulevards prioritized cir-culation, the harmonization between mon-uments, as well as providing more light and air to the streets. This image of long perspectives down long, straight boule-vards ending in city monuments was also seen as ideal to Haussmann, a product of the tendency in the 19th century to elevate technological necessities through artistic ends. Economically, these boulevards also provided certain areas a chance to rejuve-nate themselves by replacing unsanitary old buildings with new properties contain-ing much more rent-able space.
A primary purpose behind these large bou-levards was also one that the medieval city was very familiar with: to protect from at-tack, only this time, from within. In order to minimize the threat of civil war within Paris, these wide boulevards were created as a way to inhibit the erecting of barricades across the city. These streets also acted as a quick connector between the barracks and the worker’s districts, where the po-tential uprising would occur. Referred to as “strategic embellishments” by some, these wide, straight boulevards with uniform fa-cades marching down either side came to symbolize an expression of power by the self-proclaimed emperor of the time over the city of Paris and a way of restoring quick order to a city that was known for its capacity to rebel.
However, despite all these benefits to the city on levels ranging from health to state, Haussmann’s ‘boulevardizing’ of Paris did not escape verbal attack. While most crit-ics just clung to the remnants of city fabric bulldozed by Haussmann’s implementation of the boulevards, others saw the construc-tion of the boulevards as an immense ex-pression of power, one not to be expressed by one man. In this immense expression of power, the public saw not a man but a pow-er-hungry god, daring to squash the hap-hazard natural growth of a healthy city with his regular, controlled and picture-perfect sets that he had designed and constructed
Benjamin, Walter. The Arcades Project. London: Belknap Press, 1999. 123-125. Print.
Jones, Colin. Paris: Biography of a City. New York: Viking, 2005. 305. Print.076
: BaM
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
for the city. This can be seen in the assess-ment made by one critic of the changes made by Haussmann: “Haussmann’s urban works are a wholly appropriate representa-tion of the absolute governing principles of the Empire; repression of every individual formation, every organic self-development, fundamental hatred of all individuality.”
Among Haussmann’s biggest critics was Le Corbusier who said, “The avenues [Hauss-mann] cut were entirely arbitrary: they were not based on strict deductions of the sci-ence of town planning. The measures he took were were of a financial and military character.” Le Corbusier’s critique of Hauss-mann’s boulevards were more an expres-sion of disbelief for their ability to provide what Haussmann promised. He too could only see the overpowering, godly manner in which Haussmann sliced through the city.
Still others critiqued the large boulevards aesthetically, particularly several groups in the 1880’s that grew out of the conserva-tionist movement that began to emerge
in Paris. These conservationist groups at-tacked, ‘these new boulevards without turning, without perspectival adventure, implacably straight-lined…which recall some future American Babylon.’ Based in a love for Paris’s older city fabric in which streets constantly turn and change, these conservationists saw only the desire of one man to make his mark on an already thriv-ing city in the long boulevards implement-ed by Haussmann.
Yet, among all this dissent, there were a few Parisians that saw some good in the new Haussmannian Paris. One writer, Jules Simon wrote in Le Galois, “He [Haussmann] demolished some quartiers - some might say entire towns. There were cries that he would bring on the plague; he tolerated such outcries and gave us instead - through his well-considered architectural break-throughs - air, health, and life.” In this pas-sage, Simon acknowledges the destruction of the old for the improvement of quality of life, something few of Haussmann’s crit-ics at the time were able to accept. How-
Benjamin, Walter. The Arcades Project. London: Belknap Press, 1999. 130. Print.
Jones, Colin. Paris: Biography of a City. New York: Viking, 2005. 360. Print.
During and after the construction of Haussmann’s Boulevards
077
: BaM
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
ever, Haussmann himself recognizes this in the civilians of his city as can be seen in a later conversation between Napolean III and himself. Haussmann says, “I myself am charged with the double offense of having unduly disturbed the Population of Paris by bouleversant, by ‘boulevardizing,’ almost all the quartiers of the city, and of having allowed it to keep the same profile in the same setting for too long.” Haussmann sees the extensive distress he has caused to the Paris population, however he sees the act of boulevardizing Paris as one the city has been needing for some time and its monumentality as an expression of Par-is’s need for a new image as a city and as the people who inhabit it. He was simply a means of providing Paris with this new im-age.
It is easier to see now, removed from the initial shock that these large boulevards caused, how they were, and still are, a suc-cess in a number of ways. As methods of navigation, the wide boulevards connect-ing monuments within the city are useful tools for pedestrians and cars alike trying to
orient themselves, especially after emerg-ing from the dense tangle of streets that often flank either side of the boulevard. While the boulevards were unsuccess-ful in improving road mobility due to the fact that these straight boulevards gener-ally delivered speedy traffic into crossroads where they then became enmeshed in traf-fic jams, as direct routes across the city of Paris, these boulevards cut down travel time in their directness. Logistically, these boulevards did indeed provide the renewal on a health, infrastructure and economic level that the city of Paris so desperately needed.
Most importantly though, these boule-vards did a lot to encourage and allow for an image that Paris was already very familiar with: one related to a lively active street life. Many Parisian terms such as the flâneur, the dérive and détournement all relate back to the way a walker expe-riences the city-strolling through streets, observing the action teeming around him and generally letting the thriving city con-trol his motions and attentions. As a part
Benjamin, Walter. The Arcades Project. London: Belknap Press, 1999. 132. Print.
Gustave Caillebotte’s painting of the flâneur on a Haussmannian boulevard
078
: BaM
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
of life, an active street life has always been strongly valued by the Parisian people and despite tearing through existing dense and thriving neighborhoods, Haussmann’s boulevards did nothing to destroy the ac-tive street life that existed, instead it made it stronger. One obvious reason for this is that the dense, thriving neighborhoods the boulevards cut through still existed on ei-ther side of them, feeding into the broad streets a constant stream of pedestrians. Another benefit to the Parisian boulevard’s pedestrian life is the ground floor lining of small shops, cafes, and restaurants that draw people to the street for various needs and desires and provides interest to the passer-by. Lastly, these wide boulevards did not simply provide more room for fast-circulating traffic but for the pedestrians as well. Wide sidewalks line either side of the Haussmannian boulevards, allowing each pedestrian more space as well as space for restaurants, bars and cafes to install outdoor seating year round, or for stores to advertise merchandise that encourage pedestrians to stop, browse or mingle on the already active street.
Despite the strong outcry from Parisians against the Haussmannian boulevards for their expression of power by the men who designed them, these boulevards ended up creating for Paris a stronger picture of it-self. While the approach to urban planning was new and the improvements the bou-levards made on a practical scale, in terms of health, economics and infrastructure worked to renew the city, the new image of Paris that Haussmann envisioned was per-haps not so new at all. At street level, these wide boulevards in fact create the perfect playground for the pedestrian, building off the already thriving existing city fabric and ensuring the people of Paris that the flâ-neur was once again alive and well.
Works Cited
Benjamin, Walter. The Arcades Project. London: Belknap Press, 1999. Print.
Chan Chieng, Diana, ed. Projets Urbains En France = French Urban Strategies. Paris: Le Moniteur, 2002. Print.
Jones, Colin. Paris: Biography of a City. New York: Viking, 2005. Print.
Lehnerer, Alex. Grand Urban Rules. Rotter-dam: Lecturis, 2009. Print.
“The L’Enfant and McMillian Plans.” Wash-
079
: BaM
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
DeS
Angela Khermouch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
Field Conditions: An attempt to exhaust spaces in Paris à la Georges Perec082
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
083
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
084
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
085
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
086
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
087
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
088
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
089
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
090
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
091
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
092
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
093
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
094
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
095
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
096
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
097
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
098
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
099
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
100
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons:
An A
ttem
pt A
t Exh
aust
ing
A Sp
ace
101
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons,
Typo
logi
es
An attempt to exhaust street fur-niture in Paris à la Georges Perec
102
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons,
Typo
logi
es10
3 : D
eS
Ange
la K
herm
ouch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons,
Typo
logi
es10
4 : D
eS
Ange
la K
herm
ouch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons,
Typo
logi
es10
5 : D
eS
Ange
la K
herm
ouch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons,
Typo
logi
es10
6 : D
eS
Ange
la K
herm
ouch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons,
Typo
logi
es10
7 : D
eS
Ange
la K
herm
ouch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons,
Typo
logi
es10
8 : D
eS
Ange
la K
herm
ouch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons,
Typo
logi
es10
9 : D
eS
Ange
la K
herm
ouch
A map displaying Paris in a uniform triangulated street system overlayed by various rhythms of transportation.110
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons,
Map
111
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons,
Map
A three dimensional abstraction of a portion of a two dimensional map (at right) using differ-ent materials of the same palate to create a city of shadow.112
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fiel
d Co
nditi
ons,
Map
113
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
A measured drawing of the Palais Royal surface unfolded.
114
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Unfo
lded
Sur
face
of t
he P
alai
s Ro
yal
A measured drawing of the Palais Royal surface unfolded.
115
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
The folded Palais Royale surface.
Fold
ed S
urfa
ce o
f the
Pal
ais
Roya
l11
6 : D
eS
Ange
la K
herm
ouch
Fold
ed S
urfa
ce o
f the
Pal
ais
Roya
lFo
lded
Sur
face
of t
he P
alai
s Ro
yal
117
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Unfo
lded
Sur
face
of 4
3 Ru
e N
otre
Dam
e de
Naz
aret
h
A measured drawing of our appartment’s interior space unfolded.118
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
Fold
ed S
urfa
ce o
f 43
Rue
Not
re D
ame
de N
azar
eth
119
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
24 H
our C
arto
on, R
ome
120
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
24 H
our C
arto
on, R
ome
121
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
24 H
our C
arto
on, R
ome
122
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
24 H
our C
arto
on, N
ethe
rland
s: SA
NN
A’s
Kuns
tlini
e12
3 : D
eS
Ange
la K
herm
ouch
24 H
our C
arto
on, N
ethe
rland
s: SA
NN
A’s
Kuns
tlini
e12
4 : D
eS
Ange
la K
herm
ouch
24 H
our C
arto
on, N
ethe
rland
s: Co
penh
agen
Roy
al P
layh
ouse
125
: DeS
An
gela
Khe
rmou
ch
24 H
our C
arto
on, N
ethe
rland
s: Ro
tterd
am C
ubic
Hous
es12
6 : D
eS
Ange
la K
herm
ouch
Pers
onal
Pro
ject
: Sec
tiona
l Mod
el12
7 : D
eS
Ange
la K
herm
ouch
8 walks and 2 lectures
1 - Les Passages / Arcades
A link between the past and the present city, and between the previous flâneurs and our-selves. Literally, a journey through the core of the city, like a drilled corridor. References: Charles Baudelaire, Walter Benjamin, Dada-ists and Surrealists. Bourse - Bibliothèque Nationale (Labrouste reading room) - Palais Royal - Les Halles - Grands boulevards -
2 - A string of Pearls
A walk along the great axis about layers of urbanism and power, about maps and propa-ganda. An opportunity to observe the succes-sive kings’ and presidents’ desire to “mark” space. A concentration of grand urban spaces (jewels) cut into the dense fabric of Paris. Place des Vosges - Hotel de Sully - Philippe Auguste Wall - Beaubourg - les Halles - Place des Vic-toires - Marché St Honoré - Place Vendôme - Jardin des Tuileries - Place de la Concorde (view along the “grand axe”) -
3 - ZigZag, rive gauche / rive droite
Weaving between monuments and neighbor-hoods along the river axis, and observing its essential connection with the city, since the beginning. Checking that Paris belongs to us, outside and inside (school, park, museum, courthall, church...). Pont d’Austerlitz - Jardin des Plantes - Université Jussieu - Institut du Monde Arabe - Pont Sully - Ile St Louis - Ile de la Cité: Mémorial de la déportation - Notre Dame - Palais de justice - Place Dauphine - Pont Neuf - Cour Carrée - Pont des Arts - Ecole des Beaux Arts - St Germain des Prés - Place St Sulpice: Café de la Mairie (G.Perec) -
4 - Belleville
Visit of a Parisian neighborhood with a strong identity, not touristic and particularly dense, complex and mixed - in its population (Asian, Arabic, Jewish, African, French, etc.), as well as in its architecture : juxtaposition of old and new parts, individual houses and public hous-ing, secret inner courtyards, street market, park, etc.
5 - Canal de l’Ourcq, a cruise to elsewhere Seascapes and Utopias (self-guided walk)
An itinerary along and around the canal, from Ledoux’s rotunda at the bassin de la Villette to (almost) the “périphérique” and the exit
out of Paris. A catalogue of ideas on buildings and cities, and the opportunity to make links between real places encountered on the walk and visionary and utopist projects. Ledoux’s Rotunda - Ourcq canal - Ave de Flandre - Jar-dins d’Eole - 104 - Renzo Piano’s housing - St Serge Orthodox Church - Parc de la Villette -
6 - Borders: the 18th
An itinerary about territories, borders and thresholds. Also about tourism, clichés and immigration. Montmartre/Montmartreland/Pigalle/Chateau Rouge/la Goutte d’Or: navi-gating through these territories with strong identities, and observing precisely where the borderlines pass, more or less visible. Maison Tzara (Loos) - métro Abbesses (Guimard) - St Jean de Montmartre - Shoe store (former the-ater) - African market -
7 - Collage city: the 13th
A contrasted itinerary through the 13th arrdt., offering a panorama of buildings and urban-ism from the 60s until the current transfor-mations. On our way: a few Parisian towers, Chinatown, social housing from different time periods and the new Paris Rive Gauche neigh-borhood. Orientation maps and loss of orien-tation. Manufacture des Gobelins - “ghost” river Bièvre - Mobilier National (Perret) - first Parisian skyscraper (Albert) - les Olympiades - underground street - Salvation Army build-ing (Le Corbusier) - Paris Rive Gauche neig-borhood - Bibliothèque Nationale (Perrault) - Seine river - floating swimming pool - pe-destrian bridge -
8 - Student designed walk
Students (by teams) are designing a walk - and its corresponding map - and taking the group on a tour. It should be centered around some-thing they would like to investigate: a neigh-borhood, a physical component of the city, a theme, a fiction story, a sensation, emotion, etc….The walks should be seen as narratives.The students will then assemble the various walks together - in a specific and appropriate order - to compose a bigger itinerary made of several sequences.
- Lectures: Urban Wanderers
1-Getting lost
2-Discovering new territories
Personal mapping project
Throughout the semester, students are creating and developping a personal mapping project, on which they are working independently. It is about exploring a place or an idea, experimenting and creating a personal graphic language, and about learning to play and combine in the best possible way form and content, simplicity and complexity. Inventing one’s own method of working is part of the process and as important as the final result.
Angela Khermouch
UEx13 memory maps
After each walk/lecture, a memory map - highly subjective and selective (with holes, distortions, additions, thoughts, feelings, etc) - is produced by each student and handed in the following week. Postcards are sent from other cities, as travel memory maps.
- Map 0 : preconceived map of Paris
- 8 memory maps from walks
- 2 memory maps from lectures
- 2 postcards from field trips (Italy, Denmark/Netherlands)
Wal
k 00
: Pre
conc
ieve
d N
otio
ns.
130
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Wal
k 00
: Titl
e.W
alk
01: T
he P
assa
ge13
1 :
Ang
ela
Kher
mou
ch
Wal
k 02
: A S
tring
of P
earls
, The
Mar
ais
132
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Wal
k 00
: Titl
e.W
alk
02: A
Stri
ng o
f Pea
rls, T
he M
arai
s13
3 :
Ang
ela
Kher
mou
ch
Wal
k 03
: Stit
chin
g th
e Se
ine
134
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Wal
k 00
: Titl
e.W
alk
04: B
elle
ville
135
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Wal
k 00
: Titl
e.W
alk
05: M
ontm
artre
136
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Wal
k 00
: Titl
e.W
alk
05: M
ontm
artre
137
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Wal
k 06
: Can
al S
t. M
artin
138
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Wal
k 00
: Titl
e.W
alk
07: 1
3th
Arro
ndiss
emen
t13
9 :
Ang
ela
Kher
mou
ch
Wal
k 07
: 13t
h Ar
rond
issem
ent
140
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Wal
k 00
: Titl
e.W
alk
08: S
tude
nt W
alks
Ab
ove:
Map
for
Paris
Out
of C
onte
xt w
alk.
Bel
ow: S
tud
ent
wal
k m
emor
y m
ap
141
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Lect
ure
01: A
Map
Mor
e or
Les
s Tra
vele
d14
2 :
Ang
ela
Kher
mou
ch
Lect
ure
01: A
Map
Mor
e or
Les
s Tra
vele
d
With
in o
ur im
med
iate
nei
gh-
bor
hood
ther
e ar
e st
reet
s th
at
we
inev
itab
ly tr
avel
mor
e th
an
othe
rs. F
or e
xam
ple
, the
dai
ly
rout
e fro
m h
ome
to w
ork
plac
e.
In th
is v
ersi
on
of a
map
of m
y im
me
dia
te P
aris
ian
ne
igh
-b
orh
oo
d, w
hat
mig
ht b
e ti
ny
stre
ets
be
com
e b
oul
evar
ds
due
to
the
ir s
tatu
s o
f “m
ore
tr
ave
led
,” w
he
re a
s so
me
bou
leva
rds
bec
ome
smal
ler a
s th
ey a
re le
ss tr
avel
ed. O
utsi
de
the
imm
edia
te n
eig
hbor
hood
, st
reet
s b
eco
me
hazi
er a
nd s
o fa
de
away
into
the
unk
now
n.
At
right
: A
num
eric
al s
yste
m t
o ra
te
stre
ets
acco
rdin
g t
o th
eir
“mor
e tr
av-
eled
” or
“le
ss t
rave
led
” st
atus
.
143
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
UrbAn nAming Devices
In these images of three locations I have lived are naming devices used to identify them. By finding places with similar naming devices and connecting them, we can create a new landscape entirely.
300 Riverside Drive, NYC
43 Rue Notre Dame de Nazareth, Paris
3330 South Michigan Avenue, Chicago
Riverside Avenue, Riverside, CA
Michigan Avenue, Lansing, MI
Notre Dame Street, Westfield, MA
Rue Notre-Dame Ouest, Quebec, Canada
Michigan Bridge, WI
Riverside, Liverpool
144
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Lect
ure
02: U
rban
Nam
ing
Devi
ces
UrbAn nAming Devices
In these images of three locations I have lived are naming devices used to identify them. By finding places with similar naming devices and connecting them, we can create a new landscape entirely.
Rue Notre-Dame Ouest, Quebec, Canada
Place Notre Dame de Nazareth, Pernes-les-Fontaines, France
Nazareth Avenue, Eastlawn Gardens, PA
Rue Nazareth, Manage, Belgium
Michigan Bridge, WI Michigan Avenue, Buffalo, NY Michigan Ave NW, D.C. Michigan Ave, Alexandria, VA
Riverside, Liverpool River Drive, Riverside, NJ Riverside Drive, Tansmania Riverside, Newport, South Wales
145
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Post
card
01:
Ital
y14
6 :
Ang
ela
Kher
mou
ch
Post
card
01:
The
Net
herla
nds
147
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
148
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Pers
onal
Pro
ject
: Le
Petit
Thea
tre d
e Pa
ris
Follo
win
g a
rel
ativ
ely
stra
ight
pat
h b
etw
een
Pas
sag
e Ve
rdea
u an
d t
he S
eine
, fi
rst
head
ing
so
uth
and
the
n he
adin
g n
ort
h, I
cre
ated
a s
erie
s o
f se
ts f
rom
th
e fa
cad
es e
nco
unte
red
on
the
two
wal
ks. T
hese
set
s w
ere
then
arr
ang
ed s
o
that
the
y co
uld
be
pul
led
, re
enac
ting
one
wal
k w
ith
a se
ries
of
pla
nes,
and
th
en r
eset
and
ro
tate
d t
o e
xper
ienc
e th
e se
cond
wal
k, t
he r
ever
se o
f the
firs
t.
A s
crip
t ac
com
pan
ies
the
sets
allo
win
g t
he u
ser
to p
roje
ct o
nto
the
set
s th
e si
ght
s an
d s
oun
ds
of
wha
t w
as e
xper
ienc
ed o
n m
y p
arti
cula
r w
alks
.
149
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
AC
T I
Wed
nesd
ay, M
arch
7th
, 13:
00. 4
5 D
egre
es, C
loud
y.
SCEN
E I
74 b
us a
pp
roac
hes
from
the
left
, 2 s
coot
ers
pas
s
150
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Pers
onal
Pro
ject
: Le
Petit
Thea
tre d
e Pa
ris, A
ct I
SCEN
E II
A w
oman
with
a b
aby
carr
iag
e p
asse
s fr
om le
ft to
rig
ht,
A s
coot
er p
asse
s fr
om t
he le
ft m
ovin
g t
o th
e rig
ht
151
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
SCEN
E III
Traf
fic p
asse
s in
dro
ves,
Tire
s sq
ueal
, Sco
oter
s so
und
, Som
eone
sp
its e
mp
hatic
ally
152
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Pers
onal
Pro
ject
: Le
Petit
Thea
tre d
e Pa
ris, A
ct I
SCEN
E IV
The
soun
d o
f cla
ngin
g s
caffo
ldin
g
153
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
SCEN
E V
Peop
le e
at lu
nch
on t
he s
tep
s, O
ne m
an s
mok
es b
y th
e ex
it of
the
met
ro
154
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Pers
onal
Pro
ject
: Le
Petit
Thea
tre d
e Pa
ris, A
ct I
SCEN
E V
ITw
o w
omen
pas
s ta
lkin
g lo
udly
, Som
ewhe
re a
man
laug
hs
155
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
SCEN
E V
IITh
e cr
unch
of g
rave
l und
er s
hoes
, Peo
ple
wal
k sl
owly
pas
t, A
man
sits
and
read
s on
a b
ench
, Bird
s ch
irp, A
n am
bul
ance
and
chu
rch
bel
ls
soun
d in
the
str
eet
bey
ond
156
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Pers
onal
Pro
ject
: Le
Petit
Thea
tre d
e Pa
ris, A
ct I
SCEN
E V
IIITr
affic
sou
nds,
Peo
ple
wal
k in
larg
e g
roup
s fr
om t
he M
etro
sta
tion
157
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
SCEN
E IX
Peop
le s
it al
ong
the
foun
tain
, Bird
s la
nd t
wo
at a
tim
e
158
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Pers
onal
Pro
ject
: Le
Petit
Thea
tre d
e Pa
ris, A
ct II
AC
T II
Tues
day
Ap
ril 2
4th,
19:
00. 5
0 D
egre
es, C
loud
y an
d r
ainy
.
SCEN
E I
Shoe
s on
sto
ne, E
lect
roni
c m
usic
, A c
oup
le s
nap
pho
tos
159
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
SCEN
E II
A t
rum
pet
ech
oes
and
reve
rber
ates
, The
tru
mp
eter
is n
ot a
goo
d o
ne
160
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Pers
onal
Pro
ject
: Le
Petit
Thea
tre d
e Pa
ris, A
ct II
SCEN
E III
A w
oman
sna
ps
a p
hoto
, The
sou
nd o
f wat
er m
ovin
g, A
man
laug
hs
161
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
SCEN
E IV
A w
oman
ben
ds
over
a b
race
let,
A c
usto
mer
ent
ers
162
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Pers
onal
Pro
ject
: Le
Petit
Thea
tre d
e Pa
ris, A
ct II
SCEN
E V
A m
an p
asse
s w
ith h
is d
og, S
omeo
ne la
ughs
, A m
an a
sks
if hi
s p
artn
er h
ad e
noug
h to
eat
163
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
SCEN
E V
IA
str
ong
sm
ell o
f gar
lic, T
he b
ang
of a
n es
pre
sso
mac
hine
, The
hub
bub
of p
eop
le t
alki
ng, A
wom
an in
a s
tam
p s
tore
put
s st
amp
s in
a
pla
stic
sle
eve
with
tw
eeze
rs
164
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Pers
onal
Pro
ject
: Le
Petit
Thea
tre d
e Pa
ris, A
ct II
SCEN
E V
IISc
oote
rs p
ass
from
rig
ht t
o le
ft
165
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
SCEN
E V
IIITw
o w
oman
lean
in t
alki
ng a
nd g
estic
ulat
ing
in a
caf
e
166
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
Pers
onal
Pro
ject
: Le
Petit
Thea
tre d
e Pa
ris, A
ct II
SCEN
E IX
Hig
h-he
eled
sho
es s
ound
on
mar
ble
floo
rs, A
man
flip
s th
roug
h ol
d d
raw
ing
s, p
ipe
in m
outh
167
: A
ngel
a Kh
erm
ouch
bande à partAngela Khermouch