Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
coNG Hem xA- IIQI CHt NG111A VIET NAM Bac lap - Ty' do - Hanh phtic
BIEN BAN PHIEN HQP CHiNH THit HQI BONG THAM DINH
BAO CAO DANH CIA TAC EKING MO! TRIftiNG
Ten Dg "Nha may din mat treri My Scm tai xa my Son, huyen Ninh Son, tinh Ninh Thuan cüa Cong ty Co phan Dau tu Nang lugng Xay dung Thuong mai Hoang Son".
Quyat dinh thanh lap hat dOng thAm dinh: S6 993/QD-STNMT ngay 16/3/2018 cila Giam d6c Ser Tai nguyen va Mai truemg tinh Ninh Thuan.
Thai gian hop: Vao lac 08 gier ngay 29 thang 3 nam 2018.
Dia chi ncri hop: Tai Phong hgp so' 2 (tang 3) try so SO Tai nguyen va Mai trueing, &Ming Nguyen Dire Canh, phireing My Hai, thanh phi Phan Rang - Thai) Chem, tinh Ninh Thuan.
1. Thanh phAn tham dg phien hop:
1.1 Hai deng tham dinh: Thanh vien c6 mat: 09/09 thanh
Thanh vier' vang mat: 0/09 thanh vien.
1.2. Chii dg in: Ong Cao Meng Bao, Trading Ban Quan 19 du an dugc Ong Nguyen Nam
Chung - Giam doc,Cong ty Co phan Dau tu Nang lugng Xay clung Throng mai Hoang Son üy quyen dir hgp thay.
1.3. Dot vi ttr van: Ong Nguyen Van Klage — Giam de Trung tam Tir van va Dich vii tai
nguyen va moi truemg Twang va cac nhan
1.4. Dai biau tham dg:
- Ba Nguyen Thi Chuyen vien Phong Tiing ho:p va Danh gia tac dOng moi truemg - Chi cyc Bao v moi trueng.
Ong Ducmg Trgng Khi8m, Chuyen vien PhOng tOng hgp va Danh gia tac dOng.moi trixemg - Chi cyc Bao v mai tithing.
2. Ni dung va din bin phial hop:
2.1 Ong Le Khac Huy Anh - Chia tich Hoi clang, nguen chit tri phien hgp thong bao 19 do cuec 119p va gi&i thieu thanh phan tham du.
2.2. 'Ong Dinh Manh Cuemg — Nhan vien, dai din Trung tam Tu van va Dich vii tai nguyen va moi twang (don vi tu van) thay mat Chi du an trinh bay nei dung ban Bao cao danh sia tac dOng moi Otitis (viet tat la Bao cao DTM): Bao cao DTM cita Dv an Om cep phan mO dau, ket lu'an va. 06 chiming, cy the nhu sau:
Phan ma dau.
- Chuang 1: M6 ta torn tat dv an.
Chuang 2: Diu kin moi truang tkr nhien va kinh ta-xa hi khu vac thirc hien dv an.
Chuang 3: Danh gia cac tac dOng moi truemg.
- Chuang 4: Bien phap phong ngira, giam thieu tac dOng tieu circ va phong ngira, Cmg ph6 sr Co mai truemg.
Chucmg 5: Chuang trinh wan 19 va giam sat rnoi trugng.
- Chuang 6: Tham van 9 kian Ong Ong.
Phan kat luan, kin nghl va cam kat.
2.3. Thao luân, trao d& gifla cac thanh vien hOi Ong \fed Chil dir an va don vi tu van ve nOi dung dm bao cao danh gia tac dOng mai truemg:
Nhin chung bao cao dã lam rO awe mai trugng nan tir nhien; dy• bao clugc cac tac nhan c6 the gay ra 6 nhiem môi truemg, cac doi tugng, quy mo bi tac Ong beri cac boat Ong dm cla an gay ra trong giai doan thi cong xay dimg va giai doan van hanh; de xuat dugc the bien phap giam thieu tac dOng xfiu, khOng che 6 nhiem \tá irng phi sir co moi truemg; cac chtrang trinh guar' 19 va giam sat moi twang.
2A. t kien nith xet v bat) eau cüa cac thanh vien 1101 dang:'
2.4.1. )? kien nh'an xet ciia Ong Nguyen Ba Doan, i:Jy vien phan bien 1:
a) Nhieng nOi dung dot yeu eau:
Va cfiu tnac: CALI frac cUa bao cao barn sat de cucmg mu (Phil lye 2.3) cna BO Tai nguyen va Med truong ban hanh kern theo Thong tit 27/2015/TT-BTNMT, ngay 29 thang 5 narn 2015 dm BO throng BO Tai nguyen va Mai truang ve dart gia mai truemg chien huge, danh gia the Ong m6i trugng va kê hoach bao ve mai truemg.
- V nOi dung: Bao cao dal neu dirge cac can dr phap luat, ky thuat cüa viec thirc hien DTM; lam rO dugc mai Huang nen tu nhien; danh gia, dv bao dirge cac tic nhan c6 the gay 6 nhiem; de rxuat mOt so bin phap giam thieu tac dOng field circ, phong ngira, lang ph6 sir co riM ro, sus c6 cUa cly an; cac chuana trinh quail 19 Ira giam sat mai truemg pha hgp vol loai hinh Dv an. •
b) NM-mg n'ai dung del nghi xemxet chink slut va ba sung:
Dei yeti plan mer du:
Ca quan phe duyet dir an dau tu: De nghl hieu chinh thanh Cong ty CO phan dau tu nang lucmg xay dvng thucmg mai Hoang San.
Can dr phap 19: BO sung Nghl dinh 14/2014/ND:CP ngay 26/02/2014 cila Chinh PhU quy dinh chi tiet thi hanh Luat Dien lirc ve an tom n din; Van ban 688/UBND-KT ngay 21/02/2018 dm UBND tinh Ninh Thuan va viec huang tuyen dueng day 110 kV dau noi Nha may din mat toil M9 San.
DOi voi Chuang 1: MO ti tom 61 city in I 2
- Chti Dkr an: De nghi 1)6 sung ten co quan cap giAy chimg nhan dang k9 lath doanh.
- Vi tri dia 1 dm Dv an, DTM mo tã không chinh xac, c6 sçr nham tan giira vi tri cua Dv an voi vi tn cüa xä M9 San. Mat khac, DTM ding chua mo ta vi tri va huemg tuyen luâi truyen tai tir Nha may len N thong luOi Quoc gia. De nghi mo tã b8 sung.
- Tai bang 1.1 Bang toa dOvi tn dv an: Bao cao thong neu h toa d va rnüi chieu sir dung, de nghi NI sung.
- Lien quan den dien tich sir dung dat caa Dv an, Bao cao liet ke duct cac hang mpc eking trinh cüa nha may, rieng dien tich chiem dat cüa N thong duang day DTM c6 d'e cap tan man a muc 1.4.2 (kit& ltryng va quy mo cac hang mac cong trinh dkr an). De c6 tinh thong nhat, de nghi cap nhat: htrang tuyen, dien tich chiem dat dm he thong ltrai truyen tai, hien tang tang quart 19 sir dung dat \taco bang 1.3.
- Muc b, (trang 16) dal \Peri d6i tuyng benh vien, twang hoc: Killing nhat thiet phai mei tã thu bao cao, ma chi can xac dinh doi tugng c6 chiu anh huerng tac Ong bed dkr an hay khong ? kiem tra xem thong tin each truemg Tieu hoc Phuong Cvu 36 km oh dung kitting; Mat khac khi mo tá phai xac dinh tinh tuang doi ctra d8i tugng ve phia nao (Bac, Nam, Bong, cita dv an de nguai dpc nhan dang dugc nhi dung.
Nhu can Sn' dung nuac cho dv an, DTM dã dv bao cho cac giai don d6i yeti tirng, nhu, cau thanh phan (ntrerc sinh hoat, nu& PCCC, nuerc san xuat). Tuy vay nguon cap nuerc chin cg the, thieu the thOng tin ye kha nang cung img cho dtr an.
Hieu chinh lai tien dh thvc hien di, an cho phi" hap vOi thvc ta.
Thng mac du tu cho di/ an khoang 1.396.641.000.000 dang lh chua chinh xac vi :chua tinh toan tong mirc dau ttr cho bao ye m8i truemg va chi phi boi thuong, ho try thi ding luói truyen tai.De nghi tinh toan bo sung.
fbi veri Chuang 2: Dieu kien truirng nhien va kinh te - xa hi)i khu vwc thwc hien dty in
Nhom tac gia dã chiu kh6 thu thap cac thong tin, el& lieu c6 lien quan ve dieu kien moi truemg tv nhien cüa tinh Ninh Thuan dé phuc vu lp bao cao DTM, nhung tiec rang each sir dung nhung tai lieu nay thieu tinh sang to lam cho nOi dung cac trang 50 den trang 79 lan man,,dai thing kh8ng can thiet. Vi vAy, DTM can rá soat, lugc bo bat nOi dung, di thang vao timg van de lien quan trvc tiep den dv an ve : Dieu kien thity van, hai van; Hien tang chat lugng cac thanh phan moi truemg,...
D6i yeti Chuang 3: Dinh gia, dy ban tic d(ing moi &Wing cua Dty an
BO sung tac dOngdo hoat Ong thu don sinh kh6i be mat cita giai don xay dvng.
DTM can dv bao b6 sung nhang tac dOng c6 lien quan khi thi &mg hang nnic !trail truyen tai.
147
Tac dOng al' a viec km dir, tOn ti-u, vOn chuyen 121.460m3 ella lugng Ot dir ra do qua trinh thi ding cac hang mix cong trinh dy an, bao cao chua de cap. De nghi dv bao tac dOng ella khoi lucmg dat, cid nay trong giai doan xay dyng.
Mix 3.1.2.1.1 Byi va khi thai (trang 85) : Tai nOi dung nay DTM c6 dy bao nguon gay '6 nhiem van chuyen ban, dat, dá thai di do tgi Mi thai xciy citing Van Don, Hoai Dar. Dv ban nay có sy nham lan thong phO hop vai dia diem thvc hien dy an.
- Qua trinh lap dat, van hanh Dv an cac tam pin c6 bi Ku h6ng kb:51-1g? Nou cep tSil la bao nhieu? Tac Ong den moi twang mire dO nao? De nghl be, sung.
D nghl danh gia tac Ong anh huong din tü Yuan trong qua trinh von hanh du an;
Sy co tran do tran Mu tü cac tram bin áp DTM chua de cap, de nghl 1)15 sung nOi dung nay.
Theo quy dinh tai Thong tu sO 16/2017/TT-BCT ngdy 12/9/2017 coa Cong thucmg c6 xac dinh trach nhie'm dia ben ban din nhu sau :Ben bon dien co trcich nhiem thao di); hoan tra mat bang, thu clan nha may din mat trai sou khi kAt iliac dy- an din mat treei theo cac quy dinh, guy chicon ye an toan tying trinh va brio v mai truemg. Vol quy dinh nay, khi lOp bao cao danh gia tac dOng moi truang can phai danh gia, dy bap tac dOng moi truang ella giai doan thao da. De nghi xem xet, 136 sung.
DOi \Teri Chuang 4: Bin 014 giam thi&I tic Ong, phong ngiya va 06 sty Si môi trttirng
Teen ca se nhimg nOi dung gop 1/ tai Chuang 3, de nghl Cho Mu tu va dcm vj tu van can ra sok de be) sung giai phap giam thieu tac Ong, phong ngisa thich fmg. Mat khac, km 5' bo sung, lam it' them mOt so nOi dung sau:
- Tai trang 111, bin pita') giam thieu tac Ong den moi truang nutc c6 neu Khu vtrc c4 an da co ho' thong thoat ntroc, nen nu* Mai thi cling se' attar thugom vao he thong that'll nu& khu var. Tuy nhien, xem xet cy the ti-en ban ye tong mat bang dy an thong thay the hien M thong nay. De nghl xem lai giai phap thoat ntrac.
Tai trang 123, DTM de xuat xay di,mg cac kho chin ngay tai dij an de thugom cac chAt thai nguy hai nhu: pin mat tr&i, inverter. Vic de xuat nay rat tich cue, nhtmg can tinh toan cu the, phai xay ckmg bao nhieu kho, kich thuac nhu the nao, dat 0 dau trong tong mat bang &la dy ;
, Vic Mutu thong thu gom nu& sau khi sinh cac tam pin c6 can
thiet khong (trang 123) ? Trong truang hop neu thay can thiet can neu cv the cac thong s8 k9 thuat dm he th8ng nay.
DTM can ra soot tat ca cac giai phop dã d xuat trong bac, cao xem tinh pha hop kha thi 0 mat dO nao ? theo Toi nhieu giai pithy thong pha hgp vai loai hinh dy an va dia diem dau tu (phoi hop vai tram y te phixOng trong cOns tac dru chin b'enh nhan ; bo tri 2 may bum ding suat 200m3/h dal ae thu vvc dau va
Agt
miwt-
cuoi tuyen thi cong ; ..).
D4i voi Chuang 5: Chuang trinh giam sat mOi truimg
- DTM dua nhiau chucmg,trinh giam sat tai cac vj trI khac nhau, day la dau hieu tich cvc cho thay Cha dau ttr kha quan tam den van de mai truemg. Tuy nhien, cang can.xem xet tinh chat, quy mo dv an de da xuAt chucmg trinh giam sat hap 19 NT& kiem soat dugc,tac dOng m6i true/rig. Theo do viec giant sat nu& thai thi tong va mad truemg dat !thong can phai thvc hien.
B6 sung giam sat din tir trtremg theo quy dinh.
- D thuan lgi trong qua trinh ta chac thvc hien va giam sat mai truang, de nghl trong bao cap tat cá the vi tri dv kien quan trac phai neu re tua d'a caa tang vi tri.
„ * Kb luon vet d nghi: Dang 9 thong qua, de' nghi Cha chr an chinh sira, be sung cac nOi dung ten vao trong Bao cao DTM.
2.4.2. t kien nhYn xet 'Ong Nguyen Qutw Dam, fly vian phan bien 2:
a) Nitting n't)i dung dartt yeu eau:
Ve cau true: Bao cao danh gia tac dOng mai trubng Dv an (sau day got
tilt Boo ccio DTM) dugc lap dung theo huorng dart dm dm BO Tai nguyen va Mai truang tai ,Thong tu so 27/2015/TT- BTNMT ngay 29/5/2015 &nit gia mai throng chien lime, danh gia tac (Ring mai truerng va ke hoach bao ve mai truemg.
Ve nOi dung: Bao cao da vin dan &rut cac can ca phap luat, k5" thuat cila viec lap bao cao DTM; lam re chat lucmg cac thanh phan mai truemg c6 kha nang chiu tac ding five tiep tir dv an; &rib gia, dv bao dirge cac tac dOng co the gay 6 nhiem moi truemg; dua ra mOt s6 bin phap giam thieu tac dOng fiat' cvc, phemg ngira, img ph6 rai ro, sv co dm clv an; de xuat cac chuang trinh quan 19 va giam sat mai truemg pha kip vài loai hinh dv an.
b) Nhteng nOi dung dg nghi xem -yet chinh viz NJ sung:
PhAn m& du: Veco quan phe duyet dv an dau tu la Cha du tu khOng phai fly ban
nhan. dan tinh Ninh Thuan. De nghi chinh stra lai.
V can dr phap 19: Da nghi ra sok va loai 116 nhang van ban hat hieu lye va khong lien quan nhu: Lust so 21/LCT/HDNN 8 ve bao ve sire thee than dan; Luat thua bao v mai truong sa 57/2010/QH12; Nshii dinh se 03/2015/ND-CP; Nghi dinh sa 81/2013/ND-CP; Nghi dinh so 59/2007/ND-CP; ND so 179/2013/ND-CP; Thong tu so 07/2007/TT-BTNMT; Thong fir sa 63/2013; ...
+ Be sung QCVN 25:2016/BYT - Quy chuan k thuat quec gia ve din tir twang tan sa cong nghiep - mac tiap xac cho phop din tü truang tan so ding nghiep tai nui lam viec de lam can dr giant sat din tit Ulan-1g trong giai don dv an di vao hoat dOng.
Chuang 1. MO tã tom tAt thy an:
Ti myc 1.3.1. Vi tri
Dv an bao gam cac hang hive chinh sau: khu vvc 1)6 tri cac tam pin hang lugng mat tad; tram bran áp va throng day dau
iyar75
nai. Tuy nhien tai bao cao chi ma ta toa d'a vi tri Nha may dien mat tit', con cac khu we khac chin &rye de cap. De nghi chinh sira, ba sung cac hang mac sau: Tong din tich toan b0 dtr an, trong do can lam ra khu virc lap dat tram bien áp, tuyen duang day dau nal 110 kv.(kern theo toa do dia. 19, din tich chiem dung, chieu dai tuyen dtrang day dau noi, hanh lang tuyen, ...).
- Ve moi quan h dm dtr an yeti cac d& tugng KT-XH xung quanh (tai trang 14 va trang 15): Dv an narn trong khu we dat rung san xuat,• tuy nhien ph'an thang ke tai Bang 1.3 thi hien trang sü ding dat dm du an bao gam: dat trang cay cong nghiep Mu !tam; dat bang tong cay hang nam khac; dat song ngoi, kenh, rach, suoi; dat giao thong vã dat bang chin sir dung. De nghi lam di hien trang sir dvng dat cüa dtr an.
Phan ma ta cac dal tugng ttr nhien kinh t - xä hOi xung quanh dis An: Bao cao chi ma tá khu vtrc dt nhA may con &Si veri khu vtrc thy& duOng day 110 kv chin dugc de cap. Be nghi bo sung cac dôi tugng co kha nang bi tac 'ging beri dtr an, dc bit la cac, dOi tucmg bi mat de's, khu dan cu co tuyen duerng day qua, (bcio cao nen Wet ke so ha dcin có din tich dcit bi thu hoi glen phong mat bang de thi cong tuyen throng day).
Tai 'nue 1.4.2. Kit& lugng va quy ma cac hang muc ding trinh cita dtr an: De nghi tach rieng thanh 02 rthc rieng: 01 mtic la: cac hang mtic &Ong trinh chinh va 01 mtic la: cac cong trinh pth trg cüa dtr an (kern,theo nguyen if, how tiOng; thong so kj thuat; elk tinh kp thu at; clac diem, khoi king: caia tang hyng myc cong trinh cilia dif an). Cac hang mix cong trinh nay nen thong • ke theo clang Bang bieu d8 dg
V giai phap M chic thi ding, ding nghe thi ding xay dtmg cac hang myc cong ,trinh dv an. Be nghi tech thanh inert ante rieng; &mg thoi ma ta chi tiet, cu th8 v8 cac bien Oar) to chin thi cong, cong nghe thi &mg xay dung cac hang mvc cong trinh cüa du An co kha nang gay tac clang xau den mai trubng va neu ro co se lizra chart bin phap, cong nghe.
Ve nhu cAu nguyen, nhien lieu dm dtr an: Bao cao thang ke chua day du nhu cAu nguyen, nhien lieu dau vao va dau ra cOa di, an; dang thin theo bao cao trong giai doan du an di ,vaa van hanh Ichong sir ding nguyen, nhien lieu IA khong ding vori thtrc te. Be nghi ba sung va neu rO nguon cung cap.
- Chinh sira lai tang mire dan tu cüa du An cho thang that; ba sung chi phi dau at xay dung cac cong trinh bao ve mai truang cua du An va hoat dOng bao ve mai tnrong hang nam cüa du an.
Chuang 2. Dieu WO tv nhien vl kinh Ku:
Ba sung nguan trich clan sa lieu ve dieu kin dja hinh, dia chat cilia •dis an.
Ve di8u kin thüy, hai van: Bao cao chi ma ta cho toan tinh Ninh Thuan, trong khi do tai khu we du an va xung quanh khu vvc du an lai khong ma a Be nghi chinh sira, be, sung, ltru 9 khi ma ta dieu kien thily van phai the hien dirge dc tnmg thily van dm khu vtrc tai va xung quanh du an de lam co sa tinh toan, du bao cac taz tang ciia dv an.
14./6
Ve vi tri lay man nugc mat de phan tich danh gia hien tang moi truang nen: Vi tri lay mu phai mang tinh dai din vã khu vvc lay mu c6 kha nang chiu tac Ong trvc tiep bed dv an, nguon nuerc tiEp nhan nugc thai,c0a dv an, ... Trong khi do bao cao lay mau nugc mat tai song Than va song Dau co phi' hgp khong.
Ve hien tang tai nguyen sinh vat: Bao cao nen tap trung mo tã hien -yang da clang sinh hgc coa khu vise dv an va cac khu we chlu anh huemg eüa dv an.
Chuang 3. Dinh gii tic d(ing môi truteng:
Dai voi giai dogn chuan bi:
- Do dkr an sir dking mOt phan din tich lem vá qua khan, sat thkrc t cho thay hien tai khu vve dv an ca tong mOt so cay c8ng nghiep va cay hang nam knee, nhung bao cao chua danh gia nhang thiet hai ye cac tai san tren dat, anh huOng den kinh‘ te, thu nhap...c0a, nguai bi anh huang. De nghi danh gia tac Ong be, sung, dong thin th8ng ke sO h0 dan co dat bi anh hugng.
Giai dogn thi &Ong xay thfng:
- Ve danh gia khi thai phat sinh trong giai doan nay: Bao cao nen tinh toan ming dO,cac chat o nhiem dkra vao dinh mire lieu hao nhien lieu dm timg may moc, thiet bi, phucmg tin tham gia vao thkrc hien dv an.
Bo sung danh gia tac dOng bpi phat sinh vá mirc d9 khuech tan tir cac hoar dOng thi c8ng dao, dap dat trong qua trinh xay dung.
BO sung ket qua do nong do bpi tai khu vkrc xay dung (trang 88).
- D6i veri nuerc thai sinh hoat: D nghi bao coo nen tham khan TCXDVN 33-2006 cna BO Xay_clung de tinh toan lugng nuerc thai ph& sinh vá danh gia nong cre de chat 8 nhiem trong nu& thai nay.
Tinh toan lugng rac thai pith sinh tir hoar dOng pilot quang, bloc pha tham thkrc vat vã chat thai ran sinh hoar phat sinh trong giai doan nay.
. -Dv an nay ngoai vie dau at xay dvng nha may din mat tin con &au at xay dkrng tuyen dugng day 110 kv, nhung bao cao chtra dugc danh gia. De nghi bo sung danh giá tac deng do thi ding tuyen throng day nay.
Giai Jowl hogt &Ong:
BO sung tong lucmg nu& thai pilot sinh hang ngay tir boat dOng ri:ra cac tarn pin.
Tinh toan nguen chat thai nguy hai phat sinh tir cac tram bin ap da qua südyng.
BO sung danh gia tac &ling duy tu bao duer'ng tuyen dugng day dau n6i 110 kV.
Giai doan kit thfic dy• an: Be nghl b8 sung danh gia, dv bao tac dOng moi trutmg cda giai doan that) da theo quy dinh tai Thong tu ,s6 16/2017/TT-BCT ngay 12/9/2017 dm BO C8ng thuang quy dinh ve pilot trien (iv An va hgp dong mua ban din mau ap clung cho ck dv an din mat trot
14417 7
Chirung 4. Bin phap phông ngira, giam thieu tic Ong tieu eye:
Tren co sex g6p Or chucmg 3, de nghi Chu du an 116 sung cac giãi phop giam thieu tac dOng kha tn. Ngoai ra tai chuong nay de nghi chinh stira, bo sung met so nOi dung sau:
, Bo sung giai phap giam thieu Mc Ong do phat quang, giai phong mat bang; nuOc thai sinh hoat, rac thai sinh hoat, nu& thai tU qua trinh rita phuang tin van chuyen, may m6c, thiet bi trong giai doan thi cong xay dung Ong trinh.
- Bien phap giam thiL den mei truang sinh thai do chat phat cay eel trong qua trinh bao during.
Bien phap giam thieu tac dOng do nu& thai Oat sinh trong qua trinh sinh cac tam pin.
Bien phap giam thieu tac Ong do du bin op dã qua stir dvng
BO sung dien tich, ket cdu, kich think kho luu giO CTNH tam thai de" ltru chtira eac tam pin thai bo.
Chuang 5. Clam sit moil truirng dinh
* Giai doan xay chrng:
Giarn sat mod tn.rang khong khi xung quanh: De nghl dieu chinh lai
01 vi tri tai ranh gieri dau huerng gi6 khu vuc du an tai .thai diem lay mau
01 vi tri tai ranh giai can huong gi6 tai khu vtrc du an tai thai diem lay mau
Giam sat ntrOc thai: S nghl xem xet bo nei dung nay
Giam sat m6i twang dat: De nghi bO nOi dung nay
* Giai doan hoat d(ing cüa dkr in:
S twhi b6 khong giant sat chat lueng kitting khi; nuorc thai sinh hog; mei trtremg dat
Be ,sung giam sat cuerng do din truemg; euerng do tir truerig tai cac vi tri: tram bien áp 110 kv; 01 vi tri tai nha dieu hanh Ara 01 vi tri dec theo tuyen &rang day 110 kv.
Quy chuan áp dvng: QCVN 25:2016/BYT
* Nhang nOi dung khcic:
Tai Mvc c,trang 16: xem lai cac dei tueng truang hec gan khu vtrc nha may nhu truang Weir hoe Phuang Cuu 3,...
S nghi lam r6 lueng nuorc mua chay trait trong giai dean xay dung (0,108 m3/s) lai khac trong giai doan van hanh (0,055 m3/s).
* Kit luetn vii de' nghi: Deng Y thong qua, de nghi OM du an chinh stira, bo sung cac nOi dung tren vao trong Bao cao DTM.
2.4.3. t kin nhan xit dm Ong Tan Minh Dinh, fly vien:
a) Nhieng nJi dung di,‘ nghi xem xit chinh sleet vii bJ sung:
- D nghi sira ngay ban hanh Nghi dinh 43 la 15/5/2014 (trang 5); be sung Quyet dinh so 284 chap thuan chit trucmg dau tu caa UBND tinh vao phan can cir phap 151 (trang 6), va be sung dm tinh ve dutmg day tai din (trang 8), xk dinh di qua khu dan cu Q1 27 6 vi tri nao? (trang 32).
Trang 20, dong 11 ghi: Chieu cao cac tam pin hay chieu cao gia de.
Trang 53 dieu kin thay van dong 14 cluth len, be sung song Than.
D nghi b6 chi tiet cac song tir trang 54-56 vi khOng lien quan.
- D nghi co (long hoc be qua hien trang mei tubing nugc Ninh Thuan trang 62.
De nghi co Ong lai Muc 2.143 hien trang -moi truiying (tat ninh thuan hoc 136 qua vi rOng qua.
De nghi bo 7 trang me ta nai Chita (trang 73-79) vi khong lien quan.
Saa s6 hien trang 81 Mac 2.2.2- hien trang xa hOi: se he 2815, se khau 11.124, dien tich tu nhien 12.856ha, dat san xuat nong nghiep 5.659,7ha.
De nghi phan tich them viec phan quang, phan nhiet tit cac tam pin nang lugng có anh huong gi den mei truong xung quanh du an kh6ng?
Yeu cau tham gia \fed dia phucmg siva chtia, di tu tuyen tinh 10 708, trach nhiem cUa cong ty dugc xac dinh tit lac khgi ding voi qua trinh san xuat sau nay.
, * Kit lutin vet de nghi: Deng Sr thong qua, de nghi Chu du an chinh sfra, be sung cac nOi dung ton vao trong Bao cao DTM.
2.4.4. t kin nhan zit dm ong Nguyen Van Dung, fly vien:
* Nhiing nOi dung ad nghi xem xet chinh situ vii bet sung:
Chtrung 1: Trang 24 nguen cAp nugc: DTM nett "tir h theng suei chay qua khu
\int „dv an va,gieng khoan" can lam re tinhkha thi nhat la ye mita kho vã tieu chuan nutc de rira cac tam pin theo tieu chuan nao?
Trang 41 chinh sin ving mac dau tu du an, DTM neu 1.396,6 ti', tai bang 1.14 DTM neu 1.396,641 tjr, be sung chi cho cling tac bao ye moi truthig la bao nhieu?
Chucmg 2: Ve dieu kien mei throng tkr nhien: Can tap trung vao khu vat du an va xung quanh pham vi du an. DTM neu qua dai thuec pham vi cà tinh, trong khi khu vat ,du an lai qua so sai, nhat la tin trang 69-73 DTM dua cã hoat dgng san xuat muoi, viten quec gia niti Chaa.
Chuang 3:
Giai doan xay dung: tai trang 74 bang 3.1 can be sung chat thai ph& sinh la tham that vat (de c6 bien phap giam thieu). Trang 93 Chat thai nguy hai: ngoai ph& sinh 17kg/thang, can bo sung so lugng tam pin hr h6ng do qua trinh van chuyen, lap dat phat sinh.
Giai doan van hanh: trang 102 nugc ve sinh tam pin (187.200 tam) 444
—161-d
DTM neu theo chu kY 15 ngay (quanh nam) thi can lam rO (quanh nam) chu kY/thang la 3 thong hay 6 thang; trong diet' kin maa mua thi chu c6 thay doi khong? cong nghe rira pin W. dOng hay tha cong?
Trang 103 Chat thai nguy hai: b6 sung du bao lueng pin thay tha thai b6.
Tac dOng biri rid ro, sucO trong giai doan hoat dOng trang 107, can be, sung tac dOng Anh huang cUa din tir truang.
Bo sun . phan danh gia tac dOng cUa viec than do, khoi phac mai truerng giai doan hat tuai the tha chr an.
Chuang 4:
Giai doan van hanh trang 119: b6 sung bin phap thu gom nuac rira the tam pin, DTM neu se tu tham xuang dat ducri vi tri dat IA chung chung va thieu ca
Trang 123 CTNH: chinh mita, bo sung ve vi tri, din tich xay dung kho chira CTNH.
Trang 123 neu rnau thuAn veri trang 119 a tren: DTM neu h thang, thit gom nu& sau khi rcra tam pin se duge,bo tri hap I dé thu,hoi tat ca nrite ye be xir ly de tai sir clang, tranh 0 nhia-m dat va nguon nuac; can chinh sira be) sung phuung an thu gom? kich threat be? dat tai dau? tai sir dung cho mac dich gi?
Bo sung bin phap thu gom, quan 1' chuyen giao d& veri cac tam pin hat tu6i th9.
Bo sung bin phap giam thieu thi no, six ea, giai doan boat Ong trang 125 dal voi din tic truang.
Trang 127 bang 4.1: Du tra kinh phi thuc hien cac clang trinh bao moi truang, be, sung the giai (loan xay dung, van hanh cho bin phap giam thien CTNH. DTM chi neu cho cac citing trinh bao ye m8i twang IA 260 trieu la 'thong c6 cc ser that te.
Chuang 5:
Trang 131 Quan 1' mai twang: B6 sung cac giai doan (chuAn bi, xay dung, van hanh) va trach nhiem tO chirc that hien Nth giam sat ngodi chi) dãu us, dun vi thi ding, con ce, chinh quyan va cac cu quan chirc nang.
, + Trang 134 giam sat mad truang. khuyan cao chd Mu us can nghien ciru de dim ra chucmg trinh giam sat phit hap, nhat trong giai doan ,xay dung, tranh dim ra khong that hien, vim vi pham lai ton kinh phi cho cha dau ru; tucrng us ir giai doan boat &ling can bo sung giam sat dien tic truong.
Chuang 6:
Trang 141: earn kat man thU quy dinh chung v& ban ye mai .truang co lien quan cac giai, doan tha du an, DTM neu "cha du an khong khai tilde sir clang nu& du6i dat trong giai dap thi ding va van hanh caa cla an? hoan Wan mau thuan vói phan dau tai trang 24 " nguon cap mite".
B6 sung 2 van ban: van ban dm chi) Mu tic giri UBND xa My Sun va ifkilY 10
viec xin kin tham van cOng Ong; van ban phac dap cüa chinh quyen UBND xä M9 San va viec lcian tham van Ong Ong.
+ Danh sach dai dien 27 110 clan chiu anh huong dm du an tham dkr phien hop tham van (mesi chi c6 danh sach can 1)0 cha chOt dia phucmg).
* Kit luiln vii di nghP Dang ST thong qua, da nghi Chit dg an chinh sda, ho sung cac nOi dung tren vao trong Bao cao DTM.
2.43. kien nh4n xet elm Ong Dinh Him Sy, Uy vien:
* Nhieng niii dung di nghi xem _vet chinh sem vii ha sung:
- Mi)t s6 thong tin lien quan dan mai truiyng eüa chi an chua dung vai thuc te dieu kin tai dia phucmg nhu nguon nuac neu nhung khong dinh hinh dirge lay tir nguan nao (thuc te ô khu vuc nay chua c6 h th8ng thay Igi nao ca.).
- VI tri, dia danh can ra soat Icy d'a van dung sat vai khu virc xung quanh caa dia diem, khong can lay dia diem cilia xä My San.
Chin O cap dan skr anh hiremg moi truemg cüa huang tuyan.
Khgi lugng dat da. bat Mu trian khai thi tap kat nai nao caa bai vat lieu cho cc! the.
Can neu dirge giai phap chat thai khi khai cong du an nhu chat thai ran, dau nhart tai khu we du an la dat san xuat caa ba con (trang m9, laa va hoa mau khac), horn naa tai tuyen diremg vao du an la throng tinh 10 708 la duemg dat, nau khong c6 bin phap thi gay anh huang lugmg bui duang rat lon sa gay anh huang den cay tong ea a ba con tai khu we nay (di giài phap that cu the).
Va van da giao thong di lai phvc vv cho thin gian 1(1-led cong xay dung, can tinh toan da dam bao an toan giao thong qua lai trong khu dan cu.
- Neu cu tha lucmg rac thai sau khi tap kat va cach xa (Tce' cd chat thai ran, Furor thai sinh hoot va cac chat thin khac).
Neu dirge giai pith]) va chinh sach hT6 trg cho nguai c6 dAt sau khi bi thu hoi dat.
* Kit luon và dl nghP Dang 32 th8ng qua, da nghi Chu dkr an chinh saa, HI sung cac rigi dung troll vao trong Bao cao DTM.
2.4.6. t kien nh4n xet (mg Nguyen Thanh Hao, Uy vien:
* Nhteng nOi dung de' nghi xem xit chink sera vii ha sung:
MOt s6 diau kien khu we thtic hien du an chua chinh xac, can rã soar diau chinh cho pha hgrp.
Can the dinh nguan nugc da thi ding di, an \fa khi dim vac) hot Ong dm du an.
Can viat ggn phAn diau kin kinh tE - xas hOi, tij nhien khu vijc dux hien du an.
Canba sung lay 5/ kian cUa cac dai tugng chju tac Ong dm du an (phi'au tham van cOng thing).
MOt s6 dia danh chua chinh xac, thong pha hgp, thong can thiat din AtA,11
vao dtr
Can danh gia tac dOng trong qua trinh thu 1161 (tat.
* Kit va ctt nghi: Deng 5/ thong qua, de nghi Chit dv an chinh sita, 136‘ sung cac nei dung tren vao trong Bao can DTM.
2.4.7. t kin nIcain xet ella Ong Le Thanh Than, Ph6 ChO tich Hi ding:
* Nhceng nOi dung die nghi xem xet chinh sfra va a sung:
Chtrung 1. Ma ti tom tit dty in.
B6 sung ban theing ke danh myc cac may moc, thiet bj (Mm pin mat trot inverter, may bien ap,, tram bien ap 22/110kV,....) lap dat tai Dv an nay kern theo so lueng, th8ng so k5r thuat.
B6 sung giai phap thi ding cac hang myc cong trinh cUa cly an, dac bie5t la thi ding tram bien áp va duang day 110kV dai 6,532 km vuot qua rat nhieu doi dá va khang dinh cly an nay co sir ding min pha dá de xay &mg cac mong try tram Hen áp va duerng day 110kV.
Chtrung 2. Dieu kien mai &won tty nhien va kinh khu vut dty an
Di vol chucrng nay, de nghi viet gen lai, the thong tin Bong lien quan hoac lien quan it den dfr an nhu: hien tang mei truang da't,san xuat muoi, khai thac lchoang san,...ciia tinh, he (ging thvc vat Vuern quoc gia Nüi Chaa,...khong dua van trong Bac coo.
Chtrung 3. Dinh gii tic Ong mai truing
D nghi 136 b6 cym tir "van chuyen bun, (tat, da thai di do.' thai tai bai Zãy dyng Van Con, Hodi Dix" tai trang 85.
Sim cam ket tir "Cha dre an yeti cau dan vi xucit trinh h6 sic' may mac thiet bi va yeu cau dun vi thi cong bac, &rang &tear khi dtra may mac vao cOng trtrerng,....khi den lich bao &rang stra tgi ccic gara....nen dui an khong phat sinh dart nhast thcii" thanh "Than bO dau nhat thai tie cac phtrang tin thi cong, vOn chuyan nguyen vat lieu cha clau tie thu gom vao kho chtera chat that nguy chaa va chayan giao cho clan vi c6 chtiv nang thu gom„ xie IY clang quy clinh Thong tie so 36/2015/TT-B77VMT ngay 30/6/2015 cita BO Tai nguyen vie Mai trtrerng". Deng theri, de nghj be, sung cam ket xay dtmg kho chin CTNH giai doan xay chmg.
BO sung phan' cly ban ye khei lugng cac tam pin hu h6ng Oat sinh tir boat deng van chuyen va thi ding giai doan xay dipig de c6 phuang an thu gom, km trCr va xi( 131/ loai,chat thai nay cho dung quy dinh ye quan 1' CTNH.
BO sung phan danh gia tac deng den thoat nuorc mua chay tthn khu virc do thi cong 4,2951cm duerng chinh va 6,933km (bong phy cüa dkr an gay ra.
Dei vOi cly an dien mat troti sir dyng rat nhieu tram bin áp loai 0,4/22kv, 22/11,0kV,...do d6, khi du an di vao hoat dOng !wing dau may bien áp, thiet bi chuyen deri tir dien met chieu thanh xoay kSr va det xuat thai ra là c6, do d6, trong Bao cao DTM nay de nghi WO sung phAn cly bao lugng dau may bien ap, thiet bi chuyen dOi tir dien dinh kST va dot xuat thai ra de c6 ke hoach
/114712
thu gom, xirIST.,Ngoai ra, d nghl khang dinh trong bao cao dinhk3/ du an nay có tin hanh Igc au may bin ap khOng. Neu c6 bo sung quy trinh lgc au va xac dinh cac loai chat thai thai ra tir boat ang nay.
Chuang 4. Bien phip gum thieu tic Ong
- Va xir 157 dAt dá thai: Theo thang ke tai bang 1.5 trang 18 sau khi can bang dao ap tong khoi lugng dat dá thai cita dkr an, nay la 121.460m3. Phucmg an xir 15/ lugng dat a du thin ra sao chua dirge de cap trong Bao cap DTM. Ngoai ra, trong phucmg an xi: 1j7 chat thai ran xay dung (vita, cat, s6i,...) pat sinh khoang 1,5 taningay trong bao cao ghi IA "Chit dkr an 14. hgp ang vOi dun vi có chirc nang van chuyen di xir lyf hang ngay" qua chung chung. Be nghi cam kat cp the hum.
- Ve xir 157 mak thai phat sinh tir boat Ong rira xe van chuyen chat thai ran: Theo tinh toan tai trang 92 tong lugng nuerc rira xe giai doan thi cling la 27m3/ngay, nhtrng trong Bao cao chin nett giai phap thu gom, xir b? el& veri loai nu& thal nay.
- BO sung giai phap thu gom va xir bri the tam pin het han six dung va phucmg an taco der, ,hoan tra mat bang, thu dgn nha may pin mat tred theo quy dinh tai Khoan 2 Dieu 14 Thong tu so 16/2017/TT-BCT ngay 12/9/2017 cim BO Cong thuang.
-r Doi vai kho chin CTNH giai doan van hanh tai trang 123: DO nghl bo sung kt eau, kich thutic, vat lieu va vi tri kho chin CTNH nay.
- Ve bin pap phong ngixa, img ph6 rüi ro, sr cO cila du an giai doan van hang tai muc 4.2.2 trang 125: Be nghi ba sung giai phap img pito trong truang hgp cac may bien áp loai 22kv va. 110kV bi sir co re ri dau ra moi truemg.
Chuang 5. Chuang trinh twin 157 vi giim sit mai truirng.
Giai doan xay dung:
1. Mei trueng khong khi: Da nghi chi t6 chirc giam sat 02 diemtai ranh gioi tren gi6 va ranh gigi clued gio theo tien dØ xay dung cila Dv an.
Moi trueng Killing can giant sat.
Moi truemg nth:9c: Be nghl ghi rö la giam sat nuot thai rira xe.
Giai doan van hanh:
Bo sung chuang trinh glom sat din truing tai tram bien áp 110kV va cloc theo duang,day 110kV. Rieng moi truing khong khi va at là kh8ng can thiet glom sat, de nghl 1)6.
* Kit luein vet di nght Dang ST thong qua, a nghi au du an chinh sira, bo sung cac nei dung trait vao trong Bao cap DTM.
2.4.7. t kien nhn xet eim hi Doan Kim Thoa, fly vien thu k3:
- Ra sat va lugc be cac Van ban !thong lien quan: Lai xay dtmg, Luat Dau tu, Lat Tieu chuan, Lust bap ye sire kithe nhan dan, cac Nghi dinh lien quan den quan 151 du an an tu xay dung, chi phi au ttr xay dtmg, sir dung chung &mg trinh ha tang Icy that,...
Ard<
-1119-
Stia lai ,dja danh tinh Binh Thuan thanh tinh Ninh Thuan (trang 11, phuong phap thOng ke).
- MO ta lai vj tri Dv an trong do c6 be sung mo ta huong tuyan throng day 110 kV.
Theo Bao cao DTM thi din tich Dv an Ichoang.,75 ha, tuy nhien cac, van ban c6 lien quan den cong toe thu hoi, den bit thi tong din tich thu hoi la 802.645,2 m2 (khoang 80,26 ha). Da nghl lam rO sir sai khac nay.
Va nguen nu& phvc vix cho Dv an: Da nghi lam re nguen cung cap nuac sfr ding cho giai doan thi cling va giai doan van hanh.
Va tan suat it cac tdm pin theo nhu d'a xuat trong Bao cao DTM la qua day. btu tinh Ninh Thuan chi c6 2 mita: mita kho va mita mua nen de nghi chit du an Iuu Y: it cac tam pin vao mita kho la chit' yéu, Sing the.' dua ra phtrong an lira tam pin la thia cling hay clung may m6c thiet bi de Ito trg.
- Tai Chtrorng 2: Bao cao mo ta cac Wei dung lien quan dan diau kin kinh te-xd hi, hien trang moi truang qua dai ma khong khai,quat dirge dieu kin kinh te-xa. hei, hien trang moi truang tai khu we Dv an. De nghi ra soat va lugc be cac nei dung khong lien quan.
Tai Chuang 3 trang 88: Bao cao ghi "Do clue & m..6t sa 4 tri khoang 50m — 100 m el/0i hit Ong gio tgi mgt vài nai trong khu 9CC xciy dung..." ghi cau nay lam nguai d9c hieu nham la Dv an dang xay dung. Dé nghi ra sok yà hieu chinh lai.
Tai Chucrng 4: bao cao dua ra cac bin phap chua pha hgp vol hien tang va dia diem thvc hien Dv an. Da nghi xem xet lai.
• Tai Chuang 5: bao cap dua ra chucmg trinh giam sat moi twang dat,
nuerc thai thi cong trong giai doan xay dung; mei, twang dat, khong khi, nu& thai sinh boat trong giai doan hoat dOng la khong can thiet.
Bo sung vi tri kho chfra chat thai nguy hai ten ban ye mat bang tong the.
* Kit Wm vii di nghi: Deng y thong qua, cia nghi CHI di/ an chinh stra, bo sung cac nei dung tren vao trong Bao cao DTM.
2.4.8. t kien nhan xet cüa ong Lê Khac Huy Anh, Chit tich Hi deng:
Nhirng ned dung dot yeu cu:
Bao cao danh gia tac del-1g moi truemg caa Dv an Nha may din mat trai My San tai xã M'y San, huyen Ninh San, tinh Ninh Thuan ctia Cong ty CO phan Dau tu Nang lugng Xay dvng Thuang mai Hoang San dugc lap clang theo huang clan ctia Thong tu, se 27/2015/TT-BTNMT ngay 29/5/2015 dm Tai nguyen va Môi trueng ve danh gia moi truemg chien lucre, danh giá tac &Ong moi truang va ke hoach bao ve moi truemg. Bao cao cia phan tich, danh gia dugc ye ca ban cac tac dOng chinh cLla Dv an den moi twang va de xuat cac Nan pita') giam thieu tac &Ong lieu eve den mei tnrong.
Nhawg ried dung di nghi xem _vet chink sira vii ba sung:
Phan met flan:
Rd soat Ira lugc b6 cac van ban khong hoe it lien quan den Dp an (Lu4t tierr chuein, Luat bao ye sire khge nhan dcin, cac Nghi dinh lien quan den quail ij dy• on slat, tit xay dyng, chi phi dau tic xáy dyng, sir dyng chung cong trinh hq tong ky thuat, cac Thong tic quy clinkquy trinh quan trac moi trtrung, Quyet dinh phe duyet De an Quy hoach phcit trien then gig...).
Hieu chinh lai co quan phe duyet Dp an au tu la Carta ty C phan Dau flu Nang lugng Xay di,mg Thuang mai Hoang San.
Ching 1: MO ti tom tAt Dv in
MO tã lai: Vi tri ctla Dp an ('trong do, lam ro khu vitec lp d'at cac tam pin, tram biAn ap, tuyAn throng day dau WOO; cac doi tugng tij nhien, kinh ta - xã hOi xung quanh khu we Du an (Ice ca cite doi trivng co kha ming bi tac icing bgi tuyen throng day 110 kV) theo dung hien tang thvc te.
B8 sung va neu r8 huong tuyen clueing day 110 kV cila Dv an kern theo hien trang sa dung dat, din tich chiem at viral vien va tam theri cüa tuy'en clueing day nay.
B6 sung he toa do va müi chieu sü dung tai Bang 1.1 (Bang tga d vi tri Dir On,).
Bo sung va lam re din tich dat rung sdn xuat va at dv phong phat trien lam nghiep trong khu vvc Dv an do UBND xa My San (pan 15r.
Bo sung bang thong Ice cac hang muc c6ng trinh chinh va cac c8ng trinh php trg ka Dv an (kern they quy mo, ding sucit, khai hiving, thong s a 197 thuOt,... ctha tieng hang myc cong trinh).
BO sung bang thong ke danh mpc cac may m6c, thiet 1)1 (gm: lam pin Wong luyng mat trol,, inverter, may bian ap, tram Nen ap 22/110W, ....) lap at
tai Din an kern theo so lugng và thong so ky thuat.
7 BO sung nhu cau va nguan cung cap nguyen, nhien lieu phpc vv xay dvng cac hang rnpc ding trinh dm Dv an de lam, co ser dv bao va danh gia cac tac dOng mei truemg, de xuat bin phap giam thieu tai cac chuang sau.
- Bo sung tinh toan nhu eau nuerc phpc v1T cho giai doan thi ding xay thing. Deng theri, lam r8 nguan cung cap cho giai doan thi ding va giai doan von hanh cüa Dv an, ke ca phucma thirc cap mac (kern theo may moc thiet bi phyc
viec cap nugc va r fra cac tom pin) va yeu cau ve chat lugng nuot cap.
Chinh sfra lien dO thvc hien Dv an cho phi) hcrp \Teri thvc tL
Be sung chi phi du tu cho bao v moi truerng vã chi phi bOi thuemg,i1-8 trg kh1thu hoi dat de thi ding tuyen &rang day 110 kV dau noi va cap nhat tong marc dau tu cüa Dp an.
Chuang 2. Dieu kien rnôi truirng ty nhien vi kinh t - xi hi khu vvc tittle hien Dter in
dieu kin thily van, hai van; hien trang chat lugng cac thanh phan moi twang; hien tang tai nguyen sixth vat: De nghl ra soat, lugc bo nOi dung 1Thona lien quan den Du an (cy the: Cdc ho chart mak tren dia ban tinh, cac sling suoi
1447 15
khong chciy qua khu vrc Dw an, hogt dang san xuat muai, ,hogt clang khai thac khoang san, he clang thyv vat Vu6in gu6c gia Nai Chaa), bo sung va neu r8 che dO thny van min kho ya mna mua doi vori doan suoi chay ngang qua Diy an; hian trang moi throng, hian trang tai nguyen sinh vat tai khu vvc chiu tac deng caa. Dv an.
Chtrang 3. -Dinh gii, thy bio tic Ong mtli truirng
Doi ved giai doan chuan bi:
Bo sung thong ke so h0 clan có dat bi thu hi, dien tich dat bi thu hal da thi c8ng nha may va tuyan duerng day 110 kV dau n6i; tren ca so do, danh gia lai mire de tee dOng cUa vie thu hai dat den cac h0 clan nay.
+ Xk dinh lining thvc vat thai ph& sinh trong qua trinh phat quang, chuan bi mat bang dê phpc xay clung nha may va tuyen &rang day 110 kV &au n6i kern theo dv bao cae tac dOng nay den mai truerng.
- D6i vei giai doan thi c8ng:
B6 sung nOi, dung danh gia tde dOng mod truOna do thi ding tuyan duerng day 110 kV; (King thiyi khang dinh viac thi ding tuyen throng day nay c6 no min pha rid khong.
B6 suns phan danh gia tac dOng do bpi phat sinh tir cac hoat dOng thi ding dao dat, dap dat, san gat,. ..trong qua trinh xay dung.
B6 sung nOi dung danh gia tac dOng do lugng Mt cid doi du (121.460mi) tit qua trinh thi ding xay di:mg ck hang mpc cilia Dv an.
Tinh toan khoi lugng the tam pin hu hong (v0, nat...) do va dap trong qua trinh van chuyan, lap dat kern theo bran phap xir d6i veri cac tam pin hang nay.
B6 sung phan danh gia tac Ong dan viec thoat ntrac mua chay tran do xay dvng ck tuyen duong giao thong nOi b0 cüa Dv an.
D6i \Teri giai doan van hanh:
+ Xac dinh lai kh6i luqng chat thai nguy hai phat sinh (gam khai !ming chat thai phat sinh dinh kj) va tat xuat) trong giai doan van hanh cUa Di, an (nhcit la dy• bao s6 *mg tam pin bi hie hong, phai thay the; vie'c thay rcac tcim pin khi Mt tuoi thg; dau bcio dyeing may bign Op, duy tu bao clufleng tuyen chrOng dciy clau nOi 110 kV,...) de lam co se( tinh toan quy mo elm kho chin chat thai nguy hai.
+ B6 sung nOi dung danh gia tac dens do din tir truang; phan xa anh sang tit: cac tam pin; sv co tran dau tie tram bien áp.
+ Khang dinh Du an c6 hoat dOng loc Mu to may ,bin áp kliong? Nau co, de tighi bo sung quy trinh 19c dau; tinh toan lugng can dau phat sinh tir qua trinh loc dau va lugng dau thai bo khi thay dau men.
Doi \Jeri giai doan kat tithe Dv an: BO sung phuong an thao der, hoan tra mat bang, thu don nha may din mat ten sau khi kat thnc Dkr an theo dong quy dinh tai ThOng tu s6 16/2017/TT-BCT ngAy 12/9/2017 oh BO COng thuong;
,44-6
kern theo phan danh gia tac dOng mei truemg vã bin phap xir 19 cac chat thai (ct tarn pin mat trai, may bien áp, dchi bien trong giai doan nay.
Chtrcrng 4. Bin phip giam thietu tic demg au, !thong ngira vi ting pith my c6 truirng
De nghi ra scat tart ca cac giai phap cla d xuat trong Bao cao DTM va xem xet, chinh situ cac giai phap giam thieu tac deng den mei trueng (nut; dat, del then; khong khi,... ) cho pha hop vai loai hinh Dv an; diet' kin tv nhien, kinh te- xa hei khu vvc Du an.
- Doi giai doan chuan Bo sung phucmg an 11-6 trg cac hO clan bi thu hoi dat.
- Doi yen giai doan thi cong:
B6 sung giai pith!) thu gom, xà 19 46i yeti ntrOt thai phat sinh tü qua trinh rCra, ye sinh phuung tin van chuyen; bin phap xi:r 19 lugng dat cid doi du trong qua trinh thi cong.
Bo sung rigi dung xay dvng kho luu gift chat thai nguy hai tam thed phyc vv cho cã giai doan van hanh (kern theo vi tri, ket eau, kich thuoc va chi phi xay dog); bin phap xd 19 chat thai nguy hai.
06ivoi giai doan van hanh:
Bo sung: Bien phap thu gom, xü 19 thvc vat thai trong qua trinh bao dung tuyen duang day dien; giai phap üng ph6 trong truemg hcp may bien áp 22kV va tram bien ap 110kV bi sv co rO ri dau ra mOi truemg.
Chtrang 5. Chtrang trinh quart 19 vi giam sit min fruiting.
DM vai giai doan thi cong:
Ve giarn sat, chat lugng mei trueng khong khi xung quanh: S twill t6 chirc. giam sat 02 diem tai ranh gied tren chieu gi6 \fa ranh gied dual chieu gi6 theo tien 40 xay dvng dm Dv an.
134 nghi be giam sat chat lugng mei trueng dat, nu& thai thi cong.
Dai . voi giai doan van hanh:
B6 sung chuong trinh giam sat din tit trueng tai tram bien áp 110 kV vá doe theo tuyen clueing day 110 kV.
De nghi b6 giam sat chat lugng mei trueng fiat, khong khi, nuac thai sinh hoat.
Chuang 6. Tham vAn 9 kin cong dtmg
Tham vAn be sung cac he clan c6 &At bi thu hai dung theo quy dinh tai Phv 2.6 ciaa Thong tu s6 27/2015/TT- BTNMT ngay 29/5/2015 cila BO Tai nguyen Nth MEd trueng.
Phil] phy lyc: B6 sung so 46 vi tri giam sat mei trueng khong khi xung quanh giai doan
thi cong và giam sat din tü truemg trong giai doan van hanh; trong 46, cac diem giam sat phai dugc mo tá re, chit giai rO rang va c6 tga 40 theo quy chuan hien
4417 "to--
hanh.
* Kit lutin va di nghi: Dang Y thong qua, de nghi Cha dv an chinh sira, b8 sung cac nOi dung ten vao trong Bao cao DTM.
2.5. t kin phán hi elm Chii dv an:
Tiep thu cac kin gap y, danh gia cüa the thanh viten Hi don tham dinh, Chit dkr an ding dcm vj tu van se chinh sta, be) sung Bao cao DTM theo yêucâucüaHi dong.
3. Ket 1u4n phien hyp:
3.1. Nguiri chü tri phien hQp cling biti k'et luOn cüa hOi clOng tham din h:
3.1.1 Nheng ned dung dat yeti au:
Bao cao danh gia tac &Ong moi truemg dm Dv an Nha may dien mat troi My San tai xa my San, huyen Ninh San, tinh Ninh Thuan cüa Cling ty Co phan Du tu Nang *mg Xay dvng Thuang mai Hoang San dugc lap dung theo htrang clan dm Thong tt sa 27/2015/TT-BTNMT ngay 29/5/2015 cilia BO Tai nguyen va M8i tnrerng ye danh gia moi truerng chien lugc, danh gia tee dOng m8i truemg va kê hoach bao ve moi truemg.
Bao cao dã phan tich, danh gia dirge v ca ban cac tac dOng chinh cilia Dv An den m8i truemg va de xuat cac bien phap giam thieu tac (long tieu cvc den moi tnrang.
3.1.2. Nheng n(ii dung an dtrvc chinh sira va bt; sung:
b) Nhiing ni)i dung di nghi xem xet chinh slut vet bit sung:. PhAn me. d'au:
RA soot vá lugcb,5 cac van ban khong hoac it lien quan den Dv An (Lmat tieu chuein, Ludt bao ye the khoe nhein clan, cac Ngh1 dinh lien quan den (mon 1,1 dr" an clau tic xeiy clung, chi phi deiu tie zeiy dying, sit dyng chung cong trinh hg tang kji thuat, cac Thong ty quy clinkquy trinh quan trac mai trwang, Quyet clinh phe duyOt Dé an Quy hogch phcit trien din gi6,...).
Hieu chinh lai ca quan phe duyet Dv an Mu tic la Ong ty Co phan Dau Us Nang lugng Xay cluang Thucmg mai Hoang San.
Chuang 1: Mil fa tom tit Dv an
Mo ta lai: Vi tn cilia Dv an (trong do, lam re') khu vyr lap d'Ot cac tam pin, tram Nen tip, tuyen throng day clan not); cac doi tugng tv nhien, kinh te - xa hOi xung quanh khu we Dv an (Ice ca cac dal tuvng c6 kha neing bi tac clang bai tuyen dicemg day 110 kV) theo dung hien tang thvc te.
BO sung Ira nett rei huemg tuyen duemg day 110 kV dm Dv an kern theo hien tang sir dung dat, dien tich chiem dat vinh vien va tam theri cOa myelin clueing day nay.
BO sung he t9a dO va mai chieu sir dung tai Bang 1.1 (Bang tga JO vi Dv án,).
lam - BO sung va lam re dien tich /tat rfrng san xuat Ara tat dv phong Oat trien nghiep trong khu vvc Dv an do UBND xa m3,- Son quan 132.
- Bo sung bang thong Ice cac hang myc ding trinh chinh ;TA cac cong trinh phy try caa Dv an
(kern theo guy 'no, cong such, khai hiving, thong sa ìçí thucit cua terng hang myc cong trinh).
- BO sung bang thong ke danh mpc the may Ines thiet bi (gam: Tcim pin ming Wong melt troi, inverter, may bier: Op, tram bie'n Op 22/1101cV,....) lap dat tai Dv an kern theo sá ltrong va thong stik9 thuat.
Bo sung nhu cAu va nguon cung cap nguyen, nhien lieu phuc vj lay Ong cac hang myc cans trinh ctia. Dv an d lam ca so' dv bao va danh gia cac tac Ong moi taking, de xuat bien phap giam thieu tai cac chuang sau.
- Bo sung tinh toan thu cau nuerc phyc vu cho giai doan thi cong xay civng. Dong theri, lam rO nguon cung carp cho giai doan thi cong va giai clop van - hanh ciia ,Dcr an, ke cá phuong thirc cap nuot (kern theo may mac thielt bi phuc vy viec cop niroc va rug cac tam pin) vã yeu cau ve chat lugng nu& cap.
Chinh sCra tien di) thvc hien Dv an cho phü hop vied thgc
BO sung chi phi du tu cho bao ve moi trir6ng va chi phi bOi thuong, h6 try khi, thu dal de thi clang tuyen duong day 110 kV dau nOi va cap nhat to:rig mac dãutu'cUaDtrán.
Chuang 2. Dieu kien môi truirng tif nhien vã kinh t - xA hi khu Nye thyt hien Dn. an
Ve dieu kien thrly van, hai van; hien trang chat lugng cac thanh phan moi taking; hien trang tai nguyen sinh vat: De nghi ra soat, lugc bo nOi dung lchong lien quan den Dv an (cy the: Ccic ho chtia woe tren dia ban tinh, ccic song suoi khang climb; qua khu vtec Dy• an, hogt clang scin xuat muoi, hogt dang khai Mac khocing sari, 120- clang thyv vat Vicon tquac gia NW Chita), be, sung va neu rO che dO thily van min khO Ara mita mua doi veri doan suoi chay ngang qua Dv an; hien trang 'Tied twang, hien trang tai nguyen sinh vat tai khu vvc chiu tac &Ong cüa. Dkr an. •
Ch wring 3. Dinh gia, thy ban tic d(ing môi truirng
Doi yeti giai doan chuan bi:
+ B6 sung thOng ke WO' hQ dan co dat 131 thu,h6i,,di a\en tich dAt bi thu h i thi cOng nha may va tuyen dtrang,clay 110 kV dau noi; ten co so' do, danh gia lai mire de tac &ling cüa viec thu hoi dat den cache' clan nay.
+ Xic dinh hang thric vat thai phat sinh trong qua trinh phat quang, chuan bi mat bang de phyc xay citing nha may va tuyen dueing day 110 kV dau nOi kern theo clv bao cac tac &Ong nay den moi twang.
- 06i veri giai doan thi cong:
+ 136 sung nOi dung danh gia tac dong mOi truing do thi ding tuyen duong day 110 kV; clang tiled khang dinh viec thi cong tuy8n duerng day nay c6 no min pha rid thong.
BO suns phan danh gia tac dOng do bvi ph& sinh tir the boat dOng thi cong dao dat, dap dat, san gat,...trong qua trinh xay ding.
BO sung nei dung danh gia tac dOng do lugng dat cid doi du (121.460m3 )
tir qua trinh thi cling xay dvng ck hang mvc cna Dv an. Tinh toan khi lugng cac tam pin hu hong (v5', Tit,...) do ya dap trong
qua trinh van chuyen, lap flat kern theo bien phap xfr desi vai cac tarn pin hang
thy. + BO sung phan da'nh gia' tac dOng den vie thoat nuoc man chay tran do
xay dung cac tuyen dung giao thong nOt 130 caa Dv an.
- Dei yen giai doan van hanh: + Xac dinh lai kit& lugng chat thai nguy hai phat sinh (ge; m khói Wang
chat thai phat sinh clinh va d(5t xueit) trong giai doan yon hanh dm Dv an (nil& la di" bac) s a lu-eng tcim pin bi his hong, phai thay the; viec thay ,cac tam
pin khi hit tuai the; clau bilo dyeing may bien áp, duy tu bcio dieting tuyen dtcong day dau nal 110 kV,...) de' lam ea sO tinh toan quy mO eüa kho chfra chat thai nguy hai.
BO sung nei dung danh gia tac clOns do din tir Huang; phan xa anti sang tir cac tam pin; sv co tran clan tir tram bien áp.
+ Kiting dinh Dv an cep heat (Xing ice dau tir may ,bian áp khong? Nau có, de nghi bet' sung quy trinh 19c dau; tinh toan lugng can dau phat sinh tic qua trinh 19c au va lugng dâu thai be khi thay dau meri.
,- Dor i yen giai clop ket theic Dv an: Bo sung phucmg an did() d, hoar) tra mat bang, thu dn nth may din mat trai sau khi kat thee Dv an then ding quy dinh tai Thong tu so 16/2017/TT-BCT ngay 12/9/2017 cila Bô Cong thuang; kern theo phan danh gia tac dOng men truiorng va bien phap xir 19 the ch'At thli (cac tam pin mat trai, may bien áp, clau ban ap,...) trong giai doan nay..
Ch,trang 4. MO flip giãm thieu tic dOng xãu, phong ngira N/A ting pito sty cO mOi truirng
De nghi rá soot tat cã cac giai phap dä de xuat trong Báo cao DTM vã xern xet, chinh sfra cdc giai phap giam thieu the deng den mad truemg (niter; dat da thai; khong khi,...) cho pha hgp voi logi hinh Dv an; dieu kien tu nhien, kinh to- xa hOi khu vvc Dv. an.
- Wei ved giai doan chuan bi: Be sung phucmg an h8 try cac h dan bi thu hoi dat.
- Di yeti giai doan thi ding:
BO sung giai pita') thu gem, dei yen nuac thai ph& sinh Ui qua trinh na, ye sinh phuang tien van chuyan; bien phap xfr 15, lugng /tat dá doi du trong qua trinh thi ding.
BO sung nOi dung xay dung kho luu gilt chat thai nguy hai tarn then phvc yv cho cá giai doan van hanh (kem theo vi tri, kat call, kich thuot va Chi phi xay dung); bien phap xii ly chat thai nguy hat
Aisfe. 20
Doi veri giai dean van hanh:
BO sung: Bien phap thu gom, xfr 12 thvc vat thai trong qua trinh bao dutng tuyan dyeing day din; giâi phap Ung, pito trong truemg hop may bin áp 22kV vã tram bien áp 110kV bi sr co re ri dau ra mei truerng.
Chtrcmg 5. Chuang trinh quan 157 va giam sat moil trtromg.
Doi veri giai dean thi
Ve giam sat chat *mg m6i truemg khong khi xung quanh: De nghi chirc giam sat 02 diem tai ranh giai tren chieu gio va ranh giei dyed chieu gie theo tien d xay clang dm Dv an.
+ De nghi b6 giam sat chat luring mei trueng dAt, nu& thai thi &mg.
Dai voi giai dean van hanh:
136 sung chuorng trinh giam sat din tit truerng tai tram Nen áp 110 kV vã doe theo tuyen duang day 110 kV.
De nghi be giam sat chat lueng mei twang dAt, khong khi, nu& thai sinh heat.
Chuang 6. Tham van Si kien cOng ang
Tham vAn be sung cac he clan có dAt bi thu hei dung theo quy dinh tai Phu 2.6 dia. Thong at se 27/2015/TT- BTNMT ngay 29/5/2015 dm BO Tai nguyen va M8i twang.
Phan phy BO sung so do vi tri giam sat mei trueng khong khi xung quanh giai dean
thi cong vá giant sat din tie twang trong giai dean von hanh; trong de, cac diem giam sat phai duce mo tã re, chit giai re rang va co toa de theo quy chuan hien hank
Va 2 kian khác cita cac thanh vien HOi deng tham dinh.
3.1.3. Ket ban: Thong nhat thong qua Bao cao danh gia the dOng mei truemg cna Dv an
Nha may din mat trei my San tai xä MST San, huyen Ninh San, tinh Ninh Thuan cna Cong ty CO phan Dalt tu Nang Wong Xay dung Throng mai Hoang San nhung phai chinh sita, bo, sung theo kat luan cüa Hei &Mg ,va cac kien khac cüa cac thanh vien Hei &Ong. Sau khi chinh sfra, b6 sung de nghi CHI dv an gni 03 ban dv thao Bao cao DTM cho Ser Tai nguyen vã MOi truemg (thong
qua Chi cyc Belo v midi trtrang) de kiem tra, rá seat noi dung \la gici lay y kien cUa 02 Oy vien phan bin de hoan thin dr thao Bao cao DTM truerc khi trinh Uy ban nhan dan tinh phe duyet.
3.2. it kien cim the thinh vien dOng tharn dinh:
Tat ca the thanh vien tham dv hop clang voi kat luan cüa nguei chü tri phien hop.
3.3. it kien dm Chuchr an ye ket Juan HOi doting:
C6ng ty Ce phan Dau at Nang luring Xay clang Thucmg mai Hoang Son 1040 2 1
thong nhat veri kat luan cüa HOi (long tham dinh va së chinh aura, be' sung hoan chinh Bao cao danh gia tac dOng môi truOng theo ket luan cüa HOi thing tharn dinh.
Kt qua kiem phieu tham dinh:
4.1. S6 phiau th8ng qua bao cao kh6ng cAn chinh saa, b6 sung: 0/09
4.2. S6 phiau thong qua bao cao vOi diau kin phai chinh saa, b6 sung: 09/09
4.3. S6 phial.' khong thong qua bao cao: 0/09
Ngtriri tri phien hyp tuyen 136 ket thtic phien hyp.
Phien h9p kat thac vao 11w 09 gies 45 phut cang ngay.
NGU'en CHIJ TRi PHIEN HOP
CHU TICH HO HONG THU 10? HO HONG
Le Khac Huy Anh -Doan Kim lima
