Descartes e Santo Anselmo O Argumento On

8/16/2019 Descartes e Santo Anselmo O Argumento On

1/13

!"#$"% '()*('+ ,+- -./0+-1 2"34# .!5*- " .3"%6$# 7.',+-+ 87##439:;1 !"#$%&'"#( *"+,-+. " % /01"&-+1%1"2 3$'%# 10 405678+01 !69?"9 7#%6) +)%? 3$-/2, $

$;)%+'%$ 2) '($ 2/70/:-/*$ ,7)4 /- 7 \)*7'/+ =') +,'+

0) =') A) %)0,**$/7 0-$/%)()*+ )+ 2/7+/*0+)()*+ $::$%+)*/% ] 0)++) 0>,7)4 -'/ $::$%+/)*+ )* )(/++4 %):%,2@ )( FG@24A"2 1GH($2%>2 12 I:(/#"J*"K "4 Q$%/74 I)%


2/13

!"#$"% '()*('+ ,+- -./0+-1 2"34# .!5*- " .3"%6$# 7.',+-+ 87##439:;1

!"#$%&'"#( *"+,-+. " % /01"&-+1%1"2 3$'%# 10 405678+01 !69?"9 7#%6 H/.-#$% '+0/1% ,- '#I()'-(70 %),+ +% %$./)1($%J &+# /0 2-,+8 + '+1'$)(+ ,$ C$/% $ ,- %/- &$#:$); M#+&+0+A1+%8 $1(

N+ 0$%0+ ($0&+ 4/$ 1+% = ,-,+ *$#):)'-# - )1-,$4/-; M+,$0+% -%%)0 #$-2;-# -

+#).)1-2),-,$ ,+ -#./0$1(+ '-#($%)-1+ $ )2/%(#-# - )1'+1:/1,)6)2),-,$ ,+ -#./0$1(+

-1%$20)-1+ '+0 *$#%G$% &+%($#)+#$% 1- (#-,); R$ - ,):$#$1;- $1(#$ +% ,+)% :+# (-2 4/$ -06+% 1 ?8'+0 $:$)(+8 '+##$1($ %/&+# 4/$ + -#./0$1(+ -1%$20)-1+ = /0- )1:$#71')- ,-

$5)%(71')- ,$ C$/% - &-#()# ,- ),$)-8 1- 0$1($8 ,$ /0 $1($ %/0-0$1($ &$#:$)(+

$ %/60$(7A2+ ,$&+)% L '#I()'- U-1()-1- ,$ (+,- - +*- ! #$%&$% ,- $5)%(71')- ,$C$/%> S


3/13

!"#$"% '()*('+ ,+- -./0+-1 2"34# .!5*- " .3"%6$# 7.',+-+ 87##439:;1

!"#$%&'"#( *"+,-+. " % /01"&-+1%1"2 3$'%# 10 405678+01 !69?"9 7#%6%*4 (# -() SM'*#&O-() *0M() 7.* )$+# +M() &S(%3$*4 0$+# -& 5'(3*e'( (# 5'*+%*5&-( ()# %(--( 0( ?*(.:A 017 TG4 55: GfT>GfX:X A;# %( 7.( P( #'$.S( *%* 0( 5-.) %$+)*0('&O-(4 ()# 7.( P( #'$.S( (+ 3$* .+( *+1*+*#M 0a*0M() 0( %('#&*+()%Q#'( (--() +a&*(+# &.%.+( (@*)#(+%(Q#'( (+ &.%.+ -*(. 0. 3$+0(


4/13

!"#$"% '()*('+ ,+- -./0+-1 2"34# .!5*- " .3"%6$# 7.',+-+ 87##439:;1

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

72$9/12$%#0 $21 / )32)/ $21 /9 95/9 )17&)*/FH29 45/$%# E9 7.#7.)23/329 3/ $/%5.2?/*#..297#$32$%20 72 452 G 7#99D>2& E 12$%2 $5$*/ *Q2(/. / 72$9/. 21 C25901/9 G )17#99D>2& 72$9/. $/ )32)/ 32 51 2$%2 957.21# 2 $6# /31)%). /9)17&)*/FH29 329%/ )32)/0 921 92 %#.$/. 12$#9 ./*)#$/& #5 9212&Q/$%2 /# )$9)7)2$%2

3# /.(512$%# /$92&1)/$#,-./0 / 3)9*.)1)$/F6# 32 51/ 3/9 )17&)*/FH29 3/ )32)/ 32 C259 #5 32 51/

3/9 72.@2)FH29 32 51 2$%2 951/12$%2 72.@2)%# R / 2;)9%)/12$%20 7#.G10 3# 452 V$92&1#0 C29*/.%29 $2$Q51 7/99# 3A 7/./ @#./ 3/)32)/ 32 C259 / @)1 32 )$@2.). / 95/ 2;)9%2& 3/ 95/

+ I@, !"# WX0 7, "+Y, Z3, $,[\,B Z3, $,],P S^% #$ $2 3#)% 7/9 3).2 )*) 45_)& 29% E &/ >G.)%G $G*299/).2 452 :_/>#52 452 C)25 2;)9%20 /7.`9 452 :_/)

9577#92 45_)& 7#99`32 %#5%29 9#.%29 32 72.@2*%)#$90 75)9452 a_2;)9%2$*2 2$ 29% 5$20 1/)9 45_2$ 2@@2% 1/ 7.21)`.2 9577#9)%)#$ $_G%/)% 7/9 $G*299/).2N 32 12$% )$9*.).2 3/$9 &2 *2.*&20 1/)9 4520 9577#9/$% 452 :_/)2 *2%%2 72$9G20

:2 95)9 *#$%./)$% 3_/>#52. 452 &2 .Q#182 92 725% )$9*.).2 3/$9 &2 *2.*&20 75)9452 *_29% 5$2 @)(5.2 3245/%.2 *b%G9N 2% /)$9) :2 92./) *#$%./)$% 3_/>#52. 5$2 *Q#92 @/5992, -$ $2 3#)% 7#)$%0 3)9c:2 /&&G(52.*2&/O */. 2$*#.2 45_)& $2 9#)% 7/9 $G*299/).2 452 :2 %#182 :/1/)9 3/$9 /5*5$2 72$9G2 32 C)250$G/$1#)$90 %#5%29 &29 @#)9 45_)& 1_/..)>2 32 72$92. E 5$ 2./)$0 2% 32 %).2.0 7#5./)$9) 3).20 9#$ )3G2 35 %.G9#. 32 1#$ 297.)%0 )% 29% $G*299/).2 452 :2 &5) /%%.)852 %#5%29 9#.%29 32

72.@2*%)#$90 45#)452 :2 $2 >)2$$2 7/9 % &29 $#18.2. %#5%290 2% E /77&)452. 1#$ /%%2$%)#$ 95. *Q/*5$23_2&&29 2$ 7/.%)*5&)2., ^% *2%%2 $G*299)%G 29% 95@@)9/$%2 7#5. 12 @/).2 *#$*&5.2 d/7.`9 452 :_/) .2*#$$5452 a_2;)9%2$*2 29% 5$2 72.@2*%)#$e0 452 *2% 2./)$ 2;)9%2 >G.)%/8&212$%O 32125; *#$9)3G.2. 5$2 @)(5.2 .2*%)&)($2 *#17#9G2 925&212$% 32 %.#)9 /$(&290 )& 29% /89#&512$% $G*299/).2

452 :2 &5) /%%.)852 %#5%29 &29 *Q#929 45) 92.>2$% E *#$*&5.2 452 929 %.#)9 /$(&29 $2 9#$% 7/9 7&59(./$39 452 325; 3.#)%90 2$*#.2 452 725%c


5/13

!"#$"% '()*('+ ,+- -./0+-1 2"34# .!5*- " .3"%6$# 7.',+-+ 87##439:;1

!"#$%&'"#( *"+,-+. " % /01"&-+1%1"2 3$'%# 10 405678+01 !69?"9 7#%6. #)'3# #&&()*%+ #

#$%&'()*%+ #/ ;#-&?@A

B#6+'%5+/#)'# +. *+&. 9#./1'3%*. 7. '3%C)9-6.D ,-# 23.5( + -/++)+6.9%+ /+%& *./26#'+ 2+3+ . +39-/#)'. *+3'#&%+).D + %/+9#/ )&:5#6 7+

/.)'+)0+ )>. &E 1 2+3*%+6 *./. *./2.3'+ -/+ .FG#*=>. 23#5%&:5#68 +%)7+ ,-#

+ /.)'+)0+ # . 5+6# G+/ %)+345#%& #)'3# &%D 7+: )>. -# ,-# +69-3#&

#$%&'+ -/+ /.)'+)0+ *./ -/ 5+6#H +)+6.9+/#)'#D #/F.3+ ;#-& # + #$%&'()*%+

G+/ *.)*#F:5#%& *./. %)+345#%& #)'3# &%D 7+: )>. -# ,-# #$%&'+ -/

;#-& +&&%/ *.)*#F%7.??A ;#&*+3'#& )>. 3#&2.)7# + #&'+ .FG#*=>. )>.

3#%'#3+)7. + %33#*-&+F%6%7+7# 7+ #$%&'()*%+ 7# ;#-& # +*-&+)7. *#3'+

%)*.)I.3/%7+7# 7+ %/+9#/ 7+ /.)'+)0+D #/ *./2+3+=>. *./ . #$#/26. 7.

'3%C)9-6.D 2+3+ + 7#&*3%=>. +)+6E9%*+ 7. +39-/#)'. .)'.6E9%*.8 )+ 5#37+7#D + /.)'+)0+

# . 5+6# 7#%$+/J )#9+3 *.)G-)'+/#)'# *./ F+ )+ %)#$%&'()*%+ 7# +69-/+/.)'+)0+D #),-+)'. ,-# + )+'-3#K+ 7. '3%C)9-6. # +& &-+& 23.23%#7+7#& #&)*%+%&

2#3/+)#*#/ %)5-6)#345#%& L &-&2#)&>. 7+ #$%&'()*%+ 7# '.7. # ,-+6,-#3 '3%C)9-6. 2+3'%*-6+3

?MA

N %/+9#/ 7+ /.)'+)0+D 2#6+ &-+ /#).3 *.)5#)%()*%+ +)+6E9%*+D '#/

+69-/+ +I%)%7+7# *./ + /+%& *16#F3# .FG#*=>. 7# O+-)%6. +. +39-/#)'.

+)/%+). 7. !"#$%#&'#() + %/+9#/ 7+ %60+ 2#37%7+A P#9-)7. O+-)%6.D +

*.)*#2=>. 7# ;#-& ,-# 23#&%7# L I.3/-6+=>. 7. +39-/#)'. 7. !"#$%#&'#( 1

?@ QR+3D +S+)' +**.-'-/1 7+)& '.-'#& 6#& +-'3#& *0.& 7# I+%3# 7%&'%)*'%.) #)'3# 6T#$%&'#)*# #'

6T#&)*#D G# /# 2#3&-+7# +%&1/#)' ,-# 6T#$%&'#)*# 2#-' ('3# &12+31# 7# UT#&)*# 7# ;%#-D #' ,-T+%)&% .)

2#-' *.)*#5.%3 ;%#- *.//# )T1'+)' 2+& +*'-#66#/#)'A V+%& )1+)/.%)&D 6.3&,-# GTS 2#) +5#* 26-&

7T+''#)'%.)D G# '3.-5# /+)%I#&'#/#)' ,-# 6T#$%&'#)*# )# 2#-' ).) 26-& ('3# &12+31# 7# 6T#&)*# 7#

;%#-D ,-# 7# 6T#&)*# 7T-) '3%+)96# 3#*'%6%9)# 6+ 93+)7#-3 7# & '3.%& +)96#& 19+-$ L 7#-$ 73.%'&D .-

F%#) 7# ?T%71# 7-)# /.)'+9)# 6T%71# 7T-)# 5+661#H #) &.3'# ,-T%6 )TS + 2+& /.%)& 7# 312-9)+)*# 7#

*.)*#5.%3 -) ;%#- U*T#&' L 7%3# -) ('3# &.-5#3+%)#/#)' 2+3I+%'W +-,-#6 /+),-# 6T#$%&'#)*# U*T#&' L 7%3#

+-,-#6 /+),-# ,-#6,-# 2#3I#*'%.)WD ,-# 7# *.)*#5.%3 -)# /.)'+9)# ,-% )T+%' 2.%)' 7# 5+661#AQ +,- "MD 2A

XYZA??

QV+%& #)*.3# ,-T#) #II#' G# )# 2-%& 2+& *.)*#5.%3 -) ;%#- &+)& #$%&'#)*#D ).) 26-& ,-T-)# /.)'+9)#

&+)& 5+661#D '.-'#I.%&D *.//# 7# *#6+ -6 ,-# G# *.)=.%& -)# /.)'+9)# +5#* -)# 5+661#D %6 )#

&T#)&-%' 2+& ,-T%6 S +%' +-*-)# /.)'+9)# 7+)& 6# /.)7#D 7# /(/# +-&&%D ,-.%,-# G# *.)=.%5# ;%#-

+5#* 6T#$%&'#)*#D %6 /F6# ,-T%6 )# &T#)&-%' 2+& 2.-3 *#6+ ,-T%6 S #) +%' +-*-) ,-% #$%&'#8 *+3 /+ 2#)&1#

)T%/2. +-*-)# )1*#&&%'1 +-$ *0.&H #' *.//# %6 )# '%#)' ,-TL /.% 7T%/+9%)#3 -) *0#5+6 +%61D #)*.3#

,-T%6 )TS #) +%' +-*-) ,-% +%' 7#& +%6#&D +%)&% G# 2.-33+%& 2#-'J('3# +''3%F-#3 6T#$%&'#)*# L ;%#-D #)*.3#

,-T%6 )TS #[' +-*-) ;%#- ,-% #$%&'C'AQ +,- "MJ"ZD 2A XYZA

?M Q\+)' &T#) I+-'D *T#&' %*% ,-T%6 S + -) &.20%&/# *+*01 &.-& ]T+22+3#)*# 7# *#''# .FG#*'%.)8 *+3

7# *# ,-# G# )# 2-%& *.)*#5.%3 -)# /.)'+9)# &+)& 5+661#D %' )# &T#)&-%' 2+& ,-T%6 S +%' +- /.)7# +-*-)#

/.)'+9)#D )% +-*-)# 5+661#D /+%& -6#/#)' ,-# 6+ /.)'+9)# #' 6+ 5+661#D &.%' ,-T%6 S #) +%'D &.%' ,-T%6

)TS #) +%' 2.%)'D )# 2#-5#)' #) +-*-)# I+=.) &12+3#3 ^-)# 7T+5#* ?T+-'3#H +- 6%#- ,-#D 7# *#6+ -6

,-# G# )# 2-%& *.)*#5.%3 ;%#- &+)& #$%&'#)*#D %' &T#)&-%' ,-# 6T#$%&'#)*# #&' %)&12+3+F6# 7# 6-%D #'

2+3'+)' ,-T%6 #$%&'# 513%'+F6#/#)'8 ).) 2+& ,-# /+ 2#)&1# 2-%& I+%3# ,-# *#6+ &.%' 7# 6+ &.3'#D #'

,-T#66# %/2. +-$ *0.& +-*-)# )1*#&&%'1H /+%&D +- *.)'3+%3#D 2+3*# ,-# 6+ )1*#&&%'1 7# 6+ *0.

/(/#D L &+5.%3 7# UT#$%&'#)*# 7# ;%#-D 71'#3/%)# /+ 2#)&1# L 6# *.)*#5.%3 7# *#''# I+=.)A R+3 %' )#&'

2+& #) /+ 6%F#3'1 7# *.)*#5.%3 -) ;%#- &+)& #$%&'#)*# U*T#&' L 7%3# -) ('3# &.-5#3+%)#/#)' 2+3I+%' &+)& -)#

&.-5#3+%)# 2#3I#*'%.)WD *.//# %' /T#&' 6%F3# 7T%/+9%)#3 -) *0#5+6 &+)& +%6#& .- +5#* 7#& _%6#&AQ

+,- "ZD 2A XYXA `/ *.)'3+2+3'%7+D . #$#/26. 7. '3%C)9-6.D 2#6+ &-+ *.)I.3/%7+7#D 1 3#%'#3+7. )+3#&2.&'+ L .-'3+ .FG#*=>. 2.3 )E& +*%/+ *.)&%7#3+7+8 57A )AaA


6/13

!"#$"% '()*('+ ,+- -./0+-1 2"34# .!5*- " .3"%6$# 7.',+-+ 87##439:;1

!"#$%&'"#( *"+,-+. " % /01"&-+1%1"2 3$'%# 10 405678+01 !69?"9 7#%6 ,'5 288'> 8+ *3#1#

?,+5/2/#?@ # 2$6+5A$*2# /# +B284A$*2# /+ C+08 9> ,'5 80# *'1,#5#/# )

'E4+$-.' /# +B284A$*2# /+88# 2&3# ,+5/2/# 1+/2#$4+ # *'$82/+5#-.' /# 80#

,+56+2-.'F G5#4#=8+ + $+1> #$#&'(#1+$4+> # ,+56+2-.' /+ C+08 9 5#D.' 8062*2+$4+ /# 80# +B284A$*2#JKLF

M052'8' 9 $'4#5 :0+ N$8+&1' /% 01# 5+8,'84# /+ 42,' *#54+82#$' #$4+8

/+ C+8*#54+8 ) 'EO+*-.' /# 2&3# ,+5/2/#F P1E'5# *'$*+/# # +B284A$*2# /# 2&3#

,+5/2/# $# *'$/2-.' /+ $.' 8+5 ,+$8% *'1' 9 $#405#&1+$4+ ' *#8' /+ :0#&:0+5 2&3#> ,'5 /+62$2-.'>

&2124#/# /+ 4'/'8 '8 /'8KQ

F C+84+ 1'/'> N$8+&1' 2$/2*# :0+ C+08 4+1 :0+ 8+52$62$24' ,#5# 8+5 #:02&' 1#2'5 /' :0+ ' :0#& $#/# 8+ ,'/+ ,+$8#5> +1E'5# '

2$62$24' 8+O# 1#2'5 /' :0+ 40/' #:02&' :0+ 8+ ,'88# ,+$8#5F N8821 8+ /+2B##88'*2#5 # 2/+2# /+ 2$62$24' *'1 # *'$*+,-.' /+ C+08 $' !"#$%#&'#( /+ R#$4'

N$8+&1'F S5#> C+8*#54+8 9 01 /'8 62&I8'6'8 :0+ 1#28 +B,5+88#1+$4+ /+6+$/+

KL ?PB+1,&2 (5#42#H N20$4 :02/#1 #&2*0E2 '*+#$2 +88+ 2$80> :0#1 +B /2662*0&4#4+ :0#1:0+ 6#E0$405

10&4' #1,&208 :0#1 /+ 6'540$#428 2$80&28 6+5405> /2 $0&&':0+ ,'88+88'5+ #04 3#E24#4'5+ 0$2 $'$ 2$ 2$4+&&+*40 8'&' 8+/ +42#1 +88+ 2$ 5+@ 2/+' 82* +#1

$+*+88+ +84 +88+> :02# $282 60+524> :0#+*01:0+ #&2# 2$ 5+ +84 4+55#> ,5#+84#$42'5 2& +524> #* 82* 2,8# 2#1 # 4+

,5#+84#$42'5 2$4+&&+*4# ,5#+84#$42'5 $'$ +524@ V 82 2$:0#1 ,+5 3#+* 2&&+ 1232 #$ 2&201 82 8+ ,04+4 #&2:0# *+54240/2$+ 2$80+ 2&&208

+88+$42#1 #8450B288+> $282 ,5208 2,8#1 ,5#+84#$42#1 +208 8'&011'/' 82*04 5+1 *+', -, .-/0 "/$1#(,/(2 3+',-4 1"# '($'1'/(2/5 6789: Z> ,F K\]> KKFKQ=L\ ^4+B4' /# +/F

*5;42*# /+ _FRF R*31244> 5+,5'/F +1 ;"/ ,


7/13

!"#$"% '()*('+ ,+- -./0+-1 2"34# .!5*- " .3"%6$# 7.',+-+ 87##439:;1

!"#$%&'"#( *"+,-+. " % /01"&-+1%1"2 3$'%# 10 405678+01 !69?"9 7#%6 #$% &'(-0+,' 0$*?@&02% -%

*4A*40% 0-)0% -) )(2) /#$%$)(2) *)41)02'3 2%? &'$' % $)/$% &'(-0&0'(% % ('+,'-%;#0?' $%0'4 -' ;#) ' ;#%? (%-% /) *'-) *)(/%4 BC ) % ('+,' -%;#0?' ;#) > $%0'4 -';#) 2#-' ' ;#) /) *'//% *)(/%4 BD9 E'-%F0%3 )/2%/ -#%/ ('+G)/ -) .)#/ (,' /,'

*)4$#2HF)0/ )(24) /0 (% &'(/24#+,' -' %45#$)(2' %(/)?$0%('9 .%/ -#%/ ('+G)/$)(&0'(%-%/3 /A * 40$)04% > %-);#%-% %' %45#$)(2'9 :'4;#


8/13

!"#$"% '()*('+ ,+- -./0+-1 2"34# .!5*- " .3"%6$# 7.',+-+ 87##439:;1

!"#$%&'"#( *"+,-+. " % /01"&-+1%1"2 3$'%# 10 405678+01 !69?"9 7#%6


9/13

!"#$"% '()*('+ ,+- -./0+-1 2"34# .!5*- " .3"%6$# 7.',+-+ 87##439:;1

!"#$%&'"#( *"+,-+. " % /01"&-+1%1"2 3$'%# 10 405678+01 !69?"9 7#%6


10/13

!"#$"% '()*('+ ,+- -./0+-1 2"34# .!5*- " .3"%6$# 7.',+-+ 87##439:;1

!"#$%&'"#( *"+,-+. " % /01"&-+1%1"2 3$'%# 10 405678+01 !69?"9 7#%6 J&01& 3'0,5 ' &./012(3/' $%&9/)%A' 3, ; B'A1/A -'H5 (+, @'/)A'(-& B'00, B'A' ' @%7(&A'N/7/8'*+, -' &./012(3/' 6 3,(1A'A/&-'-& -,0 @'7,A&05

-/0B,(-,O0& ' 0/)(/9/3'A 1'(1, %

4&%0 (+, 0& -/01/()%/AE5 B,A1'(1,5 '1A'@M0 -& '7)%

== Y=U

Z-> (>[>=X

L\%&L !"#$

3>Z]Q ]5 B> =#5"">"^O"[>


11/13

!"#$"% '()*('+ ,+- -./0+-1 2"34# .!5*- " .3"%6$# 7.',+-+ 87##439:;1

!"#$%&'"#( *"+,-+. " % /01"&-+1%1"2 3$'%# 10 405678+01 !69?"9 7#%664%&'$ (&0%+4/(&$ F) -% 5(2'$) 64 K6LM$ -% %./0'1&2/( $4&/4$-(4%&'% &%2%00C,/( (2%,2( -% N%60;

=-4/'/&-$ E6% ( 2$&2+603$ -$ (,>64%&'$ 2(,'%0/(&$ &3$ -/5%,% -( -$ (,>64%&'$

(&0%+4/(&$ E6(&'$ R (5/,4(73$ -% 64( %./0'1&2/( 4(./4(4%&'% &%2%00C,/() ,%0'(

0(D%, 0%) 8(,( (+F4 -$ 2$&'%Q-$ -( 2$&2+603$) $0 -$/0 (,>64%&'$0 /&2+6%4

(+>64( ,(M3$ %0',6'6,(&'% % -%2/0/*( 8(,( 0%,%4 -%0/>&(-$0 -% S$&'$+:>/2$0S;

L: +9 B46$MNB6#9 3# =4OPC"$A#

= (&C+/0% -$ (,>64%&'$ $&'$+:>/2$ 2%&',(T0% I(D/'6(+4%&'% $6 &( &$73$-% N%60 $6 &( &$73$ -% %./0'1&2/() 5(M%&-$ -% (4D(0 (0 &$79%0) (0 8%7(0

-%2/0/*(0 &( 2$&0',673$ -$ (,>64%&'$; #3$ 56>/4$0 R ,%>,() ,%*/0/'(&-$ %00%0

':8/2$0; #$ %&'(&'$) K6+>(4$0 E6% IC 64( 8%7() 0%&3$ 4(/0 56&-(4%&'(+) 8%+$

4%&$0 />6(+4%&'% -%'%,4/&(&'% &( 2$&0',673$ -$ (,>64%&'$ $&'$+:>/2$? $0

8,/&2L8/$0 E6% 4%-%/(4 %&',% ( 2$&2%873$ -% N%60 % ( 8,%-/2(73$ -% %. /0 '1&2/( ;U4 */,'6-% -%00%0 8,/&2L8/$0) $ (,>64%&'$ $&'$+:>/2$ &3$ 0% ,%-6M ( 64(

/&5%,1&2/( /4%-/('( -( %./0'1&2/( ( 8(,'/, -% 64 2$&2%/'$;

= *%,03$ 2(,'%0/(&( 8$-% ('F 06>%,/, E6% $ (,>64%&'$ $&'$+:>/2$ 0%K( 64(

/&5%,1&2/( -/,%2'( -( %./0'1&2/( ( 8(,'/, -( /-%/( -% N%60) 4(0 &%4 8$, /00$

N%02(,'%0 -%/.( -% /&*$2(,) 8%+$ 4%&$0) 64 8,/&2L8/$ -% %*/-1&2/( 2$464 R2$&0',673$ -% '$-( % E6(+E6%, 8,$*(? $ 8,/&2L8/$ -( 2+(,%M( % -/0'/&73$ GV;

W%>6&-$ %0'% 8,/&2L8/$) &3$ 0% -%*% 2$&2%-%, &(-( E6% &3$ 8$00( 0%, 8%&0(-$

2$4 ( 5$,7( 8%,06(0/*( -( 2+(,%M( % -( -/0'/&73$; 6+$ 2$4$ (

%./0'1&2/( '(4DF4 -%4$&0',C*%+ -% N%60; W: E6% N%02(,'%0 &3$ %08%2/5/2() %4

GH

S=+/6- %&/4 %0' ,%4 %00% /&'%++%2'6) (+/6- /&'%++/>%,% ,%4 %00%; #(4 264 8/2'$, 8,(%2$>/'(' E6(%

5(2'6,60 %0') I(D%' E6/-%4 /& /&'%++%2'6) 0%- &$&-64 /&'%++/>/' %00% E6$- &$&-64 5%2/';


12/13

!"#$"% '()*('+ ,+- -./0+-1 2"34# .!5*- " .3"%6$# 7.',+-+ 87##439:;1

!"#$%&'"#( *"+,-+. " % /01"&-+1%1"2 3$'%# 10 405678+01 !69?"9 7#%6(,-&)1(, (54(.9&B,(

5&2, (5 1(+)2:&) & +)20(5 ( & C.*+'( *&, 2*(2&, $%( 1+5& 4+) 2))(-%,/D(2,3 4('+

4)2.-C42+ *& -'&)(:& ( *2,12.67+3 *+ $%( (5 *2'%-2*&) +, 4&,,+, $%( 5(*(2&5 (.1)(

(,,&, 2*(2&, ( &, -+.,($%=.-2&, $%( *('&, &,,%5(3 -+5+ &-+.1(-(3 (5 (,4(-2&'3 .+&)0%5(.1+ *& EF%2.1& G(*21&67+E#HA

I,,25 .7+ &-+.1(-(3 4+)J53 .+ &)0%5(.1+ *+ !"#$%#&'#() .+ $%&' ,7+((%,3 .+ ,#() --AeBef3 &,,25 -+5+ & &?2)5&67+ *& (1().2*&*( *( >(%, -+5 8&,( .& *(5+.,1)&67+ *&

2.1(54+)&'2*&*( *& D()*&*(3 .+ ,#() --AgfeeeBggef ( (5 12 32"'4542) -A'3 geee h1(?"@ #3 c&)2,3 U()?3 "PHb3 44A "@b3 "P@B"PPiA#P

EN2 (.25 D(' 2. ,+'+ 2.1(''(-1% (,1 Y2* $%+ 5&2%, -+021&)2 .($%21Z3 4+1(,1 -+021&)2 (,,( (1 2. )(3 $%+* 5&2%,

(,1AE !") -AeeQ e3 4A "T"3 ""A"bB"@AST

E L&5 4+1(,1 -+021&)2 (,,( &'2$%2*3 $%+* .+. 4+,,21 -+021&)2 .+. (,,(Q $%+* 5&2%, (,1 $%&5 $%+* .+.

(,,( -+021&)2 4+1(,1AE !") .+///A e3 "T#3 ""AbBHA


13/13

!"#$"% '()*('+ ,+- -./0+-1 2"34# .!5*- " .3"%6$# 7.',+-+ 87##439:;1

!"#$%&'"#( *"+,-+. " % /01"&-+1%1"2 3$'%# 10 405678+01 !69?"9 7#%6'2.69*20*7 3%9% 0.'&

$%& '()*& * +' &$%& '()*& &;% 3%9*2& -,45* '& 2. ?.&* +* -9. 2%(;% 3%9-9 2;%

*:-

Documents

Descartes e Santo Anselmo O Argumento On