18
March 2013 Genua © Don’t snob the PIIGS! “Bull markets are born on pessimism, grow on skepticism, mature on optimism and die on euphoria” … Sir John Templeton - 50 100 150 200 250 3/15/2004 3/15/2005 3/15/2006 3/15/2007 3/15/2008 3/15/2009 3/15/2010 3/15/2011 3/15/2012 Portugal Italy Ireland Greece Spain

Don’t snob the piigs!

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  1. 1. Dont snob the PIIGS! Bull markets are born on pessimism, grow on skepticism, mature on optimism and die on euphoria Sir John Templeton PortugalItaly IrelandGreece Spain 250 200 150 10050 - 3/15/2004 3/15/2005 3/15/2006 3/15/2007 3/15/2008 3/15/2009 3/15/2010 3/15/2011 3/15/2012March 2013Genua
  2. 2. Introduction . Europes sovereign debt crisis has been the center of all attention for the past 3 years and has been very severe due to poor political governance/management. Instead of doing the best for their countries, they do the best for theirown political carriers... pathetic! . As a result, economies in the Euro zone remain troubled and austerity measures are negatively impacting growth . However, cosmetic measures taken by Draghi and the creation of the European Stability Mechanism (ESM) have had a surprisingly positive effect, CDS levels and - by ricochet - bond yields have fallen drastically. Thank you Super Mario! Unlimited help was the trick ;-) In addition to words, hedge funds had to liquidate naked long CDS positions (naked longs = being long without the underlying) + short bans on stocks were introduced for example for the Ibex futures. Regulation seems to have effect! . Now that the hedge funds have stopped fooling with the PIIGS, and have/are gradually increas-ed/ing their LONG exposure to them Risk-ON folks! Moreover, a lot of cash is sitting on the sidelines ready to be deployed. The Dax and the S&P are at record highs. I believe that money will flow out of more mature stock markets into the PIIGS + rotations from bonds to equities. . Yields have gone back to more tolerable/supportable levels helping also budget deficits a bit. . Although most of European countries are currently in recession, expansion is just a matter of month now according to IMF projections and political leaders are currently working hard on measures to boost domestic economies.March 2013Genua 2/18
  3. 3. Conclusion . All these markets are in oversold territory, abandoned by feared investors . PIIGS stock markets have substantial upside after being killed/slashed/shorted/destroyed . Multi billion bailout programs offers sort of immunity for struggling economies . Negative media attention has disappeared. Their focus is on sink-holes, asteroids and meteors currently . After 15478 credit rating downgrades by the big 3 in the past 3 years, we will start to get credit rating upgrades!! . PIIGS offer good value especially after recent drop. I dont believe that its a value trap. . What goes around comes around. Everything always goes back to normal/mean. Ok, sometimes it takes a bit more time than we think! . I believe that even the worst of the worst-case scenarios is priced into these markets. For the pas 3 years we have heard everything about Greece. Going back to Drachmes, selling Mykonos island, replacing mozzarella in pizzas with feta, etc . I am bullish PIIGS but not necessarily bullish on the EUR currency, I favor the USD the dominant reserve currency. . Bottom-line: recent pull-back offers great opportunity to go long. Investment horizon : long term!March 2013Genua 3/18
  4. 4. 4/18Genua March 2013 204080 100 120 60 0 1/15/2010 2/15/2010 3/15/2010 4/15/2010 5/15/2010 6/15/2010 7/15/2010 Source: google trends, Genua 8/15/2010 9/15/2010 10/15/2010 11/15/2010 12/15/2010 1/15/2011 2/15/2011 3/15/2011 4/15/2011 5/15/2011 6/15/2011 7/15/2011 8/15/2011 9/15/2011 10/15/2011 11/15/2011 12/15/2011 1/15/2012 2/15/2012 3/15/2012 4/15/2012 5/15/2012 6/15/2012 7/15/2012the Google search bar 8/15/2012 9/15/2012debt crisis was punched-inNumber of times European According to Google (trends) searches, the crisis is over, for now! 10/15/2012 11/15/2012 12/15/2012European debt crisis (100=maximum searches) 1/15/2013 2/15/2013
  5. 5. Bailout programs for EU members (since 2008) Financial Support Instruments. Weapons for stability! Latest European casualty Cyprus should get 17Bn bailout in the coming days/hoursEFSM -EFSF - ESM -European European BoP - balance GLF (greekEuropean BailoutIN BN Time spanIMFWorld Bank EIB / EBRD Bilateralism Financial Financialof payments loan facility)Stabilitytotal Stabilisation Stability MechanismMechanism Facility2013-01-15Jan.2013-Cyprus negociations --- -- - - negociations negociations Dec.2015 2010-05-01May 2010- 48.1Greece--- -52.9- 144.6- 245.62 Mar.2016 (20.1+19.8+8.2) 2008-11-01Nov.2008-9.15.515.6Hungary 1--- - -- Oct.2010 out of 12.5 out of 6.5out of 20.03 2010-11-01Nov.2010-Ireland22.5 -- 4.8-- 22.517.7 - 67.54 Dec.2013 2008-12-01Dec.2008-1.10.0 2.94.5Latvia 0.40.1- - -- Dec.2011out of 1.7 out of 2.2out of 3.1 out of 7.55 2011-05-01May 2011-Portugal26--- --2626- 78May 2014 2009-05-01May 2009- 12.6 19.6Romania 11- 5- - --June 2011out of 13.6out of 20.66 2011-03-01Mar 2011-0.00.0 0.0Romania II---- - --Mar 2013 out of 3.7 out of 1.4out of 5.17 2012-07-23July 2012- 41.4 41.4Spain---- -- - - Dec.2013 out of 100out of 1008 2013-02-01Perhaps inSpainnegociations --- -- - - negociations negociations2013Total Nov.2008-Mar.2016 119.42.41.14.813.4 52.948.5188.341.4472.2Source: wikipedia, IMF, WB, EIBMarch 2013Genua 5/18
  6. 6. CDS - Credit Default SwapsSpreads Back down to more tolerable levels. Spreads could keep falling 1600Greek CDS (!)Portugal 14002510020100 12001510010100 10005100100 Jan-09Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12 Jan-13800 Ireland600400 SpainItaly200Can go lower0March 2013Genua Source: Bloomberg, Genua6/18
  7. 7. 7/18Genua March 2013 0 5 10 1520 2530 35403/2/20075/2/2007 10 12 14 16024867/2/20079/2/2007 11/2/20071/2/2008 Source: Bloomberg, Genua3/2/20085/2/20087/2/20089/2/2008 11/2/20081/2/2009 Near to death experienced!3/2/2009Irish 8Y Yields (10Y N/A)5/2/20097/2/20099/2/200910 Year Bond Yields (%) 11/2/20091/2/20103/2/20105/2/20107/2/20109/2/2010 11/2/20101/2/20113/2/2011ItalyIreland5/2/20117/2/20119/2/2011 11/2/20111/2/20123/2/2012Greece5/2/2012 Spain7/2/20129/2/2012Portugal 11/2/20121/2/2013 Can go lower
  8. 8. Debt/GDP Ratios (%)Super high but will not go much higher - now that it is taken care of () 180 160 Greece Except for Greece, most of 140 the PIIGS experienced similar debt/GDP levels in the 90s Italy 120 100 Ireland80 Portugal60 Spain4020 0Source: IMF, GenuaMarch 2013Genua 8/18
  9. 9. Real GDP (%)Past, present and future 12 IMF projections 10 Portugal Ireland86 Spain42Italy0 -2 -4 -6Greece -8 Source: IMF, GenuaMarch 2013Genua 9/18
  10. 10. 10/18Genua -30-20 -10 01020 30March 2013 2005-M01 2005-M03 2005-M05 2005-M07 2005-M09Portugal 2005-M11 Source: IMF, Genua 2006-M01 2006-M03 2006-M05 2006-M07 2006-M09 2006-M11 2007-M01 2007-M03 2007-M05 2007-M07 2007-M09Ireland 2007-M11 2008-M01 2008-M03 2008-M05 2008-M07 2008-M09 2008-M11 Spain 2009-M01 2009-M03 2009-M05 2009-M07Industrial Production (% MoM)Room for improvment. Weaker Euro = trigger? 2009-M09 2009-M11 Italy 2010-M01 2010-M03 2010-M05 2010-M07 2010-M09 2010-M11 2011-M01 2011-M03 Greece 2011-M05 2011-M07 2011-M09 2011-M11 2012-M01 2012-M03 2012-M05 2012-M07 2012-M09 Improving 2012-M11
  11. 11. Unemployment rate (%)Poised to drop.30 These levels are scary butIMF projections should start to reverse course now Governments25 have to do something. Spain20Greece15Ireland10Italy 5Portugal 0 Source: IMF, GenuaMarch 2013Genua 11/18
  12. 12. PIIGS Stock Index levels (100=March 2004)Very interesting asymmetry after 5 bear years! Room for improvement! 250Greece 200 Spain 150 Italy 100Portugal50Ireland-3/15/2004 3/15/2005 3/15/2006 3/15/2007 3/15/2008 3/15/2009 3/15/2010 3/15/2011 3/15/2012 Source: Bloomberg, GenuaMarch 2013Genua 12/18
  13. 13. PIIGS Cycle of Market EmotionsOptimism is on its way We are here Source: GenuaMarch 2013Genua 13/18
  14. 14. PIIGS In figuresValuations are ok for now my view is that earnings will go up sharply when growth comes back Perf. Since Perf. Since Current eP/E 2013eP/E 2014 Current 2Y Current 5yS&P Credit Summer 12 2007 highs10y yieldsCDS levels(x)(x)yields (%) yields (%)ratinglows (%)(%)(%)Portugal 37-5616.16 12.213.24 5.466.24 BB 380.1Ireland29.5-6119.18 14.411.48 2.896.61 BBB+ 164.3Italy29.6-6510.83 8.91 1.893.54.63 BBB+ 277.2Greece 66.3-8223.410.49 164 58.35 11.27B- 23572Spain41.5-4711.75 10.082.43 3.814.99BBB-266.9Germany29.7-2.5 11.64 10.270.033 0.41.394 AAA37.4as of March 05.03.2013 Source: MarketMap, Bloomber, Boursorama, S&PMarch 2013Genua 14/18
  15. 15. PIIGS S&P Credit ratingsRise from the grave?March 2013Genua 15/18
  16. 16. European politicsWhat to watch in 2013 Source: Deutsche Bank,March 2013Genua 16/18
  17. 17. Interested in this exciting theme? Contact us [email protected] are launching a solution to invest in this theme. On the PIIGS in EUR.Index linked. Equal-weighted.March 2013Genua 17/18
  18. 18. Bonus TextDisclaimer Important information: This document is for general informative purpose only and is not considered as a financial analysis regarding the SBA Directives aiming to guarantee the financial analysis independence. As a consequence, the principles contained in these Directives do not apply to this document or its content. This document does not constitute an offer or solicitation to purchase or sell any investment products mentioned herein. It is not intended for distribution, publication, or use in any jurisdiction where such distribution, publication or use would be unlawful, nor it is directed to any person or entity to which it would be unlawful to direct such a document. Genua Advisors is available upon request for additional information regarding offering and selling restrictions. In particular, such restrictions apply for US persons and/or activity directed to the USA. The opinions herein do not take into account individual clients circumstances, objectives or needs. In particular, structured products, derivatives or alternative investments are to be considered as complex financial instruments which might involve important level of risk such as but not limited to: credit risk, currency risk (changes in the rate of exchange may also cause the value of the investment to go up and down), political risk and markets risk. Upon request, Genua Advisors is available to provide additional information to clients on risks associated with specific investments. The information and analysis contained herein have been based on sources believed to be reliable. However, this information has not been independently verified. Therefore, no guaranty, representation or warranty (implied or express) can be accepted about their timeliness, accuracy, or completeness. Genua Advisors does not accept any liability whatsoever for any direct or indirect loss or damage resulting from the use of the present document or its content. Genua Advisors may have published or publish in the future similar documents whose information could be inconsistent with the information presented in the present document. Genua Advisors may stop at its initiative producing or updating this document. All information (including prices, performance) and opinions are subject to change without notice. Past performances, whether actual or back-tested, are not necessarily indicative of future performance. Shares valuation and any income generated from them can increase as well as decrease and are not guaranteed in any way. The financial products potentially mentioned in this document can fluctuate in value and may be subject to sudden and large falls that could equal the amount invested. Genua Advisors may from time to time, on its own behalf or on behalf of third parties, engage in transactions in the financial instrument(s) described herein, take positions with, perform or seek to perform or receive investment banking or other services. All rights reserved. No element of this publication can be copied, memorized electronically or transferred by any means, whether mechanically or electronically without the prior written consent of Genua Advisors. Genua AdvisorsMarch 2013Genua 18/18