February 23, 2009 Issue

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/14/2019 February 23, 2009 Issue

    1/12

    www.browndailherald.com 195 Angell Street, Providence, Rhode Island [email protected]

    News.....1-4Arts........5-6Sports...7-8Editorial..10Opinion...11Today........12

    Saving grace

    Nicole Stock 09 broke

    her own saves record in a

    season-ending win.

    Sports, 7

    Staging conflict

    Gever/Shebab brings

    Israel-Palestine conflict

    to the stage.

    Arts, 5

    money matterS

    Simon Liebling 12 wants the

    Universit to freeze tuition

    and tap the endowment.

    Opinions, 11

    inside

    Daily Heraldthe Brown

    vol. cxliv, no. 22 | Monday, February 23, 2009 | Serving the community daily since 1891

    Corporation deepens cuts; U. to keep building

    By chaz KelSh and

    Jenna StarK

    News editors

    Predicting a slow recovery or

    the endowment, the Corporation

    ocused this weekends meeting

    on long-term plans to reduce the

    Universitys budget by about $90

    million over the next ve years,

    and revised ambitious plans ortwo major capital projects so they

    could begin even during a period

    o economic recession.

    The Universitys highest gov-

    erning body deepened budget cuts

    recommended by President Ruth

    Simmons both or this year and or

    uture scal years but attempted to

    maintain academic priorities and a

    commitment to nancial aid. It said

    two high-priority projects a Medi-

    cal Education Building and a brain

    sciences building, would likely be

    addressed through renovations o

    existing buildings instead.

    It also granted nal approval

    or two other projects, the renova-tion o Faunce House and a new

    Creative Arts Center, to begin this

    summer.

    This is the rst meeting I re-

    member since Ive been at Brown

    where so much has been debated

    and changed, Simmons said in an

    interview Sunday.

    In an e-mail to the Brown com-

    munity in January, Simmons set a

    ramework or sustaining the Uni-

    versitys nancial situation that

    included reezing most salaries,

    postponing the expansion o the

    Graduate School and proposing to

    reduce next years budget by $4.5million and cutting roughly $60 mil-

    lion in planned budget increases

    by 2014.

    But the Corporation decided to

    take more drastic measures to pre-

    serve the health o the Universitys

    endowment and nancial stability,

    moving to increase budget cuts or

    the 2010 scal year rom $4.5 mil-

    lion to $6 million, and aiming to cut

    as much as $90 million rom the

    projected budget or 2014.

    Simmons also announced or the

    rst time in an e-mail to the Brown

    community on Saturday that the

    University plans to cut some cur-

    rent administrative and sta em-

    ployees jobs to help reduce the

    budget.

    Targeted position elimina-

    tions will be enacted in the coming

    months to help achieve this goal,

    Simmons wrote. While some will

    come rom existing vacancies made

    permanent, some administrative

    and sta positions will unortu-

    nately have to be eliminated.

    The meeting was enormously

    engaged and in some respects so-

    bering, said Chancellor Thomas

    Tisch 76, Browns highest ocerand the Corporations leader.

    There was an attempt to strike

    Bn scnc, M Schbungs w b nvtnsBy Brigitta greene

    seNiorstaffwriter

    Facing a dicult economic climate,

    the Corporation scaled back plans

    this weekend or two major aca-

    demic projects a planned Medi-cal Education Center and a brain

    science building saying those

    projects would likely involve renova-

    tions o existing buildings instead o

    new structures and would proceed

    sooner rather than later.

    The Corporation also gave nal

    approval or construction o the

    new Creative Arts Center and the

    renovation o Faunce House into

    a new campus center, which will

    begin this summer.

    In scrapping the original plans

    or the two buildings, one a cen-

    terpiece o a $100 million git to

    the Alpert Medical School and theother an ambitious building that

    was supposed to be built along The

    Walk, the Corporation appeared to

    strike a solution that allowed it to

    push ahead with important aca-

    demic priorities while navigating

    new nancial obstacles to campus

    expansion.

    We thought very hard about

    the consequences o putting every-

    thing on hold, President Ruth Sim-mons said in an interview Sunday,

    but the Corporation deemed it not

    sensible to do so.

    The cost o renovating an old

    building is about one-hal to two-

    thirds o building new, said Richard

    Spies, executive vice president or

    planning and senior advisor to the

    president. He said the University

    rst began exploring renovation in

    early January, when it became clear

    that the economic crisis would have

    a long-term eect on the Univer-

    sitys nances.

    We havent just given up our

    goals thats the other way to savemoney, he said. The whole idea

    has been to ocus our resources to

    BDS -k By Sydney emBer

    seNiorstaffwriter

    Managers or BuDS, the student

    employment arm o Dining Services,

    have introduced a new no-homework

    policy or many on-duty workers, a

    provision that was rst presented

    to students in their contracts earlier

    this month.

    The new policy, which ormally

    prohibits all non-cashier workers,

    and cashiers in the Blue Room, rom

    doing homework on the job, has re-

    sulted in some workers reusing to

    sign their annual contracts.

    We elt a ormal warning sent

    a message that this is important,

    said Cindy Swain 09, a ormer BuDS

    general manager who introduced

    the ormal policy with current BuDS

    general manager Alex Hartley 10. It

    makes sense that people are talking

    about it because it aects a lot o

    people.

    Workers have reportedly re-

    sponded with a petition, though

    Swain said no one has presented

    the petition to her or Hartley yet.

    People are going to have knee-jerk

    reactions, she said. We cant do

    anything about it until they come

    to us.

    Though the no-homework policy

    previously existed as an inormal

    rule or most workers, putting the

    policy in the contracts rather than

    just adding it to the new version o

    the handbook was aster in terms o

    getting the word out, Swain said.

    We basically wanted some-

    thing physical in peoples hands,

    Swain said. We wanted people to

    Bq bk kBy Sydney emBer

    seNiorstaffwriter

    Construction on a new aquatics cen-ter may begin as early as this sum-

    mer, ater a large bequest breathed

    resh lie into a project that appeared

    likely to be shelved by the economic

    downturn.

    Approval or designs to proceed

    on the project came this weekend, as

    the Corporation ocially accepted

    $14.75 million rom the estate o Ray-

    mond Moran 41 in the name o his

    late sister.

    That amount is enough to und

    more than hal the project, accord-

    ing to Ronald Vanden Dorpel MA71,

    senior vice president or University

    advancement. Under Browns cur-rent guidelines, nal approval or the

    project can come once the Moran

    Kim Perle / Herald

    A new BuDS polic bans homework for man workers.

    Predicts slow rebound forstruggling endowment

    Courtes of Brown Universit

    A rendering of the Stephen Robert 62 Campus Center in Faunce House, one of the projects that will proceed.

    $60 Original proposed

    reductions to planned

    spending b 2014

    $90 New goal for 5-ear

    reductions (est.)

    $6 Spending cuts for next

    ears budget, up from

    $4.5 million

    n nbs

    continued onpage 3 continued onpage 3 continued onpage 3

    continued onpage 4

    S jb, S

    were in BuSineSS

    A new partnership helps

    Brown fill a business

    education void.

    Editorial, 10

  • 8/14/2019 February 23, 2009 Issue

    2/12

    sudoku

    Stephen DeLucia, President

    Michael Bechek, Vice President

    Jonathan Spector, Treasurer

    Alexander Hughes, Secretary

    The Brown Daily Herald (USPS 067.740) is an independent newspaper serv-ing the Brown University community daily since 1891. It is published Mondaythrough Friday during the academic year, excluding vacations, once duringCommencement, once during Orientation and once in July by The Brown DailyHerald, Inc. POSTMASTERplease send corrections to P.O. Box 2538, Provi-dence, RI 02906. Periodicals postage paid at Providence, R.I. Oces are locatedat 195 Angell St., Providence, R.I. E-mail [email protected] Wide Web: http://www.browndailyherald.com.Subscription prices: $319 one year daily, $139 one semester daily.Copyright 2009 by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. All rights reserved.

    e P: 401.351.3372 | Bsss P: 401.351.3260

    Daily Heraldthe Brown

    MONDAy, FEBRUARy 23, 2009THE BROWN DAILy HERALDPAGE 2

    CS wS I love the fact that Im training a new generation of journalists. Visiting Professor of English Trac BretonK By Sarah Julian

    CoNtributiNgwriter

    Put on your pretty lies, youre in thecity o wonder. Aint gonna play nice,

    watch out you might just go under,

    sang Pitch Slapped, in its cover o

    Rihannas Disturbia, to a packed

    Salomon 101 last Saturday night. The

    group rom Berklee College o Music

    won the Northeast quarternals in

    this years International Champion-

    ship o Collegiate A Cappella, hosted

    by Browns Higher Keys.

    Brown students, as well as riends

    and amily o perormers rom Har-

    vard, Boston University, New York

    University, Northeastern University

    and University o Maine, Orono,

    gathered to watch the ve a cappellagroups compete in the 14th annual

    competition. The rst runners-up in

    the competition were the Opportunes

    o Harvard College, with the Maine

    Steiners o the University o Maine,

    Orono as second runners-up. The

    top two groups Pitch Slapped and

    the Opportunes will advance to

    the seminal round o the Northeast

    region on March 21.

    The men and women o Pitch

    Slapped sang Gravity by Sara Ba-

    reilles and Dont Stop the Music by

    Rihanna, along with the crowd-pleas-

    ing Disturbia. Cate Wright won the

    award or outstanding solo.

    The coed Opportunes, dressed all

    in black with suits or the men and

    dresses and heels or the women,

    sang Lady Marmalade and James

    Taylors Fire and Rain. Fire and

    Rain won the outstanding arrange-

    ment award o the night. The group

    also sang a medley o songs including

    parts o Michael Jacksons Beat It

    and Smooth Criminal.

    b, By Ben SchrecKingerseNiorstaffwriter

    Its almost a cliche or aspiring stand-

    up comedians and rock stars to hear,

    Dont quit your day job. But some

    Brown proessors have also taken this

    advice to heart.

    Despite their ully-booked days,

    these aculty members nd satisac-

    tion in both teaching and pursuing

    proessional careers.

    Teaching doesnt leave me with

    a lot o the spare time that I used to

    have, said Tracy Breton, a visiting

    proessor o English who has workedas an investigative reporter at the

    Providence Journal since 1973. She

    added that time spent in the classroom

    makes up only a raction o the time

    she spends on her teaching job.

    Breton, who won a Pulitzer prize

    in 1994 or her investigation o cor-

    ruption in the Rhode Island courts,

    began teaching at Brown in 1997.

    She currently teaches two sections

    o ENGL0160: Journalistic Writing

    in the all, ENGL1160A: Advanced

    Feature Writing in the spring and a

    three-week course in Browns pre-col-

    lege summer program. This year, she

    is also one seniors thesis adviser.

    Despite their busy schedules, pro-

    essors said they do not eel as i one

    job suers because o the other. Just

    the opposite, and I cant quite explain

    why, said Visiting Lecturer in English

    Tom Mooney. Mooney, who has been

    a reporter or the ProJo since 1986,

    said he has been teaching the spring

    section o Journalistic Writing or

    ve years.

    I dont think Id have the energy

    to do it year-round, Mooney said.

    But he said his productivity increases

    when working both jobs. I you want

    something done, ask a busy person

    to do it, he said. When gradua-

    tion rolls around, I become a slug

    in comparison.

    The proessors said their outside

    careers improved their teaching, and

    vice versa.

    Im oten using the real-lie experi-

    ences that Im living at that moment to

    teach, Mooney said. He said he be-

    lieves he was hired partly because Im

    really down in the trenches instead o

    sitting up in an ivory tower.

    Mooney said teaching has allowed

    him to look dierently at the practice

    o journalism. Earlier this semester,

    he was writing a piece about a veter-

    ans advocate who had gone to jail 30

    years ago or killing a man. Mooneysaid he elt rustration and conu-

    sion about how I was going to tell

    this story.

    When Mooney told his class

    about the story, he raised the ques-

    tion, Can a man ever be orgiven

    or taking a lie? Mooney even-

    tually began his article with that

    exact question.

    Breton said she appreciates the

    job security o teaching during the

    ongoing economic downturn. Daily

    newspapers have been hit especially

    hard, she said, and the ProJo hasbeen orced to lay o reporters in

    recent months.

    Though some established report-

    ers are losing their jobs, Bretons stu-

    dents still have been able to nd jobs

    in journalism, she said. Newspapers

    may be cutting costs by hiring recent

    graduates with shorter contracts, she

    said, instead o continuing to pay a

    premium or their more experienced

    counterparts.

    Sarah Fox 89 said she is en-

    ergized by teaching GNSS0090C:

    Reproductive Health: Science and

    Politics. Fox is an obstetrician-gyne-

    cologist at Women & Inants Hospital

    and teaches at the Alpert Medical

    School. This year is her rst teaching

    undergraduates, she said.

    My lie is much more busy right

    now, said Fox, who added that her

    work has begun to spill over into

    nights and weekends. But she at-

    tributed much o the added stress to

    a learning curve. I have a sense that

    the next year that I teach, it will be

    pretty reasonable, she said.

    Her students bring a diversity o

    views, Fox said, that makes the extra

    work ullling.

    The proessors said they struggle

    to pick avorites between teaching andtheir outside careers. I think I like

    the doing more than the teaching,

    Mooney said. Thats a tough ques-

    tion because they both have their own

    rewards. He said teaching allows him

    to appreciate just how much he learns

    by practicing journalism. Both jobs

    get you outside your comort zone a

    little bit, he said.

    I love the act that Im training a

    new generation o journalists, Breton

    said. The Providence Journal is a

    pretty stressul place to work right

    now, she said, but I still get a news

    high rom doing a good story.

    The proessors said they plan to

    maintain a mix o teaching and practic-

    ing. I sort o like the mix, Fox said.

    I dont know i Id want to change the

    proportions.

    Right now, Im really enjoying

    the undergraduate course, I have to

    admit, she said.

    I dont ever see mysel giving up

    the teaching, Breton said. I have no

    idea how much longer Ill stay in daily

    journalism, given the newspaper in-

    dustrys uncertainty. Still, Breton said

    she plans to continue practicing some

    orm o journalism or the oreseeable

    uture.

    And as or Mooney I hope to

    keep doing both until I drop.

    CDC By Jeremy JacoB

    CoNtributiNgwriter

    A brightly colored dialogue box

    popped onto a screen in addition to

    the two that were already present.

    Caroline Chiang, assistant direc-

    tor o the Career Development

    Center, quickly responded to the

    new conversation, handling three

    at once.

    Each o the chat boxes rep-

    resented a student with a virtual

    question or a career counselor.

    The CDCs new service, IM walk-

    in hours, gives students a chance

    to talk over the Internet with ca-

    reer counselors in real-time.Customer service is our high-

    est priority, Chiang said.

    The walk-in hours, or which

    students to sign in to chat via

    Google accounts, debuted in Janu-

    ary, said CDC Assistant Director

    Kerry Feather.

    We are trying to reach stu-

    dents where they are. For some

    people, walk-in hours are ne; or

    other students a quick question is

    good, Feather said. We (now)

    oer both.

    The IM walk-in hours began

    ater a successul two-day pilot pro-

    gram over winter break, Feather

    said. Ater conducting a surveyo participants, the CDC settled

    on regular IM walk-in hours on

    Friday rom 1 p.m. to 3 p.m., tak-

    ing the place o traditional walk-in

    hours, which are oered Monday

    through Thursday at the same

    time.

    Feather said the program,

    which has run each Friday since

    the start o the semester, has been

    very successul. She estimated

    that in each o the last coupleo sessions, the Center has re-

    ceived approximately 20 students

    with questions.

    I think the word is really get-

    ting out, Chiang said.

    To use the program, students

    must either create or sign into a

    Google account and invite a CDC

    e-mail address to chat.

    When students log on and be-

    gin to chat, the message is directed

    to a counselor, Feather said. I the

    service experiences an uptick in

    trac, an additional counselor can

    be brought in to acilitate.

    Theres been no wait time,Feather said.

    Chiang said the conversations

    last or about 10 to 15 minutes. I

    the question is dicult to answer

    online, the counselor will suggest

    an in-person appointment.

    Feather said the oce hours

    are more helpul or students who

    have only quick questions, rather

    than those who need detailed cri-

    tiques o resumes.

    Questions like, Where do I get

    started looking or an internship?

    and, Can you look at my resume

    or my cover letter? tend to be

    asked requently, Chiang said.

    Because counselors are right at

    their computers, they can quickly

    do research to help answer a stu-

    dents question.

    Feather said the newly oered

    walk-in hours t into the CDCs e-

    orts to incorporate more technol-

    ogy into their services. In addition

    to the walk-in hours, the CDC will

    be debuting a new Web site in the

    coming weeks, Feather said.

    Hang Nguen / Herald

    A cappella groups from the Northeast performed in Salomon Saturda.

    continued onpage 4

    feature

  • 8/14/2019 February 23, 2009 Issue

    3/12

  • 8/14/2019 February 23, 2009 Issue

    4/12

    MONDAy, FEBRUARy 23, 2009THE BROWN DAILy HERALDPAGE 4

    CS wS Were not paing people to come and do homework. Sophie OConnell 09, Blue Room unit manager

    I was really proud o it, said

    Carolina Franch, a sophomoremember o the Opportunes. Were

    really pleased with how we did.

    There were a couple last-minute

    things we were tweaking, and it

    all turned out really well. Lady

    Marmalade was good and we got

    some good laughs, which was good.

    We even got laughs or Michael

    Jackson, and normally we kind o

    just get awws.

    The Steiners, who will not ad-

    vance to semi-nals, sang a ver-

    sion o Circle o Lie complete

    with monkey noises and intricate

    choreography which included

    the occasional jazz hands orwhich the group won the outstand-

    ing choreography award. Nathan

    Richard, the lead o the Steiners,

    said they had spent the majority o

    their time since January working

    on choreography.

    Other groups included the

    NHarmonics o NYU, Suno a

    South Asian and Western usion a

    cappella group rom BU and The

    Noreasters o Northeastern.

    Browns Higher Keys did not

    participate in the competition but

    opened and closed the show. Their

    songs included Owner o a Lonely

    Heart by Yes and a Michael Jack-

    son medley or which the group

    donned white gloves and Manjula

    Raman 11 moon-walked across

    the stage.

    Though the Higher Keys hosted

    the event last year as well, they

    have competed in previous years.

    Lorraine Fryer 09, a Higher Keys

    member, said she expects they will

    participate next year but added thatparticipating in the ICCA would re-

    quire a big time commitment on top

    o the six hours a week the group

    already practices.

    Some singers said competing

    can be an intense experience.

    Its denitely stressul, said

    Danielle Larocque, a member o the

    Noreasters. Theres, you know,

    extra time because its encouraged

    that you add choreography. Its a

    lot o pressure, you want to make

    sure you choose the right songs to

    give yourselves the opportunity to

    do the best you can.

    Even as hosts, the HigherKeys had to prepare or the

    tournament.

    There was a lot o publicity be-

    cause, you know, we want to give

    them a good audience to perorm

    to, said Kayla Ringelheim 11.

    The audience seemed to appre-

    ciate the eort o the a cappella

    groups and joined in at times with

    clapping or cheering. Especially

    popular was the impromptu beat-

    boxing competition held while the

    judges deliberated.

    Nandan Nath 09 said his avor-

    ite group was the Opportunes. Ev-

    erything was great, arrangement

    and song choice, everything. Theyhad the talent.

    Kara Kauman 12 said, The

    NYU second piece was amazing.

    They did a really long medley and

    we were blown away.

    know about it as quickly as pos-

    sible make sure they got the

    policy, understood it and understood

    the repercussions.

    Many managers said they are

    happy with the new policy.

    Were not paying people to

    come and do homework. Were pay-

    ing them to do work, said Sophie

    OConnell 09, unit manager at the

    Blue Room.

    The policy, she said, makes it

    easier or supervisors to monitor

    employees, now that it is actually

    in writing. But among her workers,

    OConnell said, there has generally

    been a good response to the policy.

    No ones directly come to me

    and complained about it, she said.

    For the workers who work behind

    the line, the homework policy didnt

    change anything.

    Though Swain said the restric-

    tion on homework never needed to

    be ormally written beore this year,

    growing concerns rom non-student

    proessional managers about con-

    tamination rom books and study

    materials, along with cases o de-

    creasing employee perormance,

    led the BuDS general managers to

    streamline the policy, she said.

    The policy was partially imple-

    mented because BuDS managers

    are trying to avoid cutting student

    jobs, she said, especially given the

    current economic situation. Peo-

    ple need jobs, she said. Were

    trying to not get pressure to cut

    peoples jobs.

    She added that she hoped the

    new policy would improve stu-

    dent productivity and reduce any

    complaints rom proessional

    managers that might jeopardize

    workers positions.

    The new policy also stemmed

    rom growing complaints rom unit

    managers that their workers were

    slacking o, Hartley said. As a re-

    sult, the new policy, which explicitly

    changes the policy or Blue Room

    cashiers and workers at The Gate

    catering prep workers were already

    subject to new homework restric-

    tions as o last all seeks to de-

    crease clutter in the workspace and

    alleviate the strain on coworkers.

    Hartley said workers requently

    had to compensate or coworkers

    shirking their duties in order to com-

    plete assignments or study.

    But most cashiers, who are still

    allowed to bring a book, paper and

    a writing utensil, have jobs that are

    directly related to customer fow,

    Swain said. Prohibiting these ca-

    shiers rom doing a limited amount

    o homework would be a slap in the

    ace since they sometimes get only a

    ew customers an hour, she said.

    We were limiting how much clut-

    ter could be at the register, Swain

    said. I cant think o a single register

    where theres enough space.

    Though many workers say they

    are unaected by the ormalization

    o the policy, Hartley said she was

    aware that there are a select ew

    who are upset. Most o these stu-

    dents work at the Gate, she said,

    where she was aware that many

    workers had books in the area used

    or ood preparation.

    But Laurie Schleimer 12, who

    prepares ood at the Gate and works

    as a utility cashier at the Ivy Room,

    said the policy tends not to aect

    many o the students who prepare

    ood, adding that there wouldnt

    be any chance or me to do work,

    anyway. She said the policy did not

    seem necessary.

    It seems like theyre being a bit

    ridiculous, she said. Its not like

    theyre going to whip out a book

    when theyre making alaels.

    -k BDS ,

    continued frompage 1

    LSBy dan alexander

    staffwriter

    Water rom a aulty pipe fooded

    the rst foor o the Sidney E.

    Frank Hall or Lie Sciences yes-

    terday morning, soaking drywall

    and carpeting, but destroying no

    research.

    Though the fooding spread to

    six labs, There was no compro-

    mise to any r esearch projects, pro-

    gramming and equipment, Direc-

    tor o BioMed Facilities Planning

    and Operations Peter Holden said.

    The damage was pretty much to

    the building itsel.

    Water covered 10,000 square

    eet o the rst foor ater the pipebroke in the core service area o

    the buildings east wing, Holden

    said. There were two to two-and-

    a-hal inches o water in the most

    aected spaces and one inch in

    outlying areas.

    The fooding began between

    7 a.m. and 8 a.m., when pressure

    caused the cap o a water line to

    fy o, Holden said. The cause

    o the pressure in the pipe is still

    unknown, but he said it was not

    related to yesterdays rain.

    The water started to ll the rst

    foor and touched a re alarm, caus-

    ing the alarm to go o.

    When acilities management re-sponded to the alarm, they ound

    no fames but inches o water in-

    stead. Director o Custodial Ser-

    vices Donna Butler and Director

    o Maintenance Services Jim Coen

    were among the rst at the site.

    Donna Butler and Jim Coen did

    a really great job o getting every-

    one on site ast, Holden said. Be-

    cause o their eort, we were able

    to get a situation cleaned up that

    could have been a lot worse.

    Butler and Coen could not be

    reached or comment.

    Facilities Management thencontacted Water Out, a company

    the University uses or str uctural

    drying. According to Holden, Wa-

    ter Out began drying the build-

    ing within two hours ater the

    fooding began.

    What a company like that

    allows us to do is get a quick re-

    sponse, a ast cleanup and mini-

    mize any damage to the building,

    Holden said.

    Holden said the cost o repairs

    to the ve-story science research

    building is unknown at this point.

    The water soaked into the dry-wall, so its hard to know, said As-

    sociate Dean or the Program in

    Biology Edward Hawrot.

    According to Hawrot, carpeting

    and drywall may have to be torn

    out and replaced.

    The ast response by acilities

    management prevented more seri-

    ous damage, Holden said. It could

    have been a lot worse.

    continued frompage 2

    S B

    Interested in Web design?

    J t h!

    Email [email protected] more information!

    Chris Bennett / Herald File Photo

    A leak pipe covered 10,000 square feet of the LiSci in water Sunda.

  • 8/14/2019 February 23, 2009 Issue

    5/12

  • 8/14/2019 February 23, 2009 Issue

    6/12

  • 8/14/2019 February 23, 2009 Issue

    7/12

    SportsondayMONDAy, FEBRUARy 23, 2009 | Page 7

    The Brown Dail Herald

    Sk k By andrew Braca

    sports editor

    The womens hockey team ended

    its season this weekend, capping the

    college careers o several players,

    including captain and goaltender

    Nicole Stock 09, who broke her

    own single-season saves record in

    the teams nal game, a 3-1 victory

    over Quinnipiac Saturday at Meehan

    Auditorium.

    It was a nice way to go out

    on Senior Day, said Head Coach

    Digit Murphy. The kids played

    hard. Ater all the losses weve had

    all season its nice to go out with

    a victory.

    The win over Quinnipiac ol-lowed a 3-0 loss to Princeton the

    previous day. The .500 weekend let

    the teams nal record at 7-21-1 and

    6-16-0 in ECAC Hockey, each two

    wins better than last season.

    All three o the teams seniors

    Stock, a Herald sports sta writer,

    Savannah Smith 09 and Frances

    Male 09 started both games to

    bring their careers to a close.

    B 3, Qp 1

    Saturday against Quinnipiac

    (3-26-5, 2-15-5 ECAC Hockey), the

    Bears brought a sometimes trying

    season to a victorious close.

    The Bears started quickly, tak-ing just 5:12 to break through or

    the lead on the rst goal o orward

    Katelyn Landrys 12 career. Jacquie

    Pierri 12 took a shot rom the right

    point that defected o Landry at

    the top o the crease and ricocheted

    just inside the right post. Male was

    also credited with an assist on

    the play.

    It was early in the second period,

    with Brown still holding its one-goal

    advantage, that Stock recorded her

    record-breaking 1,005th save o the

    season. She would nish the game

    with 1,026 saves or the season and

    2,848 or her career, extending a

    record she captured earlier in the

    season.

    Jenna Dancewicz 11 doubled

    the lead 9:32 into the second period

    with her team-leading eighth goal o

    the season, o assists by assistant

    captain Andrea Hunter 10 and Ni-

    cole Brown 10.

    Brown notched a goal o her own

    8:09 later while her team was on the

    penalty kill. Ater the Bears cleared

    the puck all the way down the ice,

    Bobcats goalie Nanna Holm Glaas

    came out o the crease to stop the

    puck or a teammate. Brown stole

    the puck, circled behind the net,

    wrapped around and slipped the

    puck just past a diving Glaas.

    With 2:19 remaining in the sec-

    ond period, Bruno had a 3-0 lead

    to protect.

    We pulled together as a team

    and were like, Okay, we have three.

    Lets manage the game, be smart

    about it and hopeully well come

    out with a win. I think we did that

    really well in the third. We played

    good deense, Stock said.

    The Bobcats ruined Stocks shut-

    out bid 5:31 into the third period, but

    the goalie bore down to keep it rom

    getting any closer, making 12 o her33 saves in the nal rame.

    Murphy was pleased with many

    . bkb b B By Katie wood

    assistaNtsports editor

    The mens basketball team strug-

    gled this weekend to build on its

    rst conerence win, Feb. 14, over

    Princeton, as Columbia and Cor-

    nell each took a game rom theBears.

    T h e

    Bears (7-17,

    1-9 Ivy) ell

    to Columbia

    (11-12, 6-4

    Ivy) Friday

    night at the Pizzitola Center by

    a score o 70-57. The Bears then

    suered their second home loss in

    as many nights Saturday against

    Cornell (18-8, 8-2 Ivy), an 85-45

    rout that the Big Red dominated

    rom start to nish.

    Poor outside shooting plagued

    the Bears throughout the home-

    stand, as Brown shot 18 percent

    rom behind the three-point line on

    the weekend, while its opponents

    shot better than 45 percent.

    cb 70, B 57

    In Fridays game, the Bears

    couldnt keep pace with Columbias

    hot shooting, alling by thirteen

    points.

    Columbia outshot Brown 54

    percent to 41 percent rom the

    foor and 53 percent to 22 percent

    rom three-point range. Columbias

    bench also out-scored Browns by

    an outstanding 45-1 margin, includ-

    ing 21 points rom Patrick Foley

    and 14 rom KJ Matsui.

    Columbia guard Noruwa Agho,

    a starter, led all scorers with

    27 points.

    Mullery led the way or the

    Bears with 21 points on 7-o-12

    shooting, also making 7-o-8 at the

    ree throw line. Mullery also added

    our blocks, bringing his season

    total to 43. That set a new Brown

    record, surpassing Jaime Kilburns

    05 42 in the 2003-2004 season.

    Sullivan ollowed close behind

    with 19 points, going 7-o-14 rom

    the ield. Adrian Williams 11

    joined the two in double gures

    w b

    Cb f C

    By BenJy aSher

    sports editor

    The wrestling teams nal dual meets

    o the season ended on a positive note

    this weekend with an emphatic 22-9

    victory over Columbia on Saturday,

    ater struggling in a 32-9 loss to a

    dominant Cornell team on Friday.

    Cornell, ranked No. 2 in the USA

    Today/Intermat/NWCA poll, jumped

    out to an 11-0 lead ater two matches,

    but Stephen DeLorenzo 10 picked upthe rst win o the day or the Bears

    with a 5-2 decision at 141 pounds. At

    157, Bryan Tracy 10 pulled out a 3-2

    win, and Zach Zdrada 09 closed out

    the meet with a 3-2 win at 285.

    Despite the inal outcome,

    the Bears elt they wrestled well

    against Cornell.

    I thought the guys wrestled great

    and wrestled tough, said Bran Crud-

    den 10. We won three out o ten

    bouts against a real tough team, so I

    thought the team wrestled excellent

    on Friday, and that momentum car-

    ried over into Saturday or our match

    against Columbia.

    Against the Lions, Greg Einrank10 got Brown o to a good start in

    his 125-pound match, where Einrank

    scored two takedowns in the rst peri-

    w. k bBy andrew Braca

    sportseditor

    In the aterglow o Saturdays 3-1 vic-

    tory over Quinnipiac, the womens

    hockey teams seniors were honored

    in a post-game ceremony as the team

    both refected on its accomplishmentsand turned its attention to seasons

    to come.

    The star o the ceremony and

    the season was captain Nicole Stock

    09, a Herald sports sta writer. She

    leaves holding many o the teams goal-

    tending records, including a single-

    season saves record she set earlier

    that day and Browns record or career

    saves 2,848 in all.

    Ater the game, Stock was award-

    ed the Panda Cup, which is given or

    outstanding team spirit, good sports-

    womanship and dedication to play-

    ing ice hockey, according to a guide

    provided by the Athletic Department

    at the game.

    Its nice, or sure, to be acknowl-

    edged or that kind o stu, Stock

    said. At the same time, its a long

    season. You just grind it out and you

    dont really think about that stu when

    youre playing.

    Its bittersweet to be losing Stock,

    said Head Coach Digit Murphy. Shes

    just an incredible person and athlete.

    Quite rankly, Browns lucky to have

    her as a graduate, because shes going

    to go on to do great things. Shes got

    the work ethic o any Olympian Ive

    ever coached.

    Murphy also said her two senior

    orwards both closed out their careers

    with strong games.

    Frances Male 09 played with en-

    ergy and enthusiasm like she had

    the heart o a lion, Murphy said. The

    third goal was scored because o her

    ability to ... get it out on the (penalty

    kill) all the way down and allow (Nicole

    Brown 10) to go down and do thewrap-around.

    Savannah Smith 09 really ought

    hard along the boards, she added.

    Shes small in stature but I thought

    she played big today.

    Murphy said the young team will

    get older, but the Bears will bring in

    more recruits than they will lose play-

    ers to graduation.

    Well bring in seven or eight more

    kids, she said. We need to be more

    talented to win more games, so my

    assistants have been out beating the

    bushes or even more talent. I think

    well bring in a ew more talented or-

    wards so we can put the puck in the

    net. We have a goaltender, one o the

    top goalies in Canada.

    Murphy declined to name the

    goalie, but the Waterloo Chronicle

    reported earlier this month that Katie

    Jamieson, a goaltender who currently

    stars between the pipes or o the To-

    ronto Junior Aeros will join the Bears

    next year.

    I think next years team, with the

    kids that are here now, is going to be

    stronger, Murphy continued. Our

    kids are going to be wiser. Were going

    to have a big senior class. Im looking

    orward to success o our uture, and

    I think it starts because o senior role-

    modeling that happened this year.

    Courtes of Jesse Morgan / Herald

    Mens basketball fell to Columbia and Cornell over the weekend.

    Courtes of Jesse Morgan

    The Bears split the weekend, losing to Princeton Frida but beating Quinnipiac in the seasons final game.

    continued onpage 8 continued onpage 8

    continued onpage 9

    cbBrown

    7057

    cBrown

    8545

  • 8/14/2019 February 23, 2009 Issue

    8/12

  • 8/14/2019 February 23, 2009 Issue

    9/12

    with 10 points.

    Brown jumped out to a quick early

    lead against the Lions but quickly

    ell behind trailed throughout the

    second hal.

    An early scoring spurt started

    the weekend strong or the Bears,

    as Matt Mullery 10 scored our ear-

    ly points and Morgan Kelly 11 con-

    nected on a three-pointer to put the

    Bears up 11-4 with 11:16 remaining

    in the rst hal. The game tightened

    but remained close midway through

    the period as both teams struggled

    to create shot opportunities at the

    oensive end.But the Lions ound their groove

    and nished the hal on a 17-4 scor-

    ing run, breaking out o its o ensive

    cold streak while Brown continued

    to struggle. Brown headed into the

    locker room down, 27-21.

    We went cold shooting the ball,

    but when that happens, we cant

    give up runs like that, Mullery

    said. Guys are playing a lot o

    minutes, but we have to play well

    on both sides o the ball.

    The Bears scored the majority o

    their points in the paint in the rst

    hal, as the team could not nd a

    shooting rhythm rom the outside,

    going 12.5 percent (1 or 8) rom

    behind the three-point line.

    Columbia stayed in control a-

    ter the break, scoring the rst six

    points o the second hal to take a

    commanding 33-21 barely a minute

    into the period.

    Brown made a push to get back

    into the game, as a jumper by tri-

    captain Peter Sullivan 11 brought

    the Bears within ve, 45-40, capping

    a 7-0 run with nine minutes let.

    But the Lions responded to

    Browns run with a 15-6 run otheir own, and the Bears got no

    closer than nine points the rest o

    the way. The Lions built up their

    lead by shooting 65 percent rom

    the foor and 5-or-8 rom behind

    the arc in the second hal.

    c 85, B 45

    Ater a hard-ought loss on Fri-

    day, the Bears ound themselves

    on the receiving end o a thrashing

    rom deending Ivy League cham-

    pions and current league leader

    Cornell.

    Cornell over-powered a small-

    er Brown team by a reboundingmargin o 48-29. Browns shooting

    woes also continued, as the Bears

    struggled to make shots, shooting

    just 14 percent rom three-point

    range and 32 percent overall. Cor-

    nell made more than hal its shots

    rom the foor.

    The Big Red put our players

    in double digits or the game, led

    by Foote with 16, Ryan Wittman

    with 15 and Louis Dale, the reign-

    ing Ivy League Player o the Year,

    who netted 12.

    Sullivan led the way or the Bears

    with 12 points, and Mullery nished

    with 11. Co-captain Chris Skrelja

    09 played well all-around or the

    Bears, contributing six points, ve

    rebounds and six assists.

    Despite a hot start rom Mullery,

    who scored 10 o the Bears rst 11

    points, Cornell pulled away early.

    By the time a Mullery lay-up put

    the Bears in double gures, the Big

    Red had already opened a 21-11 lead

    that they would relentlessly extend

    throughout the game.

    With easy inside looks and dan-

    gerous outside shooting, Cornell

    built its lead to 44-27 by haltime,

    with orward Ryan Wittman going

    3-or-3 rom behind the arc in the

    rst period.

    I got o to a good start, but they

    started collapsing, putting the pres-

    sure on, and orcing us to make

    outside shots, Mullery said. We

    just didnt have a good weekend

    o shooting.

    With tri-captain Scott Friske 09,

    a 6-7 orward, out o the lineup

    because o illness, the Bears gave

    up a lot o size against the Big Reds

    seven-oot center, Je Foote.

    Foote began the second hal

    with two emphatic dunks, spark-

    ing a 10-0 run that blew the game

    open even urther. Sullivan ended

    the drought with 15:38 remain-

    ing, but Brown ailed to build

    any momentum.

    With the team down by 30 with

    over ten minutes to play, Head

    Coach Jesse Agel emptied his

    bench. Nearly every player logged

    at least 15 minutes o play in the

    game, an opportunity to spread play-

    ing time among the young Brown

    squad.

    The Bears second unit aired

    little better, and Cornell ultimately

    won by 40.

    We missed the leadership and

    foor presence o Friske, Mullery

    said. Hes played hard all year its hard to go out there without

    him.

    The Bears have two more weeks

    o conerence play remaining in the

    season. They will travel to Princ-

    eton and Penn or the seasons nal

    road trip beore returning home

    to celebrate their two graduating

    seniors, Friske and Skrelja, during a

    nal homestand against Dartmouth

    and Harvard.

    continued frompage 7

    bkb

    Are ou interestedin Web design?

    J

    t h!

    [email protected]

    for more information!

    MONDAy, FEBRUARy 23, 2009 THE BROWN DAILy HERALD

    SSD

    Courtes of Jesse Morgan

    The Bears dropped to 1-9 in the Iv League with two conference losses.

    MONDAy, FEBRUARy 23, 2009 | PAGE 9

  • 8/14/2019 February 23, 2009 Issue

    10/12

    ditorial & LettersPage 10 | MONDAy, FEBRUARy 23, 2009

    The Brown Daily Herald

    F R A N N Y C H O I

    w b

    C OR R E C T I ONS P OL I C Y

    The Brown Daily Herald is committed to providing the Brown University community with the most accurate inormation possible. Correc-

    tions may be submitted up to seven calendar days ater publication.

    C OM M E NT A R Y P OL I C Y

    The editorial is the majority opinion o the editorial page board o The Brown Daily Herald. The editorial viewpoint does not necessarily

    refect the views o The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Columns, letters and comics refect the opinions o their authors only.

    L E T T E R S T O T HE E DI T OR P OL I C Y

    Send letters to [email protected]. Include a telephone number with all letters. The Herald reserves the right to edit all letters or

    length and clarity and cannot assure the publication o any letter. Please limit letters to 250 words. Under special circumstances writers may

    request anonymity, but no letter will be printed i the authors identity is unknown to the editors. Announcements o events will not be printed.

    A DV E R T I S I NG P OL I C Y

    The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. reserves the right to accept or decline any advertisement at its discretion.

    lettertotheeditors

    editorial

    S S ws Mitra Anoushiravani, Colin Chazen, Ellen Cushing, Sdne Ember,

    Lauren Fedor, Nicole Friedman, Brigitta Greene, Sarah Husk, Brian Mastroianni, Hannah

    Moser, Ben Schreckinger, Caroline Sedano, Melissa Shube, Anne Simons, Sara Sunshine,

    Sff wis Zunaira Choudhar, Chris Duff, Nicole Dungca, Juliana Friend, Cameron

    Lee, Kell Mallahan, Christian Martell, Seth Motel, Jotsna Mullur, Lauren Pischel, Leslie

    Primack, Alexandra Ulmer, Kla Wilkes

    Sps S ws Nicole Stock

    S Bsss asss Max Barrows, Jackie Goldman, Margaret Watson,Ben Xiong

    Bsss asss Stassia Chzhkova, Misha Desai, Bonnie Kim, Maura Lnch, Cath Li,

    Allen McGonagill, Thanases Plestis, Core Schwartz, William Schweitzer, Kenneth So, Evan

    Sumortin, Hadar Tagun, Webber Xu, Lndse yess

    ds S Jessica Kirschner, Joanna Lee, Maxwell Rosero

    P S Alex DePaoli, Frederic Lu, Quinn Savit, Meara Sharma, Min Wu

    cp es Rafael Chaiken, Ellen Cushing, Sdne Ember, Lauren Fedor, Anna Jouravleva,

    Jennifer Kim, younhun Kim, Tarah Knaresboro, Geoffre Ki, Janine Lopez, Frederic Lu,

    Jordan Mainzer, Kell Mallahan, Madeleine Rosenberg, Riva Shah, Luis Solis, Rachel Starr,

    Jason yum

    wb dps Jihan Chao

    Marlee Bruning, Julien Ouellet Dsns

    Lauren Fedor, Geoffrey Kyi Cpy eds

    Chaz Kelsh, Jenna Stark, Melissa Shube, Ben Schreckinger Nh eds

    thebrowndailyherald

    B hh lSp le lssg tk

    m vg mJ wc KsJ SkBj asa Ba mK w

    Chris Jesu Lee

    Stephen Lichenstein

    Eunice HongKim Perley

    Justin Coleman

    gphcs edgphcs ed

    Ph edPh ed

    Sps Ph ed

    Graphics & photos

    BuSiNeSS

    Kathryn Delaney

    Seth Motel

    Marlee Bruning

    Jessica Calihan

    Anna Migliaccio

    Julien Ouellet

    Neal Poole

    ProDuCtioN

    Cpy Dsk ChfCpy Dsk Chf

    Dsn edDsn ed

    ass. Dsn edass. Dsn ed

    Wb ed

    eDitorial

    Arts & Culture EditorArts & Culture Editor

    Features EditorFeatures Editor

    Higher Ed Editor

    Higher Ed EditorMetro EditorMetro EditorNews EditorNews Editor

    Sports EditorSports Editor

    Asst. Sports EditorAsst. Sports Editor

    editor-in-chief

    S dl

    senior editors

    r ac cS ls

    associate editors

    n Jksfk K

    m Skp

    ManaGinG editors

    m Bkc fs

    oPiNioNSSarah Rosenthal opnns ed

    editorial paGe board

    James Shapiro

    Nick Bakshi

    Zack Beauchamp

    Sara Molinaro

    ed P edBd bBd bBd b

    General ManaGers

    a hsJ Sp

    office ManaGer

    S r

    directorse dSc KP mK KJ c

    ManaGers

    K wssK Ba ccs Spsm Bs

    Ss DcSs DcSs Dc

    Fnnc Dcass. Fnnc Dc

    lc SsNn Ss

    unvsy Ssrc Ss

    Cd nd Ccns

    PoSt- magaziNe

    Arthur Matuszewski

    Kelly McKowenednChfednChf

    The University recently took the rst steps toward establishing a partnership

    with the Instituto de Empresa in Madrid, a business-oriented Spanish univer-sity. The Herald reported last week that the University will plan exchanges

    with the Instituto de Empresa that might eventually include study abroad

    opportunities. We view this collaboration as a welcome development in the

    Universitys internationalization eor ts, and a valuable chance to reexamine

    business education at Brown.

    Due to restrictive language in the Universitys charter, Brown is one o only

    two members o the Ivy League without a graduate school in business. Brown

    still oers a handul o business-related courses in the engineering department

    and the Commerce, Organizations and Entrepreneurship concentration. These

    classes seem to clash with Browns academic philosophy.

    Like most reputable institutions o higher learning, Brown does not oer

    a pre-law concentration. The reasons are many: Pre-proessional courses o

    study confict with a liberal ar ts education, colleges cannot teach the subject

    as well as law schools and pre-law students do not have an advantage in

    graduate school admissions. The same considerations apply to business

    programs at the undergraduate level. Were especially concerned about thestudy o management, entrepreneurship, innovation, commerce and related

    topics at Brown because there is no organized discipline or robust tradition

    o scholarship in these areas.

    We question the rigor o business-related programs relative to other courses

    o study at Brown. For example, the Organizational Studies and Entrepre-

    neurship and Technology Management tracks in COE allow concentrators

    to ulll the statistics requirement in any o seven di erent elds, including

    the Departments o Education and Psychology. Entrepreneurial courses, in

    engineering and more broadly, contrast with the rest o the curriculum. Ac-

    cording to the Department o Engineerings Web site, these classes are largely

    intended to prepare science and engineering students or careers at start-up

    companies. We ear that other students who only enroll in engineering-lite

    courses and their fuy COE counterparts will graduate with some basic

    training in marketing but without anything marketable.

    Given the Universitys shortcomings in business education and the elds

    limitations as an undergraduate academic discipline, we strongly encourage

    administrators to aggressively pursue collaboration with the Instituto de Em-presa. Short o a dramatic transormation o Browns existing program, the

    best solution may be to outsource business education altogether.

    Editorials are written by The Heralds editorial page board. Send comments to

    [email protected].

    Human rights abuses are no laughing mattert e:

    During last Thursdays Janus Forum lecture on theuniversality o human rights, I heard a lot o laughter

    in Salomon 101, though to be rank, nothing that was

    actually humorous. Speaker John Yoos tactic o using

    jokes and snide remarks to defect questions and state-

    ments that challenged his stance was a pathetic and sad

    thing to witness. There is nothing humorous about the

    deprivation o human rights. Yoos humor was a poor

    deense mechanism and refected his complete disregard

    or human rights. Perhaps he and many o the audience

    members who laughed at his jokes should refect on

    what their laughter meant, and how it may have servedas a way to ignore a serious problem while shrugging

    away culpability or an issue that should truly concern

    all o us. Ater Thursdays talk I approached Yoo with

    a question about his use o humor. Tellingly, he chose

    to brush it o.

    a h 09

    Feb. 20

  • 8/14/2019 February 23, 2009 Issue

    11/12

    MONDAy, FEBRUARy 23, 2009 | PAGE 11

    pinionsThe Brown Dail Herald

    With nancial troubles setting in at Brown,

    it doesnt surprise me that students dis-

    contentment with the governing body o

    the University has increased r ecently. The

    standard concerns about the lack o transpar-

    ency in the Corporations decision-making

    process have transormed into anger about

    the handling o the Universitys nances,

    including resentment over what programs

    have been cut and which projects have

    lost unding.A number o students have vocally pro-

    tested the Corporations actions, with little

    regard or what those actions might entail

    or students. Its time to think about what

    exactly these decisions, and the alterna-

    tives, mean.

    Being concerned over nancial prob-

    lems at an institution where you live, work

    and study does seems reasonable. But the

    orms that recent protests have taken, and

    the issues they have ocused on, have been

    somewhat bizarre. Earlier this month, The

    Herald reported a controversial $15,000

    registration ee or Vice President or In-

    ternational Aairs David Kennedy 76 to

    attend the Clinton Global Initiatives annual

    meeting ($15k donation stirs controversy,Feb. 3).

    But $15,000 is small change or a Univer-sity with a multi-billion dollar endowment,

    and the benets o Kennedys attendance

    may have justied the cost o admission.

    Because o Browns investment, a senior

    member o the administration was able

    to advance the Universitys standing and

    network with potential donors and other

    infuential gures.

    Brown students seem less bothered by

    the $15,000 ee than the Corporations de-

    cision-making procedures. Many students

    are concerned that the Corporation does

    not actively or adequately solicit student

    eedback on important nancial decisions. At

    least, this is the charge levied against them.

    But this is hardly a bad way or a university

    to operate. When it comes to university gov-

    ernance an old adage applies. Too many

    cooks spoil the broth, however undemocratic

    that may sound. When it comes to the air

    maintenance o a university, Im glad that

    we are run by an oligarchy.

    I almost wonder i Brown students wouldbe less upset with the Corporation i it were

    called something more amiliar and less

    capitalist. The Corporation is composed o

    a mixture o people: some who were pre-

    viously aliated with the University and

    some who werent, some who have extensive

    nancial experience and some who dont,

    and none o them have a monetary stake

    in the University.

    Corporation members are not paid or

    their eorts but attempt to maintain and

    improve this University o ours. They act

    as students advocates and, unlike other

    members o the community, can govern

    equitably because they dont have any -

    nancial interest in the University.

    A democratically operated Brown Univer-

    sity wouldnt last long. In the current nan-

    cial crisis, decisions about investments, sta

    hiring, nancial aid and program cuts have to

    be made quickly. I the ederal governmentand its eorts to stimulate the economy have

    taught us anything, its that democracy isoten a slow process that cannot move at

    the pace necessary to implement changes

    at the opportune moment.

    With a small group o experienced indi-

    viduals who have dealt with the Universitys

    nances in the past, the Corporation can

    reach decisions and act on them without

    having to deal with coalition-building and

    other political pressures.

    I believe history will vindicate the Cor-

    poration or their actions in this time o

    nancial instability. Their decisive action

    is needed to keep the University afoat. Stu-

    dents are primarily interested in the short

    term, as they are only on College Hill or

    our or ve years. The Corporation, with amembership that serves or six- or 11-year

    terms, can take into account Browns long-

    term health.

    Brown students arent exposed to

    the ugly details o running a machine as

    large as the University they only see

    the people determining its direction and

    blame them. We need to look at where

    the University is going, and how ar we

    have come already beore we decide that

    the orm o governance needs to change.

    Susannah Kroeber 11 is a Slavic

    studies concentrator from Beijing,

    China. She can be reached at

    [email protected].

    C

    A curious point in President Ruth Simmons

    e-mail to the Brown community on the

    nancial apocalypse:

    In light o our commitment to meet the

    ull need o our nancial aid students, schol-

    arship expenditures have increased. Given

    all the changes that have occurred since the

    FY09 budget was approved last Februar y, we

    now expect scholarship expenditures to be

    almost $1 million more than planned.

    Ill pass on the opportunity to comment

    on just who gets to decide what constitutes

    need. In spirit, the added contribution to

    nancial aida 9.8 percent increase over last

    years aid budget, according to the provost

    is laudable. Props or nding an extra mil-

    lion or aid in a year when the endowment

    took an $800 million hit while scraping $21

    million o the operating budget.

    But then I have to wonder: i the Uni-

    versity could nd a million dollars or ad-

    ditional aid in a year like this, why couldnt

    it back when things werent so terriying,

    when the endowment was knocking on the

    three billion dollar door? The school, it

    seems, wasnt always living up to its com-

    mitment to make a Brown education a-

    ordable. And its not that the need wasnt

    there; plenty o students who even then

    were taking out loans could have used that

    added help. The Corporation acknowledged

    that when it targeted loans or reduction

    last spring.

    Im skeptical, then, that Brown is ever

    doing as much as it can to ease the nancial

    yoke that it imposes with its outrageous tu-

    ition. Gradually and sur reptitiously, it shits

    to its students the burden o unding its op-erations. (Surreptitiously, except when the

    chancellor gaes and says that Brown is

    lucky to rely so heavily on tuition.)

    The plan outlined in the presidents e-mail

    and the budget approved by the Corporation

    uses these same old habits to sustain Brown

    through its nancial di culties. For students,

    it still includes a 3 percent tuition hike. Sta

    get a pay reeze and, by the presidents eu-

    phemism, ace possible reductions. And Ill

    bet that when the layos come, the pink slip

    goes to the oce assistant, not the genius

    who lost 28 percent o our endowment.

    So despite administrative assurances to

    the contrary, their plan is built largely on

    the backs o students and sta. The implicit

    assumption seems to be that the University is

    suering rom the nancial crisis ar worse

    than anyone else. They act like the constitu-

    ent parts o the community are plenty able

    to bankroll the school while Brown roughs

    it through some tough times.

    Our amilies, apparently, will be able

    to pay even more or our education in this

    climate. Sta will clearly be in a position to

    give up their jobs or the good o the school.

    Talk about being Ever True.As one o those expected to step up to

    sustain my school, I eel comor table saying

    to the administration here that no matter

    how much money youve lost, youre still

    sitting on $2 billion. As desperate as your

    circumstances may seem, youve got it way

    better than we do.

    What is oten orgotten when considering

    Browns nancial circumstances is that no

    matter what amount o money has been lost,

    the resources still on hand are way larger.

    But the University obstinately reuses to dip

    urther into its rainy day und on this most

    rainy o days. Instead, it goes calling on indi-

    viduals with less nancial clout, less ability to

    assume debt and ar less cash stashed away

    or the uture, and demands they pay up,

    whether with their money or their careers.

    Even though things are apparently so bad

    as to warrant a $21 million budget cut and

    cancelled expansion projects, the University

    thinks it can justiy asking its students and

    their amilies or a greater contribution. Con-

    sider the basic equation in all its absurdity.

    We have to nd a way to spend less money,

    so you all have to spend more. The presump-

    tion: This situation hurts us a lot more thanall o you. I wish.

    The reality is that students cant aord

    higher tuition any more than Brown can

    aord a bigger Graduate School. Sta cant

    aord to lose their jobs. Students will be

    orced out o this school and deprived o the

    education they have earned. The amilies o

    the victims o job cuts will su er. There will

    be human tragedy wrought by the adminis-

    trations plan.

    The just answer is to cancel the tuition

    increase and guarantee the employment o

    every competent sta member on campus.

    Fill the gap by tapping a little bit more into

    that still unimaginably huge endowment.

    Give up on the superfuous construction

    projects that, unbelievably, the University

    says it is still pursuing. But dont ask or more

    money when you know that there isnt a soul

    who can spend more this year than last.

    I Brown does, people will leave. The

    University will necessarily become more

    exclusive and less diverse. But since we

    at Brown have a chancellor who sat on the

    board o an organization responsible or kick-

    ing homeless people out o Manhattan, you

    have to ask whether thats the point.

    Simon Liebling 12 is from New Jerse.

    He can be reached at

    [email protected].

    S

    Despite administrative assurances to the

    contrar, Browns plan for dealing with the

    financial crisis is built on the backs of

    students and staff.

    When it comes to the fair maintenance of a

    universit, Im glad that we are run

    b an oligarch.

    SIMON

    LIEBLING

    opinions coluMnist

    By SUSANNAH KROEBER

    opinions coluMnist

  • 8/14/2019 February 23, 2009 Issue

    12/12