110
FORBES & FIFTH The University of Pittsburgh Dietrich School of Arts and Sciences Undergraduate Magazine VOL . 1 SPRING 2012

FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES& FIFTH

The University of PittsburghDietrich School of Arts and Sciences

Undergraduate Magazine

VOL . 1 SPRING 2012

Page 2: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K
Page 3: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH The$University$of$Pittsburgh

Dietrich$School$of$Arts$and$SciencesUndergraduate$Magazine

Vol. 1 Spring 2012

������

Page 4: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

Forbes$&$Fifth*=_:<�F=�/E;<I>I8;L8K<�,<J<8I:?-:?FC8IJ?@G�8E;��I<8K@M<��:K@M@KP

� ��.?8:B<I8P�#8CC����/E@M<IJ@KP�+C8:<+@KKJ9LI>?�+������

Phone:$412B624B6828Email:[email protected]

Forbes$&$Fifth$@J�GL9C@J?<;�@E��GI@C�8E;��<:<D9<I�8K��.?<��FFB��<EK<I� �!@=K?��M<EL<+@KKJ9LI>?�+�������

�FGPI@>?K�U�� ���9P�Forbes$&$Fifth.Forbes$&$Fifth$@J�8�J:?FC8ICP�GL9C@:8K@FE�

F=�K?<�/E@M<IJ@KP�F=�+@KKJ9LI>?��LK?FIJ�?FC;�K?<�:FGPI@>?KJ�KF�K?<@I�@E;@M@;L8C�8IK@:C<J

GL9C@J?<;�9P�Forbes$&$Fifth��FM<I��IK�9P�%8D@<�)FM8B��FGPI@>?K�U�� ��

9P�K?<�/E@M<IJ@KP�F=�+@KKJ9LI>?��CC�I@>?KJ�I<J<IM<;�

FORBES & FIFTH

FFFORBES & FIFTH

O

FFIC

E OF UNDERGRADUATE RESEARCH - O.U.R.

Page 5: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

Acknowledgements Founding Editors:

&8K<CPE��CFL>?�8ICP��LEE@E> D@CP��LI?8D-8I8�+<:FI8

+8KI@:B�,@:<(@:?8<C�,FJ<EK?8C,8:?<C�-K8:?<CIF;K

%8:F9�0<IP

The editors extend their appreciation to the following for their support:

)��%F?E��FFG<I�+?��Z��<KKP<�%��8E;�,8CG?� ���8@C<P��<8E��@<KI@:?�-:?FFC�F=��IKJ�8E;�-:@<E:<J

#8C@�!<CK�Z�$EJKIL:KFI��<G8IKD<EK�F=� E>C@J?�@<KI@:?�-:?FFC�F=��IKJ�8E;�-:@<E:<J

%<8E�"I8:<�+?��Z��@I<:KFI+L9C@:�8E;�+IF=<JJ@FE8C�1I@K@E>�+IF>I8D

'8LI8�#@CCF:B� JHL@I<�Z��JJF:@8K<�"<E<I8C��FLEJ<C

%L8E�%��(8E=I<;@�+?��Z0@:<�+IFMFJK�=FI�/E;<I>I8;L8K<�-KL;@<J

%L;@K?�(:�FEE8?8�Z�-<E@FI��@I<:KFI�F=�/E;<I>I8;L8K<�-KL;@<J��@<KI@:?�-:?FFC�F=��IKJ�8E;�-:@<E:<J

+8K�(:"I8E<�Z��FDDLE@:8K@FEJ�(8E8><I��@<KI@:?�-:?FFC�F=��IKJ�8E;�-:@<E:<J

+8KI@:B�(LCC<E�Z��@I<:KFI*=_:<�F=�/E;<I>I8;L8K<�,<J<8I:?�-:?FC8IJ?@G�8E;��I<8K@M<��:K@M@KP�

%8D@<�)FM8B�Z�Forbes$&$Fifth$�<J@>E<I�8E;��FGP� ;@KFI��@<KI@:?�-:?FFC�F=��IKJ�8E;�-:@<E:<J��C8JJ�F=�� ��

(@:?8<C�,FJ<EK?8C�Z�Forbes$&$Fifth$$CCLJKI8KFI��@<KI@:?�-:?FFC�F=��IKJ�8E;�-:@<E:<J��C8JJ�F=�� ��

&<IIP�-FJF�Z�+IF>I8D��;D@E@JKI8KFI�*=_:<�F=�/E;<I>I8;L8K<�,<J<8I:?�-:?FC8IJ?@G�8E;��I<8K@M<��:K@M@KP

%F?E�.NPE@E>�+?��Z��JJF:@8K<��<8E�F=�/E;<I>I8;L8K<�-KL;@<J��@<KI@:?�-:?FFC�F=��IKJ�8E;�-:@<E:<J

.?FD8J�0@J:F

Page 6: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

Page 7: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

!

!

!

FO

RB

ES

! AV

EN

UE!

FI F

TH

! AV

EN

UE!

MUSIC 27-47: “New Representations of the ‘Golden Lineage’” (Heins)

BPHIL 07-18:“I Can Haz Cultural ������������������

O.U.R. 01:“Introduction” (Editors)

BIOSC 48-57:“A Brief Explanation of Bonding Patterns in Carbon” (Rice / Very)

WPTS 79-89:“Rest Assured, We Can ��������������������

ANTH 20-25:�� ��������������������������������������(Grant / Wuchina)

ENGWRT 03-05:“Expert Beauty Tips” and “Jar of Darkness” (Grube)

PSY 91-93:“Go to Sleep” and “An Epitaph” (Eakins)

INFSCI 59-76:���������������Tree” (Kirilloff)

“Carbon Chains” and “Skin” (McDermott)

HLMAN

WPU

Map of Contents

Page 8: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K
Page 9: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

1

Introduction

�J� 8� I<8;<I� F=� K?<� ;<9LK� @JJL<� F=�Forbes$&$Fifth�N<� ?FG<� PFL� _E;�PFLIJ<C=� EFK� FECP�GFI@E>�FM<I� K?<� KPG<�F=�NI@K@E>� K?8K� 9<JK� JL@KJ� PFLI�@EK<I<JKJ�9LK�8CJF�C@E><I@E>�FE�JFD<�8JG<:KJ�F=�J:?FC8IJ?@G�K?8K�=<<C�=FI!<@>E�KF�PFL��.?<�@;<8�F=�[8IKJ�8E;�J:@<E:<J\�@KJ<C=�LE@K<J�KNF�:FE:<GKJ�K?8K�JF�F=K<E�8GG<8I�8K�F;;J�N@K?�<8:?�FK?<I�8E;�K?@J�D8>8Q@E<�JKI@M<J�KF�LE@K<�K?<�8IKJ�8E;�K?<�J:@<E:<J�LE;<I�8�E<N�98EE<I��@EK<I;@J:@GC@E8IP�:FC!C89FI8K@FE��1<�8I<�8�JKL;<EKC<;�8E;�JKL;<EKILE�D8>8Q@E<�N@K?�K?<�>F8C�F=�:FEE<:K@E>�K?<�DFJK�89JKI8:K�@;<8J�Z�C@B<�:8I9FE�:?8@EJ�8E;�(FE!>FC@8E�=FCB�DLJ@:�Z�ALJK�8J�!FI9<J�8E;�!@=K?��M<EL<J�9I@E>�8CC�F=�K?<�LE@HL<�<K?E@:@K@<J�98:B>IFLE;J�8E;�@EK<I<JKJ�F=�FLI�LE@M<IJ@KP�KF><K?<I��*LI�M@J@FE�@J�K?8K�PFL�FLI�I<8;<I�:8E�K8B<�8N8P�=IFD�K?<�D8>8Q@E<�8�B@E;�F=�8GGI<:@8K@FE�=FI�8CC�K?<�;@J:@GC@E<J�8K�K?<�/E@M<IJ@KP�F=�+@KKJ9LI>?�8E;�C<8IE�=IFD�K?<D�K?<I<9P�>IFN@E>�@E�PFLI�FNE�@EK<I<JKJ�K?IFL>?�K?<�BEFNC<;><�F=�FK?<IJ��

1<�?8M<�JKI@M<;�KF�GL9C@J?�8�D8>8Q@E<�K?8K�?FEFIJ�:I<8K@M@KP�9FK?�M<I!98CCP�8E;�M@JL8CCP��=IFD�I<J<8I:?�KF�;<J@>E�=IFD�M<IJ<� KF� @CCLJKI8K@FE���1<�?FG<�FLI�8GGIF8:?�<E:FLI8><J�PFL�KF�I<8;�8E;�GFJJ@9CP�JL9D@K�KF�LJ�@E�K?<�=LKLI<���$E�FI;<I�KF�J?FN:8J<�K?<�@EK<CC<:KL8C�;@M<IJ@KP�?<I<�8K�K?<�/E@M<IJ@KP�F=�+@KKJ9LI>?�N<�N<C:FD<�PFLI�@;<8J���.?<P�LCK@D8K<CP�C<8;�LJ�KF�E<N�GFJJ@9@C@K@<J�8E;�?<CG�LJ�KF�JL::<<;�EFK�FECP�@E�I<GI<J<EK@E>�K?<�/E@M<IJ@KP�@KJ<C=�9LK�@E�I<GI<J<EK@E>�PFL�Z�8J�8IK@JKJ�8J�J:@<EK@JKJ�8E;�8J�@E;@M@;L8CJ��

-F�N?<K?<I�PFL^I<�8�:?<D@JKIP�>LIL�FI�8�GF<K@:�:?8ID<I�8J�PFL�KLIE�K?<�G8><J�@E�FLI�_IJK�<;@K@FE�9<�GI<G8I<;�KF�FG<E�PFLI�D@E;�KF�E<N�<OG<!I@<E:<J���J�?LD8EJ�N<�I<CP�FE�<8:?�FK?<I�KF�K<8:?�LJ�JFD<K?@E>�E<N�89FLK�FLIJ<CM<J��.?<�J@D@C8I@K@<J�K?8K�N<�_E;�@E�<8:?�FK?<I�D8P�9I@E>�LJ�KF><K?<I�9LK�K?<�;@==<I<E:<J�9<KN<<E�LJ�=L<C�:?8E><�8E;�DFC;�LJ�@EKF�N?F�N<�8I<����=K<I�8CC�C@B<�!FI9<J�8E;�!@=K?�N<�D8P�9<�?<8;@E>�@E�FG!GFJ@K<�;@I<:K@FEJ�9LK�N<�N@CC�=FI<M<I�JK8E;�J@;<�9P�J@;<�

#8@C�KF�+@KK��

BThe$Editors

Page 10: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

2

Page 11: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

3

N8J�9FIE� @E�)<N�3FIB�9LK�N8J�DFJKCP�J?8G<;�9P�K?<�DFLEK8@EJ�F=�:<EKI8C�+<EEJPC!M8E@8�� -?<� JG<E;J� ?<I� K@D<� JKL;P@E>� +F<KIP� ,<C@>@FLJ�-KL;@<J� 8E;� �?@C;I<E^J� '@K<I8KLI<� 8K� K?<� /E@M<IJ@KP� F=�+@KKJ9LI>?��*==�:8DGLJ�J?<�JKL;@<J�K?<�=<<C�F=�=<<K�FE�K?<�J@;<N8CB��-?<�@J�8�DFIE@E>�G<IJFE����8@CP�"IL9<�"FF>C<J�?<IJ<C=�K?I<<�K@D<J�8�;8P��-?<�?FG<J�KF�GLIJL<�8E�(!��@E�GF<KIP�

Caily Grube

Page 12: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

4

:8IIP�9<8LK@=LC�K?@E>J��8�JKI8N9<IIP�JDFFK?@<�N@K?�9L99C<J�`FI8C�J:<EKJ�FE�K?<�NI@JK��

FI�:8IIP�JD

8CC�K?@E>J��8�JD

8CC�9<8LK@=LC�C8G�;F>�8�989P�:<CC�G?FE<�K@EP�><D

J�@E�<8IJ��

PFL�:FLC;�D<I<CP�GC8:<�K?<�9<8LK@=LC�K?@E>J�9<J@;<�PFLI�JB@E��<O8DGC<��JFD<�

JG8IBC<�K?<�:FCFI�G@EB�8�KLIHLF@J<�J?<CC�FE�K?<�=FI<?<8;��K?@E>J�<E?8E:<�8E�@;<8C��

J<C=�JF�E<M<I�:8IIP�JF>>P�>PD�J?F<J�FE�:8DGLJ��@EJK<8;�:FE:<8C�K?<D

�@E�8�9<A<N<C<;�

EPCFE�98>��FLK�F=�J@>?K�FLK�F=�J<C=��PFL�J?FLC;�FECP�:8IIP�?FD<D

8;<�9CL<9<IIP��

DL=_EJ�@=�@E�8�:<I8D@:�9FN

C��9LK�PFL�J?FLC;�EFK�C<K�8EP�DL=_E�:FD

<�@EKF�:FEK8:K�N@K?�

K?<�JB@E��9<�:8LK@FLJ�N@K?�:FEKI8JK�GC8P�Z�PFL�D8P�:8IIP�8�9@>�98>�KF�<DG?8J@Q<�8�JD8CC�

J@Q<�9LK�;F�EFK�:8IIP�JHL@II<C�DFC;<I�KF�:FEKI8JK�K?<�9<8LKP�D8IB�FE�PFLI�E<:B���

8�JL::<JJ�JKFIP��D

P�=I@<E;�:8II@<J�9<8LK@=LC�JD8CC�I<;�8GGC<J�@E�?<I�G8CD�Z

�@K�I<GI<J<EKJ�

GIFO@D@KP�KF�E8KLI<�D8B@E>�?<I�E8KLI8CCP�9<8LK@=LC�8E;�:8CC@E>�KF�D@E;�<M<�8E;�8��

:FDG8I89C<�J<OL8C�K<DGK8K@FE��FI�:8IIP�K?@J�8IK@:C<��:LK�@K�FLK�8CFE>�K?<�G<I=FI8K<;�<;><��

@KJ�=FID8K�8E;�=FEK�8I<�8�:8I<=LCCP�:8C:LC8K<;�9<8LK@=LC�F9A<:K�KF�?FC;�@E�K?<�?8E;�

Ex

per

t Bea

uty

Tip

s

Page 13: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

5

.?<J<�;8PJ�@K�J<<DJ�@DGFJJ@9C<�KF�@E:FIGFI8K<�C@>?K���8IBE<JJ�_CCJ�FLI�D8JFE�A8IJ�N<�_CC<;�N@K?�DFC8JJ<J�1<�KI@<;�KF�GLK�K?<D�FE�K?<�98:B�JK<GJ�K?@EB@E>�8�=LCC�DFFE�:FLC;�JG8I<�8�9<8D���� ������������LK�K@D<J�K?<P^I<�K@>?K�=FI�C@>?KE<JJ�

-LEJ?@E<�KI@<;�9LK�:FLC;E^K�JK@:B�@E�K?<�9C8:BJKI8G�.?@:B�;8IBE<JJ�GFLIJ�@EKF�FLI�8G8IKD<EK�C@B<�@EJK@E:K�3FLI�K<C<M@J@FE�Z�� � �����@K�=<<9CP�>CFNJ�@E�JFD<�J@C<EK�;8IB�Z�C@B<�K?8K�8E>C<I_J?�Z�;8E>C@E>�8�`LJ?�@E�8�;<<G�9C8:B��� � � � $�NFE^K�>F�E<8I�@K��

1<^I<�NFIB@E>�FE�K?<�@;<8�F=�JL::<JJ@FE��ZJF�N<�G@:B<;�LG�K?<J<�A8IJ�K@<;�K?<D�KF�FLI�E<:BJ�DFM<;�=FIN8I;�=IFD�K?<�=8IK?<JK�C<=K�D8I>@E�KF�K?<�=8IK?<JK�I@>?K��1<8IP�8E;�?LE>IP�N<�NI<JKC<�?<8MP�JPILGLEK@C�K?<�;@DE<JJ�9C<JJ<J�LJ�C@B<�%8:F9�8K�K?<�C@D<E�F=�8�E<N�;<:@J@FE��

[#FN�GI8:K@:8C\�PFL�I<D8IB<;�N?<E�N<�9FK?�J8N�FLI�A8I�;8DG<E�8E�@EM8J@FE�F=�;8NE@E>�JLE�K?IFL>?�K?<�DFIE@E>�9C@E;�@;<EK@=P@E>��� G8:B@E>�:8I;9F8I;�PFLI�I<:FI;J���DP�I<:FI;J�

$�=FLE;�K?<�A8I^J�LJ<=LCE<JJ�FLKJ@;<�@E�C8JK�E@>?K^J�;LJB�Z�N8@K@E>=FI�K?<�9CL<9C8:B�@K�D8;<�@K�9C8:B<I�N?@C<�K?<�E@>?KA8IJ�9<>@E�DFK?@E>�9<E<8K?�K?<�9CL<N<<;�������$^M<�9<<E�KFF�J<C=F9J<JJ<;��Z�9<@E>�DFM<;�KF�D8JKLI98K<�8K�M<CFLI�K<OKLI<J�J<:CL;<;�E@>?K�JB@<J�ZDFM<;�KF�D8JKLI98K<�8K�DP�FNE�J<:CLJ@FE�Z���8E;�?FN�FLI�A8I�F=�;8IBE<JJ�;@DJ�DP�;8IB�;<<G<I�

Jar of Darkness

GRUBE

Page 14: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

6

Page 15: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

7

� � � � � � � � � � � @ J � 8 � J<E@FI �!@ CD�-KL;@<J � 8E;� E>C @J?�1I@ K @E>� ;FL9C< � D8AFI� � #<�@J � 8 CJF� GLIJL@E>� 8 � �8:?<CFI � F= � +?@ CFJFG?P� @E�$EK<IE<K �(<D<J� 8E;� $EK<IE<K ��LC KLI< � �1?<E� ?<�@JE^K �N8K:?@E>�DFM@<J �NI@ K @E>� J:I @GKJ � 8E;� :8 !IFLJ@E>� K?<� $EK<IE<KJ�� @E � J<8I:?� F= � J @ C C @E<JJ �PFL�:8E�= @E;�?@D�D<DFI@Q@E>�,?8GJF;P�@E ��CL<�=FI �G@8EF �FE<�D<8JLI<�8K �8 � K @D<�� � � � � �

N o a h L e v i n s o n

�For$reasons$of$humor,$the$word$“Internet”$becomes$plural$with$an$Bs$in$many$message$boards.

Page 16: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

8

FFFORBES & FIFTH

OFF

ICE OF UNDERGRADUATE RESEARCH - O.U.R.

Page 17: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

9

“ I Can Has Cultural Influenz?”.?<� ==<:KJ�F=�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�FE�+FGLC8I��LCKLI<

"F�98:B�@E�K@D<�<@>?K�P<8IJ�

��?<8MPJ<K�D8E�E8D<;�"8IP��IFCJD8�;F<J�8�;8E:<�8E;�C@GJPE:?�:FM<I�F=� K?<� JFE>� [�I8>FJK<8��@E�.<@\� 9P�*4FE<� 8�(FC;FM8E�GFG�98E;��#<�N<8IJ�8�N?@K<�8E;�9CL<�I@E><I�KJ?@IK�GLDGJ�?@J�_JKJ�@E�K?<�8@I�8E;�>@M<J�EFK�K?<�JC@>?K<JK�:8I<�F=�N?F�J<<J�@K��#<�K?<E�J<E;J�K?<�M@;<F�KF�?@J�=I@<E;J�N?F�8CC�BEFN�"8IP�8J�K?<�:C8JJ�:CFNE�JF�8I<�LEJLIGI@J<;�9P�K?<�M@;<F��#FN<M<I�"8IP�><KJ�K?<�@;<8�KF�GFJK�K?<�M@;<F�FE�K?<�M@I8C�M@;<F�J?8I@E>�J@K<�E<N>IFLE;J�:FD��� +<I?8GJ�N?8K�JGI<8;�"8IP^J�;8E:<�M@;<F�8:IFJJ�K?<�@EK<IE<K�JF�HL@:BCP�N8J�K?<�JKI8E><�=FI<@>E�JFE>�FI�K?<�@D8><IP�F=�8�=8K�D8E�DFM!@E>�HL@:BCP� FI� ALJK� K?<� J@DGC<� =8:K� K?8K�"8IP�;F<J�EFK� :8I<�N?F� J<<J�?@D�;8E:<�C@B<�K?@J�9LK�@E�EF�K@D<�8K�8CC�"8IP�@J�8E�$EK<IE<K��<C<9I@KP��1?8K�N<�?8M<�?<I<�@J�8�M@I8C�M@;<F��#FN<M<I�N?<E�M@<N<IJ�:I<8K<�K?<@I�

FNE�M@;<FJ�@D@K8K@E>�"8IP^J�;8E:<� DFM<J� 8E;� K?<E� GFJK�K?<D�KF�3FL.L9<�8E�$EK<IE<K�(<D<�@J�9FIE��[)LD8�)LD8�"LP\� �K?<� [ELD8� ELD8\�:FD@E>� =IFD� K?<� (FC;FM8E�CPI@:J� @E� K?<� JFE>��1� �<>@E!E@E>�N@K?�K?@J�<O8DGC<��8C9<!@K�8�K8;�FLK;8K<;�9LK�:<IK8@ECP�I<:F>E@Q89C<� 8J� 8E� @E=8DFLJ�$EK<IE<K��<C<9I@KP�9P�8CC��8C!CFNJ� ;<_E@K@FEJ� KF� 9<� <JK89!C@J?<;�@E�K?<�<EFIDFLJ�NFIC;�

F=� $EK<IE<K��LCKLI<�� =FI�N?@C<�M@I8C�M@;<FJ�?8M<�<O@JK<;� K?IFL>?�D8EP�;@==<I<EK�D<;@LDJ�8E;�=FIDJ�K?<�$EK<IE<K�(<D<�8�LE@K�F=�FEC@E<�I<GC@!:8K@FE�@J�8�JG<:@_:�F9A<:K�F=�K?<�$EK<IE<K�K?8K�:8E�GC8P�8�IFC<�@E�@;<EK@=P!@E>�8E;�;<DPJK@=P@E>�K?<�8KK@KL;<J�8E;�M8CL<J�F=�$EK<IE<K��LCKLI<�

���

Gary$“Numa$Numa$Guy”$Brolsma$in$midBNuma

Page 18: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

10

-FD<N?<I<�@E�K?<�CFE<CP�NFIC;�F=�K?<�$EK<IE<KJ��DFJK�K@D<J�C8K<�8K�E@>?K�GIF:I8JK@E8K@E>�NFIB�F=�JFD<�JFIK�JFD<FE<�JKLD9C<J�LGFE�8�J@CCP�:LK<�G@:KLI<�FEC@E<��*=K<E�@K�@J�F=�8E�8E@D8C�Z�JFD<FE<^J�1<CJ?��FI>@�@E�8�CF9JK<I�#8CCFN<<E�:FJKLD<�=FI�<O8DGC<��*I�G<I?8GJ�8E�FC;�M@;<F�JLI!=8:<J�=IFD�K?<���� J�F=�8� C8I><�-FM@<K�D8E� @E�8�9IFNE�JL@K�J@E>@E>�8�EFEJ<EJ@:8C�KLE<�@E�=IFEK�F=�8�P<CCFN�98:B;IFG��(8P9<�JFD<FE<�_E;J�8E�8NBN8I;�G?FKF>I8G?�F=�_CD�8:KFI�&<8EL�,<<M<J�J@KK@E>�FE�8�G8IB�9<E:?�<8K@E>�8�J8E;N@:?�CFFB@E>�><E<I8CCP�>CLD��.?<�LJ<I�N?F�_E;J�K?@J� @D8><� K?<E�DF;@_<J� @K� @E� JFD<�N8P� K?IFL>?�+?FKFJ?FG� FI� FK?<I�98J@:�;@>@K8C�<;@K@E>�K<:?E@HL<J�8E;�K?<E�J?8I<J�@K�FE�@EK<IE<K�D<JJ8>@E>�9F8I;J��.?<�E<OK�DFIE@E>�LJ<IJ�N?F�:C@:B�K?<�C@EB�KF�K?<�D8E@GLC8K<;�G?FKF�C8L>?�8E;�<EAFP�K?<�JKI8E><�@D8><���LK�D8EP�K?<E�LJ<�K?<�FI@>@E8C�K<DGC8K<�G?FKF�KF�D8B<�K?<@I�FNE�@D8><J�GFJK@E>�8E;�J?8I@E>�K?<D�N@K?�<8:?�FK?<I��-FFE�K?<�J@CCP�DF;@_<;�@D8><J�>8@EJ�D8JJ@M<�GFGLC8I@KP�FE�!8:<9FFB�8E;�.N@KK<I�8E;�<M<EKL8CCP�<M<E�GI@EK�8E;�K<C<M@J@FE�D<;@8�FLKC<KJ�D8P�;@J:LJJ�FI�@E:FIGFI8K<�K?<D�@EKF�K?<@I�9IF8;:8JKJ��.?<I<�D8P�<M<E�9<�8�JGFF=�FI�I<=<I<E:<�KF�@K�FE�8E�<G@JF;<�F=�K?<�K<C<M@J@FE�J?FN�Family$Guy�� .?<I<�@J�EF�;FL9K�K?8K�K?<J<�=FIDJ�F=�<EK<IK8@ED<EK�BEFNE�8J�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�8I<�9<:FD@E>�DFI<�ELD<IFLJ�8E;�GFGLC8I�<M<IP�;8P��.?<� K<ID� $EK<IE<K� (<D<� ;<I@M<J� =IFD� 8� JKL;P� 9P� QFFCF>@JK� ,@:?8I;��8NB@EJ�@E�K?<���� J�F=�><E<K@:�<MFCLK@FE�:8CC<;�������$���������$E�@K��8NB@EJ�8I>L<;�K?8K�:FDG8I<;�KF�><E<K@:�<MFCLK@FE�N?@:?�:8E�K8B<�D@CC<EE@8�KF�GIF;L:<�<==<:KJ�K?<�<MFCLK@FE�F=�:LCKLI<�<JG<:@8CCP�N@K?@E�K?<� C8JK�:<EKLIP�?8J�GIF>I<JJ<;� I8G@;CP���8NB@EJ�GIFGFJ<;� K?8K�N?@C<�><E<K@:�<MFCLK@FE�;<G<E;J�FE�><E<J�8J�DF;<J�F=�KI8EJD@JJ@FE�:LCKLI8C�<MFCLK@FE�;<G<E;J�FE�N?8K�?<�:8CC<;�[D<D<J�\�1?@C<��8NB@EJ �NFIB�D8@ECP�:<EK<I<;�8IFLE;�K?<�@;<8�F=�FE<�F=�D8EB@E;^J�FC;<JK�D<D<J�K?<�"F;�D<D<� K?<� :FE:<GK� :8E� 9<� 8E;� ?8J� 9<<E� 8GGC@<;� KF� 8CDFJK� 8EP�8JG<:K�F=�:LCKLI<��%LJK�8J�<8:?�;<:8;<�?8;�@KJ�FNE�D<D<J�Z�K@<�;P<�@E�K?<�� J�:?@8�G<KJ�@E�K?<�� J�8E;�.@:BC<(< CDF�@E�K?<�� J�Z�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�8CJF�>F�@E�8E;�FLK�F=�GFGLC8I@KP��$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�FE�K?<�N?FC<�8I<� G@<:<J� F=� :LCKLI<� K?8K� <MFCM<� 8E;� 8I<� I<GIF;L:<;� K?IFL>?� D<8EJ�F=�$EK<IE<K�8E;�N<9�K<:?EFCF>P�8E;�K?8K�?8M<�8E�89@C@KP�KF�JGI<8;�8E;�KI8EJ=FID�N@K?�9<N@C;<I@E>�JG<<;��#FN<M<I�K?<�8GGIFO@D8K<�ELD9<I�F=�D<D<J�>F@E>�K?IFL>?�KF�K?<�D8@EJKI<8D�8E;�:FDD<I:@8C�JL::<JJ�FECP�KF�JFFE�<O@K�FLK�K?<�;FFI�F=�[J<CC@E>�FLK\�@J�I<D8IB89CP�?@>?��*9J<IM!

Page 19: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

11

@E>�8E;�I<:FI;@E>�K?<�<MFCLK@FE�F=�D<D<J�8CCFNJ�LJ�KF�:FDGI<?<E;�K?<�J@>E@_:8E:<�F=�N?8K�@J�GI<J<EKCP�K?<�;FD@E8EK�=FID�F=�<EK<IK8@ED<EK�@E�$EK<IE<K��LCKLI<�� 3<K�8J� K?@J�;FD@E8E:<� IFFKJ� @KJ<C=�D8@ECP� @E� $EK<IE<K��LCKLI<�<M<E�@=�G<FGC<�?8M<�E<M<I�?<8I;�K?<�K<ID�[$EK<IE<K�(<D<\�@K�@J�HL@K<�C@B<CP�K?8K�K?<P�?8M<�8K�JFD<�GF@EK�<OG<I@<E:<;�FE<��.8B<�N?8K�JK8IK<;�8J�8�N<<BCP�<M<EK�BEFNE�8J�[�8KLI;8P\�FE�K?<�D<JJ8><�9F8I;�J@K<��:?8E�N?<I<�LJ<IJ�NFLC;� JL9D@K� :LK<� G@:KLI<J� F=� :8KJ�� M<EKL8CCP� JFD<FE<�8;;<;�K<OK�8E;�:I<8K<;�'FC��8KJ�8�N<9J@K<�K?8K�GFJK<;�K?<J<�G?FKF>I8G?J�8E;� 8;;<;� K<OK� @E� 'FC� -G<8B� 8� J@CCP� C8E>L8><� 98J<;� FE� @EJK8EK�D<J!J8>@E>� 8E;� :<CC� G?FE<� K<OKJ� K?8K� ;<G<E;J� FE� @EK<EK@FE8C�D@JJG<CC@E>J�;@J:FD9F9LC8K<;�>I8DD8I� 8E;�?LDFIFLJ�;<J:I@GK@FEJ�� 'FC� �8KJ� K?<E� <MFCM<;� @EKF�K?<� FEC@E<� <EK<IK8@ED<EK� :FE>CFD<I8K<��?<<Q9LI><I� �E8D<;� 8=K<I� K?<� JLGGFJ<;�_IJK�CFC�:8K�[$��8E�#8J��?<<Q9LI><I�\��8�>IFLG�K?8K�FNEJ�FM<I�K?@IKP�;@==<I<EK�$EK<I!E<K�(<D<�N<9J@K<J�8E;�>8IE<IJ�FE�8M<I8><�8CDFJK�FE<�D@CC@FE�M@<NJ�8�N<<B�� @E;<<;�@K�@J�:FEJ@JK<EKCP�I8EB<;�8J�N@K?@E�K?<�DFJK�GFGLC8I�� �N<9J@K<J�@E�K?<�NFIC;��FLK�F=�FM<I��� ��2�� 1?@C<� @K� D8P� 9<� @DGFJJ@9C<� KF�HL8EK@=P� K?<� 8DFLEK� F=� $EK<IE<K� (<D<J�FEC@E<��8CK?FL>?�I<JFLI:<J�JL:?�8J�BEFNP!FLID<D<�:FD� 8I<� ;F@E>� 8E� <O:<CC<EK� AF9�JF�=8I��@K�;F<J�9<:FD<�GFJJ@9C<�KF�HL8C@=P�D<D<J�N@K?�8�;@JK@E:K�8IK@JK@:�JKPC<��(<D<J�?8M<�9<<E�IFFK<;�@E�$EK<IE<K��LCKLI<�J@E:<�@KJ�<8IC@<JK�9<>@EE@E>J��#FN<M<I�K?<P�N<I<�EFK�E<:<JJ8I@CP�D<D<J�9LK�J@DGCP�M@I8C�M@;<FJ��.8B<�=FI�<O8DGC<�8EP�F=�K?<�M@;<FJ�FE�3FL.L9<�F=�G<FGC<�JC@GG@E>�FE�8�98E8E8�G<<C����� ��ALDG@E>�F==�8�IFF=��� � �� FI� GLKK@E>� 8� K89C<JGFFE�F=� :@EE8DFE� @EKF� K?<@I�DFLK?J� 8CJF�BEFNE�8J�K?<��@EE8DFE��?8CC<E><���� ��3�� .?<J<�@E;@M@;L8C�M@;<FJ�8I<�EFK�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�@E�K?<�J<EJ<�K?8K�$�N@CC�LJ<�K?<�K<ID��.?<P�8I<�M@I8C�M@;<FJ��+<FGC<�N8K:?�K?<D�8I<�=8J:@!E8K<;�D8EP�K@D<J�9P�8�JKLG@;�8:K@FE�FI�;<:@J@FE�K?8K�NFLC;�9<�NFIK?P�F=��D<I@:8^J�!LEE@<JK�#FD<�0@;<FJ�8E;�DFJK�@DGFIK8EKCP�K?<P�J?8I<�

LEVINSON

An$example$of$a$lol$cat.Image$courtesy$of$

Cheezburger$Network

Page 20: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

12

K?<D��*I@>@E8CCP�M@8�<D8@C�EFN�J?8I@E>�?8J�<MFCM<;�KF�@EELD<I89C<�JF!:@8C�D<;@8�GC8K=FIDJ�JL:?�8J�.N@KK<I�!8:<9FFB�8E;�.LD9CI���E;�N?@C<�@K�D8P�9<�8I>L<;� K?8K�JC@GG@E>�FE�98E8E8�G<<CJ� ALDG@E>�F==�F=� IFF=J�8E;�:?FB@E>�PFLIJ<C=�N@K?�JG@:P�:@EE8DFE�8I<�@E�=8:K�D<D<J�@E�K?<�N8P�K?8K�,@:?8I;��8NB@EJ�8E;�D<D<�K?<FI@JK�-LJ8E��C8:BDFI<�D8P�8I>L<�J@E:<�K?<I<�8I<�D8EP�;@==<I<EK�M8I@<K@<J�F=�8E;�@D@K8K@FEJ�F=�K?<J<�M@;<FJ�8M8@C89C<�8>8@E�K?<J<�@E;@M@;L8C�M@;<FJ�8I<�EFK�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J��� 1?P���<:8LJ<�K?<P�C8:B�:?8I8:K<I�� *E:<�N<�8I<�89C<�KF�@;<EK@=P�8�N@C;�$EK<IE<K�(<D<�N<�:8E�K?<E�>IFLG�K?<D�KF><K?<I�8E;�:FDG8I<�K?<@I�HL8C@K@<J�9<:8LJ<�JLIGI@J@E>CP�=FI�8J�D8EP�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�8J�K?<I<�8I<�K?<P�;F�J?8I<�J@D@C8I�:?8I8:!K<I@JK@:J��!@IJK�8E;�=FI<DFJK�K?<P�8I<�:FD<;@:�F9A<:KJ��.?<@I�@EK<EK@FE�=FI�K?<�DFJK�G8IK�@J�C8L>?K<I��#FN�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�:8GKLI<�K?8K�C8L>?K<I�?FN<M<I�@J�N?8K�D8B<J�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�LE@HL<�P<K�8CJF�<OKI<D<CP�J@D!@C8I�KF�FK?<I�D<;@LDJ��$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�8I<�J?FIK�8E;�98J<;�@E�@D8><J�� M<E�@E�K?<�:8J<�F=�GFGLC8I�M@;<FJ�C@B<�)LD8�)LD8�"LP�FI�K?<�I<:<EK�JD8J?�J<EJ8K@FE�F=�[!I@;8P\�9P�,<9<::8��C8:B� K?<�$EK<IE<K�(<D<�@J�J?8I<;�@E�<@K?<I�8�J:I<<EJ?FK�F=�K?<�M@;<F�FI�8�J?FIK�"$!�:FDGFJ<;�F=�J<M<I8C�=I8D<J�=IFD�K?<�M@;<F��$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�;F�EFK�K8B<�CFE>�KF�:I<!8K<�8E�<==<:K��D8EP�K@D<J�K?<�GLE:?C@E<�:8E�9<�;<C@M<I<;�@E�LE;<I�KNF�J<:FE;J�N@K?� C<JJ� K?8E����NFI;J��*K?<I� K@D<J� J<M<I8C�D<D<J�:8E�9<�8II8E><;� @E� 8� JKPC<�F=� 8�N<9:FD@:� @E;@M@;L8C�D<D<J�8J� K?<�9L@C;@E>�9CF:BJ�F=�K?<�:FD@:�8E;�K8B<�CFE><I�KF�I<8;��� .?<�:FD<;@:�=LE:K@FE@E>�F=�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�:8E�9<�KI8:<;�98:B�KF�K?<@I�JG?<I<�F=�FG<I8K@FE��$EK<IE<K��LCKLI<���FEJ@;<I�K?<�JK<I<FKPG<J�F=�$EK<IE<K��LCKLI<��8E;�$�?FG<�KF�LJ<�K?<J<�N@K?FLK�F==<EJ<�=FI�$�DPJ<C=�@E?89@K<;�8CC�F=�K?<J<�FE<�GF@EK���JK8P@E>�@EJ@;<�8E;�GC8P@E>�M@;<F�>8D<J�FI�JLI_E>�K?<�N<9�@EJK<8;�F=�GC8P@E>�JGFIKJ��HL@<K�8E;�J?P�@E�I<8C@KP�9LK�8E� 8M@;� 8EFEPDFLJ� :FDD<EK<I� FEC@E<�� C<8IE@E>� ?FN� JF=KN8I<�NFIBJ�8E;�C<8IE@E>�8J�DL:?�8J�GFJJ@9C<�=IFD�I8E;FD�@EK<IE<K�J@K<J��?FK�GF:B!<KJ��$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�J?8I<�K?<�J8D<�:LCKLI8C�8KK@KL;<J�8J�$EK<IE<K��LCKLI<��� $EK<IE<K�(<D<J�NFIB�FE�:FDDFE8C@K@<J�D8EP�F=� K?<�D<D<J�8I<� =LEEP�9<:8LJ<� K?<P� I<GI<J<EK� @JJL<J� K?8K�N<�;FE^K� ;@J:LJJ� @E� I<8C�C@=<�9LK�8I<�DFI<�K?8E�?8GGP�KF�9C89�89FLK�FEC@E<�N@K?�8�LJ<IE8D<��!FI�<O8DGC<�D<D<J�LJ<�K89FFJ�F=�<D98II8JJD<EK��J?8IK@E>�8�K<ID�N?@:?�D<8EJ�K?<�:FD9@E8K@FE�F=�=8IK@E>�8E;�;<=<:8K@E>��K89FFJ�F=�J<C=DF:B!<IP� �K?<� [=FI<M<I� 8CFE<\� :?8I8:K<I� I<GI<J<EKJ� 8CC� K?<� J@>E@_:8EK�FK?<I

Page 21: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

13

C<JJ�G<FGC<J�F=�K?<�$EK<IE<K��8E;�K89FFJ�F=�F==<EJ<��#@KC<I�@J�8�:FDDFE�D<D<�:?8I8:K<I�8J�N<CC�8J�:?8I8:K<IJ�K?8K�K8B<�@K<DJ�C@B<�I8G<�FI�G<;F!G?@C@8�8E;�D8B<�K?<D�;@J:LJJ89C<�KFG@:J�JL:?�8J�+<;F9<8I�8E;�$EJ8E@KP�1FC=���3<K�DFJK�D<D<J�:8E�9<�:8K<>FI@Q<;�LE;<I�K?<�8;A<:K@M<J�F=�:LK<�JLII<8C�JL9C@D<�G8IF;@:�J8K@I@:8C�8E;�89JLI;�Z�<M<IPK?@E>�=IFD�1?@K<�+<FGC<�!@IJK�1FIC;�+IF9C<DJ��8E�@D8><�F=�8E�LGJ<K�:IP@E>�NFD8E�N@K?�:8GK@FEJ�;<J:I@9@E>�8�GIF9C<D�F=�!@IJK�1FIC;�E8K@FEJ�JL:?�8J�JCFN�$EK<I!E<K��KF�)P8E��8K��8�CFFG@E>�@D8><�F=�8�:8IKFFE�:8K�N@K?�8�GFGK8IK�9F;P�`P@E>�K?IFL>?�JG8:<�8E;�C<8M@E>�8�KI8@C�F=�I8@E9FNJ��� 1?8K�@J�<JJ<EK@8C�KF�K?<�C@=<JG8E�F=�8E�$EK<IE<K�(<D<�K?FL>?�@J�@E�@KJ�@D@K8K@FEJ���J�CFE>�8J�D<D<J�8I<�9<@E>�:FG@<;�N@K?�E<N�:8GK@FEJ�FI�;@==<I<EK�8JJ<D9C8><J�K?<�D<D<�:8E�JLIM@M<��.?<I<=FI<�8E�$EK<IE<K�(<D<�DLJK�:FEJK8EKCP�<MFCM<� KF�:FDG<K<�N@K?� K?<�FK?<I�D<D<J�:FE!JK8EKCP�9<@E>�I<C<8J<;��$EK<I<JK@E>CP�K?<�<MFCLK@FE�F=�8E�$EK<IE<K�(<D<�:8E�9<�:FDG8I<;�KF�K?8K�F=�8�_CD�><EI<��.8B<�K?<�_CD�1<JK<IE�@E@K@8CCP�JK8IK@E>�N@K?�KIL<�1<JK<IEJ�8�C8�%F?E�!FI;�FI�Bonanza�K?<E�DFM@E>�KF�8�D8@EJKI<8D�98J<�N?<I<�<M<IPK?@E>�@J�8�1<JK<IE�8E;�<M<EKL8CCP�8�:FD!9@E8K@FE�F=�JKI8E><�G8IF;@<J�8E;�><EI<�D8J?LGJ� C@B<�Blazing$Saddles$FI�Cowboys$vs.$Aliens��(FJK�D<D<J�N@CC�<M<EKL8CCP�9<:FD<�I<`<O@M<�<@K?<I�9P�D8B@E>�=LE�F=�K?<@I�FNE�J?FIK:FD@E>J�FI�:FDD<EK@E>�FE�FK?<I�D<D<J�K?<I<9P�9<:FD@E>�D<K8D<D<J�

���

*E<�GFJJ@9C<�G8K?�8�D<D<�:8E�K8B<�?FN<M<I�@EMFCM<J�8�ALDG�@EKF�K?<�D8@EJKI<8D�� $EK<IE<K�(<D<J�:FEK8@E�8E� @DGFIK8EK� I<:@GIF:8C� I<C8K@FE!J?@G�N@K?�D8@EJKI<8D�GFGLC8I�:LCKLI<�@E�K?8K�D8EP�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�;<!G<E;�FE�:LCKLI8C�I<=<I<E:<J���"F;=8K?<I��89P���(FI<�F=K<E�@K�@J�8E�F9A<:K�=IFD�GFGLC8I�:LCKLI<��J8P�K?<�(FJK�$EK<I<JK@E>�(8E�@E�K?<�1FIC;�=IFD��FJ� HL@J�:FDD<I:@8CJ�FI�8�J:<E<�=IFD�8�_CD�JL:?�8J�#@KC<I�I<8:K@E>�KF�"<ID8EP^J�8IDP�CFJ@E>�K?<�N8I��K?8K�9<:FD<J�8E�$EK<IE<K�(<D<��3<K�FE�F::8J@FE�D8@EJKI<8D�D<;@8� �_CD� :FDD<I:@8CJ� 8;M<IK@J<D<EKJ� <K:���8KK<DGK�KF�D8B<�8�D<D<�GIF_K89C<�N?@:?�:8E�NFIB�9LK�@E�DFJK�:8J<J�C<8;J�KF�98:B_I<�8E;�K?<�_E8C�;<8K?�F=�K?<�D<D<�� �.?<�� ��_CD�Snakes$on$a$Plane�@J�8E�<O8DGC<�F=�#FCCPNFF;�8;8GK@E>�KF�$EK<IE<K��LCKLI<���=K<I�EFK@:@E>�D8JJ@M<�@EK<I<JK�FEC@E<�K?<�_CD�N8J�>@M<E�8���;8P�I<J?FFK�KF�@E:CL;<�C@E<J�=IFD�D<JJ8><�9F8I;J�8E;�=8ED8;<�G8IF;P�DFM@<J�@E:CL;@E>�K?<�@E=8DFLJ�C@E<�[$^M<�?8;�@K�

LEVINSON

Page 22: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

14

N@K?�K?<J<�DFK?<I=L:B@E>�JE8B<J�FE�K?@J�DFK?<I=L:B@E>�GC8E<\�N?@:?�NFLC;�9<�I8EB<;�����FE�[.?<�� �"I<8K<JK�(FM@<�'@E<J\�9P�+I<D@<I<�@E�� ��4��CJF�:FEJ@;<I�K?<�[�<;�$EKIL;<I�-FE>\�8�JFE>�D8;<�9P�8LKFKLE!@E>�8�E<NJ�I<GFIK�89FLK�8E�8KK<DGK<;�I8G<�@E�"<FI>@8��.?<�JFE>�I<8:?<;�ELD9<I����FE�K?<�/-��@CC9F8I;�#FK�� �8E;�JFC;�FM<I�� �:FG@<J�FE�@.LE<J�FE�K?<�_IJK�KNF�;8PJ�F=�@KJ�I<C<8J<��� 1?8K�KLIEJ�FLK�KF�9<�K?<�DFJK�:FEKIFM<IJ@8C�@JJL<�9<KN<<E�$EK<I!E<K��LCKLI<�8E;�(8JJ�(<;@8�?FN<M<I�@J�K?<�@;<8�F=�FNE<IJ?@G����?<8K!<;�98KKC<�9<KN<<E��FGPI@>?K�#FC;<IJ�8E;�$EK<IE<K�/J<IJ�:FD<J�;FNE�KF�K?8K�J@DGC<�@;<8��N?F�FNEJ�N?8K��*I>8E@Q8K@FEJ�C@B<�K?<�(FK@FE�+@:!KLI<��JJF:@8K@FE�F=��D<I@:8�8E;�K?<�,<:FI;@E>�$E;LJKIP��JJF:@8K@FE�F=��D<I@:8�?8M<�JK8K<;� K@D<�8E;�8>8@E� K?8K�FEC@E<�G@I8:P�F=�DFM@<J�8E;�DLJ@:� @J� :I@GGC@E>� K?<�<EK<IK8@ED<EK� @E;LJKIP��.?@J�;<98K<�:LCD@E8K<;�KF�8�GF@EK�FE�%8EL8IP���K?�� ���N?<E�N<9J@K<J�C@B<�1@B@G<;@8�1@I<;�"FF>C<�8E;�,<;;@K�G8IK@:@G8K<;�@E�8E�FEC@E<�9C8:BFLK�GIFK<JK� KF�;I8N�8KK<EK@FE�KF�KNF�9@CCJ�9<@E>�;@J:LJJ<;�@E��FE>I<JJ�K?<�-KFG�*EC@E<�+@!I8:P��:K�8E;�K?<�+IFK<:K�$+��:K��.?<�8:KJ�:FLC;�GFJJ@9CP�8CCFN�$EK<IE<K�:<EJFIJ?@G�9P�:FGPI@>?K�?FC;<IJ�N?F�J8N�K?<@I�D<;@8�LJ<;�N@K?FLK�K?<@I�G<ID@JJ@FE��.?<�9C8:BFLKJ�9IFL>?K�K?<�9@CCJ�KF�GL9C@:�C@>?K�8E;�:8LJ<;�8�D8AFI�D<;@8�J<EJ8K@FE���� 1?8K�E<<;J� KF�9<�:FEJ@;<I<;�FE�D<;@8�GFJJ<JJ@FE� @E� $EK<IE<K��LCKLI<� K?FL>?� @J� K?<� ;@==<I<E:<J� 9<KN<<E� @E;@M@;L8C� 8E;� :FCC<:K@M<�FNE<IJ?@G��1?<E�JFD<FE<�:I<8K<J�8E� $EK<IE<K�(<D<�N?F�FNEJ� K?8K�D<D<��-<M<I8C�FNE<IJ�:FLC;�:FD<�8E;�:C8@D�@K��K?<�8EFEPDFLJ�LGCF8;!<I�N?F�8;;<;�K?<�:8GK@FEJ�8IFLE;�K?<�@D8><�K?<�G?FKF>I8G?<I�N?F�KFFB�K?<�@D8><�8E;�GL9C@J?<;�@K�FEC@E<�@=�@K�@J�8�G?FKFJ?FG�D8J?LG�@K�:FLC;�9<�J<M<I8C�G?FKF>I8G?<IJ�JK8B@E>�:C8@DJ��.?@J�@JJL<�FG<EJ�8E�<EK@I<�:FC!C<:K@FE�F=�@;<8J�I<C8K<;�KF�C<>8C@KP�9LK�@E�K<IDJ�F=�K?<�:LCKLI8C�K?<FIP�@E�K?@J�8IK@:C<�@K�:8E�9<�8>I<<;�K?8K�K?<I<�@J�JKIFE>�8D9@>L@KP�@E�K?@J�_<C;�

���

�J� $EK<IE<K��LCKLI<� J<<GJ� @KJ�N8P� @EKF�D8@EJKI<8D�D8JJ�D<;@8� <M<IP�JF�F=K<E�9<KN<<E�8;M<IK@J<D<EKJ�8E;�JG<:@_:8CCP�K?<�$EK<IE<K�9C8:BFLK�GIFK<JK�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�8CJF�:FEK8@E�K?<�:8G8:@KP�=FI�GFC@K@:8C�:FDD<E!K8IP��*E�)FM<D9<I���K?�� ���8�M@;<F�N8J�LGCF8;<;�KF�3FL.L9<�J?FN!@E>�/���8M@J�:8DGLJ�GFC@:<�G<GG<I�JGI8P@E>�8�C@E<�F=�J@KK@E>�GIFK<JKFIJ�8K�:CFJ<�I8E><�FE�K?<�:8DGLJ^J�HL8;��1@K?@E�8�;8P�K?<�M@;<F�:8GKLI<;�

Page 23: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

15

K?<� GL9C@:^J� 8KK<E!K@FE� 9<:FD@E>� 8�?FK� KFG@:� F=� ;<98K<�@E� I<>8I;J� KF� K?<�*::LGP� GIFK<JKJ�K?8K�JK8IK<;�@E�<8ICP�-<GK<D9<I� F=� � ���@E� )<N� 3FIB� �@KP���LI@E>�K?<�KLDLCKL!FLJ� :?8FJ� 8E;� =8CC!FLK� =IFD� K?<� @E:@!;<EK�8�D8E@GLC8K<;�G?FKF� 8GG<8I<;� FE�

K?<�@EK<IE<K�F=�*=_:<I�%F?E�+@B<�JGI8P@E>�EFK�K?<�GIFK<JKFIJ�9LK��D<I@!:8^J�=FLE;@E>�=8K?<IJ�@E�%F?E�.ILD9LCC^J�G8@EK@E>�[�<:C8I8K@FE�F=�$E;<!G<E;<E:<\�Z�FI�8GG<8I@E>�@E�"<FI><J�-<LI8K^J�[��-LE;8P��=K<IEFFE�FE�K?<�$JC8E;�F=�'8�"I8E;<�%8KK<\�JGI8P@E>�8�NFD8E�N@K?�8�G8I8JFC��� �P�)FM<D9<I���E;�FECP�=FLI�;8PJ�8=K<I�K?<�@E@K@8C�GIFK<JK@E>�K?<I<�N<I<�@EELD<I89C<�G?FKFJ?FGG<;�@D8><J�8E;�=FLI�J<G8I8K<�9CF>J�JFC<CP�;<;@:8K<;�KF�K?<�D<D<�:FCC<:K@M<CP�K@KC<;�8J�[+<GG<I�-GI8P��FG�\��ABC$News�The$Atlantic�K?<�BBC�8E;�The$Wall$Street$Journal$?8;�8CC�NI@KK<E�8IK@:C<J�89FLK�[+<GG<I�-GI8P��FG�\�1?8K�D8B<J�K?@J�D<D<�JK@:B�FLK�@J�?FN�8D8Q@E>CP�=8JK�@K�D8;<�@KJ�N8P�@EKF�K?<�D8@EJKI<8D�8E;�?FN�:CFJ<CP�I<C8K<;�@K� @J�KF�:LII<EK�<M<EKJ��1?@C<�J<<@E>�+<GG<I�-GI8P��FG�:8JL8CCP�N8CB�K?IFL>?�=8DFLJ�G8@EK@E>J�@J�HL@K<�?LDFIFLJ�FK?<I�@D8><J�J?FN<;�?@D�JGI8P@E>�K?<�<P<J�F=���� �&<EK�-K8K<�JKL;<EK�(8IP�0<::?@F��=IFD�%F?E�!@CF^J� =8DFLJ�G?FKF>I8G?��J:I<8D@E>�FM<I�?<I� =<CCFN�JKL!;<EK^J�;<8;�9F;P��� +<GG<I�-GI8P��FG�?8J�:IFJJ<;�K?<�K?I<J?FC;�F=�<O@JK@E>�GLI<CP�=FI�<EK<IK8@ED<EK^J�J8B<�8E;�@EKF�8�E<N�DF;<�<O<DGC@=P@E>�K?<�`<O@9@C!@KP�F=�D<D<J�KF�J?@=K�9<KN<<E�:FEK<OKJ�8E;�GLIGFJ<J�<8J@CP���E;�G<I?8GJ�8K� JFD<� C<M<C� 8J�DP� I<J<8I:?�<OG8E;J� @K� @J� K?@J� 89@C@KP� KF�9<�LJ<;� @E�M8I@FLJ�N8PJ�8E;�=FI�M8I@FLJ�>F8CJ�K?8K�D8B<J�$EK<IE<K�(<D<��LCKLI<�JF�@DGFIK8EK�KF�@EK<IE<K�8E;�GFGLC8I�:LCKLI<��$K�@J�@E�K?<J<�LJ<J�K?8K�K?<�JKL;P�F=�D<D<J�D<I@KJ�JL:?�@DGFIK8E:<��K?<@I�LE@HL<�DF;<J�F=�:I<8K@FE�8E;�J?8I@E>�@E�:FEK<OK�F=�8�J?@=K@E>�8L;@<E:<�:FLGC<;�N@K?�K?<@I�LE;<I!>IFLE;�8E;�D8@EJKI<8D�:FEK<OKJ�J@>E@=P�8�:FEJK8EKCP�>IFN@E>�JKIL:KLI<�

LEVINSON

The$original$photograph$from$UC$Davis.Photo$by$Louise$Macabitas

Page 24: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

16

F=�<EK<IK8@ED<EK�K?8K�:FLC;�M<IP�N<CC�9<:FD<�8�D8@E�:FDGFE<EK�F=�N<JK!<IE�GFGLC8I�:LCKLI<�

����

!FI�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�KF�9<�:FEJ@;!<I<;�8�D<K?F;�F=�:FDDLE@:8K@FE�@E�$EK<IE<K��LCKLI<�K?<I<�DLJK�9<�JFD<�JFIK�F=�98J@:�LE@K�@E�N?@:?�:F?<I<EK�8E;�LE@M<IJ8C�J<EK<E:<J�

8E;�K?FL>?KJ�:8E�9<�:FEJKIL:K<;��$�GIFGFJ<�K?8K�K?@J�=LE;8D<EK8C�F9A<:K�F=�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�@J�K?<��;M@:<��E@D8C���E�8;M@:<�8E@D8C�I<HL@I<J�K?<�=FCCFN@E>��8�:IFGG<;�@D8><�F=�8E�8E@D8C�FI�?LD8E^J�=8:<�@E�K?<�D@;;C<�F=�8�:FCFI=LC�98:B>IFLE;�K?<�:FCFIJ�I<`<:K@E>�K?<�K?<D<�8K�K@D<J�F=�K?<�><E!<I8C�D<JJ8><�F=�K?<�8;M@:<�8E@D8CJ��.<OK�@J�C8P<I<;�89FM<�8E;�9<CFN�K?<�=8:<�LJL8CCP�89FM<�9<@E>�K?<�J<KLG�=FI�8�AFB<�8E;�9<CFN�K?<�GLE:?C@E<�� .?<� FI@>@E8C��;M@:<��E@D8C� :8E� 9<� KI8:<;� KF��;M@:<� �F>� @E�� �� K?<�=8:<�9<@E>�8�:LK<�'89I8;FI�,<KI@<M<I�+LGGP� K?<�98:B>IFLE;�I8@E9FN�G@<�JC@:<J�8E;�K?<�:8GK@FEJ�I<>8I;@E>�98;�8;M@:<�JL:?�8J�[�I@EB�(FKFI�*@C��&<<G�PFLI�<E>@E<J�ILEE@E>\�8E;�[-8M<�DFE<P��&@CC�?FFB<IJ�\�-G@EF==J�F=��;M@:<��F>�@E:CL;<��LJ@E<JJ��8K��["<K�K?FJ<�I<GFIKJ�KF�D<��,@>?K�D<FN\��+?@CFJFI8GKFI� �[1?8K� @=�+@EEF:?@F� J8@;� ](P�EFJ<�N@CC�EFN�>IFN�^\��8E;�"FF;�"LP�"I<>��['@B<;�8�98E;�9<=FI<�K?<P�D8;<�@K�9@>���F<JE^K�>F�FE�89FLK�@K\���(8EP�F=�K?<J<��;M@:<��F>�D<D<J�;F�EFK�<EK@I<CP�D8B<�J<EJ<�@E�K?<�J8D<�D8EE<I�K?8K�@KJ�JG@EF==J�;F�9LK�K?<I<�@J�JFD<K?@E>�NFIK?�K8B@E>�8�CFFB�8K�@E�@KJ�<MFCLK@FE��� $�NFLC;�C@B<�KF�9I@<`P�I<@K<I8K<�8E�<8IC@<I�G8JJ8><�I<>8I;@E>�K?<�8D9@>L@K@<J�F=�$EK<IE<K�FNE<IJ?@G�K?<�B<P�HL<JK@FE�9<@E>�[1?F�FNEJ�8E�$EK<IE<K�(<D<�\���I<C8K@M<CP�I<:<EK�KI<E;�@E�$EK<IE<K�(<D<��LCKLI<�

�(Below)$“Declaration$of$Independence”$by$John$Trumbull,$with$Pepper$Spray$Cop.$(Right)$“A$Sunday$Afternoon$on$the$Island$of$La$Grande$Jatte”$by$Georges$Seurat,$

with$Pepper$Spray$Cop.

Page 25: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

17

@J� K?<� :I<8K@FE� F=� >IFLGJ� FE� !8:<9FFB� K?8K� 8CCFN� LJ<IJ� KF� GFJK� $EK<I!E<K�(<D<J� K?8K� 8I<� JG<:@_:� KF� K?<@I� FI>8E@Q8K@FE� :8DGLJ�D<D<J� =FI�:FCC<><�JKL;<EKJ�GFGLC8K@E>�K?<�DFJK�G8><J��.8B<�=FI�<O8DGC<�FLI�FNE�/E@M<IJ@KP�F=�+@KKJ9LI>?^J�$EK<IE<K�(<D<�G8><�+@KK�(<D<J��$E�@K�LJ<IJ�GFJK�89FLK�:8DGLJ�9L@C;@E>J�JKL;<EK�>IFLGJ�:FDDFE�8EEFP8E:<J�8E;�K?<� F::8J@FE8C� :LII<EK� <M<EKJ�� $�DPJ<C=� :I<8K<;� 8�D<D<�98J<;� FE� K?<�I<F::LII@E>�G?<EFD<EFE�F=�:<IK8@E�JKL;<EKJ�K8B@E>�K?<�LJL8CCP�:IFN;<;�<C<M8KFIJ� @E� FLI� � � `FFI� 9L@C;@E>�.?<��8K?<;I8C� F=� '<8IE@E>� KF� K?<�K?@I;�`FFI�8E�<8J@CP�N8CB89C<�K?I<<�`@>?KJ�F=�JK8@IJ��/J@E>�8�:?8I8:K<I�K@KC<;�[3�/�)*�"LP\�$�<OGI<JJ<;�DP�=ILJKI8K@FE�N@K?�K?<�:8GK@FE�[.8B<��8K?<;I8C�<C<M8KFIJ�KF��I;�`FFI��3�/�)*�K8B<�JK8@IJ��\� 1?@C<�:8DGLJ�D<D<J�NFLC;�JLGGFJ<;CP�?<CG�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�JGI<8;� K?IFL>?FLK� ><E<I8C� GFGLC8I� :LCKLI<� K?<I<� ?8J� 9<<E� 8� :<IK8@E�8DFLEK� F=� 98:BC8J?� N@K?@E� D<D<� :FDDLE@K@<J� JL:?� 8J� ,<;;@K� 8E;��:?8E�:C8@D@E>�K?8K�K?<P�8I<�K?<�:I<8KFIJ�F=�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�8E;�K?<J<�:8DGLJ�!8:<9FFB�+8><J�89LJ<�K?<D���9LJ<�D8@ECP�D<8EJ�@E:FII<:KCP�LJ@E>�8E�$EK<IE<K�(<D<���LK�G<I?8GJ�K?@J�@;<8�F=�FNE<IJ?@G�:FD<J�98:B�@EKF�GC8P��.8B<�8�><E<I8C�8KK@KL;<�F=�$EK<IE<K��LCKLI<��<O:CLJ@M@KP��#FN�;@=_:LCK�@J�@K�KF�<EK<I�K?<�NFIC;�F=�FEC@E<�>8D@E>�N@K?FLK�:FD@E>�8:IFJJ�K?<�;<IF>8KFIP�C89<C�=FI�8E�LE<;L:8K<;�9<>@EE<I�[EFF9�\�+<I?8GJ�PFL�8I<�LE8N8I<�FI�8K�C<8JK�@CC@E=FID<;�F=�K?<�D8EP�M8CL<J�F=�$EK<IE<K��LC!KLI<�JL:?�8J�I<C@>@FE�GFGLC8I�:LCKLI<�FI�:LII<EK�<M<EKJ��.?<I<�8I<�<M<E�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�K?8K�I<GI<J<EK�K?<J<�FLKJ@;<IJ�KF�K?@J�:FCC<:K@M<�$EK<IE<K��LCKLI<� JF:@<KP���EEFP@E>�!8:<9FFB�"@IC� �[�FDGC8@EJ� 89FLK�D@JJ@E>�K?<� � J�� �FIE� @E� ������ 8E;� !@IJK��8P� FE� $EK<IE<K�&@;� �[$EK<IE<K� O!GCFI<I��.?8K^J�D<�8CI@>?K�\��� $EK<IE<K�(<D<J�8I<�8E�<O:CLJ@M<� KPG<�F=�:FDDLE@:8K@FE��@=�PFL�;F�EFK�BEFN�?FN�KF�LJ<�K?<�:FII<:K�D<D<�PFL�N@CC�9<�<O:CL;<;�=IFD�K?<�:LCKLI<�9<:8LJ<�PFL�;F�EFK�LE;<IJK8E;�?FN�K?<P�NFIB�� 1@K?�:8DGLJ�D<D<J�K?@J�I<M<IJ<J�K?<�<O:CLJ@M@KP�K?<�EFN�JLG!GFJ<;�FI@>@E8KFIJ�F=�$EK<IE<K�(<D<��LCKLI<�LEJLI<�<O8:KCP�N?8K�:8DGLJ�D<D<J�D<8E�9<:8LJ<� K?<P�8I<�EFK�8N8I<�F=� K?<�JG<:@_:�I<=<I<E:<J� KF�:8DGLJ�C@=<��+<I?8GJ�9<:8LJ<�F=�K?@J�K?<=K�8E;�I<M<IJ8C�F=�C8E>L8><�@K�@J�K?<�FEC@E<�D<D<�:FDDLE@K@<J�K?8K�:IP�=FLC�GC8P�8E;�:C8@D�FNE<IJ?@G�FE�K?<�D<D<J���<:8LJ<�N?@C<�8E�@E;@M@;L8C�D8P�=FI=<@K�FNE<IJ?@G�8C9<@K�@=�K?<P�8I<�8EFEPDFLJ�JL:?�8J�K?<�LGCF8;<I�FI�GIFD@E<EK�JL:?�8J�K?<�G?FKF>I8G?<I� K?<� :FCC<:K@M<� :LCKLI<� FNEJ� K?<�D<;@8�� $EK<IE<K��LCKLI<�

LEVINSON

Page 26: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

18

FNEJ�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�8E;�G<I?8GJ�K?@J�@;<8�F=�FNE<IJ?@G�:8E�K?<E�9<�8GGC@<;�KF�FK?<I�?<8K<;�8I<8J�F=�;@J:LJJ@FE�@E�G@I8:P�8E;�GFC@K@:8C�:FGP!I@>?K�98KKC<J�

���

$EK<IE<K�(<D<J� 8I<� K?<� C8E>L8><�F=� $EK<IE<K��LCKLI<� 8E;�N@K?@E� K?8K�C8E>L8><� N<� :8E� J<<� @KJ� 8KK@KL;<J� 8E;� DFI8CJ�� *E:<� K?<� C8E>L8><� @J�<JK89C@J?<;� @K� 9<:FD<J�<8J@<I� =FI� K?<�D<D9<IJ� KF� J?8I<�FG@E@FEJ�8E;�K8JK<J���J�$EK<IE<K��LCKLI<�9<:FD<J�JKIFE><I�<E:FDG8JJ@E>�DFI<�8E;�DFI<�FC;�D<;@8J�@EKF�@KJ�FNE�C8E>L8><�N?@C<�I<;<_E@E>�:LCKLI8C�EFIDJ�8E;�9<C@<=J�@K�JKI<E>K?<EJ�K?<�EFK@FE�K?8K�$EK<IE<K��LCKLI<�:FLC;�9<:FD<�K?<�;FD@E8EK�=FID�F=�D8JJ�GFGLC8I�:LCKLI<�<M<EKL8CCP�@E�FLI�C@=<K@D<��-?FN@E>�?FN�M<IJ8K@C<�8E;�GFC@K@:8C�K?<P�:8E�9<:FD<�8CCFNJ�K?<FI@JKJ�KF�;<K<ID@E<�K?<�M8CL<J�F=�8�E<N�><E<I8K@FE�F=�$EK<IE<K�LJ<IJ� K?IFL>?�@KJ�C8E>L8><��$EK<IE<K�(<D<J���E;�?PG<I9FC@:�@K�D8P�9<�N<�8I<�:FD@E>�:CFJ<I�KF�9<:FD@E>�JF�@E=LJ<;�N@K?�$EK<IE<K�K<:?EFCF>@<J�K?IFL>?�DF!9@C<�;<M@:<J�8E;�<M<IP;8P�@EK<I8:K@FEJ�K?8K�E<N9FIEJ�8I<�GI8:K@:8CCP�I<!:<@M@E>�@+8;J�JKI8@>?K�FLK�F=�K?<�NFD9�� M<E�8J�$EK<IE<K��LCKLI<�K?IFL>?�$EK<IE<K�(<D<J�?8J�K?<�GFK<EK@8C�KF�>IFN�<EFIDFLJCP�@E�J@Q<�K?FL>?�$�?FG<�KF�;@JK8E:<�DPJ<C=�=IFD�GI<;@:K@FEJ�8E;�JK8P�@E�K?<�GI<J<EK�FECP�KF�8I>L<�DP�GF@EK�K?8K�@E;<<;�$EK<IE<KJ�8I<�J<I@FLJ�9LJ@E<JJ�

Page 27: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

19

Page 28: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

20

Emily Grant� � � � � � � � @ J � 8 � J<E@FI �D8AFI @E>� @E�/I98E� -KL;@<J � 8E;� D@EFI@E>� @E � -G8E@J?� 8E;�'8K @E ��D<I@:8E�-KL;@<J � �-?<� @J � :F=FLE;<I � 8E;�C<8;<I � F= � -G8E>C @J?� �8 � +@ K KJ9LI>?� C8E>L8><� <O !:?8E><� :FDDLE@KP� ��JJ@J K8EK � �@:P:C< ��FFI;@ !E8KFI �8 K �K?<�+@ K KJ9LI>?��<G8IKD<EK �F= ��@ KP �+C8E !E@E>� 8E;� "CF98C ��D98JJ8;FI � =FI � $EK<IE8K @FE8C�-KL;@<J � �9IF8;� � � �<=FI<� 8GGCP@E>� KF � >I8;L8K<�J:?FFC � J?<� NFLC;� C @B<� KF � JG<E;� 8 � :FLGC< � F=�P<8IJ � @E � K?<� NFIB=FI:<� KF � ><K � 8 � 9<K K<I � LE;<I!JK8E;@E>� F= � N?8K � ;@I<:K @FE� J?<� NFLC;� C @B<� KF�K8B<�8J �8 �:8I<<I� �$ K �N8J�?<I �K8E>F�N@K?�CFM<�K?8K�@EJG@I<;�K?@J �G@<:< �9LK �@ K �N8J�K?<�:FC C89FI8K @FE�F= � KNF�NI@ K<IJ � K?8K �J K @ C C<;� @ KJ �GI<J<E:<� @E � K @D<����

Page 29: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

21

� � � � ���������@ J �8 �J<E@FI �8 K �+@ K K �D8AFI @E>� @E � E>C @J?�1I@ K @E>� 8E;��EK?IFGFCF>P�N@K?� :<I K @ = @:8K<J � @E �"CF98C � 8E;�'8K @E ��D<I@:8E�J KL;@<J � � -?<� ?8J �NI@ K K<E� =FI �The$Pi t t $News � 8E;�The$Original �D8>8Q@E< �NFIB<;�8J �8 � A8QQ��%�8K������1+.-�=FI �=FLI �P<8IJ �8E;�GC8P<;�K?<�J8OF !G?FE<� @E � +@ K K � A8QQ� 98E;� 8E;� M8I @FLJ� >IFLGJ� @E�K?<�+@ K KJ9LI>?� 8I<8� � � -?<� @J � :LII<EK CP � 8E� <;@ KF !I @8 C � @EK<IE� 8K �Sampsonia$Way �D8>8Q@E<� 8J �N<C C�8J �8 �GL9C @: � I< C8 K @FEJ�8E;�D8IB<K @E>� @EK<IE�N@K?�K?<� -@ CB � -:I<<E� �J@8E� �IKJ � 8E;� �LCKLI< � *I>8 !E@Q8K @FE� � -?<� 8CJF� MFCLEK<<IJ � 8J � 8 � -G8E@J?� =FI��<>@EE<IJ �@EJKIL:KFI �8 K � K?<��8IE<>@< �+L9C @: �'@ !9I8IP� � /GFE� >I8;L8K @E> � J?<� GC8EJ� FE� CFFB@E>�=FI � NFIB� 8K � 8 � EFEGIF=@ K � � M<EKL8C CP � J?<� ?FG<J�KF � I< KLIE� KF � J:?FFC � 8E;� K I8M<C � 8>8@E� KF � -FLK?��D<I@:8��

Merritt Wuchina

Page 30: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

22

FFFORBES & FIFTH

O

FFIC

E OF UNDERGRADUATE RESEARCH - O.U.R.

Page 31: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

23

.?I<<� P<8IJ� 8>F� FE�DP� _IJK� M@J@K� KF� K?<��8IE<>@<�(LJ<LD� F=��IK� $�I<8;�K?@J�D<JJ8><�FE�8�9CL<�:CFK?�9I8:<C<K�K?8K�?LE>�=IFD�K?<�N8CC�F=�8E�@EK<I8:K@M<�<O?@9@K��.?<J<�K?@E�:CFK?�9I8:<C<KJ�:FEK8@E<;�8�:FCC<:K@FE�F=�LE@HL<�N@J?<J�K?8K�NFLC;�:FD<�KIL<�8=K<I�K?<�98E;�=<CC�F==�=IFD�N<8I�8E;�K<8I��$�K@<;�@K�FE�DP�NI@JK���E�8IK@JK�D@>?K�?8M<�;<J@>E<;�@K�9LK�@K�N8J�DP�N@J?�Z�I$want$to$love$and$be$loved$in$big$cities��-F�=FI�KNF�8E;�8�?8C=�P<8IJ�@K�:CLE>�KF�D<��$�9FK?�EFK@:<;�8E;�@>EFI<;�@KJ�GI<J<E:<��@K�J?I@M<C<;�@EKF�DP�JB@E�8�K?@E�9CL<�C@E<�K?8K�:@I:C<;�DP�NI@JK�C@B<�K?<�M<@E�ILEE@E>�@E�K?<�FGGFJ@K<�;@I<:K@FE��-FD<K@D<J�$�NFLC;�GLCC�FE�K?<�JKI@E>J�KIP@E>�KF�D8B<�@K�JCFNCP�LEI8M<C�9LK�=FI�K?<�DFJK�G8IK�$�C<=K�@K�8CFE<��$�8CN8PJ�=<CK�K?8K�K?<�;8P�@K�C<=K�D<�NFLC;�9<�<OKI8FI;@E8IP��$�=FLE;�@K�CP@E>�FE�K?<�`FFI�N?@C<�<8K@E>�KFD8KF�JFLG�FE<�E@>?K�LEE<IM<;�9P�DP�8::<GK8E:<�C<KK<I�KF��L<EFJ��@I<J��$K�N8J�8CDFJK�8�;8P�C@B<�8EP�FK?<I��$E�8�9FO�F=�D<!D<EKFJ�$�=FC;<;�K?<�I@99FE�9<KN<<E�K?<�9IFB<E�=I@<E;J?@G�9I8:<C<KJ�F=�:?@C;?FF;�8E;�K?<�[;F�PFL�C@B<�D<�\�EFK<J�=IFD�D@;;C<�J:?FFC�Z�unos$������������$����������������!�� �#<I<�@E�K?<�DFJK�FI;@E8IP�DFD<EK�$�NFLC;�9<�LENFLE;��

���

$K^J�������8E;�K?<�9LQQ<I�AFCKJ�K?<�J@C<E:<;�8G8IKD<EK��Pipa�BEF:BJ�FE�DP�;FFI�KF�C<K�D<�BEFN�K?8K�8�G8:B8><�?8J�8II@M<;�=FI�D<��$�J?L=`<�KF�DP�9<;IFFD�;FFI�8E;�K?8EB�?<I��.?<�;FFI�J?LKJ�HL@<KCP��

$�J@K�;FNE�FE�K?<�9<;�8E;�FG<E�K?<�G8:B8><��Muma’s�:LG:8B<J�8CC�G<I!=<:KCP�D8;<�N@K?�8�98B<I^J�KFL:?�I@>?K�FLK�F=�8�postre�D8>8Q@E<��$�J@>?��$�CFM<�:LG:8B<J�=FI�K?<@I�_E@K<�JN<<KE<JJ�Z�8E�LE<OG<:K<;�DFD<EK�F=�AFP���LK� KF;8P� $�?8M<�M<IP� C@KKC<�8GG<K@K<� =FI�J8MFIP�DFD<EKJ����EFK<�NI8GG<;�B@E;CP� @E�8� I@99FE�8IFLE;� K?<�9FO�I<8;J�[.F�DP�JN<<K� D��N@J?@E>�PFL�8�M<IP�?8GGP�9@IK?;8P��'FM<�(FD�\�$�J?LK�DP�<P<J�8E;�<M!<IPK?@E>�@J�J@C<EK��$�:8E�?<8I�DP�<II8K@:�9I<8K?@E>�Z�K?<�B@E;�F=�9I<8K?!@E>� K?8K�GI<:<;<J� K<8IJ�� $� C<K�DP�N?FC<�9F;P� =<<C� K?<�G8@E�F=�DP� KIL<�9@IK?;8P�GI<J<EK�Z�D@JJ@E>�K?<�N8IDK?�F=�JFD<FE<�KF�J?8I<�K?@J� <<K@E>�JN<<KE<JJ�N@K?�D<��

I Want to Love and Be Loved in Big Cities1

Page 32: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

24

�J�$�J@K�FE�K?<�G8IB�9<E:?�N8@K@E>�=FI�?@D�KF�8II@M<�DP�9F;P�J?@M<IJ�N@K?�8�EFE<O@JK<EK�:?@CC��1FI;J�B<<G�9LQQ@E>�@E�DP�?<8;�@E�N?8K<M<I�C8E>L8><�J<<DJ�_K�9LK�$�:8E^K�<J:8G<�K?<�G?I8J<��todavía$estás$enamoBrada$con$ella$y$no$me$querés��3FL�8I<�JK@CC�@E�CFM<�N@K?�?<I�8E;�PFL�;F�EFK�CFM<�D<�� M<IPK?@E>�<CJ<�;F<JE^K�J<<D�KF�D8KK<I��$�?8M<�EF�8I>LD<EK�KF�D8B<�?@D�:?8E><�?@J�D@E;� KF�JKFG�?@D�=IFD�8KK<E;@E>�?<I�>F@E>8N8P�G8IKP�C<8M@E>�D<�8CFE<�FE�DP�9@IK?;8P��$�?8M<�EFK?@E>��#<�8II@M<J�_CC<;�N@K?�K<8IJ�8E;�JFIIFN�8GFCF>@<J�8E;�>L@CK�9LK�@K�;F<JE^K�:?8E><�8EPK?@E>��$�?8E;�?@D�K?<� ;>8I��CC8E�+F<�9FFB�?<�C<EK�D<��$�8D�K?<�K<CCK8C<�?<8IK�9<8K@E>�J@C<EKCP�9<CFN�K?<�`FFI9F8I;J��$�B@JJ�?@D�>FF;9P<�8E;�N8CB�8N8P��$�?8M<�EF�D<DFIP�F=�N?8K�?8GG<EJ�E<OK�9<:8LJ<�KF�?@D�$�;F�EFK�<O@JK��.?<�NFIC;�$�:I<8K<;�N@K?�?@D�@J�J?8KK<I<;�9<:8LJ<�@K�N8J�E<M<I�I<8C��8�MF@;�F=�?FG<�8E;�;<JG<I8K@FE�CFE>@E>�8E;�CLJK��.?<�9FO�F=�:LG:8B<J�I<D8@EJ�LEKFL:?<;�8J�K?<�GC8JK@:�[Feliz$cumple\�:8E;C<�K@CKJ�KF�K?<�J@;<�N@K?�JN@ICJ�F=�;LC:<�;<�C<:?<�DF:B@E>�D<�C@B<�8E�F==B@CK<I�JD@C<�

����

.?I<<�DFEK?J�C8K<I�8J�N<�C8P�@E�9<;�?@J�_E><IJ�KI8:<�DP�9<CCP�8E;�DP�8IDJ�D<DFI@Q@E>�<M<IP�@E:?�8J�N<�;FJ<�F==�G<8:<=LCCP����;@==<I<EK�B@E;�F=�MF@;�_CCJ�DP�J@C<E:<��8�JFIIFN�K?8K�CFE>J�=FI�<E;C<JJ�K@D<�Z�K?8K�K?@J�DFD<EK�;F<J�EFK�<E;��$�C<8IE<;�KF�=FI>@M<�8J�?<�C<8IE<;�KF�CFM<�8>8@E��$�C<8E�@EKF�?@J�<8I�8E;�8JB�?@D�?FN�KF�J8P�:LG:8B<J�@E�-G8E@J?��#<�?8J�EF�@;<8�JF�$�;<J:I@9<�8�tarta$chiquita,$como$si$fuera$una$tarta$individual…$glaseada$a$perfección��#<�I8@J<J�?@J�<P<9IFNJ�N@K?�@EK<I<JK��$�K<CC�?@D�N?<E�N<�N8B<�LG�=IFD�FLI�siesta�$�N8EK�8�:LG:8B<��JFD<K?@E>�JN<<K�8E;�J8MFIP��DFD<EK8IP�8E;�_E@K<�C@B<�LJ��

���

.F;8P� 8J� $� J@K� @E�DP�G8I<EK^J� :FLEKIP� ?FD<� $� ILDD8><�9<E<8K?�DP�:CFK?<J�8E;�Historias$de$Horror�9P� ;>8I��CC<E�+F<�8E;�GLCC�FLK�DP�9FO�F=�D<D<EKFJ�K?<�I@99FE�CFFB@E>�DFI<�K8KK<I<;�8E;�=I8P<;�K?8E�$�I<!D<D9<I<;��.?<�NI@K@E>�?8J�CFE>�=8;<;�8E;�K?<�N@J?�FECP�JLIM@M<J�8J�8E�<K:?@E>�@E�DP�D<DFIP���J�$�;I@M<�@EKF�K?<�JLEJ<K�@EJK<8;�F=�;<J:<E;@E>�@EKF�K?<�JL9N8P�8J�$�CFFB�LG�8K�JK8IJ�@EJK<8;�F=�JKI<<KC@>?KJ�8E;�8J�$�=8CC�8JC<<G�KF�8�:?FILJ�F=�:I@:B<KJ�@EJK<8;�F=�9C<<;@E>�J@I<EJ�CFM<�8E;�CFM@E>�@E�K?<�9@>�:@KP�?8J�E<M<I�=<CK�JF�=8I�8N8P��

Page 33: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

25

(P�9@IK?;8P�@J�E<OK�N<<B�8E;�$�8D�_CC<;�N@K?�9@KK<IJN<<K�D<DFI@<J��$�9<>@E�KF�@D8>@E<�8�:FLGC<�J@KK@E>�FE�8�G8IB�9<E:?�<O:?8E>@E>�te$quiero$=FI�K?<�_IJK�K@D<��$�JD@C<�KF�DPJ<C=��8�E<N�9<>@EE@E>���LK�$�EF�CFE><I�=<<C�?@J�_E><IJ�KI8:@E>�8�J?8G<�F=�8�?<8IK�FE�DP�JB@E��$�:8E�FECP�@D8>@E<�K?<�>FFJ<�9LDGJ�$�LJ<;�KF�=<<C��

.?@J� P<8I�DP�DFD�FI;<I<;� 8E� @:<� :I<8D�:8B<� K?8K� I<8;J� [.F� JN<<K�<E;@E>J�8E;�E<N�9<>@EE@E>J�K?8K�;FE^K�E<:<JJ8I@CP�D<CK�8N8P�\�)FN�$�?8M<�8�E<N�9I8:<C<K�K?8K�$�9FL>?K��$K^J�K?@:B�8E;�JKLI;P�N@K?�8�G8KK<IE�F=�DLCK@:FCFI<;�JHL8I<J��$�GLCC�K?<�JKI@E>J�KF><K?<I��$�K8B<�8�D8K:?�8E;�C@>?K�K?<�<E;J�KF�=FID�8�?8I;�N8OP�9FE;��1@K?�8�J@E><;�:FEE<:K@FE�K?<�9I8:<!C<K�NFE^K�9I<8B�LEK@C�$�:?FFJ<�KF�GLK�@K�8N8P�@E�DP�9FO�F=�D<D<EKFJ�8E�FI;@E8IP�D<DFIP�JK@CC<;�@E�K@D<��

GRANT / WUCHINA

Page 34: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

26

Page 35: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

27

� � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � @ J �8 �J<E@FI �D8 !AFI @E>�@E �(LJ@: �8E;�+?@ CFJFG?P �N@K?�8 �D@EFI �@E��FDGLK<I � -:@<E:<� 8E;� 8E� <M<EKL8C � �8:?<CFI ^J�F= � +?@ CFJFG?P� ;<>I<<� � $E � K?<� !8C C � F= � � �� � ?<�J KL;@<;�89IF8;�@E �(FE>FC@8 �N?<I<�?@J �F9J<IM8 !K @FEJ�F= �K?<�DLJ@: �8E;�:LC KLI< �;<<G<E<;�?@J �8G !GI<:@8K @FE�F= �DLJ@:8C �D<8E@E> �=FID �J K IL:KLI< �8E;�JFLE;�Z�@E�8;;@ K @FE�KF �@EJG@I @E>�K?@J �G@<:<��1?<E�?<� @J � EFK � 9LJP� I<8;@E>� K?<�G?@ CFJFG?P�F=�'L;N@>� 1@K K><EJK<@E� 8E;� ><K K @E>� CFJK � @E � K?<�?<8MP� D<K8C � F= � (<J?L>>8? � ?<� <EAFPJ� GC8P@E>�K?<�98JJ �@E �CF:8C �98E;�(P�-FE��8E@<C �8E;�IF:B !@E>� K?<�.LIB@J?�?8E;�;ILD� @E�+@ K K ^J ��8IG8K?@8E� EJ<D9C<�

J o n a t h a n H e i n s

Page 36: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

28

FFFORBES & FIFTH

O

FFIC

E OF UNDERGRADUATE RESEARCH - O.U.R.

Page 37: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

29

New Representations of the ‘Golden Lineage’.?<�(FE>FC@8E�!FCB�,F:B�F=��CK8E�/I8>

*M<I� K?<� G8JK� KNF� ;<:8;<J� J@E:<� K?<� ;<DF:I8K@:� I<MFCLK@FE� F=� ��� �(FE>FC@8�?8J�<OG<I@<E:<;�I8G@;�;<M<CFGD<EK�;I@M<E�GI@D8I@CP�9P�=FI!<@>E� @EM<JKD<EK� @E� C8I><�D@E<J� C@B<�*PL�.FC>F@� 8E;�.8M8E�.FC>F@�� $E�G8IK@:LC8I�K?<�:8G@K8C�:@KP�/C88E988K8I�?8J�:?8E><;�;I8D8K@:8CCP��E<N�8G8IKD<EK� 9CF:BJ� J<<D� KF� JGIFLK� =IFD� K?<� >IFLE;� 8CDFJK� JGFI8;@:8C!CP��FLK;8K<;�8E;�@E8;<HL8K<�IF8;J�8I<�:FEJK8EKCP�A8DD<;�=LCC�F=�'8E;��IL@J<IJ�� 8E;� E<N� J?FGJ� JKFI<J� 8E;� I<JK8LI8EKJ� :8E� 9<� =FLE;� <M<IP!N?<I<���LK�@K� @J�EFK�FECP�K?<�G?PJ@:8C�=8:<�F=�(FE>FC@8�K?8K� @J�:?8E>!@E>�� 8�(FE>FC@8EJF:@8C@JK� :LCKLI<� 8E;�NFIC;M@<N�?8J�>@M<E�N8P� KF� 8�(FE>FC@8E>CF98C�:LCKLI<�8J�[>CF98C�:LCKLI<\�=IFD��D<I@:8�"<ID8EP�&FI<8� %8G8E� ,LJJ@8� 8E;� �?@E8� @E:I<8J@E>CP� G<E<KI8K<J� (FE>FC@8^J�GFC@K@:8C�9FI;<IJ�� M<E�@E�K?<�DFI<�I<DFK<�8I<8J�F=�(FE>FC@8�C@B<�K?<�EFIK?<IEDFJK�8@D8>�FI�GIFM@E:<�F=�#LMJ>LC�KI8;@K@FE8C�G8JKFI8C�C@=<!JKPC<J�8I<�:?8E>@E>�;L<� KF� @E:I<8J<;�<OGFJLI<� KF�>CF98C�:LCKLI<�1�.?@J�I8G@;�G?PJ@:8C�8E;�JF:@8C�:?8E><�:FD9@E<;�N@K?�K?<�;<DF:I8K@:�=I<<;FD�=FI�J<C=<OGI<JJ@FE�?8J�GIFDGK<;�(FE>FC@8EJ�KF�I<:I<8K<�K?<@I�@;<EK@K@<J�8J�@E;@M@;L8CJ�8E;�8J�8�E8K@FE�� *E<�N8P�K?<P�?8M<�;FE<�K?@J�@J�KF�:I<8K<�8�JKIFE>�J<EJ<�F=�E8!K@FE8C� @;<EK@KP� K?8K� @J�;<<GCP�IFFK<;� @E�(FE>FC@8E�?@JKFIP�8E;�:LCKLI<�@E:CL;@E>� K?<� :FEHL<JKJ� F=� �?@E>>@J�&?8E� @E� K?<� C8K<� ��K?� 8E;� <8ICP���K?�:<EKLI@<J�K?<�J<D@EFD8;@:�8E;�G8JKFI8C�C@=<JKPC<�JK@CC�GI8:K@:<;�9P�89FLK�8�K?@I;�F=�K?<�(FE>FC@8E�GFGLC8K@FE�8E;�DLJ@:8C�KI8;@K@FEJ�JL:?�8J�?FFD@@��K?IF8K�J@E>@E>�FI�FM<IKFE<�J@E>@E>��LIKPE�;LL��CFE>�JFE>��8E;� K?FJ<�F=� K?<�DFI@E�B?LLI� �?FIJ<?<8;�_;;C<��� $E;<<;� K?<� J@>E@_!:8E:<�F=�(FE>FC@8E�DLJ@:8C�KI8;@K@FEJ�@E�:FEJKIL:K@E>�8�E8K@FE8C�(FE!>FC@8E�@;<EK@KP�@J�<M@;<E:<;�9P�K?<�GI<J<E:<�F=�JL:?�JK8K<�<EJ<D9C<J�8J�K?<�)8K@FE8C�!FCB�8E;��8E:<� EJ<D9C<�8E;�K?<�)8K@FE8C�(FI@E�&?LLI� EJ<D9C<�9P�K?<�JL9JK8EK@8C�:FCC<:K@FE�F=�(FE>FC@8E�KI8;@K@FE8C�DLJ@:�I<:FI;J�=FI�J8C<�@E�JKFI<J�C@B<�#@!@�,<:FI;J�@E�/C88E988K8I�8E;�@E�K?<�LJ<�F=�?FFD@@�CFE>�JFE>�8E;�DFI@E�B?LLI�@E�M8I@FLJ�K<C<M@J@FE�8;M<I!K@J<D<EKJ�8E;�GIF>I8DJ��� (FI<�@EK<I<JK@E>�?FN<M<I�8E;�DFI<�GIFD@E<EK�@J�K?<�@EK<>I8!K@FE� F=� <C<D<EKJ� F=� KI8;@K@FE8C� (FE>FC@8E� DLJ@:� @EKF�1<JK<IE� DLJ@!

HEINS

Page 38: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

30

:8C�JKPC<J�8E;�=FIDJ�C@B<�GFG�DLJ@:��(FE>FC@8E�GFG�DLJ@:�M@;<FJ�8I<�9IF8;:8JK�FE�J<M<I8C�K<C<M@J@FE�JK8K@FEJ�;<MFK<;�KF�DLJ@:�@E�?FD<J�8E;�I<JK8LI8EKJ�K?IFL>?FLK�/C88E988K8I�8E;�K?<�:FLEKIPJ@;<�8E;�K?<J<�(FE!>FC@8E�GFG�JFE>J�F=K<E�=<8KLI<�D<CF;@<J�8E;�CPI@:J�K8B<E�;@I<:KCP�=IFD�KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�9F>@EF�;LL�FI� J?FIK� JFE>J� �@E�:FEKI8JK� KF� CFE>�JFE>J�N?@:?�?8M<�8�M<IP�;@==<I<EK�JKPC<�8E;�JKIL:KLI<���.?@J�@EK<>I8K@FE�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�DLJ@:8C�<C<D<EKJ�@EKF�1<JK<IE�DLJ@:8C�=FIDJ�8E;�JKPC<J�N?@:?�<K?EFDLJ@:FCF>@JK��8IFC<�+<>>�;<J:I@9<J�8J�[?P9I@;�(FE>FC1<JK<IE�DLJ@:\2�@J�EFK�C@D@K<;�KF�GFG�DLJ@:8C�><EI<J�9LK�8CJF�F::LIJ�@E�IF:B�DLJ@:�><EI<J���8E;J�JL:?�8J�#LI;�8E;�&?8I8E>8�N?@:?�9<>8E�@E�K?<���� J�_IJK�@EKIF;L:<;�K?<�1<JK<IE�?<8MP�D<K8C�8E;�?8I;�IF:B�JKPC<J�KF�(FE>FC@8�8E;�>8@E<;�J@>E@_:8EK�GFGLC8I@KP��� .?<I<�8I<�M8IP@E>�;<>I<<J�F=�(FE>FCE<JJ�8E;�1<JK<IEE<JJ�@E�[?P9I@;�(FE>FC1<JK<IE\�DLJ@:�?FN<M<I���8E;J�C@B<�#LI;�8E;�&?8!I8E>8�8J�N<CC�8J�D8EP�:FEK<DGFI8IP�IF:B�FLK_KJ�C@B<�.?<�'<DFEJ�8E;�!@I<�8;FGK�8�JKI8@>?K=FIN8I;�IF:B�@EJKILD<EK8K@FE�JFLE;�8E;�JKPC<�9LK�@E:FIGFI8K<� KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�D<CF;@<J�8E;� CPI@:8C� K?<D<J��-FD<�>IFLGJ�?FN<M<I�C@B<�&?LJL>KLE�8E;��CK8@E�*I>@C�LJ<�KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE!>FC@8E�@EJKILD<EKJ�C@B<�K?<�DFI@E�B?LLI�K?<�KI8;@K@FE8C�J@E>@E>�JKPC<J�F=�?FFD@@�8E;�CFE>�JFE>�8E;�<M<E�8;FIE�KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�;I<JJ�;LI!@E>�G<I=FID8E:<J��-L:?�@EJKILD<EK8K@FE�JFLE;�8E;�8GG<8I8E:<�D8B<�K?<@I�DLJ@:�J<<D�DFI<�@DD<;@8K<CP�(FE>FC@8E�8E;�K?<�1<JK<IEE<JJ�F=�K?<�DLJ@:�@J�8GG8I<EK�@E�DFI<�JL9KC<�<C<D<EKJ�C@B<�?8IDFEP�8E;�DLJ@:8C�JKIL:KLI<��.?<� I<JLCK� @J� 8�DLJ@:8C� JKPC<� K?8K� @J� @E� JFD<� I<JG<:KJ� KI8;@!K@FE8CCP�(FE>FC@8E�8E;�P<K�;@JK@E:KCP�DF;<IE�8E;�N?@:?�;<C@9<I8K<CP�<MFB<J�@D8><J�F=�8�G<I:<@M<;�(FE>FC@8E�KI8;@K@FE8C�?<I@K8><�� +<I?8GJ� EF� JL:?� ?P9I@;�(FE>FC1<JK<IE� 98E;� @J�DFI<�N<CCBEFNE�DFI<�:FDD<I:@8CCP�JL::<JJ=LC�FI�DFI<�@E`L<EK@8C�K?8E�K?<�J<C=GIF:C8@D<;�[(FE>FC@8E�=FCB�IF:B\�98E;��CK8E�/I8>���CK8E�/I8>�N?@:?�CFFJ<CP�KI8EJC8K<J�KF�["FC;<E�'@E<8><\�@E�I<=<I<E:<�KF�K?<�IFP8C�8E:<J!KI8C�C@E<�F=��?@E>>@J�&?8E�@J�LE@HL<�8DFE>�K?<�8=FI<D<EK@FE<;�98E;J�=FI�K?<�@EEFM8K@M<�N8PJ�K?8K�K?<P�9C<E;�1<JK<IE�IF:B�JFLE;J�8E;�@D8>!<IP�N@K?�KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�JFLE;J�8E;�@D8><IP�N@K?�K?<�@EK<EK@FE�F=�EFK�D<I<CP�9<@E>�KI8;@K@FE8C�9LK�F=�;<C@9<I8K<CP�I<:8JK@E>�KI8;@K@FE��.?<@I�D8JK<I=LC�D@OKLI<�F=�FC;�8E;�E<N�?8J�I<JLCK<;�@E�K?<�GIF;L:K@FE�F=�J<M<E�JKL;@F�8C9LDJ�J<M<I8C�DLJ@:�M@;<FJ�G8IK@:@G8K@FE�@E�KNF�=LCCC<E>K?�_CDJ�G8IK@:@G8K@FE�@E�J<M<I8C�@EK<IE8K@FE8C�DLJ@:�=<JK@M8CJ�8E;�

Page 39: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

31

8GG<8I8E:<J�FE�E8K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�K<C<M@J@FE��.?<P�:C8@D�ALJK@_89CP�KF�9<�[FE<�F=�K?<�G@FE<<IJ\�F=�K?<�(FE>FC@8E�=FCB�IF:B�><EI<�@EKF�N?@:?�98E;J�C@B<�&?LJL>KLE�8E;��CK8@E�*I>@C�8I>L89CP�=8CC�3�.?<@I�JL::<JJ�8E;�GFGLC8I@KP�D<8EJ�K?8K�K?<P�?8M<�8�GIFD@E<EK�IFC<�@E�J?8G@E>�8�DF;<IE�GFJKJF:@8C@JK� E8K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E� @;<EK@KP�N@K?@E� :FEK<DGFI8IP�(FE!>FC@8E>CF98C� :LCKLI<� FE<� K?8K� CFFBJ� KF�(FE>FC@8^J� G<I:<@M<;� 8E:@<EK�KI8;@K@FEJ�8E;�?<I@K8><��.?@J�G8G<I�N@CC� K?<I<=FI<� @EM<JK@>8K<� K?<�N8PJ�@E�N?@:?��CK8E�/I8>�:FD9@E<J�<C<D<EKJ�F=�9FK?�KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�8E;�1<JK<IE�DLJ@:�8E;�:LCKLI<�@E�FI;<I�KF�I<:8JK�8E;�I<:I<8K<�(FE>FC@8E�KI8;@K@FE�K?IFL>?�JFLE;�8E;�@D8><�� .?<I<�8I<�GIF9C<DJ�@E�;@J:LJJ@E>�[KI8;@K@FE8C\�(FE>FC@8E�DLJ@:�K?8K�N<�DLJK�_IJK�8;;I<JJ�9<=FI<�9<>@EE@E>�8E�8E8CPJ@J�F=��CK8E�/I8>^J�DLJ@:��"<E<I8CCP�N?<E�N<�JG<8B�F=� KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�DLJ@:�N<�8I<�I<=<II@E>�KF�GI<JF:@8C@JK�G<I@F;�DLJ@:8C�GI8:K@:<J��.?<�JF:@8C@JK�G<!I@F;�=IFD������Y���� �@J�><E<I8CCP�I<>8I;<;�EFN�8J�8�G<I@F;�F=�=FI<@>E�@;<FCF>@:8C� ILC<� 8E;� F=� JLGGI<JJ@FE� F=�(FE>FC@8E� :LCKLI8C� <OGI<JJ@FE�@E�=8MFI�F=�,LJJ@8E�8E;�1<JK<IE�:LCKLI8C�<OGI<JJ@FE�4�.?<I<=FI<�[I<8C\�(FE>FC@8E�KI8;@K@FEJ�8I<�K?FJ<�N?@:?�N<I<�GI8:K@:<;�9<=FI<�K?@J�G<I@F;�F=�@;<FCF>@:8C�ILC<�8E;�JF:@8C@Q8K@FE��� /E=FIKLE8K<CP�K?<�?@JKFI@:8C�:FEE<:K@FE�9<KN<<E�K?<�GI<JF:@8C!@JK�G<I@F;�8E;�K?<�GFJKJF:@8C@JK�G<I@F;�@J�<OKI<D<CP�K<ELFLJ�8K�C<8JK�N@K?�I<>8I;�KF�KI8;@K@FE8C�DLJ@:8C�GI8:K@:<J���LII<EK�[KI8;@K@FE8C\�DFI@E�B?LLI�I<G<IKF@I<�?8J�8CDFJK�EF�;F:LD<EK<;�:FEE<:K@FE�KF�K?<�GI<JF:@8C@JK�G<!I@F;�8J�D<CF;@<J�N<I<�EFK�I<8CCP�NI@KK<E�;FNE�LEK@C�;LI@E>�K?<�JF:@8C@JK�G<I@F;�LJ@E>�1<JK<IE�DLJ@:8C�EFK8K@FE���(FI@E�B?LLI�G<I=FID8E:<�GI8:!K@:<�KI8@E@E>�8E;�<M<E�K?<�@EJKILD<EK�@KJ<C=�?8M<�9<<E�K?FIFL>?CP�DF;!<IE@Q<;�8E;�1<JK<IE@Q<;�;LI@E>�K?<�JF:@8C@JK�G<I@F;�9P�JK8K<�:LCKLI8C�@E!JK@KLK@FEJ�C<8M@E>�=<N�KI8:<J�F=�G<I=FID8E:<�GI8:K@:<�FI�JFLE;�=IFD�K?<�GI<JF:@8C@JK�G<I@F;���.?<�DFI@E�B?LLI�N8J�EFK�8CFE<��FK?<I�(FE>FC@8E�@EJKILD<EKJ�8E;�J@E>@E>�JKPC<J�=8:<;�J@D@C8I�I<:C8JJ@_:8K@FE�I<JKIL:KLI!@E>�8E;�JK8E;8I;@Q8K@FE�F=�G<I=FID8E:<�GI8:K@:<J���.?LJ�@E�D8EP�N8PJ�N?8K�@J�EFN�:8CC<;�KI8;@K@FE8C�=FCB�DLJ@:�@E�(FE>FC@8�@J�I<8CCP�K?<�?<8M!@CP�1<JK<IE@Q<;�GIF;L:K�F=�� �P<8IJ�F=�JF:@8C@Q8K@FE�8E;�JK8E;8I;@Q8K@FE�8@D<;�8K�DF;<IE@Q8K@FE��� .?@J�@J�J@>E@_:8EK�9<:8LJ<�@K�@J�K?@J�B@E;�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>F!C@8E�DLJ@:�K?8K�@J�K8L>?K�JK@CC�@E�K?<�(FE>FC@8E�(LJ@:�8E;��8E:<��FC!C<><�N?<I<��CK8E�/I8>�N8J�KI8@E<;��.?LJ��CK8E�/I8>^J�KI8;@K@FE8C�DLJ@:�

HEINS

Page 40: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

32

@J�@E�EF�N8P�GLI<�FI�8LK?<EK@:�@E�K?<�J<EJ<�F=�9<@E>�KFK8CCP�GI<JF:@8C@JK��$E;<<;�K?<J<�=8:KJ�89FLK�(FE>FC@8E�KI8;@K@FE8C�DLJ@:�:8CC�@EKF�HL<JK@FE�K?<� ;@JK@E:K@FE� 9<KN<<E� KI8;@K@FE8C� 8E;�DF;<IE�1<JK<IE� K?8K�N<� ?8M<�LJ<;�K?LJ�=8I�@E�K?@J�G8G<I��$K�NFLC;�J<<D�K?8K�K?<�[]KI8;@K@FE8C �<C<D<EKJ�F=�(FE>FC@8E�DLJ@:�8I<�K?<DJ<CM<J�8�D@OKLI<�F=�8CC�B@E;�F=�@E`L<E:<J�=IFD�GI<JF:@8C@JK�KF�JF:@8C@JK�KF�GFJKJF:@8C@JK�\��� )<M<IK?<C<JJ�<M<E�@=�K?<�C@E<�9<KN<<E�KI8;@K@FE8C�8E;�1<JK<IE�@J�9CLII<;�FI�8CKF><K?<I�EFE<O@JK<EK� K?<�=8:K� I<D8@EJ� K?8K�(FE>FC@8EJ�:FEK@EL<�KF�GI8:K@:<�K?<J<�[KI8;@K@FE8C\�DLJ@:8C�=FIDJ�N@K?�8E�<P<�KF�K?<�G8JK��.?@J�G8JK�@J�EFK�E<:<JJ8I@CP�8LK?<EK@:��9LK�K?<E�8>8@E�K?8K�@J�EFK�K?<�GF@EK��.?<�I<8C�>F8C�@E�G<I=FID@E>�[KI8;@K@FE8C\�DLJ@:�@J�KF�<MFB<�@D!8><J�F=�8�G<I:<@M<;�G8JK�N@K?�GI8:K@:<J�K?8K�8I<�K@<;�?FN<M<I�CFFJ<CP�KF�K?8K�G8JK��$E�K?@J�N8P�FE<�:8E�J8P�K?8K�K?<�I<C<M8EK�J<EJ<�F=�KI8;@K@FE�?<I<�@J�8J�JFD<K?@E>�@D8>@E<;�FI�:I<8K<;�9P�8�GIF:<JJ�K?8K�[LK@C@Q<J�J<C<:K@FE�8E;�@EM<EK@FE�F=�D8K<I@8CJ�\9��� �CK8E�/I8>�?8J�9<<E�[J<C<:K@E>\�<C<D<EKJ�F=�K?@J�JF:@8C@Q<;�KI8!;@K@FE�:I<8K<;�@E@K@8CCP�KF�JLGGFIK�8�E8K@FE8C�JF:@8C@JK�@;<EK@KP�8E;�8G!GIFGI@8K@E>�K?<D�=FI�K?<�:I<8K@FE�F=�8�E8K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�@;<EK@KP��.?8K��CK8E�/I8>�:FEE<:KJ�(FE>FC@8E�KI8;@K@FE8C�DLJ@:�KF�@;<8J�F=�E8K@FE8C@KP�8E;�(FE>FC@8EE<JJ�@J�LE;<E@89C<�Z�J<<�JFE>�K@KC<J�C@B<�[(FK?<I�(FE!>FC@8\�["I<8K�(FE>FC@8\�[.<DLLA@E\�8E;�[�CL<�(8IB�\�$E�K?<@I�DLJ@:��CK8E�/I8>�8GGIFGI@8K<J�<C<D<EKJ�F=� JF:@8C@Q<;� KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�DLJ@:�@E�FI;<I�KF�GF@EK�KF�8�IFD8EK@:@Q<;�?@JKFIP�8E;�@;<EK@KP�K?8K�@J�;@J!K@E:KCP� EFEJF:@8C@JK�8E;� ;@JK@E:KCP� (FE!>FC@8E�� #FN<M<I�K?<P� ;F� EFK� 8KK<DGK�KF� 9<� [GLI<CP\� KI8;@!K@FE8C� FI� KF� :I<8K<� 8�E8K@FE8C� @;<EK@KP� K?8K�<O:CL;<J� FK?<I� E8!K@FEJ� FI� @E`L<E:<���CK8E� /I8>^J� 9I@C!C@8E:<� C@<J� @E� K?<�=8:K�K?8K�K?<P�:8E�K8B<�K?<J<�1<JK<IE@Q<;�KI8;@K@FE8C�DLJ@:8C�<C<D<EKJ�8:BEFNC<;>@E>�K?<@I�1<JK<IE@Q8K@FE�8J�8�;@JK@E:K�G8IK�F=�(FE>FC@8^J�FNE�?@JKFIP�8E;�9C<E;�K?<D�N@K?�:FEK<DGFI8IP�1<JK<IE�8E;�DF;<IE�DLJ@!

“Altan$Urag’s$brilliance$lies$in$the$fact$that$they$can$take$these$Westernized$traditional$musical$elements...and$blend$them$with$

contemporary$Western$and$modern$musical$styles$to$create$a$national$identity.”

Page 41: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

33

:8C�JKPC<J� KF�:I<8K<�8�E8K@FE8C� @;<EK@KP� K?8K� CFFBJ� KF� K?<�E8K@FE^J�GIFL;�G8JK�8E;�GC8:<J�@K�@E�K?<�:FEK<OK�F=�8�:?8E>@E>�8E;�>CF98C@Q@E>�(FE>FC@8��.?@J� @J�DL:?� C@B<�(8IJ?^J� @;<8� F=� [:FJDFGFC@K8E� E8K@FE8C@JD\� @E� ?@J�;@J:LJJ@FE�F=�C8K<JF:@8C@JK�G<I@F;�DLJ@:@8EJ�N?F�K?FL>?�:FE:<IE<;�=FI�K?<�E8K@FE^J�DF;<IE@Q8K@FE�8E;�@EK<>I8K@FE�@EKF�K?<�@EK<IE8K@FE8C�8I<E8�JFL>?K�KF�I<K8@E�8�E8K@FE8C�@;<EK@KP�K?8K�NFLC;�;@JK@E>L@J?�@K�=IFD�FK?<I�:FJDFGFC@K8E�E8K@FEJ�10�.?@J� K?<E� @J�?FN�N<�J?FLC;�LE;<IJK8E;��CK8E�/I8>^J�@EEFM8K@M<�=LJ@FE�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�8E;�1<JK<IE�DLJ@:8C�<C<D<EKJ��8J�K?<�:I<8K@FE�F=�8�E8K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�@;<EK@KP�K?8K�@J�IFFK<;�@E�@KJ�FNE�G8JK�8E;�P<K�8CJF�<D9I8:<J�<O:?8E><�8E;�@EK<I8:K@FE�@E�8E�@E:I<8J@E>CP�:FEE<:K<;�NFIC;�Z�8J�E<N�I<GI<J<EK8K@FEJ�F=�K?<�["FC;<E�'@E<8><\�=FI�8�E<N�(FE>FC@8�� �<=FI<� ;@J:LJJ@E>� K?<�DLJ@:� F=��CK8E�/I8>� K?<E� 8� 9I@<=� ?@J!KFIP�8E;�GIF_C<�F=�K?<�98E;�N@CC�GIFM<�?<CG=LC���CK8E�/I8>�N8J�=FID<;�@E�� ��9P�J<M<E�I<:<EK�>I8;L8K<J�F=�K?<�(FE>FC@8E�(LJ@:�8E;��8E:<��FCC<><��.?<J<� =FLE;@E>�D<D9<IJ� ?8M<� 9<<E� 8E;� :FEK@EL<� KF� 9<� K?<�C@E<LG�F=��CK8E�/I8>��.?<P�8I<���� I;<E<98K�98E;� C<8;<I�8E;�PF:?@E�GC8P<I� �(FE>FC@8E� ?8DD<I<;� ;LC:@D<I��� ��� �LI<EKL>J� DFI@E� B?LLI�GC8P<I�8E;�?FFD@@�J@E><I������FCFIKLE>8C8>�;ILDD<I�8E;�G<I:LJJ@FE!@JK��(���?@D<;KF>KFB?� K?IF8K� J@E><I�8E;�9@J?>LLI�GC8P<I� �(FE>FC@8E�?FIE�J@D@C8I�KF�8E�F9F<�@E�JFLE;���#�� I;<E<KJ<KJ<>�CFE>�JFE>�8E;�J?FIK�JFE>�J@E><I��.J��"8E>88�@B?�B?LLI�GC8P<I��>I<8K�_;;C<�C@B<�8�98JJ�DFI@E�B?LLI���8E;�+��*PLE9@C<>�DFI@E�B?LLI�GC8P<I�8E;�K?IF8K�J@E><I��!IFD�K?<�9<>@EE@E>��CK8E�/I8>�N8J�K?<�C@M<C@?FF;�8E;�JFC<�:8I<<I�=FI�8CC�F=�@KJ�D<D9<IJ��.?@J�:FEKI8JKJ�FK?<I�98E;J�C@B<�&?LJL>KLE�FI��I>8��@C<>�N?FJ<�D<D9<IJ�8I<�8CC� KPG@:8CCP�8CJF�D<D9<IJ�F=� <@K?<I� K?<�)8K@FE8C�-FE>�8E;��8E:<� EJ<D9C<�FI�K?<�-K8K<�(FI@E�&?LLI� EJ<D9C<�� !FI�KNF�P<8IJ��CK8E�/I8>�G<I=FID<;�8�DFI<�JKI8@>?K=FIN8I;CP�[KI8;@K@FE8C\�I<G<IKF@I<��$E�� ��K?<�98E;�@E;<G<E;<EKCP�I<:FI;<;�8E;�I<C<8J<;�@KJ�_IJK�8C9LD�Foal’s$Been$Born��.?@J�8C9LD�;<<D<;�K?<�[F=!_:@8C� 9<>@EE@E>\� F=��CK8E� /I8>� 9P� 98E;� C<8;<I� ��� I;<E<98K� �8�B�8��[ IB8\�� D8IB<;� K?<� 98E;^J� _IJK� <OG<I@D<EKJ� N@K?� K?<� E<N� ><EI<� F=�[(FE>FC@8E�=FCB�IF:B�\11��.NF�P<8IJ�C8K<I��CK8E�/I8>�N8J�89C<�KF�J@>E�8�:FEKI8:K�N@K?�K?<�CF:8C�I<:FI;�C89<C�-FEFI�,<:FI;J�K?<�C8I><JK�8E;�DFJK�<OG<I@<E:<;�C89<C�@E�/C88E988K8I��/E;<I�K?@J�E<N�:FEKI8:K�K?<P�I<:FI;<;�8E;�GIF;L:<;�Made$in$Altan$Urag�N?@:?�?8J�J@E:<�9<:FD<�K?<@I�DFJK�GFGLC8I� 8E;�N<CCBEFNE� 8C9LD���CK8E�/I8>� GLJ?<;� @KJ� E<N� ><EI<� F=�

HEINS

Page 42: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

34

[=FCB�IF:B\�FE�Made$in$Altan$Urag�N@K?�9FC;�8E;�<E<I><K@:�KI8:BJ�C@B<�[(FK?<I�(FE>FC@8\�8E;�[�CL<�(8IB\�N?@:?�NFLC;�<M<EKL8CCP�9<:FD<�:IFN;�=8MFI@K<J�8E;�C@M<�G<I=FID8E:<�JK8GC<J��.?<�K@D<�8IFLE;�Made$in$Altan$Urag�D8IBJ�8�J@>E@_:8EK�GF@EK�@E�K?<�98E;^J�;<M<CFGD<EK�F=�@KJ�JFLE;�8E;�@D8><��%LJK�9<=FI<�K?<�I<:FI;@E>�F=�K?@J�8C9LD��CK8E�/I8>�8:HL@I<;� KNF�E<N�8E;�FI@>@E8C�DFI@E�B?LLIJ�� @EJK<8;�F=�?FIJ<�?<8;J�K?<J<�E<N�9C8:B�_;;C<J�N<I<�8;FIE<;�N@K?�K?<�?<8;�F=�K?<��C@<E�DFEJK<I�=IFD�K?<�=8DFLJ�1<JK<IE�J:@_�?FIIFI�DFM@<�[�C@<E�\��;;@K@FE8CCP�K?<�98E;�DF;@_<;�FE<�F=�K?<@I�DFI@E�B?LLIJ�8E;�K?<�PF:?@E�JF�8J�KF�9<:FD<�[<C<:KI@:\�@EJKILD<EKJ�:8G89C<�F=�GIF;L:@E>�8�;@JKFIK<;�JFLE;�J@D@C8I�KF�8E�<C<:KI@:�>L@K8I�K?<�@EJKILD<EK�JF�<D9C<D8K@:�F=�K?<�IF:B�DLJ@:�JKPC<��� �K� K?<� <E;�F=� � ���CK8E�/I8>� J@>E<;� 8� :FEKI8:K�N@K?�&?8E��8EB� (FE>FC@8^J� C8I><JK� 98EB@E>� :FIGFI8K@FE� NFIK?� 8GGIFO@D8K<CP�� �D@CC@FE�().��M<IP�IFL>?CP�� �K?FLJ8E;�/-����.?@J�JGFEJFIJ?@G�GIFM@;<;��CK8E�/I8>�K?<�D<8EJ�KF�8==FI;�8�GI@M8K<�I<?<8IJ8C�JG8:<�=LE;J�=FI�I<:FI;@E>�8E;�GIF;L:@E>�E<N�8C9LDJ�8E;�K?<�<HL@M8C<EK�F=�8�P<8I^J�J8C8IP�=FI�<8:?�98E;�D<D9<I�KF�8CCFN�K?<D�KF�:FEK@EL<�KF�=F:LJ�<O:CL!J@M<CP�FE�NI@K@E>�8E;�G<I=FID@E>�DLJ@:��!IFD�� �� K?IFL>?�� � ��C!K8E�/I8>�@E;<G<E;<EKCP�I<:FI;<;�8E;�GIF;L:<;�EF�C<JJ�K?8E�_M<�8C9LDJ�Z�Blood�Hypnotism�Once$Upon$a$Time$in$Mongolia�Mongol�8E;�NaBtion�Z�8E;�:FEK@EL<;�KF�G<I=FID�9FK?�CF:8CCP�8E;�8K�@EK<IE8K@FE8C�DLJ@:�=<JK@M8CJ�@E�%8G8E��?@E8�8E;�<M<E�K?<�/E@K<;�-K8K<J�12��� �I@M@E>� 8CC� F=� K?@J� GIF;L:K@FE� 8E;� C@M<� G<I=FID8E:<� @J��CK8E�/I8>^J�>F8C�8J�JK8K<;�FE�K?<@I�F=_:@8C�N<9J@K<�KF�[GIFDFK<�(FE>FC@8E�:LCKLI<�KF�K?<�NFIC;�8E;�KF�@EKIF;L:<�KI8;@K@FE8C�DLJ@:�KF�K?<�PFLE>�G<F!GC<�F=�K?<@I�:FLEKIP�\�.?<�98E;�8CJF�?8J�K?<�;<J@I<�KF�:I<8K<�[JFD<K?@E>�E<N\�KF�D8B<�DLJ@:� K?8K�?8J�EFK�9<<E�?<8I;�9<=FI<�13�.F�8::FDGC@J?�9FK?�F=�K?<J<�>F8CJ��CK8E�/I8>�JFL>?K�KF�9C<E;�K?<�KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>F!C@8E�DLJ@:�K?8K�K?<P�N<I<�8CC�K8L>?K�@E�:FCC<><�N@K?�K?<�1<JK<IE�DLJ@!:8C� JKPC<�F=�?8I;� IF:B� K?8K� K?<P� 8E;� K?<�PFLE><I�><E<I8K@FE�F=�LI98E�(FE>FC@8EJ�N<I<�=8D@C@8I�N@K?��1@K?�K?@J�@E�D@E;�N<�N@CC�EFN�9<>@E�FLI�8E8CPJ@J�F=��CK8E�/I8>^J�DLJ@:�8E;�GI<J<EK8K@FE�@E�M8I@FLJ�D<;@8�<O8D@E@E>� @E�;<K8@C�?FN� KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�8E;�1<JK<IE�<C<D<EKJ�8I<�D@O<;�@E�K?<�:FEK<DGFI8IP�(FE>FC@8E�JF:@F?@JKFI@:8C�:FEK<OK�� .?<� =FCCFN@E>� 8I<� KI8EJ:I@9<;� <O:<IGKJ� =IFD� KNF� JFE>J� =IFD�K?<�8C9LD�Made$in$Altan$Urag��[�CL<�(8IB\�8E;�[(FK?<I�(FE>FC@8�\�.?<J<�JFE>J�N<I<�:?FJ<E�9<:8LJ<�K?<P�8I<�?@>?CP�I<GI<J<EK8K@M<�F=��C!

Page 43: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

35

K8E�/I8>^J�[=FCB�IF:B\�JKPC<�8E;�9<:8LJ<�K?<P�8I<�KNF�F=��CK8E�/I8>^J�DFJK�GFGLC8I�JFE>J���CK8E�/I8>�GC8PJ�K?<J<�KNF�JFE>J�8K�<M<IP�FE<�F=�@KJ�CF:8C�G<I=FID8E:<J�8E;�K?<P�8I<�<M<E�=<8KLI<;�@E�K?<�DFM@<J�[(FE>FC\�8E;�[&?8;8B\�I<JG<:K@M<CP��.?<�KI8EJ:I@GK@FEJ�8I<�K8B<E�=IFD�K?<�8C9LD�M<IJ@FEJ�F=�K?<J<�JFE>J��K?<I<�8I<�JC@>?K�M8I@8K@FEJ�@E�C@M<�G<I=FID8E:<���.?<J<�KI8EJ:I@GK@FEJ�8I<�J@DGC@_<;�89JKI8:K@FEJ�8E;�;F�EFK�8::FLEK�=FI�<M<IP�JFE@:�;<K8@C�9LK�8I<�JL=_:@<EK�=FI�K?<�GI<J<EK�GLIGFJ<J�F=�K?@J�G8!G<I�� '<K�LJ�_IJK�:FEJ@;<I�K?<�JFE>�[�CL<�(8IB�\��<=FI<�;<CM@E>�@EKF�D<CF;@:�;<K8@CJ�N<�:8E�EFK<�=IFD�K?<�FLKJ<K�K?8K�K?@J�JFE>�@J�G<I=FID<;�FE� KI8;@K@FE8C� @EJKILD<EKJ� �DFI@E�B?LLI� @B?�B?LLI� PF:?@E� 9@J?>LLI��N@K?FLK�K?<�LJ<�F=�8EP�<C<:KIFE@:�;@JKFIK@FE��.?<�JFLE;�D8P�K?<E�9<�;<!J:I@9<;�8J�9<@E>�M<IP�KI8;@K@FE8C�<O:<GK�=FI�K?<�LJ<�F=�K?<�IF:B�;ILD�J<K��.?@J�@J�8�9@>�<O:<GK@FE�F=�:FLIJ<��=FI�8EP�C@JK<E<I�=8D@C@8I�N@K?�1<JK<IE�IF:B�GFG�FI�A8QQ��N?@:?�:<IK8@ECP�@E:CL;<J�PFLE><I�LI98E�(FE>FC@8EJ��K?<�JFLE;�F=�K?<�;ILD�J<K�N@CC�@DD<;@8K<CP�<MFB<�8JJF:@8K@FEJ�N@K?�K?<J<�><EI<J��.?LJ�@E�K<IDJ�F=�@EJKILD<EK8K@FE�8E;�JFLE;�N<�:8E�8CI<8;P�J<<�8�:FD9@E8K@FE�F=�[=FCB\�N@K?�[IF:B�\�� 1<�:8E�=LIK?<I�<OGCFI<� K?@J�9P�<O8D@E@E>� K?<�D<CF;@:� I?PK?!D@:�8E;�JKIL:KLI8C�:?8I8:K<I@JK@:J�F=�[�CL<�(8IB�\�.?<�=FCCFN@E>�_>LI<�@J�K?<�PF:?@E�G8IK�=FI�K?<�:?FILJ�N?@:?�8CJF�@EKIF;L:<J�K?<�JFE>��

�=K<I�FE<�@K<I8K@FE�F=�K?@J�_>LI<�@EKIF;L:<J�K?<�JFE>�K?<�:?FILJ�D<CF;P�@J�@EKIF;L:<;�FE�K?<�9@J?>LLI��

�.?@J�D<CF;P�:F@E:@;<J�N@K?�K?<�PF:?@E�_>LI<�89FM<�@E�K<IDJ�F=�C<E>K?�Z�<8:?�@J�I<G<8K<;�KN@:<�@E�FI;<I�KF�=FID�FE<��98I�G?I8J<�>IFLG@E>��.?@J�D<CF;@:�C@E<�@J�@EKIF;L:<;�FE�K?<�9@J?>LLI�9LK�FE�JL9J<HL<EK�G<I!=FID8E:<J�F=�K?<�:?FILJ�K?<�C@E<�@J�JLE>�@EJK<8;�N@K?�K?<�9@J?>LLI�8:!:FDG8EP@E>�8K�K?<�<E;�F=�K?<�JFE>��� !IFD� K?<J<� KNF� _>LI<J� N<� :8E� J<<� K?8K� K?<� :?FILJ� @J� J<K� @E�K?<�B<P�F=�!�D@EFI��#FN<M<I�EFK@:<� K?8K�N?@C<� K?<�PF:?@E�G8IK�?8J�8�JK<8;P�GI<J<E:<�F=�K?<�EFK<�!�:I<8K@E>�8�JKIFE>�>IFLE;@E>�@E�K?<�KFE@:�

HEINS

Page 44: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

36

�K?<�[?FD<\�EFK<�FI�_IJK�EFK<�@E�K?<�!�D@EFI�J:8C<��K?<�:?FILJ�D<CF!;P�JKIFE>CP�<DG?8J@Q<J���K?<�;FD@E8EK��K?<�_=K?�EFK<�F=�K?<�!�D@EFI�J:8C<���.?LJ�K?<I<�@J�8�JK<8;P�J<EJ<�F=�K?<�FG<E�_=K?��!�Y����@E�K?<�:?FILJ�N?@:?�@J�DFJK�EFK@:<89C<�@E�K?<�_E8C�98I�F=�K?<�_>LI<J�89FM<�N?<I<�K?<�D<CF;P�<E;J�FE���8E;�K?<�PF:?@E�GC8PJ�K?<�EFK<J�!�8E;����.?<�FG<E�_=K?�@J�8�GIFD@E<EK�@EK<IM8C�@E�IF:B�DLJ@:�8E;�@KJ�GI<J<E:<�?<I<�@J�G8IK�F=�K?@J�JFE>^J�IF:B�JFLE;��� �J�N<CC�N<�:8E�J<<�K?8K�FECP�J@O�F=�K?<�J<M<E�EFK<J�F=�K?<�!�D@!EFI�J:8C<�8I<�LJ<;�@E�K?<J<�_>LI<J�E8D<CP�5!��9��9����9� 96��.?@J�:FCC<:K@FE�F=�G@K:?<J�:8E�9<�M@<N<;�8J�8�GFJJ@9C<�!�G<EK8KFE@:�J:8C<�5!��9��9��� 96� N@K?�K?<�8;;@K@FE�F=�K?<�G@K:?��9�K?<�D@EFI�J@OK?�@E�K?<�!�D@EFI�J:8C<��.?@J�GFJJ@9C<�!�G<EK8KFE@:�J:8C<�5!��9��9��� 96� @J�JL>><JK<;�@E�K?<�:?FILJ�D<CF;P�9P�K?<�JK<8;P�GI<J<E:<�F=���K?<�;FD@!E8EK�@E�:FD9@E8K@FE�N@K?�K?<�JKIFE>�DFK@FE�KFN8I;J�8E;�8IFLE;���9P�EFK<J� @E� K?@J�G<EK8KFE@:�J:8C<�Z�DFK@FEJ�N?@:?�8I<�JKIFE>CP� I<D@E@J!:<EK�F=�K?<�D<CF;@:�G?I8J@E>�@E�D8EP�KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�J?FIK�JFE>J��N?@:?�8CN8PJ�LJ<�G<EK8KFE@:�J:8C<J���.?<�8;;@K@FE8C�G@K:?��9�:8E�9<�J<<E�8J�8�G8JJ@E>�EFK<�@E�K?<�;<J:<EK�=IFD� 9�KF���9LK�@KJ�:CFJ<�GIFO@D!@KP�KF����FE<�?8C=JK<G�8N8P��8E;�GC8:<D<EK�@E�K?<�D<CF;P�8I<�M<IP�I<D@!E@J:<EK�F=�@KJ�LJ<�@E�1<JK<IE�D<CF;@:�G?I8J@E>��.?LJ�N<�:8E�J<<�?@EKJ�F=�K?<�:FD9@E8K@FE�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�8E;�1<JK<IE�@E�K?<�D<CF;@:�G?I8J@E>�8E;�:?F@:<�F=�G@K:?�:FCC<:K@FE�8J�N<CC�� '<K�LJ�EFN�9I@<`P�<O8D@E<�K?<�M<IJ<�D<CF;P�F=�[�CL<�(8IB\�

�)FK@:<�?<I<�K?8K�K?@J�_>LI<�8J�$�?8M<�KI8EJ:I@9<;�@K�@J�I<G<8K<;�J@O�K@D<J��.?@J�;F<J�EFK�8;;�LG�KF�FE<��98I�G?I8J<�>IFLG@E>�9LK�@EJK<8;����98IJ�FI������98I�G?I8J<�>IFLG@E>J��.?@J�J?8CC�9<�I<D8IB<;�LGFE�J?FIKCP�� .?@J�M<IJ<�D<CF;P�@J�JLE>�9P�+��*PLE9@C<>��8�B�8��[*PLE88\��@E�8�JKPC<�F=�?FFD@@�8E;�@J�8CJF�GC8P<;�9P�K?<�PF:?@E�8E;�K?<�DFI@E�B?LLI��.?<I<�@J�8�JKIFE>�8CDFJK�FM<IN?<CD@E>�GI<J<E:<�F=���@E�K?@J�D<CF;P�<M<E�DFI<�JF�K?8E�@E�K?<�:?FILJ�D<CF;P��$E�=8:K�K?<I<�@J�FECP�FE<�!�@E�K?@J�<EK@I<�KNF98I�_>LI<��$E�K?<�M<IJ<�J<:K@FEJ�K?<E�K?<�!�D@EFI�KFE8C@KP�@J�J<I@FLJCP�:?8CC<E><;�N@K?���JFLE;@E>�DFI<�C@B<�8E�8CK<IE8K@M<�KFE@:��.?<�JLIIFLE;@E>�G@K:?<J�F=��9�8E;��9�N?@:?�<D9<CC@J?�8E;�<DG?8J@Q<�K?<���<E?8E:<�K?@J�KFE8C�8D9@>L@KP���;;@K@FE8CCP�K?<�LJ<�F=�G@K:?<J�8�

Page 45: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

37

N?FC<�JK<G�9<CFN�8E;�8�?8C=�JK<G�89FM<�K?<�G<I:<@M<;�KFE@:�@J�8�:FDDFE�D<CF;@:�JKIL:KLI<�@E�[?8I;<I\�JKPC<J�F=�IF:B�<JG<:@8CCP�D<K8C��.?@J�8J!JF:@8K@FE�@J�I<@E=FI:<;�9P�*PLE88^J�?FFD@@�MF:8C�JKPC<�N?@:?�@J�C@B<�8�;<:C8D8KFIP�>IFNC�J@D@C8I�@E�JFLE;�KF�K?<�>IFNC@E>�MF:8C�JKPC<�=FLE;�@E�;<8K?�D<K8C��.?@J�MF:8C�JKPC<�@J�JK@CC�F=�:FLIJ<�8�KPG<�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�?FFD@@�� .?FL>?�K?<J<�D<CF;@:�<C<D<EKJ�8I<�8CC�GI<J<EK�@E�K?<�JFE>�K?<�>I<8K<JK�<C<D<EKJ�F=� K?<� IF:B�JKPC<�8I<� =FLE;� @E� @KJ� I?PK?D�8E;�JKIL:!KLI<��.?<�=FCCFN@E>�@J�8�JKIL:KLI8C�FLKC@E<�F=�[�CL<�(8IB\�N@K?�KPG<�F=�J<:K@FE�GI@D8IP�@EJKILD<EK8K@FE�;LI8K@FE�@E�K<IDJ�F=�ELD9<I�F=��98I�G?I8J<�>IFLGJ��899I<M@8K<;�8J�[G>J\��8E;�K<DGFI8C�CF:8K@FE�@E�K?<�KI8:B�

�����-<:K@FE�.PG<������������$EJKILD<EK8K@FE� ����+"�'<E>K?� �������.@D<

�J�N<�:8E�J<<�K?<�KI8:B�:8E�9<�;@M@;<;�@EKF�KNF�D8@E�DLJ@:8C�J<:K@FEJ�F=�M<IJ<�8E;�:?FILJ��.?<�K<IDJ�[M<IJ<\�8E;�[:?FILJ\�N<I<�:?FJ<E�9<!:8LJ<�K?<J<�J<:K@FEJ�=LE:K@FE�8J�M<IJ<J�8E;�:?FILJ<J�@E�KPG@:8C�IF:BGFG�=8J?@FE��;LI@E>� K?<�M<IJ<J�*PLE88� J@E>J�8CC�F=� K?<� CPI@:J�F=� K?<� JFE>�N?@C<�:?FILJ�J<:K@FEJ�=FCCFN�M<IJ<�J<:K@FEJ�N@K?�8�:8K:?P�D<CF;P��.?<I<�@J�<M<E�8�9I<8B�J<:K@FE�N@K?�I?PK?D@:�8E;�D<CF;@:�D8K<I@8C�EFK�=FLE;�<CJ<N?<I<� @E� K?<�JFE>�N?@:?� C<8;J�;@I<:KCP� @EKF�8� JFCF�J<:K@FE�N?<I<�K?<�9@J?>LLI�@DGIFM@J<J�8�D<CF;@:�C@E<�FM<I�K?<�:?FILJ�D<CF;P�@E�K?<�PF:?@E�8E;�DFI@E�B?LLI�DL:?�C@B<�8�JK8E;8I;�>L@K8I�JFCF�J<:K@FE�@E�IF:B�DLJ@:��!LIK?<IDFI<�K?<J<�J<:K@FEJ�8I<�;@M@;<;�@EKF�G?I8J<�>IFLGJ���98IJ�@E�C<E>K?�8�KPG@:8C�G?I8J<�>IFLG@E>�C<E>K?�@E�IF:B�GFG�8E;�9CL<J��.?<�<O:<GK@FEJ�8I<� K?<�M<IJ<�J<:K@FEJ�N?@:?�8I<� @EJK<8;����98IJ� @E� C<E>K?��FI�����G?I8J<�>IFLGJ���.?@J�@J�8�:FDDFE�G?I8J<�>IFLG�C<E>K?�@E�9CL<J�

HEINS

$EKIF�5�?FILJ60<IJ<���?FILJ0<IJ<���?FILJ�I<8B

-FCF�5�?FILJ60<IJ<���?FILJ

PF:?@D�9@J?>LLI?FFD@@�M<IJ<�O�J@E>@E>�O�

?FFD@@�M<IJ<�O�J@E>@E>�O�@EJKI��9I<8B9@J?>LLI

?FFD@@�M<IJ<�O�J@E>@E>�9@J?>LLI

�� �G>J����G>J�� �G>����G>J�� �G>�� �G>�� �G>J����G>J�� �G>J

� �Y� �� �� �Y� ��� ����Y��� ��� ��Y����������Y����������Y����������Y�����������Y����������Y�<E;

Page 46: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

38

8J�N<CC��[.N<CM<98I�9CL<J\��9LK�@KJ�D@O�N@K?��98I�G?I8J<�>IFLG@E>J�@J�LELJL8C��$K�@J�8CJF�@EK<I<JK@E>�KF�EFK<�K?8K�;LI@E>�K?<J<�M<IJ<�J<:K@FEJ��98I�JKIL:KLI<J�8I<�D8IB<;�@E�K?<�DLJ@:�N@K?�8�:I8J?�:PD98C�?@K�@E�K?<�;ILD�J<K�8E;�K?<�<EKI8E:<�F=�JFD<�D@EFI�<C<:KIFE@:�8D9@<EK�JFLE;�<=!=<:KJ��� !@E8CCP� G<I?8GJ� K?<� DFJK� JFE@:8CCP� F9M@FLJ� :?8I8:K<I@JK@:� F=�IF:B�DLJ@:�GI<J<EK�@E�[�CL<�(8IB\�@J�K?<�JK<8;P�8E;�;I@M@E>�I?PK?D@:�GLCJ<��.?@J�:8E�9<�J<<E�@E�K?<�PF:?@E�:?FILJ�_>LI<�N?@:?�:FEJ@JKJ�<E!K@I<CP�F=�JK<8;P�<@>?K?�EFK<J��$K�@J�DFJK�8GG8I<EK�@E�K?<�;ILDJ�?FN<M<I��EFK�KI8EJ:I@9<;���.?IFL>?FLK�K?<�JFE>�<O:<GK�=FI�K?<��I<8B�J<:K@FE�K?<�;ILDJ�GIFM@;<�8�JK<8;P�9<8K�@E�����K@D<�N@K?�8�98JJ�B@:B�FE�9<8KJ���8E;���8E;�JE8I<�?@KJ�FE���8E;���F=�<8:?�D<8JLI<��.?@J�G8KK<IE�@J�F=K<E�:8CC<;�8�[98:B9<8K\�8E;�@J�8�JK8GC<�F=�IF:B�DLJ@:���J�JFFE�8J�K?<�;ILDJ�>@M<�=FLI�9<8KJ�FE�K?<�?@?8K�KF�@EKIF;L:<�K?<�JFE>�8E;�JL9J<HL<EKCP�C8LE:?�@EKF�K?<�98:B9<8K�G8KK<IE�8EP�C@JK<E<I�8K�8CC�=8D@C@8I�N@K?�1<JK<IE�IF:B�8E;�GFG�DLJ@:8C�JKPC<J�@J�C@B<CP�KF�@;<EK@=P�K?@J�JFE>�8J�8�B@E;�F=�IF:B�JFE>�� '<K�LJ�EFN�ALJK�9I@<`P�<O8D@E<�<O:<IGKJ�=IFD�K?<�JFE>�[(FK?<I�(FE>FC@8\�N?@:?� IB8�:C8@D<;�N8J�FE<�F=�K?<�98E;^J�=8MFI@K<�JFE>J�KF�GC8P�9<:8LJ<�@K�:FEK8@EJ�[D8EP�;@==<I<EK�I?PK?D@:�8E;�D<CF;@:�JKPC<J�\���.?<�=FCCFN@E>�@J�K?<�D8@E�PF:?@E�G8IK�K?IFL>?FLK�K?<�JFE>�

��� �J� @E�[�CL<�(8IB\�N<�J<<�8�;<_E@K<�B<P�F=�!�D@EFI�8E;�8E��98I� G?I8J<� >IFLG@E>���=K<I� FE<� I<G<K@K@FE� F=� K?@J� _>LI<� FE<�DFI@E�B?LLI�<EK<IJ�GC8P@E>�K?<�=FCCFN@E>�

Page 47: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

39

�J� @E� [�CL<�(8IB\� K?<I<� @J� 8� JKIFE>�GLCJ<� @E� K?@J� JFE>� 8J� K?<�DFI@E�B?LLI�;LGC@:8K<J�K?<�PF:?@E^J�;I@M@E>�I?PK?D@:�G8KK<IE��!LIK?<IDFI<�K?<�DFI@E�B?LLI�?<I<�GC8PJ�D8EP�FG<E�_=K?J� ALJK� 8J�8�>L@K8I�NFLC;�GC8P�D8EP�FG<E�_=K?J�@E�IF:B�DLJ@:��.?<�DFI@E�B?LLI�?<I<�8CJF�JL>><JKJ�8�?8IDFE@:�JKIL:KLI<�:I<8K@E>�8�DFM<D<EK�=IFD�K?<�D@EFI�KFE@:��!�D@EFI��@E�98IJ���Y���KF�K?<�D@EFI�JL9;FD@E8EK���9�D@EFI��@E�98IJ���Y���8E;�K?<E�98:B�KF�KFE@:�@E�98IJ���Y����.?@J�?8IDFE@:�JKIL:KLI<�@J�:FE_ID<;�N?<E�K?<�JFCF�DFI@E�B?LLI�<EK<IJ�8=K<I�8EFK?<I��98I�G?I8J<�GC8P@E>�K?<�=FC!CFN@E>��

� .?<��9�8K�K?<�9<>@EE@E>�F=�K?<�_=K?�98I�:FE_IDJ�K?<�?8IDFE@:�DFM<D<EK�KF��9�D@EFI�8E;�K?<���8K�K?<�9<>@EE@E>�F=�K?<�J<M<EK?�98I�K?<�DFM<�98:B�KF�!�D@EFI��.?@J�?8IDFE@:�JKIL:KLI<�@J�JFD<K?@E>�N<�;@;�EFK�J<<�JF�:C<8ICP�@E�[�CL<�(8IB\�8E;�@J�8�;@JK@E:KCP�1<JK<IE�DLJ@:8C�<C<D<EK���CJF�EFK@:<�K?8K�K?<�DFI@E�B?LLI^J�JFCF�D<CF;P�JKIFE>CP�<D!G?8J@Q<J�K?<�G@K:?�F=���N@K?�=I<HL<EK�8J:<E;@E>�DFK@FEJ�=IFD��9�9<CFN�8E;�N@K?�;<J:<E;@E>�DFK@FEJ�=IFD��9�89FM<�Z�ALJK�8J� @E� K?<�:?FILJ�D<CF;P�F=�[�CL<�(8IB�\�.?@J�D<CF;P�8CJF�:FEK8@EJ�K?<�J8D<�:?8I8:K<I!@JK@:J�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�G<EK8KFE@:�G@K:?�:FCC<:K@FEJ�8E;�1<JK<IE�D@EFI�J@OK?�<DG?8J@J�K?8K�N8J�;@J:LJJ<;�I<>8I;@E>�[�CL<�(8IB�\� 1?@C<� [(FK?<I�(FE>FC@8\� 8E;� [�CL<�(8IB\� ?8M<�D8EP�D<!CF;@:�8E;�I?PK?D@:�J@D@C8I@K@<J�K?<I<�8I<�@EK<I<JK@E>�;@==<I<E:<J�@E�K<IDJ�F=� FM<I8CC� JKIL:KLI<��.?<� =FCCFN@E>� @J� 8� JKIL:KLI8C� FLKC@E<� F=� [(FK?<I�(FE>FC@8\�

���-<:K@FE�.PG<� ����$EJKILD<EK8K@FE�����������+"�'<E>K?� ���.@D<

HEINS

$EKIF(<CF;P��8(<CF;P��9�I<8B

�I@;><�5�86(<CF;P��9�

PF:?@E�DFI@E�B?LLIJFCF�DFI@E�B?LLIJFCF�DB���9@J?>LLIPF:?@E�CFE>�JFE>

?FFD@@9@J?>LLI

�� �G>J�� �G>J�� �G>J=I<<�K@D<�� �G>J�� �G>J

� �Y� ��� ����Y��� ��� ��Y����������Y����������Y����������Y�<E;�

Page 48: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

40

/EC@B<�[�CL<�(8IB\�[(FK?<I�(FE>FC@8\�:8EEFK�9<�J8@;�KF�?8M<�8�M<IJ<:?FILJ�JKIL:KLI<�8J�K?<I<�@J�EF�JKIFG?@:�K<OK�FI�CPI@:J��$EJK<8;�$�?8M<�C8!9<C<;�K?<�J<:K@FEJ�9P�N?8K�KPG<�F=�D<CF;P�@J�GI<J<EK��-<:K@FEJ�[(<CF;P��8\� 8E;�[(<CF;P��9\�?8M<� K?<� J8D<�D<CF;P�GI<J<EK� 9LK� $� ?8M<�;@J!K@E>L@J?<;� K?<D�9P� K?<� @EJKILD<EKJ�G<I=FID@E>� K?8K�D<CF;P��-<:K@FEJ�[�I@;><�5�86\�8E;�[(<CF;P��9\�:FEK8@E�K?<�J8D<�D<CF;P�N?@:?�@J�;@=!=<I<EK�=IFD�K?8K�F=�K?<�GI<M@FLJ�J<:K@FEJ��8E;�N?@:?�@J�EFK�KI8EJ:I@9<;���)<M<IK?<C<JJ�K?<��98I�G?I8J<�>IFLG@E>�@J�JK@CC�K?<�=LE;8D<EK8C�JKIL:!KLI8C�9L@C;@E>�9CF:B�F=�K?<�JFE>�8J�:8E�9<�J<<E�89FM<�� .?<�<O:<GK@FE�KF�K?@J�@J�K?<��I<8B�J<:K@FE��1?@C<�K?@J�J<:K@FE�?8J�K?<�J8D<�;I@M@E>�GLCJ<�8J�K?<�I<JK�F=�K?<�JFE>�K?<I<�@J�EF�J<EJ<�F=�FM<I8CC�G?I8J<�JKIL:KLI<�8J�K?<�;ILDJ�;IFG�FLK��$EJK<8;�K?<�JKIL:KLI<�9<:FD<J�[=I<<\�8J� IB8�<EK<IJ�J@E>@E>�@E�8�CFE>�JFE>�JKPC<��.?FL>?�K?@J�=I<<K@D<�J<:K@FE�:FE`@:KJ�N@K?�K?<�G?I8J<>IFLG�JKIL:KLI<�F=�K?<�I<JK�F=�K?<�JFE>�@K�8::FDDF;8K<J�K?<�CFE>�JFE>�G<I=FID8E:<�8J�CFE>�JFE>�@J�KI8;@K@FE!8CCP�G<I=FID<;�@E�=I<<�K@D<�N@K?FLK�8EP�JKIFE>�J<EJ<�F=�I?PK?D�DL:?�C<JJ� JKIL:KLI<����.?LJ� @E� K?<�D@;;C<� F=� 8� JFE>�N?@:?� =FCCFNJ� 8� =8@ICP�:FEM<EK@FE8C�IF:B�JFE>�JKIL:KLI<�98J<;�FE��98I�G?I8J<�>IFLG@E>J�@J�8�K<DGFI8C�<OGI<JJ@FE�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�CFE>�JFE>�G<I=FID8E:<�8�JKIL:KLI8C�:FD9@E8K@FE�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�8E;�1<JK<IE�DLJ@:8C�<C<D<EKJ�� .?<�GI<M@FLJ�JFE>J�N<I<�:?FJ<E�8J�<O8DGC<J�F=��CK8E�/I8>^J�[=FCB�IF:B\�JKPC<��.?@J�JKPC<�;<_E<J�K?<�98E;��K?<P�C89<C�K?<DJ<CM<J�8J�8�=FCB�IF:B�98E;�FE�K?<@I�8C9LDJ�8E;�FE�K?<@I�N<9J@K<�8E;�=FI�C@M<�G<I=FI!D8E:<J�K?<P�GC8P�K?<@I�=FCB�IF:B�I<G<IKF@I<��#FN<M<I�J@E:<�K?<�I<C<8J<�F=$Made$in$Altan$Urag��CK8E�/I8>�?8J�<OG<I@D<EK<;�N@K?�FK?<I�DLJ@:8C�><EI<J�FE�JL9J<HL<EK�8C9LDJ�:FD9@E@E>�KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�DLJ@:�N@K?�M8I@FLJ�DF;<IE�JKPC<J��1<�N@CC�EFN�9I@<`P�;@J:LJJ� KNF�F=� K?<J<�8C9LDJ�� $E�� ���CK8E�/I8>� I<:FI;<;� KNF�8C9LDJ��FE<�F=�N?@:?� <E!K@KC<;�Blood�:FEK@EL<J�@E�K?<�M<@E�F=�[=FCB�IF:B\�<JK89C@J?<;�@E�Made$in$Altan$Urag��.?<�FK?<I�8C9LD�Hypnotism�@J�M<IP�;@==<I<EK��JL9K@KC<;�8J�[�FEK<DGFI8IP��C9LD\�@K�@J�8�9FC;�8E;�M<EKLIFLJ�<OGCFI8K@FE�F=�:FE!K<DGFI8IP�:C8JJ@:8C�DLJ@:�JKPC<J�8E;�<C<D<EKJ��-FD<�KI8:BJ�C@B<�[/E!JK<8;P\�8E;�[.?<�!FI<@>E�&?8E\�:FD<�;@I<:KCP�=IFD�K?<@I�_IJK�8C9LD�Foal’s$Been$Born�N?@C<�FK?<IJ�C@B<�[�ILDD@E>\�8I<�E<N�8E;�FI@>@E8C��.?<�JFE>J�FE�#PGEFK@JD�:8E�8CC�9<�;<J:I@9<;�8J�9<@E>�M<IP�<OG<I@D<E!K8C�8E;�G<I?8GJ�8J�DFI<�[89JKI8:K\�@E�K?8K�K?<P�<J:?<N�K?<�:FEM<EK@FE8C�

Page 49: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

41

JFE>� =FIDJ�8E;�JKIL:KLI<J�F=� K?<@I� =FCB� IF:B�JKPC<�� $EJKILD<EK8K@FE�FE�K?<J<�KI8:BJ�F=K<E�>F<J�9<PFE;�K?<�98E;^J�KPG@:8C�J<M<EG@<:<�J<KLG�@E!:CL;@E>�=LCC�FI:?<JKI8K@FE�8J�@E�[.?<�!FI<@>E�&?8E\�FI�<OK<EJ@M<�LJ<�F=�G<I:LJJ@FE�EFK�EFID8CCP�8JJF:@8K<;�N@K?�IF:B�FI�:C8JJ@:8C�DLJ@:�8J�@E�[�ILDD@E>�\�-FD<�JFE>J�D8B<�LJ<�F=�<OK<E;<;�GC8P@E>�K<:?E@HL<J�8E;�9@Q8II<�JFLE;J�8J�@E�[/EJK<8;P�\�� +<I?8GJ� K?<�DFJK� @EK<I<JK@E>�JFE>�N@K?� I<>8I;J� KF�FLI�GI<J<EK�GLIGFJ<J� @J�[&?<ILC<E�,@M<I�\�.?@J�JFE>� @J�G<I=FID<;�9P�#�� I;<E<K!J<KJ<>��8�B�8��[ IB8\��8J�8E�LE8::FDG8E@<;� CFE>�JFE>�N@K?�8;;@K@FE8C�I<M<I9�<==<:K�@E�K?<�I<:FI;@E>��$E�8�J<EJ<�K?@J�:FLC;�9<�:8CC<;�M<IP�KI8;@!K@FE8C��(FE>FC@8EJ�EFD8;J�NFLC;�F=K<E�J@E>�CFE>�JFE>J�LE8::FDG8E@<;�N?@C<�J@DGCP�>F@E>�89FLK�K?<@I�;8@CP�IFLK@E<�8E;�:8IIP@E>�FLK�DLE;8E<�K8JBJ����#FN<M<I�>@M<E�K?<�:FEK<OK�F=�K?@J�JFE>�8J�8E�8L;@F�I<:FI;@E>�FE�8����JL9K@KC<;�[�FEK<DGFI8IP��C9LD\�8E;�GI<:<;<;�9P�8E�@EKIF�KI8:B�:FEJ@JK@E>�F=����J<:FE;J�F=�J@C<E:<�8E;�K?<�;<C@9<I8K<�;@>@K8C�8CK<I8K@FE�F=�K?<�JFLE;�K?<�C@JK<E<I�?<8IJ�[&?<ILC<E�,@M<I\�EFK�JF�DL:?�8J�8�KI8;@!K@FE8C�JFE>�9LK�8J�8�:FEK<DGFI8IP�NFIB�F=�?@>?�8IK��*I�I8K?<I�K?<�C@JK<E<I�?<8IJ�[&?<ILC<E�,@M<I\�8J�N<CC�8J�K?<�I<JK�F=�K?<�8C9LD�8J�8�KI8;@K@FE8C�8IK�=FID�9<@E>�89JKI8:K<;�8E;�<C<M8K<;�KF�K?<�8I<E8�F=�I<`<:K@M<�?@>?�8IK��.?LJ�Hypnotism�9FK?�D@O<J�<C<D<EKJ�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�DLJ@:�N@K?�DF;<IE�DLJ@:�8E;�<E:FLI8><J�8�E<N�G<IJG<:K@M<�FE�KI8;@K@FE8C�DLJ@:�� .?<�8C9LD�Nation�I<:FI;<;�@E�� � �@J�JL9K@KC<;�[!FCB��C9LD�\�1?<I<8J�Hypnotism� <OGC@:@KCP� JFL>?K� KF� :FD9@E<� K?<� KI8;@K@FE8C�N@K?�K?<�DF;<IE�Nation�@J�DL:?�DFI<�FLKN8I;CP�KI8;@K@FE8C�8C9<@K�@E�8�M<IP�:C8JJ@:@Q<;�J<EJ<�F=�[KI8;@K@FE8C�\�.?@J�@J�<M@;<EK�@E�KI8:BJ�C@B<�[&?<IL!C<E�,@M<I\�8E;�[!8I<N<CC\�N?@:?�=<8KLI<�CFE>�JFE>�8E;�J?FIK�JFE>�8:!:FDG8E@<;�9P�DFI@E�B?LLI� I<JG<:K@M<CP�Z�8� KI8;@K@FE8C�G<I=FID8E:<�8II8E><D<EK������ $EK<I<JK@E>CP�K?@J�8C9LD�8CJF�=<8KLI<J�K?<�JFE>�[&?<ILC<E�,@M!<I�\�*I� I8K?<I�Nation� =<8KLI<J�8E�8CK<IE8K<�M<IJ@FE�F=� K?@J� JFE>� =FI� @K�@J�8II8E><;�8E;�G<I=FID<;�;@==<I<EKCP�@E�FI;<I�KF�_K�K?<�8C9LD^J�JK8K<;�[=FCB\�8<JK?<K@:��1?<I<8J�Hypnotism’s�M<IJ@FE�F=�[&?<ILC<E�,@M<I\�=<8!KLI<;�LE8::FDG8E@<;�8E;�;@>@K8CCP�8L>D<EK<;�CFE>�JFE>�Nation’s�M<I!J@FE�=<8KLI<J�[I8N\�CFE>�JFE>�8::FDG8E@<;�9P�JFCF�DFI@E�B?LLI���CK8E�/I8>�;F<J�K?@J�N@K?�FK?<I�JFE>J�8J�N<CC�=<8KLI@E>�DLCK@GC<�JFE>J�@E�;@=!=<I<EK� M<IJ@FEJ� FE� J<M<I8C� 8C9LDJ� <8:?� M<IJ@FE� :FII<JGFE;@E>� KF� K?<�G8IK@:LC8I�8C9LD^J�FM<I8CC�8<JK?<K@:�� $E�;F@E>�K?@J��CK8E�/I8>�<E:FLI!

HEINS

Page 50: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

42

8><J� K?<� C@JK<E<I� KF� G8P� 8KK<EK@FE� EFK�D<I<CP� KF� K?<� JFE>� 9LK� 8CJF� KF�=F:LJ�<OGC@:@KCP�FE�K?<�;@==<I<E:<�@E�JKPC<�JFLE;�8E;�8<JK?<K@:�K?8K�<8:?�8C9LD�JKI@M<J�KFN8I;�� $K�NFLC;�9<�LE:?8I@K89C<� KF��CK8E�/I8>^J�8IK@JK@:� @EK<EK@FEJ� KF�J@DGCP�M@<N�Nation�8J�8�I<:FI;�F=�JKI@:KCP�KI8;@K@FE8C�DLJ@:��Nation�:FE!K8@EJ�J<M<I8C�KI8:BJ�C@B<�[.?<�'@>?K\�8E;�[(@I8><�F=�!8I�'8E;\�N?@:?�8I<� ;@JK@E:KCP�DF;<IE� @E� JKPC<� 8E;� :FDGFJ@K@FE� <M<E� LJ@E>� JFD<� <O!K<E;<;� K<:?E@HL<J� FE� K?<� PF:?@E��(FI<� JL9KC<� <C<D<EKJ� F=� ;<C@9<I8K<�DF;<IE@KP�:8E�9<�=FLE;�@E�FK?<I�JFE>J�8J�N<CC�JL:?�8J�@E�K?<�?8IDFE@<J�F=�K?<�8::FDG8EP@E>�DFI@E�B?LLIJ�@E�[!8I<N<CC�\�Nation�8J�8E�8C9LD�K?<E�@J�G<I?8GJ�DFI<�FLKN8I;CP�KI8;@K@FE8C�K?8E�FK?<I�8C9LDJ�9LK�K?@J�@J�FECP�9<:8LJ<�@K�J<<BJ�KF�:FD9@E<�<C<D<EKJ�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�DLJ@:�N@K?�<C<D<EKJ�F=�DF;<IE�DLJ@:�@E�8�KI8;@K@FE8C�DLJ@:8C�D<;@LD�8�>F8C�K?8K�@J�C@E<�N@K?�K?<�98E;^J�JK8K<;�>F8C�F=�<E:FLI8>@E>�8GGI<:@8K@FE�F=�KI8;@!K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�DLJ@:�9P�PFLE><I�LI98E�(FE>FC@8EJ��� #8M@E>�;@J:LJJ<;�K?<J<�8C9LDJ�N@K?�I<>8I;�KF�8L;@KFIP�<C<D<EKJ�C<K� LJ� EFN� :FEJ@;<I� K?<� M@JL8C� <C<D<EKJ� F=� K?<J<� 8C9LDJ � G8:B8>@E>��1<�N@CC�9<>@E�N@K?$Made$in$Altan$Urag�K?<�8C9LD�K?8K�D8IBJ�8�D8AFI�GF@EK�@E��CK8E�/I8>^J�?@JKFIP�8J�8�98E;�N?<E�@K�:FEJFC@;8K<;�@KJ�@D8><�8E;� JFLE;�8J�8� =FCB� IF:B�98E;���J�D<EK@FE<;�<8IC@<I� ALJK�9<=FI<� K?@J�8C9LD^J�GIF;L:K@FE��CK8E�/I8>�8:HL@I<;�KNF�E<N�:LJKFD�DFI@E�B?LLIJ�K?8K�9F8JK<;�K?<�?<8;�F=�K?<�DFEJK<I��C@<E�F=�1<JK<IE�J:@_�Y�?FIIFI�CFI<�@E�GC8:<�F=� 8� ?FIJ<^J� ?<8;����:CFJ<LG� @D8><�F=� K?<� [DFEJK<I?<8;<;�_;;C<\�KF�LJ<�K?<�K<ID�F=�+IF=<JJFI����.J<KJ<EKJFCDFE�=IFD�K?<�(FE>F!C@8E�)8K@FE8C�/E@M<IJ@KP�8E;�@KJ��C@<E�?<8;�D8B<J�LG�K?<�:FM<I�=FI�Made$

in$Altan$Urag��$K�@J�8�9FC;� JK8K<D<EK� F=�K?<� 98E;^J� 8IK@JK@:�@EK<EK�� K?<� DFEJK<I?<8;<;� _;;C<� @J� 8�JPD9FC�F=�K?<�;<C@9<I!8K<�9C<E;@E>�F=�(FE!>FC@8E� KI8;@K@FE� N@K?�DF;<IE�>CF98C�GFGL!C8I� :LCKLI<���� !LIK?<I!

DFI<� K?<� =I@>?K<E@E>�8E;�>IFK<JHL<�E8KLI<�F=� K?<��C@<E�?<8;�8E;� K?<�9C8:B�:FCFI�F=�K?<�@EJKILD<EK�<MFB<�8JJF:@8K@FEJ�N@K?�8�;8IB�8>>I<JJ@M<�

“It$is$a$bold$statement$of$the$band’s$artistic$intente$the$monsterBheaded$$�������� �� ������������������� ���blending$of$Mongolian$tradition$with$modern,$global$popular$culture.”

Page 51: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

43

JKPC<�F=�IF:B�FI�D<K8C��.?LJ�K?<�DFI@E�B?LLI�8� KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�=FCB�@EJKILD<EK�@J�KI8EJ=FID<;�@EKF�8�E<N�=FCB�IF:B�@EJKILD<EK�8E;�@KJ�@D8><�FE�K?<�:FM<I�F=�Made$in$Altan$Urag�GIF:C8@DJ�K?<�8C9LD^J�8>!>I<JJ@M<�=FCB�IF:B�JFLE;��(FI<�@DGFIK8EKCP�8J��CK8E�/I8>^J�9I<8BFLK�;<_E@K@M<�8C9LD�@K�<E:8GJLC8K<J�K?<�98E;^J�FM<I8CC�8IK@JK@:�>F8CJ�� -L9J<HL<EK� 8C9LDJ� <8:?� ?8M<� @E;@M@;L8C� JKPC@JK@:� >F8CJ� 8E;�K?<J<� 8I<� I<`<:K<;� @E� K?<� 8C9LDJ � I<JG<:K@M<� :FM<IJ��Hypnotism� K?<�[�FEK<DGFI8IP��C9LD\� @EJK<8;�=<8KLI<J�9C8:B�8E;�N?@K<�JKI@G<J�N@K?�@D8><J�F=�<8:?�98E;�D<D9<I^J�<P<J�JK8>><I<;�@E�K?<�N?@K<�JKI@G<J��$E�:FEKI8JK�KF�Blood�K?@J�:FM<I�@J�EFK�8>>I<JJ@M<�FI�;8IB�9LK�I8K?<I�89JKI8:K�:?8CC<E>@E>�8E;�<M<E�G@<I:@E>CP�I<`<:K@M<�8J�K?<�<P<J�JK8I<�JKI8@>?K�8K�K?<� M@<N<I��#<I<� K?<I<� 8I<� EF� @D8><J� FI� ;<G@:K@FEJ� F=� KI8;@K@FE��.?@J�;<E@8C�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�@D8><J�8E;�<DG?8J@J�FE�K?<�89JKI8:K�_KJ�K?<�@;<8J�F=�DF;<IE@KP�@E�DLJ@:�8E;�K?LJ�I<GI<J<EKJ�K?<�[:FEK<DGFI8IP\�E8KLI<�F=�K?<�8C9LD��Once$Upon$a$Time�=<8KLI<J�8�G@:KLI<�F=�K?<�98E;�D<D9<IJ�;I<JJ<;�:8JL8CCP�?FC;@E>�LG�8E;�CFFB@E>�LG�K?IFL>?�K?<�:@I:LC8I�NFF;<E�JKIL:KLI<�K?8K�=FIDJ�K?<�JKIL:KLI8C�:<EK<IG@<:<�F=�8�(FE>FC@8E�><I�FI�=<CK�K<EK�?FD<��.?@J�@J�8�G8IK@:LC8ICP�@EK<I<JK@E>�@D8><�8J�K?<�98E;�D<D9<IJ�8I<�8CC�;I<JJ<;�:8JL8CCP�@E�DF;<IE�=8J?@FE�:C<8ICP�F=�K?<�DF;<IE�8E;�LI!98E@Q<;�8><�@E�(FE>FC@8��)FE<K?<C<JJ�K?<P�CFFB�LG�K?IFL>?�K?<�:<EKI8C�JKIL:KLI<�F=�8�><I�JPD9FC@Q@E>�K?<�:FEJK8EK�CFFB@E>�KF�K?<�G8JK�K?IFL>?�KI8;@K@FE��Nation�;F<J�EFK�=<8KLI<�K?<�98E;�D<D9<IJ�FI�8EP�?LD8E�9<!@E>J�8K�8CC�FE�@KJ�:FM<I��$EJK<8;�@K�=<8KLI<J�FECP�NI@K@E>�@E�K?<�KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC�-:I@GK�@E�I<;�@EB�FE�8�9IFNE�G8I:?D<EKC@B<�JLI=8:<��.?<�LJ<�F=�(FE>FC�-:I@GK�M<IP�JKIFE>CP�:FEM<PJ�K?<�J<EJ<�F=�E8K@FE8C@KP�K?8K�@J�JF�GI<J<EK�@E�K?@J�8C9LD^J�[=FCB\�DLJ@:�� *M<I8CC�9P�GIF;L:@E>�8C9LDJ�N@K?�:C<8ICP�JK8K<;�JKPC@JK@:�D<!;@LDJ�8E;�>F8CJ��CK8E�/I8>�;<DFEJKI8K<J�9FK?� @KJ�?@>?� C<M<C�F=�DL!J@:@8EJ?@G� 8E;� @KJ� ;<;@:8K@FE� KF� 9<@E>� @EEFM8K@M<� <OGCFI@E>� ;@==<I<EK�:FD9@E8K@FEJ�F=� KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�DLJ@:8C�<C<D<EKJ�N@K?�M8I@FLJ�DF;<IE�DLJ@:8C�<C<D<EKJ��$K�8CJF�;<DFEJKI8K<J�K?<�M<IJ8K@C@KP�F=�(FE!>FC@8E�KI8;@K@FE8C�@EJKILD<EKJ�8E;�GC8P@E>�JKPC<J�8EFK?<I�F=�K?<�98E;^J�>F8CJ�19�!LIK?<IDFI<� K?<� :FD9@E8K@FE�F=� KI8;@K@FE8C�N@K?�DF;<IE� K?8K�I<JLCKJ� =IFD� K?@J�M<IJ8K@C@KP�8E;� @EEFM8K@FE� @J� :8GKLI<;�M@JL8CCP� @E� K?<�8C9LD�:FM<IJ�8E;�FM<I8CC�G8:B8>@E>��� #8M@E>�:FEJ@;<I<;��CK8E�/I8>^J�;@J:F>I8G?P�C<K�LJ�EFN�9I@<`P�:FEJ@;<I� K?<@I� C@M<� G<I=FID8E:<J��,<>8I;@E>� JFE>� :?F@:<��CK8E�/I8>�

HEINS

Page 52: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

44

LJL8CCP�GC8PJ�JFE>J�@E�K?<�=FCB�IF:B�JKPC<�K?<�I<G<IKF@I<�:FD@E>�=IFD�K?<�8C9LDJ�Made$in$Altan$Urag�8E;�Blood���CK8E�/I8>�C@B<CP�JK8PJ�N@K?@E�K?<�=FCB�IF:B�I<G<IKF@I<�@E�C@M<�G<I=FID8E:<�8K�CF:8C�M<EL<J��N?@:?�8I<�F=K<E�CF:8C�I<JK8LI8EKJ�8E;�GL9J��J@DGCP�9<:8LJ<�@K�@J�<8J@<I�KF�G<I=FID�C@M<��8J�@K�;F<J�EFK�I<HL@I<�8EP�8;;@K@FE8C�FI:?<JKI8C�@EJKILD<EKJ�FI�LE!:FEM<EK@FE8C� G<I:LJJ@FE�� 9<:8LJ<� @K� @J�DFI<� <O:@K@E>� =FI� C@M<� G<I=FI!D8E:<�8E;�DFJK�@DGFIK8EKCP�9<:8LJ<�@K�@J�K?<�@;<EK@KP�K?8K��CK8E�/I8>�?8J�9L@CK� FM<I� K?<�P<8IJ�� $K� @J� K?<�DFJK� 8::<JJ@9C<�DFJK� <O:@K@E>� 8E;�DFJK�N<CCI<:<@M<;�D@OKLI<�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�8E;�DF;<IE�GFGLC8I�DLJ@:�� $E� G<I=FID8E:<J� K?<�D<D9<IJ� F=��CK8E�/I8>� F=K<E�N<8I� K?<�J8D<�;I<JJ�:FEJ@JK@E>�F=�9C8:B�KLE@:J�N@K?�J@CM<I�<D9IF@;<IP�@E�8�:FD!DFE�G8KK<IE�@E�KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�;I<JJ�8E;�9CL<�A<8EJ��F::8J@FE8CCP�K?<�;ILDD<I�N@CC�J@DGCP�N<8I�8�9C8:B��CK8E�/I8>�KJ?@IK���.?@J�;I<JJ�@J�@EK<I<JK@E>�=FI�@K�@J�EFK�8:KL8CCP�(FE>FC@8E�KI8;@K@FE8C�;I<JJ��$EJK<8;�@KJ�J@CM<I�<D9IF@;<IP�G8KK<IEJ�<MFB<�@D8><J�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�;I<JJ�N?@C<�@K�@J�8:KL8CCP�DF;<IE�N@K?�8�:FCFI�J:?<D<�K?8K�<MFB<J�@D8><J�F=�;8IBE<JJ�8J!JF:@8K<;�N@K?�IF:B�8E;�D<K8C��.?LJ��CK8E�/I8>^J�:FJKLD<�N?@C<�DF;<IE�K?IFL>?�8E;�K?IFL>?�<MFB<J�@D8><J�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�;I<JJ�:I<8K@E>�8�E<N�G@:KLI<�F=�KI8;@K@FE�8E;�<E:FLI8>@E>�K?<�8L;@<E:<�KF�?<8I�K?<�DLJ@:�K?<�J8D<�N8P�K?8K�K?<P�J<<�K?<�;I<JJ�� .?<�@EJKILD<EK8K@FE�?8J�8CI<8;P�9<<E�8;;I<JJ<;�9LK�K?<�G?PJ@!:8C�8II8E><D<EK�F=�K?<�DLJ@:@8EJ�FE�JK8><�@J�8CJF�EFK<NFIK?P��1?<I<8J�98E;J�C@B<�&?LJL>KLE�N?F�;<J:I@9<�K?<DJ<CM<J�8J�8�DFI<�KI8;@K@FE8CCP�=F:LJ<;�98E;�FE�K?<@I�N<9J@K<�K<E;�KF�J@K�FI;<I<;�@E�8�JKI8@>?K�C@E<��C!K8E�/I8>�8II8E><J�K?<DJ<CM<J�DL:?�DFI<�C@B<�8�:FEM<EK@FE8C�IF:B�98E;�N@K?�K?<�;ILDJ�8K�:<EK<I�8E;�98:BJK8><�K?<�@B?�B?LLI��98JJ��8E;�9@J?!>LLI�E<OK�KF�K?<�;ILDJ�K?<�KNF�DFI@E�B?LLIJ��>L@K8IJ��=IFEK�JK8><�FE�<8:?�J@;<�8E;�K?<�PF:?@E��C<8;�J@E><I��=IFEK�JK8><�8E;�:<EK<I��.?<�DFI@E�B?LLIJ�8II8E><D<EK�@J�DL:?�C@B<�K?8K�F=�I?PK?D�>L@K8I�8E;�C<8;�>L@K8I�@E�8�IF:B�98E;�8J�FE<�DFI@E�B?LLI�JFD<K@D<J�LJ<J�<C<:KI@:�;@JKFIK@FE�=FI�C<8;J�8E;�JFCFJ��C<8;�>L@K8I��N?@C<�K?<�FK?<I�I<D8@EJ�LE;@JKFIK<;�8E;�F=K<E�GC8PJ�DFI<�8::FDG8E@D<EKJKPC<�G8IKJ��I?PK?D�>L@K8I��� �FE:<IKJ�8K�CF:8C�M<EL<J�8I<�N<CC8KK<E;<;�8E;�N<CCI<:<@M<;�9P�K?<�8L;@<E:<�� E;@E>J�F=�JFE>J�8I<�8CN8PJ�>I<<K<;�N@K?�8GGI<:@8K@M<�8G!GC8LJ<�N@K?�<JG<:@8CCP�CFL;�8GGC8LJ<�8E;�:?<<I@E>�:FD@E>�=IFD�K89C<J�:FEK8@E@E>�>I<8K<I�ELD9<IJ�F=�<DGKP�C@K<IJ@Q<;�9<<I�>C8JJ<J���L;@<E:<J�J<<D� KF� <JG<:@8CCP� <EAFP�;ILD�JFCFJ� <C<:KI@:�DFI@E�B?LLI� JFCFJ� 8E;�

Page 53: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

45

@E:I<8J<J�@E�K<DGF�Z�8CC�JK8E;8I;�=8E=8MFI@K<J�F=�IF:B�DLJ@:��� (FI<�@DGFIK8EKCP�K?FL>?�K?<�8L;@<E:<�J<<DJ�KF�<JG<:@8CCP�8G!GI<:@8K<�K?<�DFI<�KI8;@K@FE8C�HL8C@K@<J�F=��CK8E�/I8>^J�DLJ@:��1?<E<M<I�K?<�CFE>�JFE>�J@E><I� IB8�@J�GI<J<EK�8E;�K?<P�G<I=FID�K?<�E<N�=FCB�IF:B�8II8E><D<EK� F=� [!8I<N<CC\� K?<I<� 8I<� <JG<:@8CCP� CFL;� 8E;� <EK?LJ@8JK@:�I<JGFEJ<J��*E<�8JKLK<�(FE>FC@8E�8L;@<E:<�D<D9<I�$�JGFB<�KF�F9J<IM<;�K?8K�N?<E<M<I��CK8E�/I8>�GC8P<;�[DFI<�KI8;@K@FE8C\�JFE>J�K?8K�N<I<�EFK�[JF�IF:B\�K?<�8L;@<E:<�><E<I8CCP�8GGI<:@8K<;�@K�DFI<��$E�JFD<�J<EJ<�K?@J�J<<D<;�GC8LJ@9C<��?FN<M<I�8EFK?<I�(FE>FC@8E�8KK<E;@E>�8�J?FN�8K�$B?�(FE>FC�J8@;�KF�D<�K?8K�?<�CFM<;�C@JK<E@E>�KF��CK8E�/I8>�G<I=FID�[�CL<�(8IB\� FE<�F=� K?<@I�DFI<� 8>>I<JJ@M<JFLE;@E>� IF:B� JFE>J� 9<:8LJ<� @K�D8;<�?@D�[=<<C�GIFL;�KF�9<�(FE>FC@8E\�Z�JF�DL:?�JF�K?8K�?<�NFLC;�><K�GLDG<;�8E;�[ALJK�N8EK�KF�P<CC�]!L:B�PFL�^\�.?@J�:FEM<IJ8K@FE�8J�N<CC�8J�FK?<IJ�8E;�F9J<IM8K@FEJ�F=�K?<�:IFN;J�C<;�D<�KF�K?<�:FE:CLJ@FE�K?8K��CK8E�/I8>^J�DLJ@:�@J�GFGLC8I�8E;�N<CCI<:<@M<;�E<@K?<I�JKI@:KCP�9<:8LJ<�F=�@KJ�KI8;@K@FE8C�<C<D<EKJ�EFI�9<:8LJ<�F=�@KJ�IF:B�<C<D<EKJ�9LK�GI<:@J<CP�9<:8LJ<�@K�9C<E;J�K?<�KNF�JF�K?8K�K?<�KI8;@K@FE8C�8E;�K?<�DF;<IE�K?<�FC;�8E;�K?<�E<N�:FDGC<D<EK�<8:?�FK?<I�@E�8�N8P�K?8K�@J�D<8E@E>=LC�8E;�8:!:<JJ@9C<�KF�D8EP�:FEK<DGFI8IP�(FE>FC@8EJ�� $E�8;;@K@FE�KF�K?<@I�8C9LDJ�8E;�C@M<�G<I=FID8E:<J��CK8E�/I8>�LK@C@Q<J�FK?<I�D<;@8� @E:CL;@E>�DFM@<J�DLJ@:�M@;<FJ�8E;� K?<� @EK<IE<K���J�GI<M@FLJCP�D<EK@FE<;��CK8E�/I8>�N8J� @EMFCM<;� @E� K?<�GIF;L:K@FE�F=�K?<�DFM@<J�[&?8;8B\�;@I<:K<;�9P�+<K<I��IFJ<EJ�8E;�%<JJ@:8�1FF;!NFIK?�8E;�[(FE>FC\�;@I<:K<;�9P�-<I><@��F;IFM��$E�[&?8;8B\��CK8E�/I8>� 8:KL8CCP�D8B<J� 8E� 8GG<8I8E:<� @E� K?<�_CD�8J� 8�98E;�F=�FLKC8NJ��.?<P�G<I=FID�K?<�JFE>�[(FK?<I�(FE>FC@8\�8E;�K?<E�GC8P�D@EFI�IFC<J�8J�98E;@KJ�8JJ@JK@E>�@E�K?<�I<:C8D8K@FE�F=�JK8K<J<@Q<;�D<8K��.?<�<EK@I<�_CD�@J�8�D8>@:8CI<8C@JK�_CD�K?8K�=F:LJ<J�FE�K?<�I8G@;�JF:@8C�:?8E><�K?8K�(FE>FC@8�@J�:LII<EKCP�<OG<I@<E:@E>���CK8E�/I8>^J�DLJ@:8C�8E;�<JG<:@8CCP�G?PJ@:8C�GI<J<E:<�@E�K?@J�DFM@<�K?<E�GC8:<J�K?<@I�DLJ@:�8E;�K?<@I�@;<EK@KP�8J�8�98E;�@E�K?@J�:FEK<OK�F=�JF:@8C�:?8E><�I<@E=FI:@E>�8E;�8=_ID@E>�K?<@I�GC8:<�8J�:FEE<:KFIJ�F=�K?<�KI8;@K@FE8C�N@K?�K?<�DF;<IE��� �CK8E�/I8>�?8J�J8@;�K?8K�K?<P�>I<8KCP�<EAFP�NFIB@E>�@E�K?<�D<!;@LD�F=� _CD� 9<:8LJ<� <8:?� <E;<8MFI� @J� 8�D8AFI� 8IK@JK@:� GIF;L:K@FE�20��.?@J�@J�<M@;<EK�@E�K?<@I�D8EP�DLJ@:�M@;<FJ�GIF;L:<;�KF�;8K<��.?<P�?8M<�GIF;L:<;�8GGIFO@D8K<CP�K<E�DLJ@:�M@;<FJ�DFJKCP�F=�JFE>J�=IFD�Made$in$Altan$Urag�8E;�Blood���

HEINS

Page 54: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

46

� *E<� F=� K?<�DFJK� @EK<I<JK@E>� M@;<FJ� @J� =FI� K?<� JFE>� [�9IF8;\�=IFD�Made$ in$Altan$Urag��(LJ@:8CCP� K?@J�JFE>�=<8KLI<J�?FFD@@�?8E;�;ILDJ�8E;�>L@K8I�NFIB�9P�:FCC89FI8K@E>�8IK@JK��E;I<N��FCN<CC�@E������D<K<I�8E;�@E�8�M<IP�;8IB�DF;8C�:?FI;�GIF>I<JJ@FE��.?<�I<JLCK@E>�JFLE;�@J�M<IP�;8IB�8E;�@EK<EK@FE8CCP�<OFK@:�:F@E:@;@E>�N@K?�K?<�K@KC<�[�9IF8;�\�.?<�M@;<F�=<8KLI<J�K?<�98E;�GCLJ��E;I<N��FCN<CC��8�EFE(FE>FC@8E��GC8P@E>�DLJ@:�N?@C<�:@I:C@E>�8E�FMFF�8�KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�I<C@>@FLJ�JKIL:KLI<�8E;�G8P@E>�I<JG<:K�KF�@K��.?<�98E;�@J�;I<JJ<;�@E�K?<@I�9C8:B�G<I!=FID8E:<�IF9<J�N?@C<��E;I<N�@J�;I<JJ<;�@E�8�KPG@:8C�1<JK<IE�=8J?@FE��.?LJ�K?<I<�8I<�DLCK@GC<�C<M<CJ�F=�@EK<I8:K@FE�9<KN<<E�K?<�KI8;@K@FE8C�8E;�K?<�DF;<IE�Z�9<KN<<E�K?<�FMFF�8E;��CK8E�/I8>�DF;<IE�(FE>FC@8EJ�N?F�G8P�KI@9LK<�KF�K?<�G8JK�@E�8�DF;<IE@Q<;�DLJ@:8C�D<;@LD�8E;�9<!KN<<E��CK8E�/I8>�8E;��E;I<N�8�1<JK<IE�=FI<@>E<I�GC8P@E>�8�1<JK<IE�@EJKILD<EK�N?F�@J�EFE<K?<C<JJ�@EK<>I8K<;�@EKF�K?<�DLJ@:�8E;�K?<�FM<I8CC�J:<E<��$K�@J�NFIK?�EFK@E>�8CJF�K?8K��E;I<N�;F<J�EFK�:@I:C<�K?<�FMFF�FI�G<I=FID�8EP�JFIK�F=�I@KL8C�I<>8I;@E>�K?<�FMFF��$EJK<8;�?@J�:FEE<:K@FE�@J�KF�K?<�98E;�8>8@E�GC8:@E>��CK8E�/I8>�8E;�K?<@I�DLJ@:�@E�K?<�IFC<�F=�8�C@EB�FI�:FDDLE@:8KFI�9<KN<<E�G8JK�8E;�GI<J<EK���J��E;I<N�?@DJ<C=�GLKJ�@K��[(P�@EK<IGI<K8K@FE�@J�K?8K�K?<P�8I<�8CC�89FLK�JPEK?<J@Q@E>�K?<�E<N�N@K?�K?<�FC;�K?<�G8JK�N@K?�K?<�GI<J<EK�K?<�CF:8C�N@K?�K?<�=FI<@>E���FCC89FI8K!@E>�N@K?�D<�DP�GI<J<E:<�@E�K?<�M@;<F�<E>8>@E>�K?<�FMFF�I<JG<:K=LCCP�N@K?�8�]?P9I@; �JFE>�@J�8CC�G8IK�F=�K?@J�D<JJ8><�8E;�8<JK?<K@:�\21��� $E�:FE:CLJ@FE��CK8E�/I8>�JL::<JJ=LCCP�9C<E;J�KI8;@K@FE8C�DLJ@:�N@K?� IF:B� 8E;�FK?<I�1<JK<IE�DF;<IE�DLJ@:8C� JKPC<J� @E� FI;<I� KF� J?8I<�(FE>FC@8E� :LCKLI<�N@K?� K?<�NFIC;� 8E;� @E� FI;<I� KF� @EJG@I<� E<N� LI98E�><E<I8K@FEJ�F=�(FE>FC@8EJ�KF�8GGI<:@8K<�KI8;@K@FE8C�(FE>FC@8E�DLJ@:��.?@J�9C<E;@E>�F::LIJ�FE�8L;@8C�8E;�M@JL8C�C<M<CJ�8E;�@E�D8EP�;@==<I<EK�D<;@LDJ�� @E� 8C9LD�DLJ@:� 8E;� G8:B8>@E>� @E� C@M<� G<I=FID8E:<�DFM!@<J�DLJ@:�M@;<FJ�8E;�FEC@E<��.?<�KI8;@K@FE8C�<C<D<EKJ�8I<�E<M<I�JKI@:KCP�;@JK@E>L@J?89C<�=IFD�K?<�EFEKI8;@K@FE8C�9<:8LJ<�KI8;@K@FE�@J�EFK�8�JK8K@:�F9A<:K�Z� @K� @J� :FEJK8EKCP� I<@D8>@E<;� 8E;� I<:I<8K<;���P�:I<8K@E>� K?<@I�LE@HL<�JKPC<�F=�(FE>FC@8E�=FCB�IF:B��CK8E�/I8>�?8J�LJ<;�9FK?� KI8;@!K@FE8C�8E;�IF:B�<C<D<EKJ�KF�GF@EK�KF�8�E8K@FE8C�@;<EK@KP�IFFK<;�@E�8�G<I!:<@M<;�G8JK�N?@:?�8CJF�FG<ECP�<D9I8:<J�@EK<I8:K@FE�N@K?�FK?<I�E8K@FEJ�8E;�:LCKLI<J�@E�K?<�:FEK<OK�F=�8�DF;<IE�>CF98C@Q<;�NFIC;��$E�9C<E;@E>�FC;�N@K?�E<N�8E;�CF:8C�N@K?�=FI<@>E�K?<P�:I<8K<�E<N�I<GI<J<EK8K@FEJ�F=�K?<�G8JK�K?8K�8I<�D<8E@E>=LC�8E;�8::<JJ@9C<�@E�K?<�GI<J<EK�

Page 55: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

47

“The$Mongolian$nation$of$this$timeInherited$this$motherland.Blessed$with$having

The$sun,$rising$in$the$morningBorn$the$Mongolian$fate,$eternal

Inheriting$the$custom$and$tradition.”

$ $ $ $ �[�CL<�(8IB\

HEINS

Page 56: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

48

9FIE� @E � -P;E<P � �LJ !K I8 C @8 � @J � 8 � ALE@FI � D8AFI @E>� @E � )<LIFJ:@<E:<��#<� <EAFPJ� J:@= @ � :?@ C C @E>� FE� JLDD<I� E@>?KJ �8E;� K?<�F::8J@FE8C � 8:K �F= �;<= @8E:<� �.?@E>J� K?8K�8DLJ<�?@D� @E:CL;<�:8JL8C � I?PD@E>�8E;� I8E;FD�<M<EKJ � K?8K �F::LI �N@K?�GI<:@J< �K @D@E>� ��JG@I @E>�KF � 8:HL@I< � BEFNC<;><� 8= K<I � ?<� :FDGC<K<J � :FC !C<>< �?<�GC8EJ�KF �FE<�;8P�I<J<8I:?�E<LIFCF>@:8C�=<8KLI<J � I8E>@E>� =IFD� CFE>K<ID� GFK<EK @8 K @FE�KF � J<@QLI<J � � #<� GC8PJ� IL>9P � = @E;J� >FF;� 9FFBJ�CFM<CP � 8E;� PFL� :8E� LJL8C CP � = @E;� ?@D� >FF=@E>�F== �N@K?�?@J �9L;;@<J ��

Patrick Rice,

Page 57: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

49

@J � 8 � ALE@FI � 8 K � K?<� /E@M<I!J@ KP � F= � +@ K KJ9LI>? � 8E;� @J � FI @>@E8C CP � = IFD� K?<�9FIFL>?� F= � 1<JK � (@== C @E � +�� � #<� @J � J KL;P@E>��?<D@JKIP�N@K?�8E�<DG?8J@J �FE��@FJ:@<E:<�8E;�@J �8 �D<D9<I�F= �K?<��D<I@:8E��?<D@:8C �-F:@<KP���CK?FL>?� ?@J � D8AFI � =F:LJ� ?8J � 9<<E� @E � *I>8E@:�8E;��@F:?<D@JKIP �?<� �?8J �8 CJF�J KL;@<;� K?<�G?@ !CFJFG?P�F= �8I K @ = @: @8 C �@EK<C C @><E:<�8E;�DLCK @M<IJ<�K?<FI@<J � �.?<� I<JK � F= � ?@J � K @D<� @J � JG<EK �NFIB@E>�8J �8 �D8JK<I �J8E;N@:?�:FFB�8K ��?8IC<P^J �"I@ C C<;�-L9J�

Jacob Very

Page 58: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

50

FFFORBES & FIFTH

O

FFIC

E OF UNDERGRADUATE RESEARCH - O.U.R.

Page 59: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

51

.?<�J@OK?�<C<D<EK�:8I9FE�@J�K?<�98J@J�=FI�C@=<�8J�N<�BEFN�@K���8I9FE^J�<OKI8FI;@E8IP�89@C@KP� KF� =FID�LG� KF� =FLI�9FE;J�N@K?�8J�D8EP�;@==<I<EK�G8IKE<IJ�8CCFNJ�@K�KF�:I<8K<�8�JK8>><I@E>�8DFLEK�F=�DFC<:LC<J�N@K?�K?<�?<CG�F=�8�I<C8K@M<CP�JD8CC�8DFLEK�F=�<C<D<EKJ�E8D<CP�?P;IF><E�FOP!><E�E@KIF><E�8E;�G?FJG?FILJ��$=�K?FJ<�_M<�JFLE;�=8D@C@8I�KF><K?<I�@K^J�9<:8LJ<�K?<P�8I<�K?<�8KFDJ�E<:<JJ8IP�KF�9L@C;��)��K?<�D8AFI�:FDGF!E<EKJ�F=�N?@:?�8I<�:8I9FE98J<;�JL>8IJ���)��:F;<J�=FI�GIFK<@EJ�N?@:?�8I<�D8;<�LG�F=�8�J<I@<J�F=�8D@EF�8:@;J�Z�8CJF�:8I9FE�JKIL:KLI<J��+IF!K<@EJ�8I<�K?<�KFFCJ�F=�K?<�:<CC�8CCFN@E>�@K�KF�G<I=FID�D8EP�8:K@FEJ�:?@<=�8DFE>�K?<D�9<@E>�K?<�D8E@GLC8K@FE�F=�:8I9FE�JL>8IJ�KF�GIFM@;<�K?<�<E!<I>P�E<:<JJ8IP�=FI�K?<�8:K@FE�F=�C@=<�� $E�DFJK�:8I9FE98J<;�DFC<:LC<J�K?<I<�8I<�KNF�N8PJ�K?<�9FE;<;�<C<D<EKJ�:8E�9<�8II8E><;�8IFLE;�8�:<EKI8C�:8I9FE�8KFD�BEFNE�8J�JG��8E;�JG���$E�JG���8CJF�BEFNE�8J�[KI@>FE8C�GC8E8I\��K?<�:<EKI8C�:8I9FE�@J�9FE;<;� KF� K?I<<�<C<D<EKJ�N?@:?�8I<�8II8E><;�8IFLE;� K?<�:8I9FE� @E�8�J@E>C<� GC8E<���<:8LJ<� 8KFDJ� I<G<C� FE<� 8EFK?<I� K?<� K?I<<� :FEJK@KL<EKJ�JGI<8;�@EKF�8E�8GGIFO@D8K<CP�<HL@C8K<I8C�KI@8E>C<�=FID@E>��� T�8E>C<J�N@K?�I<JG<:K�KF�K?<�:<EKI8C�:8I9FE����N<CCBEFNE�<O8DGC<�F=�:8I9FE�@E�K?@J�=FID�@J�>I8G?@K<�:FDDFECP�BEFNE�8J�K?<�C<8;�@E�G<E:@CJ��"I8G?@K<�@J�:FDGI@J<;�F=�D@CC@FEJ�F=�JG��:8I9FE�8KFDJ�9FE;<;�KF><K?<I�@E�8�J@E!>C<GC8E<�J?<<K�=FID@E>�8�?<O8>FE8C�G8KK<IE��.?<�9FE;J�9<KN<<E�K?<J<�:8I9FEJ�8I<�M<IP�JKIFE>�8E;�@K�@J�KFL>?�KF�K<8I�8�J@E>C<�J?<<K��8�J@E>C<�J?<<K� F=� K?<J<� :8I9FEJ� @J� BEFNE� 8J� >I8G?<E<���#FN<M<I� @E� >I8G?@K<�K?<J<�J?<<KJ�JK8:B�FE�KFG�F=�<8:?�FK?<I�98I<CP�:FEE<:K<;�KF�<8:?�FK?!<I�K?IFL>?�@EK<I8:K@FEJ�:FCC<:K@M<CP�BEFNE�8J�K?<�08E�;<I�188CJ�=FI:<��1?<E� >I8G?@K<� @J� IL99<;� 8>8@EJK� JFD<K?@E>� K?<J<�N<8BCP� @EK<I8:K@E>�J?<<KJ�JC@;<�F==�<8:?�FK?<I�8E;�JK@:B�KF�K?<�JLI=8:<�FEKF�N?@:?�K?<P�8I<�9<@E>�IL99<;���� $E� JG�9FE;<;� :8I9FEJ� K?<� :<EKI8C� :8I9FE� @J� EFN� 9FE;<;� KF�=FLI� J<G8I8K<�8KFDJ�FI�DFC<:LC<J� 8CJF�BEFNE�8J�8�[K<KI8?<;I8C\�:FE!_>LI8K@FE��*E:<� 8>8@E� K?<� :FEJK@KL<EKJ� 9FE;<;� KF� :8I9FE�N8EK� KF� 9<�8J� =8I� 8G8IK� =IFD� <8:?� FK?<I� 8J� GFJJ@9C<� 9LK�N@K?� =FLI�D<D9<IJ� K?@J�:8EEFK�9<�8::FDGC@J?<;�@E�8�J@E>C<�GC8E<�LEC@B<�@E�K?<�KI@>FE8C�GC8E8I�8II8E><D<EK��.F�JFCM<�K?@J�K?<�9FE;@E>�G8IKE<IJ�LK@C@Q<����JG8:<�=FID!@E>�8�K?I<<J@;<;�GPI8D@;�8IFLE;�K?<�:<EKI8C�:8I9FE��.?@J�I<JLCKJ�@E�9FE;

A Brief Explanation of Bonding Patterns in Carbon

Page 60: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

52

8E>C<J�F=�8GGIFO@D8K<CP�� ���T����>I<8K�<O8DGC<�F=�:8I9FE�9FE;@E>�@E�K?@J�D8EE<I�@J�K?<�:FDDFE�;@8DFE;����GLI<�;@8DFE;�@J�8:KL8CCP�:FD!GI@J<;�F=�FECP�:8I9FE�8KFDJ�8CC�9FE;<;�KF><K?<I�@E�K?<�K<KI8?<;I8C�:FE!_>LI8K@FE��.?@J�G8KK<IE�C<E;J�K?<�JKI<E>K?�F=�8�J@E>C<�J?<<K�F=�>I8G?<E<�KF����JG8:<�N?@:?�@J� K?<�JFLI:<�F=� K?<�[?8I;E<JJ\�F=�;@8DFE;J�FK?!<IN@J<�BEFNE�8J�@K^J�I<J@JK8E:<�KF�J:I8K:?@E>��$K� @J�8�:FDDFE�D@J:FE!:<GK@FE�K?8K�;@8DFE;�@J�K?<�[JKIFE><JK\�E8KLI8C�D8K<I@8C�BEFNE�KF�D8E���<:8LJ<�F=�K?<�K<KI8?<;I8C�JKIL:KLI<�;@8DFE;�?8J�:C<8M8><�GC8E<J�N?<I<�@K�@J�I<C8K@M<CP�<8JP�KF�JGC@K�:FDG8I<;�KF�@IFE�FI�JK<<C�� ,<:<EKCP�:8I9FE�JKIL:KLI<J�?8M<�9<:FD<�K?<�=F:LJ�F=�DL:?�I<!J<8I:?�;L<�KF�K?<�;<M<CFGD<EK�F=�:8I9FE�E8EFKL9<J���.)J����K�@KJ�DFJK�98J@:�C<M<C�8�:8I9FE�E8EFKL9<�@J�8�J?<<K�F=�>I8G?<E<�[IFCC<;\�KF><K?<I�JF�K?<�<;><J�D<<K�8E;�9FE;�=FID@E>�8�KL9<��,<J<8I:?<IJ�8I<�@EK<I<JK<;�@E�E8EFKL9<J�;L<�KF�K?<�I<D8IB89C<�M8I@<KP�F=�GIFG<IK@<J�K?<P�;@JGC8P���.)J�8I<�K?<�JKIFE><JK�8E;�JK@==<JK�D8K<I@8CJ�@E�K<IDJ�F=�K<EJ@C<�JKI<E>K?�8E;�<C8JK@:@KP�I<JG<:K@M<CP���.)J�8CJF�?8M<�GIFD@J@E>�<C<:KI@:8C�GIFG!<IK@<J�8J�K?<P�:8E�8:K�8J�<@K?<I�D<K8CJ�FI�J<D@:FE;L:KFIJ�8E;�:FE;L:K�?<8K� M<IP�N<CC�� $E� =8:K� @K� @J� 8� :FD9@E8K@FE� F=� K?<J<� C8JK� KNF� GIFG<I!K@<J�K?8K�@J�9<@E>�8GGC@<;�KF�GIF;L:<�=89I@:J�K?8K�:8E�><E<I8K<�<C<:KI@:@KP�=IFD�?<8K�@E:CL;@E>�K?8K�N?@:?�@J�><E<I8K<;�9P�PFLI�FNE�9F;P��=IFD�@KJ�GIF:<JJ@E>�F=�:8I9FE98J<;�JL>8IJ���$K�N8J�I<:<EKCP�;<DFEJKI8K<;�K?8K�8�DLCK@C8P<;�K?<IDF<C<:KI@:�=89I@:�:FEK8@E@E>��.)�C8P<IJ�N@K?�8E�8I<8�F=�8GGIFO@D8K<CP�� �:D��:FLC;�GIF;L:<�<EFL>?�<E<I>P�KF�GFN<I�8�NI@JK!N8K:?��#<N@KK�<K�8C����1?<E�K?<�=89I@:�@J�JL9A<:K�KF�8�C8I><�K<DG<I8KLI<�;@==<I<E:<�:?8I><�:8II@<IJ�N@K?@E�K?<��.)J��LJL8CCP�<C<:KIFEJ��;@==LJ<�KFN8I;J�K?<�:FC;�<E;�N?<I<�K?<P�8I<�C<JJ�;<EJ<��.?@J�GIFG<IKP�:8CC<;�K?<�-<<9<:B�<==<:K�:I<8K<J�8�DFM<D<EK�F=�:?8I><�I<JLCK@E>�@E�8�:LII<EK�8E;�I<8;89C<�MFCK8><��!LIK?<I�8GGC@:8K@FEJ�F=� K?@J�B@E;�F=�D8K<I@8C� @E:CL;<�8GGCP@E>� @K� KF� K?<� C@E@E>� F=�N@EK<IA8:B<KJ� KF� GFN<I� ?8E;?<C;� ;<M@:<J�I<:8GKLI@E>�JFD<�F=�8�M<?@:C<^J�N8JK<;�?<8K�<E<I>P�FI�LJ@E>�@K�@E�IFF_E>�D8K<I@8CJ�@E�FI;<I�KF�D@K@>8K<�8�9L@C;@E>^J�<E<I>P�:FJKJ�� .?<�JKIL:KLI8C�GFK<EK@8C�F=�:8I9FE�?8J�P<K� KF�9<� =LCCP� I<8C@Q<;�;L<�KF�K?<�M8JK�GFJJ@9@C@KP�F=�9FE;@E>�G8KK<IEJ�ALJK�8J�K?<�GFK<EK@8C�@E�K?<�@E:I<;@9C<�:FDGC<O@KP�F=�C@=<�D8P�E<M<I�9<�=LCCP�I<8C@Q<;��.?<�9<8LKP�F=�:8I9FE�C@<J�@E�@KJ�89@C@KP�KF�:FEJKIL:K�JF�D8EP�;@==<I<EK�KFFCJ�FLK�F=�JF�=<N�9L@C;@E>�9CF:BJ��.NF�DFC<:LC<J�D8P�9<�@;<EK@:8C�@E�K<IDJ�F=�K?<@I�8KFD@:�:FEJK@KL<EKJ�9LK�D8P�9<�:FDGC<K<CP�LE@HL<�FE�8�G?PJ@:8C�C<M<C��

Page 61: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

53

.?@J�J8D<�@EKI@:8K<�9<8LKP�8I@J@E>�=IFD�:FDDFE�IFFKJ�@J�=FLE;�@E�<M!<IP;8P�C@=<�Z�=IFD�?LD8E@K@<J �N@C;�M8I@<KP�F=�:LCKLI<J�9<C@<=�JPJK<DJ�8E;�G<IJFE8C@K@<J�KF�JFD<K?@E>�8J�J@DGC<�8J�FE<^J�;<J@I<�KF�9<�DFI<�:FE!E<:K<;�KF�8EFK?<I��$K�@J�K?@J�<C<>8E:<�K?8K�DFK@M8K<J��FEE8�(:�<IDFKK^J�G@<:<�[�8I9FE��?8@EJ�\���

RICE / VERY

Page 62: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

54

Page 63: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

55

� � � � � � � ����������������@ J �8 �JFG?F !DFI<� +@ K K � J KL;<EK � J KL;P@E>� :FCF>P� 8E;�1FD !<E^J � -KL;@<J � � -?<� :LII<EK CP �NFIBJ� @E � K?<� +IL@ K K�'89 �J KL;P@E>�K?<�JF:@8C �9<?8M@FI �F= �:F:BIF8:? !<J � 8E;� JG@;<IJ � � *E<� ;8P � J?<� GLK � :F:BIF8:?<J�@E � 8 � :?8D9<I � 8E;� N8K:?<;� K?<D� = @>?K � � �FEE8�@J � @EMFCM<;� N@K?�Three$ Rivers $ Review$ Li terary$Magazine �The$Original �D8>8Q@E< �8E;�*::LGP�+@ K K � �-?<� @J � I<8C CP � =FE;�F= �9FFBJ�8E;�=FF;�

Donna McDermott

Page 64: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

56

.?@J�@J�FLI�>I8G?@K<�8EE@M<IJ8IP�<:8LJ<�N<^CC�E<M<I�I<8CCP�D<<K�1<�8I<�KNF�J?<<KJ�F=�K?<�J8D<�JL9JK8E:<,L99@E>�G8JK�<8:?�FK?<I�:C@E>@E>�.F><K?<I�N@K?�K?<�=8B<JK�F=�<==FIKJ�-D8CC�K8CB�:8JL8C�AFB<J�DLKL8C�=I@<E;J�1<^I<�JF�:CFJ<�9LK�E<@K?<I*=�LJ�:FLC;�9<E;�FE<�@E:?�KF�KLIE�8IFLE;�:FEE<:K�FLI�?8E;J�E;�=<<K�8E;�9<�;@8DFE;��$�N8EK�PFL�KF�J<<�K?8K�@=�PFL�IFCC<;�LJ�LG��E;�J:I8K:?<;�LJ�8>8@EJK�G8G<I3FL^;�?8M<�8�G<E:@C�PFL^;�?8M<�-FD<K?@E>�$�:FLC;�NI@K<�N@K?��F�PFL�BEFN�?FN�:FM<I<;�@E�>I8P�$�8D�.?<I<�8I<�JDL;><J�8CC�FM<I�DP�?8E;J�!IFD�K?@J�>I8G?@K<�N?@:?�D<8EJ�K?8K$^M<�NFIB<;�JF�?8I;�8E;$^D�JK@CC�ALJK�8�D<JJ�

.?@J�@JE^K�FE<�P<8I�=IFD�8EPK?@E>�8K�8CC�$=�8�;@8DFE;�D8IBJ�CFE><M@KP�1<CC�>I8G?@K<�@J�K?<�FGGFJ@K<�(8P9<�$�:FLC;�KIP�KF�KFL:?�PFL�9LK(P�?8E;�NFLC;�JC@;<�I@>?K�9P�-F�K@D<�:8E^K�:FLEK�LJ�1<�8I<�>I8P�JK8@EJ�`8NJ�K?8K+LK�@E�K?<�I@>?K�FI;<I.<CC�D<�N?F�$^D�EFK�

Carbon Chains

Page 65: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

57

Skin

$�9LIEK�DP�=FI<8ID�FE�8�C@>?K�9LC9�$K�N8J�FE<�F=�K?FJ<�9C8:B�C@>?K�9LC9J.?8K�D8B<�PFLI�K<<K?�N?@K<�$�I<8:?<;�LG�KF�8;ALJK�.?<�C@E<�@K�?LE>�FE�E;�8CC�F=�8�JL;;<E�$�N8J�9LIEK�

.?<�9LIE�N8J�9@>�8E;�N@;<���G<I=<:K�IFLE;�I<;�;@D<�$K�CFFB<;�C@B<�K?<�KPG<�F=�9LIE�FPJ�><K�N?<E�K?<P�?FC;�:@>8IJ.F�K?<@I�JB@E�8E;�>I@K�K?<@I�K<<K?��LK�@K�N8JE^K�C@B<�K?8K�$K�N8J�8E�8::@;<EK�

18K:?�PFLIJ<C=�?<8C�JFD<�K@D<�.?<�9LIE�N@CC�JK8IK�FLK�N?@K<1@K?�C@KKC<�I<;�;FKJ��LK�K?<�;@D<�:I8K<I�>IFNJ�JB@E'8P<I�9P�C8P<I���E;�K?<�C8P<IJ�CFFB<;�;@==<I<EK�-?@EP�D8KK<�9I@KKC<�/EK@C�_E8CCP�PFL�>IFN�K?@J�C@KKC<+8K:?�F=�9CLJ?�K?8K�E<M<I�=8;<J�

18K:?�PFLIJ<C=�?<8C�3FL�NFE^K�9<C@<M<�@K�LEK@C�PFL�KIP�@K�18K:?�PFLI�;@8DFE;�9FE<J�8JJ<D9C<3FLI�JK<<C�JB@E�JKI<K:?�8:IFJJ�JKFE<�DLJ:C<J�$�N8EK�KF�FG<E�LG�C@B<�8�K<OK9FFB�;@8>I8D�$�N8EK�KF�J<<�8CC�K?<�G8IKJ�F=�D<.?8K�$^D�KFC;�8I<�K?<I<�9LK�?8M<�E<M<I�=FLE;�

��9LIE�C@B<�K?8K�FE<�FE�DP�8ID$K�?LIKJ�=FI�8�N?@C<�3FL^I<�:FE:<IE<;�89FLK�@E=<:K@FEJ�E;�FK?<I�G8@E�K?8K�C8JKJ��LK�$^M<�J<<E�K?@J�JB@E�K@<�BEFKJ-F�$^D�GI<KKP�JLI<�@K�:8E�K8B<�8�9<8K@E>�$^M<�?<8I;�DP�CLE>J�:8K:?�LG�8E;�DP�?<8IK�8CD�;FNE��E;�K?<P�;@;�8CC�K?8K�N@K?FLK�D<�<M<E�8JB@E>�$K�J<<DJ�C@B<�$�:8E�?8E;C<�@K�-F�;FE^K�=<<C�98;�LIE�D<�

McDERMOTT

Page 66: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

58

Page 67: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

59

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � @ J � 8 � J<E@FI� E>C @J?� '@ K<I8KLI< � D8AFI � 8 K � K?<� /E@M<IJ@ KP � F=�+@ K KJ9LI>?� � -?<� N@C C � 8 CJF� I<:<@M<� 8 � �<IK @ = @:8K<�@E � ,LJJ@8E� 8E;� 8JK<IE� LIFG<8E� -KL;@<J � � #<I�@EK<I<JKJ �@E:CL;<�:FDG8I8K @M<�C @ K<I8KLI< �K?<�?@J !KFIP�F= �K?<�9FFB �><E;<I �J KL;@<J �;@>@ K8 C �?LD8E@ !K @<J � 8E;� D<;@8� J KL;@<J � � �LII<EK CP � J?<� @J � 8 � .��=FI � K?<� E>C @J?� '@ K<I8KLI< � : C8JJ � [�FDGLK8K @FE !8C � (<K?F;J� @E � K?<� #LD8E@K @<J\ � 8E;� @J � GLIJL@E>�J<M<I8C � ;@>@ K8 C CP � FI @<EK<;� ?LD8E@K @<J � I<J<8I:?�GIFA<:KJ � � -?<� ?FG<J� KF � GLIJL<� 8 � +?�� @E� E>C @J?�'@ K<I8KLI< � 8E;� <M<EKL8C CP � K<8:?� 8K � 8 � LE@M<IJ @ KP��$E=FID8K@FE� 89FLK � ?<I � I<J<8I:?� :8E� 9<� =FLE;�K?IFL>?�?<I �?FD<G8><� �?K KG� � �>B�F9;LIF;FE�FI>�

Gabriel le Kir i l loff

Page 68: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

60

FFFORBES & FIFTH

O

FFIC

E OF UNDERGRADUATE RESEARCH - O.U.R.

Page 69: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

61

<Traversing_the_Tree/> OGCFI@E>�*EKFCF>@:8C�8E;�+I8>D8K@:��GGIF8:?<J�KF�(8IBLG�.?<FIP�@E��@>@K8C�#LD8E@K@<J

Introduction

�@>@K8C�?LD8E@K@<J� K?<�8I<8�F=� JKL;P� K?8K� <OGCFI<J� K?<� @EK<IJ<:K@FE�F=�:FDGLK@E>�8E;�K?<�?LD8E@K@<J�EFK�FECP�8==<:KJ�K?<�GI<J<EK8K@FE�8E;�8:!:<JJ@9@C@KP�F=�C@K<I8IP�I<JFLI:<J�9LK�8CJF�:I<8K<J�FGGFIKLE@K@<J�=FI�J:?FC8IJ�KF�8JB�E<N�HL<JK@FEJ���J�:FDGLK8K@FE8C�KFFCJ�Z�G8IK@:LC8ICP�K?FJ<�LJ<;�=FI�;@>@K8C�KI8EJ:I@GK@FE�Z�9<:FD<�DFI<�GI<M8C<EK�@E�K?<�?LD8E@K@<J�@K�@J� @DG<I8K@M<� K?8K� J:?FC8IJ� 8JJ<JJ� K?<� @;<FCF>@<J�9<?@E;� K?<� K<:?EFCF!>@<J�K?8K�?8M<�9<<E�8GGIFGI@8K<;�=FI�8:8;<D@:�LJ<��(8EP�:FDGLK8K@FE8C�KFFCJ�LJ<;�=FI�C@K<I8IP�I<J<8I:?�KI<8K�K<OKJ�8J�8E�8>>I<>8K@FE�F=�JG<:@_:�=FID8C�=<8KLI<J��.?<I<�@J�8E�@DGFIK8EK�;@JK@E:K@FE�K?8K�E<<;J�KF�9<�D8;<�I<>8I;@E>�N?<K?<I� K?<J<� =<8KLI<J� I<`<:K� K?<� KIL<�D<8E@E>�F=�8� K<OK�FI�N?<K?<I�K?<P�J@DGCP�8CCFN�=FI�FE<�GI8:K@:8C�8GGIF8:?�KF�K<OK�<E:F;@E>��.?<�I<8JFE�K?8K�8E�<OGCFI8K@FE�F=�K?<J<�8GGIF8:?<J�@J�E<:<JJ8IP�@J�K?8K�K?<�D<K?F;FCF>@<J�LJ<;�@E�;@>@K8C�?LD8E@K@<J�?8M<�K?<�GFN<I�KF�C@D@K�FI�<OG8E;�K?<�GFK<EK@8C�F=�<D<I>@E>�?LD8E@K@<J�J:?FC8IJ?@G��� .?<�@EK<>I8K@FE�F=�:FDGLK@E>�KFFCJ�@EKF�C@K<I8IP�I<J<8I:?�@J�J?8G!@E>�K?<�N8P�J:?FC8IJ�:8E�@EK<IIF>8K<�K?<@I�K<OKJ��.?@J�@J�EFK�KF�J8P�K?8K�K?<�JKL;P�F=�;@>@K8C�?LD8E@K@<J�@J�D8B@E>�C@K<I8IP�I<J<8I:?�DFI<�F9A<:!K@M<��.?<�8EO@<KP�K?8K�:FDGLK@E>�KFFCJ�8I<�K8B@E>�K?<�[?LD8E\�FLK�F=�K?<�?LD8E@K@<J�FM<ICFFBJ�K?<�=8:K�K?8K�:FDGLK<IJ�;F�EFK�?8M<�K?<�GFN<I�KF�8E8CPQ<�FI�@EK<IGI<K�;8K8��.?FD8J�,FDD<C�8�C@K<I8IP�J:?FC8I�8E;�;@>@K8C�?LD8E@JK�8JKLK<CP�GF@EKJ�FLK�@E�[���FDG8E@FE�KF��@>@K8C�#LD8E@K@<J\�K?8K�K?<�JKI<E>K?�F=�LJ@E>�:FDGLK@E>�KFFCJ�@E�C@K<I8IP�J:?FC8IJ?@G�@J�K?8K�K?<P�GIFM@;<�JG<<;�8::LI8:P�LEC@D@K<;�D<DFIP�8E;�@EJK8EK8E<FLJ�8:!:<JJ�KF�M@IKL8CCP�8CC�K<OKL8C�=<8KLI<J�9LK�8I<�JK@CC�:FDGC<K<CP�I<C@8EK�FE�K?<�J:?FC8I�1�.?<�JPJK<D8K@:�8E8CPJ@J�F=�C@K<I8KLI<�98J<;�FE�HL8EK@K8K@M<�K<OKL8C�=<8KLI<J�?8J�8CN8PJ�9<<E�8�G8IK�F=�C@K<I8IP�JKL;P��!FI�<O8DGC<�J:?FC8IJ� ?8M<� LJ<;� :FE:FI;8E:<J� =FI� :<EKLI@<J� KF� JKL;P� G8KK<IEJ� 8E;�;8K8�J<KJ�GI<J<EK�@E�8�K<OK���@>@K8C�KFFCJ�8CCFN�J:?FC8IJ�KF�J8DGC<�C8I><I�8DFLEKJ�F=�K<OKJ�8E;�G<I=FID�8�DFI<�:FDGC<K<�:FDG8I@JFE�F=�K?<�;@==<I!<E:<J�8DFE>�J<KJ�F=�K<OKJ��$=�8EPK?@E>�N@K?�DFI<�;8K8�I<8;@CP�8M8@C89C<�

Page 70: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

62

8K�K?<@I�_E><IK@GJ�J:?FC8IJ�?8M<�KF�NFIB�?8I;<I�KF�_>LI<�FLK�N?@:?�C@E<J�F=�@EHL@IP�N@CC�P@<C;�GIF;L:K@M<�I<JLCKJ��� /E;<IJK8E;@E>� K?<J<� <D<I>@E>� I<C8K@FEJ?@GJ� @EMFCM<J� @EM<JK@!>8K@E>�?FN�;@>@K8C�K<OKJ�K?<DJ<CM<J�8I<�:I<8K<;�8�GIF:<JJ�8K�K?<�?<8IK�F=�8CC�;@>@K8C�?LD8E@K@<J�J:?FC8IJ?@G��.?<�@;<8�K?8K�J:?FC8IJ�J?FLC;�@EK<I!IF>8K<�K?<�GIF:<;LI<J�9<?@E;�K?<�:I<8K@FE�F=�8�K<OK�@J�EFK�E<N��K?<�JKL;P�F=�?FN�KI8EJ:I@GK@FE�D<K?F;J�8E;�<;@K@E>�GI8:K@:<J�8==<:K�GI@EK�K<OKJ�@J�N<CC�<JK89C@J?<;��.?<�<E:F;@E>�GIF:<JJ�;<D8E;J�K?8K�K?<�J:?FC8I�D8B<J�8�;<:@J@FE�@E�K<IDJ�F=�:C8JJ@=P@E>�<C<D<EKJ�F=�K?<�K<OK��-@D@C8ICP�N?<E�E<N�M<IJ@FEJ� F=� 8� GI@EK� K<OK� 8I<� :I<8K<;� <;@KFI@8C� ;<:@J@FEJ� 8I<� F=K<E�D8;<�89FLK�8D9@>LFLJ�<C<D<EKJ�F=�K?<�K<OK��!FI�<O8DGC<�K?<�GLE:KL8!K@FE�LJ<;�@E�;@==<I<EK�GI@EK�M<IJ@FEJ�F=�1@CC@8D��C8B<^J�Songs$of$InnoBcence$and$Experience�M8I@<J�9<:8LJ<�@K�@J�@DGFJJ@9C<�KF�<JK89C@J?�8CC�F=�K?<�GLE:KL8K@FE�@E�K?<�@CCLD@E8K<;�M<IJ@FEJ��.?@J�@J�9FK?�9<:8LJ<�JFD<�F=�K?<�FI@>@E8C�GLE:KL8K@FE�@J�LE:C<8I�8E;�8CJF�9<:8LJ<�JFD<�F=�@K�M8I@<J�8:IFJJ�K?<�;@==<I<EK�@CCLD@E8K<;�D8ELJ:I@GKJ�2��� .?<I<� 8I<� 8CJF� ;@==<I<E:<J� 9<KN<<E� GI@EK� 8E;� ;@>@K8C� K<OK� :I<!8K@FE��+<I?8GJ�K?<�DFJK�J@>E@_:8EK�@J�K?8K�<M<E�@=�8�KI8EJ:I@9<;�;@>@K8C�:FGP�F=�8�K<OK�@J�=FID8KK<;�@E�K?<�J8D<�N8P�8J�K?<�GI@EK�M<IJ@FE�8:KJ�F=�@EK<IGI<K8K@FE�8E;�:C8JJ@_:8K@FE�F::LI�;LI@E>�K?<�<E:F;@E>�GIF:<JJ�8E;�<O@JK�@E�K?<�D8IB<;�LG�M<IJ@FE��.?@J�@J�9<:8LJ<�K?<�GIF:<JJ�F=�D8IBLG�LJ<;�@E�;@>@K8C�?LD8E@K@<J�@J�@EK<E;<;�KF�9<�;<J:I@GK@M<�3��� �<J:I@GK@M<�D8IBLG�J<<BJ�KF�8J:I@9<�D<8E@E>�KF�8�K<OK�K?IFL>?�K?<�:8K<>FI@Q8K@FE�F=�K<OKL8C�=<8KLI<J�� M<E�K?FL>?�D8IBLG�@J�EFK�M@J!@9C<�@E�K?<�I<8;89C<�M<IJ@FE�F=�K?<�K<OK�@K�@J�JK@CC�8�E<:<JJ8IP�G8IK�F=�K?<�:I<8K@FE�F=�K?<�K<OK��.?@J�@J�EFK�K?<�:8J<�@E�K?<�:I<8K@FE�F=�8�GI@EK<;�K<OK��$=�K?<�>F8C�F=�:I<8K@E>�8�GI@EK�KI8EJ:I@GK@FE�@J�KF�M@JL8CCP�I<GIF;L:<�K?<�K<OK�:C8JJ@_:8K@FEJ�F=�D<8E@E>�;F�EFK�?8M<�KF�9<�D8;<��$E�JL:?�8�:8J<�N?<K?<I�FI�EFK�K?<�D8IB�8K�K?<�<E;�F=�8�GF<D�N8J�@EK<E;<;�8J�8�G<I@F;�FI�8�:FDD8�@J�@II<C<M8EK�9LK�@KJ�J?8G<�:FCFI�8E;�J@Q<�8I<�@DGFIK8EK����� $E�K?<�:I<8K@FE�F=�8�;@>@K8C�M<IJ@FE�F=�8�K<OK�?FN<M<I�;<:@J@FEJ�89FLK�:C8JJ@_:8K@FE�8I<�D8;<�<M<E�@=�K?<�=F:LJ�@J�FE�I<E;<I@E>�8�;@>@K8C�M<IJ@FE�K?8K�@J�M@JL8CCP�J@D@C8I�KF�K?<�FI@>@E8C��$E�8;;@K@FE�K?<�D8IB<;�LG�M<IJ@FE�F=�8�K<OK�<O@JKJ�=FI�8J�CFE>�8J�K?<�[I<8;89C<\�M<IJ@FE�<O@JKJ���J�8�I<C8K<;�GF@EK�;@==<I<EK�DF;<J�F=�:C8JJ@_:8K@FE�8E;�K<OKL8C�@EK<IGI<K8K@FE�@E�K?<�:I<8K@FE�F=�8�;@>@K8C�K<OK�:8E�9<�D8;<�KF�8:?@<M<�K?<�J8D<�M@JL8C�I<JLCK��!FI�<O8DGC<� @=� KNF�J:?FC8IJ�N<I<� KF�:C8JJ@=P�8E;�;<J:I@9<� K?<�

Page 71: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

63

J8D<�9CF:B�F=� K<OK�;@==<I<EKCP�8J�8�G8I8>I8G?�8E;�8J�8E�<G@>I8G?� K?<�K<OK�:FLC;�C8K<I�9<�I<E;<I<;�KF�CFFB�K?<�J8D<�N8P�M@JL8CCP�I<>8I;C<JJ�F=�K?<�:C8JJ@_:8K@FE�

The Implications of Encoding

$=�@K�@J�KIL<�K?8K�K?<�@EK<IGI<K@M<�;<:@J@FEJ�D8;<�[9<?@E;�K?<�J:<E<J\�;F�EFK�E<:<JJ8I@CP�8==<:K�K?<�GI<J<EK8K@FE�F=�K?<�K<OK�N?P�;F�K?<�D<K?F;!FCF>@<J�LJ<;�=FI�<E:F;@E>�D8KK<I��.?<�8EJN<I�KF�K?@J�HL<JK@FE�?8J�K?I<<�:FDGFE<EKJ��.?<�_IJK�@J�K?8K�N?@C<�;<J:I@GK@M<�D8IBLG�D8P�EFK�8==<:K�K?<�GFK<EK@8C�M@JL8C�GI<J<EK8K@FE�F=�K?<�K<OK�@K�;F<J�J@>E@_:8EKCP�8==<:K�8EP�HL<I@<J�ILE�FE�K?<�K<OK��!FI�<O8DGC<�JLGGFJ<�J:?FC8IJ�<E:FLEK<I�8�K<OK�@E�N?@:?�K?<�:FEK<EK�9<KN<<E�HLFK8K@FE�D8IBJ�@E:CL;<J�NFI;J�K?8K�8I<�EFK�G8IK�F=�8�JGFB<E�HLFK8K@FE��[#<CCF�J8@;�K?<�>@IC�?FN�8I<�PFL�\��� �JJLD@E>�K?8K�K?<�J:?FC8IJ�;F�EFK�N8EK�KF�:FDGIFD@J<�K?<�@E!K<>I@KP�F=�K?<�K<OK�9P�I<CF:8K@E>�K?<�HL<JK@FE�D8IBJ�K?<P�8I<�=8:<;�N@K?�8�ELD9<I�F=�N8PJ�KF�:C8JJ@=P�8E;�@EK<IGI<K�K?@J�K<OK��K?<P�:FLC;�C89<C�K?<�<O8DGC<�8J�<@K?<I�FE<�FI� KNF�J<G8I8K<�HLFK8K@FEJ��1?<K?<I�FI�EFK� K?<�J:?FC8IJ�;<:@;<�KF�C89<C�K?@J�@EJK8E:<�8J�FE<�HLFK8K@FE�FI�KNF�HLFK8K@FEJ�J<G8I8K<;�9P�K?<�G?I8J<�[J8@;�K?<�>@IC\�;F<J�EFK�@DG8:K�K?<�N8P�K?8K�K?<�K<OK�:8E�9<�I<E;<I<;�8=K<I�K?<�D8IBLG�GIF:<JJ��#FN<M<I�K?<�D<K?F;FCF!>P�NFLC;�8==<:K�8�:FLEK�F=�HLFK8K@FEJ�N@K?@E�K?<�K<OK�8E;�NFLC;�8CJF�@D!G8:K�K?<�ELD9<I�F=�C<KK<IJ�:FEK8@E<;�N@K?@E�K?<�HLFK8K@FE��!FI�<O8DGC<�@E�G8IK�F=�8�JKL;P�K?8K�LJ<;�:FDGLK8K@FE8C�KFFCJ�KF�D<8JLI<�K?<�=I<HL<E:P�

F=�D8C<�8E;�=<D8C<�JG<<:?�@E�=FCB�K8C<J� K?<J<� KPG<J� F=� HLFK8K@FEJ�N<I<� KI<8K<;� 8J� FE<� JG<<:?� 8:K��-@E:<� JG<<:?�N8J�D<8JLI<;� 8J� 8�KPG<�F=�8><E:P�K?<�J:?FC8I^J�;<:@!J@FE�;@I<:KCP�@DG8:K<;�K?<�I<JLCKJ�F=�K?<�I<J<8I:?�4�� � .?<� J<:FE;� I<8JFE�K?8K�K?<�<E:F;<;�K<OK�@J�@DGFIK8EK�@J�K?8K�K?<�:I<8K@FE�F=�8�;@>@K8C�K<OK�

@J�8E�8:K@M<� @EK<IGI<K@M<�GIF:<JJ��.?@J�GIF:<JJ� @J�:P:C@:8C��FE� K?<�FE<�?8E;� K?<�N8P� K?8K� J:?FC8IJ� G<I:<@M<� 8� K<OK� J?8G<J� K?<�N8P� @E�N?@:?�K?<P�:?FFJ<�KF�<E:F;<�K?<�K<OK��*E�K?<�FK?<I�?8E;�K?<�:FEJKI8@EKJ�F=�K?<�

KIRILLOFF

“The$creation$of$a$digital$text$is$an$active,$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$interprative$process.”

Page 72: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

64

D8IBLG�GIF:<JJ�8E;�K?<�@;<FCF>P�9<?@E;�@K�8==<:K�K?<�N8P�K?8K�J:?FC8IJ�G<I:<@M<�8�K<OK���.?@J�C8JK�GF@EK�@J�G8IK@:LC8ICP�I<C<M8EK�N?<E�;@J:LJJ@E>�K?<�@DGFIK8E:<�F=�D8IBLG�G?@CFJFG?P�J@E:<�@K�8:BEFNC<;><J�K?<�GFK<E!K@8C�=FI�K?<�JPJK<D�F=�=FID8C@Q@E>�8�K<OK�KF�C@D@K�K?<�C@K<I8IP�J:?FC8I��$K�8CJF�JL>><JKJ�K?8K�K?<�JKL;P�F=�D8IBLG�J?FLC;�9<�=F:LJ<;�FE�K?<�8:K@M@KP�F=�<E:F;@E>�8E;�?FN�J:?FC8IJ�@EK<I8:K�N@K?�K?@J�GIF:<JJ��� �L@C;@E>�F==�F=� K?<� I<C8K@FEJ?@G�9<KN<<E�D8IBLG�8E;� J:?FC8I�@K� 9<:FD<J� :C<8I� K?8K� K?<� ILC<J� 8E;� :FEJKI8@EKJ� F=� K?<�D8IBLG� JPJK<D�LJ<;�:8E�@DG8:K�K?<�I<8;<I�8J�N<CC��.?<�J:?FC8I^J�:?F@:<J�F=�:8K<>FI@Q8!K@FE�8E;�=FID8C@Q8K@FE�D8P�@DG8:K�8�I<8;<I^J�@EK<IGI<K8K@FE�F=�K?<�K<OK��!FI�@EJK8E:<�@=�8�I<8;<I�N<I<�KF�F9J<IM<�K?8K�8�C@E<�F=�8�GF<D�9P�%F?E��FEE<�?8;�9<<E�<E:F;<;�8J�8E�<O8DGC<�F=�[D<K8G?PJ@:8C�<:<@K\��K?<@I�@EK<IGI<K8K@FE�F=�K?<�C@E<�D@>?K�:?8E><�@E�K?<�J8D<�N8P�@K�NFLC;�=IFD�I<8;@E>�8�G@<:<�F=�:I@K@:@JD���.?@J�D8B<J� J<EJ<� J@E:<�9FK?� K?<�D8IB!LG�GIF:<JJ�8E;�C@K<I8IP�:I@K@:@JD�8I<�98J<;�FE�@EK<IGI<K8K@FE��#FN<M<I�J@E:<�K?<�J:?FC8I^J�8:K�F=�@EK<IGI<K8K@FE�@J�@E�G8IK�98J<;�FE�K?<�:FEJKI8@EKJ�F=� K?<�D8IBLG�JPJK<D�K?<�I<8;<I^J�G<I:<GK@FE�F=� K?<�K<OK� @J� @E;@I<:KCP�@E`L<E:<;�9P�K?<�D8IBLG�JPJK<D��� .?@J� 8I>LD<EK� @J� ;<G<E;<EK� FE� K?<� I<8;<I� J<<@E>� 8E;� LE;<I!JK8E;@E>�K?<�<E:F;<;�K<OK���<:8LJ<�DFJK�G<FGC<�N?F�I<8;�;@>@K8C�K<OKJ�;F�EFK�F9J<IM<� K?<D� @E� K?<@I� <E:F;<;� =FID� K?@J� @J� 8�N<8B�8I>LD<EK��#FN<M<I�@K�@J�C@B<CP�K?8K�:F;@E>�C@K<I8:P�N@CC�@E:I<8J<�FM<I�K?<�E<OK�J<M!<I8C�P<8IJ�D8B@E>� @K�DFI<�GIF989C<� K?8K� I<8;<IJ�N@CC�M@<N� K?<�JFLI:<�_C<J�F=�;F:LD<EKJ��.?<�DFK@M8K@FE�9<?@E;�K?@J�D@>?K�:FD<�=IFD�8�;<!J@I<� KF�[;<:F;<\� K?<�:F;<�FI�LE;<IJK8E;� K?<�D<K?F;J�F=� @EK<IGI<K8K@FE�8E;�@EJ:I@GK@FE�9<?@E;�8EP�>@M<E�K<OK�JFD<K?@E>�K?8K�@J�GI<J<EK�@E�K?<�JKL;P� 8E;� :FEJLDGK@FE� F=� GI@EK�D<;@8� KF;8P����DFI<� @DD<;@8K<� 8E;�:FEM@E:@E>�8I>LD<EK�89FLK�K?<�I<C8K@FEJ?@G�9<KN<<E�I<8;<I�8E;�J:?FC8I�@J�K?8K�K?<�;@>@K8C�I<JFLI:<J�8E;�@E=FID8K@FE�8M8@C89C<�KF�K?<�><E<I8C�GL9!C@:�8I<�;<K<ID@E<;�9P�K?<�HL<JK@FEJ�J:?FC8IJ�8JB�F=�K?<@I�K<OKJ���P�N8P�F=�8� KI@:BC<;FNE�<==<:K� K?<E� K?<�JKIL:KLI<�F=� K?<�D8IBLG�JPJK<D�8CJF�@DG8:KJ�I<8;<IJ�<M<E�@=�K?<P�?8M<�EFK�M@<N<;�8�K<OK�@E�@KJ�<E:F;<;�=FID��� $E� C@>?K�F=� K?<�I<C8K@FEJ?@GJ�8DFE>� K<OK�D8IBLG�J:?FC8I�8E;�I<8;<I�K?<�E<OK�CF>@:8C�HL<JK@FE�@J��N?8K�8I<�K?<�:FEJKI8@EKJ�F=�:LII<EK�D8IBLG�GIF:<;LI<�8E;�?FN�8I<�K?<P�8==<:K@E>�I<J<8I:?��$E�FI;<I�KF�=LCCP�;@J:LJJ�K?@J�HL<JK@FE�@K�@J�E<:<JJ8IP�KF�>@M<�JFD<�98:B>IFLE;�@E=FID8!K@FE�89FLK�K?<�?@JKFIP�8E;�<MFCLK@FE�F=�K<OK�<E:F;@E>�

Page 73: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

65

Text Encoding

.?<�DFJK� :LII<EK� 8E;�N@;<CP� LJ<;�D<K?F;� F=� ;<J:I@9@E>� FI�D8IB@E>�LG�8� K<OK� JF� K?8K� @K� @J�D8:?@E<I<8;89C<� @J�2('�� OK<EJ@9C<�(8IBLG�'8E>L8><���2('� >I<N� FLK� F=� -"('� �-K8E;8I;�"<E<I8C@Q<;�(8IBLG�'8E>L8><�� 8� C8E>L8><� K?8K�N8J�;<M<CFG<;� =FI� ;8K8� <E:F;@E>� 8E;� K?<�J?8I@E>�F=�D8:?@E<I<8;89C<� K<OKJ� @E� K?<� C8K<���� J�� $K� @J� @DGFIK8EK� KF�EFK<� K?8K�8CK?FL>?�-"('�N8J�;<M<CFG<;�KF�<E:F;<�K<OKJ� @KJ�FI@>@E8C�>F8CJ�N<I<� M<IP� ;@==<I<EK� =IFD� K?<�N8P� ?LD8E@K@<J� J:?FC8IJ� EFN�LJ<�2('��-"('�N8J�@EK<E;<;�KF�=8:@C@K8K<�K?<�J?8I@E>�8E;�JKFI8><�F=�C8I><GIFA<:K�;F:LD<EKJ�@E�C8N�>FM<IED<EK�8E;�@E;LJKIP���1?<E�-"('�N8J�;<M<CFG<;�@K�N8J�8JJLD<;�K?8K�K?<�JPJK<D�F=�=FID8C�=<8KLI<J�;<J:I@9<;�NFLC;�9<�98J<;�<O:CLJ@M<CP�FE�8�K<OK^J�><EI<��-"('�N8J�EFK�;<M<CFG<;�=FI�8GGC@:8K@FE�@E�?LD8E@K@<J�J:?FC8IJ?@G�8E;�K?<�GI@D8IP�:FE:<IEJ�;I@M!@E>�@KJ�:I<8K@FE�N<I<�GI8:K@:8C��*E<�JL:?�GI8:K@:8C�:FE:<IE�=F:LJ<;�FE�:I<8K@E>�8�DF;<C�K?8K�NFLC;�9<�8::<JJ@9C<�8E;�<8JP�KF�LJ<�9�.?<�?@JKFIP�8E;�;<M<CFGD<EK�F=�K<OK�<E:F;@E>�JL>><JK�K?8K�@K�D@>?K�9<�E<:<JJ8IP�=FI�C@K<I8IP�J:?FC8IJ�KF�I<8JJ<JJ�8E;�I<:C8@D�K?<�KFFCJ�K?<P�8I<�:LII<EKCP�LJ!@E>��$K�J<<DJ�JKI8E><�K?8K�D<K?F;FCF>@<J�;<M<CFG<;�8IFLE;�GI@E:@GC<J�F=�GI8:K@:8C@KP�8I<�9<@E>�LJ<;�KF�;<K<ID@E<�K<OKL8C�@EK<IGI<K8K@FE�8E;�D<8E!@E>��.?@J�9<>J�K?<�HL<JK@FE��8I<�K?<�K<OK�<E:F;@E>�D<K?F;FCF>@<J�LJ<;�@E�C@K<I8IP�J:?FC8IJ?@G�IFFK<;�@E�GI@E:@GC<J�=FI<@>E�KF�K?<@I�:LII<EK�GLIGFJ<�8E;�LJ<���� -LIGI@J@E>CP� DFJK� F=� K?<� J:?FC8IJ?@G� FE� K?<� G?@CFJFG?P� F=�D8IBLG�@J�=IFD�K?<���� J�8E;�� J�8E;�@J�K?LJ�=F:LJ<;�FE�-"('�8J�FG!GFJ<;�KF�2('��.?<�;@J:FEK@EL8K@FE�F=�K?<�-"('�;<98K<�N8J�EFK�8�I<JLCK�F=�J@>E@_:8EK�@DGIFM<D<EKJ��,8K?<I�@K�J<<DJ�8J�@=�N@K?�K?<�:I<8K@FE�F=�2('�DFJK�J:?FC8IJ�8::<GK<;�K?<�J?FIK:FD@E>J�F=�-"('�8E;�2('�8J�LE8MF@;89C<���CK?FL>?�K?<I<�8I<�;@==<I<E:<J�9<KN<<E�-"('�8E;�2('�K?<P�9FK?� J?8I<� K?<� J8D<�;8K8�DF;8C�� E:F;@E>� 8� K<OK�N@K?�2('� @E!MFCM<J�NI8GG@E>�K?<�K<OK�@E�K8>J�D8IBLG�K?8K�;<J:I@9<J�:FDGFE<EKJ�F=�K?<�K<OK��.8>J�;@M@;<�K?<�K<OK�@EKF�<C<D<EKJ�N?@C<�<C<D<EKJ�@E:CL;<�K8>J�8E;�<M<IPK?@E>�@E�9<KN<<E�K?<D��!FI�<O8DGC<�@E�K?<�=FCCFN@E>�J8DGC<�K?<�K<OK�[.?@J�@J�8�J8DGC<\�@J�NI8GG<;�9<KN<<E�8�J<EK<E:<�JK8IK�K8>�8E;�8�J<EK<E:<�<E;�K8>�� E;�K8>J�8CN8PJ�:FEK8@E�8�JC8J?��.?<�<EK@I<�<O8DGC<�:FEJK@KLK<J�8�J<EK<E:<�<C<D<EK��� �J<EK<E:<�.?@J�@J�8�J8DGC<���J<EK<E:<�

KIRILLOFF

Page 74: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

66

� 2('�LEC@B<�DFJK�FK?<I� C8E>L8><J�;F<J�EFK�?8M<�GI<;<_E<;�K8>�J<KJ��.?@J�<JJ<EK@8CCP�D<8EJ�K?8K�K?<�J:?FC8I�;<K<ID@E<J�K?<�[E8D<\�F=�8�K8>��$E�K?<�89FM<�<O8DGC<�K?<�NFI;�[J<EK<E:<\�:FLC;�9<�I<GC8:<;�N@K?�8EP�FK?<I�NFI;�8E;�JK@CC�9<�GIF:<JJ<;�K?<�J8D<�N8P��.?@J�8JG<:K�F=�2('�D8B<J�@K�I<D8IB89CP�J@D@C8I�KF�8�?LD8E�C8E>L8><�8E;�@E�=8:K�K?<�<OG<I@<E:<�F=�NI@K@E>�2('�@J�@E�D8EP�N8PJ�J@D@C8I�KF�NI@K@E>�GIFJ<���$K�@J�@DGFIK8EK�?FN<M<I�KF�I<D<D9<I�K?8K�K?<�[E8D<J\�8I<�EFK�I<8;�FI�LE!;<IJKFF;�9P�K?<�:FDGLK<I����<:8LJ<�?LD8EJ�:8E�:FDGI<?<E;�K?<�NFI;J�NI@KK<E�@E�2('�@K�@J�<8JP�KF�K?@EB�K?8K�8�:FDGLK<I�@J�GIF:<JJ@E>�K?<�K<OK�@E�8�J@D@C8I�N8P���.?<�I<8C@KP�@J�K?8K�K?<�:FDGLK<I�@J�GIF:<JJ@E>�2('�8J�9@E8IP�D8:?@E<�:F;<�� 1I@K@E>� @E�8� C8E>L8><� K?8K�;F<J�EFK�?8M<�GI<;<_E<;� K8>� J<KJ�@E:I<8J<J�K?<�<==<:K�F=�K?<�D8IBLG�GIF:<JJ�FE�K?<�J:?FC8I��!FI�<O8DGC<�K8B<�K?<�=FCCFN@E>�J<:K@FE�F=�K<OK��[X89C<�N@E;���FEJ@;<I@E>�K?<�>I8E;�N8P� K?<J<�DFD<EKJ� 8I<�G?FKF>I8G?<;� @K� 8CDFJK� 8GG<8IJ� 8J� @=�)8M@;!JFE� @J� KIP@E>� K?IFL>?� <M<I� K?<� DFJK� HLFK@;@8E� F9A<:KJ� 8E;� <M<EKJ� KF�<MFB<�=FI�LJ�JFD<�J<EJ<J�F=�#FCCFN8P^J�<G@:�GIF>I<JJ��.?8K�FI�G8IK@:@!G8K<� @E� @K��+<I?8GJ�<M<E�:?8CC<E><� @K�\10� $E� @KJ�JFLI:<�;F:LD<EK�(8IB��8E@<C<NJB@^J�House$of$Leaves�K?<�89FM<�JE@GG<K�F=�K<OK�@J�;@JGC8P<;�N@K?� C@E<�9I<8BJ�9<KN<<E�8�GI<:<;@E>�8E;�=FCCFN@E>�G8I8>I8G?�� $=� K?<�J:?FC8I�N<I<�KF�<E:F;<�K?@J�JE@GG<K�F=�K<OK�N@K?�#.('�8�C8E>L8><�N@K?�GI<;<_E<;�K8>�J<KJ�8��G��K8>�FI�G8I8>I8G?�K8>�NFLC;�DFJK�C@B<CP�9<�LJ<;��.?<I<�8I<�EF�FK?<I�FGK@FEJ�@E�#.('�K?8K�:FD<�:CFJ<�KF�;<J:I@9!@E>�K?<�89FM<�J8DGC<�9LK�9<@E>�>@M<E�K?<�:FDGC<K<�=I<<;FD�KF�[E8D<\�K?<�J8DGC<�D8B<J�K?<�:C8JJ@_:8K@FE�DFI<�;@=_:LCK��$K�8CJF�D8B<J�@K�DFI<�K?FL>?K�GIFMFB@E>��$J�@K�@E�=8:K�8�G8I8>I8G?��.?<�_IJK�NFI;�N?@:?�@J�G8IK�F=�[LEKFL:?89C<\�@J�:LK�F==�8E;�K?<I<�@J�EF�@E;<EK8K@FE���.?<�J:?FC8I�:FLC;� :?FFJ<� KF� C89<C� K?<� J8DGC<� 8J� 8EP�ELD9<I� F=� K?@E>J� @E:CL;@E>��G8I8>I8G?���K<OK79CF:B��FI���@E:FDGC<K<7G��� 8:?�F=�K?<J<�FGK@FEJ�I<GI<J<EKJ�8�J<G8I8K<�@EK<IGI<K8K@FE�F=�K?<�K<OK�� .?LJ�K?<�J:?FC8I�@J�=I<<�KF�:?FFJ<�K?<�NFI;J�K?8K�;<J:I@9<�K?<�K<OK�9LK�-"('�2('�8E;�K?<�. $��8�JK8E;8I;@Q<;�JL9J<K�F=�2('�K?8K�@E:CL;<J�@KJ�FNE�ILC<J�8E;�C@JK�F=�M8C@;�K<OKL8C�:FDGFE<EKJ��?8M<�JG<!:@_:�ILC<J�89FLK�K?<�N8P�@E�N?@:?�K?<�K<OK�:8E�9<�K8>><;����CC�F=�K?<J<�C8E>L8><J�8I<�98J<;�FE�K?<�@;<8�K?8K�K<OKJ�:8E�9<�I<GI<J<EK<;�8J�FI;<I<;�?@<I8I:?@<J�F=�:FEK<EK�F9A<:KJ��*#�*���.?@J�8GGIF8:?�@J�DF;<C<;�8=K<I�K?<�:FDGLK<I�J:@<E:<�:FE:<GK�F=�8�KI<<�;8K8�JKIL:KLI<��.I<<�JKIL:KLI<J�8I<�

Page 75: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

67

98J<;�FE�8�?@<I8I:?P�@E�N?@:?�@E;@M@;L8C� :FDGFE<EKJ� FI�EF;<J�=FID�G8I<EK�:?@C;�8E;�J@9C@E>� I<C8K@FEJ?@GJ�� $E� K?<�=FCCFN@E>�;@8>I8D�K?<�G8I<EK�EF;<�@J�I<GI<J<EK<;�9P�9FO�����FO<J�����8E;�!�8I<�J@9C@E>J�9<:8LJ<�K?<P�8I<�K?<�@DD<;@!8K<�:?@C;I<E�F=����� .?<� ILC<J� F=� 2('�I<MFCM<� 8IFLE;� =FID@E>� 8E;�D8@EK8@E@E>�K?@J�KPG<�F=�?@<I!8I:?8C�JKIL:KLI<��$=� K?<�JKIL:KLI<�GIF;L:<;�;F<J�EFK�=FCCFN�K?<J<�ILC<J�@K�@J�J8@;�KF�9<�EFK�N<CC�=FID<;�8E;�:8EEFK�9<�GIF:<JJ<;��$E�FI;<I�=FI�8�;F:LD<EK�KF�9<�M8C@;�@K�DLJK�?8M<�8�IFFK�EF;<�8E;�9<�GIFG<ICP�E<JK<;����IFFK�EF;<�@J�K?<�KFG�EF;<�@E�8�KI<<�8E;�:FEJ<HL<EKCP�@J�K?<�FECP�EF;<�EFK�KF�?8M<�8�G8I<EK��$E�K?@J�;@8>I8D�K?<�IFFK�EF;<�NFLC;�9<�9FO����$E�FI;<I�=FI�D8IBLG�KF�9<�GIFG<ICP�E<JK<;� K?<I<�DLJK�9<�EF�FM<IC8GG@E>�?@<I8I:?@<J�12�$=�K?<�K<OK�@J�>F@E>�KF�9<�LJ<;�=FI�I<J<8I:?�GLIGFJ<�8=K<I�@K�?8J�9<<E�D8IB<;�LG�K?<�?@<I8I:?8C�JKIL:KLI<�@J�LJ<;�KF�KI8M<IJ<�K?<�;F:L!D<EK�8E;�GLCC�FLK�@E=FID8K@FE�I<C<M8EK�KF�8�J:?FC8I^J�HL<IP��� *M<I8CC� K?<� KI<<98J<;� 8GGIF8:?�NFIBJ� M<IP�N<CC�� #8M@E>� KF�@DGFJ<� 8� ?@<I8I:?@:8C� JKIL:KLI<� F=K<E� C<8;J� J:?FC8IJ� KF� EFK@:<� E<N� FI�LELJL8C�JKIL:KLI8C� =<8KLI<J�F=�8� K<OK��+<I?8GJ� K?@J�<OGC8@EJ�N?P� @E� K?<�C8JK� _=K<<E� P<8IJ� 2('� ?8J� <EAFP<;� JL:?� JL::<JJ� ;<JG@K<� @KJ� M8I@FLJ�J?FIK:FD@E>J��.?<�D8@E�I<8JFE�=FI�K?<�JL::<JJ�F=�K?<�*#�*�98J<;�JPJ!K<D�@J�K?8K�DFJK�K<OKJ�C<E;�K?<DJ<CM<J�N<CC�KF�8�?@<I8I:?@:8C�JKIL:KLI<���FFBJ�:FEK8@E�:?8GK<IJ�K?8K�:FEK8@E�G8I8>I8G?J�K?8K�:FEK8@E�J<EK<E:<J�<K:��#FN<M<I�K?@J�DF;<C�@J�EFK�=FFCGIFF=��$E�G8IK@:LC8I�D8EP�K<OKJ�:FE!K8@E� FM<IC8GG@E>� ?@<I8I:?@<J� K<OKL8C� =<8KLI<J� K?8K� ;F� EFK� E<JK� N@K?@E�FK?<I� =<8KLI<J���E�<O8DGC<�F=� K?@J�NFLC;�9<�:FEK@ELFLJ�;@8CF>L<� K?8K�<OK<E;J�FM<I�DLCK@GC<�G8I8>I8G?J���CK?FL>?�K?<I<�8I<�8�M8I@<KP�F=�D<K?!F;J�@E�GC8:<�KF�:@I:LDM<EK�K?@J�@JJL<�FM<IC8GG@E>�?@<I8I:?@<J�E<<;�KF�9<�K?FL>?K�F=�8J�JFD<K?@E>�DFI<�K?8E�8E�[<O:<GK@FE\�KF�K?<�ILC<��.?<�=8:K�K?8K�K?<P�<O@JK�8K�8CC�JL>><JKJ�8�DFI<�=LE;8D<EK8C�GIF9C<D�N@K?�K?<�N8P�K?8K�?@<I8I:?P98J<;�D<K?F;J�;<_E<�8�K<OK��

KIRILLOFF

11

Page 76: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

68

Overlapping Hierarchies

-"('�N8J�FI@>@E8CCP�@EK<E;<;�KF�I<GI<J<EK�8�J@E>C<�CF>@:8C�?@<I8I:?P�@E�8�;F:LD<EK��$K�N8J�8JJLD<;�K?8K�<8:?�;F:LD<EK�:FLC;�FECP�?8M<�FE<�CF>@:8C�?@<I8I:?P�8E;�K?8K�K?<�?@<I8I:?P�NFLC;�9<�;<K<ID@E<;�9P�><EI<��!FI�@EJK8E:<�K?<�KPG@:8C�;F:LD<EK�?@<I8I:?P�=FI�8�J:I@GK�D@>?K�9<��:8JK�C@JK�G<I=FID8E:<�?@JKFIP�K@KC<�JK8><�;@I<:K@FEJ�8:K�J:<E<�C@E<�13�*E:<�-"('�8E;�2('�JK8IK<;�KF�9<�LJ<;�=FI�C@K<I8IP�J:?FC8IJ?@G�@K�9<:8D<�F9M@FLJ�K?8K�K?<I<�@J�EF�J@E>C<�[JK8E;8I;\�?@<I8I:?P�=FI�8EP�>@M<E�K<OK��.?<I<�8I<�DLCK@GC<�G<I?8GJ�<M<E�LEC@D@K<;�:FD9@E8K@FEJ�F=�GFK<EK@8CCP�@EK<I<JK@E>� =<8KLI<J� @E�8� K<OK� I<>8I;C<JJ�F=� @KJ�><EI<�� $E�FE<�J@KL8K@FE�I8K?<I� K?8E� CFFB�8K� K?<�8:KJ�8E;�J:<E<J� @E�8�J:I@GK�8�J:?FC8I�D@>?K�9<�@EK<I<JK<;� @E� <O8D@E@E>� K?<� C<E>K?� F=� JG<<:?<J� 8E;� K?<� LJ<� F=� M<I9J��#@<I8I:?P�:8D<�KF�9<�;<G<E;<EK�FE�@EK<IGI<K8K@FE��K?LJ�D8IBLG�I<`<:KJ�8�K?<FIP�F=�K<OK�:I<8K@E>�8E�LEC@D@K<;�ELD9<I�F=�CF>@:8C�?@<I8I:?@<J�KF�9<�=FLE;�8E;�<E:F;<;�@E�8EP�;F:LD<EK��.?@J�I<8C@Q8K@FE�FG<E<;�LG�K?<�;FFI�=FI�8�ELD9<I�F=�GIF9C<DJ��� *M<IC8GG@E>�?@<I8I:?@<J�:8E�F::LI�8CDFJK�8EPN?<I<�@E:CL;@E>�K?<�=FCCFN@E>��N?<E�8�G8I8>I8G?�<OK<E;J�FM<I�DLCK@GC<�G8><J�N?<E�8�D<K8G?FI�<OK<E;J�FM<I�DLCK@GC<�J<EK<E:<J�FI�N?<E�K?<�?@;;<E�D<JJ8><�9<:FD<J�<E:F;<;�@E�8E�8:IFJK@:��1?@C<�FM<IC8GG@E>�?@<I8I:?@<J�:8E�F:!:LI� @E�8EP�><EI<�F=� K<OK� K?<P�8I<�F=K<E� =FLE;� @E�GF<KIP��.?@J� KPG<�F=�FM<IC8GG@E>�?@<I8I:?P� @J�F=K<E�:8LJ<;�9P�<EA8D9D<EK��.?@J�F::LIJ� @E�K?<�GF<D�[.?<�/EI?PD89C<�1FI;��*I8E><\�9P�1@CC8I;� JGP��[.?<�=FLI�<E>�@E<<IJ�1FI<�FI8E><�9I8JJ@<I<J�\14�$=�8�J:?FC8I�8KK<DGK<;�KF�K8>�9FK?�K?<�C@E<J�8E;�K?<�NFI;J�@E�K?@J�GF<D�K?<�_IJK�KNF�C@E<J�NFLC;�:I<8K<�8E�FM<IC8GG@E>�?@<I8I:?P����C@E<�.?<�=FLI�NFI;�<E>��C@E<��C@E<�@E<<IJ���NFI;���C@E<���� .?<�I<C8K@FEJ?@G�9<KN<<E�NFI;J�8E;�C@E<J�@E�K?@J�GF<D�;F<J�EFK�:FII<JGFE;<;�KF�8�JKI@:KCP�G8I<EK�:?@C;�8E;�J@9C@E>�JKIL:KLI<��.?<�_IJK�;@8>I8D� J?FNJ� K?<� I<C8K@FEJ?@GJ� 9<!KN<<E�C@E<J�8E;�NFI;J�K?8K�<O@JK�@E�K?<�GF<D��@K�J?FNJ�K?<�@EK<I:FEE<:K<;�8E;�FM<IC8GG@E>� E8KLI<� F=� K?<� JKIL:KLI<��.?<�J<:FE;�;@8>I8D�J?FNJ�K?<�KPG<�F=�I<C8K@FEJ?@G�K?8K�*#�*�8E;�2('�I<!HL@I<�K?<�J:?FC8I�KF�:FE=FID�KF�

��

Page 77: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

69

� � � .?<I<� 8I<� ELD<IFLJ� N8PJ�KF� J@;<JK<G� K?@J� GIF9C<D� FE<� F=�N?@:?�NFLC;�9<� KF�LJ<�<DGKP�<C<D<EKJ� KF�;<!C@E<8K<� K?<� JK8IK� 8E;� <E;� F=� K?<� NFI;�[<E>@E<<IJ�\� DGKP� <C<D<EKJ� 8I<� J<C=:FEK8@E<;�LE@KJ��K?<P�8I<�J@DLCK8E<FLJCP�

8� JK8IK�8E;�8E�<E;�K8>��.?<�JPEK8O�=FI�JL:?����� 8�K8>�@J�KF�@EJ<IK�8�JC8J?�9<=FI<�K?<�:CFJ!@E>�9I8:B<K���K8>����.?<J<�K8>J�;F�EFK�NI8G�8IFLE;�K<OK��F=K<E�K?<P�8I<�LJ<;�KF�@E:CL;<�D<K8;8K8��/J@E>�K?<D�@E�K?<�89FM<�GF<D�NFLC;�CFFB�C@B<�K?<�=FCCFN@E>��C@E<�.?<�=FLI�NFI;��<E>��C@E<��C@E<�@E<<IJ�NFI;����C@E<�� 1?<E�LJ<;�@E�K?@J�N8P�<DGKP�<C<D<EKJ�8I<�I<=<II<;�KF�8J�[D@C<!JKFE<J\�K8>J�K?8K�J<IM<�8J�;<C@E<8KFIJ�FI�GC8:<?FC;<IJ��1?@C<�K?@J�KPG<�F=�JFCLK@FE�;F<J�8CCFN�K?<�J:?FC8I�KF�J<8I:?�=FI�K?<�K<OK�9<KN<<E�KNF�<DGKP�<C<D<EK�K8>J�@K�;F<J�EFK�8:BEFNC<;><�K?<�<O@JK<E:<�F=�8E�FM<IC8GG@E>�?@<I8I:?P�F=�NFI;�8E;�C@E<�<C<D<EKJ�� JJ<EK@8CCP�@K�@J�8�N8P�F=�KI@:B@E>�K?<�JPJK<D��-@E:<�K?<�GLIGFJ<�F=�2('�@J�KF�;<J:I@9<�8�K<OK�K?@J�;F<J�EFK�J<<D�C@B<�8E�8;<HL8K<�JFCLK@FE��*K?<I�GFK<EK@8C�JFCLK@FEJ�;<8C�N@K?�K?<�@JJL<� @E�8�J@D@C8I�N8P�8E;�EFE<� I<:FE:@C<� K?<� =FID8K@M<�E8KLI<�F=� K?<�K<OK�N@K?� K?<�?@<I8I:?@:8C�DF;<C�F=� K?<�D8IBLG�GIF:<;LI<��!FI� <O8D!GC<�8EFK?<I�GFGLC8I�8GGIF8:?�K?<�LJ<�F=�=I8>D<EK<;�D8IBLG�JGC@KJ�K?<�FM<IC8GG@E>�<C<D<EKJ�@EKF�DLCK@GC<�G8IKJ��.?@J�8GGIF8:?�NFLC;�;@:K8K<�K?8K�K?<�NFI;�[<E>@E<<IJ\�9<�K8>><;�8J�KNF�J<G8I8K<�NFI;J�JF�K?8K�K?<I<�NFLC;�9<�EF�FM<IC8G�9<KN<<E�K?<�NFI;�8E;�C@E<�<C<D<EKJ��

Why OHCO?

.?<I<�8I<� J<M<I8C�;@==<I<EK� I<8JFEJ�N?P�;@>@K8C�?LD8E@JKJ� JLGGFIK� K?<�@;<8�K?8K�8�K<OK�:8E�9<�;<J:I@9<;�@E�K<IDJ�F=�FI;<I<;�?@<I8I:?@<J�� �.?<�JLGGFIK<IJ�F=�*#�*�:8E�9<�JGC@K�@EKF�KNF�D8AFI�JL9>IFLGJ��K?FJ<�N?F�JLGGFIK�K?<�DF;<C�=FI�GI8:K@:8C�I<8JFEJ�8E;�K?FJ<�N?F�JLGGFIK�@K�=FI�FEKF!CF>@:8C�I<8JFEJ��*=K<E�K?<�C@E<�9<KN<<E�K?<J<�KNF�>IFLGJ�@J�9CLII<;��.?<�FEKFCF>@:8C�8GGIF8:?�J<<BJ�KF�8EJN<I�K?<�HL<JK@FE�[1?8K�@J�K<OK�\�8E;�GIFGFJ<J�K?<�8EJN<I�[.<OK�@J�8E�FI;<I<;�?@<I8I:?P�F=�:FEK<EK�F9A<:KJ�\�.?<�CF>@:�=FI�K?@J�8I>LD<EK�I<MFCM<J�8IFLE;�K?<�@;<8�K?8K�K?<�D<8E@E>�F=�K<OK�:8E�9<�;<;L:<;�=IFD�;<K<ID@E@E>�K?<�G8IKJ�F=�8�K<OK�K?8K�@=�K8B<E�

KIRILLOFF

��

Page 78: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

70

8N8P�:?8E><�K?<�K<OK�@EKF�8�E<N�K<OK��� $E�8�G8G<I�K?8K�J<<BJ�KF�;<=<E;�K?<�*#�*�DF;<C�[1?8K�@J�.<OK�,<8CCP�\�K?<�8LK?FIJ�>@M<�K?<�=FCCFN@E>�KI8@E�F=�I<8JFE@E>��[.?<�<JJ<E!K@8C�G8IKJ�F=�8EP�;F:LD<EK�=FID�N?8K�N<�:8CC�]:FEK<EK�F9A<:KJ �8E;�8I<�F=�D8EP�KPG<J�JL:?�8J�G8I8>I8G?J�HLFK8K@FEJ�<DG?8K@:�G?I8J<J�8E;�8KKI@9LK@FEJ�� 8:?�KPG<�F=�:FEK<EK�F9A<:K�LJL8CCP�?8J�@KJ�FNE�8GG<8I8E:<�N?<E�8�;F:LD<EK�@J�GI@EK<;�FI�;@JGC8P<;�9LK�K?8K�8GG<8I8E:<�@J�JLG<I!_:@8C�8E;�KI8EJ@<EK�I8K?<I�K?8E�<JJ<EK@8C�\�����::FI;@E>�KF�K?@J�K?<FIP�@=�]:FEK<EK�F9A<:KJ �8I<�:?8E><;�<@K?<I�9P�I<DFM@E>�K?<D�FI�:?8E>@E>�K?<@I�FI;<I�8�E<N�;F:LD<EK�@J�GIF;L:<;���P�:FEKI8JK�@=�=FID8KK@E>�Z�JL:?�8J�=FEK�KPG<�Z�@J�:?8E><;�K?<�K<OK�I<D8@EJ�K?<�J8D<��.?@J�@J�J@D@C8I�KF�K?<�:C8JJ@:8C�K<OKL8C�<;@K@E>�;@JK@E:K@FE�9<KN<<E�JL9JK8EK@M<�8E;�8::@;<EK8C�M8I@8EKJ��-L9JK8EK@M<�M8I@8EKJ�8I<�K?FJ<�K?8K�:?8E><�K?<�J<EJ<�F=�K?<�K<OK�JL:?� 8J� K?<� JL9JK@KLK@FE�F=�NFI;J�N?@C<� 8::@;<EK8C� M8I@8EKJ� 8I<� K?FJ<�K?8K�;FE^K�8==<:K�K?<�D<8E@E>�F=�8�K<OK�JL:?�8J�K?<�LJ<�F=�LGG<I:8J<�FI�CFN<I:8J<�C<KK<IJ��.?<�8LK?FIJ�>F�FE�KF�J8P�K?8K�[DFJK�:FEK<EK�F9A<:KJ�8I<�:FEK8@E<;� @E� C8I><I�:FEK<EK�F9A<:KJ�JL:?�8J�JL9J<:K@FEJ�J<:K@FEJ�8E;�:?8GK<IJX"<E<I8CCP�JD8CC<I�:FEK<EK�F9A<:KJ�;F�EFK�:IFJJ�K?<�9FLE;8I!@<J�F=�C8I><I�FE<J��K?LJ�8�G8I8>I8G?�N@CC�EFK�9<>@E�@E�FE<�:?8GK<I�8E;�<E;�@E�K?<�E<OK��!FI�K?@J�I<8JFE�K?<�JKIL:KLI<�F=�8�;F:LD<EK�@J�8�?@<I8I:?@:8C�FE<�C@B<�8�KI<<�\���� .?<I<�8I<�J<M<I8C�GIF9C<DJ�N@K?�K?@J�I<8JFE@E>��$E�8�G8G<I�K?8K�:I@K@:@Q<J�K?@J�8I>LD<EK�[,<_E@E>�*LI�)FK@FE�F=�1?8K�.<OK�,<8CCP�$J��.?<� +IF9C<D�F=�*M<IC8GG@E>�#@<I8I:?@<J\� K?<� 8LK?FIJ� GF@EK� FLK� K?8K�<M<E�K?<�FEKFCF>@:8C�8I>LD<EK�@E�=8MFI�F=�*#�*�@J�DFK@M8K<;�9P�GI8:K@!:8C@KP��[.?<�G8IK@J8EJ�F=�:FEK<EKFI@<EK<;�K<OK�GIF:<JJ@E>�8E;�;<J:I@GK@M<�D8IBLG�:C8@D<;�K?8K�KI<8K@E>�K<OKJ�8J�@=�K?<P�N<I<�FI;<I<;�?@<I8I:?@<J�F=�:FEK<EK�F9A<:KJ�?8;�D8EP�GI8:K@:8C�9<E<_KJ�N?@C<�8CK<IE8K@M<�I<GI<J<E!K8K@FE8C�GI8:K@:<J�I<JLCK<;�@E�M8I@FLJ�@E<=_:@<E:@<J�8E;�@E8;<HL8:@<J��$K�N8J�8�J?FIK�JK<G�=IFD�EFK@E>�K?<�GI8:K@:8C�8;M8EK8><J�F=�KI<8K@E>�K<OKJ�8J�@=�K?<P�N<I<�*#�*J�KF�<OGC8@E@E>�K?FJ<�8;M8EK8><J�9P�K?<�?PGFK?!<J@J�K?8K�K<OKJ�8I<�*#�*J�\����$EK<I<JK@E>CP�K?I<<�F=�K?<�8LK?FIJ�F=�K?@J�G8G<I�8LK?FI<;�[1?8K�$J�.<OK�,<8CCP�\�K?I<<�P<8IJ�<8IC@<I��*E<�F=�K?<�GIF9C<DJ�K?<P�GF@EK�FLK�@J�K?8K�K?<�GIFGFE<EKJ�F=�*#�*�K8B<�-"('�N?@:?�N8J�EFK�;<J@>E<;�=FI�=LCCP�;<J:I@9@E>�K<OKJ�8E;�8KK<DGK�KF�ALJK@=P�@KJ�8GGIF8:?�9P�8I>L@E>�K?8K� @K� @J�GI8:K@:8C��.?@J� @J�8�GIF9C<D�9<:8LJ<�K?<P�8I<�8KK<DGK@E>�KF�8EJN<I�8E�FEKFCF>@:8C�HL<JK@FE��N?8K�@J�K<OK��N@K?�

Page 79: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

71

8�GLI<CP�GI8>D8K@:�8EJN<I��[1?8K�@J�.<OK�,<8CCP�\�F=K<E�=8CCJ�@EKF�K?@J�=8LCKP�CF>@:��.?<�=8:K�K?8K�*#�*�:8E�NFIB�8E;�K?8K�@K�NFIBJ�9<KK<I�K?8E�@KJ�GI<;<:<JJFIJ�8I<�GI8:K@:8C�F9J<IM8K@FEJ�8E;�?8M<�EFK?@E>�KF�;F�N@K?�K?<�E8KLI<�F=�K<OK��.?<�8I>LD<EK�K?8K�DFJK�K<OKJ�:8E�:FE=FID�KF�8�?@<I!8I:?@:8C�DF;<C�;F<J�EFK�<HL8K<�KF�[8CC�K<OKJ�8I<�FI;<I<;�?@<I8I:?@<J�F=�:FEK<EK�F9A<:KJ�\� .?<I<� 8I<� FK?<I� GIF9C<DJ�N@K?� K?<� FEKFCF>@:8C� 8I>LD<EK� K?8K�FGGFE<EKJ� ;F� EFK� 8:BEFNC<;><�� [,<_E@E>� *LI� )FK@FE� F=�1?8K� .<OK�,<8CCP� $J\�8;;I<JJ<J� K?<� =8:K� K?8K�FI;<I<;�?@<I8I:?@<J�8I<�8�;<98K89C<�DF;<C�9LK�K?<�8IK@:C<�;F<J�EFK�HL<JK@FE�K?<�@;<8�K?8K�8�K<OK�@J�:FDGFJ<;�F=�[:FEK<EK�F9A<:KJ�\�$K�D8B<J�J<EJ<�K?8K�=FID8KK@E>�NFLC;�EFK�9<�:FE!J@;<I<;�@DGFIK8EK�=FI�K?<�FI@>@E8C�GLIGFJ<�F=�-"('�J?8I@E>�C8N�;F:L!D<EKJ��#FN<M<I�:FEKI8IP�KF�K?<�*#�*�8I>LD<EK�=FID8KK@E>�8E;�M@JL8C�GI<J<EK8K@FE�:8E�9<�[<JJ<EK@8C\�<C<D<EKJ�F=�8� K<OK���E�<O8DGC<�F=� K?<�@DGFIK8E:<�F=�GI<J<EK8K@FE�@E�:I<8K@E>�D<8E@E>�:8E�9<�=FLE;�@E�House$of$Leaves�19��?8E>@E>�<@K?<I�K?<�[:FEK<EK�F9A<:KJ\�FI�K?<�=FID8KK@E>�@E�House$of$Leaves�=LE;8D<EK8CCP�:?8E><J�K?<�K<OK��� .?<I<�8I<�D8EP�M@JL8C�:FDGFE<EKJ�F=�House$of$Leaves�K?8K�I<=!<I<E:<�K?<�E8II8K@M<�8E;�8I<�@EK<>I8C�KF�K?<�<OG<I@<E:<�F=�I<8;@E>�K?<�K<OK��*E<�JL:?�:FDGFE<EK�@J�K?<�LJ<�F=�;@==<I<EK�=FEKJ��.?I<<�J<G8I8K<�:?8I8:!K<IJ�E8II8K<�House$of$Leaves$�%F?EEP�.IL8EK�48DG8EF�8E;�K?<�<;@KFI��<8:?�F=�N?@:?�@J�I<GI<J<EK<;�9P�8�;@==<I<EK�KPG<=FEK��,8K?<I�K?8E�?8M<�K?<�E8II8KFIJ�K8B<�:FEKIFC�F=�<EK@I<�:?8GK<IJ��8E@<C<NJB@�JKIL:KLI<;�K?<�EFM<C�JF�K?8K�<8:?�E8II8KFI�F=K<E�?8J�8�GFIK@FE�F=�K?<�J8D<�:?8GK<I��$=�K?<�9FFB�@J�I<FI>8E@Q<;�JF�K?8K�<8:?�E8II8KFI^J�JKFIP�F::LIJ�@E�J<HL<E:<�K?<�K<OK�:?8E><J�<M<E�K?FL>?�K?<�:FDGFE<EK�G8IKJ�8I<�JK@CC�GI<J<EK��.?@J�@J�9<:8LJ<�K?<�E8II8KFIJ�I<JGFE;�KF�FE<�8EFK?<I�8E;�K8B@E>�K?<D�FLK�F=�:FEK<OK�:?8E><J�K?<�<==<:K�F=�K?<�EFM<C��$E�;F@E>�JF�K?<�J<C=I<=<I<EK@8C�E8KLI<�F=�K?<�K<OK�@J�<C@D@E8K<;���P�?8M@E>�;@==<I<EK�E8II8KFIJ�:FDD<EK�FE�8E;�8;;�KF�K?<�K<OK��8E@<C<NJB@^J�EFM<C�I<=<I<E:<J�@KJ<C=�8J�8�G?PJ@!:8C�K<OKL8C�8IK@=8:K��$E�K?@J�N8P�K?<�[:FEK<EK�F9A<:KJ\�8I<�<JJ<EK@8C�� /E=FIKLE8K<CP�:?8E>@E>�K?<�=FID8KK@E>�NFLC;�@DG8:K�K?<�EFM<C�@E�8�J@D@C8I�N8P��-FD<K@D<J�@K�@J�@DGFJJ@9C<�KF�@;<EK@=P�N?@:?�E8II8KFI�@J�JG<8B@E>�9P�K?<�:FEK<EK�8CFE<��<C@D@E8K@E>�K?<�;@==<I<E:<J�@E�KPG<=FEK�NFLC;�D8B<�@K�@DGFJJ@9C<�KF�G8IJ<�:<IK8@E�G8IKJ�F=�K?<�E8II8K@M<���CK?FL>?�K?<�8LK?FIJ�F=�[1?8K�@J�.<OK�,<8CCP�\�:C8@D�K?8K�JL:?�8�:?8E><�NFLC;�EFK�=LE;8D<EK8CCP�8CK<I�K?<�K<OK�FE<�:FLC;�JK@CC�8KK<DGK�KF�8I>L<�K?8K�K?<�

KIRILLOFF

Page 80: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

72

=FID8KK@E>�F=�House$of$Leaves�_KJ�@EKF�8�?@<I8I:?@:8C�JPJK<D��-L:?�8E�8I>LD<EK�NFLC;�8JJLD<� K?8K� K?<� =8:K� K?8K� K?<�E8II8K@M<�:FEK8@EJ� K?I<<�;@==<I<EK�KPG<=FEKJ�@J�@DGFIK8EK�9LK�EFK�K?<�KPG<=FEKJ�K?<DJ<CM<J��.?@J�@J�8CJF�NIFE>��K?<�KPG<=FEKJ�N<I<�G@:B<;�@EK<EK@FE8CCP�8E;�I<=<I<E:<�K?<�:?8I8:K<I�N@K?�N?@:?�K?<P�8I<�8JJF:@8K<;��!FI�<O8DGC<�%F?EEP�.IL8EK^J�K<OK� @J�NI@KK<E� @E��FLI@<I��1@K?@E� K?<�E8II8K@M<� %F?EEP�=LE:K@FEJ�8J�8�D<JJ<E><I�;<C@M<I@E>�K?<�K<OK�KF�K?<�I<8;<I��.?<I<�8I<�:FLEKC<JJ�FK?<I�<O8DGC<J�F=� K<OKJ�N?FJ<�M@JL8C�<C<D<EKJ�8E;�JKPC@E>�8I<�@EK<>I8C� G8IKJ� F=� K?<� E8II8K@M<� JKIL:KLI<� 8E;� @E� =8:K� FE<�:FLC;� 8I>L<� K?8K� K?@J� @J�KIL<�F=�8CC� K<OKJ�20�1?@C<�K?<� 8JJLDGK@FE� K?8K� =FI!D8KK@E>�@J�EFK�[<JJ<EK@8C\�;F<J�EFK�;@I<:KCP� @DG8:K�D8IBLG� GIF:<;LI<� @E�;@>@K8C� ?LD8E@K@<J� K?<�=8:K� K?8K� K?<� FEKFCF>@:8C�*#�*� DF;<C� FG<I8K<J�FE� K?@J� =8LCKP� 8JJLDG!K@FE�@E;@:8K<J�K?8K�K?<�@E!K<E;<;�LJ<�F=�*#�*�<E:F;@E>�@J�EFK�@E�C@E<�N@K?�@KJ�:LII<EK�LJ<��� .?<�GI8>D8K@:�8I>LD<EK�=FI�*#�*�@J�EFK�;<G<E;<EK�FE�K?<�8J!JLDGK@FE�K?8K�K<OK�@J�:FDGFJ<;�F=�:FEK<EK�F9A<:KJ�9<:8LJ<�K?<P�8I<�K?<�FECP� [<JJ<EK@8C\� G8IK� F=� 8� K<OK�� $EJK<8;� K?@J� 8I>LD<EK� =F:LJ<J� FE� K?<�GI8:K@:8C�8GGC@:8K@FEJ�F=�K?<�*#�*�DF;<C�8E;�8I>L<J�K?8K�K?<�JL::<JJ�F=� K?<�DF;<C�D<8EJ� K?8K� @K� 8::LI8K<CP� I<`<:KJ� K?<�E8KLI<�F=� K<OK��.?@J�8GGIF8:?�@J�?8I;<I�KF�8I>L<�N@K?���FDG8I<;�KF�@KJ�GI<;<:<JJFIJ�-"('�8E;�2('�=LE:K@FE�DL:?�DFI<�<=_:@<EKCP�8J�K<OK�<E:F;@E>�C8E>L8><J�21��,<M@J@FEJ�F=�K?<�*#�*�K?<J@J�8CJF�JL>><JK�8�N8P�@E�N?@:?�FM<IC8GG@E>�?@<I8I:?@<J�8I<�EFK�8K�F;;J�N@K?�K?<�*#�*�DF;<C�8�K<DGK@E>�8I>LD<EK�>@M<E�@KJ�GI8:K@:8C�8;M8EK8><J��� $E�K?@J�8I>LD<EK�?@<I8I:?@<J�K?8K�FM<IC8G�8I<�:FEJ@;<I<;�KF�9<!CFE>�KF�8�;@==<I<EK�JL9?@<I8I:?P��O�@J�8�JL9G<IJG<:K@M<�F=�P�@=�8E;�FECP�@=�O�@J�8�G<IJG<:K@M<�8E;�P�@J�8�G<IJG<:K@M<�8E;�K?<�ILC<J�K?<FI@<J�D<K?F;J�8E;�GI8:K@:<J�F=�O�8I<�8CC�@E:CL;<;�@E�K?<�ILC<J�K?<FI@<J�D<K?F;J�8E;�GI8:K@:<J�F=�P�9LK�EFK�M@:<�M<IJ8�22��P�K?@J�CF>@:�8EP�FM<IC8GG@E>�?@<I8I!:?P�:8E�9<�;<:FDGFJ<;�@EKF�JL9G<IJG<:K@M<J�F=�K?<�K<OK��#FN<M<I�K?<�

“There$are$countless$other$examples$of$texts$whose$visual$elements$and$styling$are$integral$parts$of$the$narrative$structure$and,$in$fact,$one$could$argue$that$

this$is$true$of$all$texts.”

Page 81: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

73

[ILC<J� K?<FI@<J�D<K?F;J� 8E;� GI8:K@:<J\�D<EK@FE<;� J<<D� :FDGC<K<CP�FG<E�KF�@EK<IGI<K8K@FE���P�K?@J�;<_E@K@FE�@K�J<<DJ�8J�@=�8EP�G<IJG<:K@M<�:FLC;�9<�ILC<;�8�JL9G<IJG<:K@M<�F=�8EFK?<I�G<IJG<:K@M<�� .?<� GI8:K@:8C� 9<E<_KJ� F=�*#�*� :FD9@E<;�N@K?� K?@J� I<M@J@FE�D@>?K�@E@K@8CCP�J<<D�KF�<I8;@:8K<�;FL9KJ�89FLK�K?<�M8C@;@KP�F=�K?<�DF;<C��/GFE�8�:CFJ<�<O8D@E8K@FE�?FN<M<I�GIF9C<DJ�JK@CC�<O@JK��.?<�8LK?FIJ�F=�[,<_E@E>�FLI�)FK@FE�F=�1?8K�.<OK�$J\�GF@EK�FLK�K?8K�K?<I<�8I<�:8J<J�@E�N?@:?�FM<IC8GG@E>�?@<I8I:?@<J�8I<�:I<8K<;�9P�F9A<:KJ�K?8K�J<C=FM<IC8G�FI�FM<IC8G�N@K?�DFI<�F=�K?<�J8D<�KPG<�F=�F9A<:K��!FI�<O8DGC<�@=�8�HL<J!K@FE�FM<IC8GJ�N@K?�8�C@E<�@E�8�GF<D�@K�:FLC;�9<�8I>L<;�K?8K�HL<JK@FEJ�8E;�C@E<J�8I<�<C<D<EKJ�F=�;@==<I<EK�G<IJG<:K@M<J��$=�FE�K?<�FK?<I�?8E;�KNF�JKFI@<J�FM<IC8G�N@K?�FE<�8EFK?<I�K?@J�8I>LD<EK�=8CCJ�8G8IK���� M<E�N@K?FLK� :FEK<DGC8K@E>� K?<�<O@JK<E:<�F=� J<C=FM<IC8GG@E>�F9A<:KJ�K?<�I<M@J@FE�@J�?8I;�KF�;@><JK��.?<�:I<8K@FE�F=�JL9G<IJG<:K@M<J�J<<DJ�8D9@>LFLJ�8E;�8I9@KI8IP�� M<E�@=�@K�@J�KIL<�K?8K�FM<IC8GG@E>�?@<I!8I:?@<J� 8I<� I<8CCP� G<IJG<:K@M<J� 8E;� JL9G<IJG<:K@M<J� K?<� :F;@E>� JFCL!K@FEJ�I<D8@E�K?<�J8D<�� @K?<I�G<IJG<:K@M<J�8E;�JL9G<IJG<:K@M<J�:8E�9<�:@I:LDE8M@>8K<;�N@K?�:F;@E>�KI@:BJ�FI�G<I?8GJ�DFI<�@E�C@E<�N@K?�K?@J�I<M@J@FE�;@==<I<EK�G<IJG<:K@M<J�:8E�9<�D8IB<;�LG�@E�DLCK@GC<�:FG@<J�F=�8�;F:LD<EK��.?<J<�JFCLK@FEJ�8I<�EFK�8;<HL8K<��@=�K?<I<�@J�JK@CC�EF�N8P�KF�I<GI<J<EK�[G<IJG<:K@M<�8E;�JL9G<IJG<:K@M<J\�8J�:F<O@JK@E>� =<8KLI<J�F=�K?<�J8D<�;F:LD<EK�K?<�I<M@J@FE�@J�LJ<C<JJ��� �<JG@K<� K?<J<� ;@=_:LCK@<J� LCK@D8K<CP� K?<� GI8:K@:8C� 9<E<_KJ� F=�*#�*�8I<�I<8C��1?@C<�K?<�FEKFCF>@:8C�8I>LD<EK�?8J�DFI<�F9M@FLJ� 8NJ�K?<�GI8:K@:8C�8GGIF8:?� @J�>IFLE;<;� @E�8CDFJK� K<E�P<8IJ�F=� C8I><CP�JL:!:<JJ=LC�2('�<E:F;@E>�@E�K?<�?LD8E@K@<J��#FN<M<I�K?<I<�@J�8�;@==<I<E:<�9<KN<<E�8:BEFNC<;>@E>�K?<�LJ<=LCE<JJ�F=�K?<J<�C8E>L8><J�8E;�8JJLD@E>�K?8K�K?<@I�JLG<I@FI@KP�FM<I�GI<M@FLJ�DF;<CJ�GI<:CL;<J�K?<�;<M<CFGD<EK�F=�E<N�8E;�9<KK<I�K<:?EFCF>@<J�EFK�98J<;�FE�K?<�*#�*�DF;<C��$E�C@>?K�F=�K?<�;@=_:LCK@<J�GFJ<;�9P�FM<IC8GG@E>�?@<I8I:?@<J�@K�J<<DJ�:FLEK<IGIF!;L:K@M<� K?8K�9FK?� K?<�FEKFCF>@:8C�8E;�GI8>D8K@:�8I>LD<EKJ�=FI�*#�*�:C@E>�KF�K?<�M8C@;@KP�F=�K?<�:LII<EK�D8IBLG�DF;<C�

The Appeal of OHCO

$=�K?<I<�8I<�JF�D8EP�@JJL<J�N@K?�K?<�*#�*�8I>LD<EK�N?<I<�;F<J�K?<�@E:C@E8K@FE�KF�KI<8K�@K�8J�8�;<_E@K@M<�8E;�@E=8CC@9C<�DF;<C�:FD<�=IFD����

KIRILLOFF

Page 82: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

74

>FF;�@EJ@>?K�@EKF�K?@J�HL<JK@FE�D@>?K�:FD<�=IFD�K?<�N8P�K?8K�J:?FC8IJ�=<<C�89FLK�K?<�GIF:<JJ�F=�K<OK�<E:F;@E>��.?FL>?�[=<<C\�@J�?8I;�KF�D<8!JLI<�-K<G?<E�,8DJ8P�8�GIF>I8DD<I�8E;�;@>@K8C�?LD8E@JK�F==<IJ�JFD<�G8IK@:LC8ICP�LJ<=LC� @EJ@>?KJ��,8DJ8P�I<=<IJ� KF� K?<�<E:F;@E>�GIF:<JJ�8J�8E�8:K�F=�:I<8K@FE��[�J�?LD8E@JKJ�N<�8I<�@E:C@E<;�KF�I<8;�D8GJ��KF�G@:B�FE<�<O8DGC<��8J�K<OKJX�LK�making�8�D8G��N@K?�8�"$-�JPJK<D�J8P��@J�8E�<EK@I<CP�;@==<I<EK�<OG<I@<E:<X�L@C;@E>�@J�=FI�LJ�8�E<N�B@E;�F=�?<ID<!E<LK@:�Z�FE<�K?8K�@J�HL@K<�8�9@K�DFI<�I8;@:8C�K?8E�K8B@E>�K?<�KI8;@K@FE8C�D<K?F;J�F=�?LD8E@JK@:�@EHL@IP�8E;�8GGCP@E>�K?<D�KF�;@>@K8C�F9A<:KJ�\23�� �FDG8I@E>� <E:F;@E>� KF� 9L@C;@E>� @J� G8IK@:LC8ICP� LJ<=LC� @E� K?8K�@K�?@>?C@>?KJ�K?<�I<C8K@FEJ?@G�9<KN<<E�K?<�J:?FC8I�8E;�D8IBLG�C8E>L8><�8J�K?8K�F=�9L@C;<I�8E;�KFFC���J�N@K?�DFJK�KFFCJ�@=�K?<P�><K�K?<�AF9�;FE<�K?<I<� @J�EF�I<8JFE�KF�HL<JK@FE�K?<D��2('�_KJ� @EKF� K?@J�:8K<>FIP�8J� @K�8CCFNJ�=FI�K?<�:8K<>FI@Q8K@FE�F=�K<OKL8C�=<8KLI<J�8E;�K?<�GIF;L:K@FE�F=�;@>@K8C�K<OKJ��$E�8;;@K@FE�K?<�98J@:�JPEK8O�F=�2('�D8B<J�K?<�C8E>L8><�J<<D�;<:<GK@M<CP�FG<E�<E;<;���<:8LJ<�K?<�J:?FC8I�?8J�:FDGC<K<�:FEKIFC�@E�;<K<ID@E@E>�K8>�E8D<J�8E;�@E�;<K<ID@E@E>�N?@:?�K<OKL8C�<C<D<EKJ�KF�K8>�K?<�C@D@K8K@FEJ�F=�K?<�C8E>L8><�8I<�EFK�8CN8PJ�F9M@FLJ���CJF�:LI!I<EK�8GGIF8:?<J�=FI�;<8C@E>�N@K?�FM<IC8GG@E>�?@<I8I:?@<J�8I<�M<IP�<8JP�KF�@DGC<D<EK�<M<E�K?FL>?�K?<P�;F�EFK�=LCCP�8;;I<JJ�K?<�GIF9C<D��� �EFK?<I� ?<CG=LC� N8P� F=� K?@EB@E>� 89FLK� K?<� 8CCLI<� F=� *#�*�D@>?K�9<�8J�=FCCFNJ��!FI�8�CFE>�K@D<�G<FGC<�K?FL>?K����GC8P<IJ�N<I<�NFE;<I=LC���CK?FL>?����GC8P<IJ� :FLC;� EFK� GC8P� M@;<FJ� K?@J�N8J� EFK�I<:F>E@Q<;�8J�8�[GIF9C<D\�FI�@E8;<HL8:P�9<:8LJ<�8�M@;<F�GC8P@E>����GC8P<I�N8J�LE@D8>@E89C<��(FJK�FNE<IJ�F=�GFIK89C<����GC8P<IJ�;@;�EFK�JKFG�KF�HL<JK@FE�K?<�=LE;8D<EK8C�;<J@>E�GIFG<IK@<J�F=�K?<�KFFC�K?<P�N<I<�LJ@E>�KF�C@JK<E�KF�DLJ@:��.?<�G<FGC<�N?F�;@;�JKFG�KF�:FEJ@;<I�K?<�=LE;8!D<EK8C�;<J@>E�GI@E:@GC<J�F=����GC8P<IJ�N<I<�K?<�<E>@E<<IJ�D8B@E>�K?<D��G<FGC<�N?F�N<I<�@EK@D8K<CP�=8D@C@8I�N@K?�K?<�98J@:�GI@E:@GC<J�9<?@E;�K?<�:I<8K@FE�GIF:<JJ�� M<EKL8CCP� K?<� @+F;�:8D<�FLK�8E;�:?8E><;� K?<�N8P�G<FGC<�M@<N<;�K?<@I�DLJ@:�GC8P<IJ�� E>@E<<IJ�N<I<�89C<�KF�:FE:<@M<�F=�8�=LKLI<�K<:?EFCF>@:8C�8;M8E:<�9<:8LJ<�K?<P�LE;<IJKFF;�K?<�98J@:�;<J@>E�GI@E:@GC<J�9<?@E;�@K�8E;�:FLC;�;<K<ID@E<�N?8K�N8J�=<8J@9C<�� (FJK�;@>@K8C�?LD8E@JKJ�;F�EFK� =LCCP�LE;<IJK8E;� K?<� KFFCJ� K?<P�8I<�LJ@E>�FI�K?<�GI@E:@GC<J�9<?@E;�K?<D�EFI�8I<�K?<P�8N8I<�F=�K?<�?@JKFIP�F=�-"('�8E;�2('��.?<P�BEFN�K?8K�=FI�K?<�DFJK�G8IK�K?<�KFFCJ�NFIB��#LD8E@K@<J�J:?FC8IJ�K?<�G<FGC<�N?F�:8I<�89FLK�K?<�FEKFCF>@:8C�8JG<:KJ�

Page 83: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

75

F=�K?<�D8IBLG�DF;<C�:8EEFK�LE;<IJK8E;�?FN�8EFK?<I�DF;<C�D@>?K�<O@JK�N@K?FLK�9<KK<I�LE;<IJK8E;@E>� K?<�:LII<EK�JPJK<D��.?LJ�D8EP�J:?FC8IJ�=8CC�@EKF�K?<�KI8G�F=�LEHL<JK@FE89CP�8::<GK@E>�K?<�*#�*�DF;<C��-:?FC!8IJ�E<<;�KF�9<�8N8I<�F=�K?<�=8:K�K?8K�K?<�KFFCJ�K?<P�8I<�LJ@E>�N<I<�EFK�;<J@>E<;�=FI� K?<D�8E;�K?8K�FK?<I�FGK@FEJ�8I<�8M8@C89C<��.?@J�;F<J�EFK�D<8E�K?8K�J:?FC8IJ�J?FLC;�;@J8MFN�K?<�:LII<EK�JPJK<D�9LK�@E�FI;<I�KF�@DGIFM<�K?<I<�E<<;J�KF�9<�DFI<�IFFD�=FI�@EHL@IP�

Alternatives and Conclusions

�*)�/,�8E�8CK<IE8K@M<�KF�K?<�*#�*�8GGIF8:?�N8J�FI@>@E8CCP�8�=<8!KLI<�F=�-"('�9LK�?8J�=8CC<E�FLK�F=�LJ<�D8@ECP�9<:8LJ<�@K�:I<8K<J�:LD!9<IJFD<�8E;�M<I9FJ<�D8IBLG��.?@J�;I8N98:B�J?FLC;�EFK�8LKFD8K@:8CCP�@EM8C@;8K<� @KJ�:FE:<GKL8C�M8CL<�� @K� @J�98J<;�FE� K?<�GI@E:@GC<�F=�:FE:LI!I<EK�;8K8�JKIL:KLI<J�8�N8P�F=�;<8C@E>�N@K?�DLCK@GC<� K?I<8;J�F=�;8K8�8K�K?<�J8D<�K@D<���*)�/,�8CCFNJ�=FI�8�;F:LD<EK�KF�9<�J@DLCK8E<FLJCP�D8IB<;�LG� @E�DLCK@GC<� :FE`@:K@E>�?@<I8I:?@:8C� K8>J<KJ�� $K�N8J�EFK� @E!:CL;<;� 8J� 8� =<8KLI<� @E�2('� 8E;�N?@C<� JFD<� J@D@C8I� C8E>L8><J� ?8M<�9<<E�;<M<CFG<;�EFE<�8I<�N@;<CP�LJ<;�@E�?LD8E@K@<J�D8IBLG�24�� �CK?FL>?� K?<I<�8I<�8�ELD9<I�F=�GIF9C<DJ�N@K?��*)�/,� @KJ�98J@:�GI@E:@GC<�Z�8:BEFNC<;>@E>�8E;�JLGGFIK@E>�DLCK@GC<�?@<I8I:?@<J�J@DLCK8E<FLJCP�N@K?@E�8�;F:LD<EK�Z�:FLC;�9<�8�LJ<=LC�N8P�F=�;<8C@E>�N@K?�K?<�@E8;<HL8:@<J�F=�K?<�:LII<EK�DF;<C��$E�8;;@K@FE�K?<�GI@E:@GC<J�9<?@E;��*)�/,�D8P�DFI<�8;<HL8K<CP�I<`<:K�K?<�I<C8K@FEJ?@G�9<KN<<E�@EK<IGI<K8K@FEJ�F=�8�K<OK��$K�=FCCFNJ�K?8K�G<I?8GJ�JL:?�8�DF;<C�D@>?K�8CJF�8CCFN�=FI�8�9<KK<I�I<C8K@FEJ?@G�9<KN<<E�J:?FC8IJ�8E;�K?<�D8IBLG�GIF:<!;LI<�K?<P�8I<�LJ@E>�KF�;<J:I@9<�8�;F:LD<EK��� #FN<M<I�N@K?�K?8K�J8@;�@K� @J�@DGFIK8EK�EFK�KF�8;FGK�K?<�J8D<�IFLK<�8J� K?<�GIFGFE<EKJ�F=� K?<�*#�*�DF;<C��.?<�=8:K� K?8K��*)�/,�D@>?K�DFI<�:FEM<E@<EKCP�FI�:FDGC<K<CP�I<GI<J<EK�:<IK8@E�=<8KLI<J�F=�8�K<OK�;F<J�EFK�D<8E�@K�I<GI<J<EKJ�K?<�KIL<�E8KLI<�F=�N?8K�K<OK�[I<8CCP�@J�\���*)�/,�C@B<�JK8E;8I;�-"('�8E;�2('�8JJLD<J�K?8K�8�K<OK�@J�:FD!GFJ<;�F=�?@<I8I:?@<J��1?@C<� K?@J�8JJLDGK@FE� @J�EFK�E<:<JJ8I@CP�NIFE>�<D<I>@E>�D8IBLG�K?<FI@<J�J?FLC;�EFK�8JJLD<�8EP�GI@E:@GC<J�F=�GI<M@FLJ�<E:F;@E>�D<K?F;J�8J�8�>@M<E�8E;�J?FLC;�9<�;@J:LJJ<;�:I@K@:8CCP�=IFD�K?<�G<IJG<:K@M<�F=�K?<�?LD8E@K@<J�J:?FC8I��� .?<�[GIF9C<DJ\�N@K?�K?<�:LII<EK�DF;<C�F=�K<OKL8C�D8IBLG�<D!

KIRILLOFF

Page 84: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

76

9F;@<;�9P�K?<�@JJL<�F=�FM<IC8GG@E>�?@<I8I:?@<J�@E;@:8K<�8�DFI<�=LE;8!D<EK8C� @JJL<�N@K?� K?<�N8P� K<OK� <E:F;@E>�?8J� =FI� K?<�DFJK�G8IK� 9<<E�:FE:<GKL8C@Q<;�� .?@J� @J� 8� J<I@FLJ� GIF9C<D� 9<:8LJ<� K?<� :FEJKI8@EKJ� F=�D8IBLG�JKI8K<>@<J�?8M<�J<I@FLJ�I<8C�NFIC;�I8D@_:8K@FEJ�@E�K?<�I<C8K@FE!J?@G�8DFE>�K<OK�J:?FC8I�8E;�I<8;<I��$=�J:?FC8IJ�DLJK�_K�8�K<OK�K?<P�N@J?�KF�<E:F;<�@EKF�8�?@<I8I:?@:8C�JKIL:KLI<�;F<J�K?@J�D<8E�K?8K�J:?FC8IJ�8I<�@>EFI@E>� J@>E@_:8EK� K<OKL8C� I<C8K@FEJ?@GJ� K?8K� ;F� EFK� :FE=FID� KF� K?<�G8I<EK�:?@C;�8E;�J@9C@E>�DF;<C���<:8LJ<�K?<P�N<I<�EFK�FI@>@E8CCP�@E!K<E;<;�=FI�C@K<I8IP�J:?FC8IJ?@G�-"('�8E;�2('�:8EEFK�9<�8JJLD<;�KF�I<GI<J<EK�K?<�[KIL<\�E8KLI<�F=�K<OK�EFI�:8E�K?<P�9<�8JJLD<;�KF�9<�K?<�9<JK�C8E>L8><J�=FI�;<J:I@9@E>�K<OKJ��.?<�=8:K�K?8K�K?<J<�D8IBLG�C8E>L8>!<J�?8M<�9<<E�LJ<;�JL::<JJ=LC�;F<J�EFK�@E;@:8K<�K?8K�K?<I<�@J�EFK�IFFD�=FI�J@>E@_:8EK�@DGIFM<D<EK��$E�C@>?K�F=�K?<�?@JKFIP�8E;�C@D@K8K@FEJ�F=�:LI!I<EK�D8IBLG�GIF:<;LI<�C@K<I8IP�J:?FC8IJ�E<<;�KF�I<:C8@D�K?<@I�D<K?F;J�F=� KI8EJ:I@GK@FE��.?@J�D@>?K� EFK�D<8E� K?8K� K?<�*#�*�DF;<C� =FI� K<OK�<E:F;@E>� E<<;J� KF� 9<� 898E;FE<;��#FN<M<I� @K� @J� @DGFJJ@9C<� KF� ;<K<I!D@E<�K?<�:FII<:K�8GGIF8:?�KF�K<OK�<E:F;@E>�N@K?FLK�FG<E@E>�LG�8�C8I><I�;@J:LJJ@FE� 89FLK�N?8K� ;@>@K8C� ?LD8E@JKJ�N8EK� 8E;� E<<;� K?<@I�D8IBLG�C8E>L8><J�KF�GIFM@;<��

Page 85: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

77

KIRILLOFF

Page 86: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

78

Page 87: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

79

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � @ J � 8 � J< !E@FI � 8 K � K?<� /E@M<IJ@ KP � F= � +@ K KJ9LI>?� N?<I<� ?<�@J � 8 ���+?@ C � :8E;@;8K< � 8E;��I8:B<EI@;><� !<C CFN�JKL;P@E>� +FC @ K @:J+?@ CFJFG?P� 8E;� /I98E� -KL; !@<J � :FE:<EKI8K @E>� @E � /I98E� +FC @:P� 8E;��;D@E !@J K I8 K @FE� �#<�@J �-K8K @FE�(8E8><I �8 K ������1+.-!(� +@ K K ^J � I8;@F� J K8 K @FE � 8E;� @J � 8E� F::8J@FE8C�DLJ@: � :FCLDE@JK � =FI �The$Pi t t $News � K?IFL>?� K?<�:LII<EK � D<;@8 � G8I KE<IJ?@G� GIF>I8D� 9<KN<<E�1+.-�8E;�The$Pi t t $News.

N a t h a n i e l H a n s o n

Page 88: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

80

FFFORBES & FIFTH

O

FFIC

E OF UNDERGRADUATE RESEARCH - O.U.R.

Page 89: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

81

Rest Assured, We Can Save It AllCreem�(8>8Q@E<�8J�8�1FIB@E>��C8JJ��I@K@HL<�F=�K?<�'8K<���� J��8C@=FIE@8E��FLEK<I�LCKLI<1

1?@C<�FE�K?<�JLI=8:<�K?@J�:I@K@HL<�9P�'<JK<I��8E>J�J<<DJ�KF�9<�I<GIF8:?!@E>� 8E� 8L;@<E:<� @E:C@E<;� KF�NFIJ?@G� K?<�DLJ@:@8EJ� 8E;� 8IK@JKJ� F=� K?<���� J�=FI�K?<@I�JF:8CC<;�J<I@FLJ�D<JJ8><J��8E>J �JK8K<D<EK�@J�8:KL8CCP�@E;@:8K@M<�F=�8�:<IK8@E�9I8E;�F=�:LCKLI8C�:I@K@HL<���8E>J�8E;�?@J�<DGCFP!<I�Creem�D8>8Q@E<�JLIG8JJ<;�D<I<�DLJ@:8C�:I@K@:@JD��.?<�?<P;8P�F=�Creem�D8>8Q@E<�Z�8E;��8E>J�9P�<OK<EJ@FE�Z�@J�8�G<I@F;�:?8I8:K<I@Q<;�9P�8�:FCC<:K@M<�I<8:K@FE�KF�K?<�:LCKLI8C�KLDLCK�JK<DD@E>�=IFD�N@;<JGI<8;�=<<C@E>J�F=�8C@<E8K@FE�8DFE>�D8EP��D<I@:8E�D@;;C<�:C8JJ�:FCC<><�JKL!;<EKJ�F=�K?<�C8K<���� J�8E;�<8ICP���� J��.?@J�><E<I8K@FE�F=�D@;;C<�:C8JJ��D<I@:8EJ�N8J� I8@J<;� @E�8E�<EM@IFED<EK�F=�LEGI<:<;<EK<;�<:FEFD@:�GIFJG<I@KP�� -L9J<HL<EKCP� 8� ?@JKFI@:8CCP� LED8K:?<;� ELD9<I� F=� K?FJ<�9FIE�@EKF�K?<�:I8;C<�F=�E<N=FLE;��D<I@:8E�GIF>I<JJ�N<I<�<HL@GG<;�Z�_E8E:@8CCP�8E;�8:8;<D@:8CCP�Z�KF�<EIFCC� @E�GFJKJ<:FE;8IP�8:8;<D@:�@EJK@KLK@FEJ�:I<8K@E>�8�JLI><�F=�<:FEFD@:8CCP�J<:LI<�8E;�@EK<CC<:KL8CCP�:FEJ:@FLJ�PFLE>�D@;;C<�:C8JJ��D<I@:8EJ�N?FJ<�GI@D8IP�I<JGFEJ@9@C@KP�N8J�KF�<OGCFI<�8:8;<D@:�@EK<I<JKJ��� �J�.<IIP��E;<IJFE�JL>><JKJ�K?<�J?<<I�MFCLD<�F=�JKL;<EKJ�<E!IFCC@E>� @E�/�-��LE@M<IJ@K@<J� @E� K?@J� K@D<�G<I@F;�:I<8K<;� =<IK@C<�>IFLE;J�=FI�K?<�;@JJ<D@E8K@FE�F=�@;<8J�I<<O8D@E8K@FE�F=�:LCKLI8C�M8CL<J�8E;�K?<�GFK<EK@8C�=FI�JKL;<EKC<8;�:LCKLI8C�8E;�GFC@K@:8C�:?8E><�3�,LEE@E>�G8I8C!C<C�KF�K?@J�@E`LO�F=�D@;;C<�:C8JJ�JKL;<EKJ�N8J�K?<�;<M<CFGD<EK�F=�8�E<N�9I8E;�F=�IF:B�8E;�IFCC�>8@E@E>�GFGLC8I@KP�@E�GC8:<J�C@B<�-8E�!I8E:@J:F�8E;�'FJ��E><C<J�N?<I<�I<>@FE8C�8:KJ�9<>8E�KF�:LCK@M8K<�N@;<JGI<8;�=FC!CFN@E>J�:<EK<I<;�8DFE>�K?@J�E<N�B@E;�F=�:FCC<><�JKL;<EK��� 1?@C<�IF:B�8E;�IFCC�?8;�9<<E�@E:I<;@9CP�GFGLC8I�8DFE>��D<I@!:8E�PFLK?�J@E:<�K?<���� J�Z�EFK�KF�D<EK@FE�<HL8CCP�LEGFGLC8I�8DFE>�I<GI<J<EK8K@M<J�F=�D8@EJKI<8D��D<I@:8E�<JK89C@J?D<EK�Z�K?<�D<JJ8><J�

����$�������� ���������������� �������� ����#�������������������even$be$an$asshole$here$and$say$that$‘Nothing$is$truee$evBerything$is$permitted,’$which$is$true$as$a$matter$of$fact,$but$people$might$get$ the$wrong$idea.$What’s$ truest$ is$ that$you$cannot$enslave$a$fool.2

Page 90: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

82

LE;<ICP@E>� K?<�DLJ@:�N<I<� <OGI<JJCP� GFC@K@:8C� FECP� @EJFDL:?� 8J� K?<P�:FEK8@E<;�DFJKCP�M<@C<;�I<=<I<E:<J�KF�J<O�8E;�K?<�I<A<:K@FE�F=�KI8;@K@FE8C�EFIDJ�F=�8LK?FI@KP�Z�K?<�:?LI:?�K?<�J:?FFC�8E;�K?<�G8I<EK��1@K?�K?<�FEJ<K�F=�K?<�@E:I<8J@E>CP�<;L:8K<;�D@;;C<�:C8JJ�PFLK?�F=�K?<�� J�8E;�� J�?FN<M<I�K?<D<J�F=�J<OL8C@KP�8E;�PFLK?=LC�I<9<CC@FE�<OG8E;<;�KF�I<GI<!J<EK�DFI<�K?8E�ALJK�K<<E8><�8E>JK��@EJK<8;�KI8EJ=FID@E>�<OGI<JJ@FEJ�F=�K<<E8><�I<9<CC@FE�8E;�@JFC8K@FE�@EKF�J<C=:FEJ:@FLJCP�GFC@K@:8C�JK8K<D<EKJ�D<8EK�KF�GI<J<EK�M<IP�J<I@FLJ�:?8CC<E><J�KF�8::<GK<;�:LCKLI8C�EFIDJ�8E;�D<K?F;J�F=�JF:@<K8C�FI>8E@Q8K@FE��� �J� K?<� 989P9FFD<IJ� D8KLI<;� JF� ;@;� K?<@I� :LCKLI8C� :I@K@HL<��,F:B� 8E;� IFCC� 9<:8D<� @EK<IKN@E<;�N@K?� K?<� @EK<CC<:KL8CCP� :LI@FLJ� 8E;�GFC@K@:8CCP�:FEJ:@FLJ�D@;;C<�:C8JJ�PFLK?���CI<8;P�8�EFKFI@FLJ�8E;�GFG!LC8I�D<;@LD� =FI� K?<� <OGI<JJ@FE� F=� I<9<CC@FLJ� 9<?8M@FI� IF:B� 8E;� IFCC�>I<N�KF�D<<K�K?<�;<D8E;J�8E;�8KK@KL;<J�F=�@KJ�8L;@<E:<�I<`<:K@E>�K?<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<^J�I8G@;CP�;<M<CFG@E>�GFC@K@:8C�8E;�:LCKLI8C�:I@K@HL<�F=�K?<�E<NCP�<;L:8K<;��D<I@:8E�D@;;C<�:C8JJ��1?<I<8J� K?<� IF:B�8E;� IFCC�F=�K?<�� J�D8P�?8M<�J?F:B<;�G8I<EKJ�GI@E:@G8CJ�8E;�GI<8:?<IJ�K?<�IF:B�8E;� IFCC�F=� K?<�� J�8E;�� J�:?8CC<E><;� K?<�M<IP� JF:@8CGFC@K@:8C� @E=I8!JKIL:KLI<�LGFE�N?@:?�K?<P�N<I<�JLGGFIK<;��.?<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�?8;�@KJ�DLJ@:8C�D<;@LD�IF:B�8E;�IFCC�N?@:?�>I<N�KF�9<:FD<�@KJ�DFJK�GFGLC8I�8E;�GFN<I=LC�LE@=P@E>�=FI:<��1?8K�8IFJ<�FLK�F=�IF:B�8E;�IFCC^J�:FLEK<I:LCKLI8C�GIFD@E<E:<�?FN<M<I�N8J�8�;<D8E;�=FI�8�=FILD�F=�;@J:LJJ@FE�:I@K@:@JD�8E;�K?<�;@==LJ@FE�F=�K?@J�E<NCP�GFC@K@:8CCP�:FEJ:@FLJ�DLJ@:8C�@E:8IE8K@FE�� M<E� JK@CC�N?@C<�M8I@FLJ�GI@EK� GL9C@:8K@FEJ�N?<I<� JK8IK<;�KF�_CC�K?@J�E@:?<�Creem�<JK89C@J?<;�@KJ<C=�8J�[�D<I@:8^J�*ECP�,F:B�8E;�,FCC�(8>8Q@E<�\4��� Creem�N8J�8K�K?<�J8D<�K@D<�9FK?�8�G8IK�F=�K?@J�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�8E;�FE<�F=�@KJ�9@>><JK�:I@K@:J��1?@C<�Creem�N8J�8�JFLI:<�=FI�DLJ@:8C�Z�8E;�9P� <OK<EJ@FE� :LCKLI8C�Z�:FDD<EK8IP� K?8K� K?FL>?�?8I;<I<;><;�8E;�K?LJ��8I>L89CP��DFI<�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�K?8E�@KJ��8C@=FIE@8�:FLEK<IG8IK�Rolling$Stone�Creem’s�:FI<�M8CL<J�N<I<�JK@CC�M<IP�DL:?�@E�C@E<�N@K?�K?<�@;<8CJ�F=�D8EP�G8IKJ�F=�K?<��8C@=FIE@8�:FLEK<I:LCKLI8C�DFM<D<EK��Creem�D8>8Q@E<�JFL>?K�KF�GIFM@;<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI8C�@EJ@>?K�I<DFM<;�=IFD�K?<�@EK<CC<:KL8CCP?<@>?K<E<;�8E;�GI@M@C<><;��8C@=FIE@8�8:K@M@JK�8KK@KL;<�KPG@!:8CCP�8JJF:@8K<;�N@K?�K?<�DFM<D<EK���$E�<JJ<E:<�Creem�8E;�K?<��<KIF@K�IF:B�8E;�IFCC�JFLE;�N<I<�LE;FL9K<;CP�C@EB<;�@E�DL:?�K?<�J8D<�N8P�K?8K�Rolling$Stone�N8J�@KJ<C=�<JJ<EK@8CCP�9FLE;�KF�K?<��8C@=FIE@8�:FLEK<I:LC!KLI<�DLJ@:�J:<E<��Creem�K?IFL>?�@KJ�DLJ@:8C�8E;�:LCKLI8C�:I@K@:@JD�GIF!

Page 91: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

83

M@;<;�:FLEK<I:LCKLI8C�:I@K@HL<�=IFD�N@K?@E�K?<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�J<<B@E>�KF�LE@K<�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�I<8C@K@<J�N@K?�K?<�?@>?D@E;<;�@EK<CC<:KL8CCP�8E;�JG@I@KL8CCP�98J<;�@;<8CJ�F=� K?<��8C@=FIE@8�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<��.?@J�:I@K@HL<�N8J�D@IIFI<;�EFK�ALJK�@E�K<IDJ�F=�K?<�8KK@KL;<J�F=�@KJ�NI@K<IJ�9LK�G<I?8GJ�DFJK�@DGFIK8EKCP�K?<�8<JK?<K@:J�F=�K?<�98E;J�K?8K�Creem�:FM<I<;�� Creem’s�LE@HL<�GC8:<�N@K?@E�K?<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�@J�9<JK�LE;<I!JKFF;� @E� I<C8K@FE� KF� @KJ� -8E� !I8E:@J:F� I@M8C�Rolling$ Stone�� -K8IK<;� 8J�8E�LE;<I>IFLE;�D8>8Q@E<�;<;@:8K<;�KF�I<GFIK@E>�FE�K?<�-8E�!I8E:@J:F�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�Rolling$ Stone� N?@C<� EFK� 8J� GFC@K@:8CCP� I8;@:8C� 8J� K?<�Berkeley$Barb�8E;�FK?<I��8P��I<8�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�D8>8Q@E<J�=F:LJ<;�FE�K?<�DLJ@:�8E;�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�J:<E<�@E�-FLK?<IE��8C@=FIE@8��Rolling$Stone� @J�G<I?8GJ�K?<�CFE><JK�ILEE@E>�F=�K?<�� J�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�D8>8!Q@E<J�8E;�@J�JK@CC�@E�N@;<JGI<8;�:@I:LC8K@FE��.?@J�<E;LI8E:<�@J�@E;@:8K@M<�F=�Rolling$Stone^J� JL::<JJ� @E� K<IDJ�F=�<JK89C@J?@E>� @KJ<C=�8J�8�GI@D8IP�MF@:<�F=�K?<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�DFM<D<EK��� $=�K?@J�@J�@E�=8:K�KIL<�8E;�Rolling$Stone�N8J�@E;<<;�K?<�MF@:<�F=�K?<���� J�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<� K?<E�Creem�:FLC;�9<�:FEJ@;<I<;�K?<�DFM<!D<EK^J�N8K:?;F>��Creem�N8J�JG<8B@E>�=FI�8E;� KF� K?<�[C8JK� =IFEK@<I\��Z�9CL<�:FCC8I�KFNEJ�K?8K�8CK?FL>?�K?<P�?8;�9<<E�98JK@FEJ�F=�K?<�C89FI�DFM<D<EKJ�F=�K?<��D<I@:8E�'<=K�F=�K?<���� J�N<I<�DL:?�DFI<�JF:@8CCP�:FEJ<IM8K@M<�K?8E�K?<�D8AFI�LI98E�:<EK<IJ�8E;�:FCC<><�KFNEJ�8JJF:@8K<;�N@K?�K?<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�DFM<D<EK�F=�K?<�� J��� $E� @E;LJKI@8C� �<KIF@K� K?<� I<8C@K@<J� F=� K?<� <M<IP;8P� FM<IGFN!<I<;�K?<�[�8C@=FIE@8��I<8D@E>\��@;<8C@JD�F=�K?<�GI<;FD@E8K<CP�D@;;C<�:C8JJ:<EK<I<;�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�DFM<D<EK�� $=� [GJP:?<;<C@:;FD\�� :FLC;�GIFM@;<�8�DFI<�=LC_CC@E>�N8P�F=�C@=<�K?8E�K?<�JK8KLJ�HLF�Creem’s��8M<�

(8IJ?� 8I>L<;� K?<E� @K� DLJK�9<�ALJK�8J�<==<:K@M<�8DFE>�K?<�PFLK?�F=�K?<�@E;LJKI@8C�NFIB!@E>� :C8JJ� 8J� @K�N8J�N@K?� K?<�@EK<CC<:KL8CCP� 8E;� JG@I@KL8CCP�:FEJ:@FLJ� :FCC<><<;L:8K<;�D@;;C<� :C8JJ� K?8K� F::LG@<;�D8AFI�LI98E�:LCKLI8C�:<EK<IJ�8E;� C@9<I8C� :FCC<><� KFNEJ���8C@=FIE@8�N8J�=<IK@C<�>IFLE;�

=FI�@;<8C@JK@:�EFK@FEJ�F=�I<8JFE�=I<<;FD�8E;�CFM<��� J��<KIF@K�FE�K?<�FK?<I�?8E;�N8J�8J�:CFJ<�KF�98II<E�I<8C@KP�8J�:@K@<J�:FD<���::FDGC@J?@E>�

HANSON

“70s$Detroit...was$as$close$to$barren$reality$as$cities$come.$Accomplishing$real$change$in$towns$like$Detroit$was$the$counterBculture’s$true$

challenge.”

Page 92: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

84

I<8C�:?8E><�@E�KFNEJ�C@B<��<KIF@K�N8J�K?<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<^J�KIL<�:?8CC<E><�����J�(8IJ?�J8N�@K�[�LK�@=�N<�5K?<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<6�:8E�J8M<�K?<�(FKFI��@KP�I<JK�8JJLI<;�N<�:8E�J8M<�@K�8CC�\9��� .?<� :FLEK<I:LCKLI<� F=� K?<� C8K<� � J� N8J� @E� K?<��D<I@:8E� :FE!J:@FLJE<JJ� HL@EK<JJ<EK@8CCP��8C@=FIE@8E� 9FK?�DLJ@:8CCP� 8E;� ><F>I8G?@!:8CCP�� @K�N8J� EFID8K@M<CP� I<C8O<;� @EK<CC<:KL8CCP� I8;@:8C� 8E;� :?8I8:K<I!@JK@:8CCP�D@;;C<:C8JJ��,F:B�8E;�IFCC�?8;�9<<E�GFGLC8I�8DFE>��D<I@:8E�PFLK?�J@E:<� CM@J�+I<JC<P^J�I@J<�KF�=8D<�@E�K?<�� J�9LK�@K�N8JE^K�LEK@C�K?<�DFM<D<EKJ�F=�K?<�D@;KFC8K<�� J�8E;�<8ICP�� J�K?8K�@K�9<:8D<�8�=FILD�=FI�<OGC@:@K�GFC@K@:8C�8E;�:LCKLI8C�:FDD<EK8IP��� �8E;J�=IFD�-8E�!I8E:@J:F^J��8P��I<8�JL:?�8J�%<==<IJFE��@IGC8E<�8E;�K?<�"I8K<=LC��<8;�8J�N<CC�8J�FK?<I�DLJ@:8C�8:KJ�8JJF:@8K<;�N@K?�K?<��8C@=FIE@8�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�Z�C@B<�.?<�(8D8J���.?<�+8G8J�8E;�.?<��FFIJ�Z�I<GI<J<EK<;�K?<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�@E�K?<��D<I@:8E�:FEJ:@FLJE<JJ��(8EP�F=�K?<J<�>IFLGJ�G8IK@:LC8ICP�%<==<IJFE��@IGC8E<�8C@>E<;�K?<DJ<CM<J�N@K?�K?<�GFC@K@:8C�:8LJ<J�8JJF:@8K<;�N@K?�K?<�JKL;<EK�DFM<D<EKJ�F=�K?<�� J�Z�JL:?�8J�FGGFJ@K@FE�KF�K?<�0@<KE8D�18I�Z�8J�N<CC�8J�DFI<�I8;@:8C�E<NC<=K�JK8E:<J�F=�GFC@K@:8CCP�8:K@M<�JKL;<EK�>IFLGJ�C@B<�-KL;<EKJ�=FI�8��<DF:I8K@:�-F:@<KP�10��8C@=FIE@8�KF�D8EP�N8J�K?<�<G@:<EK<I�F=�K?@J�JKL;<EKC<8;�G?<!EFD<EFE��@K�N8J�?FD<�KF�K?<�!I<<�-G<<:?�(FM<D<EK11�#8@>?K�J?9LIP�#@GG@<J�8E;��C8:B�+FN<I���J� @K�N8J�;@JGC8P<;� @E� K?<�D<;@8� K?<�9F?<!D@8EJ�?@GG@<J�8E;�I8;@:8C�GFC@K@:8C� @EK<CC<:KL8CJ�8CC� KI8@E<;�@E�8CC�:8CC<;��8C@=FIE@8�[?FD<�\12���� ��� J��<KIF@K�N8J�M<IP�=8I�=IFD��8C@=FIE@8�9FK?�><F>I8G?@:8CCP�8E;�8<JK?<K@:8CCP��Creem�J?FN:8J<;�K?<�:FEE<:K@FE�9<KN<<E�8�M<IP�G8I!K@:LC8I�KPG<�F=�LEGI<K<EK@FLJ�IF:B�8E;�IFCC�8E;�K?<�GFJJ@9@C@KP�F=�8�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�K?8K�N8J�8�M8I@8K@FE�F=�K?<�DLJ@:�8E;�JKL;<EK�DFM<D<EKJ�@E��8C@!=FIE@8�

The$alternative$culture$in$the$Detroit/Ann$Arbor$comB����� � ��� $���� ��� ��������� � ����� "�� ����� ���������Whatever$movement$we$have$here$grew$out$of$ rock$"������������ �������"�������������������$������������out$ of$ our$ intellectual$ covens$ and$ suburban$ shells.$We$got$ excited$by$and$about$ the$music$and$ started$relating$to$each$other$on$a$high$plane$of$energy$that$has$come$to$be$associated$with$our$communitye$it$is$around$the$music$that$the$community$has$grown$and$it$is$the$music$which$holds$the$community$together.13$$$$

Page 93: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

85

1?<I<8J�K?<��8C@=FIE@8E�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�?<C;�K?8K�GFC@K@:J�8CK<IE8K@M<C@=<!JKPC<�8E;�;@==<I@E>�;<>I<<J�F=�C<=K@JK�GFC@K@:J�:<EK<I<;�K?<�DFM<D<EK�N@K?�DLJ@:�9<@E>�8�GI@D8IP�=FI:<�=FI�K?<�<OGI<JJ@FE�F=�E<N�@;<8J�8E;�8IK@JK@:�:FDDLE@KP�K?<I<�N8J�EFK?@E>�DFI<�@DGFIK8EK�KF�Creem�K?8E�K?<�DLJ@:��"FF;�DLJ@:�9P�Creem’s�JK8E;8I;J�?8;�K?<�89@C@KP�KF�9I<8B�;FNE�GFC@K@:8C�8E;�:LCKLI8C�98II@<IJ�9LK�8K�K?<�J8D<�K@D<�N8J�@E�@KJ�GLI<JK�=FID�<E<I!>@Q<;�>I@KKP�8E;�@II<M<I<EK��.?@J�@II<M<I<E:<�;@;E^K�E<:<JJ8I@CP�`FN�=IFD�GFC@K@:8C�@;<FCF>P�FI�EFID8K@M<�I<<M8CL8K@FEJ�9LK�@E��8E>J �K<ID@EFCF>P�=I<<;�G<FGC<�=IFD�8CC�I<JKI@:K@FEJ��K?<�DLJ@:�N8JE^K��@E?<I<EKCP��GFC@K@:8C�K?<�GFC@K@:J�N<I<�@E�<==<:K�DLJ@:8C��.?8K�@J�<M<IPK?@E>�89FLK�K?<�:FLEK<I!:LCKLI<�K?8K�K?<�NI@K<IJ�F=�Creem�9<C@<M<;�@E�N8J�;<I@M<;�=IFD�K?<�DLJ@:��I8;@:8C�8E;�LE:FDGIFD@J@E>�DLJ@:�:C<8I<;�K?<�N8P�=FI�>IFLE;<;�@;<8CJ�KF�=FCCFN��#@JKFI@8E�(@:?8<C�&I8D<I�NI@K<J��

� 1?@C<�� J��<KIF@K�D8P�?8M<�9<<E�8J�LE@;<8C�8J� K?<P�:FD<� @KJ�IF:B�8E;�IFCC�J:<E<�8;;<;�8�LE@HL<�JFLE;�KF�K?<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<��.?<�98E;J�=IFD��<KIF@K�;LI@E>�K?@J�G<I@F;�N<I<�8K�K?<@I�M<IP�:FI<�=LE�Z�K?<�M8CL<�K?8K�Creem�G<I?8GJ�GC8:<;�@E�K?<�?@>?<JK�I<>8I;����J��8E>J�NIFK<�[1?8K^J�KIL<JK�@J�K?8K�PFL�:8EEFK�<EJC8M<�8�=FFC�\14��.?8K�@J�K?<�=LE:<EKI@:��8C9<@K�@E�JFD<�:8J<J�<OGC@:@KCP�GFC@K@:8C��D<JJ8><�F=�K?<��<KIF@K�J:<E<�JKI@GG<;�8N8P�K?<�E8SM<KR�F=�K?<��8P��I<8^J�<8IE<JKE<JJ�����@=_:LCK�KF�;<_E<�K?<��<KIF@K� IF:B� 8E;� IFCC� JFLE;�N8J� CFL;<I�DFI<�DLJ@:8CCP� J@DGC@JK@:� 8E;�DFI<�89I8J@M<CP�<E<I>@Q<;�K?8E�K?<�KPG@:8C��8P��I<8�IF:B�8E;�IFCC�98E;��-G<8B@E>�@E�@;<8C�K<IDJ�K?<�IF:B�8E;�IFCC�F=��<KIF@K�N8J�M<IP�DL:?�I<`<:!K@M<�F=�K?<�<:FEFD@:�:C@D8K<�8E;�J:<E<IP�F=�K?<�KFNE�@KJ<C=��1?<I<8J�K?<�DLJ@:�8E;�JG@I@K�F=�%FE@�(@K:?<CC�8E;��IFJ9P�-K@CC�)8J?�8E;�3FLE>�C@M<;�@E�K?<�#8@>?K�K?<�JK8K<�F=�K?<�(FKFI��@KP�N8J�M<IP�DL:?�@E�C@E<�N@K?�$>>P�+FG�8E;�K?<�(������

Though$it$emerged$within$a$countercultural$milieu$in$Detroit,$Creem$did$not$express$a$simple,$naïve$idealism$about$revolutionizing$cultural$and$politiBcal$life$in$the$United$States.$Instead$the$magazine$attempted$ to$ develop$ a$ critique$ of$ the$ counterBculture$in$which$it$participated,$while$refusing$to$give$up$on$that$counterculture’s$utopian$dream$of$transforming$Cold$War$America$into$a$more$just,$vital,$meaningful,$and$fun$society.$

HANSON

Page 94: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

86

� !LE�=8JK�8E;�CFL;�K?<�(���G<IJFE@_<;�K?<��<KIF@K��8E;�Creem��8<JK?<K@:��1?@C<�Creem�F=K<E�I<=<II<;�KF�K?<�(���8J�K?<�I<GI<J<EK8K@M<J�F=�K?<��<KIF@K�IF:B�JFLE;�K?<P�N<I<�8CJF�FE<�F=�K?<�=<N��<KIF@K�98E;J�KF�8JJF:@8K<�K?<DJ<CM<J�N@K?�8E�<OGC@:@K�GFC@K@:8C�:8LJ<�Z�K?<�1?@K<�+8E!K?<IJ����(���D8E8><I�%F?E�-@E:C8@I�JK8IK<;�K?<�1?@K<�+8EK?<IJ�8J�8E�FLKC<K�=FI�K?FJ<�N?F�8>I<<;�N@K?�K?<��C8:B�+8EK?<I�+8IKP^J�@;<8J�9LK�?8G!G<E<;�KF�9<��8L:8J@8E���DFE>�K?<�D8@E�GF@EKJ�F=�K?<�1?@K<�+8EK?<I^J�D8E@=<JKF�N<I<�:8CCJ�=FI��[8�KFK8C�8JJ8LCK�FE�K?<�:LCKLI<�9P�8EP�D<8EJ�E<:<JJ8IP�@E:CL;@E>�IF:B�8E;�IFCC�;FG<�8E;�=L:B@E>�@E�K?<�JKI<<KJ�8E;�K?<�=I<<�<O:?8E><�F=�<E<I>P�8E;�D8K<I@8CJZN<�;<D8E;�K?<�<E;�F=�DFE!<P�\���1@K?�8� I8;@:8CCP�[C<=K@JK\� @EK<EK@FE8CCP� J?F:B@E>�D8E@=<JKF� K?<�1?@K<�+8EK?<IJ�GIFM@;<;�8E�8GGIFGI@8K<�GFC@K@:8C�I<GI<J<EK8K@FE�F=�K?<�DLJ@:�F=�K?<�(����.?<�(���?FN<M<I�JK@CC�=FCCFN<;�K?<��<KIF@K�Creem�DLJ@:8CGFC@K@:8C�@;<FCF>P�Z�K?<P�N<I<�_IJK�8E;�=FI<DFJK�8E�<E<I>@Q<;�@II<M<I<EK�8E;�=LE�98E;�<M<E�@E�JG@K<�F=�K?<@I�GFC@K@:8C�D<JJ8><��� .?<�DLJ@:�F=�K?<�(���GFC@K@:J�8J@;<�N8J�8�D<;@LD�F=�8N8B<E!@E>�F=�N?@:?�GFC@K@:8C�@;<8J�N<I<�FECP�FE<�:FDGFE<EK�Y�FE<�<OGC@:@KCP�J<:FE;8IP�KF�K?<�DLJ@:�@KJ<C=��.?<I<�@J�?FN<M<I�FE<�JKI@B@E>CP�KIFL9C@E>�GIF9C<D�N@K?�K?<�DLJ@:�K?8K�Creem�:?I@JK<E<;�8J�:?8I8:K<I@JK@:�F=� K?<�(FKFI��@KP��@K�E<>C<:K<;�K?<�DLJ@:�K?8K�?8;�GLK��<KIF@K�FE�K?<�GFG�:LC!KLI<�D8G�� .?<�EFK89C<�MF@;�@E�Creem’s�FK?<IN@J<�:FDGI<?<EJ@M<�I<>@FE8C�DLJ@:�:FM<I8><�N8J� K?<�8:KL8C�(FKFNE�-FLE;�Z�K?<�,���8E;�-FLC�DLJ@:� ;@JKI@9LK<;� 8E;� GIF;L:<;� 9P� �<KIF@K� @E;<G<E;<EK� I<:FI;� C89<C�(FKFNE�,<:FI;J�Z�K?8K�?8;�9<:FD<�JPEFEPDFLJ�N@K?��<KIF@K��(F!KFNE�,<:FI;J�9<:8D<�K?<�_IJK�[:IFJJFM<I\�I<:FI;�C89<C�@E�K?<�/-�:LC!K@M8K@E>�8�JKI@E>�F=�?@KJ�9P�8IK@JKJ�C@B<�.?<�-LGI<D<J�.?<�.<DGK8K@FEJ�8E;�-DFB<P�,F9@EJFE��.?<J<�8IK@JKJ�9<:8D<�@E:I<;@9CP�GFGLC8I�8DFE>�9C8:B�8E;�N?@K<�8L;@<E:<J�8C@B<�9<:FD@E>�8�JFLI:<�F=�GI@;<�=FI�K?<�:@K@!Q<EJ�F=��<KIF@K��� +8I8;FO@:8CCP�@E�8�:@KP�K?8K�8KKI8:K<;�C8I><�ELD9<IJ�F=�JFLK?<IE��=I@:8E�D<I@:8EJ�;LI@E>�K?<�>I<8K�D@>I8K@FE�M@8�8�9FFD@E>�D8EL=8:!KLI@E>�@E;LJKIP�8�C8I><�GFIK@FE�F=�K?<�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�K?8K�Creem�J<<D<;�KF�8JJF:@8K<�@KJ<C=�N@K?�N8J�@E�=8:K�9C8:B��Creem�8�KFFC�F=�:C8JJ�LE@_:8!K@FE� @E� K?<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�DFM<D<EK� J<<DJ� KF�?8M<�<O:CL;<;�8C9<@K�LE@EK<EK@FE8CCP�8�D8AFI�G@<:<�F=��<KIF@K^J�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�@D8><�=IFD�@KJ�G8><J�Z���=I@:8E��D<I@:8EJ�8E;�9C8:B�DLJ@:��$K�:FLC;�9<�J8@;�K?<E�K?8K�

Page 95: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

87

8�C8I><�GFIK@FE�F=�K?<�DLJ@:8C�;<D8E;�F=�K?<�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�@E��<KIF@K�N8J�=FI�DLJ@:�K?8K�N8J�FLKJ@;<�F=�Creem’s�>I@KKP�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�IF:B�8E;�IFCC�@;<8C��� �J�GFGLC8I�8J�(FKFNE�8IK@JKJ�9<:8D<�N@K?@E� K?<�D8@EJKI<8D�K?<�><E<I8C�:FEJ<EJLJ�8DFE>�K?<�FGGI<JJ<;�9C8:B�GFGLC8K@FE�F=��<KIF@K�N8J�K?8K�K?<�(FKFNE�JFLE;�N?@C<�<E>8>@E>�8E;�<EK<IK8@E@E>�;@;�EFK�8K� C<8JK� LEK@C� 8=K<I� K?<� ����� I@FKJ� I<`<:K� K?<� GFC@K@:8C� <:FEFD@:� 8E;�JF:@8C�@JJL<J�F=�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ��=I@:8E��D<I@:8EJ��1?@C<�@K�N8J�KIL<�K?8K�9<=FI<�K?<�������<KIF@K�,@FKJ�(FKFNE�8IK@JKJ�N<I<�J@E>@E>�89FLK�J<OL8C!@Q<;�CFM<�K?<P�N<I<�DFJK�;<_E@K<CP�EFK�8;;I<JJ@E>�K?<�I8DG8EK�I8:@JD�GFM<IKP�8E;�FGGI<JJ@FE�=8:<;�9P��<KIF@K^J�@EE<I:@KP��=I@:8E��D<I@:8E�GFGLC8K@FE�����CK?FL>?�(FKFNE�?@KJ�N<I<�D8;<�9P�9C8:B�8IK@JKJ�=IFD�K?<�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�@K�N8J�DLJ@:�K?8K�N8J�D<8EK�KF�I8:@8CCP�:IFJJFM<I�KF�I<8:?�K?<�N@;<JK�8L;@<E:<�GFJJ@9C<�EFK�E<:<JJ8I@CP�I<GI<J<EK�K?<�@EK<I<JKJ�F=�K?<�9C8:B�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ��� 1?@C<�Creem�;@;�JGFI8;@:8CCP�:FM<I�9C8:B�8IK@JKJ�JL:?�8J�.@E8�.LIE<I20�8E;�K?<��<KIF@K�98J<;�"<FI><��C@EKFE�+8IC@8D<EK21�K?<J<�DL!J@:@8EJ�N<I<�8I>L89CP�DFI<�GFGLC8I�N@K?� IF:B�8E;� IFCC� =F:LJ<;�N?@K<�8L;@<E:<J� K?8E� ,��� 8E;� -FLC� =F:LJ<;� 9C8:B� 8L;@<E:<J�� �C@EKFE� =FI�<O8DGC<�?8;�D@>I8K<;�KF��<KIF@K�N@K?�.?<�+8IC@8D<EKJ��8J�+8IC@8D<EK�N8J�FI@>@E8CCP�E8D<;��N@K?�?FG<J�F=�J<:LI@E>�8�:FEKI8:K�N@K?�(FKFNE�,<:FI;J��/EJL::<JJ=LC��C@EKFE� 9<>8E� KF� K8B<� EFK<� F=� K?<� 8>>I<JJ@M<�I?PK?D?<8MP�DLJ@:�F=�K?<�(����.?<�+8IC@8D<EKJ�9<:8D<�+8IC@8D<EK�8�>IFLG�F=�9C8:B�DLJ@:@8EJ�N?F�D<I><;�K?<�+FG�,���(FKFNE�JFLE;�N@K?�K?<�CFL;�8E;�8>>I<JJ@M<�IF:B�8E;�IFCC�F=�K?<�(���KF�:I<8K<�8�E<N�><EI<��!LEB��1?@C<�!LEB�NFLC;�:FD<�KF�9<�8JJF:@8K<;�N@K?�K?<�JKIL>>C<J�F=�GFFI��=I@:8E��D<I@:8EJ�898E;FE<;�@E��D<I@:8^J�@EE<I:@K@<J�+8IC@8!D<EK�N8J�><E<I8CCP�C@JK<E<;�KF�9P�N?@K<�IF:B�8E;�IFCC�PFLK?J�@E��<KIF@K�22��� Creem’s� J<<D@E>CP� ;@JD@JJ@M<� 8KK@KL;<� KFN8I;� K?<� (FKFNE�JFLE;�J<IM<J�8J�8�GIF9C<D8K@:�@E:FEJ@JK<E:P�@E�Creem’s�I<>@FE8CCP�98J<;�8<JK?<K@:��.?<�=8:K�K?8K�!LEB�8�><EI<�N@K?�:CFJ<�K@<J�KF�K?<�9C8:B�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�;LI@E>�K?<���� J�@E�G8IK�;<J:<E;<;�=IFD�8�Creem<E;FIJ<;�98E;�C@B<�K?<�(���;F<J�?<CG�KF�G8IK@8CCP�8CC<M@8K<�NFII@<J�89FLK�Creem’s�I<C8!K@FEJ?@G�N@K?�I8:<�K?<�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�8E;�K?<�:FLEK<I�:LCKLI<��$K�J?FLC;�9<�EFK<;�K?8K�Creem’s�FM<ICP�N?@K<�=F:LJ�;F<J�?8M<�8�E<>8K@M<�@DG8:K�@E�K<IDJ�F=�Creem’s�:I<;@9@C@KP�8J�8�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�:I@K@HL<�F=�K?<��8C@=FIE@8�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�EFK�KF�D<EK@FE�K?<�:I<;@9@C@KP�F=�@KJ�G8IK@:LC8I�9I8E;@E>�

HANSON

Page 96: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

88

F=�K?<��<KIF@K�JFLE;�8E;�<K?FJ�8J�8E>IP�=LE�8E;�J@DGC@JK@:8CCP�@II<M<I!<EK�� .?<��<KIF@K� <K?FJ�N8J�<JJ<EK@8C� KF�Creem�D8>8Q@E<^J�LE@HL<�FG@E@FE8K<;�JC8EK�FE�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�DLJ@:�8E;�@;<8CJ��Creem�8KK<DGK<;�KF�K8B<�N?8K�N8J�8�:FCC<><�G?<EFD<EFE��FI�8K�K?<�M<IP�C<8JK�8�G?<EFD!<EFE�K8B@E>�GC8:<�@E� KI8;@K@FE8CCP�:LCKLI8CCP�8;M8E:<;�:@K@<J�8E;�@EK<C!C<:KL8C�KFNEJ��8E;�KI8EJGFJ<�@K�KF�K?<�:LCKLI8C�B<P�F=�N?8K�N8J�8�I8G@;CP�@E;LJKI@8CCP;<K<I@FI8K@E>��D<I@:8��1?@C<�Creem�:FLC;�9<�J<<E�8J�GIF!DFK@E>�DLJ@:�K?8K�N8J�9FK?�DLJ@:8CCP�8E;�:I@K@:8CCP�J@DGC@JK@:�K?8K�N8J�K?<�GF@EK��(LJ@:@8EJ�Z�KF��8E>J�(8IJ?�8E;�Creem�Z�;@;E^K�?8M<�KF�9<�M@IKLFJFJ��� '@B<N@J<�K?<�D<JJ8><�9<?@E;�IF:B�8E;�IFCC�;@;E^K�?8M<�KF��8E;�9P��8E>J �8JJ<JJD<EK�:FLC;E^K��9<�;<<G�8E;�:FDGC<O��.?<��<KIF@K�<K?FJ�FECP�I<HL@I<;�IF:B�8E;�IFCC� KF�9<� @II<M<I<EK�8E;�I8N��.?@J� @II<M<I<E:<�@E�DLJ@:8C� JKPC@E>�NFLC;� 8I>L89CP� C<8;� KF� @II<M<I<E:<� FE� K?<� <EK@I<�:LCKLI8CGFC@K@:8C�GC8E<��[5�8E>J^6�M@J@FE�GFJ@K@FE<;�IF:B�8J�E<@K?<I��IK�N@K?�8�:8G@K8C���EFI�+FC@K@:J�N@K?�8�:8G@K8C�+�9LK�8J�8�KI8J?P�:FEJLD<I�:FDDF;@KP�N?FJ<�@DG<ID8E<EK�8E;�;<I@M8K@M<�JFLE;J�:FLC;�FLK�F=�8�J<<D@E>�JLG<I_:@8C@KP�D8B<�K?<�B@E<K@:XAFP=LC�<E<I>@<J�F=�<OGI<JJ@FE�N@;<CP�8M8@C89C<�\23��� $E�<==<:K�DL:?�F=�K?<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�DFM<D<EK�N8J�D8;<�LG�F=�K?FJ<�N?F�N<I<�GI@M@C<><;�KF�JFD<�;<>I<<��$E;<<;�K?<��89P��FFD<I�><E<I8K@FE�F=�K?<�� J�8E;�<8ICP�� J�N8J�LEK@C�K?8K�GF@EK�K?<�DFJK�GI@M@!C<><;�><E<I8K@FE�@E�?LD8E�?@JKFIP�KF�K?<�<OK<EK�K?8K�JL:?�8�C8I><�ELD9<I�F=�G<FGC<�:FLC;�8==FI;�KF�=FI>F�<DGCFPD<EK�8E;�:FEK@EL<�K?<@I�<;L:8!K@FE�8K�K?<�:FCC<><�C<M<C��'@B<N@J<�K?<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�K?8K�>I<N�FLK�F=�K?@J�DFM<D<EK�N8J�><E<I8CCP� :FDGFJ<;�F=� G<FGC<�N@K?� K?<�D<8EJ� KF�JLGGFIK�K?<@I�;@M<�@EKF�I8;@:8C�GFC@K@:J�8E;�FI�8�?@GG@<�C@=<JKPC<��� 1?<I<8J� I8;@:8C� C<=K@JK� GFC@K@:J� NFLC;� 8CN8PJ� ?8M<� 8� :<IK8@E�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�8GG<8C��D8EP�F=�K?<J<�DFM<D<EKJ�=F:LJ<;�FE�NFIB<I^J�I@>?KJ�8=K<I�8CC��?8M@E>�K?<�D<8EJ�KF�9<�8E�8:K@M@JK�FLKJ@;<�F=�8�C89FI�FI>8E@Q8K@FE�EFK�KF�D<EK@FE�K?<�89@C@KP�KF�C@M<�8E�F==K?<>I@;�?@GGP�C@=<!JKPC<�N8J�@E�JFD<�N8PJ�8K�F;;J�N@K?�K?<�:?F@:<J�8M8@C89C<�KF�K?FJ<�F=�K?<�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ��.?<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI8C�DFM<D<EK�?FN<M<I� 8J�;<D!FEJKI8K<;� K?IFL>?� K?<� @;<8J�F=� >IFLGJ� C@B<�-KL;<EKJ� =FI� 8��<DF:I8K@:�-F:@<KP�JFL>?K�KF�:FDGC<K<CP�KI8EJ=FID�JF:@<KP�K?IFL>?�LE@M<IJ8C�<D!GFN<ID<EK�F=�8CC�G<FGC<��$E�FI;<I�KF�9<�JL::<JJ=LC�I8;@:8C�;<DF:I8K@:�

Page 97: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

89

JF:@FGFC@K@:8C�:?8E><J�DLJK�9<�LE@M<IJ8CCP�@E:CLJ@M<��� $K� @J�?<I<�K?8K�8�GIF9C<D�8I@J<J��?FN�:8E�8�DFM<D<EK�C@B<�K?<�� J�8E;�� J�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�8�DFM<D<EK�GI<;FD@E8EKCP�:FDGFJ<;�F=�K?<�D@;;C<�8E;�LGG<I�:C8JJ<J�><EL@E<CP�<DGFN<I�D<D9<IJ�F=�K?<�CFN<I�8E;�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ<J�N?FD�K?<P�DLJK�:LCKLI8CCP�GFC@K@:8CCP�8E;�JF:@8CCP�@E:CL;<�KF�<O<:LK<�:FII<JGFE;@E>�LE@M<IJ8C�:LCKLI8C�GFC@K@:8C�8E;�JF:@8C�:?8E><J��Creem�I<8:?<;�FLK�KF�8C@<E8K<;�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�PFLK?�K?IFL>?�@KJ�:FEE<:K@FE�KF�@E;LJKI@8C��<KIF@K�8E;�K?<�:@KP^J�G8IK@:LC8ICP�>I@KKP�9I8E;�F=�IF:B�8E;�IFCC�KF�KI8EJGFJ<�K?<�D<JJ8><J�F=�D@;;C<�:C8JJ�@;<8CJ�KF�NFIB!@E>�:C8JJ�I<8C@K@<J�>I8EK@E>�@K�8�LE@HL<�GC8:<�N@K?@E�K?<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�DFM<D<EK�F=�K?<�� J�8E;�<8ICP�� J��� 1?<K?<I�Creem’s�I<JLCKJ�8:KL8CCP�I<`<:K<;�K?<�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�8K!K@KL;<�8E;�@E;LJKI@8C�>I@KK@E<JJ�F=��<KIF@K�?FN<M<I�@J�;<98K89C<��1?@C<�K?<��<KIF@K�DLJ@:@8EJ�:FM<I<;�9P�Creem�JL:?�8J�K?<�(��24�D8P�?8M<�>IFNE�LG�@E�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�?FD<J�8E;�GIFM@;<;�:<IK8@E�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�>I@K�KF�K?<@I�DLJ@:�Creem’s�><E<I8C�8L;@<E:<�N?@C<�G<I?8GJ�DFI<�A8;<;�8E;�>I@KKP�@KJ<C=�N8J�EFK�E<:<JJ8I@CP�8EPDFI<�I<GI<J<EK8K@M<�F=�K?<�NFIB!@E>�:C8JJ�K?8E�K?<�I<8;<IJ�F=�Rolling$Stone�N<I<�@E�K?<�_IJK�GC8:<��1FIB!@E>�:C8JJ�<==<:K@M<E<JJ�8E;�8LK?<EK@:@KP�8J@;<�Creem�;@;�F==<I�D8@EC8E;��D<I@:8� K?<� @E;LJKI@8C�8<JK?<K@:�F=��<KIF@K�GIFDFK@E>�DLJ@:� K?8K�N8J�D8;<� =IFD�N@K?@E� K?<� J?8;FNJ�F=� @E;LJKI@8C�;<:8P�Z�JFD<K?@E>�:<I!K8@ECP�LE@HL<�@E�8�DFM<D<EK�F=�`FN<I�:?@C;I<E�8E;��8P��I<8�@;<8C@JD�� 1?@C<�Creem�;@;�EFK�J8M<�K?<�(FKFI��@KP�@K�N8JE^K�=FI�8�C8:B�F=�:I@K@:8C�K8JK<��.?<�DLJ@:�K?8K�Creem�:FM<I<;�8E;�GIFDFK<;�Y�K?<�#<8MP�(<K8C� 8E;�+LEB� =FI<=8K?<IJ� K?8K�Rolling$ Stone� F=K<EK@D<J� FM<ICFFB<;�Z�<M<EKL8CCP� @E`L<E:<;�GFN<I=LC�DLJ@:8C�DFM<D<EKJ� @E� K?<DJ<CM<J��.?<�+LEB�F=� K?<� C8K<�� J�8E;�<8ICP�� J� K?8K� $>>P�+FG�(���8E;�.?<�0<CM<K�/E;<I>IFLE;�=FI<J?8;FN<;�9<:8D<�FE<�F=� K?<�GI@D8IP�><EI<J�F=�GFC@K@:8CCP:FEJ:@FLJ�DLJ@:�F=�8�C8K<I�><E<I8K@FE����1?<I<8J�Rolling$Stone�J?@<;�8N8P�=IFD�K?<J<�8IK@JKJ�Creem�<D9I8:<;�K?<D�8J�K?<�JFLE;�F=�K?<�=LKLI<�8E;�@E�8�N8P�K?<P�N<I<�I@>?K��� $E�G8IK@8C�K<IDJ�Creem’s�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�@E;LJKI@8C�:I@K@HL<�F=�K?<�GFGLC8I�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�;@;�JL::<<;��Creem’s��<KIF@K�8<JK?<K@:�Z�JEFKKP�NFIB@E>�:C8JJ�@II<M<I<E:<�@E=LJ<;�N@K?�<E<I><K@:�=LIP�Z�;@;�@E�K?<�<E;�9I@E>�K?<�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�KF�K?<�D8JJ<J�<M<E�@=�@K�KFFB�8�><E<I8K@FE�FI�KNF�KF�K8B<�?FC;���?<8;�F=�@KJ�K@D<�Creem�D8>8Q@E<�GIFM<;�K?8K��<KIF@K�N8J�8=K<I�8CC�K?<�C8JK�=IFEK@<I�

HANSON

Page 98: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

90

Page 99: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

91

� � � � � � � � � � � �>I<N�LG�@E �+<IIPFGF !C @J �+� �8 �JD8CC �KFNE�JFLK?�F= �+@ K KJ9LI>?�N?FJ<�D8@E� 8K K I8:K @FE� @J � 8 � >I @J KD@C C � �#<� @J � 8 � J<E@FI � 8 K�K?<� /E@M<IJ@ KP � F= � +@ K KJ9LI>?� D8AFI@E>� @E � E> !C @J?� 1I@ K @E>� 8E;� +JP:?FCF>P� � #<� @J � 8:K @M<� @E�+@ K K ^J �GF<KIP�:CL9 �,8@E9FN��CC @8E:< �8E;�1I@ K !<I ^J ��8=R�NFIBJ?FG� ��=K<I �>I8;L8K @E> �?<�GC8EJ�KF �JG<E;�K?<�E<OK �P<8I �;F@E>�EFK?@E>�@E �G8I K @:L !C8I �<O:<GK �=FI �K I8M<C @E>�N?<E<M<I �8E;�N?<I<M<I�GFJJ@9C< � 8E;� K?<E� 8GGCP@E>� KF � (!�� GIF>I8DJ�@E �GF<KIP�

Jarrett Eakins

Page 100: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

92

Go to Sleep

����� 8:?�=I@<E;�<EK<IJ�8�ILD@E8K@FE������������J@E>C<�;I@EB�:8E�;I8N�K@D<@CCLJ@FEJ�=IFD�DLJ@:�

.?@J�@J�?FN�@K�NFIBJ�@E�+@KKJ9LI>?�N?<E�K?<�JEFN�@J�K?@E������*E�K?<�IFF=�F=�PFLI�?FLJ<�GLIGC<�D@E@C@>?KJ�NI@K?<�[C<K^J�=FI><K\� CFCCPGFGJ�8E;�:@>8I<KK<�9LKKJ�@E�J?FK�>C8JJ<J� � 8E;�N<�?<8I�J@I<EJ�=8I�<EFL>?�8N8P� � � � � KF�9<�8CDFJK�:FD=FIK@E>�

*=�:FLIJ<�K?@J�@J�8CC�9<=FI<�� !I@<E;J�N@CC�9I<8B�K?<DJ<CM<J�@EKF�;@JK8EK�MF@:<J

�����N@K?�G8K@<E:<�������$E�K?<�8G8IKD<EK�E<OK;FFI�K?<�E@>?K�@J�FM<IK8B<EJCLII<;�@EKF�:FEM<IJ8K@FE�K?<�G@K:?�F=�:8I<C<JJE<JJ�

�����$K�J@=KJ�K?IFL>?�8�J?8I<;�N8CC�K8JK<�F=�9<<I�9I<8K?�@E�JPCC89C<J�������������������������8E;�$�C<K�K?<�EF@J<�9<�DP�CLCC89P�

Page 101: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

93

An Epitaph

��=<N�F=�LJ�:FIGJ<J�JK@CC�N@>>C<�8J�N<�I@G<E�@E�K?<�JLE��I<E;FE�?8;�K?<�DFJK�9<8LK@=LC�9FE<J�@E�K?<�:8DG1?<E�K?<�FK?<I�:FIGJ<J�JK@CC�?8;�<EFL>?�9CFF;�@E�K?<D�KF�9<8K�LJ�1<�N<I<�K?<�>L8I;^J�=8MFI@K<*LI�G@EB�98;><J�<8IE@E>�LJ�K?<�DFJK�NFIB�8E;�K?<�C<8JK�=FF;�.?<P�C<K�K?<�;F>J�G<<C��I<E;FE�9<=FI<�?<�?8;�=LCCP�I@G<E<;#@J�C<>J�JK@CC�89C<�KF�ILE�K?FL>?�EFK�=8I�#@J�:I@DJFE�9@KJ�>C@JK<E<;�@E�K?<�KL=KJ�F=�K?<@I�J@E9C8:B�D8E<J�LK�K?<�;F>J�N<I<�JK@CC�<EM@FLJ� M<E�K?<�<8IK?�N?<I<�?@J�J:I8GJ�JF8B<;�N8J�9<8LK@=LC�$�>F�KF�K?8K�JGFK�N?<E�$�:8E�><K�8N8P-@=K�DP�_E><IJ�K?IFL>?�K?<�;@IK�E;�?FC;�K?<�>IFLE;�8>8@EJK�D<'@B<�8E�<C<G?8EK�:8I<JJ@E>�@KJ�=8D@CP^J�9FE<J�

EAKINS

Page 102: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

94

FFFORBES & FIFTH

O

FFIC

E OF UNDERGRADUATE RESEARCH - O.U.R.

Page 103: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

95

References

“ I Can Has Cultural Influenz?” (Levinson)

1�?KKG���NNN�O<FIEO�:FD�ELD8E<KNFIB�89FLK�?KD���::<JJ<;�%8EL8IP������� ���2�NNN�8C<O8�:FD�J@K<@E=F�@:8E?8J:?<<Q9LI><I�:FD���::<JJ<;�)FM�������� ��3�)LD9<IJ�K8B<E�=IFD�3FL.L9<�:FD���::<JJ<;�(8I:?����� ��4�NNN�@D;9�:FD�K@KC<�KK ����������::<JJ<;�)FM������ ����?KKG���NNN�N@I<;�:FD�<G@:<EK<I�� � � ��>I<>FIP9IFK?<IJ9<;@E��KIL;<I8EKF@E<;F;JFE8LKFKLE<�8CC�����::<JJ<;�)FM������ ����1FIK?8D�%<EE8��[��+FC@K@:8C��FD@E>�F=��><�=FI�K?<�.<:?�$E;LJKIP\���New$York$Times���::<JJ<;�(8I��� �� ����JF@G<GG<IJGI8P<;K?<D�KLD9CI�:FD�=8K:FGN@K?G<GG<IJGI8P�KLD9CI���:FD�G<GG<IJGI8P@E>:FG�KLD9CI�:FD�<8KJGI8P�KLD9CI�:FD���::<JJ<;���)FM������ ��

I Want to Love and Be Loved in Big Cities(Grant / Wuchina)

���E�<8IC@<I�M<IJ@FE�F=�K?@J�G@<:<�N8J�GL9C@J?<;�9P�The$Original���D8>8Q@E<����<:<D9<I�� ���

New Representations of the ‘Golden Lineage’ (Heins)

1��"��-<I;8D98�G<IJFE8C�@EK<IM@<N�-<GK<D9<I����� ���2���8IFC<�+<>>��Mongolian$Music,$Dance,$&$Oral$Narrative.�-<8KKC<��/E@���M<IJ@KP�F=�18J?@E>KFE�+I<JJ�� �������3����� I;<E<98K��LIE<<�8E;�.LE>88�G<IJFE8C�@EK<IM@<N�)FM<D9<I����������� ���4�����&?@I>@J�(LEB?*:?@I�G<IJFE8C�@EK<IM@<N�*:KF9<I����� ������.��(<E;*FPF�G<IJFE8C�@EK<IM@<N�-<GK<D9<I���� ������+<K<I�(8IJ?�The$HorseBhead$Fiddle$and$the$Cosmopolitan$Reimagina$$$tion$of$Tradition$in$Mongolia.$)<N�3FIB��,FLKC<;><�� �����������+<>>�Mongolian$Music,$Dance$&$Oral$Narrative������Y���������E;I<N��FCN<CC�<D8@C�:FII<JGFE;<E:<�)FM<D9<I����� ���

Page 104: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

96

9��-L<�.LF?P�HK;��@E�(8IJ?�The$HorseBhead$Fiddle����10�(8I:?�The$HorseBheaded$Fiddle����11� I;<E<98K��LIE<<�8E;�.LE>88�G<IJFE8C�@EK<IM@<N�12�.J�� EB?:?@D<>�G<IJFE8C�@EK<IM@<N�*:KF9<I����� ���13� I;<E<98K��LIE<<�8E;�.LE>88�G<IJFE8C�@EK<IM@<N�14� I;<E<98K��LIE<<�.LE>88�G<IJFE8C�@EK<IM@<N����+<>>�Mongolian$Music�������$9@;�������$9@;�����������.J<KJ<EKJFCDFE�[*E�#FN�K?<�#FIJ<?<8;<;�!@;;C<��(FI@E�&?LLI������<:8D<�(FEJK<I?<8;<;�8E;� C<:KI@:�@E�K?<��><�F=�"CF98C@Q8K@FE\��������<G8IKD<EK�F=�-F:@8C�8E;��LCKLI8C��EK?IFGFCF>P�)8K@FE8C�/E@M<IJ@KP�����F=�(FE>FC@8�� ��19� I;<E<98K��LIE<<�8E;�.LE>88�G<IJFE8C�@EK<IM@<N�20��CK8E�/I8>�K<C<M@J<;�@EK<IM@<N�GFJK<;�FE�3FLKL9<����)FM<D9<I������ ����::<JJ<;����)FM<D9<I�� ���21��FCN<CC�G<IJFE8C�:FII<JGFE;<E:<�)FM<D9<I����� ���

Recordings

�CK8E�/I8>��Blood��$E;<G<E;<EK�,<C<8J<�� ��������Hypnotism��$E;<G<E;<EK�,<C<8J<�� ��������Made$in$Altan$Urag��-FEFI�,<:FI;J�� ��������Mongol��$E;<G<E;<EK�,<C<8J<�� � �������Nation��$E;<G<E;<EK�,<C<8J<�� � �������Once$Upon$a$Time$in$Mongolia��$E;<G<E;<EK�,<C<8J<�� � �����

A Brief Explanation of Bonding Patterns in Carbon (Rice / Very)

?KKG���NNN�G?PJFI>�:FD�E<NJ�� �� �GFN<I=<CK9F;P<C<:KI@:@KP�?KDC?KKG���GL9J�8:J�FI>�;F@�=LCC�� �� ���EC� �� �H

<Traversing_the_Tree/> (Kirilloff)��[���FDG8E@FE�KF��@>@K8C�#LD8E@K@<J\�<;��-LJ8E�-:?I<@9D8E�,8P�����-@<D<EJ�%F?E�/EJNFIK?��*O=FI;���C8:BN<CC�� ���?KKG���NNN������;@>@K8C?LD8E@K@<J�FI>�:FDG8E@FE���.F�M@<N�DLCK@GC<�M<IJ@FEJ�F=�Songs$of$Innocence$and$Experience�>F���KF�[.?<�1@CC@8D��C8B<��I:?@M<\��?KKG���NNN�9C8B<8I:?@M<�FI>�9C8B<����

Page 105: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

97

���CJF�KF�:FDG8I<�K?<�;@==<I<EK�GLE:KL8K@FE�LJ<;�@E�M<IJ@FEJ�F=�The$$$Night�J<<��?KKG���NNN�>B�F9;LIF;FE�FI>��C8B<�?KDC��2('�N8J�@EK<E;<;�8J�8�KPG<�F=�;<J:I@GK@M<�D8IBLG��!FI�DFI<�@E=FI��D8K@FE�FE�K?<�;@==<I<EK�KPG<J�F=�D8IBLG�J<<���FFD9J�%8D<J�#���C��C<E�#��,<E<8I�8E;�-K<M<E�%���<,FJ<��[(8IBLG�-PJK<DJ�8E;�K?<���!LKLI<�F=�-:?FC8ICP�.<OK�+IF:<JJ@E>�\��JJF:@8K@FE�=FI��FDGLK@E>�����(8:?@E<IP��� ��)FM<D9<I��������.?@J�<O8DGC<�@J�=IFD�DP�FNE�I<J<8I:?�[ OGCFI@E>�-G<<:?�@E�,LJJ@8E���!8@IP�.8C<J\�N?@:?�@J�;F:LD<EK<;�8K��?KKG���>B�F9;LIF;FE�FI>�GIF��A<:K'F>�O?KDC��.?@J�@;<8�:8E�9<�K@<;�@EKF�GI8:K@:<�K?<FIP��!FI�DFI<�@E=FID8K@FE�J<<����-:@`<<K�+8LC�8E;�-LJ8E�+��1@CC@8DJ�[+I8:K@:<�.?<FIP�8E;�K?<�!FLE��;8K@FEJ�F=��@>@K8C��F:LD<EK� E:F;@E>�\��JJF:@8K@FE�=FI��FDGLK@E>���(8:?@E<IP���*=K<E�@E�2('�K8>�E8D<J�:8D<C�:8J<�@J�LJ<;��$E�:I<8K@E>�K8>�E8D<J���JG8:<J�:8EEFK�9<�LJ<;�JF�NFI;J�8I<�F=K<E�AF@E<;���-<<��?KKG���;FEE<�F9;LIF;FE�FI>�GF<KIP�?KDC�.?@J�J@K<�:FEK8@EJ�8���GIFA<:K�LE;<I�;<M<CFGD<EK�9P�8�JKL;<EK�@E�K?<�:FLIJ<�[�FDGLK8K@FE���(<K?F;J�@E�K?<�#LD8E@K@<J\�� )"'$.���� ��8K�K?<�/E@M<IJ@KP�F=���+@KKJ9LI>?���[-"('��.?<�,<8JFE�1?P�8E;�K?<�!@IJK�+L9C@J?<;�#@EK�\�?KKG���NNN���J>DCJFLI:<�:FD�?@JKFIP�A8J@J�?KD��Journal$of$the$American$Society$$$for$Information$Science��������%LCP���������[+I8:K@:<�K?<FIP���K?<�=FLE;8K@FEJ�F=�;@>@K8C�;F:LD<EK�<E:F;@E>�\���-$"�*��� ��+IF:<<;@E>J�F=�K?<���K?���(�$EK<IE8K@FE8C��FE=<I��<E:<�FE��<J@>E�F=��FDDLE@:8K@FE������ �� ��8E@<C<NJB@�(8IB�4��House$of$Leaves��)<N�3FIB��+8EK?<FE�� ����������+I@EK����!FI�K?<�JFLI:<�F=�K?@J�@D8><�J<<��?KKG���FEA8M8�:FD�FEA8���M8�� �� �� ��;FD�?KDC���!FI�DFI<�@E=FID8K@FE�J<<��?KKG���NNN�K<@:�FI>�I<C<8J<�;F:�K<@G����;F:�?KDC�-"�?KDC���,<E<8I��CC<E� CC@�(PCFE8J�8E;��8M@;��LI8E;�[,<_E@E>�FLI�)F���K@FE�F=�1?8K�.<OK�$J�\�,<J<8I:?�@E�#LD8E@K@<J��FDGLK<I�)��$;<�8E;����-��#F:B<P��<;J�����������'<;<I<I�,@:?8I;����� ������ ���������%�����������������������$$$Language.�)<N�3FIB��-K��(8IK@E^J�� ���� ���+I@EK����$9@;�����<IFJ<�%��-K<G?<E��8M@;�"���LI8E;� CC@�(PCFE8J�8E;��CC<E�#��

Page 106: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

98

���,<E<8I�[1?8K�@J�.<OK�,<8CCP�\$Journal$of$Computing$in$Higher$$$$Education���������� ����������,<E<8I��CC<E� CC@�(PCFE8J�8E;��8M@;��LI8E;�[,<_E@E>�FLI�)F����K@FE�F=�1?8K�.<OK�$J�\���$9@;�����8E@<C<NJB@�House$of$Leaves�� ���=<N�G8IK@:LC8ICP�JKIFE>�<O8DGC<J�F=�K?@J�8I<��.he$Life$and$Opinions$$$$of$Tristram$Shandy�9P�'8LI<E:<�-K<IE<�The$Prague$Cemetery$9P����/D9<IKF� :F�8E;�Spring$and$All�9P�1@CC@8D��8ICFJ�1@CC@8DJ�21�!FI�8�;@J:LJJ@FE�F=�GI<M@FLJ�K<OK�<E:F;@E>�8GGIF8:?<J�J<<���<I���FJ<�%��-K<G?<E��8M@;�"���LI8E;� CC@�(PCFE8J�8E;��CC<E�#��,<E<8I����[1?8K�@J�.<OK�,<8CCP�\���,<E<8I��CC<E� CC@�(PCFE8J�8E;��8M@;��LI8E;�[,<_E@E>�FLI�)F���K@FE�F=�1?8K�.<OK�$J�\���,8DJ8P�-K<G?<E��[*E��L@C;@E>\��?KKG���C<EQ�LEC�<;L�G8���G<IJ�� ��� �����FE9L@C;@E>�?KDC���!FI�DFI<�@E=FID8K@FE�FE��*)�/,�J<<��?KKG���:FE=<I<E:<J�@;<8C���C@8E:<�FI>�<OKI<D<�?KDC�� ��1@KK �� ('� �1@KK ��ODC��8E;����,<E<8I��CC<E� CC@�(PCFE8J�8E;��8M@;��LI8E;�[,<_E@E>�FLI�)F���K@FE�F=�1?8K�.<OK�$J�\

Rest Assured, We Can Save It All (Hanson)

��$�NFLC;�C@B<�KF�<OK<E;�DP�J@E:<I<JK�K?8EBJ�KF��I��,@:?8I;�*<JKI<@:?<I�F=���K?<�/E@M<IJ@KP�F=�+@KKJ9LI>?�#@JKFIP��<G8IKD<EK�=FI�GIFM@;@E>�D<�N@K?���K?<�E<:<JJ8IP�>L@;8E:<�8E;�:I@K@:@JD�;LI@E>�K?<�GC8EE@E>�8E;�NI@K@E>�F=���K?@J�G8G<I�8J�N<CC�8J��I���8IC<KFE�"?FCQ�F=�)FIK?<8JK<IE�/E@M<IJ@KP�=FI���?@J�?<CG�@E�;@J:LJJ@E>�8CC�K?@E>J�I<C8K<;�KF��<KIF@K J�DLJ@:�?@JKFIP�8E;���:LCKLI<�2��8E>J�'<JK<I��[%8D<J�.8PCFI�(8IB<;�=FI��<8K?\�@E�Bangs,$Psychotic$$$Reactions$and$Carburetor$Dung�<;��"I<@C�(8I:LJ��)<N�3FIB���C=I<;������&EFG=����������E;<IJFE�.<IIP��The$Sixties$�)<N�3FIB��+<8IJFE�� ����� �4�Creem’s�JCF>8E��(8IJ?��8M<��[1@CC�-L::<JJ�-GF@C�K?<�!IL@K�\�Creem.����(8P�����������������.?@J�@J�8�I<=<I<E:<�KF�K?<�JFE>�F=�K?<�J8D<�E8D<�9P�.?<�(8DD8J�����.?<�+8GG8J�8�98E;�N?F�K?FL>?�FI@>@E8CCP�=IFD�)<N�3FIB�9<:8D<���:CFJ<CP�@;<EK@_<;�N@K?��8C@=FIE@8 J��8P��I<8�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<�@E�K?<�

Page 107: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

99

��D@;KFC8K<���� J���(8IJ? �K<ID�=FI�K?<�GJP:?<;<C@:�:FLEK<I:LCKLI<��-<<�(8IJ?�[1@CC�-L:��:<JJ�-GF@C�K?<�!IL@K�\���!FI�8�G8IK@:LC8ICP�I<C<M8EK�<O8DGC<�F=��8C@=FIE@8�@;<8C@JD�8E;�:FLEK<I��:LCKLI8C�M8CL<J�J<<�K?<J<�M8CL<J�C@JK<;�@E�-�- �+FIK�#LIFE�-K8K<D<EK��$K���J?FLC;�9<�EFK<;�K?8K�N?@C<�K?<I<�N8J�8�J@>E@_:8EK�(@:?@>8E�@E`L<E:<�@E���-KL;<EKJ�=FI�8��<DF:I8K@:�-F:@<KP�$�8D�KI<8K@E>�K?<J<�JKL;<EKJ�8J�G8IK���F=�K?<�[@EK<CC<:KL8C�KFNE\�;<DF>I8G?@:�@E�K?<�D@;;C<�:C8JJ�:FLEK<I��:LCKLI<�DFM<D<EK�9�-<<�(8IJ?�[1@CC�-L::<JJ�-GF@C�K?<�!IL@K\�10�%<==<IJFE��@IGC8E<�N8J�BEFNE�=FI�@EJ<IK@E>�I8;@:8C�C@E<I�EFK<J�@E�8C���9LDJ���CJF�J<<�K?<�CPI@:J�KF�K?<�JFE>�[0FCLEK<<IJ�\11�,<=<I<E:<�K?<�/�����<IB<C<P�GIFK<JKJ�8E;�(8I@F�-8M@F J�[+C8:<�PFLI���J<CM<J�LGFE�K?<�><8IJ\�JG<<:?��-<<��E;<IJFE�12�-<<�Time�D8>8Q@E<��%LCP������������8M<�(8IJ?��<;8P�'8I<E<�8E;��8IIP�&I8D<I��[.?<�(@:?@>8E�-:<E<����.F;8P�\�Creem���GI@C���� �14�-<<�=FFKEFK<������#<I<�$�8D�I<=<II@E>�KF�K?<�DLJ@:�F=�K?<�(���N?F�$�;@J:LJJ�C8K<I�@E�K?<����G8G<I����.F�@CCLJKI8K<�8<JK?<K@:�8E;�:FLEK<I:LCKLI8C�;@==<I<E:<J�:FEKI8JK�K?<����=FCCFN@E>�JFE>J�8CC�F=�N?@:?�N<I<�I<C<8J<;�8IFLE;�IFL>?CP�K?<�J8D<����K@D<��(@K:?<CC J�I<E;@K@FE�F=�[1FF;JKF:B\�8E;��-)3 J�[�CDFJK��LK����(P�#8@I\�N@K?�.?<�(�� J�[&@:B�*LK�K?<�%8DJ\�8E;�.?<�-KFF><J ����[,8N�+FN<I�\���.?@J�@J�G<I?8GJ�FE<�F=�K?<�I<8JFEJ�K?8K��8E>J�G8EE<;�K?<�(���@E�?@J����8L;@K@FE�C<KK<I�=FI�Creem��Creem$<EK<IK8@E<;�NI@K@E>J�=IFD�@KJ�I<8;���<IJ�8E;�G8IK@:LC8ICP�@E�K?<�:8J<�F=��8E>J�8E;�NI@K<I�;@I<:KFI��8D<IFE�����IFN<�?@I<;�=8EJ�=FI�NI@K@E>�GFJ@K@FEJ����!IFD�[.?<�%F?E�-@E:C8@I�+8G<IJ\�8::<JJ<;�FEC@E<�M@8�K?<��<EKC<P�#@J���KFI@:8C�'@9I8IP�/E@M<IJ@KP�F=�(@:?@>8E�EE��I9FI�19�.?<��<KIF@K�,@FKJ�8J�N<CC�8J�K?<�<M<EKJ�C<8;@E>�LG�KF�K?<D�J<IM<;�8J�8����J?F:B�KF��<KIF@K�8J�N<CC�8J�K?<�/�-��8J�8�N?FC<���=K<I�K?<�I@FKJ�(F���KFNE�JK8IJ�9<>@E�KF�@EA<:K�8�E<N=FLE;�J<EJ<�F=�GFC@K@:8C�8E;�:LCKLI8C����:I@K@HL<�8E;�8N8I<E<JJ�@EKF�K?<@I�DLJ@:��(8IM@E�"8P< J�8C9LD�What’s$$$$Going$On�8E;�.?<�-LGI<D<J�JFE>�['FM<��?@C;\�J<IM<�8J�<==<:K@M<����<O8DGC<J�F=�K?@J�:?8E><��-<<�K?<��������F:LD<EK8IP�[(FKFI��@KP J�����LIE@E>���<KIF@K�=IFD�(FKFNE�KF�.?<�-KFF><J�\�������(8I:?�� � �� �[.@E8�.LIE<I��-K8I J��8IJ\�Creem��(8I:?������

Page 108: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FORBES & FIFTH

100

21�"<FI><��C@EKFE�@J�D<EK@FE<;�@E�K?<�-K8I J��8IJ�J<:K@FE�F=�K?<�*:KF9<I���������@JJL<�F=�Creem�22�[(FKFI��@KP J��LIE@E>���<KIF@K�!IFD�(FKFNE�KF�.?<�-KFF><J�\����������(8I:?�� � �23�&I8D<I����24�-<<�[(FKFI��@KP J��LIE@E>���<KIF@K�!IFD�(FKFNE�KF�.?<�-KFF><J�\���-<<�8IK@JKJ�C@B<�.?<��C8J?�(@EFI�.?I<8K�8E;�.?<��<8;�&<EE<;PJ�

Page 109: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

101

Page 110: FORBESF Vol 1_Interior... · FORBES & FIFTH F F F O R B E S & F I F T H O F F I C E O F U N D E RG R AD U T E E S E A R C H-O. U. R. Acknowledgements Founding Editors: &8K

FFFORBES & FIFTH

O

FFIC

E OF UNDERGRADUATE RESEARCH - O.U.R.