Haqqani Report - CTC at West Point

8/3/2019 Haqqani Report - CTC at West Point

1/56

HARMONY PROGRAM


2/56

!"#$%&&%'()#*+,%'-."#

/012+.(1'13

%2

4%5(-%

$6789):;796!?)


3/56

6L!$97@56=M)9AN/O3/R%/&26")

%$6%7-4"%$$#.=#-'-2%.&()8/../#8/)$%: !"/-,*)I#4(6)'$&.)("%5#3##.,)--/3$#

6/(")'(-',,)*(

+*)*%3/4-)'*4#-2

%-/+("##$),*%3,"#.)


7/56

$

*#,)*(-(%*(/.=/.("#-#4).&-#4(/).#K,$)*#-("##5)$'(/).)+("#N%BB%./.#(6)*A%.&

("#.%('*#)+ ("#=*)',D-*#$%(/).-6/("A#7%4()*-2#-,#4/%$$7%$\%D/&%: !"/- /-&).#

("*)'=" % 4"*).)$)=/4%$ *#5/#62 -(%*(/.=6/(" ("# #


8/56

%

3#'-#& () #K,$%/. ("# -'44#-- )+ ("#N%BB%./.#(6)*A2 =/5#. ("# =*)',D- %3/$/(7 ()

),#*%(# %4*)-- $)4%$2 *#=/).%$ %.& =$)3%$ ,$%/.- %.& ,*)5/ 5%$'# 6/("/. #%4"

+'.4(/).%$ 4%(#=)*7: V)* #K%


9/56

&

N(E(.%.(1',%'-=%0#%.,

!"/- *#,)*( /- .)( % 4) (%/$#& #K,$)*%(/). )+

P%$%$'&&/.N%BB%./D-*#$%(/).-6/("A#7>+="%./.-'*=#.(f,)$/(/4%$+%4(/).-&'*/.=("#

%.(/H)5/#(I/"%&2 +)* #K%


10/56

'

?)!79OL=?)+="%.--#--&A/.2?59"/,%'-/,H!"#I#/*!*/)J!"#

@#5#/-.5/=0)#*).*EN%5#*()6.2?>gC%-#-#K,$%/.#&3#$)62-/.4#("#


11/56

(

!"#N%BB%./.#(6)*A"%-*#.()./)

O/'-()RR/EM#6W)*AgC)$'/,8//3G%"/+E?%-"()F2ZgXc2E>'='-(H#,(#R/Rb"%.2_!"#V/*-(P/"%&/J,#*%(/)./.>+="%./-(%.2%.&("#1/-#)+("#@$#=%/.-(("#

C)


12/56

)

I/"%& /. ("# Z]^Y- %*#6#$$A.)6.k ("#@./(#&H(%(#-2H%'&/>*%3/%2C"/.% %.&)("#*

,%*(.#*-(%(#-4).(*/3'(#&',6%*&-)+nZX3/$$/)./.&/*#4(%/&()?%A/-(%.()-',,)*(("#

/.-'*=#.47:ZU >44)*&/.= () ("# 9*/=%&/#* O#.#*%$ )+ ("# [.(#*H#*5/4#- [.(#$$/=#.4#

0/*#4()*%(# E[H[F *#-,).-/3$# +)*&/*#4(/.= ("/-


13/56

!*

-%.4('%*/#-)+M)*("%.&H)'(";%R/*/-(%. ()>+="%./-(%.D-4%,/(%$2b%3'$: !"/-2%.&

("#.%('*# )+ ("#N%BB%./.#(6)*AD- *#$%(/).-"/,- E#K,$)*#& +'*("#*3#$)6F2"#$,- ()

#K,$%/.6"7("#=*)', /-'-'%$$7*#-,).-/3$#+)*-'/4/%((%4A-4).&'4(#& /.b%3'$:XY

!"#+="%.:XX >+="%./-(%.2 6"*%'-%/,=2%#,2#>.,%-.*2ZP'.#XYY]:XZ !"#-#*#$%(/).-"/,-%*#*#5/#6#&3#$)6:!"#'-#)+("#(#*


14/56

!!

("#3)** 4/(7 )+?#-"%6%*2&'*/.= ("# Z]aY-:Xc [.#&2P%$%$'&&/.D- 4)..#4(/).- ()

S%6$%6/i>3&%$N%B2+)'.*)+("#N%BB%./77%+="%.[-$%+="%./-(%.m2("#7),#*%(#

'.*("#N%BB%./.#(6)*A%.&.##&("#


15/56

!"

("%(S'$$%"M%R/* /- 4$)-# ()H/*%I'&&/.N%BB%./%.& ("%(O'$9%"%&'*_4))*&/.%(#-

4$)-#$76/("("#N%BB%./.#(6)*A).3)("-(*%(#=7%.&),#*%(/).-/.>+="%./-(%.:`XT

!"#*# /- %$-) % B'%$/(%(/5# &/+="%./-(%.2 ("#N%BB%./.#(6)*A*#2cJ4()3#*XYY]k

V)*3%4A=*)'.&).9%/('$$%"S#"-'&-##[$/2_9%/('$$%"S#"-'&L("#!%$/3%.D-M#6G#%*/.

?%A/-(%.2`!#**.*%'7B.20'2]P%.'%*7XYY^kV)*3%4A=*)'.&).>3&'$$%"S#"-'&%.&"/-%("2-##

_V)*


16/56

!#

("/-6%7)'()+.#4#--/(72%-("#*#%*#/


17/56

!$

-##A+="%.-/)+("#3)**2("#N%BB%./.#(6)*A%$-)+'.4(/).-%-%A/.#(/4-(*/A#+)*4#

("*)'="6"/4"?%A/-(%.4%.%4"/#5# /((%4"p:dZ !"/- %((%4A26"/4"6%- *#,)*(#&$7

4%**/#&)'(6/("[H[%--/-(%.4#26%-$/A#$74).&'4(#&()-#.&%-(*).=


18/56

!%

7%&$8&-)68&,29-%&-"$)*:''%#&*(

!"# N%BB%./ .#(6)*A "%- /,8/RfC0'*/-

/3G%"/+2 ("# *)$# )+ ("# >*%3- /- #/("#* /=.)*#& )* -,#4/+/4%$$7 ./#&2 6"/$# /( /-

4#$#3*%(#& /. ("# >*%3/4 $%.='%=# 5#*-/).- )+ ("# -%


19/56

!&

,*)5#&'-#+'$ () ("#N%BB%./.#(6)*A /. ("/-4%-#%- /(3)$-(#*#& /(-4*#.(/%$-6/("

O'$+ -',,)*(#*- 6"/$# %$-) &/-(%.4/.= ("# =*)', +*)/,8//3G%"/+E?%-"()F2Xg^2EP%.'%*7Z]]ZF:dU [.%-#*/#-)+(#$#5/-#&-,##4"#-()?%-"('.%.&!%I/A#$*-&'*/.=("/-,#*/)&?*#-/.(M%I/3'$$%"

4*/(/4/R#&("#*)$#)++)*#/=.#*-+/="(/.=/.>+="%./-(%.2 b")-(%.&P%$%$%3%&2

666:7)'('3#:4)


20/56

!'

/S9NL!?9)6)OS6NL/9P!$/$6446)?)/TL@

!"#N%BB%./.#(6)*A


21/56

!(

!"#-#4(/).("%(+)$$)6-#K,$)*#-("#N%BB%./.#(6)*AD-#5)$'(/).%.&("#5%$'#/("%-

"/-()*/4%$$7,*)5/& ())("#*+="%./-(%.` -#("/


22/56

!)

+'$$ -/K7#%*-3#+)*# ("#H)5/#(@./). /.5%&>+="%./-(%.:UY V*)R/Rb"%.2$%(#*("#&/*#4()*)+("#N%BB%./.#(6)*AD-S%.3%D%$

i@$'+="%. >*%3 ,"#.)3&'$$%"i>RR%+="%./-(%.`k1'((/=k_?)*(*%/()+%S'I%"/&2

?*/8%/E0#4#


23/56

"*

+/="(#*-:UT i>RR%+="%.

I/"%& () /.(#*.%(/).%$S'-$/+="%.,%*(7$#%*-2")6#5#*2).")63#-((),$%4#("#-#5)$'.(##*-/.-#*5/4#()("#

>+="%.-(*'==$#2%.&H%77%+%.&N#A+="%.6%*()+%4/$/(%(#("#/.(*)&'4(/).)+>*%3=#.472C%3$#2[[1lhK4/-#&mf8#(#*%.>+="%./-(%.!*%5#$#*->.%$7-/-)+>$\%#&%%.&!%$/3%.

hK,$)/(%3$#;#%A.#--#-2 J4()3#*X2XYYZ2H#4*#(2666:=6':#&'fu.-%*4"/5f:U^ H##8%"/&9*)6.2_C$%--/4%$%.&O$)3%$P/"%&g>$\%D/&%D-V*%.4"/-/.=V*'-(*%(/).-2`/.B/03-P%,#'%,

M3.8/3G%"/+2#&:>--%+S)="%&%


24/56

"!

h5#.(")'="("#*#5)$'(/).%*7+/="(#*-%*#=*#%(/..'+="%.I/"%&: C$#%*$7N%BB%./2%.&.)(i>RR%RR%+(#*"/-%--%--/.%(/).2i>RR%+="%.$#%*(),*#4#i>RR%


25/56

""

P%$%$'&&/.6%- ("#h=7,(/%.I)'*.%$/-(S'-(%+%N%*%3-%( ("%( (/3& %$1%"*%3-2 6"/4" [ &/-4)5#*#& 6%- (*'$7 &/++#*#.( ("%. ("#

(*#%(3'D$;%$/&%$S%-*/g>9/)=*%,"/4%$HA#(4"2`EXYY^F2

666:4(4:'-0Q/"%+%,/3S?*/85%?59"/,%'-/,EC%/*)2Z]^]F2ca+kV%(#"'$$%"N%BB%./6%-("#3*)("#*

)+M#R%


26/56

"#

!"#),#..#--)+N%BB%./D-+*).(-%.&("#%--/-(%.4#%.&/.+*%-(*'4('*#("%(P%$%$'&&/.

6)'$&,*)5/ /. ("#%- () +)$$)66%- /.(#*6)5#.6/(" ("# -',,)*( ("#=*)',

*#4#/5#& +*)+="%./-(%. %+(#* ("#@:H: /.5%-/).: V)*#K%H?:

S%7

>$$%"

"#$,

7)':`

TZ!"#-#

4)&A/.2ZTZ: V)*/.-/="(/.()P%$%$'&&/.D-")-(/.=)+?%A/-(%./VO?XYYXYY^U^X:TZN%*


27/56

"$

5)*(#K)+?#-"%6%*%.&("#,*)3$#3' i@3%7&% %$

9%.-"/*/26")6)'$& $%(#*3#4)+="%.>*%36")%**/5#&%(?#-"%6%*/.Z]^Tg

[(6%-4'-()3&%$

1%"+="%.+/="(#*-F:TdS'-(%+%9%&/E>3'[3*%"/


28/56

"%

$#5#$("%.("%(%(H%&%:Ta[(6%-%4#.(#*6"/4"6)'$&6/..)6)'((")-#-'/(%3$#

()3# %&-A%*/77%2` %.)*=%./R%(/). ("%("%&3##.

%&5#*(/-#&%-+)*3'P%D+%* *#$%(#- ("%(3#+)*#,*)4##&/.= () ("#%&5%.4#& (*%/./.=%(9/.

G%&/.D- _*%3-3)'.& +)*S%D-%&% "%& ()

,*)4##&()Q"%6%*%5/%S/*%.-"%"%.&("#*#'.*=)(#.&%7-)+,*#$/*%3

'./(

/.

>+="%./-(%.2

%.&

/(

Ta H%&%6%-%S>bfH%77%+4%$/A"#$-',,$7,)/.()5#*("#b'**%


29/56

"&

6)'$& ,*),#$9/. G%&/. /.() % $#%*-"/, ,)-/(/). %44)*&/.=()>3'D$;%$/&2%$\%D/&%"%&()*#.(("#$%.&+)*("#-#$%((#*4%


30/56

"'

=077/*4J97("#$%(#Z]^Y-("#N%BB%./+*).(-"%&%$*#%&7#*%35)$'.(##*-2%.&;%""%3/(("#*#=/).%$$#5#$2


31/56

"(

F("G#5,-&),("&2= F("@&AA&,)3"-B#%CH-("F&.)I&,H&,2-("J)6"#+="%./-(%.k #*',(/).- )+


32/56

")

5%$/&%(#"/--/*#()#,#.("/-$)4%$%.&=$)3%$,%*(.#*-"/,: !"#4%,('*#)+("#-#(6)

4/(/#-6%-/.-(*'*%3/.5)$5#3'D$;%$/&:]c J.%$\%D/&%D-/.5)$5#


33/56

#*

(*)),-/.H%'&/>*%3/%: 0'*/.=("/-(*%.-/(/).%$,#*/)&9/.G%&/.%.&%$\%D/&%6#*#

,*/.4/,%$$7 +)4'-#& ). *#,'*,)-/.= ("# )*=%./R%(/).2 4).(/.'/.= ("#/* (*%/./.=

),#*%(/).- /.b")-(%.-(%3$/-"/.=%,*#-#.4#/.%.&%*)'.&("#>*%3/%.?#./.-'$%2

#-,#4/%$$7/.W#3' i@3%7&% %$9%.-"/*/2 %.& ("# $#%*)+ ("# _3'S%"


34/56

#!

%.&%5#(#*%.)+("#N%BB%./+*).(-&'*/.=("#Z]^Y-2%.&&/-4)5#*#&-(%(#+="%./-(%.23'(6%-%$-) $/.A#&() ("#5/#6("%(@:H: /.5)$5#


35/56

#"

),,*#--/5# %.& %.(/[-$%+="%.I/"%&26"/4"6%- -,#%*"#%&37S%6$%6/N%BB%./ %.& )("#*

(*'("+'$$#%*-2+#%(#&("#H)5/#(#+="%./-(%./.Z]]a: V*)/,8//3G%"/+E?%-"()F2ZgZXEP'.#Z]]YFk_>$"%IS%6$%6/P%$%$'&&/.N%BB%.//.%

O#.#*%$O%("#*/.=)+("#P%6%*#)+("#[.(#$$#4('%$[.5%-/).2`>/,8//3G%"/+E>*%3/4F2ZgdEM)5#/,8//3G%"/+E?%-"()F2cg]ZYES%7Z]]XFl#


36/56

##

?*).)'.4#.-%*2)*N'>F%.&N'P[:ZYU J.#)+("#N%BB%./4%/,8/1/3G%"/+E>*%3/4F2ZgZEV#3*'%*7Z]]YF:>44)*&/.=

()9:1%3&'$"%&/S'$$%A"%/$ES%.3%%$P/"%&2Z]^^^]F: V)*3%4A=*)'.&).("#

N%BB%./-D*)$#/.("#(*%/./.=)++/="(#*-+)*b%-"


37/56

#$

P%$%$'&&/.:ZY] !"#-#%.&)("#*?%A/-(%.//,8//3G%"/+E?%-"()F2cg]ZYES%7Z]]XF:ZZY N)6%*&kC#.(*%$[.(#$$/=#.4#>=#.472_N%*%A%('$>.-%*g[.4*#%-/.=!"*#%(();#-(#*.%.&?%A/-(%./

[.(#*#-(-2`0[!1]aYY^2>'='-(Z]]a2666:=6':#&'fu.-%*4"/5fMH>h99fMH>h99XXTf/.K:"(.(").70%5/-2_?%A/-(%.D-6%*37,*)K7/.>+="%./-(%.$)-#-/(-./%3/$/(72 G/,#1'K,-#33%9#,2#e#$%#&2Z

J4()3#*Z]]]:ZZZN%*


38/56

#%

H)'("#%-(: P%$%$'&&/.D-+="%./-(%.D-M)*(" %=%/.-( ("#M)*("#*.

>$$/%.4#2%+)*4#3%4A#&37[.&/%%.&)("#*4)'.(*/#-:ZZ^

!"# #%*$7 *#$%(/).- 3#(6##. %$\%D/&% %.& ("# !%$/3%. 6#*# 3'S'-%3%$

H'*/2_N#lW'./-b"%$/-m-%/&/."/-#K4#$$#.(>*%3/4%.&"/-("/4A+)*#/=.%44#.(()>3'

i>3&%$$%" l@-%


39/56

#&

4/*4'$%(/).)+*'3'N%+-%$S%-*/&/&+/="(6/("

("#!%$/3%.("#7&/&-)6/("P%$%$'&&/.N%BB%./:ZXZ

>3)'( -/K*%3/%2 9/. G%&/. /.5/(#& CMM

I)'*.%$/-(?#(#*9#*=#.()5/-/("/3'D$;%$/&%$S%-*/2T%''/-/38/41/-/3S/*/8%4/3%/7%*/37017%,%,>033/">0"/77/+S;7/*2.)&%(#2

,)-(#&()5%*/)'-I/"%&//.(#*.#(+)*'


40/56

#'

b%.&%"%*L6"#*# 9/. G%&/. %.& -#5#*%$ $#%*- +*)+="%./-(%.:ZX^ >+(#* %.)("#* ,*#-- 4).+#*#.4# ("%( -%+="%./-(%.2 #/("#* [ )* @-%44)*&/.= () ("#

I)'*.%$/-(>"#''/9#'-.-"#A.*3+J!"#

=-/-#7#,-'.5L'/7/I%,P/+#,E8#*-)2XYYUF2U^++:ZXa [3/&:ZXT 9%"*/2^^:ZX^ J.("/-/--'#2-##9*)6.EXYZY%F:ZX] O'(


41/56

#(

("# -#4'*/(7%=#.4/#- /.?%A/-(%. -/.4# ("#&%7-)+>+="%.I/"%&: !"/-+="%./-(%.2"#$,-()#K,$%/.6"7 /(6%-()("#N%BB%./

.#(6)*AD-*#+'=#/.;%R/*/-(%.2%.&.)(("#!%$/3%.D-/.9%$'4"/-(%.2("%(("#-#=*)',-

('*.#&+)*-%+#"%5#.%+(#*("#@:H:/.5%-/).)+>+="%./-(%.+)$$)6/.=("#]fZZ%((%4A-:S'4"+="%./-(%.D- /.(#*.%$4).+$/4(-2%.&?%A/-(%.D-#++)*(- ()"#&=#

/(-,)-/(/).%.&4'$(/5%(#/.+$'#.4#).3)("-/-)+("#0'*%.&G/.#: >--/-(#&37("#

ZcY >"


42/56

#)

[H[2 %.& $#5#*%=/.= /(- A#7 4"%*%4(#*/-(/4- %.& .#K'- ,)-/(/).2 ("#N%BB%./ .#(6)*A

B'/4A$7 #+="%./-(%.: !"#

5%$'# )+N%BB%./ .#(6)*A 4).(*/3'(/).- () ("# !%$/3%. "%-3##. %4A.)6$#&=#&37

-#./)*!%$/3%. $#%*-2 -'4"%-S'$$%"0%&'$$%"26")L3#+)*#"/-%(" /.XYYTL

4).+/*


43/56

$*

6/("2 %.& ),#*%(/.= %$).=-/ N%BB%./ .#(6)*A /.-'*=#.(- /. G)7% ?%A(/%:ZcX >$

\%D/&%D- 4$%/+="%./-(%.D-M)*("-/.4#XYY]:H##>.()./)O/'-()RR/%.&C"*/-(),"#*

1#'(#*2_!"#[.-'*=#.(-)+("#>+="%.M)*("2`>+="%./-(%.>.%$7-(-M#(6)*A2>,*/$XYZZ:Zcc _S'-(%+%>3'%$W%R/&D-[.(#*5/#6).%$P%R##*%2 CdB?2XXP'.#XYY]:!"#!%$/3%.%$-)4$%/3'%$W%R/&D-[.(#*5/#6).%$P%R##*%: J.("#%(")+S'-(%+%>3'%$W%R/&2-##h*/4

H4"7)'.=>


44/56

$!

A.)6$#&=#)+("#%((%4A("%("#6%-#5#.%3$#() /.(/+7).#)+("#-'/4/%((%4A#*-2

6/("6")3'N%-%.%$H%D/&/ 6%- % (*'-(#&

4).+/&%.(: !"#%("-)+)("#*-#./)*%$\%D/&%3'0'I%.%" %$\%"(%./2 %.&>3'

H'$%7\[+/='*#

/.G)7%

?%A(/%

6)'$&

"%5#

#-4%,#&

N%BB%./

%((#.(/).:

ZdY [3/&:ZdZ _>$\%e/&%"4)$\%D/&%$#%*-%.&N%BB%./+%.%$7-/-)+@:H:0*).#H(*/A#-/.?%A/-(%.2XYYdXYZY2`6.0,-#*-#**.*%'7=-*/-#94K,%-%/-%$#O/)#*2

',&%(#&%-)+XdS%7XYZY:ZdX _>$\%#&%C)


45/56

$"

C)'.(#*(#**)*/-+="%./-(%.:`ZdU [. %&&/(/). () $/3#*%(/.=b%3'$2 ("#7 %$-)6%.(#& () 4*#%(# %=$)3%$

[-$%./.5/(%(/).

()

I)/.

N%BB%./

+/="(#*-

).

("#

3%(($#+/#$&

%$-)

,*)5/-

%$

\%D/&% %.& ("# [P@6/(" %. ),,)*('./(7 () #,#. ("#/* (/#- () ("#N%BB%./ +%1#,)*(#*D-!%$#)+>


46/56

$#

%$\%D/&%()#-(%3$/-"%-%+#"%5#./.?%A/-(%.D-(*/3%$%*#%-%+(#*("#/*#-4%,#+*)+="%./-(%. /. XYYU /$$'-(*%(#- ")6 ("# N%BB%./ .#(6)*A

4).(/.'#& () -"#$(#* +)*#/=. +/="(#*- %.& $)4%$ 3&'$$%" /- +*)+="%.-k@R3#A-kC"/.#-#kC"#4"#.-k%.&(6)>*%3-:!"#7D5#*#4#/5#&+="%./-(%.E%4$%--/4%$I/"%&F2("#N%BB%./.#(6)*A

%$-) "#$,- () -'-(%/. %$\%D/&%D- *#$#5%.4# %.&3*%.&/.= %- ("# $#%* )+ ("# =$)3%$

I/"%&/-(


47/56

$$

?%A(/A%E+)'*(##.F%.&b'.%*E(6#$5#F,*)5/.4#-:ZUa ?'(%.)("#*6%72+))(%=#)+%((%4A-

/.b")-( %.&?%A(/A%2 (#**/()*76"#*# ("#N%BB%./.#(6)*A /- ("# _3'S'$%$%$9%$%6/E%$-)A.)6.

%->3'0'I%.%" %$b")*%-%./F26%- %. /.+$'#.(/%$6*/(#* ).>*%3/4$%.='%=#I/"%&/-(

+)*'!>()4)$$#4(/.(#$$/=#.4#).>73'

0'I%.%"

I)/.#&

+)*4#-

6/("

("#

!!?

%.&

%$

\%D/&%

%.&

('*.#&

).

"/-

/.(#$$/=#.4# 4).(%4(-: ;"%( 6%- +(#*XYYZ2`6.0,-#*-#**.*%'7=-*/-#94K,%-%/-%$#

O.3%24O/)#*:C#&?7#*%2/B.0,+/-%.,E>,*/$XYZYF:ZUT V)*B')(#-##H(#/.3#*=:ZU^ H(#.#*-#.:ZU] [.(#$C#.(#*2_P/"%&/8/)?*)&'4(/).O*)',9*#%A)'(37>+="%.?*)5/.4#5Z:Y2`X^J4()3#*XYY^k

8%"/&9*)6.2_N%BB%./1%/&-g>.%$7-/-)+("#0%(%2`/.(#*.%$C!C&)4')'(,)-('-#&()4)$$#4(/.(#$$/=#.4#2-##S%*AS%RR#((/2

_C[>!%A#-).9/==#*%.&1/-A/#*1)$#).V*).(G/.#-2`C#&D.*E!%7#'2cZ0#4#


48/56

$%

,'3$/-""/- l("# -'/4/)44#,(N/$\%e/&%O#.#*%$C)+="%./-(%.?%A/-(%.9)**1#=/).%.&("#;#-(2`C)'.(#*(#**)*/-$#KH,/$$/'-2_C[>-'/4/)


49/56

$&

).$/.#%4(/5/(7%.&("#I/"%&/-(4).-%*%$S'I%"/&/.

M#(6)*A2XT>,*/$XYZY:ZTX >-


50/56

$'

%6%7 +*)44)*&/.= () % -)'*4#6/(" +/*-("%.& %44#--2N%BB%./ +/="(#*-6#*#

)**#& /. ).# 4%-# /. XYY] () .)( ,%*(/4/,%(# /. %. #K,#4(#& 4$%-"6/(" ?%A/-(%./

-)$&/#*-:ZTd N%BB%./ +/="(#*-6#*# ()$& ("%( ?%A/-(%./ !%$/3%.2 .)( >+="%. !%$/3%.2

6)'$&+/="(?%A/-(%./+="%./-(%. %.& ?%A/-(%.I/"%&- %*# &/-(/.4( %.& ("# %,,$/4%(/). )+

5/)$#.4#/--#=+="%./-(%.D-H)'("#%-(+)*%

.'


51/56

$(

!"/-"#$,-()*#&'4#("#=*)',D-,#..4#',).%-/.=$#%4()*2-'4"%-("#[H[2%.&

*#/.+)*4#- /(- .#K'- ,)-/(/).: !"# N%BB%./ .#(6)*A %$-) '-#- -'4" %44#-- %.& /(-

*#$%(/).-"/,- ()"#&=# /(-,)-/(/).%.&=%/. $#5#*%=#)5#*)("#*%4()*-: V)*#K%'(")*-D/.(#*5/#66/("?/*Q'3%/*H"%"2ZcH#,(#


52/56

$)

=1'.#*.V $(,.1QI %'- /012+.(1' 13 %24%5(-% %'- ."# $\%D/&%D-=$)3%$I/"%&%.$#


53/56

%*

/.4$'&/.= H%/+ %$>$:ZT] [+ ("/- %44)'.( /- (*'#2 /(6)'$& %=%/. ,$%4# ("#N%BB%./

.#(6)*A %( ("# 4#.(#* )+ %$\%D/&% %.& /(- =$)3%$I/"%&: @:H: #++)*(- () &/-*',( %.&

=*%%$\%D/&%()&%72("#*#+)*#2%*#I'-(%-,*/$XYZZ(*/,()?%A/-(%.2("#4"%/*&,*/$XYZZ:

S#


54/56

%!

+="%./-(%.:

!"# +/.&/.=- )+ ("/- *#,)*( %&& +'*("#* 4$%*/(7 () ("/- ,/4('*# %.& ("# 4"%$$#.=#-

/.5)$5#&: H/.4#]fZZ("#@./(#&H(%(#-"%-,*)5/&3/$$/).-)+&)$$%*-/.+="%./-(%./-*#+$#4(/5#)+("#=*)',D-/


55/56

%"

.#(6)*A!>2-'4"%-("#XYYaS/*%.-"%"?#%4#>44)*&:Z^a

1#4).4/$/%(/).#++)*(-6/("("#\'#((%H"'*%!%$/3%.4)


56/56

6;;/)O?TX!$/$6446)?)/!A97M5@=79@@O?8/)@?9)6N)/TL@

)1.#Y/*Z2%'%.(1'X !"# -)4/%$ .#(6)*A- -")6. /. ("/- =*%,"/4 6#*# =#.#*%(#& +)*

/$$'-(*%(/5#,'*,)-#-).$7%.&.)(3%-#&).#

Documents

Haqqani Report - CTC at West Point