Upload
sherman-stephens
View
218
Download
1
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Indian Weather Markets…..
Weather Risk Management Services Pvt. Ltd.
Read how organizations describe their exposure…
Indian Market……
o EID Parry sales, net down 86 pc on monsoon failure. - The Hindu, Jan 17, 2003
o The Company's business is seasonal in nature and the performance can be impacted by weather conditions - Notes to Accounts, Syngenta (I) Ltd.
o Monsanto India continued its strong profit growth on the back of positive all-round business performance aided by a good monsoon. - Annual Report 2003-04, Monsanto Ltd
o The delayed monsoon has hit the fertilizer stocks badly. - Analyst, Hindu Business Line
o Over 1000 farmers commit suicide in vidarbha and Telangana in last two years – TOI
o An average drought costs upto Rs 4 bn to the state exchequer,Gujarat earthquake resulted in direct damages of about Rs.153 billion -NDMC
Indian Market
Impacts Yields
10000
15000
20000
25000
30000
35000
40000
45000
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
years
pro
du
cti
on
-3000
-2000
-1000
0
1000
2000
3000
Fu
ncti
on
(rain
fall
*tem
p)
70000
75000
80000
85000
90000
95000
100000
Production
year
pro
du
cti
on
-10000000
-5000000
0
5000000
10000000
15000000
20000000
Fu
ncti
on
of
rain
*tem
p
Impacts on Acreages
Impact on Prices
2003 2004 2005 2006
Area Sown 40.908 44.439 41.922 45.501
Yield in Kg/Hect
1019 824 796
Prices before sowing (May & June & July)
1610 1520 1380 1810 1680 1839 1268 1285 1301 1323 1260 1263
Rainfall Actual % Dep Price Actual % Dep Price Actual % Dep Price Actual % Dep Price
June 129 22 1520 81 -25 1680 82 -24 1285 26 -83 1260
July 315 3 1380 215 -30 1839 379 24 1301 282 1 1263
Aug 216 -32 1250 423 34 1891 132 -58 1265 459 58 1261
Sept 259 45 1380 47 -73 1724 165 -6 1218 257 57 1238
Impact of Weather on Farming
o Makes the earnings volatile, Affects working capital repayment
o Affects contractual obligationo In plantations/ corporate Farming Fixed : Variable cost
ratio is higho High Fixed Costs puts profits under pressure
• When production reduces in the key producing months Happens primarily on account of weather
o Possibly affects expansion plan when price outlook is positive
Impact of Weather on Farming
15 May-10 June
11 June – 31 July
Aug 1 – Sep 30
Establishment
Flowering & Veg
Growth
Pod Formation & Maturity
60mm160mm
100mmRainfall Index:
Stages:
Time:
Which crop to go for ??
When to apply pesticides ??
When to harvest ??
Seed Sale = f (Acreages, Competition)
Acreage = f (Onset, Price, Credit)
Seed Sale = f (Acreages, Competition)
Acreage = f (Monsoon Onset, Price, Credit)
Around 60% sowing finishes by 20th July
Effect of last years prices on acreage
0
1
2
3
2004 2005 2006
acre
age
(lha)
0
500
1000
1500
2000
last
yea
rs a
v pr
ice(
Rs)
Buldana Nagpur Last yrs price(Rs)
Seed Sale = f (Acreages, Competition)
Acreage = f (Monsoon Onset, Price, Credit)
Pesticides Sale = f (Acreages, Weather Conditions during Vegetative growth, Competition)
Pesticides Sale = f (Acreages, Weather Conditions during Vegetative growth, Competition)
Weather & Agri-Value Chain
Farmer
Fertilizers
Seed
Pesticides
Farm Equipment
Agro-processor
Farmer
Fertilizers
Seed
Pesticides
Farm Equipment
Agro-processor
Farmer
Fertilizers
Seed
Pesticides
Farm Equipment
Agro-processor
Credit Risk
Value Destruction - Weather
Higher InventoryLoss of sales
opportunity
Weather Becoming More Extreme
o Extreme rainfall incidents have seen a huge jump in recent decades over northwest India (including Maharashtra and Gujarat) during the summer monsoon
o Orissa has been reeling under contrasting extreme weather conditions for more than a decade: from heat waves to cyclones and from droughts to floods. The death toll due to heat waves in Rajasthan, Punjab, Gujarat, and Bihar is on the rise
o The coastal regions have been undergoing stronger wind and flood damage due to storm surges associated with more intense tropical storms in recent years. Frequent inundation of low lying areas, more flooding and increase in the salinity of rivers, bays and aquifers in the coastal regions have occurred more often during the past decade.
Weather risk management
Financial weather risk is the occurrence of an observable weather event or variability in a measurable weather index that causes losses either to property or profits for an individual, government or corporation.
Weather risk management products – packaged as either (re)insurance or derivatives – are settled off of the same index that has been determined to cause losses and reduces weather risk through mitigating payouts.
Manageable weather risks
Temperature
Precipitation
Snowfall
Wind Speed
Streamflow
Sunshine hours
Soil Moisture
Humidity
Hurricanes
A WEATHER INDEX IS GENERALLY CONSTRUCTED AS A FUNCTION A WEATHER INDEX IS GENERALLY CONSTRUCTED AS A FUNCTION OF FREQUENCY OF OCCURRENCE OF FREQUENCY OF OCCURRENCE ANDAND MAGNITUDE OF EVENT MAGNITUDE OF EVENT
PRICEPRICE VOLUMEVOLUME REVENUEREVENUExx ==
PRICE RISK PRICE RISK MANAGEMENTMANAGEMENT
WEATHER RISK WEATHER RISK MANAGEMENTMANAGEMENT
LOWER LOWER EARNINGS EARNINGS
VOLATILITYVOLATILITY++
Weather impacts volume
Less volatility equals greater value
U/H H
Earnings $75 M $73 M
EPS $0.75 $0.73
Multiple 8x 9x
Stock Price $6.00 $6.57
Market Cap $600MM $657MM
Debt $100 M $100 M
COD 8.00 % 7.90 %
Debt Svc $8.0MM $7.9MM
Historical Revenues
UNHEDGED Expected Revenues
Without Weather Protection
$75 Million
HEDGED Expected Revenues
With Weather Protection
$73 Million
Reducing the volatility due to weather has a budget cost but increases returns per unit of risk and can potentially improve stock valuations and the cost of/access to financing.
Sales Expansion Thru Weather Insurance
Example (Case for possible expansion in sales, faced with high weather risk)Threshold return on capital 25%Budget capital 250 lacsWithout Weather Insurance
Sales in an area 160 lacsPotential profit in an area 50 lacs Lower profits due to lack of scaleRisk Capital Employed due to Non Weather Risks 160 lacs Assumed @ Rs 1 per unit of salesRisk Capital employed due to weather 96 lacs Assumed @ Rs. 0.6 per unit of salesReturn on capital employed 20%
With Weather Insurance
Potential sales in an area 250 Improved sales
Potential profit in an area 125 Improved profits due to larger scaleWeather Insurance Premium 12 @ 8% of Risk Capital due to weatherProfit after Insurance 113Risk Capital Employed due to Non Weather Risks 250 Assumed @ Rs 1 per unit of salesRisk Capital employed due to weather 0Return on capital employed 45% Beating return on capital threshold
Sales can be expanded in several areas where sales are presently subdued due to weather risks
•Larger scale may also ensure reduction in price of seeds, thereby
facilitating sales• Several precautionary measures
built in sales process to tackle weather risk, which inhibit sales; scope for process improvement
Processing of data received from sensors and converting it according to specific product
On Site wireless Sensors
Farmers Console (GIS)
Organizing Real Time Data
o Covering important agricultural zones real time, at a cost of approx. Rs.500 per sq.km or Rs.5 per ha
o Generation of Historical records for any given long.- lat. Position• Statistical & Neural
Network model o Building UAV and
Advanced remote sensing applications to assist this
Spatial Interpolation
RMS error ( under square root transformation) ~ 2mm
Decision Support System
Identification &
Quantification of the Risk
Current Weather
Data
Forecast Inputs
-Crop Planning-Irrigation planning-Pest Management-Yield forecast-Risk Transfer
Front-end Output
Scientific modeling of risk
Simplified output in vernacular language for farmers
Needs to be customized for Bank’s portfolio
Hybrid Products – Filling the Gap
Thank you
El Nino/La Nina association with all-India summer monsoon rainfall anomalies during 1871-2001
Number of years with …
Deficient monsoonDeficit>10%
Normal monsoon(-ve)
Normal monsoon (+ve)
Excess monsoonexcess>10%
Total
El Nino 11 11 4 0 26
La Nina 0 1 9 8 18
Other 11 23 42 11 87
Total 22 35 55 19 131
More on Monsoon and ENSO