Murdoch on the Sovereignty of Good - Kieran Setiya · 2016-03-16 · Murdoch on the Sovereignty of Good

! ! "#$%&'!()*!+#,!- &./!01()

Murdoch on the

Sovereignty of Good

Kieran SetiyaUniversity of Pittsburgh

2! 01()! 345678!95:4;7This work is licensed under a Creative Commons

!""#$%&"$'()*'(+',,-#.$/0)*'1-#$2/"$2-3456748$.-(3-6 9:::6;<$0'3';<-#3$,;#$("6'#=>1()11->?

T <#%=<! ><'! ?>! .>! @'$$AB+#@+! .>! .+/! C?=%D'! 48!E64:4FG!HG4IJFAJHG;! F48K5! (-L1*! M64F! NO6PJKGQF! 4RH7K:! J8! :G5! HG4IJFJHG4K7I!S5IPF!48!TG4KG!FG5!T6J:5!4F!G76P!:J!R7U5!JO:,!9G5!4F!K4:5P!7F!78!

48VO58K5!W;!XJ67!Y47RJ8P*!ZJG8!NKYJT5II*![4I76;!\O:87R*!XG76I5F!]7;IJ6*!E56876P!̂ 4II47RF*!78P!9OF78!̂ JI_,1!EO:!FG5!4F!6765I;!R58:4J85P!48! 65K58:!TJ6U,!]G565!ROF:!W5!R78;!RJ67I!HG4IJFJHG56F!TGJ!G7`5!85`56!657P*!J6!G76PI;!:GJOaG:!7WJO:*!G56!W5F:!78P!RJF:!F;F:5R7:4K!5FAF7;F*!48!@<-4A'2-#-$=("B4'C4D''E,!]G5!657FJ8F!_J6!:G4F!85aI5K:!765!`764JOF,!NO6PJKG! I5_:!G56!7K7P5R4K!HJF4:4J8!7:!bc_J6P! 48! (-d),!9G5! F:JHH5P!HOWI4FG48a!48!HG4IJFJHG;!eJO687IF,!f8P!FG5!H6JPOK5P!_5T56!5FF7;F!J_!78;!U48P*!_J6!:G5!RJF:!H76:!T64:48a!8J`5IF!48F:57P,

fIJ8a!T4:G! :G5F5! FJK4JIJa4K7I! _7K:F*! :G565! 765! P4gKOI:45F! 48:5687I!:J!NO6PJKGQF!TJ6U,![56!T64:48a!K78!W5!JH7hO5*!G56!`45TF!JWFKO65,!M:!4F!8J:!57F;!:J!4P58:4_;!76aOR58:F*!4_!FG5!G7F!:G5R*!J6!KI576!JWe5K:4J8F!:J!JHHJF48a!`45TF,!f8P!TG565!T5!PJ!S8P!JWe5K:4J8F!78P!76aOR58:F*!:G546!:76a5:F!J_:58!F55R!P7:5P!J6!4665I5`78:,!i]G5!MP57!J_!\56_5K:4J8j!4F!_67R5P!7F!7!K64:4hO5!J_!9:O76:![7RHFG465QF!@<'&=<"4/(E4!."$'(*!TG4KG!:G5F5!P7;F!4F!FO65I;!657P!78P!K4:5P!I5FF!:G78!NO6PJKG!G56F5I_,2!k;I5QF!7II5a5P!W5G7`4JO64FR!4F!48!:G5!W7KUa6JO8Pl!8J!IJ8a56!7!I4`5!KJ8K568,!M8! RJ67I! :G5J6;*! NO6PJKGQF! 48:56IJKO:J6F! 765! k,!N,! [765*! TGJF5!48VO58K5! G7F! 7IFJ! T785P*! 7IJ8a! T4:G! K764K7:O65F! J_! 5c4F:58:47I4FR!78P!J_!378:,!]G5!65FOI:! 4F! :G7:!NO6PJKG!4F!8J:!K4:5P!J6!P4FKOFF5P!W;!RJF:!KJ8:5RHJ676;!TJ6U!48!RJ67I!HF;KGJIJa;*!7!:JH4K!TGJF5!KO6658:!48K7687:4J8! JT5F! ROKG! :J! G56,3! 9G5! 4F*! 4_! 78;:G48a*! I5FF! `4F4WI5! 48!RJ67I!5H4F:5RJIJa;*!48!:G5!R5:7HG;F4KF!J_!RJ67IF*!78P!48!:G5!F:OP;!J_!H67K:4K7I!657FJ8,!

M_!NO6PJKG!4F!:J!FH57U!RJ65!7OP4WI;!:J!KJ8:5RHJ676;!HG4IJFJHG56F*!FJ! :G7:! FG5! K788J:! W5! 4a8J65P*! G56! 4P57F! ROF:! W5! 65_67R5P! 7F!48:56`58:4J8F!48!5c4F:48a!P4FHO:5F*!G56!76aOR58:F!ROF:!W5!65KJ`565P*!(,! 955! Y47RJ8P! (--Lm!NKYJT5II! (-n-m! \O:87R! 0110m! ]7;IJ6! (-o-m!^4II47RF!

(-oLm!^JI_!(--1,

0,! b64a487II;!HOWI4FG5P!48!(-dp*!i]G5!MP57!J_!\56_5K:4J8j!4F!:G5!S6F:!5FF7;!48!The A'2-#-$=("B4'C4D''E!qNO6PJKG!(-n1r,!]G5!J:G56F!765!ib8!stJPQ!78P!stJJPQj!78P!i]G5!9J`5654a8:;!J_!tJJP!b`56!b:G56!XJ8K5H:Fj,! M!T4II!K4:5! :G5F5!5FF7;F!7F!:G5;!7HH576!48!:G5!WJJU,

),! b8!NO6PJKG!78P!RJ67I!HF;KGJIJa;*!F55!E6J7KU5F!01(0l!)d8,nn,

ImprintPhilosophers’

! B?'D.+!>'u?/. Murdoch on the Sovereignty of Good

v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!0!!w! "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

1. How to Be an Ethical Rationalist

M8!R;!H56G7HF!O8KJ8`58:4J87I!OF7a5*!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4FR!4F!:G5!H6Je5K:!J_!P564`48a!F:78P76PF!J_!H67K:4K7I!657FJ8!_6JR!:G5!87:O65!J_!7a58K;!J6!:G5!T4II*!7F! :G5!K7H7K4:;!:J!7K:! _J6!657FJ8F,5!]G4F!H6Je5K:! 4F!5:G4K7I! 48!:G5!T4P5F:!F58F5,!]G5!67:4J87I4F:!855P!8J:!R7U5!KI74RF!_J6!RJ67I4:;!7F!7!FJO6K5!J_!657FJ8F!J6!_J6!:G5!67:4J87I4:;!J_!KJ8K568!_J6!J:G56F,!EO:!G4F!FOWe5K:!4F!H67K:4K7Il!GJT!T5!FGJOIP!I4`5!78P!7K:,![4F!:657:R58:!J_!:G4F!FOWe5K:!4F!7!_J6R!J_!67:4J87I4FR!48!:G7:!4:!a58567I4x5F!7!_7R4I476!657P48a!J_!378:! 48!D#'&(E:'#F4 MMM,6!b8! :G4F! 657P48a*! 4:!W5IJ8aF! :J!7a58:F*! 7F!FOKG*!:J!7K:!iO8P56!:G5!4P57!J_!_655PJRj!78P!FJ!:J!W5!65FHJ8F4`5!:J!:G5!RJ67I!I7T,!yJ:!:G7:!5`56;!7a58:!PJ5F!65FHJ8P*!WO:!:G5!H6JH58F4:;!:J!PJ!FJ!4F!KJ8:7485P!48!:G5!K7H7K4:;!:J!7K:,!M:F!657I4x7:4J8!4F!:GOF!78!7FH5K:!J_!H67K:4K7I!67:4J87I4:;,!]G5!a58567I4x7:4J8!J_!:G4F!7HH6J7KG!I57`5F!6JJR!_J6!FH5K45F!J_!67:4J87I4FR!J8!TG4KG!T5!7K:!48:58:4J87II;!8J:!O8P56!:G5!4P57!J_!_655PJR!WO:!O8P56!:G5!aO4F5!J_!:G5!aJJP*7!J6!J8!TG4KG!T5!74R!7:!F5I_AU8JTI5Pa5!J6!:G5!F7:4F_7K:4J8!J_!P5F465*!FJ!:G7:!4:!4F!:G5!JWe5K:!J_!H67K:4K7I!657FJ8!:J!7KG45`5!:G5!aJJP*!:J!a748!F5I_AO8P56F:78P48a*!J6!:J!a5:!TG7:5`56!;JO!T78:,8!M8!78!7I:5687:4`5!4P4JR*!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4FR!4F!iKJ8F:4:O:4`4FRj!7WJO:!H67K:4K7I!657FJ8*!TG565!:G5!KJ8F:4:O:4`5!`45T!855P!8J:!W5!378:478!48!65FOI:,!]G5!F:78P76PF!:G7:!VJT!_6JR!:G5!87:O65!J_! 7a58K;!R7;!W5! J85F! J_! F5I_A48:565F:! J6!R578FA58P! 5gK458K;*! 8J:!RJ67I!PO:;,

^G7:5`56! 4:F! FH5K4SK! KJ8:58:*! :G5! 67:4J87I4F:! H6Je5K:!RJ`5F! _6JR!R5:7HG;F4K7I!H65R4F5F!:J!8J6R7:4`5!KJ8KIOF4J8F*!_6JR!:G5!R5:7HG;F4KF!J_!7a58K;!:J!:G5!8J6RF!J_!H67K:4K7I!657FJ8,!f!K58:67I!:7FU!_J6!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4F:F!4F!:J!5cHI748!:G4F!:678F4:4J8,![JT!PJ!T5!a5:!_6JR!:G5!is!J_!L,! ]G4F! F5K:4J8! P67TF! J8! 95:4;7! 01(0l! (Lw0(! 78P! J8! 95:4;7! _J6:GKJR48am! 4:F!

_67R5TJ6U!P564`5F!_6JR!95:4;7!011n,

d,! 378:!(noL,

n,! M8!:G7:!JO6!7K:4J8!F:64U5F!OF!7F!aJJP!48!FJR5!65FH5K:m!_J6!s:G5!aO4F5!J_!:G5!aJJPQ!F55!z5II5R78!(--0,

o,! 955!Reasons without Rationalism! q95:4;7! 011nl! (pwLr*! K4:48a!3J6Fa776P! (--dm!k74I:J8!(--nm!z5II5R78!(-o-*!0111m!^4II47RF!(-n-m!Y65456!(--n,!]J! :G4F! I4F:*!J85!R4aG:!7PP!3J6Fa776P!011-m!k7x! (---*!01((m!zJaI56!0110m!78P*!J8!J85!48:56H65:7:4J8*!9R4:G!011-*!01(1,

78P!G56!KJ8KIOF4J8F!R7P5!KI576,!^4:G!8J:7WI5!5cK5H:4J8F*! _5T!G7`5!:7U58! OH! :G4F! :7FUm! :G565! 4F! 7! IJ:! :J! W5! PJ85,! M8! :G4F! 5FF7;*! M! :6;! :J!R7U5!H6Ja65FF!G565*!:J!W648a!JO:!:G5!_J6K5!78P!KJa58K;!J_!NO6PJKGQF!:G48U48a!W;!65I7:48a!4:!:J!78!4FFO5!:G7:!4F!K56:748I;!I4`5l!:G7:!J_!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4FR! 78P! :G5! hO5F:4J8*! i^G;! W5! RJ67I{j! N;! 74R! 4F! 8J:! :J!5`7IO7:5!NO6PJKGQF!̀ 45TF!WO:!:J!R7U5!:G5R!HI7OF4WI5*!48:5II4a4WI5*!78P*!FJ!_76!7F!HJFF4WI5*!76aOR58:7:4`5I;!FG76H,!^G7:!5R56a5F!4F*!M!W5I45`5*!7!KJ8K5H:4J8!J_!a657:!J64a487I4:;!78P!:G5J65:4K7I!HJT56,!M_!4:!4F!T6J8a*!4:! 4F!T6J8a!48! 48:565F:48a!T7;Fm! :J!F7;!TG7:!:G5;!765! I45F!JO:F4P5!R;!H65F58:!FKJH5,

]G4F!5FF7;!G7F!_JO6!R748!H76:F,!M8!:G5!S6F:*!M!48:6JPOK5!:G5!4P57!J_!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4FR!78P!65I7:5!4:!:J!:G5!H6JWI5R!J_!RJ67I!657FJ8F,!M8!:G5!F5KJ8P*!M!F5:!JO:!NO6PJKGQF!F:64U48a!KI74R!:G7:!i:6O5!`4F4J8!JKK7F4J8F!64aG:! KJ8POK:j! 78P! 5cHI748! 4:F! 4RHJ6:78K5! _J6! :G5! 67:4J87I4F:! P5W7:5!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!dpr,!]GJOaG!4:F!:6O:G!TJOIP!W5!F4a84SK78:*!NO6PJKGQF!KI74R! 4F! H6JWI5R7:4K,! M:! F55RF! HJFF4WI5*! J|AG78P*! _J6! FJR5J85! :J!FG765!:G5!`4F4J8!:G7:!iJKK7F4J8F!64aG:!KJ8POK:j!T4:GJO:!7K:48a!T5II,!M8!F5K:4J8!:G655*!M!FGJT!GJT!NO6PJKG!78:4K4H7:5F!:G4F!KG76a5!W;!:67K48a!4:! :J! 7! P5_5K:4`5! :G5J6;! J_! KJ8K5H:F,! ]G7:! :G5! :G5J6;! aJ5F!T6J8a! 4F!:G5!RJ67I!J_!G56!RJF:!_7RJOF!5c7RHI5*!:G7:!J_!N!78P!Y,4!M!aJ!J8!:J!5cHIJ65! :G5!58:78aI5R58:!J_! _7K:!78P!`7IO5! 48!NO6PJKGQF!`45T*!GJT!4:!P4|56F!_6JR!:G5!7HH57I!:J!i:G4KU!RJ67I!KJ8K5H:Fj*!78P!GJT!4:!P67TF!J8!7!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;!J_!KJ8K5H:AHJFF5FF4J8,!95K:4J8!_JO6!:G58!:O68F!:J!:G5!i4R7a5!J_!:G5!tJJP!7F!7!:678FK58P58:!R7a85:4K!K58:65j!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l! n)r*! TJ6U48a! :G6JOaG! :G5! JPP! R4c! J_! 5RH464K7I! HF;KGJIJa;*!RJ67I! 5cGJ6:7:4J8*! 78P! FH5KOI7:4`5! R5:7HG;F4KF! 48! @<-4 A'2-#-$=("B4'C4D''E,!NO6PJKGQF! :G5J6;!J_! KJ8K5H:F*! 48:6JPOK5P! 48! :G5!S6F:! 5FF7;!J_!A'2-#-$=("B!78P!P5`5IJH5P! 48! :G5!F5KJ8P*!H6J`4P5F! :G5!W7F4F! _J6!7!RJ67I!76aOR58:!TGJF5!KJ8KIOF4J8!4F!R5:7HG;F4K7Il!:G7:!:G5!tJJP!4F!8J:*!7_:56!7II*!4IIOFJ6;,!M_!:G4F!4F!64aG:*!NO6PJKGQF!TJ6U!G7F!4RHI4K7:4J8F!8J:!J8I;!_J6!H67K:4K7I!657FJ8!78P!RJ67I!R5:7HG;F4KF!WO:!_J6!:G5!FKJH5!78P!7RW4:4J8!J_!RJ67I!HG4IJFJHG;,

p,! NO6PJKG!(-n1l!(dw0),


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!)!!w! "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

J6! :58P! :JT76PF*! 78! 74R! :G7:! :G5;!R7;! 8J:! 657I4x5! 5`58!TG58! :G5;!FOKK55P! 48! 7K:48a! _J6! 657FJ8F,11! ]G5! 7KG45`5R58:! J_! :G4F! 74R! PJ5F!8J:! FJ6:! W5G7`4JO6! 7F! 48:58:4J87I! J6!8J:l! 4:! J|56F! 78! 4P57I! :J!TG4KG!48:58:4J87I! 7K:4J8!R7;!J6!R7;!8J:! KJ8_J6R,! M:! 4F!8J:! 7! KJ8P4:4J8!J_!7K:48a!_J6!657FJ8F!:G7:!J85!G4:!:G5!:76a5:!48!hO5F:4J8*!J8I;!:G7:!J85!74R!7:!PJ48a!FJ,!]G4F!F:6OK:O65!7IIJTF!_J6!P5_5K:4`5!7K:4J8!48!:G5!_67R5TJ6U!J_!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4FRl!:G5!K7H7K4:;!:J!7K:!_J6!657FJ8F!K78!W5!5c56K4F5P!4RH56_5K:I;*!48!T7;F!:G7:!PJ!8J:!_OII;!7KG45`5!4:F!58P,12

]G5! 4P57! J_! 78! 74R! J6! _O8K:4J8! :G7:! SaO65F! 48! :G5! 67:4J87I4F:!76aOR58:!855P!8J:!W5!R;F:564JOF,!948K5!67:4J87I4F:F!GJH5!_J6!F:78P76PF!J_! H67K:4K7I! 657FJ8! :G7:! 7HHI;! :J! 7a58:F*! 7F! FOKG*! 65a76PI5FF! J_! :G546!W4JIJa4K7I!_J6R*!:G5;!PJ!8J:!7HH57I!:J!FH5K4SK7II;!W4JIJa4K7I!_O8K:4J8,13 yJ6!PJ!:G5;!7HH57I!:J!7!H76:4KOI76!48:58:4J8!J6!P5F465,!M8F:57P!:G5;!:O68!:J!P4FHJF4:4J8F!:G7:!KJ8F:4:O:5!7a58K;!J6! :J!6OI5F!78P!H648K4HI5F! :G7:!aO4P5!OF!4_!T5!7K:!_J6!657FJ8F!7:!7II,!]G565!4F!6JJR!:J!W5!V5c4WI5!G565,!M_!T5!:G48U!J_!:G5!74R!7F!Sc5P!W;!7!P4FHJF4:4J8!J_!5`56;!HJFF4WI5!7a58:*!T5! 58P! OH!T4:G! TG7:! 4F! K7II5P! i48:5687I4FR! 7WJO:! 657FJ8Fjl! 7a58:F!G7`5!:G5!K7H7K4:;!:J!W5!RJ`5P!W;!78;!657FJ8!:J!TG4KG!:G5;!765!FOWe5K:,!qNJ65!J8!:G4F!W5IJT,r!fI:5687:4`5I;*! :J!W5!78!7a58:! 4F! :J!/;;#'G$,/"- :G5!HJFF5FF4J8!J_!P4FHJF4:4J8F!TGJF5!:76a5:!4F!:G565W;!KJ8F:4:O:5P!7F!:G5!74R!J_!7a58:F*!7F!FOKG,14!^G58!7a58:F!_7II!FGJ6:!J_!_OII!HJFF5FF4J8*!48:5687I4FR! _74IF,! }4:G56!T7;*! J85! K78!R784_5F:! :G5!P4FHJF4:4J8F! :G7:!KJ8F:4:O:5!7a58K;*!:J!:G5!5c:58:!:G7:!J85!G7F!:G5R*!54:G56!4RH56_5K:I;!J6!48!_OII,!M8:58:4J87I!7K:4J8!4F!:G5!H6JPOK:!J_!FOKG!P4FHJF4:4J8F*!TG4KG!F5:!7!:76a5:!_J6!7a58:F!:J!R55:!48!TG7:!:G5;!PJ,

]G5!F5KJ8P!7FFORH:4J8!J_!:G5!67:4J87I4F:!76aOR58:!4F!TG7:!M!G7`5!K7II5P! i}cK5II58K5j,! M:! 4F! TJ6:G! F:65FF48a! GJT!RJP5F:! :G4F! H648K4HI5!4F,! yJ:! J8I;! PJ5F! 4:! 8J:! 65hO465! :G5! RJ65! KJ8:58:4JOF! 5I5R58:F! J_!

((,! ~J6! :G4F! 65hO465R58:*! _67R5P!7F! 78!JWe5K:4J8! :J!z5II5R78*! F55!XI76U!011(l!Lo(woL,

(0,! b8!:G5!7HH7658:!P4gKOI:;!G565*!F55!k74I:J8!(--nl!�)m!3J6Fa776P!011-l!XG,!o,

(),! 9R4:G!01(1l!(0pwL,

(p,! ]G5!6JI5!J_!7HH6Jc4R7:4J8!4F!5RHG7F4x5P!48!Y65456!(--nl!o-w-(*!-nwo*!78P!9R4:G!011-l!ddw-,

TG7:!4:!4F!:J!W5!78!7a58:*!:J!G7`5!7!T4II!J6!:G5!K7H7K4:;!:J!7K:!_J6!657FJ8F*!:J!:G5!'&=<"!J_!H67K:4K7I!67:4J87I4:;{

M8!J85!J_!:G5!RJF:!5cHI4K4:!P5`5IJHR58:F!J_!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4FR*!Z,!Y7`4P!z5II5R78!H65F58:F!48:58:4J87I!7K:4J8!7F!G7`48a!7!iKJ8F:4:O:4`5!74Rj*!TG4KG! 4F! F5I_AU8JTI5Pa5!J6! F5I_AO8P56F:78P48a,9!NJ65! 65K58:I;*!XG64F:485!3J6Fa776P!P5FK64W5F!:G5!74R!J_!7a58K;!7F!iF5I_AKJ8F:4:O:4J8j,10 M8!TJ6U48a!JO:!:G5!W7F4F!J_!:G5!67:4J87I4F:!7HH6J7KG*!T5!K78!a58567I4x5!:G5F5! KI74RF,!b8! 57KG! 7KKJO8:*! 7a58K;! 4F*! 48! 5|5K:*! 7! _O8K:4J87I! J6!:5I5JIJa4K7I!U48P*!P5S85P!W;!78!58P!J6!aJ7I,!]G4F!FKG5R7!K78!7HHI;!:J!J:G56!`45TF,! M:!R4aG:!W5! 48! :G5!87:O65!J_!7a58:F! :J!74R!7:!H56_5K:!7O:J8JR;*!7:!R578FA58P!KJG5658K5*!J6!7:!:G5!G4aG5F:!aJJP,!b8K5!T5!:G48U!J_!7a58K;!48!:G5F5!:56RF*!T5!K78!:67K5!:G5!H4`J:7I!RJ`5!J_!:G5!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4F:!:J!7!_O8K:4J8!76aOR58:!48FH465P!W;!f64F:J:I5,!k5K7II!:G7:*!_J6!f64F:J:I5*!GOR78!W548aF!G7`5!7!P5S848a!_O8K:4J8!J6!7K:4`4:;*!TG4KG!4F!:G5!OF5!J_!657FJ8*!78P!TG7:5`56!G7F!7!_O8K:4J8!S8PF!4:F!aJJP!48! H56_J6R48a! :G7:! _O8K:4J8! T5II,! ]G565! 765! F:78P76P! JWe5K:4J8F,! MF!4:! 64aG:! :J! FH57U! J_! 7! GOR78! _O8K:4J8{!YJ5F! :G5! 76aOR58:! KJ8V7:5!TG7:!4F!aJJP!C'#!78!~!T4:G!W548a!aJJP!as!78!~{!}`58!4_!:G5;!765!FJO8P*!GJT5`56*!:G5F5!hO5F:4J8F!PJ!8J:!:JOKG!:G5!H648K4HI5!T5!855P,

}��'$$'+�'l!^G58!~F!G7`5!7!P5S848a!_O8K:4J8!J6!7K:4`4:;*!7!aJJP!~!4F!J85!:G7:!H56_J6RF!:G7:!7K:4`4:;!J6!_O8K:4J8!T5II,

M_!TG7:!4:!4F!:J!W5!78!7a58:!4F!:J!74R!7:!7O:J8JR;*!J6!F5I_AU8JTI5Pa5*!J6!TG7:5`56*!TG7:!4:!4F!:J!W5!aJJP!7F!78!7a58:!4F!:J!74R!7:!:G5F5!:G48aF!5|5K:4`5I;,!948K5!H67K:4K7I!657FJ8!4F!:G5!̀ 46:O5!J_!7a58K;*!7F!FOKG*!J85!4F!:J!:G7:!5c:58:!H67K:4K7II;!67:4J87I,!]G5!67:4J87I4F:!7KKJO8:!aJ5F!:G6JOaG,

^5!K78!FH5II!JO:!:G5!P5R78PF!J_!:G4F!76aOR58:!RJ65!FIJTI;,!~46F:*!4:!65I45F!J8!7!K56:748!F:6OK:O65!48!:G5!_O8K:4J8!J_!7a58K;l!8J:!eOF:!:G7:!7a58:F!765!P5S85P!W;!78!7K:4`4:;!�!PJ48a!:G48aF!_J6!657FJ8F!�!WO:!:G7:!7a58K;!G7F!7!:76a5:*!I4U5!G7HH485FF!J6!R578FA58P!KJG5658K5*!J_!TG4KG!4:!K78! _7II! FGJ6:,! M:!W5IJ8aF! :J! :G5!87:O65!J_!7a58:F! :J!W5!P465K:5P!W;*!

-,! 955*!5FH5K47II;*!:G5!48:6JPOK:4J8!:J!z5II5R78!0111,

(1,! M8!3J6Fa776P!011-,!


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!p!!w! "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

4F!8J:!:J!H65FOHHJF5!:G5!:6O:G!J_!67:4J87I4FRm!J85!K78!7KK5H:!4:!5`58!4_!J85!PJOW:F!:G7:!:G5!87:O65!J_!7a58K;!4F!7!FJO6K5!J_!67:4J87I!8J6RF,!M_!F:78P76PF!_J6!W548a!aJJP!qua!7a58:!PJ!8J:!VJT!_6JR!:G5!87:O65!J_!7a58K;*!7F!FOKG*!:G546!a6JO8PF!ROF:!I45!5IF5TG565*!H56G7HF!8J:!48!:G5!_O8K:4J8!J_!78;:G48a,!9:4II*!:G5;!765!F:78P76PF!J_!H67K:4K7I!657FJ8,

9KG5R7:4K7II;*!:G58*!:G5!76aOR58:!_J6!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4FR!:7U5F!:G4F!_J6Rl!~46F:*!7a58K;!4F!P5S85P!W;!7!_O8K:4J8!J6!7K:4`4:;*!78!74R!J6!58P!:J!TG4KG! 4:! 4F!P465K:5P*! eOF:!7F!FOKG!�!:GJOaG! 4:! 4F!8J:!7!KJ8P4:4J8!J_!7K:48a! _J6!657FJ8F!:G7:!J85!657I4x5! :G4F!74R,! M:! _JIIJTF!W;!}cK5II58K5!:G7:!:J!W5!aJJP!7F!78!7a58:!4F!:J!7KG45`5!:G5!74R!W;!TG4KG!7a58K;!4F!P5S85P,!\67K:4K7I!67:4J87I4:;!KJ8F4F:F!48!W548a!aJJP!qua!7a58:,!9J!:J!W5!H67K:4K7II;!67:4J87I!4F!:J!7KG45`5!:G5!74R!J_!7a58K;,!948K5!4:!4F!7!P5_5K:!J_!H67K:4K7I!657FJ8!:J!W5!O8RJ`5P!W;!7!657FJ8!:J!7K:*!:G4F!KJ8KIOF4J8!T4II!KJ8F:6748!TG7:!:G565!4F!657FJ8!_J6!OF!:J!PJ,!M_!;JO!K78!7KG45`5!:G5!74R!J6!58P!J_!7a58K;!TG4I5!W548a!48P4|5658:!:J!:G5!_7K:!:G7:!;*!:G4F!_7K:!4F!8J:!7!H67K:4K7I!657FJ8,!~487II;*!4_!:G5!74R!4F!Sc5P!W;!:G5!P4FHJF4:4J8F!J_!78;!HJFF4WI5!7a58:*!T5!K78!P564`5!7!RJ65!_7R4I476!KJ8F:6748:l

M+u'D+.$?>&!.�#%u!k'.>#+>l!M_!:G5!_7K:!:G7:!;!4F!7!657FJ8!_J6!f!:J!!*!f!4F!K7H7WI5!J_!W548a!RJ`5P!:J!!!W;!:G5!W5I45_!:G7:!;,

948K5!5`56;!7a58:!4F!P4FHJF5P!:J!7KG45`5!:G5!74R!J6!58P!J_!7a58K;*!7F!FOKG*!78P!FJ!:J!W5!H67K:4K7II;!67:4J87I*!5`56;!7a58:!G7F!:G5!K7H7K4:;!:J!65FHJ8P!:J!:G5!657FJ8F!_J6!G56!:J!7K:,

]G5! 48:565F:! J_! 5:G4K7I! 67:4J87I4FR*! 48:5687I4F:! J6! J:G56T4F5*! I45F!H64R764I;!48!:TJ!:G48aF,!b85!7HH576F!:J!W5!7!`46:O5,!}:G4K7I!67:4J87I4F:F!K78!7FF4R4I7:5!:G5!R5:7HG;F4KF!78P!5H4F:5RJIJa;!J_!H67K:4K7I!657FJ8!:J!:G5!_O8K:4J87I!OF5!J_!iaJJPj,!]G5!4P57!J_!7!657FJ8!:J!7K:!4F*!J8!:G4F!KJ8K5H:4J8*!8J!RJ65!R;F:564JOF!:G78!:G7:!J_!7!aJJP!:G45_!J6!7!aJJP!KIJKU,17!]G5!J:G56!:G657:58F!:J!W5!7!̀ 4K5,!E;!HI7K48a!KJ8P4:4J8F!J8!TG7:!:G565!4F!657FJ8!_J6!OF!:J!PJ!:G7:!W48P!4:!:J!:G5!87:O65!J_!7a58K;*!5:G4K7I!

(n,! ~J6!R5:7HG;F4K7I!78P!5H4F:5R4K!76aOR58:F!_J6!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4FR*!J6!FJR5A:G48a!I4U5!4:*!F55!z5II5R78!0111l!(n)w-!78P!9R4:G!01(1,

f64F:J:I5QF! _O8K:4J8! 76aOR58:*! 4:! PJ5F! 8J:! HO6HJ6:! :J! W5! 7! a58567I!7KKJO8:!J_!=''E,!]G7:!iaJJPj!G7F!7!_O8K:4J87I!OF5!4F!hO4:5!KJ8F4F:58:!T4:G! 4:F! W548a! OF5P! 48! J:G56!T7;F*! :JJ*! 7F!TG58!T5! FH57U! J_! iaJJP!JO:KJR5Fj*!TG7:! 4F! iaJJP! _J6j! 78! 48P4`4PO7I*! J6! 5`58!TG7:! 4F! iaJJPj!3$,;0$.$"-#,15!]G5!7HHI4K7:4J8F!J_!}cK5II58K5!765!488JK58:!58JOaG,!M_!:G5!_O8K:4J8!J_!KIJKUF!4F!:J!:5II!:G5!:4R5*!7!aJJP!KIJKU!PJ5F!FJ!WJ:G!I5a4WI;!78P!65I47WI;,!M_!:G5!P5S848a!7K:4`4:;!J_!7!:G45_!4F!:J!F:57I!J:G56FQ!H6JH56:;*!7!aJJP!:G45_!4F!J85!TGJ!a5:F!7T7;!T4:G!:G5!IJJ:,

\O::48a!:G5!S6F:! :TJ!F:5HF!:Ja5:G56l!TG58!:G5!87:O65!J_!7!U48P!4F!P5S85P!48!P4FHJF4:4J87I!:56RF*!78P!TG565!4:!G7F!7!:76a5:!J_!TG4KG!4:!K78!_7II!FGJ6:*!:J!W5!aJJP!J_!:G7:!U48P!4F!:J!R784_5F:!:G7:!P4FHJF4:4J8!48!_OII,!M:!4F!8J:!58JOaG!_J6!:G5!7HHI4K7:4J8!J_!}cK5II58K5!:G7:!:G5!P4FHJF4:4J8!K78! _74I! :J! W5! 5c56K4F5P! 7I:Ja5:G56l! :G565! ROF:! W5! FOKG! 7! :G48a! 7F!4:F! 4RH56_5K:! J6! 48KJRHI5:5! R784_5F:7:4J8,! ^G565! 78! JWe5K:! R55:F!:G5F5!KJ8P4:4J8F*! 4:!K78!JH567:5!T5II!J6!W7PI;!7F! :G5!U48P!J_! :G48a! 4:!4F,!]GOF*!4_!W548a!78!7a58:!4F!W548a!P4FHJF5P!:J!7!K56:748!58P*!7:!I57F:!W;!7HH6Jc4R7:4J8*!78P!J85!K78!5c56K4F5!:G4F!P4FHJF4:4J8*!:J!:G5!5c:58:!:G7:!J85!G7F! 4:*!RJ65!J6! I5FF!T5II*! :J!W5!aJJP!7F!78!7a58:! 4F! _OII;! :J!7KG45`5!:G7:!58P,16

M8! 4:F! S87I! F:5H*! :G5! 76aOR58:! 4P58:4S5F! H67K:4K7I! 67:4J87I4:;!�!48!:G5! F58F5! :G7:! 48`JI`5F*! WO:! 4F! 8J:! 5cG7OF:5P! W;*! 65FHJ8P48a! :J!657FJ8F!�!T4:G! W548a! aJJP! qua! 7a58:,! ]G4F! H65R4F5! P67TF! J8!7! KJRH5II48a! :GJOaG:l! :G7:! eOPa5R58:F! J_! H67K:4K7I! 657FJ8! 765!7FF5FFR58:F!J_!7a58K;*!8J:!FJR5!J:G56!7FH5K:!J_!JO6!I4`5F,!]J!F7;!:G4F!

(L,! XJRH765!:G5!P4FKOFF4J8F!48!t57KG!(-Ld!78P!95:4;7!011nl!\76:!]TJ*!�0,

(d,! YJ5F!}cK5II58K5!7HHI;!:J!:G5!P4FHJF4:4J8F!J_!JWe5K:F!:G7:!765!8J:!76:4_7K:F!J6!I4`48a!:G48aF{!M8!H648K4HI5*!;5F*!WO:!J8I;!TG58!:G5!KJ8P4:4J8F!48!:G5!:5c:!765!R5:,! M_!7!R7a85:! 4F!W;!87:O65!P4FHJF5P! :J!J6458:! 4:F5I_! 48!K56:748!T7;F*!78P!:G4F!P4FHJF4:4J8!4F!JH567:4`5!TG58!4:!J6458:F!4:F5I_!48!#'&=<0B!:G5!64aG:!T7;*!4:!4F! _O8K:4J848a!T5II!7F!7!R7a85:!FJ! _76!7F! 4:!R784_5F:F! 4:F!P4FHJF4:4J8! :J! :G5!G4aG5F:!P5a655,!M_!:G4F!FJO8PF!JPP*!:G5!H6JWI5R!4F!8J:!T4:G!:G5!7HHI4K7:4J8!J_!}cK5II58K5!WO:!T4:G!:G5!KJ8K5H:4J8!J_!R7a85:F!J8!TG4KG!4:!65F:F,!N7a85:F!765!P5S85P!W;!:G546! 48:648F4K!H6JH56:45F*!8J:!W;!P4FHJF4:4J8F!:G7:!:G5;!R784_5F:!RJ65!J6!I5FF!T5II,!M_!:G565!765!HG;F4K7I!U48PF!:G7:!PJ!G7`5!7!FO4:7WI5!87:O65*!4:!T4II!R7U5!F58F5!:J!5`7IO7:5!:G546!_O8K:4J848a!�!:GJOaG!PJ48a!FJ!T4II!8J:!G7`5!4RHI4K7:4J8F!_J6!H67K:4K7I!657FJ8*!7F!:G5!_O8K:4J8!J_!7a58K;!PJ5F,


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!L!!w! "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

G5IH*! :G7:! _74I48a! :J!PJ!FJ! 4F!RJ67II;!T6J8a,!fI:5687:4`5I;*!T5!R4aG:!7HH57I! :J! :G5! _7K:! :G7:! 4:!TJOIP! W5! aJJP! :J! G5IH,! M:! 4F! :G4F! _7K:! :G7:!eOF:4S5F!7K:4J8*!8J:!:G5!W765!_7K:!J_!GOR78!855P,!M:!4F!8J:!KI576*!GJT5`56*!GJT!ROKG!T5!a748!W;!:G4F!RJ`5,!]G565!765!:G655!P4gKOI:45F,!~46F:*!GJT!K78!:G5!_7K:!:G7:!FJR5J85!4F!48!855P!R7U5!4:!T6J8a!8J:!:J!G5IH!:G5R*!J6!aJJP!:J!PJ!FJ*!4_!:G4F!_7K:!4F!8J:*!W;!4:F5I_*!7!657FJ8!:J!G5IH{!95KJ8P*!W;!:O6848a!:J!_7K:F!7WJO:!64aG:!78P!T6J8a*!J6!TG7:!4F!aJJP*!T5!_J6aJ!:G5!R5:7HG;F4K7I!78P!5H4F:5R4K!`46:O5F!J_!5:G4K7I! 67:4J87I4FR,!]G5F5!_7K:F!674F5!:G5!OFO7I!HOxxI5Fl!:G5;!K4:5!7FH5K:F!J_!H67K:4K7I!8J6R7:4`4:;!:G7:!G7`5!8J:!W558!7WFJ6W5P!W;!:G5!_O8K:4J87I!OF5!J_!iaJJPj,!~487II;*!5`58!FOKG!IJ7P5P!657FJ8F!HI7K5!P5R78PF!J8!:G5!:G5J6;!J_!7K:4J8!:G7:!T4II!8J:!W5!57F;!:J!R55:,!]G5!H4K:O65!J_!7a58:F!J8!TG4KG!:G5;!7K:!O8P56!:G5!aO4F5!J_!aJJP!4F!G4F:J64K7II;!48VO58:47I,!M:!P564`5F!_6JR!\I7:J!78P!f64F:J:I5*!78P!4:!H56F4F:F!48!RJ65!65K58:!TJ6U,19!EO:!4:!4F!KJ8:6J`56F47I*!78P!M!G7`5!76aO5P!7a748F:!4:*!7:!I58a:G*!5IF5TG565,20!M8!FGJ6:l!TG4I5!4:!R7;!W5!:6O5!:G7:!65H65F58:7:4J8F!J_!:G5!aJJP!765!5FF58:47II;!H67K:4K7I*!T5!K78!F7;!TG7:!4:!4F!:J!W5!78!7a58:!T4:GJO:!:G5R,!]G5!P4FHJF4:4J8!:J!W5!RJ`5P!W;!7HH57678K5F!J_!:G5!aJJP!4F!8J:!J85!T5!ROF:!HJFF5FF!J6!7HH6Jc4R7:5!48!J6P56!:J!7K:!_J6!657FJ8F!7:!7II,!M_!:G4F!4F!64aG:*!4:!4F!8J:!7!P5_5K:!J_!7a58K;*!78P!FJ!8J:!7!P5_5K:!J_!H67K:4K7I!657FJ8*!48!67:4J87I4F:!:56RF*! :J! W5! 48P4|5658:! :J! :G5! aJJP,! ]G5! KJ665FHJ8P48a! KI74RF! 765!5`58!RJ65!POW4JOF!_J6!RJ67I!64aG:!78P!T6J8a,!^G;!FGJOIP!7a58K;!W5!4RHJFF4WI5!T4:GJO:!FH5K4SK7II;!RJ67I!:GJOaG:{

]G5!OHFGJ:!J_!:G5F5!65V5K:4J8F!4F!:G7:!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4FR!784R7:5F!J85!`56F4J8!J_! :G5!hO5F:4J8*! i^G;!W5!RJ67I{j! M:!H6J`4P5F! :G5!W7F4F!_J6!7! FK5H:4K7I! KG7II58a5! :J! :G5!a58567I4:;!J_!RJ67I! 657FJ8F,!b8! :G5!_7K5!J_!4:*!T5!K78!65F4F:!:G4F!KG7II58a5!J8I;!W;!P4FHO:48a!:G5!76aOR58:!_J6!67:4J87I4FR!J6!W;!P564`48a!RJ67I!657FJ8F!_6JR!:G5!87:O65!J_! :G5!T4II,!948K5!:G5!F5KJ8P!:7FU!IJJUF!P4gKOI:*!T5!R7;!W5!:5RH:5P!W;!:G5!S6F:,!EO:!:G4F!4F!5hO7II;!G76P*!_J6!TG7:!:G5!76aOR58:!7FFOR5F!4F!T57U,!^G4I5! R78;! PJOW:! :G7:! 7a58:F! G7`5! 7O:J8JR;! J6! F5I_AU8JTI5Pa5!

(-,! ~J6!`7647:4J8F*!F55!k74I:J8!(--nm!k7x!(---*!01((m!]5858W7OR!011n,

01,!M8!\76:!b85!J_!Reasons without Rationalism!q95:4;7!011nr!78P!RJ65!65K58:I;!48!95:4;7!01(1,

67:4J87I4FR!K657:5F!7!H6JWI5R!_J6! :G5!a58567I4:;!J_!RJ67I! 657FJ8F,! M:!4F!:G4F!H6JWI5R!:G7:!H6J`4P5F!:G5!KJ8:5c:!_J6!R;!48:56H65:7:4J8!J_!M64F!NO6PJKG,!M!FH58P!:G5!65F:!J_!:G5!F5K:4J8!FH5II48a!4:!JO:,

9OHHJF5*!:J!W5a48!T4:G*!:G7:!f!4F!KJ8_6J8:5P!T4:G!7!K46KORF:78K5!48!TG4KG! FJR5J85! 4F! 48! F564JOF!855P*! 78P! :G5! 64aG:! :G5! :G48a! :J!PJ!4F! :J! J|56! :G5R! G5IH,! M:! TJOIP! W5! RJ67II;! T6J8a! :J! 4a8J65! :G546!P4gKOI:;*! 78P! :G5! F7K64SK5! 48`JI`5P! 48! 78FT5648a! 4:! 4F! 8J:! 5c:65R5,!^5!R4aG:!W5!:5RH:5P!:J!KJ8KIOP5!:G7:!f!should!J|56!G5IH*!7II!:G48aF!KJ8F4P565P!—!:G7:!:G4F!4F!TG7:!G5!G7F!RJF:!657FJ8!:J!PJ,!f:!78;!67:5*!4_!RJ67I!657FJ8F!765!K7:5aJ64K7I*!4_!:G5;!7HHI;!:J!5`56;J85*!f!G7F!FJR5!657FJ8!:J!G5IH!:G5!H56FJ8!G5!S8PF!48!855P,!9OHHJF5*!GJT5`56*!:G7:!f!4F!KJRHI5:5I;!O8RJ`5P!W;!:G4F,![5!U8JTF!TG7:!:G5!K46KORF:78K5!4Fl!:G7:!:G5!855P!4F!F564JOF!78P!:G5!KJF:!4F!RJP5F:,!q�5:!OF!F5:!7F4P5*!_J6!8JT*!W5I45_F!7WJO:!64aG:!78P!T6J8a,r!EO:!:G4F!G7F!8J!4RH7K:!J8!G4R,!M_!T5!GJH5!:J!P5_58P!:G5!KJ8`4K:4J8!:G7:!f!G7F!657FJ8!:J!G5IH*!TG7:!K78!T5!F7;{!M8!:G5!67:4J87I4F:!_67R5TJ6U*!JO6!JH:4J8F!765!I4R4:5P,!^5!KJOIP!GJH5!:J!FGJT!:G7:!f!4F!H67K:4K7II;!4667:4J87I*!:G7:!G5!K788J:!_OII;!7KG45`5!:G5!74R!J6!58P!J_!7a58K;*!7F!FOKG,!EO:!:G4F!7RJO8:F!:J!7!G56J4K!:7FUl! :G7:! J_! P564`48a*! _6JR! :G5!R5:7HG;F4KF! J_! 7a58K;*! 7! F58F4:4`4:;!:J!RJ67I!KJ8K568F,!^5!855P!78!7KKJO8:!J_!:G5!74R!J_!7a58K;*!7F!FOKG*!J8!TG4KG!4:!K788J:!W5!R5:!W;!78!7a58:!I4U5!f,!]G5!_O8K:4J8!J_!7a58K;!K788J:!W5!:G5!F7:4F_7K:4J8!J_!P5F465*!65a76PI5FF!J_!4:F!JWe5K:m!4:!K788J:!W5!7O:J8JR;!J6!VJO64FG48a*!KJ8K54`5P!48!T7;F!:G7:!7IIJT!_J6!48P4|5658K5!:J!J:G56F,!M:!ROF:!W5IJ8a!:J!:G5!87:O65!J_!:G5!T4II*!7F!:G5!K7H7K4:;!:J!7K:!_J6!657FJ8F*!:G7:!4:F!74RF!R7U5!J85!FOFK5H:4WI5!:J!J:G56FQ!855PF,!9JR5!T4II!7KK5H:! :G4F!KI74R*!GJH48a! :J!P564`5! _6JR!:G5!KJ8F:4:O:4`5!74R!J_!7K:4J8!FJR5!KJRR4:R58:! :J! :G5!RJ67I! I7T,18!EO:!RJF:!G7`5!PJOW:F,!]G565!4F!7!H6JWI5R!J_!RJ67I!657FJ8F!J8!:G5!67:4J87I4F:!7HH6J7KG,

M:!R4aG:!F55R*!FJ!_76*!:G7:!:G5!H6JWI5R!K78!W5!KJ8:7485P,!^5!G7`5!_JKOF5P!J8!657FJ8F!:G7:!KJ8F4F:!48!:G5!855PF!J_!J:G56F*!7FU48a!TG5:G56!J85!ROF:!65FHJ8P!:J!FOKG!855PF!48!7KG45`48a!:G5!74R!J6!58P!J_!7a58K;*!7F!FOKG,!M8!PJ48a!FJ*!T5!R7;!G7`5!4a8J65P!:G5!RJ65!F7I458:!657FJ8!:J!

(o,! NJF:!8J:7WI;*!3J6Fa776P!(--d*!011-,


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!d!!w! "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

78P! RJ67I! 5|J6:,! ��! b85! 4F! J_:58! KJRH5II5P! 7IRJF:!7O:JR7:4K7II;!W;!TG7:!J85!can!F55,!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!)Lwdr

]G5!HI7K5!J_!KGJ4K5!4F!K56:748I;!7!P4|5658:!J85!4_!T5!:G48U!48!:56RF!J_!7!TJ6IP!TG4KG!4F!.',;&03$2-0B!H65F58:!:J!:G5!T4II*! 78P! :G5! P4FK568R58:! 78P! 5cHIJ67:4J8! J_! TG4KG! 4F!7!FIJT!WOF485FF,! ��!M_! M!7::58P!H6JH56I;*! M!T4II!G7`5!8J!KGJ4K5F!78P!:G4F!4F!:G5!OI:4R7:5!KJ8P4:4J8!:J!W5!74R5P!7:,!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!)or

M8!:G5!F:76U!_J6ROI7:4J8!7:! :G5!G576:!J_! :G5!_JIIJT48a!5FF7;*!i657I4FR!��!4F!7!U48P!J_!48:5II5K:O7I!7W4I4:;!:J!H56K54`5!TG7:!4F!:6O5*!TG4KG!4F!7O:JR7:4K7II;!7:!:G5!F7R5!:4R5!7!FOHH65FF4J8!J_!F5I_!��!:6O5!`4F4J8!JKK7F4J8F!64aG:!KJ8POK:j!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!dpr,

]G7:!NO6PJKG!R7U5F!:G5F5!F:64U48a!KI74RF!4F!FJR5:4R5F!65KJa84x5P,!^G7:!4F!I5FF!T5II!O8P56F:JJP!4F!TG;!:G5;!R7::56,!̂ 5!K78!W648a!:G4F!JO:!W;!S8P48a! :G5!P4FHO:5P! KJ8K5H:4J8!J_! KGJ4K5! 48! :G5!W7KUa6JO8P!J_!F5K:4J8!(,!]G5!H4K:O65!J_!_655PJR!7F!7O:J8JR;*!8J:!P5:56R485P!W;!:G5!HI748!_7K:F!J_!J85QF!K46KORF:78K5*!4F!FG765P!W;!67:4J87I4F:F!J_!P4|5658:!U48PF*!W;!48F:6OR58:7I4F:F!78P!378:478F!7I4U5,!]G5!H6JWI5R!J_!RJ67I!657FJ8F!KJOIP!W5!FJI`5P!W;!a4`48a!4:!OH,!M8!674F48a!:G4F!H6JWI5R*!T5!4R7a485P!FJR5J85!TGJ!4F!_OII;!7T765!J_!:G5!K46KORF:78K5!:G7:!65hO465F!G4R!:J!J|56!G5IH*!J_!F564JOF!855P!78P!RJP5F:!KJF:*!WO:!TGJ!65R748F!O8RJ`5P,!]G5!:7FU!:G7:!IJJU5P!P4gKOI:*!T4:G48!:G5!KJ8S85F!J_!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4FR*!T7F!:J!5cHI748!TG;!G5!should!W5!RJ`5P*!TG;!:G5F5!_7K:F!H6J`4P5!G4R!T4:G!657FJ8F!:J!7K:,!^5!ROF:!:67K5!:G5!85K5FF4:;!J_!W548a!RJ`5P! :J! :G5! 87:O65! J_! :G5!T4II,!NO6PJKGQF! 48:56`58:4J8! 4F! :J! S8P!78!7I:5687:4`5!`45T,!~J6!NO6PJKG*! :G5!85K5FF4:;!J_!W548a!RJ`5P!W;!RJ67I!657FJ8F!I45F!8J:!48!:G5!87:O65!J_!:G5!T4II!WO:!48!:G5!RJ:4`7:4J87I!4RHJ6:!J_!KJa84:4J8,!Y5FH4:5!7HH57678K5F*!:G5!7a58:!T5!4R7a485P!4F!4RHJFF4WI5,!b85!K788J:!_74I!:J!W5!RJ`5P!W;!78!7P5hO7:5!KJ8K5H:4J8!J_! :G5! _7K:F! :G7:! 65hO465! 7! 65FHJ8F5l! i:6O5! `4F4J8! JKK7F4J8F! 64aG:!KJ8POK:j,!]G565!4F!:GOF!8J!855P!:J!58:56!:G5!R7x5!J_!JH:4J8F!48!TG4KG!T5!aJ:!IJF:!W5_J65,

7F! 78! 5FF58:47I! 74R*! I5:! 7IJ85! KJ8_J6R4:;!T4:G! :G5!RJ67I! I7T*!RJF:!7FFOR5! :G7:! :G5;! 765! P4FHJF5P! :J! :7U5!R578F! :J! :G546! 58PFl! :J! W5!R578FA58P!KJG5658:!48!:G546!48:58:4J8F!J6!P5F465F,21!}`58!:G4F!KI74R!4F!58JOaG!_J6!:G5!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4F:,!]G565!765!P4FHJF4:4J8F!T5!ROF:!7HH6Jc4R7:5!48!W548a!7a58:F*!78P!:G5;!K78!W5!K7F:!7F!P4FHJF4:4J8F!:J!KJ8_J6R!:J!78!4P57I,!]J!W5!aJJP!qua!7a58:!4F!:J!R55:!:G4F!4P57I!78P!FJ!:J!W5!H67K:4K7II;!67:4J87I,!

]G5!4FFO5F!FO66JO8P48a!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4FR!765!KJRHI4K7:5P*!78P!M!K788J:!GJH5!:J!65FJI`5!:G5R!G565,22!N;!74R!G7F!W558!RJ65!RJP5F:l!:J! FGJT!TG7:! 4F! KJRH5II48a!7WJO:! :G5! 67:4J87I4F:!`45T!78P! :J!R7U5!:G5!JH:4J8F!T4:G!TG4KG!4:!H65F58:F!OF!FOgK458:I;!:6JOWI48a!:G7:!T5!765!T4II48a!:J!IJJU!_J6!78J:G56!T7;!JO:,!^5!F55R!:J!KJ8_6J8:!7!P4I5RR7l!t4`58! :G5! 76aOR58:! _J6! 5:G4K7I! 67:4J87I4FR*! P58;! :G5! a58567I4:;! J_!RJ67I!657FJ8F!J6!P564`5!:G5R!_6JR!:G5!87:O65!J_!:G5!T4II,!M:!4F!48!F576KG!J_!7!_O6:G56!JH:4J8!:G7:!T5!:O68!:J!NO6PJKGQF!WJJU,

2. True Vision and Right Conduct

M8!657P48a!@<-4A'2-#-$=("B4'C4D''E*!4:!T4II!H6J`5!OF5_OI!:J!F:76:!7:!:G5!58P!J_!:G5!S6F:!5FF7;*!8J:!:G5!W5a48848a,!^G7:!NO6PJKG!TJ6UF!:JT76PF!48!i]G5!MP57!J_!\56_5K:4J8j!4F!78!7I:5687:4`5!:J!:G5!H4K:O65!J_!_655PJR!J8!TG4KG!:G5!7a58:!iKGJJF5F!G4F!657FJ8F!48!:56RF!J_*!78P!7_:56!FO6`5;48a*!:G5! J6P4876;! _7K:F! TG4KG! I45! JH58! :J! 5`56;J85j! qNO6PJKG! (-n1l!)pr,! M:! 4F! :G4F! H4K:O65! :G7:! F56`5F! 7F! KJRRJ8!a6JO8P! _J6! G56! F5`567I!78:7aJ84F:F!—!W5G7`4JO64F:*!5c4F:58:47I4F:*!78P!378:478,!f8P! 4:! 4F!J85!:G7:!FG5!65e5K:F,

M! FOaa5F:! �:G7:�! T5! 48:6JPOK5! 48:J! :G5! H4K:O65! :G5! 4P57!J_! attention*! J6! IJJU48a! ��! M! K78! J8I;! KGJJF5! T4:G48!:G5! TJ6IP! M! K78! see*! 48! :G5! RJ67I! F58F5! J_! sF55Q! TG4KG!4RHI45F!:G7:!KI576!`4F4J8!4F!:G5!65FOI:!J_!RJ67I!4R7a487:4J8!

0(,! ]G4F!:GJOaG:!4F!5cHI4K4:!48!Y65456!(--nl!-Lwo*!zJaI56!0110l!()Lwpd*!78P!9R4:G!011-l!ddwn,

00,! M8!95:4;7!011n*!01(1*!_J6:GKJR48a*!M!P5_58P!7!R484R7I4F:!KJ8K5H:4J8!J_!7a58AK;!J8!TG4KG!:G5!67:4J87I4F:!76aOR58:!K788J:!W5a48,


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!n!!w! "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

]J!5cHI748!78!7K:4J8!T5!65a76P!7F!`46:OJOF*!T5!:;H4K7II;!_J6ROI7:5! 7! RJ65! J6! I5FF! KJRHI5c! KG767K:564x7:4J8! J_!:G5!7K:4J8QF!K46KORF:78K5F!7F!T5!:7U5!:G5!7a58:! :J!G7`5!KJ8K54`5P! :G5R,! ^G;! FGJOIP! 4:! 8J:! W5! :G5! K7F5! ��!:G7:! :G5! 7a58:QF! KJ8K5H:4J8! J_! :G5! F4:O7:4J8*! H6JH56I;!O8P56F:JJP*! FOgK5F! :J! FGJT! OF! :G5! _7`JO67WI5! I4aG:!48! TG4KG! G4F! 7K:4J8! 7HH5765P! :J! G4R{! ��! ]G565! R7;!F55R! :J!W5! 7!P4gKOI:;l!R4aG:!8J:! 78J:G56!H56FJ8!G7`5!5c7K:I;! :G5! F7R5! KJ8K5H:4J8! J_! :G5! K46KORF:78K5F*! WO:!F55!8J! 657FJ8! :J! 7K:! 7F! :G5! `46:OJOF!H56FJ8!PJ5F{! M_! FJ*!7P`56:48a!:J!:G7:!KJ8K5H:4J8!J_!:G5!F4:O7:4J8!K788J:*!7_:56!7II*! FOgK5!:J!FGJT!OF! :G5! _7`JO67WI5! I4aG:! 48!TG4KG!:G5!`46:OJOF! H56FJ8! F7T!G4F! 7K:4J8,! ��!^5! K78! 5`7P5! :G4F!76aOR58:!W;!P58;48a!4:F!H65R4F5l!W;!:7U48a!7!FH5K47I!̀ 45T!J_!:G5!`46:OJOF!H56FJ8QF!KJ8K5H:4J8!J_!:G5!K46KORF:78K5F*!7KKJ6P48a! :J! TG4KG! 4:! K788J:! W5! FG765P! W;! FJR5J85!TGJ! F55F!8J! 657FJ8! :J! 7K:! 7F! :G5! `46:OJOF!H56FJ8!PJ5F,!qNKYJT5II!(-nol!o1r

]G5! `46:OJOF! H56FJ8QF! KJ8K5H:4J8! J_! :G5! K46KORF:78K5! 48KIOP5F! :G5!657FJ8F! _J6!TG4KG! G5! 7K:F!— _J6! 48F:78K5*! :G7:! FJR5J85! 4F! iFG;! 78P!F58F4:4`5j!78P!FJ!855PF!:J!W5!HO:!7:!57F5!qNKYJT5II!(-nol!oLwdr,!M:!PJ5F!8J:! KI74R! :G7:! :G5;!765! 657FJ8F*!J6! :G565!TJOIP!W5!8J:G48a! iFH5K47Ij!7WJO:!:G5!`45T!J8!TG4KG!4:!K788J:!W5!FG765P!W;!FJR5J85!TGJ!iF55F!8J!657FJ8!:J!7K:!7F! :G5!`46:OJOF!H56FJ8!PJ5Fj,!b8!7!RJP5F:!657P48a*!:G5!KI74R!4F!R565I;!:G7:!U8JTI5Pa5!J_!:G5!K46KORF:78K5!can!RJ:4`7:5!7K:4J8!T4:GJO:!:G5!855P!_J6!7!P5F465!:G7:! 4F!8J:! 4:F5I_!5cHI7485P*!78P!R7P5! 48:5II4a4WI5*! W;! :G4F! U8JTI5Pa5,25! EO:! TG7:! 4F! 7K:O7II;! F74P! 4F!RJ65! 7RW4:4JOFl! :G7:! i:G5! 65I5`78:! KJ8K5H:4J8F! 765! 8J:! FJ!ROKG! 7F!HJFF5FF5P!5cK5H:!W;!:GJF5!TGJF5!T4IIF!765! 48VO58K5P!7HH6JH647:5I;j!qNKYJT5II!(-nol!onr,!^G7:!T5!7HH576!:J!G7`5!4F!:G58!78!48F:78K5!J_![;H56AM8:5687I4FRl

0L,! b8!:G5!RJ:4`7:4J8!J_!7K:4J8!W;!W5I45_!7IJ85*!F55!y7a5I!(-n1l!0nw)1m!^7II7K5!(--1l!)n)wpm!95:4;7!011nl!(11wd,

fKKJ6P48a!:J!7!F4RHI5!`56F4J8!J_!:G4F!4P57l

[/v'DAM+u'D+.$?>&l!M_!:G5!_7K:!:G7:!;!4F!7!657FJ8!_J6!f!:J!!*!78P!f!U8JTF!:G7:!;*!f!4F!RJ`5P!:J!!!48!H6JHJ6:4J8!:J!4:F!F:658a:G!7F!7!657FJ8,

NO6PJKGQF! S87I! `45T! 4F!RJ65! KJRHI5c,! EO:! :G5! F4RHI5! _J6ROI7:4J8!W648aF! JO:! FJR5! K6OK47I! HJ48:F,! ~46F:*! 48! :G5! OFO7I! KJ8:67F:! W5:T558!eOPa5R58:! 78P! 5c4F:58K5! 48:5687I4FR*! W5:T558! KI74RF! 7WJO:! :G5!RJ:4`7:4J87I! F4a84SK78K5! J_! :G48U48a! :G7:! :G565! 4F! 657FJ8! :J! !! 78P!RJ:4`7:4J87I! KJ8P4:4J8F! J8! :G5! 5c4F:58K5! J_! 657FJ8F*! NO6PJKGQF!48:5687I4FR!_7IIF!J8!:G5!F4P5!J_!5c4F:58K5,23!M:!_JIIJTF!_6JR!FJR5:G48aQF!%-$(=! 7! 657FJ8! :J! !*! 7KKJ6P48a! :J! :G5! G;H56A48:5687I4F:*! :G7:! 4_! J85!U8JTF!:G5!_7K:!:G7:! 4F!7!657FJ8*!J85!4F!FO4:7WI;!RJ`5P,!^5!855P!8J:!7PP! :G5! _O6:G56! KJ8P4:4J8! :G7:!J85!W5I45`5F! :G4F! _7K:! :J!W5! 7! 657FJ8,!95KJ8P*![;H56AM8:5687I4FR!4F!`7F:I;!F:6J8a56! :G78!M8:5687I4FR!7WJO:!k57FJ8F,!M:!4F!8J:!eOF:!:G5!K7H7K4:;!:J!W5!RJ`5P!WO:!7K:O7I!RJ:4`7:4J8!:G7:! _JIIJTF! _6JR!U8JTI5Pa5!J_! 657FJ8F,! ~487II;*! :G5! :6O:G!J_![;H56AM8:5687I4FR!PJ5F!8J:!:5II!OF!TG7:!:G565!4F!657FJ8!:J!PJ,!M:!PJ5F!8J:!4RHI;!:G7:!_7K:F!7WJO:!:G5!855PF!J_!J:G56!H5JHI5!H6J`4P5!OF!T4:G!657FJ8F!:J!7K:,!M:F!6JI5!4F!8J:!:J!FOHHJ6:!78!76aOR58:!_J6!:G7:!KI74R!WO:!:J!H65`58:!4:! _6JR!W548a! :G657:585P! W;! 5:G4K7I! 67:4J87I4FR,! M_! _7K:F! J_! :G4F! U48P!eOF:4_;!7K:4J8*!4:!_JIIJTF!:G7:!T5!765!RJ`5P!W;!:G5!65I5`78:!W5I45_F,!^5!855P!8J:!P564`5!:G546!F:7:OF!7F!657FJ8F*!KJ8F4P567:4J8F!W;!TG4KG!T5!765!RJ`5P!48FJ_76!7F!T5!765!67:4J87I*!_6JR!:G5!74R!J_!7a58K;*!7F!FOKG,!M6J84K7II;*!W;!:4aG:5848a!:G5!KJ885K:4J8!W5:T558!KJa84:4J8!78P!KGJ4K5*!T5!R7U5!:G4F!KJ885K:4J8!48!J85!T7;!57F456!:J!P5_58Pl!4:!855P!8J:!aJ!:G6JOaG!:G5!R5:7HG;F4KF!J_!:G5!T4II,24

f!F4R4I76!:GJOaG:!K78!W5!_JO8P!48!78!576I;!H7H56!W;!ZJG8!NKYJT5II*!if65!NJ67I!k5hO465R58:F![;HJ:G5:4K7I!MRH567:4`5F{jl

0),! ~J6!:G4F!P4F:48K:4J8*!F55!Y76T7II!(-o)l!L)wp,!

0p,! ]G4F! KI74R! 4F! hO7I4S5P! :JT76PF! :G5! 58P!J_! F5K:4J8! )*!TG565! M! FH5KOI7:5! J8!NO6PJKGQF!KJ8K5H:4J8!J_!7a58K;,


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!o!!w! "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

48P4|5658:!4F!:JJ!FH5K47I!:J!W5!W5I45`5P,!M:!4F!7!_7K:!J_!I4_5!:G7:!H5JHI5!765!O8RJ`5P!5`58!W;!P5K4F4`5!RJ67I!657FJ8F,!fF!NKYJT5II!7KU8JTI5Pa5F*!i�_74IO65�!:J!F55!TG7:!7!K46KORF:78K5!R578F*!48!:G5!IJ7P5P!F58F5!�TG4KG!58:74IF!RJ:4`7:4J8�! 4F!J_! KJO6F5! KJRH7:4WI5!T4:G! KJRH5:58K5*!W;! 7II!J6P4876;! :5F:F*!T4:G! :G5! I78aO7a5!OF5P!:J!P5FK64W5! :G5!K46KORF:78K5j!qNKYJT5II!(-nol!odr,![5!PJ5F!8J:!F55R!H56:O6W5P!W;!:G4F*!F7;48a!J8I;!:G7:!4:!iW648aF!JO:!GJT!IJ7P5P!:G5!8J:4J8!J_!R57848a!48`JI`5P!48!:G5!H6J:5F:!4Fj!qNKYJT5II!(-nol!odr,!EO:!R78;!T4II!W5!HO:!J|,!M_!FJR5J85!4F! KJRH5:58:! W;! J6P4876;! :5F:F*! :G5;! a67FH! :G5! 65I5`78:! KJ8K5H:F!78P!U8JT! :G5! 65I5`78:! _7K:F,! M_! :G5;! 765!8J:!RJ`5P!W;! :G5R*!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR!_74IF,!^G7:!aJJP!4F!4:!:G7:!NO6PJKG!R7U5F!F58F5!J_!RJ67I!657FJ8F!4_!FG5!PJ5F!FJ!T4:G!78!48P5_58F4WI5!KI74R{

3. A Platonic Theory of Concepts

f!U5;!:J!:G5!F:6OK:O65!J_!A'2-#-$=("B! 4F! :G7:!NO6PJKG!78:4K4H7:5F!:G4F!KJRHI748:,29!M8!:G5!S6F:!G7I_!J_!i]G5!MP57!J_!\56_5K:4J8j*!:G5!H76:!TGJF5!:76a5:F!K78!F55R!P4F:78:!_6JR!OF*!NO6PJKG!K64:4K4x5F!7!ia585:4Kj!787I;F4F!J_!R58:7I!KJ8K5H:F!:G7:!P564`5F!_6JR!7!W6J7PI;!W5G7`4JO64F:!657P48a!J_!^4::a58F:548,!b8!:G5!a585:4K!:G5J6;*!i�R58:7I�!I4_5!4F*!78P!IJa4K7II;!ROF:!W5*!7!FG7PJT!J_!I4_5!48!HOWI4Kj!F48K5*!48!a58567I*!i:G5!HJFF5FF4J8!J_!�7�!KJ8K5H:!4F!7!HOWI4K!FU4IIj!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!n*!((r,!NO6PJKG!4IIOF:67:5F!:G4F!:G5J6;!T4:G!:G5!KJ8K5H:!J_!P5K4F4J8,

[JT! PJ! M! learn! :G5! KJ8K5H:! J_! P5K4F4J8{! E;! T7:KG48a!FJR5J85!TGJ! F7;F! sM! G7`5!P5K4P5PQ! 78P!TGJ! :G58! 7K:F,![JT!5IF5!KJOIP!M!I5768!4:{!f8P!T4:G!:G7:!M!I5768!:G5!5FF58K5!J_! :G5!R7::56,! M! PJ!8J:! sRJ`5!J8Q! _6JR!7!W5G7`4JO64F:4K!KJ8K5H:!:J!7!R58:7I!J85,!��!f!P5K4F4J8!PJ5F!8J:!:O68!JO:!:J!W5*!TG58!RJ65!K765_OII;!KJ8F4P565P*!78!48:6JFH5K:4WI5!RJ`5R58:,!]G5!KJ8K5H:!G7F!8J!_O6:G56!48856!F:6OK:O65m!4:!is!4:F!JO:56!F:6OK:O65,!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!(0w)r

0-,![565! M! 7R! 48P5W:5P! :J!E6J7KU5F! 01(0l! )-wpo*! :GJOaG! M! P4|56! _6JR!G4R*! 7:!I57F:!48!5RHG7F4F*!J8!:G5!6JI5!J_!RJ67I!H56K5H:4J8!48!NO6PJKGQF!`45T,!955!:G5!P4FKOFF4J8!J_!i:G4KU!KJ8K5H:Fj!W5IJT,

N#D.$!M+u'D+.$?>&l!M_!:G5!_7K:!:G7:!;!4F!7!P5K4F4`5!moral 657FJ8! _J6! f! :J! !*! 78P! f! U8JTF! :G7:! ;*! f! 4F! P5K4F4`5I;!RJ`5P!:J!!,26

NO6PJKG!65F:64K:F!:G5!FKJH5!J_![;H56AM8:5687I4FR!48!7!F4R4I76!T7;l!

�^5�!765!8J:!7IT7;F!65FHJ8P48a!:J!:G5!R7a85:4K!HOII!J_!:G5! 4P57!J_!H56_5K:4J8,!b_:58*! _J6! 48F:78K5!TG58!T5!H7;!JO6!W4IIF!J6!H56_J6R!J:G56!FR7II!5`56;P7;!7K:F*!T5!765!eOF:!s78;WJP;Q!PJ48a!TG7:!4F!H6JH56!J6!R7U48a!F4RHI5!KGJ4K5F!_J6!J6P4876;!HOWI4K!657FJ8F,!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!p(r

]G5!KJ8:JO6F!J_!:G4F!65F:64K:4J8!765!8J:!58:465I;!KI576,!~J6!F4RHI4K4:;*!M!T4II!TJ6U!T4:G![;H56AM8:5687I4FR!_J6!P5K4F4`5!RJ67I!657FJ8F*!F:65FF48a!:G7:!:G5!HJ48:!4F!7WJO:!:G5!RJ:4`7:4J87I!_J6K5!8J:!J_!:G5!W5I45_!:G7:!78!7K:!4F!64aG:!J6!T6J8a!WO:!J_!:G5!_7K:F!:G7:!a4`5!4:!:G7:!F:7:OF,27

fF! M! G7`5! HJ6:67;5P! 4:*! :G5! 7::67K:4J8! J_! NJ67I! M8:5687I4FR! 4F! :J!H65`58:! :G5! H6JWI5R! J_! RJ67I! 657FJ8F! _6JR! W548a! HJF5P,! ^5! K78!F7`5!:G5!a58567I4:;!78P!P5K4F4`5!_J6K5!J_!FOKG!657FJ8F!T4:GJO:!G7`48a!:J! TJ66;! 7WJO:! :G5! 76aOR58:! _J6! 5:G4K7I! 67:4J87I4FR! 78P! T4:GJO:!7::5RH:48a!:G5!G56J4K!P564`7:4J8!J_!RJ67I!KJRR4:R58:!_6JR!:G5!74R!J6!58P!J_!7a58K;*!7F!FOKG,!M:F!J8I;!V7T*!;JO!R4aG:!FOFH5K:*!4F!:G7:!4:!4F!_7IF5!�!48P55P*!JW`4JOFI;!FJ,28!]G5!FH5K47I!`45T!J8!TG4KG!:G5!`46:OJOF!H56FJ8QF! KJ8K5H:4J8! J_! :G5! K46KORF:78K5! K788J:! W5! FG765P! W;! :G5!

0d,! M8! I7:56! TJ6U*! NKYJT5IIQF! KJRR4:R58:! :J! NJ67I! M8:5687I4FR! 4F! I5FF! KI576,!]GOF*!48!iz46:O5!78P!k57FJ8j*!:G5!U8JTI5Pa5!:G7:!4FFO5F!48!64aG:!KJ8POK:!4F!U8JTI5Pa5!J_!78!7K:4J8!iO8P56!FJR5!FOKG!P5FK64H:4J8!7F!s:G5!:G48a!:J!PJQj!J8!:G5!W7F4F!J_!i7!KJ8F4P567:4J8!7HH65G58P5P!7F!7!657FJ8j!qNKYJT5II!(-n-l!L(*!Lpm!F55!7IFJ!Lnr,![565!:G5!`46:OJOF!H56FJ8QF!KJ8K5H:4J8!J_!:G5!K46KORF:78K5!48KIOP5F!5cHI4K4:I;!8J6R7:4`5!KI74RF,

0n,! E5K7OF5!4:!4F!65F:64K:5P!:J!P5K4F4`5!657FJ8F*!:G4F!4F!8J:!7!_OII!7KKJO8:!J_!RJ6A7I!RJ:4`7:4J8*! 5`58!TG58!T5! 4a8J65!W5I45_F! 7WJO:! 64aG:!78P!T6J8a,! M8! :G5!K7F5!J_!FJAK7II5P!i4RH56_5K:!PO:45Fj*!P5K4F4`5!657FJ8!7HHI45F!8J:!:J!P4FK65:5!J6!IJK7I4x5P!7K:F*!FOKG!7F!G5IH48a!64aG:!8JT*!WO:!:J!J85F!:G7:!JKKOH;!48P5S84:5!H564JPF*!I4U5!PJ48a!58JOaG!:J!G5IH!:GJF5!48!855P,!]G5!RJ:4`7:4J8!J_!:G5!I7::56!_7IIF!O8P56!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FRm!:G5!RJ:4`7:4J8!J_!:G5!_J6R56!PJ5F!8J:,

0o,!]G4F!KG76a5!4F!`4`4PI;!5cH65FF5P!W;!9R4:G!(--pl!(0(wL,


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!-!!w! "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

NQF!`4F4J8!J_!Y!W5KJR5F!RJ65!IJ`48a!78P!RJ65!eOF:*!FJ!:G7:!FJR5:G48a!J_!RJ67I!F4a84SK78K5!G7F!aJ85!J8,

^G7:! 4F! :G5! HJ48:! J_! :G4F! 5c7RHI5{! E5K7OF5! :TJ! 4FFO5F! 765! 6O8!:Ja5:G56*! J85! J_! :G5R! 4F! 57F;! :J!R4FF,30! M:! 4F! JW`4JOF! :G7:!NO6PJKG!4F!KJ8:5F:48a!:G5!85aI5K:!J_!H64`7:5!RJ67I!7K:4`4:;!W;!:G5!W5G7`4JO64F:!JWF5FF5P!T4:G!JO:T76P!P55PF,!EO:!:G4F!4F!J8I;!H76:!J_!4:,!NJ65!4RHJ6:78:!4F!:G5!87:O65!J_!NQF!7K:4`4:;*!TG4KG!4F!65S848a!:G5!T7;!48!TG4KG!FG5!F55F!:G5!TJ6IP,![56!a67FH!J_!:G5!KJ8K5H:F!T4:G!TG4KG!FG5!JH567:5F!�!;-#"H4.-#-,'($'&3H4 &(E$=($I-EH4 =/B!�!4F! :678F_J6R5P! 78P! 4RH6J`5P*! 78P!G56!P5FK64H:4J8F!KG78a5!7KKJ6P48aI;,!M:!4F!:G4F!HG58JR58J8*!48!TG4KG!J85QF!O8P56F:78P48a!J_!7!KJ8K5H:!aJ5F!W5;J8P!TG7:!J85!U85T!48!7KhO4648a!4:*! J6! W548a! KJRH5:58:! W;! J6P4876;! :5F:F*! :G7:! :G5! a585:4K! :G5J64F:!K788J:!KJRH65G58P,!]G5!76aOR58:!7a748F:!:G5!a585:4K!:G5J6;!4F!:G7:!:G5!HG58JR58J8!4F!657Il!_OII!HJFF5FF4J8!J_!7!KJ8K5H:!K78!:678FK58P!:G5!R7F:56;!J_!4:F!HOWI4K!OF5,!]G5!5c7RHI5!J_!N!78P!Y!4F!FOHHJF5P!:J!R7U5!:G4F!`4`4P,!M88JK58:!J_!:G5J6;*!NO6PJKG!W5I45`5F*!T5!T4II!W5!:5RH:5P!:J!P5FK64W5!:G5!K7F5!7F!J85!J_!H6Ja65FF!:JT76PF!H56_5K:4J8!48!:G5!a67FH!J_!R58:7I!KJ8K5H:F,

M:! R4aG:! W5! 76aO5P*! 48F:57P*! :G7:! :G5! F:J6;! 4F! J85! J_! H6Ja65FF!:JT76PF! H56_5K:4J8! 48! O8P56F:78P48a! 78J:G56! H56FJ8,! EO:! :G565! 4F!8J!KJ8V4K:!G565l!T5!K78!F7;!:G7:*!:JJ,!f8P!T5!G7`5!:J!657P!NO6PJKG!7F! KJ8K5685P!T4:G!a67FH!J_! KJ8K5H:F! 48!J6P56! :J!R7U5! F58F5!J_!G56!WJJU,!]G5!5c7RHI5!J_!N!78P!Y!4F!_67R5P!W;!:G5!a585:4K!:G5J6;*!78P!4:F!48F4aG:F!765!7HHI45P!:J!65H58:78K5!78P!IJ`5,31!M8!57KG!K7F5*!G56!:JH4K!4F!KJ8K5H:O7I!R7F:56;*!78P! 4:! 4F! :G4F! :JH4K*!H56G7HF!7RJ8a!J:G56F*! :J!TG4KG!:G5!5c7RHI5!FH57UF,!NO6PJKGQF!KJ8KIOF4J8!R7U5F!:G4F!KI576l

]G5!58:6;!48:J!7!R58:7I!KJ8K5H:!J_!:G5!8J:4J8!J_!78!4P57I!I4R4:! P5F:6J;F! :G5! a585:4K! 787I;F4F! J_! 4:F! R57848a,! ��!MF! sIJ`5Q! 7!R58:7I! KJ8K5H:*! 78P! 4_! FJ! K78! 4:! W5! 787I;F5P!a585:4K7II;{!yJ!PJOW:!N76;QF!I4::I5!I7RW!IJ`5P!N76;*!:G7:!4F!4:!_JIIJT5P!G56!:J!FKGJJIm!78P!48!FJR5!F58F5!J_!sI5768Q!

)1,!955*!7a748*!E6J7KU5F!01(0l!pnwo,

)(,! b8!65H58:78K5*!F55!NO6PJKG!(-n1l!0L,

fI:GJOaG!:G4F! 4F!FJR5:G48a!J_!7!K764K7:O65*! :G5! 4P57!:G7:!R58:7I!78P!J:G56!KJ8K5H:F!765!78KGJ65P!48!:G546!HOWI4K!OF5!4F!8J:!787KG6J84F:4K,!z56F4J8F!J_!4:!765!F:4II!H6JHJF5P,!^G7:!R7::56F!G565!4F!:G7:!:G5J645F!J_!:G4F!U48P!FOHHJ6:!:G5!KG76a5!7a748F:!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR,!b8!:G5!a585:4K!:G5J6;*! 8J:G48a! :G7:! 4F! 8J:! 7HH7658:! 48! :G5! HOWI4K! 7KhO4F4:4J8! J_! 7!KJ8K5H:!K78!W5!5FF58:47I! :J! 4:F!KJ8:58:,!9JR5J85!TGJ!aJ5F! :G6JOaG!:G5! J6P4876;! :674848a*! 78P!TGJ! 4F! KJRH5:58:! W;! J6P4876;! :5F:F*! G7F!5`56;:G48a!65hO465P!:J!a67FH!:G5!KJ8K5H:!5cH65FF5P!W;!7!TJ6P,!]GOF*!:G5!H56FJ8!T5!4R7a485P!48!F5K:4J8!(!K78!U8JT!7WJO:!G4F!K46KORF:78K5!5c7K:I;!TG7:!:G5!`46:OJOF!H56FJ8!U8JTF,![5!K78!U8JT!:G5!_7K:F!:G7:!H6J`4P5!7!RJ67I!657FJ8!T4:GJO:!W548a!RJ`5P,!]G4F!4F!TG7:!NO6PJKG!ROF:!P58;*!7F!FG5!PJ5F!48!I78aO7a5!5KGJ5P!W;!NKYJT5IIl

]G565!765!:TJ!F58F5F!J_!sU8JT48a!TG7:!7!TJ6P!R578FQ*!J85!KJ885K:5P!T4:G!J6P4876;!I78aO7a5*!:G5!J:G56!`56;!ROKG!I5FF!FJ,!��!^5!PJ!8J:!F4RHI;*!:G6JOaG!W548a!67:4J87I!78P!U8JT48a! J6P4876;! I78aO7a5*! sU8JTQ! :G5!R57848a! J_! 7II!85K5FF76;!RJ67I!TJ6PF,!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!0or

]G5! hO5F:4J8! 4Fl!^G7:! 4F! G56! 76aOR58:{![JT!PJ5F! FG5! P4FIJPa5!:G5!a585:4K!:G5J6;!78P!J:G56F!I4U5!4:*!:G5J645F!J8!TG4KG!:G5!JWe5K:4J8!:J!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR!aJ5F!:G6JOaG{!]G5!78FT56!I45F!48!7!F5KJ8P!U5;!:J! A'2-#-$=("Bl! 7! KJ665K:! 48:56H65:7:4J8! J_! :G5! 5c7RHI5! J_! N! 78P! Y,!]G5!5c7RHI5!4:F5I_!4F!RJ65!_65hO58:I;!K4:5P!:G78!78;:G48a!5IF5!48!:G5!WJJU,!f!RJ:G56*!N*! _55IF!GJF:4I4:;! :J!G56!P7OaG:56A48AI7T*!Y*!S8P48a!G56!iH56:!78P!_7R4I476*!48FOgK458:I;!K565RJ84JOF*!W6OFhO5*!FJR5:4R5F!HJF4:4`5I;!6OP5*!7IT7;F!:465FJR5I;!eO`584I5j!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!(dwnr,!]G4F!PJ5F!8J:!7|5K:!NQF!JO:T76P!W5G7`4JO6*!TG4KG! 4F!H56_5K:! :G6JOaGJO:,!�5:!FG5!5cH56458K5F!RJ67I!H6Ja65FFl!N!i65V5K:F!P5I4W567:5I;!7WJO:!Y!O8:4I!a67PO7II;!G56!`4F4J8!J_!Y!7I:56F,! ��!Y! 4F!P4FKJ`565P! :J!W5!8J:!`OIa76!WO:!65_65FG48aI;!F4RHI5*!8J:!O8P4a84S5P!WO:!FHJ8:785JOF*!8J:!8J4F;!WO:!a7;*!8J:!:465FJR5I;!eO`584I5!WO:!P5I4aG:_OII;!;JO:G_OI*!78P!FJ!J8j!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!(nr,!^5!765!:J!4R7a485!:G5!K7F5!7F!J85!48!TG4KG!


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!(1!!w "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

485IOK:7WI;! WJO8P! :Ja5:G56! q^4II47RF! (-oLl! (p1r,! E56876P!^4II47RF*!TGJ!R7U5F! 7! a657:! P57I! J_! FOKG! KJ8K5H:F! 48!J"<$.34 /(E4 "<-4 8$,$"34 'C4K<$0'3';<B*! K65P4:F!G4F!7HH65K47:4J8!J_! :G546! 4RHJ6:78K5! :J!7!F5R4876!:7OaG:! W;! \G4I4HH7! ~JJ:! 78P!NO6PJKG! 48! :G5! (-L1F! q^4II47RF! (-oLl!0(o8,nr,!~J6!^4II47RF*!:G4KU!RJ67I!KJ8K5H:F!765!P4F:48K:4`5!48!W548a!7:!J8K5! iTJ6IPAaO4P5Pj!78P! i7K:4J8AaO4P48aj,!]G5;!765!TJ6IPAaO4P5P! 48!:G7:!:G565!765!85K5FF76;!I4R4:F!:J!P4`56a58K5!48!:G546!OF5,!]GJF5!TGJ!a67FH! :G5! 65I5`78:! KJ8K5H:F! 765! WJO8P! :J! 7a655! 48! :G546! 7HHI4K7:4J8*!5cK5H:!7:!:G5!R76a48F!q^4II47RF!(-oLl!(p1w(r,!M8!:G4F!65FH5K:*!:G5;!765!R578:!:J!P4|56! _6JR!i:G48j!KJ8K5H:F! I4U5!'&=<"!78P!=''E*! :GJOaG!:G5!P4|5658K5!4F!H65FOR7WI;!J85!J_!P5a655!q^4II47RF!(-oLl!(L(w0r,33!]G4KU!KJ8K5H:F!765!7K:4J8AaO4P48a!48!:G7:!:G5;!765!iKG767K:564F:4K7II;!65I7:5P!:J! 657FJ8Fj! 78P! W5K7OF5! J85! K788J:! a67FH! :G5R! O8I5FF! J85! FG765F*!7:! I57F:! :G6JOaG! 4R7a487:4J8*! :G546! 5`7IO7:4`5! HJ48:! q^4II47RF! (-oLl!(p1w0r,!M8!HJFF5FF48a!7!:G4KU!RJ67I!KJ8K5H:*!J85!H76:4K4H7:5F*!H56G7HF!`4K764JOFI;*!48!7!F58F4W4I4:;!:G7:!R7;!G7`5!RJ:4`7:4J87I!_J6K5,!M8!5|5K:*!4:!4F!:G6JOaG!:G4F!F58F4W4I4:;!:G7:!OF56F!J_!:G5!KJ8K5H:!765!7WI5!iaJ!J8!48!:G5!F7R5!T7;jl!:G4F!4F!GJT!RJ:4`7:4J8!J6!7|5K:!4F!WO4I:!48:J!:G5!KJ8K5H:,

M:!4F!O8P5847WI;!:5RH:48a!:J!48:56H65:!NO6PJKG!48!I4aG:!J_!̂ 4II47RF,34 NO6PJKG!48`4:5F!:G4F!657P48a!48!G56!65_5658K5!:J!i8J6R7:4`5!5H4:G5:Fj!78P! iF5KJ8P76;!RJ67I! TJ6PFj! 48! KJ885K:4J8!T4:G!N! 78P!Y*! 78P! 48!P4FH767a48a!i:G5!4RH56FJ87I!TJ6IP!J_!_7K:Fj!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!(o*!00*!0pr,!]G5!:5RH:7:4J8!4F!5FH5K47II;!F:6J8a!T4:G!H7FF7a5F!I4U5!:G4Fl!

M_! T5! H4K:O65! :G5! 7a58:! 7F! KJRH5II5P! W;! JW5P458K5! :J!:G5!657I4:;!G5!K78!F55*!G5!T4II!8J:!W5!F7;48a!s]G4F!4F!64aG:Q*!$64-,*!sM!KGJJF5!:J!PJ!:G4FQ*!G5!T4II!W5!F7;48a!s]G4F!4F!f!E!X!YQ!q8J6R7:4`5AP5FK64H:4`5!TJ6PFr*!78P!7K:4J8!T4II!_JIIJT!

)),! }`58!T4:G!:G48!KJ8K5H:F*!:G565!765!I4R4:F!:J!P4`56a58K5,!fF!~JJ:!JWF56`5P*!4_!FJR5J85!H6JKI74RF!7F!78!iOI:4R7:5!H648K4HI5!�:G7:!4:!4F�!T6J8a!:J!6O8!76JO8P!:655F!64aG:!G78P5P!J6!:J!IJJU!7:!G5Pa5GJaF!48!:G5!I4aG:!J_!:G5!RJJ8j*!T5!T4II!PJOW:!:G7:!G5!a67FHF!:G5!KJ8K5H:F!J_!RJ67I!64aG:!78P!T6J8a!q~JJ:!0110l!c4`r,

)p,!fF!5`58!G56!RJF:!H56K5H:4`5!657P56F!G7`5!PJ85m!F55*!_J6!48F:78K5*!E6J7KU5F!01(0l!(pwLl!iM:!4F!H76:4KOI76I;!7FK64H:4J8F!J_!:G5!FH5K47I4x5P!:56RF!�KJ665FHJ8PA48a! :J! :G4KU! RJ67I! KJ8K5H:F�! :G7:! 765! q48! 65I5`78:! F4:O7:4J8Fr! 4RR5P47:5I;!RJ:4`7:48a,j

T5!R4aG:!T5II!I5768!:G5!KJ8K5H:*!:G5!TJ6P*!48!:G7:!KJ8:5c:,!EO:!T4:G!FOKG!7!KJ8K5H:!:G7:!4F!8J:!:G5!58P!J_!:G5!R7::56,!��! f! P55H5848a! H6JK5FF*! 7:! 78;! 67:5! 78! 7I:5648a! 78P!KJRHI4K7:48a!H6JK5FF*!:7U5F!HI7K5,!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!0or

]GJOaG!4:! 4F!8J:!R;!HO6HJF5!:J!P5_58P!G56!`45T*!NO6PJKG!FO65I;!G7F!7!HJ48:,![56!P5FK64H:4J8F!J_!KJ8K5H:AHJFF5FF4J8!648a!:6O5,!^5!F7;!:G7:!JO6!O8P56F:78P48a!J_!65H58:78K5!78P!IJ`5!G7F!a6JT8*!8J:!R565I;!:G7:!T5!G7`5!I57685P!85T!_7K:F!7WJO:!:G5R,32!M_!T5!765!64aG:!:J!PJ!FJ*!:G5!a585:4K!:G5J6;!4F!T6J8a,!]G5!JWe5K:4J8!:J!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR!:GOF!K788J:!65I;!J8!:G5!a585:4K!:G5J6;*!J6!78;:G48a!I4U5!4:*!_J6!FOHHJ6:,!]G565!4F!6JJR!_J6!:G5!`45T!:G7:*!TG4I5!FJR5J85!R7;!7HH576!:J!W5!O8RJ`5P!W;!U8JTI5Pa5!J_!P5K4F4`5!RJ67I!657FJ8F*!:G546!a67FH!J_!:G5F5!657FJ8F!4F!4RH56_5K:*!F48K5!:G5;!PJ!8J:!HJFF5FF!:G5!65I5`78:!KJ8K5H:F!48!_OII,

9:4II*! T5!R7;! PJOW:! :G7:! :G5! J8I;! FJO6K5! J_! 65F4F:78K5! :J!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR!4F!7!W7P!HG4IJFJHG;!J_!R48P,!]G5!4P57!:G7:!J85!K78!a67FH!:G5! 855PF! J_! J:G56F! T4:GJO:! W548a!RJ`5P! W;! :G5R! K78! W5! 5I4K4:5P!T4:GJO:!:G5!a585:4K!:G5J6;,!XJ8F4P56*!_J6!48F:78K5*!7!`46:OJOF!H56FJ8!TGJ! O8P56aJ5F! RJ67I! P5:564J67:4J8*! W5KJR48a! 48P4|5658:! J6! T57UAT4II5P,!MF!4:!HI7OF4WI5!:J!KI74R!:G7:!G4F!a67FH!J_!:G5!65I5`78:!KJ8K5H:F*!H65`4JOFI;! V7TI5FF*! G7F! _74I5P{! NJ65! a58567II;*! T5! 765! 58:4:I5P! :J!7FU!:<B! _OII!HJFF5FF4J8!J_!K56:748!KJ8K5H:F*!7IJ8a!T4:G! :G546!KJ665K:!7HHI4K7:4J8! :J! :G5! K46KORF:78K5*! 58:74IF! RJ:4`7:4J8! J6! KGJ4K5,! [JT!PJ5F!:G4F!_JIIJT!_6JR!:G5!KJ8P4:4J8F!J_!KJ8K5H:AHJFF5FF4J8*!J8!7!RJ65!7P5hO7:5! 7KKJO8:{! M:! 4F! 8J:! 58JOaG! _J6!NO6PJKG! :J! 65e5K:! 7! :G5J6;!:G7:!KJ8V4K:F!T4:G!G56!KI74RFm!FG5!855PF!:J!FU5:KG!78!7I:5687:4`5!:G7:!FOF:748F!:G5R,

[565!T5!657KG!7!:G46P!U5;!:J!A'2-#-$=("Bl!:G5!_7IF5!7FF4R4I7:4J8!J_!NO6PJKGQF! :G5J6;!:J!78!5RHG7F4F!J8!i:G4KU!RJ67I!KJ8K5H:Fj!FOKG!7F!i.':/#EH40$-H4%#&"/0$"BH4=#/"$"&E-j!48!TG4KG!P5FK64H:4J8!78P!5`7IO7:4J8!765!

)0,! ]G4F! HJ48:! 4F! 5RHG7F4x5P! W;! fI4K5! X676;! 48! L-B'(E4M'#/04 N&E=,-("! qX676;!011nl!p(w)r,!fI:GJOaG!FG5!K4:5F!NO6PJKG!78P!P67TF!7::58:4J8!:J!:G5!H67K:4K7I!OHFGJ:!J_!KJ8K5H:AHJFF5FF4J8*!X676;!PJ5F!8J:!76:4KOI7:5!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR!J6!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;!J_!KJ8K5H:F!5cHIJ65P!W5IJT,


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!((!!w "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

OF5P!:J!P5FK64W5!7!FH5K47I!657FJ8AKJ8F:4:O:48a!KJ8K5H:4J8!J_!7!F4:O7:4J8!855P!8J:!W5!5cHI4K4:I;!5`7IO7:4`5j!qNKYJT5II!(-nol!odr,!]G5!65FOI:!4F!7!ROKG!P55H56!:G657:!:J!:G5!P4F:48K:4J8!W5:T558!_7K:!78P!`7IO5!:G78!:G5! R565! 5cH78F4J8! J_! RJ67I! KJ8K5H:F! 58`4F7a5P! W;!^4II47RF,! b8!NO6PJKGQF!`45T*!:G5!P5FK64H:4J8!J_!7!K46KORF:78K5!48!R58:7I!WO:!8J:!5cHI4K4:I;!RJ67I!:56RF!K78!G7`5!7!H6JH56:;!J_:58!:GJOaG:!:J!P4F:48aO4FG!5:G4K7I! KJ8K5H:F! _6JR! J:G56Fl! :G7:! U8JTI5Pa5! J_! 4:F! 7HHI4K7:4J8! 4F!5FF58:47II;!RJ:4`7:48a,!^G7:!T5! 5cH5K:5P! :J! _7II! J8! :G5! _7K:! F4P5!J_!:G5! _7K:�`7IO5! P4F:48K:4J8! :O68F! JO:! :J! G7`5! :G5! 7::64WO:5F! J_! `7IO5,!]G4F!G7F!:678F_J6R7:4`5!4RHI4K7:4J8F!_J6!RJ67I!5H4F:5RJIJa;!78P!:G5!R5:7HG;F4KF!J_!RJ67I!H6JH56:45F,!

]7U5!R5:7HG;F4KF!S6F:,! M_!78;:G48a!4F!KJRRJ8!a6JO8P!7R4PF:!:G5!P4F7667;!J_!KJ8:5RHJ676;!R5:7A5:G4KF*!4:!4F!:G5!/4;#$'#$!FOH56`58458K5!J_!:G5!5:G4K7Il!TG7:!_7IIF!O8P56!5:G4K7I!KJ8K5H:!}!PJ5F!FJ!48!`46:O5!J_!_7II48a!O8P56!8J8A5:G4K7I!KJ8K5H:F*!y*!FOKG!:G7:!85K5FF764I;*!TG7:!_7IIF!O8P56!y!_7IIF!O8P56!},!z46:O7II;!8JAJ85!P4FHO:5F!:G4F!KI74R*!TG4KG!4F!:7U58!7F!7!aO4P5!:J!:G5!87:O65!J_!5:G4KF,35!]G5!KI74R!4F!HI7OF4WI5!8J:!J8I;!_J6!:G48!KJ8K5H:F!FOKG!7F!'&=<"!78P!=''E!WO:!_J6!:G5!KJ8K5H:F!J_!FH5K4SK!`46:O5F,!M_!NO6PJKG!4F!64aG:*!GJT5`56*!:G5!HF;KGJIJa;!J_!`46:O5!aJ5F!W5;J8P!:G5F5!KJ8K5H:F*!:J!:G5!a6JO8PF!J_!:G546!7HHI4K7:4J8,!]G5!657FJ8F!TG;!78!7K:! 4F! eOF:!J6!O8eOF:*!U48P!J6!O8U48P*!64aG:!J6!T6J8a*!T4II! F7:4F_;! NJ67I! M8:5687I4FR,! ]G5;! T4II! RJ:4`7:5! :GJF5! TGJ! _OII;!HJFF5FF!:G5R,!M8!:G4F!65FH5K:*!:G5;!KJO8:!7F!RJ67I!_7K:F*!5`58!:GJOaG!:G5;!PJ!8J:!48`JI`5!:G5!F:78P76P!R58O!J_!RJ67I!KJ8K5H:F*!:G4KU!J6!:G48,!yJ6! 4F! 4:!/4;#$'#$! :G7:!FOKG! _7K:F!�!_J6! 48F:78K5*! _7K:F!7WJO:! :G5!855PF!J_!J:G56F!78P!:G5!KJF:!J_!G5IH48a!:G5R!�!FOH56`585!J8!78;:G48a!5IF5,!948K5!RJ67I!HG4IJFJHG;!IJJUF!P465K:I;!:J!:G5F5!_7K:F*!FOH56`58458K5!4F!8J:!5FF58:47I!:J!:G5!KJ8K5H:F!T4:G!TG4KG!4:!TJ6UF,!yJ6!K78!T5!7FFOR5!:G7:! 5cHI4K4:I;! RJ67I! KJ8K5H:F! 7HHI;! J8! :G5! W7F4F! J_! _7K:F! :G7:! 765!8J:! :G5RF5I`5F!RJ67I*! F48K5! :G5! _7K:F! 48!hO5F:4J8!R7;!F7:4F_;!NJ67I!

)L,! k765!5cK5H:4J8F!48KIOP5!t64g8!(--dl!ppwo!78P!9:O6a5J8!011-*!:GJOaG!9:O6Aa5J8QF!PJOW:F!H56:748!RJ65!:J!:G5!_J6ROI7:4J8!J_!FOH56`58458K5!:G78!:J!:G5!:6O:G!J_!FJR5:G48a!48!:G5!`4K484:;,

87:O67II;,!fF!:G5!5RH:;!KGJ4K5!T4II!8J:!JKKO6!:G5!5RH:;!TJ6P!T4II!8J:!W5!855P5P,!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!p1w(r

EO:!:G5!7HH6J7KG!4F!hO4:5!R4FI57P48a,!~46F:*!TG7:!NO6PJKG!5RHG7F4x5F!48!:G5!KJ8K5H:F!:G7:!48:565F:!G56!4F!8J:!:G5!P5a655!J_!KJ8`56a58K5!:G5;!5cG4W4:!WO:!:G5!HJ:58:47I!_J6!i7!FH5K47I4x5P!H56FJ87I!use!J_!7!KJ8K5H:j!48! T7;F! :G7:! R7;! W5! H64`7:5! J6! 4P4JF;8K67:4K! qNO6PJKG! (-n1l! 0Lr,!94R4I76I;*!NO6PJKGQF!KI74R!4F!8J:!:G7:!:GJF5!TGJ!OF5!7!a4`58!KJ8K5H:!8J8A`4K764JOFI;*!:G5!H76:4K4H78:F!_J6!TGJR!4:!G7F!I4_5*!765!WJO8P!:J!W5!RJ`5P!W;!4:F!KJ665K:!7HHI4K7:4J8,!M:!4F!J8I;!i:6O5!̀ 4F4J8j*!7!H56_5K:4J8!T5!6765I;!7HH6J7KG*!:G7:!aO7678:55F!64aG:!7K:4J8,

NJ65! F4a84SK78:I;*!NO6PJKGQF! _JKOF! 4F! 8J:! J8! :G5! KJ8K5H:F!T4:G!TG4KG!T5! P5FK64W5! JO6! JH:4J8F!�!just, .'&#/=-'&3, cruel!�!78P!TGJF5!7HHI4K7:4J8!aO4P5F!7K:4J8*!WO:!J8!:G5!KJ8K5H:F!T4:G!TG4KG!T5!P5FK64W5!JO6!K46KORF:78K5!78P!:G5!H5JHI5!T4:G!TGJR!T5!48:567K:,!]G48U!W7KU!:J!N!78P!Y,!^G7:!:G5!RJ:G56!a748F!4F!8J:!7!P55H56!7HH65G58F4J8!J_!G56!JT8!RJ67I!KG767K:56*!J6!J_!G56!W5G7`4JO6*!WO:!J_!G56!P7OaG:56A48AI7T!78P!TG7:!FG5!4F!657II;!I4U5,!yJ6!PJ5F!NO6PJKG!KJ8S85!G56F5I_!:J!KJ8K5H:F!:G7:!K766;!7!FH5K4SK!̀ 7I58K5*!HJF4:4`5!J6!85a7:4`5*!I4U5!:G5!J85F!J8!^4II47RFQ!I4F:,!fF!W5KJR5F!48K657F48aI;!KI576!48!:G5!F5KJ8P!5FF7;!J_!A'2-#-$=("B*!:G5!U8JTI5Pa5!:G7:!KJ8F:4:O:5F!`46:O5!4F!8J:!U8JTI5Pa5!J_!:G5!tJJP*! J6! 5`58!J_! H76:4KOI76! `46:O5F*! WO:! J_! :G5! 657I! 5c4F:58K5! J_!J:G56!H5JHI5l!i]G5!RJ65!:G5!F5H767:585FF!78P!P4|5658:85FF!J_!J:G56!H5JHI5!4F!657I4x5P*!78P!:G5!_7K:!F558!:G7:!78J:G56!R78!G7F!855PF!78P!T4FG5F!7F!P5R78P48a!7F!J85QF!JT8*!:G5!G76P56!4:!W5KJR5F!:J!:657:!7!H56FJ8!7F!7!:G48aj!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!dpr,

M8! a58567I*!NO6PJKGQF! :7IU! J_! iRJ67I! KJ8K5H:Fj!ROF:! W5!G576P! 48!65I7:4J8! :J! 7! H7658:G5:4K! 65R76Ul! iq]G7:! R58:7I! KJ8K5H:F! 58:56! :G5!FHG565!J_!RJ67I4:;! 4F*! _J6!R;!76aOR58:*!H65K4F5I;! :G5!K58:67I!HJ48:,rj!qNO6PJKG! (-n1l! 0)wpr! ]G5! RJ67I! 657FJ8F! _OII! KJa84:4J8! J_! TG4KG!58:74IF!KGJ4K5*!7KKJ6P48a!:J!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR*!765!eOF:!P5FK64H:4J8F!J_!J85QF!K46KORF:78K5*!7F*!_J6!48F:78K5*!:G7:!FJR5J85!4F!48!F564JOF!855P!78P!J85!K78!G5IH!:G5R!7:!I4::I5!KJF:,!NKYJT5IIQF!P4FKOFF4J8!H4KUF!OH!J8!:G4Fl!i7F!:G5!5c7RHI5!J_!sFG;!78P!F58F4:4`5Q!4IIOF:67:5F*!:G5!I78aO7a5!


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!(0!!w "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

7HHI45F!:J!all!KJ8K5H:F*!8J:!eOF:!:J!:GJF5!TG4KG!765!RJ67II;!65I5`78:l!if65!:G565!_J6RF!J_!ROP*!G746!78P!P46:{!M_!:G565!765!:G58!87:O65!4F!65P55R5P!48:J! :G5! 7657! J_! :6O:G_OI! `4F4J8,! qN;! H65`4JOF! 76aOR58:! 7FFOR5F!J_!KJO6F5*! 48!\I7:J84K! :56RF*! :G7:! :G565!765,rj! qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!odr! M8!JO:I485*!:G5!:G5J6;!4F!:G4Fl!57KG!KJ8K5H:!4F!7FFJK47:5P!T4:G!8J6RF!_J6!4:F!H6JH56!OF5*!WJ:G!H67K:4K7I!78P!:G5J65:4K7Im!:G5F5!8J6RF!P5FK64W5!TG58!:G5!KJ8K5H:!FGJOIP!W5!7HHI45P!78P!TG7:!_JIIJTF!_6JR!4:F!7HHI4K7:4J8*!WJ:G!KJa84:4`5I;!78P!48!65I7:4J8!:J!:G5!T4IIm!:J!a67FH!7!a4`58!KJ8K5H:!4F!:J!7HH6Jc4R7:5*!48!J85QF!P4FHJF4:4J8F!J_!:GJOaG:*!7!KJ8_J6R4:;!T4:G!:G5F5!8J6RF,!XJ8K5H:AHJFF5FF4J8! :GOF! KJR5F!W;!P5a655! 78P!HJ48:F!:J!7!I4R4:!T5!R7;!85`56!657KGl!H56_5K:!KJRHI478K5!T4:G!:G5!8J6RF!W;!TG4KG!JO6!KJ8K5H:F!765!P5S85P,

]G4F!H4K:O65!J_!KJ8K5H:F!4F!65I7:5P!:J!Y7`4PFJ8QF!iKJ8F:4:O:4`5!4P57I!J_!67:4J87I4:;j!78P!:J!:G5!i8J6R7:4`4:;!J_!:G5!48:58:4J87Ij,!f!RJ65!65K58:!\I7:J84F:*!k7IHG!^5PaTJJP*!R7U5F!7!F4R4I76!KI74Rl

�]G5�!PJK:6485! :G7:! :G5! 48:58:4J87I! 4F! 8J6R7:4`5! K78!W5!`45T5P!7F!7!T7;!J_!K7FG48a!JO:!\I7:JQF!R5:7HGJ6!:G7:!:G5!~J6R!J_!:G5!tJJP!4F!:J!:G5!O8P56F:78P48a!TG7:!:G5!FO8!4F! :J! `4F4J8! qO-;&%0$.*! L1nWwL1-7r,!^5! KJO8:! 7F! F4aG:5P!W5K7OF5! T5! 765! 7HH6JH647:5I;! F58F4:4`5! :J! I4aG:*! :G5!OI:4R7:5!FJO6K5!J_!TG4KG!4F!:G5!FO8m!48!7!F4R4I76!T7;*!T5!KJO8:!7F!:G48U56F!W5K7OF5!T5!765!7HH6JH647:5I;!F58F4:4`5!:J! 8J6R7:4`5! 65hO465R58:F*! :G5! FJO6K5! J_! TG4KG! 4F! 7!

65I5`78:!H7FF7a5!4F!:G4Fl

! \I7:J! 7FFOR5F! :G5! 48:5687I! 65I7:4J8! J_! `7IO5*! :6O:G*! KJa84:4J8,!z46A:O5! q7F! KJRH7FF4J8*! GOR4I4:;*! KJO67a5r! 48`JI`5F! 7! P5F465! _J6! 78P!7KG45`5R58:!J_!:6O:G!48F:57P!J_!_7IF5GJJP*!657I4:;!48F:57P!J_!7HH576A78K5,!��!�576848a!78;:G48a!H6JH56I;!P5R78PF!q`46:OJOFr!7::58:4J8,![565!:G5!4P57!J_!truth!HI7;F!7!K6OK47I!6JI5!q7F!4:!PJ5F!7IFJ!48!378:r!78P!657I4:;!5R56a5F!7F!:G5!JWe5K:!J_!:6O:G_OI!`4F4J8*!78P!`46:OJOF!7KA:4J8!7F!:G5!H6JPOK:!J_!FOKG!`4F4J8,!]G4F!4F!7!H4K:O65!J_!:G5!JR84H65FA58K5!J_!RJ67I4:;!78P!5`7IO7:4J8!48!GOR78!I4_5,!b8!:G4F!̀ 45T!4:!TJOIP!F55R!R7P!:J!W5a48!HG4IJFJHG;!W;!7FF56:48a!7!KJRHI5:5!F5H767:4J8!J_!_7K:!_6JR!̀ 7IO5*!78P!:G58!7::5RH:48a!:J!a4`5!7!F7:4F_7K:J6;!7KKJO8:!J_!RJ67IF,!qNO6PJKG!(--0l!)-r

M8:5687I4FR,!^4:GJO:! :G5! 7FFORH:4J8! J_! FOH56`58458K5*!R5:7A5:G4KF!TJOIP!W5!7IRJF:!O84R7a487WI;!P4|5658:,

M8! 5H4F:5RJIJa;*! :G5! KJ8F5hO58K5! 4F*! 4_! 78;:G48a*! RJ65! F:64U48a,!E5I45_F!7WJO:!64aG:!78P!T6J8a*!J6!TG7:!:G565!4F!657FJ8!:J!PJ*!R7;!674F5!5H4F:5R4K! H6JWI5RF,! EO:! H56G7HF! :G5;! K78! W5! 4a8J65P,!fII!T5! 855P!4F! U8JTI5Pa5! J_! :G5! _7K:F! :G7:! KJ8F:4:O:5! 657FJ8F*! HI748! _7K:F! 7WJO:!JO6!K46KORF:78K5*!TG4KG! 48VO58K5! :G5!T4II,!fFFOR48a!T5!K78!U8JT!:G5!7HHI4K7:4J8!J_!R58:7I!KJ8K5H:F*!:G565!4F!8J!H6JWI5R!7WJO:!RJ67I!U8JTI5Pa5!48!4:F!RJF:!W7F4K!_J6R,

yJ! PJOW:! :G5F5! H6JHJF7IF! 674F5! hO5F:4J8F! J_! :G546! JT8,! \56G7HF!:G5!65FOI:!4F!:J!R7U5!:G5!5H4F:5RJIJa;!J_!:G5!R58:7I!RJ65!R;F:564JOF!:G78!4:!F55R5P,!^5!TJ8Q:!HO6FO5!:G7:!4FFO5!G565,!bO6!:7FU!4F!:J!S8P!48!NO6PJKG!7!:G5J6;!J_!KJ8K5H:F!:G7:!R7U5F!F58F5!J_!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR,!9G5! 65e5K:F! :G5! a585:4K! :G5J6;*! 78P! G56! KI74R! 4F! 8J:! R565I;! 7WJO:!:G4KU! KJ8K5H:F! WO:! 7WJO:! :G5! TGJI5! 678a5! J_! :GJOaG:F! T4:G! TG4KG!T5!76:4KOI7:5!JO6!FJK47I!TJ6IP,!^G7:!7KKJO8:!PJ5F!FG5!a4`5{!]G5!KIO5!:J! NO6PJKGQF! H4K:O65! I45F! 48! :G5! 48`JK7:4J8! J_! i657I4FRj*! TG4KG! T5!58KJO8:565P!48!F5K:4J8!(,!M8!7!\I7:J84K!RJP5*!NO6PJKG!KJ885K:F!:G5!657I4FR!J_!`46:O5!T4:G! :G5! i7HH65K47:4J8!J_!W57O:;! 48!76:! 78P!87:O65j*!TG4KG!4F!i7!KJRHI5:5I;!7P5hO7:5!58:6;!48:J!q78P!8J:!eOF:!787IJa;!J_r!:G5!aJJP!I4_5*!F48K5!4:!is!:G5!KG5KU48a!J_!F5ISFG85FF!48!:G5!48:565F:!J_!F5548a!:G5!657Ij!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!d)r,36!t657:!76:!FG765F!48!:G5!5c7K:85FF!78P!JWe5K:4`5!7::58:4J8!NO6PJKG!7FFJK47:5F!T4:G!RJ67IF,!]G5!F7R5!4F!:6O5!J_!technai!48!a58567Il!48!78!48:5II5K:O7I!P4FK4HI485*!iM!7R!KJ8_6J8:5P!W;!78!7O:GJ64:7:4`5!F:6OK:O65!TG4KG!KJRR78PF!R;!65FH5K:,!��!f::58:4J8!4F! 65T76P5P!W;!7!U8JTI5Pa5!J_! 657I4:;j! qNO6PJKG! (-n1l!onr,!f8P! 48!:G5!RJF:!a58567I!_J6ROI7:4J8!J_!7IIl!i@<-4(-.-33$"B4'C4"<-4=''E4$34"<-(4/(4/3;-."4'C4 "<-4F$(E4'C4(-.-33$"B4 $(2'02-E4 $(4/(B4"-.<($P&-4 C'#4-G<$%$"$(=4 C/."j!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!dpr,

M:! 4F! HJFF4WI5! :J! 5c:67K:! _6JR! :G5F5! 48K657F48aI;! 7WF:67K:! KI74RF! 7!\I7:J84K! :G5J6;! J_! KJ8K5H:F! 78P! KJ8K5H:AHJFF5FF4J8,37! ]G4F! :G5J6;!

)d,!955!7IFJ!NO6PJKG!(-n1l!o0wL,

)n,! \56G7HF!:G5!KI5765F:!F:7:5R58:!J_!:G4F!`45T!4F!:J!W5!_JO8P!48!M-"/;<B3$.34/34/4D&$E-4"'4M'#/03*!WO:!:G7:!WJJU!4F!:JJ!P4gKOI:!:J!W5!48:5a67:5P!G565,!]G5!RJF:!


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!()!!w "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

M_!:G4F!4F!64aG:*!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR!4F!KJ8:6J`56F47I!WO:!8J:!JW`4JOFI;!_7IF5,!M:!4F!`48P4K7:5P!W;!NO6PJKGQF!FH48!J8!7!KJ8:58:4JOF*!:GJOaG!8J:!4RHI7OF4WI5*!HG4IJFJHG;!J_!R48P,![56!76aOR58:F!_J6!:G4F!KJ8K5H:4J8!765!FK7::565P*!78P!M!7R!RJ65!KJ8K5685P!:J!R7U5!G56!`45T!KJa58:!:G78!:J!R7U5!4:!4665F4F:4WI5,!EO:!7!K58:67I!:G657P!6O8F!_6JR!:G5!5c7RHI5!J_!N!78P!Y! :J! :G5!KJ8KIOF4J8! :G7:!JO6!a67FH!J_! KJ8K5H:F! K78!W5!RJ65!J6! I5FF! 4P57I*!TG565!:G5! I4R4:! 4F!H56_5K:!67:4J87I4:;!J6!65FHJ8F4`585FF!:J!657FJ8,!NO6PJKG!FOHHJ6:F!78P!4IIOF:67:5F!:G4F!KI74R!T4:G!KJ8K5H:F!J_!:G5!87:O67I!TJ6IP*!T4:G!76:*!78P!T4:G!technail!:G5!4P57!J_!H56_5K:4J8!TJ6UF!T4:G48!5`56;!S5IP!J_!:GJOaG:,

]G4F! 76aOR58:! PJ5F! 8J:! :5II! OF! TG7:! :G565! 4F! 657FJ8! :J! PJ,! M8!H76:4KOI76*! 4:!PJ5F!8J:! :5II!OF! :G7:! :G5!855PF!J_!J:G56!H5JHI5!H6J`4P5!OF!T4:G!657FJ8F!:J!7K:,!M_!:G565!765!FOKG!657FJ8F*!GJT5`56*! 4:! _JIIJTF!_6JR!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;!:G7:!:G5!KJ665FHJ8P48a!8J6RF!765!WO4I:!48:J!JO6!KJ8K5H:F,!^G58!:G565!4F!P5K4F4`5!RJ67I!657FJ8!:J!7K:!48!7!K56:748!T7;*!U8JTI5Pa5!J_!:G7:!657FJ8*!48KIOP48a!4P57I!a67FH!J_!:G5!KJ8K5H:F!4:!48`JI`5F*!58:74IF!P5K4F4`5!RJ:4`7:4J8,!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR!GJIPF,!]G4F!76aOR58:!78FT56F!:G5!hO5F:4J8!i^G;!W5!RJ67I{j!8J:!W;!FGJT48a!:G7:!:G565!4F!657FJ8!:J!PJ!TG7:!4F!64aG:*!J6!W;!H56FO7P48a!:G5!7RJ67I4F:*!WO:!W;! 7`J4P48a! :G5! P4I5RR7! HJF5P! 48! F5K:4J8! (,! }`58! 4_! :G5! 76aOR58:!_J6! 5:G4K7I! 67:4J87I4FR! aJ5F! :G6JOaG*! T5! K78! F7`5! :G5! a58567I4:;! J_!RJ67I!657FJ8F!T4:GJO:!P564`48a!:G546!5c4F:58K5!_6JR!:G5!87:O65!J_!:G5!T4II,!b8!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;!J_!KJ8K5H:F*!:G565!4F!78J:G56!HJFF4W4I4:;l!:G7:!67:4J87I!7a58:F!765!RJ`5P!W;!FOKG!KJ8F4P567:4J8F!W5K7OF5!:G5;!765! 657FJ8F!�!J6! FJ! T5! 7FFOR5! 7a748F:! :G5! FK5H:4K!�!78P! W5K7OF5!67:4J87I4:;!W5IJ8aF!:J!_OII!KJa84:4J8!J_!:G5!_7K:F,

]G4F!657P48a!R7U5F!F58F5!J_!ROKG!:G7:!4F!JWFKO65!48!@<-4A'2-#-$=("B4'C4 D''E*! _6JR! :G5! 6JI5! J_! :G5! a585:4K! :G5J6;*! :G6JOaG! NO6PJKGQF!657I4FR*!:J!G56!KJ8K5H:4J8!J_!KGJ4K5,!EO:!4:!I57`5F!7!8ORW56!J_!IJJF5!58PF,!b85!4F!FH5K4SK!:J!:G5!KJ8:5c:!48!TG4KG!M!G7`5!HI7K5P!NO6PJKGQF!`45TF,! M! G7`5! 76aO5P! :G7:! FG5! 7`J4PF! :G5! H6JWI5R!J_!RJ67I! 657FJ8F!7F! 4:! 7�4K:F! :G5! 5:G4K7I! 67:4J87I4F:,! EO:! :G4F! R7;! W5! :JJ! hO4KU,! ]G5!:6O:G! J_! 67:4J87I4FR! TJOIP! KJ8F:6748! TG7:! KJ8F:4:O:5F! 7! 8J6R! J_!H67K:4K7I!657FJ8,!YJ!:G5!8J6RF!48`JI`5P!48!JO6!HJFF5FF4J8!J_!KJ8K5H:F*!

KJG5658:! F;F:5R! J_! 5:5687I! 78P! 85K5FF76;! :6O:GF! 7WJO:!TG7:!T5!JOaG:!:J!:G48U!J6!PJ!J6!_55I,!q^5PaTJJP!011nl!)r

b8!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;*!T5!ROF:!65FHJ8P!:J!:G5!8J6RF!J_!657FJ8*!7:!I57F:! W;! 7HH6Jc4R7:4J8*! 48! OF48a! :G5! KJ8K5H:F! T5! PJ,! ]G5;! 765! 7:!J8K5!7!KJ8P4:4J8!J_! :GJOaG:!78P!78! 4P57I! :J!TG4KG!T5!7FH465,38!]G5!i(-.-33$"B4$(2'02-E4$(4/(B4"-.<($P&-4C'#4-G<$%$"$(=4C/."j!4F!:G5!85K5FF4:;!J_!:G4F!7FH467:4J8!78P!:G4F! 4P57I*!7!85K5FF4:;! 48`JI`5P! 48!78;!7::5RH:!:J!P5H4K:!657I4:;!7F!4:!4F,

^5PaTJJPQF! \I7:J84FR! P4|56F! _6JR! NO6PJKGQF! 48! F5`567I! T7;F,!~46F:*! ^5PaTJJP! KJ8K58:67:5F! J8! :G5! KJ8K5H:! '&=<"*! 8J:! J8! :G4KU!RJ67I!KJ8K5H:F!J6!:G5!KJ8K5H:F!T4:G!TG4KG!T5!FH5K4_;!RJ67I!657FJ8F,39 95KJ8P*!G5!7FFJK47:5F!57KG!KJ8K5H:!T4:G!7!F48aI5! 6OI5*!J6!7! iFH5K4SK!67:4J87I!P4FHJF4:4J8j! q^5PaTJJP!011nl! (d-r,!NO6PJKG!TJOIP!7PJH:!7!RJ65!GJI4F:4K!`45T,!fF!T5!P55H58!JO6!KJ8K5H:F*!:G5;!W5KJR5!RJ65!48:64K7:5I;! WJO8P! :J! J85! 78J:G56l! i65V5K:4J8! 64aG:I;! :58PF! :J! O84_;!:G5! RJ67I! TJ6IPj! qNO6PJKG! (-n1l! Ldr,! ]G5! 8J6RF! T5! 7HH6J7KG! 48!HJFF5FF48a! 7! a4`58! KJ8K5H:! PJ! 8J:! KJ8F4F:! 48! 78! 4FJI7:5P! 6OI5m! :G5;!48KIOP5!5`56;!8J6R!48:J!TG4KG!:G7:!KJ8K5H:!58:56F,!~487II;*!̂ 5PaTJJP!R7U5F!8J:G48a!J_! :G5!KI74R!:G7:!JO6!HJFF5FF4J8!J_!KJ8K5H:F!R7;!W5!H76:47I*!:G7:!4:!KJR5F!W;!P5a655,!]G5F5!KJ8:67F:F!:Ja5:G56!5cKIOP5!_6JR!^5PaTJJPQF! \I7:J84FR!TG7:! 4F!RJF:! P4F:48K:4`5! 48!NO6PJKGQF! `45Tl!G56!KJRR4:R58:!:J!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR,!M_! _OII!HJFF5FF4J8!J_!KJ8K5H:F!58:74IF! KJ8_J6R4:;! 8J:! J8I;!T4:G! IJK7I! 8J6RF! WO:!T4:G! F:78P76PF! J_!4P57I!67:4J87I4:;*!_OII!a67FH!J_!7!P5K4F4`5!657FJ8!:J!!!T4II!58:74I!P5K4F4`5!RJ:4`7:4J8,!]G5!:6O:G!J_!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR!_JIIJTF!_6JR!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;!J_! KJ8K5H:F*! 7FFOR48a! :G7:! :G5!U8JTI5Pa5! :J!TG4KG! 4:! 65_56F!48`JI`5F! i:6O5!`4F4J8j!J6! 4P57I! KJ8K5H:O7I! a67FH!78P! :G7:! :G5!8J6RF!4RHI4K4:!48!JO6!KJ8K5H:F!765!:GJF5!J_!H67K:4K7I!78P!:G5J65:4K7I!657FJ8,!M:!4F!48!:G4F!F58F5!:G7:!i�:G5�!7O:GJ64:;!J_!RJ67IF!4F!:G5!7O:GJ64:;!J_!:6O:Gj!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!oor,

)o,!f8:J87KK4J!0111l!L0*!Low-,

)-,![5!P5_58PF!:G4F!_JKOF!5cHI4K4:I;!7:!^5PaTJJP!011nl!-nwo*!(1Lwd,


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!(p!!w "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

f8J:G56! IJJF5! 58P! 4F! NO6PJKGQF! 5RHG7F4F! J8! H56K5H:4J8! J_! :G5!48P4`4PO7I!7F!7!RJ67I!HG58JR58J8,!YJ5F! :G4F!KJ8V4K:!T4:G*!J6!PJ5F!4:! _JIIJT! _6JR*! :G5!F:J6;!J_!KJ8K5H:O7I!H6Ja65FF! :JIP!W;! :G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;{! MF! :G565! 6JJR! _J6! RJ67I! P5`5IJHR58:! :G7:! H65K5P5F! :G5!7KhO4F4:4J8!J_! KJ8K5H:F*! 48!TG4KG!J85!KJR5F! :J!H56K54`5!7! F4:O7:4J8*!J6!7!H56FJ8*!KJ665K:I;*!48!T7;F!J85!K788J:!76:4KOI7:5!48!TJ6PF{!]G5F5!hO5F:4J8F!65I7:5!:J!I76a56!4FFO5F!48!:G5!HG4IJFJHG;!J_!R48P*!78P!M!K78!J8I;!:JOKG!OHJ8!:G5R!G565,!f!:5RH:48a!̀ 45T!4F!:G7:!FG4_:F!48!H56K5H:4J8!:G7:!KJ8F:4:O:5!RJ67I!a6JT:G*!5`58!TG58!:G5;!765!4876:4KOI7:5*!48`JI`5!KJ8K5H:O7I!KG78a5,!b85!R7;!8J:!G7`5!TJ6PF!_J6!:G5!KJ8:58:!J_!J85QF!H56K5H:4J8*!WO:!J85!K78!:G48U!7WJO:!4:*!4_!J8I;!48!P5RJ8F:67:4`5!:56RFl!this!U48P!J_!H56FJ8*!that!T7;!:J!7K:,41!M!7R!48KI485P!:J!:7U5!:G4F!6JO:5*!WO:! 4:! 4F!8J:!5FF58:47I! :J!R;!76aOR58:,!f!RJ65!KJ8K5FF4`5! 65FHJ8F5!4F!:G7:!:G565!4F!8J!657FJ8!TG;!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;!ROF:!5cHI748!5`56;!7FH5K:!J_!NO6PJKGQF!`45T!78P!8J!657FJ8!:J!_576!:G7:!4:!KJ8V4K:F!T4:G!48:56H65:7:4J8F!J8!TG4KG!H56K5H:4J8!G7F!78!48P5H58P58:!6JI5,

~487II;*! :G5! \I7:J84K! :G5J6;! K7F:F! I4aG:! J8! NO6PJKGQF! 7::4:OP5! :J!P5_5K:4`5!KJ8K5H:F!78P!KJ8K5H:O7I!KG78a5,!9OHHJF5! :G7:!HJFF5FF4J8!J_! 7! HO:7:4`5! KJ8K5H:! 48`JI`5F! W548a! P4FHJF5P! :J! :G48U! J6! 657K:! 48!4RRJ67I!T7;Fl! :G5!KJ8K5H:! 4F!J85! :G7:!7!`46:OJOF!H56FJ8!TJOIP!8J:!G7`5,! }c7RHI5F! R4aG:! W5! .</3"$"B! J6! 3-0C)E-($/0,! M:! 4F! 78! 4RHI4K7:4J8!J_!NO6PJKGQF!`45T!:G7:!FOKG!HO:7:4`5!KJ8K5H:F! _74I,!948K5!:G5!8J6RF!P5S84:4`5! J_! 78;! KJ8K5H:! 765! 8J6RF! J_! 657FJ8*! a58O485! KJ8K5H:F!K788J:! W5! 48! :G4F!T7;! V7T5P,42! ]GJF5!TGJ! OF5! :G5! 65I5`78:!TJ6PF!R7;!7HH576!:J!W5!:G48U48a*!WO:!:G5;!765!8J:,!M:!4F!KJ8F4F:58:!T4:G!:G4F!:G7:!JO6!H65F58:!KJ8K5H:F!765!I4R4:5P*!:G7:!:G565!765!_7K5:F!J_!657FJ8!:J!TG4KG!:G5;!7|J6P!8J!7KK5FF*!78P!:G7:!:G565!4F!H65FFO65!_J6!OF!:J!65`4F5!78P!5c:58P!JO6!:GJOaG:F,

7IFJ!KJ8F4F:58:!T4:G!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;*!78P!T4:G!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR*!:J!65e5K:!:G5!67:4J87I4F:!76aOR58:!7I:Ja5:G56,

p(,! 955!NKYJT5II!(--pl!Ldwo*!7a748F:!i8J8AKJ8K5H:O7I!KJ8:58:j,

p0,! ~J6! 7! F4R4I76! 76aOR58:*! F55!^5PaTJJP!011nl! (dow-*! 78P! _J6! 78!JHHJF48a!`45T*!^4II47RFJ8!011),

7KKJ6P48a!:J!NO6PJKGQF!\I7:J84FR*!R55:!:G4F!KJ8F:6748:{!^5!K78!HO:!:G5!H6JWI5R!:G4F!T7;l!fKKJ6P48a!:J!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;*!KJ8K5H:F!765!7FFJK47:5P! T4:G! 8J6RF! :J! TG4KG! T5! ROF:! 7HH6Jc4R7:5I;! KJ8_J6R*!4P57I!HJFF5FF4J8!J_!7!KJ8K5H:!48`JI`5F!_OII!KJ8_J6R4:;*!78P!:G4F!4F!:G5!F:78P76P! J_! 4P57I! 67:4J87I4:;,!fKKJ6P48a! :J! 5:G4K7I! 67:4J87I4FR*! :J! W5!H67K:4K7II;!67:4J87I!4F!:J!7KG45`5!:G5!74R!J6!58P!J_!7a58K;*!7F!FOKG,!^5!:GOF!G7`5!:TJ!HJ:58:47II;!KJ8V4K:48a!`45TF!J_!H67K:4K7I!67:4J87I4:;,!EO:!T5!K78!65KJ8K4I5!:G546!KI74RF,!M_!4P57I!67:4J87I4:;!4F!_OII!KJ8_J6R4:;!T4:G!:G5!8J6RF!48FK64W5P!48!JO6!KJ8K5H:F*!78P!:J!W5!H67K:4K7II;!67:4J87I!4F!:J!7KG45`5!:G5!74R!J6!58P!J_!7a58K;*!7F!FOKG*!:G5!74R!J_!7a58K;!ROF:!W5!:J!a67FH!:G5!KJ8K5H:F!T4:G!TG4KG!:J!P5FK64W5!JO6!K46KORF:78K5,!]GJOaG!FG5!4F!8J:!5cHI4K4:!7WJO:!4:*!:G4F!R7;!W5!NO6PJKGQF!`45T,!9G5!KJ8K54`5F!7::58:4J8!7F!i7!eOF:!78P!IJ`48a!a7x5!P465K:5P!OHJ8!78!48P4`4PO7I!657I4:;j!78P!K7IIF!:G4F!i:G5!KG767K:564F:4K!78P!H6JH56!R76U!J_!:G5!7K:4`5!RJ67I!7a58:j!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!))r,!fF!FG5!aJ5F!J8!:J!F7;*!:G4F!4F!WJ:G!i7!IJa4K7I!78P!7!8J6R7:4`5!KI74Rjl!4:!G7F!:G5!F7R5!PO7I!KG767K:56!7F!:G5!74R!J_!7a58K;*!_J6!:G5!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4F:*!TG4KG!W64Pa5F!:G5!4FAJOaG:!a7H,!b8!:G4F!48:56H65:7:4J8*!TG4I5!NO6PJKG!J|56F!FJR5:G48a!I4U5!i:G5!65`56F5!J_![7RHFG465QF!H4K:O65j*!FG5!7a655F*!48!7!T7;*!T4:G!

:G5! J8I;! 5cHI4K4:! sJOaG:Q! 48! G4F! HF;KGJIJa;,! ^5! JOaG:!:J! U8JT! TG7:! T5! 765! PJ48a,! ^5! FGJOIP! 74R! 7:! :J:7I!U8JTI5Pa5!J_!JO6!F4:O7:4J8!78P!7!KI576!KJ8K5H:O7I4x7:4J8!J_!7II!JO6!HJFF4W4I4:45F,!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!nr!

]G5!P4|5658K5!4F!48!GJT!FG5!KJ8K54`5F!FOKG!U8JTI5Pa5*!8J:!7F!7!R7::56!J_!HOWI4K*!4RH56FJ87I!_7K:*!WO:!7F!:G5!JWe5K:!J_!eOF:!H56K5H:4J8*!78P!8J:!7F!5cH78P48a!JO6!678a5!J_!HJFF4W4I4:45F*!WO:!7F!KIJF48a!:G5R!J|!T4:GJO:!H65KIOP48a!_655PJR*!FJ!:G7:!64aG:!KJ8POK:!4F!7FFO65P,!]G5!iJOaG:j!J_!7::58:4J8!:J!FJK47I!657I4:;!W;!TG4KG!JO6!:GJOaG:F!765!H56_5K:5P!4F!:G5!iJOaG:j!J_!7a58K;!J6!H67K:4K7I! 657FJ8!and! :G5!iJOaG:j!J_!R55:48a!:G5!8J6RF!W;!TG4KG!JO6!KJ8K5H:F!765!P5S85P,40

p1,!fI:GJOaG! :G4F! 657P48a! 4F!HJFF4WI5*! M! FGJOIP! F:65FF! :G7:! :G5! :5c:!PJ5F!8J:! 65AhO465!4:,!̂ G4I5!NO6PJKGQF!̀ 45T!K78!W5!65KJ8K4I5P!T4:G!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4FR*!4:!4F!


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!(L!!w "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

PJ48a!48!:G5F5!H7FF7a5F*!TG;!4:!R7::56F!:J!RJ67I!HG4IJFJHG;*!78P!GJT!4:!KJ8F:4:O:5F!7!_J6R!J_!H6JJ_,

4. The Sovereignty of Good

]G5!I78aO7a5!J_!R;!7KKJO8:!FJ!_76!G7F!W558!KJ8FH4KOJOFI;!P4|5658:!_6JR! NO6PJKGQF,! M! G7`5! T64::58! 7WJO:! :G5! 8J6RF! J_! H67K:4K7I! 78P!:G5J65:4K7I!657FJ8!48FK64W5P! 48!JO6!KJ8K5H:F!78P!J_! :G5!F:78P76PF!J_!4P57I!67:4J87I4:;!48!:G546!OF5,!NO6PJKG!T64:5F!48F:57P!7WJO:!H56_5K:4J8!78P! :G5!tJJP,!k7:4J87I4:;! 4F!8J:!7!K58:67I!KJ8K5H:! 48!G56!WJJU,!]G5!KJ8:67F:!G565! 4F!8J:! eOF:! :56R48JIJa4K7I,!^G7:! 4F!7:! F:7U5! 48! :G5! 4P57!J_!:G5!tJJP!4F!:G5!O84:;!78P!KJG5658K5!J_!:G5!8J6RF!48`JI`5P!48!:G5!H56_5K:!a67FH!J_!R58:7I!KJ8K5H:F,!]G4F!4FFO5!4F!674F5P!W;!NO6PJKG!48!G56!5FF7;!ib8!stJPQ!78P!stJJPQjl

]G5!8J:4J8!:G7:!`7IO5!FGJOIP!W5!48!FJR5!F58F5!&($"/#B*!J6!5`58!:G7:!:G565!FGJOIP!W5!7!F48aI5!FOH65R5!`7IO5!KJ8K5H:*!R7;! F55R*! 4_! J85! FO6658P56F! :G5! 4P57! J_!tJP*! _76! _6JR!JW`4JOF,!̂ G;!FGJOIP!:G565!8J:!W5!R78;!P4|5658:!U48PF!J_!48P5H58P58:!RJ67I!`7IO5F{!^G;!FGJOIP!7II!W5!J85!G565{!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!LLr

]J!W5I45`5!48!:G5!tJJP!4F!:J!W5I45`5!:G7:*!48!78!5`7IO7:4`5!F58F5*!7II!4F!J85,!]J!4IIOF:67:5!:G4F!KI74R*!NO6PJKG!K4:5F!:G5!HJ:58:47I!O84:;!J_!:G5!`46:O5Fl! i4_!T5!65V5K:!OHJ8!KJO67a5!78P!7FU!TG;!T5!:G48U! 4:! :J!W5!7!`46:O5*!TG7:!U48P!J_!KJO67a5!4F!:G5!G4aG5F:*!TG7:!P4F:48aO4FG5F!KJO67a5!_6JR!67FG85FF*!_56JK4:;*!F5I_A7FF56:4J8*!78P!FJ!J8*!T5!765!WJO8P*!48!JO6!5cHI787:4J8*!:J!OF5!:G5!87R5F!J_!J:G56!`46:O5Fj!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!Ldr,43 EO:!:G4F!PJ5F!8J:!5cG7OF:!:G5!W5I45_!FG5!G7F!48!R48P,

�^G7:�!4F!4:!_J6!FJR5J85!TGJ!4F!8J:!7!65I4a4JOF!W5I45`56!78P!8J:!FJR5!FJ6:!J_!R;F:4K*!:J!7HH65G58P!FJR5!F5H767:5!s_J6RQ! J_! aJJP85FF! W5G48P! :G5! ROI:4_764JOF! K7F5F! J_!aJJP!W5G7`4JO6{!9GJOIP!8J:!:G4F!4P57!W5!65POK5P!:J!:G5!

p),! 955!7IFJ!NO6PJKG!(-n1l!-)m!NKYJT5II!(-n-l!L1w),

NJ67I! :7FUF! 765! KG767K:564F:4K7II;! 58PI5FF! 8J:! J8I;!W5K7OF5! QT4:G48Q*! 7F! 4:!T565*! 7! a4`58! KJ8K5H:!JO6! 5|J6:F!765! 4RH56_5K:*! WO:! 7IFJ!W5K7OF5! 7F!T5!RJ`5! 78P! 7F!T5!IJJU! JO6! KJ8K5H:F! :G5RF5I`5F! 765! KG78a48a,! qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!0nr

^5!R7;!855P!85T!78P!W5::56!KJ8K5H:F! 48!J6P56! :J!KJRH65G58P!JO6!657FJ8F*!:J!W648a!48:J!`45T!:G5!_7K:F!_J6!TG4KG!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR!GJIPF,

]G4F! JH58F! 78! 5c:67J6P4876;! HJFF4W4I4:;,! M_! 85T! KJ8K5H:F! R7U5!7`74I7WI5!85T!_7K:F*!U8JTI5Pa5!J_!TG4KG! 4F! 485c:64K7WI5! _6JR!KGJ4K5*!HG4IJFJHG;!K78!R7U5!RJ67I!H6Ja65FF!:G6JOaG!48:5II5K:O7I!KG78a5,!M8!:G5! I7F:! :TJ! 5FF7;F! J_! A'2-#-$=("B*! NO6PJKG! 48F4F:F! J8! :G5! H67K:4K7I!87:O65! J_! G56! H6Je5K:l! i[JT! K78! T5! R7U5! JO6F5I`5F! W5::56{! 4F! 7!hO5F:4J8!RJ67I!HG4IJFJHG56F! FGJOIP! :6;! :J!78FT56,j! qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!ndr!b8!:G5!\I7:J84K!KJ8K5H:4J8*!:G5;!K78,!fF!NO6PJKG!T6J:5!48!iz4F4J8!78P!XGJ4K5!48!NJ67I4:;jl

t657:! HG4IJFJHG56F! KJ48! 85T! RJ67I! KJ8K5H:F! 78P!KJRRO84K7:5! 85T! RJ67I! `4F4J8F! 78P! RJP5F! J_!O8P56F:78P48a,!��!~6JR!G565!T5!R7;!F55!:G7:!:G5!:7FU!J_!RJ67I!HG4IJFJHG56F!G7F!W558!:J!5c:58P*!7F!HJ5:F!R7;!5c:58P*!:G5!I4R4:F!J_!I78aO7a5*!78P!587WI5!4:!:J!4IIOR487:5!65a4J8F!TG4KG!T565!_J6R56I;!P76U,!qNO6PJKG!(-Ldl!p0*!p-r!

t4`58!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR*!:G5!5c:58F4J8!J_!I78aO7a5!78P!:GJOaG:!K78!KJ8F:4:O:5! RJ67I! 4RH6J`5R58:,! yJ6! PJ5F! NO6PJKG! F4RHI;! JWF56`5!:G4F! H6JFH5K:,! M8! :G5! H76:F! J_! G56! WJJU! :G7:! F55R!RJF:! O8J6:GJPJc*!:G546!6G5:J64K!RJF:!G4aGAVJT8*!FG5!:645F!:J!587K:!4:*!:J!65G7W4I4:7:5!:G5!KJ8K5H:!J_!:G5!tJJP*!85aI5K:!J_!TG4KG!4F!7!RJ67I*!8J:!eOF:!78!48:5II5K:O7I*!`4K5l!i]G5!4R7a5!J_!:G5!tJJP!7F!7!:678FK58P58:!R7a85:4K!K58:65!F55RF!:J!R5!:G5!I57F:!KJ66OH:4WI5!78P!RJF:!657I4F:4K!H4K:O65!_J6!OF!:J!OF5!48!JO6! 65V5K:4J8F! J8! :G5! RJ67I! I4_5,j! qNO6PJKG! (-n1l! n)r! fa748F:! :G5!W7KUa6JO8P!J_!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;*!T5!K78!5cHI748!TG7:!NO6PJKG!4F!


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!(d!!w "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

4F! 7IT7;F! 7! 64aG:! P5K4F4J8*! J85! :G7:! F7:4FS5F! :G5! 8J6RF! 48`JI`5P! 48!5`56;!KJ8K5H:!:G7:!7HHI45F!:J!J85QF!K46KORF:78K5,!E5I45_!48!:G5!tJJP!4F!5cH65FF5P!48!i:G5!4P57!��!:G7:!:G5!I485F!657II;!PJ!KJ8`56a5j!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!-nrl! :G5! I485F! :67K5P!JO:!W;! :G5!8J6RF!J_!57KG!KJ8K5H:*!TG4KG!KJ8`56a5!48!:G5!tJJP,!i~J6!7II!JO6!_674I:;!:G5!KJRR78P!sW5!H56_5K:Q!G7F!F58F5!_J6!OFj!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!-1r,!\56_5K:!a67FH!J_!5`56;!KJ8K5H:!R7;!W5!HF;KGJIJa4K7II;!JO:!J_!657KG*!WO:!4:!4F!8J:!4RHJFF4WI5,

E5I45_!48!:G5!tJJP!4F!7!H6J:5K:4J8!7a748F:!P5FH746!W5K7OF5!4:!:5IIF!OF!:G7:!5`56;!H6JWI5R!K78!W5!FJI`5P,!EO:!:G5!KJ8FJI7:4J8!R7;!aJ!_O6:G56,!f:!:4R5F*!NO6PJKG!FOaa5F:F!:G7:!_74:G!48!:G5!tJJP!4F!7!65KJa84:4J8!J_!i:G5! 7WFJIO:5! HJ48:I5FF85FF! J_! `46:O5! �78P�! 4:F! FOH65R5! 4RHJ6:78K5j*!:G7:!i8J:G48a!48!I4_5!4F!J_!78;!`7IO5!5cK5H:!:G5!7::5RH:!:J!W5!`46:OJOFj!qNO6PJKG! (-n1l! opwLr,! ]G5! O84:;! G565! 4F! 8J:! eOF:! :G7:! J_! 7! 64aG:!P5K4F4J8*!J85!:G7:!65FHJ8PF!:J!5`56;! _7K:*!WO:! :G7:! 4_!J85!R7U5F! :G4F!P5K4F4J8*!8J:G48a!5IF5!R7::56Fl!:G565!4F!8J!K7OF5!_J6!65a65:!J6!P4FR7;m!7II! J:G56! 657FJ8F! 765! iF4I58K5Pj,44! NO6PJKG! 5RHG7F4x5F*! :JJ*! :G7:!TG4I5!4:!R7;!W5!P4gKOI:*!iKJ8:5RHI7:4J8!J_!:G5!tJJP!�4F�!7!FJO6K5!J_!O8KJ8:7R487:5P!5856a;*!7!FJO6K5!J_!new!78P!hO4:5!O8P657R:AJ_!`46:O5j!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!--r,!M:!4F!7!iHF;KGJIJa4K7I!_7K:*!78P!J85!J_!4RHJ6:78K5!:J!RJ67I!HG4IJFJHG;*! :G7:!T5!K78!7II! 65K54`5!RJ67I!G5IH!W;! _JKOF48a!JO6!7::58:4J8!OHJ8!:G48aF!TG4KG!765!`7IO7WI5l!`46:OJOF!H5JHI5*!a657:!76:*!H56G7HF!��!:G5!4P57!J_!aJJP85FF!4:F5I_j!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!LpwLr,45

NO6PJKGQF! P4FKOFF4J8! 7:! :4R5F! KJ8V7:5F! :G5! \I7:J84K! :G5J6;! J_!KJ8K5H:F!T4:G!W5I45_!48!:G5!tJJP,!M8!_7K:*!FG5!4F!7!\I7:J84F:!:T4K5!J`56l!J8K5!48!65I7:48a!57KG!KJ8K5H:!:J!:G5!4P57!J_!4:F!JT8!H56_5K:4J8!78P!:G58!48!:G5!4P57!J_!7!F48aI5!H56_5K:4J8!48!TG4KG!5`56;!KJ8K5H:!FG765F,!fF!R;!P4FKOFF4J8!FGJTF*!:G5F5!4P57F!765!P4F:48K:,!]G565!4F!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;!TG4KG! FOHHJ6:F!NJ67I! M8:5687I4FR*! 78P! :G565! 4F! :G5! _O6:G56! KI74R!J_!O84:;! 48! :G5!tJJP,!fI:GJOaG! FG5! 4F! 8J:! K765_OI! :J! P4F:48aO4FG! :G5R*!NO6PJKG!F55F!:G5!855P!:J!76aO5!_J6!:G5!F5KJ8P!KI74R!48!7!T7;!:G7:!aJ5F!W5;J8P!:G5!S6F:,!9G5!PJ5F!8J:!58P!T4:G!i"<-4(-.-33$"B4'C4"<-4=''E4Q/3R4/(4

pp,! ~J6!:G5!4P57!J_!F4I58K48a*!F55!NKYJT5II!(-nol!-1wp*!(-n-l!L)wd,

pL,! b8!:G5!P4gKOI:;!G565*!78P!TG5:G56!:G5!tJJP!K78!W5!7!P465K:!JWe5K:!J_!7::58A:4J8*!F55!NO6PJKG!(-n1l!dnwo*!-L*!-n*!--,

ROKG!RJ65!48:5II4a4WI5!8J:4J8!J_!:G5!48:5665I7:4J8!J_!:G5!`46:O5F*!HIOF!7!HO65I;!FOWe5K:4`5!F58F5!J_!:G5!K56:748:;!J_!eOPa5R58:F{!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!L-r

]G5!GJH5PA_J6!78FT56! 4F! :G7:! 4:! FGJOIP!8J:,!^5!K78!R7U5!F58F5!J_!7!P55H56!O84:;!78P!J_!7!F48aI5!_J6R!J_!tJJP!W5G48P!:G5!`764JOF!U48PF!J_!5cK5II58K5!48!:G5!7HHI4K7:4J8!J_!KJ8K5H:F!78P!65FHJ8F4`585FF!:J!657FJ8F,

M! :G48U!T5! K78! O8P56F:78P!TG7:!NO6PJKG!T78:F! G565! W;! 8J:48a!GJT!ROKG!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;!I57`5F!JH58,!fKKJ6P48a!:J!:G4F!:G5J6;*!57KG!KJ8K5H:!4F!7FFJK47:5P!T4:G!8J6RF!_J6!4:F!H6JH56!OF5,!M8!J6P56!:J!a67FH!7!a4`58!KJ8K5H:*!J85!ROF:!F7:4F_;!:G5F5!8J6RF*!7:!I57F:!:J!FJR5!P5a655,!EO:!:G565!4F!6JJR!_J6!RJ65!KJRHI5:5!HJFF5FF4J8!J_!7!KJ8K5H:*!_J6!J85!:J!7HH6J7KG!H56_5K:4J8!W;!R55:48a!4:F!8J6RF!48!_OII,!yJ:G48a!48!:G4F!7KKJO8:!6OI5F!JO:!:G5!_JIIJT48a!HJFF4W4I4:;l!:G7:!:G5!8J6RF!_J6!KJ8K5H:!~!78P!KJ8K5H:!t!765!48KJRH7:4WI5*!:G7:!T5!K788J:!H56_5K:!JO6!a67FH!J_!WJ:G,!9OHHJF5*!_J6!48F:78K5*!:G7:!J85!7K:!_7IIF!O8P56!~*!78J:G56!O8P56!t,!38JTI5Pa5! :G7:! 78!7K:! 4F! ~*!T4:G! _OII! a67FH!J_! :G5! KJ8K5H:*!58:74IF!P5K4F4`5!RJ:4`7:4J8l!:G5!_7K:!:G7:!:G5!7K:!4F!~!4F!7!P5K4F4`5!657FJ8!:J!H56_J6R!4:,!f:!:G5!F7R5!:4R5*!U8JTI5Pa5!:G7:!78!7K:!4F!t*!T4:G!_OII!a67FH!J_!:G5!KJ8K5H:*!58:74IF!P5K4F4`5!RJ:4`7:4J8l!:G5!_7K:!:G7:!:G5!7K:!4F!t!4F!7!P5K4F4`5!657FJ8!:J!H56_J6R!4:,!M:!_JIIJTF!:G7:!J85!K788J:!_OII;!a67FH!WJ:G! _7K:F*! F48K5!J85!K788J:!R55:!WJ:G!8J6RF,!]G5!65FOI:! 4F!7!U48P!J_!_67aR58:7:4J8!48!657FJ8,

]G4F! P5FK64H:4J8! R7;! G76WJO6! FJR5! G4PP58! 48KJG5658K5*! WO:!4:!PJ5F!8J:! KJ8V4K:!T4:G! :G5! I5::56!J_! :G5!\I7:J84K! :G5J6;,!fII! :G7:! 4F!4RHI45P! 4F! :G7:! :G5! F:78P76P!J_! 4P57I! 67:4J87I4:;! 48! :G5!HJFF5FF4J8!J_!5`56;!KJ8K5H:!4F!O87::7487WI5,!]G565!765!:67a5P45F!48!TG4KG!T5!G7`5!P5K4F4`5! 657FJ8! :J! PJ! 48KJRH7:4WI5! :G48aF,!^G5:G56! :G4F! 4F! :6O5! J6!8J:!4F*!_J6!NO6PJKG*!7!657I!hO5F:4J8l!i]G5!8J:4J8!:G7:!s4:!7II!FJR5GJT!ROF:!R7U5! F58F5Q*! J6! s:G565! 4F! 7! W5F:! P5K4F4J8! G565Q*! H65F56`5F! _6JR!P5FH746m! :G5!P4gKOI:;! 4F!GJT! :J!58:56:748! :G4F! KJ8FJI48a!8J:4J8! 48!7!T7;!TG4KG! 4F! 8J:! _7IF5j! qNO6PJKG! (-n1l! LLr,! M_! :G5!tJJP! 5c4F:F*! :G5!8J6RF!48`JI`5P!48!JO6!KJ8K5H:F!765!KJRH7:4WI5l!:G565!765!8J!:67a5P45F!48!TG4KG*!TG7:5`56!J85!PJ5F*!J85!7K:F!7a748F:!7!P5K4F4`5!657FJ8,!]G565!


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!(n!!w "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

:J!KJR5!7H76:*!T5!T4II!65a76P!:G5!:58F4J8!7F!R565I;!7HH7658:*!65`4F48a!JO6!OF5!J_!:G5F5!KJ8K5H:F!O8:4I!4:!a4`5F!T7;,!]G5!4P57!J_!:G5!tJJP!:GOF!JH567:5F!7F!7!65aOI7:4`5!4P57I!_J6!JO6!KG78a48a!KJ8K5H:O7I!a67FH,

yJT*! FJ! _76*! :G4F! 4F! R565! P5FK64H:4J8l! 4:! 4F! 78! 7KKJO8:! J_! GJT!7! KJ8K5H:!TJ6UF*! 48! :G5! :56RF! F5:! JO:! W;! :G5!\I7:J84K! :G5J6;,!EO:! 4:!FOHHJ6:F! 78! iJ8:JIJa4K7I! H6JJ_j,46! fFU*! S6F:*! TG5:G56! 4:! 4F! 67:4J87I!:J!R7U5! :G5! 48_5658K5F! :G7:! P5S85! :G5! KJ8K5H:! J_! :G5!tJJP,! M_! 4:! 4F!4667:4J87I*!i:G5!tJJPj!4F!8J:!:G5!87R5!J_!7!a58O485!KJ8K5H:*!_J6!657FJ8F!a4`58!7:!:G5!58P!J_!F5K:4J8!),!b8!:G5!J:G56!G78P*!4_!4:!4F!67:4J87I!:J!:G48U!48!:G5F5!T7;F*!4:!4F!67:4J87I!:J!65`4F5!JO6!KJ8K5H:F!48!:G5!P465K:4J8!J_!O84:;*!:J!65FJI`5!7HH7658:!KJ8V4K:F!W5:T558!:G5R*!78P!:J!7K:!48!I4aG:!J_! :G5!O8P56F:78P48aF!T5! 657KG,! M:! _JIIJTF! :G7:! :G5!8J6RF! 48`JI`5P!48!JO6!KJ8K5H:F!PJ!8J:!5FF58:47II;!KJ8V4K:,!]G565!4F!7!67:4J87I!T7;!:J!O8P56F:78P! :G5F5! KJ8K5H:F! J8! TG4KG! :G546! 8J6RF! KJG565! T4:G! J85!78J:G56l!7!T7;!48!TG4KG!T5!765!I5P!:J!O8P56F:78P!:G5R!4_!T5!657FJ8!48! :56RF!J_! :G5!tJJP,! M:! _JIIJTF! 48! :O68! :G7:! :G565! 4F! 7IT7;F! 7! 64aG:!P5K4F4J8*!J85!:G7:!4F!67:4S5P!W;!5`56;!8J6R,!]G565!4F!7IT7;F!78!78FT56!:J!:G5!hO5F:4J8*!i^G7:!FGJOIP!M!PJ{j!]G565!765!8J!48FJIOWI5!:67a5P45F*!78P!T5!765!64aG:!:J!W5I45`5!48!:G5!5c4F:58K5!J_!:G5!tJJP,

]G4F!I485!J_!:GJOaG:!4F!78!J8:JIJa4K7I!H6JJ_*!48!:G7:!4:!RJ`5F!_6JR!:G5!87:O65!J_!7!KJ8K5H:!:J!:G5!657I4:;!J_!TG7:!4:!F:78PF!_J6,!M_!:GJOaG:!7WJO:! :G5!tJJP! 4F!HJFF4WI5*! 4_! 4:! 4F!8J:! :G5!R565! 4IIOF4J8!J_! :GJOaG:*!:G58!J8!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;!J_!KJ8K5H:F*!4:!ROF:!W5!67:4J87I*!78P!4_!4:!4F!67:4J87I*!:G5!KJ8K5H:!J_!:G5!tJJP!K788J:!W5!5RH:;,!b_!KJO6F5*!:G565!4F!8J!H6JJ_!J_!:G5!78:5K5P58:,!NO6PJKG!7FUF*!7WJO:!JO6!48`JK7:4J8F!J_!:G5!tJJPl!iX78!T5!a4`5!:G5R!78;!KI576!R57848a!J6!765!:G5;!eOF:!:G48aF!J85!s_55IF!48KI485P!:J!F7;Q{j!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!L-r!]G5!W5F:!7FFO678K5!J_!F58F5!4F!:G7:!JO6!HO:7:4`5!:GJOaG:F!7WJO:!:G5!tJJP!765!J85F!:G7:!F55R!48:5II4a4WI5!:J!OF!48!iJ6P4876;!I4_5j!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!n0r,!f_:56!:G7:*!i:G5!

pd,!NO6PJKG!K4:5F!:G5!J8:JIJa4K7I!H6JJ_*!H7658:G5:4K7II;*!48!65I7:48a!H56_5K:4J8!J6!7WFJIO:5!aJJP!:J!85K5FF76;!5c4F:58K5!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!L-wd1r,!q]G4F! 4F!J85!J_!:G5!HJ48:F!7:!TG4KG!M!:G48U!FG5!KJ8V7:5F!:G5!657I4:;!J_!:G5!tJJP!T4:G!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;!J_!KJ8K5H:F,r!]G565!4F!7!KG7H:56!J8!:G5!J8:JIJa4K7I!H6JJ_!48!M-"/;<B3$.34/34/4D&$E-4"'4M'#/03! :G7:! 4F!W6J7PI;!KJ8FJ878:!T4:G!:G5!657P48a!J|565P!G565m!78!7P5hO7:5!:657:R58:!I45F!W5;J8P!JO6!FKJH5,

/3;-."4'C4"<-4F$(E4'C4(-.-33$"B4$(2'02-E4$(4/(B4"-.<($P&-4C'#4-G<$%$"$(=4C/."j*!TG4KG!M!G7`5!:7U58!7F!78!5cH65FF4J8!J_!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!dpr,!M8F:57P*!FG5!TJ6645F*!65H57:5PI;*!:G7:!_J6!7II!4:F!HF;KGJIJa4K7I!W585S:F*!:G5!4P57!J_!i78!O8KJ66OH:5P!aJJPj!4F!i:G5!R565F:!KJ8FJI7:J6;!P657Rj!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!L-r,!f::58:4J8!:J!:G5!tJJP!R7;!W5!7!FJO6K5!J_!RJ67I!5856a;m!4:!R7;!F7`5!OF!_6JR!P5FH746!:J!:G48U!:G7:!5`56;:G48a!R7U5F!F58F5*! :G7:!iT5!ROF:!65K54`5!7!65:O68!TG58!aJJP!4F!F48K565I;!P5F465Pj!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!d0r,!i�]G5�!J8I;!P4gKOI:;!4F!:G7:!8J85!J_!4:!4F!:6O5j!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!n1r,!^G7:!4F!NO6PJKGQF!76aOR58:!_J6!:G5!657I4:;!J_!:G5!tJJP{

�JJU48a! W7KU! :J! :G5! 58P! J_! F5K:4J8! )*! I5:! OF! W5a48! T4:G! :G4Fl!fKKJ6P48a!:J!NO6PJKG*!T5!K78!W5KJR5!RJ67II;!W5::56!W;!F5548a!:G5!TJ6IP!48!I4aG:!J_!:G5!tJJP,!NO6PJKG!J|56F!:G4F!KJ8K5H:!H65K4F5I;!7F!7!FJO6K5!J_!iRJ67I!G5IHj!78P!iO8KJ8:7R487:5P!5856a;j,!M8!7!T7;*!:G565!4F!8J!R;F:56;!G565,! M:! 4F!8J:!R;F:564JOF!TG7:!T5!a748! _6JR!W5I45_! 48!:G5!tJJP!J6!GJT! 4:! K78!7|5K:!JO6!7K:4J8F*! 4_!NO6PJKG! 4F! 64aG:,!]G4F!W5I45_!4F!7!FJO6K5!J_!RJ67I!RJ:4`7:4J8,!]G5!HOxxI5!4F!TG7:!:G4F!G7F!:J!PJ!T4:G!:G5!5c4F:58K5!J_!:G5!tJJP,!^G;!FGJOIP!H67K:4K7I!657FJ8F!_J6!OF48a!7!KJ8K5H:!J6!GJIP48a!7!W5I45_!FGJT!:G7:!:G5!KJ8K5H:!4F!8J:!5RH:;!J6!:G7:!:G5!W5I45_!4F!:6O5{!NO6PJKG!4F!7P7R78:!:G7:!G56F!i4F!8J:!7!FJ6:!J_!H67aR7:4FR!J6! 7!HG4IJFJHG;!J_! s7F! 4_Qj! qNO6PJKG! (-n1l! n0w)r,!^5!FGJOIP!8J:!F4RHI;!H65:58P!:G7:!:G5!I485F!KJ8`56a5m!T5!765!eOF:4S5P!48!:G48U48a!:G7:!:G5;!PJ,

M8! J6P56! :J!R7U5! F58F5! J_! :G4F*! T5! 855P! :J! F7;!RJ65! 7WJO:! :G5!KJ8K5H:! J_! :G5! tJJP,! ]J! :G48U! 48! :56RF! J_! :G4F! KJ8K5H:!�!J_! :G5!H56_5K:4J8!J_!:GJOaG:*!7F!FOKG!�!4F!:J!48:56H65:!:G5!8J6RF!48`JI`5P!48!J:G56!KJ8K5H:F!7F!H76:F!J_!7!KJG5658:!TGJI5,!fRJ8a!:G5!8J6RF!:G7:!P5S85!:G5!KJ8K5H:!J_!:G5!tJJP!4:F5I_!765!:G5F5l!_6JR!:G5!_7K:!:G7:!:G5!8J6RF!J_!7!KJ8K5H:!65hO465!FJR5!65FHJ8F5*!48_56!:G7:!4:!4F!65hO465P!W;!:G5!tJJPm!78P! _6JR! :G5! _7K:! :G7:! :G5!tJJP! 65hO465F! FJR5! 65FHJ8F5*!48_56!:G7:!8J!J:G56!65FHJ8F5!K78!W5!65hO465P,!M_!T5!657FJ8!48!:G4F!T7;*!T5!T4II! KJ8KIOP5! :G7:! :G5!8J6RF!J_! 5`56;! KJ8K5H:! 765! KJ8F4F:58:! 48!H67K:4K5!T4:G!:G5!8J6RF!J_!5`56;!J:G56,!^5!T4II!W5!KJRR4::5P!:J!:G5!65FJIO:4J8!J_!KJ8V4K:,!̂ G58!:G5!P5R78PF!J_!P4FH767:5!KJ8K5H:F!7HH576!


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!(o!!w "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

NO6PJKG! 48F4F:F! :G7:! :G5! I78aO7a5!J_!RJ67I! 657FJ8F! 4F! iO87`J4P7WI;!4P4JF;8K67:4K!78P!487KK5FF4WI5j!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!))r,!]G565!4F!8J!F48aI5!58PAHJ48:!:J!:G5!H56_5K:!a67FH!J_!R58:7I!KJ8K5H:Fl!:G565!R7;!W5!F5`567I!T7;F! :J!7HHI;!7! KJ8K5H:*! 78P! :J! 65FHJ8P! :J! 4:F!OF5*! :G7:!765!5hO7II;!78P!H56_5K:I;!4P57I,!fF!T5!5`JI`5!48!P4|5658:!T7;F*!T5!R7;!W5KJR5!48K657F48aI;!O848:5II4a4WI5! :J!J85!78J:G56*!T4:GJO:!78;!J_!OF!G7`48a!aJ85!T6J8a,47!]G4F!_57:O65!J_!NO6PJKGQF!`45T!R7U5F!G56!JHHJF4:4J8!:J!:G5!a585:4K!:G5J6;*!T4:G!4:F!5RHG7F4F!J8!HOWI4K!F:78P76PF*!5FH5K47II;!FG76H,!EO:!4:!4F!8J:!5FF58:47I!:J!4:l!7!\I7:J84F:!_J6!TGJR!57KG!KJ8K5H:!G7F!7!F48aI5!H56_5K:!_J6R!TJOIP!F:4II!P58;!:G5!a585:4K!:G5J6;!78P!KJOIP!76aO5!_J6!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR!48!:G5!F7R5!T7;,!f8P!4:!4F!HJ:58:47II;!7:!JPPF!T4:G!NO6PJKGQF! F5KJ8P!\I7:J84FR*! 7WJO:! :G5!O84:;! 78P! 657I4:;!J_!:G5!tJJP*!TG4KG!F:65FF5F!KJ8`56a58K5*!8J:!4P4JF;8K67F;,!MF!:G565!7!KJ8:67P4K:4J8!G565{!M8!R;!`45T*!:G565!4F!8J:l!:G5!7HH57678K5!J_!KJ8V4K:!4F!FOH56SK47I,!]J!W5I45`5!48!:G5!tJJP!4F!:J!W5I45`5!:G7:!J85!K78!H56_5K:!J85QF!a67FH!J_!5`56;!KJ8K5H:,!M:!4F!8J:!:J!W5I45`5!:G7:!:G565!4F!eOF:!J85!T7;!J_!PJ48a!FJ,!E5I45_!48!:G5!tJJP!4F!:GOF!KJ8F4F:58:!T4:G!:G5!H64`7K;!J_!H56_5K:!O8P56F:78P48a,!9:4II*!J8!R;!657P48a*!:G5!PJK:6485!J_!H64`7K;!K78!W5! F5`565P! _6JR! :G5! 65F:! J_!NO6PJKGQF! `45Tl! 4:! PJ5F!8J:! _JIIJT!_6JR!G56!K58:67I!KI74RF,

]G5! S87I! :G5R5! 4F! 48! 7! T7;! :G5! S6F:l!NO6PJKG! JH58F! G56! WJJU!W;!I4F:48a*!7RJ8a!:G5!i_7K:F!��!TG4KG!F55R!:J!G7`5!W558!_J6aJ::58!J6! s:G5J64x5P!7T7;Qj! 48!KJ8:5RHJ676;!HG4IJFJHG;*! i:G5! _7K:! :G7:! IJ`5!4F!7!K58:67I!KJ8K5H:!48!RJ67IFj!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!0r,!]G5!F5KJ8P!5FF7;!J_! A'2-#-$=("B! 65H57:F! :G5! KG76a5l! i^5! 855P! 7! RJ67I! HG4IJFJHG;! 48!TG4KG!:G5!KJ8K5H:!J_!IJ`5*!FJ!6765I;!R58:4J85P!8JT!W;!HG4IJFJHG56F*!K78!J8K5!7a748!W5!R7P5!K58:67Ij!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!pLr,!fH76:!_6JR!4:F!4IIOF:67:4`5! OF5*!R;! P4FKOFF4J8! G7F! 6765I;!R58:4J85P! IJ`5,! M:! SaO65F!48K4P58:7II;!48!65_5658K5!:J!7::58:4J8!�!:G5!i:6O5!̀ 4F4J8!�:G7:�!JKK7F4J8F!64aG:!KJ8POK:j!�!7F!eOF:!78P!IJ`48a,!EO:!4:!G7F!8J:!W558!5cHI7485P,

pn,! NO6PJKGQF! KI74R!R7;! W5! I5FF! 67P4K7Il! :G7:! RJ67I! P5`5IJHR58:! K78! _JIIJT!P4|5658:! H7:GF! :J! :G5! 4P57I*! TG4KG! R7;! 48`JI`5! F:7a5F! J_! RO:O7I! 48KJRAH65G58F4J8,! M! _JKOF!J8! :G5!F:6J8a56! 657P48a! 48!H76:!W5K7OF5! 4:! F55RF!RJ65!H6JWI5R7:4K,

HG4IJFJHG4K7I!sH6JJ_Q!��!4F!:G5!F7R5!7F!:G5!RJ67I!sH6JJ_Qj!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!n)r,!]G5!H67K:4K7I!76aOR58:!_J6!:G5!tJJP!�!:G7:!4:!4F!67:4J87I!:J!:G48U!48!FOKG!:56RF!�!4F!:G5!H6JJ_!:G7:!tJJP!5c4F:F,

fF! W5_J65*! M! PJ! 8J:! R578! :J! 58PJ6F5! NO6PJKGQF! 657FJ848a! WO:!:J! 5cHI748! GJT! 4:! TJ6UF,! [56! 76aOR58:! 4F! KJ8:6J`56F47I! 8J:! eOF:! 48!7FFOR48a!:G5!48:5II4a4W4I4:;!J_!:G5!tJJP!WO:!48!4:F!KG767K:564x7:4J8!J_!:G5!KJ8K5H:!78P!4:F!65I478K5!J8!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;!J_!KJ8K5H:AHJFF5FF4J8,!9:4II*! P5FH4:5! 7HH57678K5F*!NO6PJKG! PJ5F! G7`5! 78! 76aOR58:,!^G58!FG5!65KJRR58PF!:G5!i4R7a5!J_!:G5!tJJP!7F!7!:678FK58P58:!R7a85:4K!K58:65j*!FG5!4F!8J:!58a7a48a!48!R565!HF;KGJIJa;!J6!F5I_AG5IH!WO:!F:7:48a!7!H65R4F5!J_!G56!J8:JIJa4K7I!H6JJ_,![56!KJ8K568!T4:G!:G5!R5:7HGJ6F!T5! I4`5! W;! 4F! 8J:! 7! F4a8! :G7:! G56! 48:565F:F! 765! RJ65! I4:5676;! :G78!HG4IJFJHG4K7I!WO:!7!KJ8F5hO58K5!J_!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;*!J8!TG4KG!JO6!KJ8K5H:F!R7;!P5:56R485!TG7:!T5!PJ!78P!J8!TG4KG!T5!K78!76aO5*!48!RJ67I!:56RF*!7WJO:!GJT!:J!:G48U,!NJF:!FO6H64F48aI;!J_!7II*!T5!K78!76aO5!_J6!:G5!657I4:;!J_!:G5!tJJP!_6JR!4:F!RJ67I!̀ 7IO5!7F!78!JWe5K:!J_!7::58:4J8*!WI48P48a!WO:!4IIOR487:48a*!7:!:G5!I4R4:!J_!F4aG:,

5. Concluding Thoughts

]G565!4F!RJ65!48!@<-4A'2-#-$=("B4'C4D''E!:G78!5`58!78!5c:58P5P!F:OP;!KJOIP!5cHIJ65,!M!G7`5!76aO5P!:G7:!i]G5!MP57!J_!\56_5K:4J8j!R7U5F!6JJR!_J6! NJ67I! M8:5687I4FR! W;! 65e5K:48a! :G5! a585:4K! :G5J6;! J_! KJ8K5H:F,!]G6JOaG!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR*!NO6PJKG!K78!7`J4P!:G5!H6JWI5R!J_!RJ67I!657FJ8F,! 9G5!855P!8J:!P564`5! _6JR! :G5!87:O65!J_! 7a58K;!J6! :G5!T4II!7!F58F4:4`4:;!:J!RJ67I!KJ8K568F,!]G5!65F:!J_!:G5!WJJU!P5_58PF!7!_J6R!J_!\I7:J84FR!7WJO:!KJ8K5H:F!:G7:!`48P4K7:5F!NJ67I!M8:5687I4FR*!78P!7!F5KJ8P!\I7:J84FR*!7WJO:!:G5!O84:;!J_!67:4J87I!8J6RF!78P!:G5!5c4F:58K5!J_! :G5!tJJP,! M! 58P! W;! :JOKG48a! J8! :TJ! _O6:G56! :G5R5F*! :G5! S6F:! J_!TG4KG!K78!W5!_67R5P!7F!78!JWe5K:4J8,

^4:G!:G5!5c7RHI5!J_!N!78P!Y*!NO6PJKG!FGJTF!GJT!JO6!a67FH!J_!R58:7I!KJ8K5H:F!K78!P55H58!78P!a6JT*!GJT!4:!K78!:678FK58P!TG7:!T7F!7HH7658:! 48! :G546! 7KhO4F4:4J8,!9G5!aJ5F!J8! :J!R7U5!7!RJ65! F:76:I48a!KI74R*! TG4KG! FG5! 65H57:F! RJ65! :G78! J8K5*! :G7:! i:G5! RJ`5R58:! J_!O8P56F:78P48a!4F!J8T76P!48:J!48K657F48a!H64`7K;j!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!0or,!


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!(-!!w "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

J8:JIJa4K7I!H6JJ_*!_J6!7!F5KOI76!48:56H65:7:4J8!J_!iIJ`5!;JO6!854aGWJO6!7F!;JO6F5I_j{!]J!KJRHI5:5!:G5!657P48a!J_!A'2-#-$=("B*!J85!TJOIP!G7`5!:J!TJ6U!:G6JOaG!:G5!65I7:4J8FG4H!J_!IJ`5!:J!:6O:G!78P!:J!:G5!tJJP,!b85!TJOIP!G7`5!:J!5cHI748!TG;!isfK:!IJ`48aI;Q!�T4II�!:678FI7:5!sfK:!H56_5K:I;Q*!TG5657F!sfK:!67:4J87II;Q!T4II!8J:j!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!--r,!f8P!J85!TJOIP!G7`5! :J! FhO765! :G4F! T4:G! :G5! _7K:! :G7:! IJ`5! 4F! iK7H7WI5! J_! 48S84:5!P5a67P7:4J8!78P!4F!:G5!FJO6K5!J_!JO6!a657:5F:!566J6Fj!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!(11r,!]GJOaG!M!K788J:!PJ!:G5F5!:G48aF*!M!7R!JH:4R4F:4K!:G7:!:G5;!K78!W5!PJ85*!:G7:!:G5!I485F!KJ8`56a5*!78P!:G7:!T4:G!65S85R58:!J6!P55H5848a*!T5!K78!KJR5!:J!O8P56F:78P!:G5!KJ8K5H:!love!7F!NO6PJKG!PJ5F,50

References

f8:J87KK4J*! N,! 0111,! K$."&#$(=4 "<-4 S&,/(T4 @<-4M'#/04 @<'&=<"4 'C4 U#$34M&#E'.<,!bc_J6Pl!bc_J6P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

E6J7KU5F*! Z,! 01(0,! M8:6JPOK:4J8,! M8! Z,! E6J7KU5F*! 5P,*! U#$34 M&#E'.<H4K<$0'3';<-#,!bc_J6Pl!bc_J6P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF*!01(0l!(w-0,

XI76U*!\,!011(,!z5II5R78QF!7O:J8JR4FR,!Ethics!(((l!Lo1wL-),X676;*! f,! 011n,! L-B'(E4 M'#/04 N&E=,-(",! X7RW64Pa5*! Nfl! [76`76P!

�84`56F4:;!\65FF,Y76T7II*!9,!(-o),!U,;/#"$/04O-/3'(,!M:G7K7*!y�l!XJ685II!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,Y47RJ8P*!X,!(--L,!@<-4O-/0$3"$.4A;$#$"T4V$""=-(3"-$(H4K<$0'3';<BH4/(E4"<-4

M$(E,!X7RW64Pa5*!Nfl!NM]!\65FF,Y65456*! Z,! (--n,! [OR578! PJOW:F! 7WJO:! :G5! H67K:4K7I! eOF:4SK7:4J8! J_!

RJ67I4:;,!M8!t,!XOII4:;!78P!E,!t7O:*!5PF,*!Ethics and Practical Reason,!bc_J6Pl!bc_J6P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF*!(--nl!o(w(11,

~JJ:*! \,! 0110,!W$#"&-34 /(E4W$.-34 /(E4X"<-#4 J33/B34 $(4M'#/04 K<$0'3';<Bm!F5KJ8P!5P4:4J8,!bc_J6Pl!bc_J6P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

t57KG*!\,!(-Ld,!tJJP!78P!5`4I,!!(/0B3$3!(nl!)0wp0,

L1,!~J6!P4FKOFF4J8!J_!:G5F5!:JH4KF*!M!7R!a67:5_OI!:J!ZJG8!NKYJT5II!78P!}`a5847!N;IJ87U4*!:J!H76:4K4H78:F!48!R;!FH648a!01(0!F5R4876!J8!IJ`5!78P!5:G4KF!7:!:G5!�84`56F4:;!J_!\4::FWO6aG*!78P!_J6!KJRR58:F!J8!F5K:4J8!(*!:J!ZOI47!N76UJ`4:F!78P!:J!78!7OP458K5!7:!:G5!\7K4SK!f\f,!9H5K47I!:G78UF!:J!:G5!78J8;RJOF!657PA56F! _J6!K<$0'3';<-#3Y4 U,;#$("*!TGJF5!P5:74I5P!78P!KJ8F:6OK:4`5! _55PW7KU!T7F!:G5!FJO6K5!J_!R78;!65`4F4J8F,

NO6PJKGQF!:G5J6;!J_!IJ`5!4F!484:47II;!HOxxI48a,!^G;!FGJOIP!7KKO67:5!H56K5H:4J8!J_!78J:G56*!5`58!T4:G!H56_5K:!a67FH!J_!:G5!KJ8K5H:F!7HHI45P*!aJ!7IJ8a!T4:G!IJ`5*!8J:!IJ7:G48a!J6!KJ8:5RH:{!9OHHJF5!Y!657II;!T565!:465FJR5!78P!eO`584I5*!J6*!4_!:GJF5!765!P5_5K:4`5!KJ8K5H:F*!KJ8F4P56!:G5!iKI576A5;5P!KJ8:5RHI7:4J8!J_!:G5!R4F56;!78P!5`4I!J_!:G5!TJ6IPj!qNO6PJKG!(-n1l!L-r,!NOF:!:G5!7a58:F!J_!5`4I!W5!JWe5K:F!J_!IJ`5{!NO6PJKGQF!:GJOaG:!4F!:G7:!:G5;!ROF:,!]G5!746!J_!H767PJc!48!:G4F!KI74R!K78!W5!P4FFJI`5P!48!H76:!W;! 65K7II48a! :G7:! :G5! IJ`5! 48!hO5F:4J8! 4F!8J:!F5I5K:4`5!�!4:! 4F!8J:!_J8P85FF!J6!7|5K:4J8!J6!:G5!P5F465!_J6!48:4R7K;!�!WO:!IJ`5!7F!7!RJ67I!5RJ:4J8,48!q]G5!5c7RHI5!J_!N!78P!Y!4F!R4FI57P48a!48!:G4F!65FH5K:,!M:!4F!78!7KK4P58:!:G7:!:G5!JWe5K:!J_!NQF!IJ`48a!a7x5!4F!G56!P7OaG:56A48AI7T*!8J:!7!RO6P5656!J6!78!7KhO748:78K5!7:!TJ6U,r!]G5!IJ`5!:G7:! 48:565F:F!NO6PJKG!4F!:G5!IJ`5!J85!FGJOIP!G7`5!_J6!J85QF!854aGWJO6!— :G7:!4F*!_J6!78;J85!T4:G!TGJR!J85!48:567K:F,49!M_!IJ`5!48!:G4F!F58F5!4F!H76:47I*!:G7:!4F!J8I;!W5K7OF5!T5!765!I4R4:5P,!i�J`5!4F!:G5!5c:65R5I;!P4gKOI:!657I4F7:4J8!:G7:!FJR5:G48a!J:G56!:G78!J85F5I_!4F!657Ij!qNO6PJKG!(-L-l!0(Lr,!948K5!5`56;J85!4F!657I*!T5!JOaG:!:J!IJ`5!:G5R!7II,!M:!PJ5F!8J:!_JIIJT!_6JR!:G4F!:G7:!T5!FGJOIP!_55I!7|5K:4J8!_J6!5`56;J85!J6!:G7:!T5!FGJOIP!HO6FO5!:G546!48:565F:F,!�J`5!48`JI`5F!i:6O5!`4F4J8j!78P!I57PF!OF!:J!7K:!:JT76PF!J:G56F!7F!T5!765!RJ67II;!65hO465P!:J!7K:,!M:!R4aG:!W5!JO:!J_!IJ`5!:G7:!T5!H65`58:!:G5R!_6JR!PJ48a!G76R*!J6!W567:5!:G5R*!J6!65_OF5!:J!7FFJK47:5!T4:G!:G5R,

]G5! hO5F:4J8! M! I57`5! O878FT565P! G565! 4F! TG5:G56! T5! K78! :657:!NO6PJKGQF!OF5!J_! iIJ`5j! 48! :G5!RJ67I! KJ8:5c:!7F!RJ65! :G78!hO4cJ:4K,!^G7:!PJ5F! IJ`5!7F! :6O5!`4F4J8!G7`5! :J!PJ!T4:G! IJ`5! 48!78;!J6P4876;!F58F5{!f65!:G565!R7:5647IF!48!:G5!\I7:J84K!:G5J6;!J_!KJ8K5H:F*!J6!48!:G5!

po,!XJRH765!z5II5R78*!TGJ!K4:5F!NO6PJKG!48!FOHHJ6:!J_!G4F!378:478!`45Tl!i65AFH5K:!78P!IJ`5!�765�!:G5!65hO465P!R484ROR!78P!JH:4J87I!R7c4ROR!65FHJ8FA5F!:J!J85!78P!:G5!F7R5!`7IO5j*!:G7:!J_!H56FJ8GJJP!J6!67:4J87I!T4II!qz5II5R78!(---l!)ddr,!~J6!z5II5R78*!IJ`5!P4F76RF!JO6!5RJ:4J87I!65FHJ8F5F!78P!48`JI`5F!i657II;!IJJU48aj!7:!:G5!H56FJ8!T5!IJ`5!qz5II5R78!(---l!)d(r,!Y5FH4:5!:G5!65FJA878K5*! :G4F! 48`JK7:4J8!J_!NO6PJKG!K788J:!W5! 64aG:,!]G5! IJ`5! :G7:! 48`JI`5F!i657II;!IJJU48aj*!_J6!NO6PJKG*!4F!8J:!JH:4J87I!WO:!65hO465P*!78P!P465K:5P!8J:!7:!JO6!67:4J87I!87:O65F!WO:!7:!JO6!RJ67II;!7RW4aOJOF!R58:7I!I4`5F,

p-,!b8!IJ`5!J_!J85QF!854aGWJO6*!F55!NO6PJKG!(-n1l!0(*!n0*!78P!48!KJ885K:4J8!T4:G!378:*!NO6PJKG!(-L-l!0(-w01,


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!01!!w "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

k7x*! Z,! 01((,! Z#',4 *'#,/"$2$"B4 "'4 O-3;'(3$%$0$"B,! bc_J6Pl! bc_J6P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

95:4;7*!3,!011n,!Reasons without Rationalism,!\648K5:J8*!yZl!\648K5:J8!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

95:4;7*!3,!01(1,!9;RH7:G;!_J6!:G5!P5`4I,!M8!9,!]5858W7OR*!5P,*!1-3$#-H4K#/."$./04 O-/3'(H4 /(E4 "<-4 D''E,! bc_J6Pl! bc_J6P! �84`56F4:;! \65FF*!01(1l!o0w((1,

95:4;7*! 3,! 01(0,! M8:5687I! 657FJ8F,! M8! 3,! 95:4;7! 78P![,! \77UUO874858*!5PF,*!U("-#(/04O-/3'(3T4+'("-,;'#/#B4O-/E$(=3,!X7RW64Pa5*!Nfl!NM]!\65FF*!01(0l!(w)p,

95:4;7*!3,!_J6:GKJR48a,!M8:58:4J8*!HI78F*!78P!5:G4K7I!67:4J87I4FR,!M8!N,!z76a7F!78P!t,!�7|5*!5PF,*!O/"$'(/04/(E4A'.$/04!=-(.BT4J33/B34'(4"<-4K<$0'3';<B4'C4M$.</-04L#/",/(,!bc_J6Pl!bc_J6P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

9R4:G*!N,!(--p,!@<-4M'#/04K#'%0-,,!bc_J6Pl!EI7KUT5II,9R4:G*!N,!011-,!]G5!5cHI787:J6;!6JI5!J_!W548a!67:4J87I,!M8!Y,!9JW5I!78P!

9,!^7II*!5PF,*!O-/3'(34C'#4!."$'(,!X7RW64Pa5l!X7RW64Pa5!�84`56F4:;!\65FF*!011-l!Lowo1,

9R4:G*!N,!01(1,!E5;J8P! :G5!566J6! :G5J6;,! M8!k,! ZJ;K5!78P!9,!346KG48*!5PF,*!!4V'#0E4V$"<'&"4 W/0&-3T4 J33/B34 '(4 N'<(4M/.F$-Y34 J##'#4 @<-'#B,!YJ6P65KG:*![JII78Pl!9H648a56!01(1l!((-w(p1,

9:O6a5J8*! y,! 011-,! YJOW:F! 7WJO:! :G5! FOH56`58458K5! J_! :G5! 5:G4K7I,!XGC'#E4A"&E$-34$(4M-"/-"<$.3!pl!L)–-1,

]7;IJ6*! X,! (-o-,! A'&#.-34 'C4 "<-4 A-0CT4 @<-4M/F$(=4 'C4 "<-4M'E-#(4 UE-("$"B,!X7RW64Pa5*!Nfl![76`76P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

]5858W7OR*!9,!011n,!!;;-/#/(.-34'C4"<-4D''ET4!(4J33/B4'(4"<-4*/"&#-4'C4Practical Reason,!X7RW64Pa5l!X7RW64Pa5!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

z5II5R78*! Z,!Y,! (-o-,! K#/."$./04 O-[-."$'(,! \648K5:J8*! yZl! \648K5:J8!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

z5II5R78*!Z,!Y,!(--0,!]G5!aO4F5!J_!:G5!aJJP,!Noûs!0dl!)w0d,z5II5R78*!Z,!Y,!(---,!�J`5!7F!7!RJ67I!5RJ:4J8,!Ethics!(1-l!))ow)np,z5II5R78*!Z,!Y,!0111,!@<-4K'33$%$0$"B4'C4K#/."$./04O-/3'(,!bc_J6Pl!bc_J6P!

�84`56F4:;!\65FF,zJaI56*! X,! 0110,! O-/3'(/%0B4 W$.$'&3,! X7RW64Pa5*! Nfl! [76`76P!

�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

t64g8,! Z,! (--d,!W/0&-4 N&E=-,-("T4 U,;#'2$(=4X&#4J"<$./04L-0$-C3,!bc_J6Pl!bc_J6P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

[7RHFG465*! 9,! (-L-,! @<'&=<"4 /(E4 !."$'(,! yJ:65! Y7R5*! Myl! M8P4787!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

378:*!M,!(noL,!D#'&(E:'#F4'C4"<-4M-"/;<B3$.34'C4M'#/03,!]678FI7:5P!W;!N,!t65aJ6,!X7RW64Pa5l!X7RW64Pa5!�84`56F4:;!\65FF*!(--o,

3J6Fa776P*!X,!(--d,!@<-4A'&#.-34'C4*'#,/"$2$"B,!X7RW64Pa5l!X7RW64Pa5!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

3J6Fa776P*! X,! 011-,! A-0C)+'(3"$"&"$'(T4 !=-(.BH4 UE-("$"BH4 /(E4 U("-=#$"B,!bc_J6Pl!bc_J6P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

NKYJT5II*!Z,!(-no,!f65!RJ67I!65hO465R58:F!G;HJ:G5:4K7I!4RH567:4`5F{!k5H648:5P! 48!M$(EH4 W/0&-H4 /(E4 O-/0$"B,! X7RW64Pa5*! Nfl! [76`76P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF*!(--ol!nnw-p,

NKYJT5II*! Z,! (-n-,!z46:O5! 78P! 657FJ8,!k5H648:5P! 48!M$(EH4W/0&-H4 /(E4O-/0$"B,!X7RW64Pa5*!Nfl![76`76P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF*!(--ol!L1wn),

NKYJT5II*!Z,!(--p,!M$(E4/(E4V'#0E,!X7RW64Pa5*!Nfl![76`76P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

NO6PJKG*! M,! (-Ld,! z4F4J8! 78P! KGJ4K5! 48! RJ67I4:;,! K#'.--E$(=34 'C4 "<-4!#$3"'"-0$/(4A'.$-"BH4A&;;0-,-("/#B4W'0&,-!)1l!)0wLo,

NO6PJKG*!M,!(-L-,!]G5!FOWI4R5!78P!:G5!aJJP,!k5H648:5P!48!JG$3"-("$/0$3"34/(E4MB3"$.3T4V#$"$(=34'(4K<$0'3';<B4/(E48$"-#/"&#-,!�J8PJ8l!XG7::J!�!^48POF*!(--nl!01Lw001,

NO6PJKG*!M,!(-n1,!@<-4A'2-#-$=("B4'C4D''E,!�J8PJ8l!kJO:I5Pa5,NO6PJKG*!M,!(--0,!M-"/;<B3$.34/34/4D&$E-4"'4M'#/03,!�J8PJ8l!XG7::J!�!

^48POF,y7a5I*! ],! (-n1,!@<-4K'33$%$0$"B4 'C4!0"#&$3,,!bc_J6Pl!bc_J6P!�84`56F4:;!

\65FF,\O:87R*![,! 0110,!@<-4+'00/;3-4 'C4 "<-4 Z/.">W/0&-41$.<'"',B4 /(E4X"<-#4

J33/B3,!X7RW64Pa5*!Nfl![76`76P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,k74I:J8*!\,!(--n,!b8!:G5!G;HJ:G5:4K7I!78P!8J8AG;HJ:G5:4K7I!48!657FJ848a!

7WJO:!W5I45_!78P!7K:4J8,!M8!t,!XOII4:;!78P!E,!t7O:*!5PF,*!Ethics and Practical Reason,!bc_J6Pl!bc_J6P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF*!(--nl!L)wo1,

k7x*!Z,!(---,!J(=/=$(=4O-/3'(T4X(4"<-4@<-'#B4'C4W/0&-4/(E4!."$'(,!bc_J6Pl!bc_J6P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,


v<?$#>#v<'D>Q!?&vD?+u! w!!0(!!w "#$,!()*!+#,!-!q&./!01()r

^7II7K5,! k,!Z,! (--1,! [JT! :J! 76aO5! 7WJO:! H67K:4K7I! 657FJ8,!M$(E! --l!)LL–)oL,

^5PaTJJP*! k,! 011n,! @<-4 */"&#-4 'C4 *'#,/"$2$"B,! bc_J6Pl! bc_J6P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

^4II47RF*!E,! (-n-,! M8:5687I! 78P!5c:5687I! 657FJ8F,!k5H648:5P! 48!M'#/048&.F,!X7RW64Pa5l!X7RW64Pa5!�84`56F4:;!\65FF*!(-o(l!(1(w((),

^4II47RF*!E,!(-oL,!J"<$.34/(E4"<-48$,$"34'C4K<$0'3';<B,!X7RW64Pa5*!Nfl![76`76P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

^4II47RFJ8*!],!011),!�8P56F:78P48a!78P! 48_5658K5,!K#'.--E$(=34'C4 "<-4!#$3"'"-0$/(4A'.$-"BH4A&;;0-,-("/#B4W'0&,-!nnl!0p-w0-),

^JI_*!9,!(--1,!Z#--E',4V$"<$(4O-/3'(,!bc_J6Pl!bc_J6P!�84`56F4:;!\65FF,

Documents

Murdoch on the Sovereignty of Good - Kieran Setiya · 2016-03-16 · Murdoch on the Sovereignty of Good