PeoplePlanetProfit

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/7/2019 PeoplePlanetProfit

    1/16

    JanStoner FinalPaper 7/29/2009

    1

    PEOPLE,PLANET,PROFIT

    Good.Smart.Business.Profit.Thosearethecriteriafornominationasoneofthe

    WorldsMostEthicalCompanies,awardedbytheEthisphereInstitute.(AboutEthisphere,

    2009)In1970,MiltonFriedmanwrotehisessay,TheSocialResponsibilityofBusinessisto

    IncreaseitsProfits.(FriedmanM.,1970)JuxtaposedwithFriedmanisTheStakeholder

    TheoryoftheModernOrganization,writtenbyR.EdwardFreeman,whicharguesthat

    companiescanbegood,smart,businessoriented,andprofitable,whileatthesametimebeing

    goodcorporatecitizens,reducinginequality,andengagingtheirstakeholders.(Freeman,2002)

    Ourstudiesinthisclasshavemadeclearthateconomicstratificationshaveincreasedmarkedly

    inthepastthreedecades.CouldFriedmansprofitspecificviewbecontributingtoinequality?

    Isittimetorethinkthesocialresponsibilityofbusiness?Thispaperwillexplorebothspectrums

    oftheargumentandhighlightwaysthatmanyorganizationsandcorporationsareworking

    withintheirmissiontogrowthetriplebottomlineofpeople,planet,andprofit.(Price,2007)

    Whyallthisclamoroverthesocialresponsibilityofbusiness,otherwiseknownas

    corporateethicsorcorporatesocialresponsibilityCSR,forshort?AsRobertReichhastoldus

    inhisbookSupercapitalism,theriseofcapitalismanditsescalationintosupercapitalismhas

    widenedthegapinequality.(Reich,2007)Twentyyearsago,thetotalpayoftheaverage

    executivewas40timestheaverageworker;nowitis110timestheaverage.(Leaders:Rich

    man,poorman;Globalisationandtheriseofinequality,2007)Eightypercentoftheworlds

    grossdomesticproductbelongstothe1billionpeoplelivinginthedevelopedworld;the

    remainingtwentypercentissharedbythe5billionpeoplelivingindevelopingcountries.

  • 8/7/2019 PeoplePlanetProfit

    2/16

    JanStoner FinalPaper 7/29/2009

    2

    (ReportontheWorldSocialSituation,2005)In2001,11to13percentofAmericanswereliving

    onlessthanwhatgovernmentexpertsestimatetheyneedtobuybasicnecessities.These

    peoplecouldnotescapepoverty,despitelivingwithafulltimeworkerworking50weeksa

    year.(Kerbo,2006)

    Whatdoesthathavetodowithcorporations,youmayask?Again,IrefertoReich,who

    tellsusthatsupercapitalismhasspilledoverintodemocracy.Themergersandtakeoversof

    corporationsinthelate1990sandearly21stCenturyhavecreatedmegacorporationswhich

    arestronglyinfluencingourcultureanddemocracy.Theoligopoliesofthe20thCenturybig

    business,biglabor,regulatoryagencies,andlegislatureswhichusedtohelpspreadthe

    wealth;balanceworker,corporate,andcommunityrights,haveeroded.Corporatecampaign

    contributionstopoliticalcandidatesandthestampedeofWashingtonlobbyistsaredrowning

    outthevoicesofcitizenry,ineffortstoinfluencepublicpolicyinfavorofcorporations.Reich

    alsotellsusthatpowerhasshiftedtoconsumersandinvestorsandthatdemocraticcapitalism

    hasbeenreplacedbysupercapitalism.Additionally,asourcountryisinthemidstofthis

    economiccrisis,atitsheart,onalmostadailybasis,weseeexamplesofirresponsibleand

    unethicalcorporateleadership.

    Whyshouldwecareaboutthepowershifttoconsumersandinvestors,corporate

    ethics,andtheerodingofdemocraticcapitalismtotheproliferationofcorporateglobalization?

    Weshouldcareforseveralreasons.AsJohnF.Kennedysaidinhisinauguraladdressin1961,

    Ifafreesocietycannothelpthemanywhoarepoor,itcannotsavethefewwhoarerich.On

    ahumanitarianlevel,weshouldcarethatmillionsofpeoplearestarvinganddyinghungry

  • 8/7/2019 PeoplePlanetProfit

    3/16

    JanStoner FinalPaper 7/29/2009

    3

    everyday.Onamoreselfishlevel,weshouldbeconcernedaboutthegapbetweenwealthand

    povertybecause,astheworldbecomesmoreinterconnected,thewellbeingoftheworldsrich

    willbecomeincreasinglythreatened.(Kerbo,2006)Thevastmajorityofpoliticalviolenceand

    terrorismisbredinextremepovertyandsocialdisruption.Thishasbeenborneoutinrecent

    yearsintheMiddleEast.InAfghanistan,followingthedemiseoftheSovietUnionin1991,

    muchofthecountrywasdestroyed.Peoplewereverypoor,andtherewasanarchy.Islamic

    fundamentalistsfromoutsidethecountryinfiltrated;andtheultraconservativeTalibanwon

    controlofAfghanistan,whosepeopleweretiredoflivinginconflictandcorruption.InIraq,

    whentheIraqiarmywasdisbandedinthecurrentwar,andallofitssoldierslosttheirjobs,

    addingtothecountrysunemployment,againIslamicfundamentalismmadeinroadsin

    mainstreamIraqbecauseofitspromisestohelpimproveconditionsresultingfromthewarwith

    theAmericans.(Ferguson,2007)

    Safetyisnottheonlyconcern.Worldpovertyalsocontributestoloweringofwagesand

    standardsoflivingforthebottom50percentofAmericans.Themorepeoplegloballythatare

    willingtoworkinsubstandardsweatshops,thelessmultinationalcorporationshavetopay

    higherwagestoAmericansathome.Intermsofhealth,theWorldHealthOrganizationhas

    indicatedthatpeoplewhoareweakenedduetopovertyaremoresusceptibletodeadly

    infectiousdiseasesthatcouldalsospreadtowealthiernations.HIV/AIDS,acuterespiratory

    syndrome,andavianinfluenzaaresuchexamples.(Kerbo,2006)

    Inhisarticle,FromHegemonytoDemocracy,BostonCollegeProfessorofSociology

    CharlesDerberisalsoonparwiththeassessmentsofReichandKerbo.(Derber,Summer2007)

  • 8/7/2019 PeoplePlanetProfit

    4/16

    JanStoner FinalPaper 7/29/2009

    4

    Derberwritesaboutthreesuicidalprinciplesdeeplyembeddedincorporateglobalization.The

    firstandmostcomprehensiveishegemony,inthiscasetheobjectiveofdominationbyglobal

    corporationsandthesuperpowerswhichsupportthem,particularlytheUSgovernment.He

    pointstothe9/11attacksasevidenceofhowtechnologyhasmadeitpossibleforsmallnations,

    networks,orevenindividualswithsocioeconomicandpoliticalresentmentstodestroywhole

    citiesorcountries,inreactiontothisdomination.

    Derberssecondglobalsuicidalprincipleistheeconomicpolarization,thewideningof

    thegapbetweenrichandpoorinthemidstofvastglobalwealth.Hesaysthisissocially

    unsustainablebecauseitwillencourageclassbasedviolence,oftenunderthecloakofreligion.

    Finally,Derberaddressesenvironmentalsustainabilityand,inparticular,globalwarming.He

    tellsusthatmostclimatologistsbelievethatglobalwarmingwillthreatenthesurvivalof

    civilizedlifeandnatureinlessthanacentury.

    Ifwebelievetheclaimsabouttheinfluenceofthecorporationonworldpoverty,the

    environment,workingconditions,health,andsafety,wecanseethatthecorporationcanalso

    haveanimpactonsolutionstotheseproblems.Thusenterstheideaofcorporatesocial

    responsibility.Andlikeallcomplexissues,thesolutionsmaybealsocomplex.Ontheone

    hand,wehavetheviewoftheesteemedeconomist,MiltonFriedman,whoin1970wrotehis

    famousNewYorkTimesarticle,TheSocialResponsibilityofBusinessistoIncreaseitsProfits.

    Friedmanwrotethatbusinessmenwhopromotedesirablesocialends,takeserious

    responsibilityforprovidingemployment,eliminatingdiscrimination,avoidingpollution,or

    whateverothersocialconsciencedictates,wouldbepreachingpureandunadulterated

  • 8/7/2019 PeoplePlanetProfit

    5/16

    JanStoner FinalPaper 7/29/2009

    5

    socialism,notfreeenterprise.Friedmanelaboratesthatacompanysresponsibilityistoits

    shareholders;thatifmanagersthinksomethingbeyondmaximizingshareholdervalue,theyare

    operatinginviolationtotheirresponsibilities.

    IncontrasttoFriedman,wehaveTheStakeholderTheoryoftheModernCorporation,

    writtenbyR.EdwardFreeman,in1984.Freemanarguesagainsttheprimacyofthe

    shareholderandreplacesthisconceptwiththatofthefiduciaryrelationshiptostakeholders.

    Hedefinesstakeholdersassuppliers,customers,employees,stockholders,localcommunities,

    andmanagement.Thesearegroupswhoeitherbenefitfromorareharmedbycorporate

    activities.Freemantellsusthateachofthesestakeholdersisnotameanstoanendandmust

    participateinthefuturedirectionofthefirminwhichtheyhaveastake.Thequestionheasks

    isForwhosebenefitandatwhoseexpenseshouldthefirmbemanaged?Additionally,

    accordingtoFreeman,externalities,moralhazards,andmonopolypowerexist,whichpreclude

    managementsabilitytoactsolelyintheinterestsofitsstockholders.Externalitiescanbe

    regulations,suchastheEnvironmentalProtectionAct,TheEqualPayAct,andtheCivilRights

    Act.ExpandingonFreemanfromtodaysperspective,someaspectsofthesubprimemortgage

    debaclescreamofexamplesofmoralhazards.

    Aswecansee,thereiscompellingevidencebothdomesticallyandgloballyforthe

    rationaleandneedforcorporatesocialresponsibility.Whilewehavealongwaytogo,since

    thelate1980sandearly90s,amovementtowardsfundamentalchangehasbeenunderway.

    NotonlydowehavewriterssuchasFreemanraisingsocialconsciousnessonthematter,but

    alsowehavesuchhistoricallysignificanteventsasthefalloftheBerlinWallin1989.According

  • 8/7/2019 PeoplePlanetProfit

    6/16

    JanStoner FinalPaper 7/29/2009

    6

    toanotherFriedman,ThomasL.,inhisbook,TheWorldisFlat,thefalloftheBerlinWallwasa

    globaltippingpointtowarddemocratic,consensual,freemarketgovernance,andawayfrom

    communism.Friedmanwrote,Henceforth,moreandmoreeconomieswouldbegoverned

    fromthegroundup,bytheinterests,demands,andaspirationsofthepeople,ratherthanfrom

    thetopdown,bytheinterestsofsomenarrowrulingclique.(FriedmanT.L.,TheWorldisFlat,

    Release3.0,2007)

    Bythemid1990s,agrowingnumberofcorporationsbegantoseecorporatesocial

    responsibilityasbeneficialtothebottomline.In1992,theorganizationBusinessforSocial

    ResponsibilitywasfoundedbytheCEOsof50sociallyorientedcompanies.Theirmission:to

    supportgoodcorporatecitizenship.In1994,thephrasetriplebottomlinewascoinedbythe

    BritishconsultingfirmSustainAbility.Theircontention:corporationslongtermsuccess

    requiresattentiontosocietyandenvironment,aswellasshareholders.(Price,2007)

    InOctober2005,ReasonMagazinerevisitedMortonFriedmans1970contentionsand

    sponsoredadebatebetweenFriedman;JohnMackey,CEOofWholeFoodsMarket,Inc.;andT.

    J.RodgersofCypressSemiconductor.(RethinkingtheSocialResponsibilityofBusiness,2005)

    FriedmanstatedthathethoughtthedifferencesbetweenhimandMackeywereforthemost

    partrhetorical,yetMackeythoughtotherwise.Whilehehighlyregardstheaccomplished

    Friedman,herespectfullydifferedandcontinuedhiscallforanewbrandofcapitalism,onethat

    consciouslyworksforthecommongoodinsteadofdependingontheinvisiblehandto

    generatepositiveresultsforsociety.Mackeygoessofarastosaythatextendingourloveand

  • 8/7/2019 PeoplePlanetProfit

    7/16

    JanStoner FinalPaper 7/29/2009

    7

    carebeyondournarrowselfinterestisantitheticaltoneitherhumannaturenorfinancial

    success.

    Ofcourse,thecriticismsofcorporatesocialresponsibilitystillexist.IntheReason

    debate,T.J.Rodgers,referredtoasthespokesmanforthetoughloveschoolofLaissezfaireand

    dubbedasoneofAmericastoughestbossesbyFortune,arguedthatcorporationsaddfar

    moretosocietybymaximizinglongtermshareholdervaluethantheydobydonatingtime

    andmoneytocharity.FurthercriticismswerethatMackeyisrunningahybrid

    business/charityandthatMackeysphilosophyismoreattunedtoKarlMarxthanfreemarket

    capitalism.

    Yetastheyearsgoon,eveninthisverydifficulteconomy,wecontinuetoseesignsof

    continuedeffortstowardcorporatesocialresponsibility.TheDomini400SocialIndexwas

    launchedin1990asacommonstockbenchmarkindexfundconstructedusingenvironmental,

    social,andgovernancefactors.Thefundisconsideredastandardformeasuringtheimpactof

    socialandenvironmentalexcellence.Theindexiscomprisedof250S&Pcompanies,100

    additionallargeandmidcapcompanies,and50smallercompanieswithexcellentsocialand

    environmentalrecords,suchasemployeeandhumanrelations,productsafety,environmental

    safety,andcorporategovernance.Businessesengagedinalcohol,tobacco,firearms,gambling,

    nuclearpower,andmilitaryweaponsneednotapplyforinclusion.Thefundwasdesignedfor

    sociallyconsciousinvestorstoweighsocialandenvironmentalfactorsintheirinvestorchoices.

    (Domini400SocialIndex,2009)ComparedtotheS&P500,theDominihasshownannualized

  • 8/7/2019 PeoplePlanetProfit

    8/16

    JanStoner FinalPaper 7/29/2009

    8

    returnsof8.43,comparedto7.78,respectively,sinceitsinception5/1/90.Thisisevidence

    thatfocusingonpeopleandtheplanetcanindeedyieldprofit.

    Thetopicsofcorporatesocialresponsibilityandbusinessethicshavealsobecome

    subjectsofdiscussionintherealmofhighereducation.Aspartofitscentennialin2008,

    HarvardBusinessSchoolheldanunprecedentedcolloquiumofworldwidebusinessschool

    deans,corporaterecruiters,andexecutives.Theirdiscussionssurroundedthefutureofthe

    MBA,followingcontinuedinstancesofcorporatescandals.HBSprofessorRakeshKhurana

    argued,Manybusinessschoolshavebeencomplicitincreatingrecentcorporatescandalsby

    turningoutgraduatesfixatedonshareholdervalueattheexpenseofallotherstakeholdersin

    society.SomeofthekeyideasarethatMBAprogramsputtoomuchweightontheoryandnot

    enoughonleadershipinourglobalenvironmentanddevelopmentofsoftskillsandcultural

    awarenessforstudents.ManyoftodaysMBAprogramsbeganduringthelate1950s,atatime

    ofverticalcorporatebureaucraciesmostlyintheUS.Today,withbusinessschoolschurningout

    500,000MBAsayear150,000intheUSaloneandorganizationsbecomingflatter,theneed

    isforleaderswhocanseeopportunitiesacrossfunctionalandculturalboundaries.

    InadditiontotheHarvardBusinessSchoolstudy,anotherwayuniversitiesarepreparing

    studentsforglobalizationandsolvingsocietysproblemsistheconferringofdegreesinthe

    relativelynewsubjectareaofpublicpolicy.Publicpolicycurriculumcoverscrossdisciplinary

    subjectssuchaseconomics,socialsciences,andpoliticalscience,givinggraduatesamuch

    broadereducation.AtourownUniversityofChicago,studentscanspecializeinurbanstudies;

    humanrights;economics;education;sociologyworkandfamily;politics;ororganizations.

  • 8/7/2019 PeoplePlanetProfit

    9/16

    JanStoner FinalPaper 7/29/2009

    9

    Educatedinthesedisciplines,onecanonlyhopethatfuturegenerationsofbusinesspeoplewill

    actdifferentlythanthebusinesseshighlightedintheNovember8,2008,60Minutesexpos

    entitled,FollowingtheTrailofToxicEWaste.

    ThenewsshowtookustoGuiyu,China,toarecyclingdumpoftoxicewaste.Muchof

    thepoisoncomesfromhomes,schools,andofficesoftheUnitedStates,intheformofourold

    TVs,phones,andcomputers.Thewasteisbrokendownforthepreciousmetalsinside.

    Peasantworkers,withoutproperequipment,handlelead,cadmium,mercury,chromium,and

    polyvinylchlorides,allofwhichareknowntoxins.Whydotheseworkersworkinthese

    conditions?Whenasked,oneworkersaid,Becausethemoneysgood.Jim,Puckett,founder

    oftheBaselActionNetwork,awatchdoggroupforstoppingrichcountriesfromdumpingtoxic

    wasteonpoorcountries,remindsus,Desperatepeoplewilldodesperatethings.Butwe

    shouldneverputtheminthatsituation.Youknow,itsahellofachoicebetweenpovertyand

    poison.Weshouldnevermakepeoplemakethatchoice.(FollowingtheTrailofToxicEWaste

    [60Minutes],2008)

    Finally,wehavepeoplelikeNobellaureateMuhammadYunus,whourgesleadersto

    rethinksystemsthatkeeppeoplepoor.Yunus,aBangladeshieconomistknownasthebanker

    forthepoor,wonthe2006NobelPeacePrizeforhissystemofmicrocredit.ThroughGrameen

    Bank,whichhefounded,hehelpsthepoorlivebetterlivesbymakingtinyloans.Povertyis

    createdbythedecisionsthatwehavemadearoundtheworld,bytheframework,thetheory,

    andbusinessdefinitionswehavecomeupwith,saysYunus.(Mellgren,2007)

  • 8/7/2019 PeoplePlanetProfit

    10/16

    JanStoner FinalPaper 7/29/2009

    1

    Whilewehaveseensomehopefulsignstomovetowardssociallyresponsiblebusiness

    operations,wealsocontinuetoseethecausesandeffectsofcorporateirresponsibilityand

    inequality.Howcanwechangethesystem?AccordingtoBjornAndersen,inhisarticle,A

    FrameworkforBusinessEthics,aholisticframeworkisneededtodepictitasamanageable

    processandtoencouragemoreorganizationstoswitchtoabusinessethicsmodel.Anderson

    outlinesafourstepprocesswhichcanbefollowedtoconstructanethicalbusinessapproach.

    Thestepsareaprogressionoflegal,ethical,economic,andphilanthropicdimensions.

    (Andersen,2008)

    Atthemostbasiclevel,theorganizationmustcleanupanylegalissues.Afrequent

    exampleinourclassofcorporateirresponsibilityhasbeenWalMartStores,Inc.;andWalMart

    oflateseemstobeaddressingitslegalconcerns.OnthelistofHumanRightsWatch,

    http://www.hrw.org,forseveralyears,WalMarthasalsobeentherespondentinmanyclass

    actionlawsuitsfiledagainstitforsexdiscrimination,aggressiveantiunionorganizingtactics,

    andviolatingworkersrights.InDecember2008,WalMartsettledtwoclassactionlawsuits,

    oneinMinnesotafor$54.25million,andanotherfor$352millionforcasesfiledacrossthe

    country.OvertwomillioncurrentandformerWalMartemployeesaretheplaintiffs.Thisalso

    markstheendoftheembarrassingeraofoutgoingCEOH.LeeScott,Jr.,whowassucceededby

    MichaelT.DukeinFebruary.(Greenhouse,2008)

    Followingcompliancewithlawsandgovernmentregulations,thenextstepin

    Andersonsframeworkiscleaningupethicalissues.Thisisachievedbyfollowingstandardsof

    acceptablebehaviorasjudgedbystakeholders.AccordingtoAnderson,onlyafterthecleanup

  • 8/7/2019 PeoplePlanetProfit

    11/16

    JanStoner FinalPaper 7/29/2009

    1

    cantheorganizationbeseenasagoodcorporatecitizenthathasthewellbeingofits

    stakeholdersinmind.Finally,aftermaximizingstakeholderwealthand/orvalue,the

    corporationcantakethesteptowardsbeingaphilanthropicorganization.Whetherthe

    remedialactionsofourWalMartexamplewillreachthehighestlevelandcontribute,as

    Andersenwrites,beyondthedamageithasinflictedremainstobeseen.

    Insummary,thetitleofthispaperisPeople,Planet,Profit.Thatisthetriplebottom

    linethatproponentsofcorporatesocialresponsibilityseektomeasureintodayscorporation.

    ItiswhatWilliamGreiderdescribesasthemoraleconomy,inhisessayinInequalityMatters.

    (Greider,2005)Capitalismisahumanconstruct.Itwasnotinscribedontabletshandeddown

    byAdamSmithorGod;itwasmadebypeopleandsoitcanbealteredbypeople,Greider

    writes.

    CSRistheattempttoaltertheconstructofcapitalism.Itistheattempttobalance

    AdamSmithsothergreatwork,TheTheoryofMoralSentiments,(Smith,1790)withtheoneso

    oftenquotedbyeconomistslikeMiltonFriedman,TheWealthofNations.InTheTheoryof

    MoralSentiments,Smithtellsusthathumannatureisnotjustaboutselfinterest;itincludes

    sympathy,empathy,friendship,love,andthedesireforsocialapproval.Itisthesignof

    maturitythatonegrowsbeyondchildhoodegocentrismandbeginstocareaboutothers.

    (RethinkingtheSocialResponsibilityofBusiness,2005)

    Willcorporatesocialresponsibilityreduceinequality?Inourcurrenteconomic

    meltdown,thesearetryingtimes;thejuryisstillout.Afewthingsarecertain,however.The

    NorthernTrustBanklaidoff450peopleinDecember2008,itsCEOFrederickWaddellsaying,

  • 8/7/2019 PeoplePlanetProfit

    12/16

    JanStoner FinalPaper 7/29/2009

    1

    Themacroeconomicenvironmenthasbeenextraordinarilydifficultandhasimpactedall

    segmentsoftheglobaleconomy.Thenextmonth,thispastJanuary,Northernstoppeople

    lavishedatexclusivehotels,agolfouting,andbignameconcerts."ThekeypointisNorthern

    Trustisabusinessthatearnedanoperatingnetincomeof$641millionlastyear,"saidsenior

    vicepresidentDouglasHolt."Wepaidfortheseeventsourselves.Theywerepaidforaspartof

    abusinessdecisionregardinganannualeventtoshowappreciationforclients.NorthernTrust

    isnotabankthatwasorislosingmoneyandthereforehadtogotothegovernmentfor

    assistance."Thisflipflopinactionspointstocorporateirresponsibility,noteconomicequality.

    Thesubprimemortgagedebaclenomoneydownloansgrantedwithoutproofof

    creditworthiness,securitizationofloanstoinvestors,creditdefaultswapstohedgethe

    investmentsallpointtotheneedforamoralitycheck.Intheglobaleconomy,notonlyisthe

    USsuffering,butalsotherestoftheplanet,forthisirresponsibility.Currently,intheUnited

    Statesalone,12.5millionpeoplehavelosttheirjobs.Whenyouaddtothattheinvoluntary

    parttimeworkersanddiscouragedworkerswhohavegivenupfindingajob,thetotal

    unemploymentrateis14.8percent,oroneinsevenAmericans.(Aversa,2009)Recentnews

    reportsfromJapanandevenChinaindicaterisingunemploymentaswell.

    ThetownofGuiyu,China,anditspeoplearedrinkingcontaminatedwater,livingand

    workingintoxicewaste;thesignalspointtocorporateirresponsibility,noteconomicequality.

    Theworldsbiggestretailer,WalMart,paysitsemployeeswagessolowandprovideslimited

    healthinsurance,sothatmanyofitsemployeesneedtorelyonMedicaidandothersocial

    services,whilethecompanyanditsownersenjoybigprofits.Again,thesignalspointto

    corporateirresponsibility,noteconomicequality.Whencapitalismgrowstosupercapitalism,

  • 8/7/2019 PeoplePlanetProfit

    13/16

    JanStoner FinalPaper 7/29/2009

    1

    withoutanychecksandbalances,asReichtellsus,thesignalspointtocorporate

    irresponsibility,notequality.Whilethecompleteeffectsofcorporatesocialresponsibilityare

    notyetknown,Ithinkitisfairtosaythatthelackofcorporatesocialresponsibilitycertainly

    doesnotreduceinequalityeither.

    EventhebastionoftheMBA,HarvardBusinessSchool,feelsthepainandtheshame.

    BankofAmericasCEOKenLewisinthespotlightrecentlyforthegrantingof$3.6billionto

    topperformersatsubsidiaryMerrill,Lynch,whichlost$28billionin2008,andflyinghis

    expensivecorporatejettoNewYorkCitywhiletakingfederalbailoutmoneyisagraduateof

    theprogram.

    Themoderncorporation,asFreemancalledit,impactsmanymorepeoplethanAdam

    Smithcouldhaveeverimaginedin1790,whenhewrotehisfamousinvisiblehandessay.As

    weregularlysee,wecannolongerrelyontheinvisiblehandormoraljudgmentofafew.

    SomeonesdecisioninaskyscraperintheUSaffectsgenerationsinasmalltowninChina.We

    areinterconnectedasneverbefore;andweneedamoreproactiveapproach,capitalismwith

    someregulation.Wealsoneedindividualstoactethically.Theinvisiblehandisbecoming

    imperceptible.Disastrousthingshappenfartoorapidlytoday;reactionaryfixesmaycometoo

    late.Itistimetochangetheconstruct;itistimetogiveattentiontoAdamSmithslessquoted

    writing.Itistimetolookatnotonlyhowacompanyspendsitsprofitsbuthowitmakesits

    money.

    Inmyopinion,corporatesocialresponsibilityisalsoaresultofsupercapitalism.Both

    ReichandThomasL.Friedmantellusthatpowerhasshiftedfromtherulingelitetoconsumers

  • 8/7/2019 PeoplePlanetProfit

    14/16

    JanStoner FinalPaper 7/29/2009

    1

    andinvestors.Freidmanspeaksofthreeglobalizationdemocratizationsinhisbook,TheLexus

    andtheOliveTree.Theyare:thedemocratizationoftechnology,thedemocratizationof

    finance,andthedemocratizationofinformation.(FriedmanT.L.,TheLexusandtheOliveTree,

    2000)Inthedemocratizationofinformation,nobodycanhide.Countriescannolongerkeep

    peopleinthedark,andneithercancorporations.Wearebombardedbyexamplesofcorporate

    irresponsibilityandmoralitygoneamuck.CSRisthemomentumbythoseconsumersand

    investorsadvocatingasustainableapproachtobusinessoperations.Itisthedemandsof

    consumersandinvestorsandotherpeopleimpactedbycorporateactionstolooksidebyside

    atsocial,environmental,andfinancialperformanceofbusinesses.(WhatisCorporateSocial

    Responsibility(CSR)?,2009)Itisthedemandstoendthegreedanddestructioninourglobal

    economy.Itisnotonlytimetorethinkthesocialresponsibilityofbusiness;itistimetoact.

  • 8/7/2019 PeoplePlanetProfit

    15/16

    JanStoner FinalPaper 7/29/2009

    1

    Bibliography

    AboutEthisphere.(2009,March).RetrievedFebruary20,2009,fromEthisphere:

    http://ethisphere.com/about/

    Andersen,B.(2008,March).AFrameworkforBusinessEthics. QualityProgress,41(3).

    Aversa,J.(2009,March6). JoblessRateBoltsto8.1Percent.RetrievedMarch7,2009,fromThe

    AssociatedPress:

    http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5jsanM66tszKz1zFq0LOG4XvWS7zAD96OO4U01

    Derber,C.(Summer2007).FromHegemonytoDemocracy. JournalofCorporateCitizenship,2829.

    Domini400SocialIndex.(2009).RetrievedFebruary20,2009,fromInvestopedia:

    http://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/domini_400.asp

    Ferguson,C.(Director).(2007).NoEndinSight[MotionPicture].

    Pelley,S.(Performer).(2008).FollowingtheTrailofToxicEWaste[60Minutes].NewYork,NY,USA.

    Freeman,R.E.(2002).StakeholderTheoryoftheModernCorporation.InP.H.ThomasDonaldson,

    EthicalIssuesinBusiness(pp.3848).UpperSaddleRiver,NJ:PearsonEducation.

    Friedman,M.(1970,September13).TheSocialResponsibilityofBusinessistoIncreaseitsProfits. New

    YorkTimesMagazine.

    Friedman,T.L.(2000).TheLexusandtheOliveTree.NewYork:AnchorBooks,adivisionofRandom

    House,Inc.

    Friedman,T.L.(2007).TheWorldisFlat,Release3.0.NewYork:Picador/Farrar,StrausandGiroux.

    Greenhouse,S.a.(2008,December24).WalMarttoSettleSuitsOverPayfor$352Million. TheNew

    YorkTimes,Business/FinancialDesk(LateEdition(EastCoast)).NewYork,NY,USA.

    Greider,W.(2005).BuildingaMoralEconomy.InJ.L.Smith, InequalityMatters (pp.247257).NewYork:

    TheNewPress.

    Kerbo,H.R.(2006).WorldPoverty.NewYork,NY:McGrawHill.

    Leaders:Richman,poorman;Globalisationandtheriseofinequality.(2007).TheEconomist,12.

    Mellgren,D.(2007,March30).YunusUrgesLeaderstoRethinkSystemsThatKeepPeoplePoor. The

    AssociatedPress,p.450words.

    Price,T.(2007).CorporateSocialResponsibility.CQResearcher.

  • 8/7/2019 PeoplePlanetProfit

    16/16

    JanStoner FinalPaper 7/29/2009

    1

    Reich,R.B.(2007).Supercapitalism.NewYork:VintageBooks,adivisionofRandomHouse.

    (2005).ReportontheWorldSocialSituation. NewYork:UnitedNations.

    RethinkingtheSocialResponsibilityofBusiness.(2005,October).RetrievedFebruary6,2009,from

    Reason.com:http://www.reason.com/news/show/32239.html

    Smith,A.(1790).TheTheoryofMoralSentiments .RetrievedMarch6,2009,fromLibraryofEconomics

    andLiberty:http://www.econlib.org/library/Smith/smMS.html

    WhatisCorporateSocialResponsibility(CSR)? (2009,March6).RetrievedMarch6,2009,from

    CSRwire.com:http://www.csrwire.com/pdf/WhatIsCSR.pdf