Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
POLITECNICO DI MILANO
Master in
Building Information Modelling
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design
Process? The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Supervisor: Author:
Prof. Zanelli Alessandra Georgios Triantafyllidis
Dr. Viscuso Salvatore
Arch. Edwards Kristian
a.a. 2019/2020
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ ii
AUTHORSHIP RIGHTS AND CONDITIONS OF USE OF THE
WORK BY THIRD PARTIES
This is an academic work that can be used by third parties, as long as internationally accepted rules and
good practices are respected, particularly in what concerts to author rights and related matters.
Therefore, the present work may be used according to the terms of the license shown below.
If the user needs permission to make use if this work in conditions that are not part of the licensing
mentioned below, he/she should contact the author through the BIM A+ Secretariat of Politecnico di
Milano.
License granted to the users of this work
Attribution
CC BY
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This research was done with the collaboration of Politecnico di Milano and the Architecture-Design
Studio Snøhetta, Oslo. I would like to thank my supervisors from the side of the Politecnico di Milano
Professor Zanelli Alessandra, PhD Viscuso Salvatore for their great support and all the useful material
that they provided me.
From the side of Snøhetta, I would like to thank Arch. Anne Cecilia Haug for accepting my application
and gave me the opportunity to work together with them. In addition, I would like to thank the Arch.
Kristian Edwards for providing me the case study taken into examination in this project, for providing
me his great insights towards the current development and concepts related to sustainable design and
more precisely the implications of the carbon accounting in the early design stages.
In addition, I would like to thank the Concortium of the Master program for the scholarship that they
offered me.
Last but not least, I would like to thank all the curious and engaged people that are producing and sharing
all their knowledge in youtube tutorials, dynamo scripts and other online open source platforms.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ iv
STATEMENT OF INTEGRITY
I hereby declare having conducted this academic work with integrity. I confirm that I have not used
plagiarism or any form of undue use of information or falsification of results along the process leading
to its elaboration.
I further declare that I have fully acknowledged the Code of ethics and conduct of Politecnico di Milano.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ v
SOMMARIO
Abstract page (University national language – ask the help of your supervisor and do not forget to
include the translated title. The abstract and keywords below must fit into a single page).
Parole chiave: (5 keywords in Italian, separated by commas and in alphabetical order)
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ vi
ABSTRACT
In the age of the Anthropocene, architecture has to face critical challenges that are affecting the quality
of life and the existence of life in a globalised form. The built environment cannot be seen as a sum of
single elements, but rather as a system which on the one hand interacts with its inhabitants and serves
them and on the other affects their behaviour. Accordingly, the job of the architect is shifting from mere
form-giving to creating systems that support human interactions. The design of those systems requires
well-coordinated actions and an explicit communication of goals and methods between teams, so that
the artefacts are coherent.
BIM can provide the common ground upon which the design team can interact and collaborate in order
to create the conditions under which the participants can design. That is, to create environments in which
conversations can emerge. In other words, it helps to generate the situations in which others can create.
It is a methodology, that recognises circular causality as a quality and thus creates a system, in which
the goals are negotiated in an open-ended and integrated process. Circular causality requires readiness
not only to affect the others, but also to be affected by them.
Additionally, the digital tools in the disposal of the architect enable feedback-based human-computer
interactions. Digital simulation tools allow the designers to reflect in action while testing their intentions.
By receiving the data from the simulations, they become conscious of the impact of their design choices
and are able to adjust their decision making.
This study proposes a further investigation in the way in which digital tools inform design. To this aim,
I will focus on the use and development of a dynamic Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) in BIM
environment by linking the materials of the model with LCA databases. Dynamic LCA can be applied
both for new constructions as well as for building rehabilitation. Traditional LCA methods do not
consider factors that vary during the building life cycle or are executed only at the end of each phase. A
dynamic LCA will allow the design teams to be aware in real time of the environmental impact on their
choices of materials during the design phase and allow them to investigate and evaluate multiple
alternatives.
Keywords: design process, decision making, digital tools, dynamic LCA, Building Information
Modelling
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ vii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ..................................................................................................... III
SOMMARIO ............................................................................................................................. V
ABSTRACT ............................................................................................................................. VI
TABLE OF CONTENTS ....................................................................................................... VII
LIST OF FIGURES .................................................................................................................. IX
1. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................. 10
1.1. MATERIAL CULTURE AS CARRIER OF KNOWLEDGE .............................................. 10
1.2. GENERAL CONTEXT AND THE NEED FOR THE SUSTAINABLE TURN IN DESIGN
DISCIPLINES ................................................................................................................................... 10
1.3. DESIGN PROBLEMS AND SYSTEMS THINKING ......................................................... 11
1.4. BIM AS AGENT TOWARDS DESIGN PROBLEMS SOLUTIONS AND
COLLABORATIVE PRACTICES ................................................................................................... 11
1.5. STATE-OF-THE ART AND PURPOSE OF THE THESIS ................................................ 12
1.6. STRUCTURE OF THE THESIS .......................................................................................... 14
2. DESIGN RESEARCH AND SYSTEMS THINKING ..................................................... 16
2.1. DESIGN RESEARCH AND DESIGN PROBLEMS ........................................................... 16
2.1.1. Design Research as a field of study ............................................................................... 16
2.1.2. Design Problems – Wicked Problems ........................................................................... 17
2.2. APPROACH TOWARDS THE SOLUTION OF WICKED PROBLEMS .......................... 18
2.2.1. Systems Thinking and Design cybernetics .................................................................... 18
2.2.2. The spaces in which design actions are taking place .................................................... 20
2.3. SUMMARY .......................................................................................................................... 22
3. DIGITAL TOOLS AND COLLABORATIVE DIALOGUES ......................................... 23
3.1. BUILDING INFORMATION MODELLING ...................................................................... 23
3.1.1. Collaboration – information accessibility ..................................................................... 23
3.1.2. Information Exchange – interoperability ...................................................................... 24
3.1.3. Simulation and Computation ......................................................................................... 27
3.2. LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT .............................................................................................. 27
3.2.1. LCA Specifications ....................................................................................................... 28
3.2.2. Existing tools about LCA calculation ........................................................................... 31
3.2.3. Dynamic LCA in BIM environment ............................................................................. 32
3.3. SUMMARY .......................................................................................................................... 34
4. CASE STUDY AND PRACTICAL INVESTIGATION ................................................. 35
4.1. DESCRIPTION OF SNØHETTA ......................................................................................... 35
4.1.1. The HouseZero – Harvard Center for Green Buildings and Cities - Case study
description ..................................................................................................................................... 36
4.2. LCA CALCULATION IN BIM DURING THE DESIGN STAGES ................................... 37
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ viii
4.2.1. Material Database .......................................................................................................... 40
4.2.2. Mapping of materials between ÖKOBAUDAT and Revit native library...................... 40
4.2.3. Alternative solutions for the exterior walls ................................................................... 42
4.2.4. LCA parameters and filter parameters ........................................................................... 43
4.2.5. Dynamo scripts .............................................................................................................. 44
4.2.6. Reports and optimization ............................................................................................... 46
4.3. SUMMARY .......................................................................................................................... 48
5. CONCLUSIONS .............................................................................................................. 49
6. BIBLIOGRAPHY ............................................................................................................ 51
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ ix
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1 – Stages of designing dialogues according to Glanville, as cited by Fischer and Herr, 2019) 21
Figure 2 - Schema of the traditional information exchange and the CDE,
https://bimportal.scottishfuturetrust.org ................................................................................................ 25
Figure 3 - Structure of data inside the CDE according to PAS 1192-2, (Kensek, 2018) ..................... 26
Figure 4 - Stages of LCA Analysis, ISO 14044:2006 ........................................................................... 29
Figure 5 - Existing Computer supported LCA Tools (Hollberg, 2016) and input from existing BIM –
LCA Tools (Cristine Bueno, 2016) cited by (Genova, 2018). .............................................................. 31
Figure 6 – MacLeamy curve, (Curt,2004) cited by (Hollberg, 2016) ................................................... 32
Figure 7 - From left to right: state of the building before the intervention, picture of the building after
the retroffiting / All rights reserved by Snøhetta ................................................................................... 36
Figure 8 – Main workflow to follow during the design process ........................................................... 37
Figure 9 - Design stage and production of variants based on the optimization of their embodied energy
- (Hollberg, Hildebrand and Habert, 2018) ........................................................................................... 38
Figure 10 – System map of the workflow for the LCA calculation in Revit ........................................ 39
Figure 11 - ÖKOBAUDAT Excel Database ......................................................................................... 40
Figure 12 - Material ID mapping in Revit ............................................................................................. 41
Figure 13 - Three fassade material variations ....................................................................................... 42
Figure 14 - Screenshots from the Revit properties of the model ........................................................... 43
Figure 15 - Dynamo scripts for the automated insertion and deletion of parameters in Revit .............. 44
Figure 16 - Dynamo script for the insertion of external database, material mapping, LCA calculation
and report of the values back in objects in the model ........................................................................... 45
Figure 17 - Dynamo script for the data report in Excel format ............................................................. 45
Figure 18 - Comparative Report of the final LCA values ..................................................................... 46
Figure 19 - Comparative diagram of the overall performance and impact for each variation .............. 46
Figure 20 - GWP Charts for each of the three variations ...................................................................... 47
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 10
1. INTRODUCTION
The first part of the introduction presents the general scope of the thesis and introduces the reader to the
fundamental concepts and the framework that will be further developed in the next chapters. The
intention of this part is the attempt to bring forth the existing interrelationships among the disciplines of
architecture, design research to the Building Information Modelling (BIM) methodology.
The second part will be focused on the definition of the purpose of the thesis, the definition of the
problem that will be treated and the objectives.
In the third and last part, the structure and a summary of the next chapters will be presented.
1.1. Material culture as carrier of knowledge
Architecture and design belong to a transdisciplinary branch of knowledge which is shaped by, interacts
with and affects other dimensions of knowledge. Architecture and design practises belong to the artifact
- artisan practises and are embedded in the social realm. They act as external representations and are the
carriers of knowledge. This material dimension of architecture and design are shaped by the cognitive-
and social- dimension of knowledge. The material dimension therefore contains the traces of the other
two dimensions from which it has been shaped by, while at the same time it leaves traces on our
cognitive constructs, which at their turn are getting shaped by those concrete situations. The three
dimensions can account for the evolution of knowledge. (Renn, 2020).
In that sense, knowledge is part of a system, where its part are affecting each other in a circular causal
fashion. In this system, each dimension is affecting the system, while at the same time is getting affected
by it. Whenever the system is confronted with new technologies or challenging objects, it is getting
transformed in the process. Consequently, the emergence of novelty can be seen as the result of the
transformation of the existing system. (Renn, 2020).
1.2. General context and the need for the sustainable turn in design disciplines
In the Anthropocene, the era where the planet has been deeply shaped by the human interventions and
it is approaching the planetary boundaries, is challenging the knowledge system. To maintain and
promote sustainable solutions which will maintain living conditions on earth, more knowledge needs to
be produced, shared globally, and applied locally.
During the United Nations Climate Change conference that took place in Paris in 2015, it was agreed
that all the countries should take special measures in order to reduce the global warming by reducing
their carbon footprint. It is widely acknowledged that GHG emissions are having a direct impact on the
global warming and therefore part of the measures should be on the reduction of the GHG production.
Building industry is accounted for contributing around 40% of the total CO2 emissions and the goals
from the Paris agreement is to set a limit of the rising temperature to 1.5 degrees. Therefore, architect
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 11
and designers need to keep a track on the impact that their decisions are contributing towards the global
warming. Life Cycle Assessment (LCA), constitutes a methodology for accounting the environmental
impact caused by the whole life cycle of products, processes, and services. LCA results a complex
methodology which includes lots of information and consequently its calculation results a time and
energy consuming task for the designers.1
1.3. Design problems and systems thinking
Solving design problems that are arising by such complexities, requires a different approach than the
one used in traditional natural sciences and engineering. This is due to the different nature of design
problems which in a pluralistic society there no absolute objectivity of what is considered as good, or
any objective definition of equity therefore design problems are defined as “wicked problems”. (Rittel
and Webber, 1973)
The approach taken in consideration in this thesis regarding the design problems has been developed by
the theory on the second order cybernetics.
The approach towards the development of wicked-problem solutions according to (Rittel, 2010), is
giving importance among others to:
1. The presence of the subjective observer both as an actor and controller
2. The circular causality as quality
3. The value of conversation in the “solution-finding” process
4. The collaborative practices and the refusal of the figure of the specialist - expert
Consequently, the job of the designer is shifting from mere form-giving to creating systems that enhance
collaboration, conversation, and exchange of information from all the participants-observers. At the
same time, the design of those systems requires well-coordinated actions and an explicit communication
of goals and methods between teams, so that the artefacts are coherent. (Fischer and Herr, 2019)
1.4. BIM as agent towards design problems solutions and collaborative practices
Due to the complexity and the nature of the design problems on the one hand, and the complexity of the
buildings themselves, the design of those systems is making use and taking advantage of the evolving
technological advantages. The use of computer and computation in design is seen as a tool that serves
towards the fulfilment of the intentions of the designers. It has therefore to be used in such a way that
will facilitate the designers to reach their goals.
BIM methodology is joined with this line of thought since its ontology is very much based in such a
way in order to help the architect and the other stakeholder towards their approach to the rising
complexities towards the generation of wicked-problems’ solutions. Although there are several
applications of computer technology applied in the Architecture, Engineering, Construction (AEC)
1 More detailed description about the LCA will follow in the second part of the introduction, where the description of the purpose of the thesis
will be described.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 12
industry during the design, construction and operation phases, the information flow both of the existing
information as well as the new data produced by the different stakeholders in the different stages are
lost or is hard to be retrieved. This happens mostly due to the lack of a precise method which the
information flow should follow, the use of different mediums of information’s transmittance between
the stakeholders as well as problems that regard the storage and retrieval of information whenever
necessary.
By applying BIM method, all information produced and collected by the different participants is stored
in digital models i.e. comprehensive digital representations of building. This approach dramatically
improves the coordination of the design activities, the integration of simulations, the setup and control
of the construction process, as well as the handover of building information to the operator. In addition,
by reducing the repetitive manual tasks by the re-entering, the chances for errors is reduced, while at the
same time repetitive work is avoided. (Kensek, 2018)
As a consequence, BIM method promotes collaboration, knowledge sharing between different
stakeholders, a common ground where collaboration takes place, while at the same time creates a data-
knowledge depository in an organised fashion where information can be created, shared, stored and
retrieved. By doing so, it creates a system, where conversation can emerge. In other words, it helps to
generate the situations the others can create. The goals are negotiated in an open-ended and integrated
process and recognizes circular causality as a quality.
1.5. State-of-the Art and purpose of the thesis
New technology and on-going research are trying to give answers and establish methods and frameworks
on how the building industry will result more sustainable and will enhance the human health and well-
being. Life Cycle Assessment is a relatively not so new concept whose goal is to analyse the energy and
impact of the production of construction materials, the energy produced by their transfer, on side
construction, operation, demolition and their potential to be reused for future buildings. LCA analysis
results a complex operation which requires a lot of information and calculation especially if one
considers big and complex buildings. Its complexity limits its use and therefore, LCA analysis is mostly
produced at the end stage of the design process. This has therefore to minimize the room for significant
changes and therefore for significantly reduce the CO2 emissions.
There is a need for an integration of the LCA analysis in the early design stages, where the initial
decision making in taking place. In addition, there is a need for an integrated design process where all
different disciplines are participating in an open and continuous conversation. Architecture and design,
as described above, are part of a collaborative transdisciplinary field, acting in a systemic fashion. In
this open system, every component should be ready to be affect and to be affected. An integrated design
approach will offer a deeper understanding on the interrelationships between architectural-, structural-,
MEP- and environmental design, which will allow for better solutions with lower environmental impact
by integrating different sources of knowledge and perspectives.
The purpose of this thesis is to trace a connection between the disciplines of architecture, design research
and the Building Information Modelling (BIM) methodology. More precisely, this research is focusing
on how the Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) is informing the decision making during the design process
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 13
in BIM environment. This research is trying to make use and to implement the workflow introduced by
the research by (Genova, 2019). The scope of this is to test and appropriate the workflow in an attempt
to possibly improve and make it more flexible and usable for a variants research LCA evaluation
process.
In the architecture field, the LCA due to its complexity is usually calculated at the end of the design
process. In order to improve the speed and being able to use the LCA as a tool in the earlier stages, there
is the need to simplify-or speed up the process/computation of the data while having more time to invest
in finding alternative design solutions and therefore reducing the cost, and the impact of the building
through its life cycle. In this sense, the accounting and calculation of the environmental impact that the
design of a new building or product is producing through the LCA methodology leaves traces in the
object itself as described in the subchapter 1.1.
The digital tools employed now for the LCA calculation are extracting the information regarding the
materiality and quantity from the 3D model and compute the life cycle assessment in cloud or in external
platforms, outside the BIM environment. This has as a consequence that the results of the calculation
are not connected with the 3d model, but are mere data which represent the impact values of the building
at the certain point in time, when the analysis has been executed.
This separation of the analysis’ data from the model is causing a problem, especially when we are talking
about complex problem which require an integrative design approach. One of the main revolutions of
the BIM methodology is the collection of all the necessary data in one platform and make it accessible
to all the participants of the different disciplines. There is therefore a need for the LCA to be integrated
in the BIM authoring tool in order to:
• facilitate the optimisation of the design solution
• make it parametric and automatically updated according to the changes in the model
• make the results of those changes visible and available to other disciplines
• connect and map the impact that each building component is causing in the whole in order to
allow the designer to focus only on the points where there is excessive production of CO2 and
give her space to act
In this thesis, I will try on the one hand, to create make use of a dynamic LCA analysis using the visual
programming tool Dynamo applied to the and on the other to Harvard Center for Green Buildings and
Cities building, and on the other make the link between the influence on the decision making during the
design phase and the influence – participation of the digital tools in the process of creation of the
architectural design of the building.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 14
1.6. Structure of the thesis
This thesis is divided in two main parts. The first part is introducing theoretical framework, the definition
of design problems and concepts. The second part is based on the presentation of the case study taken
into examination. In this second part, the case study will be presented and will emphasise the ways
digital tools informed the decision making and shaped the final building. Later, there will be presented
the computational script will be developed. This will present how an automated LCA process inside the
BIM environment is facilitating the decision making of the architect towards the decision on the choice
of materials, while at the same time giving the opportunity to share, exchange, update and include more
information in a collaborative fashion by the inclusion of the participation of the other stakeholders
involved in the project. The thesis structure will be subdivided in 5 main chapter, as follows:
Chapter 1:
The first chapter introduces the reader to the fundamental principles of design research and their
relationship with the systemic thinking. The chapter starts with the definitions of the theoretical concepts
and their definitions. Later, there will be presented the peculiar characteristics of the design problems
and the justification why design problems cannot be treated the same way as problems are treated by
other disciplines. Design problems therefore are not looking towards design-as-problem-solving but
towards design-as-problem-finding or needs-finding. (Fischer and Herr, 2019). In the last part, there
will be presented the position and the role that the design researchers play in that process and their
criteria of judgment and decision making. In the last part of the chapter there will be briefly discussed
how the special agency included inside the design studio affects the designers. In addition, it will be
briefly discussed the notion of Reflection-In-Action and Knowledge-In-Action as characteristics of the
design process.
Chapter 2:
After defining the nature of design problems, the methods employed by the designers in order to
approach the decision making and the spatial qualities that are affecting the designer, the third chapter
approaches to position the role of BIM, its qualities, structure inside this framework. BIM is seen as a
“space” and as a “tool” in which conversation takes place, allowing different stakeholders to collaborate,
exchange information, share knowledge. In the last part of this chapter, there will be discussed the
principles of LCA analysis, its role inside the design process and decision making, while there will be
presented the state of the art and the method applied in the next chapter.
Chapter 3:
In the fourth chapter, there will be presented and analysed the case study, according to the themes
introduced in the previous chapters. The case study presents an exemplary case of a retrofit of a two-
storey building in Boston. The building presents a lot of peculiar characteristics and themes which span
from historical conservation and memory to passive house principles, well-being, human – sensor
regulators, digital computational- and simulation tools. Later in the chapter, the main topic of the thesis
which consists on the integration of LCA analysis in the BIM environment as agent that enhances
collaboration and produces justification for decision making will be presented. In addition, there will be
presented the
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 15
Chapter 4:
In the last chapter, there will briefly summed up and brought together the concepts described in the
previous chapters in order to arrive to conclusions and discuss the limitations of the thesis, the relevance
of the research and suggestions for further research.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 16
2. DESIGN RESEARCH AND SYSTEMS THINKING
In the first section of the chapter, there will be explained the principles of design research as field of
study and the nature of design problems. Later, there will be discussed and defined the term and
principles of cybernetics, focusing on their relevance towards the design solution approach. The second
part will be focused on the processes which designers are employing in order to formulate judgement
and decisions. In order to do so, there will be discussed the constellation both of spatial qualities as well
as tools and instruments employed during the design process as well as during the decision-making
process. The aim is to present the complexities of this dynamic interrelated system, which includes
human and non-human objects while creating sets of atmospheres which in their turn are affecting the
process.
2.1. Design Research and Design problems
In the first part of this chapter there will be introduced the definitions of Design Research as a field of
study and its main characteristics. Later there will be discussed the nature of design problems, their
characteristics, and the approach towards their solutions.
2.1.1. Design Research as a field of study
Design research as we know it today, is a result of two main evolutionary phases. The first took place
during the 1920s and the second during the 1960s. In both cases there was the attempt to place design
inside the milieu of sciences, by on the first case introducing concepts of universal objectivity as a mean
for designing and on the second by the launch of design methodology as a subject or field of enquiry.
This second movement was even more focused on how to base design processes and design products on
objectivity and rationality. (Cross, 2006)
New technological, computational and scientific methods were the foundations of this new approach to
design. It was claimed that the design science revolution based on science technology and rationalism
could provide solutions to the problems that politics and economics could not solve. Despite the rising
interest of the application of scientific discourses inside the field of design, during the 1970s initial
supporters and pioneers of this movement started questioning its validity. Among others, Christopher
Alexander, who had originated a rational method for architecture and planning was proposing the
complete refuse of those methodologies and he went on by saying “ I’ve disassociated myself from the
field… There is so little in what is called “design methods” that has anything useful to say about how to
design buildings that I never even read the literature anymore. I would say forget it, forget the whole
thing”. (Alexander, 1964)
Aligned to this way of thinking, were the contributions and questions raised by Rittel and Webber in
1973, who recognised the nature and complexity of design problems - planning problems embedded in
the society. They introduced the term “wicked problem” and assigned it to describe the design problems
while they made the distinction between the wicked problems and tame problems that traditional science
is dealing with.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 17
Design as a field of study seeks solutions towards the design problems. Research according to (Archer,
1981) as cited by (Cross, 2006) is the systematic enquiry, the goal of which is knowledge.
Consequently,
Our concern in design research has to be the development, articulation and
communication of design knowledge. Where do we look for this knowledge? I believe
that it has three sources: people, processes and products. (Cross, 2006)
In this sense, the role of the design researcher lies on the capacity to understand and reflect on the design
practises and investigation of the human ability to design and on the methods of how to learn to design.
In addition, design research is focusing on the material manifestation of forms of knowledge that reside
on one hand on processes and methodologies and on the other on products themselves. In the first case,
the tactics and strategies of designing are defining the tools and techniques that the designer is applying
during the design stages. Much of this research revolves around the study of modelling for design
purposes. Modelling is the ‘language’ of design. Traditional models are the sketches and drawings of
proposed design solutions, but which in contemporary terms now extend to ‘virtual reality’ models. The
use of computer-based models has stimulated a wealth of research into design processes. (Cross, 2006)
Secondly, the design researchers recognise the value of tradition and history as a depository of
knowledge contained in the products themselves. This form of knowledge is manifested in forms,
materials, techniques, finishes and the tools employed in order to give same to the product.
2.1.2. Design Problems – Wicked Problems
As described above, architecture and design disciplines are transdisciplinary fields, that in order to be
constructed require interdisciplinary teams. Architecture and design problems are disciplines based on
the social realm and they result from the interactions between the users with the object themselves. In
this sense, the final product is shaped by the interaction between designers, materials, processes and
users. Design problems are characterized as wicked problems. The nature of those problems is not
following a linear process, but a messy one which is unique for each case and cannot be repeated.
In the pluralistic society where no absolute good or right decision can be considered, what a designer
has to face during the decision making makes this task hard to cope. This is one of the main principles
upon which the distinction of wicked problems has been made. Consequently, architecture and design
urges for a collaboration between as many people that stem from more as possible consequences. In this
sense, wicked problems do not provide solutions, but rather temporary solutions, which can
continuously get improved, re-appropriated and reshaped. This makes the whole process an open source,
open ended process which runs in feedback loops and in which every output is used as input for another
sub-process and all this interaction web which they form constitutes the system.
Architecture, design, urban planning among others dealing with problems that differ from the problems
that scientists and engineers are dealing with. Although this is a conception that in contemporary
research is not regarding those two aspects as completely separated, in this thesis I will focus more on
the concept of wicked problems vs tame problems as discussed by Webber and Rittel.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 18
Design problems, or else wicked-problems as described by (Rittel and Webber, 1973) and they have the
following 10 characteristics:
1. There is no definitive formulation of a wicked problem
2. Wicked problems have no stopping rule
3. Solutions to wicked problems are not true-or-false, but good-or-bad
4. There is no immediate and no ultimate test of a solution to a wicked problem
5. Every solution to a wicked problem is a "one-shot operation"; because there is no
opportunity to learn by trial-and-error, every attempt counts significantly
6. Wicked problems do not have an enumerable (or an exhaustively describable) set of
potential solutions, nor is there a well-described set of permissible operations that may
be incorporated into the plan
7. Every wicked problem is essentially unique
8. Every wicked problem can be considered to be a symptom of another problem
9. The existence of a discrepancy representing a wicked problem can be explained in
numerous ways. The choice of explanation determines the nature of the problem's
resolution
10. The planner has no right to be wrong
2.2. Approach towards the solution of Wicked Problems
As described previously, design problems have particular characteristics that at they turn require a
different approach towards the formulation of solutions. In this sub-chapter it will be discussed the
systems thinking applied in design by focusing of the second order cybernetics. Firstly, the reader will
be introduced to the main definitions and concepts of cybernetics and later it will be presented the
relevance of cybernetic thought inside the design and architecture fields. At the last part, it will be
presented how the designers design, the influence of the designers’ studio space and the tools they
employ to design and how those two aspects is affecting the overall design process and as a consequence
the design object itself.
2.2.1. Systems Thinking and Design cybernetics
Systems thinking recognises the interrelations between all single elements with the whole. In this sense,
the building cannot be seen just as static assemblage of different elements, but rather as a part of a system
which integrates, reacts and creates the place for interaction among the other parts of the built
environment in which it is embedded. Systems thinking recognizes the interrelations between all
different parts of the whole as a quality, where each part is influencing the behaviour of the other. There
is a growing interest to reduce the impact of the built environment in the ecosystem. This is a complex
issue which involves the participation of different experts from different fields in order to formulate a
coherent strategy. Therefore, it can be said that
…even seemingly insignificant artefacts have an influence on the systemic context they
are embedded in. If we want to solve the resource situation for the future and avoid the
destruction of the planet, we need a consistent concern with the systemic influences of
our artefacts and actions. (Sevaldson, 2008)
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 19
Systems thinking has evolved thought the years and there have been different approaches to it. Still the
core of this kind of “meta-theory” remains the study of the interaction between the members which
constitute the whole.
Cybernetics, as part of the systems thinking has appeared first in Plato’s writing. The origin of the word
stems from the κυβερνητικός, steersmanship with similar connotations to the word government. Later
in 1948, Wiener seminal work Cybernetics; or, control and communication in the animal and the
machine. Wiener’s work was introducing cybernetics in order to describe the self-regulating systems by
means of a circular feedback dependency. Although his work and generally the term cybernetics has
been disassociated by its philosophical dimensions and been used as a science of deterministic,
instrumentalist control technology inherited the Cold-War reputation (Fisher et al., 2019), Wiener
recognized the agency of the interactions of those systems. In other words, Wiener recognized the
influence and importance of the observer, the circular causality and non-determinability inside the
system in which the action is taking place. In this sense, he recognized that cybernetics have a reflexive
character instead of a linear one.
This first stage known as first order cybernetics is putting the foundations for the second order which is
based on the transition from the a detached, “objective” pose, where we can duck responsibility, right
into the messy middle of things, where we must take responsibility for our actions. (Dubberly et al.,2019)
Second order cybernetics are putting forward the importance that the subjective observer has during the
design process. The subjective observer is seen as an active agent who influences and takes a precise
position and perspective within the problem. In architecture and building industry where different
designers and stakeholders are involved during the design phase, is becoming a ground in which people
meet, collaborate, exchange knowledge and information and negotiate in an open-ended fashion.
Conversation and dialogue are fundamental parts of second order cybernetics. Dialogues and
conversation are shaping and are being shaped by an open-ended continues feedback loop, in which the
outputs are becoming again inputs in a circular causal manner. During this process, the involvement and
participation of each of the members are of equal value and each of the actors can challenge and
influence the system.
Architecture and design due to the rise of computing technology and its role in human communication
are expanding from form giving to create systems that support human interactions. (Fischer and Herr,
2019). At the same time,
a building cannot be viewed simply in isolation. It is only meaningful as a human
environment. It perpetually interacts with its inhabitants, on the one hand serving them
and on the other hand controlling their behaviour. In other words, structures make sense
as parts of larger systems that include human components and the architect is primarily
concerned with these larger systems; they (not just the bricks and mortar part) are what
the architect designs. (Pask, 1969)
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 20
2.2.2. The spaces in which design actions are taking place
In this section it will be presented and discussed the literature regarding the design practise and the
spaces in which design takes place. The goal is to present how the designers are getting affected by the
tools, their spaces and the dialogues between the self and the other. In this sense, spaces in which design
is taking place is part of the dialectic which is stimulation the generation of circular causal feedback
loops. Architecture and built environment according to (Sloterdjik, 2015) is the design of immersions.
Immersion, in this context, means to engage with one’s immersion in artificial environments, assisted
by technical equipment, for instance a virtual reality helmet or an electronic visor. In addition, according
to (Ash, 2016), the studio space should not be understood as geometric containers in which action takes
place, but instead as a series of co-existent spheres and atmospheres that shape the possibilities for action
of those that work in studio settings.
This necessarily leads us on to architecture, for it is properly considered, together with
music, the original form in which the immersion of humans in artificial environments
has been developed into a culturally controlled process. House building is a sort of basic
version of immersion technology, while urbanism is the developed stage. (Sloterdjik,
2015)
In this sense, architects and designers are the constructors of those immersive conditions, in which at
the same time they are immersed by. The design studio as a constellation of such an immersive space
includes both human and non-human objects and tools. The interaction and agency existed inside the
spacial constellation of the design studio can create situations in of knowledge production.Accoridng to
(Ash, 2016), this relational account of studio space points to the ways that any form of knowledge
produced within a studio does not simply emerge from individual human bodies or brains, but is co-
produced with a range of objects, which in turn produces the space of the studio as a particular location
in which particular activities take place. that the affective capacities of non-human objects are absolutely
fundamental to how a studio space is produced and that affect also shapes the potentials for new
knowledges and objects to be generated. Affect is not then an additive or emergent effect of a relation
between human bodies, but one of the basic components that enables the possibilities and limitations of
a space to appear through non-human objects as well.
In the same line of though is the contribution of Donald Schön, who challenged the positivist doctrine
of the design as a science and he proposed the shift to the design as a reflective practise. According to
(Schön, 1983), design together with city planning, engineering, management law, but also education,
psychotherapy and medicine require series of activities in domains that involve reflective practice.
(Visser, 2011)
The reflective practitioner is then a figure which is part of an open system in which a there is a
continous flow of inputs that are being processes, both material, immaterial, emotional and digital, that
are creating outputs which in their turn are becoming inputs again in a continous circuar – causal
manner. The reflective practitioner is a figure whose knowledge is based on the tacit dimension since
on the main processes of knowledge production is generated by intutitive processes which some
practitioners bring to situations of uncertainty, instability, uniquenness and value conflict. (Cross,
2006)
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 21
Designing according to Glanville, is unfolding as a conversation between a self and various possible
kinds of other, such as a pen and paper, a person, an imagined person, computer soft- and hardware,
physical models and so on. The crucial requirement is for the self to allow the other to “speak back” and
to accommodate the unexpected so that self affects other, and other affects self. Avoiding requisite
variety, both get partially “out of control” in a mix of positive and negative feedback, thus conversing
along non-determinable trajectories to arrive at previously unknown destinations. (Fischer and Herr,
2019)
Figure 1 – Stages of designing dialogues according to Glanville, as cited by Fischer and Herr,
2019)
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 22
2.3. Summary
In this chapter, the reader introduced to the principle ideas of Design Research as field of study. It has
been also presented the different stages of the evolution of research in design and design methodologies
as part of a scientific milieu. A distinction between methods applied to science and those that need to be
applied in the design have been made. Methodologies may be useful for scientific research especially
then the result need to be validated. The results of design on the other hand do not have to be repeatable
and in most of the cases must not be repeated or copied. (Cross 2006). Research in science and in design
as well as the methods and strategies employed in order to conduct research differs.
Later, the characteristics of the problems that the designers are dealing with have been described.
Moreover, since design problems - wicked problems differ from tame problems, the method with which
they need to be faced is different. Due to their complexity and interrelations of the different components
of the wicked problems, it has been discussed how the systemic thinking and more precisely the second
order cybernetics can assist the definition of goals during the design stage. In the beginning of the second
sub chapter, the main concepts, and principles of the second order cybernetics and their relevance with
the design stage has been made. Second order cybernetics recognises circular causality, non-
determinism, the subjective observer and other concepts avoided by natural science. In this way, it offers
an approach to self-organising systems that negotiate their own goals in open-ended processes – in other
words: design. (Fischer and Herr, 2019)
In the second part of this chapter, it has been discussed the spaces in which the design action is taking
place. Spaces are seen not as containers of material and immaterial objects, but as the active matter
which creates atmospheres as results from the interaction of humans and non-humans. In addition, it has
been discussed the ways in which designers work in an reflexion-in-action fashion, by involving the
reflection and conversation between the self, the other designers or even the material and immaterial
objects such as models, sketches, digital tools and digital simulations.
The goal of this chapter was to introduce to the reader the complexities of design as well as the ways in
which designers work, the spaces and agency of their design studios, as well as the feedback loops and
conversations happening by the interaction between both human, non-human and the self in a circular
causal manner.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 23
3. DIGITAL TOOLS AND COLLABORATIVE DIALOGUES
This chapter is focused on how digital tools and more precisely the BIM methodology can enhance the
collaborative practices and how the use of those tools can inform the decision making during the design
stage. To this aim, there will be discussed the main characteristics of the BIM methodology in relation
to the information use, storage and exchange between the different stakeholders. Later, there will be
discussed how BIM by following those rules about the information management, can become the base
for other simulation and computational tools. In the second part of the chapter, the focus is based on the
calculation of the LCA analysis. It will be presented the main characteristics and standards that the LCA
should follow, and there will be presented the current tools that help the designer with the calculation
task. In the last part, there will be presented the advantages of the LCA analysis in a BIM environment
and how this dynamic approach can have a positive impact during the decision making and how this
exact process is a part of a reflective dialogue between designer and machine as described in the previous
chapter.
3.1. Building Information Modelling
BIM is the method by which 3D objects and buildings are designed in a virtual environment. Buildings
and their parts are containing sets of properties and information regarding a wide range of different sorts
of information for the early conceptual design stage to the operation and end of life of the building. The
inclusion of such information makes the model the carrier of knowledge which include the participation
of all different stakeholders that take part in it. At the same time, makes the information easily
retrievable, updated, shared, stored or cancelled. The main advantages of this methodology are to be
seen during the development of big complex projects that include accordingly the analogous amount of
information. BIM is promoting the collaborative practices and the integrated design by the participation
of the different disciplines. In this first part of the third chapter, there will be discussed some of the main
characteristics upon which the BIM methodology is based, and how those characteristics can contribute
towards the developments of solutions for the wicked-design problems that the designer has to deal with.
3.1.1. Collaboration – information accessibility
One of the main characteristics as mentioned above, is the enhancement of collaboration throughout the
design of a building or object. BIM recognized the interdisciplinary approach as a quality and allows
multiple stakeholders to meet and work together in a collective fashion where every participant is
contributing to the same scope which is the development of a solution for a design problem.1
There are many definitions about what BIM is and how it is about to change the process of construction.
In most if not all of them, the collaborative aspect is constantly emphasized, and according to what have
1 This inevitably brings in mind the similarities in the approaches existed during the medieval times and the guilts’ organisation and scope as
described by Richard Sennet’s book The Craftsman, 2009 and in that way creates a link between the transition and transformation of the crafts
as an act done with the hands, in German Handwerk, to the digital era.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 24
been discussed in the second chapter, it dismantles the hierarchies and recognizes the unique knowledge
that stem from each of the individuals which are participating in the design process.
Accordingly, BIM is seen as:
… a digital representation of physical and functional characteristics of a facility. A BIM
is a shared knowledge resource for information about a facility forming a reliable basis
for decisions during its life cycle; defined as existing from earliest conception to
demolition. A basic premise of BIM is collaboration by different stakeholders at
different phases of the life cycle of a facility to insert, extract, update or modify
information in the BIM to support and reflect the roles of that stakeholder.
(buildingSMART alliance, 2015)
where
…collaboration describes the cooperation of complementary partners with a high level
of trust and reciprocal support. An important objective of collaboration is the creation
of collective knowledge in order to develop solutions for complex problems.
Collaborative processes are frequently highly creative, and all partners are of equal
standing. (Schapke et al., 2018)
3.1.2. Information Exchange – interoperability
In order to create a common place in which the design actions can take place, it is necessary to establish
among others the ways in which the information is going to be stored, who is going to have access and
when, to who is the information relevant and so on.
In order to ensure a constant flow of relevant information, BIM methodology follows a structure based
on different standards that is common to all stakeholders. In that way, quality assurance is maintained
and the work of the design teams and the stakeholders becomes easier since the information management
follows certain rules which are common and known to all of them.
Building is the result of a complex process in which different companies are participating. In addition,
the planning process is divided in several different phases, which are in their turn executed by different
teams and companies. Finally, the collaborations between the different companies involved are or may
be alliances that are new, and their bonds are not based on long-term collaboration on older projects.
(Borrmann et al., 2018)
In this diverse landscape, collaboration and information exchange is therefore a complex task.
Information accessibility by the different stakeholders is based on two main properties. The first is that
the stakeholders have access to the information pool, and second that the information is machine
readable. But in an integrated design approach, that seems not to be enough. Integrated design requires
not only precise information management rules but it also needs to be ensured that the information
exchanged from one stakeholder to the other it can be used without the need for further manual
processing and additionally that the information that has been transferred has remained unchanged and
complete. That means that interoperable information exchange is a crucial aspect of BIM integrated
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 25
design. Since different stakeholders use different software tools and consequently different formats,
there is a need for a common language where the information can be exchanged without been lost or
altered.
Creating a common framework in which data exchange formats is of great importance in the
Architecture, Engineering, Construction (AEC) sector. To this aim, there are not only the native formats
of each software house, but also agreements on formats that are ensuring the quality of the information
transference and that constitute the “universal” language of BIM. One of them, the .ifc format developed
by the buildingSMART organisation is aligned with the goal of creating an interoperable communication
channel in which the information is contained and can be exchanged between the different software
inside the building industry.
Despite the efforts, it is still hard to say that there are no interoperability issues. The variety of
information and the continuous growing number of digital tools, as well as the information that they are
producing may still not be fully readable from another software, although the exchange format is
common.
To assure that the information that the relevant information is remaining updated, interoperable and
accessible to everyone is a very important and difficult task. The common place where information is
gathered is called Common Data Environment (CDE).
The use of CDE constitutes a common depository of information, which by following certain rules set
by standards is facilitating the retrieval, control, update and dissemination of information to all the
stakeholders. In addition, it helps to reuse the already existed information while at the same time reduces
the time and cost needed in order to create coordinated information to the team.
Figure 2 - Schema of the traditional information exchange and the CDE,
https://bimportal.scottishfuturetrust.org
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 26
According to the British Standard Institution (BSI) the CDE is:
The single source of information for any given project, used to collect, manage and
disseminate all relevant approved project information. Stored digitally, this is where
information is shared collaboratively in a logical, accessible way to help all key parties
gain access to information. This means that, firstly, information is readily accessible
(using universal naming conventions) and is not duplicated, and secondly, information
has both a defined purpose and owner. (BSI, 2020)
For a CDE to succeed its scope, there is a need of a clear definition of roles and responsibilities between
the project’s team, a clear definition of the workflows. Moreover, there is a need for a common use of a
common glossary of terms, definitions, data architectures and file formats, while at the same time it
needs to be ensured that information is available and accessible anytime from anywhere.
Project- and information management play therefore an important role towards the structuring of the
information inside the CDE. To do so, the formation of the CDE should follow one general accepted
format. The one mostly used is according to the Specification PAS 1192-2, published by the BSI.
Figure 3 - Structure of data inside the CDE according to PAS 1192-2, (Kensek, 2018)
The CDE by centralising the information storage as well as by creating packages of information and
workflows supports the easier coordination of the huge amounts of information that is present in the 3D
digital models.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 27
3.1.3. Simulation and Computation
The use of computer in architecture and design is seen as a tool, which contributes the designers towards
their attempts to solve complex problems and allows them to compute faster complex and repetitive
operations. Digital computer then, is seen as
…essentially, the same as a huge army of clerks, equipped with rule books, pencil and
paper, all stupid and entirely without initiative, but able to follow exactly millions of
precisely defined operations. There is nothing a computer can do which such an army
of clerks could not do, if given time. (Alexander, 1976)
The way in which the digital tools are embedded inside the architectural design process, is
focused not on the necessity or trend to use the computer itself, but it’s use should be clearly
articulated and focused on in which ways this army of clerks could be helpful to solve those
design problems. (Alexander, 1976)
As explained in the previous chapter, the solution of a design problem is very much depended
on the perspective in which the designer approaches, frames and analyses the nature of the
problem. The use of the digital tools therefore can bring to a misleading formulation of purpose
and focus of a problem which is not the main – or the original design problem which should be
solved. The main purpose should be not just to use the digital tool, but first to know what and
in which way this tool is going to help the designer solve the problem which has been defined
in an earlier stage.
The importance then of using the computer according to (Rittel, 1976) lies in the fact that it can
make possible what could not be treated by the unarmed natural human brain.
In this context, BIM can play an important role towards the management and preparation of the
data that need to be computed. BIM capacity to store, re-use and extract information directly
from the geometrical 3D model, is raising on one hand the productivity while at the same time
it reduces the errors by avoiding the constant manual re-entering of information. By following
standard formats and data architectures commonly accepted by other platforms, the information
can be easily used in order to compute or simulate the performance of the building, either inside
the same software by the use of plug-ins, or in cloud.
3.2. Life Cycle Assessment
The building industry is responsible for the consumption of more than the 40% of the world’s primary
energy (PE), while at the same time is causing the one third of the greenhouse gas emissions (GHG).
(UNEP SBCI, 2009)
These numbers are considering the whole life cycle of the building: from its construction including the
to the operational and the demolition phase. Consequently, the energy consumption and GHG
production is very much influenced by the decisions taken during the design phase of the building. The
design stage is the initial stage in which the analysis of the design problems is starting to give shape to
the first solutions of it. It is crucial then, that during the design stage there should be taken in
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 28
consideration measures towards the reduction of the energy and material resources. The design stage is
of particular importance because it is setting the rules, priorities and the way the building will operate,
maintained and demolished. During the design phase, the interdependencies of the construction,
operation and demolition stages are decided. In that sense, the design stage can be seen as wicked
problem, whose solutions are influencing and have an impact on the construction operation and
demolition stages, while at the same time, those solutions may cause new problems on the life cycle of
the building.
There have been regulations regarding the energy efficiency of the building during its operation stage,
which successfully managed to reduce the its environmental impact. Therefore, there is a raising interest
in the embodied energy during the production and disposal of the building elements. European
regulations will require that from the beginning of 2021, all new buildings will need to have operational
energy demand close to zero. As a result, the embodied energy will become even more significant.
(Hollberg, 2016)
In the first section of this subchapter, there will be presented the LCA methodology and framework.
Later, there will be presented the some of the most common tools which are allowing for a smoother
calculation of the LCA, and on the last part, there will be discussed the advantages that the integration
of LCA in BIM environment. In addition, there will be highlighted relevant workflows towards this
goal, which there will be developed and tested in the next chapter.
3.2.1. LCA Specifications
The increased interest towards the analysis and reduction of the environmental impact of the building
industry, has led to the development of different methodologies. One of them is the Life Cycle
Assessment which is focus on the analysis of the environmental impacts of products, goods and service.
LCA is based following the standard ISO 14044 of 2006. According to the ISO standard, the LCA
analysis assists in the identification of opportunities in order to:
• improve the environmental performance of products and services at various stages of their life
cycle
• inform the decision making
• provide a selection of relevant indicators of environmental performance
• make an environmental product declaration, or help towards the marketing of the product by
implementing an ecolabeling scheme
To do so, the LCA is taking in consideration among others the use of resources and environmental
consequences of releases during the life cycle, from raw material, through production, construction,
operation, disposal or/end reuse. This life cycle is commonly known as cradle-to-grave.
The LCA method follows four stages according to the following schema:
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 29
Figure 4 - Stages of LCA Analysis, ISO 14044:2006
The goal and scope definition are parts of the first stage. The aim of this stage is to set the boundaries
and level of detail of the analysis, as well as its intentions. The second stage focuses on the inputs and
outputs of the data according to the product or service taken under examination. In other works, the
inventory stage involves the collection of the data that are necessary in order to arrive to the wished
result of the defined study. The third phase is providing further information in order to assess the
inventory results in an attempt to further understand what the impact of the system is. The last stage is
focusing on formulating conclusions, recommendation and decisions-making in accordance to the goals
and scope definition. (ISO 14044:2006)
LCA is system boundaries is structured according to the EN 15978:2011. The calculation regarding the
embodied energy and impact in the building materials is divided in following five main modules and
they describe the embodied energy of the materials according to different stages, from production to
end-of-life and reuse. The main point of simplification in LCA is determining the system boundaries. In
system boundary of the LCA analysis is defined by the choice of the different cycle modules of the
materials.
Figure 5 - LCA material modules, EN 15978:2001
The data for each one of the about modules comes is shared by the companies that are producing the
products or services and are published in the Environmental Production Declaration (EPD). Despite the
precision of the values included in the EPDs of each material, there is still some information which is
rarely included according to the different modules.
The modules A1-A3 during the product stage of a material account for the largest amount of embodies
energy, and therefore are compulsory in during the analysis. The module A4, depends on the distance
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 30
between the construction site and the production site of the material. This information is usually unknow
during the early design phases. The data for the modules A5, B1-B3, B5 and C1-C2 are usually not
available and therefore the modules are neglected. In addition, the integration of the module D is
optional, but nevertheless its recommended in order to provide a holistic picture including the recycling
potential of the materials. (Hollberg, 2016)
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 31
3.2.2. Existing tools about LCA calculation
The LCA calculation results a very complex and time-consuming task. In order to assist this process,
there have been developed different tools. Some of those tools need a deep background knowledge about
the LCA calculation and are therefore addressed to experts.
In addition, most of the tools that are running outside the BIM environment are requesting a manual
input of the geometrical and material data, which can easily cause errors. At the same time, BIM
embedded tools require a higher level of detail of the information, which at the early stages is not always
available. Despite the number of existing tools, none of them is allowing for optimisation. This remains
a big issue since the LCA analysis should be made in order to evaluate and optimise the design solution
in order to achieve a better performance of the building and not just for documentation purposes.
(Hollberg, 2016)
Figure 5 - Existing Computer supported LCA Tools (Hollberg, 2016) and input from existing
BIM – LCA Tools (Cristine Bueno, 2016) cited by (Genova, 2018).
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 32
3.2.3. Dynamic LCA in BIM environment
The LCA analysis due to its complexity presents an interesting and worth investigating task to be
executed by the computer. The integration of the LCA in BIM environment can help the designers to
reduce the time they need, while at the same time allows them to have a holistic view of the
interdependencies between the form, materiality, function and sustainable planning. Including the LCA
in the early design stage, it offers more space for changes and investigation for optimal solutions, as
shown in the Figure 5. In addition, by re-using and automatically extracting information that are
incorporated in the geometry of the model such as the Bill Of Quantities (BOQ), the designer can easier
and faster investigate more alternative solutions. By parametrizing the process, it will allow the
designers to have a real-time feedback of the environmental impact of their design proposals and in that
way, they will be able to focus on the optimisation of their design and also investigating more alternative
solutions in shorter time.
Figure 6 – MacLeamy curve, (Curt,2004) cited by (Hollberg, 2016)
As said previously, in order to calculate the LCA, there is the need to set the boundaries - limits of the
investigation. In other words, there is the need to set the level of detail and the LCA modules that are
taken in consideration. Accordingly, there are different research projects that are proposing different
levels of detail for the LCA calculations. The European research project EeBGuide, proposes three
different levels of LCA analysis
• the screening LCA, which is used in the initial phases
• the simplified, which is similar to the screening one, but it includes more data and it’s conducted
usually in a more advanced design stage
• the complete, which corresponds to the framework as described by the ISO 14040:2006
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 33
while the “ACADEMY” European research project promotes a fourth type of LCA analysis called
streamlined. This framework is based on the one proposed by the Society of Environmental Toxicology
and Chemistry in 1999 and it is recommended for the early design stages. (Santos et al., 2019)
According to (Santos et al., 2019), for a streamlined approach the objects of the BIM model should
contain the nine following environmental categories:
• acidification potential (AP)
• global warming potential (GWP)
• eutrophication potential (EP)
• abiotic depletion potential of materials (ADPM)
• abiotic depletion potential for fossil fuels (ADPE)
• photochemical ozone creation potential (POCP)
• ozone depletion potential (ODP)
• renewable energy (PE-Re)
• non-renewable energy (PE-NRe)
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 34
3.3. Summary
In this chapter it has been presented a synthesis of the main topics that this research project is focused
on, and that will be applied in the case study in the next chapter. The first part of this chapter was
introducing to the reader some of the main topics of the BIM methodology, with focus on the ways in
which BIM can enchance the collaborative practises. In addition, it has been presented the main
structures and standards that the data should follow, in order to allow a smoother and fast way of
exchange, read, use, store and compute the information by an inderdisciplinary team of stakeholders.
Later it was discussed the importance of interoperability and by using open formats can help towards
the collaboration among humans and among humans and computers. In addition, it was presented the
importance of the centralized depository where all the important information of the project is included
and is made accessible to all the participants. By doing so, the retrieval and sharing of information is
information becomes faster reduces the errors and frustration of the designers by avoiding them to use
information which is not relevant or obsolete. In the last section of the first sub-chapter, it was presented
how BIM can set the base for the commputation and simulation of complex data, in order to allow the
designers to inform their design and their decision making. Simulation and computational tools are seen
as a part of the dialogue which is taking place between designers and machines, and it can generate a
continues feeback loop in which the designers are contantly optimizing their design solutions.
The second part of the chapter was focus on the LCA analysis. In the begingin, the reader gains a general
overview about the importance of the LCA during the design stage, the different methodologies,
standards and the stucture that the LCA should follow. Later, there were presented the existing tools for
the LCA calcualtion, while at the same time the main the major problems arrising lack of integration of
those tools with BIM. In the last section, there was highlighted the importance of a dynamic aand open
apporach for a LCA analysis. In addition, there was presented how BIM methology can help towards
the computation, calculation, information and data exchange by taking in advantage the main
characteristics of the BIM methology.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 35
4. CASE STUDY AND PRACTICAL INVESTIGATION
In this chapter, there will be presented the practical investigation and the development of a parametric
schema that will allow for an automated calculation of the LCA in BIM environment. The first part of
the chapter is dedicated to the description of the architecture office Snøhetta based in Oslo, together
with which this research has been conducted. Later, the case study will be introduced. In the second
part, it will be presented a system map of the process that has been followed. Moreover, there will be
presented the scripts developed in Dynamo as well as all the supporting material such as the database of
the materials that has been used and a step-by-step description of the workflow. In the last part, it will
be presented the result of the computation together with the diagrams with which the designers can
obtain a holistic view of the impact of their design proposal and allow them to optimize their design,
and therefore inform their decision making.
4.1. Description of Snøhetta
Snøhetta (Norwegian pronunciation: [ˈsnøːˌhɛtɑ]) began as a collaborative architectural and landscape
workshop, and has remained true to its trans-disciplinary way of thinking since its inception. Our work
strives to enhance our sense of surroundings, identity and relationship to others and the physical spaces
we inhabit, whether feral or human-made. Museums, products, reindeer observatories, graphics,
landscapes and dollhouses get the same care and attention to purpose. Today, Snøhetta has grown to
become an internationally renowned practice of architecture, landscape architecture, interior
architecture, product- and graphic design, with more than 240 employees from 32 different nations. A
definite relationship between multiple disciplines is a driving force in all of Snøhetta’s work. This is
demonstrated through the company’s long history, where landscape and architecture work together
without division, from the earliest stage possible. We place experience at the center of our design
process, for a design that engages the senses and physicality of the body while fostering social
interaction. This allows our design to promote both individual and collective empowerment in the
communities where work. (Snøhetta,2020)
The overall philosophy of the office is based on five main piles:
• The studio space as an actor whose openness enhances the interaction and collaboration of the
employees
• The design methodology is based both on the simultaneous exploration of handicraft and
cutting-edge digital technology as a complementary agent that strives the creative process
• The collaboration between the client, user and stakeholders through workshops and charrettes.
• The commitment to social and environmental sustainability
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 36
• The transpositioning which allows the participants to break from the professional roles and
switch perspectives as an attempt to foster a greater sense of possibility, to free themselves from
habitual thinking and build empathy for others involved in the process. (Snøhetta,2020)
4.1.1. The HouseZero – Harvard Center for Green Buildings and Cities - Case study description
The case study is based on the retrofitting of headquarters of Harvard Center for Green Buildings and
Cities at the Harvard Graduate School of Design in Cambridge. The operation is focused on the
transformation of a pre-1940s building into a living-laboratory and an energy-positive prototype for
ultra-efficiency that will help to understand buildings in new ways. (Snøhetta, 2020)
The goals of the project retrofit has the followign performing goals:
• zero delivered energy to heating and cooling
• 100% natural ventilation
• 100% daylight autonomy (No daytime electric light)
• Zero carbon emissions, including embodied energy in materials
The building is concieved as a self regulating organism which can adjust itself seasonally and even
daily in order to reach thermal comfort for its occupants. By implementing the feedback from 285
sensors which allow to collect almost 17 million data points each day, the building can be self-adjust
in response to both the internal and external variables such as outdoor air temperature or rain, and
indoor CO2 levels and air temperature.
In addition, the goal of the building is not to sacrifice spacial qualities for performance purposes. In
this sence, the building is seen as a holistic system which is self regualted by the interaction between
the human experience and sensory participation, together with cutting-edge technologies and
innovative applications. This synergy has as a result a harmonic co-existance between history of the
place, human-centric sustainable architecture, and environmental sustainability.
Figure 7 - From left to right: state of the building before the intervention, picture of the building after the
retroffiting / All rights reserved by Snøhetta and the Harvard Centre for Green Buildings and Cities
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 37
4.2. LCA calculation in BIM during the design stages
It has been discussed that there is the necessity for the implementation of the LCA analysis in the early
design phases. This will give the possibility for an overall better performance of the building in terms
of its embodied impact.
The design stage is the moment where the first information is examined by the designer. In this stage,
the designer by analysing those inputs is trying by providing different variations to create different
solutions which will respond in a better or worse way to the goals that are set. This comparative
evaluation of different solutions is crucial part during the design stage. This process is based on the
following general process schema:
Figure 8 – Main workflow to follow during the design process
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 38
Figure 9 - Design stage and production of variants based on the optimization of their embodied
energy - (Hollberg, Hildebrand and Habert, 2018)
This stage and in order to optimize the design solution, there is a need for the production and examination
of different variations. The variant-based design approach is the only way to optimize the enevironemtal
performance of the building systematically. This requires additional effort and time but by using a
parametrized schema and a real time calculation and feedback this effort is greatly reduced. Other than
that, the variant-based approach requires also the willingness and openess from the designer’s side to
question, revise the design decisions already taken. This method is usually employed in architecture
offices. (Hollberg, Hildebrand and Habert, 2018)
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 39
Figure 10 – System map of the workflow for the LCA calculation in Revit
The goal of this practical investigation is to establish a workflow with which the LCA calculation can
be automated and dynamically updated inside Revit by the use the visual programming tool Dynamo.
In order to do so, there have been followed the next steps:
• Identify the scope and the boundaries of the analysis
• Check the characteristics of the 3D model, and adjust it in order to facilitate the analysis
• Map the materials used in the model from the native library of Revit
• Research for a material database from which the data can be used in order to compute the
calculations
• Create project parameters that would facilitate the filtering process of the revit elements
according to variation number and layers
• Creation of project parameters with the nine environmental categories for the LCA calculation
in order to allow the automated assignment of the calculated values to each object in the model
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 40
4.2.1. Material Database
As discussed previously, the scope of this practical application is to create an automated and dynamic
workflow inside Revit with which the designer can obtain a holistic overview of the design process. In
this sense, the embodied energy calculation of the materials are becoming an actor which is playing an
important role during the decision making of the designer and as a concequence of the design of the
building itself.
Firstly, there was the need to find a material database in digital format, that would allow for an automated
integration in the workflow. Most of the databases found during the this research stage, were single EPD
files in .pdf format, related to specific products by specific companies. For the purpose of this research,
there have been used the database created by ÖKOBAUDAT.
ÖKOBAUDAT, is and online platform developed by the German Federal Ministry of the Interior,
Building and Community. The scope of the platform is to promote the sustainability inside the AEC
sector. ÖKOBAUDAT contains a material database in .xls format, with life cycle assessment datasets
on building materials, construction, transport, energy and disposal processes. All the data contained in
the platform are publicly available and free of charge. The database contains both generic datasets and
specific enviromental declaration datasets from different companies. The database is compliance with
the DIN EN 15804 regulations. (BBSR, 2020)
4.2.2. Mapping of materials between ÖKOBAUDAT and Revit native library
First important step was to create the link between the .xls database and the native material library of
Revit. Since the major part of the information contained in the ÖKOBAUDAT database, there should
be a carefull examination that the right materials have been mapped in Revit material library.
Figure 11 - ÖKOBAUDAT Excel Database
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 41
In order to create the link between the external database and the material library in BIM, there hs been
created a material shared parameter inside Revit named as Material ID. After the correspondence
between the materials has been set, it has been assigned the unique ID number of each material from the
external database to the Revit material library.
Figure 12 - Material ID mapping in Revit
This procedure needs to be done with extra care because every error both in the ID Number and the
material correspondence between the English and German description of the material can have a huge
influence in the final LCA calculation.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 42
4.2.3. Alternative solutions for the exterior walls
For the proof of concept of this research, there have been developed in total three different fassade
solutions. The first one, is the as-built solution provided by the architecture office and the other two are
developed by myself. A more detailed description of the materiality of the three variations can be seen
in the following figures. For all three variations the vapor barrier layer is not taken in consideration. In
order to calculate the quantities of the materials for all three variations, there was the necessity to design
all the different layers as different walls. In addition, in order to substruct the embodied energy of the
existing wooden structure, there has been designed also the wooden frame from which then the quantities
had been automatically extracted.
Figure 13 - Three fassade material variations
The three fassade variations are focusing on how different construction techniques may affect the
quantities of embodied material energy. In the first (from thee left), the architects choice was focused
on the use of natural materials that can be recycle. A ventilated fassade is contributing to the overall
energy performance of the building, while at the same time the reclaimed and re-use of the wooden
structure contributes to the minimize the embodied energy of the building envelop.
In the second variation, the intention was to re-use the existing wooden structure in order to lay on it the
interior and exterior layes. For the exterior layer it had been chosen the sandwich panel. This material
is mostly used in industrial buildings, but the production companies are offering a lot of exterior
finishings with different materials that could be used also for office and commercial buildings. The
advnatage of such a system is that the sandwich panels are acting both as insulation and as finishing
layer. The fact that are prefabricated gives the possibility for a faster conclusion of the construction
phase with the use of less energy, while at the same time it can be dissassembled and re-used or repaired
easily. For the interior finishing, there had been chosen a two-layer plasterboard.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 43
For the third variation, there had been chosen a “traditional” construction with the use of load-bearing
partitions out of concrete, bricks for the non structural enclosure, mineral wool insulation and plaster as
interior and exterio finishings.
4.2.4. LCA parameters and filter parameters
In order to facilitate and automate the filtering process of the different elements during the LCA
calculation in Dynamo, there have been inserted different shared parameters assigned to the wall
elements that were the main object of examination in this study.
By developing a script in Dynamo, it had been automatically created a set of parameters regarding the
function of the walls i.e. if the different layers have load-bearing function, insulation et cetera. Using
the same method and by developing a Dynamo script, there has been inserted the LCA categories that
they need to be calculated. Lastly, there has been created a parameter with contains the number of the
variation in which the element is part of. In that way, later in the calculation and data export it can be
obtained a report with the LCA values for every variation per function of the wall.
Figure 14 - Screenshots from the Revit properties of the model
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 44
4.2.5. Dynamo scripts
The main scope of the development of the Dynamo scripts, was to create an open system which can
communicate, extract, compute and report different data between the designer, external databases and
the data extracted from the model. For the present research the focused was based on the LCA
calculation, but it could be also applied for other calculations such as the Life Cycle Cost (LCC) and
others. By creating an open system in which data flow and feedback loops are created between the
machine and the human, if offers the designer the possibility to have a control on the whole design
impact, while at the same time gives them the possibility to produce more alternative solutions by a
continious optimization process. The results of the calculations are using the potential of the digital
computer to compute and combine huge amound of data faster, while at the same time the data can be
given back to the designer in an organized form by which she can interpret, evaluate and proceed with
the decision making. For simplification purposes1, the elements taken into examination have been
reduced. The development of the scripts though can be used in order to calculate all the different
elements present in the Revit models.
The main organizational scheme of the scripts are divided in three main bodies:
The first is focusing with the integration of the necessary parameters in the Revit model, that would then
assist towards the calculation and data extraction parts that are taking place in the next bodies.
Figure 15 - Dynamo scripts for the automated insertion and deletion of parameters in Revit
The second is focusing on the integration of data from an external database, in this case the Excel
ÖKOBAUDAT database. In addition, in this second step, the correspondance between the materials
1 The simplification of the elements examined in the model through the Dynamo scripts was mainly caused by the lack of time that this research
project had to be concluded.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 45
used in the model and their LCA values that are present in the Excel database is taking place. In the last
part of this script, the quantities of each material is extracted from the Revit model, and calculated with
the value of the single measure unit that is written in the external database. The last step, is to assign
back to the objects in the Revit model the final values of the LCA calculations.
Figure 16 - Dynamo script for the insertion of external database, material mapping, LCA
calculation and report of the values back in objects in the model
The third and last script is focused on the extraction of the final LCA values present at the Revit model.
The goal is to create a final report in Excel, which presents the final LCA values of each fassade variation
and the values of each functional layer of the wall. In addition, by creating this automated report and the
comparative diagrams, the designers can obtain a faster and holistic view of the best performance of the
solutions that they provided.
Figure 17 - Dynamo script for the data report in Excel format
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 46
4.2.6. Reports and optimization
After running the LCA calculation using the script in Dynamo, the following data has been obtained in
Excel format. From there, there can be set different combinations in order to analyse and compare the
different solutions according to the goal of the designer. For the purpose of this research, the interest
was based on the overall evaluation of the embodied energy of each variation and in addition the
Figure 19 - Comparative diagram of the overall performance and impact for each variation
Figure 18 - Comparative Report of the final LCA values
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 47
The following digrams were produced in Excel and they can automatically updated by re-running the
Dynamo script. The new values are overwritting the older ones and therefore the designers can get an
updated version of the diagrams, that will allow them to compare and evaluate the different solutions.
Figure 20 - GWP Charts for each of the three variations
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 48
4.3. Summary
This chapter was focused on the practical examination and development of a set of scripts that would
allow the deisngers throught a arametric schema to compute faster and easier sets of repetitite and
complex calculations such as those that the LCA requires. In addition, this workflow creates a dialogue
between the deisnger and the computer, which by providing a feedback in form of calculations and
diagrams gives the possibility to the deisngers to un derstand the impact of their decisions and giving
them the possibility to optimize their design till they will arrive to a satisfactory solution.
In the first part, there was presented the architectural office with which this research has been developed
with. In addition, there was described the design metholody and philosophy of the office with focus on
the collaborative aspects. Later, there has been presented the case study, its design strategy and goals.
In the second part of this chapter, there has been discussed the methodology and workflow that has been
followed. More precisly, there has been presented the system map with the description of the main
process schema, as well the map of the different steps that have been followed. Later, there has been
discussed more precisly the external database that has been used, followed by a step-by-step description
of the workflow and of the design variations. In addition, there has been described the Dynamo scripts.
At the end, the final reports with the calculations, together with comparative diagrams has been
presented.
The overall goal of this research is to see how the computer as a tool can be part of a collaborative
dialogue between the designers or-and other human and non human actors. In this sense, the use of
computer according to (Alexander, 1976) is to examine a much larger range of alternatives than a
designer would have the time or patience or insight to examine. It should be underlined, that the
evaluation and the decision making that this comparative evaluation of different variations cannot be
made by the computer. According to (Rittel, 2010),
...it is easily seen that design in the sense of forming judgments can never be simulated
by a computer, because in order to program that machine you would have to anticipate
all potential solutions and make all possible deontic judgments ahead of time before the
machine could run. But if you did all that you wouldn't need the computer because you
would have had to have thought up all solutions ahead of time. Therefore it is almost
ridiculous to claim that there will be a designing machine if design is thought of in this
sense.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 49
5. CONCLUSIONS
The purpose of this thesis was to bring under the same roof the disciplines of architecture, design
research and BIM. Those disciplines complement each other, and their processes and methods are using
the same line of thought and similar structures. In addition, the scope of the thesis was to create a
workflow which is considering the ways in which designers and architects work inside the BIM
environment. In that way, the process of knowledge production and dissemination is following the
advancements and novelties and new tools that technology offers, as a drive towards innovation in
architecture. This recognises the evolutionary transformation processes in architecture since its origin.
Architecture and material culture in general are the external manifestations of knowledge, which is
produced by and for a certain place and time in history. The knowledge and the processes out of which
the object had been created and constructed reside inside the material object itself. Accordingly, in this
project is has been explained how a new digital process and a parametric tool can infuse the production
of architecture.
This project started by the definition of how architects and designers work and the nature of the problems
they are dealing with. On the main problems that architecture and humanity is facing nowadays is the
consumption of natural resources, the rise of the temperature and population. Those problems are
defined as wicked problems and in order to provide solutions it is necessary to analyse the different
implications of the problem from different perspectives. In addition, problems of such complexity
require different methods and tools in order to be able to provide better solutions in shorter time. Digital
and computational tools can provide the platform where designers and architects design, and BIM is
very much based on this idea.
Another crucial aspect of complex problem-solving is collaboration. Collaboration requires the active
participation and involvement of different stakeholders. During the collaboration process, all
participants need to present their subjective views in a dialectic fashion. Collaborative practices are
based on the respect and recognition of the contribution of each member. As explained in the chapter
three, BIM is built around those principles and uses standards and data structures that can facilitate the
collaborative practices and to compute, store, share and exchange big amounts of information. In
addition, it has been discussed that the digital tools are useful, and they can be more profitable when the
designers know the reason why they are using them.
Digital tools allow to designers and participants to compute faster complex information in order to
evaluate and decide which solution is better. Digital tools therefore create a dialogue between the
designer and the computer, by providing a feedback loop. This allows the designers to reflect and
provide new inputs in their processes. This circular-causality feedback loop is of great importance during
the design stage because it helps the designers to arrive to optimal solutions by a continuous re
elaboration and optimization of their design.
For the purpose of this research, it had been chosen the examination of how a development of a dynamic
and open system in BIM can facilitate and inform the decision making during the design stage. To this
end, the dynamic calculation of the LCA in BIM environment had been chosen, since the LCA according
to the author presents a complex sets of data calculation, which in order to be developed it need the
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 50
collaboration of different participants such as energy and environmental planning experts, building
physics experts et cetera.
During this research, it was developed a dynamic script by using the visual programming language tool
Dynamo inside Revit software. These tools allow the designers by setting a set of parameters in the
model to obtain automatic calculations of the environmental impact of the materials that have been used
in their design. In addition, this system produces and automated report in an open format, in which a set
of charts are created in order to allow the designers to evaluate the different solutions. The reports and
charts are automatically updated when the LCA values in the model are changed. Lastly, this tool can
be applied also for other kinds of calculations such as the integration of Life Cycle Cost (LCC) analysis
or others. The development of this tool, creates an open system in which the designers can have a holistic
view of their design, while at the same time the dynamic feedback provides them the quantitative data
in order to evaluate their design, by combining the qualitative data of the space that their design
produces.
By providing dynamic tools, the designers can save both time and money, while at the same time they
can invest their time and creativity in a research to provide alternative solutions that have a better
performance. In addition, digital tools embedded in the BIM environment, enhance the collaboration
between different stakeholders while at the same time it creates a common place in which information
is stored, retrieved, exchanged and shared.
The main challenges during this project were firstly the short time in which this research should be
developed and concluded. In addition, the experience of working from home was a decisive factor which
slowed further the development of this project.
This research can be further developed by implementing as mentioned above together with the LCA
data, other sources of analysis. It is worth to further examine the introduction both of qualitative and
quantitative information inside the model and test it in a real case example. In addition, the workflow
can be further optimized by including automated methods of the material mapping between the external
database and the Revit native material library.
As closing remark, it is important to mention about the “dangers” of the digital tools in the field of
architecture. Those dangers are caused by the misuse of the tools and the purposes that they fulfil. It
should be clearly stated that despite the development of machine learning and artificial intelligence, the
role of the designer is still actual and of great importance. This role can not be substituted by
technological tools, since involved a plethora of data that are unique and present in each individual,
including emotions, memories, intuition, ethics.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 51
6. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Journal article
Alexander, C. (1965) ‘The question of computers in design’, Landscape 14, pp. 6–8.
Ash, J. (2016) ‘Theorizing studio space: Spheres and atmospheres in a video game design studio’, Studio
Studies: Operations, Topologies and Displacements, pp. 91–104. doi: 10.4324/9781315756523.
Borrmann A., Beetz J., Koch C., Liebich T., Muhic S. (2018) Industry Foundation Classes: A
Standardized Data Model for the Vendor-Neutral Exchange of Digital Building Models. In: Borrmann
A., König M., Koch C., Beetz J. (eds) Building Information Modeling. Springer, Cham
Cavalliere, C. et al. (2019) ‘Continuous BIM-based assessment of embodied environmental impacts
throughout the design process’, Journal of Cleaner Production. Elsevier Ltd, 211, pp. 941–952. doi:
10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.11.247.
Dubberly H., Pangaro P. (2019) Cybernetics and Design: Conversations for Action. In: Fischer T.,
Herr C. (eds) Design Cybernetics. Design Research Foundations. Springer, Cham
Fischer T., Herr C.M. (2019) An Introduction to Design Cybernetics. In: Fischer T., Herr C. (eds) Design
Cybernetics. Design Research Foundations. Springer, Cham
Glanville, R. (1999) ‘Researching Design and Designing Research’, Design Issues, 15(2), p. 80. doi:
10.2307/1511844.
Hollberg, A., Genova, G. and Habert, G. (2020) ‘Evaluation of BIM-based LCA results for building
design’, Automation in Construction. Elsevier, 109(October 2019), p. 102972. doi:
10.1016/j.autcon.2019.102972.
Ilozor, B. D. and Kelly, D. J. (2012) ‘ Building Information Modeling and Integrated Project Delivery
in the Commercial Construction Industry: A Conceptual Study’, Journal of Engineering, Project, and
Production Management, 2(1), pp. 23–36. doi: 10.32738/jeppm.201201.0004.
Kylili, A. et al. (2016) ‘Integration of Building Information Modelling (BIM) and Life Cycle
Assessment (LCA) for sustainable constructions’, Journal of Sustainable Architecture and Civil
Engineering, 13(4). doi: 10.5755/j01.sace.13.4.12862.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 52
Nilsen, M. and Bohne, R. A. (2019) ‘Evaluation of BIM based LCA in early design phase (low LOD)
of buildings’, IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 323(1). doi: 10.1088/1755-
1315/323/1/012119.
Østergård, T., Jensen, R. L. and Maagaard, S. E. (2016) ‘Building simulations supporting decision
making in early design - A review’, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 61, pp. 187–201. doi:
10.1016/j.rser.2016.03.045.
Pask, G. (1969) ‘The Architectural Relevance of Cyberspace’, Architectural Design, (7/6), pp. 68–77.
Rittel, H. W. J. (2010) ‘On the planning crisis systems analysis of the first and second generations’, The
Universe of Design: Horst Rittel’s Theories of Design and Planning, 9780203851, pp. 151–165. doi:
10.4324/9780203851586.
Rittel, H. W. J. and Webber, M. M. (1973) ‘Dilemmas in a general theory of planning’, Policy Sciences,
4(2), pp. 155–169. doi: 10.1007/BF01405730.
Röck, M. et al. (2018) ‘LCA and BIM: Integrated Assessment and Visualization of Building Elements’
Embodied Impacts for Design Guidance in Early Stages’, Procedia CIRP. The Author(s), 69(May), pp.
218–223. doi: 10.1016/j.procir.2017.11.087.
Santos, R. et al. (2019) ‘Integration of LCA and LCC analysis within a BIM-based environment’,
Automation in Construction. Elsevier, 103(September 2018), pp. 127–149. doi:
10.1016/j.autcon.2019.02.011.
Schapke SE., Beetz J., König M., Koch C., Borrmann A. (2018) Collaborative Data Management. In:
Borrmann A., König M., Koch C., Beetz J. (eds) Building Information Modeling. Springer, Cham
Sloterdjik, P. (2015) ‘Sloterdijk , P ., & Engels-Schwarzpaul , A . -C . ( 2011 ). Architecture As an Art
of Immersion . Interstices : Journal of Architecture and Related Arts , 12 , 105-109 . ( Original work
publishe ...’, Journal of Architecture and Releated Arts, (January 2011), pp. 105–109.
Visser, W. (2011) ‘Schön : Design as a reflective practice To cite this version : HAL Id : inria-
00604634’, pp. 21–25.
Book
Cross, N. (2006) Designerly Ways of Knowing. London: Springer-Verlag. doi: 10.1007/1-84628-301-9.
Fischer, T. and Herr, C. M. (Eds. . (2019) Design Cybernetics: Navigating the New. Springer
International Publishing. Available at: https://www.springer.com/it/book/9783030185565.
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 53
Kensek, K. (2018) Building Information Modeling, Building Information Modeling. Edited by A.
Borrmann et al. Cham: Springer International Publishing. doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-92862-3.
Renn, J. (2020). The Evolution of Knowledge: Rethinking Science for the Anthropocene. Princeton;
Oxford: Princeton University Press. doi:10.2307/j.ctvdf0kpk
Sevaldson B. (2008), A System Approach to Design Learning. In Systemisches Denken und Integrales
Entwerfen / System thinking and Integral Design, ed. Achim Menges, Präsident der Hochschule für
Gestaltung Offenbach am Main, Offenbach
Conference proceedings
Herr, C. M. and Fischer, T. (2019) ‘Design cybernetics and CAAD research’, Intelligent and Informed
- Proceedings of the 24th International Conference on Computer-Aided Architectural Design Research
in Asia, CAADRIA 2019, 2, pp. 541–550.
Hollberg, A., Hildebrand, L. and Habert, G. (2018) ‘Environmental design - Lessons learned from
teaching LCA’, 6th eCAADe Regional International Symposium, pp. 65–74.
Lee, G. and Lee, J. (2019) ‘Sustainable Design Framework for the Anthropocene Preliminary research
of integrating the urban data with building information’, eCAADe 37 / SIGraDi 23, 2, pp. 561–568.
Dissertations
Genova, G. (2019) ‘Bim-Based Lca Throughout the Design Process: a Dynamic Approach’, Building
Information Modelling (BIM) in Design, Construction and Operations III, 1, pp. 45–56. doi:
10.2495/bim190051.
Liu, G. (2009) ‘Integration of LCA and LCC for decision making in sustainable building industry’,
Chalmers University of Technology, (Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering), p. 35.
Hollberg, A. (2016) ‘A parametric method for building design optimization based on Life Cycle
Assessment’, (August 1985). doi: 10.25643/bauhaus-universitaet.3800.
Sattrup, P. A. and Strømann-andersen, J. (2015) ‘architecture and engineering . Integrating daylight and
thermal performance across the urban and building scales .’
Standards
Building, E. (2010) ‘ENSLIC BUILDING Energy Saving through Promotion of Life Cycle Assessment
in Buildings GUIDELINES FOR LCA CALCULATIONS Deliverable D3 Version 2010-03-30 D3 .
How Digital Tools inform the Decision Making during the Design Process. The Case of the Environmental Planning with Life Cycle
Assessment in BIM Environment.
Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme – ERASMUS+
European Master in Building Information Modelling BIM A+ 54
1Guidelines for LCA calculations in early design phases D3 . 2Recommendations on choice of LCA
ind’.
International Organization for Standardization. (2006). ‘ISO 14064-1:2006 Greenhouse gases – Part 1:
Specification with guidance at the organization level for quantification and reporting of greenhouse
gases.’ Geneva: ISO.
Website
BBSR, Ö., 2020. ÖKOBAUDAT. [online] Oekobaudat.de. Available at:
<https://www.oekobaudat.de/en.html> [Accessed 27 June 2020].
Snohetta.com. 2020. Snøhetta. [online] Available at: <https://snohetta.com/> [Accessed 29 June
2020].