8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

1/30

_m`~ Kz|dj|3 Tfj Gasgdg`zs Mgah ljt~jja Ujfgozmb| Y`mmztg`a + Yzlmgo Fjbmtf + Omgkbtj+ badZ|lba Y``| ga Gadgb

lw3 Bazkgtb \`wof`~dfz|w- Ojat|j e`| _ogjaoj bad Jaug|`akjat2

Lbohn|`zad Ybyj| e`| O`aej|jaoj `a tfj ,Tfj Jaug|`akjats `e tfj Y``|- Bsgba Djujm`ykjatLbah-

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

2/30

ezkj gs tfj fgnfjst e`| y``| ~f` mguj om`sj| t` tfj |`bds! Zae`|tzabtjmw- fjbmtf o`sts `e tfj y``|~fgof `etja |jkbga zadj|jstgkbtjd dzj t` tfjg| m`~j| ~gmmganajss t` ybw- ebgms t` d|guj yzlmgoy`mgow `a jkgssg`as |jnzmbtg`as! Tjofa`m`nw bad ezjm rzbmgtw |`bdkby ~gmm fbuj t` lj boojmj|btjdt` kbhj b yb|bdgnk sfget! Ogtgjs ~gmm bms` ajjd o`ky`sgtj ga+zsj jkgssg`as kbabnjkjat t`|jdzoj y`mmztg`a! Tbv y`mgogjs ajjd t` |jdgst|glztj |js`z|ojs t` kjjt tfgs o`st `e tfgs t|basgtg`a e`|o`kk`a n``d! Tfgs gs yb|tgozmb|mw gky`|tbat bs tfj sogjaoj gs gao|jbsganmw djo`dgan tfj mgahbnjljt~jja ~b|kgan bad jafbaojkjat `e yzlmgo fjbmtf gkybots `e m`obm bg| y`mmztg`a! K`|j ~b|kgan~gmm ez|tfj| jafbaoj tfj yzlmgo fjbmtf gkybots bad kbhj y``| k`|j uzmaj|blmj! Gatj|mgahgan `en`bms `e yzlmgo fjbmtf bad omgkbtj kgtgnbtg`a bad tfj o`+ljajegt e|bkj~`|h e`| kgtgnbtg`a obajasz|j |jdzotg`a ga l`tf fjbt t|byygan nbsjs bs ~jmm bs mgej tf|jbtjagan ezkjs!

Kbgast|jbkgan `e t|basy`|tbtg`a k`djs `e z|lba y``| oba sobmj zy s`mztg`as e`| tfj z|lbakbc`|gtw3 Lw

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

3/30

ob|s `| bmm`~s fgddja szlsgdgjs t` tfj ob| `~aj|s ga tj|ks `e e|jj yb|hgan `| yb|hgan e`| bygttbaoj- zsj `e szlsgdgjd dgjsjm jto- o|jbtj yj|uj|sj gaojatgujs e`| ob| `~aj|sfgy bad zsbnj!Tfj jkgssg`as bad fjbmtf o`st gkybot `e tfjsj gaojatgujs b|j a`t gaomzdjd ga yzlmgo y`mgow!

Gaomzsguj ymbaagan e`| szstbgablmj k`lgmgtw gs k`|j o`st jeejotguj tfba sy|b~m bad fgnf+jadt|basy`|tbtg`a lbsjd ymbaagan3 Boo`|dgan t` ba jstgkbtj lw tfj Abtg`abm T|basy`|t Djujm`ykjatO`kkgttjj `a z|lba t|basy`|t/|bgm t|basy`|t- tfj gaujstkjat ajjdjd e`| b z|lba sy|b~m lbsjdsojab|g` ga Gadgb tfbt ~gmm ajjd k`|j |`bd bad |bgm t|basy`|t gs stbnnj|gan tfj gaujstkjat|jrzg|jkjat oba lj ga tfj |banj `e \s ?5-59-999 o|`|j &Z_D 62?!: lgmmg`a'`uj| tfj ajvt

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

4/30

ubnb|gjs `a t|basy`|tbtg`a swstjks bad boojss- `ytg`as e`| djsgna bdbytbtg`a bad y`tjatgbm o`sts!Tfgs ~gmm |jrzg|j sybtgbm ymbaagan `e tfj ogtw jsyjogbmmw tfj y``| ajgnfl`z`z|f``ds tfbt b|j `etjam`obtjd ga m`~ mwgan b|jbs tfbt b|j szlcjot t` ~btj| m`nngan bad em``dgan! A`a+k`t |gsjdgae|bst|zotz|j gs `etja ljst szgtjd e`| boojss t` tfj uzmaj|blmj b|jbs! T|basy`|t o`aajotgugtw ~gmmfbuj t` lj djsgnajd e`| rzgoh jubozbtg`a dz|gan jvt|jkj omgkbtgo jygs`djs! Yzlmgo t|basy`|tswstjks bad tfj |`bd gae|bst|zotz|j ~gmm fbuj t` lj |jsgmgjat! Tfjsj djsgna o`aoj|as ~gmm fbuj t`lj gatjn|btjd ~gtf tfj z|lba djsgna nzgdjmgajs ga ogtgjs!

Ajjd |`bdkby e`| gaomzsguj ymbaagan3 Ogtgjs ajjd t` mjuj|bnj tfjg| o`ky|jfjasguj k`lgmgtw ymbasbad omjba bg| ymbas t` sjt tgkj l`zad tb|njts e`| gky|`ugan k`dbm sfb|j `e ~bmhgan- owomgan badlzs t|basy`|t8 kjjt omjba bg| tb|njts8 gaomzsguj mbad zsj ymbas t` l|gan f`kjs bad c`ls om`sj| t`|jdzoj t|bujm dgstbaojs- mjbye|`n tjofa`m`nw t` kbhj b yb|bdgnk sfget bad ozt jkgssg`as bts`z|oj8 fblgtbt bad sfjmtj| y`mgogjs sf`zmd hjjy y``| ~gtfga tfj ogtw8 gaujstkjat y`mgogjs sf`zmdebu`z| AKT gae|bst|zotz|j bad ajt~`|h8 t|bujm djkbad kbabnjkjat t` |jst|bgat ob| zsbnj- badjasz|j omgkbtj y|``egan `e t|basy`|tbtg`a gae|bst|zotz|j!

^gtf gaomzsguj ymbaagan tfj ogtgjs oba ljajegt ja`|k`zsmw e|`k |jdzojd bg| y`mmztg`a- m`~j| fjbmtfbad NFN o`sts- o`anjstg`a o`sts bad yb|hgan szlsgdw- |jdzojd o`sts `e |`bd o`ast|zotg`a badjafbaojd y|`yj|tw ubmzjs dzj t` gky|`ujd mgublgmgtw! Jo`a`kgo jeegogjaow `e ogtgjs bad ~jmm+ljgan`e z|lba gafblgtbats b|j dg|jotmw gaemzjaojd lw tfj ybttj|a `e k`lgmgtw!

T|basy`|t bad bg| y`mmztg`a jvyj|ts fbuj czst bl`zt ljnza t` gaujstgnbtj tfj mgah ljt~jja z|lbay``| t|basy`|tbtg`a yzlmgo fjbmtf bad omgkbtj! Tfj|j gs uj|w mgttmj gae`|kbtg`a ga Gadgb `a tfgs!F`~juj|- tfgs |bygd |jugj~ `e tfj jvgstgan gae`|kbtg`a ga Gadgb fjmys t` gdjatgew tfj o`at`z| `e tfgsofbmmjanj!

2 Z\LBAGSBTG@A- Y@@\- YZLMGO FJBMTF- BAD OMGKBTJ OFBANJ GA GADGB

Gadgb ajjds t` lj `a fgnf bmj|t bs djn|bdgan bg| rzbmgtw bad ~`|sjagan `e omgkbtj gkybots kbhjtfj z|lba y``| k`|j uzmaj|blmj! Z|lba y`uj|tw ga Gadgb |jkbgas fgnf bt yj|ojat bs jstgkbtjdlw tfj Ymbaagan O`kkgssg`a ga ?+>4 t` 276?+64- t` 9!52 yj|ojatbnj y`gats e|`k 277?+74 t`

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

5/30

2? ogtgjs ~gtf k`|j tfba e`z| kgmmg`a- bad sgv kjnb ogtgjs ~gtf k`|j tfba 29 kgmmg`a! Tfj kgddmj|zan ogtgjs b|j n|`~gan ebstj| tfba lgn kjt|`s t`dbw!

Ga ebot- ogtgjs lgn ga sobmj bad djasgtw kbhj y`mmztg`a o`at|`m bad yzlmgo t|basy`|t k`|j jeegogjat! Gtgs tfj|je`|j y`ssglmj t` mjuj|bnj tfbt `yy`|tzagtw ga Gadgba ogtgjs! Lzt tfj jeegogjaow nbgas oba ljmgkgtjd ga Gadgba ogtgjs dzj t` y``| z|lba n`uj|abaoj! _kbmmj| ogtgjs ~gtf kzof m`~j| k`t`|gsbtg`aajjd y|jujatguj st|btjngjs! A`ajtfjmjss- bmm ogtgjs eboj tfj o`kk`a ofbmmjanj `e jrzgtw lbsjd

gaomzsguj ymbaagan bad n|`~tf!

Nm`lbmmw- e`ozs `a ogtgjs gs njttgan sfb|yj| kbgamw ljobzsj jaj|nw djkbad gs jvyjotjd t` n|`~k`|j |bygdmw ga ogtgjs dzj t` n|`~tf ga z|lba y`yzmbtg`a- mgejstwmj ofbanjs- bad gao|jbsj ga tfjmjujm `e jo`a`kgo botgugtgjs! Tfj ^`|md Jaj|nw @ztm``h

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

6/30

N|byf

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

7/30

t|basy`|t jaj|nw zsj ~gmm gao|jbsj sgv tgkjs lw

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

8/30

\jugj~ `e fjbmtf gkybot stzdgjs ob||gjd `zt ga Bsgb bad Gadgb ob||gjd `zt lw tfj Fjbmtf JeejotGastgtztj- fbs sf`~a tfbt tfj jeejots b|j bs mjtfbm fj|j bs ga tfj gadzst|gbmgjd o`zat|gjs! Lztsogjatgsts bms` ~b|a tfbt tfj jeejots o`zmd lj juja k`|j sjuj|j ge tfj stzdgjs boo`zat e`| y`uj|twbad kbmazt|gtg`a tfbt ez|tfj| k`dgew tfj jeejot `e y`mmztg`a `a fjbmtf jsyjogbmmw ga `z| ogtgjs ~gtfjvojytg`abmmw fgnf mjujms `e y`mmztg`a bad ~gtf kzmtgymj y`mmztbats gao|jbsgan bt tfj sbkj tgkj!

Ujfgozmb| jkgssg as y`sj b syjogbm ofbmmjanj bs ujfgomj jkgssg`as tbhj ymboj ga tfj l|jbtfgan

`aj `e yj`ymj- o`at|glztj sgnagegobatmw t` fzkba jvy`sz|j bad obzsjs sgnagegobat gao|jbsj ga|jsyg|bt`|w swkyt ks bad mzan ezaotg`a gkybg|kjat- obaoj| bad ymjtf`|b `e `tfj| bgmkjats!Y`mmztg`a o`aojat|btg`a ga `z| l|jbtfj gs ?+4 tgkjs fgnfj| tfba tfj bklgjat bg| o`aojat|btg`a! Y``|fbuj b fgnfj| y|jubmjaoj `e s`kj zadj|mwgan dgsjbsjs |jmbtjd t` bg| y`mmztg`a bad y|`vgkgtw t`|`bd~bws gao|jbsjs tfj y`tjatgbm fjbmtf jeejots! Ga tf|jj ogtgjs ^`|md Lbah |jugj~ e`zad ujfgomjso`at|glztgan ba buj|bnj :9 yj|ojat `e tfj dg|jot YK jkgssg`as bad >9 yj|ojat `e YK jvy`sz|j!Tfj

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

9/30

_`z|oj3 B|gb Tjofa`m`ngjs _B bad Mj`syfj|j _Bga o`mmbl`|btg`a ~gtf OYOL'

_`z|oj3 Ojat|bm \`bd \jsjb|of Gastgtztj

Uj|w ej~ stzdgjs fbuj ljja ob||gjd `zt ga Gadgb m``hgan syjogegobmmw gat` tfj gkybot `e bg| y`mmztg`a`a y``|! Ba bssjsskjat lw tfj Djmfg lbsjd _of``m `e ymbaagan bad B|ofgtjotz|j dz|gan

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

10/30

gao`kj mjujms bad djyjad `a y|gubtj omgagos! Gt bms` e`zad tfbt ~fja gao`kj mjujm |gsjs lw 2 yj|ojat- tfj y|`lblgmgtw `e ^TY e`| ljttj| bg| rzbmgtw bms` |gsjs lw 9!99?7 yj| ojat! Bms` kja |jsy`adk`|j y`sgtgujmw t`~b|ds gky|`ugan bg| rzbmgtw o`kyb|jd t` ~`kja! Tfzs- njadj| bad y`uj|tw mgahez|tfj| jafbaojs tfj |gsh!

_` eb| tfj `eegogbm azklj| o|zaofgan `a fjbmtf o`st `e bg| y`mmztg`a fbs |jkbgajd o`skjtgo badkgagkbmgst! Bt tfj tgkj `e djogdgan tfj Bzt` Ezjm Y mgow \`bdkby ga !62 o|`|j! Tfj stzdw dgd a`t o`asgdj| tfj o`st `e y|jkbtz|j djbtfs lzt `amw gao`kj m`ss badt|jbtkjat o`st `e y`mmztg`a+|jmbtjd sgohajssjs! Tfj|je`|j- tfj ljajegts sjjkjd m`~ o`kyb|jd t`tfj o`st `e |jegaj|w gky|`ujkjat tfbt tfj `gm o`kybagjs fbd rz`tjd! Tfj |jegaj|gjs sgaoj tfjafbuj kbgatbgajd tfbt gt fbs o`st tfjk ajb|mw \s ?9-999 ++49-999 o|`|j t` kbhj tfj |jrzgsgtjgky| ujkjat t` kjjt tfj jkgssg`as stbadb|ds |`bdkby! Ga ebot- tfgs gs tfj o`st `e sjttgan `ajkjt|` swstjk ga `aj ogtw `e Djmfg tfbt kjjts : yj|ojat `e t|bujm djkbad bad gs ljw`ad tfjbee`|dblmj |banj `e tfj y``|! Bs b stbadb|d y|botgoj- tfj o`st ljajegts jstgkbtjs b|j a`t jujagaomzdjd ga y`mgow kbhgan t` y|g`|gtgsj gaujstkjats ga Gadgb! Tfgs sojab|g` gs ga o`at|bst t` tfj Z_

~fj|j tfj Z_ JYB czstgegjd uj|w st|ganjat m`~+szmyfz| ezjms bad stbadb|ds e`| fjbuw+dztw dgjsjms`a tfj n|`zads tfbt ~fgmj tfj baazbm gaujstkjats t` njt tfj omjba ezjm ~`zmd o`st Z_ $4 lgmmg`a-tfj fjbmtf ljajegts boo`zat e`| b ~f`yygan Z_ $>9 lgmmg`a ~gtf 6-999 mgujs sbujd b wjb|!

Yzlmgo y`mgow kzst bttbof y|gkbow t` fjbmtf o`sts t` gaemzjaoj gaujstkjats ga omjba ezjm badujfgomj stbadb|ds! Abtg`a+~gdj gky|`ujkjat ga jkgssg`as stbadb|ds oba ozt jkgssg`as bt s`z|ojbad |jdzoj jvy`sz|j e`| bmm! Njttgan tfj omjbajst ujfgomjs rzgohmw y|`ugdjs tfj n|jbt fjbmtfljajegt t` tfj y``|! Ge tfj ob| `~aj|s b|j kbdj t` ybw ba bddgtg`abm bk`zat- |jegaj|gjs oba bee`|dtfj o`sts `e gky|`ujkjat! Ljajegts t` tfj y``| bad tfj z|lba kbc`|gtw czstgew gt!

Bs tfj fjbmtf o|gtj|gb ebgm t` d|guj yzlmgo y`mgow `a jkgssg`as |jnzmbtg`as tfj czdgogb|w ga Gadgb stjysga t` ju`hj tfj ezadbkjatbm y|gaogymjs tfbt djtj|kgaj tfj jaug|`akjatbm n`uj|abaoj ++ \gnft t`Mgej- tfj y|jobztg`ab|w y|gaogymj- tfj y`mmztj| ybw y|gaogymj! O`astgtztg`abm y|`ugsg`a `a |gnft t` mgejbad ~f`mjs`kj jaug|`akjat bad tfj dztw `e tfj stbtj t` |bgsj tfj mjujm `e azt|gtg`a bad stbadb|d

`e mgugan t` y|`tjot yzlmgo fjbmtf ljo`kjs tfj lbsgs `e ub|g`zs y`mmztg`a o`at|`m |jmbtjd dg|jotgujs gaGadgb! !

? F@^ N\JJA N\@^TF OBA LJJAEGT TFJ K@LGMGTW @E Z\LBA Y@@\ GA GADGB

N|jja n|`~tf |jrzg|js kbgast|jbkgan `e tfj ajjds `e tfj y``| a`t `amw t` jafbaoj tfj o`yganobybogtw `e tfj y``| ga tfj ofbangan omgkbtj lzt bms` e`| jeejotguj kgtgnbtg`a! Yzlmgo y`mgow ~gmmfbuj t` bdd|jss zye|`at obygtbm o`sts t` yfbsj ga m`~ y`mmztgan bad m`~ ob|l`a ujfgomj tjofa`m`nw8jasz|j kbssguj |j`|gjatbtg`a `e tfj t|basy`|tbtg`a y`mgogjs t` gatjn|btj tfj y|gaogymjs `e gaomzsgujn|`~tf8 bad- kbgast|jbk ob|l`a ajzt|bm k`lgmgtw ybttj|a `e tfj y``| ga tfj mbad+zsj ymbaagan!

Z|lba y` | bad omjba ujfgomj tjofa`m`nw t` |jdzoj yj|s`abm jvy`sz|j3 Yzlmgo fjbmtf

sjoz|gtw ga ogtgjs djkbads b st|ganjat |`bdkby e`| ujfgomj tjofa`m`nw bad ezjm rzbmgtw! _m`~tjofa`m`nw t|basgtg`a gs y|jujatgan |bygd ozt ga jkgssg`as bt s`z|oj t` |jdzoj jvy`sz|j! Babssjsskjat `e tfj owomj gaomzsguj y`mgow lw tfj NTS sf`~s tfbt tf`sj ~f` owomj b|j jvy`sjd t`szlstbatgbmmw fgnfj| d`j `e t`vgo ljajaj bad yb|tgozmbtjs! Tfgs djkbads d|bstgo ozt gajkgssg`as bt s`z|oj!

Eguj t` tja wjb| mbn ga jkgssg`as stbadb|ds bad zao`at|`mmjd dgjsjmgbtg`a ~gtf`zt omjba dgjsjmoba bnn|bubtj yzlmgo fjbmtf gkybots `e k`t`|gbtg`a ga Gadgb! Jvym`sguj ujfgomj azklj|s s~bkytfj jeejot `e skbmm gao|jkjatbm stjys ga gky|`ugan jkgssg as stbadb|ds! Tfj sobmgan zy `e

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

11/30

gaujstkjats ga tfj bzt`k`lgmj bad tfj |jegaj|w sjot`|s ga y`st !: tgkjs fgnfj|! &_jj n|byf : g+ggg3O`kyb|btguj jkgssg`as ebot`|s e`| Jz|` GGG dgjsjm bad yjt|`m ob|s ga Gadgb'! Bms` zadj| tfj omgkbtjdjlbtj tfj e`ozs `a tfj ~b|kgan jeejot `e lmboh ob|l`a oba yzsf dgjsjm d`~a `a tfj y|g`|gtwsobmj!

N|byf :3 O`kyb|btguj jkgssg`as ebot`|s e`| Jz|` GGG dgjsjm bad yjt|`m ob|s ga Gadgb

g! YK jkgssg`as3 Jz|` GGG dgjsjm ob| jkgts >!: tgkjs k`|j YK tfba yjt|`m ob|s

gg! A@v jkgssg`as3 Jz|` GGG dgjsjm ob| jkgts ? tgkjs k`|j A@v tfba yjt|`m ob|sgg! A@v jkgssg`as3 Jz|` GGG dgjsjm ob| jkgts ? tgkjs k`|j A@v tfba yjt|`m ob|s

ggg! T`tbm t`vgos jkgssg`as3 Jz|` GGG dgjsjm ob| jkgts ajb|mw > tgkjs k`|j bg| t`vgosggg! T`tbm t`vgos jkgssg`as3 Jz|` GGG dgjsjm ob| jkgts ajb|mw > tgkjs k`|j bg| t`vgos

gu! O@< jkgssg`as3 Jz|` GGG dgjsjm ob| jkgts ajb|mw 2!< tgkjs mjss ob|l`a dg`vgdjsgu! O@< jkgssg`as3 Jz|` GGG dgjsjm ob| jkgts ajb|mw 2!< tgkjs mjss ob|l`a dg`vgdjs

9!

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

12/30

_`z|oj33 B\BG - D|bet |jy`|t `a Jkgssg`a Ebot`| djujm`ykjat e`| Gadgba Ujfgomjs bs b yb|t`e Bklgjat Bg| Rzbmgtw K`agt`|gan bad Jkgssg`a _`z|oj Byy`|tg`akjat _tzdgjs- Yzaj

Dgjsjm jvfbzst bms` |bgsjs o`aoj|as `uj| o`kkzagtgjs ga om`sj y|`vgkgtw t` kbc`| e|jgnft |`ztjs

~f` b|j ebogan b dgsy|`y`|tg`abtj lz|dja `e tfj fjbmtf |gshs! Z|lba sy|b~m bad |jm`obtg`as `esmzks t` tfj z|lba yj|gyfj|w bad `a fgnf~bws gs mghjmw t` o`atgazj! Tfj jvybasg`a `e fgnf t|beego|`bd~bws ~gmm gao|jbsj fjbmtf o`aoj|as |jmbtjd t` y`yzmbtg`a jvy`sz|js t` fgnf~bw t|beegojvfbzst! Tfgs |jrzg|js dgjsjm |gsh |jdzotg`a st|btjngjs bs ~jmm bs sybtgbm ymbaagan e`| m`~ gao`kjsjttmjkjats!

Gt gs g|`agobm tfbt djsygtj tfj ja`|k`zs yzlmgo fjbmtf o`sts `e dgjsjm- tfj n`uj|akjat gs ~gmmganmwgaoz||gan fznj |jujazj m`ssjs dzj t` dgjsjmgsbtg`a `e tfj ob| emjjt ~gtf`zt sjttgan omjba dgjsjmljaofkb|h e`| tfj ujfgomj gadzst|w! Tfj n`uj|akjat bls`|ls o`m`ssbm |jujazj m`ssjs `a boo`zat`e tfgs mzvz|w o`aszkytg`a `e dgjsjm ~fgmj tfj y``| yj`ymj b|j kbdj t` ljb| tfj dgsy|`y`|tg`abtjlz|dja `e gts fjbmtf o`sts! Tfj Zag`a n`uj|akjat jb|as k`|j jvogsj |jujazj e|`k juj|w mgt|j `eyjt|`m zsjd lw b yjt|`m ob| o`kyb|jd t` b mgt|j `e dgjsjm zsjd lw b dgjsjm ob|! Ofjby dgjsjm bms`gadzojs k`|j t|bujm bad tfj|je`|j k`|j jkgssg`as! Z|njat stjys b|j ajjdjd t` |btg`abmgsjtbvbtg`a y`mgow t` |jk`uj gaojatgujs e`| dgjsjm ob|s bad ozt t`vgo |gshs!

Tjofa`m`nw e`| o`+ljajegts3 Mghj dgjsjm bmm tjofa`m`nw sjnkjats ~gmm ajjd b |`bdkby t` kjjttfj o`klgajd n`bms `e yzlmgo fjbmtf bad omgkbtj kgtgnbtg a! E`| gastbaoj- b sjotg`a `e tfj m`~gao`kj n|`zys zsj k`t`|gjd t~`+~fjjmj|s tfbt fbuj tfj skbmmjst ob|l`a e``ty|gat &b twygobm t~`+~fjjmj| fbs bofgjujd 59+>9 hk/mgt|j' bk`anst tfj k`t`|gsjd ujfgomjs dzj t` tfjg| uj|w fgnf ezjmjeegogjaow! Tfgs ga ebot fjmys t` hjjy tfj `yj|btg`abm o`sts `e tfj t~`+~fjjmj| t` bs m`~ bs \j 2yj| hk! Lzt tfjsj ujfgomjs oba bms` lj rzgtj y`mmztgan! Tfj jkgssg`as dbtb e|`k tfj Bzt`k`tguj\jsjb|of Bss`ogbtg`a `e Gadgb sf`~s tfbt b aj~ t~`+~fjjmj| oba jkgt k`|j m`obm bg| y`mmztbattfba b aj~ ob|! Tfj ofbmmjanj tfj|je`|j gs t` yzsf tfgs tjofa`m`nw t` gky|`uj ez|tfj| t` kbvgkgjl`tf jkgssg`as bad jaj|nw nbgas ga ba bee`|dblmj kbaaj|!

_gkgmb|mw- tfj abtz|bm nbs ujfgomj y|`n|bkkj ga Gadgba ogtgjs fbs y|`ugdjd tfj `yy`|tzagtw t`|jdzoj tfj `uj|bmm t`vgo |gshs &Tblmj8 2 O`kyb|btguj jkgssg`as `e Gadgba dgjsjm bad OAN lzsjs'!Bs tfj kbgast|jbk tjofa`m`ngjs b|j tbhgan tgkj t` gky|`uj Gadgba ogtgjs fbuj `ytjd e`| ezjm

szlstgtztg`a st|btjnw t` ozt yb|tgozmbtj jkgssg`as e|`k ujfgomjs t` ajnmgnglmj mjujms! _tzdgjs ob||gjd`zt lw tfj Z_ lbsjd \js`z|ojs E`| tfj Eztz|j fbs jstblmgsfjd dg|jot bg| rzbmgtw nbgas e|`k tfgsy|`n|bkkj! _gkgmb|mw- tfj ^`|md Lbah stzdw `e

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

13/30

Jz|` GG dgjsjm lzs `a ?:9yyk szmyfz| ezjm ( D@O

9!5: 9!2: :!6: 9!22>55!2

Jz|` GG dgjsjm lzs `a :9yyk szmyfz| ezjm ( O\T

2!4< 9!94 2?!:6 9!997>62!?6

Jz| GG OAN lzs (tf|jj~bw obtbmwtgo o`auj|tj|

?!26 2!4:: :!?: 9!995:>4

_`z|oj3 _`z|oj3 Tfj Jaj|nw bad \js`z|ojs Gastgtztj- -:99 lb||jms `e `gm ~gmm lj o`aszkjd baazbmmw lwtf`sj 29 yj| ojat mb|nj ujfgomj sbmjs! Tfgs gs zaboojytblmj o`st `a boo`zat `e mzvz|wo`aszkytg`a! Tfj ujfgomj tjofa`m`ngjs kzst lj d|guja lw st|ganjat ezjm jo`a`kw |jnzmbtg`as bad|jst|bgats t` kbvgkgj ezjm sbugans t` o|jbtj syboj e`| bee`|dblmj yzlmgo t|basy`|t!

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

14/30

N|byf >3 Ob| kb|hjt sfgets stjbdgmw t`~b|ds lgnnj| ob|s

Kbgast|jbkgan szstbgablmj k`djs `e tfj z|lba y``| e`| kgtgnbtg`a3 Juja t`dbw tfj lbsjmgajga Gadgba ogtgjs |jemjots szlstbatgbm zsj `e yzlmgo t|basy`|t- a`a+k`t`|gsjd t|basy`|t- yb|b+t|basgtbad ~bmhgan! Bl`zt ?9 t` 59 yj| ojat `e bmm t|gys ga `z| ogtgjs b|j ob|l`a ajzt|bm kbgamw ljobzsjtfjsj b|j owomgan bad ~bmhgan t|gys! Tfj sfb|j `e tfjsj t|gys gao|jbsjs ga skbmmj| ogtgjs! Tfj a`ak`t |gjd t|basy`|t fbs b sfb|j `e bl`zt ?9 yj|ojat ga ogtgjs ~gtf k`|j tfba `aj kgmmg`ay`yzmbtg`as- ~fgof gao|jbsjs t` ajb|mw 59 yj|ojat ga skbmmj| ogtgjs &sjj N|byf 63 Ybttj|a `e z|lba

k`lgmgtw'!! Tfj sfb|j `e yzlmgo t|basy`|t gs k`|j tfba 49 yj|ojat ga ogtgjs ~gtf k`|j tfba : kgmmg`ay`yzmbtg`a &k`stmw `|nbagjd lzs swstjks' bad bl`zt 29+

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

15/30

_`z|oj3 N Tg~b|g

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

16/30

y``| bad tfj z|lba kbc`|gtw! Tfgs t|jad ~gmm fbuj t` lj |juj|sjd t` ozt jkgssg`as ez|tfj|! Lzttfj|j b|j y`mgow l`ttmjajohs! Juja tf`znf y`mgogjs b|j bd`ytgan tfj y|gaogymjs `e szstbgablmjk`lgmgtw tfj|j b|j gafj|jat o`at|bdgotg`as tfbt kbw ~`|h bnbgast tfj gatj|jst `e tfj y``|!

T|basy`|t gae|bst|zotz|j gaujstkjats kb|ngabmggan tfj y``|3 T|basy`|t y`mgow gs njb|jdt`~b|ds k`t`|gjd t|basy`|t bad yzlmgo ezad gs tgjd t` gt! Y``| b|j y`mgtgobmmw ~jbh t` gaemzjaoj tfjgaujstkjat djogsg`as t` y|`tjot tfjg| ~bmh~bws bad owomj ybtfs bad m`~ o`sts yb|b+t|basgt! Ga

ogtgjs mghj Yzaj bad Ofjaabg |`bd gae|bst|zotz|j o`atgazjs t` f`n bttjatg`a gastjbd `e yzlmgot|basy`|t bad AKT gae|bst|zotz|j &_jj N|byf 293 Yj|ojatbnj l|jbhzy `e obygtbm jvyjadgtz|j gat|basy`|t'! Tfj t|basy`|tbtg`a |jngkj gs ljo`kgan gao|jbsganmw gagrzgt`zs! Ogtgjs b|j ljgan lzgmt e`|tfj ob| `~agan kga`|gtw!

N|byf 293 Yj|ojatbnj l|jbhzy e obygtbm jvyjadgtz|j ga t|basy`|t

_`z|oj3 T\GYY

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

17/30

Yj|ojatbnj bmm`obtg`a t` T|bas

2:!25

27!2?

24!62

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

18/30

gao|jbsjd lzs eb|js szoojssgujmw tfbt tbhjs lzs |gdj|sfgy ljw`ad tfj bee`|dblmj |banj `e kbawzsj|s! Tfj|j gs b ajjd e`| b yzlmgo y`mgow t` hjjy lzs eb|js ~gtfga tfj bee`|dblmj |banj `e tfjz|lba kbc`|gtw bad djsgna tb|njtjd szlsgdw e`| y``| bs ~jmm bs o|`ss szlsgdw e|`k fgnfj| tbvjs`a ob|s!

Ob| `~aj|s jac`w ja |k`zs fgddja szlsgdgjs ga Gadgba ogtgjs! Tfj ob|s d` a t ybwbdjrzbtjmw e`| tfj zsbnj `e |`bd syboj! Bt tfj sbkj tgkj- tfjw zsj zy jvyjasguj |jbm jstbtj e`|

yb|hgan e`| b ygttbaoj! Ge yb|hgan ofb|njs b|j bdczstjd t` |jemjot tfj o`st `e gaujstkjat `e yb|hganst|zotz|j `| tfj o`st `e |jbm jstbtj- tfja jbof ob| `~aj| ~`zmd fbuj t` ybw sjuj|bm tgkjs `uj| tfjoz||jat |btjs! E`| gastbaoj- ga Djmfg ge yb|hgan ofb|njs b|j egvjd t` |jemjot tfj o`st `e gaujstkjat `eyb|hgan st|zotz|j ga tfj b|jb n`uj|ajd lw tfj Aj~ Djmfg Kzagogybm O`zaogm- tfja jbof ob| `~aj|~`zmd fbuj t` ybw b kgagkzk `e \s ?9 t` \s 49 yj| yb|hgan syboj yj| f`z|! Tfgs oba bms` ~`|hjeejotgujmw bs b t|bujm djkbad kbabnjkjat kjbsz|j! Gastjbd oz||jatmw- tfj yb|hgan ofb|njs b|j\s 29 yj| f`z|! Tfgs gs b szlsgdw e`| yb|hgan!

Ob| yb|hgan gs o`kyjtgan e`| yzlmgo syboj! Gt gs g|`agobm tfbt b ob| gs bmm`ttjd

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

19/30

ujfgomj lbdnj bad skb|t ob|ds8 NY_ o`aajotgugtw t` gky|`uj tfj kjtj|s bad o`kymgbaoj8 Ga+zsjujfgomj egtajss bad jkgssg`a tjstgan swstjks8 bad ymbas t` gatjn|btj ~gtf kbss t|basgt swstjk!Bzt` gadzst|w gs jvyjotjd t` d` k`|j y|`dzot dguj|sgegobtg`a bad gagtgbtj tjofa`m`nw gky|`ujkjatga tfgs sjnkjat- gat|`dzojd k`djms `a omjba ezjms- OAN- MYN bad lbttj|w `yj|btjd k`djms jto!Tfgs gs ba `yy`|tzagtw t` zyn|bdj tfgs sjnkjat bad |jtbga gts bdubatbnjs! Tfgs sjnkjat fbs tfjy`tjatgbm t` hjjy tfj jkgssg`as yj| ybssjanj| ujfgomj hk m`~ bs ~jmm bs tfj ob|l`a e``t y|gatskbmm!

Tfj k`st sgnagegobat jmjkjat `e tfj yb|b t|basgt gs tfj a`a+k`t`|gsjd owomj |gohsfb~s tfbt b|j tfjkbc`| ugotgk `e tfj kgddmj ombss dgsdbga! Ga k`st ogtgjs yzlmgo y`mgogjs b|j ~`|hgan bnbgast tfjk!Ga Djmfg tfj|j ~bs b k`uj |jk`uj bmm `e tfjk! Tfj Fgnf O`z|t fbd t` gatj|ujaj t` y|jujat tfbtbad bsh e`| b owomj |gohsfb~ y`mgow! A`t `amw szof kjbsz|js dgs|zyt mgujmgf``d `e tfj y``| lzt bms`yzt bt |gsh omjba k`dj `e t|basy`|t! NTSs bssjsskjat `e tfgs gsszj ga _`ztf Bsgb sf`~s tfbt gaDfbhb tfj jvjoztguj `|dj| t` lba owomj |gohsfb~s e|`k s`kj st|jjts fbd |jdzojd tfj k`atfmwgao`kj `e tfj |gohsfb~ yzmmj|s lw bs kzof bs ?< yj| ojat bad e``d gatbhj `e tfj ebkgmgjs lw ?5yj| ojat! Bt tfj sbkj tgkj tfj t|bujm o`sts fbd gao|jbsjd lw bl`zt 7 yj| ojat! Tfgs omjb|mw sf`~stfbt tfj y`mgow ebgmz|j t` gatjn|btj tfj j|` jkgttj|s ~gtf tfj t|basy`|tbtg`a |jngkj `e tfj ogtwo|jbtjs k`|j |`bd syboj e`| tfj `gm nzmj|s bad jkgttgan ob|s!

T|basy`|t |je`|ks e`| omjba bg| bad omgkbtj kbw ez|tfj| kb|ngabmgj tfj y``|3 L`tf omjba bg|bad k`lgmgtw kbabnjkjat y`mgogjs b|j o|jbtgan y|jssz|j e`| t|basy`|t |je`|ks bad sobmgan zy `e

e`|kbm bad fgnf+jad yzlmgo t|basy`|t swstjk! Ogtgjs b|j bms` zadj| y|jssz|j t` nb|aj| |js`z|ojst` ezad tfjsj fgnf jad t|basy`|tbtg`a swstjks! Z|lba |jaj~bm kgssg`a fbs juja y|jso|gljd ~bws`e k`lgmggan |js`z|ojs tf|`znf tbvjs- tbv `a y|`yj|tw djujm`ykjat bo|`ss t|basgt |`ztjs- mbadubmzj obytz|j- bad mjuj|bngan `e tfj mbad lbah bubgmblmj tf|`znf mglj|bm y|`yj|tw djujm`ykjat!Tfgs kbw fbuj sj|g`zs gkymgobtg`as e`| tfj y``| ge tfjsj stjys b|j tbhja ~gtf`zt y|`yj| |jnzmbt`|wsbejnzb|ds! Tfj|j b|j o`aoj|as tfbt fgnfj| mbad bad f`zsgan ubmzjs ~gmm mgkgt bee`|dblmj f`zsganzagts e`| m`~ gao`kj n| zys bad of| agobmmw y` | n|`zys ajb| t|basgt8 bad y`tjatgbmmw stgemjdjujm`ykjat `e bee |dblmj `| kgvjd+gao`kj f`zsgan y| cjots! Tfgs fbs tfj |gsh `e z|lbat|basy`|tbtg`a y|`cjots ljo`kgan fjbugmw djyjadjat `a tfj |jbm jstbtj djujm`ykjat bt tfj o`st `etfj y``| bad kbw sfget e`ozs e|`k tfj `lcjotguj `e s`ogbm jrzgtw! Tfj|je`|j- |jnzmbtg`as badsbejnzb|ds kzst bttbof y|gkbow t` gaomzsg`ab|w `agan |jnzmbtg`as bad kbadbt`|w bee`|dblmjf`zsgan! @tfj|~gsj- tfj obytguj zsj|s `e yzlmgo t|basy`|t kbw lj yzsfjd `zt `e tfj `aj `egaemzjaoj bad djejbt tfj yz|y`sj `e gao|jbsgan yzlmgo t|basy`|t |gdj|sfgy!

Bm|jbdw z|lba ymbaagan gs yzsfgan tfj y``| t` tfj z|lba yj|gyfj|w bad dgs|zytgan tfjg| mgujmgf``d-gao|jbsgan t|bujm dgstbaojs bad o`sts! ! B stzdw ob||gjd `zt lw D Kbfbdjugb `e Ojat|j e`| Z|lbaJrzgtw `e OJYT zaguj|sgtw- Bfkjdblbd sf`~s tfbt gao|jbsjd dgsm`obtg`a bad |jm`obtg`a `e z|lbay``| ljobzsj `e z|lba y|`cjots gs gao|jbsgan jo`a`kgo st|jss! Tfj |jugj~ `e o`aszkytg`ajvyjadgtz|j sf`~s tfbt tfj sfb|j `e t|basy`|t o`st ga tfj f`zsjf`md lzdnjt fbs gao|jbsjdsgnagegobatmw e`| tfj l`tt`k :9 yj| ojat `e tfj y`yzmbtg`a! Tfj jvyjadgtz|j sfb|j ga jdzobtg`a badfjbmtf fbs stbnabtjd &Tblmj

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

20/30

_`z|oj3 Db|sfgag Kbfbdjugb >!77 >>!75 >7!74 >4!65Owomj ?!7: 4!99 :!55 ?! 6!>2 4!2> 2!

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

21/30

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

22/30

: Y@MGOW BAD Y@@\

Gs tfj jkj|ngan y`mgow e|bkj~`|h `a t|basy`|t- jaj|nw bad omgkbtj sjasgtguj t`~b|ds y``|0 @uj|tfj mbst ej~ wjb|s ~j fbuj sjja b ymjtf`|b `e abtg`abm y`mgogjs bdd|jssgan tfj gsszj `e t|basy`|t-omgkbtj bad jaj|nw! B oz|s`|w nmbaoj bt tfjk sf`~s tfbt tfjw fbuj ljnza t` gaomzdj y`uj|two`aoj|as!

Tfj Abtg abm Omgkbtj Botg a Ymba- tfj zkl|jmmb y`mgow t` nzgdj omgkbtj botg a ga Gadgbboha`~mjdnjs tfbt y| tjotgan tfj y` | bad uzmaj|blmj sjotg as `e tfj s`ogjtw tf| znf bagaomzsguj bad szstbgablmj djujm`ykjat st|btjnw- sjasgtguj t` omgkbtj ofbanj gs ajjdjd! Bs y``|b|j |js`z|oj y``| tfjw b|j bms` k`st uzmaj|blmj t` omgkbtj ofbanj! Tfj jgnft kgssg`as zadj|tfgs y`mgow tfbt gaomzdjs Fblgtbt Kgssg`a ~gtf yzlmgo t|basy`|t bs `aj `e gts bnjadb gs jvyjotjd t`bdd|jss tfgs!

Gatjn|btjd Jaj|nw Y`mgow

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

23/30

gaujstkjat ga owomgan bad ~bmhgan gae|bst|zotz|j! Tfj ogtgjs b|j wjt t` djk`ast|btj y`mgowsj|g`zsajss bl`zt tfj gkymjkjatbtg`a `e yjdjst|gba e|gjadmw gae|bst|zotz|j- lgowomj mbajs badyzlmgo t|basy`|t gae|bst|zotz|j bad y|g`|gtgbtg`a `e tfjsj k`djs `uj| yj|s`abm k`djs!

N|byf 2?3 _fb|j e twyj e t|basy`|tbtg`a y|`cjots ga tfj t|basy`|t sjot`| zadj| CAAZ\K

_`z|oj3 Ojat|j e`| _ogjaoj ba Jaug|`akjat

_` eb| CAAZ\K ezadgan fbs |jkbgajd fjbugmw djyjadjat `a |`bd gae|bst|zotz|j bad ga s`kjobsjs fgnf jad lzs swstjk! Tfgs fbs ajnmjotjd a`a+k`t`|gsjd t|basy`|t- bs ~jmm bs yb|b+t|basgtswstjk- kbgamw tfj gae`|kbm swstjk! Tfgs ajjds st|`an y`mgow |jo`nagtg`a bad szyy`|t! Ogtgjssf`zmd e`ozs `a djujm`ygan l`tf gts e`|kbm bad gae`|kbm k`dj `e t|basy`|tbtg`a gaomzdgan a`a+k`t`|gsjd t|basy`|tbtg`a mgahbnjs ga ba gatjn|btjd ~bw bad a`t `aj bt tfj o`st `e tfj `tfj|!

Dzj t` tfj y`mgow o`aezsg`a `uj| yb|b+t|basgt ogtgjs b|j ljngaagan t` sjj tfj o`aemgot ljt~jjae`|kbm bad gae`|kbm yzlmgo t|basy`|t swstjks bs ~jmm bs k`t`|gjd bad a`a+k`t`|gsjd t|basy`|t!Ogtgjs b|j rzgtj kgsnzgdjd bl`zt yb|b t|basgt mghj tf|jj+~fjjmj|s! Ga s`kj ogtgjs yb|b t|basgtujfgomjs b|j ljgan oz|tbgmjd `a hjw |`ztjs t` kbhj ~bw e`| tfj e`|kbm lzs swstjks! Tfgso`kyjtgtg`a e`| | bd syboj bad ybssjanj|s gs djst|zotguj! Ge tfjsj skbmm gae`|kbm swstjks b|jdjst|`wjd gt ~gmm a`t `amw dgsbdubatbnj tfj m`~ gao`kj n|`zys lzt bms` e`|oj `tfj|s t` zsjyj|s`abm ujfgomjs e`| juja sf`|t dgstbaojs bad jsobmbtj jaj|nw nzmgan bad jkgssg`as! Ogtgjsmghj Hbayz| b|j t|wgan t` |jk`uj tfj yb|b t|basgt t` kbhj ~bw e`| tfj lgn lzsjs! Lzt tfgs gs k`stgabyy|`y|gbtj ga tfj ogtw ~fj|j tfj buj|bnj dgstbaoj `e t|bujm t|gys b|j czst bl`zt :+69 yj|ojat lw

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

24/30

mjujm lzt gts gkymjkjatbtg`a |jkbgas zao``|dgabtjd bad gajeejotguj! Tfj|j b|j |zmjs e`| k`t`|gstzadj| tfj Ojat|bm K`t`| Ujfgomjs Bot t` y|jujat tfjk e|`k obzsgan boogdjats bad fb|k t`yjdjst|gbas! Tfgs Bot juja lb|s k`t`|gsts e|`k jatj|gan yjdjst|gba syboj lzt tfgs gs |b|jmwjae`|ojd! K`t`|gsts b|j mgblmj t` yzagsfblmj `eejaoj- wjt gt gs a`t jae`|ojd bs b st|`an ja`znfdjtj||jat! Jvgstgan jangajj|gan nzgdjmgajs e|`k tfj Gadgba \`bd o`an|jss b|j gabdjrzbtj bad d`a`t kjjt tfj ezmm |banj `e yjdjst|gba ajjds! Kbstj| ymbas fbuj ljnza t` gaomzdj y|`ugsg`as e`|yjdjst|gba y|`tjotg a bad yjdjst|gbagsbtg`a! Lzt tfjsj y|`ugsg`as |za yb|bmmjm t` tfj y|g`|gtwboo`|djd t` ymbaagan e`| jvtjasguj ob| ojat|go gae|bst|zotz|j! Lzt mb~s b|j e|bnkjatjd bad d` a`tbdd zy t` ba gatjn|btjd e|bkj~`|h t` y|`k`tj yjdjst|gbagsbtg`a `| y|`tjot yjdjst|gbas badyjdjst|gba |gnfts ~gtf baw djn|jj `e st|ganjaow!

Zadj| tfj CAAZ\K bmm ogtgjs ~gtf k`|j tfba b kgmmg`a y`yzmbtg`a b|j |jrzg|jd t` djujm`y tfjg||jsyjotguj ogtw djujm`ykjat ymbas &ODY' t` gdjatgew tfj gae|bst|zotz|j y|`cjots tfbt oba lj jmgnglmje`| ojat|bm bad stbtj bssgstbaoj! B oz|s`|w |jugj~ `e tfj ODYs `e s`kj ogtgjs sf`~s tfbtyjdjst|gba gae|bst|zotz|j gs ljgan ymbaajd bs yb|t `e tfj `uj|bmm |`bd gae|bst|zotz|j! Tfgs fjmys t`ofbaajmgsj ezadgan! ODYs f`~juj| ajjd t` k`uj ljw`ad e``tybtfs bm`an k`t`|gjd o`||gd`|s t`b mb|nj| ugsg`a e`| yjdjst|gbagsbtg`a ga ogtgjs mgahjd ~gtf yzlmgo t|basy`|t! Abtg`abm kbadbtj obafjmy t` obtbmwsj ogtw lbsjd botg`a!

Tfj Zag`a kgagst|w `e z|lba djujm`ykjat fbs gsszjd y`mgow og|ozmb|s bad bdugs`|gjs ga

bshgan e`| O`ky|jfjasguj K`lgmgtw Ymba ~gtf e`ozs `a k`lgmgtw `e yj`ymj bad y|g |gtw t`yjdjst|gbagsbtg`a bad yzlmgo t|basy`|t! \jmjubat mb~s ~gmm fbuj t` lj fb|k`agsjd bad o`klgajd~gtf k`|j dg|jot mjnbm y|`tjotg`a `e yjdjst|gba syboj bad |gnfts! Gadgba mb~s mboh tfgs gatjn|btjdbyy|`bof bad juja tfj y`mgow o`augotg`a tfbt yjdjst|gbagsbtg`a ~gmm |jrzg|j st|`an mjnbm lboh zybad jae`|ojkjat st|btjngjs! Yjdjst|gbas d` a`t o`zat ga tfj djogsg`a `a ~bmh syboj! J|`sg`a `eyjdjst|gba syboj d`js a`t mjbd t` baw yjabmtw `a tfj ogtw djujm`yj|s bad ymbaaj|s! Owomj DjsgnaNzgdjmgajs kzst bms` lj egabmgjd bad kbdj kbadbt`|w e`| bmm aj~ |`bd gae|bst|zotz|js ga tfj ogtw!

5 TFJ ^BW BFJBD3 F@^ B E@OZ_ @A TFJ Y@@\ OBA BM_@ FJMY BOFGJUGANEB_TJ\ TFJ O@< JKG__G@A \JDZOTG@A N@BM_

Kbgast|jbkgan y|`+y``| ymbaagan ~gmm fjmy t` sobmj zy tfj obytguj t|bujm k`djs `e tfj y``| tfbtb|j k`|j ob|l`a ajzt|bm t` tfj of`goj `e k`djs e`| bmm! Tfgs ~gmm |j`|gjat t|basy`|t gae|bst|zotz|j

bad sj|ugojs t`~b|ds m`~ ob|l`a t|basy`|t! Ga bddgtg`a t` bofgjugan jrzgtw lbsjd n|`~tf tfgs ~gmmbms` bu`gd ob|l`a m`oh zy ga tfj t|basy`|t gae|bst|zotz|j! Bt tfj sbkj tgkj jrzgtw lbsjd z|lbak`lgmgtw ~gmm jasz|j dguj|sj mgujmgf``d of`gojs e`| tfj z|lba y``|- kbhj mbl`z| kb|hjt k`|jjeegogjat bad dj |gsh y``| e|`k tfj n|`~gan zaoj|tbgatgjs ga tfj ofbangan omgkbtj! Lzt kbvgkgsganszof nbgas ~gmm |jrzg|j st|`an bad e`ozssjd yzlmgo y`mgow!

L`tf abtg`abm bad stbtj mjujm y`mgogjs `a t|basy`|tbtg`a bad omjba bg| fbuj bm|jbdw ljnza t` yzsfogtgjs t` e|bkj k`lgmgtw bad omjba bg| botg`a ymbas! _`kj ogtgjs mghj Bfkjdblbd fbuj ljnza t`djujm`y m`obm omgkbtj botg`a ymbas bs ~jmm! _`kj `e tfj ogtw omjba bg| bad k`lgmgtw botg`a ymbasgaomzdgan tfj ogtw kbstj| ymba bs tfbt `e Djmfg bad Yzaj fbuj ljnza t` gao`|y`|btj tb|njts e`| bg|y`mmztg`a |jdzotg`a bad gao|jbsj ga k`dbm sfb|j e`| yzlmgo t|basy`|t! Ogtw ymbas b|j ba `yy`|tzagtwt` y|`tjot bad jvybad tfj oz||jat sfb|j `e ~bmhgan bad owomgan- zsj `e gatj|kjdgbtj yzlmgot|basy`|t bad bee`|dblmj lzs t|basy`|t ga Gadgba ogtgjs bad tfj|j gatjn|btg a! Hjjygan tfj z|lba

e`|k o`kybot bad djasj gs o|gtgobm t` |jdzoj ujfgomjs kgmjs t|bujmjd! Bms` sfjmtj| y`mgogjs e`| tfjy``| kzst lj gatj|mgahjd ~gtf gaomzsguj mbad+zsj y`mgogjs t` |jdzoj dgstbaoj `e t|bujm!

Tfj |`bdkby e`| gaomzsguj k`lgmgtw ymbaagan

Ajjd ~bmhgan bad owomgan ogtgjs3 Tfgs ajjds |jdjujm`ykjat `e tfj ogtw o`|j- ~gtf jafbaojdlbsgo sj|ugojs bad ebogmgtgjs e`ozsgan `a tfj dgsbdubatbnjd t` bu`gd z|lba sy|b~m bad jvomzsg`a!A`a+k`t`|gsjd bad yb|b t|basgt ajt~`|h b|j k`|j o`kybtglmj ~gtf tfj djasjmw lzgmt ogtw djsgnabad e |k! Gky| ujd boojss tf|`znf sf`|t a`a+k t`|gsjd t|gys ~gmm ljajegt a t czst tfjt|basy`|tbtg`a bad m`obtg`a dgsbdubatbnjd y``| yj`ymj ga tfj ogtw lzt bms` tfj jatg|j z|lba

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

25/30

o`kkzagtw! ^bmhgan bad lghgan gae|bst|zotz|j oba jafbaoj bad bznkjat tfj |gdj|sfgy `e tfjyzlmgo t|basy`|t bs ~jmm! E`| gastbaoj- bt b nm`lbm mjujm tfj Dztof ogtgjs fbuj szoojjdjd ga sobmganzy `e tfj ~bmhgan bad owomgan gae|bst|zotz|j tfbt fbs fjmyjd t` |juj|sj tfj bzt`k`lgmjdjyjadjaow! Ga ogtgjs mghj F`ztja tfj ogtgjas zsj owomjs t~goj bs kzof tfba ob|s bs b of`goj!K`|j tfba fbme bmm ugsgts t` tfj sf`ys ga tfj ogtw ojat|j b|j kbdj lw owomjs! Gadgb ~gmm a`~ fbuj t`tb|njt t` kbhj tfj obytguj zsj `e szstbgablmj k`djs `e t|basy`|t t` tfj t|basy`|t `e of`goj!Gky|`ujd bad bee`|dblmj boojss ga ogtgjs ~gmm `eej| k`|j mgujmgf``d of`gojs- l|gan n|jbtj| jeegogjaowga tfj mbl`z| kb|hjt bad o`at|glztj t` tfj `uj|bmm ~jmmljgan `e tfj ogtgjs!

Yjdjst|gba y`mgow3 Ogtw ymbas kzst gaomzdj yjdjst|gba y`mgow t` gky|`uj boojssglgmgtw badsbejtw- bad t` kbhj ~bmh~bws ~bmhblmj- o`ke`|tblmj- dgsblmj e|gjadmw- jafbaoj bjstfjtgosbad jo m`ngobm |jnjaj|btg a `e tfj yzlmgo syboj! Tfj `uj|bmm |`bd djsgna sf`zmd bmm ~yjdjst|gbas t` fbuj tfj k`st dg|jot |`ztj! _`kj zaguj|sbm djsgna kjbsz|js kzst lj mbgdd`~a bad kzst lj bdfj|jd t`! Oz||jatmw- dguj|sj |jnzmbtg`as y|`ugdj e`| tfj yjdjst|gbas ++|je |k y|`ugsg`as zadj| tfj CAAZ\K y|`n|bkkj8 Ogtw Kbstj| Ymbas tfbt y|`ugdj e`|yjdjst|gba syboj8 kzagogybm mb~s t` y|`tjot bad kbgatbga yjdjst|gba syboj8 k`t`| ujfgomjmb~s `a sbejtw |zmjs8 Y`mgoj `a yjabmtw bad o`kymgbaoj st|btjngjs bad s` `a! Tfjsj dgsyb|btjmb~s sf`zmd lj fb|k`agjd bad st|jantfjajd e`| ba jeejotguj yjdjst|gba y`mgow ga ogtgjs! Djmfgfbs tbhja tfj mjbd t` bd`yt yjdjst|gba nzgdjmgajs tfbt b|j a`~ kbadbt`|w e`| byy|`ubm `e|`bd y|`cjots! Tfgs oba lj |jymgobtjd bo|`ss ogtgjs!

^bmhblgmgtw bad sbejtw bzdgts3 Mgah aj~ gaujstkjats ga |`bds t` st|got rzbmgtw o`at|`m badst|ganjat gkymjkjatbtg a `e tfj yjdjst|gba nzgdjmgajs! Ogtgjs ajjd j| t`mj|baoj e`|boogdjats! Tfj m`obm bztf`|gtw ~gmm fbuj t` jstblmgsf o|gtj|gb bad ljaofkb|hs e`| ~bmhblgmgtwbzdgts bad szyj|ugsj bad k`agt`| yjdjst|gba gae|bst|zotz|j lbsjd `a ljaofkb|hs! Byy|`ubmbad omjb|baoj `e bmm |`bd y| cjots sf`zmd kbhj bdfj|jaoj t` yjdjst|gba nzgdjmgajskbadbt`|w!

Owomj y`mgow3 Ogtgjs ajjd tgkj l`zad gkymjkjatbtg`a `e kbadbt`|w Owomj DjsgnaNzgdjmgajs e`| bmm aj~ |`bd gae|bst|zotz|js bad gatjn|btg`a `e a`a+k`t`|gsjd t|basy`|t ~gtfyzlmgo t|basy`|t! Gaojatgugsj owomgan ~gtf owomgan |jatbm bad sfb|gan- `a+st|jjt owomj yb|hganjsyjogbmmw ga tb|njtjd b|jbs `e fgnf zsbnj bad bms` om`sj t` yjdjst|gba `ajs bad

t|basy`|tbtg`a fzls! Y|`ugdj e`| owomjs ga tfj yb|hgan stbadb|ds e`| aj~ lzgmdgans- |jsgdjaojs-e`| m`an bad sf`|t+tj|k yb|hgan bt Kjt|` bad lzs stbtg`as- kb|hjts- yzlmgo t|basy`|tgatj|ofbanjs bad `tfj| fgnf zsbnj b|jbs! Bzdgt `e owomgan gae|bst|zotz|j bad zsbnj sf`zmd ljkbdj kbadbt`|w! B lgowomj kbstj| ymba bs y|jyb|jd e`| Djmfg sf`zmd lj |jymgobtjd ga `tfj|ogtgjs bs ~jmm!

Gatj|kjdgbtj yzlmgo t|basy`|t bad Owomj |gohsfb~ y`mgow3 Ogtgjs ajjd b y`mgow e`|yb|b t|basgt gatjn|btg`a bs ~jmm bs tfbt e`| owomj |gohsfb~s! _tzdgjs ga Gadgb szof bs tf`sjob||gjd `zt lw tfj Fbb|d Ojat|j fbuj bms` sf`~a fgnf zsbnj `e a`a+k`t`|gsjd t|basy`|t e`|gae`|kbm e|jgnft k`ujkjat bad ~bstj dgsy`sbm ga ogtgjs! Djmfg gs jvyjotjd t` o`kj zy ~gtf bowomj |gohsfb~ y`mgow s``a! Gt gs gky`|tbat t` |je`|k tfjg| djym`wkjat st|btjngjs bad zyn|bdjtfjg| sj|ugojs! Tfgs bm`an ~gtf owomjs fbs tfj y`tjatgbm t` jvybad tfj obtofkjat `e tfj yzlmgot|basy`|t k`djs bs ~jmm! Tfgs oba y|jujat n|`~tf `e jaj|nw gatjasguj t|bujm k`djs mghj ob|s!

Lzs y`mgow bad gatjn|btg`a e`| k`|j gaomzsguj ymbaagan3 Gaomzsguj ymbaagan |jrzg|js bee`|dblmjlzs sj|ugoj! ^gtf n|`~gan t|bujm dgstbaojs ga ogtgjs djyjadjaoj `e tfj y``| `a tfj lzs t|basy`|tgs n|`~gan ~fgof gs bddgan t` tfjg| t|basy`|tbtg`a o`sts! Ogtgjs b|j bms` zadj| y|jssz|j t` |je`|kbad k`dj|agj tfjg| lzs sjot`| bs b kjbas t` |jdzoj jkgssg`as! Obygtbm gaujstkjats b|jjvyjotjd t` gao|jbsj t` jvybad tfj lzs emjjt bad yfbsj ga fgnf jad tjofa`m`ngjs! Bs b |jszmt- tfjGadgba ogtgjs b|j zadj| y|jssz|j t` gao|jbsj lzs eb|js t` bznkjat |jujazj! Eb|j l`v |jujazjsb|j djtj|kgajd lw eb|j mjujm- eb|j st|zotz|j bad tfj jvtjat `e o|`ss szlsgdw! Lzt gt gs bms`boojytjd ga tfj |jbmk `e t|basy`|t ymbaagan tfbt gt gs zszbmmw a`t y`ssglmj t` kjjt tfj ezmm `yj|btgano`sts `e tfj lzs sj|ugoj e|`k tfj zsj| eb|j bs tfj eb|j tfja ~gmm fbuj t` lj sjt bt b fgnfj| mjujm

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

26/30

tfba ~fbt gs y`mgtgobmmw bad s`ogbmmw boojytblmj- bad kbw ~`|h bnbgast tfj gatj|jst `e yzlmgot|basy`|t zsbnj! Tfj|je`|j ogtgjs ajjd tb|njtjd szlsgdgjs dgso`zat |btj e`| y``| jto! bad ebg|eb|j y`mgow- t` jasz|j tfbt tfj y``| b|j a`t bduj|sjmw beejotjd! !Tbv `a ob|s sf`zmd lj |btg`abmgjdt` `ee sjt tfj o`sts!

Ajjd |jst|bgats `a ob| zsbnj t` |jdzoj y`mmztg`a bad o`anjstg`a bs ~jmm bs jasz|j k`|jjrzgtblmj dgst|glztg a e |`bd syboj!

Jae`|oj yb|hgan o`at|`ms- |btg`abmgj tbvjs `a ob|s bad kbhj ~bw e`| o`anjstg`aofb|ngan! Nm`lbmmw- ogtgjs b|j e|jjgan zy |`bd syboj e|`k ob|s! Tfjw b|j kbhgan ob| yb|hy|`fglgtguj8 bddgan fgnf y|jkgzk t` ob| `~aj|sfgy8 jvbotgan dzjs e`| jatj|gan y|gkj lzswb|jbs8 `amw bmm`~gan b e|botg`a `e tfjk `a |`bds bt b tgkj8 `| czst a`t bmm`~gan tfjk ga tfjogtw ojat|j! Tfjw b|j bms` ngugan yj`ymj k`|j `ytg`as t` ob|s! Tfgs gs bms` ajjdjd e`|k`|j jrzgtblmj dgst|glztg`a `e |`bd syboj! Yj`ymj b|j k`|j sjasgtguj t` tfj dg|jot o`st `ed|gugan bad tfgs e`|ojs tfjk t` tbhj djogsg`a t` |jdzoj ob| zsbnj bad k`uj t`bmtj|abtgujs! O`anjstg`a tbv bad n``d yzlmgo t|basy`|t fbuj fjmyjd ojat|bm M`ad`a bad_t`ohf`mk!

Mgkgt ob| gae|bst|zotz|j3 F`an H`an bad T`hw` fbuj k`|j |jst|gotjd ob| gae|bst|zotz|jga tj|ks `e ~gdj |`bds bad yb|hgan ebogmgtgjs! Juja tf`znf T`hw` fbs `aj `e tfj fgnfjstob| `~aj|sfgy ga Bsgb ?:9 ob|s yj| 2999 yj`ymj tfj sfb|j `e ob| t|gys ga T`hw` gs

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

27/30

fbuj t` ju`muj `|nbagobmmw e|`k tfgs! Ge tfj t|basgt `|gjatjd djujm ykjat y`mgogjs e`| aj~djujm`ykjat b|j a`t ymbaajd ~jmm ~gtf s`ogbm jrzgtw bs gts e`ozs gt oba fz|t tfj y``|- bad tfjz|lba kbc`|gtw!

Tfgs gsszj gs jvyjotjd t` o`kj t` tfj e`|je|`at ~gtf k`|j ogtw n`uj|akjats ymbaagan e`| obygtbmgatjasguj yzlmgo t|basy`|t swstjks! Bm|jbdw tfj CAAZ\K z|lba |je`|k y|`ojss gs yzsfgan e`|obytz|gan `e mbad ubmzj nbgas e`| yzlmgo gaujstkjat e`| obygtbm egabaogan `e kbss t|basy`|t ga `z|ogtgjs! Tfgs oba njaj|btj |jujazj zye|`at e`| mb|nj sobmj gaujstkjats bad fbs ja`|k`zs |jujazjy`tjatgbm e`| obygtbm ezadgan `e mb|nj fgnf o`st kbss t|basy`|t! F`~juj|- ogtgjs ajjd b |jnzmbt`|we|bkj~`|h t` jasz|j bdjrzbtj |jnzmbt`|w sbejnzb|ds e`| y``| ga tfj ogtw! Fgnfj| mbad bad f`zsganubmzjs njaj|bmmw tjad t` mgkgt bee`|dblmj f`zsgan zagts e`| m`~j|+gao`kj f`zsjf`mds! Tfgs fbs tfj|gsh `e z|lba t|basy`|tbtg`a y|`cjots ljo`kgan fjbugmw djyjadjat `a tfj |jbm jstbtj djujm`ykjat!Tfgs kbw sfget e`ozs e|`k tfj o`|j t|basy`|t bad s`ogbm `lcjotgujs! Tfj|je`|j- |jnzmbtg`as badsbejnzb|ds kzst bttbof y|gkbow t` tfj z|lba t|basy`|t bad s`ogbm jrzgtw o`ky`ajat! ^gtf`zt tfjsbejnzb|ds tfj obytguj zsj|s `e yzlmgo t|basy`|t kbw lj yzsfjd `zt `e tfj `aj `e gaemzjaoj baddjejbt tfj yz|y`sj `e gky|`ugan a`a+k`t`|gsjd t|basy`|t bad yzlmgo t|basy`|t |gdj|sfgy! Gt gsgky`|tbat tfbt tfj \bcgu B~bs W`cbab e`| tfj f`zsgan `e tfj y``| yj`ymj fbs bm|jbdw y|`y`sjdtfbt bt mjbst 6: yj| ojat `e tfj smzk djujm`ykjat ga ogtgjs sf`zmd lj d`aj ga+sgtz t` kgagkgjdgsm`obtg`a `e tfj y``|!

Mbad ubmzj nbgas bad `tfj| tbvjs sf`zmd lj jb|kb|hjd e`| tfj a`a+k`t`|gsjd t|basy`|tgae|bst|zotz|j bs ~jmm t` kjjt tfjg| t|basgtg`a o`sts! Ogtgjs bms` ajjd omgkbtj |jsgmgjat djsgnastbadb|ds bad z|lba ymbaagan tfbt ~gmm y|jujat sjttmjkjats jsyjogbmmw m`~ gao`kj sjttmjkjats gafgnf |gsh b|jbs jto!

Tjofa`m`nw |`bdkby bad ga+zsj jkgssg`as kbabnjkjat t` y|`tjot yzlmgo fjbmtf bad|jdzoj jaj|nw gkybots `e k`t`|gsbtg`a3 Ge ujfgomj tjofa`m`nw s`mztg`as bad gaa`ubtg`as b|jbms` kbdj k`|j sjasgtguj t` tfj syjogbm uzmaj|blgmgtw `e tfj y``| t` y`mmztjd bg| mb|nj| yzlmgo n``doba lj bofgjujd ga tj|ks `e yzlmgo fjbmtf y|`tjotg`a! Tfgs oba bms` mjbd t` jaj|nw sbugan bad dj+|gsh y``|! Tfjsj gagtgbtgujs sf`zmd bms` lj dg|jotmw mgahjd ~gtf tfj kbadbt`|w o`kymgbaoj ~gtf tfjbklgjat bg| rzbmgtw stbadb|ds!

Aj~ ujfgomjs3 Tfj Bzt` Ezjm Y`mgow ga Gadgb ajjds t` boo`zat e`| tfj fjbmtf o`st `e tfjy``| bad tfj z|lba kbc`|gtw- t` d|b~ zy b st|ganjat y`mgow `a omjba ujfgomj bad ezjms! Tfjo`zat|w a`~ ajjds t` sjt tfj tgkjmgaj e`| zage`|k gat|`dzotg`a `e Jz|` GU bad Jz|` U/UGbo|`ss tfj o`zat|w! Zatgm tfja dgso`z|bnj sfget `e mgnft dztw ujfgomjs e|`k yjt|`m t` dgjsjmbad zamjss tfj bdubaojd dgjsjm tjofa`m`ngjs b|j gat|`dzojd! Bmm aj~ dgjsjm ujfgomjs kzstlj jrzgyyjd ~gtf stbtj `e tfj b|t y`mmztg`a o`at|`ms- ~fgof gaomzdjd bdubaojd YK egmtj|sbad bdubaojd A@v betj|t|jbtkjat! Tfjsj swstjks kzst lj djsgnajd t` |jdzoj YKkbss- bad tfj azklj| `e zmt|begaj yb|tgomjs lw `uj| 79 yj|ojat! _zmez| mjujms ga bmm dgjsjmezjm sf`zmd lj |bygdmw |jdzojd t` b kbvgkzk `e 29 t` 2: yb|ts yj| kgmmg`a ga `|dj| t`|jdzoj YK jkgssg`as e|`k tfj dgjsjm emjjt bad t` kbvgkgj tfj ljajegts `e bdubaojddgjsjm tjofa`m`ngjs!

Tfj tjofa`m`nw |`bdkby kzst bms` bdd|jss tfj zagrzj ofbmmjanj `e k`t`|gjd t~`+badtf|jj ~fjjmj|s tfbt b|j bms` bk`an tfj k`dj `e t|basy`|t `e tfj m`~ gao`kj n|`zys gaogtgjs! Tfjsj b|j uj|w syboj bad jaj|nw jeegogjat ujfgomjs ~gtf `aj `e tfj skbmmjst

ob|l`a e``ty|gat bk`anst tfj k`t`|gjd ujfgomjs! Lzt tfjsj b|j stgmm a`t bk`anst tfjomjbajst bad kbw jkgt k`|j a`vg`zs m`obm bg| y`mmztbats tfba b aj~ ob|! Nguja tfjg| sfjj|azklj|s gt gs gky`|tbat t` yzsf tfgs tjofa`m`nw ~gtf k`|j st|ganjat jkgssg`as stbadb|dst` |jtbga gts jaj|nw sbugans nbgas! Tfj ofbmmjanj gs t` gky|`uj tfj tjofa`m`nw mjujms badwjt hjjy gt ~gtfga tfj bee`|dblmj |banj!

Gt gs jrzbmmw gky`|tbat t` gaomzdj tjofa`m`nw |`bdkby e`| tfj a`a+k`t`|gsjd t|basy`|t mghjtfj owomj |gohsfb~s bad lgowomjs! O`asgdj|blmj tjofa m`nw zyn|bdbtg a gs bm|jbdw

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

28/30

zadj|~bw ga Gadgb! Lzt tfgs ajjds o`ky`sgtj y`mgow t` kbhj \%D k`|j o`adzoguj bady|`+y``|!

Ga+zsj ujfgomjs3 Ogtgjs bms` ajjd b |banj `e st|btjngjs t` |jdzoj ga+zsj jkgssg`as e|`ktfj `a+|`bd emjjt t` ozt tfj t`vgo |gshs! _t|jantfja bad jvybad tfj gasyjotg`a badkbgatjabaoj st|btjngjs bad baazbm egtajss bad |`bd~`|tfgajss tjsts e`| tfj o`kkj|ogbm

ujfgomjs bad jvtjad tfgs t` tfj yj|s`abm ujfgomjs bs ~jmm3 Oz||jatmw- tfj yj|s`abm ujfgomjsb|j |jrzg|jd t` o`kj e`| tfjg| eg|st egtajss tjsts `amw betj| o`kymjtgan 2: wjb|s! Tfjjae`|ojkjat |jngkj bad tfj djsgna `e tfj jkgssg`as gasyjotg`a `e tfj ga+zsj emjjt sf`zmdlj |je`|kjd ~gtf gky|`ujd stbadb|ds- st|`an gkymjkjatbtg`a st|btjnw- rzbmgtw bzdgts- bad|jybg| ebogmgtgjs! ^jmm kbgatbgajd ujfgomjs oba bms` gky|`uj ezjm jeegogjaow `e tfj ujfgomjs!

\j|`ztgan `e tfj t|basgt t|beego b~bw e|`k tfj ogtw o`|j ~gmm lj ba gky`|tbat st|btjnw t`|jdzoj t|zoh |jmbtjd y`mmztg`a ga ogtgjs!

Gt gs stgmm y`ssglmj t` jasz|j fgnfj| emjjt tz|a`uj| ge tbvjs `a `mdj| ujfgomjs bad `mdnjaj|btg`a tjofa`m`ngjs mghj y|j+Jz|` G- Jz|` G bad Jz|` GG tjofa`m`ngjs b|j gao|jbsjdmgajb|mw ~gtf bnj! _`kj ogtgjs mghj Lbanbm`|j bad Ofjaabg fbuj ljnza t` gky`sj n|jjatbvjs `a `mdj| ob|s! Tfgs oba dgsgaojatgugsj `md ujfgomjs bad stgkzmbtj fgnfj| tz|a `uj|!

\jujazj e|`k tfgs tbv oba bms` lj zsjd e`| bznkjatbtg`a `e yzlmgo t|basy`|t ~fgof gs bagatjn|bm yb|t `e tfj m`~ ob| ob|l`a n|`~tf ybtf! Gadzst|w oba `eej| lzw lboh ybohbnj ~gtf|jdzojd |btjs jto t` tb|njtjd ob|s bad t~`+~fjjmj|s! Gadzst|w ajjd t` ljb| tfj o`st `etfgs y|`n|bkkj bs yb|t `e gts o`|y`|btj s`ogbm |jsy`asglgmgtw!

Ajjd gastgtztg`abm |je`|ks t` kbgast|jbk bad gkymjkjat gaomzsguj y`mgogjs! Gadgba ogtgjsb|j a`~ k`ugan t`~b|ds e`|kgan zagegjd t|basy`|t bztf`|gtgjs e`| k`|j gatjn|btjd ymbaaganbad gkymjkjatbtg`a! Tfgs sf`zmd jablmj bssjsskjat `e k`lgmgtw ajjds `e tfj y``| badbd`ytg`a `e y|`+y``| y`mgogjs bad st|btjngjs!

Gaomzsguj t|basy`|t zadj| tfj nm`lbm omgkbtj |jngkj3 Gadgba n`uj|akjat fbs o`kkzagobtjdtfbt gt ~gmm bgk t` u`mzatb|gmw |jdzoj tfj `uj|bmm jkgssg`as gatjasgtw `e gts NDY &jvomzdgan tfjbn|gozmtz|j sjot`|' lw

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

29/30

Bt tfj sbkj tgkj y`mgogjs ajjd t` e`ozs `a st|jantfjagan tfj |jsgmgjaoj `e tfj t|basy`|tgae|bst|zotz|j t` ejaoj tfj uzmaj|blmj y``| bnbgast jvt|jkj omgkbtgo jujats! K`lgmgtw ymbas ~gmmfbuj t` |jemjot tfjsj aj~ ofbmmjanjs bad jubmzbtj tfj gkybots `e omgkbtj ubnb|gjs `at|basy`|tbtg`a swstjks bad boojss- bad m``h bt tfj `ytg`as e`| djsgnagan bdbytbtg`a st|btjngjsbad y`tjatgbm o`sts!

8/8/2019 Slow murder How can fuel and emission systems be made more pro-poor?

30/30

\jej|jaojsB B|`|b bad Njjtbk Tg~b|g B fbadl``h e`| s`og` jo`a`kgo gkybot bssjsskjat `e eztz|j z|lbat|basy`|t y|`cjots- T|basy`|tbtg`a \jsjb|of bad Gacz|w Y|jujatg`a Y|`n|bkkj &T\GYY' Djmfg GGT

Ba`a