Surviving Fight- Books and the Historiog

8/18/2019 Surviving Fight- Books and the Historiog

1/45

!

#$%&'() !

*+),-,-./ 0-/$'12334* %.5 '$( $-*'3)-3/)%&$630 7(5-(,%8 #372%' '(#$.-9+(*

:;?@A= BCDDE?D B ;F= ?O O=>F=Q

1 !"#$%&' )*+%,#

'K ;? AEKI LG; E>;? F?>;=S;R C J=DE=J ?O AE;;A=1

T>?B> OEKK ;D=C;EJ=J OD?M ;;GDE=JQ %> C>CANJEJ ?O ;; L?JE;E?> ?O O=>FE>K J ;I E; CAJ? C;;=ML;J ;? JCA IEOO=D=>F=JR ;K M=IE=HCA ;D=C;EJ=J D=LD=J=>; C F?; CD;

?O F?M@C; ;I FGA;GD= E>;? B;J ;? C

M=IE=HCA MCD;ECA CD;R C> CD; B; GJ= ?O @?;< ; C>I ;JEH=

CDM?GD @G; BI E>;? >?;E?>J ?O >?DMC;EH= ?D EI=CAEY=I @= ;= MEAE;CDN WOEKKXR C>I ;F; CJJGML;E?>J

C@?G; ;; ?O O?DF= B=F=JJCDN C>I CLLD?LDEC;= E> C F?M@C;Q

5=JLE;= ;; CJJGML;E?>J C>I CLLAEFC;E?>J ?O L?B=DR @?;< ;DCIE;E?>J JFELA=J

;?B> C>I ;CGKJ;DC;= OCD M?D= =SL=D;EJ= C>I JTEAA1E>1CDMJ ; EJ GJGCAAN CJJGM=IR C>I ;


2/45

Z

JTEAA ;DC>JAC;=I IED=F;AN ;? FGA;GDCA F?>F=L;E?>J C@?G; ;J ;I ;J= ?O E>IEHEIGCAEJM BI==IR ; ;K OEKK ;D=C;EJ=J EJR CLCD; OD?M ;=B E>JEK;? FK ;? MN J?GDF=J[ ?DEKE>J\?>= -;CAEC> C>I ;B? /=DMC>\- O?FGJ ?> ; (GD?L=R DC>KE>K OD?M ; ;FELCAE;E=J C>I -;CAN

E> ;K ;;=S; O?D ?O ;E;E?> ?O ;I OE>CAANR ;? J ?O JGF< @??TJ MEK;? ;J

?O E>O?DMCA =IGFC;E?> ;I==IR ;TCK= ?O JTEAA ?D LD?B=JJ C>I F?>;D?A ?H=D HE?A=>F= C>I L?AE;EFCA A=KE;EMCFN MCT=J ;; ?O ;;=D=J;E>KR ?BE>K ;? ;>=F;E?> @=;B==> ;K ?O CDMJ C>I ;J= ?O E>IEHEIGCAE;N F?MM?> E> (GD?L=C> FGA;GD=J ?O ; C @D?CI JFCA=R ;>=F;E?> D=OA=F;J C>I L=D;DE@G;=J ;? ;F=L;E?> ?O ;JE?> @=;B==> ;V

=SL=DE=>F= =SCME>E>K C>I ;=CFK ;N ID=IJ ?O J;GI=>;JQ 2N I?E>K J?R -


3/45

^

BCDR D?MC>F=JR FEFA=JR EF?>?KDCLI JGDHEHE>K CD;EOCF;JQ 7N E>;=>;E?> EJ ;? ;CT= ;K =HEI=>F=

C>I GJ= ; J?

I?E>KR - J ?> B ;I B=AA E>;? ;L?BI=DQ - CAJ? CAR I=AE@=DC;=R C>I

=A=KC>; J?AG;E?>J ;? ;CA I=O=>J=Q 'J ID=E>O?DF= ;DCIE;E?>J ?O E>IEHEIGCA =ML?B=DM=>; C>I D=JL?>JE@EAE;N ;

?O E>IEHEIGCAEJM ;;? ;CEJJC>F= C>I ;;Q

->;D?IGF;E?>

*;GI=>;J ?O M=IE=HCA BCDOCD= C>I FI=DJ;C>I EFA=JR JFC;;=D=I CFF?G>;JR

IELA?MC;EF A=;;=DJR D?AAJ ?O I=FD==J C>I F?GD; D=F?DIJR D?MC>F=J C>I T>EKF=AN

I@??TJR D=H=CA H=DN AE;;A= C@?G; J B=D= GJ=IQ *GDHEHE>K EF?>?KDCLJ C>I CDM?GDR KD?JJAN

MEJG>I=DJ;??I C>I CD= K=>=DCAAN EK>?D=I E> OCH?D ?O F?MM?> MEJF?>F=L;E?>JQ % O=B B?DTJ ?>

! %> =SF=L;E?> EJ `Q)Q $CA=[J MCJ;=DLE=F=R -$%.+%+ *'/ 0*$1*$# .' %2# 3#'*.++*'4#5 .=B $CH=>_ 6CA=+>EH=DJE;N &D=JJR !aabQ 0?D ;?KDCLF= GJ=OGA ?>AN E> ;K=A=M=>;J ?O LI CDM?GDQ


4/45

c

B?G>I LC;J ?O J ;? OEAA ;K

CJJGML;E?>JQ *GFF=JJEH= BCH=J ?O J;GI=>;J =SLA?DE>K ;FGM@=D=I @?;< @N =SF=JJEH= CDM?GD C>I

;=FEFCA EK>?DC>F=R O?GKKJEI= ,EF;?D5CHEJ $C>J?>Rd O?G>I CDM?GD ;? G>EMCKE>C@AN #E;NR #%_ #R +LLJCACR !a^aQ

^ ,=D?>EFC 0E?DC;?R %>;R C>I #2# -$42*#&,&": &1 *

?*++ @$*A# 1$&6 %2# 8*%%,# &1 >&B%&' -C DEFD5 3SO?DI_ 3SO?DI +>EH=DJE;N &D=JJR ZbbbQc )=1=>CF;?DJR O?D =SCMLA=R JEI=DC@A= =SL=D;EJ= E> B;J ;? =SL=DEM=>;CA CDFCF;?DJ ACDK=AN EK>?D=I BE; =H=>;; CFCI=MEF ;D=C;M=>;J ?O M=IE=HCA @C;;A=Q 3>= JGF< B?DTR >2# ?#/.#A*, G&,/.#$= DH%2 )#'%7$:)*6I*."' J.1# 3#4$#*%#/ .' )&,&7$ K2&%&"$*I2+Q 8?>I?>_ ]E>ID?B i /D==>=R !aacR EJ JGL=D@ @G; J;C>IJ CA?>=Q

f `? 4==KC>R >2#


5/45

f

FCM= ; JL?D; ?O O=>FE>KR C>I E; EJ O?D ;AN O=>FE>K J B


6/45

e

=>IGDC>F=Q ->I==IR ;? I=O=C; C> CDM?GD=I MC> BE;< JJ B?GAI E>J;=CI =>F?GDCK=

JTEAAR LD=FEJE?> C>I ;; CLLAEFC;E?> ?O O?DF=Q ] F?GAI =H=>;GCAAN EO

E>=OOEFE=>;AN @= @C;;=D=I I?B> E> CDM?GD ?O MCEA ?D LAC;=Rj I=D=I

E>=OO=F;EH= ?D IEJLC;FK *$&7'/ ;K O?FGJ=I =>=DKN C; C FDE;EFCA

L?E>; E> J=Qa ->I==IR ;AN CFF=L;=I CJ ; D=CJ?> O?D T=N FK=J E>

; ?O ;;GDN_ E; @=FCM= @?;< M?D=

CFG;=AN L?E>;=I C>I ;I=IR CAA?BE>K C J=F?>I I ;? @= LACF=I ?> ;;D?A C>I A=H=DCK=Q!b 'F=M=>;J ;=GH=D ;; @=;B==> LAC;=J ?O ED?> C>I J;==AQ2G; BDE;=DJ A??TE>K C; ;I )=>CEJJC>F= K O?AA?B=I (K=D;?>

#CJ;A=[J A=CIR B ?O OED=CDMJQV!! %>I OGD;E>K LD?F=JJ E>H?AHE>K C> G>I=DJ;C>IE>K?O F=D;CE> @CJEF LDE>FELA=J C>I ?O ;K ?G; ?O ;R ;R ; BJ ?O =>;R BCJ ;>=DQ 'ID=B ]Q 2?CDIMC>R D=>?B>=I ]CD ?O ;EFA= =HEI=>F=;K;< C>I =>IGDC>F= B=D= LD=I?ME>C>; C; A=CJ; IGDE>K EK; ?D /=DMC> UBI=I ;?BCDIJ ;JRJGF< CJ ; E>FAGI=J C LAC;= OD?M ;;;GDN /=DMC> ;D=C;EJ= @N $C>J'CA= ?O


7/45

d

(CDAN BDE;=DJ ?> M=IE=HCA MEAE;CDN I=I ;? J== ;EKEMCKE>C;EH= E> BCDR =>FGM@=D=I @N C@JGDI C>I B=EK I=O=>J=JR G>C@A= ;?

=OO=F;EH=AN ?L=DC;= BE; BCJ I FJFE=>;EOEF =SLA?E;J ?O CDMJ:QV!c %D;K E> !ad!R

F?>FAGI=I JEMEACDANR U'K J?M= JES;N L?G>IJ ?O

J ;I J;D=>K;< BCJ ?>F= M?D= KEH=> OD=J< FGDD=>FNQ 4==KC>R D=1ACG>FK ;CDDC;EH=\;K ?O ; ?O ;CA CFCI=MEFJR ID=B FAGJE?>J @CJ=I ?> JN>;ICDN J?GDF=JR

E>FAGIE>K ;


8/45

j

2GD>=QZb ]E; ;I J==ME>KAN BE;CA

HE=BJ ?O T>EKC@A= ;? M?H= BE;< =OOEFE=>FN ?D D=CA =OO=F;EH=>=JJQ 0?D =SCMLA=R R U; M?J; =SL?J=I:;D?;o=Ip @CFTBCDIJ @=O?D=

;F< JL=CDL?E>;JR lBD?>K1O??;E>K[ ;=>;J WC JL=CDM=> ;EM=J ;AN JE>F= ; ID=B =S;=>JEH=AN ?> F?MLCDEJ?>J BE;< M?I=D> FEDFGMJ;C>F=JQ %; ;I?> OD?M !aejQ

ZZ

-; EJ AET=AN ; ?O M?I=D> J;GIE=J E>O?DM=I MC>N ?O ;=DLD=;C;E?>JR

@G; 4==KC>[J CLLD?CF #E;NR #%_ #2# R W' X.,,.'"= >2# K+:42&,&".4*, )&+% &1 J#*$'.'" %& X.,, .' 0*$ *'/ G&4.#%: R 2?J;?>_

8E;;A=12D?B>R!aafQ


9/45

a

L' G.%[

-> ?DI=D ;? =J;C@AEJ< ;F= ?O ;


10/45

!b

;K;I M?D= EML?D;C>;ANR ;=JJ=J\?O C I=>J=R MCJJ=I FCHCADN FI E;J

C@EAE;N ;? @D=CT CLCD; ?LL?JE>K G>E;J E>;? E>F?;R ACDK=AN E>=OO=F;EH= E>IEHEIGCAJQ Zd

' ;CDDC;EH= J?GDF= CHCEAC@A= O?D MGF< ?O ;K I=@C;= F?>F=D>E>K ;K M=;EFA=JR F?>FAGIE>KR U]E;< FCD=R

MEAE;CDN ; @= D=F?>J;DGF;=I

@N F?MLCDE>K E; BE;< ;DCIE;E?>CA LDCF;EF=QVZa *GF< ;DCIE;E?>CA LDCF;EF= MCN @= O?G>I E>

F?DD?@?DC;E>K FEFA=R E>H=>;?DN C>I LCNM=>; D=F?DIJR D?MC>F= AE;=DC;GD=R T>EK?KDCLI JGDHEHE>K CD;EOCF;JQ 2G; E; MCN CAJ? @=

O?G>I E> C>?; MEAE;CDN COOCEDJ ?D F2# ?.//,# -"#+R^!

@=;;=D A=H=DCK= JGDHEHE>K LF= ; =CDAE=D =OO?D;JR @G; I? >?; =H=> M=>;E?> ;?;C@A= CM?>KJ; ;


11/45

!!

=SEJ;=>F= ?O ;;N JGDHEHE>K M=IE=HCA OEKK ;D=C;EJ=JQ ]>=;[J @??T EJ

=JJ=>;ECAAN C H=DN K??I EO FGDE?GJAN1>CM=I @C;;A= >CDDC;EH= JGDH=NE>K B=AA1T>?B> M=IE=HCA

@C;;A=JR )?K=DJ JNJ;=MC;EFCAAN =SCME>=J >=CDAN =H=DN CJL=F; ?O ?L=DC;E?>J GJE>K C L?;=>; CDDCN ?O

LDEMCDN J?GDF=J D=E>O?DF=I @N EF?>?KDCLF=J E> C JGL=D@ LD=J=>;C;E?> ?O AEO= ?> ;K C>I CO;=D C FCMLCEK>Q .=E; @G; I?=J IDCB CKCE>J; ;F< E> !fcfR BCJ O?G>I CKCE> E> !aed C>I BCJ DCEJ=I E>

!ajZ BE;< MGF< ?O ?O JGDHEHE>K CD;EOCF;J E>;?;K ;CL=J;DN ;PGEDN E>;? ;1C;1CDMJ

BAN JLCDE>KANQ^Z

-O O=B CFCI=MEFJ N=; HE=B M=IE=HCA OEKK CJ C (GD?L=C> MCD;ECA CD;R ;;

BDE;=DJ ;EKE>K ;I I=OE>E;E?> ?O F IMCDT !ajc @??T

)2.A*,$:R ^^ =ML;=D>C;E?>CA MEAE;CDN FGA;GD=Q )EFI J=I ; ;; E> ; )2.A*,$: *'/ V.&,#'4# .'

?#/.#A*, !7$&I#5 BK E> 0*$ d )2.A*,$:R I=M?>J;DC;=I

;EK C DC;E?>CA BCNQ *;=H=> 7G; 7CD;E>J[ &D=JJR !ajZQ

^^ 7CGDEF= 4==>R )2.A*,$:R .=B $CH=>_ 6CA= +>EH=DJE;N &D=JJR !ajcQ^c )EF>=INR C>I /=?OOD?E I= #CD>NR >2# 8&&P &1 )2.A*,$: &1 @#&11$&. C#

)2*$': >#_%5 )&'%#_%5 *'/ >$*'+,*%.&'R &>JNAHC>EC &D=JJR !aaeQ


12/45

!Z

F?>>=F;E?> @=;B==> O=C;J ?O CDMJ C>I L?AE;EFCA A=KE;EMCFN E> ;;< F=>;GDNQ^f 2=D; *Q

$CAA[J 0#*I&'+ *'/ 0*$1*$# .' 3#'*.++*'4# !7$&I# CFF=L;J 4==>[J FGA;GDCA CDKGM=>;J E>

J;DEHE>K ;? D=F?>J;DGF; C M?D= >GC>F=I LEF;GD= ?O J B=D= CFF=L;=I E>;?

(GD?L=C> CDME=JQ^e 3H=D ;I EAAGJ;DE?GJ FCD==D `Q)Q $CA= C;;=ML;=I ;? HE=B

;CEJJC>F= J?AIE=D ;K CD;B?DT C>I AE;=DC;GD=R^d B C;;=ML;E>K ;? D=JGDD=F; ; ?O ; 4&'/&%%.#$.

?O ;;< C>I OEO;==>;< F=>;GDE=JQ^j

*AEKFEJ /E=J[

>2# X'."2% .' O.+%&$:R

cb

C>I ,=J=N .?DMC>[J >2# ?#/.#A*, G&,/.#$ B=D= CAA BDE;;=> IGDE>K ;I =CDAN !ajbJQc! %A;= E>FAGI= ;; MCT= ;>=F;E?> ;? ;FELA=J C>I ;=FEPG=J O?D JGF< O=C;J =SLD=JJ=I E> ; ?O 0E?D= I=E 8E@=DE[J JEK;? BIE>K ;=S;Q -;

EJ L=D?; JGDLDEJE>K ; B?DTR >2# >&7$'*6#'% .' !'",*'/5 DD]]U

^f *;=H=> 7GOE=AI i .EF?AJ?>R !ajaQ


13/45

!^

DE]]c^ MCT=J >? M=>;E?> ?O ;?>= CD= T>?B> OD?M (>KAC>I IGDE>K ; (H=AN> HC> I=D .=J;=[J >&7$'&.+5 Q&7%#+5

K*+ /Y-$6#+ /*' ,#+ V.,,#+ /# = MEKK ;? M=IE=HCA BCDOCD=R T>EK


14/45

!c

@??TJ IC;E>K OD?M ;;GDN =SEJ;Q 8ET= (K=D;?> #CJ;A=R FE>K

R ;I ACFTE>K E> UG>I=DJ;C>IE>KV O?D ;FELA=J ;K

@=KE>>E>K BE;< ;=J= MCJ;=DJ E> ;;< F=>;GDNR U;I ;


15/45

!f

IEJMEJJEH=>=JJ J;=MJ OD?M ;B? L?E>;JR - @=AE=H=Q 0EDJ;R ;=;DC@EAE;N ?O ;I ;CDD?B B?DAI ?O O=>FE>K JQ

2G; C I=;CEA=I C>CANJEJ ?O ;

?O J=;;A=I LDE>FELA=JQ %>I ;FELA=JR G>I=DJ;??I E> ;JEI=D O?EA O=>FE>K CJ C JGE;C@A= LD=LCDC;E?> O?D C>N TE>I ?O I1;?1I OEKKQ %>I N=;R ;J= ?O LD?KD=JJEHEJM C>I M?I=D>EJM L=DHCI=J M?I=D> ;=CFK ?O MCD;ECA CD;J C>IO=>FE>KQ

ff -@EIQR LLQ ^^1cQ


16/45

!e

?>AN ?> ;EK1C;1CDMJR FEHEAEC>J C>I FA=DKNR @G; CAJ?

E>;? ;


17/45

!d

.?>= ?O ;;E?>=I E> ; I=;CEA E> ?GD F;? H=DN AE;;A= JL=FECAEY=I B=CL?> MC>=GH=DE>KR =E;JEH=AN ?DI=O=>JEH=ANQ *B?DIJ B=D=R E> =OO=F;R >?;K M?D= ; KEC>; FC> ?L=>=DJ:Qe!

7?D= ; MC>N O=>FE>K F?CFK=AEJ;C BCJ E>;=D=J;=I E> ;I FD=I=>;ECAJQ

%ICM %IDEC> #D?B>R C B=AA1T>?B> FACJJEFCA O=>F=D C>I MCJ;=DR J;CD;J BE;< ; !cdcR BE;< ;EJ< JFK ;

fa %D;K=AEJ;C 5 >2# -$% *'/ G4.#'4# &1


18/45

!j

; BCJ JEMLAN C DCLE=D BE;< ;; OAC;;=>=I ?G;Q 'FE>K @=FCM= C>

CD;QV

e^

$= BCJ JL=CTE>K ?O ;I ;;E?>=I EJ /ECF?M? I=/DCJJE W!fdbXQ 0?D PG=J;E?>=I KD=C;>=JJ CJ C O=>F=D C>I F?CFN M?I=D> O=>F=DJR

;F= E> =CF< ?O

; O=>FE>KR BJ?AEFE;=IR E>;? MN IJQVec

]EAAECM /CGKA=DR BDE;E>K E> 2# O.+%&$: &1


19/45

!a

;DCIE;E?>R U@CJ=I ?> OEH= ID=I N=CDJ ?O O=>FE>K =SL=DE=>F=RVee C>I K

;R ;


20/45

Zb

F=>;GDN MCJ;=D $C>J 'CAI=>;R MCE>;CE>=I C> ?>K?E>K I=@C;= BE;< $=DKJ=AA E> ;=;==>;< F=>;GDN ?H=D ;=FEFCA CJL=F;J ?O ; Q -> !abZ 0D=I=DEF< 5gD>


21/45

Z!

O?AA?BE>KQ $=DKJ=AA[J OCFJEMEA= ?O $C>J 'CA BE;< C @DE=O E>;D?IGF;E?> @N #CDA *FI '?DJ;=> ,=DT E> !aajQde

]KAEJ< BDE;=DJ O?AA?B (K=D;?> #CJ;A=R #CL;CE> %AOD=I $G;;?>R )EOA= 2DEKCI=\B FE>K E> ;I MEI1!jabJ\;??T C M?D= F?>FEAEC;?DN CLLD?CF


22/45

ZZ

:;F?G>;=DJ E> ;=

?O ;{(K=D;?> FEDFA= ?O J; ?O

*EAH=D[J @??TJ E> !jajR C>I B=>; ?> ;? CIH?FC;= O?D C D=HEJE?> ?O 2DE;EJ< JC@=D ;=FEPG= @CJ=I

?> ;FELA=J O?G>I E> *EAH=D[J B?DTJQjZ *EAH=D[J K*$*/&_#+ &1 C#1#'4# BCJ CKCE> D=LDE>;=I

@N ; !a^^Qj^ '=DDN 2D?B>R O?AA?BE>K E> ;R JN>;I AC;=D JGDHEHE>K (>KAEJ< J?GDF=J E> KA? *CS?> 2??TJR !aajQjf &CGA ]CK>=D C>I /=?DK= *EAH=DR ?*+%#$ &1 C#1#'4#= >2# 0&$P+ &1 @#&$"# G.,A#$ R 2?GAI=DR #3_ &CACIE>

&D=JJR Zbb^Q


23/45

Z^

E>OAG=>F= E> MCE>;CE>E>K ;FE=>; DEKKAEJ ;? @=CD CDMJ C>I GJ= ;F= E>K (>KAEJ< &EL= D?AAJR

CA?>KJEI= C LA=; ?O O=>FE>K MCJ;=DJ ;I D?NCA LD?FACMC;E?>JQ $= EJ

FCD=OGA ;? MCE>;CE> @=;B==> FEHEAEC> ;DCIE;E?> ?O O=>FE>K C>I ;K ?> ; ?DI=D ;? MCT= K ;>=F;E?> @=;B==> ;K ?O CDMJ C>I ;C;GD= ?O (>KAEJ< F?>J;E;G;E?>CA OD==I?MJQ $EJ B?DT MCT=J >? GJ= ?O ;; F?>JEI=DC@A= MC;=DECA ?> ;OAG=>F= ?O ;;<

F=>;GDN (>KAEJ< MCJ;=DR /=?DK= *EAH=DQ %NABCDI[J CDF ?O ;=N %>KA? E> !aajQ

3#4#'% O.+%&$.&"$*I2: &1 %2# $#*%.+#+

%O;=D !afeR ; E> (>KAEJ< ?> ;;EA ; F1I=L;< C>CANJEJ ?O CAA

T>?B> (GD?L=C> O=>FE>K JF ;K HCAG=R ;K OD?M FQ!Zaf x !fbbR D=MCE> ODGJ;DC;E>KAN

je `Q5Q %NABCDIR >2# !'",.+2 ?*+%#$ &1 -$6+ 1$&6 %2# >B#,1%2 %& %2# >B#'%.#%2 )#'%7$: R 8?>I?>_)?G;A=IK= C>I 4=KC> &CGAR !afeQ

jd *NI>=N %>KA?R >2# @$#*% >&7$'*6#'% 3&,, &1 0#+%6.'+%#$f - )&,,&%:I# 3#I$&/74%.&' &1 %2# ?*'7+4$.I% R3SO?DI_ 3SO?DI +>EH=DJE;N &D=JJR !aejq U8C `=G I= AC $CF;< #=>;GDN 'D=C;EJ= ?> ;


24/45

Zc

C>I J;G@@?D>AN ?@JFGD=Q ]E;< D=KCDI ;? ;KA?

BDE;=JR U7CJ;=DJ C>I J;GI=>;J CD= IEJ;E>KGEJK C FD?B>R CA;JEJ;=>;AN CJ E> 7* -Q^^:;J CD=

K=>=DCAAN B=AA E>IEFC;=I:;K= =CF< KD?GL ?O L?J;GD=J

D=AC;E>K ;? J?M= LCD;EFGACD ;NL= ?O F?M@C; E> C A?KEFCA J=PG=>F=QVjj %>KA? CJJ=JJ=J ;=JJ ?O ; ;>=F;E?> ;? M?I=D>R JFE=>;EOEF

LD=J=>;C;E?>R C MGF< M?D= J?LI CFCI=MEFCAAN DEKEI CJJ=JJM=>; @G; L=DO=F;AN E> AE>=

BE;< B @=O?D=Q $= I?=J >?; J== ;;C;E?> @=FCGJ= CBCD= ?O ;=F=JJCDN ;? UG>A?FTV ;F=JRB IJ C F?; MCD;ECA CD; CM?>KJ; ;CEJJC>F= MCJ;=DJR BKR FG;;E>K C>I ;K CD= CAA E>;=KDC;=I C>I ;CGK

JNJ;=MC;EF BCNJR ?; F?>FAGI= C JEMEACD D=JGA; O?D ; EML?D;C>; E> -;CANR J;GI=>;J ?O

;DCIE;E?>CA O=>FE>K J;NA=J


25/45

Zf

;D=C;EJ=J CJ LCD; ?O


26/45

Ze

0E?D= I=E 8E@=DER!b^ C>I 0EAELL? ,CIEQ!bc ]D=J;AE>K @??TJR JGF< CJ $C>J #NY>=D[J 0e$"#"$.11 7'/

?&$/+42,*" CD;EFGAC;= ;K T>?BA=IK= ;? ;CEJJC>F=Q!bf

%;?L ;;=DLD=;C;E?>J ?O ;;=IQ 'KAEJ<

B?DT E> ;= EJ `? #A=M=>;J[ !aaj ?#/.#A*, GB&$/+6*'+2.IR BN O=>F=DJR D=1=>CF;?DJR C>I MCD;ECA CD;EJ;JQ!be *?M=

F?AA=F;=I B?DTJR JGF< CJ MN ?B> >#*42.'" *'/ L'%#$I$#%.'" O.+%&$.4*, GB&$/+6*'+2.IR!bd

*;=L $C>I[J *&%5% - C>I *&%5% --R!bj ;=DLD=;=DJR G>O?D;G>C;=ANR D=L=C; ;I =SCME>= ;J ?O D=AC;=I ;=FEPG=R ?O;=> OCEAE>K ;? A??T I==LAN =>?GK< ;? IEJ;EAA ;>=F;EH= ;EJJG= >=F=JJCDN ;? ;DC>JO?DM ; ?O ;=FEPG=J E>;? JNJ;=MC;EF D=JL?>J=JQ

3;I=DJ;C>I ;>=F;EH= CD; ;IJ ;I ER IDECR ,%_ 8GAG &D=JJR ZbbaQ

!bc 0EAELL? ,CIER 8GFC &?DYE? C>I /D=K?DN 7=A=R -$+ @,*/.*%&$.* C.6.4*'/.= DH %2 4#'%7$: GB&$/+6*'+2.I&1 ?*+%#$ E?> #E;NR #%_ #>=DR +;= 2=DK>=DR C>I `?>=J /E=JJCGOQ 0e$"#"$.11 7'/ ?&$/+42,*"= /.#


27/45

Zd

3.'"#4Pc+ X'."2%,: -$% &1 %2# J&'"+B&$/ q!!^ K$.6&$.+R @N 7CDT 8C>FCJ;=DR 7CDT 2=DDNMC> C>I

`CM=J &CN;?>q `CJ?> ,CEA[J ?#/.#A*, *'/ 3#'*.++*'4# C*""#$ )&69*% q!!c *;=CL 0EFT[J >2#

8#".''#$Y+ @7./# %& %2# J&'"+B&$/= 0#+%#$' ?*$%.*, -$%+ 0#*I&'$: >#42'.`7#+q!!f 7EFJR @N F?>;DCJ;R CD= ?O C H=DN

;R /CAHE>E IE /DCYEC>?[J J;GIN ?O 0E?D= I=E 8E@=DE

!!a

EJ MC;F


28/45

Zj

JF FA=CD LDE>FELA=JQ!Z!

'=H=> PGCAE;N ?O ;I CFF=L;C>F= CM?>KJ;

J;GI=>;J ?O M=IE=HCA MEAE;CDN C>I CD; ?O O=>FE>K JR ;;=I D=MCE>

?@JFGD= C>I BEAA D=MCE> J? G>;EA >=B K=>=DC;E?>J ?O M?D= DEK?D?GJ E>;=DLD=;=DJ I?FGM=>; ;J C>I LD?HEI= LD??O ;CA ?D UMEFD?V F?M@C;Q*?M= E>D?CIJ CD= @=E>K MCI= BE;< J;GI=>;J ?O %JEC> MCD;ECA CD;JQ ';E?>=I

!aabJ CD;EFA=J @N 7C;; ;? AE>T (GD?L=C> C>I %JEC> MCD;ECA CD;J E> ; O?D ;FE=>;R M=IE=HCA C>I FACJJEFCA J?GDF=JQ ->I==IR

D=KCDIE>K ; C JGL=DOEFECA C>CANJEJ ?O ;Q ' kGIKM=>; ?O ;I M=IE=HCA O=>FE>K JNJ;=MJ EJ ?H=DAN JEMLAEJ;EF EO >?; I?B>DEKEYE>KQV!ZZ

'=N %>KA?[J C>I '=DDN 2D?B>[J @??TJ J;EDD=I J;EAA M?D= E>;=D=J; C>I

LD?HEI=I C F?D>=DJ;?>= B?DT ;K KDCLLAE>KR

k?E>;1A?FTJ C>I ;=J;I=DJ;C>IE>K C>I F?MLD=JE?>Q *?M= ?O

;;=DLD=;C;EH= B?DTJR JGF< CJ ;;E?>=I J=DE=J E>;=DLD=;E>K $C>J

!Z! 2DEC> )Q &DEF=R GB&$/ .' %B& 2*'/+= * 17,,U4&,&$ %$*.'.'" "7./# 1&$ ?#/.#A*, ,&'"+B&$/ 9*+#/ &'


29/45

Za

'CA CM?>KJ; J;GI=>;J ?O %JEC> MCD;ECA CD;JQ

'F=V E>;? ;JFE?GJ>=JJ ?O ; MCD;ECA CD;J F?MMG>E;NR JLGDD=I @N

LG@AEFC;E?>J JE>F= !aabR EJ C J;CD;\@G; ;?B EJ ;? =S;=>I ;;?

; OEKK ;D=C;EJ=J ;? =SLA?D= ;? B; B= FC> OE>I C ;DCIE;E?> ?O JNJ;=MC;EF

MCD;ECA CD;J BE; M=IE=HCA FGA;GD=Q!Z^ *;EAAR >?>= ?O ;CEJJC>F=V CD= ;=;==>;< F=>;GDNR B ; ;I )?M= C>I ;AEKM=>; J

F?>;=S;GCA @CKKCK= @?D>= ?O ;I UM?I=D>E;NV BR J? A?>K CJ

CLLD?LDEC;= FCG;E?>J CD= ;CT=>Q 0EDM I=AE>=C;E?>JR J=>JEFCAQ

2G; E> ;=DMJ ?O G>I=DJ;C>IE>K IEJ;E>F;E?>J ; ;C;GD= ?O BCDOCD=R IG= ;? ;;=KDC;E?> ?O KG>L?BI=D B=CL?>DNR LD?L=AA=I FK=J E> CDM?GD

!Z^ - LD=J=>;=I C LCL=D C; ;;EOEF #?>KD=JJ O?D 7CD;ECA %D;J C>I #?M@C; *L?D;JR ,EJ=CGR&?D;GKCAR U$EJ;?DEFCA C>I 7?I=D> &=ICK?KE=J E> (GD?L=C> 7CD;ECA %D;JRV ?G;AE>E>K C M=;J ?O J EJ

L=>IE>K E> ;


30/45

^b

C>I ;CF;EFJ ;JEI=DC;E?> I

U)=>CEJJC>F=V ;? IEJFGJJ ;G;JI OA=SE@EAE;N

WFD=C;EHE;NX ?O CF;E?>R =MLK ;I CD= OEDMAN F?>>=F;=I E>;? ;J ?O

FI FGA;GD=Q U)=>CEJJC>F=V CD;JR @N F?>;DCJ;R =ML C>I ;EM=R C>I

;IEHEIGCA FD=C;EHE;NR J;DEHE>K E>J;=CI O?D C JFE=>;EOEFJ=>J= ?O L=DO=F;E?> IDCB> OD?M ;F= ?O K=?M=;DNQ '


31/45

^!

UMCDE;CA CD;JV C>I UO=>FE>KRV CD= @?;< CJJ?FEC;=I BE;< JL?D;R N=; @?;< J @=N?>I

E;\CJ C KD?GLR MCD;ECA CD;J ;E?> ?O J?M= BDE;=DJR CLLAEFC;E?>J O?D J=AO1I=O=>J=R E>

?D ?G; ?O C MEAE;CDN =>HED?>M=>;Q 0=>FE>KR =H=> CJ E; BCJ LDCF;EF=I E> ;I L=DJ?>CA I=H=A?LM=>;R CAJ? J E> ;J=R ?D E> C

MGF< M?D= AEME;=I J=>J=R ?> ;I=DJ;??IR C>I N=; M?D= JAELL=DNQ #=D;CE>AN J?M= MCD;ECA CD;J

E>FAGIE>K OEKKR BR ?D L=DO?DMC>F=Q -> (>KAEJ?;C;E?>J BJAC;E?> C L?;=>;ECAAN IEOOEFGA; EJJG=Q 'KAEJ<

;=DM F?M=J OD?M ;\ 1#42%#' \C>IR CFF?DIE>K ;? ;KAEJ< 5EF;E?>CDNR EJOEDJ; D=O=D=>F=I E> 2=?BGAOR CJ 1#&2%*'R E> afa %Q5Q!Zf 'K FQ !bbbR U/?I

:;}F=~ IC ME>= ;? 1%#qV OD?M !!dfR U2=? J;D?>K= ?> 1.2%#qV OD?M !ZbfR U;?1K}ID= C>I A#2% >=? @EKG>>=>qV OD?M ;;< F=>;GDNR U J== E> ;F=J C@?H= J;D?>K F?>>=F;E?>J ;?

FEDFGMJ;C>F=J B EJJG=\E> 2=?BGAOR E> /?I[J ;=CFK ?O UME>=V I ;?

OEK ;K;< ?O 2=? R ?O ; ; ;


32/45

^Z

0A?DE? CJ UC @C;;A=V ?D UC OEKQ

#?>;DCJ; ;F=QV!Za G42#$6& E>KJR UC O=>F=R C I=O=>J=R C BCDI=R C JJAC;=I E> M?I=D> -;CAEC> CJ U;? JFD==>QV .?;= ;; F?>>?;C;E?> ?O

D=JL?>JEH= ?D I=O=>JEH=>=JJq +42#$6& EJ @=J; ;DC>JAC;=IR L=DJ=R B;DCJ;R C 4&69*%%#'%# ? I=O=>JEH=

F?>>?;C;E?>\; ?OO=>JEH=>=JJ ;? ;; OD?M ;I?>_ %D>?AI $C;OE=AIR !fajq D=LDE>;=I .=B 6?DT_ /=?DK 3AMJRZbbcR LQ cbQ 'E;E?> ;? J?M= I=KD== JGLLAC>;=I @N ; ;=DM 4&69*%%.6#'%&R CFF?DIE>K;? ;C_ !f^eQ '=J= JFE? 7C>FE?AE>?R ;NM?GJ ;DCF; 8[%D;= I=AAC *LCICR C>I 5CAA[%KK?FFER C>I ; 2?A?K>C J;=CIEAN OD?M!^^j ?>BCDIJ_ 7C=J;D? )?J?AE>? W!^^jXq 7C=J;D? 0DC>F=JF? W!^fcXq C>I 7C=J;D? .=DE? W!^jfXQ *== ;;D?IGF;E?>;? ;?>EM? 2?A?K>=J= @N 7CDF? )G@@?AE C>I 8GFC #=JCDE 5 JY-$%# /#,,* GI*/*= >$*%%*%& /. G42#$6* /#,,Y.'.g.&/#, bVL G#4&,&R )EME>E_ -A #=DFEF?R ZbbfR C>I CAJ? ;; CLLCDC;GJ @N 0DC>F=JF? .?HC;ER


33/45

^^

BE;< C F?MLCDEJ?> @=;B==> C +42#$6& C UJFD==>V ?D UI=O=>J=RV C>I C 9*%%*",.*R C UF?M@C;V ?D

UOEK @Np;1C;1CDMJR BOAEF;J BE;< C M?J; HCAGC@A=J=DHEF= ;R - I=FEI=I ;? BDE;= C @??T C@?G; ;K E; E> HCDE?GJ OEKGD=J BE;< ;


34/45


35/45

^f

KD?BE>K GL C>I J==TE>K @?;< J;D=>K;< W 1&$g#X C>I T>?BA=IK=R - J;D?H= ;? A=CD> C@?G; ;I M=; ?O JGF< CD;Q

,CIE MCT=J >? M=>;E?> ?O 0E?D= ?D ;K ;1C;1CDMJ CD= >? A?>K=D M=>;E?>=IQ

->J;=CIR ;CDN

?>NM O?D ;JE;E?>CA @=;B==> ; =S;=>;R ;FD=CJE>KAN

E> ; MCD;ECA CD;JR ,* +4.#'g* BEAA JGLLAC>; ;I ; BEAA

JGLLAC>; ;1C;1CDMJQ

)?MC>F= AE;=DC;GD= E> -;CAEC> EJ IEOOEFGA;R JE>F= ; E> 3FFE;C> ?D &D?H=>nCAR C>I J? CD= ?O AE;;A= AE>KGEJ;EF GJ=Q $?B=H=DR IGDE>K ;;< F=>;GDN E> LCD;EFGACDR FEFA=J @=KE> ;? CLL=CD E> 'GJFC>R C>I - I >? ;DCF=

?O ;N ?O E;J HCDEC;E?>J E> ;ER 2?FFCFFE?R ?D 5C>;=Q

*;CD;E>K BE;< 0D=>FR B= OE>I

BE; 0D?EJJCD; ;I +. 4&69*%%#$ R @G; B= I?>[; J== #+4$.6#q ;F= - C@A= ;? OE>I EJ FQ !cebQ

!^^ -@EIR O?D =SCMLA= ?> OOQ ^H C>I cDQ!^c 0A?DE?R LQ ^faQ


36/45

^e

' B?DI 1#42%#' MCN @= ;DC>JAC;=I =E;FE>KRV 2G; ; F?>>?;C;E?> O?D ;;ECAAN H=DN IEOO=D=>; OD?M E;J ;=S;R FCDDNE>K

JGKK=J;E?>J E>OAG=>F=I @N ; JL?D;\;K J;DEL WULEJ;=VXR

C>I GA;DC1; O=>FE>K O?EA E;J=AOQ

%A?>KJEI= ;KGEJ;EF F?>JEI=DC;E?>JR ;;ECAAN I=O=>JEH= F

OEKKR CJ B= BEAA J== E> ;=S; F ;I E;[J M?D= JL=FECAEY=I


37/45

^d

CLLAEFC;E?> FA?J=AN @?S=I E> E;J GJ= ;? C JL=FEOEF J=; ?O T>?B> LCDCM=;=DJR @?G>I=I C>I

=>F?GDCK=I @N J?FECA FK=J ;F?GDCK=I FEHEAEC> IG=AE>KQ

2G; BE;E?> =AGJEH=Q (JFK M?J; =SLAC>C;?DN I=OE>E;E?>JR 5CHEI (Q `?>=J ?OO=DJ

BE;E?>_

X*%*_ '=J= F?>F=L; EI=>;EOE=J C LD=CDDC>K=IR ?D F= ?D GL ;? ID=IJ ?O LCD;EFELC>;JQ ' A??T CAM?J; AET= IC>FE>KR C>I ;T @=;B==> OEKK @=I IC>FE>K EJ JEK>EOEFC>;Q

(ML *KIEJ;C>F= ;=FEPG=J\@?B C>I CDD?BR D?FT1;KR C>I JAE>KE>K\MCN CAJ? @= E>;=KDCA;? C MCD;ECA CD;J JNJ;=MQ 2=FCGJ= ?O ;IEFC;=J C D=L=C;=IR ;? C MCD;ECA CD;Q 0?D =SCMLA=R E> &?AN>=JEC>MCD;ECA @== OE>IJ CLL=CAJ ;? AE>=CK= C>I F?MMG>E;N K?IJ O?D JGFF=JJ E> @C;;A=Q

'=FEPG=R D=L=;E;E?>R C>I IDEAA_ ]E;;E>GCA LDCF;EF= ?O @CJEF ;=FEPG=JR ?>= BEAA>?; I=H=A?L ;K;J= >==I=I ;? C;;CE> C>I MCE>;CE>; F?M@C;Q

*LCDDE>K_ %AA MCD;ECA CD;J E>FAGI= J?M= O?DM ?O JLCDDE>K @= @=;B==> ;I ;DG= @C;;A=OE=AIF?>IE;E?>JQ *LCDDE>K EJ >?; E>;=>I=I ;? TEAA @G; ;? LDCF;EF= I=CIAN ;=FEPG=J J?M=B;D?AA=I @N DGA=JQ

(>;=D;CE>M=>;_ *?M= ?O ; ;?B OE>I ; F?>F=L;R ;;=D;CE>M=>; F?ML?>=>; ?O MCD;ECA CD;J K @==> E> =HEI=>F= E> ;M=>;1?DE=>;=I LG@AEFI=M?>J;DC;E?>J ?O HCDE?GJ MCD;ECA CD;JR U*CMGDCEV >?H=AJR C>I F?>;=ML?DCDN ;=A=HEJE?>J=DE=JQ

*==TE>K E>;=D>CA L?B=D_ 7?J; MCD;ECA CD;J C>EMEJ;EF F?ML?>=>;R C @=AE=O ; ;EH=DJ= FC>R EO CBCT=>=I C>I =JJ=IR J =H=> J;D?>K=DR =JEC KD=C; BCDDE?DJ B=D= @=AE=H=I ;?


38/45

^j

)C>TE>K C>I E>IEFC;E?>J ?O DC>T_ -> J?M= FCJ=J DC>TE>K EJ @CJ=I =>;ED=AN ?> J=>E?DE;NR C>IE> ?; @AC;C>; OEKK LD?B=JJQ )C>T EJ I=>?;=I @N F?A?D=I @=A;J ?D F=D=M?>ECA?G;OE;JR @CIK=JR ?D JL=FECA E>JEK>ECQ

#?>>=F;E?> BE;< J?FECA =AE;=J_ ' CAA J?FE=;E=J I=I ;? @= JTEAAOGA

OEKI MEAE;CDN A=CI=DJQ -> 7=IE=HCA (GD?L=R O?D =SCMLA=R ?>AN ; @N ;=J= *CMGDCEQ 2C;CEAA= 2?EJ ?O 'DE>EICIC>I '?@CK? EJ @CJ=I E> ; JACH=JR CJ EJ 2DCYEAEC> #CL?E=DCQ ->`CLC> J?M= MCD;ECA CD;J CD= LDCF;EF=I =SFAGJEH=AN @N OCDM=DJQ!^f

#=D;CE>ANR B= MEK=J[ FC;=K?DE=JQ 0?D =SCMLA=R LDCF;EF= ?O

; M?I=D> %M=DEFC> J?FE=;NR C>I E> MC>N J?FE=;E=J CD?G>I ;>?;

=CJEAN @= =PGC;=I BE;< J?FECA =AE;=JQ -> MC>N FCJ=JR ;?B ;DG=R BE;< F?M@C; CD;J

JFJEI=DC@A= A=>K;I

AE>=CA F?>>=F;EHE;NQ *;CD;E>K BE;< ;=JR U'?BCDIJ C 5=OE>E;E?> ?O 7CD;ECA %D;JRV E> )&69*%5 3.%7*,5 *'/ K#$1&$6*'4#= -'%2$&I&,&": &1 %2# ?*$%.*, -$%+R ]=J;L?D;R #'_ &DC=K=D &G@AEJFQR ZbbZR LLQ SE1SEHQ


39/45

^a

@N 2CAICJJCD= #CJ;EKAE?>= E> ;;=Q %>I OE>IE>K BE; 7?>;=

C> CD;EFGAC;= F?>F=D> O?D ;;=DD=AC;E?> ?O ;I LDCF;EF=R GJE>K ;=>F=;? ; ?O C H=DN EML?D;C>; @G;D=AC;EH=AN AE;;A=1J;GIE=I JG@k=F; E> ;=F=JJCDN ;? =J;C@AEJ< ;;=AA=F;GCAR MEAE;CDNR C>I CD; F=L;GCAEYC;E?> ?O CD; CJ @?G>I=I E> K?H=D>E>K LDE>FELA=Q 3H=D ;=S; O=B FKA?R GJE>K C ;CA F?MLCDC;EH= M=;CDN

LD?KD=JJEH= CLLD?CF< ;K ;? LG; ;;? ;I ;=S;Q

7=; ;;E>G=I O?D >=CDAN ;=N %>KA?R >2# ?*$%.*, -$%+ &1 3#'*.++*'4# !7$&I#5 \#B O*A#'= h*,# j'.A#$+.%: K$#++R !aajR LLQZ1^Q


40/45

cb

N=CDJQ 5=JLE;= E;J ACFT ?O EMCK=JR ;CAAN HCAGC@A= @=FCGJ= ;;CDN EJ

>=CD ;?R ?D L=D;=ML?DCDN BE;JEI=DJ

;;CA CJL=F;J ?O ; ACDK=AN

CH?EIQ

0E>CAANR B= JL=>I =S;DC ;EM= BE;< ;GJFDEL; - CA D=>I=D=I EAAGJ;DC;E?>J BE;< D=AC;EH=AN FA=CD =SLAC>C;?DN LCDCKDCL O??; C>I ?> ?O LDE>FELA= FCDDE=I CFD?JJ B=CL?>1O?DMJR @G; MC>N ?O ;FELA=J CD= =SLD=JJ=I ?>AN CJ

JG@;=S;Q

'=J ;=DC;E?>J ?O

O=>FE>K J C>I LDCF;E;E?>=DJQ (H=> E>;=DLD=;E>K M=C>E>K OD?M ; J=F;E?>J C>I ;;C;E?>J EJ IEOOEFGA;R JE>F= CD;EJ;EF F?>H=>;E?> W=JL=FECAAN E> ;I AE>KGEJ;EF CM@EKGE;N I=OE>= CAA ;K O?D E>;=D>CA ;

;J ?O C> =SFAGJEH=AN L;=DLD=;C;E?>JR @?;< OD?M ;K ;FN EJ C I=JED=I =>I1J;C;= O?D C F?M@C; JNJ;=MQ ' IV

=SLA?DC;E?>J G>I=D;CT=> ?H=D C @D?CI L=DE?I JLC>>E>K M?D= ; C I=FCI=R BE;< ;BEF=1

?D M?D= B==TAN J=JJE?>J CM?G>;E>K ;? J?M= ^fbbƒ


41/45

c!

M?D= ?>

;=CDAN A?J; MCD;ECA CD;J ?O M=IE=HCA (GD?L=Q


42/45

"##$%&'()

*+,-+ ./0-12 3+45- #-560775-80566-09 :+;-52 //00 30=?0-

"@->+1 $A *0;>72 //00 30=?0-

$5?0-/ 3A />152 //00 30=?0-./0BC01 D5-@02 //00 30=?0-

$>EC+-@ 3E12 - 56 /C0 (0B+-/=01/

56 G>7/5-9H+=07 (A 300-1>I2 "E/>1J (0+1 56 /C0

K5,F5,70 8-+@,+/0 .EC55F

KG' 3"$KL"* "$K. %D 3'(L'&"* 'M$%#'

N->+1 $A #->E0

(>770-/+/>51 #-0B+-0@ 65- /C0 (0J-00 56

(%


43/45

>V

K"N*' %D >>

7/5->5J-+BC9 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA]

#0-751+F 5- ^3>E-5_ F>/+-9 G>7/5-9 AAAAA`

L1 .>/a AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAb

G>7/5->+17 51 /C0 "-/ 56 D01E>1J AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT\

1/ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATb

$0E01/ G>7/5->5J-+BC9 56 /C0 D>JC/>1J K-0+/>707 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR\

:5-I>1J (06>1>/>517 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARb

30@>0V+F V7A $01+>77+1E0 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARb

3+-/>+F "-/72 D>JC/>1J2 +1@ D01E>1J AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA\S

30/C5@5F5J9 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA\b

RA $" 3. LA\\ "P( KG' K$"(LKL%P %D 3"$KL"* &'$.') ('D'P.' D%$

KG' 8'P'$"*L. :LKG .:%$( "P( NM


44/45

V

51 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAdS

\A "(&L0; AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAdR

KC0 !"#$%&'( K-+@>/>51 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAdc

8P3 \RRY+ ?9 G+1I5 (e?->1J0- AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAdY

51 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATR\

]A KG' )*+,-. 0*+,123+,. %D DL%$' ('L *LN'$L AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATR`

%V0-V>0; AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATR`

G>7/5->5J-+BC9 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATRY

24 1"56$789 D>5-0 @0> *>?0-> AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT\\

V>1J K-0+/>707 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT]]

)*+87: ;*+8/9 56 #->1E>BF0 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATc`

#->1E>BF0 56 8,+-@7 f@9A:87"8$6g AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATcd

#->1E>BF0 56 #5;0-AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATcbL=B0-+/>V0 #->1E>BF0 56 1>7C>1J2 D5FF5;>1J %1 fK>=0g +1@ /C0 #->1E>BF0 56$075FV>1J #-077,-0h#57>/>51AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATY\

D5FF5;X51 .0F0E/>512 ^D>1>7C>1J2_ B6?68$6 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATY]

(>7+-=>1J) -98 4" ;"5"C -98 ;6 $D";: AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATY`


45/45

./->I>1J) @94D68: +1@ B:868: AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATYc

N>1@>1J) )65"8: 46 %8"=6 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATYb

N-0+I>1J 5- ,977#8:AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATd\

#,//>1J /C0 %BB5101/ 51 /C0 8-5,1@) 1:77:84: 6? 7:88" AATd]

KC0 D>V0 KC>1J7 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATdc

`A KG' 3'(L'&"* 3'"PLP8 %D ^*i"$K'_) "$K "P( 3'3%$O AAAAAAAAAAAATdb

"->7/5/F0 +1@ "-/0 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATdb

K-+17=>77>51 V>+ "-+?>E K0W/7 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATbb

.EC5F+7/>E "@5B/>51 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARS\

H5C1 56 .+F>7?,-9AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARS`

.+F>7?,-9 +1@ -(: 1"876"4 +87$ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARSY

$0E5-@>1J +1@ $0=0=?0->1J) 30=5-9 #+F+E07 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARSb

KC0 E+F $55/7 56 30@>0V+F "BB-5+EC07 /5 30=5-9 AAAAAAAAAARTS

+8$ 1:1 /C0 3>@@F0 "J07 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAART]

(>V>@>1J >1/5 M1>/7 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARRT

$5F0 56 N55I7 >1 /C0 3" AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARR\

K-+E>1J D5-=+F 30=5-9 K0EC1>j,07 >1 30@>0V+F D>JC/>1J K-0+/>707 AAAARR]

cA K%:"$(. "

Documents

Surviving Fight- Books and the Historiog