Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
The Times Of India - Delhi, 2017-11-11 Cropped page Page: 23
Copyright 2016 Olive Software 2017-11-11 07:43:43
THE TIMES OF INDIA, NEW DELHI SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 11, 2017 23TIMES NATION
New Delhi: High drama thatstarted unfolding in the Su-preme Court on Wednesdaypeaked on Thursday when atwo-judge bench exceeded itsjurisdiction to order listingof a petition on allegedjudge-middleman nexus be-fore a five-judge bench, be-fore climaxing on Friday asa hurriedly assembled five-judge bench quashed thetwo-judge bench’s order andasserted the CJI’s supre-macy in assigning petitionsto benches.
The final countdown tothe fast-paced developmentshad the twists and turns of aBollywood potboiler.
Hours after a two-judgebench referred a petition,which made identical allega-tions on judge-middlemannexus, to Chief Justice Di-pak Misra, the registry is-sued a notice at 2.42pm say-ing a seven-judge benchheaded by the CJI would hear
the petition by Campaign forJudicial Accountability andReforms (CJAR) at 3pm. Thebench comprised the CJI andJustices A K Sikri, R K Agra-wal, Arun Mishra, AmitavaRoy, A M Khanwilkar andAshok Bhushan.
At 2.52 pm, barely 10 min-utes after the first notice, a sec-ond notice was issued sayingthat though the timing of thehearing remained un-changed, the bench wouldhave five judges. Justices Sikriand Bhushan, who had re-ferred the petition to the CJI inthe morning, were removed.
Referring to Thursday’sorder of Justices J Chela-meswar and S Abdul Nazirreferring a petition, whichwas identical to that ofCJAR, to a bench of first fivesenior judges and the issuefiguring before a five-judgebench headed by the CJI onFriday, advocate KaminiJaiswal said in the last cou-ple of months, a large num-ber of cases were being with-drawn from other benches tothe CJI-headed bench.
The CJI defended his deci-sion to take over a petition re-lating to finalisation of mem-orandum of procedure(MoP) from a bench headedby Justice A K Goel and thendismissing it. The CJI said, “Ihave the administrative pow-er to do so. That is my prerog-ative. A two-judge bench can-not take a call on MoP.”
7-judge benchturned into a5-judge one
in 10 minutesDhananjay.Mahapatra
@timesgroup.com
Advocate KaminiJaiswal said that in the last couple of months, a largenumber of caseswere beingwithdrawn fromother benches to the ChiefJustice-headedbench, but CJI DipakMisra defended his decision
New Delhi: Chief Justice Di-pak Misra rejected a seniorlawyer’s suggestion to bar the media from reporting the courtroom drama on Fri-day, where a sea of lawyers re-acted angrily to advocatePrashant Bhushan’s unsub-stantiated allegationsagainst the CJI and soughtcontempt of court proceed-ings against him.
The CJI said, “I believe, allof us believe, in the freedom ofpress. I am always in support offreedom of speech and expres-sion and the right of media toreport proceedings accurately.I do not favour restraining thepress in any matter. A similarprayer was made before mewhen I was a judge of MadhyaPradesh high court during thehearing of a very sensitivematter. I had outright refusedto restrain the media from re-porting the proceedings. Press
must have its freedom.”Members of the five-judge
bench, especially JusticeArun Mishra, told Bhushanthat he had made unsubstan-tiated allegations for whichhe was liable for contempt ofcourt proceedings.
Not new to the court initia-ting contempt of court pro-ceedings against him — one ispending in the SC against himfor alleging seven years agothat most former CJIs were
corrupt — Bhushan tried tomake his submission.
But his voice was drownedas a large number of lawyersspoke in unison accusing himand his band of lawyers of at-tempting to terrorise judgesthrough wild allegations.
Frustrated by his voice be-ing drowned in the cacophony,Bhushan stormed out of thecourtroom. After this, Su-preme Court Advocates on Record Association office-bearer Gopal Singh suggestedto the bench to treat the pro-ceedings in camera and re-strain the media from report-ing it. The CJI immediatelyshot down the suggestion.
The bench also rejected asuggestion from former Su-preme Court Bar Associationoffice-bearer Ranji Thomas toconstitute a full court andplace both the petitions, whichalleged judge-middleman nex-us in grant of favourable or-ders to undeserving privatemedical colleges, before it.
The bench questioned thepropriety of senior advocateDushyant Dave mentioningKamini Jaiswal’s petition before a bench headed by Justice J Chelameswar onThursday despite knowingthat a similar petition by Cam-paign for Judicial Account-ability and Reforms was or-dered to be listed before abench led by Justice A K Sikri.
But there were lighter mo-ments too in the courtroom.When Bhushan pleaded withthe CJI to grant him “some in-dulgence” to make his argu-ments, a smiling CJI said, “Inevery case you argue before us,you are given indulgence. It isanother matter that you havemade wild allegations today.”
Bhushan returned thesmile and acknowledged theindulgence granted to him.But minutes later, he angrilytold the CJI to pass any orderas the bench was not givinghim opportunity to argue andstormed out of the courtroom.
Lawyers Wanted Ban After Bhushan’s Unsubstantiated Allegations
Won’t gag media, I believein freedom of the Press: CJI
CJI Dipak Misra also shot down asuggestion to hold the courtproceedings in camera
We make it clear with-out any hesitationthat this is followed as
a convention to maintain judi-cial discipline and decorum,”the bench further said.
It added, “Once the CJI isrecognised as the master of theroster, neither a two-judgebench nor a three-judge benchcan allot a matter to itself or or-der constitution of a largerbench as if it is a direction tothe CJI. Such an order cannotbe passed. It is not in accord-ance with law and is irrespon-sible... There cannot be a direc-tion to the CJI to constitute aparticular bench.”
Making it clear that the or-der of Justices Chelameswarand Nazir was null and void,the five-judge bench stressed,“If any such order is passed byany bench, that should nothold the field as this will becounter to the order of the de-cision of this ConstitutionBench of the SC. Needless tosay, no judge can take up mat-ters on his own without it be-ing referred to the CJI.”
The five-judge bench said
the two petitions alleging ajudge-middlemen nexus wouldbe listed before an appropriatebench. Both pleas were basedon common information — aCBI FIR that led to the arrest ofa retired HC judge and othersin connection with a conspir-acy to obtain favourable ordersfor private medical collegesfrom courts by offering illegalgratification to public servantsand judges — and sought iden-tical relief in setting up of an
SIT to probe this under the su-pervision of a retired CJI.
Justices Chelameswar andNazir had acceded on Wednes-day to advocate PrashantBhushan’s plea and orderedlisting of a petition by Cam-paign for Judicial Accountabil-ity and Reforms (CJAR), whichalleged that the CBI FIR relat-ing to admissions to a Luck-now-based private medical col-lege had detailed how a judge-middleman nexus was beingused to obtain orders favouringmedical colleges debarredfrom admitting students.
The CJI had ordered listing
of this petition on Friday be-fore a bench of Justices A KSikri and Ashok Bhushan.
However, on Thursday, se-nior advocate Dushyant Davementioned a petition by advo-cate Kamini Jaiswal, identicalto CJAR’s plea, for urgent hear-ing before a bench headed byJustice Chelameswar. Dave’spleaded that the petition mustbe heard by Justice Chelames-war’s bench, and not by the CJIas the latter had been hearingmedical college cases and Jus-tice Chelameswar’s benchagreed to hear the matter. It or-dered the petition to be listedbefore a bench comprising firstfive senior judges on Monday.
On Friday, the bench of Jus-tices Sikri and Bhushan re-ferred the CJAR petition to theCJI for listing before an appro-priate bench. The registry tookout a notification at 2.42pm say-ing the matter would be heardby a seven-judge bench at 3pm.
However, at 2.52pm, anoth-er notification said the CJARpetition would be heard by afive-judge bench at 3pm.
Word spread rapidly andthe CJI’s courtroom waspacked with lawyers. Bhushan
and Kamini Jaiswal wereswamped by a sea of lawyerswho demanded contempt ofcourt action against them formaking wild allegations mo-ments after Bhushan said theCBI FIR in the medical scammentioned the CJI’s name.
The five-judge bench re-peatedly questioned Bhushanas to how a lawyer of his stand-ing could make such an irre-sponsible statement. “Can anFIR be registered against a ma-gistrate, a district judge, an HCjudge, an SC judge or the CJI?There is a procedure. You mustwithdraw this irresponsiblestatement,” it said.
Bhushan repeatedly re-quested the bench to hear himout. But the bench questionedhis arguments incessantly.
Simultaneously, SC Bar As-sociation leaders insisted oncontempt proceedings againstBhushan. ASG Narasimha P Ssaid the CJI alone had the pow-er to order listing of cases.
Tired of keeping cool,Bhushan raised his voice, “You(the bench) want to pass orderswithout hearing me. Go aheadand pass any order you want,”and stormed out amid protests.
‘Two-judge bench’s order null & void’�Continued from P 1
COURTROOM DRAMA
Tipu fest held in Karnataka amid protests, shutdowns: Tipu Sultan Jayanti in honour of the18th century Mysore ruler was held in Karnataka on Friday amidst mass protests, shutdowns andpreventive arrests by the BJP and other right-wing organisations. Tipu’s 267th birth anniversary wascelebrated with special functions at his birth place in Devanahalli village on Bengaluru’s outskirtsand in cities and towns that were part of his kingdom in the Deccan region. IANS
`̀1.14cr looted at gunpointfrom bank cash van: Cashworth Rs 1.14 crore was lootedfrom HDFC Bank’s cash van atBhogpur in Punjab’s Jalandhardistrict by seven armed robberson Friday. One of the robberswas involved a gun battle withcops and has been arrested. TNN
CCI NG 3.7 Product: TOIDelhiBS PubDate: 11-11-2017 Zone: Delhi Edition: 1 Page: TOIDCP23 User: annu.mathew Time: 11-10-2017 23:53 Color: CMYK
NORTHERN RAILWAYE-Procurement System
E-ProcurementTerxler Notice No.196-5171/2017-2018 1TS/Tender Notice Dated 10.11.2017On behalf of the President of India , Chief Engineer/TSP, Northern Rail' uyHeadquarters office . Baroda House . New Delhi-110001 Invites the following tencersthrough E-Procurement system:S. Tender Brief Description Qty. Earnest Tender Date & PeriodN. No. Money value time of of
(in Rs.) (in Rs.) opening supplyof tender
1. 211- Item No. (i) 6400 mm 1457 10 ,00 .0001- 21 ,96,75 .880 05 .12 . 17 122563- Over riding (Curved ) Fan Sets 00 at `.10,;h,2017- Shaped Switches for 1 in 14:3018-NR 8.5 T/Out for BG 52Kg his
(UIC) on PSC sleepers toRDSO Drg. No. T4866Att. 5 (with Check rail) asamended up to datecomplete with stock railsand all parts includingcheck rails as listed In thedrawing but excludingGrooved Rubber SolePlates, Insulating Liners,Elastic Rails Clips. Fishp lates and Fish Bolts.Item No. (ii) 6400 mm 1170Over riding Fan Shaped SetsSwitches for 1 in 8.5Turnout for BG 60 kg onPSC sleepers to RDSOOrg. No. T-4966 Alt. 4( w i t h C h e c k r a i l )complete with stock railsand all parts includingcheck rails as listed in thedrawing , but excluding,Grooved Rubber SolePlates, Insulating Lines ,Elastic Rail Clips. FishPlates and Fish Bolts.
The complete information along with tender document of above E-ProcurementTender are available on website https ://www .ireps .gov.1n . 3436117
DMI C INTEGRATED IND USTRIAL TOWNSHIP
Notice inviting RFQ cum RFP for selection of ICTConsultant
DMIC IITGNL invites "Request for Qualification cum Proposal" frominterested bidders for selection of ICT Consultant for IntegratedIndustrial Township Project at Greater Noida . RFQ cum RFP documentshall be available on https://etender.up.nic.in for organizat ion'Greater Noida Industrial Development Authority ', www.iitgnl . coni &www.dmicdc.com from 11.11.2017. The bids shall be submitt ed onl ineonl y on ht tps: / /e tender .up.nic . in . N I C / U P L C (UP E lec t ron i c sCorporation Ltd) registration is compulsory to submit bids. Pre bidmeeting will be held on 22.11.2017 at 03:00 PM & last date for bidsubmission is 22 .12.2017.For any modification & notification p lease follow the e -por ta lregularl y. Any queries must he addressed to:CEO & MD, DMICIntegratedlndustrialTownshipGreaterNoidaLimitedH-169 Chitvan Estate, Sector Gamma - II , Greater Noida , U.P. 201308Phone: +91 120 4256300 website : www.iitgnl.comEmail: gnnpinggnida@ mai1wm, pnd.iitgtil@gtnaiLcrom, tenders@dmicdccom
GLOBAL NOTICE INVITING TENDER (Global NIT)
A916 INDIA GOVERNMENT MINT
13 (A Unit of Security Printing & Minting Corporation of India Limited)
(Wholly owned by Government of India)(A Mini Ratna Category - I CPSE)
D-2, SECTOR-1. NOIDA-201301 (U.P.)Phone : 0120-4783116 Fax No.0120-2537609L-mail:igm.noida@spmcil .com Website : www.spmcil.com
Sealed Global tenders are invited from eligible and qualified tenderers for supply of following goods:
SI Brief Description of Goods/ services Quantity (with unit) EMD Last Date ofNo Submission
1 Tender No. NM/220/1151/2017-Pur 1660 Million pieces Rs 1 ,91,00,000/- 29.12..201 7Manufacture & Supply of Re 1 FSS Coin (6291.40 Metric or upto 300 PMBlanks to India Government Mint , Noida Tonne )
US$ 294150
2 Tender No. NM /220/1152/2017-Pur 2000 Million pieces Rs.2 , 94,21,000/- 29,122017Manufacture & Supply of Rs 2 FSS Coin (9700 Metric or upto 3.00 PMBlanks to India Government Mint , Noida Tonne)
US$ 453100For further details & Hindi version of this advertisement please visit our websitehtto://iamnoida .spmcil .com. Future amendment/revision of these tenders, if any , shall be published inour website only.
-Sd-davp 15211/11/0010/1718 General Manager
492-A GOVERNMENT OF ODISHAOFFICE OF THE CHIEF CONSTRUCTION ENGINEER,
ANANDAPUR BARRAGE PROJECT, SALAPADA(E-mail Id : - cceab [email protected]/ [email protected])e' Procurement Notice No. CCEABP- 03 of 2017-18
E-Procure- Name of Work Bid Id No. Tender Bid Cost of Class of Perod of Availability of Date ofment Cost in Securty Bid Contra- Com- Tender On-line for Opening of
Officer Lakhs in Docu- ctor pletion bidding Technical Bid(Appx.) Lakhs ment From To (Cover-1)
Chief Improvement to Left ABP-ACD-01 266.22 2.66 10,000/- A& 04 ( Four) 15.11,17 04.12.17 08.12.17Construction Service Bank of /1 of 2017-18 Special Calendar 11.30 Hrs 17.00 Hrs 11.30 Hrs
Engineer, Ranital Distributary Class monthsA. B. Project, from RD 00 Km to excluding
Salapada Rd.13.50 Km under rainyIRC & IS (Balance season.
Work)
Further details can be seen from the Govt. website www.tendersorissa.gov.in/ www.dowrodisha.gov.in. Addendum/ Corrigendum/Cancellation if any required will be published in Govt. website only.
Chief Construction Engineer,3217711110005117-18 Anandapur Barrage Project, Salapada
NATIONAL SPORTS UNIVERSITY, IMPHAL, MANIPURRegistered under the Manipur Societies Registration Act. 1989
Government of India , Ministry of Youth Affairs & Sports(Department of Sports)
ADMISSION NOTICENational Sports University, Imphal , (Manipur) presently under the administratve control of Department of Sports , Ministry of Youth Affairs& Sports, Govt of India, invites Applications from candidates aspiring to make a career in sports for the academic year 2017-18_
Name of The Course Eigibility Available Seats Duration
Bachelor of Physical Education 50 3 years (6 Semesters)and Sports (As per UGC norms) 12th Pass or
Bachelor of Sports Coaching Equivalent 50 4 years (8 Semesters)(As per UGC norms)Admission Form , Fee , Syllabus , Eligibilit y Criterion and Rules are available on the Ministr y of Youth Affairs and Sports website
or can be obtained from the Office of National Sports University at Khuman Lampak , Imphal , duringworking days from 10:00 am to 4:00 pm.Admission forms can be downloaded from this Ministry of Youth Affairs & Sports website: www.vas.nic.inDuly filled-in Application forms alongwith the requisite fee and related documents should be sent to Deputy Secretary (Sports),Department of Sports, Ministry of Youth Affairs & Sports (MYAS), Room No. 520, C-Wing, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi-110001.on or before 30/11/2017. Contact No. 011-23383336, E-mail: [email protected] test, including physical assessment , will be held on 10.12.2017 from 10.00 AM onwards, at Imphal, Guwahati,Koicata , Bangaluru, Thiruvanthapuram, Gandhinagar, Gwalior, Patiala and Delhi.Application fee to be paid only by Demand Draft of Rs. 300/- in favour of National Sports University Society payable at New Delhi.Note: Achievements in sports at National Level will be an added advantage , Tuition-fee waiver for Athletes who have participatedin international competitions will be considered based on their participation/achievement in such events during the lastthree years .
(Sunil Garg)Deputy Secretary to Government of India
Ph.: 011-23380625011-23383336
davp 47108/ 11/0014/1718
CAD-673
ODISHA SPACE APPLICATIONS CENTRE (ORSAC)Dept. of Science & Technology, Govt . of Odisha
Plot No.45/48(P), Jayadev Vihar, Near Gopabandhu Academyof Administration
Unit-16, Bhubaneswar -751 023TENDER NOTICE NO. 16/2017
Sealed RFP are invited from established and registered firmsfor empanelment under DGPS/ETS SURVEY at Odisha SpaceApplications Centre, Bhubaneswar.Tender Paper Cost : Rs.1000/-Date of Issue of Tender Paper : 14.11.17 to 06.12.17 (11AM-4PM)Last Date of submission of Tender : 08.12.17 by (4 PM)Opening of Tender (Technical/Commercial Bid) : 11.12.17 (3.30PM)For details , please visit http ://www.odisha .gov.in orhttp:llwww.orsac .gov.in or in the above office for the Requestfor Proposals.ORSAC reserves the right to accept/reject/modify & cancel thefull RFP or part thereof at any time without assigning any reasonthereof.
28007/11/00 19/17 -18 CHIEF EXECUTIVE
DMIC INTEGRATED IND USTRIAL TOWNSHIP
Notice inviting RFQ cum RFP for selection ofSystem Integrator (SI)
DMIC IITGNL invites "Request for Qualification cum Proposal" frominterested bidders for selection of SI for designing, development ,implementation , integration , testing, commissioning and support foreLMS for Integrated Industrial Township Project at Greater Noida . RFQcum RFP document shall be available on https://etender.up.nic.in fororganization 'Greater Noida Industrial Development Authori ty ' ,www.iitgnl.com & www.dmicdc.com from 11.11.2017. The bids shallbe submitt ed online only on https://etender.up.nic.in. NIC/ UPLC (UPElectronics Corporation Ltd) registration is compulsory to submitbids. Pre bid meeting will be held on 23.11.2017 at 03:00 PM & lastdate forbid submission is 22 .12.2017.For any modification & notification p lease follow the e-por talregularly. Any queries must be addressed to:CEO&MD,DMIClntegrated Indust ialTownshipGreaterNoidalimitedH-169 Chitvan Estate, Sector Gamma - II , Greater Noida , UP. 201308Phone: +91 120 4256300 website : www.iitgnl.comE m a i l : g m p in g g n i d a @ g m a i l . c o m , p n d . i i t g n l @ g m a il . c o m ,tenders @dmicdc .com
INDIAN PORTS ASSOCIATION (IPA)1 n Floor, NBCC Place, South Tower SWAB WA
B,R Marg, Lodi Road, New Delhi-110003TeL No. 0091-011-24369061/63, 24368334
Notice Inviting RFQIPA/GAD/CoE/RFQs/2017 Date: 10/11/2017IPA invites Request for Qualification (RFQ) for Empanelmentof Consultants for the following:
1. Safety and Security Audit.2. Navigational Audit.3. Acquiring ISO Certifications.4. Energy Audit.5. Lock Gate Systems.6. Coastal Road Works.
RFQ may be downloaded from www.i a.nic.in and CPPPortal.
Sd/-Chief Administrative Officer
davp 37203/11/0055/1718
Tender No.D1175297 Subject : Ratecontract for procurement of DesFire 4KBMF31CD41 model EV1 smart Cards.Opening : 05.12.2017 (15:30 HRS). &Pre-bid: 20.11.2017 (11:00 HRS).TenderDocuments can be downloaded fromWebsite ww v reps.gov. in. For futurem o d f c a t i on; e x t e n s i o n p l. seewww.ireps. ov.inwebsite
poll'
THE TIMES OF INDIA GROUP .
CAREERGUIDAN CESEMINARPOWERED
I PRICELESS CAR EER CO UNSELLING SEMINAR TO UPLIFT YOUR PROFESSIO N
TimesPro brings to you an info rmative and interactive sessionwith the leaders of the SAP industry.Get a chance to connect with them and broaden your knowledge MAbase as well as get career direction fro m none other than thepeople who are leading the SAP arcade . Professionals with
1-4 years of experience
SAP Asia Pacific JapanChannel Head
I SAP India Education HeadI I I
I I I i I ' I
I
I I I I I '
I . ' I I
I
I I
18T" NOVEMBER 2011 ,TIME: 2 PM
VENUE: DELHI T I M E S P R O
9871857516/97179 96463 www.timespro.com/SAP
