REFUTATION OF RNGINEER ALI MIZAS HIDDEN SUPPORT OF
INSURRECTORS
4
REFUTATION OF RNGINEER ALI MIZAS HIDDEN SUPPORT OF INSURRECTORS
A REFUTATION OF HIDDEN RAFID:I NOUNED ASENGINEER ALI
MIRZAAHLUSSUNNA VS ALI MIRZA
ENGINEER ALI MIRZA AN ENYMY OF SAIYIDUNA USMAN RD AND A
SUPPORTER OF INSURRECTERS. Engineer Ali Mirza is a Supporter of
those who insurrected against Saiyiduna Usman RD. He opines that
Saiyiduna Usman RD and his Noble Governors did committed some acts
of transgressions, however the way adopted by the insurrectors and
rebellions was an error of interpretations. He Opines that
Saiyiduna Muaviah RD ,Saiyiduna AMRV BIN AL A:S: RD a, Saiyiduna
A:ISHAH RD and those who insurrected against Usman RD all are
equally Transgressors and all commit errors in insurrections with
only two differences.1] Those who insurrected against Usman were
not S:H:ABAH RD in general, while those who insurrected against
Suiyiduna ALI RD WERE NOT ingeneral.2] There were some flaws and
errors on the side Of Saiyiduna Usman RD. AL AYAZ:. BILLAHI
TAA:LA:, While there is no such error or flaw on the sides of Ali
RD.The question is what was the alleged error on the side of
Saiyiduna Usma:n RD as according to the Engineer Ali Mirza Jhelumi,
the founder of Jhelumiah sect or Engineeriah Sect.As according to
him and his Ali-Mirzais [Ali-Mirzites] the governors of Saiyiduna
UsmanrRD were cruel and unjust.On the contrary the truth is quite
different.The noble governers of Saiyiduna Usman RD were good in
character and Just. The insurrectors were however unjust, cruel and
heretic. It was there scheme to make a conspiracy against Saiyiduna
Usman RD by making allegations against Usman RD in regard to his
Noble Governers. But these allegations were false and untrue. If it
is assumed that some of the accusations were true ,even then there
nature was no great that an insurrection was engineered against the
Noble Caliph Of Muslims nounly Saiyiduna USMA:N RD.The only thing
Saiyiduna Usman did not do was to crush these insurrectors and
terrorists by iron hands. If he had done this they must have
vanished from the line of actualization like the denouncers of
Zakah. But nobility of Usman was undoubtly greater than the
nobility of Saiyiduna Ali , who attempted to fight all those who
insurrected against him regardless of their Sahabihood. Ali Mirza
alleges[partially explicitly and partially implicitly] that the
Governors of Saiyiduna Usman RD maltreated their subjects .When the
public used to report their misconducts to Saiyiduna USMAN RD ,
Saiyiduna Usman RD usually disposed them, but used to re-appoint
them upon their excuse due to his extreme rather infinite love of
Banu Umaiyah.This caused an insurrection.But but but but tetera
times but (1) The truth is some what different:= The governers were
noble and followers of law.Hey were just ,wise and true.Their
RIGHTEOUSNESS is beyond doubt. On the contrary these insurrectors
rebellions were terrorists or terrorist minded . They use to make
false accusations.T he policy of Saiyiduna Usman RD was to dispose
an accused person from his post say Governorship, If the
accusations were found false and untrue, the Noble Caliph used to
reappoint the person against the post.There was no occasion that
these allegations were found true.In other words ALL THOSE
ACCUSATIONS AGAINST THE NOBLE GOVERNERS WERE FALSE.But Ali Mirza
tries to shew that the falt was on the side Of Usman RD who in his
extreme love of Banu Umaiyah and his relatives , and due to his old
age never investigated these accusations properly . A very
incorrect accusation AL AYA:Z:. BILLAHI TAA:LA:.WHAT IF THESE
ACCUSATIONS AGAINST USMAN ARE TRUE:=
If both of these accusations are found true (2) then it is
implicated that Saiyiduna Usman RD had done to great crimes. Al
Ayaz:. Billahi Taa:la: .1] An Undue love for family of Banu
Umaiyah2]His Old age caused him not to investigate these objections
properly.These two accusations are sufficient enough to exclude
Saiyiduna Usman RD from S:ULH:A: If he was too old to decide , he
would easily make a committee for the works.To ascribe these two
crimes to Usman RD is to support the views of Killers , Murderers
and Assassinators of Saiyiduna Usman R.D.These insurrectors were
Heretic, DIS OBEDIENT and ENEMIES Of Islam.They challenged the
Right of the Caliph to Exercise his Legitimate Powers.What so ever
Saiyiduna Usman Did was his Right and these insurrectors had no
right to make objections on the essential right of the the third
Caliph.But Engineer Ali Mirza SUPPORTS the cause of those heretics
who were opponent of Usman RD, MAKING HIM A PURE FAFID:IHad such
objections were made against Saiyiduna Ali , Engineer Ali Mirza
would certainly have declared them as false.Some notes:If it is
proved that Muhammad Bin Abi Bacr was involved in the Murder of
Saiyiduna Usman, he is not getting any benefit of being son Of
Saiyiduna Abu Bacr RD, SINCE HE WAS NO MATCH TO Saiyiduna Usman. He
was surely a heretic for his views about Usman.A Possible Defenses
of Ali Mirza:=1] An error will be called an error even if it is
commited by Saiyiduna Usman RD.Answer:=Engineer Ali Mirza has no
authority to make Judgement on acts of Saiyiduna Usman, that they
were errors . Who has bestowed this Authority to the Engineer. He
is nothing in this regard.He is not the Supreme Justice on the
issue of alleged errors of Saiyiduna Usman.2] A number of other
scholars have accepted some flaw in the managements of Saiyiduna
Usman RD.ANSWER:Engineer Ali MirzAa does not follow any one of
them. He claims that his ideas AND VIEWS depends upon reason
[Dalil] and evidences. So the engineer cannot argue as such even
upon his own claimed standard.3]Some Sah:abah also disputed from
the policies of Saiyiduna Usman RD.Engineer Ali Mirza himself have
said several times Saiyiduna Ali RD was Righteous, and was on
Righteousness [S:H:ABIYAH ].The same answer is for the Caliph Usman
RD, WHO WAS SUPERIOR TO SAIYIDUNA ALI RD.ALI MIRZA IS CHALLANGED
TOMAKE A LIST OF ALLEGED ERRORS OS SAIYIDUNA USMAN,AND IT SHALL BE
OUR DUTY TO DISCUSS EACH AND EVERY ALLEGED ERROR AND TO REFUTE THE
ALLEGATION OF BEING ERROR FROM THE CORRECT ACTS AND DOINGS OF
SAIYIDUNA USMAN RD. OF COURSE ALI MIRZA IS NOT THE ONLY PERSON WHO
THOSE BOOKS OF AH:ADI:S:. WHICH ARE NOT STUDIED IN GENERAL. FURTHER
SHAIKH ALI ZAI IS NOT THE ONLY AUTHORITY ON ASNAD AND
CATOGIRIZATION OF THEM.Problem of Insurrectors and their supporters
like Engineer Ali Mirza:=They all opine that Saiyiduna Usman should
have accepted their demands. This is incorrect. They did not have
any right to demand. At best they could request. What so ever Usman
RD DID was correct and accurate. Unlike Saiyiduna Ali who fought
any one who did not accept him as caliph , If Saiyiduna Usman had
inflicted a war against these rebels these rebels would have
annihilated immediately like denouncers of Zacah. How ever these
ruthless insurrectors did take the advantage of Truthfulness
,Rightneousness ,Kindness and Justince Of Usman RD. The Caliph of
such a large Empire had the Power to Annihilate the rebellions and
the very insurrection it self. But he did not do so. Some people
opine that he should have done this. Our opinion is that what He
did was correct , how ever if he had annihilated them it was also
his right.PROBLEM OF OFFERING PRAYERS BE BEHIND THESE THESE
INSURRECTORS AND TERRORISTS:=Athough Usman RD permitted to offer
prayers behind these Insurrectors , but this permission war
PRE-MURDER . At that time they had not commited the extreme
heretical transgression , so the permission of Usman RD to pray
behind them cannot be used to offer prayers even after the
Martyrdom [SHAHA:DAH] of Saiyiduna Usman RD. Ali Mirza Of Jhelum
cannot use this permission in support of There Terrorists and
insurrectors who killed the NOBLE CALIPH OF ISLAM based on false
allegations. NOTE:=1] I PERSONALLY THANK ALL THOSE WHO PRAYED FOR
THE EYE OPERATION OF MY SON WITH THE EXCEPTION OF ENEMIES OF USMAN
RD LIKE ALI MIRZA AND ENGINEERIAH SECT [FOLLOWERS OF ENGINEER ALI
MIRZA] EVEN IF THEY PRAYED FOR THE SUCCESS OF OPERATION STATED
ABOVE. THERE PRAYERS ARE NEVER REQUIRED SINSE THEY ARE RAFID:I, AND
ALI MIRZA EXERCISE TAQAIYAH.2] IT IS EVIDENT THAT ENGINEER ALI
MIRZA BELIEVES THAT SAIYIDUNA ALI IS SUPERIOR TO SAIYIDUNA USMAN
[AL AYA:Z BILLAHI TAA:LA:], BUT HE HAS SAID IT IMPLICITLY WITH A
CLOSE APPROXIMATION TO EXPLICITY. INSHA ALLAH THE DOGMA OF
SUPERIORILTY OF ALI RD OVER USMAN RD SHALL BE REFUTED INSHA ALL-H ,
INDEPENDENTLY.End of Part 1:-
.
4
