Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 2
Introduction
Welcome to East Riding College’s fourth edition of the Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity (RSA). This journal, published every year, showcases examples of research and scholarly activity which staff and students have participated in, particularly on Higher Education programmes at East Riding College.
Staff are supported to complete RSA projects as part of the curriculum and Staff Development projects fund. There are some excellent examples of RSA projects within the College and a variety of papers including seminar papers from staff competing Cert Ed and PGCEs.
Any staff and students who would like to submit a paper for this journal in the future can do so through the editors, Paul Smith and John Uzzell. All submissions are carefully considered although it may be necessary to edit papers to a maximum 3000 words. The complete papers are available from the College Quality and Teaching Standards Unit (QTSU). The journal is also available on the College’s website and shared with partner universities and colleges.
Please take the opportunity to read the following papers in this edition which are both informative and thought provoking.
Congratulations to all the staff and students who have contributed to this third edition of the Journal.
Paul Smith and John Uzzell (Editors) February 2016
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 3
Contents
Title Author Page
1. The development of teaching strategies for the effective delivery of one element of preparing and maintaining environments for early years settings
Jane Rodley Early Years and Care Tutor at East Riding College
4 - 8
2. Literature Review - Evolution of Apprenticeships within the context of national vocational education programmes in England from 1945 to 2010
Mel Raven – BA Hons in Education and Professional Development at East Riding College Introduction
9 - 14
3. Reflective Essay on an Autobiography – Dave Spikey
Louisa Westmoreland – FD in Learning Support at East Riding College
15 - 27
4. Cognitive Theories into Practice: Introducing Effective Strategies & Structure to an Audio Production Learner with Cerebral Palsy
Phil Owst – Media and Music Course Leader and Music Academy Manager at East Riding College
28 - 36
5. Critically Discuss How Childhood And Youth Research Builds On A Series Of Values, Beliefs And Images About Children And Young People
Tracey Herridge – Curriculum Leader in Early Years and Care at East Riding College
37 - 43
6. Understanding Part Time College Higher Education
Dr Arti Saraswat and Anthony Hudson – Researchers at London: Association of Colleges with Dr Anne Thompson, Independent Researcher
44 - 49
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 4
The development of teaching strategies for the effective delivery of one
element of preparing and maintaining environments for early years
settings
Jane Rodley
Early Years and Care Tutor at East Riding College
Introduction
The rationale for this paper is to improve the delivery and student participation for teaching the
group about creating displays and their importance in early years settings. Bulman and Savory
(2006) reinforce the importance of displays by stating that high quality, engaging displays play a
vital role in creating a positive atmosphere in child care settings. Therefore it is important for
students to understand the importance and be able to create high quality displays.
Having delivered this element last year it was evident that students did not engage with the topic
and as a result motivation was low. Three hours were allotted to creating the display but results
from both groups of students were poor (see Appendix 1).
Reflection following summative assessment, and subsequently for this paper, led me to evaluate
how the subject had been taught and to consider more appropriate teaching strategies. The aim of
this paper is to research and develop more engaging strategies to teach this element and in turn to
motivate and inspire students. It is also intend to ensure that students fully appreciate the role that
displays can play in enhancing children’s experiences and learning in early years settings. It is
further hoped that students will produce thoughtful and creative displays for summative
assessment.
The subject I teach is the BTEC Children’s Care, Learning and Development (CCLD) at level 2. I
am employed at a college which is split across three sites although I am only situated at one site
located close to the centre of a town. There are ten students in the cohort aged between 16 and
19 years of age. Academic ability ranges from entry three up to GCSE and four students have
varying degrees of dyslexia.
The module outcomes I intent to cover are:
KU1 - Critically reviews key pedagogical principles and their implications for teaching and
learning in the specialist area.
KU2 - Critically analyses the theoretical concepts of innovation and creativity in teaching
and learning and their application to a particular specialist area.
A3 - Collaborates with other specialists to develop own professional practice.
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 5
A4 - Applies appropriate teaching strategies and methods within the specialist area.
This will be achieved by researching and implementing teaching strategies aimed at improving
student motivation and participation, including more student-centred activities.
Finally, it is my intention to introduce a task as part of the assessment process in which each
student must produce a short written piece justifying their level of participation in the summative
assessment task. This is to prevent, as previously noted, an imbalance in the amount of work
produced for assignment criteria from some members during the creation of the displays which is a
small groups task. Race (2007) advocates the positive value of small group work in teaching as
this type of collaboration can lead to further learning taking place outside the classroom. However,
Race (2007) also discusses the importance of effective monitoring of such groups by the tutor to
ensure all students are contributing equally. This element of working as a member of a team is
especially important when students become part of a team of early years practitioners.
Critical Discussion
It became apparent during the delivery of this topic that students lacked motivation and were not
engaging with the subject. Reece and Walker (2006) state that the motivation and interest level of
learners can be improved with an appropriate choice of teaching strategies. Having examined the
teaching strategies used to deliver this topic it was noted that they all involve low levels of student
participation according to Reece and Walker (2006). Although student’s motivation is a key
pedagogical principle for vocational courses it is vital that students feel they can relate the topics to
their role as practitioners. This is reinforced by Curzon (2000) who states that students have to
perceive the content as being relevant to them. This could further explain the students’ lack of
engagement as not being included in the creation of displays in their placement settings, they
cannot appreciate fully the relevance of them in their role as trainee child care practitioners. This is
reinforced by Maslow (1970) who cites a sense of personal responsibility as being an important
motivating factor.
I looked at a selection of teaching strategies and evaluated them with reference to the published
levels of student participation according to Reece and Walker (2006). Re-examining these
strategies enabled me to focus on more appropriate and engaging methods. This led me to
consider collaborating with a colleague who, as part of the course she teaches, motivates her
students to produce eye-catching displays. This strategy is reinforced by Reece and Walker
(2006) who consider that more positive results are achieved when students have more than one
tutor. Curzon simplifies this concept further by stating “two heads are better than one” (2006:347).
Acknowledging limitations in my expertise and collaborating with more experienced colleagues
ensures a more positive learning experience for students according to Curzon (2000).
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 6
In order for the students to achieve higher grades for this element of the course it is vital that
strategies are introduced to increase their level of motivation and engagement. This in turn would
help students to secure a higher overall grading for the course which would facilitate progression
on to higher level courses or to gain employment in the child care sector.
As far as possible, and for all practical elements, I decided to utilise various student-led strategies.
Following a short discussion with the group it was noted that the majority of students paid little or
no attention to the displays situated around the campus or in their placements. One such activity
to engage students would involve evaluating the displays around the campus as well as those in
their placement settings. Students would be encouraged once the displays were evaluated, to
enter into discussions around which displays they liked or disliked and why. If photographs were
available students could vote on their personal favourites. These strategies replace previous
classroom based, tutor-led sessions with more student-centred learning. This puts the student at
the centre of their learning experience which enables them to develop their own understanding of
the impact of quality displays in early years settings and perhaps more importantly reach the
Gestalt moment with minimal input from tutors (King and Wertheimer, 2007).
I also decided to adopt a more creative approach by introducing the use of feely bags or treasure
baskets to encourage learners to use their senses. This is important as the assignment criteria
states that the display should promote children’s use of their senses. There is also a section in
which students must justify the way children’s senses could be used positively in encouraging their
interest and participation in the learning environment. To further develop and build on this the
students would be encouraged to participate in tasting and smelling activities. I felt that this was
important as the completed displays had to include the use of the senses which can easily be
overlooked in classroom-based sessions. Tassoni (2008) advocates the use of treasure baskets to
stimulate young children to explore and investigate the objects using all five senses. This concept
can be introduced to early years students and expanded to include how displays can be used to
promote the use of children’s senses which is an intrinsic part of the criteria for this topic.
I also recognised the importance of the vocational element of the course. As each student attends
placement on alternate weeks this could provide opportunities for activities based in the settings.
Kolb (1984) defines learning as an ongoing process that is reliant on experience. An example
could be to choose one or two displays and write about positive and negative points, if the children
engage with them and how they could be improved. The students would also consider displays that
would link to current themes or topics at the setting and also how displays are used to stimulate
children’s interest. Also, as this is a creative activity I could include how students could engage
with the children and get their assistance with creating a display in the setting. The Early Years
Foundation Stage (2012) states that, early years practitioners must support children’s efforts and
encourage them to be independent. This would also link theory to practice and promote the self-
esteem of the children in the child care setting.
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 7
It is important that students understand that displays are not only used to enhance the children’s
interests in specific topics. Displays can be utilised as stimulating resources throughout all areas
of the EYFS (2012). For example they can be used to promote equality and diversity and inclusive
practice by displaying greetings in different languages for understanding communication and
language. They can also be used to encourage the exploration of new objects. The EYFS states
that “children will become more deeply involved when you provide something that is new and
unusual for them to explore” (2012:6). Furthermore displays of family, pets or special people can
be used to help children settle and overcome attachment issues.
However, as with any new topic there was still an element of theory which needed to be covered to
introduce the session and to provide information that students could refer back to when compiling
evidence for assessment. A power point presentation would, therefore, be used to provide minimal
background information and to introduce activities. It would also, as usual, be made available on
the college VLE for future reference.
Having recently introduced an element of peer assessment into my teaching and assessing
strategies I believe this could be effectively utilised when students are planning and creating the
displays. By encouraging them to evaluate their peers’ work it will, in turn, lead to them examining
their own efforts hopefully with a view to making improvements as they progress. Heron (1989)
stated the importance of action and practice in creating more positive learning experiences. This
would again highlight the need to, as far as possible, take learning out of the traditional classroom
based sessions for this topic and utilise the students’ practical experience in placement.
Conclusion
As well as addressing the issue of motivating my students to be more engaged in the creation of
displays it was also vital that they develop an appreciation of the importance of displays in early
years settings. Furthermore it was also important for me to develop more innovative and creative
strategies for teaching this topic, and potentially, other areas of the CCLD curriculum.
Following this research I have broadened my range of teaching strategies to include more
innovative and creative methods which have enabled students to benefit from more practical
activities and less tutor-led classroom based sessions.
Although the link between theory and practice has always been a strong element in the delivery of
the CCLD course, this paper has enabled me to encourage the students to appreciate that the
theory based sessions will have a greater significance once they are employed in the early years
sector. For others, it has given them the motivation to progress on to a level 3 course to further
their knowledge.
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 8
Due to the planning of the curriculum and assessment programmes it has not been possible to
complete the teaching of this topic prior to submission of this paper. However, the research
undertaken has enabled me to identify strategies that, having been used to deliver other aspects of
the course, have been more positively received by the student cohort.
References
Bulman, K. and Savory, L. (2006) Children’s Care, Learning and Development. Essex: Heinemann
Curzon, L. (1997). Teaching in Further Education: An Outline of Principles and Practice (5th ed.).
London: Continuum
Department of Education. (2012). Statutory Framework for the Early Years Foundation Stage.
London: HMSO
Heron, J. (1989) The Facilitator’s Handbook. London: Kogan Page
King, D., and Wertheimer, M. (2007). Max Weirtheimer and Gestalt Theory. New Jersey:
Transaction.
Kolb, D.A. (1984) Experiential Learning – Experience as a Source of Learning and Development.
New Jersey: Prentice Hall
Maslow, A.H. (1970) Motivation and Personality (3rd ed.). New York: Harper Collins
Race, P. (2007) The Lecturer’s Toolkit; A practical guide to assessment, learning and teaching (3rd
ed.). London: Routledge
Reece, I. and Walker, S. (2006) Teaching, Training and Learning: A practical guide (6th ed.).
Sunderland: Business Education Publishers Ltd.
Tassoni, P. (2008) Practical EYFS Handbook. Essex: Heinemann
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 9
Literature Review - Evolution of Apprenticeships within the context of national vocational education programmes in England from 1945 to
2010
Mel Raven – BA Hons in Education and Professional Development at East Riding College Introduction Introduction
Boote and Biele (2005), state that the purpose of a literature review is to evaluate the literature
related to the area of study, which will provide a theoretical basis and also enable determination of
what the research could focus on. This literature review will analyse a selection of literature related
to policies of Conservative, Labour, New Labour and Coalition governments since 1945, referring
specifically to England.
Conservative Party Policies
The Conservative party has traditionally been the party of business and trade, looking to free
choice and market forces to inform policy decisions (Gillard, 2011). Conservatism looks to maintain
traditional institutions and practices in order to maintain social order (Encyclopaedia Britannica,
2015), which is an Elitist ideology (Mufti, 2009). The first post-war Conservative government
formed in 1951, and the party stayed in power until 1964. Educational policy in this time was
closely related to the policies set out by the wartime coalition and National governments in the
early to mid-1940s, and the post-war consensus reached between all political parties was
continued by these consecutive Conservative governments. These governments oversaw an
educational expansion, with the building of around 6000 new schools and 11 universities, and the
introduction of Colleges of Advanced Technology in 1956. Royle (1987) notes that these
technological colleges were brought in to enable Britain to improve workforce skills to enable
competitiveness in the world economy, but that they did not achieve this as fully as possible due to
a perceived need to also deliver humanities and other non-technological subjects in order to meet
demand; there were less people who wanted to complete technological subjects, perhaps due to
societal perceptions.
The Conservative government of 1970 ushered in the age of universal secondary education for all,
by increasing the school leaving age to 16 in 1972; Mufti (2009) states that this could have
conflicted with their ideology, but they did it anyway. Lowe (1989) states that it was during the
1960’s that conservative educational policy shifted towards the comprehensive system.
Conservative policy started to change again with the Thatcherite neo-liberalist era from 1979 to
1991. Kaseem et al (2006) define the neo-liberalist ideology as being one of marketization, choice,
diversity and competition, with high levels of state control. This agrees with Gamble’s (1988)
assertion that ‘liberal democracies tend to develop along the lines of the strong state and free
economy’, which Whitty (2008) concurs with when he states that the Thatcher government looked
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 10
to reduce public expenditure and apply market choice to education. Taylor (1988) states that
critics of the Government declared that state education had been deliberately run down in order to
boost independent education and the public school system. Gillard (2011) and Whitty both agree
that the Thatcher era of government brought education under State control by centralising much of
it; the introduction of a National Curriculum, rigorous inspections, structural reform, and competition
among schools and colleges, all made English education an entity based in the market place as
opposed to being a public service. The defining Act of this period was the 1988 Education Reform
Act, which gave 451 new powers to the Secretary of State; previously, State involvement in the day
to day running of education was minimal, with the only requirements being Religious Education
taught, and children prepared for exams at age 16 and 18. Avis (2007) states that the educational
policies of the Thatcherite era undermined the Technical and Vocational initiative, which prevented
the development of vocational education in order to meet skills gaps; the prescriptive educational
system as set out in the 1988 Act was at odds with the needs of the post-compulsory sector.
The Major years, from 1991 to 1997, followed the same marketization and centralisation policies of
his predecessor. His government introduced the 1992 Further and Higher Education Act, which
extended these policies to the post-compulsory education sectors as well. Gillard states that this
made post-compulsory educational establishments competitors in the market to attract students.
Hodgson and Spours (1999) also agree that this Act, and the 1991 White Paper Education and
Training for the 21st Century (HM Government, 1991) introduced market-orientated approaches to
post-compulsory education. Conservative policy for education during this government was
concerned with economic development and consumer-led approaches. Vocational education
qualification systems were reformed to give them uniformity and credibility (Hodgson and Spours,
1999), and Work-based learning was identified as needing recognition as an important element in
vocational further education. (Richardson et al, 1995). Richardson and Gumbley (1995) identify
that even though work-based learning was recognised as an important element, apprenticeships
declined and the work-based learning route was marginalised in favour of full time college courses
until the mid-1990’s; they were seen as a way to increase participation in education, so Modern
Apprenticeships were announced in 1993 (Richardson et al, 1995). Modern Apprenticeships were
sector based and not time served, and Steedman et al (1998) argue that work-based learning and
apprenticeships reduce the skills deficit more than full time education because they are directly
related to employer needs.
Labour Party Policies
The first Government to come into power post-war was that of the Labour party in 1945, which
heralded the start of the Social Democratic era of ’30 glorious years’. This government enacted
Butler’s 1944 Education Act, which introduced the tripartite system of schooling and enacted Local
Education Authorities (LEAs) to provide county colleges which would provide facilities for full and
part time further education. The Act could have enabled a classless secondary education system
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 11
(Gillard, 2011) but Labour did not go that far; the Act mentioned three types of education – primary,
secondary and further – but these were not enacted in England and the tripartite secondary
schooling system was selected instead. Lowe (1989) identified that many Labour supporters
thought the Government did not go as far as it could have and actually was divisive; a new class
distinction was created in which all those who failed the 11 plus exam were seen as failures who
had to go to secondary modern schools. There were also a lack of places in some areas for those
who passed the 11 plus, so many who were capable of grammar school were unable to go; there
were only places at grammar and technical schools for 25% of all children in England (Royle,
1987).
The next Labour government did not come to power until 1964, by which time, Mufti (2009) states,
it identified much more with the Comprehensive schooling system and the Social Democracy
ideology of prompting equality and widening participation by eliminating elitism (Kaseem et al,
2006). The government of 1964 to 1970 was one which believed in modernisation through the
technical revolution, so preparing people for the workforce was an important factor in developing
education policy (Hodgson and Spours, 1999). This era saw the introduction of Industrial Training
Boards, which became responsible for training the workforce vocationally to meet the needs of
Industry and economic development; as well as providing the courses and apprenticeships, they
designed them so they met the needs of their industries (HM Government, 1964).
The Labour government of 1974 to 1979 oversaw what is seen as definite movement away from
the social democratic ideals of education (Whitty 2008, Chitty 1989 and Gillard 2011). Chitty cites
the School Education in England: Problems and Initiatives (1976), also known as the Yellow Book,
as being the catalyst for the changes that were to come in education. The Book stated that a lack
of discipline and too much freedom was allowed in classrooms, and also that influences outside of
school affected educational attainment. It may have been this report that prompted Callaghan’s
Ruskin speech of 1976, in which education was brought to the forefront of Government thinking.
Callaghan stated in his speech that industry was being let down by the education system,
producing people who were not well enough educated to enter the workforce. The Ruskin speech
started the Great Debate, in which education was put in the spotlight and discussed, and the
results of the debate paved the way for the centralisation of education (Ross, 2000, and Gillard,
2011).
Although the Labour party lost power during the 1980s and most of the 1990s, it was still involved
in trying to shape education policy; Hodgson and Spours (1999) note that Further Education was
neglected in the 1980’s especially, but that the Labour party pushed for the work-based learning
and apprentice systems to have a unified delivery system.
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 12
New Labour Policies
New Labour, under the leadership of Tony Blair, came to power in 1997 with a landslide victory
and the promise of change for the country. New Labour’s attempt at Education policy was to find a
Third Way, in which they would find the middle ground between Conservative neo-liberalism and
Labour social democracy. Mufti identifies this as a Revisionist ideology, which is similar in many
ways to the neo-liberalism of the Conservative era but with injections of socialism. The New
Labour policy statement of 1998 stated that “The Government believes that the excessive
emphasis in the past on market competition has inhibited collaboration, and that strong
partnerships are now needed to develop efficient local strategies for learning” (DfEE, 1998).
Pearce and Hillman (1998) suggest that the Third Way is a position between “the dynamism of the
flexible markets of North America and the social regulation and inclusivity of Continental social
democratic models”, while Hodgson and Spours (1999) take the more common and down to earth
approach that it is a “..pragmatic response to historical legacies of both the Conservative
marketised era and Labour’s past corporatism and ‘tax and spend’ image.” Whitty (2008) disputes
this somewhat, his opinion being that the New Labour policies were merely a continuation of
Conservative policy, with further marketization and privatisation. He states that New Labour
demonstrates a significant move away from traditional Labour ideology. Mufti (2009) concurs with
Whitty’s (2008) opinion, stating that New Labour adopted the neo-liberal ideology of encouraging
market forces in education.
Hodgson and Spours (1999) state that New Labour inherited a compulsory schooling system which
was centralised and had many regulatory systems, whereas the post-compulsory sector had been
left to evolve over time with little regulation; in this respect, Hodgson and Spours (1999) argue,
New Labour could have steered the post-compulsory sector whichever way they chose. New
Labour chose to introduce more regulation to the post-compulsory sector, ostensibly to improve
economic success and increase social justice; they introduced compulsory teacher training for all
staff teaching in the post-compulsory sector, and moved Colleges under the umbrella of OfSTED
so inspections would be carried out to the same standards as schools (Avis, 2009). Coupled with
increased regulation, funding was increased for education with a 56% budget increase from 1997
to 2007; this was done to help industry and business, as opposed to an altruistic reason such as
improving social mobility, but social mobility and inclusion would be increased somewhat anyway
(Gillard, 2011).
New Labour put work-based learning as a priority in 2002, and introduced the idea of using
Apprenticeships as a way to encourage progression onto Higher Education (DfES, 2002).
Apprenticeships were marketed as being a pathway for everyone; a way for those who were
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 13
disaffected at school to engage with education and gain a qualification, and also for those who are
academically good but want to develop work skills and go straight to a career. Avis (2002) states
that the reasoning is sound, but that the quality of apprenticeships was variable and was
sometimes poor; Unwin and Wellington (2001), and Wolf (2002) agree with this. The 2009
Apprenticeships, Skills, Children and learning Act introduced a statutory framework for
apprenticeships and centralised control of further education, and was introduced as a way to
improve the quality of apprenticeships. Apprenticeships and Further Education were now seen as
a way in which to give people the skills to get a job (Nuffield Foundation, 2008). The Guardian
(2009) published an article in which New Labour was accused of encouraging vocational
qualifications instead of academic qualifications such as GCSE’s, a response to all the policy
initiatives introduced since 2001 which championed vocational education for everyone aged 14 and
above (Gillard, 2011).
Coalition Government Policies
The Coalition Government came to power in 2010, and is an alliance between the Conservatives
and the Liberal Democrats. Hazell and Yong (2012) completed a study of the impact of a Coalition
government, in which they identified that instability, incoherent policy, weak decision making and
blurred accountability are all features of a Coalition. They refer to the 56% chance of Coalitions
failing due to inter-party conflict.
The Coalition policies were set out in the 2010 policy document ‘The Coalition: our programme for
government’, and education is low down on their list of priorities (being item 26 for schools and 31
for Further and Higher Education). Their priorities were to ensure that education prepares people
for working, and to remove colleges from direct state control (HM Government, 2010). There was
a definite move to make the secondary education system a marketplace which responded to
parental and market demands, with the creation of Academies which are state funded but run
independently by parents, teachers, charities and community groups. Gillard (2011) notes that the
Academies Act 2010 was supported by the Liberal Democrats and was passed with their votes in
parliament, even though this was the opposite of what they had set out in their 2009 manifesto
Equity and Excellence. Gillard (2011) goes on to state that the academy and free school system
was likely to do harm to English education and create a divisive system in which class and
affluence would affect the education of children; Chitty (2010) and Wiborg (2010) agree with this
view, both stating that inequality and segregation would become more widespread in schools.
There was a large cut in funding, affecting vocational programmes for 14-19 year olds, and the
emphasis moved to academic education for all with increased focus on examinations and tests at
all stages of compulsory education (Gillard, 2011).
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 14
Further and Higher Education also faced cuts and changes; the tripling of tuition fees went against
everything the Liberal Democrats had said before the election, and Cohen (2010) highlights that
the Liberal Democrat submission to Conservative policy caused much discontent among their
supporters. The Educational Maintenance Allowance was also scrapped, which, Gillard argues,
affected the uptake of Further Education by disadvantaged youngsters. Mortimore (2010), in
Gillard (2011) identifies the tacit acceptance that education would become privatised with the
introduction of academies and more stringent funding controls, and goes on to state that the state
education system is collapsing. Ranson (2010) backs up this view by linking the neo-liberal
agenda of choice and competition in schools to the undermining of state education.
Conclusion
The literature review has brought up some somewhat surprising ideas; the movement of New
Labour so far away from original Labour party ideology was unexpected, and the vitriol with which
Coalition policy has been received is surprising; no one has anything positive to say about their
policies.
The remainder of this paper will look at participation in apprenticeships, focusing on the period
1993 to the present day; the reason for this is because Modern Apprenticeships in their current
form were introduced that year, so a fair comparison is more likely as figures will be of a more
comparable nature.
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 15
Reflective Essay on an Autobiography – Dave Spikey
Louisa Westmoreland – FD in Learning Support at East Riding College This assignment is based upon the autobiography of actor, writer and director, Dave Spikey. Born
on 6 October 1951, he was christened David Bramwell, but for the purpose of this assignment and
for ease of referencing his book, he will be referred to by his stage name of Spikey. The main
focus of Spikey’s education and social influences was mostly during the 1950’s and 1960’s,
therefore while his experiences of learning and education will be very different by today’s
standards, comparisons will be drawn with modern education systems and social contexts. Firstly,
his home and family background will be examined to help the reader familiarise themselves with
the setting, before moving on to schooling. As Spikey continued to learn within his medical career
lasting many years, this assignment will only cover his education until approximately age eighteen,
due to word count restrictions.
Spikey was born in the industrial town of Bolton, Lancashire. Living there until the age of twelve,
he described his home as being “…a small terraced house amongst rows and rows of terraced
houses that surrounded the many cotton mills of the town” (Spikey, 2010:17). Complete with an
outside toilet and a tin bath, these were common features of such a house in the 1950s and at first
glance, it could be very much considered an average working-class home. Jackson and Marsden
discuss the homes of the working class during their 1962 research, published in the form of a book
entitled Education and the Working Class. In the revised 1969 edition, they noted the similar
homes which belonged to the ‘prosperous working-class families’ in Huddersfield (p60).
Huddersfield is approximately thirty miles from Bolton, giving a good comparison of location and
prosperity for this assignment. Whilst small in size, the owners of these homes appeared to be
proud of their houses. It is highly likely that this was achieved through hard-work from one or both
parents. However, the idea that Spikey’s own parents were of the ‘prosperous working-class’, is
argued against slightly by some research in the inequality of British education in the twentieth
century. Halsey, Heath and Ridge (1980) used “…a sample of 8,529 males born between 1913
and 1952…” (Kirby, 2000:197). Their report included the use of a three-class model covering
Service Class, Intermediate Class and Working Class. Spikey’s parents in this case fell into the
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 16
Intermediate Class, which included the self-employed and clerical or sales workers. Spikey’s
father was a self-employed painter and decorator, while is his mother was a part-time wages clerk
(Spikey, 2010:14).
During the 1950’s and 1960’s, a typical working class housewife and mother would have been a
full-time job in itself. They would generally stay home to prepare meals, clean the house and look
after children while the husband worked and took charge of financial matters (Castelow, n/d).
Spikey makes no mention of his mother’s education, however Castelow also notes that women of
that time, especially of the working classes, generally left school and went straight into work until
marriage. At this point, a young Spikey would probably have been in Maslows (1954) third level of
his hierarchy of needs. Basic physiological needs of basic care have been met, as well as the
safety needs of level two. The structure of his family appears to be sound which enables him, in
the third level, to give and receive love from those around him (Gross, 2009:141).
There are no reports in his book about any major life-events prior to age four which had any lasting
effects, aside from the birth of his younger sister, Joy, who is three years younger than him
(Spikey, 2010:88). The sibling relationship has always been a close one with Spikey describing
times of protecting her when necessary during childhood, all the way through to time the book was
written in 2010 – “…and when we get together, it’s immediately like old times, like she’s never
been away” (Spikey. 2010:89). Throughout his life, Spikey has also maintained a close
relationship with his parents and often speaks highly of them in the book. As his parents never
separated at any time, it is safe to say that Spikey lived in a normal nuclear family. A close-knit,
nuclear family brings with it effective socialisation. With the main wage earner usually being the
father, the wife “…is mainly responsible for raising the children” (Haralambos, 2004:484). Parsons
(1955a) stated that a nuclear family in an industrial society had two main functions; the
socialisation of the young and of adult personalities (Haralambos, 2004:98). It would be logical to
suggest then, that the choice of early schooling for Spikey was chosen by his mother.
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 17
By all accounts, his first vivid memory is of starting his nursery education at the age of four. Based
within Oxford Grove County Primary School, his recollection of this momentous day is that of the
usual things at school – from obtaining his coat peg to playing games (Spikey, 2010:19). “The
transition from nursery to primary school was seamless, being as it was in the same building”
(Spikey, 2010:19). For some children, beginning a new chapter in their education can be
traumatic. New surroundings and peers can disrupt a routine a child may have previously
developed, especially for those who come from poorer backgrounds and may lack a good support
network in their family (Woodhead, Moss, 2007:13). Spikey had two benefits in his situation.
Firstly, because the nursery was part of the primary school, the surroundings and teachers were
familiar to him. Secondly, Spikey’s supportive parents would likely to have alleviated any fears
prior to moving into his new class.
It is unknown if this is why the school and nursery was set out this way – to help with transitions. It
may have been purely been a price factor when the school was built, keeping children in one
building will cost less than two buildings. The school itself is still operational today, however it was
rebuilt across from the old site and opened in September 2000, under the slightly shorter name of
Oxford Grove Primary School (Jones, n/d). Spikey goes on to thank his teachers from Oxford
Grove and also his “…wonderful parents, who had encouraged me to read and write from an early
age” (Spikey, 2010:79). This reinforces not only his supportive family, but also shows that perhaps
his parents had the higher educational expectations of the prosperous working class, rather than
many of the lower working classes. Douglas noted during some of his own research that:
“…parents who are unskilled workers, for example, will often be of low educational attainment, take
little interest in their children’s school-work…and may well send their children to primary schools
which are ill-equipped, with large classes and less than first-rate teaching”.
JWB Douglas, 1964
Douglas reported these findings on the lower working classes. It can then be said that his findings
also reflect the intellect and aspirations of those families who identify with being prosperous
working class, middle-class or similar. His research is also very much applicable to this
assignment due to it being conducted over eleven years – from approximately 1953 to 1964, which
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 18
also covers much of Spikey’s early education. Collectively, the home and family life enabled
Spikey to pass the eleven-plus examination for entry to grammar school. This will be covered later
in the assignment.
During his primary and junior school years, Spikey often reflects on the many happy times he
experienced with friends and family. Socialising outside of school generally involved playing
outside in the streets which were close to the mills of the town (Spikey, 2010:39). Activities of the
time ranged from What Time is it Mr Wolf? to football, hopscotch and various other traditional
childhood games (Spikey, 2010:39-40). Because of the era this autobiography is set in, it is
important to note that childhoods of the 1950s and 1960s are very different to that of modern
society. A report commissioned by the Daily Telegraph in 2014 concluded that, from one thousand
parents, a quarter of all children spend less than thirty minutes per week playing outdoors.
Reasons for this culture vary between health and safety concerns, blaming the weather and
children having more activities inside the home than ever before (including televisions and
computer games) (Carter, 2014). A majority of the parents surveyed acknowledged that their
children played outside far less than they did during their own childhoods (Carter, 2014). This can
be seen as a generational difference, either on its own or due to other contributing factors such as
consumerism.
The traditional childhood games that Spikey played were mostly because of what resources were
available at that time. The concept of Mr Wolf involved some imagination and running around,
pretending to be scared of the wolf. The game itself cost nothing to play. No special equipment
was needed therefore no nagging of parents, asking them to buy the latest toy for which to enjoy
themselves with. When it came to football, Spikey and his friends would “…play for hours,
sometimes in the dark…” (Spikey, 2010:39). This confirms the Daily Telegraph’s findings of how
little children play outside today and how much things have changed.
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 19
A simple game of tennis with only one racquet was considered fun. Lack of resources meant
improvisations had to be made – hitting the ball against a wall substituted a tennis court, yet much
fun was still had and apparently, “…the wall always won”. (Spikey, 2010:40). Simplicity was part of
everyday life. This may have been an extension of the ‘make do and mend’ attitude from the
Second World War. With today’s health and safety rules, many of the games and activities to pass
the time which once graced British streets are no longer allowed, or perhaps now frowned upon.
But again, with children spending less and less time outdoors, the art of communication and
exercise that Spikey’s generation experienced as children, is being lost. Although Spikey’s family
were reasonably affluent, the social lives of children within his circle were probably not too
dissimilar to those of the lower working classes. Spikey describes an evenings entertainment
which consisted of comics, puzzles, listening to music and watching the coal fire burn (Spikey,
2010:41). Everyone was happy, mostly due to the lack of consumerism.
Consumerism can be defined as “attachment to materialistic values or possessions” (The Free
Dictionary, n/d). In contrast with the twenty first century, children who are from poorer
backgrounds can suffer from material deprivation. Not only can a child feel ‘left out’ because they
do not have the latest gadget, but it can also include the lack of access to resources which other
families take for granted, for example, being without a laptop or a tablet computer. This has
potential to hinder a child’s educational opportunities, simply because they cannot access the
internet. The more affluent families are able to cater to their children’s desires for toys and
devices, perhaps driven by the desire for consumerism. In Spikey’s era, this was virtually non-
existent. This lack of competition between friends over who owned what toys would surely have
continued into school. Material deprivation is also closely linked with cultural deprivation. A child
deprived of culture lacks important skills and values which are extremely important to gaining a
high level of education (Haralambos, 2004:741). This can affect language, cognitive and
personality development (Haralambos, 2004:741), which can be partly due to being unable to
access materialistic possessions such as the computer.
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 20
The friendships created outside of school continued into the classroom. In modern society,
children are at risk of bullying and being labelled by their peers if parents cannot afford even basic
elements for them, such as new shoes or a clean uniform (Chapman, 2011:79). This in turn
impacts on personal relationships and processes, which in a classroom, is defined as
interactionism or labelling theory (Chapman, 2011:79). Interactionists describe someone’s self-
concept as being “produced in interaction with others” (Haralambos, 2004:751). Ones own self-
concept will develop much more deeply when interacting with others on a regular basis. For
Spikey, having regular, physical contact with friends outside of the home enhanced his own self-
worth, adding personal security to his already stable home life. Compounded, this socialisation
was a very positive experience which clearly helped pave his way to passing the eleven-plus
examination and gaining entry to grammar school.
Another element of primary school that Spikey briefly discusses is corporal punishment and his
ability to dodge the impending ruler across his knuckles (Spikey, 2010:19). The punishment was a
form of operant conditioning. Skinner (1958) believed that because punishments and rewards can
control many behaviours, the idea of operant conditioning in corporal punishment would
discourage repetition of undesirable behaviours (Pritchard, 2014:8). At Spikey’s school, the
punishment was the threat of being struck across the knuckles with a ruler. Another recollection of
punishment was from his maths teacher. In the absence of a cane, a broken chair leg would be
used (Spikey, 2010:47). Other settings may have adopted different forms of physical punishment
which were viewed as ‘character building’ (Politics.co.uk:n/d). So despite the reference to the
punishments being fairly short, it must have had an impact on him to be able to recall these events.
The act of corporal punishment in school was not abolished until 1986, with the exception of some
private schools (Politics.co.uk:n/d). It was finally eradicated in 1998 under the Human Rights Act
(1998) by the Department for Constitutional Affairs (2006:15:3.26).
The eleven-plus examination was a result of the 1944 Education Act, which itself was a major
milestone in terms of educational provision in England. Up until this point, many schools had fees
to be paid before a child could attend and the Act enabled free education to all state secondary
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 21
schools (Bolton, 2012:3). However, with the introduction of the examination, results of this
determined which of three types of school a child would attend the following year, automatically
stratifying by academic ability (Heath, Jacobs, 1999:3). This selection system became known as
the Tripartite System. In theory, sending children to a school which suited their abilities or
aspirations is an excellent idea. It meant that for those who were more interested (or suited) to
manual labour jobs went to secondary modern schools, while the more able and gifted pupils
attended grammar schools, where focus was on “…academic studies, with the assumption that
many of their pupils would go on to higher education” (Politics.co.uk:n/d). The Smithills Secondary
Modern School confirms the academic abilities of its intake in a document published in 1965 by the
headmaster of the time. He said:
The policy of offering two-year courses with commercial, engineering and nursing biases to the
more able children and a practical Technical Course for children of lesser academic ability has thus
received a heartening response from pupils and their parents.
KJR Robson, 1965, p107
In the publication there are no mentions of social class, however, due to the “heartening response
from pupils and their parents”, it can be taken two ways. Firstly, those who did have lower
academic expectations or whose families all worked in manual labour jobs, wanted to continue with
their standards of life, perhaps because they were comfortable with the world as they knew it.
Secondly, if the pupils really were of lower abilities, the parents could have been happy to support
their children in whatever career path they chose for themselves, be it managing a home and a
family or a factory job. These traits generally came from the lower working classes.
When Spikey took his examination in 1962, his previous academic attainments meant he was
allocated his first choice of school – Smithills Grammar (Spikey, 2010:79). It is noted on the same
page that Spikey says “my first choice of secondary school” that this appears to be his own
personal decision, rather than that of a parent. This could reflect a growing personal confidence in
the ability to make choices and an awareness of potential life opportunities that can be gained
through academic achievement. Relating this to Maslow (1954), Spikey is now completed the
fourth level of needs, which covers self-esteem, self-respect and a sense of competence (Gross,
2009:141). The next level of cognitive needs is that which can be attained at grammar school.
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 22
The need for knowledge and understanding, curiosity and exploration will highly likely have been
satisfied over the next five years at his school.
Interestingly, Spikey has his own theory on the school systems of that time in Bolton. He believes
that Smithills Grammar, Smithills, Technical and Smithills Secondary Modern were part of an
experimental base (Spikey, 2010:79). Due to the close proximity of these three schools, each one
part of the tripartite system, the pupils from each school were encouraged to mix together during
break times and for sporting events. Originally, the tripartite system was designed with
stratification in mind, yet here was an example of all three schools coming together. Upon further
research, comprehensive schools “emerged as an experiment in a few areas in the early 1950s”
(Bolton, 2012). These experimental schools continued to grow until the 1965 education reform and
the abolition of the tripartite system. If Spikey himself noticed the situation then it is likely others
did too. The research did not uncover any names of experimental comprehensive schemes but
they are likely to have stemmed from those who opposed the tripartite, deeming it to be unfair to
those of lower classes and lower abilities. Spikey puts forward the nation that his experience of
this scheme was in fact a great idea (Spikey, 2010:79). Children still got the education which
suited them the most (academic or vocational), yet still reaped the benefits of coming together,
which helps to break down social barriers by mixing with many types of people. Spikey also had a
fairly unique experience with this experiment. Even during some lunchtimes he would have his
dinner at the technical school instead of his own (Spikey, 2010:80). Another interesting point he
makes is that pupils could either be moved up or down between schools, depending on
performance. Even within modern schools, this is an unheard of practice, so far as this current
research allows. Coincidently, it was the Conservatives who introduced tripartite after the war and
it was Labour who abolished it in favour of comprehensive education. Historically, the
Conservatives are seen as the political party who work for the more affluent of society, which is
why they favoured grammar schools. The Labour has always been the party for the working
classes, who objected to such class divisions and wanted education to be inclusive (Heath,
Jacobs, 1999:3).
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 23
Stratification continued at school for Spikey. Not only were pupils streamed prior to entering
grammar school, they were further streamed from the second year onwards. This was determined
from examination results at the end of the first year (Spikey, 2010:81). As Spikey missed out on
the top stream, by his own admission he “was rubbish at maths” and felt disappointed by this. This
is a reflection of his own desire to succeed academically, whether for himself, to make his parents
proud or a combination of both. From the third year, subjects were now streamed. Although a few
memories of teachers are mentioned at this point, no further references to achievements are
made. It is known, however, that Spikey carried on his education into the sixth form with “…a
vague idea that I’d like to go to university and study medicine” (Spikey, 2010:90). One can assume
from this that he passed his exams with good grades with aspirations of becoming successful in a
medical career. It is here that the reader learns of the unfortunate circumstances which greatly
changed the direction of his studies. “…My dad had an accident at work and as a result I had to
leave school and get a job” (Spikey, 2010:90).
For anyone to find themselves in a situation they could never have anticipated, it can be a time of
uncertainty and worry. Spikey, with his love, sense of loyalty and pride for his parents, stepped up
to the mark and put his studies on hold. Applying for a job at Bolton Royal Infirmary, he
successfully became a Junior Medical Laboratory Technician. At seventeen years old, Spikey
demonstrated a great level of emotional maturity, which can be measured in the ability to make
informed decisions in problems faced in life. Some identifiers of maturity have been listed by
Heartland Family Service (n/d) and include the ability to handle frustrations and control anger,
unselfishness and accepting disappointment without becoming bitter. These are very true of
Spikey’s response to his family’s situation. A great influence on the speed of maturational levels
comes from the nature and nurture provided by the parents as the child grows. Rutter et al. (1997)
defined five principals which play a part in this process, specifically “The interplay between persons
and their environments needs to be considered within an ecological framework” (Bee, Boyd,
2007:472-3). In this instance, it refers to an event which will be interpreted depending on the
function of family structures, culture and possibly social class. For Spikey then, his reaction to
leaving sixth form to earn a wage for his family, came from the care and values instilled in him over
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 24
the years, concluding in what could be considered a success, in the sense that he was able to look
after his family as they did for him. On a developmental level, Maslow would likely say that Spikey
has now met the fourth level of needs – esteem. Within circles and families, we have a need for
recognition. With recognition comes power (Gross, 2009:141). This is observable with Spikey’s
decision making for himself and his family.
It is at this point that Spikey’s formal education will be concluded in this assignment. As mentioned
at the beginning of the writing, Spikey did continue with his medical career for thirty-two years,
working his way up from the entry level position of Junior Medical Laboratory Technician to Chief
Biomedical Scientist (Spikey, 2010:229). To progress this far up the staffing structure would have
taken much hard work and dedication, possibly inspired by his parents aspirations as mentioned
on page five of this assignment. Referring back to Jackson and Marsden (1969), they noted how
“middle-class parents are much more aware of the relativity of procedures of selection and
rejection…” (p99). The authors are referring to primary school selection, however, this knowledge
can be applied to many different circumstances, including that of acceptance to grammar schools
or even gaining employment. Spikey may well have learned these important rules for life at quite a
young age and they made a lasting impression on him. Therefore he could be working and
studying to get what he deserves or desires (Haralambos, 2004:365) in an ideal meritocracy.
The types of school mentioned have also played very large parts of pupils lives, not just Spikey’s.
Those who were successful in grammar school education benefitted from the encouragement and
standards expected from the teachers at such schools, whose aim is academically focused for
preparation of further studies. Similarly, those who attended technical or secondary modern
schools may have also been suitably educated to the levels that were expected of them, largely
based on their social backgrounds. Whilst comprehensive schools were introduced to try and
eradicate or reduce such stratification between schools, for example the grammar schools mostly
attracted the middle-classes, the streaming within subjects nowadays still can have the same
effect, with those in the lower ability streams facing “…a lowering of the morale and consequently
of the achievements of those children who are assigned…” (Yates, Pidgeon, 1959:2:1:65). Pupils
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 25
are still stratified on their intelligence and abilities – something which the comprehensive schools
were created against. Now, the pressure on pupils to do well comes when they take their GCSEs
at age 16. In Spikey’s era, the pressure was on the 11 Plus examination. “The class competition
for educational advantage may simply have been shifted…” (Heath, Jacobs, 1999:1). Education
during the tripartite era compared to today’s standards, had many benefits over comprehensives.
And vice-versa. It can all depend on the social expectations of the family and our socialisation
experiences. While some grammar schools do still exist alongside comprehensives, parents have
a choice as to how to guide their children through school. This means a child will be successful in
whichever school they attend, according to how they are raised and the standards they aspire to.
To surmise, Spikey’s parents have been one of the greatest influences in his school and working
life. His frequent recollections of fond memories throughout the book reflect this and is openly
thankful about it. “I have gained so much respect for my mum…A lesser woman would have been
crushed” (Spikey, 2010:312). Finally, Maslow (1954) could also conclude Spikey’s development as
reaching self-actualisation, whereby he has found contentment and realised his potential in several
areas, including the family and in work (Gross, 2009:141). A happy, supportive childhood has
certainly led to a happy, successful career.
References
Anon, (n/d) Grammar Schools [online] available at: http://www.politics.co.uk/reference/grammar-
schools [accessed 29/04/15]
Bee, H and Boyd, D (2007) The Developing Child (11th edt). Allyn and Bacon, Boston
Bolton, Paul (2012) Education: Historical Statistics. House of Commons, London
Carter, Claire , 6 April 2014 Children spend less than 30 minutes playing outside a week [online]
available at: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/lifestyle/10747841/Children-spend-less-than-30-minutes-
playing-outside-a-week.html [accessed 27/04/15]
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 26
Castelow, E (n/d) The 1950’s Housewife [online] available at: http://www.historic-
uk.com/CultureUK/The-1950s-Housewife/ [accessed 28/04/15]
Chapman, Steven (2011) Revise AS & A2 Sociology. Harper Collins, London
Department for Constitutional Affairs (2006) A Guide to the Human Rights Act 1998 (3rd edt),
Crown Copyright, London
Douglas, JWB. 1964 The Home and the School [online] available at:
https://ebridge.hull.ac.uk/access/content/group/Secondary_PGCE/0_FiPs%20Materials/Social%20
Class/The%20home%20and%20the%20school050.pdf [accessed 29/04/15]
Gross, Richard. (2009) Psychology, The Science of Mind and Behaviour (5th Edt), Hodder Arnold,
London
Haralambos M and Holborn M (2004) Sociology Themes and Perspectives (6th edt), Harper
Collins, London
Health, A and Jacobs, S (1999) Comprehensive Reform in Britain, Working Paper Number 72.
CREST, Oxford
Heartland Family Services (n/d) Teen Maturity [online] available at:
http://heartlandfamilyservice.org/tips-for-families/teen-maturity/ [accessed 05/05/15]
Jackson, Brian and Marsden, Dennis (1966) Education and the Working Class (2nd edt), Penguin
Books, Middlesex
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 27
Jones, H (n/d) Schooling in Halliwell [online] available at: http://www.halliwell-
lhs.co.uk/articles/schooling-in-halliwell/ [accessed 20/04/15]
Kirby, Mark et al. (2000) Sociology in Perspective, Heinemann, Oxford
Pritchard, Alan (2014) Ways of Learning (3rd edt). Routledge, Abingdon
Robson, KJR (1965) Vocational Approaches in a Secondary Modern School. The Vocational
Aspect of Education, Vol 17, Issue 37
Spikey, Dave (2010) Under The Microscope, My Life. Michael O’Mara Books, London
The Free Dictionary (n/d) Consumerism [online] available at:
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/consumerism [accessed 07/05/15]
Woodhead, Martin and Moss, Peter (2007). Early Childhood and Primary Education: Transitions in
the Lives of Young Children. Early Childhood in Focus (2). Milton Keynes: Open University.
Yates, A and Pidgeon DA (1959) The Effects of Streaming. Educational Research, Volume 2,
Issue 1
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 28
Cognitive Theories into Practice: Introducing Effective Strategies & Structure to an Audio Production Learner with Cerebral Palsy
Phil Owst – Media and Music Course Leader and Music Academy Manager at East Riding
College Introduction
Bruner (Bruner, J, 1957) states that learners should be encouraged to discover solutions via
appropriate tasks. For a learner with cerebral palsy the ability to make effective decisions and
achieve desired learning outcomes within the chosen area of audio production, is one of the most
important competencies. Therefore, this specialist paper aims to critically evaluate how effective
strategies and structure can help develop an individual with cerebral palsy and achieve required
learning outcomes. The learning outcomes which I intend to address are, K1 & U1, A2 & 4.
The start of the paper will discuss my specialist area and address key factors affecting teaching
and learning within the area. It will then go on to explain the development of researched methods,
and how specific learning theories and literature have helped assess the learners needs.
It will then discuss the implementation of these methods and critically evaluate how effective
strategies and structure within learning can help achieve effective choices and positive learning
outcomes for a learner with cerebral palsy.
Specialist Area
I teach audio production in further education on the level 1 and level 2 media national diploma
programme at a college in East Yorkshire. Audio production is a practice which involves different
stages of creative production relating to topics, such as; radio production, sound design for film and
audio manipulation. The concepts of audio and sound are very similar to mathematics in that the
subject matter revolves around numerical equations, theory and formulas, and applying these
concepts to course work and specialist software. To put it into context, audio production is a
subject that examines how audio is structured and built within the media industry.
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 29
Factors affecting teaching and learning within my specialist area
Within my BTEC level 1 media group I have one specific learner with cerebral palsy. Learner A has
been aided by a wheelchair and a carer all his life. Due to his disability, learner A is unable to
move, talk and he uses his wheelchair (via computer system) to communicate, instruct and apply
daily tasks. Cerebral palsy is a neurological condition which affects body co – ordination and
general movement. With issues relating to the brain and nervous system, individuals with cerebral
palsy lose the inability to control muscle movement, which results in random uncontrollable body
movements and balance deficiencies. Within the U.K alone an estimated 1 in 400 people are
affected by cerebral palsy (NHS, 2015). Within education physically handicapped learners
experience an array of difficulties due to their motor skills (the inability to use muscles and engage
active movements from the body). Learners with cerebral palsy may incorporate, spasms, which
can effect basic communication. This is very problematic for the learner, as it may reduce learners
to emotional difficulties, self-confidence and low self-esteem within the classroom.
Within the media curriculum Learner A has to follow the BTEC Level 1 syllabus for audio
production, which specifies learning outcomes for the topic, structure and areas of guidance for the
learner. It also specifically outlines the techniques and methods that should be delivered, and
specifies the amount of time for delivery, it also suggests reading lists and online sources. To
summarize, what the learners are receiving is documentation which focuses purely on subject
matter, and while it gives suggestions of creative ideas and practices, it only offers a directory of
discipline to be covered. Learner A found the structure very confusing and the content left the
learner overwhelmed and frustrated. (Criteria example in appendix B) He was unwilling to
complete simple tasks, he became very disruptive, unresponsive to direction and achieving all
learning outcomes became very problematic.
According to the Training and Development Agency for Schools, 2009; “Teachers have a statutory
duty to modify the programmes of study” It also states; “Teachers can modify the curriculum to
remove barriers so all pupils meet the same objectives”. (TDA, 2009, p.05) With this in mind, I
needed to provide an alternative solution through research and investigation to achieve
assessment and learning outcomes for this learner.
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 30
Research (Teaching Practice)
According to Doctor Henning Rye and Professor Donath Skjorten, authors of the – Children with
Severe Cerebral Palsy Guide; “Regardless of presumed, physical, sensory, or cognitive defects,
students should be taught, through skill adaptions wherever necessary.” (Rye, Skjorten, 1989,
p.20) They also state, teachers should “provide the frameworks and clues which the child needs in
order to be able to understand the meaning.” (Rye, Skjorten, 1989, p.26) I feel what they are
suggesting here is, teachers have a duty to incorporate effective creativity, strategies, skill and
structure to enable learners (regardless of their physical nature) to understand the meaning of the
content provided to them, either through the curriculum or another governing body. Also within their
guide Rye and Skjorten, demonstrate a specific model for teachers which outlines five different
types of strategies for effective learning for learners with cerebral palsy; 1) Person - Attachment to
specific persons and thus the establishment of meaningful social relationships will provide a basis
for communication and therefore for learning. 2) Place - The child can learn to recognize and
differentiate between places (and thus between activities and people) 3) Order/ Sequence - It will
be necessary to help the child to receive an overview of the different actions and their sequence in
a single activity as well of what it may expect will happen during a day, a week or a longer period of
time. 4) Time - Time will be closely related to order and sequence and will often be part of it, but
must also be considered separately. 5) Space - An understanding of space is connected to
experiencing, understanding, differentiating and relating something that is two a three-dimensional.
This will also include understanding distance, direction, size, shape, firmness and hollowness.
Another model outlined by the Special Education Support Service (2015), highlights other
possibilities for effective teaching and learning strategies. They suggest teachers should: 1)
Encourage independence 2) Use computers and audio-visual aids in the student’s learning and
teaching programme 3) Allow students extra time to complete tasks 4) Encourage communication
to prevent isolation
Both models seem to address similar areas of teaching strategies. The main emphasis seems to
derive through effective communication with the learner and time management, which allows the
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 31
learner sufficient time to complete tasks. I also believe, through the use of computer technology
better teaching and learning can be achieved.
“Computers can store sequences of instructional objectives and student performance information,
as well as track student progress, complete proper forms and provide required record keeping
data” (Abhiyan, S, p.44)
I also began reading and researching different cognitive learning theorists, such as Piaget,
Vygotsky and Gesalt, and the theorist that seemed more relevant to my specific area and the
implementation strategies for the learner with cerebral palsy, was Jerome Bruner. Bruner’s theories
of meaningful learning and structure are based on the premise that students (even learners with
specific needs) learn something, they manipulate it, apply it and evaluate their work. Also, within
Bruner’s learning theory he advocates the use of discovery learning as “a student – centred
approach in which the teacher’s role is to provide opportunities for the learner to work out
problems” (Scales, 2008, p.65)
“Learners should be encouraged to discover solutions via appropriate tasks” (Bruner, J, 2006)
With his structured approach in mind, I also discovered two interesting literature resources by
authors and teachers, Tanya Dickinson – Teaching Students with Learning Difficulties and Jerome
Rosner – Helping Children Overcome Learning Difficulties. These specific books really opened my
eyes and became the fundamentals into my teaching strategies for the learner with cerebral palsy.
They expressed how to structure learners with these specific needs and keep them engaged by
relating topics to something they are interested in (very similar to Bruner’s methods of structured
learning in that the teacher provides a format to guide the learners). One very interesting method I
read was how implementing frameworks can help simplify learner’s objectives and structure
learners with specific needs. One of the fundamental factors I had affecting teaching and learning
was achieving all criteria objectives and capturing evidence for assessment. Through the use of
frameworks these targets could be achievable.
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 32
Conclusion (Implementation)
Through ICT methods, researched practices and the BTEC level 1 media, audio production
curriculum, I designed digital structured frameworks (appendix 1) to help this specific learner with
cerebral palsy to understand the criteria and become more confident within the module studies.
Within the framework I included all course requirements, but avoided oppressing the learner with
too much information and allowed sufficient time to complete each task, which Rye and Skjorten,
and SESS suggested.
“Pedagogically, the disabled pupil might need a slower rate of progression than others” (Rye,
Skjorten, 1989, p.36)
I made the framework content relevant to the subject matter of audio production, and made all
learning outcomes clear and achievable. It offers the knowledge relating to the subject (discovered
and delivered), and a chance to apply this knowledge to design tasks, such as investigation into
radio products and how audio is used within the industry. Within the framework, there are
opportunities to use specialist software, attain basic skills and apply knowledge to extend the unit
in a personal and creative direction, for example; creating a radio station product. I also embed
literacy into the framework by introducing crossword tasks which incorporate word associations
relating to the subject. While I don’t formally teach comprehension or sentence/ paragraph
structure, I do encourage good writing by giving the learner samples of essay structures (this gives
the learner an insight into different levels of writing and prepare them for what is expected).
Numeracy is embedded in the processes of design work and software practices (example; Adobe
Audition use; timecode, sample rates, bit rates etc.). The learner also has to work out design
structuring, i.e. scale and measurement for poster designs and leaflets based on the information
provided within the framework.
“It is very difficult for students to achieve a learning goal unless they understand that goal and can
assess what they need to do to reach it (Black et al, 2003, p.49)
With the implementation of researched methods and the construction of these digital frameworks,
I believe I now have a medium which helps assess learners with specific needs such as,
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 33
cerebral palsy, and help learners achieve required learning outcomes. Through the effectiveness of
the framework, learner A has successfully completed all relevant criteria outcomes and applied his
own evidence into the digital framework. After achieving positive learning outcomes within the
module, learner A is currently studying within a level 2 media programme and hoping to attain
relevant grades to progress onto a level 3 programme.
Bibliography
Black, P. (2003). Assessment for learning. Maidenhead: Open University Press.
Bruner, J. (2006). In search of pedagogy. London: Routledge.
Daniels, H. (2001). Vygotsky and pedagogy. London: RoutledgeFalmer.
Dickenson, T. (2013). Teaching Students with Learning Difficulties. 1st ed. England: Inclusive
Learning.
Helpguide.org,. (2015). Helping Children with Learning Disabilities: Practical Parenting Tips for
Home and School. Retrieved 23 March 2015, from http://www.helpguide.org/articles/learning-
disabilities/helping-children-with-learning-disabilities.htm
Neary, M. (2002). Curriculum studies in post-compulsory and adult education. Cheltenham: Nelson
Thornes.
Nhs.uk,. (2015). Cerebral palsy - NHS Choices. Retrieved 23 March 2015, from
http://www.nhs.uk/conditions/cerebral-palsy/pages/introduction.aspx
Piaget, J. (2006). Piaget. London: Routledge.
Reece, I., Walker, S., & Walker-Gleaves, C. (2003). Teaching, training and learning. Sunderland:
Business Education.
Rosner, J. (1993). Helping children overcome learning difficulties. New York: Walker and Co.
Rye, H., & Skjorten, M. (1989). Children with severe Cerebral Palsy. France: Special Education.
Scales, P. (2008). Teaching in the lifelong learning sector. Maidenhead, England: Open University
Press.
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 34
Sess.ie,. (2015). Strategies for Learning and Teaching | Special Education Support Service.
Retrieved 22 March 2015, from http://www.sess.ie/categories/physical-disabilities/cerebral-
palsy/tips-learning-and-teaching
Sharp, H. (2010). Special needs 'used too widely'. BBC News. Retrieved 1 March 2015, from
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-11287193
Appendix A
Framework
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 35
Criteria and Aims
Knowledge Assignments Design practices
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 37
Critically Discuss How Childhood And Youth Research Builds On A
Series Of Values, Beliefs And Images About Children And Young People
Tracey Herridge – Curriculum Leader in Early Years and Care at East Riding College
Concepts and images of childhood have evolved historically and changed the way in which society
views children and the life stage recognised as childhood. Current concepts of childhood view
children as unique and competent learners with specific and differing needs in comparison to
adults, however, this has not always been the case.
According to Ariès (1962), the concept of a child having their own specific set of needs was not
considered in the Middle Ages, nor was the idea of childhood as a specific life stage, indeed, the
child was viewed as an ‘adult in waiting’. However, Locke (1632-1704) challenged these views
and argued that the emphasis on childhood was on ‘becoming’ rather than ‘being’ (Uprichard,
2008). Followers of the romantic discourse of childhood, argued that children were innocents and,
as such, need protection and moulding to become responsible adults. This belief acknowledges
that practices should ensure children’s well-being is catered for along the pathway to adulthood
and that that pathway should be supportive and nurturing. This concept was evident in the
aftermath of World War 1 when children were considered as the nation’s future with childhood
needing to be preserved and nurtured. This era also acknowledged that children had their own
identity and their own set of unique needs that differed to those of adults which paved the way for
children’s rights and, eventually, research ethics. Each of these historical conceptual changes of
children and childhood have consequently impacted upon the way in which researchers conduct
research with children and young people and these will be discussed in more detail.
One of the key aspects of research that has been influenced by historical beliefs, values and
images of children and young people is that of individual identity and having a set of unique needs
which have been subsequently enshrined within the United Nations Convention on the Rights of
the Child, referred to hereafter as UNCRC, (1989). The era where children and young people are
seen and not heard has long passed and, in stark contrast to Ariès’ (1962) concept of ‘adult in
waiting’, are acknowledged as individuals in their own right and not ‘mini-adults in the making’
(Nairn and Clarke, 2011). When undertaking research on the lives of children and young people,
who best to provide first-hand information on these experiences than the children who live them
day-by-day. Pahl and Pool (2001) refer to children as being experts within the contexts of their
own lives and that researchers need to listen to their ‘close up worlds’. Adults are unable to truly
understand the diverse experiences and sense what it means to be a child or young person as
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 38
their perspective is biased from an adult’s view and, as such, Fraser et al (2014) refer to the move
away from research ‘on’ children to research ‘with’ children by adopting a more active participatory
approach.
In order for researchers to fully understand issues that involve children, young people and the
experiences of their lives, these same children and young people need to actively participate in the
process. Under the UNCRC, children and young people are awarded rights to provision, protection
and participation which, within the context of research, affords them the right to participate whilst
ensuring their protection from harm. However, these rights do not come without challenge from the
adult world, particularly in relation to children being perceived as competent to make decisions and
become involved in issues that relate to them and their lives. Historically, children have not been
involved in research due to being considered incompetent, as Qvortrup et al (1994) state
“children [are] often denied the right to speak for themselves either because they are held
incompetent in making judgements or because they are thought of as unreliable witnesses
about their own lives (Qvortrup et al, 1994:2)”
However, this perception is critiqued by Hyder (2002) and Lansdown (2005) who consider that
even the youngest children are able to make decisions. Woodhead and Faulkner, (2008:26)
argued that children demonstrate their competencies “in situations which make sense to them”.
Kellett (2004) refers to three different elements relating to children and young people’s involvement
in research; participation, voice and agency. For participation to occur, children and young people
need to be listened to, consulted upon and involved in any decision making. Hart (1992) and Shier
(2001) both theorised the different levels of participation which children may achieve when involved
in research projects, however, both theories were critiqued by Kirby and Gibbs (2006) due to the
constant shifting balance of power which makes it difficult to assign and sustain a single level of
participation, therefore, suggesting that children and young people could not ascertain ownership
or power within the research process. Gabb (2010) challenges this view and argues that research
participants can control lines of questioning, thought and disclosure and, as such, cannot be
considered powerless.
In order to fully participate in research, individuals need to be able to express their thoughts and
views freely and this right is awarded by Article 13 of the UNCRC (1989) which states that children
“shall have the right to freedom of expression”. Children and young people are able to exercise
this right by being involved throughout the planning, implementation and evaluation process of the
research project, which is evidenced in Davidson (2008), however, in order for individuals to
exercise their voice, an environment that is safe and conducive to expression must be established.
In addition to verbal expression, Bucknall (2004) places equal emphasis on listening to silence
which can convey multiple meanings including lack of comprehension or misunderstanding,
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 39
reluctance to answer for fear of potential reprisal or effects based on their response. Failure to
acknowledge and respond to these silences clearly excludes the child or young person from
participation. Whilst the UNCRC (1989) awards children and young people the right of expression,
this right is not universal as it does not take into account cultural or geographic differences which
then results in children’s right to expression being inadvertently suppressed. This is seen in Porter
and Abane (2008) who argue that researchers have an ethical responsibility in ensuring all children
are listened to.
In order for children to participate, have a voice and express their views, researchers need to
ensure the methodologies they employ are age/stage appropriate for their participants. Clark and
Moss (2001) did precisely this by adopting a selection of methods that facilitated the young
participants in their study to document aspects of their daily lives in nursery. The range of methods
utilised provided a fully inclusive approach which enabled even the youngest children to take an
active role in the project. A similar approach to listening to children and young people was adopted
by Pahl and Pool (2011) who utilised a multimodal approach to their research methodology which
gave the research participants licence to develop their own methods rather than have them
imposed upon them by the project leaders. Aldgate (The Open University, 2014) also supports this
view by stating that when conducting research adjustment to research techniques were made to
meet the needs of younger research participants.
Kellett (2014) argues that the final element of agency can only be achieved once change has been
effected as a result of participation and voice, however, the extent to which full ownership or total
participation in research can be achieved is challenged by Franks, in Pahl and Pool (2011) who
refers to total participation as a ‘false goal’ and that a more realistic idea is for children and young
people to acquire ownership of elements of the research, thereby becoming stakeholders rather
than owners. Punch (The Open University, 2014) argues that although the changing role of
children and young people in research is helping to address some of the imbalances of power,
control will ultimately remain with the adult as involvement of children and young people at all
stages of research may be difficult. Evidence of this is seen in ‘The Growing Up in Cities Project’,
Chawla and Driskell (2006) whereby despite the children undertaking the research as active
participants and primary researchers, the findings from the children’s perspective were not
compatible with the perspectives and priorities of the key stakeholders.
Whilst participation in research is one way of children and young people exercising their rights, this
participation must be underpinned by a series of ethics and protocols that support and protect the
individual concerned. According to Alderson (2014) rules for ethical research place an emphasis
on principles, outcomes and rights which aim to ensure research subjects are respected, awarded
dignity and receive sensitivity towards their needs and feelings. Harm or costs that may impact on
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 40
the project are avoided and promoting the research in informing future policy and practice is a
focus. Finally, children’s rights are promoted in accordance with provision, protection and
participation as underpinned by the Articles of UNCRC (1989).
Children and young people are vulnerable to exploitation from external factors so it is imperative
that ethics are applied in order to protect children and young people from unscrupulous conduct
and processes which may cause them harm. The participation of children and young people in
research is essential for governments, organisations and other agencies to understand their worlds
so that policy and practices can be informed with a view to improving outcomes. Every Child
Matters (2003) government consultation paper states that ‘Real service improvement is only
attainable through involving children and young people and listening to their views’. Nairn and
Clark (2011) state that researchers are faced with a challenge of finding the balance between
protecting children whilst at the same time allowing for their voices to be heard. Participatory
research also contributes to children and young people being empowered as well as developing
thinking and decision making skills that are essential for life as an independent adult.
One of the key ethics in relation to research with children and young people is that of obtaining
consent to participation. Obtaining consent is essential in ensuring that potential research subjects
are aware of what is involved in the study, along with the potential risks, demands and implications.
Research participants need to enter the study freely and of their own accord, with an
understanding that they have the right to withdraw from the study at any time. However, ethical
guidance suggests that parental consent is sought from young people as old as 16/17 years of age
which could result in a possible scenario whereby the child has expressed their view to participate,
yet the parent has declined consent. In this instance, the rights of the child are in direct conflict
with the rights of the parent. Whilst the UNCRC (1989) gives children and young people the right
to express their views and actively participate, Article 18 states that parents have responsibility for
raising their child and should act in the best interests of their child, thereby over-ruling their child’s
rights under the same convention.
Before children are offered and then give their consent to participation, the question of competency
needs to be considered. Historically, children have not been considered competent to participate
in research due to their level of immaturity, lack of expressive or receptive language and inability to
understand the research processes. Each of these factors resulted in children being perceived as
ineffective and invalid contributors to research, however, the same could be said of some adults.
Equally, there are some children who are competent at participating in research in the same way
as adults (Fraser et al, 2014). It is important that researchers and parents do not mistake
immaturity for incompetence and accept that children can be competent participants as evidenced
by Flewitt, et al (2009) in Cooper (2014) whereby age and cognitive/language factors were evident,
yet the children actively participated.
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 41
Whilst participation and consents are amongst the many different ethics that underpin research
values, it is important not to become preoccupied with ethics as this may lead to the outcomes of
the study being shaped (Gabb, 2010). Leeson (2014) further warns of being over-cautious with
ethics as this may result in research being diluted which results in children’s voices being silenced.
To conclude, contemporary values, beliefs and images of childhood have been influenced by the
disciplines of psychology, anthropology and sociology in different ways. The psychological
discipline views childhood as a unique life stage dissimilar to the experiences of adults, as does
the sociological discipline, which also recognises that children and young people are competent
and social actors within an adult-shared world (Kellett, 2004) who are able to participate in issues
that relate to them. However, recognition of childhood as a unique life stage signifies that research
subjects must be treated differently to adults in a way that meets their unique and developing
needs, with research methods that are age/stage appropriate and facilitate full participation.
However, the ethnographic discipline is faced with a conflict regarding children and young people’s
rights, especially in relation to participation and voice as these rights may not necessarily be
compatible with the life practices of non-Western cultures. This could potentially cause conflict and
harm to the child participants so researchers need to adopt their practices to ensure this is avoided
and the children protected.
References
Alderson, P, (2014) ‘Ethics’ in Clark, A., Flewitt, R., Hammersley, M. and Robb, M. (eds)
(2014) Understanding Research with Children and Young People, London, Sage.
Ariès, P (1962) Centuries of Childhood, London: Cape
Bucknall, S, (2014) ‘Doing Qualitative Research With Children and Young People’ in
Clark, A., Flewitt, R., Hammersley, M. and Robb, M. (eds) (2014) Understanding Research with
Children and Young People, London, Sage.
Chawla, L and Driskell D, (2006), ‘The Growing Up in Cities Project’, Journal of Community
Practice, vol 14 no1-2, pp 183:200
Clark, A and Moss, P (2001), Listening to Young Children: The Mosaic Approach, London: National
Children’s Bureau (2nd edition, 2011)
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 42
Cooper, V. (2014) ‘Designing Research for Different Purposes’ in Clark, A., Flewitt, R.,
Hammersley, M. and Robb, M. (eds) (2014) Understanding Research with Children and Young
People, London, Sage.
Davidson, S (2008) ‘What children think about having a thyroid disorder: A small-scale study’, The
Children’s Research Centre, The Open University [Online]. Available at
http://www.open.ac.uk/researchprojects/childrens-research-centre/research-children-young-
people/aged-9-10 (Accessed 15 March 2014)
Donaldson, M (1978), Children’s Minds, London: Fontana
Every Child Matters (2003), London: Chief Secretary to the Treasury, Stationery Office
Fraser, S, Flewitt, R and Hammersley ,M. (2014) ‘What is Research with Children and Young
People?’ in Clark, A., Flewitt, R., Hammersley, M. and Robb, M. (eds) (2014) Understanding
Research with Children and Young People, London, Sage.
Hart, R (1992), Children’s Participation: From Tokenism to Citizenship. Florence: UNICEF
Hyder, T (2002), ‘Making it happen: Young children’s rights in action’, in B Franklin (ed), The New
Handbook of Children’s Rights: Comparative Policy and Practice, London and New York:
Routledge
Kellett, M. (2014) ‘Images of childhood and their influences on research’ in Clark, A., Flewitt, R.,
Hammersley, M. and Robb, M. (eds) (2014) Understanding Research with Children and Young
People, London, Sage.
Kirby, P and Gibbs, S (2006), ‘Facilitating participation: Adults’caring support roles within child-to-
child projects in schools and after-school settings’, Children & Society, vol 20 no 3, pp209-22
Lansdown, G (2005) The Evolving Capacities of the Child. Florence: Innoncenti Research Centre
Leeson, C (2014) ‘Asking difficult questions: exploring research methods with children on painful
issues’, International Journal of Research and Method in Education, vol 37 no 2, pp206-222
Nairn, A and Clarke, B (2011), ‘Researching children: are we getting it right?’, International Journal
of Market Research, vol 54, no 2 pp177-198
The Open University (2014) ‘Quantitative and qualitative research: What is research?’, K313 Study
Resources [Online], Available at
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 43
https://learn2.open.ac.uk/mod/oucontent/view.php?id=371838§ion=1.3.2 (Accessed 16 March
2014)
Pahl, K and Pool, S (2011), ‘Living Your Life Because it’s the Only Life You’ve Got’, Qualitative
Research Journal, vol 11, no 2 pp17-37
Porter, G and Abane, A (2008), ‘Increasing children’s participation in African transport planning:
Reflections on methodological issues in a child-centred research project’, Children’s Geographies,
vol 6, no pp151-67
Qvortrup, J, Bardy, M Sgritta, G and Wintersberger, H (eds) (1994) Childhood Matters. Vienna:
Europe Centre
Rousseau, J (1762) Emile, or On Education, transl Alan Bloom. Harmondsworth: Penguin (1991)
Shier, H, (2001), ‘Pathways to participation: Openings, opportunities and obligations’, Childen and
Society, vol 15 no 2, pp107-17
United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) (1989) Geneva: United Nations
Uprichard, E (2008), ‘Children as being and becomings: Children, childhood and temporality’,
Children and Society, vol 22, no 4 pp303-13
Woodhead, M and Faulkner, D (2008), ‘Subjects, objects or participants? Dilemmas of
psychological research with children’ in P Christensen and A James (eds), Research with Children:
Perspectives and Practices, 2nd edition, London: Routledge Falmer: pp10-39
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 44
Understanding Part Time College Higher Education
Dr Arti Saraswat and Anthony Hudson – Researchers at London: Association of Colleges
with Dr Anne Thompson, Independent Researcher
Executive Summary
This summary presents the main findings from the research on part time English College Higher
Education (CHE) commissioned by the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills and the
Association of Colleges. The research has been undertaken by Continuum, University of East
London.
The research is based on a sample of 30 colleges chosen to reflect different patterns in the level of
change in part time HE numbers, the volume of the part time HE numbers, delivery of prescribed
as well as non-prescribed provision, delivery of directly funded and indirectly funded provision, as
well as the location of colleges (in English regions). The sample included 2 colleges from the East
of England, 2 from the East Midlands, 4 from Greater London, 4 from the North East, 5 from the
North West, 3 from the South East, 4 from the South West, 1 from the West Midlands and 5 from
the Yorkshire and the Humber region.
The research used qualitative as well as mixed methods approaches. The fieldwork included in-
depth face to face interviews with College HE leaders/managers, as well as completion of student
surveys by students at the 30 participating colleges. Findings from six focus groups have enriched
the findings from the student questionnaires.
Key points
Trends in College HE
Provision of higher level qualifications in colleges has a long history with variation in its recognition,
funding and regulation. The role of FECs in providing HE has largely been framed with an
emphasis on vocational, accessible, local, responsive and employer-focused provision.
There is a disjunction between policy and practice. HEFCE has for some time encouraged an
expansion of higher education in colleges but the reverse has taken place.
Based on the total population of students registered on programmes of HE at HEIs or FECs in
England in 2012/13, (including students registered at FECs only where they are studying a
prescribed course of HE), a total of 6.7 percent of HEFCE recognised undergraduate HE is taught
in FECs. Therefore, the proportion of recognised undergraduate HE that takes place in FECs is
only a relatively small proportion of the overall recognised undergraduate HE that takes place in
FECs, HEIs and other providers.
In comparison with HEFCE recognised provision, the NPHE (that is not funded by HEFCE) is a
smaller component of College HE. Whilst the FPE count for total HEFCE recognised numbers was
108, 595 in 2012/13, the NPHE numbers were 40,110 (in headcount terms).
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 45
There has been an overall decline in part time College HE. The decline in HEFCE recognised part
time HE was 32 percent, which is a steeper decline in percentage terms in contrast with the decline
of 12 percent in part time NPHE.
There has been a decline in HEFCE recognised part time student numbers across all regions of
the country, and although NPHE part time numbers have also declined, some increase in the
numbers have been noted in London and in South West England. The part time HEFCE
recognised as well as part time NPHE are studied predominantly by older students (25 and over)
and therefore it confirms that part time CHE strongly caters to the needs of older students. The
numbers of both male and female students studying recognised HE has declined, however, the
numbers of female students have declined more steeply.
The most popular HEFCE recognised subjects studied by the students are Education, and Initial
Teacher Training, Business and Administrative Studies, Creative Arts and Design and Engineering
and Technology. Education and Training, and Business and Law are also the most studied NPHE
subjects. Whilst there has been a steep decline in the numbers of students studying part time
HEFCE recognised Education, and Initial Teacher Training courses, the numbers of those studying
NPHE Education and Training courses has shown some increase. Students studying part time
Business courses (both HEFCE recognised and NPHE) have declined notably.
While the number of students from ethnic minority groups has declined in terms of part time
HEFCE recognised courses, the numbers of students from minority groups studying part time
NPHE courses has increased. Both HEFCE recognised as well as NPHE (non-HEFCE funded) are
predominantly studied by students whose domicile is English.
Reasons for decline in part time College HE
The decline in part time CHE is of significant concern to the colleges. It is known to play a crucial
role in widening participation and providing HE opportunities to this who may otherwise not have
access to HE. The decline is also of concern because part time CHE makes an important financial
contribution to the colleges.
One of the main reasons for the decline in part time HE was perceived to be related to the new fee
and funding regime. The introduction of part time loans was generally viewed to be unhelpful
because mature students with work and familial commitments, were known to be debt averse and
were less likely to take out loans to fund their part time studies. The lack of awareness of loans
was cited to be another reason which affected part time recruitment.
The economic situation and employer reluctance in investing in staff training and development was
also viewed to be a crucial factor in explaining the decline. This was a particular issue in regions
were any economic recovery was very slow. Part time HE was noted to be studied mainly by those
in employment and often funded by the employers. Under financial constraints, employers were
also believed to expect their staff to take out loans with a possibility to repay their loans.
ELQ ruling is also believed to hinder the recruitment of those with prior HE qualifications and
wanted to retrain to change careers. This was believed to ‘limit’ the career options and ‘trap’ people
in their jobs. Recruitment of part time students was also viewed to be more challenging than
targeting prospective full time students.
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 46
Part time recruitment is also believed to affected by the relative attractiveness of the full time offer
at some of the colleges. In instances where the colleges delivered full time HE over a contact time
of one or two days per week, colleges advised their students to consider full time options,
especially in instances where the student was likely to secure a maintenance grant. Rather than
working full time and studying part time, students were offered alternatives to study full time, work
part time and draw a maintenance grant.
The decline in part time HE numbers was also noted to be underpinned by the complex decision
making of mature students which were based on a number of factors, such as, finances, childcare,
personal circumstances of their partners and families, and under multiple pressures, students were
believed to often forego their opportunities to study HE. Furthermore, targeting and recruiting part
time students was viewed to be notably more challenging than identifying and promoting CHE to
full time students. Unlike UCAS, there was no centralised admissions channel to provide any early
indicators for part time recruitment. Targeting part time students often meant reaching out to the
local employers and more targeted community based promotional activities.
College strategies to address the decline in part time CHE
A number of colleges had lowered the fee for part time provision, this lowering of fee was driven by
making the provision attractive to employers as well as prospective students, for others, it was
guided by low cost principle based on the less contact time that part time students had at the
colleges. Colleges were focussing on raising awareness of and promoting part time tuition fee
loans to encourage more students to study part time HE.
Most colleges were focussing on enhancing internal progression of students on apprenticeships,
FE and NPHE courses. Colleges were also simultaneously expanding and revising their offer, and
promoting their part time courses more strategically. Furthermore, a number of colleges were
considering flexible delivery models including block delivery, delivering over the weekends and
evenings, delivering courses on the employers’ sites. Whilst e-learning and blended learning
models were favoured by a number of HE leaders, they were expensive and colleges did not have
the resource and capacity to support this form of learning. Separating part time provision rather
than in-filling with full time, accreditation of prior experiential learning and credit accumulation and
transfer were also areas of strategic focus for some colleges.
Working closely with the employers and meeting their needs was crucial aspect of part time HE.
Whist most colleges exemplified ways in which they collaborated with the employers, it appeared
that there were specific instances of good practice, however, colleges needed to develop their
relationships with local employers. Business development units were helpful in developing and
strengthening these relationships.
A need for colleges to differentiate their offer was also noted. Interviewees from city based colleges
that operated within short distances from local universities, perceived a stronger need for
differentiation in contrast with colleges based in rural areas where the competition was less
intense.
Recommendations are also directed for colleges to help make part time HE more attractive and
accessible. Colleges need to identify innovative ways of engaging with the local communities as
well as local employers. Colleges also need to establish innovative approaches to make part time
HE more attractive by considering flexible modes of delivery, and recognising prior learning. Part
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 47
time HE needs to be conceived as flexible provision rather than viewing part time HE as a residual
form of HE.
Student choice and motivations
Although a majority of the respondents were mature students, part time students are not strictly
indicative of them being mature students. Nearly one fourth of the respondents who took part in the
survey were young students under 21 years of age.
The main reasons identified by the students to study HE were instrumental in nature, however,
other non-instrumental reasons were also important during their decision making. Students also
indicated that they wanted to do something for their own self and they wanted to do something
useful/different with their lives. The key reasons underpinning the students’ decision to study part
time were because they were in employment and they did not wish to risk losing their jobs, as well
as to gain work experience whilst studying. Other personal reasons, such as, family commitments
also influenced students’ decision making to study part time HE.
In terms of choosing a further education college over a higher education institution, apart from the
availability of course, lower tuition fees and location, familiarity with the college learning
environment in general or a particular college were also important. The key reasons for choosing
their courses were the ability to fit their course around their work commitments and the funding
from the employer. A majority of students were in employment and the ability to manage their work
and studies was a crucial aspect of their decision making. The choice of the course also related to
their career enhancement and employment opportunities in general. The choice of the particular
college was also related to their employment because for a notable proportion of students the
employer links with their colleges was an important factor underpinning their choices. Location of
the college and its proximity to home was also an import part of students’ decision making.
Employers were also rated to be one of the main sources of careers advice and guidance,
however, a number of respondents did not use any source of careers advice and guidance. This
suggests that the colleges can develop this aspect of support and guidance for part time students
so that part time students can make better informed choices and decisions for their studies.
Tuition fee and part time loans
The tuition fees were fully paid for by the employers for a majority of students, although a higher
proportion of prescribed HE students secured full funding for their tuition fees than NPHE students.
Nearly one fourth of the prescribed HE students who started their courses on or after September
2012, used part time tuition fee loan to fully pay their tuition fees. A large proportion of students
were not even aware of the tuition fee loans and there was some evidence from the focus group
discussions to suggest that the students may become aware of the loans only after commencing
their studies.
Nearly one fourth of the students (prescribed HE, new fee regime) confirmed that they would not
have studied their course if the loans were not available. Therefore, there is a need for clear
information about loans to be provided by the colleges as well as nationally.
Colleges, in particular, need to ensure that this information is provided to the prospective students
during the early stages of students’ decision making process.
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 48
Student experiences and employer support
Students rated their experience of studying HE in their colleges to be generally positive. A majority
of students believed that their courses were intellectually stimulating, they were satisfied with the
level of learning support they received, and were satisfied with the feedback they received from
their tutors. A majority of students indicated that their experience of studying at their colleges had
been positive. However, students seemed to be less satisfied with the library and IT facilities, and
through the focus group discussions, other aspects of their learning experiences, such as, the
inflexible assessment deadlines emerged to be challenging for part time students.
Extended deadlines were also noted by the survey respondents as one of the ways that could help
improve their learning achievements. Students also preferred completion of one module prior to
commencing another one to help their learning. Colleges need to consider flexible approaches of
delivering HE for part time students in order to assist them in balancing their studies with other
work and family commitments. A large proportion of respondents confirmed that they did not have
enough time as they would like to devote to their studies. This mirrors the arguments made by the
focus group participants who ‘juggled’ with work, studies and family commitments.
Although the employer support can take a number of forms, the most common and valued support
is in the form of funding of tuition fees and time off work to attend college. However, not all
employed students received support from their employers. The most valuable form of support from
the employers that could help improve the learning achievements of students were funding for the
courses, options for study leave as well as flexible work options.
Recommendations for the role that can be played by the Government
The following recommendations were made by the college HE leaders and managers:
The government could incentive the employers by offering tax incentives to employers that
sponsored a larger number of employees each year.
A reconsideration of funding of part time prescribed HE was highlighted by a number of colleges,
as part which, the costs of delivery of part time HE could be subsidised by the government.
Recommendations were also made to make part time HE more affordable to the students by
offering maintenance grants to part time students in the same way as they are extended to full time
students. This was noted to help reverse the switch in the preference of those students who
preferred full time studies over part time studies for financial reasons, especially where full time
provision was delivered almost in a part time mode.
The need for a national campaign on promoting part time tuition fee loans as well as promoting the
significance of part time HE was strongly voiced. The necessity for individuals to understand the
enhanced prospects and better opportunities that HE could present were critical to secure a ‘buy-
in’ from potential learners. The campaign should focus on the opportunities that part time HE could
provide to individuals in advancing their careers and lives and particularly target mature students
who may already be in employment and may feel ‘why do I need HE, I am already in employment?’
or those who are not in employment but do not think of HE as a way forward in life.
A revision of the ELQ ruling was also demanded and whilst the government was not expected to
fund those completing multiple degrees generally, however, it was recommended that exceptions
Journal of Research and Scholarly Activity 2015-2016 49
must be made for part time students wanting to study to secure or change employment. In other
words, those using part time HE as employment routes must be exempt from the ELQ rule.
One of the routes for increasing part time HE was through growth in apprenticeships. The
government could assist in promoting part time HE through funding higher apprenticeships,
although the method of funding (directly to employers) was recommended to be carefully
considered.
Related to funding, it was recommended that the government could encourage more 19-24
students who study Access to HE courses, by waiving their loan repayments for the Access to HE
programmes after they graduate.
The government could also promote specialisation in specific subject areas amongst the colleges
through capital investment, for instance, through setting specialist centres that require large sums
of investment, which in turn, will deter other colleges to compete for identical markets.
College HE leaders did not necessarily have access to accurate and adequate labour market
intelligence sources and any information held by specific unit within the colleges was seen to be
patchy and detached from those making strategic decisions about HE. Colleges did not understand
the ‘markets’ in which they were operating. It was recommended that the government could assist
by re-investing in the Sector Skills Councils.
In addition to the recommendations made by the interviewees, the research team recommends
that an integrated dataset for prescribed HE and NPHE is maintained, because dual reporting
systems do not help understand and interpret breadth and patterns in CHE.