-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
1/27
$'##%&%&
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
2/27
V
W _aXXW^_ X^[ _\ZS TXVS S U[ZYWZ`S VWXWU` `[`W [cW^ _\ZW cU
ZWYS`bW SXXWU`_ `W ZW^bW_a\\ `[ `W [cW^ T_ TSVVW^ SZV T[cW W_aXXW^_
X^[ S T^SZ VWXWU` S_ cW
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
3/27
`W `W _W cS_ `c[SZVSXWS^_ [V _W cS_VSYZ[_WV S_ ^W`S^VWV Sa`_`U
Z[` Xa Y^[cZ Z[`
STW `[ cS [^ `S _aXXW^ZY X^[ WS^` V_WS_W TSVWS^ZY SZV TSV WW_Y`
W cS_ aZSTW `WZ `[^WU[YZ_W W^ \S^WZ`_ W SV TWWZ SV``WV `[ `W[_\`S
ZZW `W_ VaW `[ aZ_`[\\STW U^ZYTWWbWV `[ TW USa_WV T \SZ
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
4/27
"""
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
5/27
JW UST^[aY`T`W\S^WZ`_[XSUV
T[^Zc`_WbW^WVWXWU`_SYSZ_`S\_USZ
ZWYYWZ`YWZW`UU[aZ_WZY \[__T``S``W[`W^cYbWT^``[_aUSUV
`Wc[aVZ[`SbWU[ZUWbWVSUVX`WSVTWWZYbWZSVW]aS`WZX[^S`[Z
XSZY`[VSYZ[_WSU[ZV`[Z[X`WXW`a_[X`W[`W^Va^ZY\^WYZSZU
`Wc[aVSbWST[^`WV`WXW`a_X`WSVTWWZ\^[\W^ZX[^WV[X`W^__
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
6/27
JnO WSU [XZWYYWZUWSS^_W\^[^`[U[ZUW\`[Z
O `W\S^WZ`_cW^WVW\^bWV[X`W[\\[^`aZ` [Sb[V
`WU[ZUW\`[Z[^\^WYZSZUZ`WX^_`\SUW ZWYYWZ`\W^X[^WV_`W^W_S`[Z[^
bS_WU`[
SZ[__[Z`[cS^ZST[a``W^__[XS_`W^_S`[Z
[\W^S`[ZXSZY`[SUWbW`_\a^\[_W
ZWYYWZ`YWZW`UU[aZ_WZYST[a``W^__[XSbZYSUVc`SU[ZYWZ`SV_ST`
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
7/27
n#J
f#Jn^[ZYXa ^`
^WZS`SZWYYWZUW[UUa^^WVTWX[^WT^`
V[U`[^ XSWV`[VSYZ[_WVWX[^`W_V_ST`W_[X`WXW`a_
XSa^W\W^X[^SZUW[XST[^`[Z
^[ZYXa[ZUW\`[Z
^WZS`SZWYYWZUW[UUa^^WVTWX[^WU[ZUW\`[Z XSWV_`^W^_S`[Z bS_WU`[
Jnn ffnfn fnJ ffnfn nff
nnn
fffJ
ff nff
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
8/27
ffnf
nO [ZYXaT^` Z[``WUV`_WX_aZcSZ`WV
VWXWU`bWUV_aZcSZ`WV
O [ZYXaU[ZUW\`[Z Z[Xa^`W^UV_cSZ`WVS`S
aZcSZ`WV\^WYZSZUW_
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
9/27
ff YWZW^SVSSYW_\SZSZV_aXXW^ZY
YWZW^SVSSYW_[__[XSWZ`
_\WUSVSSYW_ [__[XWS^ZZY_ZUa^^WVT`W[`W^
`WU[_`[Xa\WW\[X`WUVaZ`#
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
10/27
fnfnf
088319
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
11/27
@fnO WbWSV_S
O SWbSa^UW
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
12/27
fnfnfO US^SZWbS_VWWS`[S^V
Z[[ZYW^WZ``W`[^WU[bW^VSSYW_
O SWbSa^UW TST_SW``Wa\WW\[X`WUV`#[`W^_[__[XWS^ZZY
O WZb[[_Ta^WS`[`[^`
YWZW^SVSSYW_ SZ`XXS_[^WUWbWVUS_X[^[__[X[`W^_WS^ZZY
U[_`[XW]a\WZ`UVZVZYU[_`_SZVU[_`Z^W_\WU`
[XSU[ZbW^_[Z[XSYS^SYWZ`[X[a^`TWV^[[
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
13/27
fnfnfO S^Z_[Zb`SW_
O S^VSZbZ
O WZW^SSSYW_
SZVbS_`[^_W`WS`a`[^`
UWSZVb^WS`W^S_Y[cWS`[S^V
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
14/27
fn
O ZSZUS[__S^_ZYX^[`WUV_V_ST`
[__[XWS^ZZY S^VWZbZ
WS`UV Z[`WZ``WV`[US[_`[XWS^ZZY_`^WS`WVS_S\S^`[X^WS^ZYU[_`_
VaUS`[ZSU[_`_ WZS^^bW``W^ZYWS`
WZ``W`[^WU[bW^ZWUW__S^W\WZ_W_ \^bS`W
WVaUS`[ZSXWW_
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
15/27
fnO ZSZUS[__S^_ZYX^[`WUV_V_ST`
cS^V`[Za^_ZYUS^W[_`_[XUS^W
_bU[SZVcWZ`WS`Sa`[^` cS^VWVUS_X[ Za^_ZYUS^WTa Z[`ZYZ^W_\WU`
[X[__[XWS^ZZY_ YbZYT[`US_c[aVS[aZ `[ V[aTW WU[bW^
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
16/27
ffnJ
O ZYSZV SUS^SZWbS_VWWS`[S^V
WW_bS^ZY`[ZW[^S[_\`S
O W`W^SZV_O W^SZ
O ^SZUW
O a^[\WSZ^[Z`
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
17/27
fnf
O aTU[UaTUZ`W^W_`
VSWb[[_Ta^^WSWS`a`[^`
`WU[a^` WWU`WVUS_ c[aVU^WS`WS_aTU[Z_U[a_\^W__a^W [WZU[a^SYW
ST[^`[Z_TWVUS\^SU`[ZW^_Z[^VW [Sb[VUS_TS_WV[Z`WU[_`[X^S_ZYSUV
O V_\^[\[^`[ZS`W[X`WUa\ST`[X`WV[U`[
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
18/27
O _[XX^SaVaWZ [ XU``[a_US_
WUbWVUS^[`WU`[Z
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
19/27
,ffnf
O S[cZYSUSc[aVTW_WWZT`WUV[ZUWT[^Z`S``cS_Z[`cSZ`WVS`X^_`
O
T[^`[ZO WSa`[Z[[a_VWU_[Z[X`[_WVW\^bWV[X`W
[\\[^`aZ``[Sb[VSbZYSUV[^SUVc`\S^`UaS^`^S`_
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
20/27
9ffn
fO `[`WSa`[Z[[a_VWU_[Z[X`[_WVW\^bWV[X`W
[\\[^`aZ``[Sb[VSbZYSUV[^SUVc`
\S^`UaS^`^S`_O _^Y``[_WXVW`W^ZS`[Z`W^Y``[VWUVWX[^
[ZW_WX[cSZUV^WZ
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
21/27
ffnnf
O \^[`WU`ZYSZV\^[[`ZYc[WZ_^W\^[VaU`bWX^WWV[
O
\[^`SZUW[XWZ_U[Z`^Ta`[Z`[UV^WS^ZY
O
#[V`W\[`WZ`S`[^WZX[^UW`S``WZWYYWZ`XSa^W`[\^[`WU`c[WZ_^W\^[VaU`bWU[UW_
U[Z_``a`W_S^WSS^O `W^W\^[VaU`bW`[^`_U[aVWZSZUWc[WZ_
^W\^[VaU`bWX^WWV[TWZX[^UZYYW^_`SZVS^V_[XWVUSUS^W
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
22/27
ffnnf
O #`WScS_[\S_SZ\[^`SZ`^[WZ^WXWU`ZY`W^WS`SZVVbW^_`[Xc[WZ_bW_
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
23/27
,fff9n
O W^W_Z[VWUVWVUS_WZSS_S[Z`_\[Z`
O bW^aUZXaWZUWVT`WScSZV\^SU`UWZ[[ZcWS`U[aZ`^W_
VWbW[\ZY`W^[cZa^_\^aVWZUW[XZWYYWZUW^TVaSVTVaS_V
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
24/27
,fff9nO [a^`_SWSbW``[S^SWZ``[^W_[bW`___aW
Z[_`S`a`W_`[VWUVW
O cS^WZW__[X^W\^[VaU`bWWS`SZV^W\^[VaU`bW^Y`_ S[ZYSS_SZ_
O SU[XZ[cWVYWSZVW\[_a^WST[a`^W\^[VaU`bW
^Y`_
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
25/27
,fff9nO XXUa``[_aWV[U`[^_TWUSa_W[X`WVXXUa`Z
[T`SZZYW\W^`WbVWZUW
O ST[^`[ZWYSZSS_S[ZYXa^`
O [aVU[Z_VW^`WZWWV_[XSS_S_a`^SUS_[UW`
O SU[XW`ZUY^[a\S_`_[cZ\W^\WU`bWST[a`UVT^`
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
26/27
-
8/3/2019 Wrongful Birth
27/27
nO SS_SSZV`^Vc[^VU[aZ`^W_
O WZY_ScSZV[`W^WYS__`WZ[`W^
U[aZ`^W_ SUUW\`WV`Wc^[ZYXaT^`US_W_ SXWS
[X`WU[a^`_TWZY_cS\WVTSa`\U`[XUS_
Z[a_`[^_WZ_TW_`[\\ZY\[Z`
