SNG LC (SCREENING)(L THUYT TR CHI)
CHNG 9
5/15/2015 2
CH 9. SNG LC (SCREENING)
9.1 Thng tin khng y 9.2 Sng lc (Screening)9.3 D on ca Coase9.4 Kh nng lm cam kt
3 Ch7, 8: c 1 gi thit kh mnh cho m phn: cc bn mphn bit y thng tin cn thit cho vic ra quyt nh.
Trn thc t, vic khng c thng tin v nh v kh nngchi tr ca khch hng l mt iu ph bin Nhng ngii m phn mt rt nhiu cng sc tm hiu mc tiuca i tc v tm cch che y mc tiu ring ca mnh, ththut c s dng:
t my nghe trm Tung tin gi mt cch c tnh ton T ra thn thin qu mc
LTTC c th gip ta s dng thng tin mt cch c tnhton.
9.1 Thng tin khng y (incomplete information)
5/15/2015 4
Thng tin khng hon ho l tnh trng mthay nhiu ngi tham gia th trng khng cnhng thng tin h cn ra quyt nh.
Thng tin khng hon ho bao gm: Thng tin khng y Thng tin khng chnh xc Thng tin khng th thu thp c Thng tin b che giu
9.1 Thng tin khng y Thng tin khng hon ho
(imperfect information)
5/15/2015 5
Thng tin bt cn xng l tnh trng trongmt giao dch, mt bn c thng tin y hn v tt hn so vi bn cn li.
Tnh trng thng tin bt cn xng hin dinrt nhiu trong cc lnh vc. V d: Th trng nh t Th trng lao ng Th trng bo him Th trng chng khon
9.1 Thng tin khng y Thng tin bt cn xng
Th trng hng ha Ngn hng Lnh vc u t Th trng c
5/15/2015 6
Thng tin bt cn xng l l mt tht bica th trng v n gy ra S la chn ngc (la chn bt li)
(adverse selection AS) Ri ro o c (tm l li)
(moral hazard MH) Vn ngi y quyn-ngi tha hnh
(principal-agent PA)
9.1 Thng tin khng y Hu qu ca thng tin bt cn xng
5/15/2015 7
9.1 Thng tin khng y V d v Bn i
89.1 Thng tin khng y V d v Laptop IBM
$1100
Ngi bn
$1040
$1000
Ngi mua
Nhu cu cao Nhu cu thp
s lng ngimua tim tng
Gi s ngi bn c sc mnh c quyn v c kh nng gi cam kt, gic c ngi bn ghi r, v ngi mua ch c th chp nhn, hoc tchi mua, m khng th mc c (take it or leave it):a) Nu ngi bn bit c ch xc kh nng chi tr ca ngi mua
c th khai thc ton b li ch sinh ra t trao i thng mib) Ngi bn khng c kh nng phn bit c ngi mua thuc nhmc nhu cu no mc phi mt trong hai loi sai lm: i gi qu cao,t gi qu thp
Trng hp 1
99.1 Thng tin khng y V d v Laptop IBM
$1100
Ngi bn
$1040
$1000
Ngi mua
Nhu cu cao Nhu cu thp
S lng ngimua tim tng
NB ch tp trung vo high-end $1100: Kim $100/v, b l chi kim li Trung bnh, nhn c $50 li nhun/1 ngi mua tim tng.
NB nh mc gi $1040 : Bn cho ton b ngi tiu dng Trungbnh, nhn c $40 li nhun/1 ngi mua tim tng.
CL no c li hn? CL nhm vo high-end th trng l c li hn. Thng tin l sc mnh ca m phn
V d: nhm low-end sn sng tr n 1055 USD, NB nn quyt nh ntn?
Trng hp 2
10
$1100
Ngi bn
$1045
$1000
Ngi mua
Nhu cu cao Nhu cu thp
54%
S lng ngimua tim tng
70%
46%
V D: NH GI?
11
$1100
Ngi bn
$1060
$1000
Ngi mua
Nhu cu cao Nhu cu thp
S lng ngimua tim tng
9.2 Sng lc (Screening)
80%
12
9.2 Sng lc (Screening)
Ngi bn c th p dng chin lc nh gi tinh vihn. H c th thit k cch giao dch nhm xui khinngi mua t bc l v s thch ca mnh. Ta gi lvn sng lc.
Gi s hng bn ra c tnh thi trang. Ngi mua thucnhm nhu cu cao c th mua ngay khi hng mi tung ra;hoc c th i ti cui k. Nhng khi , i vi Ngimua, gi tr ca hng mua c ch cn bng 80% gi tr sovi vic mua ngay vo u k.
5/15/2015 13
9.2 Sng lc (Screening)
Gim gi lin tc:
1. in thoi di ng.
2. Laptop.
3. thi trang (qun o,
ti sch, giy dp)
L mt chin lc nh gi,khng phi v hng kmcht lng.
14
9.2 Sng lc (Screening)
Ngi bn c th p dng hai mc gi.
Mc gi cao p dng vo u k; v sau hgi vo ma sale cui k; vi gi thit rng lc ch cn ton ngi mua thuc lp nhu cu thp.V vy gi vo cui k nn nh l 1060 USD.
Vy nn nh gi lc u k l bao nhiu, khuyn khch nhi mua thuc nhm nhu cucao mua ngay, m khng i ti ma sale.
15
9.2 Sng lc (Screening)
Gi s mc gi lc u ma l P: Nu ngi mua nhu cu cao mua ngay, h s hng li l
(1100 P).Nu h i ti k sale, h s hng li l
0,8.(1100 1060) = 32.Vy nn, nu mc gi u ma l khng qu cao, tc l:
(1100 P) 0,8.(1100 1060) P 1068
ng mua nhu cu cao s mua ngay m khng i gim gi. ngi bn thnh cng trong vic sng lc khch hng. Li nhun s l ( 68 + 60) > 60 USD (nu nh khng p dng chnh sch sng lc).
16
$1100
Ngi bn
$1042
$1000
Ngi mua
Nhu cu cao Nhu cu thp
S lng ngimua tim tng
9.2 Sng lc (Screening)
80%
17
22
Ngi bn i
18
12
Ngi mua
Nhu cu cao Nhu cu thp
S lng ngimua tim tng
9.2 Sng lc (Screening)
80%
18
9.2 Sng lc (Screening)
V d: Nhm low-end ch sn sng tr n 1042USD: tm P? NB nn nh gi nh th no c li nht? Cho mt vi v d v CL Snglc?
Kt lun: Khi m c s phn bit qu ln v nhucu hay kh nng chi tr ca cc lp ngi muakhc nhau, sng lc khng phi l chin lc cli.
19
9.3 D on ca Coase [Coases conjecture]
Chin lc Sng lc thng p dng cho th trng hng khng lu bn.VD: Kinh doanh chiu phim, dch v du lch, khch sn
Nhng i vi hng tiu dng lu bn (ngi mua ngy hm nay s tkhi quay li mua hng vo ngy mai)
Hng em bn ra trong ngy hm nay cnh tranh vi hng s bn vongy mai.
nhng nh c quyn bn hng tiu dng lu bn cnh tranh vi tnglai ca chnh h.
nh c quyn chu sc p phi gim gi trong tng lai. V ngi tiudng cao c th on trc iu v i n ngy mai, khi nh cquyn buc phi h gi. iu lm nh c quyn bn b thit thi.
Hy xem xt k hn m hnh ny.
20
9.3 D on ca Coase [Coases conjecture]
Gi s rng bn c mt mn hng c. nh th n chngc gi tr g i vi bn na (gi tr hng ha bng zero).Bn mun em ra bn li cho ai cn n.
Ngi mua c th tr bt k mt gi no trong khong t 0n 1 triu. Gi V l kh nng chi tr ca ngi mua timtng; P v l mc gi bn giao bn.
Khi , bn c th gp phi mt trong hai loi sai lm: giaogi qu cao, P>V , v bn s mt i mt giao dch c li;hoc giao gi qu thp, P>V , v bn s b mt li nhun.
Vy bn nn giao gi l bao nhiu cn bng mc ri rot hai loi sai lm ni trn?
5/15/2015 21
CHUN B CHO TUN TI
c thm cc chng tip theo. Chun b thuyt trnh v phn bin.